odts
chemical activationapplication to air and water treatments
wastewater and gas treatments have been determined using response surfaces methodology. In order to have a
is widely used for water and gaseous emissions puri- oxygen groups (Bansal et al., 1988). Activated carbons
are commonly obtained from various organic precursors
such as peat, wood, bituminous coal, coconut shells,
polymers, etc. (Bansal et al., 1988). In the physical
activation process, the precursor is rst carbonized at
600800 C under an inert atmosphere and activated
*Corresponding authors. Tel.: +33-2-5185-8295 (S. Rio),
tel.: +33-2-51-85-82-94; fax: +33-2-51-85-82-99 (C. Faur-
Chemosphere 58 (2005)Brasquet).
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (S. Rio), cather-high mass yield and to minimize the energetic cost of the process, the following optimal conditions, 1.5 g of H2SO4 g1
of sludge, 700 C and 145 min are more appropriate for use of activated carbon from sludge in water and gas treat-ments.
2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Sewage sludge; Valorization; Activated carbon; Chemical activation; Porosity; Adsorption
1. Introduction
Activated carbon is a highly eective adsorbent that
cation. This is due to their extended specic surface area
between 500 and 2000 m2 g1, their high pore volumeand the presence of surface functional groups, especiallySebastien Rio a,*, Catherine Faur-Brasquet a,*, Laurence Le Coq a,Philippe Courcoux b, Pierre Le Cloirec a
a Ecole des Mines de Nantes, GEPEA UMR CNRS 6144, 4 rue Alfred Kastler, BP 20722, 44307 Nantes Cedex 3, Franceb ENITIAA, SMAD Department, rue de la Geraudiere, BP 82225, 44322 Nantes Cedex 3, France
Received 24 March 2004
Abstract
The objective of this study is to optimize experimental conditions of sorbent preparation from sewage sludge
using experimental design methodology. Series of carbonaceous sorbents have been prepared by chemical activation
with sulfuric acid. The sorbents produced were characterized, and their properties (surface chemistry, porous and
adsorptive properties) were analyzed as a function of the experimental conditions (impregnation ratio, activation
temperature and time). Carbonaceous sorbents developed from sludge allow copper ion, phenol and dyes (Acid Red 18
and Basic Violet 4) to be removed from aqueous solution as well as VOC from gas phase. Indeed, according to
experimental conditions, copper adsorption capacity varies from 77 to 83 mg g1, phenol adsorption capacity variesbetween 41 and 53 mg g1 and VOC adsorption capacities (acetone and toluene) range from 12 to 54 mg g1. Eachresponse has been described by a second-order model that was found to be appropriate to predict most of the responses
in every experimental region. The most inuential factors on each experimental design response have been identied.
Regions in which optimum values of each factor were achieved for preparation of activated carbons suitable for use inExperimental design methof carbonaceous [email protected] (C. Faur-Brasquet).
0045-6535/$ - see front matter 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reservdoi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2004.06.003ology for the preparationfrom sewage sludge by
423437
www.elsevier.com/locate/chemosphereusing steam or carbon dioxide at upper temperature.
ed.
and elemental composition of sludge samples are assessed
C) and activation time (60180 min) are analyzed usingexperimental design methodology. The regions of
424 S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437When activated carbons are prepared by chemical
activation, the precursor is mixed with chemical com-
pounds such as phosphoric acid or sulfuric acid and
carbonized-activated in a same step at various temper-
atures (Bagreev et al., 2001a). In recent years, a grow-
ing research interest consists in the production of
carbon-based adsorbents from a range of low-cost
precursors, mainly industrial or agricultural by-prod-
ucts. Polymers (Yue et al., 2002), wastes tires (San
Miguel et al., 2003) and numerous agricultural by-
products including wood (Tseng et al., 2003), almond
shells (Toles et al., 2000), apple pulp (Suarez-Garcia
et al., 2001), sugarcane bagasse (Mohan and Singh,
2002) or pecan shells (Bansode et al., 2003) have been
successfully converted into activated carbons on labo-
ratory scale.
On searching for economical and available starting
material, sewage sludge, the by-product generated dur-
ing wastewater treatment processes, has been identied
as an attractive precursor for activated carbon produc-
tion (Chiang and You, 1987; Lu et al., 1995; Bagreev
et al., 2001b; Tay et al., 2001; Calvo et al., 2001). In
France, sewage sludge production is about 950 000 tons
of dried matter per year. The traditional ways of sludge
valorization include farmland application, landll and
incineration. But, with some traditional disposal ways
coming under pressure like farmland applications and
others being phased out like landll, it is necessary to
seek cost-eective and innovative solutions to sewage
sludge disposal problem. Activated carbon preparation
from sewage sludge can be considered as an attractive
method in reducing sludge volume, and at the same
time, it produces reusable by-products. But, recent
studies which have shown the feasibility of this conver-
sion rarely determine the eects of activation conditions
on physico-chemical properties of sorbents produced as
well as on adsorption capacities of standard industrial
wastewater pollutants and volatile organic compounds
(VOC) in gas phase.
In this work, we focus on the preparation of acti-
vated carbon from sewage sludge. This is carried out by
chemical activation process using sulfuric acid. The
preparation of activated carbon is inuenced by many
factors. For this reason, a preliminary study on the eect
of these factors on activated carbon production has
been carried out in order to determine the most impor-
tant ones and their regions of interest (Rio et al., 2003).
In this study, the most inuential factors were found to
be impregnation ratio, activation temperature and acti-
vation time. Dierent characteristics of the activated
carbon produced are analyzed as a function of these
three factors. The main advantages of experimental de-
signs are: (i) the ability to evaluate the eects of inter-
actions between tested examined parameters; (ii) the
gain in reducing the number of experiments to beinterest of these factors have been detected in previous
study (Rio et al., 2003). This study, factor by factor,
was carried out by varying activation temperature be-
tween 400 and 900 C, activation duration between 1and 3 h and H2SO4 concentration from 1 to 3 M. And,
the inuence of these operating conditions on porosity
development have been studied. Notably, higher acti-
vating agent concentration is not used because pre-
liminary experiments have shown that, when sulfuric
acid concentration is higher than 3 M, destruction of the
material structure occurs during the thermal treatment
(Rio et al., 2003).by French standard methods (AFNOR NF U 44-171,
1982).
2.2. Activated carbon preparation
Chemical activation with sulfuric acid is carried out
using an impregnation method. Dried viscous liquid
sludge is mixed with H2SO4 solutions (13 M) for 6 h.
The resulting mixture is ltered and dried at 105 C.Then, the impregnated sludge is introduced in a 2 l
horizontal furnace and carbonized under nitrogen
atmosphere at 20 C min1. Nitrogen ow rate is equalto 2.5 l min1. The eects of impregnation ratio (0.51.5g H2SO4 g
1 sludge), activation temperature (600800undertaken, in comparison to a classical approach for
the same number of estimated parameters (Box and
Draper, 1987). This methodology is widely used in
chemical engineering notably to optimize adsorption
processes (Ricou et al., 2001; Annadurai et al., 2002) but
also to optimize experimental conditions for activated
carbon preparation from waste (Bacaoui et al., 2001).An experimental design is used to represent the re-
sponses of the factors in all the experimental regions
studied and to optimize the experimental conditions
for carbonaceous sorbents preparation from sewage
sludge.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Raw material
Viscous liquid sludge collected from the municipal
wastewater treatment plant of Nantes-Tougas, in France,
is used as precursor in this study. In this domestic
wastewater treatment plant, wastewater undergoes a
biological treatment by activated sludges. Viscous liquid
sludge corresponds to aerobically digested sludge dewa-
tered by centrifugation. Dried matter content, ash content
S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437 4252.3. Activated carbon characterization
2.3.1. Porosity measurements
Nitrogen adsorption/desorption isotherms are mea-
sured at 77 K with a MICROMERITICS ASAP 2010
surface area analyzer. Samples are outgassed between
100 and 350 C, depending on the materials activated ornot, in a vacuum during 3 d before analysis. The specic
surface area (SBET) is calculated by BET equation(Brunauer et al., 1938). The mesopore (250 nm) and
micropore (
3. Results and discussion
pollutants, the following responses are also studied:
426 S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 4234373.1. Characterization of raw sewage sludge
The results of physico-chemical analysis of viscousmethodology allows experimental responses behavior to
be described as precisely as possible as a function of
factor variation and optimal conditions of the factors to
be determined for each experimental response.
Table 1
Experimental design matrix
No. Exp. Temperature
(C)X1
Time
(min)
X2
Impregnation
ratio
X3
1 600 60 0.5
2 600 60 1.5
3 600 180 0.5
4 600 180 1.5
5 800 60 0.5
6 800 60 1.5
7 800 180 0.5
8 800 180 1.5
Central run 1 700 120 1
Central run 2 700 120 1
Central run 3 700 120 1
Star point 1 532 120 1
Star point 2 868 120 1
Star point 3 700 20 1
Star point 4 700 220 1
Star point 5 700 120 0.15
Star point 6 700 120 1.85liquid sludge are presented in Table 2. First, dried
matter content of viscous liquid sludge is equal to 19.2%.
The relatively high quantity of carbon within viscous
liquid sludge (39.4 wt%) shows that it has the potential
to be converted in carbonaceous sorbent. Viscous liquid
sludge develops low SBET of 2.9 m2 g1, and the porestructure of the sludge is mainly macroporous. Finally,
the sludge contains heavy metals like lead or mercury
but their concentration are lower than the values xed
by French regulation. To evaluate the stability of these
toxic metallic compounds, the raw material and the
resulting sorbents have been submitted to leaching test
adapted from the French standard AFNOR X31-210
(2000). The results notably show that these heavy metals
are very stable within the raw material and the resulting
sorbents. The leaching percentage of these metallic
compounds was very low and did not exceed 2% in
demineralized water acidied at pH 5.
3.2. Responses analysis and interpretation
The experimental responses studied include: activa-
tion mass yield Y1, porous structure, surface chemistryand adsorption capacities at equilibrium. Porosity
development is characterized by SBET Y2, mesoporevolume Y3 and micropore volume Y4. Surface chem-istry evolution during activation is determined by mea-
surements of surface pH Y5, acidic surface functionalgroups Y6 and basic surface functional groups Y7.These characteristics are chosen because of their strong
inuence on activated carbon adsorption capacity
(Boehm, 1966). In order to estimate adsorption e-
ciency of sorbents produced towards standard industrial
Table 2
Physico-chemical characteristics of raw sewage sludge
Property/element Sewage sludge
SBET (m2 g1) 2.9Macroporosity (vol.%) 97.0
Dried matter (wt%) 19.2
Ash content (wt% of dried matter) 22.0
Carbon (wt%) 39.4
Oxygen (wt%) 19.8
Hydrogen (wt%) 5.6
Nitrogen (wt%) 6.4
Sulfur (wt%) 0.9
Phosphorus (wt%) 1.9
Calcium (wt%) 2.9
Potassium (wt%) 0.7
Magnesium (wt%) 0.5
Iron (wt%) 0.8
Copper (ppm) 306
Nickel (ppm) 76
Lead (ppm) 64
Zinc (ppm) 634
Mercury (ppb)
Table 3
Experimental design responses
No. Exp. Yield Porosity development Chemical prop
Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y5 Y6
1 44.3 157 0.061 0.084 5.8 0.89
2 44.9 259 0.048 0.131 5.4 0.92
3 44.1 177 0.042 0.094 6.1 0.77
4 45.2 353 0.244 0.129 5.9 0.79
5 36.4 77 0.048 0.032 5.9 0.71
6 37.1 322 0.217 0.125 5.0 0.80
7 36.4 58 0.046 0.023 6.5 0.64
8 36.6 327 0.239 0.125 6.0 0.75
Central run 1 38.4 248 0.046 0.128 6.4 0.83
Central run 2 38.6 251 0.045 0.13 6.3 0.79
.81
.84
.65
.85
.76
.70
.81
.967
1); Ymeqg
on of
betwe
S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437 427Central run 3 38.9 255 0.047 0.131 6.5 0
Star point 1 49.6 69 0.042 0.029 6.7 0
Star point 2 33.3 61 0.047 0.024 7.1 0
Star point 3 37.5 200 0.046 0.104 5.9 0
Star point 4 35.1 252 0.048 0.125 5.6 0
Star point 5 38.7 231 0.23 0.085 6.9 0
Star point 6 37.6 352 0.231 0.148 5.9 0
R2 0.941 0.895 0.806 0.929 0.672 0Lack-of-t test 0.03
Y1, mass yield (%); Y2, SBET (m2 g1); Y3, mesopore volume (cm3 gfunctional groups (meq g1); Y7, basic surface functional groups ((mg g1); Y10, adsorption of Basic Violet 4 (mg g1); Y11, adsorptiadsorption of toluene (mg g1); R2, coecients of determinationlack-of-t statistical test.statistical model, and experimental responses. The ef-
fects of the three factors on mass yield Y1 are presentedin Fig. 1. Activation temperature X1 has a highlynegative eect on yield Y1, i.e., the increase of tem-perature from 600 to 800 C leads to a decrease of massyield, compared with others factors that have a very
weak eect on this response. Indeed, the increase in
temperature quickens the gasication reactions and,
therefore, the removal of amorphous components which
obstruct the pores, leading to a decrease in mass yield
(Bacaoui et al., 2001). Then, no signicant interactionsbetween the factors have been observed.
Fig. 1. Main eect plot for mass yield (%).erties Adsorptive properties
Y7 Y8 Y9 Y10 Y11 Y12 Y13
0.34 78 47 69 50 26 29
0.29 81 52 77 49 49 51
0.27 79 49 70 48 24 31
0.24 83 54 89 54 48 54
0.22 77 41 63 46 15 18
0.18 82 53 88 53 48 53
0.20 77 41 62 48 12 14
0.16 82 53 88 53 48 54
0.23 81 42 76 49 49 52
0.24 81 43 77 50 50 52
0.24 81 43 77 49 51 52
0.39 77 51 63 46 14 15
0.14 77 47 64 46 12 13
0.20 80 54 76 47 32 40
0.20 81 51 77 47 49 51
0.36 81 52 75 53 30 39
0.20 83 54 88 53 51 54
0.914 0.907 0.748 0.895 0.901 0.899 0.887
0.11
4, micropore volume (cm3 g1); Y5, surface pH; Y6, acidic surface
1); Y8, adsorption of copper (mg g1); Y9, adsorption of phenolAcid Red 18 (mgg1); Y12, adsorption of acetone (mg g1); Y13,en observed values and predicted values, Lack-of-t, p-value of3.2.2. Porosity development
The activation process allows to create and develop
the porous surface and volume giving adsorbent quali-
ties to resulting activated carbon. The nal porous
structure of the activated carbon is governed by the
precursor structure and by activation conditions (Bansal
et al., 1988). Generally, porosity of commercial activated
carbons is mainly constituted of micropores and even
mesopores.
First, the SBET Y2 of the sorbents varies from 59 to352 m2 g1 according to the experimental conditions(Table 3). These values are in agreement with literature
datas. Lu and Lau (1996) have obtained, during sewage
sludge chemical activation with 3 MH2SO4 at 650 C, anSBET of 220 m2 g1. Identical experiments have also beencarried out by Rozada et al. (2003) and they have ob-
tained adsorbents developing 390 m2 g1 at 625 C. But,SBET values obtained in this paper remain lower thanthese of commercial activated carbons which usually
vary between 500 and 2000 m2 g1 (Bansal et al., 1988).Note that commercial activated carbon consists of vari-
ous mineral compounds (ash) in quantities lower than
10% (Hassler, 1974) where as sorbents produced from
sludge in this study contains between 35% and 40% of
ash (Table 4). That ash content limits the porosity
development occurring within organic matter and be-
haves only as an inert material which does not contribute
to the porosity (Linares-Solano et al., 2000). By this way,
porosity development could be recalculated, taking only
organic matter content into account, and reaches about
500 m2 g1 of organic matter.A correct correlation between observed responses
and predicted responses is obtained by the statistical
model, with coecient of determination of 0.895 (Table
3). The eects and interaction of the factors on SBET Y2are presented in Fig. 2. On one hand, response analysis
shows that activation temperature X1 has slightlynegative eect on this response, but, the important
estimated variable as a function of pairs of factors. In
each plot, the SBET evolves versus the rst written factorin the X-axis and is parameterized according to the
second written factor. The + curves stand for the
maximum values of the parameter and the ) curvesstand for the minimum values. So, important interac-
tions exist between activation temperature and impreg-
nation ratio X1X3 (positive) which is more importantthan the eects of X1. Indeed, Fig. 2 shows that when theimpregnation ratio is xed to the lower value (0.5 g
H2SO4 g1 sludge), the increase of temperature leads to
Table 4
Ash and carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen and sulfur contents (wt%)
X1 X2 X3 Ash content Carbon Hydrogen Oxygen Nitrogen Sulfur
600 60 0.5 35.0 42.2 1.2 11.0 4.4 3.1
600 60 1.5 34.5 40.8 1.2 11.6 3.7 4.1
600 180 0.5 38.1 37.3 1.5 10.4 4.2 4.3
600 180 1.5 37.4 35.9 1.5 10.7 3.8 4.4
800 60 0.5 40.3 44.5 1.5 10.1 3.0 3.9
800 60 1.5 40.3 39.9 1.6 10.3 2.6 5.0
800 180 0.5 41.7 42.5 1.2 8.6 2.7 4.1
800 180 1.5 41.2 37.0 1.3 9.1 2.5 5.0
700 120 1 35.9 43.1 1.6 8.6 3.6 5.0
428 S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437quadratic eect observed suggests that an optimal SBETvalue is reach between 600 and 800 C. On the otherhand, the increase in activation time X2 and impreg-nation ratio X3 allows SBET Y2 to be developed.Interaction plot is also presented in Fig. 2, it shows theFig. 2. Main eect plot and interaction plot for SBa dramatic decrease of SBET, while, when experiments arecarried out with high impregnation ratio (1.5 g H2SO4g1 sludge), the increase in temperature allows SBET to beincreased. Such interaction is observed between activa-
tion time and impregnation ratio X2X3.ET (m2 g1) and mesopore volume (cm3 g1).
For micropore volume response Y4 which resultsare not presented in this paper, exactly the same trends
for SBET response in terms of eects and interactions ofthe factors are obtained. In addition, these two experi-
mental responses are very dependent, the coecient of
determination between SBET Y2 and micropore volumeY4 is equal to 0.937 (Table 5). The increase ofimpregnation ratio X3 and activation time X2 im-proves the micropore volume Y4 of the sorbents ob-tained. The increase of activation time X2 would causethe opening of closed or non-accessible micropores. The
increase of impregnation agent concentration improves
SBET and micropore volume because the role of theimpregnation agent is to minimize the formation of tars
and any other liquids that could block the pores and
inhibit the porous structure development within the
sorbent (Guo and Lua, 1999).
The value of coecient of determination (Table 3)
between calculated and observed mesopore volume
impregnation ratio X1X3 and between activation timeand impregnation ratio X2X3 because the increase oftemperature X1 or time X2 improve mesopore volumeY3 if impregnation ratio X3 is xed to the value 0.5while, this response decreases with increasing tempera-
ture or time when impregnation ratio is xed to the
value 1.5.
Finally, the observation of pore size distributions of
the resulting sorbents activated at 600 and 800 C, withan impregnation ratio of 1.5, conrms the positive eect
of temperature on mesopore volume Y3 (between 2 and50 nm) and the positive eect of activation time (be-
tween 1 and 3 h) on mesopore volume (as well as on
micropore volume (
of acidic surface functional groups as shown in Table 3.
Amount of acidic surface groups Y6 is always at leasttwo times more important than basic surface groups
Y7. The quantities of acidic surface groups Y6 andbasic surface groups Y7 can be very correctly describedby a second order model, R2 values are equal to 0.967and 0.914, respectively (Table 3). In the case of surface
pH response Y5, the second order model is not adap-ted. A lack-of-t test is performed to test the adequacy
of the model. The p-value of lack-of-t statistical test isless than 0.05 and equal to 0.03 (Table 3). So, there is
statistically signicant lack-of-t at the 95% condence
level. This means that the model as tted does not
adequately represent the data. In addition, during the
analysis of variance of surface pH response, the test of
statistical signicance of each factor is also performed. It
is carried out by comparing the mean square against an
estimate of the experimental error. The results show that
only two eects, activation duration X2 and impreg-nation ratio X3, have p-values less than 0.05, indicatingthat they are signicantly dierent from zero at 95% of
430 S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437First, every sorbents produced are acidic, surface pH
varying between 5 and 7, due to the important quantity
Fig. 3. Pore size distributions of sorbent produced with
impregnation ratio of 1.5.
Fig. 4. Micrographs of dried sludge (a) andcondence level. The statistical analysis of this response
is not carried out in this paper.
Then, Fig. 5 clearly shows that activation temperature
X1 and time X2 have a negative eect on amounts ofacidic surface groups Y6 and basic surface groups Y7.As indicated in literature, surface groups decompose at
elevated temperature and their decomposition increases
with increasing activation time (Boehm, 1966). The in-
crease of impregnation ratio X3 leads to increase inacidic character of the sorbents produced because this
factor has a strong positive impact on amount of acidic
surface groups Y6 and a negative eect on amount ofbasic surface groups Y7 (Fig. 5).chemically activated sludge (b)(d).
he variability of the response (Table 3). These values are
n agreement with copper adsorption capacities obtained
ith commercial activated carbons (Faur-Brasquet
t al., 2002) and activated carbon prepared from agri-
ultural by-products (Toles et al., 1999). Main eect plot
hows a negative eect of activation temperature X1,hile, activation time X2 and impregnation ratio X3ave a positive eect (Fig. 6). But, the important qua-
ratic eect of activation temperature X1 reveals thatptimal value of this factor can be achieved. The eects
f the three factors are similar to those obtained for SBETY2 (Fig. 2) and micropore volume Y4. This observa-ion is conrmed by the important coecient of deter-
ination between copper adsorption capacity Y8 andBET Y2, and between, copper adsorption capacity Y8
S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437 431The elemental analysis carried out on the resulting
activated carbon shows that oxygen contents decrease
when activation temperature X1 and time X2 increase(Table 4). It would conrm that amounts of acidic and
Fig. 5. Main eect plots for acidic and basic surface functional
groups (meq g1).basic surface functional groups decrease with the in-
crease of these experimental design factors (Boehm,
1966). Sulfur content varies from 3.1% to 5.0% accord-
ing to the experimental conditions, the highest values
(between 4% and 5%) being found for the highest
impregnation ratio of 1.5 (Table 4). Sulfur content
within dried sludge being equal to 0.9%, important
quantity of sulfur incorporated into the materials during
impregnation step, is not removed during thermal
treatment. Table 4 also shows that both oxygen and
sulfur contents increase with increasing impregnation
ratio because of the oxydizing eect of H2SO4 (Daley
et al., 1996). Carbon content varies from 36% to 45%
according to activation conditions and carbon content
seems to decrease with increasing impregnation ratio
due to dilution eect. Finally, ash content varies from
45.0% to 51.7% and it increases with increasing tem-
perature and time. Ash content seems to slightly de-
crease with increasing impregnation ratio because the
activating agent limits the formation of tars (Martin
et al., 1996).
3.2.4. Adsorption tests in aqueous solution
First, copper adsorption capacity Y8 varies from 77to 83 mg g1 and this response is correctly modeled bythe statistic model because it explains more than 90% ofand micropore volume Y4 (Table 5). So, these porouscharacteristics seem to partly control the copper removal
eciency by the sorbents produced. During copper
adsorption experiments, the evolution of calcium con-
centration in solution has been followed. The evolution
of Cu2 removed and Ca2 exchanged during kineticexperiment with chemically activated sludge at 600 Cfor 180 min and with impregnation ratio of 1.5 are
presented in Fig. 7. The simultaneous desorption of
calcium in solution would indicate that ion exchange
mechanism would also take place in the sorption phe-
nomenon of metallic ion.
Experimental design results show that phenol
adsorption capacity varies from 41 to 54 mg g1
according to activation conditions and the second order
model as tted explains only 75% of the variability of
this response (Table 3). So, a lack-of-t statistical test is
realized to test the adequacy of this model. The p-value
of the lack-of-t is greater than 0.05 (Table 3), the model
appears to be adequate for the observed data at the 95%
condence level. The values of phenol adsorption
capacities remain lower than phenol adsorption capaci-
ties obtained with commercial activated carbon (Nevs-
kaia et al., 1999) but they are similar to those obtained
using activated carbon from sludge (Martin et al., 1996;
Fig. 6. Main eect plot for copper adsorption capacity1t
i
w
e
c
s
w
h
d
o
o
t
m
S(mg g ).
volume Y4 responses. So, when the quantity of sulfuricacid is low during impregnation, the increase of activa-
tion temperature would lead to a micropore widening
(or destruction) and a decrease of phenol adsorption.
And, when, impregnation ratio and activation temper-
ature increase, an important micropore development
would occur, favoring phenol adsorption.
Finally, similar adsorption experiments have been
carried out to estimate the anity of the sorbents pre-
pared to remove Basic Violet 4, a cationic dye, and Acid
Red 18, an anionic dye, for aqueous solution. The
experimental data can be correctly tted by second order
model, the coecients of determination between experi-
mental and predicted adsorption capacities of Basic
same trend is observed for Acid Red 18 adsorption in
Fig. 7. Evolution of Cu2 removed (mM) and Ca2 exchanged
432 S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437Chen et al., 2002). The increase of activation tempera-
ture X1 and time X2 lead to the lightly decrease ofphenol adsorption capacity Y9 when the increase ofimpregnation ratio has a positive eect on this response
(Fig. 8). Even no strong dependence between this re-
sponse and porosity development, notably micropore
development Y4, has been identied, this increase ofphenol adsorption with increasing impregnation ratio is
attributed to the important microporosity development
(Martin et al., 1996). Experimental results show that
highest phenol adsorption capacities are observed when
important microporosity development occurs during
activation that corresponds to experiments (nos. 2, 4, 6,
8) carried out using impregnation ratio of 1.5 (Table 3).
Finally, an important interaction exists between activa-
tion temperature and impregnation ratio X1X3. Asshown in Fig. 8, when impregnation ratio X3 is xed tothe lower level (0.5 g H2SO4 g
1 sludge), the increase ofactivation temperature X3 leads to important decreaseof phenol adsorption capacity Y9, and, when impreg-nation ratio X3 is xed to the value +1 (1.5 g H2SO4
(mM) during kinetic experiment with chemically activated
sludge at 600 C for 180 min and with impregnation ratio of 1.5.g1 sludge), phenol adsorption capacity Y9 slightly in-crease with increasing activation temperature X3. Thesame trend was observed for SBET Y2 and micropore
Fig. 8. Main eect plot and interaction plot fterms of eects of the experimental design factors. First,
activation temperature X1 seems to have no eect ondye adsorption capacity but important quadratic eect of
this factor allows an optimal value to be determined. The
increase of activation time X2 and impregnation ratioX3 allow dye adsorption capacity to be increased (Fig.9). The factors eects are identical to those obtained for
mesopore volume Y3 (Fig. 2). Indeed, a strong depen-dence would exist between dye adsorption capacities
(Basic Violet 4 and Acid Red 18) and SBET Y2, mesoporevolume Y3 and micropore volume Y4 (Table 5). Due todye molecule size (23 nm) both micropore and meso-
pore development are important for the adsorption
process of these organic pollutants. Because of anionic
character of Acid Red 18 molecule, an important corre-
lation also exists between Acid Red 18 adsorption
capacity Y11 and the amount of acidic surface groupsY6 that would participate to adsorption mechanism ofthis dye, negatively charged in aqueous solution.
3.2.5. Adsorption tests in gas phase
Adsorption experiments in gas phase are carried out
to estimate the eciency of the sorbents produced to
1Violet 4 and Acid Red 18 are equal to 0.895 and 0.901,
respectively. Fig. 9 presents the statistical results ob-
tained for Basic Violet 4 adsorption because exactly theor phenol adsorption capacity (mg g ).
and 800 C due to quadratic eect of this factor, andpositive eects of activation time and impregnation ratio
(Fig. 10). The eects of these factors on VOC adsorption
capacities are identical to those obtained for SBET andmicropore volumes responses (Fig. 2). This observation
is conrmed by values of correlation coecients
revealing a strong dependence between these responses
(Table 5). This dependence between VOC adsorption
and microporosity development have been observed in
numerous research works (Subrenat, 1999; Chiang et al.,
2001; Lillo-Rodenas et al., 2002).
3.3. Optimization step
S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437 433remove two dierent VOC: acetone and toluene.
Fig. 9. Main eect plot for Basic Violet 4 and acetone
adsorption capacities (mg g1).Experimental design results show that adsorption
capacities of acetone Y12 and toluene Y13 vary be-tween 1251 mg g1 and 1354 mg g1, respectively.Adsorption capacities of acetone and toluene onto
commercial activated carbons are, in the same experi-
mental conditions, at least two times higher than values
obtained in this study (Subrenat, 1999). These data are
correctly tted by a second order model (Table 3). Solely
statistical results of acetone adsorption capacity Y12are presented in Fig. 10 because the same trends are
observed for toluene adsorption capacity Y13. First,main eect plot shows negative eect of activation
temperature, even an optimal is observed between 600
Fig. 10. Estimated response surfaces for SBET (m2 g1) and mesoporeconditions.volume (cm3 g1) with impregnation ratio of 1.5; (+) optimalTable 6 summarizes the eects of experimental design
factors on porous structure and adsorption capacities of
the sorbents produced. It shows that optimization of all
the responses under the same experimental conditions is
impossible because the inuence of the factors is dier-
ent.
Using response surfaces methodology, the ranges of
each factor allowing the ideal activated carbon to be
obtained are determined. The rst step is to establish the
values of structural characteristics of an ideal activated
carbon. This sorbent should have a large SBET Y2 andimportant micropore Y4 and mesopore Y3 volumesallowing their use for removal of a large range of pol-
lutants. Experimental design analysis has shown that
impregnation ratio X3 must be xed to the value 1.5 toobtain well developed porous structure. The optimal
point for SBET indicated by the model is equal to 376m2 g1 corresponding to an activation temperature of691 C and an activation time of 220 min (Fig. 10). Thesame optimal temperature is determined to obtain a
maximum micropore volume Y4 of 0.155 cm3 g1 butfor an optimal activation time of 140 min. More devel-
oped mesopore volume Y3 is obtained when activationtemperature is equal to 868 C and an activation time of220 min (Fig. 10). But, as shown in Fig. 10, when acti-
vation temperature varies from 532 to 868 C for anactivation time of 220 min, mesopore volume remains
nearly unchanged (0.2250.240 cm3 g1). So, if activa-tion temperature is xed to the value 691 C in order to
163 min, respectively (Fig. 12). These values are very
close to those obtained during response surface esti-
Table 6
Summary of the eects of experimental design factors on sorbents properties
Response Activation temperature Activation time Impregnation ratio
Micropore volumeSBET ) + +Mesopore volume + + +
Copper adsorption ) + +Phenol adsorption ) ) +Dye adsorption + + +
VOC adsorption ) + +
434 S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437maximize SBET and micropore volume, the mesoporevolume obtained is 0.232 cm3 g1 which is very close tothe optimal one (0.240 cm3 g1).
Then, optimization of adsorption capacities of cop-
per Y8, phenol Y9, Basic Violet 4 Y10 and Acid Red18 Y11 have also been carried out. First, the optimalconditions to maximize copper adsorption capacity Y8are impregnation ratio of 1.5, activation temperature of
680 C and an activation time equal to 220 min (Fig. 11).Under these experimental conditions copper adsorption
capacity reaches 84 mg g1. The response surfaces ofBasic Violet 4 adsorption capacity Y10 is identical tothis of copper adsorption capacity and optimal value of
this response is 91 mg g1. It conrms that adsorptionmechanisms of these two positively charged molecules in
aqueous solution would be identical and favored under
the optimal conditions determined by response surfaces
methodology. The estimated response surfaces for Acid
Red 18 adsorption capacity Y11 is also presented in Fig.11 and reveals that this response is maximum when
impregnation ratio is equal to 1.5 with activation tem-
perature of 750 C and activation time of 180 min. But,the variation of these adsorption capacities weak in the
experimental conditions studied allowing a compromise
to be found.
In the case of acetone Y12 or toluene Y13 adsorp-tion capacities, The optimal conditions maximizing
these responses are impregnation ratio of 1.5, activation
temperature of 703 C and activation time of 145 andFig. 11. Estimated response surfaces for copper and Acid Red 18 ad
optimal conditions.mation of micropore volume Y4 (X1: 691 C, X2: 140min, X3: 1.5) because VOC adsorption eciency isstrongly dependent on microporosity development
(Table 4).
To optimize all the responses under the same exper-
imental conditions is dicult because regions of interest
of the factors are dierent. Therefore, a compromise
must be found. The cost of the process must be also
taken into account and this activated carbon should
have a relatively high mass yield (3540%).
The optimal experimental conditions already identi-
ed can be classied in two distinct regions. The rst
one: activation temperature of about 700 C, activationtime of 145160 min and impregnation ratio of 1.5,
correspond to optimal conditions of the following re-
sponses: micropore volume Y4, acetone Y12 and tol-uene Y13 adsorption capacities. The second region ofinterest, corresponding to optimal conditions for SBETY2 development, copper Y8 and Basic Violet 4 Y10adsorption capacities, is dened by an activation tem-
perature of about 700 C, an activation time of 220 minand impregnation ratio of 1.5. Results of response sur-
faces methodology allow the experimental design re-
sponses to be estimated in these two regions of interest
and compared. As shown in Table 7, on one hand, some
experimental responses, like micropore volume Y4,copper Y9, Acid Red 18 Y11 and toluene Y13adsorption capacities do not signicantly vary between
the two optimal conditions obtained due to the lowsorption capacities (mg g1) with impregnation ratio of 1.5; (+)
rptio
0
5
olum
1, ad
S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437 435eect of activation time X2 on these responses. On theother hand, response surfaces curves of SBET Y2 andmesopore volume Y3 show an increase, even weak, ofthese responses between the rst and the second region
of interest (Fig. 10). Finally, a slight decrease of VOC
adsorption capacities is observed between the rst and
the second region of interest (Fig. 12). It could be
Table 7
Predicted responses for optimal activated carbons
Optimal conditions X1, X2, X3 Y2 Y3 Y4700 C, 145160 min, 1.5 wt/wt 350 0.175 0.13700 C, 220 min, 1.5 wt/wt 377 0.232 0.12
Y2, SBET (m2 g1); Y3, mesopore volume (cm3 g1); Y4, micropore vphenol (mg g1); Y10, adsorption of Basic Violet 4 (mg g1); Y1(mg g1); Y13, adsorption of toluene (mg g1).Fig. 12. Estimated response surfaces for acetone and toluene adso
conditions.attributed to the decrease, even weak, of micropore
volume Y4, these responses being strongly correlated asshown on Table 4.
To conclude on this optimization step, in order to
limit the energetic cost of the process and to obtain a
satisfying mass yield, the following conditions: activa-
tion temperature of 700 C, activation time of 145 minand impregnation ratio of 1.5, allow to obtain a satis-
fying compromise between the dierent responses stud-
ied in this paper.
4. Conclusion
Carbonaceous materials with adsorptive properties
have been produced from sewage sludge by chemical
activation process using sulfuric acid. Experimental de-
sign methodology has been used in order to determine
the eects of activation temperature (600800 C), acti-vation time (13 h) and impregnation ratio (0.51.5 g of
H2SO4 g1 of sludge) on chemical properties, porous
structure and adsorption capacities of the sorbents pre-
pared. Response surfaces methodology allowed the
optimal conditions for activated carbon preparation to
be determined.First, the carbonaceous sorbents produced are acidic
in nature due to the important quantity of acidic surface
functional groups. This acidic character increases with
increasing impregnation ratio while the increase of
activation temperature and activation time lead to an
increase of surface pH of the activated carbons. The
analysis of the responses characterizing the porosity
n capacities (mg g1) with impregnation ratio of 1.5; (+) optimal
Y8 Y9 Y10 Y11 Y12 Y13
83 50 88 52 58 62
84 55 91 52 54 61
e (cm3 g1); Y8, adsorption of copper (mg g1); Y9, adsorption ofsorption of Acid Red 18 (mg g1); Y12, adsorption of acetonedevelopment shows, on one hand, a negative eect of
temperature on SBET and micropore volume and positiveeects of activation time and impregnation ratio on
these responses. And, on the other hand, the three fac-
tors seem to have a positive eect on mesopore volume
in the ranges studied.
The eects of the three factors of the experimental
design on VOC adsorption capacities in gas phase follow
the same trend as micropore volume development, i.e.,
positive eects of activation time and impregnation ratio
and negative eect of activation temperature. Anionic
and cationic dyes adsorption capacities in aqueous
solution are strongly dependent on micropore and
mesopore development. In the case of copper adsorption
capacity, this response depends on porous structure
development but, an ion exchange mechanism has been
identied, taking part in the adsorption process.
The optimization step, carried out using response
surfaces methodology, allows two dierent optimal
experimental conditions for activated carbon production
to be identied. The rst region of interest: activation
temperature of 700 C, activation time of 145 min andimpregnation ratio of 1.5, correspond to optimal con-
ditions for micropore volume and VOC adsorption
capacities. The second region of interest, corresponding
436 S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437AFNOR NF U 44-171. AFNOR Ed., Paris, 1982.
Annadurai, G., Juang, R.-S., Lee, D.-J., 2002. Factorial design
analysis for adsorption of dye on activated carbon beads
incorporated with calcium alginate. Adv. Environ. Res. 6,
191198.
Bacaoui, A., Yaacoubi, A., Dahbi, A., Bennouna, C., Phan TanLuu, R., Maldonado-Hodar, F.J., Rivera-Utrilla, J., Mo-
reno-Castilla, C., 2001. Optimization of conditions for the
preparation of activated carbons from olive-waste cakes.
Carbon 39, 425432.
Bagreev, A., Adib, F., Bandosz, T.J., 2001a. pH of activated
carbon surface as an indication of its suitability for H2S
removal from moist air streams. Carbon 39, 18971905.
Bagreev, A., Bandosz, T.J., Locke, D.C., 2001b. Pore struc-
ture and surface chemistry of adsorbents obtained by
pyrolysis of sewage sludge-derived fertilizer. Carbon 39,
19711979.
Bansal, R.C., Donnet, J.B., Stoeckli, F., 1988. Active Carbon.
Marcel-Dekker, New York.
Bansode, R.R., Losso, J.N., Marshall, W.E., Rao, R.M.,
Portier, R.J., 2003. Adsorption of volatile organic com-
pounds by pecan shell- and almond shell-based granular
activated carbons. Biores. Technol. 90, 175184.The authors wish to acknowledge ADEME and
Region Pays de la Loire for nancial support. The au-thors are also grateful to Communaute Urbaine deNantes and Loire 21 for supplying sewage sludge and to
Y. Gouriou (Ecole des Mines de Nantes) for the
experimental assistance.
Referencesto optimal conditions for SBET development, copper andBasic Violet 4 adsorption capacities, is dened by acti-
vation temperature of 700 C, activation time of 220 minand impregnation ratio of 1.5. In order to have a high
mass yield and to reduce the energetic cost of the pro-
cess, the following optimal conditions, 1.5 g of H2SO4g1 of sludge, 700 C and 145 min are more appropriate.
Further experiments should be carried out to increase
the porosity development and adsorptive properties of
activated carbons produced from sludge, like the intro-
duction of a preliminary carbonization step at low
temperature (300400 C) in the overall activation pro-cess. A pre-development of porosity could occur allow-
ing a more ecient impregnation step before activation.
Finally, in order to evaluate the economic feasibility
of sludge chemical activation process, a technico-eco-
nomic approach will be carried out and based on a mass
yield of approximately 38%. This cost analysis would
include equipment, sulfuric acid consumption, nitrogen
consumption, electricity usage. . .
AcknowledgementsBarrett, E.P., Joyner, L.G., Halenda, P.P., 1951. The determi-
nation of pore volumes and area distributions in porous
substances. J Am. Chem. Soc. 73, 373380.
Boehm, H.P., 1966. Chemical identication of surface groups.
Adv. Cat. 16, 179274.
Box, G.E.P., Draper, N.R., 1987. Empirical Model Building
and Response Surface. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Brunauer, S., Emmett, P.H., Teller, F., 1938. Adsorption of
gases in multimolecular layer. J Am. Chem. Soc. 60, 309
319.
Calvo, L.F., Otero, M., Moran, A., Garcia, A.I., 2001.
Upgrading sewage sludges for adsorbent preparation by
dierent treatments. Biores. Technol. 80, 143148.
Chen, X., Jeyaseelan, S., Graham, N., 2002. Physical and
chemical properties study of the activated carbon made
from sewage sludge. Waste Manage. 22, 755760.
Chiang, P.C., You, J.H., 1987. Use of sewage sludge for
manufacturing adsorbents. Can. J. Chem. Eng. 65, 922927.
Chiang, Y.-C., Chiang, P.-C., Huang, C.-P., 2001. Eects of
pore structure and temperature on VOC adsorption on
activated carbon. Carbon 39, 523534.
Daley, M.A., Tandon, D., Economy, J., Hippo, E.J., 1996.
Elucidating the porous structure of activated carbon bers
using direct and indirect methods. Carbon 34, 11911200.
Faur-Brasquet, C., Kadirvelu, K., Le Cloirec, P., 2002.
Removal of metal ions from aqueous solution by adsorption
onto activated carbon cloths: adsorption competition with
organic matter. Carbon 40, 23872392.
Guo, J., Lua, A.C., 1999. Textural and chemical characterisa-
tions of activated carbon prepared from oil-palm stone with
H2SO4 and KOH impregnation. Micropor. Mesopor.
Mater. 32, 111117.
Hassler, J.W., 1974. Activated Carbon: Industrial, Commercial
and Environmental. Chemical Publishing Co. Inc, New
York.
Horwath, G., Kawazoe, K.J., 1983. Method for the calculation
of eective pore size distribution in molecular sieve carbon.
Chem. Eng. J. 16, 470475.
Lillo-Rodenas, M.A., Carratala-Abril, J., Cazorla-Amoros, D.,
Linares-Solano, A., 2002. Usefulness of chemically acti-
vated anthracite for the abatement of VOC at low concen-
trations. Fuel Process. Technol. 7778, 331336.
Linares-Solano, A., Martin-Gullon, I., Salinas-Martinez de
Lecea, C., Serrano-Talavera, B., 2000. Activated carbons
from bituminous coal: eect of mineral matter content. Fuel
79, 635643.
Lu, G.Q., Lau, D.D., 1996. Characterisation of sewage sludge-
derived adsorbents for H2S removal part 2: surface and pore
structural evolution in chemical activation. Gas Separat.
Purif. 10, 103111.
Lu, G.Q., Low, J.C.F., Liu, C.Y., Lua, A.C., 1995. Surface area
development of sewage sludge during pyrolysis. Fuel 74,
344348.
Martin, M.J., Balaguer, M.D., Rigola, M., 1996. Feasibility of
activated carbon production from biological sludge by
chemical activation with ZnCl2 and H2SO4. Environ.
Technol. 17, 667672.
Mohan, D., Singh, K.P., 2002. Single- and multi-component
adsorption of cadmium and zinc using activated carbon
derived from bagassean agricultural waste. Wat. Res. 36,
23042318.
Nevskaia, D.M., Santianes, A., Munoz, V., Guerrero-Ruiz, A.,
1999. Interaction of aqueous solutions of phenol with
commercial activated carbons: an adsorption and kinetic
study. Carbon 37, 10651074.
Norme AFNOR NF X31-211, DechetsEssai de lixiviation
dun dechet solide initialement massif ou gene repar un
procede de solidication, 2000.Petrov, N., Budinova, T., Razvigorova, M., Ekinci, E., Yardim,
F., Minkova, V., 2000. Preparation and characterization of
carbon adsorbents from furfural. Carbon 38, 20692075.
Ricou, P., Lecuyer, I., Le Cloirec, P., 2001. Experimental design
methodology applied to adsorption of metallic ions onto y
ash. Wat. Res. 35, 965976.
Rio, S., Faur-Brasquet, C., Le Coq, L., Le Cloirec, P., 2003.
Structure characterization of porous carbonaceous materi-
als from sewage sludge. In: Proceedings of Carbon03,
Oviedo.
Rozada, F., Calvo, L.F., Garcia, A.I., Marin-Villacorta, J.,
Otero, M., 2003. Dye adsorption by sewage sludge-based
activated carbons in batch and xed bed systems. Biores.
Technol. 87, 221230.
San Miguel, G., Fowler, G.D., Sollars, C.J., 2003. A study of
the characteristics of activated carbons produced by steam
and carbon dioxide activation of waste tyre rubber. Carbon
41, 10091016.
Suarez-Garcia, F., Martinez-Alonso, A., Tascon, J.M.D., 2001.
Porous texture of activated carbons prepared by phosphoric
acid activation of apple pulp. Carbon 39, 11031116.
Subrenat, A., 1999. Procedes de traitement dair chargee enCOV par adsorption-de sorption sur tissu de carbone active.
Ph.D. Thesis, University of Nantes, France.
Tay, J.H., Chen, X.G., Jeyaseelan, S., Graham, N., 2001. A
comparative study of anaerobically digested and undigested
sewage sludges in preparation of activated carbons. Che-
mosphere 44, 5357.
Toles, C.A., Marshall, W.E., Johns, M.M., 1999. Surface
functional groups on acid-activated nutshell carbons. Car-
bon 37, 12071214.
Toles, C.A., Marshall, W.E., Wartelle, L.H., McAloon, A.,
2000. Steam or carbon dioxide-activated carbons from
almond shells: physical, chemical and adsorptive properties
and estimated cost of production. Biores. Technol. 75, 197
203.
Tseng, R.-L., Wu, F.-C., Juang, R.-S., 2003. Liquid-phase
adsorption of dyes and phenols using pinewood-based
activated carbons. Carbon 41, 487495.
Yue, Z., Mangun, C.L., Economy, J., 2002. Preparation of
brous porous materials by chemical activation: 1. ZnCl2
activation of polymer-coated bers. Carbon 40, 1181
1191.
S. Rio et al. / Chemosphere 58 (2005) 423437 437
Experimental design methodology for the preparation of carbonaceous sorbents from sewage sludge by chemical activation--application to air and water treatmentsIntroductionMaterials and methodsRaw materialActivated carbon preparationActivated carbon characterizationPorosity measurementsChemical properties of materials
Adsorption testsAdsorption experiments in aqueous solutionAdsorption experiments in gas phase
Experimental design methodology
Results and discussionCharacterization of raw sewage sludgeResponses analysis and interpretationMass yield (Y1)Porosity developmentChemical propertiesAdsorption tests in aqueous solutionAdsorption tests in gas phase
Optimization step
ConclusionAcknowledgementsReferences