Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Embodying Hacker Culture in Womenfriendly Free Software Groups
Yuwei LinESRC National Centre for eSocial Science
University of Manchester
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Free/Libre Open Source Software● Software whose source code are available for
users to run, copy, study, modify, improve, and redistribute.
● Free software is a matter of liberty, not price. To understand the concept, you should think of free as in free speech, not as in free beer.
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Free Software and Safe Living● Security holes or software glitches: users can not
only report a bug, but also define what is a bug. ● Transparency and openness: “Given enough
eyeballs, all bugs are shallow.” (Eric Raymond)● Peer production● Freedom of re/configuring and re/designing
technology● Taking control
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Hacking
codinghandson activities
tinkeringhandling tools
working with machinesbuilding prototypes
(all these activities originate from engineering culture and are prominently male defined)
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Motivations of Getting Involved
Just for funReputationMutuality
GratificationJob required
Selfhelp: to fix a bug at handGod told me so
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
What is visible?
mencodinghacking
taking control'hacker' as a homogeneous social category
8Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Problems● overemphasis on coding and hacking● visibility of women in free software● current societal inequality and knowledge gap
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Barriers of Including Women● Cyberbulling & trolling, sexist & discriminative languages● Unfriendly and inhumane online environment (e.g. RTFM)● gendered role in FLOSS development inequality of different types of knowledge & women's reduced role● Housework (childrearing) – lack of time● Lack of role models, mentors and support● Education (official curriculum, experiences)● A maledefined competitive mindset (reputation, flaming)● Any other reasons that differ from culture to culture, nation to nation, region to region?
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Women's Voices and Networks
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Beyond numbers and the binary gender codes and biological differences
Contexualisation & Embodiment
12Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Methods & Data Sources● virtual ethnography: DebianWomen (mixed sex) &
GenderChanger Academy (single sex)● informal conversations● content analysis (webpages, mailing list) with the
help of Text Mining + Corpus Analysis techniques● who (memberships), said what (topics), done what
(actions)● limits: neither real life nor real time
13Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
IMCWomen
14Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
GenderChanger Academy
15Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Belonging to a group
keyword-in-context (KWIC) concordance
16Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Helping
17Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Participating
18Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
DebianWomen● training and providing support for
women interested in Debian and FLOSS
● organising online tutorials, bugsquashing parties, mentoring
● 9 female Debian Developers (total 1049 DD to date 20Nov07, 0.8% women)
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Female Memberships● computer security analysts● programmers● system administrators● translators● anthropologists
21Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Bodies and Technologies● ICTs used: mailing lists, irc, cvs, wiki, webpages● common participants: names● issues: events, problems, sharing information
(forwarding messages)● (technologicaloriented) experiences embedded
in the conversation about fixing problems or bugs● emotions
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
I’m one of these males on #debianwoman and mailling list. I found your “debianfriendly” project idea extremely interesting. I’d like a more collaborative and less competitive Debian world and I think that’s exactly why DW has been so successful.—Carlos (comment) March 31, 2005 @ 8:51 am
I’m not a developer and have never been on debianwomen or any other developer site/group/list but I use debianuser a lot and do think there’s something gettting very struck about the culture: a focus on programming and fixing compatibility problems but in a rather macho way. The result is that we don’t have a good hardware compatibility list for Debian, we don’t have good documentation, we don’t have good ways the expertise on, say, the user list, creates FAQs etc. I’m not sure what the answer is but I think it is linked with a stereotypically Western male gendered component to the problem. If there’s a way I can help I’ll try but time is very limited sadly.Chris (male, end user of Debian for years now)—Chris Evans (comment)April 10, 2005 @ 3:30 pm
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
The DW project got my attention because it promoted a “positive, welcoming and friendly atmosphere” still I did not try to participate because I’m, well… male.
I would very much like to see a “positive, welcoming and friendly atmosphere” Debian project for all people.
—Tim Blokdijk (comment)April 06, 2005 @ 4:07 pm
Sometimes I get worry about the idea of the “invasion” by men in womengroups… but is interesting to see this places like “friendly places” where everybody can have access to (without gender specific).—gaba (comment)April 09, 2005 @ 2:19 am
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Where the joy lies?
●SELFREFLECTION● (Emotion + Body + Technology)
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
But we have achieved *a lot*. I don't feel anymore it is a taboo to talk about females within Debian (be it Developers, Translators, Users or whatever form of involvement), and are no longer stuck with XXL night-gown sized tshirts in Debconf (LOL). To me it has made a great difference and my involvement in the project feels more "normalized" to me.
Also, in RL meetings, the default assumption that the attending females were $girlfriends of some male "actually" interested in the meeting has decreassed significantly.
I don't know whether it is related, but since Debian Women exists the feeling of a "social" community on top of the "technical" community has been much reinforced. This might be my subjective perception of "belonging" to this community, improved by the existance of other females in it, and other members of the project being welcoming and inclusive about us. (DWZL220106)
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
% M W U200506 61,88 36,78 1,34200507 56,01 40,72 3,27200508 60,02 37,49 2,49200509 52,66 42,66 4,68200510 50,3 42,37 7,33200511 58,05 36,57 5,38200512 65,14 30,58 4,28200601 59,69 37,89 2,42200602 70,8 26,96 2,24200603 70,72 28,4 0,88200604 73,54 25,58 0,88
As one can see, even if I can't "identify" one third of the people, I have identified the most contributing people.
I see an interesting tendency for men participation to increase while women participation decreases. I already have this feeling for quite a long time but it seems that numbers are proving me correct. Is it good or bad: I leave this up to you, people...:)
(CPDW250406)
Statistics about the IRC channel
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
I'm not sure if it's inherent aggression in male communication style as much as it's simply how communication on a "realtime" textbased medium goes. A situation where are several people in one "area" holding several different conversations is much different than say Jabber or AIM where you are speaking directly to one person, and you wait for their response before you type again. Sometimes comments get lost in the shuffle because people are trying to follow multiple conversations, other times that conversation thread simply dies out. I don't attribute this to inherent aggression of males, but rather the way conversations flow on IRC.
I tried to introduce family members to IRClike gathering areas, thinking it would be worthwhile to actually be able to hold conversations with more than one person at a time. It very much didn't work. They felt the same way that people were "talking over" them, ignoring them that they couldn't keep up with everything going on because one group of people was talking about one thing, another about a completely different topic and yet another group of people poking fun at each other. They gave up because they just couldn't catch up and keep up with the conversation flows.
(PLDW260406)Practice + Experience + Body + Technology
28Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
GenderChangers Academy● since Nov. 1999
● ladies only● /etc eclectic tech carnival
● The /etc is named after the directory in which *nix systems store system configuration files.
● DIY or DIO (handson training)● exchanging computer related skills
● grass root and local
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
The Eclectic Tech Carnival
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Memberships● system and network administrators● anthropologists● artists● musicians● accountants● social workers
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
events in 2007● September 3: A bit of everything. Get together,
exchange experiences, lounge, cook, eat and watch a geek movie.
● October 1: Computer Hardware Crash Course● November 5: Introducing Free Software.
Installation, configuration and use of a few of the best FLOSS applications
● December 3: Building and managing a Website: HTML and CSS
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Ladyfest.net● Ladyfest is a volunteer run
DIY festival of music, art, performance and workshops. It helps to showcase the skills and talents of a diverse group of people.
● Lecture Evening Virtual Identities and female Internet Networks. Sara and Nancy from the Genderchanger Academy speaking about female networks (IRC)
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
How Girls Make Knowledge● coding knowledge is still considered as more
advanced (reproduction of hegemonic mainstream hacker culture)
● layered & networked & embodied epistemic cultures● rationality + sensitivity = hybrid: femininities
(complex, layered, strategic, adaptive, emotional) + masculinities (disconnected, emotionally avoidant, instrumental, simplistic)
36Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Achievements
● visibility & awareness raising● identity building (exploring & experimenting)● knowledge sharing, mutual learning and support
(“a lowRTFM environment)● creating a more intimate collaborative space● beyond the simplistic categories of gender talks,
it's women's play embodied in these online narratives; a women's version of 'just for fun'
37Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Women's Play on GNU/Linux● strengthens the importance of networking, sharing
experiences and problemsolving tips, of socialising and social capitals in FLOSS dev.
● creating a more harmonised & reflexive space● In Janice Raymond's words: 'The empowering of
female friendship can create the conditions for a new feminist politics in which the personal is most passionately political'.
● resistance & change; sameness and differences
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Mihmointeraction designer at Red Hat's engineering department
cofounder of GnomeWomen
LinuxChix appears to be succeeding on these fronts. However, as large as the group seems to be, I'm somewhat skeptical that it's produced many open source *developers*. Think of it this way,
only men write books and women and men read books. It's good that there are literate women, but if the books are created only by
men, then a male perspective will dominate. I use this analogy because I have thought for a long time that programming is a new
literarcy, and that as computers become more and more pervasive in everyday life, those who fail to gain some ability in
programming will be left behind.http://mihmo.livejournal.com/6071.html
Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Anne NicolasDirector of Engineering at Parisbased Mandriva
As a woman, I feel like a human being working with other human beings (I hope so :) ). So one may encounter
relationship problems in this team as in any other field. It's hard to avoid bias, and of course the Linux world is also
suffering because it. But I must say I haven't had any major problems until now (I cross my fingers twice :) ). I think the most important words are open mind and dialogue, sane
discussions and respect. Yes, there are very few women in the Linux world, but it's up to them to contribute and to
become part of it. It's just a question of interest.http://distrowatch.com/weekly.php?issue=20071022#interview
40Codes and Conduct Workshop, 1920 November 2007, Lancaster
Whose Wonder Woman?Whose Female Hacker? Global or Local versions?