Crowdsourcing a strategy for #FutureNHS#AHPsMandate
Suzanne RastrickChief Allied Health Professions Officer
Dr Joanne FillinghamClinical Fellow to the Chief Allied Health Professions Officer
NHS Five Year Forward View
• Published in October 2014
• A shared vision across seven national bodies
• New care models programme key to delivery
• Focuses on both NHS and care services
The challenges we face
Radical upgrade in prevention
Health and wellbeing
gap1
New care models
Care and quality gap
2
Efficiency and investmentFunding gap 3
3
2015-16CAHPO visits.
Agreement that gains can be made for all AHPs and the health and care by working towards common goals and challenges together. • National conversation about
collective impact of AHPs• What do we need to start, stop,
or differently?• Examples of how we are doing
this already.
Professional bodies workshopAHP strategy?
A mandate for change.
The obvious reasons for using crowd-sourcing in place of traditional methods are:• engage more people within the process of solving challenges and generating
insight;• engage people that are time constrained and geographically dispersed;• reduce engagement costs – using less resource and time to reach out to staff and
customers to get feedback;• reduce the innovation cycle time – creating collective insight and catalysing
collective action, fast.• We’ve also found a reason that is much more important – half of the best ideas lie
within the 80% of people who normally don’t contribute.*Clever Together http://clevertogether.com/web/
Why crowdsource?“helping great leaders listen and empowering great people to be heard”*
Crowdsourcing is a process of empowering people to solve challenges and generate collective insight.
#strongertogether
Ultimately…..
Content analysis overviewA thematic analysis approach to understand the contributions shared was used.
• Joanne Fillingham, with the support of Clever Together, facilitated and analysed all of the contributions shared in our first online conversation.
• This thematic analysis approach included– Reading through all of the contributions and clustering them into different
themes and subthemes.– Creating a narrative for each theme directly using contributions from the online
workshop.– Resulting in draft statements to present back for validation and improvement.
• 94% of coding was agreed by five regional AHP leads. The outstanding 6% was re-analysed.
Feb/March • Professional bodies workshop 17 Feb 2016• Review of national documents, polices and publications.
Apr/May• Phase one - online workshop launched 18 April & extended to
6 May.• Thematic analysis.
June • Thematic analysis and draft emerging mandate.• CAHPO Conference 23 June – validation and improvement.
July/Aug• Online workshop open to AHPs and wider stakeholders on 4th
July until 15 July.• Thematic analysis and write mandate for change.
September • Formal processes for sign off.
October • Launch Mandate for Change #AHPsmandate
Towards a mandate for change.
Engagement – How? Who with?AHP networkOwn organisationDirect invite by emailProfessional bodySocial mediaNominated by a colleagueNHS EmployersWord of mouthNHS EnglandNHS England website/blogOther/blankCAHPRClever TogetherHealth Educaton EnglandHealth WatchCouncil of DeansNHS Commissioners
How?- Email- Platform- Nomination
Across England and the UK…
…and wherever they were in the world!
Phase One – 18th April 2016Generating Insight
18.04.16
19.04.16
20.04.16
21.04.16
22.04.16
23.04.16
24.04.16
25.04.16
26.04.16
27.04.16
28.04.16
29.04.16
30.04.16
01.05.16
02.05.16
03.05.16
04.05.16
05.06.16
06.05.160
50
100
150
200
250
300
Phase One - Logins
18.04.16
19.04.16
20.04.16
21.04.16
22.04.16
23.04.16
24.04.16
25.04.16
26.04.16
27.04.16
28.04.16
29.04.16
30.04.16
01.05.16
02.05.16
03.05.16
04.05.16
05.06.16
06.05.160
40
80
120
160
Phase One Ideas and Comments
Ideas Comments
18.04.16
19.04.16
20.04.16
21.04.16
22.04.16
23.04.16
24.04.16
25.04.16
26.04.16
27.04.16
28.04.16
29.04.16
30.04.16
01.05.16
02.05.16
03.05.16
04.05.16
05.06.16
06.05.160
200400600800
1000120014001600
Phase One - Votes
www.england.nhs.uk
Which professions took part?
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
England AHP HCPC registrants 2016 Engaged in online workshop
www.england.nhs.uk
Smaller AHP professions keen to have their voice heard.
0.00%4.00%8.00%
England AHP HCPC registrants 2016Engaged in online workshop
www.england.nhs.uk
AHP professions needing encouragementData saturation reached by third week.
Diagnostic & Therapeutic Radiographer
Paramedic Chiropodists/Podiatrist Prosthetist/Orthotist0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
England AHP HCPC registrants 2016 Engaged in online workshop
High level findings
Defining our potential revealed:4 ways AHPs will impact health & wider care system.4 areas of commitment to achieve this change.
Realising our potential revealed:4 themes which AHPs need to focus on with, 16 specific enablers that will help us to honour the commitments.
“I honestly believe that if all AHPs in England were used effectively, it would signal the total transformation of health and social care which we desperately need. We save lives, we rebuild lives and we do it all at a fraction of the cost of other colleagues. We understand the medical but crucially, we understand the social determinants of health -education, poverty, housing, stigma”.
Phase Two – 4th July 2016Quality Assurance
Do you agree/disagree?
04.07.16
05.07.16
06.07.16
07.07.16
08.07.16
09.07.16
10.07.16
11.07.16
12.07.16
13.07.16
14.07.16
15.07.160
50
100
150
200
250
300
Phase Two - Logins
04.07.16
05.07.16
06.07.16
07.07.16
08.07.16
09.07.16
10.07.16
11.07.16
12.07.16
13.07.16
14.07.16
15.07.160
20406080
100120140160180
Phase Two - Comments
04.07.16
05.07.16
06.07.16
07.07.16
08.07.16
09.07.16
10.07.16
11.07.16
12.07.16
13.07.16
14.07.16
15.07.160
100200300400500600700800900
1000
Phase Two - Votes
www.england.nhs.uk
Physiotherapist
Occupational th
erapist
Diagnosti
c & Thera
peutic Radiogra
pher
Paramedic
Speech
and Languag
e Therapist
Chiropodist
s/Podiat
rist
Dietitian
Orthoptist
Art, M
usic &
Drama Thera
pist
Prosth
etist/Orth
otistNurse
Other healt
h and ca
re staff
Blank/O
ther0.00%5.00%
10.00%15.00%20.00%25.00%30.00%
England AHP HCPC registrants 2016 Engaged in online workshop phase oneEngaged in online workshop phase one and two
Operating Department Practitioner, Healthcare Scientist, Psychologist, Assistant/Support worker, Doctor, Patient/Service User, Dentist, Pharmacist, Fireman, Carer.
Who took part?
“As a patient I am pleased to see the recognition of individual and population/community wellbeing as this is interlinked. There is huge potential for AHP to become strong bridge builders between healthcare and patients/citizens/communities helping to renegotiate the relationship between citizens and health/healthcare, e.g. implementing shared decision and co-production approaches, promoting self-care and education, being the pioneers of using digital as an enabler etc”.
TOTAL1949
people engaged16,128
contributions
Thank you#AHPsmandate launched October 2016
“I’m a qualitative researcher and listening to what you have done I just think that it sounds like a superb piece of work to me. It just sounds so valid, it sounds reliable, because you have got people’s voices and you have gone out to so many people, it just sounds brilliant. So I am really looking forward to it being published in October, can’t wait”.