Craig D. Jerald, Break the Curve Craig D. Jerald, Break the Curve ConsultingConsulting
NSBA 2009 Federal Relations ConferenceNSBA 2009 Federal Relations Conference
Washington, DC Washington, DC February 1, 2009 February 1, 2009
Preparing Preparing StudentsStudents
for thefor the
21 21 stst CenturyCentury
2© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
I. How is the world changing?I. How is the world changing?
3© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Forces changing skill demandsForces changing skill demands
Automation
Globalization
Workplace change
Demographic change
Personal risk and responsibility
4© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
AutomationAutomation
5© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
What kinds of work can What kinds of work can computers do?computers do?
Follow routine directions: Any job where information can be digitized and key tasks can be broken down into a set of predictable rules.
► EG, Airline reservations, tickets, boarding passes. Now you can complete the whole process without ever talking to a human being!
Recognize simple patterns.► EG, On the telephone, recognizing simple sentences in
response to prompts, then providing the appropriate information or connecting to the appropriate human.
6© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Changing mix of jobs in the Changing mix of jobs in the economyeconomy
12%14%
38%
18%
8%
22%25%
33%
12%14%
0%
40%
Blue collarworkers
Admin supportworkers
Sales relatedoccupations
Technicians,professionals,
managers,administrators
Serviceworkers
1969 1999
Source: Levy, F. & Murnane, R. J. (2004). The new division of labor: How computers are creating the next job market. Princeton, NJ: Russell Sage Foundation. (p. 42, Figure 3.2)
Pe
rce
nt
of
em
plo
yed
ad
ults
Pe
rce
nt
of
em
plo
yed
ad
ults
7© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Job tasks are changing across the Job tasks are changing across the economyeconomy
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
1969 1980 1990 1998
Per
cen
tile
Ch
ang
e in
196
9 D
istr
ibu
tio
n
Complex Communication
Expert Thinking
Routine Manual
Routine Thinking
Source: Levy, F. & Murnane, R. J. (2004). The new division of labor: How computers are creating the next job market. Princeton, NJ: Russell Sage Foundation. (p. 50, Figure 3.5)
8© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
What kinds of work What kinds of work can’tcan’t computers do (yet)?computers do (yet)?
Non-routine manual labor:► EG, driving a truck, security guard, etc.
Non-routine thinking work:► “Expert Thinking”—The ability to solve unexpected
problems for which there are no predictable and programmable rule-based solutions.
► “Complex Communications”—Interacting with other people to acquire information, explain it, or persuade with it.
► Doing both well also requires creativity, which computers also are not very good at.
9© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Automation has big Automation has big consequences for educationconsequences for education
Computers can follow directions better, faster, and cheaper than human beings, and the number of tasks computers can do grows every year.
Any curriculum that emphasizes following directions to find a single correct answer is, by definition, preparing students for jobs that probably will not exist by the time those students graduate.
“To educate our children to compete with either a computer [is to educate them for] a competition they cannot win.”
—Frank Levy and Richard Murnane (2007)
10© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
GlobalizationGlobalization
11© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Work can increasingly be done Work can increasingly be done anywhere … and there are more anywhere … and there are more workers who can do it!workers who can do it!
Technological advances (internet, interactive software, digital technologies) allow work to be carved up and shipped around globe.
Historic political and economic changes around the globe freed up more than 1 billion people—in places like Russia, Eastern Europe, China, India, etc.—who could potentially compete for that work.
“The result is a world in which it is just as easy to create work teams composed of people on four continents as it is to create work teams composed of people from four divisions of the same firm located in the same city.”
—the New Commission on the Skills of the American workforce (2007)
12© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Implications for your studentsImplications for your students
“Suddenly more people from more different places could collaborate with more other people on more different kinds of work and share more different kinds of knowledge than ever before.”
—Thomas Friedman (2005)
“Highly skilled people with roughly the same qualifications are competing directly with each other, no matter where they are located on the globe.”
—the New Commission on the Skills of the American workforce (2007)
Sources: 1) National Center on Education and the Economy. (2007). Tough choices or tough times: The report of the New Commission on the Skills of the American workforce. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. (p. 19)2) Friedman, T. L. (2005). The world is flat: A brief history of the twenty-first century. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. (p. 81)
13© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
National implications, too:National implications, too:Human capital has a big impact Human capital has a big impact on economic growthon economic growth
If the U.S. improved students’ performance on international tests to the level of top performing nations, its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) would be:
► An additional 5 percent higher 32 years from now (enough to entirely pay for K-12 education), and
► An additional 36 percent higher 75 years from now!
Source: Hanushek, E. A. & Woessmann, L. (2008, September). The role of cognitive skills in economic development. Journal of Economic Literature, 46(3), 607–68. (p. 650)
14© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Impact of higher math & science scores Impact of higher math & science scores on economic growth, on economic growth, projections through 2064projections through 2064
If it took 10 years to meet goal
If it took 20 years to meet goal
If it took 30 yearsTo reach goal
Total U.S. K-12 spending
0
10
20
30
40
1989
1994
1999
2004
2014
2019
2024
2029
2034
2039
2044
2049
2054
2059
2064
Percent addition to GDP from raising U.S. math and science scores to near top in the world
NOTE: “K-12 education expenditures are assumed to be constant at the level attained in 2005. These data show that economic benefits from a 1989 reform that raised the U.S. to the highest levels of test performance would cover the cost of K-12 education by 2015.”Source: Hanushek, E. A., et al. (2008, Spring). Education and economic growth. Education Next, 8(2), 62-70. (p. 69)
15© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Workplace changeWorkplace change
16© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Major shifts in the workplaceMajor shifts in the workplace
Companies focusing more on providing information than “things.”
Companies are “flatter,” with less hierarchy and less direct supervision.
Employees have more autonomy and responsibility. Work is much more collaborative. Jobs are less routine, predictable, and stable.
17© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Growth of the information-service Growth of the information-service economyeconomy
19%
35%
11%
36%
11%
56%
7%
27%
0%
60%
Material products Material services Informationproducts
Informationservices
1967 1997
Source: Apte, U. M., Karmarkar, U. S., & Nath, H. K. (2008, Spring). Information services in the U.S. economy: Value, jobs, and management implications. California Management Review, 50(3), 12-30.(p. 18, Table I)
Sh
are
of
US
GD
PS
ha
re o
f U
S G
DP
18© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
More collaboration in the More collaboration in the workplaceworkplace
In top 1,000 companies:
Use of self-managing work teams rose from 28% in 1988 to 65% in 2005.
Work teams are increasingly global.
19© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Work has become more challenging Work has become more challenging … and more satisfying… and more satisfying
27%
66%
28%32%
45%
20%
69%
45%
62%
55%
0%
75%
My job lets me usemy skills and
abilities
It is basically myresponsibility todecide how myjob gets done
My job requiresthat I learn new
things
My job requiresthat I be creative
The work I do ismeaningful to me
1977 2002
Source: O’Toole, J. & Lawler, E.E. III. (2006). The new American workplace. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. (p. 55)
Pe
rce
nt
of
wo
rke
rs w
ho
“st
ron
gly
ag
ree
”P
erc
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
wh
o “
stro
ng
ly a
gre
e”
20© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Demographic changeDemographic change
21© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
A more diverse population: A more diverse population: “Minorities” will be U.S. majority in “Minorities” will be U.S. majority in about 30 Yearsabout 30 Years
42%45% 47% 49% 51%
54%
34%
40%38%35%
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
2008 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
Per
cen
t o
f p
op
ula
tio
n N
OT
no
n-H
isp
anic
wh
ite
Source: Census Bureau. (2008, August 14). An older and more diverse nation by mid-century. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor. (Table 3: Projections of the Population by Race and Hispanic Origin for the United States 2008 to 2050)
22© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
More diverse populationMore diverse population
Entire U.S. population = 2042
Working-age population =2039
School-age population = 2023
Year in which “minorities” will become the majority of …
Source: Census Bureau. (2008, August 14). An older and more diverse nation by mid-century. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor.
23© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
More diverse populationMore diverse population
Schools will need to be able to educate a more diverse student population
Schools will need to prepare students to interact in a more diverse society and collaborate in a more diverse work environment
► More diverse U.S. society, which will be reflected in the workplace, but also …
► International collaboration, global work teams
Implications:
24© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Aging populationAging population
By the time the last Baby Boomer reaches 65 in 2030, nearly one out of five U.S. residents will be 65 or older.
Between 2008 and 2050 …► The 65 and older population will DOUBLE► The 85 and older population will TRIPLESource: Census Bureau. (2008, August 14). An older and more diverse nation by mid-century. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor.
“Fewer of us will have to support many more of us than has ever been the case before.”
Source: National Center on Education and the Economy. (2007). Tough choices or tough times: The report of the New Commission on the Skills of the American workforce. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. (p. 7).
25© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Personal risk and responsibilityPersonal risk and responsibility
26© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Shift in corporate benefit policiesShift in corporate benefit policies
Job security: employment more contingent on performance than loyalty
Financial planning: more 401(k)s, fewer defined-benefit plans
Health care: consumers increasingly called on to choose own coverage & care
Individuals now shoulder more responsibility for personal well-being:
27© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Employment is less secure: Those who Employment is less secure: Those who cannot perform will not keep their jobscannot perform will not keep their jobs
67%
77%
5%
60%
29%
16%
0%
80%
Rewards tiedto seniority
Loyalty tocompany isrewarded
Continuedemployment
based ondeveloping
skills &knowledge
Rewards tiedto individualperformance
Rewards tiedto groupand/or
companyperformance
Continuedemployment
based onperformance
Source: O’Toole, J. & Lawler, E.E. III. (2006). The new American workplace. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. (p. 67)
In the late 1980s, 56% of corporate managers said loyal employees deserve continued employment.
Pe
rce
nt
of
ma
na
ge
rs r
esp
on
din
g “
tru
e”
to
Pe
rce
nt
of
ma
na
ge
rs r
esp
on
din
g “
tru
e”
to
“gre
at”
or
“ve
ry g
rea
t” e
xte
nt
“gre
at”
or
“ve
ry g
rea
t” e
xte
nt
28© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Retirement coverage is shifting toward Retirement coverage is shifting toward individually controlled investmentsindividually controlled investments
Pension plans with investments controlled by employers are being replaced by IRAs and 401(k)s that require individuals to make at least some investment decisions.
Retirement was once something that workers did not have to think a lot about. Today, they do have to think about it, and how well they think about can have huge consequences for their future well-being.
29© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Consumers are asked to make own Consumers are asked to make own decisions about health care and costsdecisions about health care and costs
Health coverage choices are more complicated and varied
Information about the quality of health care providers and treatment effectiveness is more transparent and accessible
“Consumers therefore require more knowledge and greater skill to take full advantage of new sources of information and to make appropriate choices.”
Hibbard, Peters, Dixon & TuslerConsumer competencies and the use of comparative
quality information, 2007
30© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
II. What kind of knowledge and II. What kind of knowledge and skills will young people need?skills will young people need?
31© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
More important in the 21More important in the 21stst Century Century
Postsecondary education and training Academic knowledge and skills Practical literacies: The ability to use knowledge
of math, English, science, civics etc. to meet real-world challenges.
Broader competencies: Critical thinking and problem solving, communications and collaboration, creativity, self-sufficiency etc.
32© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Occupations requiring more Occupations requiring more education are predicted to grow education are predicted to grow fasterfaster
7.7
14.8
10.5
0
16
High school or less Some college or postsectraining
Bachelor's or higher
Pe
rce
nt
ch
an
ge
, 20
06-
16
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2008, February). Occupational projections and training data: 2008-9 edition. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor. (p. 4, Table I-3)
Projected growth in jobs requiring …
33© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Nearly two-thirds of new jobs will Nearly two-thirds of new jobs will require postsecondary education or require postsecondary education or trainingtraining
36%
33%
31%
High school or less Some college or postsec training Bachelor's or higher
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2008, February). Occupational projections and training data: 2008-9 edition. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor. (p. 4, Table I-3)
New jobs, 2006-2016:
34© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Earnings boost for college degree Earnings boost for college degree has grown immenselyhas grown immensely
53%
13%-
6%
14%
40%
-30%
-10%
10%
30%
50%
H.S. dropout H.S. graduate Some college Bachelor's Graduate orprofessional
degree
Per
cen
t ch
ang
e in
co
nst
an
t do
llars
Source: Mortenson, T. (2007, November). Average family income by educational attainment of householder 1967 to 2006. Postsecondary Education Opportunity, 185. (p. 15)
Change in average family income from 1973 to 2006:
35© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Income inequality has increased Income inequality has increased massively over last 40 years driven massively over last 40 years driven by demand for high-skilled workersby demand for high-skilled workers
$186,529
$101,467
$57,464
$42,847
$29,810
$13,331
$38,304
$61,444
$91,881
$16,068
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
Lowest fifth Second fifth Middle fifth Fourth fifth Highest fifth
Income group
Fam
ily
inco
me
in 2
007
do
llar
s
1967 2007
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Historical Income Tables - Families, Table F-3 Mean Income Received by Each Fifth and Top 5 Percent of Families, All Races: 1966 to 2007, http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/income/histinc/f03AR.html
36© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Academics count: Preparing Academics count: Preparing students for college and workstudents for college and work
Completing advanced math courses in high school has a greater influence on
whether students will graduate from college than any other factor, including
family background; students who take math beyond Algebra II double their
chances of earning a bachelor’s degree.
Just taking advanced math has a direct impact on future earnings, apart from any
other factors; students who take advanced math have higher incomes ten years
after graduating—regardless of family background, classroom grades, and
college degrees.
Recent studies suggest that higher math skills at the end of high school*
translates into a 12 percent boost in wages. (* Scoring one standard deviation
higher on a standardized math test.)
37© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Advanced math improves earningsAdvanced math improves earnings
5.5%
3.1%
3.2%4.2%
6.5%
1.6%3.0%
4.6% 4.6%0.7%
0%
15%
Pre-algebra Algebra/geometry
Algebra II Trig/ Pre-cal Calculus
Due to college completion boost Due to cognitive boost
Source: Rose, H. & Betts, J. R. (2004, May). The effect of high school courses on earnings. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(2), 497-513. Based on data in Table 2 on p. 501.
Incr
ea
se in
ea
rnin
gs
ass
oci
ate
d w
ith m
ath
co
urs
eta
ken
in h
igh
sch
oo
l
38© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Math skills are more consistently Math skills are more consistently related to postsecondary success related to postsecondary success than other competenciesthan other competencies
0.005
0.015
0.018
0.003
0.007
0.0000.001
0.008
0.017
0.010
0.002
0.024
0.015
0.037
0.029
0.011
0.004
0.029
0.000
0.010
0.020
0.030
0.040
Enroll in postsecondary ed Earn a bachelor's degree EarningsMa
rgin
al i
mp
ac
t o
f 1
0 p
erc
en
tag
e p
oin
t in
cre
as
e in
ea
ch
co
mp
ete
nc
y
Math test score Work habits Sports-related competenciesProsocial behavior Leadership roles Locus of control
Source: Deke, D. & Haimson, J. (2006, September 15). Valuing student competencies: Which ones predict postsecondary educational attainment and earnings, and for whom? Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. (p. 21, TABLE IV.1)NOTE: Only the values at or above the red line were statistically significant.
39© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
The screening test for electrician The screening test for electrician apprenticeshipsapprenticeships
Source: National Joint Apprenticeship and Training Committee for the Electrical Construction and Maintenance Industry, http://www.njatc.org/training/apprenticeship/index.aspx
40© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Trades becoming more technical, Trades becoming more technical, requiring stronger math & readingrequiring stronger math & reading
“Don't be influenced by those who see the electrical construction trade as an occupation requiring only a strong back and a weak mind. The electrical trades are becoming more technical each day.”
—Website of the Electrical Training Institute of Southern California
“If you want to work in the real world, if you want to wire buildings and plumb buildings, that's when it requires algebra.”
—Don Davis, executive director of the Electrical Training Institute of Southern California (Los Angeles Times, January 30, 2006)
41© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Trades becoming more technical, Trades becoming more technical, requiring stronger math & readingrequiring stronger math & reading
ACT Study: The math and reading skills required for electricians, construction workers, upholsterers, and plumbers same as what’s necessary to succeed in first-year college courses!
… but those skills are also increasingly important OUTSIDE of jobs!
ACT, Readiness for College and Readiness for Work: ACT, Readiness for College and Readiness for Work: Same or Different, Iowa City, IA. 2006 Same or Different, Iowa City, IA. 2006
42© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Financial planning: Major shift in Financial planning: Major shift in retirement coverageretirement coverage
11%
61%
28%
60%
17%
23%
0%
75%
Defined benefit only Defined contribution only BothPe
rcen
t o
f p
riv
ate
se
cto
r w
ork
ers
with
pen
sio
n c
ov
era
ge 1980 2004
Source: Munnell, A. H., Haverstick, K., & Sanzenbacher, G. (2006, October). Job tenure and the spread of 401(k)s. Boston, MA: Center for Retirement Research at Boston College. (p. 1, Figure 1)
43© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Health care: Numeracy mattersHealth care: Numeracy matters
Have worse understanding of risks and make worse decisions about the benefits of mammography and experimental cancer treatments ;
Have a harder time taking prescribed medications (inhaled steroids, anticoagulation drugs) and as a result worse health outcomes and more hospitalizations ;
Have a harder time comprehending nutrition labels important for patients with chronic illnesses like hypertension and diabetes ;
Have a harder time comprehending information about health coverage options and make less informed choices about health plans ; and
Choose lower quality hospitals than more numerate patients when given the same information on medical outcomes.
Patients with lower math literacy:
44© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Stronger literacy, more job success and Stronger literacy, more job success and more more civic engagement!civic engagement!
68%73%
45%
73%76%
86%
57%
84%
45%41%
18%
54%56%62%
31%
57%
0%
100%
Employed Earn $500+ per week Volunteered in pastyear
Voted in lastpresidential election
Pe
rce
nta
ge
of
U.S
. ad
ult
s b
y p
ros
e li
tera
cy
lev
el
Below basic Basic Intermediate Proficient
Source: Kutner, M., Greenberg, E., Jin, Y., Boyle, B., Hsu, Y., & Dunleavy, E. (2007). Literacy in everyday life: Results from the 2003 National Assessment of Adult Literacy. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
45© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
64%
66%
67%
67%
74%
74%
75%
75%
63%
64%
64%
64%
50% 75%
Foreign languages
Self-direction/Lifelong learning
Written communications
Ethics
Work ethic
Oral communications
Leadership
Handling diversity
Creativity/Innovation
Teamwork/Collaboration
Information technology application
Critical thinking/Problem solving
Percent of employers who believe skill will become more important over next five years
Broad competencies: Employers Broad competencies: Employers expect them to become more expect them to become more importantimportant
Source: Conference Board. (2006). Are they really ready to work? (p. 49, Table 12)
46© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Broad Competencies: Which are Broad Competencies: Which are most critical? The 3 C’s!most critical? The 3 C’s!
Critical thinking and problem solving► Labor economists Levy & Murnane call it “expert thinking”
Communication/Collaboration► Levy and Murnane call it “complex communications”
Creativity
47© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Solve This ProblemSolve This Problem
Suppose you are a doctor faced with a patient who has a malignant tumor in his stomach. It is impossible to operate on the patient, but unless the tumor is destroyed the patient will die. There is a kind of ray that can be used to destroy the tumor. If the rays reach the tumor all at once at a sufficiently high intensity, the tumor will be destroyed. Unfortunately, at this intensity the healthy tissue that the rays pass through on the way to the tumor will also be destroyed. At lower intensities the rays are harmless to healthy tissue, but they will not affect the tumor either. What type of procedure might be used to destroy the tumor with the rays, and at the same time avoid destroying the healthy tissue?
48© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Critical Thinking & Problem Critical Thinking & Problem Solving: Important for high school Solving: Important for high school grads entering workforcegrads entering workforce
Nearly 60% of employers rate critical thinking and problem solving as “very important” for h.s. grads entering the workforce … yet 70% of employers rate them “deficient” in those skills.
While 73% of school superintendents think h.s. grads meet expectations for “problem solving,” only 45% percent of employers think so.
78% of employers expect critical thinking/problem solving to become even more important in the near future.
Sources: 1) Conference Board. (2006, October). Are they really ready to work? New York: Author. (p. 21, Table 3 and p. 32, Table 6)2) Conference Board. (2008, March). Ready to innovate: Are educators and executives aligned on the creative readiness of the U.S. workforce? New York: Author.
49© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Here’s another problemHere’s another problem
A small country was ruled from a strong fortress by a dictator. The fortress was situated in the middle of the country, surrounded by farms and villages. Many roads led to the fortress through the countryside. A rebel general vowed to capture the fortress. The general knew that an attack by his entire army would capture the fortress. He gathered his army at the head of one of the roads, ready to launch a full-scale direct attack.
However, the general then learned that the dictator had planted mines on each of the roads. The mines were set so that small bodies of men could pass over them safely, since the dictator needed to move his troops and workers to and from the fortress. However, any large force would detonate the mines. Not only would this blow up the road, but it would also destroy many neighboring villages. It therefore seemed impossible to capture the fortress.
50© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Did you see the pattern?Did you see the pattern?
Both problems have essentially the same answer: Dispersal of strength and re-gathering of strength at the point of attack.
Solving problems is hard because you get stuck on the surface facts and don’t see the deeper patterns and relationships.
51© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Critical Thinking & Problem Critical Thinking & Problem Solving: Require deep content Solving: Require deep content knowledgeknowledge
Cognitive scientists used to believe that “thinking skills” could be taught directly and then applied to any situation.
Now they believe that’s wrong. Critical thinking is not a generic skill, but rather tied closely to contextual knowledge—deep understanding of the topic in question.
What is “deep knowledge”? Getting below the surface:► WHATs: Factual knowledge about the field, and► WHYs & HOWs: How those facts fit together, how and why
things are the way they are, and how things work the way they do.
52© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Communication & Collaboration: Which Communication & Collaboration: Which interpersonal skills need most work?interpersonal skills need most work?
47%
21%
12%
28%
10% 8%
81%
35%
54%
0%
100%
Written communications Oral communications Teamwork/collaborationPe
rce
nta
ge
of
em
plo
ye
rs r
ati
ng
en
tra
nts
as
"d
efi
cie
nt"
H.S. grads 2-yr college grads 4-yr college grads
Source: Conference Board. (2006, October). Are they really ready to work? New York: Author. (pp. 32-34, Tables 6-8)
53© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Communication & Collaboration: Communication & Collaboration: What are the most critical sub-skills?What are the most critical sub-skills?
Source: Conference Board. (2006, October). Are they really ready to work? New York: Author. (pp. 32-34, Tables 6-8)
54© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Creativity: Superintendents and Creativity: Superintendents and employers define it differentlyemployers define it differently
23%
48%
14%
47%
24%
37%
0%
60%
Problem identification orarticulation
Problem solving Comfort with "no rightanswer"P
erc
ent
ch
oo
sin
g s
kill
am
on
g t
op
th
ree
fo
r d
em
on
stra
tin
g
cre
ati
vit
y
Employers Superintendents
Source: Conference Board. (2008, March). Ready to innovate: Are educators and executives aligned on the creative readiness of the U.S. workforce? New York: Author. (p.7)
Top choice Top choice
55© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Creativity: Superintendents and Creativity: Superintendents and employers have different views of employers have different views of H.S. grads’ creativity skillsH.S. grads’ creativity skills
57% 58%
75%
33%35%
56%
0%
80%
Comfort with "no rightanswer"
Ability to identify newpatterns of behavior ornew combinations of
action
Fundamental curiosityPe
rcen
t w
ho
say
H.S
. gra
ds
me
et
ex
pe
cta
tio
ns Employers Superintendents
Source: Conference Board. (2008, March). Ready to innovate: Are educators and executives aligned on the creative readiness of the U.S. workforce? New York: Author. (p.7)
56© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
III. Implications for schoolsIII. Implications for schools
57© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
Five big takeawaysFive big takeaways
Students who obtain more education will be at a great advantage; increasingly, some postsecondary education or technical training is essential for an opportunity to support a family or secure a middle-class lifestyle.
The need for traditional knowledge and skills in school subjects like math, language arts, and science is not being “displaced” by a new set of “thinking skills”; in fact, students who take more advanced math courses and master higher math skills, for example, will have a distinct advantage over their peers.
At the same time, for success both on the job and in their personal lives, students must also better learn how to apply what they learn in those subjects to deal with real world challenges, rather than simply “reproduce” the information on tests.
Students who develop an even broader set of in-demand competencies—the ability to think critically about information, solve novel problems, communicate and collaborate, create new products and processes, and adapt to change—will be at an even greater advantage in work and life.
Applied skills and competencies can best be taught in the context of the academic curriculum, not as a replacement for it or “add on” to it; in fact, cognitive research suggests that some competencies like critical thinking and problem solving are highly dependent on deep content knowledge and cannot be taught in isolation.
58© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
And when it comes to competencies And when it comes to competencies … clarity counts!… clarity counts!
1) Is there a shared definition of [critical thinking/collaboration/creativity] in your district, or is everyone free to define it however they want?
2) Does the definition match the real world demand for that skill, e.g., the way employers define it?
3) Is the definition detailed and specific enough so that teachers and students and other stakeholders really understand what is expected of them?
4) Are these skills incorporated into the curriculum, or have you just asked teachers to “address them” somehow?
Don’t assume “everyone knows” what [critical thinking/collaboration/creativity] is. Ask these questions:
59© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
A few policy implicationsA few policy implications
Curriculum► Integrate into curriculum instead of purchasing stand-alone
“thinking skills” programs: They don’t work.► Where is the time for deeper understanding, real world
application, problem solving?► Focus: U.S. tends to have a curriculum that is “a mile wide
and an inch deep”—shallow and repetitive EG, U.S. math textbooks cover almost twice as many topics
per grade as Singapore’s. In Singapore, students expected to complete about one thorough lesson on a single topic per week; in U.S., about one lesson on a narrowly focused topic each day
► More time to explore subjects through open ended problems, collaborative projects, creativity
60© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009© Craig D. Jerald for the Center for Public Education, 2009
A Few Policy ImplicationsA Few Policy Implications
Assessment► Teaching to the state test is too narrow:
EG, Recent study found that math tests in 10 states had too few complex problem solving questions to even measure whether there is a gender gap in such skills let alone whether students are being adequately prepared for real world work.
► Supplement with more challenging local assessments (other countries do that).
► Find early ways to gauge college preparedness, EG ACT’s EPAS system.
► For problem solving and applied literacy, key is to challenge students with less structured, more open ended problems in each subject. OECD’s Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) framework and items can be helpful.
Craig D. Jerald, Break the Curve Craig D. Jerald, Break the Curve ConsultingConsulting
NSBA 2009 Federal Relations ConferenceNSBA 2009 Federal Relations Conference
Washington, DC Washington, DC February 1, 2009 February 1, 2009
Preparing Preparing StudentsStudents
for thefor the
21 21 stst CenturyCentury