Cosmology and Religion —An Outsider’s Study
(Big Bang and Creation)
Dezso Horvá[email protected]
KFKI Research Institute for Particle and Nuclear Physics (RMKI),
Budapest
and Institute of Nuclear Research (ATOMKI), Debrecen
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 1/46
Outline
Big Bang, Inflation.
Lemaître and Einstein.
Evolution and Religion.
Big Bang and Hinduism, Islam,Christianity.
Saint Augustine on Creation.
Saint Augustine on Time.
John Paul II and Stephen Hawking.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 2/46
Warning
Physics is an exact science (collection of formulae)
It is based on precise mathematical formalism.
A theory is valid if quantities calculated with it agreewith experiment.
Real physical terms are measurable quantities, wordsare just words.
Behind the words there are precise mathematics andexperimental evidence
What and how: PhysicsWhy: philosopy?
And theology?
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 3/46
What is Cosmology?
Its subject is the Universe as a whole.
How did it form? (Not why?)
Static, expanding or shrinking?
Open or closed?
Its substance, composition?
Its past and future?
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 4/46
The Story of the Big Bang Theory
Red Shift of Distant Galaxies
Henrietta S. LeavittDistances to galaxies
1908–1912
Vesto SlipherRed shift of galaxies
1912
Edwin HubbleRed shift ∼ distance
1929
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 5/46
Expanding Universe
Cosmological principle: if the expansion linear
v(B/A) = v(C/B) ⇒ v(C/A) = 2v(B/A)
the Universe is homogeneous, it has no special point.
Expanding metric (space, coordinates)
local gravity ⇒ local inhomogenity
Alexander Friedmann, 1922 and Georges Lemaître, 1927
theoretically deduced from general relativity
Nobody believed it (least of all Einstein)
A. Friedmann
G. Lemaître
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 6/46
Hypothesis of the Primeval Atom
Monsignor Georges Henri JosephEdouard Lemaître (1894 – 1966)
Belgian catholic priest and physicsprofessor
(Catholic University of Leuven)
G. Lemaître: The Beginning of the World from the Point ofView of Quantum Theory,
Nature 127 (1931) 706.
The Cosmic Egg exploding at the moment of the creation(A Day Without Yesterday)
A sarcastic Fred Hoyle who believed in a steady Universe:Big Bang theory
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 7/46
Lemaître and EinsteinEinstein in 1927 on Lemaître’s deduction of an
expanding Universe on the basis of general
relativity:
Your math is correct, but your physics is
abominable
Einstein in 1933 at a conference, after
Lemaître’s presentation of the Hypothesis of
the Primeval Atom (although he did not quite
believe it): This is the most beautiful and
satisfactory explanation of creation to which I
have ever listened Lemaître and Einstein, 1933
Slowly developing experimental-theoretical evidence for 30 years
Final proof: Cosmic background radiation, 1964
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 8/46
Cosmic background radiationArno Penzias and Robert Wilson, 1964
(Nobel Prize, 1978)Irreducible microwave background radiation
Model: T = 3 K cosmic MW background (CMB)
COBE: COsmic Background ExperimentT = 2, 728 K, precise temperature curve
Cooling of primordial 3000 K photonsat (1000-fold!) expansion
Local spatial anisotropy: seeds of galaxy formation(Quantum fluctuations before inflation (fast
expansion)?)
Much more precise confirmation:WMAP: Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe
John C. Mather and George F. Smoot (COBE):Nobel Prize, 2006
The COBE space probe
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 9/46
The Big Bang TheoryVisible matter:
∼ 75% hydrogen, ∼ 25% helium, < 1% restHydrogen → helium in stars only, how come so much?
⇒ hot primordial Universe
Origin of Cosmic Microwave Background:30 min after Big Bang: plasma, T = 300 000 000 K.
Radiation dominates, photons in opaque (non-transparent)medium of charged particles
380000 years: cooling to 3000 K, neutral atoms,transparent for photons
By now: space expansion, photons cooled down
Origin of galaxies:Space anisotropy ⇒ gravity wells of dark matter
⇒ dense baryonic matter ⇒ stars form
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 11/46
Hubble telescope: Deep Universe
Observation of a dark spot for 250 days ⇒
> 10000 young galaxies more than 1010 years ago
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 13/46
Hubble telescope: results
Formation of first galaxies500-800 million years after BigBang already
Early galaxies are smaller andless symmetric ⇒ fastformation
Black holes in centers ofgalaxies usual
On the farthest picturesformation of stars seen
Part of Ultra Deep Fieldpicture
galaxies 1010 years ago
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 14/46
Time sequence after Big Bang
Event time temperature ρ1/4
Planck time (inflation ↓?) 10−36 s 1018 GeVGrand Unification 10−32 s 1016 GeVElectroweak ↑?
(bariogenesis) 10−6 s 1015 K 100 GeVQuarks → hadrons 10−4 s 1012 K 100 MeVNucleons 1–1000 s 109 − 1010 K 0,1 – 1 MeVDecoupling 105 year 2500 K 0,1 eVStructure formation > 105 yearToday 13,7 G year 2,7 K 3 · 10−4 eV
Present picture: accelerating expansion of the Universe
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 15/46
Dark energy??
Cosmological constant: Λ > 0
Einstein’s biggest blunder, but true
Gravitating energy of vacuum, > 70% of the total mass!
Large after Big Bang, smaller in early Universe, grows withspace expansion
Dominant today. What is it?
Not vacuum energy: lower by 10−120!(World record for disagreement between theory and
experiment :-)
Not really energy, constant in an equation!
Many models, speculations: inflaton, quintessence,multiverse...
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 16/46
Matter balance today
Friedmann equation (X0: value today, normalized by /H2
0)
8πG3H2
0c2
(ρR0 + ρM0) − kc2
a2
0H2
0
+ Λ
3H2
0
≡
ΩR + ΩM − Ωk + ΩΛ = 1Radiation + matter - curvature + cosm. const. = 1
Universe is flat if Ω0 = ΩR + ΩM + ΩΛ = 1
Present picture: flat, matter-dominated (ΩM >> ΩR)Universe
Cosmological parameters: ΩR, ΩM = ΩB +ΩCDM, ΩΛ, H0
Radiation small, ΩR ∼ 0Baryonic matter (stars, black holes, dust, gas): ΩB ∼ 4%Clustering, non-baryonic, cold dark matter: ΩCDM ∼ 22%
Accelerating expansion: dark energy ΩΛ ∼ 74%
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 17/46
Evolution and Religion
Evolution is crucial forinterpretation of Big Bang
Protestantism mostly rejects evolution
Pius XII already in the 1950’saccepted a partial evolution.
Vatican now fully accepts it.Pope Pius XII
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 19/46
Pope John Paul II on Evolution
John Paul II, Pontifical Academy of Sciences,
1996:
Today ... new knowledge has led to the
recognition of the theory of evolution as more
than a hypothesis. It is indeed remarkable that
this theory has been progressively accepted by
researchers, following a series of discoveries in
various fields of knowledge. The convergence,
neither sought nor fabricated, of the results of
work that was conducted independently is in
itself a significant argument in favor of the
theory.
http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_jp02tc.htm
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 20/46
Evolution and the VaticanFebruary 2009: Archbishop Gianfranco Ravasi, President
of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences at the Vaticanconference for the 150th Anniversary of the publication of
Origin of Species by Charles Darwin:
Although Vatican was hostile to Darwin’s theory in the past,... it has never been formally condemned by the RomanCatholic Church, nor was the book banned. The idea of
evolution could be traced to St Augustine and St ThomasAquinas.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 21/46
St Thomas Aquinas on Evolution
Saint Thomas Aquinas (1224–1274):Summa Theologica
http://www.newadvent.org/summa/
For St. Thomas primordial matter is the common ground ofsubstantial change, the element of indetermination in
corporeal beings. It is a pure potentiality ... It is producedout of nothing and can only cease to be by falling back into
nothingness.http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10053b.htm
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 22/46
Protestantism: Reformed ChurchAs the Reformed Church is not hierarchical, I could not find
official statements, but what I found on the web did notsupport evolution or the Bing Bang theory, interpreting the
Holy Script literally.
Reformed Church in America http://www.rca.org
Protestant Reformed Church in Americahttp://www.prca.org
The first attack against Holy Scripture is rooted in thetheory of the Big Bang. This false teaching ... maintains...
(Beacon Lights, Vol. LIX, No. 7; July 2000)
... claims that the world had its origin in a "big bang" andthat man came from a monkey. It is all rather silly to claim to
find such preposterous things ...Protestant Reformed Theological Journal, April 1997, p. 35
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 23/46
Protestantism: Evangelists
Evangelical Lutheran Church in Americahttp://www.elca.org
Discussion forum on evolution and cosmology
Search: Cosmology — 83 papers, Big Bang — 101 papers
Essays of Big Bang as possible Creation and the role ofGod.
They watch and discuss both science and Vatican theology
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 24/46
Judaism and Modern Science
http://www.faqs.org/faqs/judaism
/FAQ/06-Jewish-Thought/section-4.html
Judaism has a long tradition of not interpreting thecreation narrative of Genesis 1 literally
Maimonides: Literal reading of the opening ofBereshis [Genesis] is for the masses.. Mose ben Maimon
1138 – 1204Some present solutions of the conflict
Rejection of scientific data, complicated interpretation of fossils.
Invoking relativity or whatnot to show that 15 billion years can be5758 years in another frame of reference.
Multiple creation times (dinos belong to a previous one).
Rejection of a literal read of the Torah.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 25/46
Judaism and Big Bang
http://www.judaism.com
Genesis and the Big Bang — The Discovery of HarmonyBetween Modern Science and the Bible
by Gerald L. Schroeder
... this volume presents a compelling argument that theevents of the billions of years that cosmologists sayfollowed the Big Bang and those of the first six days
described in Genesis are, in fact, one and the same —identical realities described in vastly different terms.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 26/46
Hinduism and CreationDick Teresi: Lost Discoveries : The Ancient Roots of Modern
Science–from the Babylonians to the Maya, Simon & Schuster, 2002(excerpts)
Indian cosmologists ... the first to estimate the age of the earth at morethan 4 billion years. They came closest to modern ideas of atomism,
quantum physics, and other current theories. India developed very early,enduring atomist theories of matter. Possibly Greek atomistic thought was
influenced by India, via the Persian civilization.
The cycle of creation and destruction continues forever, manifested in theHindu deity Shiva, Lord of the Dance, who holds the drum that sounds the
universe’s creation in his right hand and the flame that, billions of yearslater, will destroy the universe in his left. Meanwhile Brahma is but one of
untold numbers of other gods dreaming their own universes.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 27/46
Hinduism and CreationR.A.S. Kocha: The Big Bang and the Bhagavad Gita,
Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan, Mumbai, 1991 (excerpts)The early saints of modern day Hinduism knew about this cosmic event
through mystic insight
Brahman representing the Ultimate Reality in Hindu religion appears to benothing but an implicit reference to the Big Bang itself. The word Brahmanis derived from the Sanskrit root brh which means to grow big without limit
and can be an oblique reference to an explosion.... As the point ofsingularity, Brahman is the impersonal absolute of pure timeless
existence.
Various branches treat Creation differently, but all accept evolution.
The Kashmiri cult of Shaivism: The whole universe was at firstconcentrated at one point or dot (Bindu). It is the Primordial Seed of
creation. After a period of germination it undergoes an explosion (Sphota)resulting in the sound (Nada) of creation (OM).
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 28/46
Shintoism and Creation
Creation of Heaven and Earth
Initially, both were combined into a substance analogous toan egg. This mass contained germs within indefinite
borders. As this composition separated, the purer, clearelement rose out, forming Heaven. The denser, impure
substance sank to become Earth. Heaven formed easily,thus was completed first. Earth, however, evolved with
more trouble, and therefore developed later.
http://creationtheologies.tripod.com/creationtheologies/id2.html
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 29/46
Islam and Creation
Mirza Tahir Ahmad: The Quran and Cosmology
http://www.alislam.org/library/books/revelation/part_4_section_5.html
... the concept of the continuous expansion of the universeis exclusive to the Quran. No other Divine scriptures even
remotely hint at it.
Do not the unbelievers see that the heavens and the earthwere a closed-up mass (ratqan), then We clove them
asunder (fataqna)? And We made from water every livingthing.
ratqan: (1) ’the coming together of something and theconsequent infusion into a single entity’; (2) ’total darkness’.
Black hole?
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 30/46
St Augustine, Bishop of Hippo, 354–430Confessions of St Augustine of Hippo, A.D. 397
(Translated from Latin by J.G. Pilkington,revised by Kevin Knight)
http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1101.htm
Autobiography and discussions with Godabout the Holy Script
Structured to Books and Chapters
Translators usually supply each with asubject as title, although the Latin original
has none. A chapter can be severalpages long or as short as a paragraph.
St Augustine
(Painted by Philippe de
Champaigne, XVIIth c.)
His world view was very close to modern cosmology
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 31/46
Confessions of St Augustine, Book XICreation
Chapter V: God Created the World Not from AnyCertain Matter, But in His Own Word.
Chapter VI: He Did Not, However, Create It by aSounding and Passing Word But there was nothingcorporeal before heaven and earth; or if there were,certainly Thou without a transitory voice had createdthat.
Recurring question: What God Did Before the Creationof the World?
Chapter XI: They Who Ask This Have Not as YetKnown the Eternity of God, Which is Exempt from theRelation of Time.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 32/46
Confessions of St Augustine, Book XI
Understand time: what it is and how it can be measured
Chapter XIII: Before the Times Created by God, TimesWere Not.
Chapter XIV: Neither Time Past Nor Future, But thePresent Only, Really is.At no time, therefore, had Thou not made anything,because You had made time itself.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 33/46
Confessions of St Augustine, Book XITime is measured by motion, but not identical to motion
Chapter XXIV: That Time is Not a Motion of a BodyWhich We Measure by Time
Chapter XXX: ...nor will I endure the questions of men,who ... say "What did God make before He madeheaven and earth?" or "How came it into His mind tomake anything, when He never before madeanything?". Grant to them, O Lord, to think well whatthey say, and to see that where there is no time, theycannot say "never". Let them therefore see that therecould be no time without a created being.
Thus time had to be created at Creation
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 34/46
Confessions of St Augustine, Book XIIGod created formless matter
Chapter IV: From the Formlessness of Matter, the Beautiful
World Has Arisen
Chapter VII: Out of Nothing God Made Heaven and Earth.
For Thou, O Lord, hast made the world of a formless matter ...
Of which invisible and formless earth, of which formlessness,
of which almost nothing, You might make all these things of
which this changeable world consists, and yet consists not;
whose very changeableness appears in this, that times can be
observed and numbered in it. Because times are made by the
changes of things, while the shapes, whose matter is the
invisible earth aforesaid, are varied and turned.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 35/46
Confessions of St Augustine, Book XII
What does “Heaven” in Genesis really mean?
Chapter IX: For, doubtless, that heaven of heavens,which Thou in the Beginning created, is someintellectual creature, which, although in no wiseco-eternal unto You, the Trinity, is yet a partaker of Youreternity, and ... does greatly restrain its own mutability.
Chapter XIII: Of the Intellectual Heaven and FormlessEarth, Out of Which, on Another Day, the FirmamentWas Formed
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 36/46
Confessions of St Augustine, Book XII
Back to Creation:What did Moses mean by the first sentence of Genesis:
’In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.’
Chapter XXIV:For his thoughts might be set upon the very beginningof the creation when he said, "In the beginning"; andhe might wish it to be understood that, in this place,"the heaven and the earth" were no formed andperfected nature, whether spiritual or corporeal, buteach of them newly begun, and as yet formless.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 37/46
Big Bang and Creation: Pope Pius XII
In 1951, much earlier than the physicist community Pius XIIhad welcomed the Big Bang theory as the Creation of the
World.
The proofs for the existence of God in the light of modernnatural science,
Address of Pope Pius XII to the Pontifical Academy ofSciences, November 22, 1951.
http://www.papalencyclicals.net/Pius12/P12EXIST.HTM
51. Hence, creation took place in time. Therefore, there is aCreator. Therefore, God exists! Although it is neither explicit
nor complete, this is the reply we were awaiting fromscience, and which the present human generation is
awaiting from it.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 38/46
Big Bang and Pope Pius XII, 1951
Edwin Hubble received a letter from a friend asking whetherthe Pope’s announcement might qualify him for “sainthood.”The friend enthused that until he read the statement in themorning’s paper, “I had not dreamed that the Pope wouldhave to fall back on you for proof of the existence of God.”
Georges Lemaître and the Vatican’s science advisor knewthat it is a contested theory and worried what might be theeffect if the Pope pinned the Catholic faith too much on its
proving true. They spoke privately to Pope about theirconcerns, and the Pope never brought up the topic again in
public.
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 39/46
Big Bang and Pope John Paul II
Pope John Paul II, Pontifical Academy of Sciences, 1996:
...it would seem that present-day science, with one sweepback across the centuries, has succeeded in bearing
witness to the august instant of the primordial Fiat Lux [Letthere be Light], when along with matter, there burst forth
from nothing a sea of light and radiation, and the elementssplit and churned and formed into millions of galaxies. ...
Thus, with that concreteness which is characteristic ofphysical proofs, [science] has confirmed the contingency ofthe universe and also the well-founded deduction as to the
epoch when the world came forth from the hands of theCreator. Hence, creation took place. We say: therefore,
there is a Creator. Therefore, God exists!
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 40/46
Big Bang and Pope John Paul II
Stephen W. Hawking discussed the Big Bang with JohnPaul II who advised they should not inquire into the Big
Bang itself because that was “the work of God.”
Hawking: I was glad then that he did no know the subject ofthe talk I had just given at the conference — the possibility
that space-time was finite but had no boundary, whichmeans that it had no beginning, no moment of Creation.
I cannot see any controversy here...
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 41/46
Result of WMAP, 2001-2003
Acoustic spectrum:vibration modes
Peak locations:dark matter is not
baryonic
Flat Universe,k = 0; Λ 6= 0
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 43/46
Distance scales in curved space-timeCo-moving coordinates: (t, r, Θ, Φ)
Euklidic distance: dℓ2 = dr2 + r2(dΘ2 + sin2 ΘdΦ2)In curved space:
dℓ2 = a2(t)[
dr2
1−kr2 + r2(dΘ2 + sin2 ΘdΦ2)]
a(t): 2D space-time corveture k: 3D space-time curvature
k = 0 k > 0 k < 0flat universe closed universe open universe
Distance of galaxies ∼ a(t) ⇒ expansion
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 44/46
Friedmann’s equation
Changeof
scalefactor
(
aa
)2
≡ H2 = 8πG3c2 ρR + 8πG
3c2 ρM − kc2
a2 + Λ
3
∼ a−4 ∼ a−3 ∼ a−2 ∼ a0
Radiation matter curvature vacuum
Dominance sequence(some may be missed)
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 45/46
Matter balance today
Friedmann’s equation (X0: , /H2
0)
8πG3H2
0c2
(ρR0 + ρM0) − kc2
a2
0H2
0
+ Λ
3H2
0
≡
ΩR + ΩM − Ωk + ΩΛ = 1
Flat Universe if Ω0 = ΩR + ΩM + ΩΛ = 1
At present: flat, matter-dominated (ΩM >> ΩR)
Cosmological parameters: ΩR, ΩM = ΩB +ΩCDM, ΩΛ, H0
Baryonic matter (stars, black holes, dust, gas): ΩB ∼ 4%Clustering non-baryonic, cold dark matter: ΩCDM ∼ 22%
Accelerating expansion ⇒ dark energy: ΩΛ ∼ 74%
Dezso Horváth: Cosmology and religion Wien, 10.03.2010 – p. 46/46