Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 1
Chapter 4Enforcing
Contractual
Obligations
Legal Fundamentals for Canadian Business
Third Edition
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 2
Learning Objectives
• List the events that can bring a contract to an end• Identify the various mistakes that can end or
otherwise affect a contract• Describe four forms of misrepresentation• Explain the effects of duress and undue influence
on a contract
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 3
Learning Objectives(Continued)
• Consider the implications of privity and assignment for a contract
• Describe how a contract can be breached or otherwise ended
• Outline the remedies that are available for breach of contract
• Summarize risk-reduction strategies when forming or ending a contract
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 4
Disputes
• May revolve around – The existence of the contract– The conduct of the parties at time of
negotiating the agreement– Performance of obligations under contract
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 5
Mistake
• When parties have a different understanding of terms of contract
• Shared mistake– Both parties have made same mistake– Contract void for lack of consensus– If mistake only in recording the terms, may ask
court to rectify (correct) agreement
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 6
Mistake(Continued)
• Misunderstanding– Each party has a different understanding– Courts will imply most reasonable
interpretation and enforce– If both interpretations equally reasonable,
contract void for lack of consensus
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 7
Mistake(Continued)
• One-sided mistake– Usually has no effect on contract– Caveat emptor (let the buyer beware)– Only if different understanding is a result of
misrepresentation would it be actionable
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 8
Mistake(Continued)
• If mistake as to nature of document signed, contract may be void– Non est factum (It is not my act)– If mistake as to nature of document due to
carelessness, claim is ineffective
• Contract Interpretation– Terms and words given “reasonable meaning”– Industry usage for special or technical terms
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 9
Exemption Clauses
• Also known as exculpatory, exclusion, or limitation clauses
• Attempt to limit or eliminate liability for one party to the contract
• Due to one-sided nature, courts interpret– As narrowly as possible– Against the favoured party
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 10
Exemption Clauses(Continued)
• Must be brought to attention of other party
• Usually found in standard-form contracts
• Create an unequal bargaining position
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 11
Misrepresentation
• False and misleading statements that induce a person to enter into a contract
• If a term of contract, can sue for breach• Must be statement of fact• Statement of opinion actionable if made by
expert• Silence generally not misrepresentation,
unless duty to disclose (duty of good faith)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 12
Innocent Misrepresentation
• Misleading another without knowing or being careless
• Only remedy is rescission– If goods destroyed or not available, no other
remedy possible– Not available if any wrongdoing by person
claiming rescission– Not available if contract affirmed
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 13
Fraudulent Misrepresentation
• Intentionally and knowingly misleading another to induce him/her to enter into contract
• Victim may seek rescission, damages, or both• If made innocent misrepresentation, and later learn
it is false, but fail to correct it, it becomes fraudulent
• May seek punitive damages in extreme cases• Easier to sue for innocent or negligent
misrepresentation
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 14
Negligent Misrepresentation
• If person making misrepresentation should have known what he/she was saying was false, he/she was careless
• Victim may seek rescission, damages, or both
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 15
Criminal Fraud
• Specific provisions of Criminal Code deal with fraudulent activity – Examples:– S. 361-365 prohibit knowingly making false
representations intended to induce someone to act on the representation
– Other sections deal with specific areas of fraud including the falsification of employee records, books, and other documents
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 16
Duress
• Entering into a contract because of coercion
• Threats may be violence, financial pressure, scandal, etc.
• May be against you, your family, your property, or business
• Contract is usually voidable
• Threats may also be criminal offence
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 17
Undue Influence
• Abuse of trust relationship• Contract voidable• Presumed in certain relationships
– Lawyers, doctors, trustees, guardians, religious advisors, adults with infant children, adult children with aging parents
– May be rebutted by evidence
• May have to prove in other situations
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 18
Unconscionability
• Taking advantage of vulnerable person’s situation– e.g., poverty, mental impairment (short of
incapacity)
• Bargaining positions of parties are unequal• Contract grossly unfair to victim• Court can set aside or modify contract• Also regulated by statute
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 19
Privity
• Only the parties to a contract are bound to it or may enforce it
• Exceptions– Interests in land bind subsequent owners of the
property– Trusts – beneficiaries may enforce– Life insurance – beneficiaries may enforce– Some statutory exceptions
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 20
Privity(Continued)
• Agents acting for principals– Agent never a party, so no privity issue
• Novation– One person taking over obligations of another
in a contract; no privity issues as new contract is required
• Employees– Contract clauses often extended to employees,
thus ignoring privity
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 21
Assignment
• Transferring a benefit under a contract to a third party
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 22
Assignment(Continued)
• Usually assignor and assignee must join together to sue if debtor fails to pay
• Statutory assignment allows assignee to sue directly if – Assignment is absolute (complete and unconditional)
– Assignment is in writing
– Proper notice was given to debtor
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 23
Assignment(Continued)
• May only assign the benefits, not the obligations
• Assignee takes assignment “subject to the equities”
• Assignee cannot be in a better position than the assignor
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 24
Negotiable Instruments
• Controlled by federal Bills of Exchange Act• Freely transferable from party to party • Innocent third party (called a holder in due
course) may enforce a negotiable instrument against the person who made it
• Include promissory notes, cheques, and bills of exchange (aka drafts)
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 25
Negotiable Instruments(Continued)
• Promissory note– One person promises to pay another a certain
sum of money at some future date or on demand
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 26
Negotiable Instruments(Continued)
• Cheque– Drawer orders bank to pay a certain sum of
money to a third party (the payee) on demand
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 27
Negotiable Instruments(Continued)
• Bill of exchange – May be an order to any person or business to pay
money to someone either now or at a future time
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 28
Negotiable Instruments(Continued)
• Holder in due course– Innocent third party who acquires possession of
instrument– Right to collect whether original obligations
met or not– If instrument is endorsed, that person can also
be held liable for amount owed
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 29
Discharge of Contracts
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 30
Performance
• Once parties have performed as required under the contract, it is discharged
• Conditions - major terms of contract– If breached, contract ends (if other party wants to end
it)• Warranties - minor terms of contract
– If breached, obligations continue– May seek damages from breaching party
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 31
Performance(Continued)
• Substantial performance– Substantially all obligations have been fulfilled,
but a condition is breached in a minor way– May seek compensation for small part
remaining– If contract requires payment, must be cash
unless otherwise specified• Limits on coinage set under Currency Act
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 32
Performance(Continued)
• Tender of performance– Ready, willing, and able to perform; other party
refuses to accept performance– Contract has been breached by refusal;
performance no longer required– Debt treated differently – if party refuses to
accept payment, money is still owed but debtor must seek payment and bear all costs of collection
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 33
Breach
• Incomplete or improper performance of contract
• Repudiation – breach by refusal to perform• Anticipatory breach – repudiation before
performance is due gives victim two options– Treat contract as breached– Continue to demand performance
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 34
Breach(Continued)
• Anticipatory breach (Continued)– If contract is treated as ended, victim may sue for
breach immediately– If victim demands performance, unexpected
events may discharge both parties– If victim of repudiation does not perform during
waiting period, he/she will be in breach– Choice of remedy is binding
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 35
Breach(Continued)
• Exemption clauses attempt to lessen liability for breach– Narrowly interpreted by courts
• Fundamental breach– Breach of very essence of contract– Exemption clauses can still apply if properly
worded
• In some cases, a breach of contract can be a criminal offence
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 36
Frustration
• Outside, unforeseen event that is out of the control of either party and renders contract either impossible to perform or completely different than what parties contemplated
• Caused by things such as illness, destruction of subject matter, government actions, natural disasters
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 37
Frustration(Continued)
• Effect used to be “let the loss lie where it falls”
• All jurisdictions now have legislation that require payment for benefits received and the return or apportionment of any deposit
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 38
Agreement
• May modify or end a contract by agreement• All elements of contract must be present• Cannot impose change on the other party• Each side must receive new consideration
– May be just relieving each of his/her remaining duties
– If only one side relieved, change is not binding(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 39
Agreement(Continued)
• Contract itself may contain conditions for changing or ending obligations– Condition precedent - Contract begins only if
conditions are met– Condition subsequent - Terms in contract
specify when continuing obligations will end
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 40
Remedies for Breach
• Rescission– Returning parties to original positions
• Damages– Compensation to attempt to put victim in position
he/she would have been in if contract properly performed
– Sometimes includes emotional stress or pain(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 41
Remedies for Breach(Continued)
• Liquidated damages– Term in contract to limit damages
• Deposit– Amount forfeited as pre-estimate of damages
• Down payment – First payment of purchase price; not meant to
be forfeited
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 42
Remedies for Breach(Continued)
• Victim must mitigate loss• Damages must be reasonably foreseeable at
time contract entered into• Equitable remedies
– Only available if damages not sufficient– Not available if any wrongdoing by party
claiming– Not available if innocent third party affected
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 43
Remedies for Breach(Continued)
• Equitable remedies (Continued)– Specific performance
• Requires breaching party to perform contract
• Only if subject matter of contract unique
– Injunction• Requires a person to stop doing something
(Continued)
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc. 4 - 44
Remedies for Breach(Continued)
• Equitable remedies (Continued)– Accounting
• Disclose financial records and dealings
• Pay profits of wrongdoing to victim
– Quantum meruit• Pay a reasonable price for services rendered