CMA: NATIONAL CONFERENCE NEW YORK, NY MARCH 2012
DR. RICHARD GANAHL BLOOMSBURG UNIVERSITY, PA
2 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
TABLE OF CONTENTS
• APRIL FOOLS’: THE PRANK
• ADMIN: PULL THE PLUG!
• BUnow: GET SITE BACK UP!
• COMMUNITY: RU KIDDING?!?
• FUTURE: WHAT’S AHEAD?
3 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
4 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
“PURE PLAY/STAND-ALONE”
BU NOW: MISSION
* Student Organization
* Indie Blog & Website
* Co-op & Con-verge
* Student Moderated
* Multiple Platforms
* Pics, Audio, Video
BU NOW: TRAFFIC
* 187,808 visitors
* 125+ visiting countries
* 434,243 page views
* 127,738 unique visitors
• over 18,567 video views
• 35-55 student staff
5 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
Lock Haven shutting down. Students
to be transferred to Bloomsburg.
• ‘story’ breaks first thing in morning • ‘story’ featured as BN headline story • advisors discuss exit plan w/ editors • traffic builds quickly throughout day • ‘story’ goes viral as FB LIKES spiral • advisor meets tech-vp in rec center
6 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
• BN student-editor tracks shut-down • BN advisors initiate talks w/ vp-tech • spoofed-school considers ‘action’ • vp-tech initiates talks with pres • BN advisors told will take weekend • BN advisors contact Frank @ SPLC!
BUnow is ‘shut down’ at @ 3.55 pm Friday
‘1\SPLCSTuDENT PRESS LAw CENTER
April 1, 2011
David Stanwick, Editor-in-Chief, BUNowBloomsburg UniversityBloomsburg, PA 17815VIA FACSIMILE
Dear David,
Thank you for letting us know about today’s shutdown of the BUNow newswebsite. As we understand the situation, your online news site carried a conspicuouslyidentified April Fool’s story that poked fun at a neighboring institution, LockhavenUniversity. Lockhaven responded by demanding that the BUNow website be completelydeactivated, and your administration complied, resulting in a complete denial of accessto the site for readers and staff.
Shutting down a student-run news website at a public university is a very severemeasure, and it can be justified — if ever — only by the most extreme necessity. The factsthat you have provided furnish no lawful basis for the university’s action, andaccordingly, it appears that a serious violation of the students’ First Amendment rightshas occurred and is ongoing.
At a public university, student journalists have extensive First Amendmentprotection that applies across all mediums, including the online medium. Whilespoofing Lockhaven may have been annoying to its administrators, there appears to benothing even arguably illegal about the story, based on your description of it. As theSupreme Court has affirmed, a public institution may not use its funding authority topenalize a student organization such as RUNow based on the content of its lawfulexpression. Rosenberger v. Rector & Visitors of Univ. of Va., 515 U.S. 819 (1995). As theFourth Circuit U.S. Court ofAppeals ruled in a censorship case involving a collegepublication, “Censorship of constitutionally-protected expression cannot be imposed ata college or university by suspending editors, suppressing circulation, requiringimprimatur of controversial articles, excising repugnant material, withdrawing financialsupport, or asserting any other form of censorial oversight based on the institution’spower of the purse.” 477 F,d 456, 460 (4th Cir. 1973) (emphasisadded).
Even in the ver unlikely event that the single Lockhaven story could have beendeemed to be constitutionally unprotected speech, the university had less FirstAmendment-intrusive efforts to achieve the same objective, such as asking that theeditors pull down the single offending story. The appropriate course of action when acomplaint is received about content in the student media is to refer the complaint to thestudent editors. I am certain that, had the proper procedures been followed, you and
1101 Wilson Blvd.. Suite 1100 I Arlington, VA 222022 11 I 703SU7 I ‘04 sn1cBsnLore I WW\\ DicOre
7 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
• ‘shutting down a website is a very severe measure’ • ‘the university’s response…denied readers access’ • ‘Besides being illegal, this…damag(es) reputations’ • ‘has potential to ‘go viral’…make the subject of ridicule’ • ‘the SPLC has a relationship with pro-bono…counsel’ • ‘We will also be pleased to publicize this episode’
“student journalists have extensive First
Amendment protection…across all mediums”
8 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
‘It was meant as an April
Fools’ joke…there were
plenty of signs it was a
prank.’ ‘it w
as a blatant joke to
highlight the severity of
the 50% budget cuts
scheduled to affect
education’
9 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
BUnow is ‘live again’ @ 6.58 pm Friday
• vp-tech ‘turns BUnow on’ • BUnow editors add disclaimers • disclaimers not a ‘quid pro quo’ • advisors & provost design protocol • BUnow launches as .com in Fall
IMS Proposal v1Revised 3/2/12
Mass Comm Teaching SpacesIMS Professional Sta! O"cesIMS Student Sta! Work Area‘Public’ Reception AreaGeneral Use Computers (Student Teachers, Business Students, etc.)Video Equipment StorageBuilding Consultant/ResComp Work Area & StorageVacated Spaces: 1146 - Communication Studies Research Laboratory 1247 and 1247A - o"ces available for faculty 1226 - o"ce available for faculty 1231 - hallway and storage area available for building mail room, etc.
UP
STAIRS
MEN'S TOILET
WOMEN'S TOILET
# 2
UP
# 3STAIRS
STAIRS # 1
UP
1117
1116
1115
1114
1113
1112
1118 1119 1120 1121 1122
1136 1137 1138 1139 1140
1111
1110
1109
1108 1107
1132
1105 1106 1103
1133
1134
1123 1124
1125
1141 1142
1126
1164
1128
1129 1130
1160
1146
1150 1151
1148
1266
1156 1154
1267
1265
1264
1250
1252
1259
1247 12441239
1277
1254 1257
1158 1269
1255
1262
1,577.74
1258
1210
1211
1212
1218
1213
1220
1228
1223
1224
1230
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
STORAGE
STORAGE
WORK
OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE
FACULTY LOUNGE
OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE ELECTRICAL
MASS COMM IMAC LAB. COMPUTER LAB.
OFFICECOMPUTER
MECHANICAL ROOM CUSTODIAL ROOM
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE OFFICE
OFFICE PRO
JEC
TORS
,LA
PTO
PS, A
ND
LE
GA
CY
EQU
IPM
ENT
FORMERLY SPECTRUM MAGAZINEPROPOSED LOCATION FOR iMAC LAB
MASTERCONTROL
TV STUDIO "A" CONTROL
SQ. FT.
TV SHOP
TV STORAGE
TV/FILM EDITING
XSAN VIDEO EDITING LAB XSAN VIDEO EDITING LAB
MOCK INTERVIEW ROOM 2 CAMERA TV STUDIO (BLUE ROOM)
WBUQ
RADIO STUDIO "A"
RADIO STUDIO
CONTROL
RADIO STUDIO "B"
RADIO STUDIO
CONTROL
OFFICE
OFFICE
SECRETARY'S OFFICE
ROOM
COMMUNICATION STUDIES
CHAIRPERSON OFFICE
TRASH ROOM
CORRIDOR
CO
RRID
OR
ROOM
LOBBY
PIT
PIT
CO
RRID
OR
CORRIDOR
CORRIDOR
OFFICE
1127
1162
1229
1229
STORAGE
1231
NORTH
ELECTRICAL
1149
PANELS
1100 1101 1102
PROPOSED MEDIA CONVERGENCE LAB
1210A
1210B
1210C
OFFICE
PROFESSIONALVIDEO EQUIPMENT
STORAGE
143.46SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.84.00
90.95SQ. FT.
87.17SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.175.00
133.03SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.94.75
SQ. FT.748.89
3 CAMERA TV STUDIO 1261
380.99SQ. FT.
383.64SQ. FT.
224.94SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.140.89
SQ. FT.846.97
209.60SQ. FT.
211.46SQ. FT.
345.32SQ. FT.
513.58SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.570.23
326SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.922
SQ. FT.188
93SQ. FT.
SQ. F
T.54
SQ. FT.95
STORAGE
SQ. FT.89.54
SQ. FT.94.16
SQ. FT.92.68
SQ. FT.93.93
92.69SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.92.69
SQ. FT.91.70
185.33SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.186.54
SQ. FT.80.66
SQ. FT.81.89
124.69SQ. FT.
81.21SQ. FT.
128.42SQ. FT.
40.33SQ. FT.
CIRCULATION
196.51SQ. FT.
STO
RAG
EST
ORA
GE
STO
RAG
EST
ORA
GE
12.28SQ. FT.
12.28SQ. FT.
12.28SQ. FT.
12.28SQ. FT.
STO
RAG
E
14.67SQ. FT.
564.46SQ. FT.
90.67SQ. FT.
46.00SQ. FT.
1,337.79SQ. FT.
10.89SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.136.34
SQ. FT.67.56
SQ. FT.66.33
142.28SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.185.37SQ. FT.
139.29SQ. FT.177.91
SQ. FT.90.87
SQ. FT.94.19
SQ. FT.94.19
SQ. FT.94.64
SQ. FT.93.64
SQ. FT.94.64
1135 OFFICE
SQ. FT.90.09
SQ. FT.93.34
SQ. FT.93.34
SQ. FT.92.66
SQ. FT.93.34
SQ. FT.92.66
SQ. FT.91.39
SQ. FT.91.39
SQ. FT.91.39
SQ. FT.91.39
SQ. FT.91.39
SQ. FT.91.39
SQ. FT.91.39
SQ. FT.92.66
SQ. FT.93.34
92.57SQ. FT.
SQ. FT.94.64
1248 1244A
1131 CONFERENCE ROOM
SQ. FT.275.09
SQ. FT.129.55
SQ. FT.127.49
SQ. FT.129.99
SQ. FT.127.16
OFFICE
SQ. FT.64.21
SQ. FT.55.83
SQ. FT.25.00
SQ. FT.26.67
OFFICERESTROOM
RESTROOM
RESTROOM
1240
1243
1240A
SQ. FT.94.19
1S7
259.45SQ. FT.124.50
SQ. FT.
1,441.85SQ. FT.
185.99SQ. FT.
1154A
678.81SQ. FT.
1CO4
37.271CO6
1CO7
1CO8
211.88SQ. FT.
75.69SQ. FT.
29.26SQ. FT.
202.56SQ. FT.
OFFICE
CIRCULATIONOFFICE
COPY/FILING 1210D
124.09SQ. FT.
RECEPTION AREA
DEPT. CHAIR
STORAGE
SQ. FT.263.94
1210E
SQ. FT.614.48
1242
SQ. FT.65.65
1,328SQ. FT.
CLASSROOM1316
233SQ. FT.
WOMEN'S 1315
TOILET
206SQ. FT.
MEN'S 1314
TOILET
55SQ. FT.
ELEV.1312
MACH.
756SQ. FT.
MECH.1311
EQUIP.
120SQ. FT.
ELEC.1310
EQUIP.
744SQ. FT.
CORRIDOR1308
53SQ. FT.
JAN. STOR.1306
206SQ. FT.
MECHANICAL1307
STEAM EQUIP.
1,379SQ. FT.
CORRIDOR1305
3,469SQ. FT.
LECTURE1303
CLASSROOM
1,072SQ. FT.
CORRIDOR1301
97SQ. FT.
VESTIBULE1300
397SQ. FT.
LOUNGE AREA1302
102SQ. FT.
VESTIBULE1309
192SQ. FT.
AV / DATA1304
16SQ. FT.
JAN. 1313ELEV.
1EV2
CLOSET58
SQ. FT.
STAIRS # 4
2SQ. FT.
2SQ. FT.
2SQ. FT.
2SQ. FT. 1
SQ. FT.
1SQ. FT.
1SQ. FT.
1SQ. FT.LOUNGE AREA
218SQ. FT.
1SQ. FT.
1SQ. FT.
1302A
1214 OFFICE
SQ. FT.90
OFFICE90
SQ. FT.
EDUCATIONAL STUDIES ANDSECONDARY EDUCATION
OFFICE
DEPT. OF MASS COMMUNICATIONS OFFICE
1214A
1221
SQ. FT.126
COMPUTEREQUIPMENT
1217
1219
SQ. FT.135
EQUIPMENT FORMASS COMM STUDENTS
SQ. FT.134
OFFICE
1226OFFICE
SQ. FT.130
1222OFFICE
SQ. FT.136
OFFICE AREA
EQUIPMENTFOR GENERAL
USERS
SQ. FT.
()*()$+,-."-$/"01
)2*34$/"01
=4*64$/"01 )2*64$/"01
)2$?>'@$#>''
52*64$7"-89+"$:,;.<"-
=2$#>'' =2$#>'' ()$#>''
()$#>''
=4$#>''
=4$#>''
()*()$+,-."-$/"01
)2*34$/"01
)2*64$/"01
)2$?>'@$#>''
=2$#>'' =2$#>''
()$#>''
()$#>''
)2*34$/"01
)2*64$/"01
)2$?>'@$#>''
52*64$7"-89+"$:,;.<"-
=2$#>''=2$#>''
)2*34$/"01
)2*64$/"01
52*64$7"-89+"$:,;.<"-
)2$?>'@$#>''
52*64$7"-89+"$:,;.<"-
=2$#>''=2$#>''
()*()$+,-."-$/"01
)2*()$/"01
)2*(2$/"01
)2*64$/"01
52*(2$7"-89+"$:,;.<"-
()$#>''
=4$#>''
=4$#>''
()$#>''
)($+,-."-
:;-8"/$?>'@$#>''
=2$#>''
)A*3)$9B>+$<>C'" )A*3)$9B>+$<>C'"
)A*3)$9B>+$<>C'"
23+4*5%+&(653**&
?(!"#$%&'()*&+,+(
/+3<$80%+&$
)$!"#$%&&'"$G0>.$
/+3<$80%+&$
($!"#$%&&'"$G0>.$
/+3<$80%+&$
!"#$%&'(=#85>*&(
%-">
!"#$%&'(-+1+3(
)0$*3(2
3#&8*3
7&$839
58+3(6
80%+&:
5$!"#$%&'()*&+,+
5$!"#$%&&'"
($!"#$%&&'"$
@$0&()0;8+;$
($!"#$DE$
)0;8+;$
!"#$%&'(
:>C9."<$@,
-$
)0;8+;$
!"#$FB
E7$
H>+1
23+4*5%+&(653**&
)-.(+&(/011
)-.(+&(/011
)-.(+&(/
011
10 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
“The proposed media hub will also serve as a convergence and information
exchange point for the various media on the BU campus, which include
WBUQ, BUTV, The Voice, and BUNow. Equipment and software will be
installed to allow the hub to access information from the various campus
media outlets for distribution to and use by each other. Such an exchange
will allow for efficient sharing of news resources on campus that can
enhance the overall image of the department, the college, and Bloomsburg
University as a whole.” Submitted 3.9.2012
A $129,948 ‘Emerging Media Hub’ Was Recently Proposed
With OUT the Knowledge or Input of Campus Media
11 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
• watch topics: rape is NO NO!
• no hurtful, demeaning stereotypes
• prank institutions, NOT people
• sure you can say it, but should you?
• have an ‘exit’ or ‘make it right’ plan
• be .com…avoid class assg & servers
• keep open door w/ admin & staff
• have SPLC contact info close at hand
Courtesy of Student Press Law Center
12 APRIL FOOLS': BEFRIEND THE 1ST AMENDMENT!
Engage!
www.BUnow.com
Student Press Law Center