8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
1/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
OperatiOn Cast Lead
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
2/112
Bkg h slc cv m obl hough h gou uo
of vul fouo clug: th Moh Fouo, h nw ilFu, iCCO, siVMO, Oxfm GB, mco ol, Ch a (UK), h
Bh emby tl avv, h My of Fog aff of h nhl,
h sh agcy fo iol dvlom Cooo h eU.
th bookl w ouc ulc hk o fug fom h eU, h
Govm of h nhl, h sh agcy fo iol
dvlom Cooo.
th co oo x h bookl o o h eU, h
Govm of h nhl, o sh agcy fo iol dvlom
Cooo, olly h obly of Bkg h slc.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
3/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
svl moh hv c h of Oo C L Gz,
my il ll o w of wh lly h h. Fo lck of bc fc,
we are forced to accept unconditionally the positions of the ofcial bodies, which
u u h of y oub, h idF couc w full ublc
ccoubly ucll fo. th ublco clu h mo of ou
hy comb who ook h oo ly 2009. th mo h h w gh ov h fw moh fom ol who v
ll co of h oo. th mjoy of h ol who ok wh u
ll vg h gul mly u u o u h
mol oo of h idF. alhough h ublco o o clm o ov
bo, comhv vw of ll h ol h u who c ou h
oo, h v ough o bg o quo h cbly of h
ofcial IDF versions.
There are many signicant gaps between the testimonies we gathered. Thesemo cb u of h nghbo pocu of wh hohou
mmuo ly hb ghbohoo, mv uco of bulg
ul o y c h o il foc, mv ul of ggm
h l o h kllg of oc. W lo h fom h ol bou h gl
atmosphere that accompanied the ghting, and of harsh statements made by junior
and senior ofcers that attest to the ongoing moral deterioration of the society and
h my. dug h oo, h mly bb m ow cobuo
o h xo wh ouc coovl lgou olcl
o u h uc of h idF wh blg.
Although certain features characterized this operation as a whole, signicant
ffc c b fou mog h vou goghc u. such
vo lo h ublco.
i h fw moh, h idF oko h go o g lgh o ov
h f h w y mol oblm wh h w ll, hy w mly o
h lvl of h lqu ol, h h w, ymc u. tho of h ublco ov h w o lg wh h flu of vul
ol, o flu h lco of vlu mly o
ymc lvl. th idF co of uch hom o l ol
cc u o lc h obly olly o vul ol o h gou
o v kg obly fo h ym ou vlu comm
flu. th mo of h ol h collco xo h h mv
uc blow o h fucu cvl of h Gz w
c ul of idF olcy, clly of h ul of ggm,
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
4/112
culvo of h oo mog ol h h ly of w qu hm o
hoo o o k quo.
th collco of mo off bf glc Oo C L,
wh occu ug h oo h h of h idF o bhlf of il
ocy. W blv h h xc of mol ocy clly qu
ofou, ho cuo, of whch h voc of ol o h gou bl .
That this voice was missing from public discourse around the ghting in Gaza
oblg u o h ublco of h mo hm. Bcu of m
u h comlx oc of vfyg h mo, w o bl o
ublh h ll h ml ou oo. th mo h book
cgoz by ubjc h xc lgug of h ol kg.
Mly mology xl h.
tho who bk h lc h ublco cb h mo
how actions dened as anomalous yesterday become the norms of tomorrow,
how h m of il ocy cou, log wh h mly
ym, o l ogh ow h mol ly lo. th ug cll
o il ocy l o ob u vg w h ul of
ou co.
W woul lk o k h oouy o hk ou my volu uo
who bl h ublco of h bookl o uch ho oc. Whou h
xv c uo, h ublco woul o hv ch you
h.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
5/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
TesTimony 1 - Human sHeild
It was the rst week of the war, ghting was intense, there were explosive charges
o xo, ul o c m m hou. Comb w
low bclly vy mll w occu. evy u, vy foc h
mll g of obly vl oz hou oly, whch hy
h o k ov, h ook whol wk. th comb ook wholwk. thy lly mov lowly. Clo o ch hou. th mho u
h w m ow _ o log 'ghbo ocu.' now ol cll
'Joh.' thy' pl cvl, hy' cll Joh h
were civilians there who stayed in spite of the yers the army distributed before
w . Mo ol lv, bu om cvl y o wch ov h
hou. ph hy h owh l o go. L w w ol h who
coul o wlk, om mly y o k wch. to vy hou w clo
o, w h ghbo , 'h Joh,' f h m m , w
, lk wokg h 'u cook' h W Bk.
evr t r wth rt k 'rr ckr' rctc.
Wht b t?
i'm o u h bou h 'u cook' ocu h, hy coul b
ff. elly h o w o g hm ou lv, go , o cch h m
m. th w' my cou. Ju fw. i o c, ou m o
get them to come out, then they opened re, red some anti-tank missiles at the
house and at some point brought in a D-9, bulldozer, and combat helicopters.There were three armed men inside. The helicopters red anti-tank missiles and
again the neighbor was sent in. At rst he told them that nothing had happened
to them yet, they were still in there. Again helicopters were summoned and red,
i o' kow wh g of clo ( h u of foc). th ghbo w
sent in once again. He said that two were dead and one was still alive, so a D-9
w bough molhg h hou ov hm ul h ghbo
w , h l m m cm ou w cugh o o h
shbk th comm ll wh hy w mk u w kow how
hg wok o h . thy lo lk bou hg h boh hm.thy h cvl w u o g x h ju g hm
o hou. Fo xml, om of hm w m o mh wll wh 5 klo
lghmm. th w wll ou y wh h foc ' w
to use the gate, it needed an alternative opening for fear of booby-traps or any
oh vc. so h "Joh" hmlv w qu o bg o oh
hol wh lghmm. tlkg of uch hg, by h wy, h w oy
ublh by am H Hz ly w, bou Jbly wh
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
6/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
7/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
8/112
u, wh m mo mo u, v h hou ll g,
mo of hm k gg hll h h. th xlo w go w
h wh h gul ol w , hy kw whch hou w blog o
Hm cv whch o. a Hm cv' hou uully go hll
oc o wc ju o mk u
Tk h?
Y. i o' kow whch k, i w' h. th og w h Hm
houses posed much more of a threat because of potential booby-trapping,
ul, combo hof, c. th why hy w hll, o v
whol of xlov chg, mo h lk.
The idea is that becase we know in advance that a hose belons to
H ctvt, w bw t t k r thr r xv
chaes.W hv o ff h bw blg hou hllg , l' u
h wy. Blg hou blowg u h . th omhg h k
hll ju co o, you' xlov fo h, ll k of u lg wh
explosives do this. And they did. You re some shells, and whether intentionally
o o, whol wg k ow. a whol wg of hou w o
. Wh mog cm, w w h uco of h hou bg o
lz wh w w, omwh. W w h Zyou ghbohoo fo
of u, wh Gv' (fy bg) h ly bgu o gg, h
uco of h ghbohoo w w . O mu coly k m
that we were under enormous threat. All possible dangers whether anti-tank
re, light arms re, explosive charges, kidnapping, mortar shells any scenario
was denitely possible. Luckily, but for a few exceptions we didn't witness or
xc uch hg oulv.
Abot shellin the activists, when yo wee biefed which hose to destoy
and which not to, who did the bien and when?
H o ll, bu i hk w my lkg wh Gv' guy wh w lc hmh hy xl h h w h ocu. i' h o y whh
h w uhoz ouc o o. Bu h lf l umo.
However I can't tell you that someone was ofcially authorized to say this: an
intelligence ofcer, battalion commander or someone else. What I can say is that
it was already mentioned in the preliminary brieng, that the idea of demolishing
hou o zg h ghbohoo wofol: o h o h h' h
ool cy, h' wh w h ll h m. i cll hvg coly
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
9/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
h h ov ou o. th h w o o joz il ol
by g hou wh w o' kow wh' , o g wh
h k of xlov chg, hfo fom xc h my of h
houses, whether every second or fth house, various things were said anyway
a signicant part of the houses were booby-trapped, some of them had tunnels,
others mortars red by remote control, such stuff, those were things we saw.th w o o o molh hou, h coul l mo mv
hllg.
To sch an extent that a whole win wold collapse?
Worse. Or that it's a house that a D-9 bulldozer would take care of, and if not
obly lly v Co of eg, oh wo bl o hgh
heaven. If not, it could be shelled, but more thoroughly So the rst reason,
i , w o oc ou foc, l' u h wy, mg o k ou m
ll obl. W' molh uc hou h w o hg. thother reason was already brought up at the preliminary brieng at Tze'elim, in
fc: of h coc of zg w wh h il my cll 'h y f'
coo. Obvouly h cmg woul om o, clly h
w o o o com bck k ov h Gz s, w obvou
w' lv vully. th quo w wh coo w' lv h ,
whether more exposed, a state that would afford us better ring and observation
coo, f g cool. th w h cl bh ll h zg,
namely razing for our benet.
What was the exact wodin at the peliinay bien?
"th y f." rzg w o wh h y f ou lvg m, h
we would want this ability, outright, this eld of vision and range of re. The
xo "h y f" w m g, v w w ll
co.
When yo wee on the ond, did yo et to deolish hoses? Ode
d-9 rct th?
su, h hg cully ook lc, fo wo o. th wo l of
uco x fc, o ju l.
Bt yo went in behind the elas, the neihbohood was aleady epty.
The elas had aleady left, and yo wee actally takin ove in a 'staw
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
10/112
10
ww' rcr.
no c. th gul bg wh h my cll offv comb. thy
fgm my , h' wh i kow. thy fgm h Gz s
cool b, ook ov clly loc hou o
cool h . to h cool w . thy o
ch ll h hou h w , w cool ov h , ook ovmo hou, clmb g, hll h ook ov w hou h
l h foc.
Din the week yo wee inside, yo wee still continin deolitions,
I ean continin to eceive intellience infoation abot all sspect
h.
su. a lo molhg of h coc of ou ow cuy, fo f '
og gov, h coul b f of g fom , o h och woul
b z fo ou ow fy, o o lv c of gou ov whch w o o
hv ol cool, o vo hg u, lo wh h fuu m.
C tt hw h? m, w?
no u. i c y h omo who oo gu uy o lk y
oh gu o, h ol h c ov whch h uo o
k wch. Qu of h bou of uch w m ucl, fo
w kow hm, h bou fom o hou o oh, o f o of h
hou w o log g you h o co oh hou, whch w lo' l. th bou w m ucl by h hou molo, i
m hou molo cou. th' fo u.
Din the week yo wee inside, yo wold still be shellin hoses with
explosive chaes, o wold yo deolish the with D-9s o wold the
Cops of Eninees be wokin on the?
all of h bov, i hk.
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
11/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
TesTimony 3 - Rules of engagemenT
somhg h wh comm of m who' goo guy i hk
h ' vol h o h c. W y ou of h f
the family was waiting in an exposed spot - a father, grandfather, young mother
and babies. As we were coming in, the commander was ring a volley, andmkly kll oc.
Wht xct h?
W go o h hou. i w uou by y, fc. af h g
broken in, he goes in with live re. Several bullets, not a full burst.
a th wht h?
We go in, there's a break-in and search squad. Several stories to the building.
We didn't enter every room with live re, but dry.
a th ?
th fmly w hg fom h bombg. thy w u h h
happened to be just in front of the door and when he went in and red, he didn't
see who he was ring at. So he happened to kill an elderly guy.
y w h wht ?
th hou lf w my. W bok l c hoog oo. th
fmly mu hv b ch ou of h y i o' kow. i ' oc. th
boy m.
H th t?
i o' kow. Wh i hk bck, lly m h i o' kow. i hu
o m , bu o h i ' c. i k h my m o
w h blo comm bou bu i ju ' hv h m. too b i
', com o hk of .
Wht t t wrt?
th hg hg h blo of whch h h o . Whou
cully mg yo. i'm g fomg o ol. Bu f i look fom
h , h ol who v o go o jl.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
12/112
1
Yo don't eebe the siht of the faily.
Fom h gfh ow o h gchl. thy h mu hv b
o o go wy. W ' y h hou. W mov o fw hou
l.
****
TesTimony 4 - Rules of engagemenT & Home oCCupaTion
af h sco Lbo W h my bg o o Gz,
l f i kow. W h cl muv fo uch oo wc,
blo muv ccog o vou lg. th blo w g
o rfh Kh Yu, ol rfh o h oh foc woul b
bl o ch rfh loc ul. i w cll u o suy.
As soon as the ond offensive bean.
Y. th gou offv suy gh. W o o suy,
w h ly Flly wh w w o Fy gh, whch
w ly wo wk f gg cll u, lcm fo h Gol
(fy bg) comy' oo. Lk u, hy h b u comm
of gul k bg. th bg comm w comm of h
w w u h comm W ook ov h hou h Gol h
k, o by o. i ' h ou blo of yo who hf oo
h ho m w w h. i hk h Gol oo y h m oo
o hou. i hk h k hf, bu o oo much.
y tr h wht th k k? Wht ct w th
h ?
elly ll h muv w h c y w o xcu 'y' y,
'w' y, f w w loy w bg o g lo l
from the ghting in Gaza, we realized there's no such thing as a 'dry' entry. All w 'w,' g o h uo, ully. th w o uch hg
y mo , 'y' y.
s hw 'wt' tr wrk?
Missiles, tank re, machine gun re into the house, grenades. Shoot as we enter
a room. The idea was that when we enter a house, no one there could re at us.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
13/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
nully by comb og w woul o k hou h h Hm woul
expect us to take, for it would be highly likely for the Hamas to booby-trap it.
So 'wet' enty eans closin in on the hose and in La issiles?
Y. rpG, LaU. th' wh w w fo. i fc, wh w v
house, it was intact, no one had red at it, no one red at Golani when they wentin, they had no one to re at. Just like the houses I saw where we'd been, which
had not been red at, and nothing was broken. No walls were broken to get in.
th m mu hv k h hou 'y.'
Wht w th tt th h, t ctt?
W w hou wh vy ll fuu. th w om lc ch
m h boom co b, clo k of commo.
i hk Gol h ch h clo, k how h cloh ou
o ch, o mk u h w o xlov chg .
y 't trct b tht? Jt r tr
rch.
Y, h w o ol uco byo h oml mly ch. Vy
ll. Oly om cookg ul w h kch, fgo, g ov,
ll h. th w bowl wh b h ol h bfo hy
ou o o h ouch h b, o o , h Gol, o w.
accog o comb logc, you o' yhg h mgh co om o of
oo. a hy lly ' ouch . W u h m blk fog lg. a fo oh hou wh guy fom my comy y,
o hou w ll oly h kll g o ohg h w oy,
h w o qum . aoh hou, f i uoo cocly, i m
o u, bu h' wh i w ol i blv h w cvl hl u
h ow hom, u o h my' oml ocu, wh hy' cugh,
cleared and conrmed that they're not carrying any weapons or explosives.
Wh w w ll g w w ol h woul clu wom h
lly. W' hv o cl hm, mg hy hv o lf h gm, k
off whv w cy, clug wom, clug uvlg hmlv,
bcu om Hm m wom h lo wom uc
bomb. th' ocu. aywy, h co o h hou h comy
ook h w fou ol, h ow' fmly. W cm h o k foo
i w h hou. i w lgly fuh cly bul. i oo w bg
look f h wy w ou. M o vlz olly. thy
m fbl mly u of oly.
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
14/112
1
TesTimony 5 - aTmospHeRe
Wht bthr t bt th rt?
Bothered me? Many things. Firstly, all that destruction. All that re at innocents.
th hock of lzg wh whom i'm h ogh. My m, lly, h'how hy' bhvg. i w mly mzg. icocvbl. th c of ll h
f ogg. You hv ll h cl lf who o' l fo om o o
oh, o y clo o hom, h wh you comb u look lk.
What disappointed yo in the ys who wee thee with yo? They'e still
r .
thy' my l, bcu h' o oh wy, i hv o b f wh hm.
i o' hv much choc. i lv wh hm. Bu h h, h joy of kllg,
o "i kll o, who W blw h h off"
s th thr thr w bck, rr, rrvt?
Thee was nothin to hold the en back?
Wh you comy comm blo comm ll you, "Go o,
re!" the soldiers will not hold back. They are waiting for this day, the fun of
hoog flg ll h ow you h.
Yo wee feelin it?
The way you feel with your nger on the trigger, where in one slight pull you can
k ow hlf bulg. so y, you fl .
s c bck vr t?
Vy. Bu i ' hv y oh xco. i o' k mylf. i' you my,
after all. At the end of the day it's 60 nineteen-twenty year olds for whom vulgarity
volc wy of lf. i' o th' ohg o hol you bck. i w'
oo u.
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
15/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
TesTimony 6 - BomBaRdmenT
The 120mm Mortar (a type of mortar shell red by the IDF in Gaza) is a relatively
w ym whch Gv' o o y o.
Wht w th k?
th ol o h whl o u. i k hlf hou o g hll ou. i h w
ym h comu o h whol clbo oc. i hv m, l
hoo. a co m. i m gv fc o. i clck o h comu. i'
ouch c. i hv kybo. i clck h fc o. i how m wh
is on the map. I press, the mortar is aimed and my subordinate simply res.
Hw ccrt t?
Highly accurate. 95-100%.
Wht' ht?
i o' mmb h h u, f ' 30m ov 50m, o 50m ov 75m fo wo
bomb. do' cll .
Do yo eebe what the killin o wondin anes ae of this thin?
svl oz m. i' vy g hg. th' chc of hl
bu
The qestion is what yo ean by taeted.if h c c hol h z of h c hl ll ou.
What ae the taets?
Most of the time, they were open spaces. Once I was allowed to re and I realized
it was really inside a neighborhood. Houses. Then I nally understood. Most of
the time we were ring at launcher crews in open spaces, but it didn't take much
to aim at schools, hospitals and such. So I see I'm ring literally into a built-up
. i o' kow o wh g w ll hb bcu h my mcobl m o g ol o lv, bu i u h
Did yo hesitate while pllin the tie, o did yo ask aain?
I don't know about hesitating It feels terrible that we red there. But we'd always
g ho cll bou h ul of ou h. W w o ol w h kll
oc, bu w w ol w h h luch cw. i o' kow how my
m ch cw. Bu w kll h b guy h h of h Hm
high-arc [high - trajectory] ballistics section, so yes, you're proud of yourself and
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
16/112
1
you bl. You fl lk df Foc. W hg oc ou
artillery re there was insane, but on the other hand you hear about shooting out
of Gaza and you return re immediately.
Wht' t rtr?
t of ou bomb fo vy o of h.
Evey tie they e, yo e ten onds at the sae lanch spot. Isn't one
enoh?
scg.
Wht ?
thy fll x o ch oh, h' lo of h clculo wo hll fllg
ogh x h h u. alo, i uo of h coo boh
open and built up areas is the tunnels. The rst shell hits the oor, the third might.
Bt what do yo ean by scattein? Do yo neve e a sinle shell
?
no. abou h m. i , f ll, lg g, you o luch
vl o o h.
And they don't all hit the sae spot, is that the scattein effect?
excly.
All the taets yo ed at, was that stictly in esponse to thei in
t ir?
O o bomb lc bfo y.
In eneal, they e into Isael, thei lanch spot is located, yo etn e,
t c?
There were days we red only into built-up areas, inside Gaza City itself.
How is open space dened?
accog o wh i w o h m, o hou. emy.
y r ht?
W w l hoo oly om of h m. th comu w u. p
w o m, o l hoo. i o' mmb xcly.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
17/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
y ' r' chck?
Y.
Wht tht, r?
i m ou foc o h . Ou comu o lly
u bou vy idF co. so h chck w m fo u bfo wcv ou fc o.
s wht r r r w rc?
300 meters under re. Something like that. A scattering and a last bomb. Then
h ochbl.
Wr ch r cr r pt, r w tht t
rvt?
Cvl? if ' o c, i uo h w o my pl
that time. As for identication of areas, thats already about the instructions they
cv o vcu h hom.
So how ch do yo estiate yo ed altoethe?
Upwards of 620 shells. It's written somewhere in the brieng. We evaluated all
ou h, ll h goo hg b hg wll h umb of hll
red.
a xv?
Y. i c you cu, om of hm fuy.
When did yo e fo softenin the esistance?
Most of the time ring was for softening resistance I think. I don't know quite how
o guh . W mly cv o. if w h o, h i gu h
w h uo. Bu f w ol h idF uo o go gh w
take this to mean ring to soften resistance. But we are not told prior to opening
re each time.
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
18/112
1
TesTimony 7 - Rules of engagemenT
Before the rst time we went in, the battalion commander had us all stand in
fomo o Fy vg : "W co u hm wh ou mg,
hy kow wh. W co u hm wh ou loco, hy kow xcly
where we're coming in. What we do have is re power." And in fact all that reow, wh wh foc, lly, mo co h quy of fy
that went in, the awareness of each soldier going in is simply a light nger on
h gg. You omhg you' o qu u? You hoo.
Is this soethin yo wee told?
i' omhg h w : h (h blo comm) h
mom i w qu u of wh h m. i y much g wh hm. H
: no h wll fll off ol of m, i m o wllg o llow ol
of m o k hmlf by hg. if you o u hoo. if h oubh h o oub. W uoo h h ' o bcu ol
w o kll, o collc h o gloy. i' bcu hy w o v hum
lv y co. W ll kow, w' ll lvg h couy kow h h
of blly cul ll of h w, hy mly w o ck o h,
comlly. L lo buco ocu uch hg, wh h uco
w xlc f you' o u, kll. F ow w . W w h
boom w ju m. th mu w go o ou g l, w mly bg
to re at suspect places. Also, it was still dark when we went in, we got there
ju bfo w. You hou, wow, hoo h wow. You o'
o h? F h wow. i w l ub wf. th h
ffc bw ub wf lm cofoo. i ub wf,
yo you my. no oc. i w mly ub wf vy wy.
We went in there house after house, going around each other every time. 99%
of h hou w my.
Yo ente hoses with live e?
no. th uco w o g vyo ou of h hou o coc hm o oom. aouc hough louk. Gv fw mu, f h
person is not out after 2-5 minutes, whoever is left inside is a dead man. Whoever
com ou mbl hm ou o o of h low oom, h go
upstairs with live re. This was the instruction, and it was not always followed
bcu of h hou w my. so why w mmuo? Ju hoog
fo fu? som ol bu h w o lwy h c. evully h
w o cofoo ll ol w o bg o l off
m mly hoo. i gl ol (pl) cm ow, w'
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
19/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
o hm o go ov h, o om co ll hm o go h.
thy' o, 'Bu h ou hom. W hv owh o go,' w th
w h o, f o o h blo lvl, h fom h bg o gl
my uco. i o' kow. Bu ' o omhg h loo o comy
comm c o h o. i w obvou wh w w h h ol
o llow o y h hou. W c hm ow c hog hy woul' b h h. i ou g w c hm
ouhw h Gz s ow wh ou foc w o . W
sent them south. We did not abuse them. But it hurts when ve mothers, an old
wom ll chl look you h wom y "i hv owh o
go" h' ohg you c o. i h o h. You ough u. You look
h h y y: "Ov h." a hy wlk wy. a oo omo
com ou, you ouc h h oc movg ouh uully
lo h ym, o ghm. th hou k ov w
oulv ccog o l.
****
TesTimony 8 - Rules of engagemenT
& use of WHiTe pHospHoRus
What ae the instctions, the objective, the oal when yo o in? Whobiefs yo, the battalion coande? The biade coande?
th comy comm, blo comm bg comm. th
hgh u h k you go, h mo gl bcom. exc fo h comy
comm w w wo loo, oh comy comm of
loo h blog o fy comy o o w cl o wh w w
gog o b og h.
And the les of enaeent?
if w c yhg h houl o b h w hoo. W' ol h
force distributed yers telling everyone to go to Gaza City. If beyond this line any
ol c hy o uo o b h. i h o fom
oh cw who ho ol wo klom wy. i mmb i woul chg
lc wh h gum k look. You ol mo o l ug
their life routine, taking a walk, stuff like that. Denitely not terrorists. I hear from
other crews that they red at people there. Tried to kill them. The younger guys,
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
20/112
0
g o h co. thy m o hk ' cool o wl uch ow wh
no one wanting to rein them in. They gave permission to open re.
Yo had it, too, was it a eneal peission to open e?
Wh h bou of ou g .
it' ct, kw. fr wr trbt, bt r b t b
on the ove, obviosly thee wold be civilian tafc. It's not a ilitay
aea. People live thee. No one addessed this in biens? Coandes,
? n tct w t b btw cv,
ch w c r rct? Thr r t b
cr.
th' gh. no cl mo w m of oc.
Yo said that fo the oent he detected the vehicle with insents(the inteviewe is efein to identication and initial e of anothe tank
that the witness descibed ealie in his testiony), the st shell was ed
and yo didn't hold yo e afte that. What does that ean?
Fo mo of h oo w w ug h ghg vc w h h
tank within our designated area as it was dened for us, and ring machine guns,
co, whv w h.
Fiin at what?
evyhg: hou f h uy blo comm hough hou look
uc, w' blow wy. if h fym ' lk h look of h hou
we'd shoot. Everything. We red This wasn't non-stop. Our ammo supply
w o l.
y wr t tht vt th rc w b cb, tr
wold coe fo hee and then eveyone wold be helpin ot to level
eveythin ahead?
i w l h wy. i occuy c 'cl' , k u oo go ou gh o h ghbohoo you occu o k ov hou
vou g you molh.
Yo bean to speak abot ao qantity?
Our tank red. Shall I tell you how much?
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
21/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Yes, to ive s an idea.
35 c of mch gu ou, omhg lk h. 40 hll, 30 hll, wo
c of hvy mch gu ou, 20 mo ou. i kow of oh cw
who even red white phosphorus.
y hv tht r ?Yes. Our battalion mortars were also using phosphorus. I know of an ofcer's
tank that red phosphorus, too.
Yo'e speakin in eneal, ty to be specic. A 60 . ota is not
rc t .
th' gh. th o h w u w m lc w w o cl,
g uch. Wh w w c o o w h m. i kow h
are storage structures there and that kind of stuff, at a range of 200-300 meters.
th g mo o l c.
What was the stoy of sin white phosphos ota shells?
th comy comm gv h mo loo comm g
orders him to re.
Wht w thr, kw?
A target. They dene targets. I can't really say what there was. Sometimes you'd
h o o "pm, hohou h ." th' . i o' cll f h wever conrmed by the company commander, but I know of an ofcer that also
red without requesting permission.
Why e phosphos?
Bcu ' fu. Cool.
Pofessionally do yo have phosphos fo se aainst sch theats?
i o' kow wh ' u fo. i w ju lkg bou h yy. i o'
u wh ' v og ou ul f w' o uo o u uchmmo. i' culou.
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
22/112
TesTimony 9 - Rules of engagemenT & House demoliTions
From the onset, he and the brigade commander and other ofcers made it very
clear to us that any movement must entail gunre.
n ttr wht k vt.
You don't need to be shot at. Sufce it that you suspect there's movement,
h w bfo w ou ow g . i o' mmb
f h bg comm h o omo l. i'm o u: o o
uo o b h, f you y g of movm ll, you hoo. th,
lly, w h ul of ggm. shoo f you lk. if you' f, o
you omo, hoo.
Even if thee's no dane?
th' h mg of h, y. You o' oly hoo wh h. thumo h you coly fl h, o yhg h h
you, you hoo. no o cully "hoo gl" o "hoo yhg
that moves." But we were not ordered to open re only if there was real threat.
Did yo feel theatened coin in?
Y. W go l h whol m. th of h w llly bg bul
u u. i c y h bou oulv, w w vy fgh. i cul fc
h w o o o b, bu w fl h. no h yhg h o
jufy h, bu fom h ou, w Gz f. i' mo o
h v, w w o g bck hom fly obl. i' ff.
L, i hv b gul. i' ff k of flg. You' f v
o g o k o muv. You o' w o g hu, you o' w
yhg o h o you. Coquly w' lo mo cuou wh og
re, we don't want to start off something that would get us stuck there. In general
v mo cful, hy o' u ucy k. a fo h ul of
ggm, w o g uco o hoo yhg h mov, bu w
w glly uc: f you fl h, hoo. thy k g ous that this is war and in war opening re is not restricted.
Afte ettin in positions, wee yo watchin the hoses all day o at
niht?
W wch hm ll h m.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
23/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
y rrt ct vt?
th w ohg h. Gho ow. exc fo om lvock, ohg
moved. One tank of our company had a run-in, identied an anti-tank missile
that was about to be red at it, so it red and that was that. Rumors ran that our
k w hll by mo. th hou l omo o u, "d' you
hear you'd been red at?" We had no idea we were red at. Alerts kept coming inll h m bou wom uc bomb bou o ch u wy mu.
no of h l v mlz.
How was she oin to each yo?
W go o fomo o h o o, hy ju ol u whch co h w
uo o com fom o k o h lookou h co. Byo h,
w ' h much.
sh w t c t?Y. th l w "Wom uc bomb o h wy o h oo."
somhg log h l, o oo my l. "Wh hou o wo." W k
getting alerts about a sniper in our area, about a group of ve observed inside a
house that could be an anti-tank missile crew. We constantly got all these alerts
o of hm mlz f ou comy w coc. th o
o m hy w my l. th of h m w h k
were on lookout and ambushes, and kept seeing re all around us, constant
artillery re, navy, air force, and regular units that were activated continuing fromwh w h b u.
Ou g w o ow bcu byo ho 500 m, il
my u w co, oo blo ***, w w o
allowed to re outside our area. Occasionally another area was opened to us. We
heard that company L opened re a lot, there were rumors around the battalion,
c' ll you how u hy w, bu umo h h hy h x lg
mou of mmo ogh wh h fym. Byo h umo i o'
kow wh h o '.
i c oly lk bou wh ou comy whch o much th w llybu c ug ou y h. O y w h ou foo
coffee. Suddenly the battalion commander's tank, ve meters away from us,
red a shell into a building. Why did he shoot? I don't know why. Perhaps he
cv l, myb o. i w' o o. i look goul o m, mo
of "wku cll" fo h comy. th w c wh o w
uc o b hgg ou h k. i hk h omo mly cm ou
of o of h k lookou c hm hough h w o
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
24/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
25/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
TESTImONY 10 - BrIEFINgS
What ae yo told at the biens befoe entein?
That's a complex question. In ofcial, formal briengs, there was no talk about
wh w w bou o o. W ' kow wh w w gog o o. Ul hvg bfo ou y o h Gz s, w ' kow wh h co
ou woul b lk. Bu ' mo o y h vyo who lk
o u, whh ou ow bg comm who ' k gl
in the action, but joined because a battalion from his brigade did or ofcers
we somehow got to meet, all sounded extremely militant, used very erce
lgug.
What lanae was that?
L' y h h gl och w 'w' gog off o w' i c wi h ou bg comm l oc, wh g wh u ug
maneuvers for a combatants talk around the campre at Tze'elim at night he
h o jo u w k hm wh w gog o Gz wh w
o b xc, uff lk h, h w o f o y h w w
w w, o coo of cvl w o b k. You hoo yo
you . i'm hg h, o llly quog, bu h g of h m
w vy cl.
Hw tk th?
Look, w' y ol comy. W' foug blo, ll of u 33
y ol, w ook h vy kclly, b fful of h my' och. i
kow fo mylf, i o' kow wh vy gl guy h gh fl bou . i kow
olly h h y much gu m. th w cl flg, h
w whv oh ok o u, h o hum coo
ly y ol h my . th gol w o cy ou oo
wh h l obl cul fo h my, whou v kg lf wh
h c woul b fo h oh . th w h hu of hg h w hfrom more than one ofcer.
What ofces?
C' ll you. Who ok o u? exc fo ou ow bg comm who'
a regular ofcer there were ofcers from that base. I don't remember who
talked to us, I can't name their ofcial title, I really don't remember.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
26/112
In ofcial talks this tone was epeated?
There weren't too many ofcial talks. We were training most of the time. A part
of the company perhaps did have ofcial talks, but we didn't attend too many of
ho. i gl, w w muv coul' g oo my l bou
our unit's activity. So we didn't talk to any intelligence NCO or senior ofcer,
at least not our company, except for ofcers from our own battalion: our ownblo comm, ou ow bg comm. Byo h, w ' u
into too many senior ofcers. When our brigade commander spoke, the tone was
vy obvou.
Yo entioned yo had a talk with the biade coande.
Y. imov.
Whr w th?
a tz'lm (g b).
Yo wee condctin aneves on how it was all oin to look inside
(th str)?
Y. Gg u o h c of ocv coy oo. th
k o h f cc, ' gh, h k k ou
h oo w ogz ou wh w , k muv h'
h oo ff. th ll w. so w h o h ou
campre and the brigade commander joined us. He described to us exactly whatw kg lc Gz. pcly.
Wht?
He described the incidents of friendly re. I think this was a day after a tank red
Gol blo comm. i o' cll h xc l. H xl
wh h, why h, how h. H ol u bou om mo
c h , bou m buco of Gol (fy) ol
how h go ou of h. H ol u o fom h h quo
cm u o wh w' b og h wh vyy lf wll b lk. H ,"You wll y h k h whol m." W lk bou ccl m,
bu h bc och o w w vy bul, h w my mo. ph
oh fl ffly. H omhg log h l of "do' l moly
bcom u. th wll com u l." H h h g lgug: "Lv
h ghm hoo h wll com u fo l, ow ju hoo." th w
h of hg, mo o l. th w w h cy bul u fo cc
tz'lm, w xc h b oll , wh k co
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
27/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
enter. There was an ofcer with us, can't tell you what his duty was, who talked
to us about lessons learned and conclusions drawn from the ghting in Gaza.
th w bg o h whol m, h w bookl comg ou o h
coly. i o' kow wh w hm.
i th wr?
During the rst days of the campaign. It kept coming all the time. Whole booklets
o lo l h w o Gz, hy w bg coly u.
so h (bg comm) ook u fo ol o wh ub comb woul
look lk k, h oo, h bc och, h lo h o g
co o u, w h h w o chc k. if you fc h
h by bulg you k ow h bulg. Quo uch "who lv
h bulg" o k. Whv g you wy, you o vyhg o
v gg you wy, gl of h hum mlco of
uch co. th w h of hg wh yo w h o lk o.L' y h h u of 'uy of m' o com u ll h lk.
****
TesTimony 11 - use of WHiTe pHospHoRus
& Rules of engagemenT
th w w bck oh, bou 500 m fom h fc, y h ll
night as look-outs. We saw nothing special. The next day we got back to base to
g w mo o w oc g g o foc fom Blo
*** wh whom w w . W wlk wh hm o h bch w ll h
wh hohou bomb i'v ol you bou, w w glzg o h .
C crb t? Wht ?
You' wlkg log h h h cuch of omhg bg cuh.
W look ow w wh look lk h h of hou of bokgl bol.
Wht cr t hv?
a y bow.
d r th whr rb?
There was an area of about 200-300 square meters of glazed sand like that. We
uoo h ul fom wh hohou, w ug.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
28/112
Wh?
Bcu g you l h wh hohou o u, you'
taught that it's not humane. You watch lms and see what it does to people who
h, you y, "th, w' og oo." th' o wh i xc o
. Ul h mom i h hough i blog o h mo hum my
h wol, i kw h v h W Bk, wh w go o ghbohoo,w o quly o h ol wo' u, bu lo o o o ub
hm, o l. W' o ev wh Moloov cockl w how u
h W Bk, w woul' hoo, h ul vy xlc. if you ow lf
k, you hoo. Bu u o oh ccumc. pcclly kg, how
often are you really in a life-threatening situation in the West Bank? Until that
moment I had never red a shot except at cardboard targets, just at the shooting
g muv, i lo uoo why. a idF ol o o hoo
fo h k of hoog o o h ly xcv foc byo h cll of
the mission he is to perform. We saw the planes ying out and you see from
whch bulg h ock luch g il you h fou hou
uoug h bulg collg oo h foc bomb. i o' kow
f w wh hohou o o, i o' lly c h much, bu whol
ghbohoo w mly z bcu fou hou h v o
luch Qm ock. i o' kow wh l c b o, bu o m
omwh uf.
Wht, th rrt?
Y. i' ooo.
Wh wt , th rrc w t ct th hv qt
not ies, bt atilley, ao and axiliay e. Yo wee watchin what
was bein ed thee, and how the tanks and otas wee sed?
Fom wh i w ou mo, k w of , loo fom Blo
***, o cu clo cov, ogh wh vl k o g, h
tanks waited for something to move in order to return re effectively. I didn't go
wh h hvy qum, w w ch o cl u who o wokwh h hvy qum.
What do yo ean by "waitin fo soethin to ove"? What wee yo
les of enaeent? What wee yo told at the biens?
"Anything looks suspicious to you, open re."
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
29/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Wht c? ar tt r bth v thr, t?
Y. You hv o c wo, vfy h o o o of ou. if h h
omhg o hm, h gou ough o
n tt, v wtht tt.
thy w umg h yo bomb zo, cyg Klhkov, o wo collco.
Yo o into Al Atata, and yo see bildins, hoses?
ru. i al a f g l hoo ' fy yhg,
my hooghc mmoy o h b. i mmb h 200 m
fuh o ow h ck h houl b juco, wh wo lg hou
h co, h w'. i mmb h w uo o b qu
wh Hm mmol moum, h w'. th w ubbl, bok
block.
How did the destction affect yo ability to conicate, to naviate?
It got to the point where we would try to report to eld intelligence about a gure
sticking out its head or a rocket being launched, and the girl (at eld intelligence)
woul k, "i h o h hou"? W' look h l hoo y,
"Y, bu h hou o log h." "W, fcg qu?" "no mo
qu." sh woul k u f h w h h o fouh juco, w' ll h
h hou ll cuh ov h juco you o' gl juco.
i go o h o wh w coul hly ou wy. L i w o hlookout war-room and asked how things worked, and the girl-soldiers there, the
lookou, h fc h hy h o wy o c h l, bcu ll
of h fc o w z. so hy woul c hm gl m
o ly olly o coo. thy fou h fc o o l hoo
shared by the pilots and the war-room, and very approximate, which also annoys
m. Wh h, oxmo? i' hghly obl h ow h lo wll bomb
h wog hou.
Wee yo told of this appoxiation, o is this yo own take on thins?
i w my ow k o hg. sh ll hm, "tk om 800 m of h
o o m uch uch zmuh fom h o h l,"
you y, "W, f h o o u h com oh um h
cockpit for these measurements, then possibly he'll miss targets, it's not so far-
fch. th o h 'm bomb' w h b wokg o o h. Coul b
h' ug uch bomb, bu mg h wog g."
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
30/112
30
TesTimony 12 - Rules of engagemenT
When yo o in, what is yo objective?
W w ll wg o cv o o , w h' h yhg y,
v ou comm h' h much. W w mly ol o "hol hjuco, cool ." aly h hgh chlo w cl bou o gog
fuh o ph 3 oly g o o c u h
just put their foot on the rst rung of the ladder, just in case we do eventually
clmb . Bu w w kowg w fo fw y bcu w' og h
ph. alhough w h h olcl mov w fomg, l' y.
s ct thr w bjctv.
rgh. W h o k ov mly . W h o m l of vo oo
tch o. aoh loo fom ou comy hl h. My ow loo oh fom h ohmo l, h mo fow, h fuh fom h
fc thy cv uco o o llow y movm log tch
o.
Wht tht ?
i m h f vhcl mov log h o, o o hoo ju h
of h vhcl o h h v woul lz h bg g mu'
vl h o h' u bck. th w o c wh ul hy lz
h uck w ho , bu u ou i o' kow whh yo
w ju.
This was in effect both day and niht tie?
eclly gh. no vhcl. F of ll, pl w' movg ou
there at night, and secondly, in the day time there was trafc and it was stopped
by gunre. Our distance from the road was about 200-300 meters. That was
mo o l h g W cooll h o v movm
w w uc. th w o c h of moocycl g ou, io' kow wh wh h ul of ggm w fo h mo co,
but anyway the tank red a shell at the motorcycle and hit it. I don't know what
h o bu i blv ohg much w lf of h guy.
I want to back p soe. Yo entioned a tck that was taeted. What
h thr, wht w th tr r kw?
W h uco o o llow g. Whov w o uy h m h
uck v o oc wh w hg my hv u hm.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
31/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
It advanced further than the instructions allowed, so he red in order to stop it,
ring at the spot that was usually targeted. The truck had already reached that
spot and he simply red at it.
This took place in day- o niht-tie?
dym.
The instction to shoot in font of a ovin vehicle applies to achine
n e o shellin?
Not shells, light gunre, machine gun or M16 rie. One can easily aim in front of
h vhcl, h lo mkm, o oblm.
Okay, what abot pedestian tafc?
For pedestrian trafc, the entrance was on the road coming out at Sufa Crossing.
th whol o w o wh h gou offv bg. thy bulloz hck lll o h o, o w o fo movm.
a cv?
no h. a oo h oo , hy ll c o h ow.
So all the villaes aond thee actally
W lmo olly bo. i'm u h w cvl h h, bu
o my.
Yo didn't see even one thoh yo binoclas?
no. im llg you, i w o, h guy my comy w llg m
and I couldn't gure out if they were pulling my leg. I assume it was the truth.
When yo ente a hose, yo'e iven cetain instctions not
trtv, rt?
th il my u ouo ocu by h book O of h hg
h ocu g l. i m h whov co h lm ho, o quo k.
sht t k?
shoo o kll, y. i ou c, h hou wh w w, h w x, ou
oo fo w h oh o, h hou o o h w, y
uou by cm block wll, bou 15 m fom h hou oo. W
w uc o hoo o kll yo g h y. sm w u fo oh
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
32/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
33/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
34/112
3
TesTimony 13 - Rules of engagemenT
Wht w t k th h?
Well, you know. Routine. For our rst two days there, we were hungry, then we
go foo vyhg fll o lc, ul woul v vy y o wo.Once in a while we'd break the routine re in some direction, at one house or
oh. th w comy fom h blo o w of u h h
some engagement. There was no ghting in the houses.
Was thee any htin to bein with? How was yo inteaction with the
cv?
thy w h hou. i ' y wh my ow y bu i o hk
there was one civilian killed in the rst house, when the house was taken over.
When it was entered with gunre, then the procedure changed and there weremo ch. th w fmly h co hou o w ' go
with gunre. We yelled at them to get out, banged on the door. As soon as that
rst one was killed, I think he was an elderly man, the policy was changed and it
was more searching and less opening re.
So, at st, thee was iediate e? meanin yo shot at those
h?
Y.
They didn't ealize they had to et ot?
i gu hy w f o.
What wee yo assinents inside the hoses? Occpyin o only takin
th t rtct r?
W' k ov hou, k chgg, cug h o. Glly, ou mo
w o ol h . no o l y vhcl v o h o.
Wee thee vehicles ovin thee at all?
No. Occasionally there were people, usually we opened deterrent re.
So what was diffeent fo yo, o difclt, in this paticla wa?
Mo of h m w bog. th w o lly oo my v. th w
one pretty difcult incident where we had to A man suddenly appeared at a
distance, something like 150-200 meters, at night. We detected him carrying a
ickering torch. We detect from rather far away, we request conrmation to open
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
35/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
deterrent re. He approached on a zigzag, advancing towards the house. We ask
for conrmation. At the time we couldn't tell whether he was suspect or carrying
yhg. W hough h wh h och h my b ghg fomo bou
ou lcm. W h ll k of . W o g h OK fo
re. Our commander went up to the roof with other soldiers, and all that while the
guy w vcg oh ul h comm lc hmlf o h oof whh oh. th m fom gh bh om . th x m w
detected him, he was 15-20 meters from the house, which by all our instructions,
fy mu, co zo g f w coc f
omo cyg xlov. th w lo of uc bomb l h
m, ll h m, cly. so w h o k ow h guy. if h cyg
xlov chg k xcly o co fo hm o u o h hou. a
that moment the soldiers on the roof shoot him, another soldier too opens re.
Later it turned out this was an old man with a ickering torch and a white shirt.
d t?
W o.
Opened e iht away?
evully u ou o b mk.
What wee the les of enaeent?
i of w, h ul of ggm h ol o h gou mu
xc h ow jugm, h comm' jugm h mom.
d th v kw wr tht h?
L, i hv o wy of kowg. O h o h, ho hou i o
kow how yo coul o b w of ou c, h w hvy apC
coly comg gog. You coul kow w w h. i hv o
fom wh h m cm. H w clo o h hou i o' kow f h
kw w w h. a f w' coc h ju o u.
Wh t th rtcr tr?
You asked about a difcult experience.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
36/112
3
Bt t w tk.
Y, bu oo w h voc i fl woul lg o my m fo
while, the man down there was crying out. So I recall it as a difcult moment. I
kow h ly h fo wo y ul h w mov.
****
TesTimony 14 - Rules of engagemenT
One night, I don't know whether it was the rst or second week, but it was
certainly after about 5-6 days we had already been inside. I think this was
already the second week. There was an outpost brieng. Everyone assembled
h m hllwy. th comy comm ok, h loo comm
ok. W ok, *** k m f i, oo, omhg blkg o ho? W obv fo fw co lgh blkg f wy f
oh fw co lz ' o. somo wlkg ow h o
ou co. a m go by w c fy mo. H' wlkg, holg
och, wg wh h, h log b, ol m wlkg ow h
ml of h o. W fom bou h co, h och h
ly um. th h comy comm v, ll wok u,
looks around, identies it and says "All snipers up to the roof." We ask, "Why
ll u o h oof? Wh' h m?" H oly , "all h
u o h oof, you c ly o m." i k whl fo hm o g h. th
m com clo, bou 150 m fom u, h h comm go o
yg, "do' woy, 'll b ll gh." a c of 100 m w c ll
fo u h h' o holg yhg. th oly hg h mgh b cyg
xlov bl, o h fomo gh fo h Hm. i c' ll. a
fo y h, howv, h w ohg. W kw h. W o o
h comy comm h h guy holg ohg k hm o llow
deterrent re. This was nighttime. The rules were "gray." On the one hand at
gh f you omo you k hm ow. O h oh h you' lookg o wlkg ow h ml of h o holg och, lookg mo
hough h chg fo hl o foo o h' ugg. H o' m o
b o h wy o kll u. Bu you kow, h of h y ' h ool
considerations that count. We ask for permission to open deterrent re. The
comm fu y hy'll b y oo. th pl ly
70-80 meters from us and we ask again about deterrent re. It's getting touchy
bcu c of 50 m xlov bl c k ow vyo
h oom. H och vyo' ly o o hm i h guy
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
37/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
fom oh hou llg u o k hm ow ly. th m 50 m
from us and there's yelling on our radio. At this point it's re proper, not deterrent
re. The man reached about 20-25 meters from the house. Another second and
we're pulling the trigger. Suddenly a burst of re is heard from upstairs, making
u ll jum. th ol m gv uch cm i'll v fog log i lv.
evyo hoog hoog h guy' cmg. th commcom ow, glowg. "H' o fo ogh." H w k why
he wouldn't conrm deterrent re. He said, "It's nighttime and this is a terrorist."
Wh w h kw h guy h ohg o hm oly holg och,
h , "th o' m. i' ghm, c., c." th w flg h
ol w ou o kll h, o o fl b bou . L omo bough
u g wh h comy comm wh w go ou, k hm g
why he didn't approve of opening deterrent re. After all it had been a man
wlkg o h o wh och wh h. th x mog w
out the explosive-detector dog to sniff him out. The guy was clean, nothing onhim. Except for a torch in his hand, a white shirt and a long beard. A 50-60
year-old man lying on the road. I felt uneasy about the whole thing, but knew
h woul' o y goo o bg u gh h cofo h comy
comm h ml of Gz.
Wht w th tk wth h bt tr c t?
somo k hm why, h g w bcu of ghm
uch. Guy ol hm h m w oc w mu mmb h'
cvl oulo h wll, o ju o, h fc h o
w cvl cloh o' m y cvl mu b kll c H '
agree and couldn't give a damn, and nally the guys felt that even if they would
k h u wh hgh chlo, woul b ffcv. so h wh m
y.
****
TesTimony 15 - RaBBinaTe uniT
O y o o h y o Gz, mobl u v fom h mly
bb u. thy och m hy blog o ogzo
cll "Jwh aw," hy cm o lk wh h ol gv ou
ml co of th Book of plm om bochu. i o' hv h
uff hy gv ou. O w mjo, h oh w o ufom o i o'
kow wh h k w. i c' ll whh h w o v uy o o. thy
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
38/112
3
h c log b, cul. thy h com o lk wh h ol, whch
was ordinary procedure, not only prior to a signicant operation. The rabbi would
ummo h lgou guy ou u, whov w o woul g ogh o
h hy woul hol uy o ogh o cu sbbh o'
o'. th bg bb, fo xml, woul k yo
xl o hm wh Jwh lgou lw llow o fob wh m fo comb. th w o hg.
The abbi of yo eseves biade?
Y. aoh hg w o "cch" o gh ll h ol fo cuo.
y wr vr t th t?
Y, vou xc. th w c o fo ff k of cc.
so hy cm h w ol who w lly g h. i m, hy
w ug uch mg 'wh w, cu bg fo h blwh slh l d?' thy lly lk h lgou o of w. O h oh
h, h w oh who lov ly coc o , comg u
hugly wllowg h o of lk. i ' l o h lk h l
bou 15 o 25 mu.
W't ttc cr?
no. i w' mbly wh vyo. i m howg u wh vyboy
w ywy whov ' w o y coul g u lv. so of
half-captive audience. I remember that one of the things I resented I am sorry I
' u h o o bk u h cuo how h guy ou v f h
w uhoz by omo o oh w h h h w g fou
enemies. Whereas the army dened the aim of this war to weaken and topple the
Hm, wh h mo o l uul my fomulo, h fllow x h
fm of fc o : "W hv fou m," h . H
wh i. now i ovg lwh, o ou my h
w, bu uully il cou cv my, gl
of wh you o, ' h my. so l' um h h cou h'pretty much the norm. Then he went on to mention the Hamas, which was dened
h my ywy, oc o k of h pl auhoy. if i
mmb cocly, h b mo comlx. th pa o o g Gz
o goo v f mly vul, h fouh my h
ab cz of il. i w xlcly. i o' cll h xc m, whh
h u 'h ab of il' o 'il ab,' bu hy um u. H
' qulfy ll o om who H xlcly ok of hm my, whl
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
39/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
addressing this specic operation. This is, of course, a false and problematic
m.
Wht c th tk?
Lo of ho, h k of lgou cou i'm b fml wh: w of choc,
holy w ffg ul. H ok l lgou mology, v of h ki kow, w much mo o ml fh. H m g h m wh
coug, culy, ggv, xo uch 'o y, Go oc
you, everything you do is sanctied.' The gist of these statements was perhaps
o bg hg o gm wh lgo, wh Go whov h m w
uo o , h vyhg o ly vyhg mbl. th
were no specic scenarios discussed, for example whether everything goes
f h' g wom g h. Bu fom h cox w y
obvou h cm o ll u how ggv m w o b, h
w mu w bcu h holy w.
H k bt th pt?
i c' cll. Of h ul log m, qug h pl
wh h amlk, fo xml. th pl h my, whh hy
il cz o ubjc of h pl auhoy mk o ffc.
th cov vyo.
Soe soldies wee sayin they wee bein teated like 'csades.' What
w tht?
Y, cul guy, o ho who fom (Jwh) o lgo,
stood there rather amused or horried at this talk. What is this thing? Here comes
guy w o' kow, wh om k o oh, xl o u bou holy w
h my whch h ab il h w mu' how y mcy,
and have to attack in proper ghting spirit. What has all this to do with me? You
can imagine, even in lms you don't see that any more, it's out, like heroes. You
can imagine a priest preaching on ghting spirit and explaining the importance
of chg h V doloo o h Holy s. a f i kow h w oholy .
How did the ofces ead this? Was it discssed at the coand level,
did yo bin it p fthe? Was it accepted? Did it o nnoticed?
i m yg o cll. F of ll, oly f i w h Hz (h w
fg o ublco Hz ly w of Juy 26h 2009 bou
mhl bu by h amy rbb o ol who ook h
Gz cmg), i lz h w w homo. if you' you
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
40/112
0
u omo com log lk, oky. th wo vywh
h w o lkg o u ' ou of l, h l vy clo
ccl w lk bou how ou of l h w. Bu o mu' mk uch
bg l of vy uch vul. My lly w hm g. th'
how i go o you, i w h w oy lz h ch o oly
ou ow , w much mo ou mo hoough lookgo. th w lo o h of h my bb o xm ow
ol, o l mo h vyhg h o ol. th xmly
v fc bw h lgou h cul, Jwh l
lf cv who cll cl v hough hy v h v,
fo vou o i o' mmb xcly, bu i'm lmo u h w
lk bou h bg ul of h 'ggm' h bckg off whch
om fl bou ll of h, h h' oouy o w, o 'mug
hg u.' i hk ll h hg ou of lc h.
****
TesTimony 16 - RaBBinaTe uniT
W w tz'lm bg muv o fo ou y o h
Gaza Strip. We were actually going through various exercises for our specic
gm. i h fmwok, gg wh w' lkg bou h my
bb wo hg h ou coc wh hm h m. th
rst was the distribution of pamphlets, an indirect sort of contact. It's the kind
of mhl h bu mly ygogu, o g of h wkly
g h lo bu mly ygogu, cog h xlc
olcl co. Lk wg, fo xml, h h pl lk h
phl of ol, wcom who o o blog h l, l l o
ou ol whch houl clly u o u. th w lo h coym of h
m of h Jwh lm nzm h houl b bul.
What wee these paes, exactly?
There are yers containing the weekly religious reading that are very similar to
ll k of mly mhl you h ygogu, bu hy hv h idF
m o hm h of h mly bb. i h mly bb h
m cll 'Jwh aw fo Wg idF' whch fc h
m chg of movo u olvg oblm of moly
ghting and the like, for soldiers.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
41/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Wht rb hv wth tht?
polly, i hk h cz of mocc wh boh m
cully h buo of olcl mhl wh h m of h idF o hm
boy h uo o b olcl. i hk h o oom fo olcl
vw h my, gl of whh i g wh hm o o. i hk hy
ou of lc my fmwok. th' o wy blo comm ccom o h ol y: w ow hv o go bck l nzm.
th ou mo. th wh w houl o, bul nzm. Clly,
blo comm who woul y h woul l b m, h
is likely to be penalized even more severely. And here an ofcial institution tightly
coc o h my, cg h m of h my, com m
h m mg, o o y yhg. th wh boh m h.
th co hg, h mo mm mu w w bou h w
wh w w g o of h tz'lm zo. W h ju coclu
xc w w g fo h x o, h h amy rbb
ofcer came along with his ranks, uniform and all, and asked us if we were
wllg o l o bb who w wh hm, cvl . W g. U
cm m who ouc hmlf rbb Ch, h w h m, who
cm cvl o k o u. th whol lk w o: h
rst point throughout his speech later you see it in the pamphlets as well is
h cy of h pol of il. H u h wy: h h whl gog
h, w houl kow h o ccoug fo h c. th mg
of h, i'm gg o om o h whch vbl, ohwo o o lz how oblmc uch m . Wh bb y
'h' o ccoug,' h mg h wh o zo h
ully vy gou vyo f o o o kow wh
wll h, wh h fuu h o fo u, of cou h f. such
fears are intensied by each person's own past and deeds he must confront, and
ully h lwy h ml f h h h lc wh ll my
wll b fo. so vw of h, h bb u y: o' woy h'
o ccoubly. O h mo bc lvl h how i u h mg.
i o' y oh wy o . Fuhmo, h m co m bou h fuu: f h lly o ccoubly fo wh i hv
o h , h ully h o fo wh i m bou o o h
mm o fuu. i oh wo, w houl kow h whv w
do is ne.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
42/112
W thr t th pt? Wht h bt th?
aoh o h cm u w wh h bb w cully coucg
h w of 'h o of lgh' g 'h o of k.' th fc
m wh hghly mc lgug. th w h h wy fo
nal redemption. This is outrageous in itself. Again, we witness a language that
is not acceptable to all present, denitely a legitimate view and as such I haveno problem with it. But it must not receive any kind of ofcial stamp, it must not
b u wh y mly fmwok. i ju lk olcl vw. Bu h mo
ubg o v, h h hologcl o, mozo of h oh
. i u h oh gly o 'o of k' whl w bcom
'sons of light.' There is no differentiation which we would expect to nd between
civilians and others. Namely, here is one people ghting another people, with all
h mc mlco. Bu h' h o: h lo lgou og.
i oh wo, h my o vvl mg. th o h o ol
l. thy o o u o ufom o o b Juz b bo h
fh.
****
TesTimony 17 - House demoliTions & Rules of engagemenT
Wh w go h, h m molo w wf, u cook.
From the point we got there, infrastructure work began. D-9s were brought in
hy wok oo o z och k ow hou uc of
containing tunnels. Occasionally there was sniper re inside the refugee camps
h w m o c h ouc, m w c comb
helicopters and tank re at the house that was supposedly the source of re. You
have to be extremely professional to detect the source of re and direct exactly
ow . th g w ov klom vy cow .
Detectin snipe e ove a kiloete away inside a efee cap is nealyb.
Tank re was directed in response.
Tanks in heavy anition, shells?
Yes. After detecting sniper re.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
43/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Wh rct th d-9?
th u comm.
H w c whch h w t b tk w?
Y. af coulg h comy comm. th comy comm woul
request conrmation of the Brigade Headquarters and the unit commander wouldwok cly wh hm.
In all of that hose azin activity, wee thee cases of explosive chaes
blowin p?
no whl i w h.
a th rchr r?
Not while I was there. But I was told there were during the rst week.
Yo'e sayin thee was plenty of infastcte wok din yo week
thr.
Y.
Hw d-9 ct?
two o h.
Wokin nonstop?
Y i w' block of cow bulg wh hou z h
ml. th w c bulg. i fmg , h ly of
fruit groves between houses. There's sort of a street, several streets, not well-
o fucu, o f kg ow hou h w h b flg,
bu you h fu gov o och whch w olly z hou
k ow h ovll mgh b h vyhg w my. i'
o lk h. th w hou k ow h h. th flg '
ll u, ll h w oy h w hll fom h
bombg bfo h gou offv. a l h h logcl xlo.W w h fo wk, o og oo much bclly holg ou oo,
bg o h lookou, g ou occol ch, kg oh hou
over to search it. At some point our ofcer decided he'd hold a grenade-launching
cc bcu w h' mg h bfo w . so w w o
hou x oo, ook oom, ch o cm log hw
grenade inside. The house was totally devastated. At some point a grenade ew
ou wow h g , g lkg w o h cc.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
44/112
W bck. Occolly om cvl woul how u. aoh foc ch
hou by fou cvl . thy mbl hm, i o' kow
wh hy wh hm. O y om fug, cvl, cm w
ch k wy, o mbl h hou x oo. i hk hy h
b h h whol m. th w o much cool ov h. thy w
u Joh ( ff o h vw h w cb hJoh ocu, ug pl cvl hum hl ug hou
searches), and then released, and were nding them in later searches.
****
TesTimony 18 - BRiefings & Rules of engagemenT
i gl, w h quck comb ocu. igly, 24 hou bfo hoperation began, a general brieng was held about how long we were going in
for. The battalion commander said he estimates about 3-4 weeks. You couldn't
kow fo u. th blo comm goo k, kow how o
mov u. O of h hg h oo ou w ubjcv , omhg
vy mv bou h whol hg. H w w gog o xc
re power with artillery and air force. We were given the feeling that we were not
ju bg ou h, bu wh omou cuy cov. H
y, "i' o h you' ou o cy ou mc, bu" h w h
o vyhg h h bfo, bw h ow jok whch
made me laugh, too. Like, "We have an Arabic-speaking grenade launcher, and
a heavy machine-gun that speaks Arabic." This was the spirit of things.
Was anythin said abot les of enaeent?
My mo bou ul of ggm w h, l ou lvl, hy
w o cl. th w o cl l. i ub ' vy much
the commanders' own discretion. As for the re-power actually used, the feeling
w of w g gul my. O h o h, w w ol o vyhouse under live re. A grenade or two, shooting, and only then we enter. Things
were said that in a way made us condent that our own lives were top priority.
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
45/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
TesTimony 19 - BomBaRdmenT
Wht w th bjctv th rt?
It was very clearly dened: to gain control of the area, there would be no Qassam
re while we were on the ground; aiming to strike a real blow at Hamas, to theo ogzo gl.
How ae yo sitated to bein with, ae thee seconday defense positions?
H?
My own company, of our battalion, goes in rst. We wait for two of the battalions
to occupy their objectives, they nish, then we follow.
The taets ae elds?
no. a ghbohoo. no qu kbh, bu l.
i t rr r?
Y. Cy ouk. W' u fcg m o. th whol cov hg
starts, massive re, auxiliary re, and then my company goes in. We hold the
line of houses across the road, following heavy re. In the rst phase, we open
re in every zone.
Wht rt ? Wht th z ct?
th comy' g clu jc o h hou. th'
o c o k of. som xlov fou hou, wo,
signicant stuff like that, but no real resistance. Behind there's another strip of
gardens and small orchards, elds.
Yo o into evey hose?
Y.
Yo o in, einfoced by ota e, heavy eqipent, achine ns
?
F of ll, gog w hv lly foc cov, comb hlco,
vyhg. a mo oo.
So yo position yoselves and then what? Bein a sleep cycle and ove
?
Bg g u f. s bg, ll hoog hol h wll, bul u
ouo, l h f of h hou. a h of h y h loo
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
46/112
u h hou. ech hou bcom mll my ouo wh oo,
w o.
Wht r t t?
No signicant missions came out of the house. Days afterwards, for example,
every time we'd move houses, we'd re on the houses around, on every zonew' . W' mov hou u w, loo woul chg ou,
' o uch chg. i h o y wo o h hou ou
y h.
Did yo see any people in the neihbohood, at all?
Yes. These are the outskirts of Gaza City, not a village. At rst there were civilians
in the houses we entered. In the rst house that was taken, there was a family
whch w mbl o oom, f hou o wo, h m mog,
w w uc o mk hm lv wlk o h cy.
****
TESTImONY 20 - ruLES OF ENgAgEmENT
Our objective was to split the Gaza Strip, fragment it. Netzarim is the mid-point
ou objcv w o l h s fom h ml. W o h , h'
our mission. We reach the rst house and even at a distance, simply becauseh' h uco, w hoo bcu h o o w uo
o b . Fly w bu wo y l hy w fom w w
coming. From a distance the house is taken down and there is lots of gunre. A
D-9 bulldozer makes the rounds to verify that the house is not booby-trapped.
Suddenly the D-9 jumps in the air and the entire ground oor collapses as well
as part of the second oor.
Did the blldoze hit an explosive chae?
Yes, nothing happened to it. We moved to an alternate site and again, red like
czy.
What did yo e with?
Hvy mch gu w h o apC, luch.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
47/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Yo liht as?
Y. th w' oo much qum o molh h hou fo w h o
y . th h f h yo h hou who woul fom of
our coming, he would be taken down. We hold our re and approach the house
c. W hv om fllow fom cl u of h Co of eg
who would blast the door open. Suddenly we see an old man, about 60-70 yearsol. H com ou wh wh kchf y abc, "do' hoo, o'
hoo". abou 30 mo ol follow h ol m, ll of hm o c, o
o wou o h.
At what ane did yo taet the hose?
30 m.
a th c t th h?
Y. a o o w hu. amzg. W w hock, oo. eclly fg h hou g wh w o . no o w hu. abou
hy ol com ou of h, clug chl, wom lly. thy g
c ju lk h W Bk, wom hol h gm gh g
h bo, m k off h , u ou, hy' chck o
mk u hy' o cyg yhg.
y rt th?
Y. Wom m. You oc hm o by o. You cthem one by one. It took place outside the house. According to the brieng we
h, f w cou uch cvl, w w o ch hm wy o h ouh.
rmmbg w' lg h s o h ouh of u h o foc,
and indeed we're exposed to re from the south, but if there are civilians, we
houl ch hm wy o h ouh. th w h fml, o h h of
each family, and only he entered their home for ve minutes, took whatever he
hy h o oc ouh.
o t?Y. thy hv o vhcl
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
48/112
TesTimony 21 - BRiefings & Rules of engagemenT
H (h blo comm) lo ok bou hvg o m l
o b f, h h h w o lm cofoo uch
Hbo, o o h o hoo f w uc omo, o fl b bou
uco bcu ll o fo h fy of ou ow ol.
Bt yo had liht as, yo wee not in tanks. And destction, I ean
how ch of that cold yo inict?
It was a combined operation. There's a D-9 bulldozer and 'Matador' (missile) that
c fo bulg. H h whv w oy c b bul, bu
h lf of ol oc kll co b o.
d h k tct btw cv trrrt?
th, oo, w mo l, o h m lk, h f w omhguc hoo, b h oc h h o g my. You
exercise judgment. The rst house we entered contained not a single enemy.
We red at windows and re was not returned. So we went in and opened it the
wy w uully go hou Hbo: w go , cll ou o h ow o o,
gh ll h ml, hckl hm, gh h fmly o oom
bg o ch h hou. th o omhg h uully o w.
Wh tr h, kw wht wr t
rt r thr r th Wt Bk? Hw th rt?
Wh you hou, h h co my. You' uo
to shoot your way in. We didn't do this in the rst house because we had opened
re and no re was returned. So we assumed there was no one there. Then we
kock o h oo ol hm o cll vyo ow, gh hm
oom comb h lc culy, lookg fo cmg ml:
wo, o, og uff.
Who did yo nd in the hose?
Men, women and children. This was our rst objective in the operation plan. We
wlk , ch h ghbohoo bg h offv vc. Whl
you' ckg you hoo lo v whl coug o o. You mk
u you' o bg u. sy w hohou cug
: you cu hol h hohou, hoog h l ow. You'
not on automatic re, but you do give a few bursts to make sure you won't be
u.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
49/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
50/112
50
mbuh. a oo omo hm you hoo. th ' l'
procedure is to report, request permission to open re.
Is thee sspect-aest pocede like wanin e o callin ot to
whvr' thr? i 't rk . it' th t' rvt
lanae.
Y, ' v co.
i rch, hw r h? d hv
eaphones?
no. W o'. i o' kow how you fom hm. Bfo w , h foc
dropped yers and people were supposed to get out of there. As for those who
' g ou, w w o hoo h o h f. Bu f omo woul
co h l, you w uo o hoo hm. Ul h' cl
announcement, for there were humanitarian ceaseres all the time, when wew o hoog.
Wht w th tc btw th h ch r ?
100 m. a lgh m g. th lo h wh u h
hou who gh fuh wy c och.
Hw c t tht tk wth th btt cr?
i ' fl h g, olly. th w bcu of h wy h x
hmlf bou c hg. th gl flg w h w w g h
oo wh zl, ol w g hmlv vvg hmlv
u bfo gog , h gog h.
Wht h tht trb ?
"My b abc lo my g luch." i o' mmb h cox,
ju h g of hg.
p r brw t th?som. Bu h' wh oubl m mo. O of h ol com h
gou u o og who' b u lo. th og g ll wok u h
' c omo o o 'go g hm.' i' u. ify blo
lo of h ou vc, ' lk h y my. Youg ou fo
co mo of hm hv y c vw ywy, om of hm y "i
o' w w, bu wh c w o, h how hg w'll v hv
c wh h ab." th' h gl cu. O h oh h h
om ol wh lf vw, bu hy' h moy.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
51/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
52/112
5
foc, wh whch yo c uc g c uo oo h
shbk oky .
Wr th r?
No. The report specied that they were unarmed. But that's not the point. The
o h fou m g ou h hou cofg look uc.
And that takes place 300 etes fo o foces?
200-300 meters. And it's on a hill. Our forces are downhill, and they're standing
above, say two-thirds of the way up.
****
TesTimony 23 - Rules of engagemenT & Home seaRCHes
i ou wok h ouo, wow, obvo o you
wch ou o, f, y, you kow h you hv cuo gh,
you mgh go fo wlv hou o mo, bu wlv hou w h vg m of
an incursion: you go out, take the house, spend two-three inside, then go back
o h m hou o o oh o. You you o, h vg, you
realize that at midnight you're already going out, you see the ghter planes bomb
you g, you wlk, ly gh x o h k h hllg h hou
which you will be entering, then you go into urban ghting, with live gunre. Ifyo w h bfo, h' o chc h ll h. i o o
gl ab h whol m w w h, h whol wk. You o ch
h g wh blk o mll g bu. Whh hy ug h ch
bcu hy w fo you o bcu h' f ug h hllg. You
h w ol h ul cly. i h hou, w v, w
entered through a hole broken in the wall by a tank shell. You try to re a RPG
o Lu ml. Bu h k h o vully mkg h hol. You' lo
told to wreck the oor tiles to check for tunnels. Television sets, closets youo' kow wh' wg h. My xlov chg w fou, hy lo
blw u, o o w hu. tk Co o Co of eg u blw hm u.
Uully hy o xlo bcu mo of h o w fou w w
h o b o, bu whov w uo o o hm h u off.
i w lv, howv, y
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
53/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Yo talk abot tanks in while ovin. Was thee assive e?
Y, hllg, mch gu o k, ou oo. Bfo you hou, you
hooi c' y h' h c of ol wg o l go, yg o
luch h Lu ml hy' houlg, o h h comm w h.
Y. i c' quo yo, bu w h . polly i hk ' h, i' b
lyg f i w y c. sll wh i w, h c, h o wnot over-zealous. I think some forces were more zealous than ours, perhaps the
gul. Bu mog v you fl ol w o g o wh quckly
obl g bck hom. i w h wy gu uy hf wll. th
comm oo, vy much o, fc. ev f h ol w o hoo, h
'. Bu wh h h chc, h h . pofolly h ' lly
o hoo f h k h wck h hou, bu h' my ow ol
feeling. We did re a Lau missile once. So that's more or less what we did there
fo wk. phyclly h hou w u.
i o hou w i w guy h fc w. th w
drawings and grafti on the walls. I don't even remember what. I remember a
lthy drawing in a children's nursery. There were Mickey Mouse and Minnie
Mou ck h, omo h w hug ck o M Mou.
i lly fl hm h, o o guy who w wh m. i w fuy
because it was drawn really well, but you feel lthy. Even to tell about it.
Whr w th?
i B Lhy, hou wh w h lc gul ol. W w uchhg wo hou. i o h w fw wg o h wll, om of hm
v m wh lck, h clo w ll h. i ou . You
com ou of wck hou ll w cl u f oulv. W h lo
of foo lf whch w lf fo hm (h fmly). W l u ll h m.
In Operation 'Defensive Shield' I was platoon sergeant. People slept on the oor,
we locked up the living room in another room and slept on the oor. In Gaza it
w ff. W u ol' m blk, bu w ' l
h b. W ook ow h m, h w ly of m
ch hou, l o hm. W ' u h w. W ' hv o.th' , i hk. th' mo o l wh w lk.
Is thee anythin beside the shit in the dawes that seeed 'ncalled fo'
t ?
no, you c y o ' hv o mh lvo o hoo clo
hough, bu yg h woul b ug o . i ' go o hou
kck lvo i ' y of my v o h. O h oh
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
54/112
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
55/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
of h ol l cyclly: "so kll h oco." th comm l
mgly, o ug h cycl , wc: "W' moccy,
w c' o hg h wy w woul lk o o hm." H ' lv y m
fo quo, h.
How did the ys eact at this bien?
My guy w o hock. i w. My w u, bu h ' lv
y m fo quo, f yo w o k bou h cvl oulo.
Bcu, g, h ' v mo cvl.
y tht r cv r tk bt.
Yes. There was a discussion at the end of our term of duty, led by the brigade-
comm, colol, who h h my how coo. H
mo h cvl. Bu h w f w ll ov.
usally the isse of civilian poplation is boht p?
Y.
a d-9 rtr, th cv t r tchc r
line becase of yo eld of vision and the size of yo eqipent and all.
In yo ela sevice, is that soethin that is especially ephasized?
The D-9 operator is not the one who can show consideration to the civilian
oulo. i m, h c oly o mo mg h h ly mu, bu h
co how coo. if h' o o "molh hou," h molh
hou. O h oh h, h coul b h y of oo who bcm fmou
(h my' vo of) J, who wh uc o molh c
hou look fo h ou h woul vbly molh h lg umb
of hou o h wy o h g hou.
So coandin ofces wee sittin in on this talk?
Yes, the entire company, as well as the battalion-commander, company-
comm.
They actally desinated taets on the ap?
Y.
Yo ae sally assined to a foce on the ond; yo ae not diectly
sbodinate to the Cops of Eninees.
th' h uul o of hg. W' g o oh foc. Bu wh w
did, two tanks led an armored convoy, two D-9s led an armored convoy. What
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
56/112
5
w , ou objcv w o molh hou. W w cu by hvy apC
k. i h c h k w g o u h h h oh wy
around. There were ve or six D-9s active on the ground all of the time. And
hvy apC k h cu u.
So when did yo actally o in?
if i'm o mk, h gou foc bg o o thuy.
This is afte the infanty had been thohot this aea?
Y. th w comlly my. evyhg w my.
ghost town, not a sol in siht?
Y.
So yo o in, who coands the opeation, this ission?amo Co, i gu.
So how did yo et yo odes? Yo sat with a location ap?
First there was a brieng before entry, and then inside Gaza, and we got our
uco ov o.
y'r t, "s tht h th t? g r t"?
Y.
Yo wee doin ainly hoses thee?
Y, hou, gculul wll, och hohou.
Those aeas whee yo destoyed hothoses and elds, wee thee any
explosive chaes thee?
The battalion got two explosive charges as well as anti-tank missiles.
Aainst the D-9s?
Y. a i hk h m coc w h ul w bg bul fom wh
ho hou.
T bct r?
Y.
So why deolish one hose and not the othe, becase of intellience on
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
57/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
th t?
Y, llgc fomo.
And in the aicltal aeas, do yo ecall explosive chaes aainst
?
Y.
How ch was actally deolished thee? Anythin the likes of which
yo had seen as a ela soldie?
th w . Uully hou molo o omhg you o lo. if i
mmb cocly, fom h blo comm' lk h , h
"W molh 900 hou." th mgh o b boluly c, bu w
lly hug umb. W molh lo. th w ol who h b
Gz fo wo y coly molhg o hou f h oh, w'
lkg bou whol blo, o coul b. th w lo of hou, h'
fo u. th blo w cv boh h oh h ouh, bu oly
jc o h fc.
In yo bien yo wee told yo wold be cleain explosive chaes
becase infanty wold be followin yo?
no.
d c tr ?
no.
So in fact yo wee the closin foce. The aea had aleady been 'cleansed.'
itr h r b thr, w r .
Y.
Yo ys coe to deal with all the aeas whee intellience epots tnnels
ch.
Y, o hou h w u o hoo ou of, uff lk h.
And when yo wap thins p, yo wee thee at the end?
By the time the operation ended we had been inside for three weeks. The rst
week there were briengs, the second week mostly operations, and the third
week was already under ceasere, but we were still going in, this time closer
o h fc o molhg hou, ju och uff lk h. Oly
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
58/112
5
hg h f wh gou coo. W' lvl h gou h fc
o x vbly fom il.
Hw r r th c?
200 m. i ' go h o, bu w 200 m.
****
TesTimony 25 - BRiefings & Rules of engagemenT
th blo comm h woul b lo lo of o w
houl lly wch ou bu o' woy, vyo wll hv k ly of ol
down. At the brieng, I think it was the day we were about to go on to another
mo, h w lkg bou ou gog o Gz, h wll b ly ofo fo vyo.
evyo w o bou o ggg yo. You go czy
yg fo omhg o h ly. som ol fom so h
ouh il locl lo w o k vg (fo h ock hllg o
h homow) o o. so h comy comm , "do' woy,
once we go in you'll have no space left on your rie butt, you'll have to mark your
X-s on your shirt sleeves" When the battalion commander spoke, his personal
mg w h h w o wllg fo y of u o g hu o k hmlf
bcu of uc, f h' w k ow yo. H woul o
vyhg h ow o h o of h ol woul g hu. th w h
general attitude in the army: go in with insane re power because this is our only
vg ov hm.
And was thee eally sch seios e powe?
There were rockets, Lau, whole containers of Negev machine-gun ammo ying
ou h, i'm ll lkg o you ju bou h fy, l lo comb
hlco k ll h.
Whee did all of this y aond?
suc lc. th w ly of luch. You kow you' gog o
hou uully y u ' h my, o ju o . so you
luch ll h wow, h wll, h h Mo. tk k ow
hou f hy' o u bou hm. O gh hy w o h
disappeared so they decided he'd gone into a tunnel, so they brought a D-9 and
z h whol och.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
59/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Oky, i lz h ool coo wh c you o, v f
hu o . no o mmuo o wo.
What abot the tank takin down a hose?
somm you kow h hou my. You kow f you c kow.
now f h hou u you f l, you k ow wh k o bulldozer. We took an eight-story house and the instruction was not to enter any
doorway because it would be booby-trapped. That's what we have the Matador
fo, o k ow wll hough h. Bu h Mo ov lf
omwh l ffcv, o k hll ou hol h wll h' how
w go .
Wht mtr?
i' ml fo ub wf. i' vy ffcv. Bu wh w w wh w
didn't really use it so much. There were places where we red at a house andh cov h w ol .
Was thee a notion of deteent e, show of pesence?
Sure. Every other day we'd initiate a blast of re. Not towards people. Just at
wow whch w' obv fo whl kow h h hou my. no
o woul y hou clo o h o h idF w yg . thy coul
lv fuh wy.
At what level wee the e blasts? Liht as? Tanks?
As for re power, it was light arms and Negev machine-guns. Tanks re only
u uco. th w c wh k w u h comm of
h comy. th w lo c wh hlco v h comy
comm ol hm wh o k ow.
Wht h thr?
a w bg h offv, h w hou h clo o h o w occu,
o w ook ow. th gou fo h w ool, w hou hh gc vg ov h o w w g . W w o o h
h w o wo bu w ook ow bcu cooll ou
ow oo.
****
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
60/112
0
TesTimony 26 - BRiefings & Rules of engagemenT
th gh h fy w w muv ***. W h o g o h b
l, bfo k bou hlf hou o hou l. W w h
zvou ***, mbl o of h mbly hll h blo
comm hl ch fo h whol blo. H w o gog o bsimple. He dened the operation goals: 2000 dead terrorists, not just stopping
h ml luch (il) commu ou h Gz s. H clm
h woul bg h Hm ow o k. th umb woul b ucc
fo h my. a fo ul of ggm, h my' wokg umo w
h h whol woul b vo of cvl. a oo h my woul go
, fom h oh, c h ll o fmg c ul you g o al
a, o c, h woul o log b ol h, o f w
w coc yo h uc h wokg umo w h
o cvl woul ll b ou. thy woul c ouhbou o Gz Cy.ayo h, f h my w coc, w o b kll.
sht t k?
th wo w o u, mo lk mly xo uch 'k hm
ow.'
no o 'kll oc.' Bu h uco w h fo h my, yo
h uc houl b k ow.
W thr t ct? d rc ch cr?
do' k m my wo, bu w obvou, h blo comm m
vy cl h obvouly f omo' oc, hy' o o b ouch.
Clly h objcv w o g o, bu i hk h mly c w h
rule of the game. Everyone was certain we were going to face massive re as
oo w go o h s. th u of cvl bcm lv oo
you' comb h ul chg. You hoo. i' w. i w o quo
are asked. In war those anti-tank missiles are blowing up people all around you
that's the situation that was anticipated there, and that's what dened the rulesof ggm. i h oy, cvl w l lv.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
61/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
TesTimony 27 - House demoliTions
Of hou h w uc bcu of ul o xlov chg w
hou h w g wh vou hohou hll, hkg h woul
cv ll h chg. i oh wo, hohou w o v g,
simply make it all go up in ames, which then ignited the explosive charges. Andh ul. evyhg w g.
Is that what yo wee told at the peliinay bien?
no, i y ow comm. th w o l of og.
Wh hr bt th hhr, r wh?
i o , h w ll o of umo bu i w wh my ow y o of
h hou ou mm .
Wht' th tr?
th oy w h hou w ouly uc of cog xlov
chg. th w lo llgc fomo bou ul h lk.
Naturally a shell was red, that didn't do too much. We didn't get the indication
w w, o h lly foc c o g h hou, hy w
h o ug hohou. th' wh cully h. i o' mmb
whether they red just one shell or more, I think there were several used. This
house went up in ames. Later there were secondary blasts and shelling into
il o h hou w ghly uc. Bu 'xlog mok' w
denitely used there.
d th hhr ht jt th h?
i o' kow fo u. i w bcu i w o gu uy h gh. i c
k of umbll. i xlo vl oz m bov h hou fom
umbrella of re on the house. To tell you that it was pinpoint precision? Artillery
never achieves pinpoint precision. But I know that the artillery ofcer said the hit
w o g.
a tht th rc rtr r r?
W k hg lly. W w clo ough o h bo o h boh h
ring and the impact. There was also mortar re from our own outpost. Targeting
hou.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
62/112
mv rtr?
i o' kow wh you m by mv. Bu i hk h oz of m
ug h wk w w h.
prc rtr? d rbr?
a mo o co wo. i uully mo c h 52mmclb mo, bu o y ' c? i o' hk yo co co
wo. ag, i' lk o h h ghbohoo h w kow wh
cy my of ol, o l h o uo o b ol h.
Whov h co ug. th h och. Obvouly.
Therefore, the main fear is for the lives of soldiers. The risk of friendly re. That's
the story here. But mortars were denitely used.
****
TesTimony 28 - Rules of engagemenT
So yo take positions that st day inside, and then what's the otine
k?
At rst we took positions, in the two-three-four rst days all the tanks were in
oo. th gu h comm o vy wo hou, om o
the driver and loader-signaler also rotate, monitoring the area near the tank.
svl y l h guy fom blo *** w kll by bull o h
h, uco cm ou fobg u o xo ou h ou of h
k. Oc vy fw gh w' go ou o co.
Wht tht ?
At rst we were in our own zone, here. We took positions in this area. We cleaned
h ghbohoo.
What does 'cleanin neihbohoods' actally ean? How was it done in
gz?
th hou wh fy h o y . W com log. F
hll o hou h h l, .
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
63/112
www.breakingthesilence.org.il
Yo knock a shell only into that specic hose?
Depending on the instructions we receive. Once we red twelve shells at a
house. Someone was reported to be shooting automatic re there at the infantry
guys. So rst it was really in the area we left behind, and then slowly we entered
h, cully gog o al a lo. th x gh, ow h of h
rst week. The following Saturday night we already went into Al Atatra, detectedh o, kll hm. th, gg ou of h w w wh oo,
they came in from here. We were on this track here with some two-three tanks.
We cleared the area, shooting at whatever the infantry identied for us, we also
c om Hm oo h, obbly. am. Kll h of hm. th
comy comm' k kll oh wo. Comg ou, ou k clo
bh w w h fom h by h rpG. th you u u mok
screen and re a shell as well.
Thee was a lot of enaeent, elatively.no, h w h mo v w h Ou k kll ol, i hk i
c y wh cy h v of hm w m. th w h hg h
h guy lly lk, wh h lookou. You wok wh fym, hy c
lookout about two kilometers from you, and you re a shell.
Wht' kt?
I don't know the exact denition, someone who gives the coordinates to their
mo o , whv.
H' tw ktr w, hw kw h' kt?
i hv, you kow, h hml ghg vc, ck u wo uff.
Bu who kow, coul b cm, o bocul, coul b cu of coff,
you c' ll.
So thee wee any cases whee infanty told yo, o fo this and that
h?
At the second positions. This was our rst advance, then there was another.i w suy gh, w h h h of h oo. so w ook
u oo ov h, lly o o of sh. You fom o
half kilometers away. They have these sky-scrapers there, there were lots of
co. W k wokg wh , fy 'w wow,' wh hy
identify targets for you and you re shells.
8/8/2019 Breaking the Silence - The Gaza Offensive
64/112
it shtt?
Y, i hk h w ly h oh of Gz Cy. th c.
So in fact infanty tells yo, "That bildin ove thee, lookot on the
oo."
svh wow fom h o, gh, ' h. Wch ou, boom.
s t th kt r th ww?
The window. You shoot even if it's not identied. Let's put it this way. If the
fy fy, chc you wll oo.
****
TesTimony 29 - House demoliTions & BomBaRdmenT
so fo h m mo of fgmg h Gz s, w cully cv
o o cool om hgh o, h whl w w h w ' kow
how log w w o z much obl of h . such zg
uhmm fo ol, ymc uco, blg ol vbly. rzg
was meant to give us the advantage of full control over re and eld of view, to
xcly wh w hg houghou h zo. so h o o coul h
yhg fom u. two o w cully mo fo h uco. i'll
lk ow mo bou h uco of hou bcu h h m oblm
h. O o my b m ool. Mg hou uc o
be booby-trapped, contains tunnel openings, is wired in all sorts of directions,
o h g of ggg. O w hv om ou llgc fomo bou
, mkg uc of ll h hg. smmg fom h ool l of
thinking, is a house from which re is opened, whether light arms or mortars or
ml, G ock, ll ho hg. th hou w molh. You
coul y h y ul xo of h oml my ocu i kow
at least in the Gaza Strip. A house that has often been a source of re hasu hllg, o v b molh ly. Bu h w w ol
h hou o b molh fo h k of "h y f."