Assessment of Heavy Metals (Arsenic, Cadmium, Lead and Total Mercury) in Tilapia sp.
in Sri Lanka
B.K.K.K.Jinadasa1*, E.M.R.K.B. Edirisinghe1
Post harvest Technology Division, National Aquatic Resources Research and Development
Agency (NARA), Colombo-15, Sri Lanka.
E-mail- [email protected]
Abstract
In a 2008, samples of the muscles, liver and gills of Tilapaia sp. (Oreochromis sp.) in five size
classes (<18, 18-19.9, 20-21.9, 22-23.9 and >24 cm) were obtained from a eighteenth (18)
Reservoirs in 3 province and four district which are Anuradapura and Polonnaruwa in North
Central province, Ampara in Eastern province and Hambanthota in Southern province in Sri
Lanka. The elements Arsenic (As), Cadmium (Cd), Lead (Pb) and Total Mercury (Hg) were
detected in the sample by atomic absorption spectroscopy. In Tilapia sp the mean Cd, Pb, Hg and
As concentration in muscle 0.0340, 0.0571, 0.2624 and 0.2585, gills 0.0225, 0.4374, 0.3640 and
0.2506 and liver 0.2966, 2.0651, 0.5247 and 0.3552 mg/Kg in dry weight basis. That result
revealed that the levels of heavy metal concentration in Tilapia sp is not exceed the maximum
permissible level for human consumption according to the EU, WHO and Food Standards
Australia and New Zealand guidelines.
Introduction:
Sri Lanka is well known for its dam’s construction, and is reputed to have one of the highest
densities of reservoirs in world (McCully 1996; De Silva 1989). Most of the reservoirs of Sri
Lanka are located in the dry zone. At all reservoirs are used for freshwater aquaculture. Common
features of this fishery is the dominance in the landing of the exotic Cichlid species introduced in
1952, the Mossambicus Tilapia (De Silva 1985; Fernando & Indrasena 1969). Reservoir fish are
the main source of animal protein of the rural people living in dry zone of the country (G.
Allinson etal 2008, Amarasinghe and De Silva, 1999; Chandrasiri, 1986).
Metals are found throughout the earth, in rock, soil and sediments primarily trapped in some
stable from bedrock by weathering and erosion and allowed to circulate in water and air. This is
essential because many biochemical processes require a given amount of some metals. But some
heavy metals introduced to environment by anthropogenic activities may adversely affect the
system. Heavy metals can be uptake in difference ways by the aquatic organisms. Include
passive diffusion, facilated diffusion, active transport and endocytosis. Fish can uptake metals
through gills, through digestive tract and via skin. Bioaccumulation is the uptake and
sequestration of contaminants by organisms from their ambient environment, in certain cases, the
uptake of contaminants by biota directly from the ambient medium by this air, soil, sediments or
water (Phillips, 1993 and Senadheera and Pathiratne 2003).
Of all the heavy metals, lead probably has the longest history of environmental contamination
and toxicity to humans. Environment lead contamination arise s source including agriculture and
manufacture process, atmosphere emission from motor vehicles and incineration of municipal
solid waste. The primary sources of lead intake in the general population are food including
water, accidentally, via paint dust even or soil (Sonia Lucia Blanco etal; 2007).
Cadmium is a high toxic element. Even minute amounts of cd are sufficient to cause poisoning.
Cd is widely distributed at low levels in the environment; the sources for human exposure air,
water food and tobacco, with food representing the major route of the uptake for general public
(Anon; 1993).
Mercury is one of the ancient metals and it occurs naturally in the environment. Inorganic
mercury enters the environment from industry, mining and pollution and natural geochemical
processes; its accumulation in sediment generally transformed by microorganisms in to organic
mercury, resulting high toxic molecules, such as mono methyl mercury, which bioaccumulates in
fish.
Arsenic also one of the most toxic metals can be released to the environment by natural and
industrial sources; fish can be accumulated high levels and contributes significantly to daily
intake of the elements.
In many cases Tilapia was used as a bioassay organism in toxicological studies in which it was
substantiated with the highest sensitivity to toxic effect (Rashed M.N. 2001). Chronic renal
failure (CRF) was reached in high levels in the North Central province area in last few years
(Bandara J.M.R.S. etal 2008). Heavy metals such as As, Cd, Pb and Hg are a threat to public
health, even at low concentrations, since long term, chronic exposure may result in the
accumulation of toxic level. Low to intermediate levels exposure is associated with chronic
toxicity, so detection of food is related from a toxicological point of view. The maximum
permissible levels of export fish As, Cd, Pb and Hg have been gazette by government of Sri
Lanka (No 1528/7). The level of above metal levels varies according to species. These study
focuses on the distribution of As, Cd, Pb and Hg level in Tilapia sp. in North Central province
and compare with same sp. in Southern and Eastern province.
Materials and methods:
The study areas were four district, Anuradapura and Polonnaruwa (North Central province),
Hambanthota (Southern province) and Ampara (Eastern province) in Sri Lanka. Number of
reservoir selected from above district for ease of access and also to cover the fully area of
district. Six reservoirs from Anuradapura district (Kalawewa, Koobichchiyankulama, Thuruwila,
Padaviya, Rajanganaya and Wilachchiya), five reservoirs form Polonnaruwa district (Minneriya,
Girithale, Maduruoya, Parakrama Samudraya, and Kaudulla), 3 reservoirs form Ampara district
(Senanayake Samudraya, Ambalanoya and Nawagiriyawa) and four reservoirs form Hambantota
district (Udawalawe, Lunugamwehere, Udukiriwila and mahagalwewa).
Fish samples were obtained from commercial landings and brought to the laboratory in ice. In
the laboratory the total length and body weight were determined. Fish were divided in to five
length classes (<18, 18-19.9, 20-21.9, 22-23.9 and >24 cm) and pooled within categories under
the each reservoirs name. Then fish were gutted and the liver and gills removed. Individual fish
were filleted and from the middle of the right fillet and above 50 g of block of muscle devoided.
All samples were oven dried at 800C to a constant weight and stored in air tight bag until further
analysis.
Fish samples were digested using Mars CEM XP-1500 (model No 927065) microwave digester.
Sample was weighted (0.5 g) in four decimal places and 5 mL of C. HNO3 (supra pure) was
added allowed 15 min in fume hood for pre digestion. Then digested were filter (Whatman No
542) in to one mark grade A 100 mL volumetric flask and volume up with double distilled water.
The CRM (FAPAS/canned fish/T0774) samples and blank samples were run with each batch.
Spectra AA Varian atomic absorption spectrometer (AAS-240 FS) from Varian with graphite
tube atomizer (Varian GTA 120) was used for lead and cadmium determinations. Vapor
generation accessory (Varian VGA 77) with close end cell use for mercury determination and
open end cell were used for determination arsenic. The following analytical wavelengths were
monitored: As, 193.7; Cd, 228.8; Pb, 283.3 and Hg, 253.7 nm, respectively. The limit of
detection (LOD) was based on mean sample blank value + 3s.
All statistical analysis was conducted using Microsoft Excel 2009 version and SPSS version 16.0
for windows.
Results and Discussion:
Analysis of the certified reference material ((FAPAS/canned fish/T0774/except lead) found that
analyzed trace elements to between excepted values (75%-125% recovery).
The concentration and the ranges of the four metals of the muscles, gills and liver tissues of
Tilapia sp. in the dry weight in each tank and mean value of each district are presented in table 1
and figure 1 and the analyzed metal concentration of each length classes are presented in table 2.
374 Tilapia samples were collected from 18 reservoirs in four districts. The mean length 21.1 ±
4.0 cm and the mean length was 216.6 ± 162.1 g. The number of samples in each length classes
(A; <18, B; 18-19.9, C; 20-21.9, D; 22-23.9 and E; >24 cm) 75, 86, 83, 61 and 69 respectively.
Results indicate that the mean level of the cadmium in the muscle tissues of the Tilapia sp was
0.0340 ± 0.03 mg/Kg, dry wt basis (n = 56). The highest value (0.1003 mg/Kg in dry wt) was
recorded from Mahagalwewa reservoir in Hambanthota district. The mean level of lead, total
mercury and arsenic in the muscle tissues 0.0571± 0.13, 0.2624±0.23 and 0.2585±0.15 mg/Kg in
dry wt basis (n = 56). The highest value of lead (0.6591 mg/Kg dry wt), total mercury (1.1173
mg/Kg dry wt) and arsenic (0.6039 mg/Kg dry wt) were recorded from Mahagalwewa tank,
Senanayake Samudraya in Ampara district and Wilachchiya reservoir in Anuradapura district.
The mean level of the cadmium, lead, total mercury and arsenic in the gills (n = 56) of Tilapia sp.
was 0.0225 ± 0.04, 0.4374± 0.83, 0.3640 ± 0.47 and 0.2506 ± 0.17 mg/Kg in dry wt basis. The
highest value recorded from Rajanganaya tank in Polonnaruwa district, Wilachchiya tank in
Anuradapura district, Ambalanoya tank in Ampara district and Rajanganaya tank respectively.
As same cadmium, lead, total mercury and arsenic in the liver sample (n =55) of Tilapia sp was
0.2966 ± 0.35, 2.0651 ± 2.23, 0.5247 ± 0.93 and 0.3552 ± 0.38 mg/Kg in dry wt basis. The
highest value was recorded in Rajanganaya tank, Udukiriwila tank in Hambantota district,
Senanayake samudraya and Thuruwila tank in Anuradapuraya district. The higher concentrations
of heavy metals were recorded in the gills and liver than in muscle tissues of fish sample. Those
levels are greater than in maximum permissible level in some sampling places.
There is no statistically significant correlations (p<0.05) between Tilapia length classes and
metals concentration muscles, gills and liver tissues and between four district and metals
concentration mussels, gills and liver samples. That is excepted results, because freshwater fish
maintain constant internal metal concentration; that metal concentration do not increase with age
(Allinson etal, 2003).
As best of our knowledge unable to found the maximum permitted levels for metals in fish in Sri
Lanka, but there is government of Sri Lanka published gazette notification (No.1528/7-17 th Dec.
2007) to heavy metals in fish for the fisheries export purpose. According to that the maximum
level of Pb, Cd and Hg is 0.20, 0.05 and 0.50 mg/Kg in wet weight basis, but there is not mention
about the As. Guidance value of the WHO/FAO committee on food additives (JECFA) and food
standard Australia and New Zealand (FSANZ) have established the value with permissible level.
FAO Codex level for metals in fish are 0.5 mg/Kg and 1.0 mg/Kg wet weight basis in non
predatory and predatory fish (Allison etal, 2008). FSANZ general accepted level of Hg, Pb
1mg/day and 0.5mg/day, JECFA also established the As and Pb level as 0.12 mg/day and 3.6
mg/day. As well as EU regulation specifies the maximum heavy metals limits in fish meat as
0.05 mg/Kg Cd and 0.2 mg/Kg for Pb and 0.50 mg/Kg for Hg (Anon 2005).
Sri Lankan consumes an average of 12.3 Kg fish per person per year (Anon 2007). After
calculating these value, observed that the daily intake of the metals after consumption of Tilapia
is below the standard levels. Though the metals concentration of gills and liver samples of
Tilapia is comparatively higher than the muscles tissues, are not arise problem, because when the
preparing Tilapia for cooking removes those parts normally.
The heavy metals content of Tilapia fish has variously been reported in previous studies were
given in table no 03. The heavy metals levels in Tilapia in Sri Lanka are slightly lower than with
the compare with other countries.
Conclusion
Present study showed that the total Hg, As, Cd and Pb level in Tilapia muscle was below the
maximum permissible level.
Acknowledgement:
Authors wish to thanks to the National Aquatic Resources Research and development Agency to
the financial assistant.
Follow-up action
1. Finding the Bio Transfer Factor (BTF) of heavy metals
2. Calculate Provisional Tolerable Weekly Intake (PTWI) amount of Tilapia
3. Assess the heavy metal concentration of other indigenous sp and aquatic plant.
References:
Allinson G., Salzman S.A., Turoczy N., Nisikawa M., Amarasinghe U.S., Nirbadha K.G.S., De
Silva S.S. (2008). Observation on metal concentrations in two species of Tilapia (Oreochromis
mossambicus and Oreochromis niloticus) in cascades of reservoirs of Sri Lanka. Submitted
paper of Environmental Contamination & toxicology.
Amarasinghe, U.S. and De Silva SS (1999). Sri Lankan reservoir fishery; a case for introduction
of a co-management strategy. Fish Mange. Ecol.6, pp 387-399.
Anon (1993). Guidance document for cadmium in shellfish. Washington (DC); center for food
safety and applied nutrition, US FDA.
Anon (2005). Commission regulation EC No 78/2005 of 16th January 2005 amending regulation
EC No 466/2001 as regards heavy metals. Official journal L 16/43.20/01/2005 pp 43-45.
Annon (2007). National Aquatic Resources research and Development Agency, Sri Lanka
fisheries year book, 2007. http://www.nara.ac.lk/Year%20Book-2007/chapter7.html#ch7n4.
Arain M.B., Kazi T.G., Jamali M.K., Jalbani N., Afrid H.I., Shah A. (2008). Total dissolved and
bioavailable elements in water and sediments samples and their accumulation in Oreochromis
mossambicus of Manchar lake. Chemosphere 70; pp1845-1856.
Bandara J.M.R.S., Senevirathne D.M.A.N., Dasanayake D.M.R.S.B., Herath V., Bandara
J.M.R.P., Abeysekara T., Rajapaksha K.H. (2008). Chronic renal failure among farm families in
cascade irrigation system in Sri Lanka associated with elevated dietary cadmium level in rice
and freshwater fish (Tilapia) Environ Geochem Health 2008.
Chandrasiri J.M.K.D. (1986). Socio economic conditions of inland fisherman in Sri Lanka.
Agrarian research institute, Colombo.
De Silva S.S. (1985). The Mahaweli baisn, Inland fisheries in multipurpose river basin planning
development in tropical Asian counties; three case studies. FAO fisheries technical paper, 265.
pp 91-166.
De Silva S.S. (1989). Reservoirs of Sri Lanka and their fisheries. FAO fisheries technical paper
298. pp 128.
Fernando C.H., Indrasena H.H.A. (1969). The freshwater fisheries of Ceylon. Bull fisheries Stat
Ceylon 26: pp83-95.
Khallaf E.A., Galal M. Authman m. (2003). The biology of Oreochromis niloticus in polluted
canal. Ecotoxicolgy 12; pp 405-416.
McCully, P. (1996). Silenced Rivers. The ecology and politics of large Dams. Zed books,
London.
Phillips D.J.H (1993). Bioaccumulation; In handbook of ecotoxicology pp 378-396. Blackwell
Scientific Publication, Oxford.
Rashid M.N. (2001). Monitoring of environmental heavy metals in fish from Nasser lake.
Environ Int 27: pp 27-33.
Senadheera S.P.S.D. and Pathirathne K.A.S. (2003). Bioaccumulation potential of three toxic
heavy metals is shrimp, Penaeus monodon from different fractions of the culture environment .
Sri Lanka Journal of Aquatic Science Vol 8, 2003.
Sonia Lucia Blanco, Jose Carlos Gonzalez and Juan M. Vieites (2008). Mercury, cadmium and
lead levels in samples of the main traded fish and shellfish species in Galicia, Spain . Food
additives and contaminants 2008, 1-7. iFirst.
Table 1: Level of Cd, Pb, Hg, As in Tilapia Muscles, Gills and Liver in four distric1 and 18
reservoirs in Sri Lanka (value in mg/Kg dry weight basis)
District name1 Muscle Gill Liver
Reservoir name Cd Pb Hg As Cd Pb Hg As Cd Pb Hg As
Anuradapuraya1 0.0463 0.0245 0.1436 0.2655 0.0406 0.9753 0.0495 0.2770 0.2511 2.2207 0.1662 0.3880
Kalawewa 0.0958 0.0871 0.1393 0.1630 0.0091 0.3241 0.0937 0.1437 0.1528 3.7090 0.1176 0.2761
Koobichchiyankulama 0.0016 0.0000 0.0534 0.0940 0.0029 0.3567 0.0442 0.0854 0.0002 0.2449 0.1909 0.0869
Padawiya 0.0563 0.0000 0.0771 0.1183 0.0630 0.5263 0.0343 0.0548 0.0960 2.0246 0.1863 0.1836
Rajanganaya 0.0539 0.0484 0.1016 0.3083 0.0945 1.4583 0.0461 0.4349 0.8060 3.6630 0.0865 0.2795
Thuruwila 0.0215 0.0000 0.0735 0.5249 0.0338 1.2337 0.0424 0.4645 0.1985 1.2944 0.1417 0.9396
Wilachchiya 0.0348 0.0173 0.5763 0.3020 0.0139 2.2274 0.0379 0.5008 0.2323 2.0457 0.3424 0.3253
Polonnaruwa1 0.0205 0.0218 0.2393 0.2899 0.0133 0.1323 0.3969 0.2816 0.2821 0.9007 0.6164 0.4564
Minneriya 0.0321 0.0000 0.0717 0.3767 0.0290 0.2465 0.0341 0.3575 0.2017 1.3018 0.0533 0.5204
Girithale 0.0010 0.0160 0.3676 0.1737 0.0000 0.6154 0.2915 0.1767 0.4198 1.4574 0.2794 0.1575
Parakramasamudraya 0.0298 0.0151 0.1654 0.2738 0.0193 0.1144 0.4941 0.2416 0.4345 1.0224 0.2543 0.3472
Maduruoya 0.0108 0.0317 0.2809 0.2114 0.0001 0.0000 0.5504 0.1983 0.1640 0.1736 0.9546 0.5011
Kaudulla 0.0117 0.0445 0.4176 0.3073 0.0046 0.0145 0.5737 0.3343 0.2347 0.6023 1.4568 0.5538
Hambanthota1 0.0404 0.1248 0.3377 0.2041 0.0173 0.3132 0.5853 0.1665 0.3892 3.3022 0.5182 0.2438
Udawalawa 0.0310 0.0697 0.2421 0.1648 0.0269 0.0312 0.5344 0.1695 0.5671 0.9159 0.6863 0.3319
Mahagalwewa 0.0858 0.5541 0.3184 0.1287 0.0450 0.4472 0.7441 0.1900 0.2408 2.7917 0.5848 0.1515
Udukiriwila 0.0248 0.0000 0.3788 0.2643 0.0087 0.5263 0.4915 0.2155 0.5252 6.1908 0.4417 0.3832
Lunugamwehera 0.0328 0.0000 0.3725 0.2147 0.0000 0.1580 0.6215 0.0852 0.1971 1.8640 0.4380 0.0726
Ampara1 0.0198 0.0768 0.4592 0.2852 0.0086 0.0173 0.6233 0.2925 0.2466 1.5092 1.2639 0.2931Senanayake Samudraya 0.0095 0.0205 0.6709 0.3609 0.0028 0.0000 0.6020 0.3621 0.2826 0.3996 2.5996 0.2068
Amabalanoya 0.0350 0.1459 0.2049 0.2153 0.0258 0.0604 1.0695 0.2427 0.2004 0.3059 0.2704 0.2928
Nawagiriyawa 0.0201 0.0922 0.3961 0.2415 0.0000 0.0000 0.2090 0.2380 0.2007 4.1978 0.2624 0.3822
Table 2: Level of Cd, Pb, Hg, As in Tilapia in each length classes (A; <18, B; 18-19.9, C; 20-
21.9, D; 22-23.9 and E; >24 cm) in four districts (value in mg/Kg dry weight basis)
DistrictLength Class
Flesh Gills Liver
Cd Pb Hg As Cd Pb Hg As Cd Pb Hg As
Anuradapuraya
A 0.2323 2.0457 0.3424 0.3253 0.1297 0.0000 0.0918 0.0009 0.1965 1.6140 0.0347 0.0221
B 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
C 0.0724 0.0759 0.1432 0.1162 0.0083 0.3728 0.0550 0.1160 0.1279 3.5550 0.1088 0.1176
D 0.1172 3.4441 0.1001 0.3105 0.0045 0.0000 0.0679 0.5313 0.0019 0.4015 0.0199 0.4542
E 0.0591 0.7220 0.1086 0.2659 0.0649 0.0200 0.0395 0.2213 0.0415 2.9992 0.0400 0.3178
Polonnaruwa
A 0.1400 0.6706 0.8661 0.5929 0.0164 0.0000 0.2503 0.2477 0.0304 0.2046 0.2601 0.3176
B 0.3977 1.1605 0.5164 0.5253 0.0286 0.0067 0.1192 0.3334 0.0246 1.2018 0.1067 0.3632
C 0.0953 0.3634 0.2684 0.1200 0.0110 0.0000 0.2768 0.1110 0.0016 0.0188 0.3530 0.3224
D 0.2645 0.6428 0.7663 0.3231 0.0109 0.0200 0.1558 0.3099 0.0156 0.0839 0.4576 0.2295
E 0.2548 0.6518 0.8458 0.6701 0.0276 0.0370 0.2668 0.2412 0.0081 0.2618 0.3052 0.2702
AmparaC 0.1187 4.0842 0.3880 0.5104 0.2007 4.1978 0.2624 0.3822 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
D 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0190 0.1109 0.4293 0.2869 0.0081 0.0332 0.8668 0.3692
E 0.1764 1.6946 0.4145 0.3854 0.0214 0.0551 0.5675 0.2729 0.0115 0.0071 0.5072 0.2193
Hambanthota
A 0.1971 1.8640 0.4380 0.0726 0.0336 0.0000 0.3531 0.2671 0.0000 0.0219 0.6318 0.0577
B 0.2896 4.8341 0.2582 0.1838 0.0286 0.0000 0.3722 0.1936 0.0062 0.3505 0.5465 0.3058
C 0.1367 3.7927 0.2150 0.1947 0.0269 0.2019 0.1538 0.0561 0.0285 0.3887 0.6040 0.1224
D 0.2562 3.3963 0.4883 0.2704 0.0306 0.3166 0.1012 0.1046 0.0174 0.2327 0.2151 0.0800
E 0.0940 1.5625 0.2859 0.0000 0.0206 0.0000 0.4642 0.2314 0.0000 0.6298 1.2782 0.1275
Table 3: Investigated heavy metal level in Tilapia sp in previous studies.
Fish Sp. Country
Metals level in muscle(mg/Kg wet wt)
ReferenceAs Cd Hg Pb
O. niloticus Egypt _ 0.02 0.45 0.15 Khallaf etal
O. mossambicus China 0.65 0.09 0.07 0.29 Allinson etal
O. mossambicus Pakisthan 0.59 0.35 _ 0.6 Allinson etal
O. mossambicus Sri Lanka 0.26 0.05 0.02 _ Allinson etal
O. niloticus Sri Lanka <0.90 <0.15 0.01 _ Allinson etal
Oreochromis sp. Sri Lanka 0.03* 0.06* 0.26* 0.26* This study
* Value in mg/Kg dry weight basis
Figure 1: Mean concentration of Total Hg, As, Cd and Pb (mg/Kg dry wt.) in the muscle, gill and liver tissues of Tilapia sp. in four districts.
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
Cd Pb Hg As Cd Pb Hg As Cd Pb Hg As
Flesh Gills Liver
Sample type and metals
con
cen
tart
ion
(m
g/K
g)
Anuradapuraya
Polonnaruwa
Ampara
Hambanthota