Details of Proceedings Environment Clearance: Public Hearing
Public hearing from Ministry of Env. & Forest, GOI, New Delhi, Regarding the enhancement
of excavation capacity of KTR L/s Mines from the present 0.9 MTPA; for which capacity
enhancement upto 0.06 MTPA from Left Bank; whose total lease area is 91.14 hectare (Vill: KTR,
Vijayraghavgarh, Katni ,M.P.)
Place: Govt Middle School, KTR Date: 28-02-2014
KTR, Katni
As per the guidelines of Ministry of Env. & Forest, GOI, New Delhi Notice No. – S.O. 1553 Dt-
14-09-2006, to attain the Env. Clearnce.
Application has been given before the specialists Assessment Committee set up by Ministry
of Environment & Forest, GOI, New Delhi. Committee has asked for Public Hearing vide TOR Date:
13-05-2013 issued to the project.
In line with that it was applied before the MPPCB to organize the Public Hearing which is scheduled
on 28-02-2014 at 11:00 AM at Govt. Middle School, KTR, Barhi, Katni.
As per the Notice issued the advertisement of Public Hearing was published in newspaper
Hari Bhumi, Katni; Dainik Bhaskar, Katni, Desh bandhu, Katni and Times of India on 26 & 28-01-2014
respectively. Also to inform the nearby villages a motor vehicle was provided with banners and loud-
speaker. Public Hearing was organized under the presiding chair of Shri Dinesh Shrivastav, A.D.M,
Katni. During the period Shri P. R Dev and other officers of MPPCB were also present, from the side
of Mining Project Shri R. N Jha, GM (Flux) ; Shri K. K. Pandey, DGM (Flux) ; Shri D. Pandit, AGM
(Mines) and other executives were present. The representatives of M/s Anna Lab Ltd., Hyderabad,
the environmental consultancy of the mines, were also present. The local villagers were also present,
whose details is attached as per the attendance register.
Detail of Proceeding of Public Hearing
Shri P. R Deo, Regional Officer, MPPCB first welcomed all the present members and provided the
knowledge regarding the provisions of the Environmental Input Assessment Notice Dt- 14-09-2006
and the procedure of Public Hearing to the common people. Also informed the efforts taken by the
Board to conduct the Public Hearing. Following this the social and economic development in the
mines area was narrated by Shri D. Pandit, AGM (Mines) from the management side.
After that the brief of the Project EIA report was presented before the common people in locally
understood language, Hindi by the project management. Shri D. Pandit, AGM (Mines) presented the
main points for information as under –
The mining lease granted by the GOI is valid till 14-05-2022. The lease area of mines is 91.14
hectare an enhancement of “Excavation/ Production” capacity of 0.06 MTPA of the opencast
project is proposed.
The mines is running since 1992-93. No residential activity is present on the project land.
Total lease area belongs to M/s Kuteshwar Limestone Mines, SAIL.
Expected life of the mines is 52 years.
The mines lease of Left Bank is spread in 91.14 hectare. It is located in Tehsil:
Vijayraghavgarh, Village- Kuteshwar of M.P. State. Total mining lease area falls under the
Bansagar Project. The Compensation has been given. Mines is working since long. The mine
lease area has excavated area, O/B dump, roads etc.
The haul roads shall be maintained by compression, gradation and water drainage system on
both sides and regular water sprinkling will be ensured to check the dust generation. Water
sprinkling shall be done by a 28000 litres capacity high- pressure water sprinkling in the
mining area and along the haul roads.
It will be ensured not to allow the trucks to carry with overloaded quantity and their speed
to be controlled under the permissible speed limit.
Regular water sprinkling will be arranged at this work-place and plantation shall be done on
the OB dump and along the roads.
Wet drilling and modern A.C. Cabin drills machines will be used. To solve the problem of
vibration in nearby areas, new blasting technique of NONEL detonator will be used. Wet
drilling method will be used to control the dust and noise level. Serial blasting/controlled
blasting techniques shall be utilized.
Rock breaker will be used in place of secondary blasting.
Fast growing creep plants shall be planted to stop the degradation of OB Dump.
Pollution Management/Control cell will be formed to monitor the environment.
There is no chance of a fall in unground water level as the Mahanadi river is in the vicinity of
the mines. No chance of water pollution is there as no polluted water will be generated
from the quarry.
The mines area will be reclaimed and dense forestation will be done.
A committee will be set up to control /manage the environmental aspects, which will work
in consultation with nearby villagers.
Material is transported to railway siding at Khanna Banjari which is 14kms away from the
lease area, from there the limestone is despatched to various steel plants of SAIL. To vanish
the traffic load between mines and Khanna Banjari Railway siding it is proposed to bring the
railway siding upto lease area (Right Bank) itself. This will check the pollution caused by
vehicles and transportation.
Lease area falls under the submergence of Bansagar Project and mining activity will be done
for a limited period in a year.
Left out area will be developed as a lake.
Around 100 labours will be deployed in Left Bank lease of KTR mines. Indirect employment
will be increased.
Basic facilities like dispensary, D A V School, local market, shopping complex etc. are
established in KTR Limestone Mine. Water is mainly required for dust suppression, work-
shop and domestic use. Industrial requirement of the water is 13 KL/day at present which
will be fulfilled by the small ponds in lease area. Drinking water will be supplied from the
Borewell of Right Bank Lease area.
Proper maintenance of mines roads , water sprinkling by tankers, use of spray nozzles at
Hopper, Crushing & Screening and material transfer points will be ensured. Waste dump will
be improved by planting grass, bushes over it.
Dust masks will be provided to labourers working in dust prone areas.
Noise level monitoring will be done periodically in villages around the lease area. If the noise
level exceeds the permissible limit more efforts to control it, will be strived.
Blasting will be carried out in morning only.
The project provides many services in nearby villages like Hospital, Primary Health Centre,
School, Play ground are important one. Many beneficial works have been done by the
project under CSR. About Rs. 101.45 Lakhs have been spent under CSR schemes in last years
in which deepening of pond, beautification of areas, providing bore wells with hand pumps,
extra classes in schools and erection of solar lights, construction of community halls, facility
at schools, roads and culverts, blanket distribution to senior citizens of BPL category , relief
material to flood effected people are to be highlighted. Provision of Rs 252 Lakhs is kept for
Environmental management and CSR activities.
To monitor the environmental aspects Water, Air, Noise pollution levels will be measured
and report will be sent to the concerned departments. Pollution control cell will be set up,
which will monitor the above parameters and make the necessary scheme for Pollution
control.
Mining is a precarious exercise, thus a workable disaster management plan will be drafted
after studying all the aspects of the safety. So that the chances of accidents will be
minimised.
Local people will be benefited by the mines. Opportunity of Direct employment, Medical and
educational facilities will be developed, benefit from developed infrastructural system and
improvement of the financial level of the people.
Following Suggestions/ Objections/ Observations were raised mainly by the people present there –
1. Proper compensation should be given to villagers whose land comes under the lease area.
2. Employment for the villagers whose land comes under the lease area.
3. Employment for the nearby local people.
4. Mines should be started very soon in order to provide employment to poor people.
5. Plantation in nearby areas to be done.
6. Huge vibrations are faced in the houses of nearby villages due to blasting.
7. Ponds in nearby villages should be filled.
8. Transportation facilities should be developed in the area.
9. Social works organised in the area should be supported.
10. Local Students should be given admission in the school run by the project and the field of
education should be expanded.
A.D.M ensured the public that all the objections raised by them will be sent to MoEF, New
Delhi through MPPCB. During the Public hearing total 37 objections raised are attached herewith in
details. After that, the management was asked to submit a written reply of the objection/
suggestions.
The reply given by the mines management i.e. statement of issues is attached with the
details of the Public Hearing activities and is a part of it. After receiving objections/suggestions
from present people and reply given by the mines representative the details of Public Hearing
process was provided to the people present there. After the reply of each point was made by the
mines management the Public Hearing proceedings were ended by A.D.M, removing all the
misconcepts of the local people.
At last a vote of thanks was given by Sri P. R. Dev, RO, MPPCB, Katni to A.D.M, local people
and representatives of mines management, for taking part in the Public Hearing.
P. R. Dev Dinesh Srivastav
RO, MPPCB ADM, Katni
Ob
jecti
on
/th
ou
gh
t/s
ug
ges
tio
n/n
ote
w.r
.t.
of
Pu
bli
c H
eari
ng
of
L.B
. L
eas
e o
f K
ute
sh
wa
r L
ime
sto
ne
Min
es f
or
En
vir
on
me
nt
Cle
ara
nce
Sl N
o.
Nam
e o
f P
rop
ose
r &
v
illa
ge
Ob
jecti
on
/th
ou
gh
t/su
gg
esti
on
/no
te
Rep
ly o
f S
AIL
Man
ag
em
en
t
01
R.S
.Sin
gh
K
ute
sh
wa
r T
ree
s n
ot
to b
e c
ut
an
d e
nvir
on
me
nt
sh
ou
ld b
e i
mp
roved
. In
du
str
y
alw
ays
pla
y a
vit
al
role
in
de
ve
lop
me
nt
of
the
are
a.
Do
no
t ig
no
re
pro
ble
ms
of
pe
op
le a
nd
th
ey s
ho
uld
be
he
lpe
d f
rom
tim
e t
o t
ime
. E
nvir
on
me
nt
de
pa
rtm
en
t s
ho
uld
co
ns
tan
tly m
on
ito
r th
at
an
d m
ore
a
nd
mo
re t
ree
s s
ho
uld
be
pla
nte
d.
1.
As
th
e l
ea
se
are
a o
f L
eft
Ba
nk
will
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 2
. W
elf
are
o
f vil
lag
ers
is
ta
ke
n
ca
re
of
thro
ug
h
va
rio
us
pro
gra
mm
es
ru
nn
ing
un
de
r C
SR
. 3
. G
ua
rdin
g
of
tre
es
is
b
ein
g
en
su
red
th
rou
gh
se
cu
rity
p
ers
on
nel.
02
Avin
es
h
Ga
irta
lai,
Ba
rhi
In m
y o
pin
ion
en
vir
on
me
nt
do
es
no
t p
rovid
e a
ny t
yp
e o
f p
oll
uti
on
in
th
e m
inin
g.
It i
s t
o b
e s
aid
th
at
we
are
wo
rkin
g u
nd
er
co
ntr
ac
tor.
P
lea
se
in
clu
de
all
th
e w
ork
ers
un
de
r ‘B
’ re
gis
ter.
Ple
as
e p
rovid
e
pe
rma
nen
et
em
plo
ym
en
t &
th
e la
nd
w
hic
h w
as
ta
ke
n o
n le
ase
. P
rovid
e u
s m
on
ey.
1.
Th
e w
ho
le le
as
e a
rea
h
as
b
ee
n ac
qu
ired
b
y B
an
sa
ga
r P
roje
ct
an
d d
ue
co
mp
en
sa
tio
n t
o t
he
la
nd
ow
ne
r h
as
be
en
p
aid
. 2
. A
ll m
ine
wo
rke
rs a
re in
clu
ded
in
B-F
orm
.
03
Ab
his
he
k
Ku
ma
r D
ub
ey
Ku
teh
wa
r T
ow
ns
hip
I li
ve
in
Ku
tes
hw
ar
sin
ce
199
2,
till
da
te t
he
re i
s n
ot
a s
ing
le d
ea
th
or
inju
ry d
ue
to
K
TR
e
nvir
on
me
nt.
O
n th
e o
the
r h
an
d,
for
the
pu
rpo
se
of
job
in
th
e K
TR
min
e,
Go
vt.
pro
vid
ed
us
ed
uca
tio
n.
Yo
u
ha
ve
to
le
arn
an
d f
ac
e t
he
co
mp
eti
tio
n a
nd
co
me
in
th
e m
eri
t li
st.
T
his
min
e p
rovid
ed
eve
ryth
ing
. I
am
pro
ud
to
be
a K
ute
sh
wa
rian
.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
04
Sa
rpa
nc
h
Ku
teh
wa
r V
illa
ge
Reg
ard
ing
no
t p
rovid
ing
an
y f
ac
ilit
y o
t e
mp
loym
en
t b
y S
AIL
M
y k
ind
req
ue
st
is t
ha
t th
e l
ea
se
of
91
.14
Ha h
as
bee
n s
an
cti
on
ed
in
th
e n
am
e o
f m
y v
illa
ge
Ku
tes
hw
ar,
wh
ich
is
op
era
tio
na
l ti
ll d
ate
w
ho
se
To
po
Sh
ee
t N
o.
63
D/1
6.6
4.1
/13.
It i
s r
eq
ue
ste
d t
ha
t in
sp
ite
of
ind
us
try i
s u
nd
er
op
era
tio
n b
y R
MD
, S
AIL
, B
SL
fo
r la
st
50
ye
ars
o
ur
farm
ers
ha
ve
no
t b
ee
n p
rovid
ed
an
y e
mp
loym
en
t, l
ite
rate
bo
ys
a
re r
oa
min
g h
ere
an
d t
he
re.
Ou
r h
om
es
are
be
ing
de
str
oye
d d
ue
to
min
es
. T
he
refo
re,
it i
s r
eq
ue
ste
d t
ha
t w
e s
ho
uld
be
pro
vid
ed
e
mp
loym
en
t.
Ex
pa
ns
ion
o
f m
ine
s
cap
ac
ity
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will b
e
fro
m l
oc
al
pe
op
le o
nly
.
05
Hetr
am
s/o
Ram
rup
C
ha
turv
ed
i V
illa
ge
- K
ute
sh
wa
r
It i
s m
y k
ind
req
ues
t is
th
at
I H
etr
am
Ch
atu
rve
di,
s/o
Sh
ri.
Ram
rup
C
ha
turv
ed
i a
m
a
stu
den
t o
f V
ill-
Ku
tes
hw
ar,
P
O-I
tto
ra.
It
is
req
ue
ste
d t
ha
t m
ine
is
ru
nn
ing
in
th
e n
am
e o
f B
ok
aro
, S
AIL
-RM
D
for
las
t 5
0
ye
ars
. O
ur
farm
ers
h
ave
n
ot
be
en
p
rovid
ed
a
ny
em
plo
ym
en
t ti
ll d
ate
. O
ur
ho
us
e a
nd
la
nd
ha
s b
ee
n l
os
t d
ue
to
le
as
e.
1. T
he
w
ho
le le
as
e a
rea
h
as
b
ee
n a
cq
uir
ed
b
y B
an
sa
gar
Pro
jec
t a
nd
d
ue
c
om
pen
sati
on
to
th
e
lan
d
ow
ne
r h
as
be
en
pa
id
2.
Ex
pa
ns
ion
o
f m
ine
s
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will
be
fro
m l
oc
al p
eo
ple
on
ly.
06
No
Na
me
Vil
lag
e -
Ku
tes
hw
ar
It i
s m
y k
ind
req
ue
st
is t
ha
t I a
m r
es
ide
nt
of
vil
lag
e K
ute
sh
wa
r. T
he
Min
es
is
ru
nn
ing
in
th
e n
am
e o
f K
ute
sh
wa
r, b
ut
we
ha
ve
no
t b
ee
n
pro
vid
ed
an
y j
ob
ne
ith
er
an
y f
ac
ilit
y f
rom
SA
IL.
Ed
uc
ate
d w
ork
ers
s
ho
uld
ge
t em
plo
ym
en
t a
nd
we
sh
ou
ld g
et
all
th
e f
ac
ilit
ies
.
Ex
pa
ns
ion
o
f m
ine
s
cap
ac
ity
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will b
e
fro
m l
oc
al
pe
op
le o
nly
.
07
Ma
nu
Na
rla
Vil
lag
e -
Am
ari
T
he
de
pth
of
min
es
wa
s n
ot
red
uc
ed
aft
er
refi
llin
g a
nd
th
e w
as
te
wa
s t
hro
wn
in
to f
ield
s.
Th
e c
on
se
nt
of
vil
lag
e p
an
ch
aya
t w
as n
ot
tak
en
fo
r s
up
pre
ss
ion
of
du
st.
T
he
in
form
ati
on
re
ga
rdin
g
ap
pro
va
l o
f la
bo
rato
ry
reg
ard
ing
e
mis
sio
n o
f S
O2
, N
itra
te a
nd
CO
Ca
rbo
n m
on
o-o
xid
e.
Th
e i
nfo
rma
tio
n r
eg
ard
ing
pe
rio
d o
f P
H t
ak
en
is
un
ava
ilab
le.
Alg
ae
a
nd
Fu
ng
i w
as
no
t p
ut
into
wa
ter,
th
ere
fore
th
ere
wa
s n
o o
xid
ati
on
o
f w
ate
r.
1.T
he
L
eft
B
an
k L
ea
se
m
ine
s w
ill
no
t g
o b
elo
w 32
0 M
SL
a
fte
r e
nc
ou
nte
r o
f w
ate
r ta
ble
. T
he
refo
re,
the
re
is
no
p
rop
os
al
for
refi
llin
g o
f m
ine
s.
Th
e w
as
te i
s b
ein
g t
hro
wn
at
ap
pro
ve
d w
as
te d
um
p s
ite
s w
ith
in l
eas
e a
rea
. 2
. D
us
t s
up
pre
ssio
n m
eth
od
s a
re a
do
pte
d t
o k
ee
p a
irb
orn
e
du
st
wit
hin
th
e
no
rms
o
f P
oll
uti
on
C
on
tro
l B
oa
rd.
Th
e
mo
nit
ori
ng
of
du
st
is d
on
e b
y o
ur
ap
pro
ve
d S
AIL
la
bo
rato
ry
an
d a
lso
by M
P P
oll
uti
on
Co
ntr
ol
Bo
ard
. T
he
Th
e r
es
ult
is
se
nt
to M
PP
CB
qu
art
erl
y.
It i
s n
ot
req
uir
ed
to
ta
ke
co
nse
nt
of
vil
lag
e p
an
ch
aya
t.
3.
Th
e
mo
nit
ori
ng
o
f a
ll
air
bo
rne
g
as
es
is
d
on
e
by
ou
r a
pp
rove
d
lab
ora
tory
a
nd
a
lso
b
y
MP
P
oll
uti
on
C
on
tro
l B
oa
rd.
4.
Th
e P
H o
f w
ate
r is
an
aly
se
d q
ua
rte
rly b
y o
ur
En
vir
on
me
nt
Ma
na
ge
men
t D
ep
art
me
nt,
Ko
lka
ta a
nd
se
nt
to M
PP
CB
.
5.
As
th
e m
ine
will
be
su
bm
erg
ed
8-9
mo
nth
s i
nto
th
e b
ac
k
wa
ter
of
Ch
ho
ti M
ah
an
ad
i, t
he
re i
s n
o n
ee
d p
utt
ing
Alg
ae
an
d F
un
gi
into
th
e w
ate
r fo
r o
xid
ati
on
.
08
Deve
nd
ra d
ub
ey
Vil
lag
e -
Ga
irta
lai
Ho
us
es
are
ge
ttin
g d
am
ag
ed
du
e t
o b
las
tin
g.
Pe
op
le a
re b
ec
om
ing
sic
k d
ue
to
fu
me
s o
f e
xp
los
ive
s.
Th
e c
los
ed
min
es
at
Gair
tala
i is
no
t b
ein
g f
ille
d.
1.
Ad
va
nc
ed
b
las
tin
g
tec
hn
iqu
es
w
ill
be
u
sed
to
re
du
ce
vib
rati
on
d
ue
to
b
las
tin
g.
Ho
we
ve
r,
pre
se
nt
gro
un
d
vib
rati
on
le
ve
l is
wit
hin
th
e p
res
cri
be
d n
orm
. 2
. T
he
to
xic
gas
es
ge
ne
rate
d d
ue
to
bla
sti
ng
is
wit
hin
th
e
no
rm.
3.
Th
e
min
es
a
t G
air
tala
i w
ill
be
w
ork
ed
as
p
er
min
ing
p
lan
/sc
he
me
an
d w
ill
be f
ille
d u
p a
s p
er
ap
pro
ve
d I
BM
pla
n.
09
As
his
h
Ku
ma
r G
au
tam
V
illa
ge
- G
air
tala
i
Th
ere
is
n
ot
an
y ty
pe
o
f h
ara
ss
me
nt
or
da
ma
ge
b
y m
ine
s.
Th
e
tree
s w
hic
h a
re p
lan
ted
by m
ine
s a
re c
ut
by v
illa
ge
rs.
Th
ere
is
no
p
oll
uti
on
by m
ine
s.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
10
Ma
he
nd
ra P
al
Sin
gh
B
ag
ri,
Ub
ra
My s
ug
ge
sti
on
is t
ha
t ro
ad
s s
ho
uld
be
rep
air
ed
fro
m t
ime
to
tim
e
by t
he
co
mp
an
y a
nd
tre
es
to
be
pla
nte
d w
ith
in 1
0 K
M a
rea
wit
h
ma
inte
na
nc
e.
Fa
cil
ity o
f p
layg
rou
nd
to
b
e m
ad
e s
o th
at
peo
ple
re
ma
in h
ea
lth
y t
hro
ug
h g
am
es
. T
his
is
my s
ug
ge
sti
on
.
1.P
rovis
ion
h
as
b
een
m
ad
e
for
co
ns
tru
cti
on
a
nd
m
ain
tain
an
ce
ro
ad
s o
f n
ea
rby v
illa
ge
s u
nd
er
CS
R S
ch
em
e.
2.
As
th
e l
ea
se
are
a o
f L
eft
Ba
nk
will
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 3
. D
eve
lop
me
nt
of
sp
ort
s a
nd
oth
er
rec
rea
tio
na
l fa
cil
ity h
as
be
en
en
vis
ag
ed
un
de
r C
SR
Sc
he
me
.
11
Ak
hil
es
h
Ku
ma
r D
wiv
ed
i, G
air
tala
i In
my o
pin
ion
mo
re a
nd
mo
re t
ree
s t
o b
e p
lan
ted
. In
my a
rea
th
e
Ste
el
Au
tho
rity
o
f In
dia
h
as
g
ive
n th
e e
mp
loym
en
t. L
as
tly th
ey
ha
ve
hig
h p
rod
uc
tio
n &
th
ey h
ave
giv
en
em
plo
ym
en
t. T
he
y h
ave
to
be
giv
en
th
e p
erm
iss
ion
to
sta
rt t
he p
roje
ct.
As
th
e
lea
se
a
rea
o
f L
eft
B
an
k
will
be
su
bm
erg
ed
8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
.
12
Dh
arm
en
dra
K
um
ar
Dw
ive
di,
Ga
irta
lai
Un
em
plo
ye
d s
ho
uld
be
giv
en
em
plo
ym
en
t. M
ore
pe
op
le s
ho
uld
be
em
plo
ye
d b
y e
xp
an
din
g th
e m
ines
. M
ore
a
nd
m
ore
tr
ee
s to
b
e
pla
nte
d f
or
en
vir
on
men
t.
1.E
xp
an
sio
n
of
min
es
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
.
2.
As
th
e l
ea
se
are
a o
f L
eft
Ba
nk
will
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
.
13
As
hw
ini
Ku
ma
r D
wiv
ed
i, G
air
tala
i M
ine
s
sh
ou
ld
be
ex
pa
nd
ed
s
o
tha
t m
ore
e
mp
loye
me
nt
is
ge
ne
rate
d a
nd
we g
et
em
plo
ym
en
t.
Mo
re
an
d
mo
re
tree
s
sh
ou
ld
be
p
lan
ted
s
o
tha
t e
nvir
on
me
nt
rem
ain
cle
an
.
1.E
xp
an
sio
n
of
min
es
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. 2
. A
s t
he
le
as
e a
rea
of
Le
ft B
an
k w
ill
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 1
4
Pu
sh
pa
raj
Sin
gh
R
ag
hu
va
ns
hi,
G
air
tala
i
En
vir
on
me
nt
sh
ou
ld
be
cle
an
a
nd
b
ea
uti
ful,
a
ll
un
em
plo
ye
d
pe
op
le
of
this
a
rea
s
ho
uld
g
et
em
plo
ym
en
t a
nd
e
nvir
on
me
nt
sh
ou
ld b
e c
lea
ned
by p
lan
tin
g m
ore
an
d m
ore
tre
es
.
1.E
xp
an
sio
n
of
min
es
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will
be
fro
m l
oc
al
pe
op
le o
nly
. 2
. A
s t
he
le
as
e a
rea
of
Le
ft B
an
k w
ill
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 1
5
Pre
m K
um
ar
Du
be
y,
Ga
irta
lai
Tre
es
to
be
pla
nte
d a
nd
em
plo
ym
en
t to
be
pro
vid
ed
. In
my o
pin
ion
th
e
pro
du
cti
on
o
f co
mp
an
y
to
be
d
ou
ble
d
or
trip
led
, th
ey
are
re
qu
es
ted
to
pla
nt
mo
re &
mo
re t
ree
s a
nd
th
eir
pro
du
cti
on
ha
ve
to
b
e
do
ub
led
o
r tr
iple
d,
the
em
plo
ym
en
t h
ave
a
lre
ad
y
giv
en
b
y
the
m,
the
y h
ave
to
be
giv
en
pe
rmis
sio
n.
1.E
xp
an
sio
n
of
min
es
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will
be
fro
m l
oc
al
pe
op
le o
nly
. 2
. A
s t
he
le
as
e a
rea
of
Le
ft B
an
k w
ill
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s i
nto
th
e w
ate
r, p
lan
tati
on
wil
l b
e d
on
e i
n a
dja
ce
nt
lea
se
are
as,
vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 1
6
Ja
ge
sh
wa
r K
um
ar
Se
n,
Dis
t. -
Katn
i T
ree
s t
o b
e p
lan
ted
. H
ere
, th
ere
is
no
po
llu
tio
n a
nd
pe
rmis
sio
n
sh
ou
ld b
e g
ran
ted
fo
r e
xp
an
sio
n o
f m
ines
. A
s t
he
le
as
e a
rea
of
Le
ft B
an
k w
ill
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
jas
be
en
p
lan
ned
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 1
7
Gya
ne
nd
ra D
wiv
ed
i,
Ga
irta
lai
In m
y o
pin
ion
th
e S
tee
l A
uth
ori
ty o
f In
dia
ha
ve
to
pla
nt
mo
re &
m
ore
tre
es
& h
ave
hig
h p
rod
uc
tio
n,
the
em
plo
ym
en
t h
ave
alr
ea
dy
be
en
g
ive
n
for
fulf
illi
ng
o
ur
ne
ed
s.
Th
ey
ha
ve
to
b
e
giv
en
p
erm
iss
ion
to
sta
rt t
he p
roje
ct.
As
th
e l
ea
se
are
a o
f L
eft
Ba
nk
will
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
.
18
S.N
.Sin
gh
, K
ute
sh
wa
r A
ll th
e p
eo
ple
o
f th
is a
rea to
b
e p
rovid
ed
em
plo
ym
en
t s
o th
at
em
plo
ye
d
pe
op
le
ge
t o
pp
ort
un
ity
to
imp
rove
th
eir
s
tan
da
rd
of
livin
g.
We a
re s
ati
sfi
ed
wit
h e
nvir
on
me
nt.
Mo
re t
ree
s t
o b
e p
lan
ted
s
o t
ha
t e
nvir
on
me
nt
be
co
mes
pu
rifi
ed
.
1.E
xp
an
sio
n
of
min
es
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will
be
fro
m l
oc
al
pe
op
le o
nly
. 2
. A
s t
he
le
as
e a
rea
of
Le
ft B
an
k w
ill
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 1
9
Ma
ng
al
Pra
sad
Pa
l,
Ex
. S
arp
an
ch
, G
air
tala
i
En
vir
on
me
nt
is
cle
an
a
nd
b
ea
uti
ful.
M
an
ag
em
en
t h
as
p
lan
ted
tr
ee
s b
ut
pe
op
le h
ave
cu
t th
em
an
d u
se
d i
t in
th
eir
ho
me
s.
I h
ave
no
ob
jec
tio
n r
eg
ard
ing
en
vir
on
me
nt,
we
sh
ou
ld b
e g
ive
n m
ore
an
d
mo
re e
mp
loym
en
t.
Ex
pa
ns
ion
of
min
es
cap
ac
ity w
ill
de
fin
ite
ly c
rea
te a
dd
itio
nal
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will
be f
rom
lo
cal
pe
op
le o
nly
.
2
0
Ind
raje
et
Du
be
y
Ga
irta
lai
Ag
ree
d.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
21
Ksh
ab
en
dra
K
um
ar
Dw
ive
di,
Ga
irta
lai
I h
ave
no
ob
jec
tin
reg
ard
ing
en
vir
on
me
nt.
I a
nd
my v
illa
ge
rs a
re
sa
tis
fie
d w
ith
e
nvir
on
em
en
t. 2
5%
p
eo
ple
o
f vil
lag
e h
ave
jo
b o
f o
nly
op
po
se
. M
ine
s t
o b
e e
xp
an
ded
so
th
at
new
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
fo
r e
mp
loym
en
t is
ge
ne
rate
d.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
22
Su
jit
Ku
ma
r P
aro
ha
, V
ill-
Ga
irta
lai
En
vir
on
me
nt
is v
ery
go
od
an
d t
he
re i
s n
o p
oll
uti
on
of
an
y t
yp
e.
En
vir
on
me
nt
cle
ara
nce
to
be
giv
en
. T
ha
nk
yo
u.
23
Bas
an
t L
al
Ch
au
dh
ry,
Ga
irta
lai
Ta
ke
ca
re o
f jo
b.
Th
an
k y
ou
. T
ha
nk
yo
u.
24
Ram
es
h S
ing
h K
ol,
Ku
tes
hw
ar
Em
plo
ym
en
t to
b
e g
ive
n.
En
vir
on
me
nt
to b
e ta
ke
n ca
re o
f a
nd
p
rod
uc
tio
n o
f m
ine
s t
o b
e e
nh
an
ced
. E
xp
an
sio
n o
f m
ine
s c
ap
ac
ity w
ill
de
fin
ite
ly c
rea
te a
dd
itio
nal
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. E
mp
loym
en
t o
f w
ork
ers
will
be f
rom
lo
cal
pe
op
le o
nly
. 2
5
Devid
in K
ew
at,
K
ute
sh
wa
r P
rod
uc
tio
n
ca
pa
cit
y
of
min
es
to
b
e
inc
rea
se
d
so
th
at
ne
ab
y
pe
op
le g
et
em
plo
ym
en
t.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
26
Bag
ho
la K
ol,
Ku
tes
hw
ar
En
vir
on
me
nt
is c
lean
, m
ine
s t
o b
e e
xp
an
de
d.
I h
ave
no
ob
jec
tio
n.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
27
Harp
ras
ad
Sah
u,
Ku
tes
hw
ar
Ag
ree
d
Th
an
k y
ou
.
28
Devid
in K
ew
at,
K
ute
sh
wa
r T
he
re i
s n
o h
arm
fro
m e
nvir
on
me
nt.
Min
es
to
be
ex
pan
de
d a
nd
e
mp
loym
en
t to
be
pro
vid
ed
. E
xp
an
sio
n o
f m
ine
s c
ap
ac
ity w
ill
de
fin
ite
ly c
rea
te a
dd
itio
na
l jo
b o
pp
ort
un
itie
s.
29
Sa
roj
Ku
ma
r D
ub
ey,
Ga
irta
lai
Ku
tes
hw
ar
Lim
es
ton
e
Min
es
, K
ute
sh
wa
r s
ho
uld
b
e
gra
nte
d
pe
rmis
sio
n w
ith
re
ga
rd t
o e
nvir
on
me
nt.
T
ha
nk
yo
u.
30
Bh
aiy
a L
al
Ko
l,
Ku
tes
hw
ar
Min
es
to
be
ex
pan
de
d,
trees
to
be
pla
nte
d a
nd
em
plo
ym
en
t to
be
p
rovid
ed
. 1
.Ex
pa
ns
ion
o
f m
ine
s
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. 2
. A
s t
he
le
as
e a
rea
of
Le
ft B
an
k w
ill
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 3
1
Ram
es
h K
ol,
Ku
tes
hw
ar
I w
ill b
e b
en
efi
tte
d f
rom
ex
pa
ns
ion
of
SA
IL.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
32
Harp
ras
ad
Sah
u,
Ku
tes
hw
ar
We
do
no
t h
ave
an
y h
arm
on
en
vir
on
me
nt,
min
es
to
be
ex
pa
nd
ed
. T
ha
nk
yo
u.
33
Ch
an
dra
ka
li K
ew
at,
V
ill-
Ku
tes
hw
ar
Th
ere
is n
o h
arm
fro
m e
nvir
on
me
nt.
T
ha
nk
yo
u.
34
Ram
ba
i K
ew
at,
V
ill-
Ku
tes
hw
ar
Th
ere
is n
o h
arm
fro
m e
nvir
on
me
nt.
T
ree
s t
o b
e p
lan
ted
, em
plo
ym
en
t to
be
pro
vid
ed
an
d m
ine
s t
o b
e
ex
pa
nd
ed
.
1.E
xp
an
sio
n
of
min
es
ca
pa
cit
y
wil
l d
efi
nit
ely
c
rea
te
ad
dit
ion
al
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. 2
. A
s t
he
le
as
e a
rea
of
Le
ft B
an
k w
ill
be
su
bm
erg
ed
fo
r 8
-9
mo
nth
s
into
th
e
wa
ter,
p
lan
tati
on
h
as
b
ee
n
pla
nn
ed
in
a
dja
cen
t le
as
e a
rea
s, vil
lag
es
an
d s
urf
ac
e d
um
ps
. 3
5
Go
rela
l K
ol,
Ku
tes
hw
ar
Jo
b i
s b
ein
g p
rovid
ed
by S
AIL
min
es
, th
ere
is
ne
gli
gib
le p
oll
uti
on
, w
e a
re b
en
efi
tte
d.
Th
an
k y
ou
.
36
Su
raj
Kew
at,
K
ute
sh
wa
r T
he
re i
s n
o h
arm
fro
m e
nvir
on
me
nt.
Em
plo
ym
en
t to
be
pro
vid
ed
a
nd
min
es
to
be
ex
pa
nd
ed
. E
xp
an
sio
n o
f m
ine
s c
ap
ac
ity w
ill
de
fin
ite
ly c
rea
te a
dd
itio
nal
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
. 3
7
Raju
Kew
at,
V
ill.
-Ku
tes
hw
ar
Th
ere
is
no
ha
rm f
rom
en
vir
on
me
nt.
Em
plo
ym
en
t to
be
pro
vid
ed
a
nd
min
es
to
be
ex
pa
nd
ed
. E
xp
an
sio
n o
f m
ine
s c
ap
ac
ity w
ill
de
fin
ite
ly c
rea
te a
dd
itio
nal
job
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
.