M’Lisia Williams
Professor Wolcott
ENC 1102 Section 0018
23 October 2013
Aging Out of Foster Care
According to childrensrights.org there are 400,000 children in out of home care.
This number continues to increase over time and shows no signs of decreasing in future
years. Foster care is typically a place for “delinquent or neglected children”. (Google
Definitions) Once in the system some kids may be adopted, some may go to a relative,
others may spend their whole life a ward of the state. But what happens when children
are to old to be in foster care? They have to jump-start straight into the real world with no
help or guidance. Many worry about health care, housing, food, and other basic
necessities. A large percentage of those who age out of foster care end up homeless,
others struggle every day to survive. There are a select few who do end up successful.
Throughout this bibliography I plan to annotate various research to determine
what happens to children, youth, and or their families once they age out of foster care.
Valid sources in this conversation come primarily from scholarly journals that contain
background research on my field of study. They also contain information or points of
view from people who have lived in the foster care system and therefor validating the
information they chose to share with the world. Other valid sources to consider are those
written by everyday working people who have witnessed or experienced first hand what
it is like to age out of foster care. Such as lawyers, social workers, teens who have aged
out and many more. This bibliography is useful to others in the social work field
performing research on aging out of foster care or finding what the system lacks in doing
for those who have aged out. It can also be beneficial to those getting prepared to
transition from foster care to the real world if they want to know who to run to and or
what’s available to them once they are no longer covered by the state.
Cunningham, Miranda, and Marcelo Diversi. "Aging Out: Youths perspective on foster care and
the transition to independence." Qualitative Social Work 1 (2012): 587-602. Print.
This Journal article is an excerpt from “Qualitative Social Work”. It’s written by
Miranda Cunningham of Portland State University, and Marcelo Diversi of
Washington State University. Cunningham and Diversi evaluate the youth’s
outlook on aging out of foster care. They used ethnography techniques to get
various youth’s opinion. Cunningham and Diversi chose this method because
generally children in the system have a hard time trusting adults, especially
strangers. Observations and informal interviews allowed them to get most of the
information needed to conduct he study. They found youth were generally more
concerned about overall stability. Such as where would they stay, and who would
help them through the process of “aging out”. They were scared about becoming
completely independent. Cunningham and Diversi’s research is relevant to my
project because it gives another viewpoint on my topic, Aging out of Foster Care.
Most journal articles or research are based on statistics and the researchers own
opinion. Which doesn’t allow readers to see multiple viewpoints of a situation and
can also be quite biased.
Day, A, J Riebschleger, A Dworsky,, A Damashek, and K Fogarty. "Maximizing
educational opportunities for youth aging out of foster care by engaging youth
voices in a partnership for social change." Children and Youth Services Review
34.5 (2012): 1007-1014. Print.
The authors of this article come from various social work, clinical psychology,
and interdisciplinary health sciences programs. They work at prestigious
universities such as, Wayne State University, Michigan State, University of
Chicago, and Western Michigan University. This study target youths and the
challenges they may face while transitioning form high school into college.
Researchers analyzed the transcripts, of youth going through the transition, form a
panel where they gave their own testimonies. Eight specific challenges or barriers
were identified. The one that repeated itself the most was lack of supportive
adults. This research is relevant to my topic because it address the voice of youth
in foster care who are determined to make it. College is a big step and is not for
everyone. The youth in this study face challenges of adapting into a new
environment that holds their future as well as health risks and risks of being
homeless.
Dworsky, Amy, and Mark Courtney. "Homelessness and the Transition from Foster Care
to Adulthood.." Child Welfare 88.4 (2009): 23-56. Print.
Amy Dworsky is a senior researcher at Chapin Hall of, the University of Chicago.
Mark Courtney I a professor at the School of social work at the University of
Washington. Homelessness has shown to be great problem amongst youth aging
out of foster care. Courtney and Dworsky conducted a longitudinal study to
determine how, why, and or if there are any indications of homelessness. They
used an ample from 3 midwestern states that held youth who recently aged out of
foster care. They broke their data down into tables. The first contained
characteristics of the youth in the sample. The second set of results was a graph
that contains the probability of youth becoming homeless once they age out of
foster care. Table 2 contained the results of those who were actually homeless
once exiting the foster care system. Table 3 listed the number of places those who
haven’t been homeless have stayed since exiting foster care. Table 4 compared
results of those who were homeless with those who were never homeless. Table 5
shows odd estimated on predicting homelessness. This article shed light on a
specific aspect of aging out that other articles did not include. Homelessness is
something that we see everyday but no one addresses it. Even the ones who had a
place to stay most of them couldn’t say the place was physically theirs. They
stayed with someone else.
Freundlich, Madelyn, and Rosemary Avery. "Transitioning from congregate care:
Preparation and outcomes.." Journal of Child & Family Studies. 15.4 (2006): 503-
514. Print.
Madelyn Freundlich works for Excal Consulting Partners of New York, and
Rosemary Avery is of Cornell University. This journal article focused on the
youth in congregate care in New York City’s foster care system, as well as the
process of aging out in New York, and post transition. The research method was a
qualitative study of youth age 12 and up in congregate care, which are group
homes. Twenty-one other youth were interviewed ranging from 18-25. They
represented those currently aged out. There were 16 female, 7 male, and 1
transgender. Researchers found them through various outreach programs, and
even interviewed some of the people who worked with the children/young adults.
They also talked to judges, social workers, and professional stakeholder groups.
As expected the results varied from person to person. Many were scared, some
eager to leave, and some who believed the system allowed a successful transition.
This article is important because it allows me to dig deeper into the controversy of
whether the system prepared the youth for what was to come. Some believe they
were while others argue the weren’t. There may be underlying factors, such as
maybe some of the ones who weren’t were adopted many times and brought back
or maybe those who were successful had more access to outside information and
used it once old enough.
Jaudes, Paula. "Health Care of Youth Aging Out of Foster Care.." Pediatrics 130.6
(2012): 1170-1173. Print.
This article was written by MD Paula Jaudes, and an excerpt from the American
Academy of Pediatrics. Other contributing authors of this article include, James
Pawelski, Cynthia Pellegrini, and Daniel Walter. Here Paula aims to educate her
audience about the health care available to youth aging out of foster care or the
lack thereof. She addresses government programs and policies used to support
those who are transitioning and inform other pediatricians on how they can be of
assistance. Jaudes begins with research on health challenges youth aging out of
foster care may face. Such as developmental delays, mental retardation and many
more. Jaudes continues with how the lack of coverage may negatively affect the
youth but also what policies can help those who have aged out. For example the
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 says youth who age out of
foster care can be eligible for Medicaid up until the age of 26. Jaudes encourages
Pediatricians to help these youth by working with the welfare agency of their
specific state to make sure the child’s needs are met. This journal showed me that
there are people out there who have thought about the lives of the youth aging out
of foster care. There are actual programs/policies out there designed for them
specifically you just have to know where to look. Which unfortunately most
people do not know but articles like this one gives hope.
Keller, Thomas , Gretchen Cusick, and Mark Courtney. "Approaching the Transition to
Adulthood: Distinctive Profiles of Adolescents Aging out of the Child Welfare
System." Social Service Review 81.3 (2007): 453-484. Print.
This Journal article was written by Thomas Keller of Portland State University,
Gretchen Cusick, and Mark Courtney of the University of Chicago after a study of
transitioning into adulthood. They investigated “the capacity of adolescents on the
verge of emancipation from the child welfare system” (paragraph 1). The team of
researchers performed an interview style longitudinal study of select youth
preparing to age out of foster care. They excluded youth who after emancipation,
became incarcerated, in an inpatient psychiatric institution, or with a
developmental disability. This is because they are not or cannot make a smooth
transition into independence once out of foster care. They are still under
guidelines or responsibility of a third party. Keller, Cusick, and Courtney
analyzed seven indicators of individual status. Starting with employment and on
to, grade retention, parenthood, problem behavior, placement type, placement
stability, and runaway history. This study is related to my topic because it shows
the percentage of teens that successfully transitioned from well fare living to
adulthood. Although success levels may vary from person to person they create a
stable thesis.
King,, Laura, and Aneer Rukh-Kamaa, . "YOUTH TRANSITIONING OUT OF
FOSTER CARE: AN EVALUATION OF A SUPPLEMENTAL SECURITY
INCOME POLICY CHANGE.." Social Security Bulletin 73.3 (2013): 53-57.
Print.
King is a research analyst with the social security administration and Aneer Rukh-
Kamaa is a statistician with the Social security administration. They wrote this
article to address how those who age out may lose their foster care befits. This can
be especially tough for those who may have disabilities. Some youth going
through the aging out process may be eligible for Social Security Income once
foster care stops. The time needed to process eligibility creates a large window of
time where many things can happen. King and Kamaa evaluated a policy change
that allows youth to apply for these benefits 60 days prior to the date that the
previous policy stated. This buys more time for those who are close to aging out
but still need some stability that the foster facility is able to provide
Liebmann, Theo, and Emily Madden. "HEAR MY VOICE—PERSPECTIVES OF
CURRENT AND FORMER FOSTER YOUTH.." Family Court Review 48.2
(2010): 255-261. Print.
This scholarly Journal was written specifically to give youth in foster care a voice
and to allow those who have been in foster care but transitioned a way to speak up
for those still there. Liebmann is the director of the interdisciplinary Hofstra Child
Advocacy clinic, while Madden was a child and family advocacy fellow at
Hofstra until she graduated law school in 2009. This article contained personal
quotes written by the youth, which adds ethos and pathos and allows you to
sympathize with those who are expressing various emotions such as sadness anger
and fear. Results found from this study include various amounts of fear, anger,
and or sadness expressed by the youth involved. They worry about there future
just as some of the youth from other articles mentioned in this bibliography.
Morris, Rita. "Voices of Foster Youths: Problems and Ideas for Change.." Urologic
Nursing 27.5 (2007): 419-427. Print.
Rita Morris of San Diego State University wrote this journal article. Rita was
assisted by Antonia Giaffoglione who collected data for her graduate thesis. The
purpose of this study was to pinpoint the specific characteristics that lead to a not
so smooth transition. Which would be a lack of self-sufficiency and economic
independence. In order to test her theory Morris conducted various interviews
with 16 subjects who had aged out of foster care and currently living
independently. Morris found five major themes in her research such as “From My
Past”, “No Place to call home”, “Broken Promises”, “The system failed Us”, and
“Ideas For Change”. This research is relevant because Morris’ objective was to
find youth who may not have made a successful transition versus the usual
finding those who had. She allows us to see the point of view of someone who
more than likely represents a large percentage of teens who age out of foster care.
Samuels, Gina, and Julia Pryce. "“What doesn't kill you makes you stronger”: Survivalist
self-reliance as resilience and risk among young adults aging out of foster care."
Children and Youth Services Review 30.10 (2008): 1198-1210. Print.
This scholarly Journal is written by Gina Samuels of the University of Chicago,
and Julia Pryce of Loyola University. Samuels and Pryce studies forty-four
Midwestern adults who were currently aging out of foster care. They used audio
taped interviews to record all the data they had found. Each interview was one
and a half hours designed to explore the persons history in foster care, their
understanding of why they were there and how their relationship with their
biological family developed/changed over time. This study address problems head
on by interviewing youth who are currently going through the aging out process.
These youth answered many questions pertaining to their trials, tribulations, and
what they want to overcome.
Scannapieco, Maria, Kelli Connell-Carrick, and Kirstin Painter. "In Their Own Words:
Challenges Facing Youth Aging Out of Foster Care.." Child & Adolescent Social
Work Journal 24.5 (2007): 423-435. Print.
Painter of Texas Woman University, Carrick of University of Houston, and
Scannapieco of University of Texas collaborated to write this journal article. The
research method done was based on program development. They used this to ask
those in the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services foster care. The
goal was to determine what the youth saw/see as challenges and what services
could potentially be helpful. Focus groups were created in order to conduct
interviews. They found teens wanted to involved with the decisions that were
going o impact the rest of their lives. Most things were left up to the social worker
to handle. They didn’t want to feel like they owed anybody so the teens expressed
wanting their own. (i.e. Money, jobs, goals, etc.) I found this research relevant
because this is another article that includes what the children had to say. They
represent a greater number of youth out there who haven’t had the opportunity to
express how they really feel .
Scott, Tonia. "Placement Instability and Risky Behaviors of Youth Aging Out of Foster
Care.." Child & Adolescent Social Work Journal. 29.1 (2012): 69-83. Print.
Tonia Scott works for he School of Social Work at Arizona State University.
Scott’s research focuses on the negatives associated with aging out of foster care.
The risk for negative outcomes in adulthood increases once youth age out of
foster care. In order to complete the study a recruitment packet was sent to last
known addresses of youth who turned 18 between July 2004 and June 2008 while
under Child Protective services. They sent out a total of 2045 packets, 214 had no
address, and 601 were returned to sender. Those who desired to participate
received a $10 gift card for returning the packet, and a $45 gift card for
conducting the phone interview. Results found that 25% had used drugs or
alcohol in the past 30 days (of the study), one fifth uses substances frequently, and
two-fifths had been dunk or used drugs in the past 6months. Most of those who
said to be sexually active used some form of contraception and 88.8% all
consented to the various sexual activity. Out of all participant three of them stated
they had not been through any trauma or experiences as the others who
interviewed. This research is relevant to my topic because it shines light on other
negative outcomes. Having a negative transition isn’t limited to unstable housing
or minimum wage jobs, it can also mean unhealthy relationships, or abuse.
Shook, Jeffrey, Sara Goodkind, David Herring, Ryan Pohlig, Karen Kolivoski, and Kevin
Kim. "How different are their experiences and outcomes? Comparing aged out
and other child welfare involved youth.." Children & Youth Services Review 35.1
(2013): 11-18. Print.
The various authors of this article wanted to compare experiences and outcomes
of youth aged out of foster care in comparison with those whose families receive
welfare services but still stay in home. As well as those in some form of out-of-
home placement but have not aged out. This methodology could be useful and or
relevant to my topic because I didn’t think to consider other means of welfare
besides foster care. The children may have similar outcomes and or experiences.
In order to answer their question the researchers needed to create a profile with
the data. The profile told care careers and other system involvement. The resulting
data was broken down into tables. The fist represented demographics, the second,
placement experiences, and comparison of placements/care careers. The third
table represented the percentage of youth who could be categorized in another
group, because they were also involved in other systems at one point.
Wiseman, Eva. "Ready or Not: Youth Aging Out of Care." Youth In Care 21.3 (2008):
15-26. Print.
This source is a journal article written by Eva Nardella Wiseman. Wiseman works
in Toronto as a independent contractor with children youth and families. In this
article Wiseman evaluates other articles or literature about children leaving the
foster care center. She analyzed risk factors, protective factors, and youth’s
perspective. As well as positive outcomes, negative outcomes, after care services,
and connections in the filed of youth care & foster care. Wiseman used various
databases like, ProQuest, Academic Search Premier, etc. and searched key words
pertaining to youth in foster care. All journals or articles selected were based on
youth leaving foster care specifically because they had “aged out”. Wiseman
discovered that youth leaving foster care have a tougher time than others that are
the same age but do not come from a “welfare background”. (Pg. 24) A handful of
those who have aged out show that they are on their way to leading a successful
life. All the literature she acquired talked about the state extending the care age of
18 or 21 (depending on where you currently reside).
Yates, Tuppett, and Izabela Grey. "Adapting to aging out: Profiles of risk and resilience among
emancipated foster youth.." Development & Psychopathology 24.2 (2012): 475-492.
Print.
In this scholarly journal Tuppet Yates and Izabela Grey of the University of California
studied how youth adapt to aging out of foster care. Yates and Grey used the profile
analysis to find patterns among 164 youth who had aged out of foster care. Those still in
foster car were allowed to participate if they were going to be leaving within a two-year
period of their current age. Phone interviews were conducted first as a screening process
in order to weed out candidates who could not help the study. Next phone interviews
were conducted. Researchers measures educational competence, occupational
competence, civic engagement, relational competence, self-esteem, child welfare history,
and much more. Yates and Grey found that on average most of the participants entered
the system around 8 years of age. Also most of them endured some type of abuse whether
it is physical, emotional, or mental abuse. Not to mention neglect and domestic violence.
They showed higher rates of homelessness, unemployment, and parenthood. This study
done by Yates and Grey is important to my research because they tested youth who were
already emancipated from the system. Their results show what happened to the people
who were now completely on their own. Although the study was not an accurate
depiction of all youth aged out of foster care it was a high enough percentage to shed
light on the subject.