Analysis of High Resolution Propane Spectra and the Interpretation of Titanโs Infrared Spectra For ASTR 498: Independent Study Course
Valerie Klavans
June 2, 2011
2
Table of Contents
Glossary .............................................................................................................................................. 3
1. Background .......................................................................................................................... 4
1.1 Objectives .................................................................................................................................. 4
1.2 Titanโs Atmosphere .................................................................................................................... 4
1.3 Propane in Titanโs Atmosphere ................................................................................................... 6
1.4 Vibration/Rotation Spectrum of Propane ................................................................................... 7
1.5 Radiative Transfer .................................................................................................................... 11
2. Laboratory Data Analysis .................................................................................................... 12
2.1 Acquisition of Laboratory Data ................................................................................................. 12
2.2 Characterizing Spectra .............................................................................................................. 13
2.3 Line Modeling ........................................................................................................................... 15
2.4 Results ..................................................................................................................................... 16
3. Radiative Transfer Modeling of Titanโs Atmosphere ............................................................ 18
3.1 Sample Calculations .................................................................................................................. 18
4. Summary/Conclusion .......................................................................................................... 23
Appendix ................................................................................................................................ 25
References ............................................................................................................................. 27
3
Glossary
(C3H8) Propane โ Spectra of this hydrocarbon were analyzed in this project
(C2H6) Ethane โ This hydrocarbon was used in the Radiative Transfer section of this project as an aid in investigating the interaction of radiation with an infrared active molecule having well established spectroscopic parameters.
CIRS โ The Composite Infrared Spectrometer is one of the instruments on board the Cassini orbiter that records the infrared spectrum of targets in the Saturnian system and provides details on their chemical composition and thermal structure
ESA โ The European Space Agency played a large part in the Cassini-Huygens Mission
FTS โ The Fourier Transform Spectrometer is an instrument that collects spectra. The McMath-Pierce FTS is a modified version of the classic Michelson type interferometer. This instrument was used by Dr. D. E. Jennings in obtaining the spectra used in this project.
GEISA 2009 โ Gestion et Etude des Informations Spectroscopiques Atmosphรฉriques is a spectroscopic database (similar to HITRAN) for the management and study of atmospheric spectroscopic information. The current distribution was released in 2009.
HIPWAC โ Heterodyne Instrument for Planetary Wind And Composition probes planetary atmospheres such as Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Titan, and Neptune
HITRAN 2008 โ HIgh Resolution TRANsmission is a compilation of spectroscopic parameters used widely for analysis of atmospheric constituents (similar to the GEISA database). The current version was released in 2008.
KPNO โ Kitt Peak National Observatory hosts the McMath-Pierce spectrometer used in obtaining the propane spectra discussed herein.
LMM โ The Levenberg-Marquardt Method is a technique for model parameter optimization.
NASA โ National Aeronautics and Space Administration was one of three partners (along with ESA and the Italian Space Agency โ Agenzia Spaziale Italiana) in the Cassini-Huygens Mission
๐๐๐, 922 cm-1 band โ Vibrational mode of propane that was primarily analyzed in this project
VPL โ The Virtual Planetary Laboratory is a project with the goal of understanding the characteristics and environments of extrasolar planets. The projectโs publicly accessible resources include compilations of spectra and spectroscopic parameters for molecules of interest in planetary science.
4
1. Background
1.1 Objectives
The goals of this project are to study the following topics:
โข Background research o Titanโs atmosphere o Propane molecule o Atmospheric radiative transfer
โข Analysis of laboratory propane spectra
โข Radiative transfer modeling of simulated Titan atmosphere
1.2 Titanโs Atmosphere
Titanโs atmosphere, dominated by nitrogen, includes a range of trace species such as hydrocarbons, nitriles, and carbon dioxide (those of interest are summarized in Table 1). Due to differences in gravity, Titanโs atmosphere is more extended than Earthโs. Earthโs atmosphere extends to about 50 km while Titanโs atmosphere extends another order of magnitude to roughly 600 km. In addition, Titan has a greenhouse effect as well as an anti-greenhouse effect. Its greenhouse comes from its nitrogen, methane and hydrogen. Titanโs atmosphere is so dense that molecules collide and acquire induced dipole moments.1 These molecules are primarily N2-N2, N2-CH4, and N2-H2 pairs (dimers) in the troposphere. When these molecules collide, their symmetry is perturbed and they can absorb radiation. They are transparent in the visible but opaque in the thermal infrared, which allows shortwave solar radiation to reach the surface but does not let longwave thermal radiation to escape. Titanโs anti-greenhouse is a result of its optically thick organic haze. It absorbs at shortwave solar radiation but is transparent in the longwave thermal infrared. Thus, it regulates the shortwave energy reaching the surface, creating a cooling mechanism.2
In the Radiative Transfer section of this project, tests were made by varying certain parameters for Titanโs troposphere and stratosphere, such as the abundance of major gases, and altering the thermal profile in those regions (see section 3. Radiative Transfer). This paper will only cover Titanโs atmosphere from the troposphere through the stratosphere. The surface temperature of Titan is ~93 K and decreases through the troposphere until the tropopause where the temperature reaches ~71 K (Figure 1). Convection occurs in the troposphere mixing the hotter atmosphere near the surface with the cooler atmosphere closer to the tropopause. Then the temperature increases into the stratosphere, where heating takes place due to aerosol absorption, reaching a maximum temperature at ~170 K. The abundances of most chemical species increase in the stratosphere, and they condense out of the gas phase near the tropopause. In the stratosphere, haze particles reflect and absorb some sunlight, leading to a well-defined stratopause maximum in temperature. Some sunlight reaches the surface, but the greenhouse effect in the troposphere raises the temperature by ~13 K. Examples of trace species abundance profiles in Titanโs atmosphere are shown in Figure 2.
5
Figure 1: Titanโs thermal profile in the troposphere and stratosphere. The tropopause is well-defined around 100 mbar separating the troposphere (negative slope) with the stratosphere (positive slope). The stratopause is well-defined at 0.100 mbar. The two gases used in this project are ethane (C2H6) and ethylene (C2H4). Their profiles used this project are reresentative (not measured) as shown in this figure.
Figure 2: Vertical profiles for major hydrocarbons inferred from limb data from CIRS (blue lines, 15ยฐS and red lines, 30ยฐN), and the model simulations (black lines). The model simulations correctly reproduce the results from CIRS nadir and limb data.3
Pres
sure
(mba
r)
6
Table 1: Composition of Titanโs atmosphere4
and mixing ratios of trace gases.2
1.3 Propane in Titanโs Atmosphere
The Cassini-Huygens mission is a joint NASA and ESA mission studying Saturn and its natural satellites. The Cassini orbiterโs 12 instruments have been returning cutting-edge information on the Saturnian system since arriving in 2004. One such instrument is the Composite Infrared Spectrometer (CIRS). The CIRS instrument records the infrared spectrum of targets in the Saturnian system and provides details on their chemical composition and thermal structure. CIRS infrared mapping of Titanโs atmosphere has confirmed the presence of many chemical species and detected new isotopic varieties.
Titan is one of the prime targets of the Cassini-Huygens mission. Titanโs atmosphere, dominated by nitrogen, includes a range of trace species such as hydrocarbons, nitriles, and CO2 (Figure 3). One such hydrocarbon is propane (C3H8). Propane is a critical species spectroscopically, as it has 21 active IR bands covering broad regions of the mid-infrared, and so its ubiquitous signature may potentially mask weaker signatures of other undetected species with important roles in Titanโs chemistry. Thus, modeling the C3H8 contribution is of current scientific interest. Unfortunately, C3H8 line atlases for some spectral regions (bands near 869, 922, 1054, and 1157 cm-1) have not yet been analyzed and therefore cannot be used for research. When available, such line atlases will be the basis for modeling and subtracting the C3H8 signal from the CIRS spectral data to reveal, or constrain, the signature of underlying chemical species. In this project, the 922 cm-1 propane band was inspected and fitted with the goal of producing a line atlas of spectroscopic parameters (e.g., frequency and intensity) and then to use it for a Titan radiation model prediction.
The analysis of C3H8 will allow us to better understand the composition of Titanโs atmosphere and planetary atmospheres in general. In the long run, projects like this will help us better understand the
Composition of Titan's Atmosphere
Constituent Formula Equator North Pole Nitrogen N2 0.95-0.984 0.95-0.984 Methane CH4 0.045-0.015 0.045-0.015 Hydrogen H2 0.001 0.001 Acetylene C2H2 3.25x10-6 5.10x10-6 Ethylene C2H4 1.35x10-7 5.50x10-7 Ethane C2H6 8.00x10-6 1.15x10-5 Propyne C3H4 5.90x10-9 2.40x10-8 Propane C3H8 5.00x10-7 6.95x10-7
Diacetylene C4H2 1.32x10-9 2.30x10-8 Benzene C6H6 3.00x10-10 4.20x10-9
Hydrogen Cyanide HCN 1.13x10-7 9.70x10-7 Cyanoacetylene HC3N 5.00x10-10 4.60x10-8 Carbon Dioxide CO2 1.11x10-8 1.40x10-8
7
interaction of hydrocarbons and other species in Titanโs atmosphere in photochemical reactions and its methanological cycle. This understanding can shed light on Titanโs weather, along with the feasibility of hydrocarbon rain and lakes on Titanโs surface. Titan is the only other body in the Solar System besides Earth that has flowing liquids on its surface, which could support life. One tantalizing conjecture is that life may even exist within these liquid hydrocarbons.
Figure 3: CIRS model spectral data at an altitude of 125 km5
1.4 Vibration/Rotation Spectrum of Propane
The chemical bonds in polyatomic molecules such as propane can be approximated by a number of masses connected by springs. The movements of each mass (atom) connected by springs (bonds) are comparable to the vibrational and rotational movements of a molecule. Therefore, the motion of each molecule is harmonic, where each oscillator (atom) has its own characteristic frequency and spring constant (from the strengths of bonds). The expected number of modes of vibration for propane is (3x11)โ6 = 27 (see Table 2). This number signifies that the 11 atoms in the propane molecule may stretch, bend (scissoring, twisting, rocking or wagging), or exhibit torsion in 27 different ways. A simpler molecule that illustrates vibrational modes is the molecule of water (H2O). As shown schematically in Figure 4, water has two stretching modes (๐1, ๐3) and two bending modes (๐2). 6 An example of a torsion can be seen in the ethane (C2H6) molecule, more similar to propane (Figure 5).
8
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 4: The normal modes of vibration for H2O7
(a) Symmetric stretching mode: ๐1 = 3657 cm-1 and (b) Anti-symmetric stretching mode: ๐3 = 3756 cm-1 (c) two bending modes on the x and y axes, the scissoring and rocking modes: ๐2 = 1595 cm-1 (rocking mode is not shown)
Figure 5: Sample torsional mode of the ethane molecule8
Rotation of a molecule occurs when a molecule rotates about an axis with a non-zero moment of inertia. The energy of rotational transitions is much lower than that of vibrational transitions.
Propane is a much more complex molecule than ethane or water. It has many more atoms which increases the number of degrees of freedom in which to vibrate. Table 2 shows the normal modes of vibration for propane. Each one corresponds to a certain vibration of the propane molecule. For example, Figure 6 shows the stretching and bending (in-plane: scissoring and rocking; out-of-plane: twisting and wagging) modes of vibration for a molecule containing a CH2 group. Note that the figure does not show the CH3 modes given in Table 2.
9
Table 2: Normal Vibration Modes of Propane from VPL9
* Infrared-inactive modes
Normal Vibration Modes of Propane
Fundamental Frequencies Vibration
ฮฝ1 2977 cm-1 CH3 stretch
ฮฝ2 2962 cm-1 CH3 deform ฮฝ3 2887 cm-1 CH2 stretch ฮฝ4 1476 cm-1 CH3 deform ฮฝ5 1462 cm-1 CH2 scissor ฮฝ6 1392 cm-1 CH3 deform ฮฝ7 1158 cm-1 CH3 rock ฮฝ8 869 cm-1 CC stretch ฮฝ9 369 cm-1 CCC deform ฮฝ10
* 2967 cm-1 CH3 stretch ฮฝ11
* 1451 cm-1 CH3 deform ฮฝ12
* 1278 cm-1 CH2 twist ฮฝ13
* 940 cm-1 CH3 rock ฮฝ14
* 216 cm-1 torsion ฮฝ15
* 2968 cm-1 CH3 stretch ฮฝ16 2887 cm-1 CH3 stretch ฮฝ17 1464 cm-1 CH3 deform ฮฝ18 1378 cm-1 CH3 deform ฮฝ19 1338 cm-1 CH2 wag ฮฝ20 1054 cm-1 CC stretch ฮฝ21 922 cm-1 CH3 rock ฮฝ22 2973 cm-1 CH3 stretch ฮฝ23 2968 cm-1 CH2 stretch ฮฝ24 1472 cm-1 CH3 deform ฮฝ25 1192 cm-1 CH3 rock ฮฝ26 748 cm-1 CH2 rock ฮฝ27 268 cm-1 torsion
10
Figure 6: Normal vibration modes (stretching and bending) for the CH2 (methylene) group10
Figure 7: Propane molecular structure11
showing one CH2 (methylene) group surrounded by two CH3 (methyl) groups
11
1.5 Radiative Transfer
In order to understand propaneโs role in Titanโs spectrum, one must understand radiative transfer. This is the process by which electromagnetic radiation propagates through a medium, in this case, the atmosphere of Titan. By studying reflected, absorbed, and emitted radiation, one can gain insight into the properties of planetary atmospheres. In particular, infrared spectroscopy tells us about the physical and chemical traits of the emitting or absorbing material.12
The Schwarzschild Equation explains the transmission of radiation of a particular frequency through an absorbing medium. The change in intensity after passing through a thin layer which absorbs a fraction of incident radiation (first term) and contributes emission (second term) is given by:
๐๐ผ = โ ๐ผ๐ ๐๐๐ง + ๐ต๐ ๐๐๐ง
where:
โข ๐ผ = radiation intensity at any given height (erg/cm2/cm-1/sr)
โข ๐ = absorption coefficient (cm-2/g)
โข ๐ = density of the absorbing/emitting gas (g/cm-3)
โข ๐ง = thickness of absorbing layer (cm)
โข ๐ต = Planck function, the source function:
๐ต =2๐โ๐2๐3
๐โ๐๐/๐๐ โ 1
where:
โข ๐ = wavenumber of the line being considered (cm-1)
โข ๐ = absolute temperature (K)
โข ๐ = speed of light = 2.998 ร 1010 cm/s
โข โ = Planckโs constant = 6.626 ร 10-27 cm2 g / s
When the Schwarzschild Equation is integrated on both sides:
๏ฟฝ๐๐ผ
(๐ผ โ ๐ต)= โ๐๐๐ง + ๐๐๐๐ ๐ก๐๐๐ก
ln(๐ผ โ ๐ต) = โ๐ฯ๐ง + constant
When ๐ง = 0, ๐ผ = ๐ผ0, therefore, ln(๐ผ0 โ ๐ต) = constant
ln ๏ฟฝ๐ผ โ ๐ต๐ผ0 โ ๐ต
๏ฟฝ = โ๐๐ ๐ง
where, ๐ผ0 = incident radiation intensity
12
Simplifying the previous equation:
๐ผ = ๐ผ0 ๐๐ฅ๐(โ๐ฯ๐ง) + ๐ต[1 โ ๐๐ฅ๐(โ๐ฯ๐ง)]
(1)
where ๐๐๐ง = ๐, the optical depth. Rewriting the above equation,
๐ผ = ๐ผ0๐โ๐ + ๐ต(1 โ ๐โ๐)
When ๐ โช 1 (optically thin medium) ๐ผ = ๐ผ0(1 โ ๐) + ๐ต(๐)
When ๐ โซ 1 (optically thick case) ๐ผ = ๐ต
In equation (1), the formal solution of the Schwarzschild Equation, the two terms take into account that an atmosphere not only absorbs but also emits radiation. The first term of this equation is an expression of the Beer-Lambert Law, which relates the absorption of incident light to the medium in which it travels. Also, the second term is the source function (i.e. emission) modulated by the opacity of the medium.13
2. Laboratory Data Analysis
2.1 Acquisition of Laboratory Data
C3H8 spectra taken at the McMath-Pierce 1-meter Fourier Transform Spectrometer (FTS) at Kitt Peak National Observatory (KPNO) by Jennings et al.14
We used two different data sets taken on April 26, 1984 (โwarm dataโ) and on May 15, 1989 (โcold dataโ). (They were named โwarmโ and โcoldโ data for their differing observational ambient temperatures.) For the warm data, the laboratory conditions are as follows. The 2400 cm gas cell was filled with propane, at a pressure of .558 torr and observations were made at an ambient temperature of 293 K. For the cold data, the 30 cm gas cell was filled with propane, at a pressure of 3.2 torr and observations were made at an ambient temperature of 175 K.
were used in this analysis. (See Appendix A for all propane data taken.) The spectra were obtained at full-resolution of 0.005 cm-1 and the raw interferograms were already converted to calibrated spectra (by application of a Fourier Transform, followed by radiometric and wavelength calibration).
13
2.2 Characterizing Spectra
There were no empty cell data available for either warm nor cold data (gas plus cell data). Usually subtraction of cell data from gas plus cell data results in only gas data with a smooth, linear baseline (Figure 8). An example region on an expanded scale is shown in Figure 9.
Figure 8: Transmittance shows a smooth, linear baseline for C3H8 IR spectrum: 720-1250 cm-1
Figure 9: Sample C3H8 spectral region 929.627 to 930.55 cm-1
14
Therefore, in order to obtain a flat baseline, attempts were made to model the shape of the baseline (Figure 10). Initially, a spline was used to model the structures in the baseline. However, this method did not prove sucessful because there were at least two visible fringes (instrumental interference) and the overall shape of the baseline also had a component from the strength of the lines themselves.
In Figure 10a, the gas plus cell data is shown in white near the ๐21 band. The gas plus cell data was smoothed in an attempt to manually subtract the overall baseline shape, shown in red. After attempting this method, a manual fit of the fringes was then attempted, shown in Figure 10b. This also did not prove sucessful because there were two fringes or possibly more present that could not be modeled easily. A sine wave function was used to model the underlying fringe (shown in red):
๐ผ = ๐ด ๐ ๐๐(๐1๐ + ๐1) ๐ ๐๐(๐2๐ + ๐2)
(a)
(b)
Figure 10: (a) First baseline subtraction technique โ smoothing. (b) Second baseline subtraction technique โ modeling the fringe patterns. In an attempt to model and then subtract them, another fringe pattern appeared. In both images: white โ original spectrum, red โ one modeled fringe
15
After these attempts were made, it was found that regions (~.25 cm-1 or smaller) showed to have very little variance in baseline. Therefore, .25 cm-1 regions were fitted sequentially.
Then, the spectral region around the 922 cm-1 band was inspected. Selected regions that did not have strong spectral lines, and therefore presumably dominated by noise, were used to estimate the noise level. The noise level was determined by the standard deviation (assuming Gaussian noise):
๐ = ๏ฟฝโ (๐ฅ๐ โ ๐ฅ0)2๐๐ท๐=1๐๐ท โ 1
2.3 Line Modeling
As an initial test of the fitting procedures, allene (CH2CCH2) was fit in a region of known spectroscopic parameters from 1002.4 to 1002.8 cm-1 (๐9 999 cm-1). Figure 11 shows the comparison between previously published results10 and initial guesses for the allene lines generated by an automated algorithm which was based on the first order differential of the spectra.
(a)
(b)
Figure 11: (a) Figure from VPL Molecular Spectroscopic Database15
of allene (C3H4) (b) Testing my peakโfinding technique using allene. The dotted lines refer to initial guesses of the peaks of individual allene lines. The solid lines are actual data.
In our initial fitting we approximated the shape of the spectral lines with a Gaussian line shape:
๐ผ๐ผ0
= ๐โ(๐โ๐0)2
๐ฟ๐2
where ๐ผ = intensity, ๐ผ0 = amplitude, ๐ = frequency, ๐0 = linecenter, and ๐ฟ๐ = half-width. The example region shown in Figure 9 spans the 929.627 to 930.55 cm-1 interval and contains ๐๐ท = 208 data points.
16
Each spectral line is assigned two parameters which characterize the line shape: transition frequency (๐0๐) and amplitude {๐ผ0๐} for the ๐๐กโ line. The half-width, ๐ฟ๐, is assumed to be common for all lines. The automated line guessing program identifies lines deeper than 3s (where s is the noise level) and reports the center frequency and amplitude for each. For the spectral range in Figure 12a, the algorithm found
๐๐ฟ = 26 spectral lines. Manual inspection shows ~23 are acceptable. Figure 12c shows the guesses without the manual rejections.
(a)
(c)
(b)
Figure 12: (a) Plot of linecenters and amplitude guesses for region: 929.627 to 930.55 cm-1. (b) Gaussian multi-line fit for region: 929.627 to 930.55 cm-1. Top has initial guesses with data points. Bottom shows the LMM Gaussian fit with data points and residuals below. (c) Table of fit results.
17
These guesses were fed as initial values to a non-linear parameter optimization program to determine solutions for the set of line shape parameters: half-width, intensity, and an offset correction. This algorithm is based on the Levenberg-Marquardt method (LMM) for parameter optimization (see Appendix B) and is implemented in an IDL code called curvefit. As a part of this analysis we developed IDL based codes for parsing of the data, initial guess generation, and interfacing to the standard routines.
2.4 Results
Fitting of large regions, several wavenumbers or more, resulted in a poor fit. Thus, it was found by trial-and-error that smaller sections on the scale of a quarter of a wavenumber should be fit in a larger pipeline procedure to make the fitting process accurate and more efficient. Figure 13 shows a large region of the ๐21 band modeled. For the region, 925.0 to 932.2 cm-1, the fitting program was able to mimic the shape of the baseline. Towards 925.0 cm-1, the lines become deeper because this is part of the R branch of the 922 cm-1 band. Although the baseline is fixed (the offset ๐๐ is constrained), the strength of the lines create the cascading shape. However, smaller sections were not fit properly as shown in the residuals below the fit region.
Figure 13: Gaussian fit for region: 925.0 to 932.2 cm-1. The 929.627 to 930.55 cm-1 region (Figure 9) is a subsection of this larger region. The subsection was not being fitted in the larger region. Therefore, it was fitted for a smaller range. The smaller the range, the more acceptable the fit.
18
From the converged solutions to the Gaussian fit, the line amplitudes can be used to determine the line strengths (๐). Transmittance due to the gas is given by
๐๐ = ๐โ๐๐
and ๐๐ is the optical depth: ๐๐ = ๐ ๐๐ฅ๐ง
where ๐ = opacity (cm2/g), ๐ = density (g/cm3), ๐ฅ๐ง = path length (cm). ๐ ๐ can be approximated using ๐๐, where ๐ = line intensity (cm-1 atm-1) and ๐ = pressure (atm). For an optically thin line, the calibrated
intensity of the ๐๐กโ line is given by
๐๐ =๐ผ0๐๐๐ฅ๐ง
and the line intensities can be found. These can be used to model the emission of chemical species from each layer in an atmosphere.
Therefore, an IDL pipeline of procedures were made to make initial line lists for the ๐21 and ๐20 bands. It converted amplitudes to calibrated intensities and made an initial line list in the GEISA 2009 and HITRAN 2008 formats.
3. Radiative Transfer Modeling of Titanโs Atmosphere
3.1 Sample Calculations
The radiative transfer code (CoDAT) used in this analysis is based on the formal solution to the Schwarzschild Equation discussed in the section 1.5 Radiative Transfer and is from the members of HIPWAC16. For the purposes of understanding the radiation transport in Titan, I assumed a representative Titan thermal profile (Figure 1) including the troposphere through the stratosphere. Two gases were used in this code: ethane and ethylene. The surface temperature was set to ~93 K. The line atlas that was used as the source for the molecular parameters was HITRAN 200817
Figure 14 shows a small portion of the simulated Titan spectrum with ethane (one line). It is using an un-altered Titan thermal profile and un-altered abundances for the hydrocarbons. The sample calculations in this section were performed in order to understand how changing the thermal profile and abundances of hydrocarbons present in the atmosphere affects the resultant spectra.
.
19
Figure 14: Spectrum using representative Titan thermal and abundance profiles
When setting the thermal profile as isothermal in the stratosphere of Titanโs atmosphere to 80 K, one will see an absorption spectrum. This is because the temperature of the surface (93 K) is higher than the stratosphere (Figure 15a). Kirchoffโs laws tell us that a source viewed through a cool gas will produce an absorption spectrum. The stratosphere acts as this cool gas. When the stratospheric temperature exceeds the surface temperature one will see an emission spectrum, as when the thermal profile is isothermal at 110K in the stratosphere. Not much change occurs when the thermal profile is altered in the lower troposphere because the temperatures are too cold and the vapor pressure is too low (Figure 15b). C2H4 and C2H6 condense out and rain to the surface. However, one will notice that the wings of the lines grow when the tropospheric temperature is increased. This is due to the tropospheric temperatures reaching sufficient values to appear in emission, and these regions being dominated by collisions that broaden the line shape more than at higher altitudes (which have lower pressures). I judiciously selected the abundance so that the lines are barely saturating in the isotherm region. Figure 16 demonstrates the effect of increasing the isotherm temperature: the brightness increases with temperature, and the brightness temperature of the line matches the isotherm temperature.
20
(a)
(c)
(b)
Figure 15: (a) Plot of thermal profile altered isothermally for 80K in the stratosphere. (b) Plot of thermal profile altered isothermally for 110K in the stratosphere. (c) Resultant spectrum after altering the thermal profiles isothermally. Red line = 80K Isotherm. Blue line = 110K Isotherm. Assuming surface temperature of 93 K.
21
(a)
(c)
(b)
(d)
Figure 16: Plots (a)-(c) Thermal profiles altered isothermally for 140, 170, and 200K in the stratosphere. (d) Resultant spectrum after altering the thermal profiles isothermally. Red line = 140K Isotherm. Green line = 170K Isotherm. Blue line = 200K Isotherm.
22
In addition to altering the thermal profile, one can alter the abundances of molecules in the atmosphere. Figure 17a shows the result of changing the abundance of ethane to .1, 1 and 10 times the original abundance. The wings of the line as well as the amplitude grow with increased abundance. In Titanโs atmosphere, these hydrocarbons would exist mainly in the stratosphere, as they freeze out in the troposphere. This change in abundance simulates what could happen in a change of seasons when certain portions of Titan receives different amounts of sunlight, resulting in the destruction or production of a certain species.
In Figure 17b more lines were added to the spectrum to simulate a more realistic Titan atmosphere. Just as in the single-line example, the wings and amplitude of the lines increased with increased abundance. Note the saturation that occurs in the strong line at 851.5 cm-1, while the weaker lines remain optically thin and therefore their amplitude continues to increase with increasing abundance.
Figure 17a: Plot of varying abundances of ethane in the model Titan atmosphere. As the abundance increases, the lines widen and the wings grow. (red = .1x original abundance, green = 1x, blue = 10x)
23
Figure 17b: Plot of varying abundances of ethane in the model Titan atmosphere. As the abundance increases, the lines widen and the wings grow. This plot would be equivalent to figure 15, but this plot shows more than one line to further illustrate the growth of the wings.
4. Summary/Conclusion
The purpose of this project was to study Titanโs atmosphere, the propane molecule, and atmospheric radiative transfer to understand the analysis of laboratory propane spectra with the application of radiative transfer modeling of a simulated Titan atmosphere. This was achieved by researching how Titanโs atmosphere behaves, the basics of vibrations and rotations of simple molecules, and the theory behind radiative transfer. It was also achieved by analyzing propane spectra over a number of years through fitting individual propane lines in certain bands. Then, understanding and altering a model of Titanโs atmosphere brought all the knowledge gained full circle.
24
For future work, we could use the calculated intensities to model propane spectra of Titan from Cassini/CIRS. Also, the Gaussian approximations for the individual lines could be replaced by Voigt lineshapes. This will take into account Doppler and pressure broadening of lines (derived from temperature and pressure measurements from the observing conditions).
This project is just the beginning of creating line atlases for the C3H8 bands. The ๐8, 869 cm-1; ๐20, 1054 cm-1; and ๐7, 1157 cmโ1 bands of C3H8 still need to be analyzed. The atlases will be needed to subtract the C3H8 signal from the infrared spectrum of Titan from CIRS. Subtracting the ๐21 band may result in the detection of propylene (C3H6) at 912 cm-1. Ultimately, these line atlases will be used to search for more chemical species in Titanโs stratosphere. Then, we will analyze other molecular species for the same goal, e.g. allene.
In addition, more radiative transfer modeling using the propane line lists along with other hydrocarbons present in Titanโs atmosphere may lead to a better understanding of the dynamics as well as constituents in Titanโs atmosphere.
25
Appendix A
Figure 18: Table of propane spectra taken at KPNO from 1983-1989
26
Appendix B
The Levenberg-Marquardt Method (LMM) is a standard technique used in fitting non-linear models. Its purpose is to minimize a statistic, chi-squared, which estimates the deviation of the model from the data and find a solution for the model parameters. It should be noted that the LMM finds only a local minimum not a global minimum.18
In the LMM, the degree of the model fit is characterized by Chi squared
๐2 = ๏ฟฝ(๐ท๐ โ ๐๐)2
๐๐2
๐๐ท
๐=1
where ๐ท๐, ๐๐, ๐๐, are the data, model, and error values, respectively, for the ๐๐กโ element. The spectral model for the lines is a function of the set of parameters {๐๐}: ๐บ๐ (๐๐) = ๐บ๐ ({๐๐}, ๐๐) In the LMM, the
parameter values are iteratively changed to search for a minimum in ๐2. In our case, the model consists of a complement of Gaussian functions that represent these spectral lines. The bandshape is represented by the contribution of this set of lines and is given by
๐๐ = ๐๐ โ๏ฟฝ|๐ผ0๐|๐โ(๐โ๐0๐)2
๐ฟ๐2
๐๐ฟ
๐=1
The vector of parameters (๐๐ , ๐ฟ๐,{๐0๐}, {๐ผ0๐}) has 2๐๐ฟ+2 elements, where 2๐๐ฟ refers to the parameters {๐0๐}, {๐ผ0๐} characterizing each of ๐๐ฟ spectral lines and the +2 refers to the offset correction term (๐๐) and half-width (๐ฟ๐) which is common to all lines. For the example in Figure 6, the total number of derived parameters is 54 (2๐๐ฟ + 2 = 2(26) + 2). The number of data points per line is ~8 (๐๐ท/๐๐ฟ = 208/26).
27
References 1 McKay, Christopher. "Titan: Greenhouse and Anti-greenhouse, Talk by Chris McKay, Part III."Astrobiology Magazine -- The Origin and Evolution of Life in the Universe. 03 Nov. 2005. Web. 25 May 2011. <http://www.astrobio.net/index.php?option=com_retrospection>.
2 McKay, C., J. Pollack, and R. Courtin. "The Greenhouse and Antigreenhouse Effects on Titan."Science 253.5024 (1991): 1118-121. Print.
3 Coustenis, A. et al. "Titan Trace Gaseous Composition from CIRS at the End of the CassiniโHuygens Prime Mission." Icarus 207, 461-76 (2010).
4 "Titan Exobiology Page." Mark's Webpage. Web. 18 Mar. 2011. <http://www.markelowitz.com/titan.htm>.
5 Coustenis, A. et al. โModeling Titan's thermal infrared spectrum for high-resolution space observations.โ Icarus 102, 240-260 (1993).
6 "Water (H2O)." Virtual Planetary Laboratory. Web. 25 May 2011. <http://vpl.astro.washington.edu/spectra/h2o.htm>.
7 Chaplin, Martin. "Water Absorption Spectrum." Water Structure and Science. 14 Mar. 2011. Web. 25 May 2011. <http://www.btinternet.com/~martin.chaplin/vibrat.html>.
8 "Section 3.1: Conformations of Straight-chain Organic Molecules." UC Davis Chem Wiki. UD Davis. Web. 4 Mar. 2011. <http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/Organic_Chemistry/Organic_Chemistry_With_a_Biological_Emphasis/Chapter__3%3A_Conformations_and_Stereochemistry/Section_3.1%3A_Conformations_of_straight-chain_organic_molecules>.
9 "Propane (C3H8)." Virtual Planetary Laboratory. Web. 05 Mar. 2011. <http://vpl.astro.washington.edu/spectra/c3h8.htm>.
10 "Chapter 15 Infrared Spectroscopy: Theory." Online Edition for Students of Organic Chemistry Lab Courses at the University of Colorado, Boulder, Dept of Chem and Biochem. University of Colorado, Boulder, Dept of Chem and Biochem., 2002. Web. 24 May 2011. <http://orgchem.colorado.edu/hndbksupport/irtutor/IRtheory.pdf>.
11 "Alkanes." Welcome to the Chemical Education Digital Library. Web. 04 Mar. 2011. <http://www2.chemeddl.org/services/chempaths/book/General Chemistry Textbook/Properties of Organic Compounds and Other Covalent Substances/1357/a>.
12 Hanel, R. A., B. J. Conrath, D. E. Jennings, and R. E. Samuelson. Exploration of the Solar System by Infrared Remote Sensing. Cambridge [England]: Cambridge UP, 1992. Print.
13 "Schwarzschild's Equation." Barrett Bellamy Climate. Web. 05 Feb. 2011. <http://www.barrettbellamyclimate.com/page45.htm>.
14 Jennings, D.E., et al. 0.0025 cm-1 Resolution With The Kitt Peak Fourier Transform Spectrometer. (1984).
15 Wang, W.F., Sirota, J.M., and Reuter, D.C. Allene ฮฝ9 and ฮฝ10: Low-Temperature Measurements of Line Intensity. J. Mol. Spec. 194:256-268 (1999). Virtual Planetary Laboratory. Web. 05 Feb. 2011. <http://vpl.astro.washington.edu/spectra/ch2cch2.htm>.
28
16 "Heterodyne Instrument for Planetary Wind And Composition (HIPWAC)."Missions/Projects - Sciences and Exploration Directorate - 600. Web. 27 Mar. 2011. <http://sciences.gsfc.nasa.gov/sed/index.cfm?fuseaction=projects.view&project_id=318>.
17 Rothman, L.S., I.E. Gordon, A. Barbe, D.Chris Benner, P.F. Bernath, M. Birk, V. Boudon, L.R. Brown, A. Campargue, and J.-P. Champion. "The HITRAN 2008 Molecular Spectroscopic Database." Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer 110.9-10, 533-72 (2009).
18 Press, William H. Numerical Recipes in C: the Art of Scientific Computing. 2nd ed. Cambridge [Cambridgeshire: Cambridge UP, 1992. Print.