8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
1/30
Presented By:Dilip Kumar
(09PG432)
An Analysis of Financial Statement andAn Analysis of Financial Statement and
Working Capital Structure of KIOCL LtdWorking Capital Structure of KIOCL Ltd
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
2/30
OBJECTIVEOBJECTIVE
To gain insights of the organizational structure and operations ofKIOCL Ltd.
To apply the accounting and analytical skills learned in previous termsand use those skills in a work environment.
To analyze, interpret and evaluate financial statements and workingcapital structure ofthe company.
To understand how analytical tools help management make decisions.
To identify major changes or turning points in trends, amounts andrelationships by focussing on data provided in external reports plussupplementary information provided by the management.
To provide information that can be useful to various stakeholders in
making various lending and investing decisions.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
3/30
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
4/30
INDUSTRY PROFILEINDUSTRY PROFILE
Iron-Ore and Steel Industry
Highly volatile
Market Condition in late 2008-09 Bankruptcy ofnumber ofGlobal Steel Producers
Recovery since July, 2009-10
Modest growth expected
More pronounced recovery in 2011
4% rise shown for Iron-ore and Steel Industry
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
5/30
MAJOR PLAYERSMAJOR PLAYERS
Major players in Iron-ore Industry:
Tata Metaliks
Essar Steel Limited
Kirloskar Ferrous Industries Limited
KIOCL Limited
JSW Steel Hy-Grade Pellets Limited
Sesa Goa Limited
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
6/30
COMPANY PROFILECOMPANY PROFILE
KIOCL Limited, a wholly owned Government of India
Enterprise, was established in 1976.
Countrys prestigious 100% export oriented unit and Mini
Rathna Company
M
issio
n &Visio
n Statem
ent To Strive to be an efficient organization, committed to customer and
stakeholders satisfaction.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
7/30
PRODUCT PROFILEPRODUCT PROFILEUnit BFU Mangalore
Major Products Product: Hot Metal-Pig Iron
Byproduct: Auxilliary & Slag
Product: Iron ore pellets & Pellet
fines
Competitors Tata Metaliks, Kirloskar and
Sesagoa.
Essar Steel, JSW Steel and Hy-grade
pellets Limited.
Market Share The production of Pig Iron and
auxiliaries was 0.118 Million MT
which represents 2.23% of the total
production in the country. The market
share of the product is around 10% of
the total market in India.
The capacity of the pellet plant at
mangalore (3.5 million tonnes)
represents 22.58 and 1.04 percent of
the total production capacity of pellets
in India (15.50 MT) and the world
(336.62 MT) respectively. The market
share of export of pellets of the
company in terms of overall export in
the world market worked out to 1.17%
during 2007.
Projects under Execution Ductile Iron Spun Pipe Project and
Pig Iron Casting Machine.
Railway siding project and
Horizontal pressure filters.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
8/30
SWOT ANALYSISSWOT ANALYSIS
y STRENGTH Strong brand image world wide. Expertise in handling hematite ore through wet
grinding system at Pellet Plant.
100% EOU status.
Shore based Pellet Plant with captive berth, with automatic ship loading system.
Expertise in Mining, Beneficiation & Pelletisation.
A Mini Blast Furnace facility, a lone PSU unit which produces foundry grade Pig Iron.
Captive Power Plant.
SkilledManpower.
The company has high cash reserve ofaround Rs.1200 crores.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
9/30
SWOT ANALYSIS..SWOT ANALYSIS..
y WEAKNESS
NoCaptive Iron Ore mine.
Lower value addition due to bought out ore and higher cost oflogistics.
Non-availability ofrequired quantity ofIron ore.This restricts
Company from entering into long term sales contracts with assured
quality.
Applied Mining Leases are under litigation.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
10/30
SWOT ANALYSIS..SWOT ANALYSIS..
y OPPORTUNITY
Utilization ofMechanical Ship Loading System.
Expansion ofmining activities with available core competence.
Value addition namely producing Ductile Iron Spun pipes at BF Unit.
Venturing into new business areas namely - Coke Oven Plant, SettingupofIntegrated Steel Plant.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
11/30
SWOT ANALYSIS..SWOT ANALYSIS..
y THREAT
Global Economic crisis.
Delay in getting new mining leases.
Infrastructure Dependence on Railways for allotment ofrakes for
movement ofraw material.
Sourcing ofwater from Lakya Dam.
Delay in withdrawing from Kudremukh in view ofSupreme Court order.
Migration oftrained manpower.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
12/30
QUANTITATIVE ANALYSISQUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS
Various Quantitative Analysis techniques and tools used;
y Trend Analysis
y
Key Ratios Analysisy Comparative Analysis with Industry
y Inter-firmComparative Analysis
y Cash flow Analysis
y Pro-forma statement Analysis
y Working Capital- Operating Cycley Working Capital- Cash Management
y Working Capital- Receivables and Payables Management
y Working Capital- Inventory Management
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
13/30
Trend AnalysisTrend Analysis-- Balance SheetBalance Sheet
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
250%
300%
350%
400%
Mar' 09 Mar' 09 Mar' 08 Mar' 08
INDUSTRY KIOCL Ltd. INDUSTRY KIOCL Ltd.
136%
100%
206%
100%
342%
103%
397%
102%54%
185%
105%
200%201%
75%
241%
75%91%
29%
151%
34%
334%
95%
350%
93%
ShareCapitalReserves and Surplus
Net Fixed Assets
Total Current Assets
Total Current Liabilities
Net Working Capital
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
14/30
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
15/30
Trend AnalysisTrend Analysis-- Income StatementIncome Statement
-100%
0%
100%
200%
300%
400%
500%
600%
700%
800%
Mar' 09 Mar' 09 Mar' 08 Mar' 08
INDUSTRY KIOCL Ltd. INDUSTRY KIOCL Ltd.
117%
494%
149%
602%
352%
112%
417%
118%125%
544%
13
7%
548%
134%
381%
148%
381%
-15%
160%
244%
785%
Net SalesOther Income
Consumption ofRM
Total Expenditure
Profit afterTax
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
16/30
FINDINGSFINDINGS
y There is significant fluctuation in the net sales figure ofthe companyfrom 2008 to 2009. Whereas, for the company the sales trend wasbetter than KIOCL.
y Compared to the Industry standard, the expenditure ofthe companywas very high in 2008 and 2009.
y The company has increased its production capacity and introduced pigiron production. So as to run new and old plants, the consumption hasincreased, which caused increased in expenditure.
y Profit after tax improved in 2008 after low performance in 2007, butdue to worldwide recession in 2009, the sales and hence the profit wasstruck hard.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
17/30
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
10.00
12.00
14.00
16.00
18.00
iquid atio InventoryTurnover
atio
Debt- quityatio
Operatingprofit
margin
eturn onInvestment
8.64
2.33
0.00 0.020.01
7.30
5.27
0.000.11
0.070.61
7.28
16.5
1.290.42
7.17
2.47
0
2.071.21
KIOCLLtd.Mar' 09
KIOCLLtd.Mar' 08
INDUST Y AV AG Mar' 09
INDUST Y AV AG Mar' 08
COMPARISON WITH INDUSTRY AVERAGECOMPARISON WITH INDUSTRY AVERAGE
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
18/30
FINDINGSFINDINGS
y The increase in current ratioofthe company in 2008-09 shows that the firmis having very high margin ofsafety for creditors and it can ably meet itsobligations.
y Inventory turnover have been affected twice in last three years.
y The company is 100% debt free.There is nooutstanding long-term debt inlast three years (2007-09).This shows strength in owners equity to run thebusiness.
y The company is highly liquid in nature and there is no sign ofgettinginsolvent in near future.
y The operating profit margin has declined for both industry and thecompany. During 2008 & 2009, the demand for iron and steel products
were severely hit due to recession.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
19/30
ANALYSIS OF CASH FLOW STATEMENTANALYSIS OF CASH FLOW STATEMENT
y Cashflow from Operating activities
In 2006: Rs 2,783,702 Lakh, in 2007: Rs. (1,431,933) Lakh, in 2008: Rs(655, 921) Lakh, in 2009: Rs (1,854,378) Lakh.
In 2007, there was switchover from captive mines at Kudremukh to 100%
hematite ore sourced fromNMDC and others.
In 2008, the company realized highest ever sales price ofUS $245per MTofpellets and Rs. 33000 per tonne ofpig iron.
In 2009, the worldwide recession set in.The customers in China, Japan andSouth Korea requested cut in their demand for Pellets and Pig iron.Also, prices reached to rock bottom US $54per MTofPellets.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
20/30
ANALYSIS OF CASH FLOW STATEMENTANALYSIS OF CASH FLOW STATEMENT
y Cash Inflows
In 2006, the operating activities generated 71.89%ofneeded cash.
Later it made no contribution to the inflow ofcash.
In the following years, the company was dependent on the interest
received from Long term investment (acquisition and disposal oflong
term assets).
In the period (2006-08), the company saw merger ofKISCO withKIOCL.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
21/30
ANALYSIS OF CASH FLOW STATEMENTANALYSIS OF CASH FLOW STATEMENT
y Cash Outflows
The major contributor to cash outflow has been operating expenses
i.e., 60.80% in 2007, 48.67% in 2008, and 86.22% in 2009.
In 2008, the operating expenses were covered to some extent.
Here, the company used 42.41%ofits reserves and surplus part of
shareholders fund to cover the increasing operating expenses.
Although, the situation is improving in 2010 with increase in
demand ofIron and Steel in global market, it will take couple of
years for the company to check its cash outflow and improve
operating activities.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
22/30
WORKING CAPITALWORKING CAPITAL-- OPERATING CYCLEOPERATING CYCLE
Year: 2009 Year: 2008
GROSSOPERATING CYCLE days days
1. Inventory Conversion Period
(i) Raw Material 158 50
(ii) Work-in-Process 20 19
(iii) Finished Goods 62 16
240 85
2. Debtors Conversion Period 3 36
3. Gross Operating Cycle (1+2) 243 121
4. Payment Deferral Period 59 72
NETOPERATING CYCLE (3-4) 184 49
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
23/30
WORKING CAPITALWORKING CAPITAL-- SCHEDULE OF CHANGESSCHEDULE OF CHANGES
Particulars Amount Changes in Working
Capital(in lacs)
2009 2008 Increase Decrease
(Debit) (Credit)
Current Assets
Inventories 64,703.96 34,655.50 30,048.46 -
Sundry Debtors 813.23 14,102.61 - 13,289.38
Cash and Bank balances 119,986.61 127,841.88 - 7,855.27
Loans and Advances 11,13
9.56 21,752
.01 10,612
.45
Current Liabilities 22,772.86 27,167.70 4,394.84
Working capital (CA-CL) 173,870.50 171,184.30
Increase in Working Capital 2,686.20
34,443.30 34,443.30
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
24/30
WORKING CAPITALWORKING CAPITAL-- CASH MANAGEMENTCASH MANAGEMENT
y
Size ofcash
y Size ofsales
y Control ofcash
Year Cash (In Lakhs) Trend
2007 129889.8
3100%
2008 127841.88 98%
2009 119986.61 92%
Year Sales (in Lakhs) Trend
2006 117,978.31 100%
200723,460.63
20%
2008
141,310.52
120%
2009
115,956.93
98%
Year Cash to CARatio
2007 0.49
2008 0.64
2009 0.61
Year Cash Turnover
ratio
2007 0.17
2008 1.09
2009 0.9
3
Year Cash to CL ratio
2007 1.63
2008 4.71
2009 5.27
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
25/30
WORKING CAPITALWORKING CAPITAL-- INVENTORY MANAGEMENTINVENTORY MANAGEMENT
y Composition ofInventory
y InventoryTurnover
Year Raw
Material(%)
Finished
Goods(%)
Stores Spares &
consumables,
additives(%)
Total(%)
2007 53% 8% 39% 100%
2008 43% 19% 38% 100%
2009 55% 27% 18% 100%
Average 52% 22% 26% 100%
Year Ratio In days
2007 1.30 276
2008 5.27 68
2009 2.33 154
Average 166days
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
26/30
WORKING CAPITALWORKING CAPITAL-- RECEIVABLES & PAYABLESRECEIVABLES & PAYABLES
MANAGEMENTMANAGEMENT
y Receivables management
y Payables management
Year Debtors
Turnover
Ratio
Average
collection
period (in
days)
2007 162.67 2
2008 20.04 18
2009 15.55 23
Year Creditors Turnover
Rati
o
Average Payment
Peri
od(in
days)
2007 3.46 103.94
2008 11.62 30.98
2009 6.73 53.50
Average 7.27 49.52
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
27/30
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
28/30
RECOMMENDATIONS & CONCLUSIONRECOMMENDATIONS & CONCLUSION
yThe most worrying factor for the company is the cash flow fromoperatingactivities. It needs to consider following points and improve its operatingactivities;
Instead ofgenerating cash fromoperations, the company is generating cash fromother sources like receivables, sale ofscraps.
Manage its inventory in such a way that there is minimum raw material holdingperiod and high inventory turnover.
There should be balance in composition ofthe inventories.
Sudden fluctuation in receivables and payables ofcredit should be checked.
The company should consider taking power supply fromother trusted economicsource instead ofits captive one, at least for another 2 years.This will cut lot ofundesirable operating costs.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
29/30
RECOMMENDATIONS & CONCLUSIONRECOMMENDATIONS & CONCLUSION
y Seeing intopast and comparing present ROI, it can be said that thecompany has the potential to bounce back.
y But due to certain circumstances like closure ofcaptive mines,shifting ofcaptive plant and restructuring process ofoperations, its
whole structure has transformed.
y This period is the new beginning. It has cash reserve, is in control ofcredits.
y The need is to work optimistically towards improving sales and earnmore prospective customers.
8/6/2019 An Analysis of Financial Statement and Working Capital
30/30