Upload
thavam
View
215
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 1/10
You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer
Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own
– Sumanthiran
02/11/20
14 -[HON. M. A. SUMANTHIRAN – SPEECH ON SECOND READING OF BUDGET
DEBATE 28TH OCTOBER 2014]
Tha! "#$% H#. P&'()*)+ M','&% #& h' ##&$)" +)' # ('a! a h' S'#* R'a*)+
# h' B$*+' h)( "'a&. A( I ha' *#' ) a33 # h' S'#* R'a*)+ D'a'( ()' 2010
)3$*)+ h' #' # A#$ # ha "'a&% I 5)(h # #,,'' 5)h a a&)$3a& O('&a)#.Th)( "'a& I ha' ($#& #& ha #('&a)# &#, a F&#'h'& &#, h' G#'&,' &a!(%
h' H#. 6'.7 Ah$&a3)"' Rahaa Th'&#. $( a'& h' B$*+' S''h " h' H#. M))('& # F)a'% h' ''&a3' Th'&# 5a( a(!'* " h' &'(( a#$ h)( #,,'( # h' B$*+'
P&##(a3( a* h)( &'(#(' 5a(% 9:' h#' '; "'a& h' B$*+' 5)33 ' &'(''* " a M','&
# h' H#$('<. N#5% h)( )( (#,'h)+ ha I ha' (a)* #& #$& "'a&(= ha ) Pa&3)a,' )( #
';'&)(' #a3 # #'& $3) )a' a( ,a*a'* " A&)3' 148 # h' C#()$)# – h'H#. 6'.7 Ah$&a3)"' Rahaa Th'&# 5a( a3(# 3'a('* # ,')# ha A&)3' ) h)( #,,'
– h'% ) )( ''((a&" ha h' M))('& # F)a' )( a M','& # h)( H#$('. :' ha' h' (a*
('a3' "' a+a) h)( "'a& # h' D'a' #)$)+ 5)h#$ h' M))('& 5h# &##('* )
')+ ) h' H#$(' a( a M','& # h)( H#$(' a#$a3' a* &'(#()3' # &'(#* #
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 2/10
(''&a3 )a3 #,,'( ha a&' ')+ ,a*'. I ## 5)(h% 3)!' h' G#'&,' F&#'h'&% hah)( 5)33 ' &','*)'* a 3'a( " '; "'a&.
T## +##* # ' &$'
A( 5' 5a3!'* a5a" &#, h' Cha,'& ha '')+ )# h' T'a Pa&"% a '&" (')#&
G#'&,' #))a3 5a( h'a&* # &',a&!% 9Th' #3" h)+ ha h' O#())# a (a" a#$
h)( B$*+' )( ha ) )( ## +##* # ' &$'<. I h#$+h ha 5a( 5'33 (a)*. :ha h' (a)* )( &$'. I
5a # &''a ha> 9Th)( )( ## +##* # ' &$'<. I a% h)( )( a +&a' &a$* # h' '#3' #h)( #$&". Th)( a# ' &$'. :' ha' ''& ('' a B$*+' 3)!' h)(. :' ha' ''& (''
&##(a3( ha ha' '' ,a*' (# )&&'(#()3" 5)h h' '"' #3" # h)( &'-'3')#. Th)( #$+h
# # ' *#'. I h)! h' H#. M))('& # Na)#a3 ?a+$a+'( a* S#)a3 I'+&a)#
a3a$*'* a 3)3' ## 'a&3" '#&' I #)$'*. H' ,)+h &'+&' h)( a3a$(' #5. Th)( )( a ,#(
)&&'(#()3' h)+ ha ha( '' *#'. I h' &')#$( "'a&(% h'&' 5'&' 3a,#$&( #& &'3)' #&
(''&a3 ('#&( 5h)h 5'&' &#,)('* $ # +)'. S#,' 5'&' &#,)('*= (#,' 5'&' #
&#,)('* a* '' h#(' ha 5'&' &#,)('*% ''& (a5 h' 3)+h # *a". A* "'% '' h&#$+h
h#(' "'a&( – 5' 3##!'* a h' a3a' # a#$ – 5' (a5 h#5 ,$h # h)( 5a( ')+ $*'*
&#, #&')+ #&)+(. A( 5' (a& h' D'a' # h' S'#* R'a*)+% 5' ha'% a3'*
'#&' $(% a A,'*,' # h' A&#&)a)# A # 201@ # )&'a(' h' #&)+ 3),) "R(. 200 )33)#. N#5% 5ha *#'( ha ,'a I ,'a( ha h' (!"- h)+h 3),) ha 5a( (' ''
a ha ),' ha* # '' '#$+h # ,'' h' ';'*)$&' #& 3a( "'a&. N#5% 5)h h)( B$*+'
P&##(a3% h#5 5)33 h' G#'&,' '' '+) # $* h' ';'*)$&' ha h'" ha' &##('*
h'" 5#$3* )$& #$ a# ,'&'3" ,a!' &##(a3( # +)' '#3' (#,' +##* ''3)+. Th'&'
)( (#,'h)+ a33'* 9#'&*#)+< a* ," ($())# )( ha h' H# M))('& # F)a' ha(
#'&*#' ) h)( ),'. H' ha( (# #'&*#' )% ha '' h' '&" #&*)a&" '#3' # h)( #$&"
*# # '3)'' )= h'" *# # '3)'' ). A"#' 5' ,'' # h' (&'' )( a(!)+ $( h' $'()#%
<
Th'" a&' a(#)(h'*. S#% "#$ a# ##3 a33 h' '#3' a33 h' ),'. Tha% 5' !#5. B$% ) h)(
)(a'% '' h&#$+h (5'''((% "#$ ha' # '' a3' # (a)(" h', 'a$(' h')&($())#( ha' ''% &)+h3"% a&#$('*. H#5 a h' G#'&,' ,'' h'(' ';'('( ha ha'
'' (# +''&#$(3" a* 3a)(h3" &##('* I 5#$3* # +# )# h' *'a)3(. S''&a3 M','&( #
h' O#())# ha' *'3'* )# *'a)3( a* (h#5 $ h'(' B$*+' P&##(a3( #& 5ha h'" a&'%
a( I (a)*% a &a$* # h' '#3'. I 5#$3* # +# )# ) a h)( (a+'. P'&ha( *$&)+ h'
C#,,)'' Sa+'% 5' 5)33 ha' a ##&$)" # +# )# h' *'a)3'* E(),a'( a* h' &'a3)"
a( ##('* # h' +3#&)#$( )$&' ha ha( '' a)'* " h'(' P&##(a3(.
A3" (a,' #' 3#+) # N#&h
T#*a"% I 5#$3* &ah'& +# )# (#,' # h' #3)" (a','( ha h' H#. M))('& # F)a'
,a*' 5h)3' &'(')+ h' B$*+'. Th' H#. M))('& 5a( 3'a('* # &''& # '&a) ''( )
h' &'' a(. H' (a)* ha h' 5a& 5a( #$+h (# ha a33 h' '#3'( # h)( #$&" 5)33 3)'
''& 3)'( a* h' a&#ah # h' G#'&,' ha( ''& ha* a #,,$a3 (3a # ). H'
$#'( h' &'($3( # h' h&'' P&#))a3 C#$)3 E3')#( h'3* h)( "'a& a( &## # h' a
ha h' G#'&,' ha( 3a&+' $3) ($#& #& h' *)&')# ha ) )( &a'33)+ ). Ma" I
'$&' # a(! h'% " h' (a,' #!'% 5ha 3'((# ha( h' 3'a& &#, h' &'($3( # h'
N#&h'& P&#))a3 C#$)3 E3')# h'3* 3a( "'a& :ha% ) a a33% ha( h' 3'a& I h' a!'(%
a( h' 3a),(% 4 '& ' # h' #' #& h' UPFA a( a #a3 '*#&(',' # h' '#3' #& h'
5#&! &#+&a,,' # h' G#'&,'% h#5 *#'( h' &'a* 3'(( ha 20 '& ' # #'( h' UPFA
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 3/10
&'')'* ) h' N#&h'& P&#)' H#5 *#'( h' &'a* 8. '& ' # h' #' ha h' TNA&'')'* ) h' N#&h'& P&#))a3 C#$)3 E3')# A*% ) h' 5a& 5a( #$+h% a( h' 3a),(%
# *'3)'& h' Ta,)3 '#3' &#, h' 3$h'( # '&&#&)(,% 5ha ha' h#(' Ta,)3 '#3' #3*
h), ) S'','& # 201@ Th' H#. M))('& 5h# &'3)'( (# h'a)3" # ha #' # ,a!' a
#) a#$ h' ($#& h' ha(% ))+ a ,'&' 4 '& '% a# ('' ha 3'(( ha 20 '& '
#'* #& h)( a&" a* a3,#( 80 '& ' #& h' TNA ) h' N#&h'& P&#)'% 5h'&' h' 5a&
5a( #$+h. I a, 3)!)+ h'(' 5# # a(! h' H#. M))('& # F)a' h' $'()#% h#5 ha'"#$ #&,$3a'* h)( #3)" H#5 ha' "#$ #,' # h)( #3$()# # "#$&( ha h' '#3' )
h' N#&h'& P&#)'% 5h'&' h' 5a& 5a( #$+h% a&' a33 *$3" (a)()'* 5)h "#$& *''3#,'
&#'( a* a&' '&" ha" ha h'&' )( # )+h)+ #5 :'33% '#3' a&' ha" ha h'&' )(
# )+h)+% I 5)33 #'*' ha. B$% ha )( # a33. I h' 5a& 5a( #$+h # a '* (# ha
'#3' 5)33 3)' 5)h *)+)" ,#&' ha a"h)+ '3('% 5)h *)+)"% 'a' a* &#('&)"% ha
ha( # ha''* a* ) ha )( # h' &$)a3 )33 ha a''* h)( #$&" a33 h'(' "'a&(% #&
(''&a3 *'a*'(% '&ha( ()' I*''*''% 5ha )( h' ', ha a)3( h)( #$&"
I( h)( h' (a,' Raaa!(a ('a!)+
I ha )(($' a# ' &'(#3'*% – ha )( a3(# a '##,) )(($'= 5' a3! a#$ h' @0- "'a&
5a&% h#5 ha ),a'* # h' '##,"% h#5 ha ),a'* # h' 3)'(% # #3" # h' '#3') h' 5a& #'% $ '' # h' '#3' 5h# 5'&' 3))+ #$()*'% – ) ha )( # a**&'(('*
&#'&3"% a h)( H#$(' a3a$* h' M))('& # F)a' #& (a")+ h)( *$&)+ h' #$&(' #
h)( B$*+' S''h H' ha( 3a),'* ha h' a# ('' h' &a)#a3' # *'#3' h' ($'( #
3a* a* #3)' #5'&( # )' ('a&a' P&#))a3 C#$)3(. N#5% ha )( a '5 #'. S$**'3"%
h' a# ('' h' &a)#a3' #& *'#3)+ 3a* a* #3)' #5'&( # )' &#))a3 #$)3(.
Th)( )( h' (a,' '&(# 5h#% ) Ma" a* $' 200% ,a*' #) Sa','( 5)h h' P&),'
M))('& # I*)a ha h' 5#$3* ),3',' h' Th)&''h A,'*,' ) $33% +# '"#* ) a*
,a!' *'#3$)# ,'a)+$3. H' ()+'* h#(' #) Sa','( a* ($('$'3"% h' H#.
M))('& # E;'&a3 Aa)&( ()+'* h' #) C#,,$)$' # h' h # $'% 2011% I '3)''%
5)h h' M))('& # E;'&a3 Aa)&( # I*)a # h' (a,' ''. N#5% a'& h' '* # h' 5a&%a'& h' #3$()# # h' )+h)+% (''&a3 ),'( h)( &#,)(' ha( '' +)'% # # $(. Th'
&#,)('( +)' # $( a&' 5#&h3'((% a&' # 5#&h –
[I'&&$)#.]
'(% "'(% # 5#&h a3!)+ a#$. Th' H#. ?#ha Ra5a' ($**'3" 5a3!( ) a* h' )(
a,a'* – 'a$(' h'" a&' 5)33"-)33" &'ah'*. B$% h'(' a&' &#,)('( +)' # a '&"
&)'*3" ')+h#$&)+ #$&"% # h' P&),' M))('& # ha #$&"% # h' S'&'a&"- G''&a3# h' U)'* Na)#( a* # h' )'&a)#a3 #,,$)" a 3a&+'. I )( '&" ('))% # $(
95' 5)33 (#3' )<. N#% h'" (a)*> 9:' 5)33 ),3',' h' Th)&''h A,'*,' ) $33 a*
$)3* # ) (# a( # ah)'' ,'a)+$3 *'#3$)#<. H#5 ,a" ),'( h)( 5a( (a)* I a, +3a*
ha h' H#. D'$" M))('& # E;'&a3 Aa)&( )( h'&'% 'a$(' h' M))(&" # E;'&a3
Aa)&( ha( h' &'#&* # a33 # h#(' &#,)('( a* h' #) C#,,$)$'( ha ha' ''
)(($'* &#, h')& M))(&". A ($**' 5)(*#, ha( *a5'* #5 # h' H#. M))('& # F)a'
# #,' )# h)( Cha,'& a* (a"% 9I a# ('' h' &a)#a3' # *'#3' h' ($'( # 3a*
a* #3)' #5'&( # )' ('a&a' P&#))a3 C#$)3(<. Th)( )( "' a#h'& )*)a#& ha '33(
h' '#3' # h)( #$&" 5ha a3$' h)( &#,)('( a&'. O #$&('% 5)h h)( B$*+'% h'"
('&)#$(3" ($(' ha #' # h'(' &#,)('( 5)33 ' !'. :h" ha( h' *#' h)( H' a3!'*
a#$ h' N#&h% a* a3(# a#$ h' 9a3 D')< # aa. B" h' 5a"% 5' 5'3#,' h' 9a3
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 4/10
D')< # aa. Tha ha( 'a&'* ,)33)#( # &$''( ) a #$3' # *a"( #& h' G#'&,'. I )(+##* #& h' G#'&,' a( ,$h a( ) )( +##* #& h' '#3'.
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'& – D'$" M))('& # E)&#,' a* R''5a3' E'&+"7I )( +##* #& h' '#3'.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7S#% 5h" *# "#$ # 3)(' # 5ha I (a" I $( (a)* ha ) )( +##* #& h' '#3'. –
[I'&&$)#.]
S#% I (a)* ) )( +##* #& h' '#3'. :h" *# "#$ # 3)(' )&( I *)* (a" ) )( +##* #& h'
'#3'. :' ,$( ha! h' G#'&,' # I*)a #& ,a!)+ h' )a' aa)3a3' #& ha &#'. :' *# # !#5 h' a&&a+','( #& )a' ha "#$ ha' ,a*' 5)h h' Ch)'('.
S#% I 5)33 # ha! h', #& "#$ #& ha ,a'&.
B$% 5ha ha( ha''* :)h h' #,)+ # 9a3 D')<% a '5 &'(&))# ha( '' ),#('*
# #&')+'&( &a'33)+ # h' N#&h. N#5% a"#' 5h# #,'( # h)( #$&" ha( # #a) 5#)(a(= a" #&')+'& 5h# )'*( +#)+ # h' N#&h ha( # #a) 5# )(a(% –
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7
Tha )( 5&#+. D# # (a" 95# )(a(<% ) )( a '&,). :' a# )(($' 5# )(a( # #& a"#*"
5h# #,'( )# h)( #$&".
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
– #' # #,' )# h)( #$&" a* a#h'& –
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7Tha )( 5ha P&aha!a&a *)*.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
#$ a&' *#)+ 5ha P&aha!a&a *)*. Tha )( ," #,3a). P'#3' ha' # #a) 5# )(a(%
#' # #,' )# h)( #$&" a* a#h'& # +# # h' N#&h% $( 3)!' 5ha P&aha!a&a *)*.
:h" a&' "#$ *#)+ 5ha P&aha!a&a *)* ) "#$ a&' #,3a))+ a#$ P&aha!a&a
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7
#$ ha('* M$(3), '#3' &#, h' N#&h.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
:' *)* # ha(' h',. –
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7
H#. S$,ah)&a% 3'a(' #)$' 5)h "#$& (''h.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
H#. P&'()*)+ M','&% –
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 5/10
[I'&&$)#.]:' ha' *'a3 5)h ha ),' a* a+a).
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7D# # (h#$ #5.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7:' !#5 5h" (#,' '#3' (h#$ a* 5ha ha''* # h' &)' a(' a* 5h" h'" ha' #
(h#$% 5h" h'" ha' # $, ) h' )&( 3a' a* 5h" h'" ha' # '&)#*)a33" +' $ a*
(h#$ a* 5h" a('( 5'&' 5)h*&a5= 5h" h' a('( # +&a' &a$* '*)+ ) h' H)+h C#$&
5'&' 5)h*&a5. –
[I'&&$)#.]
F#&% ) a '&" $*)+))'* ,a'& 5a3!)+ a&#(( h' a)(3' –
[I'&&$)#.]
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7
?' h' H#. M','& ('a!.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
S)&% 5' $*'&(a*. I a, # a3!)+ a#$ h),. –
[I'&&$)#.]
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7
P3'a(' 3' h' H#. M','& ('a!.
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7
H' a# $( )($3 ,'. I ha' # a(5'& h),.
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7
#$ a a(5'& 3a'&.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
I a $*'&(a* 5h" (#,' '#3' ha' # (h#$. :ha h' a,#$ # h' &a$* 5a(% ) 5h)h
#$& h' a(' 5a( '*)+ a* 5h' h'" &#(('* #'& 5ha ha''* # ha a('% a33 # ha
5' !#5. S#% 5' $*'&(a* 5h" h'" (h#$. B$% ha a# *)(&a ,' &#, 5ha I a,
(a")+ #5. –
[I'&&$)#.]
9:h" )( h' N#&h ')+ &'a'* a( a ('a&a' #$&"< )( h' $'()# ha I a, #()+. P'#3'
5h# #,' )# h)( #$&" a &''3" +' a#$ a"5h'&' '3(' $ # # h' N#&h. #$ ha'
# +' a (')a3 '&,) # +# # h' N#&h.
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 6/10
Tha )( –
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
N#% 5' a&' # a(!)+ "#$ #& ';3aa)#. N# ';3aa)# ha( '' +)'. I ha''* 5)h h'#,)+ # 9a3 D')<. :h" ha( ha '5 &'(&))# '' ),#('* I h' B$*+' S''h% h'&'
)( –
6A H#. M','&7
Th'&' a ' ?TTE'&( +#)+ # aa.
6Th' H#.M.A. S$,ah)&a7
:h'&' )( h' ?TTE I h#$+h "#$ *'(&#"'* h', $33".
6A H#. M','&7
A *)a(#&a.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7I ('' Th'&' )( a (a),#)#$( 3a), ) h)( B$*+' S''h ha h' E,'&+'" R'+$3a)#(
ha 5'&' ) #&' #& "'a&( 5'&' &',#'*= ha P$3) S'&)' h&#$+h#$ h' #$&" ha( ''
&'(#&'*= &'(( &''*#, )( '#$&a+'*= #*$ # &'+$3a& '3')#( ha' )3$*)+ h'
N#&h'& P&#))a3 C#$)3 a* h' #$&" ha( 5)'(('* a #a3' ),&#',' )
+#'&a'. E,'&+'" R'+$3a)#( 5'&' &',#'* # h' @0h # A$+$( 2011% $*'& )'('
)'&a)#a3 &'(($&' $ 5)h ha% h' '&" (a,' R'+$3a)#( 5'&' &#,$3+a'* a( PTA
R'+$3a)#(. :h#, a&' "#$ ##3)+
:h# &'')'* h' # 9E;')#a3 G&#$*(< &)#&)"
Th#(' '&" (a,' E,'&+'" R'+$3a)#( ha 5'&' ) #&'% H#. M))('&% 5'&' &#,$3+a'*a( PTA R'+$3a)#( h' '; *a". :h#, a&' "#$ ##3)+ A*% "#$ ha' h' &a(( # #,' a*
(a" ha E,'&+'" R'+$3a)#( 5'&' 3)'* a* h' #$&" )( a 'a'% $( *a"( a'&),#()+ a '5 &'(&))# $3a5$33"% ha "#$ ha' # #a) a (')a3 '&,) # &a'3 # h'
N#&h. I )( 5'33-!#5 ha (''&a3 h#$(a*( # h)3*&' a* #h'&(% 5h#(' a&'( a&' 3))+
) h' N#&h% ha' ,)+&a'* # a&)#$( #$&)'( a&#$* h' 5#&3*. Th'" a&' ))'( # #h'&
#$&)'( a* ha' '' $a3' # #a) *$a3 ))'(h) 'a$(' # "' a#h'& &'(&))#
a33'*% 9A ',#&a&" ($('()# # h' +&a # *$a3 ))'(h)<. I h' C#,,)'' # P$3)
A#$(% 5' #$* ha *$&)+ h' ',#&a&" ($('()# # h' +&a # *$a3 ))'(h)% ,#&'ha 1%@00 '#3' ha' '' +&a'* *$a3 ))'(h). Th'" (a)*% ) 5a( # 9E;')#a3
G&#$*(< (#% (#,' 5'&' +)'. B$% # ," !#53'*+' a* # h' !#53'*+' # ," C#33'a+$'(
h'&'% ##*" &#, h' N#&h #& h' Ea( ha( '' +)' *$a3 ))'(h) *$&)+ h)( ),'. S#%
a3)a)#( ,a*' " '#3' #& *$a3 ))'(h) a&' '*)+ 'a$(' h' G#'&,' )( #
+))+ h', *$a3 ))'(h) a( +)' # h' #h'&(. Th'" a# '' &''3" #,' a* +# #
,'' h')& a&'( #& a'* a 5'**)+ #& a#h'& '&',#" # h')& &#h'&(J #& h')& ()('&(J. –
[I'&&$)#.] 6Th' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a7 E' ) h'" 5'&' #& –
[I'&&$)#.] 6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7 &#('.
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 7/10
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 I 5)33 +)' 5a" # h' M))('&% h' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a. –
6Th' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a7 Th#(' 5h# 5'&' #& ) h)( #$&" 5#$3* # ha' ##a) –
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 Th' H#.A*$3 Ca*'& )( *)($&)+. I a# h'a& "#$% H#.M))('&. –
[I'&&$)#.] 6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7
H' )( +#)+ # &'a' a#h'& 5a&. Th'" a&' 3))+ ) 'a' #*a". –
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 I +a' 5a" # h' M))('&% h' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a% $I a# h'a& h),.
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7 H#. S$,ah)&a "#$ ,a" a&&" #.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 S)&% I +a' 5a" # h' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a # &'(#*% $ I #$3* # h'a& h),.
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7 O!a". H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a "#$ a ,a!' "#$& #).
6Th' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a7 H#. M','&% h#(' 5h# 5'&' #& ) h' #$&" ''* #
#a) '&,)(()# '' ) h'" a&' )())+ h'&' &#, a #&')+ #$&". I &'a* ha ) h'
'5(a'&(. I #3" (a)* ha.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 N#% a"#*" 5h# h#3*( a #&')+ ))'(h) ha( # #a)
(')a3 '&,)(()# # &a'3 # h' N#&h.
6Th' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a7 E' ) h'" 5'&' #& h'&'
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7
'(. Th'&' ,a" ' +&a*h)3*&' #& '3('5h'&'. I (#% 5ha *# "#$ 5a h', # *#
6Th' H#. ?#ha Ra5a'7 G' '&,)(()#.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 D# "#$ (a" ha h'" ''* # +' '&,)(()# # +# 5)h h')&
a&'( # ('' h')& +&a*a&'( H#. Ra5a' &#, 'h)* (a"(% 9G' '&,)(()#%< #!)3".
H' 3)'( ) Ka*". H' ha( # a). H' *#'( # ('(' –
[I'&&$)#.] 6Th' H#. ?#ha Ra5a'7 A&' "#$ a3!)+ a#$ h' Ta,)3 '#3' 5h# 3)' )
Ba,a3a))"a
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 H' *#'( # ('(' h' a'a)# # h' *)+)" # #$& '#3'.
:h' "#$ #,' # "#$& #5 #$&"% *# "#$ ha' # a!' (')a3 '&,)(()# # +# # "#$& #5
h#,'#5 O3" # +# # h' N#&h% "#$ ha' # +' (')a3 '&,)(()#. E' h'" ha'
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 8/10
a3)'* #& *$a3 ))'(h) $ ha )( !' '*)+% 'a$(' h'" a&' &#, #' a& # h'#$&". :ha )( h)( (a),#)#$( &'ah)+
6Th' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a7 Th'&' a&' a 3# # '#3' 5h# ha' a3)'* #& *$a3))'(h) $ h'" ha' # "' '' #()*'&'* 'a$(' ha #'&a)# ha( # "' '+$.
S')a3 a('( a&' a *)'&' ,a'&.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 #$ a&' a ,','& # h' C#,,)'' # P$3) A#$( –
6Th' H#. a($*'a Naa"a!!a&a7 I ha' ," )''( 5h# ha' # +# h' *$a3 ))'(h).
T# $33 5##3 #'& h' '"'( # h' '#3'
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 '&" 5'33. :' 5'&' #3* &'(#()3" ha #'& 1%@00 ha' ''
+)' *$a3 ))'(h) a* # a()( 5a( *)(3#('*. I a (a" &'(#()3" &#, h' F3##& # h)(
H#$(' ha # Ta,)3 ha( +#. :h# h)( (')a3 a'+#&" # '&(#( a&'% 5' *# # !#5. I )( )
ha a!+&#$* ha h'&' )( h)( ($**' ),#())# # &a'3 &'(&))#( # h' N#&h. O h'
#' ha*% "#$ ha' 9a3 D')< #,)+ a* 5' 5'3#,' ). Tha 'a&( &''$' ) ,)33)#( #&
h' G#'&,'. O h' #h'& ha*% "#$ (# '#3' # h)( #$&" +#)+ # ,'' h')& '&"
'a& &'3a)'( " 3a)+ &a'3 &'(&))#(. I( ha # &'a)+ h' N#&h *)'&'3" Th)( )(a3(# a a', # $33 5##3 #'& h' '"'( # '#3'% # # h' '#3' # h' N#&h. I h'
'#3' # h' N#&h 5'&' ##3'*% h'" 5#$3* ha' #'* #& h' UPFA. Th'" 5'&' # ##3'* "
a" # h' &#a*(% h' &)*+'(% h' ,'+a &#'( #& h' +)( "#$ +a' &#, '3')# 3a#&,(.
Th'" 5'&' # ##3'*. Th)( )( a a', # $33 5##3 #'& h' '"'( # h' '#3' ) h' S#$h.
E3')#( a&' #,)+ '&ha(% #h'&5)(' h'&' 5#$3* # ' ($h (5'''(( ) h)( B$*+'.
A*% #5 "#$ 5a # &'a' a !)* # $&'(% a !)* # 'a& ) '#3'J( ,)*(> 9Oh Th'&' )(
(#,' ,)3)a a))" ha h'" ha' #,,''* ) h' N#&h. Th'&' )( '&&#&)(, (a&)+ a+a).
I a, h' #3" #' 5h# a #$'& '&&#&)(, ) h)( #$&"% (# "#$ ,$( #' #& ,'<. M'&'3"(a")+ ) )( # '#$+h.
Do a few things like imposition of travel restrictions to the North. You do not
care what inconvenience people are put to because you do not consider them
your own. You do not care worse what indignity they suffer because you do not
consider them your own. That is the hard truth and that is what this House
must understand. Merely claiming that the war has ended and you have
defeated terrorism is not enough if you continually sow the seeds thereafter for
discontent, for people to suffer indignity, for people to feel that they are
somehow inferior to the others, for people to think that they do not belong or
they are not wanted in this country, that when they freely eercise their
franchise and if it is against the powers that be, they will suffer punishment for
that, and even the representatives whom they freely choose will not be given
any power and that area will be administered directly from the !entre.
Tha ,$h a3!'* a#$ R(. 8 )33)# 5h)h )( (a)* # ha' '' +)' # h' N#&h 5a( #
+)' # h' N#&h% # #& h')& '#3'J( R'&'('a)'( # ('* #& $(' ) h' 5a" h'"
*')*'% # 5ha *''3#,' )( +##* #& h',. I )( *')*'* h'&'= ) )( (' &#, h'&' a* +#'(
)# #!'( h'&'. G#)+ )# #!'( a"5h'&' )( #')#a3'% $ ,#( # ) +#'( )#
#!'( h'&'. M#'" *#'( # '' +# h'&'.
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 9/10
I a, # h' #' 5h# (#3' &)'
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7 S)&% I &)(' # a #) # O&*'&.
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7 ) S)ha3a %
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7 I S)ha3a ඒ. % .
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7 Tha )( # a #) # O&*'&. H#. S$,ah)&a% "#$ a&&" #.
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 S)&% a( I (a)* 'a&3)'&% 5h' I a3! a#$ &)'( #& #,,)(()#(% )
h$&( #' '&(# ) h)( H#$('. –
[I'&&$)#.]
6Th' H#. A.R.M. A*$3 Ca*'&7 &#('.
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7 H#. A*$3 Ca*'&% 3'a(' ' ('a'*. –
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 H' (a*( $ a* (h#$(. :ha a I *# –
6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7 H#. A*$3 Ca*'&% 3'a(' ' ('a'*. ?' h' H# M','& ('a!. H#.S$,ah)&a% "#$ a&&" #
6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 S)&% I a# h'3 ). I a, # h' #' 5h# (#3' &)'= I a, # h'
#' 5h# 5a( )*)'* ) h' H)+h C#$&= I a, # h' #' 5h# &#(('* h' F3##& a* +# ,"
)*),' 5)h*&a5 a( a &'($3 # ha. –
[I'&&$)#.] 6Th' P&'()*)+ M','&7 H#. S$,ah)&a% "#$ a&&" #.
P&'()*' a'( #' &$h6Th' H#. M.A. S$,ah)&a7 S)&% a( I 5a( (a")+% 5ha I ';3a)'* 'a&3)'& )( h' h)+ ha#'&( $( ,#(. :)h a33 # h)(% h'&' )( #' 5'3#,' h)+ h#$+h ha h' H#. M))('& #
F)a' a* P3a)+ ha* (a)*.
He had said, "# want $ he has named our party $ the Tamil National %lliance
to engage in conversation&. # say # welcome it because at least this time, he
has not decided that by talking to people who sit on that side of the Divide he
can solve anything. He has finally reali'ed that we are the true (epresentatives of the people and that he must, rightly, talk to us. )o, that is a
welcome statement from the Hon. Minster of *inance. +ut as before, our
worry is, that is said, but nothing is done.
I 5#$3* # +# ## ,$h )# h' h)(#&" # ha 'a$(' I '3)'' ha '#&' 5' #3$*' h'
D'a' # h' S'#* R'a*)+% a $33 &'#&* # ha 5)33 ' 3a'* ) h)( H#$('. S)&% I 5)33
#3$*' " #,)+ a! # h' B$*+' P&##(a3( ha ha' '' ,a*'. ?' ,' $(' h)( H#$('
a( a 3a' &#, 5h)h a 5a&)+ a ' a**&'(('* # h' '#3' # h' #$&". Tha )( 5ha )
,$( '% ha h' ('),'( ';&'(('* h'&' " h' M','&( ,$( ' h'a&* 3#$* a* 3'a& "
h' '#3' # h' #$&". D'()' 5ha ha( '' (a)* a#$ &'(( &''*#, ) h)( S''h% 5'
!#5 5ha 3''3 # &''*#, h' &'(( '#"( a* ," a'a3 # h' &'(( a( 5'33 )( ha h'
8/10/2019 You Do Not Care What Indignity Tamils Suffer Because You Do Not Consider Them Your Own – Sumanthiran
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/you-do-not-care-what-indignity-tamils-suffer-because-you-do-not-consider-them 10/10
&))a3 #,,'( ha a&' ,a*' ) h)( H#$('% a&)$3a&3" " h' O#())# 'a$(' h'B$*+' P&##(a3( a&' " h' M))('& # F)a'% ,$( ' a!' # h' '#3'. Th' '#3' #
h)( #$&"% #*a"% a&' &''3)+ 5)h #$()#% 5#*'&)+ h#5 a h)( ' a &'a3)() B$*+'%
h#5 ) h' 5#&3* a h)( G#'&,' ,'' a33 # h'(' ';'*)$&'( h'" ha' &##('*.
:h' h' O#())# )!( )% 'a&( ) # )''( a* ';#('( ha h)( )( a &a$* # h' '#3'%
ha ,$( ' h'a&* " h' '#3' a* #3" 5h' ) )( h'a&* " h' '#3'% h'"% 5h# a&' a3&'a*"
($())#$( ha h)( )( # a B$*+' $ a '3')# ,a)'(#% 5)33 #)&, ) h')& ,)*( a( #5ha h)( &'a33" )(.
Tha! "#$.
R'a* a( a PDF>S$,ah)&a O 28 (''h
C#$&'(" – TNA ,'*)a #)'