13
Environment and HAI 041114 ICAN 2014 1 I have absolutely no knowledge of.. environmental or healthcare.. waste management.! Andreas Voss Radboud UMC & CWZ Nijmegen The Netherlands Robert Weinstein esFmated that the source of pathogens causing a healthcareassociated infecFon in the intensive care unit was as follows: paFents’ endogenous flora, 40%–60%; incl. anFbioFcdriven changes in flora; cross infecFon via the hands of personnel, 20%–40%; other (incl. environment): 20%. modified from Wenzel and Edmond

Ycml

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Yves Chartier Memorial Lecture during ICAN 2014 in Harare, Zimbabwe: My view on environment

Citation preview

Page 1: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   1  

I have absolutely no knowledge of.. environmental or healthcare..

waste management.!

Andreas  Voss  Radboud  UMC  &  CWZ  

Nijmegen    The  Netherlands  

¤   Robert  Weinstein  esFmated  that  the  source  of      pathogens  causing  a  healthcare-­‐associated      infecFon  in  the  intensive  care  unit  was  as      follows:    ²   paFents’  endogenous  flora,  40%–60%;  

²   incl.  anFbioFc-­‐driven  changes  in  flora;    ²   cross  infecFon  via  the  hands  of  personnel,      20%–40%;    

²   other  (incl.  environment):  20%.  

modified  from  Wenzel  and  Edmond  

Page 2: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   2  

MRSA  

ESBL  

C.dif  &  Co  

CRE  

…..  

PREVENT  everything  

Page 3: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   3  

Adapted  from  O^er  et  al    ICHE    july  2011,  vol.  32,  no.  7  

Innate  surfaces   Water  

Air  HCWs  &  pa?ents  

Coming  here  

Hematology   OperaFng  room  

Airborne  isolaFon  

or type

Page 4: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   4  

Brandt et al, Ann Surg 2008; 248:695-700.

¤  63  surgical  departments  parFcipaFng  in  KISS  

¤  >99.000  operaFons  

¤  Turbulent  +  HEPA  versus  laminar  airflow  +  HEPA  

¤ MulFvariate  analyis  to  comtrol  for  other  factors  influencing  outcome  (SSI)  

Brandt et al, Ann Surg 2008; 248:695-700.

Significant                              ns                                              ns                                              ns                                              ns                                            ns                          

Brandt et al, Ann Surg 2008; 248:695-700.

Follow-­‐up  study  taking  in  account  the  size  of  the  LAF  plenum  shows  no  difference  in  outcome      

¤   Mycobacteria  &  endoscope      reprocessing  

¤   Legionella  and  aerosols    

¤   Nonfermenters  (especially  Pseudo-­‐    monas  &  Acinetobacter)    in  sinks  &      venFlators    

¤   Molds  in  hematology  units  

Page 5: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   5  

Villegas  et  al    ICHE  2003;24:284-­‐95  

Thus,  what  is  all  the  fuzz  about?  

Weber  et  al.    Am  J  Infect  Control  2010;38:S25-­‐33  

Page 6: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   6  

Kramer  et  al.  BMC  Infect  Dis  2006;6:130   Kramer  et  al.  BMC  Infect  Dis  2006;6:130  

Kramer  et  al.  BMC  Infect  Dis  2006;6:130  

C.  difficile  ,  VRE,    MRSA    103  to  109  CFUs/g  in  stool  Norovirus  1012    parFcles/g  

Environment  is  generally  <10  organisms  per  cm2  

¤ The  infecFous  dose  for  most  environmentally  associated  nosocomial  pathogens  appears  to  be  low.    ²   Less  than  15  S.  aureus  cells  were  sufficient  to      cause  infecFon  in  experimental  lesions,  

² Less  than  1  CFU/cm2    was  sufficient  to  cause    C.  difficile  disease  in  mice  

² A  single  norovirus  parFcle  is  thought  to  have  the  capacity  to  cause  infecFon  

O^er  et  al    ICHE    july  2011,  vol.  32,  no.  7  

¤ The  surface  environment  in  rooms  of  colonized  or  infected  paFents  is  frequently  contaminated  with  the  pathogen.  

¤ Contact  with  hospital  room  surfaces  or  medical  equipment  by  healthcare  personnel  frequently  leads  to  contaminaFon  of  hands  and/or  gloves.  

Weber  &  ICHE  may  2013,  vol.  34,  no.  5  

Page 7: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   7  

SFefel  et  al    ICHE  2011:32:185-­‐87   Bonten  et  al.      Lancet  1996;348:1615-­‐19  

Bobulsky  et  al.      CID    2008;46:447-­‐50  

Skin  (orange),  gloves  (blue)  

¤ Improved  environmental  cleaning  has  led  to  reduced  risk  of  VRE  and  C.  difficile    transmission.    

¤ Admission  to  a  room  previously  occupied  by  a  paFent  with  MRSA,  VRE,  Acinetobacter,  or  C.  difficile  increases  the  risk  for  the  subsequent  paFent  admi^ed  to  the  room  to  acquire  the  pathogen  

Weber  &  ICHE  may  2013,  vol.  34,  no.  5  

O^er  et  al.      AJIC  2013;41:56   Huslage  et  al.  Infect  Control  Hosp  Epidemiol  2010;  31(8):850-­‐853  

Page 8: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   8  

Huslage  et  al.  Infect  Control  Hosp  Epidemiol  2010;  31(8):850-­‐853  

Obviously  all  should  be  clean,  but  high-­‐touch  really  needs  to  be!  

Eckstein  et  al.    BMC  Infect  Dis  June  2007   Eckstein  et  al.    BMC  Infect  Dis  June  2007  

C.  difficile  

Eckstein  et  al.    BMC  Infect  Dis  June  2007  

VRE  

Page 9: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   9  

Boyce  et  al.      ICHE  2008;29:723  

Copper a day - Keeps MRSA away

Noyce  et  al.    J  Hosp  Infect  2006;63:289-­‐297  

Thom  et  al.      Infect  Control  Hosp  Epidemiol    2014;35:1060-­‐62   Thom  et  al.      Infect  Control  Hosp  Epidemiol    2014;35:1060-­‐62  

¤   MSDS  Poly  spray  (silicone  quaternary  amine)  

¤   8  surfaces  

²   sink,  call  bu^on,  bedside  table,  monitor,      telephone,  supply  cart,  door  handle,  floor  

¤   Results:  

² No  significant  effect  on  environmental  contaminaFon  

Page 10: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   10  

Thom  et  al.      Infect  Control  Hosp  Epidemiol    2014;35:1060-­‐62  

¤   Problem  adherence?  

¤   Love  the  concept  of  changing  the  surface    

¤   Studies  with  copper,  silver  silica,  Biosafe  HM      4100  (polymer)  embedded  in  polyurethane,      light-­‐acFvated  anFmicrobials,  …  have  worked      before  

Freeman  et  al.    AnFmicrob  Resistance  Infect  Control  2014;3:5  

¤   We  systemaFcally  sampled  8  surfaces  in  the      rooms  and  bathrooms  of  adult  paFents      colonized  or  infected  with  ESBL-­‐EC  or  ESBL-­‐KP      throughout  their  hospital  stay.  

¤   Environmental  contaminaFon  was  defined  as      recovery  of  an  ESBL-­‐producing  organism      matching  the  source  paFent’s  isolate  

Freeman  et  al.  AnFmicrobial  Resistance  and  InfecFon  Control  2014,  3:5   Freeman  et  al.  AnFmicrobial  Resistance  and  InfecFon  Control  2014,  3:5  

Rooms  of  paFents  with  ESBL-­‐KP  have  substanFally  higher  contaminaFon  rates  than  those  with  ESBL-­‐EC.  This  finding  may  help  explain  the  apparently  higher  transmissibility  of  ESBL-­‐KP  in  the  hospital  serng  

Page 11: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   11  

Kampf  et  al.  BMC  Infect  Dis  2014;14:37     Kampf  et  al.  BMC  Infect  Dis  2014;14:37    

¤ Reusable  Fssue  dispensers  with  different  surface  disinfectants  were  randomly  collected  from  healthcare  faciliFes.    

¤ 66  dispensers  containing  disinfectant  soluFons  with  surface-­‐acFve  ingredients  were  collected  in  15  healthcare  faciliFes.  28  dispensers  from  nine  healthcare  faciliFes  were  contaminated    

¤ In  none  of  the  hospitals  dispenser  processing  had  been  adequately  performed  

…  it  is  not  about  the  details  of  this  paper,  but  the  point  that  even  

“helpful  parts  of  the  environment”  may  be  a  source  for  infecFons  

¤   Roomservice  ¤   Roomservice-­‐plus  ¤   Registered  nurse  ¤   Nurse  asistant  ¤   Cleaning  

Even  if  you  think  you  know  it,  are  they  actually  doing  it?  

Page 12: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   12  

Weber  et  al.    J  Hosp  Infect    2012;80:252-­‐4  

¤ Highest  rate  of  mannequin  contamina?on  was  long  sleeves  +  ?e  (transmission  occurred  in  4/5  experiments)  and  lowest  with  short  sleeves  no  ?e  (0/5).    

>   >  

Weber  et  al.    J  Hosp  Infect    2012;80:252-­‐4  

Eli:  “flaw  in  this  study  was  that  Fes  were  narrowly  defined  as  neckFes  and  excluded  bow  Fes”  

h^p://haicontroversies.blogspot.nl  

¤ Enter  a  soluFon  to  all  of  our  infecFon  control    problems:  the  Jumbo  Squir?ng  Bow  Tie!    

¤ This  oven  overlooked  clothing  accessory  is  a  veritable  infecFon  prevenFon  dream.    ² A  bow  Fe  can  increase  our  professionalism  and  limit  pathogen  transmission.    

² Add  in  the  "Jumbo  SquirFng"  acFon  and  you  can  squirt  alcohol  hand  rub  into  the  eyes  of  non-­‐compliant  clinicians  (operant  condiFoning)  and  also  into  your  own  hands  to  improve  compliance  with  the  WHO  5  Moments.    

h^p://haicontroversies.blogspot.nl  

Page 13: Ycml

Environment  and  HAI   04-­‐11-­‐14  

ICAN  2014   13  

hZps://www.surveymonkey.com/r/2XG8LV6