Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
WWW.AEL.AF
I
I
rl
r s BN 178-t00-57q?-11-!
ilillll|JfilltlruffiLril
WWW.AEL.AF
�,;
�LO) �Ji �J.J-.i;S
jf '"5�� .\o� �
��,,"'�
!,)�;Ml
�.;,iJ.\!}
�f.:>4�
WWW.AEL.AF
Jrr. "i, :L5 Vh r*9t :lyl -;Sl,i t €AF,dL{-? Ul .J-$f Jrg*t o:l-, .!t^ oe &:t-;
r,.L1 i q * .(L^ q r SoL:.-Xl
ilt1W..r! -tJU.l-r
Fiftieth Anniversary EditionFriedrich von llayek
The Road to Serfdom
With A New lntroduction ByMilton Friedman
The University ofChicago Press
1944. 1972.1994
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
\0
Y\
YO
Y1
fY
f0
00
?\
t\\.0\YI
\rq'\0Y
YY\
.brrea
oLer- e"fL E
6*-;;teJa d f :tS..,rl VE ;r..rt3i '-fl\ t.gl+,ri" EI
uL:5 ;L:il 4+;-JU ,, .r:Jll::L- E
\1V2 JL rF:t< rU,i("'! o110P .rr: ?q rU,Kr;:t E
\qYf ul+ rU5r! u
alJ-tA
,,rlJ;l.t S n^q t g-lf >S Iq-r L -
,< r,{.U,, <,j:lluL:.-l .fvJ-'
.rlf y, ) ,SJ-;a*t.d;tlt3 c-jS- I 6yy"ly .?
:l.r;-l _9 .g>L*:il JF .V
tl ' Je9-5a>.Aro . o
,5:l,1i -9 c-;l .1
l.l-5 ,-* :l; 1Lo;: tar,-ri.l 1r> .\ .
{-41i- ,fqq .\ \
f--jU "i;!-- .gLar5; .l Y
L,r!" tr gLal4c-.,.[.i .ll
WWW.AEL.AF
Y0q
YqV
Yql
r.r
,-5'-' J-' n ?
.,JLri.rlJ^l 3,-9:L Lrl; .\f;k- d's5L-i1i: '\o
c;a+$.\?
6"U+US ,, .r:;l::L- E
bl-*- v Lapl-; a,Ll E
WWW.AEL.AF
l.ri;tj +,
rgL".-.;" 4,0'li^
p$ .rt-olr- 3 gLlr;Lo:il U--,-d<tjl F-.tl^ "e ;*61 &--tx-;s
gLaa^isl .ilrl L -<,-La . \ 1Vf JL ;r .i*l f--*: jJ ,) 4;t-61-#)lji Lgtaa^:.-il
3) ,s$-y*,ilr .o .11.r.:L,a:!l ,)\"-ry ;\K ! l;:- 13p o, >Lo;,il,Jc + :-r 6.*oy)t-c ..r3-c ;!L-,r l; .1.,1; +! .(;;lr rLolil ;r Jl .litjL oL); 2: Jl-); ele)t: 6,"1*e 61 3t, 6 eio,.s., !* 1's-lo
. .9* L; o*L, A,i--J-i 1.: &-l"o, ":Lji l r-,.sVt )>t -,1 L^.-+;;l ;:.r-oLl zUiy;;1, -r4 s f , cfL.;;l,.."a-os rl ,g:Lz.!il -r,Liip z-,1, .7, l,1,;;l -5(..s-^br 6b ,-&-t U-;l .;;lj(J JE.J
oLp \,qH lp 3--:4 ,c.---;l J-, ;l-r."L .il-,:Lr.iil ! .lr+ -r+ + \ 1\"'
.e-:;1"r
;, . j t.-o;, o-l L>J )t \ A11 a. oL A ;: el 3 ;-l &-tl :_s-S .<,-G .Krlj
.rr5;*-s;Lat+-,r*-rl 6;glr-l.r-yl ;, y Ut.l ",.;;r,J9l jl.- 3;)) cr?-e:Lo.iil )'.p.15 ! O:;- t^;z 2,t c-G 3;*;;31\;re * Ka oiE L
Jyl .jQ: & .;[*L .M ,s-s oK:r;1, )l ajS" +.:s JGJ + '+y" .rl** fyb
a-lrq r: L*- ,'rl ^,-b
e -r;LS L3*" oLy + l; .-,l*;B-.,i- tl ,:l+, rstil*lJ v- (:-
:.*l oJj o:Li:-l ;4j .SLn.:kS:Jtt" .r-rt 1l'l*-. ul;. gal dd-r$ ;: .\
.-J;n s34S .f t o^z;,5_1" jJ.9 .j-_)J.-l G)La:3\ J .r\- 6[^.:.-r,\ ,.Ilr .J:-_, -.\r^v,; F,ilrs
C! .:rl;L::;t ,,Jl,.4j ,rl,r:)j, itlors ;S: {-a-;, ,5:\j f:- ;r,,5:t" Ji ;A,t*} -.\rAY,F
,r-J" ,S) J 6)a- J"i-{- CL- {-z;,6>\;i 3 6r\r(;U .,JiU,,lit^ bg ,;<;x-} -.lr^. ,Jj 7,L utrV-.t.Jt ,e,)l i ;e
.\rA\ .)/r,, "K ;.;116, .i_t""rarr',rty;r-r-r'], -.\rvo,; ;,bt*,5--S q* -f '*.;.o\q sry. i\,\:>Lr:!\,,5>,t, SrU -
WWW.AEL.AF
6,t J; o
ri-,3a.rT frJ JJ;s aS s-e,1./"t^4 : ei fiN,*L t-, ,S-,il*l a-l *-l Jzl
I L*-.&-V -,, .-ul 0-4; ;T.9L"c*!* t 3 "-y.dtirt ,/J y,! p" aLoe 2.:3
.rt' l+.:y rLJl -tt j4.a+ jl r t^rrr .r"[ -,t St-r. a-,il*l
^- .;--;l u3* aJl; byd 1.: .5--G \ 1Yf JL ;s l.r:il \ 1Y . aa-: 1-:
,*; L. \ 1 YV -, \ 1 Y 2 6toJL -tt 'ry : n-"5 u. -yor, rs-j* 64 &3t"J ;3Vy &S?" A*i' o,,1r- 3 )J o.3,a:a r:""ril 6-:La;!l .gG",:ati a*3a io_J-Ja a
c-*L; ,s3, -ll ;rL ,y* ;tg d JL -2s a**j^.-,,-l t.:: ,y .r-*-L l-s,g;V
-219,,l
.rlr ;L:u;l rrllslr-" ",iriit$r
ol* G.9laJl.;i. \ 1Yl JL -,2r ..:*::lr o"rnc a, lr;ri
.)tJ* els.,[-jil ,r+l-, Jiy] &i, .*p * s ".tsT
:\ * sl el-t6.,[-; ;Jrr& at
,ri r-!- p*V e slal orS-:;l-:,,--: aLr J y 3 "lta
J+ es;r,.,,r-J5il
,;l-.:-o ,:,-i \ 1f \ JL _,1r a5 # ."'f r jl-ru* &; .(- :lrr-l 6l2.i_lo;l .rr1
.;.iL_ rf ujl (!i J tr.;*.il;LT e .,L-:ri I -,2r .9.rL-. I s J + 4l-U\, tadlj;* ;y-l,L.* I ;I "q,l--t r
,r! c* ",,_l
2.r \ tfA JL l; 3 * u. t-;,^.rrJ .r!- 1:lo I ,L-$l o-r5,Jl,.;lr ;.t
&U|cry oV : Jy,r*,U-x*U :sJ ;- "u;rrl .:5 -,\+ ol;3J qr,-l -,s .$L
s.t.b"-,, a-l (\tff )firr oL,(\1fl) ,9-2l.t34ln * j olt, J r-r,(\1YV).(\1rA).erL :!l p: e)$*: {rls
ol(L;1r 2: i-e[l $)3 t "f U?l aa*li ,.9r1;l ;.* aJ .t--b , \ 14. JL ;-:
,K-r -lJ 4--.;J-.;-l ;r.-'r5..r--:s l9rT;.: \tiY L'3 -ul .,,y^'"0 -ft<r.,
,'L a- .9rK-, .rL:S r : ( \ 1 P \ ) g;.rl;T !t+ . ( \ 1 O Y ) .*l, -,),ttl -u :tf ,.:,;;^L:'\1tYrl .-r,.1 *i el 621:*lr,-3 jcSzL* !at(\10f);Br-r* jsg2lv'_Vr-sLr*l \ 1YF U' ,*?* 3 6\X 3rr4lS oK,:ll, 1., Lr)L.a:i;l 6rlKa-lr. rti-.| \ 1Vf
,tKa U r.5) 3)r+-l; ot(:.;1, +i14.i1.s;2.r[i S-,y.JV ot(,r:;1.,2r rLr.iil
-l.5 a*. o-,2e.r.y-l 9.sJ Li- l; olK;|" 6T;Lr.grt*l .r-; \11Y JL s" 3t..liL3 ,(\ 1YP) sL :!l : c*t*. ,+iJ.i 1s ,.jtJt!" ,# VH ) \t4; e -K",
-, s*t.i" .a.iJ! -2.r u{J,, r:Uth," J (\ 1Vf-VA) .rL a*. ,rSii s ,g_21jK 6;13
.(\ tVA) ta+,:"_sl 6.,2b: sLa:il
1l 621113,-o 3 slzT rLanil c.-_t-t' l* .rrl;T;l 1Us l.rl aLe rl ,-1la d..,oq-.grlu'5; ! ,*l-rLS JJ;" ti \ 1Vf JL 2, of .r^K- .r31 53.)5 fJtl,*y'.ar" xi :s ( \VY2-\AY\ ) "<r--)\5 -^ji ,lriJ"t .r^lc ,.gGc,-a;;;l
WWW.AEL.AF
D gL>,:" d.IL
J o.* nJ, +L'd^-l \ tf . aa.: 2-r ;! l.rr .rV ;l+ 1_, +_-Jq,.r n ;.41 u1y)r ,)?J bF &-su-;r t 5- JrS,.:LaJl
"G g;L't, .5i""il .-K. F-, O[!
..,: -,|-,tr 1J! : ,l;! a--tt' a. )ib. t 6. ri orrerr;*, c.ii;-
f2Y !; JL.lt -tt s cg?.J-r.r. J-u :;eL:^-: ,r-Jtr1grljT,.<,-l'a o-qiic a,
rljT d.*fJt !;61Jfu rL- rs o.tt- elr 2, g;rl)T.c*l ;i 6V s 1l3t 6lt;l .c*l ..u raje,;t(l ,rlrt, & .r*-,Lo6Ll 6l*".r;lrl;T -!.rty ;:;i.3 :,3U..l U .rF-, a:* F- j ;i;l.-lL .i- t- : a(- .<,- *) s' -,t-,! p 3 6:li ,3;;-l
o,ijrl &- l'1; l-2.9r1;l 19 aS ':*l;r-l .9rl;T;l .(,-G ol5'r,-, Ji-t.-+ ,g.,91r<,*Ji;r r-.,:. l;.9r1;i.6T;l ir+ u-il, dl.t ,5.,r ,rtt; "fli?l
t" .,i)l;'lr;:- Jl .c*l oj; L;1 L-Oi ,-Ll: 6J+ nri Lrl^i;31t,.)
"f5 a5 sl-r,r. ;;-
Ll ,c*l o-u: -i,iS o;J" grL..a:irl a.:,-Jl 2r lril .9rl;T jL;ri -,6y-,L oS c.*l
"t'U?l ,r(s; rtnl 4.4 a(J.r,;*{ a*L 6.'La,jil c;L a, )l; q- rSe;L r-l)l ,**- s J-*l4-.i dq.-gL" t: c;rl;T,.5--t-" o.r*;io * .t#," 22"1;oi cs.V t.rFc/ V;- i tf ,,/ J.*, ,4.15 ,k ft1,^ { trgg;[irr cs-- Jr*a^p -, J5 'rtly;*,.6!;T 3 ,g2lK i;13 ,Js,G lV i.:3,- 6rl-7a-- .-,5:r .f--b .e;;al 1l
.9rl;T tt i 4lr3 ;r;G ;*; W* b'; iiy ep\'* o-b ;;-$ -rl ,*e)56"
f l:t .,Hl .1, f,; l, e"lj -t.s," .s-L* : e|l ..g.:Lo;iil d;t",*Lj .<,-ta
;l el .grLi: j 65lj -2lel 1Gr.Jlr,r. s;-,Lanil .Grt lly fll:rlr: )n-\ A*dL+. n.:.-*.t altr c-+ ai).tl s.,ji),Lil lt u :.,-9--e1,--.t .,+ gJ!*r\r'o: yl .# r.^l+ ozbl ;i t ir-r4 a."rl.r,,-l ;, f-r- o( ,21-' .r.lc s sbcln6lr-1 *l J-:;b^ j "[1-:.r. i**(]r *. f*lt o-&-r ry^ ";-$ * "<t" lt*,r* c5-" ols ? s;*l .9rl;T J, J ::;1.r, :3*.3 -n;* .l-, ..(- oGz y .rx + .rJ*.r
e- t . e J le !. . -
.c*l _lj
0.r5..:-;l.r ,-4-t..r*.lt "f,yjY;f, t q.4U d.16,\1Y. aas.gl.ul 2.:
oS 6y -tl t<l-t.s .r--,.1, a )t:,* o-rS,-:.jl: ,,1 2) .oxJ .r-U* pb -9 rL":il
015,.:;lr lr*i;!lsrLaniil .9:Lz6l .sGc*U* , d- b *J,r*Kt ,t-St
:, J* .-:.r. jl y '-?f
):*-? r-y e-S L,+. (\AAY-\ \Y?) i.S ,rL.. OE ,e#,sl 1r cJel J[-.r 1;o e "lj.iU: -,lj!.9L-lr" -,11 i5,-].,Lii. 2t rS 4; 6 rg,
WWW.AEL.AF
.!ttJ-, n \'
GOT + }! d ,;, l) .<,-l^ .rl^jl-n;* A o\r,-u( 1G: er-L r:-;1 .9.r1-.il.c*l .;J 1"r- .:*lr;,r. E l: 6* Jui 4-.,*o .-u:; orL:il
-t .trL &-;-' \ 1f \ JL* ;s 4J-:J oKl-;1, g;:Li*l o.l .i-l^ -Laal L JL."u; ;Ei;;J : :l .rf,. o"r.^-. .9laLl; ,-S--' .;-b;, !b--r -t, ct$ rL,anil acl;l..s_,lj! rl ^'iil ;i*_r -,l$-h,.!ij, y c+ cJJ)4 r 'ij d*-Jrr..<,_taJb:.ll ;-r
'."-:np J.rL' ,9;lj2 u;Nl; ;J-"r{;, ,12T.9;lr+!-
f b a5 r9 rii:-
1,- 4-.. .:3* .9;t(1 s :-$,s 6_y- a, .1l ,l jl;l a:ji j ;r".L;S ;.: e :;lr l, JrKs -,lS Gs*-,Yt5 ,_91,o;l;L J) !.*, a. >a Lt J ri.i*) ,i:..*! dJ,_-L
jtL;l !.*;5t ) \;r-rJi -,2r i;-r3
"f-15 Jt ;l JrL;'r,-lyL s *t *. ;l--142s o,-lr*
.r_l o: ,;r"rt ,; ,;:*l o"r".L_r5 "it"j &l jS W "!tj &l ."!Li.2-: ..i,j.r"
.9r1L.!LL;l ,-S -b J-'t-->.rrg-lorrr;-r.-u!;s L +"a> 3l uK * t a5 #,.>yL? Jll gr-Gc.-r3"r= la ou:L- l2- a*
, J_s-, s o-" .Jtidl e* aiil j* \ # *:r- -lJ \ 1 f p JL rr.x.'J ,.9:W5l.l-U;o g-;L' -ts <<6-# -)ii;lr ,,L
a, ,J)Li;l -,s,b .-o_r J )i ;;r4.11;ls-rLo:,iJl- eL;l:-:Loiil -\,_J? ,-[-- .r!. ;, l_, )F tpv c:rar,x gcr* + vK ..r-l
;-+ y rri l..r*,- "!+ r*N-* ;, GJ9-: ) t u? 3 t-"otK; l, ;.r e--a.i - c#
r*J 4. (GlS *:(.1 il3,s ;i -:[-iil ;-: sl js* : :$ i*-: t .sni *ryy;;3> ,x-rK u-,c;l ;$ 6l2lts) rl .F- ,:- d;Jr"L
"l*, ,tre|, ;l 2, .-r..7
.((c*l r,-b rL-:!l ,-tr rlj(Ln:L-:,.!l ;r Jy, y J* ;LU. Jl ai .u.ll-: sbrl el 1i .r^;Ls ,.5 ;rl)*)u/-:N s *sb ;-& t orl:p 6 .s-,tsn11 s'-$-t d:s';-, e "r5i; JE. .g;1.:+-Lr*y Jy. isb,"*."1*" rl o.:1;';,1 L c*"1 o-r.T ,fl 4 j J) J o.l3, .L^.$l ep-l ,,K-t,,sl-,-l s Je o;,-* *-l;l O--bjl ):.- lr rJy # ^.>-f & 6jJ -""l.; JLq9;lra-,_L_r* sl--Idl g3L:' -L;Lr; ,-uJj Y! -ds, ,s:lK *-lr* 3;i GG$st\ ,1.-* gzlra--Lr* .9t93J -,! .i- JL ,s.r^ \ 1\". a.or 6{; elr:1; .u;La
.# *lr 6[i l; .9;lr+-Lr* r[.-:il y ;oJ sl;l; is.r=
.r)(.^:- y .grL<*i ! .l-+ LtsLoj$l -r"-"r^:; :{ .(- ;: .rl-+ a( \ 1\". aas ;s&-l,o J;+l-, l:;L ,.2\3 a-og ) ,*U,.1 .s,-e ,4a ,rJG. J* + ;l3lr.i JL,J; .jli .9G2l5e;L* ! L'r1r .--r,i -r[.aiil + .r"-L "u..(,r" n{ so-.rr^ A * J:r;'U.;.r-r: olg j\a r1 ->a Ll s "*",c + g:-tJLt-;l c*:" ,rSLo-
WWW.AEL.AF
\\ U JL+ ,:j 4-o-L&
el ;l aS Jt- -,, ,t;"-5 rs ,sl$: ;lal.s;s .91^c*V ,sri;lJii ,;3, 2, beT
;.: ig;l.ra--L-r* -'Lo:!l aJ JJr;--l 1c4 ;tF eqgq)) oS s+;.r ft,.r-l-rl.r -t :*<so p-r -,8, -t-rj t f.*-*.4 dr\<..i 9 1352 .vL;r J!, * L a5 j123.>
c*l .9;L(1 aL*;* ak*:;",*: ,r^r-;l.u ak- rLanil u.l ,> pr; ,k*.u""5,_s -L-r,ji'16 Jri i+ ! y ,-:;,-r;Lii,.grLiil ,t', ! .5
o;*,a,,9;:.5 .9L6c*t** jl I tJ .+,-|# e ,e. JY"r-"| "al
.iJE .f--l,o
,L;+ a\5 rL:61 1r.r*"El $l:; p:, t rr-,! oLj.A;r.riL;:..,3* J!.raS 6l^L* -t;--S ,.r <.9:r5; pgr L- <1..ro-:,
"-S-ru 1,, pr ! (art(* 3) ,1$2 or:,i
4i : A 44 o'. u,,.K;l J l(-J"l 2; .9;1.,a,-L-r* rLo:iil ;r \ 1Y' aor ,, 1E-1-*
dJ^J---p;rJ"";uL.(--t-o.;*3r1" (gs *:t 6* * g;;;J e[:lr-'Lo:ril -b *.
&t1 .9t-";-t < JjI- l(-,,J .:Lo::il \ 1Y. a.or <31;,tlrar> S tJ,_+ JY-r;l'rL*r qir.;.-1 jU r&i 4.j-trijl Je.,..gLo.;-lo* J[ol r, ,-S J eftL-
,S3rJ> 3 ,;rS o-:l-r 9t-11 .r"-! .11r..., (: tSll 3 .e*l Dr9 alr ;-l ;.r <Gc.^!i
Jl.-l ^J;Jrlr sUirl .(--G,a-o)L ,-* *..r2|-rra.ri e) * ty 113> <;ljL
..u ulr; 6fyt te9lV-\,p s pi : -!6 6',Lolil .Iy; :t-+1 + )v, :.S;t--J,
.-9L:-i 2r j,--Ii*;--l ;12t5.+ : &-jl ;L--b t..l tt.(-G or";-l 2.>
J orl: j sja:srS J:Ja ) CJJ) ;$ tLS 3.t .rrJ ,L,i6l olSI;1, 6# )b
J# .<,-tA .l^:,K .r-l -,., .( \ 1f \ ) qLr* ,pa 62P J ,(\ 111) ,92i|5 4l.tir--l ar ,3r*- rg,lL.;A .9to1U; r, CL ,-a*az f-.y- )l g;s[:l
"[l .i- a:lrl
9 6la--Vr-.91-rXt5 li al-t o--;cit.a eL +.;[lb c*f rr aS 4-, av-;;
a-.i .ij13; 1-r-' .914L,* g9GXt5 4*y + .ll-rJy dr-a. .9t6Yti .glra L>1ii;;ll;._r,-l;1,-.9
.rL^,s-F:", *-b 5'rrl ( \ 1f 1-f 6 ) ).:S J-b JL .r* d ;:, jL6 3,+
,l.5 o: d;r+ gJ-: -t 6,y1'. ;,L;.4 lr r-r .rG,-i)t' o^p L' #.r llt$ l-1 ,s.ri,
r;lji;L ,;* b 3l aS 4;4 e-:t l-t C*6- Al3*- -&-" ,s*jl -r -rj*ol2 2r c*-L.r- o- V -;J-$ j51.,.- a5 .t3i .r,-l f*." ,a/-!q ."rl5 c";'19,r:; !L-=l Jyr r, aJ ;"--!.f ,*" cSsLaSl df [.-"4j' s s, :S * 3-z ] G)s*$ 'J,.5 4..r <+ .gt^jt+ .r3.r g4 ,l 1, 6)-e* ) 3;. ^** A:E .)bl )t a: J
. l, .',1;i q .li * l"ii Je, .;lK-r5.i-- a' I )l)i- az \ s >*l& r"-! )r +;L.r-; : t)i fV -,'15 o-"[i:* lJ L-^.iT a-([,;ulr;r"li.r"tb ;*;e
WWW.AEL.AF
j:rr ol; Ll \t
3:- ;ly" )' JIJ)IS .),i6r JrtJ 4, -t-; tu"# 3 Grr^;: .;;u6,s
f 9Larl .;- y .)c;;I.:,r. )j- G)S1.iLl r.1l,r-.3.-i)E lr rll tl 6"r-d c*.r.r3r o-\-.:; 1tt ;Jlt L,i
y f*5L .gr-rLi y q-a;; ,g;tO"L \ 1f A Jl* -,, .iil" .p) ;!Lr? i>o)J-! jl ;"-L4 !.rr<- 6l;!L;le_.r.i- "lU
jl .r*.-r*-r 6t-t" aq
"-*-lsor-r aJ l1 a*h y.,L"or!l J;5 -U 3 Jse o-:J Jt l <+;l;y.:1.: al s3"r<L
J-_r/ ! e "r-:.5 o;1.:l .i:; ;L"o L l; .:La$l ;; 3,J. )l ,-*_ $ -urJ fi ,*r_r1
l;.9;L5e j S"*-S : *,3.,2 6l;-,r.rclel ;l*",^J 4! ! 3 a*L zLilLLjrr A-e;, .rUT r-1 Lr* ,r-:l 6J* jU) rl;, ,03){o + .15 -,1,r +:*s ,912.
g,, tl$.r^l ;L.-r;,* 6t..(J u6J.-r,_;L L Le;l .gtoc*-;y' aS t), *endf, l-, 6:X J -r; t ,4!q(- ".ytJ ;t+l[' t.
s ,4f .9ta6l_5:,": u:l-r s
r-+# 6-,!'ul: G,1'[rl 3 o:l:;lii"',JL*l .gl.oc*q- y r*!L*l ;l 6;lx]:Li:l eT ;t oS tzj ;sr: a.l; cs-!-r. .,.U- r ,L-l;;-l .-ri-li arV Grlrrrorre
.r;6AutLi-6 Klr,*t*f 1..'a: ,rSVs.rL,,.or,,r-5* AUfo# )_r,'J rr" qfJLl y 6s-tF 7W
jl "rii; t U,_r* oS -p ro*.i!lJ,=^3 ,ft*" jl d,J-G y ,-JL-b, y-4 *.ir:t;f rs c.^,a---a fJL-:- 5." 1;t or!-,, !el ;l a!;*r* c^*-;e.S;K*--,r; 3;L-;; 3 t-,xg,-;:" .rls;l 9 6,_1lt4.Vr*
.r# rtirlei, | *.r*14 -,r r! ;,u; .-5 lr-i \ 1 f 0 J L* -,, -SrlS -. ;- r**X; l r,-t) .J--s liy-29e-;;,,Ui- a, ,f-r- .rB q JI J;.5 J ,29.[ ;*. *l-t *.jSl
.s: cg)s*;l ,S ;$3^s a.? )r sl ul_s* s * ;s.l ,:1: Jis: At(t , K"r"i
n G?"jl .r.o.,l ,.r.i:3, o-r..T :2-9 * 6r$i:;32.lrE !*" 6 Olj GJ-4 J &.o-r.;;;Y!l ;: u5'9 aS c:*l c*4 ."r;.r,: lt-,K-sL:!l;r."Jr, or-nJ.:JEs;M a-"L.gsLojil ;3.1 ;-: Jjl JEl u-tsp ;l 3l;i;t4,3 6lJc-jS-\ (t .ro; A\:rl ,i)Qr i.9t^r-s-,J,ri :" E "J d.:&" Alirs ,s"J eF.r_l -r 4f ,.^V 6lf.;,:,a3;3 6lrlj(;*l.,",.11;lr.;1,, -Jcl .re u-ty,z
.;*l 6_y-> rSJy ,-.rL t-,';'l ,-"E 3 :[-iil J-,rS al s:,Jl* -,, .-r---,lr l c.i.l" -rr d.16 ,.i-tn .,.(.:r4 ol-, vK a5 .:, L,-l; ;,-l ,s
"flt* qJ ;r,-l3 -*l o.,rui irE -,! ,h-" JLIL' .rtJ ;-1 .&i[- rL:il \ 1f f
"S ;i-S g,a t "-, al6'U*^r L.t; e,-l o-uL;:- jl 5.t^ .c*l ;T etr-" vb
WWW.AEL.AF
\r U dLei &-r,tu
;-"1 ;!l-r-e,l .r5 rtfui l2 'Sr;^ 6t;bNt lt! ,lrftj ..sGr"!, 3 j*.st^+-L-
-y j;:*.;trt-S !lr lr_r-.gGaale; r l^r[ lr* 6-t.sa"N-t ai l.:3a "r;i:- rtr);
S-- ? 6;* t.->;dp-l oJ c;l-: gl r,'i-t^ l."l .tS g otzillyiJ ;L-L>
Ju: -. :3r;, rstLa^Lr1 o;e-t3 I "J ,X*,'U^-> ::--+ <.r^i,r,-f.,L;Lr
,9L;,21a: -l\*,1 .9;L- G;i + 6 ol -,1.r-* r c.iL- sl3; ,n;G i pt .ftat.)--c.. A ,L-L; r"- tt-* ,31e;r5.ulyo.(5;l;;+"Ly .uUl.E.gGa;le;I
.J*"q:jl -\alF 19r,r19G.9rl;i * o*LJ 2 grLo:il tV oe*.Z;:.r,-l;15
;T .ruul, -r .rLolE: L* G."-t;Y:Q \ 1rr JL -," JV 'l-, *15 rrh !j! !.t rir3r rii.:a oS ;;t:'u^ r9lslil. s;*-r,;Ll3-.[.U .AV ,:5 .S-S-r"
e-l )l s -ul".rr5 *..,;' < l, ,'rr,- c;*l o.:L- ol; rLa.iil -e 4*F t J:, .S!, ,r,5
,rr !;* 7lS;-:42 )l Jeti Crz Gf; a: cPl-*" ,tj .stJ -,r.b l, .5--tt c-6
6\J- J4aol-,.:15 1: oti1rfu.sG.-,.I; )l ,s-t\-raS.u:^;1.: rl.;irl ;l:;J(il."r.$L- -:9i .f L"-! ! .pl:" ..r-l-r! 3 orjq .:La:!l y a-! )) )-r-f .gloc-ll, L
K-y', aU-JKj t r: .iK,.rr-l ;L:;r; I + ./ye rt$ I,Ji.S lJ ;+ q ^Si U*b
.r,_+ t rti-ll t<,-r"i;.: y c.!z ,r:; gn: & t-b t vK;-l ;L-K;l ;, 'rya
t-, ^J
rrJ ,l:;.|-,i J o^.;l; <.:**41, )-tu- ,r> L?r^ l+ y +*r Jl-* ifE,-r,<e c. +;-ir^ :r-l J-tt K--*i :, Js .fr ,-ry i;13;clr; lbe JLt-t"t-*"9,;:$..r-;rls,rL,j J + e5;l"r r5ly Ot(;t, r y;si;;, JiVo--5 6 .*< Ja,JILrl .rt d l-e:$; Jt,t; I ,l-u;i;l J: slr l, vKuL),ra13;5; 5l,jl ;l Jy,1l.r-; +>.J g;-L-, e+ !-.r".rl.^-!; ,-r )).tj -,1;;l 6J Lt;t )l alirr."ri.;L ,u:;ls u*: ;s l, 1-r"l ,,L;
(.f'-tr e ;r3oGt--:bNt pU.; ai c*l c5:.r..^.;;:.(b ;-^. [.] ,,-* 3
"S -.y ]-! Jy
9 ,1r,-,(,r "'lil eL+ a5 .pL -rolr; g9y-.: .,'lJl -, -,!rl t 1.4" jf, ,-fJ-' a, lr^:.
-5 g a-60:lS + -,se l, t";T L- s xll,rl +;L t rv, L l, 6rl-tst-:A^ts. J (*;\(il ,.91r.71 Jt rS *'a aV.;; Jtt ol-,:,l5.JL * +
;r-l . t'j,r ra- 6,V.1, L y 6 ":La.'ii I .;lrlS;r, + ti N :-.4 J L;: fr;"2 r,)i ;tJ [*:"",-, l-ry !,ry3 ;,t t-; ozL;., ..(--G .9 L^i lF .:Lj ! :,15
.+ jr- Gt":.tbi-t;r-$ ,&-la JX"u:*l u-L .;*l eLl .li;r;U-Jftt"ulr;.lr;c*^[i 9,-g;l.uul c*39- a, +;l;;L -,-b *l-, J-r*,.9bc*!!*3*;--l ..r-; I o:,ij .1i .r-- ;r j*'* o s) g--t t f J6\ ;: j)L I }[, I a5 s L:5
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtt J-t a \f
Jj4l rL; dr ..r-o-r.,r a;l;l ;lIT 2.: a--jti e .'lu;l ,J-l*'rl .].l." J"" -r; ./K,.s-s-:b}-t&i6-)L u*r "S c*l ;i vtS .r-1 ;G*s" ,r.;f+"jl .r(-.rt{\"5 t"z- a( -';lr .r1G2Le2: G."jrl ,a l1 jLld Ll {i"..ni,Jr"Li a;L'6rLa$l+5 -*l ,T tB ;--l 6L*l "j,.u ,a,a)- 13! 1 .'uc*l ,jl*- .9-'lrl "rs ,sl_t
Ltlt ir.- 6l;:t -.il.ul a, 6L-c*r .tlr.t .**;r ,.3;-rLo:!l Gt-:bls.-r5 .:L;'l
;*Jl-r ej ^S C:yL +:3-:,utr-.- -:lilj oql,s zVir 2 y) J*i +
.""J +l_y" a*:,*+ !.j:*p ,>L o"lJ"UrI
oilc.;'t!9Jir'-l* oK; ;lrl;;;il la tu 6l:" $l.rGi vL+;l 4lr.r. lrl E.r-l r,!;:,e,*6 @ ;l 9t5,t-l ter : t c +*;L*sl a, o.V +i3 ;"-[r ! a5
i ,-l*.t3;;l;L:;::l .,.)ty. oLS,tS.r.U rl't-; .€S ;-t:.ul..o"a sl.rr5;
'1"r-[.r a,,lfuV
\l'A1 oLyr-,13 t -al*.rEU; o9.!-j.3lsb.r.a>
,; ,,rW ol,-S ;5: {.-i .S-"ta 6>La:!\ 3 .r-f" 6\^o;-S\.JXL.jJ-,.1 :r -r;5 olK; .l.1Y._l .u-,\rAV.;
WWW.AEL.AF
.ll5.r-f "lt
Cr+st+t" sFt-, r.St<"*io
go.L# oS-Lp fttg {a, a5 sgrlil fU .s! ;i 6slr- .c*l o-u! G,rlr ..(1,.)t5 1l .5-- -15 ;ltrsro,-r-;rl-: ri)\c
"i.gLJ* ,lr.o;b-bO.: ,.t-t'gts;l s:*!:.., *6E :*,s,tVt;r.s13,,r.3 Jar;9;'sli"+ ;; 6V; c;K tr"i fL, ,S c*l gl5 .c*lL--l ; + vE .-_l 1t+, -L6 r-4 )l ;- .-utt ort ;';, I
"[U o,;l e L); 2l
Jt* -,. r3; ru;isl qlyl ,l .r*'L a5 jL; L'c*l i.i-, o.r,ia ollsl .913ral
.c;lK sgL a, \1ffI i-"./t-5 .!UT rll.; .slr sel+-"rL .(\ 1V\ ) J*i a; ei_ g; :r.r>
,Slr: ,t-\- L.r; ";t..r-;l
4-.. i {"}ii. .ri.r3a .f'-[^ ,'l*, .rrr ;l-lL o-r:-t:.rL-j
c-i-.,* 1:e-;l aS;e-l cry.q.cj*l t*U.<,-G 5-*15 r1 ;,-l 4l+!" -h rFL!,-r-l ;, &S ,-* + l-,"T,d asL;l ;14 l-r {-r: -l);; ,S a.l jl J+ y fi! .r,
''d" o[
JL,'p-ru- .JrL 1t-; L;L, ",;l-l $ v4;^;;l l;:y; sla:*;l , d$z J a;,;l:
l;aT a-"rL;i;; ,L;il 6^ aS e*\,_ttt 4"4 ,Jl:* ,r-l 3"! ;r-r:JE aS .;.1
.rL;r 3 dliJ- 6l* oj<s ^1
.9$.;32 L, .(","(,-b 23..e-97, tSi : g aJL;.pl-r
c.-! L.t;i JQi.;ul.rJ;*:r; gL-.rU:* 2' 3;- J-* -t" a5 c*l jl3ry
1. Der Weg zur Knechtschaft: Den Sozialisten in allen Parteien, 1971, Verlag modernIndustrie AG, 86895 Landsberg am Lech.
t: "*is- -,, Jrr Jl ,.L-Ji a-.-7r, q)^ ..lr-J; :/L" ,iLJi -1.: a5 c-l u:'-lry j))\ J,l
.t'f *4 \qr^ JL2. collectivist
WWW.AEL.AF
6tt,l: n \?
.f-r-;r to6'[ ,;T;a o3)lc ."r;l Jzr "n*,
jl "i.i
l-t ,s* ,9:l;1 ;;2l e Lr*. aS o.r.:,
:;lf o;L-2.r .(--Lo ..gGd..t,j+,,GOT ,l;;r .r!Iorj, ^;l-V €;L;L.5..ul;
t-";T;b.tjo aJ -u-..r.s-,ftT -l*'ily KL osL .,;J ;i[bl d ,u1lJ g; L-):.Jjl.), *.r] .:;tl ;: l_s
,l;:6 ral c& 4V & olL3s.aolL &l .i-ti -,1 J+:,K "!lrj! -,r
: u,sly;l t,#.rL(:i 9 C)leJL-q-;r e J-i:*. y.t6-,lr CW .ejc--r3*L .i- y Jb .gl..t;L,T .9 l1 l, "l;^;
y g)Uc J J,-b,*i l, s,els t*cl 4.a* ..;l or3, .*Ls ;lq.;l;
"g.7 .9l1ls ./l-:t d .:.*ilr;3L uli j .;it-t.dil. rL'rl ,! qlyl .rl-i .-,6 I jl-* ALp + _* oyral I iJ :lj;
"i,.t+,4,"U'.-r
"T f !, Ll .d^j( a-alr- ;;*;** ir+ sr-r &l -2.: -r*l jt+ ,rr^ ) )lK;l
./q l, yral sLl37 Jjli.f ,tJ rS +V l-, ,-*r"" .1137 ol). s OV E o2lsl ;L*J-.1 ; erl.,.iL:-;.9lra L-t;T;l .<--la rS,ai jl .r..r j SJ?;lzes o)5,4.-r:5s3; ;lzLf;l .g;Lur- ,Sl-t E l, 6L1 o;lJ g; a!_, y .# o-rU';,,| .:3- ;lreL.+.i ,t-rt aJ,ls s or3- L;T 3* ;l rn
'l 4;ly.,o:2.ru * ,.sF ,"sL.:.i ;rtiJ,
2, 6;[- t> a;L-lr{ gf g;GU--; ,rL+ jyrl .c*l orz9l .:-9.3 a, o"ru.il-ei 3 o.iio-3,
o-., f l, j.J L 9er-l .c-,,1 JJLI- oi olr r J-l UL. Ll ,r.,l.rrJiJ JL--q gb t<.u.:Gl3T
c.-l.r-o> -* s ,<,3r.*.Slt !i)) ,<<;5r.:- G)<1uN2ll.o;lr,* g-l $ ryau" *K -"yr_* otl;;i* Grn Ol*. )l ,to_*-t".f-*,5L
"_y 3 ,,*+ 6lr-;l :c-."1 "f- JrU ly, o.:-,nJ.9Ga.[7 A-b ;l V
r.-tr, -; -t) t?.Str + # ,:V:s1.r,-! a5 -r,j.r. r-9,-.J aJ G-6lJ;.sL;6Lt(;rt1
;lr* ;--1,tr y -K-" *-h )l :;u;Lr,.t2;l t l;,rLl"fL.rl dls.:+-* -L.+;L+ .'.i5, i . jr- ;l:c*l J3.r ,.s_y- )l 0"j.3,.91.o.9;2a.Lr1 "u2!.9L+ q 6"_*.s- s:lS +\ ol3;orL; oLlSj! aLp t-i 5 .r.r.usL .gt^"ijrlo"i3 Lrtaa.LJi r"ji, 4l _e Jl.:3* *-S ,t r, .g[;,re[j+l .gtrcJr-- 1t4l;o L:;"1 -ri! L- oti,2.rlJr...;l :r.-li c.-La 0"r5. i^" jl -u;l-,:1 L'"r.:.-a ,:l:.>.*;6r J---* * jFe a i "yr-l o4i ''q o.,"*.1 rrjl_9|;
",ne;r Ja!> slr.
,d-S tlr, or[i:-.| :y-n otjL3 o)J-e a-y r! qlyl 6l_rr. ;V;;l a( ,r.K,".-:3": rl.r^Iii i jlsls Jlrb *. c;lr,r.
o.:;3+ Js. a;L-lJ :; cgt^.).jJ I J* \ rt"l J € "G;rl, r;; K -:u: Le ; eer"l
1. conscious direction
WWW.AEL.AF
\V tr \qV2 JL:.h^:h ,,8G*
o.lit-l.c*l .-rr5 c';,e, l1 ,K:"t+L; i,:;2 ;-l 3;" cJ3" *.i1 ,g13,2: .c*l*jJ.r[.;,ti;:.,iL"6 * ,rlj*l 2; ssafio .,,-lr;..o,',<cJL, q}o 6lo"i3Al-,-. s ,S* JKs;g;Lro-:*. ;i..llr sglra .<s3,- ul13.l pldl 2rr, .9rlrl;i:rl, .9ly
all3r a-5 -.*l: crL- bl-s-e,a[: -;--l 2.: r-!: !.:21": r3-.9 6-,1* glJ-rt,*, .i-Ll aS a:$s}.s:*l o"r*.; 6:l I or!:, ,r15"; i D+-) r *. ,eG €.9t '^ i Jl- -,, Lr-' .j,-l 155;4-t? .i- -u"iu iae,.i)l t-l ,-,5.r ,it* ail)J*,L*l ar l*;'cJjr -Jt i .ri 2, ,5 s,-15 ,d.j[- .;r "-il"ul dr,-l a, Jlicr. Jl-d.t.rji.r- sgJJ 1;\.Jt JL+, l-, O[;rF.-il"r-ol -rlr;1 -rlil 6T JJ:.:;; ,S qr.,-tV
o.ru.l, -i'lJ 6rV ,ylJ-t^, \ J*-s.s! JLIU'aJ .:*l .s-,K-riL \.; ,l;i r\;t'c*l
.4-xoa N o-t-* rslo"j,3 ,-* -.i-:l;l y.il.ral "rr, ^\l: )l.ltl..U^
c--Le a-.:L-lrf ga .tl;l:l ,.r-;;lr ,pl +.:L-frrr .il-r-ol - ai .r,-b;'[ ;l .9;!.-a:*:;lr.rtjilcl -31 "".ralei ou-i..r;5 lr, l2 3r;-l ibi\ $U-l 4s'. uSu"
V ;l 3,_--l s ,)-lyrJ ":lil cgGjJl.*i ;+.'rj .ft+l dt^&)lri f t*-!.ralr; -.r; j." 4"A ,,s;S g* ir\lr,,.l o2"r! jl (L r;,- J- *!l) -.3; dLooLil
or l-,.rT JIJ-d ;-1, ^S -;*l .r,-L;-r9; y -LL*l "u"jtn lii otLr,-, ;-l .'u
,u2,uii sglzlr t<.r.3,-rr g;ta.rL; I lt- ^S S-l J2, 'c.-.4 2 u4*-V2 3 ,r3i .>*,
13; Otil2ll ! ,ul-r.r dlt-rii ;y+ i.grl-o slr.il "t JL -tt ,t.tirt :-e73 4 oj;
f;U: 3 0"3- ,,Si;, "[J+
.r-r! ..r,""r 1l+,1 5.j Jl.ol i )&15 a;t-ll3ls ,.91t(r
,>*l "!u :1, J *et".i-;l"U:.L.c*l c*;)t c.3! 2l oLt*l as*
;l el;r-;l ;--l L' ,rzlr ";nq -e -:llu--l ,l a5 o-Lo.uL:-.; ,V\,u;lJ g7lra aS
1Ur 2.: aS JY.r-.I .)Ferl.r^li;; ."rilrsJ!; a, jleli s a'li 6 ,e-l-1';
.c*l ,r-l*t Ur-.11x--l e osjl olg;l Ll orL ,)-*d ^:l;l u;lJ g7 ^--b :l
..(-- 3 ore-.1 rsj" t aiGt<-.iJ" ,4iu- +Jlrl ,s--VU;l lLir;-t a5 JYul Ll
l2 4- aS .aLraT -t t r-rb..:li I 2 I 19rl.n*.i 2.: .c*l f"d* * cl)Iip JX.u. I
6l-* )l -n:*;t**t 6lot--s t H s xb ;-* { cr{L*l .91; ,-uL,r" ;SeJ)."rul4itL- 4-"i i)lJie
1. establishment
,:.r-* J.il:S a,,1l -,r 4U F >1-ea 4;l::v *dt);l'Lot;l y (\11f 1: o-tJo.:3il).Y
.:Li:-l :lj.5La-,1l;L j:-9-u* cJ3: -^-a:1,!cr -J J.*l lt4b 4.,\qOt u'llrJ ,U;KG*.c-l ii JIiU" 1SU- r t*F 6 or>.:.. c,)!l ,> 61, -r-Li l:* .. i € ,t
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jt-rJ-,n \A
:l ^S (ar'
,*-, ,r#l) Jp Ut )l t* u.f )' e-15"t t c"lj € * 3;.,rLr.a;, Jl3* i.,--l .. ryt" S;*l ui*bs oa ;" "2K g..(,_t^ ,*lr JL) )Uil
.c*l ;3Li G+.i-sl .rLr6 2, s 6i$ y^l\ 1f A JL* 2s ,-r.ir-i vL+ .(-l^ g;t"t"f.J< ! d s,-t^.,T ,dls ,_yl..,t-,.7 ;",l-.i jl L.lj a-1 i-Jy: ,.;1"r. .r,:t ?4. r;rS oJ.oLi- l_t cS*,.o jl jJl .gG.uL":;,;
s rst-tbNt L*_; e'S d.p)L s Gs-te\tf lri.l-;("tr LL"o L_ ..grrs drlji.r"r;s "u.,; ,!ti_ra;; a; --qL- u"j\S.:L-; c,";lr; cSr ,y-1 ,"[^c;r Ll .4r dr3-li.rt^J-^s cSy- )1.9-r;' .9tt"r:Sl'2 u-2=;i .l[li 2r 9 .o-\aL ;YLl 1.: a; J ^;ljJl+J c;rL*;l c*lr " tS-t* \ G^.Le,Sf 3 c-:,1s.::-.y cgjL i;er.9.:lu.-l
.;"J o1raf plr ,:Uirl S*"J c-15 € ^--b -t ,)* .r,i J j,S .y-l )u e-\ h \,.:-llr c--"pl t ,:li-_r )) D)--J * 3 ,J:l GJ+ .$)y."}.^!r r.l e-l :s s*3, iril6)--s \."r; rt(;i &-t^; .,4- ..>,1 64 e"lj e Af:^ ,.St-_tuN,, * .c,,V,-n-
trr";-){o dr J;rS, *;yt-t fr;;^ 61-2a.N2..r*Ll ;LlJl d.rG
c;* .1!-(, Jy<N_S.tL^)K a- l; .:lil aJ .:,;ls ;;-r.ri Jer J ,t* ,5 *O.*p "-.r.-ury -5= "!l5.rlsl + Ub_-,t.rr ga j-ra Jt*J.Sl^;r ,l , ualrt:l;IA: ) r-i .j[-1;.t :e. :Sr* tS22uNyi*jp"agj a. &;V; O,_l 45 s.t<rr #).rrq .ii.e,r"!KN b,- ,"J,.r J-i"S lt G"lj € S ,s-K-" 6r* .G*.ral_r4rfT
5 ! -, o-u:gq*' "-il.r,rl a, O':.',..-t Glt L CL, "r5 o;l:l l, to5; -r3; ;rG Je.:
S,4lf1ry 6\su32sr* 9.g-,..-lrtSL.!)L'! -,, Jy. .*5 .,.6"rrjL"jL utrL^ r*_yglr-l 2r :3t;-; ls: uJrG +;*; .9sL-1 dbr,-i,:---, d./-+ ."9 r"; #
.-r."1 -:3,-.9 1 [,o+"Lr1
s* &f:>: S J-tS l;;J3-' "u;r.:^;1r: G6€ *"-b J-iS,dl;Lts_y.- ! Js> t-; o-r"lo;lrl G+li 6G,Jt s ;l ;1.-r;.e;L ;r-; l;.ri J,,:,
1l .J3.: JL;i:l .gLrr."N-t,Sy- \ & s er;.gt^c5;; t .a* * J-,W
:3-* -3t g;lo"r-c.9lr4;\*;rtsl .!.ro ! rl,sl ;:;l ;UL.srrici J#.:L-<l .uU
"[^c ;-: l^l ;^tJ 6" us_yo -lo atj ,J o---, ] Gy.lr, pL a, ..rfu ,S .u
,).r,-)y1 u.l; g;;a'.: 6Srsj c-J +;Kta*.r r*!u.l, dGajlzL- )l ,r;J."J rs er b & ,"f , jl .srtij udl pl-r" yb q Je: a74
l. control of engagements order
WWW.AEL.AF
\1 ! \qvt JL rF ?h tU;S;..
,c;1, ,LAcl s--lrf)i * $ 64 gglra o"r.T;*;4, 4+., .Loa.i-:r.:l .r\: tr,t J t--.-;'a. t .xeL '-$;trr*a.r-:l_r.r"
-nl .r-l ,-b.(- rl .ri ,;;1;^-V2-J. .J-
;rrS 3:^L". a-(;--l -.;*l .rrJ ro-l; l).i-G "l--l
.t(.r,-, ,\.rl .l.; ^;eSl*.*l,-r,Lool, a.;LDel: .9)K-+ O--b -,1 t Jr- c.-l.r.r p-rl ,l rlril .gbcJLi.6"lil 6j* ar ge: s Jt-t e-y- *. Jel ,s-y.cs ,;; ;r[it" y"tS l* t5 | I>lSl 6lraj5r;:. c*l"r.r -)5,s" il3ru ;ri 4 i 1,t.93;t-l c;l;y .5-- ,al AL*
.O|ol; rS-y- +;*l .ral, a;Lllel: cg-,ifu s -fe Gy + c*l ,ralz.9rloL:.r-l .srj,et'l; lr..u;rJ-i5.^1c
"*-!T.(- Ly-rrJ ef :,Sr AVI
r;;lr r3-9 r:;lr 9.f J;l,4;l gL-f--;lr*" t.$t* i-r.i ,l:i; rr ! jLrr"l, drtja iUt-5 ..91".r,r: Ll ,slo.u:; t.t- F"K_ )l S,4 rl .pl.; ;:lr* ;l 2: Id-r-{. l; ;l;l 6f--> : f-* c"-l-r,t ;p- .r-- -;r;la:ir,-.r," .f Lr-l .ra:.1L1L .91y
;j.: 4;j34; rs-. :s4..t r a[lT a : ,G-r;LIT .-a^ rt*,T ){"tS * 6-b .c*l3 slu*,| ,lr-." J-J &_ 2, .S C-,&|- 4i 6lse*;: Ctr ;l lr; .i:5- :r;
.Jst s.grl1T;T -3"';-b p -t u;-1s'.-lf- .l.,ti. otii.; tt o.fr J-t,[lT "u;L"a j*j r.a- J J;lJ*l,a;!.13lr- 2-:
.rL.rlj! ,5o d-+,lj e 353.u,j:"ry ,r,,1-L ,)2.\<&-,JL.-,y, -,y\i -,,j-)
-,t:"r..1 1l 2Ll,*:r .rLiLrr. j rri.."o;"r- E-rfu, JL;: --r-;l*,-t ;ia ,l;T
;fu S b:e C_S + Gr*;eS o216';e$l.,iL*J"l,.o ;l ,y:;l.srL-J,-5-.qf, dp-l SrSS'r^ "j};r jt+: .rl^..-o **=ls 6ly 6-s-:+^t-t 4..-Li 4.,j; .,l&.,1..x es:- )l J rr; ;-L3V.:r crbj-,. 1l c*l ts4 6 c*l u;*-#
."s afi_b,-.r; ,s-* g;taj ,.<,-t6 *--b ;l 32; j l;)*,-f,U 6,-.,L-;-l ,,c/c.tlJl+J .rr-t+t .5t-o.r"rJl .;!3., .9!-l ;l .,,-to.uU;;
j -,'6,raLj5 o23r.i- jl .r-".c-,.G;.rl1i ;r\-q t-> -* y.LS oS ;*l ,"J cSr- G*^ tti;-lJ.o..rr;o.r-ot*i-
.9$ .gLorl-ll ,l .f--b .--l .4!r. 6lrt .c*l r9r3 J3: 9 u.t-; ;.$JV*ulj( a-., &-;l .;...,3 j c-- ,o)3ral .V-tc:r -b * L-* d;).E lr',5L
p_'p J"G &* + tS g-;; l, J-* ,y-l sl_r.r 6h \ a(rr-l .":p.r. oLlll: det.9L-ooK-r--, sT;, a-5 ,'-ll, j! .i-b rl ,9$-t -lS t nJ.; 1 L ..:*l
,jtt olr./L:S 45 -f;U""..r5,slrl *S U Cr.i-.rF JYI a;;=;;SiNb oti*t d e;-g ;Jc ..i*l o-:l-: xlrl u.:;K -Yl * .--*, l, ,r,-Gol3.q,
WWW.AEL.AF
;!:y J1 rs tr
.-91-9L-; a5.r-;"3-J-j:5.,- o-tj.;-. .-"6 C4 jj..) ryr{ 2, o,.V .rt
^S c*-g d:-tc 5Ji.," 1Nt 3 t1;t i1 g21-:+_Lr* pU; 3 -r:.a;.r. ,* x\l-St;..:*l ot(-r,--' ral -tJ[' *\.rx ,5o ;,q.9to,r.;L;
.i- .r*l lJu* r- Glj< 19 ) fu::;t]!t ;"-Lc ",;-l;]l
,.r.:rL .-"r5 i:L_e try .,-ltr5 OT 4:l ,,s& JC;Lp j"j ir,"l .<,-ta sLs o.u! c.o! -c*l ;.;;-;143-2.s-^,U OIq 1l ;l1i r.: wt;S +rt r/L ,S 6.!;l:.r".1 -r,-!.-*t, -*[;3-- -^ j! y rr ,";lK ,gQ2lolr-: -l o.r-il" -YL-l ,r;i 4rl ,Lul a5.uL't
,',-.r; G;i + l-, .-&K .5,t" .t -l;l .r.li .sln;-*Jl*.J-, .s-y- )s*"'9"1j 612t r 3 o-Li :L+ .r-"! -3-t t\.i- .r*! .grlri.gl-o;L;l a( "ualj;,r" -St ,S e
'sr r*l'-aJ .:*l ,-"::;- q.r ,dy .:15 iUT:E 2 aS 6la.$^if Jit" iljb\,y\l;.qlr-.r rlr-_, ;ELs-p...r;L a:;l: slta- J-S ,* a- slguj o;9r^l
;l2l*) rl a5 o"r; c.-cL ;n4 4':." rLe, 1b@ 3 .r;ri o-y i-;.- 2: ,. *J J
r*JL*:* aJ ; .l .r--l -, -b 6l;'l .eer"l .:j^i .r*5 ,;-,,*,SrU (i ,t-tf gr6l;5.;.;3, o-"L;15,;ri *)-S .y-l Ll ..:*l d.J-iJ" .<, g;;lra,-Lr* J d**-fu, .<,-
;l c* ^J JL- 2r.*l ,rJ)J; ,.4-Lun.-r*"L;ita
"t(",,_, oa.,;i G_y- *
---b -,1-ulicr "L.d
ar-: 14.l jaaJ-;*l c?ra; d^.5JLJ sl;T.9b1l1L
Ll --r.5 1Li-' .g-'Laril :s^l s, Jer JL;-' l& s -;S t *J rUt< top .9rt;i-uS.r" ;-[r Je"r u;.rii .rj;S aF * ,l t5t_r -,] * efi*_t-t a-t+ c"_jSl
stlJ tt.:lr.il ;l c-qLa- 612c*l .r,ol2 Jer;r$ u;-lj.il Lyg 6Jn ++ l:_;
'ol- -.a.6ralJ "B)l L- 3 c*; t**,l c L;l< ,r- J^tJ ,-u.Sti .gtiJ,-:alf,i,:*3r..r5,r. .rlrl l-t s)-tL.Jt:.;;l+ ,.9t-o.:alr. .9! ,j. a.L; ,51 o2!2":
.r:5 rLi 1;;i i-T rrli"l Ll ,.r;L u"_5 'L"1.: G;);gS ;*l ;*
;YL-l jr-5 c*t or vLS;_l ,,l; trtaa:-t it )ln S f"J "2Ul;li,i2,;LL-l (tJ )J-/. c:.-!
"r-*. ..,; ,,+ ,9-r-;.: ,5 e*l
"it j jl -rii-r)) or.di.a
Js ,rs,- ja@ rK l!, + + ):yl \ a---l;L;.: ;L-, ;i ,s-5. ,s16... (r,ijl,7
1,1: &* rl J-n .r3r;; J3; ., "rl L' s'J g J^, ;lo ;1.r, a*i(;,
:-l:- F-t )l "b*r- ."-5,.f ;JL;.: :yl :s -ii-S 9 os3, )sfl )l ;3*6L-o;T; ,,.r1;,r" L; >r; tS-ts+t c*L-, JL e-;a.,l -,,
trK-, ol Jy, ,-r"jiS[. Reagan
WWW.AEL.AF
I \ ! \qvt JL rr* ?ta ,U;KG*
Gii 6lr- tJr-t
sgLar-"Lra ,4K1, r.rT u>4 c;ly.,r J: $),-;atS l)
.rl-rau orU., uJrlr t,*,
4lj; :,$..4.9b.(J e tac*lr. .[*p -;l .lr; *.tr;l --cl-;J3, JS CrE .-r:"rj,r.rr lr-l * u$* u.;K-r.l .1'J3I-u i/Y J (JL.
\ 10. Jt* ,, .i- --f , "lS
tay Y0 ,l o.l-;i ;YL-l 2s -& :,r:Jt-l ,JlrJi
.r;l o.r,*2 \ 11f JL 2r Lazr f O t !,"r-e.F .q.....i ; 1<** ): S.;l a5 .:-l dt- ; t*;b-,1 ;, c&t ;+*
r rl-,i.EL^;l-,!;l Oy'l ,re c^*JL-:-- -.r-.(-- \->lp u;K 2" I JrS2y u,*)V*.9Gc*!, .3t-; of ;; ,\S ^L;V :r s S r? 7G: u.".;6s-t l. ol-s * .Jy, ;KJL J rr(Lc 9j- )l r"J e*,"2j u^ ;t l,r-l * l_1 J2lSc--L.,.slr-.1 e-e^e Cf lU rl ;;l_r;j f L'l-l .*l(,1.tr:L';rt(rL rrjrK1l -ro <rr*l J-LS,),lyU &ir.ry jl * aJ 'ui o":l;.;,1 JUJ.sl^.rj;l ,l J_r",.
,lro" o,r-;. ;YL-l &," trai 2., aSr,-l f* t.:3r or^:J ,+r jLa 31s, 3;-
Jt* t t-*-: ,,ib^l J-9s Ll ,-:3r oJ; tlSlt u.r-; ,"r4 *;r"l ;l ,rr-r; j,l!..sS 4 tr,l -tt Gi4JE, e "15 {,-} t,
"i "r"-5, )l rsi;;*F- \ 14.
s e-l-5"s.<-;)l;ji.ry$l 6-e*))* r" 3 g--&. Jl 'r..ulr; Aal-*l.g-risr' lrrl t l, 4V- )1.-' aS JL -,, ,d e6J+ l; .r1G, c;;ls+-L-,*
.,.; tS, t,L;; t a:eaer-; lJ .; d.i lss b-
{-tl ,sl-t vV -, 'J ell: 6t" ol-r:,[5 .i)Ki \ 1f . -rt La, -,, 6GF-S> i5";3,i .*y-: +r &-t" .J-t r:;:a;U*t(t 2: \ 1f f ,-1L ."rr;.r;L) r;ia.s o.;*,:u;Y!l a1 J*-1 ) -,5 ,Sl-r. J,-*-Jl i.rat1 .i- ol* *d r(--Ji<.
, -.i oJ-i ,ls;;l AKalo -st 6.;V 1L;'l ,r,-l;ls cia-t"t* o;l.rl ;., \ 1f f JL ;.>
a5;--l 1l J.+.rr+.r1.:2li -15 r/E "r!_,r,;lS,.r.i;L .(_ ! U rlr,,t,2l;;lJl: -;u-'31 orrS r; l;dl.iq;L *- ,4i rtl 6lS* oK;1, ;lrL*l + vK,2-e* &- 2., $l-r- 4JJ--l L" e rr5 -r-olr*, q* o.tt.:\rS 6 "r,;;lr rUirl L-
rJ3r or.Li ,-J, 6 tru,3l(.> o.*;r-r.r.
J\:r^ ?N.i- :*L l, *6 t^;i..rrL-
l. Johnson 2. Bush 3. MargaertThatcher
,r! ,(Alex Philipson) i j*:J+ u-Sli y- r.5 *r ,l *-l g*; t _i- _r, jl Jr!..i a3
.c-l o-r-1 fi".il ft<:j ot(-:il.: ul;l i:.1 ,[rl;1,4. Fritz Machlup
..\.5.t< fq u, ,Y +:l::L ;: \qOP JL.r*r.:ta;: e(,La;ki5";* r.A
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jt_, "lt n YY
:L^ '61 .3,5 ,-.b ;L 61_- ,,zs- 'nrr52-, asj> *lr3i.r*Kt th .Et^ayi"rS..:-.jl.r a, al-:.rt-aiil .5-- Al-rr +3;. Olt -,1 .r* e;lr.r-ii I 6W otK;1,
al.:rLo-:iil .i- aS Y<e,:"-L; .el "*l-J, ,Ji +k" ..>1., .rLji .rrrit .t(::1, j Ay-
J--[ -- ,]-- .#tt rL&,, ! y .#;iL;.' l; ta.uy;-l ,r3, oL(,J,.;1, 2s d+2.rl: +*; ,T o1 lzeT.*l5 :h \ 6S$ ot(;lr;lrLtl
;.: ;l-9;' it "11g;1, &-[ao!5 rel,ijb )l ,r,. * otS,-:.;1, ;lrL;l4-.r .r-r-, :tt= u*)K;l;+E ^- Li,J, aS 4.1g;q t ./tiJ ;*lr;n oJ-*15: l -r2 l-i t(-r,i zr ri .rL rsl t sl \ \ 1 f f J L _l*rri r, - :j I r; * lS-- r-l ;*-> e
"[le I - "u t-.1 r I r2 lji t(-r.T ;, :Li vE rSl t E .3L; OLp :' V-* .'; U^l
r.: oJ-i,.iq1; 8..,T;, ,-rL e, -t:8 *;U*t3;t .1t j 6lxo t _* -J-rja1 "L ..i- ,pf :" ;<* S.rj1 -r[;l;3-: jl4; ! ]i, lU*.t(t 2., Jel .,L .-q34
i *V)st.Lr* y ,rJ6r ,r:3 ,:p;i;l G*"L;e; -:: y .rl!L. -tt .ii-t '*sj,llrl l.-o,r,-15_-"lJE , l y-z; )l Jt-.--l L Ll-"u;lrr, rr j *.raK.u;|7Srs..so rr;b ,s.s;+l:S 6*a.vL5 r*' * :.:T r,
"r-* .l^^L
#.+ cI. l-, vK -,-1.?EaL: urii. ! y -E -,1',-y, 1: \ 1 f f JL* *4* f^r+^ t, f tfu :L,Ua-.-r*l ,t2! 4-l ..:31 .giL-il;l .rt.t?l5 )E:n ) J-,;-orla-3r .i- oJ
t;&*
.9 ,i: "Jrl> ,+.-5,-s.r, lS,,', olK;1, ;lrL:il -,Llts.rLz ei2, a5
0;3(*l
jV S;:.-:i 2r 3'uK*2 ,j-sr:l L*i*l;.-,;.* 2s -r.i, ail;l -15;-l ,a,5rr.SL^;-; s o3*; -[:51 &- l;oi,r r3-t {$-brs.$.t- yl rii ..r.*r *F *nrrja.g-; S3-rsl-;.gst* a-l<1y;5 l,
uaJG .9-,la r;i 5;l 1l "p
Ll .;ulr;,r.
,r,-L-rc*19;;.r )_s; J+ u! ," .yr"9, o":l; ,12[u rE -,1-,.6n t, b l:, .f tr ,f.+r:
":r5 c-iL;r LroU y-L e.g"r.Ja,.;U!*l .;l1T.9t"61.5 4:,1:t.rh .s! l-,
d ,r-rr. oslr ;;[.i*- J+ -,l,l6y" -,rl-t 7r th ,*$, fi] J d-.-:.r rr J f.,-re...g-rl-:.,i-lil rq;l;ro: + lrrT r* 2:,
.9111 [o;15 2 ).:e. a;;3;sLU t, rl5 t".K;r; )l ,s-tV*.rNSl .L JJl {.;.a L'
JL-p j | . . . ),er o.r-.i, d:-.r I rt-; t5 ;s s3-!,f t"-"; * J @ i J J.F . tjtt*-,-t?...:y ,iLy 2, ;l ";1,
Ll ..ul,.r. o.rl: .1[i; 6T 1 .grL; ..1,-U .vlrJ 4!l JU::il
l. Aaron Director 2. Frank H. Knight-ul o-ii (C. Hartley Cratlan) j),Ulf ,rl.;)La .,.- ai \ qf 0 +, oL 6J: ;: 6 .gluLi .Y
4. John Chamberlain 5. John Scoon
tl. Sunday Times Book Review6. Orville Prescott 7. Hcnry Hazlitt
WWW.AEL.AF
YT tr \qvt JL rF ?t+ rtx(Jjt
4-1 + 4J s,Laaj,l;L; c;j5 [r>.;*l 6rU e Jra J_s*l Jq J-..,.[ o2!;, -r-;.tl-r;.r- -,,ro 1rr*) ..:*l +3L- .p-l;.il .9:L-, -r- L' ,-r3;.r" .,;13 1rLS
.r-olr-.r- *Gl-s.i_G;r:.;l-r, b r:;lr;.rr tr;l U6i lr-:t:5 Jrl-a- &;b.K-
.rt( I-r,;K
43 ); :Lt l-, ./tit jl ,ir*o)a \ 1ro JL J--,i :" t,,.--.41,
):4.:t> l,=Y
!/L- ! .-r-:5;r '<oL -L;5 -._#r, L*i j ^-\; _rl uS ,ly;-;,t ,l .b.
JL -,k -rr r::lj 4t.<,-t^ Jl-;,;* :i * ari ! r c-,-+.ls rr\-r _r: -15 +-)L
1L+l n-: o"j-S ,_rL + lt.; liq a5 ,*J ,r^^ ill)Ltil ..rar 1h-;l \1f0:_*l: olll;;11 9 a:rS ;9t= "rL 2l;or t l_,:,6)kxl jit5:3J Ll .sL,4jEuLS r, .Ll;l S :E .r* glsl ;, l;.rl , ,r;-[5 -15 glsl ,l L.c;L
.-:ylr r3>.3 sL- -L OLp;l rlt S-" y 3^ ua",::jl J*-.. 6\5.j" oL(:;lr.il)L:.-xl ,"tS re.rl ,L:;rl;l a( JL.L- .r! 2r
;l .9j--cl5 r-L L )"\.c )l,.o \Y0 J ,r-l*lE ! ,"rr llro A\ ,*1+ O*t*" pq-.i_JL" -,, *J fll dl-& rl- L a5;lrL:tl ,-r-l :E l3l .c*l 4r;ri l, utl5
*t:5 +-l :l :V q: i...; .:3-E;.: a5 szl.,.r. rtrLl ..<,-t6 _* t"lr1
..:31 \ 1AP
.rl^aii ,r1,.t r((an^^i
o.:rr> e-.L. ,r, GrJ ,S\s-rl 6.r.t(^ .rI J o9)tc .e;l o-ri vE...r-: 1l+l ,I.^.1U ,,-L VU-t , *(; .;t--l ,LJi.r-, LgLajlj a i )V ts s o$t).rL"y-p 2" j-e 6-* 5- .<,-::6 ,r,-l oJ) \ J.(-la,.glo.u; A ;^.*.fu .c*l
.:ji o)J. cSr*.-,,-l ,t: :*++ 9 r*i 0., j-i..;: "=n.J a, :Liirl
-nol+ "rlgl ,-9b.1l3oL J lar# _,r .i6 a;lrl,i rl*;l ,-12 ;1e." gL,y; AL; rl
,':y t-o135 r,-l ;.: a(,.,-la"iL-2-: Lt+ )Jril," gL- rl .c*l .U 7-jl;til ,hL ,SS-tp
..uLr.tr:"ali)ic L,arl ,* *,J> ol_,,.:15 ,y-l +,s fl ,* +.i-b +
l,s : ,r*+-$ .91-o,-,-j-, ;, el -!.iL' \ 11Y JL* ;r &G -1-" 6V; ;lel ;l;L; .:2l.r -:e-.3 .,L.1 g;rl;i oJ
"!L; L: .c*l o-r-:; aSLrl j-* ,r*ir5
..r:; L, le"ro"l orU I e3i .:tJ ;_l ;:S + ;$tl L,r.: l-r,r
qr.a,-J Orj4a
,j,li r! c.:.2,; L-l olK-:;b
\ l1f .[.r:T \ f ,li,.iiJl,5
1. Reader's Digest4. Iron Curtain
I
!
2. Book of the Month Club 3. Lawrence
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
I tYt JL"r c'r:c.o ??;hif,j*,! L'"u^' ar- dpi j,j^ tr \ 1ro tj' \ 1r . .gl.rJL .ry : rliT c,J-3 ;: 8 ,.:6 .r-l
drr- r,-Li 61")* * -:-b a, ,o.r; a;l,!l-(; ,.:ja J.;i , h- ,1[^-il c:-i ,$b;t Cr L.i;'u;;; ;,-l ..:*l ou J,-J? +j .(- 1, aJL.9. c.,lt-, c-6 :: cr 6ll.
JjE -,, q5;tj ,;r:: ;l o"r-:;:r5l2l lI; a,1l.';l ,. .r-l;L ..r-L-l 0.r.,-l; ,-r,--r- ;'t-,Li9.,4.t e)Z-fWJ r rsl-tr:;r'l-::L- b.ul c.p! al Le-L*l ''r r*i(t .95;.d-5 Jt*rl \1fA JL- 2; ,o\* rji; Ll.;;.: +JLii. 5,- sL,<or:J rL-ji.il LrJ.))
L*. e 7 ;i, !, ft(+ oK;;1, )l j+< .d .tsf )-yse-r.c*lj;;: + a5 ,u:l::L--tt-J
J--[ l* gt-b 8,y"lL-q , .c;U- rL:r,;l -o el uory* c*!* iJLztr r' .rl-rl:p
.rjl.<i- i)l)l dL- .$L #r".r.-s*Kt .3,) alFe pti 1"r"-:,r. oS ,ii':,o::"
Li-r"T;, ,T:l-; uJ-.:Lf ,)r- a;- y.t5 d,o.i!J" fr'le .l)lr I' r l1 aJL; ,r-l
..r,1*l 6*.f .L-r ur".5ly &;,:lrSs;-r34 ,*oK;t ;, ,T Vb ,l ;a"l;$;t" 6;-
.(--;--l d lr- .r; fy"l V-l-r- -t5 rl.;-1,-;: o5 u..r.o.ar*ls ;Trl Jt-;ru- aS -uuil-r :Url .f U?l 7* ;: c:"rl(e;l.li-:.;l-r -dl Ll ,c*l .e*t - 9L(
;l a5 -;lr.;;l;t-; u-L*l ;'3;- t l*-5 rK +.r^Fl p:s L,r-t".,1Ut-r;
o-:;; ;l el3';.,i b..,,-l r, .l*t ;lS.e.i rLdl ,l 2 ^;lK tlslt\.rj> o.:-eJ3
o.r-;. ;l[-l -, !b--, ;,: ;i ',;ieo .iFi .i),lctl L- J r, rl4l &V ,S-r;: -15 a5
2, ui.rs vQ -t .gla-""rii. ,)) ,y;l ;s .rltl" d*" JL ;-*a-rS ;"*.f! o:1, 6l; l, usJ;;3- or-irS g;tt.plr*<c aS S-l 6111 !; ',*: t(-rl
-ir*-li !.1* l\- elr;j +S ,2*:-.r9*li S--^S {e.2blr,-la, tii!aJ ros'.r ,"J &)r* Arig./Ut.{+ rl -r.2.1 -bY +1, 31 3 a;;; -N 6,$'-"
!r31 orle; 5*1.,*6 -* rr o+ll
WWW.AEL.AF
;)l olJ u \2
,r- g li.l Jt,f F rL.il * b f 6;\ .r:;* t d."-l p'/' Ut
plo-.r-; r;19 L-;l-r: gl"-ul;*r;-"- ,-b + 3 -Ut- .5 pL t.o; .r*L-l ;_l ;l l,;;,5-'A>* )1 .-riji-..-6.gs1-:ril .-SrF "!L )l JF^ r;;KlrulV rt,, ,
.-lJr;a l:-:: a-.i : rg;L*;-;e, "r;;! ,,ldrl C) :' ..1..rtlo:,i< jl rS;1.^*;L-;11 l;.:3- ,-FS ,_b 4;:;a a;lr: *.ye+ a;,yaicf l, vK 4t,r.t<jijl lr- d5F rL- u;- e pl* Gr.rr dL fr-;lr5; ,a aS u;la6;eL.J 3
s .{ ,s)""s;.-i.r .r* r..b y l^uly .iy;l orl-"; I ;: ,S u**11.:t-o!allIli.r-J ,c*l 6i.r"-,, q,ti d ,.rrt -t .gt^iJt.i .rl^.u!, ,932 ,, :* *)ldlyr" .-,-:,ti J,-tt J-* ,lL ,-srl;! lb .i- qgLoc_;i3. -, L.-g*-jt, 1L* ,-:s4
.)j*e L", 1t' +k- ;Le t plo:lr,.1+l .r,r a .3L, ;irl 4t .,,_t6rtt jl .s_,U.-.r
1L: a- Ju* ,+L5 ,rlrT l[}; .i- c...oL 6-__ri.g€ )r l,o;)L ,r-l ,..rj +blf-Jt*l .9G;t5r ll.# .,* ,.yll ;_b t .rT -,>
,5 -:;, (\ \? .) eJ;,T ::,1,:.++ 4to,-l 4 & l rS;a<*- l, l-t;l e .# ;! i:.r< l; e.ji ,j, .<,*)5l-,.:3o 6G1*1" 1rt' ',"X,d G, eL,r.] lr,,r.";Yl;* &t xlie 6rr+ ot-.i
,. ;T;el rl- 4J 65 a:trt 6:l;I e 6j3 6;G.O;G fL ! ,.r^q-;l .(-;s.s :b \ 1Vr JL
,,.L:5 ;r ^5 ",UL- + + ir .l l, .ati( ;U c^.,e.,-br.r a5 pl.: sLii:ol
lrr: l, *.15 ;,r-- ;p)p;.: gS.r-c F a5 *.r^ c*l uiL- .i_l;l ..uFQ;o- $.,',rllgo ,V;5,;a,d,,_l ir^-ii -bY *.1_, vE a5;_l ;l -r4 .,;L oslI J - | - r--6.:g- e-tJ--- )- l. -f
rr-11-l fU GL.IJ^* .Jl--:-"r a-l -L5 n-uA -hC + r;W;;y,,*L-l 6..r
a.l up :: ,S J..l i^e.d^i^iL _,, .d.r"; ,b.il ai + -,tr 4:l al-t aJ ,a:.::ls
a5;;-l iV;i.^El Ll ,#lr(,i vtS.n.iy ir g ll4jJt.Lr,r,_[-e.-.*.-;r"
f$t e -u;losr-f;Lll lr;. .-gl.^oK.l. gltl a- L'.9-q ggt-o;tS S gi e :l);.-(-;;r.1 Ll .-uL "r:";rrl ,-l Or--;;- All. rfg q dta"p)t pl:-r*"I a("r-l
! ,j- i+ e orL .,,-L;i G".t> I € +.r.jt(ul+ 1:.c + lr -l;5 ;-l ,,-,;L..>.l,;t o:l: g""!. l-! aJ c*l .rt-t-.r-;+ tl 5." _,:-;* rUirl + ai "u"..a
"p_L*1t", ,(rLT j,b a'" ,S c,*l ca- Jl+ ap-l tj .t +-:, r^l:; Vp-t "-r:tr;Lyl :' ;; Jt'y* +-l + ;r" wlr 6,,;l: l; -.15 j-l J-l .sta.gla,.i t,Li ;l;t3;le;.r- U) * 2-: a5.:*l !{l ,-S 4rL;l .r,-L d.-gla;S; .J-;fr^.;*l c":".5t;6r *i .:-- fS ,f .r! .:K _,r .r d +,;i rl
"fJ, .*+ + : .lla:iL_ 4^;.
WWW.AEL.AF
YV tr llvt JL rr* ?E rff"r-*
: 4; -,ltl a"f ,-i- .st* 4 &s,t ,-b + y4Vyf-te l, :,6 d .rGJ.= ,--! )s-"1 ,u;y;l-"-r a" $y-,u;so r,-l -l-,.-,31 6J1" 6:lo'il csl-tbNs.
"5 JL-;r.J-:L ".u.rasLlL*.r..*JL:-" u:yo 4.F--il t- UL"-t jl --S;r--l -bV a- ;--l ."r5,r. ,t-:;.J!*y* ,F ,-#.51 Al:- 4 t\* ;lV3*o---b :l l^.r-.T1, or13 "4 e)i g;l-" * L'.r^o fJ!*- rl a5 c*l ;;i*;;.J ;t-^r'U ,fJLr- p, Le )" .5*e-;1.:y .oGl Jer ,.r[^rV 3 j\:-;ULl2 sy,- ra!1.: -,-J oa I g*p,u^.oT.t'r.f ,lj;* rt:.:,5 cr-l t: u"
aS ,g;;-lS Ll .-:jr "r-olr+ at*(- p s:f ,-s.V aa;: aS 1'tlr sLiirl '.r:r.:,r.oLi
otl:7ab,) -t5,'r1-l ;., a5 u*;.gJ--l-P r*-l )Ll( -,,i.r.;*, + 6,-U;T ,y.-b ,l'}jlo,Ii
p -ts;3r o:-S -* l,"J a6++.++,.J" a( o'r-i Grl ,-b,t"lit$';--1 Ll ,syl.::3+.9 tL, O'-l rSJ-l
,,cJ^lt cf .)y-e:.-;.:1"u-l + ll*r-a.( i;*l ,l-r-:n -i- b S,s r[.1 vE 6 +i.rS,r. iL :,tit oS ,4 Ghg+l3;,.rr,-L:J-L 6_e.li "ul-l ,,*5.; C)t-l l; -:3,;.9iac*V J-?-l I irvo tt
.rr*"; ;T rLl:- )S G" c,lLs- G.:*l=- ;,-l 21 ,5 ,-gslr.il ;l d-,f,-..1 d "y
,u5i n--l ,, l,*.ll"rrJ oL;!1 '1;5,r-l ,, {,-r.,-L*l a5,rr"!,0:51
,-f-.1G ;ulr;.r. aS .ra$l -;l,u;|.'y -i'S +ns-,2, ,'*l# 4t c*Al *. aS c*lij* .*- 3.:- ;" L;[-.i,e rL;.ri1, +-:-, g,.l!,r:ll-'.rL- a Jt x'U.;r4
.rLiery!5,'U rl j-\5 -,* + lr l)y- 14-.1a:.;13;; aS ;:*l O--l -o -K-"
;L:-;s3,r,-.r,La.2.y iysl 8 prlr,r. eil)k l a**I 2s: pL G;6,-l; a;L-r*alel-u
eI;u1 a3 \: ;*;4 Ga+t ,i,1 2.r aS g;I:,rr UtS ;9^'U= s .{ at SI I,t
-:y.r3[i u;-r! ]r-^ 5l a5 ;;l-'.r. c:rc.4 rr*t 6 l, ."-l ,Jt:" al:", o1 ."ra )$N)t6 8 4{ xl5;u" 6 +r.r-",r3i orzei !-*) r'.: iiG }"tS .J*.i.i- 4 1-r rr-
)t".JeJ, t;**15
,:-G :t*c-t a,oL;, i.ln aJ ttSc*l dL a;U c-;S- ",Ui;,1r-lc ;l"r*;-; l, 3 ,31"c^.*=J!*:-- tE)Lly il cs-,L.--.i -,.-\-;r,
t5*-'J ..rt JvrG
te e; sj-;+ &JlL ,? q l;s.sla;.:ls rJtJ "rf; "*p + Uir,GOitl -r+.s-L-
;l 2 c*l o.:l:,-;i-lr.il lr.r" o\3 e ll-r,:.r .t-l 'oi iLrL y a&66*-|5;L* ar,.:L3J.IL:Uirl 4 t AVy ",.-L;i,' a,L t'.flori lr.:W oS iL;
.;*1 +;!L- u:."\;l urTg JS t-b a, .9-:1..r":..1 Gta;;$ JtrU 4;[. Hans Kelsen 2. Harold J. Laski
WWW.AEL.AF
,.Frr "1, n YA
.,.L.r JLr 6 b j S a4T )l; t -n*.,r lr. a5 orlr pl,J ,F 4k- J,-l
a,_t*;r l; r3,; ir-i or- .gLru.;; aS;--l ;l r+ .,r*lc UUS TiS .i_ L u"k l.# etrr-, 112t5;--l 6' ,f "j cs*j! oL; ai;>K;;l aJL.r- 666r:i,*Jlrj .oT,;:i e, S.rr,:L zi:":l.r .-r" ,s-,Q;15; -Li c*l 59< ^-.,J1aS ,;;;-.nr!.s! re.gl,uL^all.; uiX Ll ,{ e*.rl."rJgE;311 l; to.lT
ol,-L rl L' ..rJ Ecl .510r, dr" ./tr aS 6iSl *. ,g* l2 cr-tad;* ; .,Uirl a,
.uS ,gy" rl$N
6it^.l...il
WWW.AEL.AF
I t0t & *grtrfgir,ar-::l-:.i)L;.l aK--*T;15;u;ly* ! .rF J;,tt;l -t;5 ,al c*l ,f* +5ta::iL-:9; ,Slt -,y* 4-l 2s,h;^ * )+j s ii'*L-
"PlK-q )stl +b Ll ,"uL
&- lr,.1T:"r 4 rLr tl ,Jl* ;--l ! .5L.r" a)t!t-c 6;5 l:"T.r"--ri! d6 I I
"[.al Jlr L'c*l ,r,*L. ;-; ,J ,\.:;l l3l ,l rn JL .r jl .;*1 y -r,--rr J*
.33-a c,W u;trl J .J-ijd*u+ c*;ir. olL-rr J+.llp e ""f gt:;l.tOi.-5 xlrl 1., 1# e,-l ;, .,i
61, lir-.-- 3 ot; aa)g OU*f(t .s" S,:-.9L.JL* y' 2; -15 ;--l,.sl+--, -,t*-r ^+ Ol Jl3 o"r-c ,ilrrr.i*l o.ri o)) 6\;u,,.K;l ;t(;u:lr;or l-, :,LS ;- a3 or3{ ;[5 :: .94lji' ^-F e.c*l .9*1l(j I ;K;i:; lr; 2l
;: a5 o-:r,.r J*t *V,6i c*; j5l .f l.# ,+-r;i'<.,1;l pLi .gLoc*J["-yrr
,J; JrLr' .sla;rls us ,s6*"15,5 :p 6115;+ y oL-3s \ u;3 JL .-, ,r!.Py l: Jt, t, a( ,3q u*l*" .1La a"l:l ;-: 6!le2'r r 11.;
suJ ot(llr 2": a5 .r3- JL- .r-"rjt ,J'3-; o2$ .1 .1llT 2, ]:+ 4t .r.t<j^
r:Li l, (,,r..J< l rl *l !:rl r, *-S -,t-* eGy ! .l-+ .r*U Ll, 7 "f ,s e;$
J- K', c--,aL, I ^-;1, g-l r1J.c-:, l -: a- 1 -, I o t-r ap- I -; 3.a 73 ; N 2
Jl.-(-il aJ fS oU*t A+ L'c-.Jlrle !,,r, o-r,-) cr)lJ.L"l r.l,n dL6Li,i:..-?
"l,t* o-.1 .:*: <.91+li;."e"rr -r--Uie a5; .,L*3, 9l* -rr op a,u,,"K;l u"t-t
(.[+.+..rJ J-,, c?* -,-b +lt l,o.;;; ;-l;-*L -uli"l ,"r::alr,rcl.;tl
.rL* l, .rU ap-l &.1J1.i*.1 ,-;e a)l;^6 -,, L'-u d.l! lk*- ;r-l ,3.;- ;luL.lB 2l "'i3;*2:Li l-,r.r,-l o5 1.# "rt*l J*;t-L;l ,-" Ll ."5
.r-ol3; ,.9.r- o|b )st. c>a\,+s-t .V {.r: o[*,t* -,1 ,+ll r L ;L^;, .e"!-
WWW.AEL.AF
ftt Jt n \"'
t-1,ir* )l o-");li6" r**t(t .,r; oS ,. ColJ\"-l ,4[- a,,,1 ,1bq* .-.r4 .41 jl -K", .rGE;, l2 qgrlli,Gc*!* L-r AL""
oS ,y .r*Kl ;*JL"y- ;l.r:*;-sl 1 ;1"r,:.o ftl .t, _,: :,K 4) ,3;4-l ;ly-p\ai 2" \1f f JL -,L,..},-lyl-,rL-V ,5,+ -bV., -ryi'L jl .r, tEl_,*c*S a3;r--l -bC + rr^lrr 6 r.l;t'1 d.J- Cr-; );li<s" 6-;L'"r-l ,i;U.t .c;t;, AL.r[,:,t' pt * c+; rr; ;lJi; l)2. )-r.1.9191;ul U'.f ! u;\" ;;r;K ;;*
.d:,U':t ;lll2r arirS-; t- J\erl L'"i^o lr C-GJU. 3 otJ 4t3b 3J-4-i + tlie L;; ;" y.;iL_ y"! 6l**; aLI ;.: .r,VS .t -24 rp: *.oi *..,.o ,r* l(--"T r, ;T;-*Ar. rl y."5 cJ -LU a, o5 ;h-J(il ,, ,1i coa_r,
-15 .Lr-.+ r, .f ! ,*lr Jk ; o.U*l ,s3a iyLci y,:S 3: :" .4y Ly.grlil L*5; 64 ,* + u\ JYul e ti 4*2..-l: al .s-Li .glb. t asr\;l;lr":*"1,," ;ra .gL:ul *..;"5 j; cr:t.:;3r ,J:34 *-S ,lS -l.l- .r23. ai
ol^.r-"lj ozl-.11: r- r--Ur.sl_i Jli .,lu;-l-r;,r^ ar $ -JtS a.? *-t,aJ "r.-;rl.r )l; L? ,ru -.€ a/-l jl l, ./lJ ,-r;.;i! ..'r3i -*J t -r 4ljJ--L53* a-;lrS-ii 2 u. lL^ ,-r:t\ -L5 aS;-l -g*l o"ui ey ,*-,Y.i- t-,,.r-r*:1l,r- -:3;4Ui-c ;t-;c-f lr:_l- lr"i eV 6 S-S ,lS .9rll J5.,.J-+ATr, LnV.al:5 4J.,1L,,ll 661# r1L* o1!2r a.l*-;n"e.'r,
"Jq r["*,
d.+6,oUI.srtj u.)- )l -q,-l*- 6 J';;l;*J.e;*l6rt--* s.rb L"rr.5jl -(-.:j1 oJ1*2;+ aUi a-.: &-Ur :s ,ri-s-rr;T *qr[:r:l q; -,1rE r+
.frr"f i lr;) G.i,-i." 5* 8 ry vl.SlL;l .eGJL;j;uy-a ,4V)Kl ;.r ;T rt m1 1l ,*, LroL aJ o-r*i -XL-l 2.: ./tij jl Jt+-lJ!t-,I s-:_yu 81:1.',r" ,rSsl Jt *l .al ar^"ii f
Kl^ .;3a uet-oi ,.9191;ul V ,rrJ-S
,,i*-" Jl* c.--1 .lr_ri o"r,.r ;YL-l :'6 S.s\, j"A tt^< rl; G,-t<,-r"i 6t(;i;lr;u! t s ft'.r cJt's E.ri;, ui'<' r927;l;.1--;lr t d r: (*15,;ur;2l).r--Ui,c;-r o*J ;y.- arYJj ! ,y; !L;rl .9l9lLul L-',L-;i;l gi;e; uJ*
-" dl1:l jl s isyss l)Lrt fEtrt ll :-a 1t e- .'ti ;l :US _,1 .a!b-:t :Ltil o-u,l^i &r:e .\q-l;l .c*l (\Cft.;,JjJ J C.*:,-r.iJ) e;;,-rn"\,:r -.; 6>\j.6lya ca; Gt or)t"G.
"r-;l ! .elr} J4)a iJ*a? p ;* JY*-t "r-Ll
:1 o.te \ ".r^:" .:,YLl ;: ji;l& .oJ .;.,5oL*^ .r--:L uiLl: l;,ri.: -**^l -r:! "rt{_ji ""r-;lr 4 _il ui:i 45 ..-f ,<.5.3 )----i) uj,-.I .sirJ,5.L^;LU-r 6 r-)L/ },o ,,t5_t ihlrJlJKi/.J.jlj,
. (\ lf 2 a:'1j,.1 j4 6:\-a3l tt-, (Chester I. Barnard) :;[i;L
WWW.AEL.AF
r\ tr \ qAt d.- uti :U;3;*=
el-r-;l a- L';,- c.-! 6 f ! 5^f. ,;;t;j .,,:31 o.:1": c*r jl l) Gcr,-t<,-J"l
oJ ,:-r tj,-*; ilJ.--)".\y .r:Jlr *lr .r,-6,j rllla:* L ,rq.ir.- !\rrl-4-; ,'U-.'-# 1L;l ;i ?L? jl .-ur rL;+ t"6l a, 1*,1 .:[5 d G-,rV u-
uL ;t,i F al;t- J--r; -tJ rL:;l;l -rt a5 ry.r.t(a *,- ;1;')::-.s-;> J.'4. "eL*q ,L:- Cr'-l -;l qE ,.sl-, E ct: G-gS t .,:^.i !.r5sl o-ug .:q-, -L* 7L:- 9r,l, 6Ls, ;5le y: re>er 6-:i e rsl-t i:* ;r ;r91.-"-;- t -e - L - r J v J.J f
, *L*1 rl rLJ d->e^-.-6 a-,.,t:f o- vLJ jl a5 rlil L?J )- )l -;." .F_t-e .,.9,3 o#:L*l olJK-, 2: aS :2a 6jt;
.*LV o-i-^c lKrj;r 15 LgrlJ.il t*te -b *,;L-K;l 1: u. r"rq e);2
:-J y t tsry4 ,s:; )l l; Ls;T -r-.-Ulc U-ir-.c ^S "!J, ,r-+ lr;i,s-'y -t5,:-*l-tJ d*t- J-V t l-\ j* : "rf r),:jr o:lr ,lS b 13n.r:-.r:L)eo,l: ,lle-L5 ,8 .il\Z,gGr;,1 ,=/ )ra::gr,6+;L,.lrls,l p,1L;;l
J. g , e J, tJ v--
Gl4i<j Ll .rrj,. o.:Ul6;t- 3.59J- L' gi-; ;; .eJ;l: ,j*.9 t^;l ;r a5 .r-L-l 3
,*:l'u ,l!:l J* 6 r3a 6rlr.il ,it!U;" Jll"1 r31 j,.a"; l-l-t i'^S;;J 1 a5
,'rlr r-.:: iJ-:^ d.9-:lr!l 2l ts-t\* s-"uL o-ulei l; U.7t5 1r Cxl ,l ,lr.i")l ork*l ) J ?-:lea,.b,s o5 J oiLi,l lL g.Ju^:L o-r.;13* lr,,.L(;-l "Lrjl9
L-e
a-.o ;r)) aS t;u-;yirL-.r. \ rfs-t -,-* +l-, t;rSl ,J ;l-r.oLi -iijL ,u[5
tbd+l .*o6 ,-ry -bY + J oie,t:*3 Jlo:e 5sl .grlri.r*;le 6L-e: .6ile"
t-li;tr-^t q LJtc ;L;:il.r.ol a5 s9.,lr-61 L l:; ;:ls s:r, ! ..*p a5 e*l o-,3,
c*i-!y olL;: ;!'r; -bl- !;11 a5 f-lr.r-,., r-r d)t* G"tKr jl ,r! rrtt a',)Uz-"3 \
L-;:L2.91r...*.L,Ur l; +t:5 6 at4L ::f nr.rt- cs::l:; q o<il -r-!:ts-L5 stKr:,\;pr )), 5. j . J) 6 J-,LI " .,*- tu .l5.K) *;-r,lr>,r;* ;L; 5.eJJ.\..,U-
:s\.5 c-^rj-a)r r -r-5 ot-('i i J ..*l.r;,F fYY.u, .1104 "[t;l
,:l;l :rr .rrr-ri.il;1.:;-:l :S;313c),,.rtL"i--\ 1r-U -Uj; S\;,*; ,^3* o\iuLS .r^::= -:;t;5
,:t.V-l 23! r:! L=;ar )) r- ):*"j +-\: j:I--r -r) -ltri-*tJ*ri}fi t,tf)^..u! fl+:l ,-!'1U f-.*,t:'r1 d fi+ djt' glf ul7l- y.tS r-rl q nJq.".rl
f5 .L\-pl "g;L-o:L- oi ---1 ,_rf-l J jL ;l c-r" ,.(., .: ".t +l d--"." 4 q9;L-.:,.3
:;jL-: -n-;L gi+ pl-""jl f*ly.l W )r 4 ,l ,-+ -r J>Bl ;r-,, 6;*"a Ll :_e-.l.r"
.*t u4_ ; ,; ,>
eoL ,: ")L.:-l 45 J:5 olnL:. l_.: o:Li:-l "j* ,$;l t xr; rAlJ+ a5 .gl"-u:ly> p ,Sl.t Y(Herman Finer) ;1Li oG:^ ::--ssl,:tS fS.," a*e, ,c--1 )| L. )@;-. rrL" 5",:15i
.$lJ+ (\ qfo ,c^S r ),t_ilrr !l! :oi- y.) (Road to Reaction) .r:s\J .\r ,tl:o ! l:4- Lord Acton
WWW.AEL.AF
.,):; ol; u rY
eb" Ls241r.*l Sa-b ry 4J.!_1.1, ir,-l ..Lilo-r; i3-4,,.0s3a;_eU:;
.<rd*l or9;.rl*tli.ril*rl Ls_r.Jr)r ./tit jl Jt+:.-l L2i .2:.rj- .jy:;l Ul t*.te -b +
plxLii:cl ,rJ-l )l.u!;_et-ca .i.L-r, )pe -bV + & a, !;i .(+)l:ri
"-: oJ ,rUt* .r3,1 9tJ rt*:;l lK;." -2.: u3U;l. 6-* L-1"* .'3-.J #r + -rl al
u1* \L;;l 2rL3 r, 6l.l*t5it -,2s a5 .:3- 6r!; o.r-. .-;lrr-".r- Lo;T
Li- P L-o;r" ,f"J,e €)JaS.r,_b;L2T.J,i-r;"l Cb el;;l g;t^.-i*J,)u al.gbr-t+" y -K:r- d-t i [_o6i;l2l"ril .,r-j.!Lr^:- ,;- s ,tJc;bor,-t ;l ,:*lt;o-,r;p-l )1.J.:3a of o"uLi .r,ll, ,* *1., [nai r2;t5
r -\-jU '"J *.-i.i-, -;t l, t-o;i,;* r f ,vtS ,_L"erl 61,(;r;lr- pl.i d ,*,-r^r) P u1* \...u.;.:ja o.rr5..r* jy:l 1* -.X+ l^Oi ,S l, a4T 6;lr.r*e .rJs31 Jt *'*-,Q, -* "f*; ,l
b.lLrT a/-l .e, ); ay:t s 4 >:-r Jr"t+.c;L.,. i)tfui L ;:)tfu- s J\rr a/-l l"jii .G.;i o;[-lr(:w .r.r,
o.:;l Ja;ii ."!.r9 r,)1r.,:*,; r UL' jr- o-r-a" ;YL-l ;, la.lL;T;-l ,-K-, ,S_t* )lo r-i ;L -:,a rG 6,-l + t(-r"i 6 l.u*:.-;u I 2 I q9 I o "u-c ul4 ^S
r.91,_i.1. J L ., t" t-
y.r:: dL c.p-b3 4-l -&" JL A j,h t- Ja;l ^S o*l*1.i1;r1-s-,j1,EL" .9l2ls a*\e jl .E.r,_.1+ [--r t t^6i 6toul .\<,_[,_rjarr c*!r,, t ri gr"V-iSl ,slt n3:i.r_5a ,"t; &; J*\r1 1L*$ *.g;.,1;;l.r; t j:.a .a)I.;ic'
.9.r*.1 .r,_L(-r"l .9trJt<,-rl, ,S; .2> ,41o.ri.l Y<a.:rJ
1.9j!,) ;lr,? &-t )l b.;L"rrl
;, l;.rT u32; ulr-y> qrl;3.r ,-p.l .rt^JL J* -t" S jrc OV Gl-t:e6L:;2.>.-:31 orl.: ,iSSl" S ,Aj ,;*i
I Ol-e-e ,b * 4yslp s ,S rS 5; oJ..i -YL-l ;s crr.* a1 4Uic
;r-;&ljl a5.r31 re"tr Ua ;".5 ,4 Jt tol-,, *15 2l;;l ,l "f; a5 ,;yT r[-
-r-o[i,':2e" oo*92 6r$t 3 .:3..1 c--La ):- cgr+ 2] 7 6"Lo:il ,g;-'o.Er1 7;;;-l ..ur;lr l;,s"yo :yl -ts f+" rr"r.gLi-l r-l o-uj;.r ,S ry usr! zlrJ sg:l,il-r li I i*; I -: -p-; 613 I t-l, r; C-rJ' .ri .(" L- .l.i .(_ ;) olJ,6. b L*yJ[* _,, aJ r_i /! {<j ;-_l c*l JtS }ii ..:j1 "r-al3> dv;-e .:*-t :;L .9rt5
-t*r; o.r^;:a:lrl 62-1"-N2.ly + .srU +_; & tss--tbt-t.r.o-'L'.rl; gr.,a t f f fa-1 t o;3;J ii-e jl, r+ JL o.r ..-il -r Jy-r* rc.li t *s,t, Uli-l . JUT rr.t rlr-1. New Deal 2. vieux jeux
WWW.AEL.AF
rr D l10, ,r:- .?q ,UX".l
3 or; u.r-"jYrt <+ ,1le Gj;l L'a.* ! -, '# rL- <.9rl"r;;lrr s9l-o;j5 ;13,-'
,r d v1.5 ap-l .rq,rr t"l.F# (2-rL ur-,* 3;1, ,n pV r:5 ! tssi *jl ilb ,r-5 rs -rJl:';b.grLail crG.:*U- ! l'"rvS ,-r-l .rL* i*i -t[l;t3* 6Lf,\: e.J-1,:; y;3 al ;: gia-2aaN2;l;l-rirl L-t; --a; ) e 6i)dfAL-" -;r;f JX.r;l gru> 3 or! ,sls *-s-; ;l 6s-2a^N2 ;j: 'S i# )K'il
aJ .:*l ,t(;i c-;1, 5--r ;--l aJ -.:;l: -,Wl *;* ;-ri:u jl ,F- .(
.<Jilor*; rl.u,l * .,il= dta.l, J ,5'a;UTe;,,1;.+-y;,Uli-l 66J-.5
-L:5 )L;l-:l oS ,y .,,L:, ;, ,uL:5 ,L:.;l ;L2;, 6r^i E ,s* rs\,a"
Jt F "1';t, L-, .# lfur l.S U- t, .F-..,,j1e *,sG"t-S 6l>s.l ;.;l; u"j tt' -b:13r;l4.il;-r9 *;-*;l3;; ull5,.:ji r99W:.oa3^ etb ,4;:.':jL.i- .rl ,JL .r-l ! .r;13 .rt- + !+-l ;r ,.:31 o:!4 -K-, .St^E 2, 'S l; dl4,t' t"
&-S ,lS Je ,ts^ 6lo"j3 t-* + $t"l.;T or.-c ,9\t6$ a4 a5 c*l i-*'!le
;L+ .91-oa;L; f4# y f*-*lG 43 ii< u- oS -Sl,.i*" JL orjle-: '.1*l
.-b; sr,t*rt'.r-[: g;:Loi,l .rL"-*JLi rU f/- J-^5;l o5 -r-r".o.9:l-r;-l
csrLo;y! &-.r--l 5-" ):-nl Ll ,r.:,,r..'lrJJ;L"r; q "*ai ":lr!l 21 ..9;la.-1
J .r..Lti r-l &-.(-*:!Jj"r r!t*r* r5 -r.;lor7 6.:lr!l tSl :yl .;;.;*1el-t 8 -r;l-r JL;.: o: .;l^",-.!" 3 o":31 jL:r-iLi'Lrl;l: o92r;l a5 c*l ,1.r,-L"L
.c*l,1"1N ;; i ;:lzl Nlil .s-,U^ r,x:;.tar; t;U,-
d/-l oe"l*" I d-lr 6\ac* -e orl.:a2 eG: + ori
,rrt3i;-l at ,l.I=,r ,t: 6jQ+";i ,uLS a/-l d:!" ! n--U;.;: ;ul3;,r""1]r*
.&iL- )L::l ,! qlyl .sl-i g* o)ta + rS .r"K:^ i; .r J-l; .r; .-uiL +;-:1,
clirl o-r-,-;1.; rjr3;,a,L:- g;G;l"r-::.-t c*l ;5r al 'u..r,o.rJf .#L g".4 gl;l:
.:; e-" ; -(.,, J +.,'l or I ; ;lr-6 riij -:;3r'5 .r,-Gc*l** ; I..r-L ; lrE Ll'Sr'l'l
-rJt ---! e-l r..r!r, .rT .gtlc,-j" ;l o:;K.:,LS .r-l -:;:e uoJ rli ,5t:
A\j -.g;:Ld6l Gl-:a.Ntlr- ,S a-|.!)-: .r;l;3^a t ,*'" a,.-t-t, * Klr ,"t5"+
..rjl.:ra,.r. ,)*e.rL ai rl eb .rr-l a5 .gr.-l,i oJU.: oL'-:' ,ai.a ,)a::^ a1
.9LrJY-r-l 4-i .-9+ a+j 6ls.6'-rl rsr:yl L); ple4"l."l-J, q-p +
,- ;- -rLii:.ol .r.,:: ,.iii" r! qlyl ,-sl; :,6 d .r;! jLr rl ,,t*L ..'\5 ,r.tl9
).-ii -"J-F .)J. (Ceorge Orwellt J-e;9r er1-- \\A\ *LS .'ry
.c-l o:f C\r:L.c--P\ l; uLS r,l
WWW.AEL.AF
,jty. st a \"f
;T."u;..ro .ttS ">-* l;:3; uL.i;4! ,.r11-,.;pl -u;l ;-r a-;T rS;*l ;_l
-L-.9"r^r.r,uuLlL g;;* ri a$L-;L;L.f 6.ri-,, S _s_t);; f!L-*;-y vL-( : -'e *J ;:y. {i.J"-Ly::L, L.- Al:- t Jyr -b-3;.g:[ail,--l ;*JL .r7j ..:*l G:J4L JL ;, !-_,-' -.; AQ* ;r ,o-L.ri, n rK; j * a;l .sr!.^--.? * ;i ll+"t ci6 .r:-: At-L" + \ 1f A JL re-\> ;-: -r,b f!L-_r Lytr r:j"n-"" 9,--(,.gL-.L 2s 9ll+-3, tJr,r;l,l:l: ri;l "f lr,)LL;1,ya;
*fu e- ..*l o.rl: r:*.: jl l; lj- .gGc..1'lr: rl .Er!* f l.; ;.1 .o,r,i; ;yL-l
.,J:-_Jdli',-;l a5.r,-L-o"l:-.slr lL ;l t i* J-r? _rr.r-l^..p)i. aS ;_;c--1 q3 oj"r-l Ll .r:.-sr(.ulr; o;3a ,r,j41-J G-i*S * ).r&lUtG'*)t-)-'.91o':'-+ d,r-1.+l ;L)L-l 9r*:-,,.*L*,ii ! .jrf" 2 t),r)
.:_f rlrJi JL; ;L;;r ! .rrLr" ucj c*l 6t ,s"J rf y*i l; t;Se-;-* Ll ,u:.L o:;S + L_y-rytrr f!!"r c*l ;Sr a( -uro.lj.,*:s-, ;l c--L>1 a*:i 6l-t ::rl ,.5-* )1.:;L .J<* :213 ,9lo"j3 rrt + ,i f+bs 'r -t a-rl l, a*! -r-:alr;,-- -.f .rt-a;: J,r-:l :l;l yr"l Jl .,r;1.-u
,- a5 r-;;ls .:-.: cr_,f-r :lil ;y".o l.l .r:;5 .rjL;! "!Lrl
JJ-l ds u,Ll t|fLh:Laljl :,r-*,-rjL*Jr-,_rlJ,J-15 -,* + "+* a5 s;1.: )t-a&l (J,td)l**
,-6t+ ,1* ,yr^l y.-u:r,_J,L ar*;-l a, a;l4L 2r[ +. x"l;u" Ll ,sl._ut;
a.-;rl": L .lc;licl ar-u-4;-, a5.r,l-oc*l** rl .:.-t-a-.*..1, o;lK; ?lJ ot..lL;;l
f L-L .gta;L,i G-) .'y."raL; qi ,**s"-6.., ,-r! rlK;L ,lri r*q 6
j.6.t-.,",L+C)trl -!r-o;lr,r ar y oG;;J3r 1L e= x: rr1r-1,tj -^l;l J
f; [**>- .9 G 1e L* -: ao-; 6 Ll.g ta.r;e L*,.: a-S j D-o ;.:, J I o l); f! l=**a5 c**; I ;" Jl! J--l Ll .JJ,; .9+4L": e .(.(;'.tt :-l ! *-t, .-ul! o;1,..i.r--o * Jt:*t 6l-t.9rL_, .gGol; Ll .;u;L .F-L r:;r, , .[^, ;i -!l-rol *;,.91-i L G-pL) aJ.:"*."--o _*.Li J--l *a- *-* wb3 zse:;1.:.:jo.y gL--(,-
"ujli.,. qr",4t Jrs c!-r* dzl;l -L;-:jl * 1, L c*l Ofu,e* e.b + Or.*t,l;'[ a*L Grl)n* ! rll;.+ Ll ,;u*:L,r-t- -il-r-ol "r ;*-r 6111 uy-V zlal
^J JL- ;: .,,-lr-l .9la",:;.1 2: u:4r; : ;i JV). \ .p)-|.-;_l;!l .-r;L ,lKrLa-i Jri J*:- L-: -ui!,-iK.il-r.rl L+ 4 j{*t.giy llr,*.,-'"s*.r^,ly.l,-*;,l a-;$G o:LL*l oJ JL ;> "92L;l;L*; .r."*[., Jrr *rr:- ,_rGJ_^jjl -'K- j_r--.4 .y,i ,-1- :lr-il Gy- )1.r,:rr:; .rt*.:..Jt* I .r:li.r. JL CU
WWW.AEL.AF
rA n \102 ,rr:a ?E -16r.*
.9 Lr;*l*- ;u li.r aS c:,*l ;*-J !-r, iU, t a J LL a, -r^i;-r!,-9 G; l-n^
.-ra-:;lr^5 4V il;-r,"j!rl o"u-l ;.: l; Glj^:S
*.1; E.:t;4+ -(-.er r ".uj 'V 6)in-L r*l i(r a( Lri;t
S;, 32r1--ljl ,.rJ 5;;;til;i D-r;-L-rp .-i-r-o.f-- sl: )r 4-.i $li J +liL-
r,-# rLr-:il .9[."+L -u'ltrr" reL;;Ul-ul ".-J,ri ,y--b , a5.9-r-lr! -f-15
,l ,-rJ :_$_r lr rl;T.,r-( &- OX; csG:* ul:t; -t-* a e D)J cr1 ;l l; rlrL
l*l -;-r Aij<? )lr- I y:-t.lr, .r-l *. -Sl V .e*l ;142;2.91';e ;*+l: .-Ujl-r+r rlJ rl l, .rl;l a-"L S-- 2";t.gtiJ+ lalrcs" 6:Lanil q9t^J-^-5
u23-- ,s--l;s ."r.:*i;L JL+; 4+j a.p-l ;: *t t* * ):.1i./ Li["]$l + E rt-l
.r-Se.- -.)L^ 6 ,-b-l; ,sy- *lt L ,rc[+l b")\ 6,q;-! zle-r*.I 1*,li.r".# *l-r;.;_lu,s*;
,Jrl- aS g;l:.r*"1 .;*l {r,-r-l + ll*-t e.i-? r).(J; -15 r,-l .-i.u
,9;2sl 6\;c + o' ,rF a-. j, u\:5 *.,cltcfrUJl 6 4 j o# il) al6 2t
:ilr. d rlr::-.r.5--;13-r t Klr;r"rT t- $r:*" a-S * J.6" 2: c-3li" r9l1
;-' "f5-; ar1; a-$ n,;*l ;l-e:, t-n;l;l .r,-G, aS iLL-r? t "\i' jl "l+ '.*!c-rG ../LS
"!lo" .rt^ [, ;l ,(-;., 8) ,sl,;e.glar':.?LrT;l -r-! ;L.9G;L6;
.tS :* (."u1,;"-r,..l;G
.)*)Gr -b * ,-u *ly Uli-,. !."J , )L(il .9t, LLt :,LS d d4i- a,-l
f-,p J-rl" o:l:;lii *X ci64 :-b a1 l; L.lT d.;K-rJ 6t(:i::1-r; al-t 6;l t-:'-o: ryrag t-L.E.l.l t, a5 ,2lr .:3o.3 u!5 g;jllr,ojl: ot!r, d5j .t'" Ll ."r*lL
, J-l1gL-:.* 1, nJl-f*l, ijl9 il ,-tr5 -r}-r t" .t* ,s#)z ;ry,1; ,* *$ g2: 919 ;-l .rLl* ,S ,,lorJ o:U:;l ..--l Ol, UL:-,,t t, e j;x^ a5;i .r+r;, d;.i:*l L;b-;r;, ..,T qrL- J'U. 4lrj ;, qg"tL-; :9J- L' ..t-K-r.i 6-l; rr1;15
)l c-,\*t;;t. ry'ir+ s ,*J u--l ,sl-S.r*.gG.;41 .sr6;LA,,Cl:r,;--L"c.9L*" a, <JlaJu g$ $ ar;;, i-".tL ,.u;l;1., g;rl1'l + ily:Lir:rl 6.r,-i-";T
;, a5.r,-GeT lr- 3 flcj<i )5 )-e-b.:-:;.:lrJii J:t J-nS Lt -p\.* Jqjly .,--l Ul-S:^-r +5 slorlr ,ql qnd .-Ul.: -:Lii:cl g;"'lrT +
"L;1, o-r*i ;YL-i
.jl3.<-- ,11-r-,s- a-.;i,:.-,,-t,l( t ! -* L:r-,r; "5.u;14:-e* jl li jU- !-rrj
)l a-,V-.,;l o-;;", lp.c*l .;U'.,1L Liitl;l .;l.rj .(J t"Oi ^t Ak
.xS Or* )\tabiv j* * l2 rj* r;lr Je.U cj.il9.sl^JUJ
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5',, Jt a Y?
sL;irl -rir*i ->,\,L5 cJr, a-1 a5 .r,-[^.,T ! 4U- 2., a5 e*l c*;.: ,,-l ,a;Jl
5 -;! aul: .;lrl5aLit< L .rSJ\-:- ;Lri.r*t,. ,r c+--! .r-i13 .9trJl! .s;lrt !-r*.,; SU rSS-" olz.u;le,r. -t-U 1.J*.SUL--4 r: alr;l ,L); u-r1 2t
3c*l Lr- .925a1iiE jl e )* &l: fJl! Ll .r:.;;L a:*::lr :3,- .9G.1L;T
6l?l J F- *..r^ 6;lS,hiV .*L ;ti_El:ti.+ F"< U G;i ","u
au"}LJ rl .9;5aJi!t-<.-!,r"[-:l LL].<,_ $licl Ll .c*l;l-r,-t, i*! ,.t pY
;.5., f!t*r* "r t^El ,t;r3a o:tiLrr" ) sp.;a,e2.ti."+*JLr*-tj a\^r*-15.3t .1. .--tr l y, t})1.;;r. *, al-lJ c-; sC,*) -S -bV * j . &l: rJ l-tJ U. e; t
:=I; 1, 6tl;l 3;L13- a-.3;' ,Jt:*_r oL;( sl23-: )r t+,;;1, "r^l:; _5r^
T r, ;ly-"..;'"*: -\--! .a.-;L a;-:l-: ,Sj;--a ;rt.a f+l:-,r^ ,!l x '';...-^ aS tS10,4- uol;;l;bl .st glt^,dlj }U + ,215a!-iL<;r"1 .9-- .# ;rr-.gLr*,;t 'r.l ,l ,r-L. Jt ,Ul .;:*t,rfu 4.: -;.r!i t ,;lrl*:.1 ;rl L;^.,.91r,
cs*t tsly 69- ;rL:;|.: "K y";*
s u)3t ;t:;. *tK g.J*- ui..*L. e dyl:. Jl$ oK-r,-, .(,- !l-rr- ,,"*.:i b";,e 6lJ--" ,9,2.631- L-lr; ;t a5 .u;L :lil
.r;lr ,r5L'2L;l a657 rl5;l..,-_ v5.$i,,:l:.;Ll a5 g-! a;l: +.\;; -&.r.r^1r,,* .(,,-;. *-L-
"ri1r,,lorr5.r* Lr!.tq "/t-1
4:ct 4*; ,f L7.o JL..,;ler!;; c;S ;l!: .# g.r; \ G;i.r-iJ r,.t t -,,-! ai -utlr "rs 6-:Q;K , rJ .;o;!tsl-t ,.:- g;L"Ji!'Ll .1rrJ,-r .r! ..s-n-:*
"[,).: y "ul4 t t- J -ri.i.., -btr-l
-15;s-&_ 2.: -;jl-; el"; J* -3-, a5 :y a.( ar-l Ftr .rl.r.-yj!
-*L* jl .rlJ+ ,4J bt,/ $ *,*- 3 ply- 4h- J,-l 4 J- a.p-{ U',5.;5.v;<su rF + li ;"--* a.t3:;.all}. "! -,, .ri.rr-- ;kl .ol -,-,\ rsG6:-:,) -r--t?.dJ allzl .:*;-l * elr.r l; -_-l_,^ 15,,10,r.*r 4".:.; j-l a,,ilj.l )la5
110.:l-: ,'L;l .9r-r-,;r. .rYLi-;.: l; 215 ;-l y .,.,"t"jl*1 l; G;i ,(.,-, dtla;.::i?L:5 4J gl.9rl - '$l t r;J;G";,n.r-r1 o;!;, ,_r\:k j- t"6irl ;,s oi-:,-ll "o;L2.,,,-9J, vK rs .tr5,r. rJl;l .o-f .;t;l l.o;T a,. L;n r->V;l u;t L G;i -tU;l ,*u-*: 1,lorl.: ,l; fi r.,:. Erxl ;: oS .g.r,_Us. .gl-oa.:;_,
,K-., -t- &- 2r l: rll-h -r.-s ,y-l.gfi.gla.,:;- t-iK$V y.*,,.liir$
[. patemalistic 2. lndividualism and Economic Order(Chicago, I 948)
WWW.AEL.AF
rV tr \q0t .,* .-,q- ,[X"r:l
&" l-.i l, :,5 ;--l ,".-* y"l5, J.l ).6 6*) * I 1:ls*l: .',,1.rr5 cl;lt.d
J*.r Jl.r' e ,stlt.*.-bLrlrl jeV ,s:s.r-ol;+ ;l-bl a-;lrL' ,_J +;- rl .-i;l9i a5 ,21, .3rye ue\; 7y4^Ll.i-;r:;; ry.r: rT { r.n-lrr1, 15 "r..,o d! -},rl,,}l .rT t 3rl; l.a;l ;s e-;1.:
,Ju Jrq,tJ rl r'i;1 jl .*" JL .(-;l "r-* .rS;ul .;';L gt5 slr;,rr "r'-ra 915
,* -e H JL*;; --L. { I *-; -:.riit;*!f",r }t'.*$ gUb-: -,,
Jl;* Cr-l L 6J-a:1-13,; Jil-r- L',# elr- .r- E"r-l ;.:.liL.+!;rS(Ulr-: t, *-Jf,-_r el3.: sJ.--2 -r-uli ar) *f .t-l glsl a- l.:'a( 4": "Jlll;* lr 6lJ; ,"ja oS o<* ,yf e.l..lJ ,2 ! y +-L ; 6\^ilf,,-"*jli;l .r-,L----.r .9lr- .31":,J ozl:l L-a;l q 4J l) .r,-Lb.;;- ,c^*'elj ,'rii:u 9 or..:ju
.c*l a;L* J)y,);*J +;- o-: o-lltl .gLoJY-r:*l t "u:;lr,rr aS LrrlJ.il
+5.r,-G+.-rE -,1 .il;,5 rj- -5rlS -.:* J-r-,; -r$ + jl Jn,r5;ul ,61il3,-r
,*L* c*! ,!.1 ;Vr;rr^ + t*b--,: -t' ,$"J ,/.:; l; l-osi 6-,"i r, ;'" ;-rilrits-s-suN-r c*1,. ;l a5 rlu*l -b; y,r*;.:L,l -t:6>s) t,rl-..1"i.1,-"t;a+ -u;li, -r ',<2-
^<-^ .cJ-S ,l; 6,)J I ;* "y^i;-*.s.+ .rL sgsL,r:ll. J e r -" (:-
:) or-;, .1q (\ 1f V JL* g;rLo:'jil g;Lr6-r-rr 'a)1 2' 3 ,--) a;; 9l-r-;l(:e "rr5 r.-:l2l ,1Tg9ll.13**J r rU,rL" t lr,rl JL6Le +-r, 2: y 2)9c-*;.<-- 4J )y)c/ &! ,rt*J!,",r .gGi*U* o9rr )) )r-r ,,jL:^ a5 .u: ;t.;;
..i- i :l i '* I +L- r!y* :i JV!-,ee N ;* J* r""1" AV:* ;Js":*l
J3l .:;1, >jz:S:lf t>tSJLblJ3gg:1.r;-l 6t)c^LIJ.l .r-Ll c,:[,j4
.r-il q dJ.-) grl, .:jLs, cJ3: ,5tajt.i C,L, | 6aS 6La.:*lr- 3 o\t": pLj
.)jL"r" f:-,* 9t*;l .5rl1i;l \ 2l j o>1ji yL,!^i :.it ,, ,5tJ.* 6lastst L c-i-t-a
,5. t +-g e pL(:r. - ; .i;lrSrr: rr5 6 t, d-.4b,fyt u.-. ql ;JL"-(-, -\ J-
+, l; .:,;Li J,"l &--olJJ) r) Ul+,a prr".3;r,l jl +irL r. 6)Jre 3 2; 3..,) ts).S r.(,- p: -o r,q>Lr J-! ; r: Ll .'r5 6t4:l: tlS Ssi L; .i-J:lr c-J3>JJ .\ J .)
"i-,3;;-l jl .-r-,a:.r^l -2ll c.J3; ;L:;l ;.: l; ol-xutiil Atl-ti F ,^.{lt',,",A;:* +5.r5 c1l-ra gt-b y l; ,il6>La^il ,St-:blr.r:-"r[ &lrSy"> c-J::
.J:5 -U; 13> r.rllyr.6^:, 6ly l1 uli:;l g>lri rl ;(* o
1. The Counter Revolution of Science (Glencoe, In., 1952).
,-rUj ;: ,r;lr:;- ,Le J* :: :a ,*.(! l-i 7-rr J-\\;f t:f r: et- CP .\.c-i o-r--l,.lla (\q04."J,.U) o3.\i,:-r<- .,-q-
WWW.AEL.AF
J:."1 ,l rA
3 Jo oL d.j ,4r aL"A a5 i*l ,,_l "!ry- ;! .r-l ! I+l_, _,, JE K
.,-Llr l-, ;3 Gt*- *+j fLLj .-rr-;- gl_,.r.s*ylL * :s4 g)- sl;et ;:lL+l j-i :i JV!
^-$ e;!"i-. ;r ,;L+"a t ..r1.lKl .-,yG .-,15;., .ri o^L;"*i
,.:;l: l; o-rKrr; rai rjJ al)"ri jl o)ti'L"l li Jr, oJ "r.iL;, 1rr. Jt tr-; ,e*$,t
- ;:;5l .-r-:L.r--:,olr; un$ y)Jl.cl .i- )::- ;Sxl o,\, ty'' o;j,a 4-l ;:;: r.5 JL 2s r5.g;L::-iL r,; eL+i , +;l; 4;;<- dp *n* d c*l ,ly::;o-; A-);-6 -\--6r ua;.::J aJ c*"1 ;J9: il4L9t j_?Sl E -r5.r. E.l -u*;L"a
.9.,Lajil .9G.JL!> E a-l s ao:y 115 "i- eL * jt**; e.<? ))gl;";l ,rli;lc*pl jl -:;l-5*,,1.tf a( -r.o-, ra5;-; -r,-! Jy":r5,ra-r:LL ..L i" e.,7 2tl2
.(dj<. rli G&"t - ol, ,, -r-! ;l.ral ,.1-r5 3 srlrrr;r, .5:L-,
;-rS- .!;l .,;L:_; 6* alr-J(t;r Gi;J!-3*.;r(- JL.;; ,"!l?Lji .9l.-lJi*al .!L ,^l ,y-l xS o" 1.'.rl ,5,r,. 1r;T Ll .c*l a:*ll-u .9:l;*:*l,t.t-1-*" aSr,-l :"llo15 .r-*l; l, &l ,t<j .(,- ai13r, ,S,r .^,U l; J4.1 ol-2
Jtz : l-*' &-,r;9T,r- )t-.9 +"-Jr, a-rt*-". Jyi-S;l-- 3 Ji: *;;c*l ut*r:,;; s tS -,5 S.U:) i ,_) s..:*l -'lril -,f; z*d'LLa L_ ,r:;L;;lj,,r"j\3 & y, L- .i- ,+;.: -!-ti aflr J:':l ,-tt JL ,) ,, , a( ;-l ,,st:.-l; s
^.:-r; l-o,1T rr3,-j2, i &-,s*L* ,-st uLrT oS .:*t J.r_l rr" i.* .+L-.r
oU ,",-;S.,. ,J", at ,9lS G 15.9l.e*L*.sGrV rl .a5 elsl oL"o + cJl-,-: .Lt"r-!, y-L aL. 2, a5 c*L* ll+ .r-l .\:---.6 j; zlSa\; l-odT ri ,:2--r,".,.
t3-2 ,L;,-,,.-l lr-t ,-r-;;L .grl;i ,gla 6y;;,[lid .s-f. .grl)i g;;e .:^; *(*q-. )l -t,'f J)*l-,J Cr, t)r; *-r1.l,.1..sb.;*l*. y GrL.;*l ;(r a5.:;1.>
.9rl;T;T )r )fta as-t $ j-,-ro ;" ,"J ,g$;a-G-r"L ;-l jl ;li.r "!l ,u*
-rr -A;-+.r *f l: t.o6T aS t, ,-*:-S Va U;L, a:-L flfu at, L l;:e;.r.;13;i
Ul, f* ! r 0.,-, G. -b;T co+ a, Kl" +;ll3 1""; ,*r.r" &* SN;LL r^*a4*9 rLi:rl ,y-l *. aS szlri :-e*.3 ,-9rL-2 rolr; .JL .r-l L ...r..tr -g;' l-t )r 1-^
.;*l o:Lil 6Li'l .1U-JS;1 ;-:4;l r)_r. F:i!-,, d! -5r\S -.> c-_,6- i;er 2: l,;'a.; .Ulr--, d 16;;, ai .jly+'Ll-,1";pJr:lrYL*;*- oG; J3, "i- g;la;,aJ^ rl ;L ;l & ,t 6.g;jYj.t l;y-:
,f l_r- cl lr ;Y3l y +--' .r-l .;J l r ;e: b ;l t l ; C l, .:*. 1 o-J :_e>. 3 a-, ]ilo.:3r
a*e *.--jli.i" .*.! .# J"; ,rS;,i 2. .rs t* -Sl Ll .rf e--,* iLi +
WWW.AEL.AF
rq E \ q0t c*:z gE )U;K rra
<s.;.*,-5-. ) ^*-St r-f i-l5(: dr-"r-:7 4i,a-iJA ;12:o a =..rJ ,.L*l lr.;l
,.sL".F-ll ,-.;)9: L*; ,r-l,r.o.r;LL ;r igy;o:L-; *L -, d ,,;L*lr*l3-rr-ii a: rl
"[.0 t--l; a: a;.-t-s;-l ..:;lr 4lr; "rL:l ,.:jl.:r1.,r. ,;\:13* .r-oi
)fil rL OJsl ,Sl:.:L5 +-l d "!t"j
.rb r., ;;ijL )) ,+1-,5-,5 Jy, J+-,;l;e:;: Jr\S ;)r, +r-.r,q" .91-o;;Ll ,l ;L ;tr9'U L Ltr , a:;l:7 ..;.iL-
::;lr;15:r3.2.-r-rt-.r- .Jj.als fJl-t" 13b * >lSl6GutJl ")r,-&t 6G+ jl ;11 cbr"6-.i ;>ljl ,J)q-^-l ,Jr- ljt-l a+ r).so -,.6ri s ;s> rsGt^-l.: c;L5j-" rdr;'$;-)
J "r;, Lj* !,c. " l ;J,ot5" \ : S ra 6l r, La,ii ll-?-jl
J y* t * a, +5 6La'f t^i
,iriu. "J""L rrrll-ti3rnp-i S;1V, ;Slr"t aS 6lr;'i,5lr,t>tai.c-l o.t-i rrl Lull-t, L
:r: eS l;.iL-o+j 3 o.:r5 r:.,-!.r.a J;li J<4- pll JK:f f1"-2 U $lo-u ..;-'Ua-5 c-l * -S t\l6raA J9 ji J*a:.,, oLxi i-r-.lL ,,:-i1: uli.;l Goi;: Jl9;.r"
oli-a 4.Sr-1it"j .J; ..:ra 
J:."1 ,n fr
-L>l; j ;i: so-ra J-rl i jl Jl4si-j !l; LL"-+l o,€ r-?.-r:sJJ 2l;-: a+t>
L-^,JiJ-j jl -rjli,F; Li)l .ttdtt-f s >ttt et.rs^i .;- I su_ri.r,
s,t f f-,J f; lJ ji 4<l,-r:(;.r; l; rr.i o:111 .J::<, YL l:, f s"J-.: ?t*S:.:* a, Ll c.rS.r^; -t:*u cS-tS gt+;l f "t(6,^ l1 >S:JSu, c-ib^.r:-jl {<J, .J5.r*i .:--;a l; ,r-y "K6^ 3,l-ri ..r.^a.-r:5-f 6- ;L5 gE ;l jl l; :l)l)i, )VJ €^,=j lr L3.rir-Lt,JiUl (J-s(J^j dg fr, q..6.r" 6.3_S.Ji.rl"JoUlr*,- .i-" .<-- t
"li{ d-L 6 B.s.-L t.odT jl l: *l so:rS.p1g io>l:
e5 El".:y- .:LLrl ,,1 J + .c-..1 cJ_9.: ; dt^:JtJ," 6 *:-'l Gq t J-;
)l -r-t ! r5.r- F *i )l y:>11 r.li,salro J fG J prtl Jty. g; 3-l.j".5t- Fe p I:|I :1> J"li6, G> Jo)1r 0114.6 jL-.J:u'es>l)\ (yl
r.rr-t:S c-i)-li./ /y, in- -.r" 4? L'aJ ;*l ir-l -r5; a-.:, Jl+ rr,-[,.;5;r9ru a,;l
J.; ;L- e;S;;;t-r rlJ.il aS JL _,, .rq j! .lF<J ,_;tL ;tJL J-icS :"Jut ,;r* .gLb,F-"t^l; lU ,y:ilr< t, -r-j ! y g-:3"r.<ti yL +.:;;\;u" ;;-1,
.J6l{.>;$ -r* J. Ls.Vyi-l;;*J!"r*.sL^CL+ j* f .g-,yTrL- o-r-:.;ly; a, c;l p'J -r,-b
l\5+ J*,-i- L" j "r-ilor3- q9:1*r*l .-gl-rg-jr J55 .t, r, ir^;' d ll.rF,c;1r g-Lar4tj a3.:*l JSJ ;*!!-:-".rr.r!.9to;.+.jl/i; at llor::.;,:u "li,)l u; :: i W--t ,.-i a5 plo:lr ,l; c* rt-r. :,5 ,,-l ;r a*:T ."r*lL
G:--:A-N-t.iU-l J-rt; l; Ll .J*-jJ-*",:!.rt"J-t*, aS c*l r,-l ,or_e, ,i,s_.;-:au}-td*1,, alp + 5l J & -," S ,;e.4>e *.12 &-l;;-J!"r""6U"U-tr-...s.13;1.r 6"1.u;l rsGy+ ;i6rK ;rS t.r1x" c[^, AV*G.,r, ;i t-., t^c;t*-r- -iSl E "y-,-t Jlrl.;lr.*y, + rJ!":"-r I { o;*Jt --r- ,.SL.CE .(.'lJSJr, .glaeL;l; 6 { C ^sWl ,;* 9 rr-r.::-.."r jJl<
JJuL-, 1L+l .rlr 43 \ JKr*.ri .t36.- ta;T r .:: uiJ 1; ta;i.g_rE .4$;--l -r*r- JrS -.f Jy, jl aS 6;e,z;.4jU*L.<t-ru;::ls ,c*l pY gLi-t.;6
-,, i* U lr-j .s lr'; t*_r" .* 2: ( 5; ll_:,r .9 t-.; Lri ) G" sr l >r ! r,_ l a5 .,31
JL g. : ;.**;, .rUT 2, t^;T c;;r. ;l;lLi-+ c.r!.- -rs ;r.:. .9taor;211L 1l
or-ti J"4 JS +U a-, .J- .grkz uLS .g:: .:*; .\<"-r"i ;: .s-\f :,, .jes; e: .I . t
.r+d:-t l; rt;-t* oG; .:J j, ",!j!r- ;p c,l;l:-9r 1:U 6 ,j"_f y :t .F, .r-*r q t )J-:
l-, *V.:t5 olJ-to ci .:*l r-q.r- .r3rr,r * ,j-F -y :t t* 4r1.t ar,l LU;I .), .,, .LLJ
..:1j-",yi a,
WWW.AEL.AF
f\ tr \qO2 Lrn."Q -tUKi*
\.lr* -," a5 \ 1Y . irs ;r 6t1T .9t";f3", J[-y- aS;-l .;*l & *i .rr'1 Jp
dy- + !b-,,. $\S -Jes 6;lr:l a" J? ,x::alt;lrj; LgrLdliil t:lsrt ..,.; e ..,,L,<,-
.slF l+ ua.lr{ 6"lt*1 ,g2-;r-Ns.
.1jl:-,-r Lo.:*l.", ;-l ;l7uL;' a1 )-;,^ ,* *V,) r, ,-lrJ a5 L;i;l
.jl-'bL ,34 63*;l ^:J-rr,.,.9G;3L:!;1 .91a.-L # et+ e- ..r2f)'
.g5 a-;lrl ,.,r,;-;L ,r:.;ls o.t*a:.iy--L ,+- rl -r,-Uic *,4.9-,^.J -l-y c*l ;5r aS
.:3j- ,;3s ,il"r_l;,rj o;;,,K 2t aS c*l ,s\3 63-;l G:tJi:Jl t uJ 6l.q;i-iL ir
1s:-: \.j;, of e6-,r.'uoLi ,ri)r,r,,*u;l .slo:3, -5rS -.r 6l*l ;l,b> aS t*rn 6$aa.r-l *.r-l a;Ll>2"o.r-;T;l ,yo Ctf jle Cr$ 4
rJL*r- : /Vr.*-..ts + jl jli.,+.;L;l .r-Ll g;Ld,l;i p' ^L;;t aS ,;\t.rJl6.:l.u*l L" l-scn Jes 2l .i[^4;y,fu t^;T .4.Jt,1,, r(",i"p \a(L ,szlr -;iij ollsl .i- * r-*r.5 : 74Vr l,ii ii .,-Ll J-r,-l
.tu-r.j,G ;JLt f*..irU : ul * alirs:---/ e6llrl i-\trJi $ JV!-L;.<-" ,tb,*-|;ry. Je d-J6+;r +5
"!-)r -'L:iii, ,c.*l 6;G c-rG LjLe ,S ,LL-J ,gnj 6;lr( l!2 u4Lx,l-r:*,t -;$.-.i jl J+ ta;"r. r.-lr.i d/-l 4l .*l ,or; o;tJl -[5 "r-l t*,p;J.5./l..o;)U Ll .:31aiL- 4-u; y 3-2 U;\ "S il) LeJ- JrtS Jt',glrLi * l-, e-l-p ,,1 ,e:*-S uy,a 6,t\.a:il 62-;o^N2q€ Jr 3 JtlS Ca" tglt)
.;*q(,-)) .tsls 7le; l+b- r t, jy-o <.r-rG.;r(-> ;;3 ;*\ * JltG oJ +l.5c---'4-.i .+ l*b-,a t JG.1l3,-: ,J ;*L"-, .r-#" JL gy, s c**. d n.r",,-r+ 6rl-i;,1aS ,c*l o.u;-L;'l di.i- .<,- aS .;".* b -5-- r; fy." ,t2 orlr llu-o ;) ,t*e---b ,,1LgilJ...:-*l c--r(- ;--l .Y;*l .-'J .rG!l at *i*l ; <;-**";;Sl>'Ae
u--l ,- A tao s "Fr? utlK l-l *- 15sV y a;l;15;-2r --)'^tS
nl;trt Lj &-+5 c*l a-"15r3* c-3,(- .i- ,r_e13 !,-l t ,l-l .;*l ,tS 6. I irl ,5 .ul*"a reL
^. '";
j rL;L r ,3."1 J['l .rT ra .rU-,!. c:* )l 6* J-iS 46 e; "[.c ,:
;qj jl ,.r,-[; ."r;r; rt-rlr;4; jl-r-ol ,l 4e .lra ,o 4 .l*-t ,SU E ;*l 6la;tK
l. Ivor Thomas
2. The Socialist Tragedy (London: Latimer House Ltd., 1949), pp.241,242.c,;\13 ;1\.i- *../r-, .,".i3,,..rr\;J -;t ,\qOf #Jj \t olL--i 1: aJLi".(-;:.f
"1 15 ,,LJ Jll 45 J-l oJ--:.:a (ltOt .rL,iortrt :o-rJ :llvt ")L*i JU--) g;;91:J
..:-l +Jl-t" C-to*t a:.11-1 .r::u -u,d)tr .g;r;uli s ,rlf s:t.r-*oly,,
WWW.AEL.AF
J))r 61, Ll rY
o:ryl "f-.c
t G.Al_s a.l ;l aS,Jjr J*t4 ,, 'ta;
I .5 .,*JKl ar*., ;l-,.ie; .(-2, L L;li_ra ;t o)er-l> ai r31 oJ.:*l 4++ ar-l * fd& a' u! Aal;l rL-j ,.ry
[5 or, *. j (.r- e .lL*i rli.,-r ,* JLijl e,iJ.? r- *.9:il(r ^;Le ly c-jS*;L;!l 1r ).L5 ;r-ul d L.1"T ;l 3 ;-",-l + L'.ry_-l,, u:_yo OyGt2-3 ,gr-K1t ;3- d1.(- L-: *-Ll ;;G ;1 .9rl.o J# ,l *;ly Jr'S *6 e,. "-r-;L;! .Sl.^lK ,5 ;* I oll; 6113, *
3"1 ;r .9.,L-; ,,Sbf K ,S;i .e;l;r:
.'(-ru*).,. ,t; t .5:cl [oel L a-Ui.
,45:a+r Lob-,, J-,3 :> Je,.g-,Lojil g;Gi*!r,, ;,:jJ JE rslte--b _:l;;* ,iU;T -[.:5 + ori;ly; S { n a-,; ,t^6i.rtrd*L* ..Jl^..!".tS 7r: (\1fA,;\.(";lrLri,I ,;rJ) t,_,1r
,-tV:sas_t a:;y 6L2aal.ir1
# ;rr- + a5.r,too-r.--r,;l .9*r 6toJL-: d*! alu r_$L.:6 -rr ,.* A *.Lr;-l -t: ):.-+ 7r-, *6 * ;l A xle;u"v6 ri..;-l o-u: .il)l .or-: "
\u.- tl;lr, OLlc*+l a5:r;;ei.,L. l;./-t^"K y.rJ J*6 l; -15;_l c*L..ry-,"r l.jf--r
o: Lr:L--t ;: ,s5.' Jrll J3" 6. 5l ;- ,aS s*-;cs^ J# * _b *.,a-#l
r )l ,:1.--s ** ,tls Gt--:*NJ t 6l.b.9t-o*L-.r[.4 o;!9r.-u., j;-ro
.rl.-ajb J d;L'd**S; ,.rL6;, ,9;.-' o-LL r- .u.;L* ,Lb--r;, Ll .r73,L -';3T gl; . u; " .9rl;T L; rL*l:; ai ,-9rlr!l 612 l1 u.Vi -r*pt!; f l*,r;17- ;U 9 .:r5 .r*;l- l) r3j JI-6.;L)\ , o-t-J.r.--
"Ji 2: .r-:;1, 4-.i -L:.;lrr
,yr ,-l.:-iL ;iA_b.l;i r-*L &-.91r1 .r*:ly.r 4J l, ,-!t*J*;l .;i:L;!6p,JL+;r c*l ;5r,;Lf l.tl -ilrol ,l .:;,- Jl;:l _,r cs*j! ls4.$s--t
.-u: 61 4- ,i ;s <--sr- + l, L sl;.r" JU. tr;t-p of ,.-tlr,a plS
6r-t-6.1 ...r1
I . G. W. Keetou, The Passing of Parliament (London, 1952) 2. John Jewkes
WWW.AEL.AF
ttrr??;l$5J+,',i^bt J$l t-,t.-yrs.rL* qK fL+l y^l ,r-o;:^ 5)^tJ.9-" aS jt";
-;--, t 45 r.-,.ri7.-;*l .rL- vt5 t5,-;i .5 r5;Lr l)l(:i.5 -;*l ;-l el
S-- ;a:l;$rt-L. :lt!.9rli(.L ! -r,-[- a5 .g-,]lb r,,-1, aLL l; a5: .r,-l ..,i
.,li! "S G-L-l {,5(j ,-r:L a--ro lt-; .Ll .,.;!.#,}+,r"8-l a"J;r rJUi-
.rf e a^;D,.J*,i.- .t-b .5G.)-j)l ,l f-&l-! .r o+l *"o ai .:*l ;,-l "r;L,r.
:-;L o:lr 1L+l .1L5 -t-* o.l, fn^ j6 d s p"'ai"y) '.'US .+$ r) .* p1:-r..1
.c;l ,ril t^;i a,;-./U 6.itc.sG..-*j-,l i.o a:y.jLi;
.s-f,* vl:5.(-;-l r-..j":d a;Dl OT t dl.4t 5l-:.:3>.3 a5.:.(,-,1'rr*
,;\ 2: ot;ar-L..SGry! aJ f...a i- L^ C6"' t3 -* f lsl + cI-';-: 'r;-lo5 3l *L
" i I z 6 .' r.l t. lJ, z.+ -* .+:. 1 .*-' ;* .,;; a).c .rLl -*..J J
c---;Sl a1 t:' .1-tr a-il;l ;, 4 61r*.q9t-l; 6t--Lls. t,,rS -b 4 -")L^ ,.* ,31s.
;,- a: df,*:.. sl;L!i+ G-y- )l a:**.gle;-: .f.\,5'p# l':" )l c**s
L:- ot c^!; 6r,ae :\^. 7-:" 'r"L '.l|'"Lojil '9-, ;1:-c ^'. aS 4*4 a;K
J:+ + roGl;"';,; +5;i r.Ls;-; r)l -16,r".o -nt3 6T t, oS.gto*g
J*J, o-'1;LI .9L^.1(-r,-, L;. cJl-::4t r:l"..-n,J^L el;ul ;Lp + ri l^;i c;l;T
..r.y G:!-^r .gL"oK-,., ^S l- c*; .l,s 31;.Gll ! .r a;T 1l sL;.:;,;3Ui
l;;[o:!l + r-JU. a( o-ui *.3^ :,.r] l*rlirl G.1i + ilrr;:;, a5 lzl-'
S*---.;:.e-L* , ',rl jl .yl-t f 2: glz\,.;: + o5;Li.rl-r .liL )* oc-f
le .r1-,r l, JL*'l #, ," ;r. I { a;L;l ,;lyi -r,-U ,sla:Lt!ai; g;U.;(l
u-:r^ )l crrf,^.-r ;rr:i ,r*^ a.r-l -L-./,J .plr;L=l -,", .aW ,r-l ;L*l t" j-;,
;1.:le ir- J-l q9+ . plr alL;*1r !ly, .JU ;, l1 Gj L.Jn; ,si,ti ,-r aJ .:*l
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5r-, "\t I ff
:' i al*. : fS rs.J*L-l 6i< ;k*-.;oi t c+; rS l2 6,;\5 L' ;*l "15ts_;sl>r*-" aS;l ,-+ )l tf--,r^ j:pl&r[5 -l-.r .],-1" .Sj.o .::*pl ;-r""r-LrS 6- c.-l-r-o lr-" ;l+ ; ;)L_ti a+ A ,g;S.*,rt5i"t4p, il e-b .ry-t "rlr_,.>
';*l ,r*aT rl *;--!"+ +S ,9 ^-;'.be.rl-*r a, l, :6 &l ir"!i ,ir, -51,,-,,-l .rj*3 L
c*!" ff s eL, ,_Ji"t J), o: b.r^o ror.r:lj ali-). r2e. -l JE ,;l*;l jl-5 .;l-u:l *.,)2* * lrs rS ;*l JL .rLj r, orii.grl -'$l i;L* + Ly.-x
eL;l.,rLjilc-_j5lc*[.tJL*,f-,Jle ,S ;*l d;.*rlJ.i_;-l .-rur-.r CL- j
a+J -rr e ,.u;10r.:L 5t* ;t*ler .-L aL*19 7 e ot,]. 3.:- "1;L -.3l4.--l"r-"o -(tai : *.ierlr.il -t-r; ,6l,tS6l$: l- L',$L- a-l 4 gj o yl.;-l ;.r.,r-;21-: ss-* Clr< ;il* u1s:l*3rL- u-;; d^,.i! ai 6>lSl ,tyau.l, ,r,LAjlF ,Jly.f ,-?- 4. r;l: .].:l .JLi .Sl-, el; ;* ,S o*S jl ,L-lrr,L-<l -u;5 ,rt*.r l; L"OT J:li.f ',-no 3.921o,,: eGll ;: l_! 6-l; .gtncr!-lJt 4t
\:A .G)r*f ! ;- ,o3to; L-l; ; ,ut-- " -.uS,; L$l y .1ls K; 13; ;r -r,-tr
e ) )-Jt:"" fi a5 le;*lK jLJ ".qc + lr,i c*l*- + L:tyrEG.r*,,,
.-r,;:...r,5 ,912;aaL:,<g.:l.aiil ,'U;: 3 .9rl;Tl :;1";p ,"*z ,.91+J[jL 2, l.ul :t:l5 ,"-l ,r*Ll c.^
"$-:i ;-r t*. s L-"-S aJl;l \<_r.ot*
"6)) ;Ji 2-: \ 1\"A "|,__,yT;,
,S tt ,s;-rc)..9, .6l )_yrtJ" L*g A <(r?:*o c*!- 661j5, ;l ;f-- ol* * 6tgr._t..r.-",r VE t or!y, (\1f1)r3r o.ul, e-ls-s 6W oL(;;lr;lrLrjl AU'iS
.fe -5*,-b tr,:*.-l,h.l...rl
1. Contemporary Review 2. H. D. Gideonse
WWW.AEL.AF
4^Ai^
.rr".r:5.r, l.:rl lJ [a4&r;l a."ti1L; +5 c-l ;tiL5l jl ri.Jj])rlji .S-r.jl .:GL51n
t,i-*Slr]
a- +5,r-[;i ,l t- ,ti;^: +5 -[:--a 5;L; jl c.;3l-i:" ,r-.oG-,5[-a:l-r",3;
3Gj 613-".t f*lr.r" ,^:)K !.r^Gi !.g:;l-r, .fytl ,-,i t^\f ,f s
J!: r.itr;j t-fiJ Aadti-r- g aS ,1.tt^J.! 3 o:;l.i ,-r-;)t.11 a;,5U .c-; E:;t- L ,Sl, )s:d,r-,, )f )f;-a )t 6:t[ oS Jf -,, ,t 1 ,1-"5
.r^K f*l:-.f artu L.,)s,Srf dy#-r 4i'LiU Lt')f 4 ol l-,
o:f Jt-;;--ct f.> ,t ,So -Sl ,.-,(* ;*31cr-*- J) ^+,1t Jt^-lo-La[^:., y-i 4-S ,.7i lrLr, ,r:b fU L 3 La:1,q3; JL.^ ti ,Jj.r, o:1: L a,
_b y.:.,3l,ii )Ji<G 61r,. lyl .tyd oyli:e f- jla l- "K-i ,,t-lor3,j
6ln}^ s g+ -,4 d-, J 4.-*JJ;'slf- 6 ;l-*y; s rr--srta:-::lr .gla.r.{ ;;, ;ulj.ro f -* ,-lti 5 r:ti ott rjr .lL: !:;*;.r" .;J+
.-L-ti.r^j .i5 c-ry; ,ti;t ;.-:! g:;i: aS ,, .ty3 6* r r*!
#, ,-*1 y"l;"rt J ,r:S.,^j tlF lr ,Jr'y,t5 f -* 3.ttt az;\ ,\J4--
JIF Jl .r:3 -rL4l .J,r- U f=.'-;"f .i-13 ,1-t-U-rl::-l ,ll..* 6^ 45
ryslt=i o\ rh; ;\ u^6 q91r, oL-l i-& r! a;i;K ,l ly .rnl; oL-a
l; t-orl-r,y; QE ,,!L; s a:_p ;l u2>Lz, ,4 ;.c***i c-u31 /t'Q r-j[j.)jL./ yt(;[,.:fi o,raL]." j-1b os AlrJ c.,.j dL-l .i- ,sl-r
l. Lord Acton
WWW.AEL.AF
,-!tt Jt I ft
jt-f ,JXt o;L3: g;1r, "fu
t"r"; tJ+, 4 Jf.-,5J-;E-i-a..^-Ga-;rll tL:-" t[-t J-5; orr5 o]aLiu ";L3: ]1-r- ! o;3: erL"-r ;:l)J )J:S &- -,: .J c*-, J."r* 3 r*1 tFi 4 ;al oS Jt- E i, .r)3} ,gGo;jr ;: ,-t^, .!u:t'. {L: .;6- hlr; -,, ,IiL o>r5 --J
Q oL-, 6. -,tL: j,c-l a,Lt- 6)!j -to l; c--l ,i,*:l3 ..rll ,r-r,":" 5taijl a!.7.rt.a !.r.l_r,f .rr 4.r-atS,,tL;_-r, .J;.:5s- J^" JL..(1 .-,-or-\.+l.j "-L^L- o;L3.: l; 6* $i*" tL:; J-lr" $..-t ,;S \ tS:s"Sti .-tijt* cgla-,-r! )-p 6 .r"t<r^ .-r.jlo.i.; u:t ,fV ,t* y .-r.ls-,.el,1QL^,ll ti,,.-: JU 7.1 J * !.:.--* r! rJ:l +5 l, ou.:--k*.glr;L."(:-:/cr:p !l-, c5.!-ra 6L^" L^ii )y-t/
E_:) -r!.51r,,c*1 a:;b:;3-rriVt-"r-tJ;lJ-,Llrlrjll ,Lail .x_S,r )J- 4i
"n- tl:;51.5Gi1;;"
.r;*l -ualg ,_*l: ,rgb ,** tac^!r+ ,S x;Su, +r.ey
c-iy" r- i,.l 45 ,*.5 p)/Lrl ly qti3>ti c-;^;> ;-l .-l S_,sro Jf4.tt -W,c-lc.-;:.g;b;l;.e.J.JIF -h; .rr;.: L 6.:*"loUJi
6L"Jt- tt 6 ,_b-li jlj;r o-t-r" -rYL-l3oL--K;t _tt \lr J *L cj;4d ,-slyr/ G:\-y-) r e5:;l: 4l-G ,)tr-,lio-L-i oIrL** oLJi;r ,"-l*l .r-rl; ,c-l ;Yr.t J-; q_5 ,Jt- &l ! f.s.f ,:S 7 r- gL-o ;:tt -Jl .rt-Jrs- ;;lr*: Gsr+,ol-:_,a;: y-i-e a- c^S;L ji;, nS
ab;:! ,*l cd-rl*oli; r: p"*i :3> i-;yrt,Jt<l.ijl- L ,crr-l;Let el :..s. 4-a: _=;-:.-; -Jr, -
| ) ); .51 tp .r,ilo)_i- ;"1, 45 fa-*a.g.-! +-tr -rr"lsi;r S;4"
,C j:S K-+ ot-"lt ,.5,.J;.^ oLJi q ".i-;. .-.rYL-l y oL*-Kl ,4-^-aJn1 !
^5 "u"l t;li.f LA i-,-$l r- Jl$:.-^J; ,*<!.:;l,r-J.ruL; i_SeJ 34 U"A J*;, eLJi ;: fi; rr- aV G,.L- c--aL^i: ;l s* SR;l ;r,l3;Sla-a.>;l::3,-y La.r-lrS;,":;r Loa-:.,til .SF JL-f :,,:i;l -f,1
c-illil a- 45 6A...r,aJL;L- a5:;b :j->- j J>lj lf ,?.li::.-U. ,t^rr;S
;SJSJlf ;*.,o.-ul; Jal3- L;-,-rta; r.atr".rlt S! a-$! *:.rcG:,tL.-o ,jl^("r- 6D J er:ey, rr-JtJ;rr ,-rL.-a ,,.o:;;-; cl/ dl; dl,.
WWW.AEL.AF
)t ;t2r. J'-t- ).))t> rf ) ,ra!U:L.zl 3Lr-r.i9;r LUrfyS Ji).rt1 ..(:., ;-1 ;l L -t-ilcrl:;" t- gr^l=^r+ iQtc)l.-.pl *. ^S r-r-;) o: ,r,S\t r * -, #,5 rL- JL aA :\ b.td +5 r,:--"a 6-J, UU, er(L *:;l: f*l;# :-.-^,o;:15;-l J* -,t L.Jlo:i> Et+ll;;I.g;tl ptE:t---l
;: l;,tL^Ji JL,olr,.r L^ii -,) 45 J-;)l) rj-7 l rK-t !Li; u-,f--i "-o:
oL:i
,t .r;.-J!- *:ub 6 ;U: jl.>:- Jt;: JL c.*-rr U ":;,1- iL.,G ,S1
.t-:f L;- -t-Li.; :;y- C;Jl & a\ie \,-rLol-;; L-i G_r.o ::5;) ":+;) ,c**l ii,srrt! .. J-11" .r-S ,*tf ,r;t3 16rL-; otJL-
J n ef 6t-a"q 45 oJi; cgld-r- _,yS * "[-! Sr ,r.7l.gLoJL
..uil:.r- tt-5.lt * \ ii* jlrl4tel- 5;L-5 pLj .*l oJ; a:;r;
.,<;-7 j'-fl ilJ+,j* 4 c,r" ! $1-r- ,jUi:rfl^. t f,i ;$.4 S,a'"U c-; ;u;r^o
"t-u,' -r!!l ,5:3.io U 3 iU*t(t ;: l; G*L- -, L^gLj
.C*l o:b ;l;u-L*J J),.-,!il,:-al_(:l; )t \) ;\;)13-ry,tl-ly: -l1 .r-"r3 .;J 3,'
-o o-l-t'r cr)Ll ,: t; :3.>- ,.c-o -6, no -. .JUi 3,Sj*2; J*, ! 4.:,,
J-rN 45 .*l o-L; CG "*-:1, ,,* o:.Err i;t: ;r .C--1 oJ-.-il;j(,iL*J<l
J r:-r JL* jo t+;al r;t":; o:y,Li sLJi ;: l; g:l;i6 -.ab:-,o )l .f S
oL.[;, aqX;l ;^S e ,ilS*l ol5a y ,rL;;r.l CU s .5;.j S;-t
;: a5;-l ;l:>f u* 4-E-y. jJu oS J;t er)ll )J-t/ o,-t--s! ry,
LJ* J.-u;p*J.r1t-o,tL:l al* \,5! a+ )l -:l>-t7t'Ur.-c E.r,,tt^.lia5 I:l f+".tb:ro 6lr'\ J;;L-tq, 6 J:3,.!\f_r"r.9La;y5;r..,t.;rF )t-?--l ljii.-f.; ;r o<; ,[t; L5Jl{t- Ji:3r _,,ix, t^;f o+,i pU; ;t
"ts,,\s-, ".,54,r<rl:- ::-;yr )\ G;;-r.,sl; L lli ,Jt= ;lt.l)p ;> ,'-i)Lu SL^gjl:.tr{ y L^-r="I -},-: Slr t .r(:t"i J };Lt,I .4:;l: :y->3 s,LariLr :3-t* Ul .>;l> .-t:;----a F CU:3*l; *li 6Lt; ;L-7: c*l;-(* * f"Vra )ts t U fr! +;1.:.5fi --ta-l; 6;-l,i.- -:jli -r f*=-t, ))+ 45 ,--;l> l; -r:l .r.,t!, 6tU;"5 .O;tr "-r*:Ji S,t::-:rUj! n<! );+ .i* i;-rr .^*J!"y.-SL^otir- sl1 :: o:;S\j
l. inevitable trends
WWW.AEL.AF
J:,"1 ,n rA
.r"t<l^ s> ,J:^+t f::;., .f,1" f)-," -r--* a5 .:-l G;g.rl .:l t^,J!:a
;: .rlb .gG,'-:j; +Li,JrU 6\sa-a;-:- -,1 .S-,!-: ,-rt-y sgLoc*a[*: 45
J) ...t; o-rr* t#J t* y. -*!t*"y- Jtj-l-[ ..-rt^Ii 3 .**ryJ a*-;;I-,I.u,,.f f-iju 6l^;<rLi ,l ;t-ly tl-s )F 5 ,tlii;l G_r!t ,++r,
dLi&.i 5 cr,Lalt"j.5lr, Jt- E :s ,J')itb.ti6l^+l* pL; ;l +;G:La 3
.-t.Sc, ,:.')" tt-1rf l)o*:1*-l a, ra.;r-t-!i^*.o oJ;i .jJ[; .5La;_9-5 ;r La;ira1 g! CL:i oJ,:J ao-o ,alJl
,..t:l ;t, c-'a &j+^-A .f^r.r- Jll ./kili a.r.+ Cq J.l: >F e.a ,. Ll
,'r,-l ,'f- y Gl s, j.-ua 7-.a r);r g*t ,<l $JrJ.-tj-rl.::-l tac-.s,+ 45 c^*+v-v J vr.e (iL
j<.* Jt"'--t-a"i)U oS -u-a) u4:;;; ey y pf ;1 .c.*:;l:,_.*j )J-J ?15-u-l ,;ljl ;_l U t-l .J-Xu- c^;1"- t^$r:* )l ,tr-S -pq a, c-lril^J "raLi 5 ); ))-
-y -5;$ --F -* 5 c*j:b t3> j ;it\
r-* 6l,,gL; ,o;51 o5 L.:c/ h y rA_$,Jt- r^ t.d-l J tl eySi3-: )* l'J"U- tas- JJ;SI r-;t *U, Lpy -p;;t;r ,; t,t5L..lL, Cr;" J.l J) 45 ))l) )FJ oav,f,!:;-*"^a r.(1,:3;.rr "4*#
.gr a<ly bS t-b \uVyo-r !,rL.r J-fl\)! c,,i-1, q L^_,_r! 6 ;L" orf Ch'rL1 .rySl ,_r; uK c*l;-(^.4 r"r- c..>-a ji;rLr, u 45 L,^JL-J* ul.c*+ ,ri;b oy[; jid!+ rr Cb SC;-; L [, e,a:;3,.91o.r:-] J .u-..a, Gf U),4-f
c-l -5* ,-;6-,,-l !-u.:^*a ,*JL-.* il^l-r, rl-K: ;l )-^S G, j;-iL; U:-.1,, -)t qooJ.-(-^-ilr" -bL,*-L-r-^ol, JL-C- ,r- - r--' ,-f .r )')r -- c* r* ') r=':"-r;a,-rl!Lo"t5-r,r n5l; GS ;l n5 c*lulf*" e .r^lJ+ -&t er-S,sGcr'\f y:-r:93;51 .rK"t oUi';.Jl. --tl:: :;lt3u-;'U -;r'*L,rr +5 r-^^-y r.-1, r5'L C-l -&-r.-ur(t .r:fc-;V:- G>ss- l: 6.r::*a
,t(:i 1; c-a^ilJ 6 l* c*l ,_,--.r er=+a rrcl-;*o .*Jt-r 5^^ AiSt
g-a> a"bl l; fJL*f- t+ tu c.S,- {! t" 5 :;lr -Lrrj ,r; ;J .c-t
,r-V.+ t-i ,t-S &-f o. l, c^S f ,.:lU 'r;--l)li ,: L i-i S-tQ* s
.rf;L -i;*
WWW.AEL.AF
fq tr uJi.
.,*5 5r i<? J.l ;: L +5 c*l "l,t" ,ss f t*F ,#, a,:-$ !
l-, aK i.r* .r;L ;a!toL--71 lrii 45 >;ls) > j-71 ua 413 J-t" e^.kl n-.r,.rr5 f+lf ,s.2' tt6yy-t-i7rr q9r,.l,-[i.rL:-1 CyLrl ! i;!-:)
o351;[:bU:rl6 u,ry Li.r7 r^lr- l*5 a,l; L 5f ;16.-l;1oLeil 3l rn .g:lr-il :-9-l*" -L,i-e .r5,i -r:,lr.i tr rar.rr .5-r-*[i;-ylr-" 1,-l tajl t11 ,5la;*lt; J or; #\.jt C-:> j L:;[i,JK"l ,-u1Li orati l, $rl:
cglr-,:! a.S.r.l !15 La; ,a:jl: Jt;;- 5F \ lJ c^+SL :lil +.-o;1 6ili-
"<Ll c*+:r-i-,t il't- -LLJ ralJ, t+5 q l-, t ,,)t,F €t"s,
6lGrjl; Li.r;b jL-.:LJlq99-r c-.-^al aS jnL--.:-L -,15*f:3; ;-r-.j q ..rrl> .$; 5lr, a-:tat(.ril ;r a5 .:;lr )J<J J--l )l tS :-r.il sl-e ^s ;-:il )e4J tl-t G* J t; ^t*lt;li ,)13 sgl-ooLi q aU""
!g[:r5.;;L)* toL;;l-,: -r:!l:+ 6ry-l t;7:;1.: ,_rJ ;SJ,..rU, ";-j)\: rtr;j :7zs atl: f*Jl"r Jl.;*-U d,-tb:ro y.+t Gl:,. GVor.-[-:.. ))-t- L-t--.a-y;.:3,--;,-;r l: -:;Lr" ;:[! l; L ,..1 ',,1 6 ty;:a5g;LA,JL"j);l ,Sr:l ci[.: j9b 6 J; ;J.oli.f .,-5 5;: l; r-ia,-rf"
Atl j Sly L +5 -*,b.-r" .,.*^ <-+ Jl- , t^ji.glre 5 :;b rg3 \n.r;r.
."-tr- c*l "g;5 -r-l .,'=a: -$; ot":t^-,:tt ,"tb l-, ,f -SJ') U ,-eJ
,L., j$. SltG 5 Ja+ ";i:"
qgta;3[ L ot oi {*.n it5..tt .c*; ;t5 t"l
;.: ta;:U :j-- ").al,SUCL
jl ,r! Jl'b L. .>L1!i ;l a5,r:.-f;: ,,11. ::.-rlr jt* J5.rr orLi;li Jt(":i ari-9U -,: d! )* ,c;,5:;1/J1+:-J. frr- oL." l; c,G*L: ..el 6:r-* 6 ,lG) c-l ,ji[SU ,Jf c:* ::jriir. c*<-i ! .:U"l; J,l ;l6 Sfu"t SV f : d-# i:; ,5Lo;3"5
Jl-S-r.i F-r! )r.rJ) ft c--;;t5,p:;-r! -,Lo a,;;; raly""., ;r jl
.,-.rl ,5ll L Jl ;ol: 3 *l -u.;jrl i<;2J,',I;;l,q t "rri 5 n*a: rl-:;
c-*lo:t-4J,JrrS t^,Jiq f:$ cSU:6 ;l-W JIJ :t {J- dU),{9:;L."ts.r+, CIUS
.5lo.5;3rL!: ! urLl;:;-9-r1 -,, l^.rlf -f: 6 c-l ..tt f;-u'U .:-;9l. positive ideals
WWW.AEL.AF
J:-.1 ,n
a5 .ullo:lr .-rl;i l_r ui-r-a ,l ,_/Js, al4*Llt 3 .r;lU .<,- ,<+ ;l .|*! rtl;3:
;l l; oUi +5 .r,Lac-,3t-a c-aAl" J dL:*LaoUj i;L;: u3;>r- ,J*,3 a,. L-i)
;, o-ii ;l ,-:J .tlj:r a-r dJ J c.*l e-- i.f-t-o c;t-- ;L;" a,*i;r;*L"5 L .c^^il: : j7i ,:L;;$:- -i[al c- ;: 3 .>[Ii ;: o[i-Laj)l:t- 45 siLaJJ! oi -,lrl J) J&ir 6 gtrrS:-, l-, -,y! .,el l,1j fl".;,- ?:yrF):r f:+- ;-&"r,5Gt-crli-,!tr G: c-i[-.e a: oL:t,c:clJJ, o. bii I?? 6 -tJlo:;3-*J
-, JJtn;lL *l; ,* s =<
yl;.-ltii.c*ld:1,
f*.Jf'-r Jti:;I ,-^a ! : )r 4l;l>a,Lr* c/.t; ;, .^*Jl=-r JUJ*U
3:1 ,- -r-y" p::, * ) +l; Jl-r -.4^ ,lL, )l +-a;-i -r+ fr-5 niJt>,
;t(;L-[ _r pU;: ji jl 4?J5i t, j+ La.r dcli;l ]G ii-l ol;i +?? u I
;V-b;.gLa.L:;l:lu f,-;b \J Li- ! r#l L 6 -i:-*o .g>lj +-t- [,:tt., *S l: u4,: o5;1#, ! g:I",u:Sr" 3O U-oL; ;l: }! t" +S
,g--6 J_-.,r; P y4* .;*l yKtrc;..,,g:r5r-.] 5;: g-r;,, a+l;r,
6 l* ,pJ 5;r 1, c*l or.; )l[-l \ f 6 ;)_,; a;-tr,-; aSoI
..^l:.: 4i f;5* U 45lr '..rbe, ,r-t^*;l-S c-l ;K.- ,-F;, .ra4.t5:3,,1i -;-.a Logl ;l
: .5;:6 ,lt: b ,r3, a-oly;.; .F_," ba[Ji! oL-rrrr, :t f _r^U
-S-t ,\ 6 Sl*--}l ,"=<ji c.-l JE L^..rT ; ;.u51r, 5 lj jLarr.L -L-:ja, ctl-ti:*,-517 -u.:---o ,t;'Ul:6jU"F*a L^;tJi5 c*l ;,1 ::f u" Ch.)\ A* tt*L *-_b ;tl.Jr-"J!:L;cl"l.l!,_rl+ e :1G:
"!tr *_: ji
,.+,1s,LJi fi; ;: ,c-;K JL- r- J* ,:t aS \ ;J-SL-rt(t ;t*.":._-r;t
Jli Cil,-.i >;yr lilo:r.( -o[^=j l;:3, ; ,<l ^ol L;;C : :5,. ,f*.Jt- oS u4K)^.-iri, JL- :h.:-a a5 5.f .-,^"lf*a i;;>;l ;l .-r-ar.r,
)p f ;l -;+ c;i6,l, rr.g:lj;rL r)) )J; !Lj1.5 oJU"
tJ", .:;l;l-lJ-t J':)f ,LeJt-oJ:., -* j_fdsi, ,.,iJS -3LJI y: oly ;lgf,r
l. illusions 2. John Stuart Mill 3. On Liberty 4. Goethe5. Wilhelm von Humboldt(Lord Morley) )-,:- t) u"t_6 ,*;"* AJV\ it u"y o! u.t c-.r ..'(^- 4g)pjt*^ .P
u(i r;3- :: jtf (Recollections) .9 nLn.r-tL;l 1l 9 eS r-t! J, .p c-Li -r,13;"r".r-r^:; n:rrSoUI;l l(.L:r: Jl"-t, rg:lriirLr:r 4JLJul-l J)-rLl 4i t;Su, c*.JJ,jlr;l
WWW.AEL.AF
A\
Jl,r*[ dF jL5t", ,.r;)*t )l p st d Su- G:-l; lr c*;lJqg-ruljt(-l 4 -',Jr.-a c-,;ly=--l o-r--* -r "filrS ,yby -f*Jt=--.:*ljL5 6la u,Kl nfl ,.*lB Jl(:;i;: .lK.l:;1.$:y ..r*Kl4 _,
.tr-Se ;tijL',UJi6:ly qgLaqr.L 6la+a*.. &i+ ti,iiC -,;ti ! nt
:* o: ai ,-ul*-a JJJr ot.;qc&A L-;Ui l* 6 c*- j: J-l 4J"t-
;=.n .l"t-- 4S!,J--iLi ,rr At lrr jl ;.:1c-*l;5*,g:l;;rLtS-t:p, s o:fl)s: rjr Jt-il ,aLiK JL :Li,o J* -t, a5 c*l ,Al-;,jil c-it+ :tl-fi d...,al -, c-l oJj :q-r\s [^-,;!
-,1 u,cV a-oj * 4la.rLJi;..." o ji .c-*l.rrj)! a, l; tajl dt*" :r toW,t-t :sr cS:s;-..-L- L^jLJl ,".ty*Sla-a 6 ,.rrG cEL^_,y! )l Jp 6t+ a1 Grt -p )l
s: 413 +rd 4 "Lr _,, 6 ;L5 17; c-l SV-E fr -p 1l ";* r;l:
-r L^-,lr ,-91.ss;l 6:;1r rgy ,ti jl "rl-,^
.tSut ;-f J.Su, g3;.r!; jioLJi q )y.J.z aS c-l^ j\l; J-,", -,1
.lJSl L 6 t"\' ,sl-S t-S .*y Cr.d.-tbr-,! Jl+lril ss, 7:) Js.f ;r L r,l:, i-f j *.rt*-t ! y -r:--*
J-eL;- .b .i),g tJ.-J {. g.s-rc/ l),)tiJf L^;t-Ji.lu.;t-6,)U+-A t"
)s+J I l-, cgjU ftJoJ LA;LJI o;a3 c-J+ir L A 45 J!-u"l ulllt )y;,-r
,3i oS .;U^rt41 -,1 cS-,t"** *5;-,1 ,5lr- )y-d,J11-9L-r trt "r-t ,(-l o:;3i
.llf .f".-; L ,, $lo:rjT )-trs \ l, :;Lr;)y-Lru a-51;l .-,L5 ;l ;: a5 .g-r- L: lQl ; ,JLJI;, La&rJ"k f*dc--iFl J g5tlG olrrL; ;:* L*i c5.:*l Ct* al jl .iJl ,i.^ rl^..-
a,.l7.".^ ,uL c.*;: r-*r' ;,-l ;ll"l .rt;- o>l: La;3*5 ji;l La.g-t*;
, L-a. <l*j rl , < 'L- 9 -;; & ,61 ,- I ,+ aJ :lr -t-al ; v-; i- r vJ- .l) u -vJ J a J L_-
d c*l ,-5* *a-1: ,u*.lkl : ali-r"l .gLoa,Li;3, ,l)Col:Kfl; Grl43; iiU.r-:U a:^:l::tftel.r--Jt=-:- 6rlr.5La.t(4) l -rpv Jt- ;:Jt *-U ;: e5 oJ\:.-i J Gr.L- ;-& ai.J5 o-Lat^:. *;r ,g;[ila;-7 ;:L 4LL- d.lL^ii L-i 45 :,.-,5Lr- oJ.oL:-- lJ ,_.-:SlJ br* f-lV*€,+ )rb 4J.-t*; nt;K1.":k!l.r- -E y-*Jl---* {-rJ+ li iLirrtr"
[. Thomas Carlyle and Houston Stewart Chamberlain 2. escapism
WWW.AEL.AF
J)-al'tl AI
,* d,, c-:L.- :;3- ,.IloJLjt.l $r--*. J ;l 5l^L;;: 5 .tl.j'[ a.-a t-;g--Jt1.'"r JU-6-U .r n5 al^-,-rtr Jt-;.;t -rr ot-j eL.-a ;.: t^JT
^5 qr,o
l; ---;t, $r:+- ifl ,iTd3;: ;: oS S*- L j ,"l.jr3, JGI ^*3 u<*AS i;;-;,1 ,Ll ...r*-Lj S; tt...rl:;_ry;5 J,:y yj,>t,rjoErl C ot+lfG^ ,rl jl "i*.i
rir;,, G.g;Ll tll. :t € i,.-*)elta;; :l.l^; i-r- jlt^,ifIir3r oI; .-*J!"f t-;Ui 4-&A ,iar"., ..AL- t : .!.r ;r 5 -r-a:.r^j
45 JJ.bJt^A .)yr ou .IlJ .**Jt - _r-- Li if,, d;L* a- f*JlrJ _,
.-!!"f Jt _r"U {{r--,q.)) 3 rrc-l;l JV S>f s j3r cg-a: ,-rL:; 6:l:.r*l
.;! c*J! y.4-16L^CE r-tt* orl**a 5 c-l1;- jl dy ,bVJi :t,,rl;l g-,!* +5 c.*L-
"rl q ,-utr c*;: ,"-ii J,l fl ,J; f C J,-t/
;: o:l;1 tiJ4 ti ,JJ51f- ,o[1Lor3t +, &--i ! ,-*.Jl."r ot(.u-nL,
.J:5,r" .(.5 c.-l 4:rJ JLJI 6 .r^1, q oL*:*;. 1r5 c+l"r.o ! ri.lt-6-1
6L.oo15-ur L oUyl ,16 ,r G"-Sl-rKl cltr";) jl.3rL-..1 5 a;|.:.r"
-,1>Litsl'\r-a145;LJiot<sQ o!, ;l .ro1;l ,* u.45 s:* tr;teLiUl .Ilor-i ,>:, l,i:6 ,trS- ttl 4:t :s_f Il_r.-r-.tL:,,_r*J!-y-
;*.i .$[:b Jti;l -r:.*o ;tJi ^t ..tl,.(, C l; yl 4l,,1lr5.rat^L d.dl J+J]
-rq 4i l) L^iT .JU4i,+, a5 rir-9, .4b--Jl=-r L^Jil 6 *l .ri c-;:o+-r oUJ,)L*J<jl _, l51y';.: Gc-**'lty J- ,s Jjt-r ii ;l ;lS iJ-,)l G*. c--it^- JLJ,JL"i*Jt - J- a-5.- .,1 i*;: .e-Jl .-u!.:ra
SxsL-*f ;l 3ll":;3iJ* q otiJJS :> G*-sJ,c-.:r Lr*, 4l.l ,J;:,al{-r et etl C oqJ- 3rr+ ol.J;: 6 ,p* dl=-r J
\f-+l*- Jt, oV
d.lr -ualr; .L-.1 Ll t.-t-^rr- ,*) tu t" ./rl ei+:.-l :l S;-:*./k+l. Prussianism
,ra-uL;L Ajl-a6i'iL .l aS s-J:i J;: -),|-(:; r g*JL-r o!* .r- .r*."..$ 45j,l .yL--;'l* _e; ..1 ,,j11;;K;1 ,:ro ,rl-t 5-(-, -,::-S 6l ;: aJ S.:* o::3- oJ-.i
pL: .9;U5.-! oUJi 45ii ,l p Lacr.r- .S.r, d_r* 4jblj Lgili d jl .5Lrc--.J!-_i*
"-t-:; gQJl .,drjyo-,r f-Jl-- ,dltr 4jttJl5 "<i oJ,+*A -ElJ J3,rl g-Ll11 .J-9:
6 j1t *rl- er, r_:, ":f -i'[ ,kDl ,cl ,l ,! (Novalis) n)l-sy 1rtt JrLi ,rJti:3*i a--[L) (o_1 oJ^LJ o;bl +iE,1l5 4 ^r.- ;A gt"!..r 61; 3," AUl jl g*1; .tu.]Lr
Glauben und Leibe, oder der Kiinig und die Kiinigin .[3;:;L^ 'ry "r.::*;] .r!lt_r 'tt.([\v1^]
WWW.AEL.AF
OT, tr a-"rir
.:r5:t411 1;:l-t*-l ,pt-r ,a;s 6l- 4-.: J)31 j6 -f gS -,-,tr
\ *-s: j Uql l'.i ;LJi oS )-.t p-*q-r, d : #L- y- 6l-a"K4> 7 2;,f,) J)-f .*-St- C-:* ;) 6 .,iU,.t ;1 a,j 3 o:y; ;l - y .-;b S p tp
.t 5 , ,* -;t"- ry JL;3"-1J 6 :3,. o>rS cAJl.r^il- 01 jl J
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
I *, - a
#J.u*h,S; $l_1
d;;L-i ltlii 6 c^+ ,al r-rl ;:Q 1 6 6la.Ny.l
r.r*l or;3> J^-l-i ..1-J -.r-:l 2> >r- ,gls. >l;\
.> ) j--p.ti.Jl.: .r-)L j.9-:.a ei .:*l ji "lJ.i
rc*lutfi
cJ3j3-2.s .jl
J-a:,r-o dLl-i 13; )l ")r' *.*Ja.,i dJ-oj r- 45 u'l<61: 1; r_1> .glo.:_9-, J I Jt-Lil , 6 6r":*.Jr":+, Gq \ 6 CU: -t-" ol-r-",o cu-;J 4*K ol;3: ;l a5 g*L-.,-. .4L-4.:;lr*: 44 oe f.f.^r.r tlS lilr )s-r\ r.rLrr; -fr\6k -f ,*rJ :* y-Jjrjcr-,!*r t*ir.-t.rr$ ,-p-; 11- 6La6l.l1i A;g! &tl" -(^ U Ui
,-.a Ujf.r-;l".r;SJ 1t5 -ie at=i, dr:rt- ,51r. pl.r- cL .rLall U--k )loJ-l-l orlr O_* *. A>l)i s cJt.r-" coU; i--6.71r L 6La.r.-l J t^",")g
cV u. jt-c-*t" -il-r-al1lrryU:" J$Jit^",ry, U-l ,PVJ\tc*t#;; ti-.r-:,.^ ot f.:" 6ja ;4a s u$':,;,Urt,,5tt,"[i-2 3,5rljit-" +5 r,-r:-.:L o:rS -rir, jfr:b t- t>t-i d-"q 7F S6:t 6 cri_* )ll-t -*.:_rlol; fty-1 as;i;t Ji 45 f# Sss-r.:l.ri ,.1t1!y
# f;. )l 6 6,\<b.J*:t, J<-. 6 ,.-a tJ"a -f fr;*i ):a +\ p6
WWW.AEL.AF
.,):; ol; u dP
# 1::t+ -t-.iq .rl!-l ;lra,L f -pb dJ; -,.4 tt #,61^,14a -e L. ) -rv" 6,rrL^.11,t-l;,li t* t.-,slK I 1. ciL"--, oaC *L .<1
,S1 rt.K.^ -..:*1,s b6r\"SJ; ft' sl, y bi glaL .j_,F
J* tt 6 Cs-*,,5t-aoJ,15:r,r-e, ,>l9l 4l U JelY t" f* j*, k;: .r*Ll .:l-,,-$ J $y. S,*tolr;<; l)J- r+t 6ly. r.lK ,J;,Sl-tJ.-t--iL o:y t-t;;utr;; c*lor19T )-frJ \11L,rct -71 ,_SX::&+ :n:+t g;--a.r["T.tLil; j-f ol--.j|.*; f \""r, ,-it-*,dir-ly .l..i!.rLr3-- u-tl6;lJ;6aa.l xliC it-3-7;J5 (J 6>t"S.rorU CpJa1,-rLql-a.t[- ti ;r'-;;z;l:c- .yr )l rfl6&,
.c*lor;31 )j?J b. g":.ilr;Uill+7iljt rr3U:."
a.-:1-", .<, o-.Ka;--l O:l; ,3y* .-tr-c J e3-tl +-o-a c5 ,Jt- r,tl ,P ;- 6 g,-t_r! -bV y,c.*l;ly^ir .:G3l.raK ,_*e nlJb)r-t*,llJ, ,*;*-o .j-,t* JL-- 1: L^diLSly .i95le t 6 crl'^d-:j;l .(:-cr-,aV Jt- -,) q-Sl.rr_S t-y.L -3t cgte r.: -t cof -,1_.p.r,-.ri .lty,.rt-ir;r: ,gly &a Jt-;r 6 u"el;.b ,F ey )l G:l;,y c5l^.Jt Ji
"f^<-i^s .!;t ;;- ir,l o5 € .;ytS -r-_L; c:rJ*- Ch tu
dU- J-i-, r3r,-r1U,:tlelJ jr.j afTtly;r :) c,-i#, ciy.# nj cGqj,.t.il
a-, ,.:*l.Ja4t+lc"5.r_9.-6L^;S rtq.1t a, 45 6,lA;\l;6y13 c*lAiJ) O)Jl qJ^.,.:*l o.ri r3-bco J.ilo-\--i -L- t-a.ti a, a5.at-a;y-}.S
r-c j Lgs Laoi6;y;. cJ--iL 3:- 9 Jr*: iJX qtl /t'Jl-;.rFyr )l 6f-:-.rSlt ;lll:,_ptl,r
"lil*. ! u#)f il ,Sttl: e-&t
.sr.r" c#) tu c-*,1 o.u-(il c,L a:-ly e t 6[ld&i J 6cll_j;-c a- i ca-.j;6tL-::i t-i t-Jt "l3,.lLJia;Lrr lJ rlt,jJla-r
9.,6...1Ty, 1,6 6-* o-i 4 JJ4* d* y+(L .r3U:" 6t^dq-X _t* g q p t-. .tt:"--i ro;;5U
"5c*: t..:* I I l3*i : 6loj l-lJ I tj
",lory;r a--jTe .rsiyG:, U jl X"t5 taJi r;5 fJ 45 c*l ;..ll.-iy ,ir:+11 6
l. people of good will
WWW.AEL.AF
AV tr oJjla; ol;
J) I"^JJJS r*leJU,Jt- d./lq.J^, ? la;l1r rli,r.; r$l jt;lQ.lit*it-".:iu u 6lr ;!sl6tt*,Kjr-e c6.r1-L;-l lV ::* il$ g;t^JL
c.*1.;L,:-rl -# C-S -S> Jj..".* ,i)V rt-d.c.*lo:1.r clLlJ g.:.'jrlt-;j"U;-,1L rt-a; ?-f 6 J-;ta:iJ ,-*, tgf .ltT olr(.: rlilr 6
.c*lo.r3"J ,J,t,-r. -*G .-t-lc.*l ,* Ug;taoLriL
Jjl5l 6oU?=ii t, .it6+ ctJt*it o:l-,11 (SJt J l"a4-!$l ,*i, 6 ,".1 ,rl .(;r
-; v-a aS,'rl I c-r.i: ,(i , ;+, '.., lr r,-U l$jt.jl J:7r-a cwl a;;-L c*-.4
J-- C_- V- J J er.V
.r'.* e;L JU 5.b\S-tGj- cSlr l-, t,:.,y at+ &ti- -s: igtfJ \J
JJr.r-l a- LiSc-r^iU;l-i,.:r JJsl-jK\.rlr.:L ,slt eVJl t +ul-.-LiloIL"'-& !-ulgr- jlcS-,L*t Jl .rit;i,F lr,:i.c;r4;l;: 6c.-l-t-o 4*S ,F el-t 1-,1- -.r o.:1.: c^-4; L ol nS.;LajLriarLtr j;;a
ir,-t Jl J t;-#e.;;: o.rii;., Li| 6 -l,-.rJl,r^ ,-gt-a,:LriOlr;r a, ritorrS
L5LAlr-l.S "<! .rU<- t+raj 4*i< JL Y A )t 4J* t^Ji 45 a;-; "tfl rt,--131 J=.,o Li .:*;.: a5 ,.,:lr ;U:el rlL^^.o .-tjl..lrS A-$ J t t l:b )-f-, # 6J;it )-alQ erri rry g;t^a:-sl tr t* *. +i,)*.>:
4 t '. \
): il";; )l s -St.gb;y5 ,_-J\a-*1t-c." J).F), :-rC o'L"Li 't;l5
ur4 ,5ly.,J#y c-*1 ;r5-" Jsg, ejSc d e* ,sl-t.6.it^Jilt 6* L;! I,l,;riyJUJ<I.\ lY'\ v qftt l.J-iU a:J,l> >j>i61iL.
o:i-, ,-rx* J$Ji0t"i JiU .J:- ,r;r; * ,gl:i * iry df j4,JlFr> SttF,st 7:t '*:zil,f-r g;LrJt- a-, rlL-xa-tiL- o5;lJ -tii 5 -r;ry
r.c-l or q, J*;1.^ t9 e E t Jl;,Sl;, 6 a5 $1.:,r"
c.r-i;l.:,r5Il.,1!t aGi oi ;t L lr, )-# 6.91.15;..^; a:( cLl
I . laissez-faire
9 ;3)S;,1 cJ3: "y,fi *r;l
'>,U (Macmillan Report) iX."6" r\lf Ja ji ;: .r: .t(l)r/ cJrJl -ru;L"-a .rar,-t" q .?i q ,?)- )l -b-ro,ji "-r'il,r J *.iJ) .r"-l sl;-e:
t-t-u,6:lK,tiE JJ,-i-. l-t "rtf .gl".ll;-i -,:l q,-rlJ:I,:l +Li,r" {iLrl j JSue w
.,!L -,, o;"slgs : :;1: l; pl i\;1t ,r^l o: L s::,.i\;r,a" .r.iCtai(i..!Ji c.-(? rr 6;l p c;ly.r" aF- ;rl .,IS.r" Je, t),y :j"d ;-:rb;l 6;t-'>t"S .-1,1 ,l ,+ es
6LLi t> y r-:.tU! !:*;-rut -:t+ r) iU--l(:t ,JL- jL" ;t\t*.ty, uK gl.c;a JF f ' )--e: )l ;lt l; ;:!ail lU; \qYl-Yq ;"(*; .gLoJL.uf
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtt. J, I 6A
j--14<l c.*lo-rLilcgldl4ii< F&;r aS c-'-i 3lr-+ f+- L;i.5L,oa-L--Ul ,|"lS;.rarc..(-? J, ,J.ts rr.J .i" ta,)ifJ& 6 c*l c.-qi>45di jlJ+ Jt- YO fl.r-- er- 4-.i L.c-*lU,rrL":-l fi : e-*jr.; d5.-i)q! 6!'aa--*l jl eJ$ t ,r-5.*ll cS{J# rlu-l ,_f -yS
a":3 q lrOTt" 6 ,-f fyl5r,1.1.r3r ori;3r c*l..r*i q Ji t C.fc,*1^>3 ! l_, t- d--q ,-hrrs U-*.,--Yl: cgL^gjly*J+ 3 t-a-r-"l
q-5 c.*lo-l."l;),F at -r (p ,-5_y o::* *.,L5 111>j, ;!-Str-;l.Jt-- iXl!:uj,-f )L.y &&* c.*il3 3.: d:j s:* jlct-rl-.a-.,o
t )-p dS J:5 +! t-, L sg:l1i4i-$,it5tj Jl-ri-a uli.*Gr.e,a*r,,.g:l;i.rTo3.q a5.g.rL,,:il _t1*l ; 6:t;i Ai {la,r;u L" .g-;yi,r+ ..t!j.,-lo.r^.l^s c*r c*l +il.ri t_*J j _e 4*K r: c*!+ J ,s4;,Jt
ry-F i rr -u;Lr a,a.rjj d_p .rt*, .JlFa" d-;+J _tl ,rt r+r^+: cC*l ,JttsgtJ^" a- f!t*- 6 -r.jlo:lr;lJ^l^a oL +1
Y;ri5ttj,
j5.j 45 J9*5lf-,r .g+lu;, "! f!t* -r F 9 ;;lj:9-- yrl
lJ Jl-r,^:^-6 drldU. cr*,lorrS oJ-aLL,,-rLotKj jl#lt Jrt eVl_,I,S.r,--la
9U;1 .r;-i; ! &JE-"! ,ty" e: rti.rjy- V eltd ,*l.rr5 jrJ"lj">Ulst.*1-
J5 q "<! rJt*r G-* \ ;l a;-:'iK t qroi c-*K os 6,-t
6t* L.,-,,-l- I-.1-r j:y;) r,c*l .i.,."":UA ,?-f d.L+j J.-t<i
f^)j3- of 4j1-n:.]^,, J:6 -,,'b-* ,; 1JJT 5 :_*g rt(.xi f*l!--L ;i4; oe)r t t, .,.,5 4Ly" s;JU ,;yj: jl"Ulg-e 6 _,, s-! 4J
nsY 6lsi u-- Q .up3-r -r
t.=*l plri.oc.-:tr, y
t.r-!K .5t_^oL(-i.r
l. De Tocqueville 2. Lord Actonq Ql rilo:rS +[.;l i -.2: .9lo:t-J19 _f )] \ 6 ,S,t f p.gL^;l.u-" ,l 6rl, ., .r> .la5:r..r(; (Hitaire Belloc) .'JJ? -!^ ,-rur jl JL ,r )t^.-Ulor:: u-xJ,li ,!6 .r*:l-t -e; .ri jl r-,1 u-5 ;trt; ,Ui 2L- ;l ;4;*l o:l: 3 jLJi r: .TiorLrr.rK r:.G-,,:!L_,- ul> u olVy- ";a\ ,1,, d rr- j:j ,-La)r, G;i J,Lt a:-J,yrr(;lK:"-u) c-L?; )) -J3: ,.5=^,.: - ri1 oi;"r-;rit.r.--q 9 ;l c, {;:, u"3-- ;-.- :1411
[The Servile Stare, 1913; 3'd ed., 1927], p. xivl4. Cobden 5. Bright 6. Adam Smith 7. Hume 8. Locke
WWW.AEL.AF
A1 tr oJjt-a; ol;
o.Sif-l t €*,*l: d,-f da-j {*-J eu 6 }:il ,,(1 a(1 .\.19L
.€e La; rc.*l,ciL- r!-, b./r, y ta.lU-:rJ ctry.lF.rLl-r1l oJ+;d;;lor iXr!-l ,-*lf tt +(l co.rjgj 3 oJ>.-a .l9rr --Jlrl la;C
,u.,*l,-{+},' u)<,.r,0.r,y+-U J' -l -* )l r' d -rl Y
s,,1*l;1.-U-#,-f A*'IK y[5 a, a:i;a:i;
o-LJ) 't; Jl3:'c o: l-., 4[-;t- JU3'*U .-',,]jil oJ,SiLi -^-'{3 ,rrl J,.l .c;<;;- c*rl:.r"uyt r-t o?"i jl ,.fo ,-?-:t t )}d *i")U t-:.t .fl.j-r tas )l iJ;J. dl.ll 6;r.j .-.r-;ij :> > j,.6)A'.>-^1';-
Jl2:e "; jr-"\ ,u,lf :; .ty *\l-S "S J-t.i .(" .+-a jl ir:n 45 uTJi 3 t:y
Ll .c.*l o,J-.-l Lrrr-,,elFrf J 6) -p) F ar "jly ;-l 3 crllr 6J-.1
,;-lJ tfJr Jt<;1 4--a j dq-J- "!.iLi" ;r ,ti;l J as a-lf ry
yl LrU-!1 t, eJ$ a, J"ii .r;l$ b..*1 ! 6-ssse !F;l 6* € e WeGJ 1: t"l .1.,iL ,rs-:l: :V:' ).olJ) dF
"[6 ,r f+lJr;.:G .,,lS
oL-L,tlryr.5=*X oi,)it j.-=,,..- -*b -sl o.S ru.-lf >j bi*-Ul
J-lr JL"j,)i jlJ c-it- .t*j"S ,* y,fet dlrJ> t, -,!.-.*l-e.r"ia.^lr!
-c*l e;j!l-i t*1 eel*1n,r:i r.u-+jr.tlyo ! trOiU 5;ir.:3 orf
.ftj-J! ,_r-*-,ntc*l Jtil 45 JJ, ,-r-1 41 dLil t ;l;"-hi jl c-t olLc+5,.-o :4 -*rr-;lt' srJj -f )-15 ,>11e a,31q51s+i5l! :6,-)Fy .:)L-L; LA,)til a5 c.*1 ?lL. o5 -,y! U-l s rttf J,"r*i dqi.<u!
Jt-;) \'n,r.ol-y,;-.:l;irr3 q(6)lii, .bt ;# 1; ot-3.:i* 6:i 6t-4.:l-r--l
-,>,r+! 5 p 6 l';^*-a,glcaS 6Lo"j13r,t-^oi 11 o:Li:-l e-9- 3 orli:-l \, -eVJrU--l cJl;3r di;.: Jl*rrtB e- +5 .41-aeiLri,lQ 6lyl-abi 6j jSa,
fJ# o$.a n.5 -LJti gl.jly k; t'r,l;lJ-o,r -t L.i.rar ol; .:3i e, 'rr-.:ri 'rirrS
;lgLaJL- -,) LS." j:y L)* cll19.:;rlL^^ J+ 1.: 61; J*l ,ySryU'>L5.g:lu--l c.- j9.- ))-ebl.e5;-1 U c*l o.:t4i ,.:.i1 a, 3; o;L3.:
.J;5,s, Li,-r>>Ju.
l. Milton 2. Erasmus
6. Periclcs 7. Thucydides
I 1. tolerance
3. Montaigne 4. Cicero 5. Tacitus
8. man qua man 9. freedom 10. liberty
WWW.AEL.AF
6', J., I ?'
a: ol--X,r-arst jl* Ajti;- f CW ftJai .<-1c#--r.rj J<- r.*.;:X: ot--iry,- 6t;: a-,r-nr"p": 6ly. t:.11.,.$l,r- La,tt*;la5 s"l,tjlt 6 tq Jf:; Jt*1 .tt ., ./kil : SrS t\ c,-? t dUl 6 .3l+ l-r5
:l,JS: ! JiJ- ,;;J.trf C otr^a.:;t-*j.r--, !"14, cJ-.lL a:.!1.:
?_r? r A;lj A") )t,JL".--: s ?-f !,JL^.i ,JqJql 6-tQ g;l^,,6-
gn-x e:V; !.tiQ; x.l? :;aL,.r-i1.r L.9ta;-,,5 toUir;:yli bi e j5r--' 6lr, ,gle-lSrf .+L- .)tri 6,o aS tal : +t*_r
Qt ; J "cq .r-"T;.: ! 15tayj,.:-S;: r);l=.j ...r-j13.r,r, 4-LJ J*:U 4ilri
-,t-.: .,Jyl ,Sly, s s j- ;ls1ei;. ;-;*3 arr-J-ts jl JYlt jb Slt,--1,rcL^:71 s o-V Jt:: ot*; J:5 J-:J ,,;blriL; c-.-i,b p j1L cr"-a.ia-a J e.ija o); ;lJl ;r a5 r_.e-r t+.tirt ,l_l : .ttf tAJJ.15i
F y yJ (-L-J- "rLx;
c-.l rJi s ? -p \ 6;&;:,y"S J* t, -&t.r.-.l-, qJ;l S-ly"t:t "s.,./q- g* t Fl*6t".(a d ,.tt- .!_ltl o:G
'.tr- ;;3 *.Uf c:y a!l- s:oL-f lt.seb4'*'i L-/_* S#e*,!ytl3-:U d1-t: ol;,9: ;-lp[_-i;.:q 1-, -rl c5 i:*l .it^q y -i+ -,1
:r-i ct:y*l >l;i 6$c.gc,rcL-.715;: ;1.);1 c*L J+ JJ,.*",J1^cJt-, _t: G_f U.-r-iy-3.3; L5l^"r:
EU;; rt-7.,-la-: -rrli 6:lil ,-r*rf3.,r;-;Jr5,JL^.r")s +5 4jt-.KT
l; a5 "ql,r- AL-J1;,--l .1, -,r k! *:*r.5rLr:!l .gtaclt*s ;l 6lol.*.-,c-aL*- tt ,t3;l- JY"r:-t -<i +t-:" C*i.)y o).5 cr/t 6lojl.r.;l
{-lJplj -,."q c5 ry 6:L.a:il c.Jl'.i il:lji -r*:, *-,lijL ..g:La:il .g>l;i;l.)_9r oJ--l,./q- .g:11i ;.r- :";& y
$.;tc^;* JJ,; q)>j eGeitlcS-,LL^-, .:;3[:*r c.-rS:t 4Vt_roi:dL.-l<l V uif Ulll-)l &p 4l.l,y.:l;i,r,,;r a-5;y
E3Jr
;-;* 4-J6* *. a:-XS )l-ael 1,rjtJt c.+yr;i 6j,l.c^rt-.rt-:r
,S-&l* 9:l ,ilI +---,1 a;3t;*.-,1 jr^d.-:;.-irt^"r-t *L45,tA;;-S,,l ,.,tr,f<".\.:j, ra:;lL- ; grr;,! ;-t jS ;: )x olK:l;-ill:l L-; ;l^fi 6;11);-t.iVf
WWW.AEL.AF
t\ DoJjLo;ol1
.)tJ I d3"-i .<;t"r;t,SLa,Sj!:q-l jl g-,!*: I : co)J-l,rri:S clt- rt\ p 6Lr.<-5; cJr+, f t'* 4s.it-".t<:-, y-L v "r^--:;P
i dJo:-* 6\-l,c-JrX?, t> d.,rp j IiloJ-.X 4't- f* t-"'y;g;LaJrS r:---j 45 6jt-c-^rl- 3 rJJ-u cs:,*a,-l-j il gb ,;l; ,;b,i)t .5.rl11,1.c,*1oJ-ati J.6 1t*: c, c-u:-:l-ti;lr.i o*illrjL
Laoirt 'rt
S cu+t" ,>Vl;;l )l Gre t"r-# 6rtjilc^.6-71r 5a-, , [*. , ],'**J 6) H dJ ot-* tlj:y $*,6rG * :-b y.u- rJ v&
+-*a ,5lr-, b*- ol): d5 L?Oi U ,fi :-f r ocy' q ,.F1, 6;l jL-.:*;r a-"-;i;;L;: l):- jl J tl s---;51 el-:Ln=ll.ly oJ5:3J-*'"
.rUj jlk",.c--r ett CVe-t i;3 -,,trKil Gs-t ll; ol; .:*l..*'L"
;t j -lt \g j ":j.:3 {-re eilr il +;blji 6-:ti:-l r, \ o\1 s*6;l;i 6fro, .r-S 6 ,;:ye j, f-.ti3 - ory b-$i s cf )J gl.lU ;.t +-r 6..^J.el +5 )r; AWl.l-! y - -r5 s,-L.'- ..li;t ,r; dJ{*6-J ! U -t^x.f
o,r-i orr* taoi o, f * s:"St j,-r)t't*, 5 .-,il,l-i, 'aL.-' )\ 6.tt= tl e:
: * *;: Ila:*jlel 6.il^ft< o;l:; U"r{ 6Uf6 t*ili gLe r,ry
.r;5 JJ^j J *;h, 1-, o9r-*e-;2, Jal JL 't+i-Jil;U or3+;rt-fui,.li,lL"--l,r r-, U dr.j c-aL S -iiL*l a:r<U
.;L-.il cr'-a.r1;j ...lf ol-i---c.."r[oir,\r,.:5 ',>-iKi' 6 JJ,'tJt$:elioL:-3:(()J-> ft' ,Je ,p dv-e Lsu'-t6a-p a-*"t? ,lr- e:lLr ,J5,r"
erjJ- dl CU: ,3;lS 1\: J.)t€, dt* lr L" dr.j 6 '-y, Gs* Cl-rl'
.>tj-t .,"L"j Jrt- -,F:^ -,.: L+, ii.,JL^o-, y d-l-S>i ;J: J4-.1 Jr:?,4;Loo;9: ,r a7;ipLj p:rl.t* I P O, c6-rlji a, c*l a"l7
U JU^J<IjlJi t,"- ;".3..-a r rs,4 ciL- .l..:-, GtW: : JjK^.^V tp.ty.g a.,")E U,;;16;[i rVf ;.r 3 J:la
t. ) _ff -f Cl -r S Fr^ .-r-, .rl;t!:l ft.; il ili ;1 s-, Jtl "a+.,
c,e)! a1 r.rL*;lr-t-^i a:^il:r., d+ jl ;Ljl Ll+j nl>l)i 6j lt'sa, ol; ,-
l. Augusle Comte
WWW.AEL.AF
,j', J-, n 7\
JE -,, 3..t5 V;ll-t tf.9t-a+-13,- 'i;3 Jt-;: rSL^.jf c.Jli
cJu-l c--"t-- 1: ,r(r;U dt^o(.J lj.l5 a, ,,r..." ta:;l,fiL-l Ct- i;rl Y! e5
:1a3 6lei,-b1U=td:5 Jr"-.j l; tooTc*,ily.r*,.1L:t -&, $.-dL^o(c.Jt"r, +t? l" ..t.,i! .rF o:l-a;",1--ti.r..-e €_f .5t^c-ir+, jl 45 c*ilJJ
6tarll-tJl:--l L.l, ;Klor"- djft .rl f+ly- Jt,-t.:f c^:b_, l_,
)t-3 lilo:y,: c^tr-! ,ll , -f-f )-f 6 41-a:;1.[L,l rrr,7:^a Jt j3sy \,si 1jal, *:ln nSyl 6ly .s,yiu,rtfti t-,;..tT.g[a,r:-l5 jl cS_,!*tl-2.li.,:-*1! c5-a: -,rll L./)J:13+ cJjlo)3r ,'.a- r-rT;: aS 6:lSl ,L,c-rl; +5 c-*+.F 6a:f+--r .:lrel.'rii,JJl SGI-J sto-r-t-Ll;! -, uiJt :" a5 c*luiJ Jt*jlr.t*);3) crbL-:-r )l ;;l;s ai c.r;A,y c^..."1 rsg;L oU; 1l ,gJ-> bi y:y 'u-Q f :6 4 **;:; Uy'*
q.lTo-: .-/p) L,.! Jt* s-e ,S r,r o:i[- c.*.:.grr"i J:,U:-t
.:y;K..".l_y lalr-- a.r,"l;j W_f yt ;i;'U ;rrjc.u:;3r : A-;rK*q,yli-* J )f c-:,tfJ.i rt-.:;l;:-.tl: ! + ojU o-p- ey 6e5 try; JQly .:--- r:-.e 4;ly > jJ->."U .gLo4lilr; O:--lb a-, rti:plsc-j6-9," ar--l .i_ ;: .ry*j rt-a,-l L-ailt*1l ; r o.l,Tc.*) o-l ")\j e* -f45 J-: #G ,_:- 6ltl: d- arl_rl _r _ siL- -ri_, ; urL;l qgl-a.gjlJXq,>i- 1rL, Lr:+fLSll6J-ei ".(,-
,llj;c a' 4*S rr a.*;i.-r;U _,lll4s *1:* );: a-. -u.5,J, c^iJ+, c-ef tJ:.,;,_s- -b y ,SS -&t;l ,p isflc.Li.:y orr.S;ly ,a.:rr&,_.cl_t1_r ob 4*S ,t S ,)yl;lf o:t"' ",1:ty-.Ft,5[.ac-J-i3, Zui ) L;- J.lf blj:.e * S;,1*5.U.r"T,r-.rL*- -.rief c^i-"+, ol: fJ..#U Jlyc * *$
.JS.f a.*lr;c1F jlycr o-,y' J--qar.,"l.<,- lJJld5.:;lli .:3,>.3 (-9j-1? 6i!,f!t;.-r,Ll J2el 9rL"", 6lt s t! 4 +5 a*.o 6ly o;* 3 c^i-,jiti *a r-qL-; U--l
:j->. 1j*"|rt,_+r& -rr 4! L e5;,.rt=-.: $"1..*1.:;tri r_9"-.3 c-\...!L .:,ti
WWW.AEL.AF
?Y tr oI;La; oll
#l-,-- Li 3 or;5 o:Li:-l **V Jf)f 6.as,,.Jjld.,<"" -u y-r:.:t1t:
.c,*l 6r.t-:, c---b.st .gt-ary;l5 6l;1: .fU ,ty ,Fg, ), tu fu'L:4)J# c^.fGt ..1'i .-r3;r 1; a5 c*l ,r"tE oI^-;* ,t?Al ;rJ La''3Ui
11.;
6^1t^=t.r;l: .r3>. j oa;l )Jb a, ,t-4.:t6j ,i)\*d"" ,.i;r,3 a*1: eiL-;a
p Uly L--J 6il r. t^Jl; G;J 'a"l>,-r ,S-lSt" 5jl-tll +, ;.>J: jl d:.i cJt--: p.r U- rr;t5 J ::-5 6>[it ),el l,t,li yjga" 45 c;-a-,.l.l-J .c*l a>L*j :;l-9 .-".,i,-rJll .gt ^,tt";i* r,.:*;3,"1 ;: r:Jy.>
,.:o[;- ,1.-Li, ;: .> e, -,L:71 ,yG * J 6y)e ;i -el;-,"I,p,1+* S+L U. J J.. 't)' J'
;: c-Liry tltl €t.gl7.rLl.ril €J.$-y. )J$-r il.-51- 6,S-,t-j*
,;:? 6i^ cJ-i:y .-J "ilU
6t*' \, f"a' ,,c laoi6t'".-'*i os;;La.rirt J )_* el: jy i;- r c-L ;ili ;*"-a 6j1"[lr c*;lyi,r^i
Lp.g:l;i;l c4t^.- J) .,4(,!,0 "* j J -bL^r-l 4 -t "rr, "lyt d
; dl5.l n-r< € 6 diG -51o,s-f +, oi o:1rl t "1,"1-
csy or-x a5l;l
J* t^l.*o-^ \Ji )J;r c-*"3ti,o o5 ry.t .r,-t-.l,-l-r!olc^-t!,roJ
')j*,L/
dJ &-,;: Jl-"J .r.F:,tt(-r-arft-, jlcs-,tri 6 u* j"l.c-l.l.aoi;-;: eil,* )t?"alq 6 t*,rn -b y:Vl )'.\; ,.a'14.;: tt':tJ*:.,- ;r;* u"\<.^tabi ge-r.-r.itl-P,r-F: CflfU # t* ,.
?-*)q cs--:Ji:#-: -!-r-a U e5 La.li.5Loc-t=* c-ir+. c>-cr- )l aS
..r-i c-K g;*.l,.U.fL:tl -r* *.c)y o-\^i 6t:*-l,rl;i a^"t-7 .(" Jl"jL6 ,b-lr| t-rla* J 4*"t t1!s-*jl t 6to.rat5i r*i, q c.:^ir"l1 ylt- -,l-5 45 t--. Ji jl.c.-.xlr S*' crjt-,r-. q<.. LaJl -t]6 ,Sl-*l-r cyj,l .r+ljq.r+.;Jytc:l tra.ti6tae-Jt-i J""<J gjY gt, -r: y tJt!-^.<-{ jl 6 c*l .,;t..c! -r^;Lr a-"lq a, t-^Jlr! }F €.5;: l1 LaJi a5
c.r-:5 t-a-" oil;, 6l-e,ls \l;,-r-lly e5;-,-l eD 6 S.r .+1r" .F.-r--xL a:^ilr u^tKi ai A,; -tS 6F; -,t L il dr<-. isl-r= U ;-"!
d31:;r +5 6lo:l- ;Jli "5,uiq +:".ib -r.1rri +t"i,-*Kidtil e^
WWW.AEL.AF
,.Ftr. J, r: 2Y
4-tij .! L A,-U.r*l ,.ll* erj3- 5-r-- s5rL,a:!l.gLac.*l*, J;r.,altacti
: @F e:ta l; La; ,rl+ -r.-! jJ:,a U d ;." ,t* *iry. UlrgL(,.1T1: 6 e*;r c^ir:*.i 6lr. u.l3lS.5Lac^.jr, ty- J.r,-fL +5;y',r" kV Ct* _rrt<,j c^i-r:d, ylLl.c.-.:.1::3-3 c,.,rt4i.r,jlfdlJ+ U d! a;--il.r 13> -E ,:_f cgL^r_r 61U;r,rLK o.uli ,:jl:jl c^t-;t.f ft+jl J_iti .grL;,5Lay6 oa;*, * r. ._5 .:Lc_l l,ocli
cSL^_.,6 .ri- t- I ,,:i ,)g L- rt-a,".;t )l 6; -+,,Jrl fG aylrl ,[:*.9111,5:Lj o;-ti llcJ3: cJJ-.rri.l:* 6dt^,J:;t _:: t€ Llr3a-:rl;
.|,6 c5-rr ! f",l- j-l-, 4 ,>itsrl;tL:;ty t-y jts-*t r : * J*t. g,F t;." g,g ;"ic=;; t" t * *..:;,ri yl jl crr)t-(l,,
f* ,;lj-c y;ti ;tLr* ,S o-";,i 61* a-. t=,Sr> 6,rJt-- y.: cLl
-hV ".r-r:;taU f.!U a5.Jt- , J )y a^iLjJcJ--i,r..;L r,.:-.lon
..g:l1i;l,r^:U o[i; ..#;$ &l]1, d)Uj .r= tj,gr c_j& t dJ:+_r
l-, c^i',.l+, dHl o-5 aUCrt tr pl.t" r, -,hU ;." -&, A-jl dit, .,*"truita -,ft ...(i t 1.;t; cal3l ;l.Str ._,_,t", Jt-;r c.rl.:r5..r." ..r,-.141
-:lr,r-;lr.i.:lr.il;L:;l-rr l, g_f gi_r+, jlrrs-l;l f6- lyj S ,Lr.,c"",!* Jt"."! a,o: bl_* y Ai ;t $1t e or--i ,ic*.,of-S ,K1r .S.#-r&\Ji L-,)* f!t; ...,lJi dt^$ 6 c^K ati;u" e .bc;rl16r[T.rt*ilc.:y-.J*: J,#t-- 4*S;r d.4Lac.=ri -r -bV a,.c.--ilr Jti, q&G *; Ir-r ,i-i31r -rr jrA d.lL^.S"rr )^.; 611l; ry,-
"f,1.;.;3r o)l: c.*,: jl_tj*t..f -E ya:sr* -* : "1".;: Jl-/- g;L-a(-tr*. J:5 ci_-:*, jl ;U o-u,-l; dL-fuU JJ, q
:fs -t*e s x:-Se ort-e:.,1,-rct"-;l JG 4:.loq.t'jlLU) c^6;4* K ; r o.r-i,
"f -.c t - .g: l-" c..iri-1, 1 gl-L +S .t t*!,; .gG"rn lr--. : U;
f!t; ,.-fLl Jj,el *.rt-i:cl crlr.i "f,l3l;:
c-t:5 a.-y lJ t-6.)i c*ilis,4-.t (:,1 o.r..i c*.r o1 03,i3 .cJ; )lp ;J,f\ ))-f *.J F.1
WWW.AEL.AF
?d ! oI;Lo; ol;
d+lsr c-4) tu a-:=*a.gly J Jq 4 o5 g*l J jrJ. ',J; e(1 o)y*s,g -b y4S J*: -rJ"t ".5l"1l;.5Lrjti tS-t- lgr-rrclK.l-,.r"i;,
dt-l.J-q o-u-i ;l_2.i: ,,r^1Ji J_*l y.:tj ,r(J.: -hV ytn.li gr t':6L-ac^iri.a* 6 *3J -:ly ..i.;,u, >13." 6lo>13 t* y i -b Ma.5.gl,r-K ?_fr)q.r--..l; b*; rl.r:,1 1: a-i dlJi.,-/ ;": \ ,gJ-->
J-S -l rJ-an ,5jl-J.r- Ll t6rJ a.(li oy o.:r5 -*l-t a:-.:j(,5tac^rr.=1
.rYi;;U )Ja# ti s .;^b>t?\,; -fi-t tJt4l Atu.r:-.!l:1U.:;I.1t ^71
F r.",t+5 t-. "rirty.:r, t",-ri"["5 e&q;;.-'1-[l1y.r +(L eryG_# '*-.qc/arf;t5 t ,[r c:y ,$ i;L*.jt ">\.lr5
15L^jr" I df4..1 + L" rJb jldJ*: a:-tS L s t.5 .#si tL.c1t a, Ln,li.5-.,, -t,'*"-.il3 f-=- U-l )f S.-.1 "?-i;l t-".rat3i<.J,-J- f:.-.- tf 216'r3^-,
.c^tt_ J:^lS -* xr-lt
J."l iJ<3 +5:;lL9-.3 ot!.-,el;r e.r. eG GS Jte." ta;gt;,
)l JaV.5rSi .:lrLr J JL- dJ 6J-.*.:*j +i ;l ), ,;6 r"-;J,r'* f/r,rl..r:J^jl.:6r5i gbLe ,;-:-)t* Jt--- !,t.r- ,J1r-r.,"-i.tL;^,o :* yLa;--la-".o ^;J<< 6..cly ,q)J cgi cj"+-r4a
+511 1L".71 Gil J. *f ot,r*.1*l,.St^.r." :t )l ,PV 6qL;
.r*il:
(#U"U.rt"jl,- 4;Lo.lLli3 4:rL JL:els, c.*Laoi,5La?d ! raL..
c*l;--l ..ar rlL:*i tag4l;: g,;1: .r.ai eifU.trrS.,1o"*, L?* J.
,s|,l"eG L e,.n-,Ii t* yqr^ car.ta tSy \V ;-5; n-fu 6\ '-u'-c.r-i o,laL^,i.,o -# L:-t gt-l ;l al--yra 1.: ofT.c*l {.rt" ,"ij ,rs"1,*"V
J LL*+l q c.r- d*Jl; r,r--S ')-& ;*.r-Ll .:-rG; 6 jy:jl J-ts cX J ! ,-x -tlt #..x1 .rl .rrt"qt .J,t*. q Ay )-fls-t
015.q: GJIS re> Jl- L. &-cr*ry orr5 a) 6 G&ls\A$..g.c,*lo:r5.itrl-, G.-f oN ,S A\lJ>S
ut7 +Jtt" : al f /o ;lr;c L *Jt* G r ss 1s \ 1 au rs J-l rGi *)F ;yj -ilj" . l(The Counter-Revolution of -1r u)/rL;l .r-an -9 rScientism and the Study of Society)
.194144 oH ,L-i.7l; Economica i-L* 1: 6 :l: a"l:l nScience)
WWW.AEL.AF
6', Jt a 2?
^:6,a +5 c--; al -&, Jbl 4"* ,G_# -St- ,5t-a.t5.r,: ,-t-lr,rlria--t--.(.-;: )_ffy J*rf6L^:; jll; o:[o;.1 ,t_:*olye\ gl")* * eV 6 La:_* ..*loy+ 45 _ldrJi, i"." gtyr, ,lJt.tJ
ct'q 3 rrCl"at(iu c--l-r.-n y o:b a-,lrl tF F t g*lr.f c$lo:rS .:ta.1l
JSf JL-- yr or..l"-til ,rd& -il.t-al e* e, +5,rcL;1l.gta_9,.; ptjk e).git- )l)L ,se;-l -* s rr!t"l-,5yjt- A&lq l1.r;:*-o
! ,y-./S tr 'rrr*t+U J$,t L-r, oJ-:;lijl C!_f o)lJilt *ly.s-e,iU* :-t-f *,tj* t * *.6 t.5jL_,1L r-.ae,LL.:7l 3 c.rl*Jlrr cr13;c
Cyl#l yi-};. 6;L;: J:>rr -l5 oe*"i l;3r;l o_tlj6 r$j< )l;if-L{rt" J;5r5r Fs -U -,Wl4_r d,ir+ qq qg:l;i 6} ,gysanLr,llJ c.*J # fE fl"rjt' )p cjyd Lrr:rr-9J,r." ;";--,-;t5 r,1;.:
-*, * fJ s---lrr :Ltr€,g ))FJ.Lk-l!.j-r:"1 6 ttKii'r..:.>,r^ cJa)cs+ ,Jt.i^j c.,ilJ< il.rct -rl .rq- Jt J .frp 4. _*. I
\.r,..r*5 ,J; >f tSlt i ,-lS, c.-.--t 4.rF g f -*
F * t l.a4j"-Jjl e#cgt: ;*+ yl 6 c-l ,,1;r ga." a:(
.gGa-:--$lJt- c.*;r )l &.* tr.c.+lor3;..rL;^a tA4-L-Jjl .>57
-oL*K;l;: a5 qg.:lji,JiG.rjit,r- ');3 6F S:- * u*lK:t
c\AV. Jt* U .r\r;.-;*3 oV yEr;r c---lb t-,aic;j,o-r..ic.*:
,,--l,r,r t dt j oT;1.:y .J*-, ;j :-s, ,3/ U1*-tl-^4-!$ldJilJr.!r! o;Li Ldi.i o5 cit-64-L-$ljl,_frb "4eJ .+ j:f ,;r:;,-,)s s,j;,S P -t.ik*l< I .St- dy, .e ) o p jl cI:y .,--r; ; .- "L; ^<!
-r-i cStti" * f -*oUi;,Jrn JL c^4; * _,r.S .h+ La4j"-Jl
.r--U, _r La:[a; ..r- $)LS .l_f V..!-; ;t J rr)-S CL- Jt<-, 45
Q torl",y*.orJr ;tL- t.-;,t;rL
t* #fu A* )lo- JLJT
2. Man and Society in an Age of Reconstruction (1940), p. 175
5. Schmoller 6. Somhart
l. Karl Mannheim
3. Marx 4- List
WWW.AEL.AF
tr oJ.jla; oll
,-op t-1.tTJt5,-:t, y"[5 ot<*x ,, ,-Jt ..r 'aL*lJ L. \ s.tgt+["
+r t*r -ttjJ *.;;., ..ti;*;U-"},-U Ly- lltr6 *,sa,Vy) J (s^)dt-AjL)
.4J Jli rJ;; :,_it1.):-r p\JJ+ JLJi-,r.: ,g-Jt .,-1* o?J yJ (J{Ja.gL"aa.:---r;l ,51 .u-',r.a
Jjl 11r r erj-il bP ni y: J* 1) 3 o-\-.x J[^* ta.'lirr Llc,-r::iLi
.ii 45 fs,-,-. J-flS --lrl oj3r"l Ll.-U.r...; ,J"t5 L/ q f:-..:i ,.Ji
o;l-r.it e-- U --JL-r e.t--rd J tu";}j J""* -, .:iJ+, * :r..lUi.gr-,o5;r-1-ilJ+,-!*j 4.5 Ar;3i:L- -b;i c.*l,rrl5.i.:*lory ;-*.91,21: oLJi a1J.,! .'r3-: ,h{ ouJl;t s> 3.4.Ji*" 6 t g;t -r.(-, ":i i J i,--l,l ;t-.-o U.r:- l >y, 3 stc*;lr,J-./j- "(-rJ l:/ ,J- J
)l J c--tf ,s-, o:f ,-r-;13 rll._Ji;: d)Lj -r--- L-; f*JL-fllLt"-" f*Jlr.r rl Lag*l-r c,r=,-;j o)st'l u-- aS .:*-l-rir*nsgt-,^c.*]!- -r -;l.J.J:y o:r5 &b-,1^0Ui 6 t_*e Ui At^L;:
Jis "jU taJi 4'.rEt*" g"-Fl 6 .rJb,_r^; e jJ*^ c.K-yi : **tKtd-,---, r;;* ,jS t* a, jtJi6t.--!t -f L--r k l.ag.l, crJlo.r,f
.J"rJr {.e; )lJo;y: ,rl J* ,",rj.:y a:*11-/ .,juidr,-ts;:. 6 Al,S-*,gttK)ll:+KtltLJTqg.:t, ,J; sJr+, !L:: l-6:;c...r-*U c^:,lroQ3 iti Sss IU-fe'J rrtr:".$l) 6.:Ulq9;t-- o*3 tu-L -r: ai ;t 64 Vly t ,*n: ,&t ,! Q,:LJI aS uel<a r $S Jt* .* J* t, +5 ry ,r;Uic)3r o-L" 1;) L,ytl .5;-:.- d-L+i -,+1 e J J*,V,J.14 pc r.! olJp
-dtj- 45 c-rt- zltr..rLJitr 4Laa5--tJlL^.ut Ul..-t-i)y orr5u^J- c_--
ir,-l o5 .5:lit #l* L .Lrj[Ji s f .*i : rl ;L*-i a, .1.r,;tli qgt-^.'tt 1
.f;:-.flr^" +7.;i:"U ty "Ki ,-f )V C.l )l 6f a, c.$1: rt-:;l1, -qti-c
aj13 oi;: 45 J-X ,a; trari>tt OJi ,>yy-a a, l-"Oi,5ly cr31 L3;l ,l'L ;
l*. t ^<! L,ttt ,* 6t-nie)r,-j+ Ji trS .5U" 9 i nuzri>l
1. Mannheim
WWW.AEL.AF
Jrt d: o ?A
rru:.flej$y9al";,1;r.-t--i o:;1t5 a, rryl;rr tut.>ry; ," 6lar*)f3 rllT.:;l-*; ,r-s-lJ>-p j 6rl>*Vr* re\{y>, ,*Jl; \ t-y, At
.;*j:g)-c r '*IJU3*U
il L! fcri +- c*i I-^.,;LJT jl csttr*r ,jLgi eipfr;f",=Io .Ut
.gLaa.:.--$lcl:rS 1113 \ e)?-p d[5l-,b.tr, GrJ"- dl"a.ll."Jit-6,li.r-l.j .rlrt-i:cl 6 xr_S,g JY'r:-l & e3 J.:l:,r." ol:l jUTA__5" r : rlji o;L*; 3 rilory 6d* iU" 5J-isi)Ue ott*b-*)*pg r3r o-t--i {Fl i*b--r Cb r"U ;.a'U c-a.71: a5:ya--L j o..r--.r a* dL,r! c"K-ri:.-=t(;t Ufa *,,=-.9ta,it"Ji
.x>yeiJ.\-
WWW.AEL.AF
? t . & r I .,
r.) r rl IIJLI' tlJ rlJJ. \r'v t 4
,r-) tSS-l )5 6-**? a-\ ;j:3 +i ,",^ a>iln
,:irt a*t.: c,a- dL;l a5 "r3, ,,tLlr "r,5 "L{.nrjL- r5;* ,Sll G:+.t#rrtr^.-t
+sl;l ttL-olr; el u--51 L-g a5 .r-,;5: ol3-c *. dl; a5j{l
rlr-rl d c*"; .r*" C-*'b -e l:*1 orlr f-lt*- \ l: ) -f 6l-7 co-t-l
ltly6-rt-.p: b {,-xK Jl-) 31; U;;:" 3:i.^;l-&3 l.a,,1l.t-:s
-ryi:lilr-,le5 c*lor3,,p: dri+ d!.Ji:_2 ory:t* rt.,rtr5a"t+5 c-l ;--l .:tJlgl1l-; 4k*. .rilo)-9,: J-6L: lJ ig$K AGA-!,*,6>l1i 6lr. ); a;3y1t b13:.e 4-i ki4j l-nl.1; 5,r*Jq-J- JL"^
L,Slr a*;l,i ..,)|i;ljl .,^iU f-tt; * i lJt*i Kl r-r-.i..r" 4rti
G^-' *.d9;Sl.cjt{ c-a) u'J*e +JJ.-.-{ e,6:l;i,5l3J yj c:l: clLi.j
..ri.ry-.g:1,r.:-l,r"t}l ;*\ a,. ti U;;) f.]L-r e5g,lb rU- a,
6r -u;r$ Q lr .r-y f*Jt*r cSbqt, 6 e_*lS..rt(.r:-; jl a:-:
a-t+ .SJ3,L(1> L5L^.!"J,<- bi e.lUi 6t.a+.!-Ul 6 .tLtl$ sftrr.:l: rrL-Ln,Slr i$ ,P \fJ!-- ,iUTr; t.:.r*y,.ul9
"[".cl. F. Holderlin
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtt J, tr V.
4Ll* ,-t6l-la--"E 6;L3.:3 oJ->e.:+ r+r,Jt jt- &-b )lr..r)li.ll a,
e- ak*" +5.atq,..ti..: _f; ), a1;;a qsp i:lJirr 4 q o-ilt ?rlr")Ji J--U" )l) )l.e!!6-^ f*]l*-,ilrD<jQ ,fi€ Ly"r" 6>l)irl,rJi a,orjy; o-p a."tectllt^i a-i,; ill,i"-c a, 1; o.Li.c,5rtrT,.tUT..r-*t.u
.r+.r+, .* rd-y clly;+"[ir, fK+,'uj "* df D 6.it- U xr-igLAATL.-u:-( c--*j 3lsgrQ:.i-,
'l,Lbil^.:h il 4s dtqii 6 ,-Sr-t
.rr.t-i, .t"olr;;Li; clly_= "|l"rrry \Af A JL -r)tiiljt# "<rl-5_,") J,-ri .)\L.j;'U c.; ta;
JiJ 6tL-1.:J-" Ul.:b .-;-iy.l3-;1.rl1T.gLay* ! l-r .r;,- ft-,ry 6dL-.tKJ-.i c*jli J{J- ne(:\rSj*: f*J!-r, J--lU +:jb.f i:t )l -* *.
"-Se*.)ra ,-c-,l l-, r,e,- Jf.! L*:,, olui:371*
tJ:/'L;lrl-+ "! ol_* y,;lf _rt s +-&. ayra, c*;tj,r^;.r;b--]L-r tr ;{U,ijL rr:Lj .("
ls 6)-p 6;:l;i6l; ; ,r-lf _r>'t c.5 c.*ilr Jt-#l \ Af A Jl* tr :llU.,-l-S_r":..15,r, :3J>-r IJJTp*;tl-_f 6 Jtr 1r cJ-ar,-r.o arri-^ f*J[-y- 5 Jt- -tt .tssid oL,;la, )Jp y' a, 1; ;(*" 15L^.,.ij-,l
a-t-ci 6a g-J!"r s ,*l-5-* ))J-1,-t';Lo-.1, a, >* ,S{t;r.c l, >S
;--l .:3U; Ll .c.*l r6y.l_yrt f^ diy .""15 .(- jlrf;;, $Jl$ e t, .jrr*"
\.r,.r*../ Ju.,cr-)3J>er rr tr.ti-,!! -r- rSe _*
lU -r o); g1;1 jltr L-".,jLJri J.-lIlya d;-,-t6lr- g*l!:"_e-olr-o-o r,9,-- L 1; -,5:lji4-.: t-t.-l, .l.a Ut"^-./q." 6la.fl dJ6gc*lt;u, f!L-- .:1r,r,. oJ-ca l; rr.,l,J>.g.rlri .! a, .t^"1 pl-t-" ojLoT o9.r, 6 r-,y! n 6: Lr:i l .gr l jTrr t>*l r; u,. J.<, J t-.-1,JF-.\. | 1,g >l 1iW \-& c*l r; 4.rr c---l l$ s: rl 6=^, .r.-!- 6L-a.5rl;i pL;
Saint-Simon<<Discours pronounc6 d lpassemblde constituante le l2 Septembre 1848, sur la question duproit au travail>>, (Euvres compldtes d'Alexis de Tocqueville (1866), IX, 546.
1
2
WWW.AEL.AF
V\ aS)? r4;Jl,j
F q 1;6.:11ior;3ic*, ytSl-s,ip-;r-: e:.(*5.rily.f fJ!--.c*1 ,ti &r" #:l ./q- .5.:1;i a, .;[:-r +5 .51,5-:l1i.lL*a 655
J.;- JY.ul J,l tj J-: rt-11 rr.g.:l-lirr :'"15 .r.*" ;r +5.g1+i[5;j ..*;
)l ),- .,.d!-,grtri;1rl.r-; -b -sl -b y.e*laa* * ut -b ".
rl ,;bt ,olrK: a,il-r-:--, .>yi ,K4 )l 6>11i,.;j) s rt -tl,5rl;T,,grl;i
6ly.l: c.*:Y[ rlr-ol;--li jlca.i )l * Sl*f 6,4 aS.rl^+ r +o-tV r-9r o-\-.lortr o-G3 6 *-.g..g:l1i -i.l-a cLl.ry ,iilj-(.p! ,y,* y6 &l; fi -tl..ab-, y -,L=.7l ";-S e;l6:l1i11rr-,el-s 6 qJ^ cJ5,r" )jJ>-r lJ t-, 4..^ ol;t-=l 5r-9-u.-" 6;j,U-rL.71.r*rl3a crl*il o5Cr-l jl,-k t-"1 .:;l.r(.r" ;'U..tt,6: jl r+ -,L-.: b.*J A*lK -,l.5 1-, (,-ro-*+ 15LrJU; 66ts-*;frr,j*,-q Ltr; >l;iCilt
) l. &.jl l-l rr6rLa:i1 1t-E,5Lac-"-)3J>.-o rr
.* ;joUt L--r '.>r$ pp t,olie 11,5r1;i o:f yl;:,a:Jll; .9rl-" oJl o>13.rilil 6t-aoJ-ca :Icl q.ra gg:lji yl oafl rst .>;c.*J 61;l: 6 ,t,t" e i,.+6 jl Ll :l:,r" c*J!-r a,.ta 6 -,.:
.-uiL a:-il.: 15rt-,r:il .g:l;irt-b:t c*jlis*i ,rJ c-r-!U.r- (c^.:i)
6La.r3U;6.ry ;1-i-"r pl*jl o;licA -1,-.la 6-t.oy rrl6 6;15 Fls1; ,ral3;-:l;i r-91.u,-ljl .:-,* aa ;l t; .j!; :lit -rk;l 6)f :> )-F-fl_: S-&, ajly {-r.7 fU }lt,l.rt+ lU
os-) At 6)t ti/.r{) jlj bliegglojl3 cc*l,l.r olr^a al tac-lt1-r Gllc-tj1\.: :G=ldl+ i tAJl; 5J) s,f;.1 ;.r oj13 U-l q -5 1,...*l;! .,$r5 .ti ;l L,.rB J.o ).U. c---l-6; t ".li +S
-,r;:ji,u r-,.tJ, )l;J.:-U.r-l ",L:: i;,r
rU;,@! -,r!ii,t.r-l a":":.. ,.-l .c.;l:-* dlJ. &t5 ;;,! .r l+;al ,Jiiu,- 45 c--\ 6t>;3 1t;tt.5L^o:-:-, eS ,,5 j-;llt -ru."-:'-;b .(1 .r:+ Jt- )l ,^ qiJ* dS oJ-i ura* .-41: "r(PaulJanet, Sant- .9:!iLp;.1 a5 c---il: ,L6-tl .-r-r:.r" )lt c> s;i"l;JI tGy*i-\,.rL-r Simon et Le Saint Simonisme, 1878, p. 268), <est i elle seule tout le socialisme>>
;-l ;l n5 *l 6:S ,t-t )-F. ,a\S1r"i 5lf .ra 3 1r-. e j*J4,(John Dewey) rr,r-3:
pEl l, etj,(La )|1! -t l.; : a5 *l S;J" i)Je,6:llir 3r:5L|el r.J5.r LVt Lt-t"\,/u )Q
(<Libety and Social Control>, .n.:*l o;ri u,, tt;?"f;3 X];;*[],;;*:J f;
WWW.AEL.AF
6'v ): a VY
J .rJ), e,L-;* -ey:-lyla,.rJ:lylLl c>_9,. ul;,-,- gLr 6lj: "jJ-t-ly.f t je 3" 6tl;i L.y -et ;ll t-i 6 b4e rJ, jl qgrlr.il :y.r-r ;r;,t
.ri r""i;: ,.^ tr L;l,lI
.SI^CL eJ-;y _jl.,! t -&,5t-a.g:l1i..rcJ 45 c-;,F e*f!!-r +5.:U:cl e"l:*e^3 oJ--l ji{ t^.---Jt."r.tU,Jl,_# l::tj ftUt.c*t"ri-l_, : dlsggrLlcl ,ryliuo rlL,;la, l-r.g:l;i
Cll-,, ()J,J o-\--i orl: oJrJ u6:l;i 61* af ,_/lt) ,llg.e a, t a, a7;i 6.J*f rAlJ, J-t-1 i5:jl; .i- q oJ-o_9 u4l ,>y. t,u$ *,. ,S_r \ GIJ :1,tSy L. t^Jl; * q-*:Ja :.ay" .;:* .g:lyi a&y .,.^a ."t-t*"
./Ll lyl J?i 45 d_t8 - t, t-a.tT6-7 co-u.-t L-oc*Jt"-3-
91; U a=L;:[! l; t-ac*JVy t a:+ :yb r9-.3 flr.J I p-Jt."r
.ll-,"" csl3:,o r-',fJ!--..t5 r3,-- Oi1rl,10-\ r5>l;i g$ -r1-rll dl-u.J^-_-r:ljl6l":r:*5 Lr:+ Jt-A--l:t_r- f-tt; .:* y'."^-
f-J[-y +5 or& ;.,"lJUTp jl 6 c-"""j ;ji,. *;,,-.,r1;! .r*;.r*i! _,_,! J6 _; 6l,,,xito 6c-*-A f_lU ! c+.u;l.r,qy
6.15,r-.r,& .)L1; ;l n5 +ny:,5.l;1,ft ,;l .gLnJL .,t ;:r,Llj\6;lrJa;1j,-,;"s 6 *6 )lL"e _&, ,\.i- c;tr )y+y fJL..1-.rtJ[t" 45 ;r4l C hb..5.:L; .lti.i.--" .c.* t o,r"T;: lV yr,c^i;.r, l-o.ti
ot-iU c^-,.j t,ti:3, "tf Ali or" lc*: r, eti -ry, .,rlJlJajl tr l_l :fn,*-.-ll.irr, dt= \t-i e..)t6.a 6Jt *.t jt 6 6l..rUlcltt-.Sl-a.:".aLidL*J<l;: rclt-a13,-jr;l 6..rJt- _t, .fi-S;lri c:yl: r3*.3 n,*.;;nSr _t
"liU" :-.t.i 3r g*jtr; f--t:J 6 oI& .-,,-l! l-, )J, j3:.a LIL fg 3
uy.l s3,-- jl :lrJl jl g-,L-"r cJirj,r,. Jf I, dtJr,j,- jJ:.a (fi.-^ e+,t-L- 3 ,it*1," g:6&l; a+"i -qr- g:la1 -f : & ::l.r-:-l dr,l qT a5
d,.:.rJ dJ) c#3),trt;'*:--lr*SLr.:rt6 i -b C.6d_6.-f .J+
l. Max Eastman
WWW.AEL.AF
. S ), *)al" j
Li s -s,_/)Bl r+ c/aJ$LeU, i * s, I J,:K; 9-.!U- I .c--*a
l-5 *4i,r:-+U rlyl" lroic-*lr:x,r 6r ,,-l sne>*l ;a|Sr">;*"-a +5 6.13$J .J*! o.:l: rlts 6>sb U lr t^c*+;,"S .l,.! p-,eY -r
./t + 'a,yi 4,St " t g-.]L-f 0t"^ .,.JU-l 6.1L",r";r .-0.13,.
e5 c.*l rl:r5 Jl $l 3 .t:r5 J et-*,0-r*;*;r:.,. l,l yj,U-,L.7l
3lqgt-aa:it- cry orr5 qS dt+ \nU-t
;l ,gyV 'o',1-7.r 4 ,t+ll,5ly lt-l.t-ft"_f 6lo;..9.:*"-al a:,aS *.
q r*r a-, glLtLJU-:L +; , [-U ,l- ,',^:*?l.5Ui,5laa:s! -qU' 'J U' J- 'l)
.ib+:rti ;,.+ q a-.31 alr$ yl jl 5 14 6tS, rtU kji ! -r #_llsFJt* o:j13.: * ^s
t#--o.d .r"!, ,J+ JL otr+ .r4:,6a
l; .:3,> sgL-^.tl-.;ipL; G!l-{--fi )\K.x, "<-- ,sl1:-o n- *u1) )_1>
-,* yl-, UQl3,-rLJi.,a-* s-t i )-i gUt-t" 6U c-!r,r," ""rJtg^tl45 -t5.,- .:*,ti rol;1Li,T1r ptr- --lt- -*,r 6 r;,it* i.,i"" 4.rx-
-r cS-ryL{: # :,513il:{r 6-* \+-(1.5-:lji6 -f \a-;,r-al;qgL,a;l;l ,""-b )1.5 .,*;q* y s ct*l,rlb 6^&a.y;d!i-3:13-o
r.trll: ,-;-l,.j b-,{-iclt-";T 6t .:5 *'l;;,r., -rr--1.r" c*: a, .(;1r53*r
,',rJ:.a rl, ,- 6.c-*l rc-j.!..-rleU q, al.:Ql 6J:*J, 4..,.(, qL:"9' t - V | \ .9-
6/^ap;"q L,:tl 9 o;uf .>;j-c ,gl-ac.|r1..1,{ri 6J^15 Jt-lr.s t:y),g ro. 1.Jt*;,- JL;3,*U : g*.;U t ryS-lL,r 5 J:S,r"
yt l, tu..,{ -)ls, s.o.,c.*l ;f3*l -J!*r JUJ*U -, f-::-"U , LL.;
e5 Ilr,r" \-F yJ g,-:b ,.lrr,: oll L 5 pf rr 6 o*l oJ-; ,=.nr
:-j.-- 6Lo;l.51r .f."-c StDi S4 a, t-aoLjl 5 .,jUj J^r../ ,Ss-t GU6l \Sly,l_: 6;*f Js: t,"..li +7t'1 ..ri;lrr^, .)UJJ,"I ,rarclLyL q -,q-l Lt
L 43 ij<oL-a c.t:;S,.f*f*t,-rirt,qU F -,r L"lcJ:n>c/ o-[cysjia-\ t3ic4+ -,LaU a- jj -.il.ut LJj rdit-dL;l- c-lrl-r-" J;*3I . Stalin's Russia and the Crisis of Socialism (1940), p. 82
3. A False Utopia (1937), pp.202-3. 4. F. A. Voigt6. Walter Lippmann
2. W. H. Chamberlin
5. Unto Caesar (1939), p. 95
WWW.AEL.AF
u,s:s "\; a
a-.t-.i a-:-il: i-*:j c.*1 ;1 _9..lua:.r" d)y c$.:JU-*:, J;t**a.\njL;l -tyl 9 C7.,LL )el a$,6;sa,l y
)l Clrlt qt-- gL^_E ;l$l c;t,5GJt- ;; ollr.l.::." Cb jta- cc-*iL_ blye,.r-j;l.: l; L*y;,1a;!;r ,>jVi c-,--)t.a e5 6:lr.il
--! t, ,*- udlJ o)J,r d;)l+rl61.,oy35 *s#oJ;Sle5 ,g>l;l 1l o3'3
.:_i* r*ijyl 4Lic;l rtL* ;r -[ilo-\--i )fy lF S_t_t )l J a*lK f45lJ ;Ui.-[*-y "(,- ol;Q]l t_rK: o,_9*,6 dl,;r a,..t:5 !- +r+J) +:;[- (s) c-r-.i L-/)J"N; .S olrfl: Jll..ir) *Li; qb Gtr q
.glll.rr ta;al
.r-ly.f f "-JtU 6 oJ-.ic d/l,J"t5 c,*--(il :J.L#aa tt'ltr r-ia-.,t- dL^^ dJ- a, l, o:r5 )-pl-t *:_s )JJldli"Jl \ 6lll. _9 6:l;in5 r;1:r- (G Sylt j 6!;i ;l6j-o 6tl*,:31 * J c;b")\,t5.5:1-r.;-t
f-A t"J$,)i.J t+l s6l*-l,p rt-4U y f"*.1,*5.,.:*lorrS.rt.tUi
"[q p! Jq, 4 t f**].5 6.rrl jl r- c6il3;r .r:*"i -3--*" *
a5 o;lrjl,tL..o e- f:S"f o-I..a[-;.-o J s hig )_trJ lfJtl o_*,/.ru ry ;3"t,'
"^^ e rlr.^ jl $i .tUT.r y ?l y 6- JU.l L--,-,
,;lslj c,.=*al )l H G..,-:,U _r cgjLj d1_,+_, jlg_,[*t -& -*.r,"t* oLJi! r
tqlqt;: l; Lar:;,*l$_, s 6 -*.s-*l 1l>1r;r,
Jll (<iJ-s j tJleY ,o;!_r_rJ# jt)..rl-,t^_, .:l-r,.; rj'U d.e.j o)3,,
f-;U U",*-.-U q L^+ J.)r.,;Jq-,- -r,-[ir,5l;1.:1.r:1 9 aS azf.r31 Laoi.tlr-.4-, jly'r,-.i.i .;- 6>G l)r, d..t :t .*.lf al 3.,.t i':pJol:+ .(1oLJi;r a5 -i::*jl.:.r- -&, .# -*jlJ:g Ct - J)J^ ;..1",J_b :t .&t\t:6, &6,:J 1 $l_r",_r ,-?l: ycrju U c4,'Jl. Atlantic Monthly, November, 1936,p.552. 2. Peter Drucker3. The End of Economic Man (1939), p.230.
LL- oS) lv." er);./15 -r: c..:iG slr=a; 1l cs-,q^*i LgF -- ;l f::,j, o+: 4 .f(Robert Michels, Sozialismus und ::1-i.r- crli (J?"t-;u- r:".,--!U c*-J;L l; :r-
Faszismus, Munich, 1925), Il, 264-66.311-127. Quisling5. Mussolini 6. Laval
WWW.AEL.AF
a S )j ,p;ot")i
*"3;L !-uljt 45.rt<,-J"i j u*=l*t r.rL-3'7:-;1: jlcs-,L*r \ 1Y' i-a.>
dqJl 4ii*"" J,lllLlr.:*j[] t" .l;:*a d-.-iF 6 J:-f ;:.L *;:y..u:.j!l: -* C.f JlrJou;15 -u:.i,1.:
cSQt{lJ \ qff JL;t.}4.rLJi;r +5:11.: c,*Jlr i r,.lylca;JlL 45di jl uin L6c.--+U L- L-o,gjL; r 1"6c,-+3J c \ tY Y Jt- 1t ..1-r
..u:-.11: tS#:re.-i)\:;1 &JS--L rJu*lL +:.-:lr .-i)l;rl -&, ell,,sfclUr 6K- [1 .Sji" 3 ,tL*.(,- 6-* b 4 ,: *rii y .:"-Lo .5ly t-a.l l
L^oi ;; -l.: .51: y !Q-, I .(a r3,--. 3 f;t-lj.lL:"-t o;fJ"'o LI .'r:'rr5,r"
6a f .u:.--a .r^,--ii ,5LoJlrJ dt ! sJlJ ,.,*3> *3f 3:ro .:$:.cl a, .ry
.rJlr L..ri..l:r5 *l-i:.",31y ji cE.qrl6*: +:-xl-r; ta,iTt,r5j5 Ujj
;.r 3 L-o15jlj L,6c--+3'"5 -E tt J tac-+# t^.SjU P ;: a5,rJt- 1.:
45 .J.;?J^ cJ::*^ c-.Lic.*1l Gl)U.f L^g*-JL-f L-^.liyrr.-^ rJi,;
+5.r-jlr,r- 3:r--a Ll.-ru-i,U o:l:li ;-S i CL-U.r1-,.^-, I c*l;.('..J;1: .:U:cl tS>i 6>lt-l *.L,i,lj 6 g;rlil3 t-^oi;- ,y'-,U J o-.JL-" 6a
..uiL a:.ib .:y,-3 fl3i.r^f
elrs : # -,4t ,sJ 3: eUIr ;'u c..-; :lr-il +5;,1 ,51;
r5 rq, "&' g* 4 jl 1-, -&' ,# -,kDt 6 elr.r .;1.71 c*;j.5
,glaJti";r clLJi,r.ai p.-Jt-r rllr.a; jl,ri \u;'--lo r1t3:h )-*Jl,
,.-a l; .r3,-- J^lf,-.r f-"-rL"^,r:J^r-y,r." rfJl; o;Ly: ,-i..x5n,.llyo lr
f-.arl9 3.Lr.: "l- L;\\,-!!,f g-a -1.#lf u*lf y":oly.e ar.
-;;1.r :3,;3; c-+l3 jl,glo;:41-aLc:l u"q 6116 c*lyl.5tJg
d'.J-q ,JF6t^;-F ;; ,"Ll $\is""t"l* 6;l; ;t* 61";!
jU y.rll: l; c--a.--," jl6;1-r-L 6w;;1 3,*lS tlS Altltr ! f-"-,L.^ulie;.l"-il>t"tS.*-A * ,? +5 c*l;-,-1.5tJg qJlJr_j.--3 ;K-iiy"ts ci!> S.-";*ai +.,a;l dF -r.>
t,l .r-xL ;l:;.,.c*lo:,-(j l; ;.:,! f""lt; .! cl;l ,S.r>l j-* -I"^ +5.lloiy r;l.r
1. Eduard Heimann
WWW.AEL.AF
,.!tt J., a Y?
;: ;r-r5r U;610-* e.l.-^^ +5.r;l: l-t e,--f d/l f;l; calu,l 1l
\t-a j -S e) o5 r-,5 dL;l.1-t;lJ 4j<j yl 1r,.c.*1.:y rl",a:;j
t rI+ +5;1jl.-l-plJPj.c.*l+:-ilr "f.-e;.r
)J- drl: ot-:;.gly,r5.[1
n5 rl fJ!-- ,,.t-l s )_yo:r,",.lLJl st -b r" jl,.Jl; t-y,>yi..l3'1 q:5ltdl
r*+u t 1*^'JL-r .Jr+ -, Jtirl +5.rUill 6rt-n slt 6 Jl- r,t-"1*:*1..* rt-li,i.r+, jl",+ d.tj Li 3: ylo3Uj c.rjlo.rrS oJaLx,. l;
ts>l)l s f!L-- 6 $$:,." rliljl.J-,tr": t* 5-jl-5_rr,-gLaptli;rjJ$ 6 -uiL +-i,lr : j>j xlyu; F e*.JUf :+_i a,o ! -u;l-,".,..
j I; l: )tj:rl dl; ;l ..r-"i; Ji.l-l .g.:l;i a, "t4." t^c;t ."r Fl;1 Lg:ljT L-o.li.gL-^a-"1;;q IJJ-.I ut"-e olj*-r: +5 J:-y a4"l ;r'-l e". flJ.rjJT4k*" J-l.:r5 "r:.alr,- G+:?ic r,9,-- -!tic jlc^i-, -r^lf iXf- r5;: jl.-i ! d,:Sl.S;-r-,U"rjt- .gL,a..ql J$JTJ ,>l4_bH' ,,tJ rS f,=JL-r, ,H jl 6;>l-4 >f"S .gU^olp 6 r:ss, Ju,c*l ;-oi c^J Al -Sl .l-S e :lj ,*:t3 ee., ):-r 6E :* y,
gf-ljlyf<* 6k € ost';l;.: c.t:S,r" J,-J- 1-5qj) .i- r-,1,., lJ U e5
st *Josj-c o\,-,;,rjl3 c="al6J,q- )* q t" 6 J-it Jjli,r"i
-*. ;"-li.l ta; L .gLaartr a5 -r+f .f.^, :l/ d)J. )ty l:,&t UW
#-,:.1j-ljli,r^; lr,7 6yl"[Y: t-l.r;.i -t-'U r{" jtt l..i gGj\fi;jr't .; d)JL.;." J-x J-61J;i oa;^Lor5 rl-uJ! up:l-a:l1c.(=;1r53,: f!t*-.li..rrt"-;l Jx: J<- r.r- Jl J\4lcElacr-
"l.t$rf tg;C."Url:.r" o*3a*,5 db.-t- 45 s,Jera;.lt 1i.ti,-r"*,-
)ey.,-|.-o..c*l ;5*" I bi y.d*-t .Sl; .f$ +(! ,c.*l ,_,,-?)
,l+a J-Yr n-5 c*,1 f; J!L: -tL;;l ,,1 ;: .Social Research, Vol. VIII, No.4 (Nov. 1941) .\e.1g ,-l1l :t ,rl,-ls o dl^;lr=,- ;l ,rS, ;.: a5 .r-: cJ.a lJii..t;L osj, aS tay(Cf. The Bulletin of n.-r::."-" .ri Lt-l f--*.s)L J f;!"J- Jll-r-Un 6 .ljs lyJ \qf I
Intemational News, Royal Institute of Intemational Affairs, XV[, No. 5, 269).2. individualist socialism
WWW.AEL.AF
VV a34ra;;t!j
.,,rj;l: 11.-ri6 ,)\ 6 d)lr.iljl,rJ rl-u L;3 45 ty i:li>>t"S;t--"l, JL j rr)\(L-" U-l ,lgtL* 3 c;y 'ual-ei.li.itr," u.:;j' arLi
> F tt(ei t oe;^ry"s t^oi -Uu;l 6yl -fu t -5.r:alrij ;3L
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
f WtdgWs*srprai*p
,r:> 1t>jlba Y"tS;"t 3; ar L-ac^JL-3-rr
.n,-rLrL 3 ,5:l1i:ri;l.: :ti:cl ,r-;iL:" f^ {Lit.s.rlt,
Jj
l-, pl- .i- -r--tr.o:r: t"l:l \ JI4l +k*. a;L;: t!.r=, 4SOJ1jl J'i- '' \-6 fr.* Jt*" ,-tls r--j ,-s e.--"U"b.r^c 6 6la'gJ 9:16 / (*,.:r, jl -* 6k ! t$ .-*ly .rF o-b1^-qL cc-*{
"-Sef ?-*.
€* \c.*l;5-" g-*J!r..r;i,r-; L_r.y f*JL-r lWc.r-5i crt+ .!I..r-al a5 c-.;l y oU; cr;i1 6 r,l 1. rucL:>l cJl-r-e,5Lr.lL;i
Fl4-5 c*l u-cV.gL-"jlt P \d.,x# l-.1..r-:i, ,*;ur*
jl,J-,1-*1 3 J;-, 1.:y,-' -il.r-al ! .u^lf.f t ^oi ;-rt jl l^c*Jqi,f
.)J:*t 6lr-:jay" 4;l-auls: t<]j 45 JSG- s* c;-)L^aL prr-"
6t-cJy' -ri--,r^*" t ,.JL-f pP U-l a, .rjl,-.i-tn Al ". lef
fG,.i- it>1jl>j--j ol: !;, j;l4 j"c; casJt c)- cu"aye;
tl.5 ,-.r- el-s.6 ,*-pi:S oil: a5 .:y J-al-g rro-L.xq91;+.[i 1 4;:l-,a:il
t. Ete Hal6vy
.$:../ ef -r 6t-:b51^ rW 4 \l-s )r e4 S't
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtt tt D A'
A6;:S.gLac.=lt*r a- ot-.i+i)\-e C* 6.r.J;l.r r_9,-. y.5.:U__1 :lil-il-r-.al dL^^ 4-i "$*
J J-:,U.,-" c*Jt*f l-: :_t' tu,c3-e; 6eia5 J::5s" 5;: ai y.r;1r c.=*aldj dt-!_l,, Ll-r.i1l: )U3l,*,!q.-,* dt{,*il.ul yl tu -[:^lJrs, L;3 ;r5"". d".rA y' ! y "\r._, L^l.lTo, dlic, );L-c -!L."r -tJ;!.:.rL:rl 6 6:l;l r"^L"r, _b ,t uryl!..r-U- c-:fft*r ,.aB sgl.ooy,.l, cc*t *iLc* > ts^alu 6 ^<l.i *l 6"br*a- oS 6:lSljl6_,q^-.i r-&t e-r )l.s,\5yri..il.r-al.rr,- 5jl-r..ila, f^;-y.t:llyr.r^j .u:*a ;pU "rjrl f*Jt#;r-,-iU,-il-ual a, Lac*Jti:.;- 6jl$l4-.: tic*Jt.-
- 6l-astss +5 -U;l: r[,c^cl l-r,j -t5 .,;l-+ f!L-y- jfu)dljl.c--l Uti-b Las*jtl -3, alyc-il-r-al 6.-l a-.os-.' _1rb:-
-/ -t' q-5 -il.url )f p ,. +,1;t*c f*]t*- ! o!l_., g )-al )S_*LT e-5 r-.11.: t-*s i Jlg" 6,-l a5 -r-tf - c*t^.ri t g*J
111.1 3laui,3_2
.c^i! c*r f",.Jt*- ,-i!;" .-il-r"olpL;1.rL-.,"-^ _t* *olig+-\ j-, d_r ogJ ,*l s .\i tfs ! 4{+ .(- U c*l ./K ,*l y;l;nlrJi;Lo .i d lp l, -il.r-al dp-l {S 6:lrtl ..5..f Jl.<jl 6 :Feu"lK$ *t.+ j-il J*., L",6 Ul .I;{.r- tJ La.)i t cu:.._r
6;sa-.lr't,;l1l,tL"a ;16 gltl.4 +..clq o5 \*gr"{ftLrlJ-, cc.*l .rJt .y- .:L-)\-zl al rJ-r::"-r tl a!.,y #,sl 5 nr5:Lr.il
eii {5 elre Jt.t-*e or["o:,.1 i -&r.:.t :. --il.r-alt rJJ:--rty s5rl,- $ldt^cJt.r.i-"!,-Liq,rct^.-l .:Jl.rp ,J)l_f tr y** -;j
.r: -u.AlJ, t6,1-;a.lr,t tt-lf c:3-i1 n.r3- ,Sl; +J_rr U"F-"ta (r),ejt* os:re.r:l_rr c.t-i[ cJl.r-c J)\;r: 61; * La.r"i;r Cti Jtt t
re l*, ..clvr dL^j?" d f"^lr.r fl.t_rr^l3; pjY csi-:a.U;t,J; 4.t" fB Ct - e(1 6VclL- cl-o.9ytisl(-l ,rL: c6>lj Jt<; tu
.r--! ,r .r_ulr; jto ,t-l- _,t5 .r*l el-t 6 otoj_r: ,rK. &a jly'l.r:5 dr"#i l: tlt 6ur -ulyr 6 -Liq .;Laj_r_r
WWW.AEL.AF
A\ z.clsve t .lStiQ.JL.JO.J
6l-au,"s: - "L-ai 6t; tg-.JL- 3-t'"j\ 11o.:tiil c-*l ;(*" 4t-:
-,1 g-,!*t --Lj 1.: a5,51.j13..r*iU c!:teU .li;t.r-"t *i,St+ q dT
+1 .rJ:*-r ,Sly 6.rL-ajlt r-jq r+.1 ,-!Li .c.*l ciG Jt"Ji.! rlil.;- ,,i , t-l S *.-= '(-ej +U -t,ls *$ r-*;lr.i o:Lc-l r;y* ,--ira yJ:->-JsJL'J
t-r d:l.r-Ji (e"lJ f) ir-r*7r,:i tt;;-; l: f![- _y r $;-$ :l r.p tS--t<J tic*JV:- -Jl -b s> "S Jll e*..JL- ,,1
lJ 4j( ;t-l o- ^=^^ l-"l c-r*L .*t: fJL- -r -&g rity.f Clj f..*l;Q J o)r.t e.lJ Cf "Sa
:t ij- g*-Jt+;"" 5 i:-'-il.: ,l; r, r,-!J--q ; g*Jt*r 6-r!t: g*t (-9:L..o d-lf Cqrj,o arL;: eir^,.:-t"Jll J t^crJq-;r- j)\:;l ,y 6;W pt";L;.-u.iL ct.:t""
5 ;:- Glf f tsi, J[ft1f!; ,* -tt 6 $sJ,g Lyy 3,l^]st yorLi:*l P.^\.-il".t-al .91; Lrc-*fV-y 6 .;t-oj-u a-i y J::^--a
jl rlr a-.a13.-- Jl; d..-,., r:;- ./K yl;.: 61, OLa.t"t1 gL; -9.-t:;S,r"
,r-t-^oi)l.- q o5,ril-r-,al )l -#*-* e"lJ Cq ja ,jaje;:l :L- jl J--q; ;"i 1-, *( ;1 ;-::-",a .t_rg 6^rV ,J;lAnJ;lrj ..:Lc-l
t4j24a-cLgt\ u'"lf g,z ,Sj; ,g,-/J€ t-€rd ,'..1Jtr;,- oJ5U 6.r-eti:" lJ .i;ll .rlp;,51-1lr rlil 6 c*l fJL-- yl +(L c.*lgL.a rJ:-o:;r ;j g;rL^eJlft_t.J .<ii -!,1: ,: il ,:i r" f1> -,! .i- U o:f
-l.: l-l L-acJ3: c.t*u,l pl:iJ3-r 4-.1 ,45 JJ, al a, oli:3'-'y/ os.rtlr,
, dLE )_t' )l.,jt J":.-,I fU: 6lr. t-;j-*.r e5'uucs* )lP .*-f.JJ:y o:r5 :-f f l;oir,\r,-r:-ilL -$::)
.:L^a:ilrr dft t* J: 4.i 6ly.t,a-lJ g*7,r 6j1-e jl f-al3+ t" t'lr.r ^^5 o;Li:-l c, <: ra-oUJ -E ,t_f -i.ta;1 -b--e <o.L-i61;+"Uy
VJJ
L-. Jl.i Jt+--^./q.. 611; L9boj13 .:LtgljlJU .:)\.(:" ,>y,," ,sl
oe;^bV 6 t:-g ,..i,r-r cSl.jl,llU,-r"t<3 ojl3 yl,5L*..:y .t:-al3,
ue>; ,glsc-;l::L ;l (Dugald Stewart) a;l j.:al -rJK-9: ;l rc-*l pbi uL::!rr ;: o,u,li .\.IVAA JL ;r (*l
WWW.AEL.AF
.,):rr ol; tl AY
--S _* ui; ,gly r.5 c.*1 6tsbEt ry),:i 6y-1+"UJ )t ))b". fS4-:J$l4-5 4ilJL.^ Llc,.:*1 6_ss-p od;r ,*; -_,,_gLaot-.;T
f# ;):"^ iy-J.12 )j)> s*U?.5rL;;;lljl V Sf -r 6:Le^il 6t-:bVlt q il J+ oi J-;u-o F y e -rsr*...cl;Q cJJl.:.r." .ri 6L" d:,
.(rr gli + ol;e.!r fl#j Gss r,, col6Lar"L ) GU'GJ)c-iJr-;-l Ojr.t-..g:L; -i-- Lj l; :3; g-*3": n6y;+"[Jyrr ccJl
L dF.^. J-- U l:j; .:)\*.- L" a5:;lr (*y.r .r*Sr^ +5 -r.ilr,r"
t-r; ,;tt:- a5 ,-,:t .r:ilr 6f.;u,iOt; oL*^ ! s o:-F J- *+,U"r;l-t-i .:tj:cl )ti JWJ ^1 J-tS ,* -.6 u-S,^::;J4;l;: .-5os2:. g, UatVt r_f y -ijly.f ,r-[* J* r^ c-r--iL;;+"Uy 4 -rjl_,,.f
9ysaulr..+ J ?J> tS;s+"Lr;-.iLa.rjlai tE *Jly ("t^l! +! U")
"i" .-f."i_f d:r,. 4jt+4ij5 J 4iLi."--l 6;sa-ly. rrK"tt-i j 4iyrt,3 oL-1La;S 6lr. :lSl 6ys+uVt 3_* ,*:tJlJS fL"i eS cillr:L,aill
pp ,-.6y-sb\t -rJti. -ril:,.1 5 c*l Lgj ;ifi,c*l-^.liptajl;,,.1 o1 .jly ;-l )l ol-36y2a.U-r a^"tt .! otrt.r;; ,JJ51 t"l .rit JTft,
! :-b.r,i;r y o:t g:i d f^tr.r ft\u.J:56"i o:Liit;-,! .tr:S Gysu\-t fy+q",JL"^ 4i J{qi -u:! "rtr SLar;l-uE-l;,,lie& .-l-p ritt-i-illnl ?G *. _t rg)sylcrl i-:a*"U_p o.Jgi,
.rLl_r t ;Lr 6Lac^Jt-s -r-ilr Jl:i" :l-il +5.rrU:ytt[rl-i:pl c-.+.rit5 cJ*JL-y 6t=;l +-.r oTltytr yr ;3-i g:r.i,5t-a+"Uy
a-"tJr, ;-_l .gil3 ;: s - J-l f 6 s,L uE -r dl_r.r*i lJ Jl; +"Liy y-lr.Lao I
q 6,y-l6tUr t)?l;,g[."ol5-l: c*t*r-, .r^la gll O.*+ 6lo.Vyri;l: jt-: L oly;+"[iy ei.r.iq ,J*x G-l;b.,t*iL c;l> (Sh 41 65t+ s ..,;lsLU;.(,. ,yllt 6:l-a-il.5L^cJt", rL; Sf y s*U^j:iL- o:;31r-, c---&> J) e .slS: e- aoi-- CU jt u+;Lot(T5rti:-lr
.c*1 --il.t o1 ;yjtiJta, s S)s:^lol1-;+"Uy & )_F_f ,; .-iy:;l_r i-*.r,..e1;!
WWW.AEL.AF
Af tr el 5* i. rl 5:le', L - Q')
1, F" 6LL.:-1)-ti.i 6LadtijL .x jlc..l;: ! *! U a5 cri ;,l([^.)iUf, pt-E: +! rf 6-r)ss;;r.16;L;r 6t-_su11- 6ly. aS yl\: g-F t;*" ol;;.,;..al qi c.*l u-tl f ,i g^-.f:^i! o.;t, $. : irl-,-1,ir,-l +: ol=*-r SlyL) 5 c*l g-l Jl3,-.c*1.,.al; aa;6 ylpta.,lcSl_r
;.r e5l5 ,p"lr3:taql-ai3 l: )f o;-r-i;u^j;-ti ,j # 13,t a,.-i.i.a
a>E:; )) J o) y slt s s; t. gfu..[^," grlji jt :lrJl t+)\, ; ;"-l> ..rT
jlcd)Ue 6j:y ,(a 45JJlt-lt- t"t::5 6y_:u5... fL.j c.TAJ* U *.;l;,i tn..tl
4 .f Ll; L^.JL,J fU .S_5r" e"-lra J er^J,["JL r"jt/ )JaJ. CU,6L- cLagL-- pt-s 5t ac*J!;,- .c* I or.l, 4rJj +;Lo15i n,r15 arLiy rr
": f S+.;,="-a ; i_#l S cl:.il:.r" *[:, ug] i;+r[i;r;jlj 6lr, l; p3t
Ly i.l ei c.*l.,"- dl+ ;J"l g-Sl,Ll.c.*l f p Jp ,:y ,t :*
-r-l ilyt, Ul .c-l JJ-.! fi-Jl j i*,*L ;r.r.-)l.no "l-r ki JlsouElui r 1LAJI; j oly;,ani16 c.*1,Jl{<i,lt*^"Ujr ;,ly.c.*; ;;7
.I;1r p -iYrlot(-q.r U \ 61souV1 Ly U-lq ciJti. J,-1..5 c*lra" i *( alr, GJI; JY-u--t .c);.!'-il \n"[-*r
.9rlyi,r;LJ; 6rL1.r +;t-:"--ulE7a
.lrr5 .K :^t a 6lS,5lA.--3 olj:,-o a: ctGt jl iJ-(.-" 6rL,--.,1 ,f-Rr- l.aJTJYrrl..:y"- Jt-- t:_rl6rl$tj d e:;tr -r5'U;U;f .JL^;)L;--lcrr5 rL+ilj_'- _r .t"n clli-r rll3a e51+r^ 6 c*lll,:"1oI& r,_l
lJ 4j<j .*ly.-t.-i! .:1r-rl.gLaj)U c--l.ta 4;11. ol; r,-r-a1 -[ly;.rr clli;_:l ,sf 4-i dl,+ *S;.1 61y.6 S.f ; Jf'tJ ,:i ,. S.:f; ;t-(l ta;;+:
J+dr*^.c*lpjY 6p ;yG ?J"rq .i-,rr5 6;1rr:o;+ crU;
,"fly .r:^i,! e J "!L!ljl 6p ,:-lj:u; tg_tsJ) s S)syl .,+li dJ,,-l
6jsr.org.Sl-,i fjY Al; rl4,-l otil l+r^ 6 r5,r^; _,lKli l'1 c(4i Ji!.5>La.il gLac-Jt*r ),.:4" g;l--, c.t-^iU f^lr, --tU-, ) ;1-;.au 4$l+ -4Jl;. gg)L^."-.it fJt; ,Ll.g-:j ,tr* ;i-> 6ta4i::
l. Laissez-Faire
WWW.AEL.AF
J:rol,Ll Af
-rr 6 $.: ;-lq kicl-, gtti-, 6 c*lc?"^lrs ,gl-asis-t:aL ! c^rlr-,
.Xlqr .tirt;:o .r:- ^K! r:*loriqrLi "r,lt
U-;;y \l; -;Sl&- c-Jt--.:.1:J-1 lt L^c--Jt J bl-rr-* diL dS c.*1.r-i3r l+ oS #,cgil3;r .-i5.,- :l-uJi lJ ,PG.i r.:r5 (:^i.^ ga ! U-rt=l .:.,r"r;
ajt.KiJr:;Sn +5 s*l;-,1 *--,.[i; jl LL-r) ;) oJ-se a;taJY.r:-ljl._'(1
L; -tarcs+ )l; ,lpl;L:il ;r l: .* j y ajlr 6)J-F ,! | truel.al
':".:,li,-* oal-; Uf 4;i.gttc-.UJ,, J l^jt$lf:" Ui s_&. f*.*.-t-i! .lt5 o;l.r olr^-a a' 6 ;)l);3 t-a,_r:-l5 bl6 6ly.
.il. :l rrrL^:-l,Jl-jt* "l-l ..S{ ,llj:,c a, s,1l.i-r jl.r"irtS o:Li;l
.-J &, e,J )lt-.| cJ5,r" 6.3 _b 6>l*dl lf -,, ta4,,7+l.-l"r,
e:\l-t L,a.lTrr5;5 dl4-E-y" ,!6 :-b I -ruil-rr.r 61; ta.4,7+L-1,r"
Ll .-t-;lr,r" 6)Jt' 11 cJ3: cJt--r 6>-sl-f , G- 3 :;1.-i..r" ;1tar,-t:5
JL.rlJl ; aS )l;,iL*^ L- ,-.L" ltl,J 1; e5 r;b )ffJ 6f U),.Jil'$J rly -r5'U s13t oj-s:* y.rtrK rt; orLi:-l)r;" *-! -ryj
,r+; ri a-,3 cbl;Tu;lyl tlj! s> -fV6t^Cg c-lgjY Jj'i-r"
"-Sf 1*e t -t:S glsf s 4f r;t;un eli y J,ti" -rrt t 6
6:l;Tc.r-iL J:-* :4_r J-.:U ^5 6h -f Jst s.r,-r,.lJy -rr {!+*a 6ly 6:6 -iL; cSL^_,[S I ssss ttlr-x c*l ljY .J-q a*1.:
"["-cJr-S c.-<a -,, ,,xt $-6 €jl J,-qj dyU -r .ry a.olri
gil-,.e s-b *. tcslr ot-6:i L- j! gL^y,r e* )l.jl:;" 4l6"sf t- rlit -t-y; t6c.+.rU-" t+ Lac-+ J;-S c^<+ -,, ,i$ *_$ *.r:5 J*""J 1.,1 -,lj! u. )J)J
.(--:l--.,-11: oi.r;J-i jl l1 c.-ti1 vli.l Al;.rY3"e-*, .U;$li,r^i I'Ac*.i.:lr*;lyi -rS pF rllt,5[-or",!i; e -;?-<at""$t 3o.r3r L-agli=1rL -rr -br-. elr-"X ttr -fiV,>,ye,si.,:
.-t--it .: lr.;1 .r1"""--"; 61y .rL":.cl J"t dL"slJ -tj li.r*J:9J>vo lt lJy,.tiU 6t^i,lt 6 .,itrl$l ollp"Lyr",r r"l;ll-lot(.r:S-gy pL.i 1.ac.-.:3.r-*, jil 6 .,jl-j U J!l.r-- o;lri c-e.*a cJ5,r."
WWW.AEL.AF
AA E.ls9e e cls)-pA.J L - Q-J
J,5;.r eiu*, * )* ar y orl.r Jlj ;'U s^-,.j dt*<,. )Jb ,,1-, .F!l'
Jr+ 4J qJ^ .-,UJS o:; -lt5 u. o\ j-,a-a -tJi ol;=" J L^c.*+
t;_r.s it-el6L^+,;,J"-^J e-L: +Ji qgta._e.i JF r, .,rt-ajl;L."tc(:-/.r" pt);--* Ct-. -,torLi:-l ,u.r.'J3.a^r.(" !, 6lt'.r;;*)g* ! ":rJirt-;U-r;13-"
jlo:[i:*lry,^."..tu^iU a:.il: jrrl Jrli,s,
.g;l.5 eLc[,-rrr5:y.L*-" ,la,:i 6131So;; ta;l"t3a ,-?J. tu +i f:)Q:j..ii;lr ,-,iij c..G; L;- i.r(^,*:-tt.ra, gslt \ qi o-tst'\jlji-, .r.:J.#t - Cb ft--.r-113-e ;r L-lcJ c.*lar{lar<*" heptJli.<- L r;l ,j, -- --,:L!-, -Lj--.lt:*t oJ.i,-[ao*i
"ft":?l 6LA{-"J^\ - . Je
;--1,r-o:.tLjL e5 .,jt j U
"pl.u-J*:U -,6)t*.rrt"-7l.:L.t- e>;3
.),1 rr..r )lt $jL< 7!- y c"l,i, .r:;-.,jla5 .r..iu 6."-S a, sL-t.-
i J {-:,K;r 6 c.:*i JKi" Ji Jxl 45 r"J^ ,r>*t S;t1-;1t:1.-ic,..7;r:rfl"." c^- t*l/ * rg;:"5 t!*laay -g. LW L *-t ",r-o.:.ll--1t* ;u."jl!l+;oj.iLrt ltJij .<i r-5-,t5.l:*lo-t--i .-iG: lEdl.arJy' 45 - .,;l"e)(tt,gt o+(i, 3 rLa;l;U,Jy,,j"r jl tr.arlaj € J GScc.*l-r.:5 eli .-,its :* yl, t-^,:i;t dt Eli,* $; At*;c-[!l jlf- 05.--[:, j-i3 f+ .(1ry,--.3 dJ (4-4^ jliY!r,o<!
pUi; as;l .c ",1 a:-ly (J:5 jt-J6,-rtil .r- l; l;.ti,,-a J o)-F cat"-.:..*r a., r--q l; :l:ylf erDi t dtp c-5J1, J'-',1JiU..-rrU-r
.!jr r-e lr'l ! J."q j.:* "+ cLiU Lrr[-S $li,r-j 4?J6P ar cJ-Li
d)J,+itj-L.-t5 Kil -iL;,51,ac.-y.;3 ! !F-,1;.l c-,"(t gr,a-
c-i ;L ..r.rU-r ,t-U; rirts y. Mtie 6 G;* drli J[*1 fEj"a:l1l tslf u-. c;r, C;laJY.r:-l ,-f l3 r.:*l '$ 4if oJ,.:U r,-\:*.lL a;-.Xlr
OJi* ! "!l-, , ofu 4 ALGJ-7 6l-dJ.'*;3 L-o.:y^5 €J 6 );oi;t ;-;,n; l; c.*,1.i; ,-5;5l4;+' csgll-a:-:l -t,gV dL.ac.sy'c, tG; l.AoJJ-- jlcS-,t *t ;: a5 JloI.-X d--cq ^<! -t-iL c--L,r" a5 Jil":rS
.:3"..1 ry[i s t]s d, sl
WWW.AEL.AF
6', s-, a A?
Cilj.:!-;_r ^;-S €t-^oi;r 6 J;b )f _, G;t ,-iL^,.r."j ;qU
Lt'_p ct(t" J.iU_, pLtj o:y r; 45.r5.:t-11 l: &\* 'rrili.r-jr; jl.r.-l;1.: Q y YtS 6::L- aS ;;-"..** ,-ri! ;13"-l ulr:, bi a,5lr-, Yl.5 ,:i aS ;tp. fL*; rtl.r {. J )xr-ry Yt5..rT.:L.s dJ-i il3?-t )1.5l:ro -(: o5 l--iT.JL:,.t1,9-^-e t.r;! 6it.o>.5.:ta.1l olr-(-r
-i_al,^., c-1U., ,.:;3iaali c^*i cilry q dli.r.i lJ )t5 cJrt .:Ll;.r,f*- Y[5 -^-L.." )_,r 45,r"t<:^ J t-u5 +li l; .:,L.u.lT.:*;tr;plli .>23-.";,1;:.ryjj l: )3'6YL5 jl;.: olf> a, o-u.i:[a1l olp.d,_/-l;l,.(-cr;l;-, ;xl fk r) .)Ji -L^lF )lS ;l 7 1gllS --a*ck;l oG-r J 45 dIAJTJ x-yg cd; .1t -t -" .:ylj o5, ,1^*-Juis: olf ,s- c.ry' _;jo ,l"lfl: gl "K g J f)Jl) > j-j rJ,jK," ;Ujl.r5 d5lJl lr b t-s_f .:L.g -rJly a5 c.it_l_, ctU-,
-,1 * S&,oJ-.lr- -: Jr;tt ,-,a" _,tt * r)y,6-o cC;10.u5-i r4. r j 5'a ,;t;lc^..-l:y ci Laort- ry,- it:rj c*;) *V yc>11j, ,)Sl;r cy Lao.:Q;.>
u;y cu,_l:1)<+ _,Qtj .>l.,J ;r.,JlJJs; _,rt.,**.:t' .lolr,^;
a-, l; La,-JL-116 5lt-a J f J.:jr lLoLj.:l/lQ 611j1-1S,Sb,i_l_,
e"&1. eG e -&-t "i-r-, {! \st)l-r c.r:t;r .rr5 rj.t-*-" taliJl^-tp
c-,rt L: 4i J--! L 45 cj.;.rlLl.,';! c-J rtSJjL ,fLlt.:_,t!J1-,.r1--b Lily',Jli.,^i t o))p r,l;r 6 6f J*t".:J3: -i:^-.lt,li,_* oS +.:ilt cl[i-, {! t" oS c*-j ,r*" ,ct cr_S a,oli c--li; .gly
€ *-f r cIi'L ai'il:.li-,6
.r<". -t-- L; c.:[!;,-ri;r o5 &lrr rL-l i-l"j;.r JJly],r, c-J3r
t+ -r or;t ji J*<" cx,Xl jy Jli.r.j crE-, e5,_dtAt?;) L o:3r di.,.,jl
1r Ju.Jlj.r-" +5 -U>r,ar r,-:-*1 ,t-rTJ3-,
a- +5;L-f--,tr;3ia-^lr-i;r
s* oL" jlUl.-u*iL , c+" 3
_s j,a*"t.7.i- ely ,f* a;1.: ",rjYUl; .rlr-il )l ;+rS "J; \ )l _.a t-li^ .ruil3;,r^i f -* S rJ;l:;y>y
.r"LLi .'^;: ."r-5 c;tri ln s o* dy* _r $ j-*3 _,* yr.uj cjlr I
WWW.AEL.AF
tr -1 J* o ,l J:-ie-r - - e-r
-fu )* \, a5 c.*l e y6:*:q ..(1 -\:"J[j .r"lJtS J _;y ,?,G)
c-i6_ts:+.+.-*ti )g )L- \l; ! ;rl-u" )* \y o-L-i €|h,-y, ;-) 6;l5lcr J 1.JjJ )l 613 -b Lrr!- cdi,-#t" rt'J*c jti",i",.p *;, j ;ti c-Jt -i 31; -tl-^.(- ,r+y ,,, c(.:lil ,r^tflU jl o:Lir:-lL_./ t> J
.c-*lo.L"rJ ft+,l41-r" t,J"ts :* +.+s6* q jj*a 5 S,_f
)* \jr^ c.:l.i_, .r.:!jl,S1; :*b./yAth "i- rta-*l1t5 cLl
ar 3 o.-L.-l oEJ6trjT jlL^dJr pLJ +5 r-H o9-r pt-+,t+-.r ,[-sJl;- t.-Ur-5 t\ ,*tJ rU,:. "y"tS
3 * ji:u J-l ,li U Ci e+f-"tz.ry, oT ,-FS or6"L? 45Ji a- u:;n)ly c-tG-r c-;i: 4: 5,-r,Jel{, 'c +- .:5 2 :; iV .'1jss l; 6la:( lJl*i o;L;,1 ;.: qS c-l $sst',9-J , \-- \
fLcj o5 c*l .5"t-"t-- frJ. t o:3r CrGl J-b I 6f .61;+"ly a53-
pL-; e5',--l "t * 3.-LiloJ-: l-.+.tl J :: --.:U; -{,r_) dl:+--lr
\ e-l - (-
tAJl; a51r.4t"arL:"lcg?,1 ,ll _$1: li "t::S,r",r- .i-L; J;t^&l-S
Sl:t,r4L-f -14I; ;-1t-l ,L'rK.r-" t-Liry +-zJ ts;:i ;t
t otly.l 1-r )y'c-:+ c..[i; .jJti",5tallr.J crd tr eS c*l61sa'11
:l J d.r).r, )J-.i o-t-.I oJLi-i3 j 6 GW 6;? )* a, j o:;3ic*ra--:i \.-l.U,r-
r1.4,-l c-\.:-..il.: l1 e-l.!; :-f -* -d 43 etlpl e-*6;:-..-r-J: ,*-a cl:S,r" -b.:^ e L l; .:*11 J !-? CiLacJl.",3,*
,:5:111 :;-i; -* )t --i 9 ul:Li:il )L:i.:-.:,-' .sai<t,r J;L".4- rrr23.rt1)tt,;U, r*]!"r ,l J-qr- Ly.)r--/J4.:uLrSf r-:t- !5Jr*E:*) 1 o:rS oV7\ ,gf y Gt:2uJ, c)); 1;>\Ki- ,l .t lj1 I;1-9.r.rl a5 rJl":r5
!;- --:l *L* "z .". -14 P, ; i "--^l J t, -c: ; -<:' ;i -!-\S
Li- . r- ."-ar.:-(JL J j-al;|..t^:-L- .r" j* t ; su J.\ i 6^ a*- o Ll ,or-: aP -"Jt .:rX2* ;: f*J!-r, {-q--n_l nS ,ytrb :l: JL:; $rr, G-l: r,fi.1 ,*n ).\ J,\ ;l *-u? .rr5 ttllfS".f^i xL^1* .r.l aS (: j:' 7;-.1\1f . Economica r) ,ra: ,rL:.i .&., aq ;: ":rS u*ov-! .s-tJ-l, Cu l* ss; t J js JL,l r'.r" e r url! u*tt av,51 ;l v .:3, ;lyil
f*Jf-r, 1]Lol u;il r.iU (-r 45 -r:+l .c-l f* *of u, ;1; o:Li:-l :;3rLl ,c---:l: ts\r- 6;flSlt-F .F ggf ," c>\'G',9j* rl .-upt -;l .91;+"Lir,.r-+1.!;
.:y rr19 p ).r(=U ,c-U, "l;l 4".:a ;: I o:i ;3Ui:" LLI ;ii crtit
WWW.AEL.AF
u!:1. olz ! AA
.r:*loJ-.1c,-U-6 )Ld;l 4 !,.ti-"$tz a, ta,lilE y c.tl.i; L t-".ti
ely.Lt* ng*J[-3*rr 3 t-JL,t5l LrL-aojlj rl a-a jr^ o-5 .utr^
+, L-aojl3 r,,rlLrlcJ5"r- o.:Li:-l ,tti, o*,5 t el1Jt<.:,i, .","r;
i&-,U (o# oi rt rtS Jt- ;r aS l1 6liJ-ra c-sl, r6$J,il 6qI ' .JJ.rs,
eL- y Sf y c--l.lo c-u tu oJ..io.lal-j.,o r:lrj; 6yl .tqrr cLl
lK r, c-.:U-, J*b | "tL{. ",:(5 c*j;b ,!1r5 c1g>L,a:3l,jl^qJt-
aj 3 ully;a."Lj J, { 6 $)..r" l: 6t* i.:,?J O.*l :r-3 a, .r:.;1-!j J3l
U- ":*Jt<,"r:-,ra"ULjt* )l
g_r:ryl: +K; ,_*l-t -Ul_f.r^i lJ taJl;;r 6i;a-"U SJI oJ,-),-.,j|_r-
"L,, d c,6;.li1r 6 CU \n,rSr,.lr
;qu:l+l ,.,.-ti aJyl ,r,-l .t-3,-; )lt Ji;*. etu )la;t J JLirl
-t, L_*.* J* e ! crli-, ! ,.rt-;"ya; J) f)J, ,.lT;: e5 c.*l ,rt ly';r .:rU; d:_e o* jlU .,ri;l:
--S -E 6Wl -{-"t,FL rr-,,1; 6 Jl-"$\lf )le-.;l JL"e16.:l;13 oLr.i c.r.i J*t5 )* \oJ:*S.j *p-o ,el+1, ">\-; *s J-il .r:.7J^ Ll-t .$; r^lJ; )t j btJ )ts 3 rrlltrqt-.r-.rlj-,t* jlcS-,!*t -i.r-a 6 J+r^ 3 ai"ilr >1-j o13 _r* l,dt^dt jP: c*iJ;-lt-.1(g ".1 L11r*: ;,1:t4l 6t_:b}-t sgty .tLt-Ucc)-i-).> 1r..t-.XL o-.>. i
"l,ti 6),1.ic ,:* yU 3 +:-i1: pl3r .rjl3a 5 cri
.:l-.i'U.!Xrr .,il;"U ;;lie eb ,SyjlrJi*" 1gr,sa,V'; 6g"J-t'.Xl o: *s 45.r"t(^.-r-iU a*ib G, f tSt_:ui1^ _E tr_fL-; 611-a-;l eU-? Jr;S.c-li I o- .>-:3;! .sl; ol; t-4:,i c-\tng
-i,J.6 eJg t J,-! (r-:ti d:"nilf.^tr.r ft rs J-;-S -c.*l c-J3>
.i.ri Ji o-.znr* ! t- o5 c-*l .gl+l.> " r-rL.-a rrl J;_* lrr-# S
J^l-'ti o5 ,_r5 o;t-.ll a-Ua:ca ,..(ic<r- jl # -o5 ,oS urlK;a.fyrl
a+6i-,"*;l eb J;rs L "u;l: J.4, tJbJ .llr"-a; aS r-rb .:,9.3 c5-rL*r
oi tf _f *sjt d-t, rr3ir, c*;lr;s" 6 J::5 .('5 .,i" cir.:?i
1. corporative
WWW.AEL.AF
A1 - .,\ Sr* e ."1 S)fQ'r L ' Q'r
+5 c*loJ-.Li: -r--lr.e ;--l+1 d)Lj Jer ,3:ry,..tU;..:i1t..r;U.rU;
.J-x J^lJ, ,i:: &,jl .ri rr.rL; .*ij( ! .lia.r-*" ,>l);J t6.j.;crtL-l f- jJ- s5:L,o:ilc5t e=Jt- c-{lr^,J,tS6:U;5r*. a.:"--i:I
.jlIljl.i-r-,5 dr{lo5 JJ, ,.r-14.i kJd ojlJil,r" .rl_* * ly rliljlgL.j c."-l.u a.i"Jlt: )_ft_f .r"J/ #) q rllrl &.,_* +(l o.:y'l13"i:
- -J y c-& >wt ! gsl.r J ;l cl-r4.." .c*l o.ry J>ly f ,* 4 )l :-rl
f- jJ- :lilr'lSt +5 c*l p: ;s.l'l;r., ,t's.sd J*, Ns &>fs 6f y.:,-l.t-a 3 rra;t-lr5plrr c*l[ir ..X ..ftr .l-, 4 +tr JJ;1.: .:U:cl
)l ;J_fu ;tL:a )l;l.9lr, l.nl1.r .rjl3;oi rt e? r6il3;r.r.iL a-.xl:
611*f ,^* a*; 3 :l1i --..llJJ jl ,r,-bjrSr; d.i t -iJ^ o5 -ti! +":"--[l yl-t-:.>,y'.\:-.-6 siss s>P -fu J (#J) ?4; +-(l arUy .<,-,J"ts
tr.liotr;; Lt c-L-iU a-il; r-9.- 1: l; c5r^i3jU il ,rS-i Jlr;"r.. c.Li;
c4 gs:l: 14 r'6;saali.;n -9 ..:r5 -4; Sl:*Liy U "l3iJr olj"" q
,Fg i-ejlt" a5..r*5.:ta..l lJ jl;'U.ril-ea c-S .3f. o13.,a f c6
6Lr111lc-u--iL ,-pV ;l tSf -rl:,-l.r-a g^ -r eli: t'.grt, rt-UilOi
.5-i J- elt.6 tx-a )3-,"1-9rr.a l.ayli:y J:-aly>,5-r,irSU J Wfls6-a o5 rl -tal3r,_+ d.,?+ 3r yleJrj -t Lssr_l 1t5 a, .$".-,*_fjlrJi o.i-oT.:*ra-, 'aaa: *->y u-.il.: ai-,t5 c*jli SIJ;.rQ q L"."r-i.f o.:ti:-l Ttlu :* a, taj_u arl jl .,! jl 6 :y -ra13"-
n5 rr5..-5r aa tr ol-;-,.f G:-* -,r ki 1-, clti-, 3 61so*Vy r;Kt.c^.:l.i_r rJ.a yrr ri; J-.i! crti; rr4;lyr tsl-:ut.';
.r-iL a:ib _b tt V[5,_.*lde.r lrl, f<, # *(J..*lJ,-q..ujl3,
erL.a gjl3;r.l*;5r^:" ai ep r, t " 6L-a:l-i:ilfL"i 6 61sa.L1.6
u&lq rrlr.r ''s 6;sa-vJ dLa - s*l srl.i: .r-z ; ts-tsbvto)3J>u ?-ft)q 1: aal3;,r^, tr e5 lJ." c*l ,r^<* A* ,-,*l .S! ,.:rl.it
.r-- l,-; l; c.-[!1 ;;l_re 6 6_ts-* k,S]r*U; 4 51L1r -.,t5;,1
1: rr6i:+-"U r.r *S *iSbLa t l.g-r e.--, :;13 c:jL l;15 J jj. dl'<"l
WWW.AEL.AF
6't J. n 1'
JJ, oa cc-loJ-.i l:*a jT.j.l.i Ut\\""* 5r 6.)q o:Li:-lr_,y, #Got;---o a- L :;;l-rlo-5 r-,-.t .r-alF r*-r-.U:t-:.al-l;* )ld;l; iL+,-l.(- rf oUJI; Slt 6 c*l.r:-,tl.r, ;1 oS -r+r^r,.,,-,1 fU cst-:bi -.r--jr Goi 6l yl: Grk c.-:,h- oS i)lis 6-.p! :y- .rJ.; "jl,l
's'../
WWW.AEL.AF
l-*w @ 4ry ryw,@
,rrl F); J),u-t * --rr;L-S l3lLra-, tl-^.iL J-"la*i,l-U.; d-: I e::- J\S;t
.'5 )-, ;t )ril 4L :i g:tj I "jrril jL"-a
.)*o aQ- J J J -,
b-J<\ L r*V 41 11 +uV 1..5-r.J1 dS c* I r[<--:i c-4L .i" ..*l
Ji.," Jt ilt^,)iFl.c-l *-. ):_r tStsbE, 6,-Frd" tS;puL;1
)l e)V 6 &\| /'U c.-; r dq a:il: -.,[iil F gti-; -&t 6jl 4-i L.g"5 -Ut ;^fllq\,57sa.lr; tyg )p c.r::-*a t JF6L--ac^irL r,;.sL c-^-; c-[ir d,JJ, ,-rJ-.a {<! >j-- o>li 4y1
lG .* -':l i: lJ)g j-. )l )f 4. )f .1, Jis jl ?B 5:irEJJY-r:-lr-iL^-6l;;,tt- ;;3 *lie.:;$ t JY.r:-t u1l j.ga,u,,>:f a- llj; ril;r 6 ,-Sgt f1, ".s:*1r,'j1,51".-l-ay 45 Jj!"s"
\ -kl-S.c*l ,-Ll J ^'-\ iF .* riU 3 {i-rr;r oua;ir,--L ii.i- .(,-
U Jr::5 tl erG +S r;,-s c-i.j--rr 6 ^+j tst--saVt j j,.,"-il 6j-;;S 3 r-l; o; fr: * :, a5 -u*a 6J,-Li.c JJ4-- +(l
"r3"J r.l-i,L
.J;lrS; :j; ")-- c^.*j lJ L 6tac.*[- lU y dt-
ts:t:A-tl.St!U:l+l ttrlr oLi.i e\ 6 d)-Ld.a .gtalY.t:-l ,tt .. ;l
WWW.AEL.AF
,-|t-r. J, n 1Y
.51-ac^ir:1a5 c*l C-l tye"JriQE iS}i -r;lta$ llr.i ost-iilr13,
;.:3 {+14r1* j<"" ,4,g>l--1,3:50)f;.: 1; c.-[!; ,;-:lfJL-; 4y J-# a 5 c*lyl.riL,r".-/! t" elt.6 et--f t6J 4+ri
.*j t l, ,,.("cc-J3: oI*3 a1 t:"-l.t-a J 6ep 6j.a;l6t^c5r*,,t 3, n.r'l:; up[:-a 5 *i,r , ;.*J,L ',, 5r jl .5rtj -t> [; o-r.-i.o ylJ- e g J , (J - r a)-J
r;l: .!J3; L,EL-." i o)jll6s:.t .5Jt J,-tio jl cg-,t .*f .t^iL q 6 J+fl-r.-5 jl o'Lj-c;-l +5.rJl:.r*; i tf J o+) l"^,-li+ (:+) tu .:*) as
.,:.-l nzJ oll;4*S JL- .tor, * y JUlp;l or,-lj.i J^:r ,;.iJti c^,i^,L ra.Jt
r;3-o cil*l dE alU, L-o,.llrr aS 3l-a")_j-- 1) ll)yJ>.-o .*.lSl:q.^ .J---1,. aril .i;3.t1;- :;r- ;.: +5 -r:-ay ,t_r$ u* -,ty .iJEu! Jr-; ar-ilL-Ta,5 c*la,,-l.-4a Jl3,* Ul.tr-#,-r-.4iJt- J dl,il.,r--x JL.,c! .gLac-* [- rq$'lt t' t- .:y ggj_/3;51; *ir+, ; j, U-rL:71
Jr-; ytd;l3 ,+! 5 ry a.-a13,-
.r,at^i t7y11: .c*l [IJJ*I.S Fl -,,"5 fr*:q t*b rtr;r 1; 6(; a.,ilJ,"q l.r:,lt,l.:;b .rfL *l ts-r tL-_p
911 j-,a-)lr-xJ r-Jlier- ojlllaq U U"-f ,5,:lr:*.rYr,-;.-r.jjt*1 ;j,L;-.,Lql ,6-s g:l.l,o)f
6lJc>S)'u-" )l*">;l J-lJ t'-^-eL C3lt* e.5 t--e:l;-l+;L:-l
i,:r*3.-ei-,t5 tt- ;r 6 cc-..l 4_f dl^c*Sy' t 3:t6t"og5i,51 ;.:,-rJi if-y- .gLrr*-lt ..r-"T.r. cr) tu .rl !i O, 6;larsi s-s
,,rJ-i;o1; .rilil!.t1";* t"oiy.r +5,Ilo.:;3i )-trJ \b Jbrl;' eV,€*-llll 31;6t^rJ_*..tioa;;: 6 c.*lr"ili.,bts ,j Yts !i *-r^
o+ jl t $; :3rLi l1 *_S dt-ac5y' J.jl{**jli r.drr_t, 6t"r,*-.;t" y .(." Qs c-*-.,a / tr 5 s.rl{ $lJ, +"bl ;L, U "riy-, ,,13 .JJ;lry
jl J1 -,1 JY"r*l ,_.xl .r_r .t,-al3, Jl* 31;. c^Si 4j> jrx rl.u; fl.r-:,:-11 Ji3,) )t*J-t,.JLi." q -i;5 .t<,l t- ;,1 o;L;: ;;; ,+.glr,.\
<The Inevitability of Monopoly,>> The Economic Basis of Class Conflict (1939), pp.45-80.
WWW.AEL.AF
1r tr,cr,ut ",<,iLiuL:-l
J J-56- "r.S'b,c-*1.1,-",",r,.(,jrJ.<j cjr.:.?, q .*G a5 6t-ar"L
6-, e-n :l : t-S g oI-rU rJ5,r," ,.>57 .|1U" c^6; 1': 6 l; ,.rt'"Ji
L+f-l ;: .rl*j -tl> s -i t .-,it-..ltl" .tt-*J ;t s^{^. 4ilJi:-. jl j- r'
! ki J f+) slp e:t )rJ- fL.i oq? L lJ 4k*. arl ft,li,ri,* :, *-!o-st* c/)J c-tyV'€g oJ:*t >3>3e 'r^l-/ ir-r+.::lt$ f *rot!:r 3
\r,4;;t^a:il & .Sn r-*Stt L-i;,r.-l6t-aJLJ.;li,s;'li.;>
^5) qJ .,rl .tk, ,-i ,lf ..:*1 o.ui J^, t
Yr,6-rL',:il
aS s-ru* d.2-i dr-,-l y(tArll f$l t-ty ,)l-/-.r[--e.; #, q
c-rU-, F: ejl JJ, .;,1l 4i t,t-#.ti-,l5 oi * t.6.rat(*-ry.rr,c*; slrs-il )try :[:."lo! 1: ,r^("=" dlJa dtrj". jln cc.*l
r: lr ;-L co) e: oJ-.i 1*. qS 6lr, a):,.,-;lolL;: 'S JL4;' ;rlft r e ' J' :s.r v')r-.J,i rt (
.tLJ qS 6L-ac-; "ri:c.*lotj .>[.-]1 31;.,>l*? tl6T;t5't,t.jf jlcS-,[* -t>l: >f Jld*jlij oy -u-nly- ga jll; clG-, c^it.f) _fr s 6 l-..5 rr,..J"L.L j I
",-iU 6;\-a 4ja u t-,o,ts*.^ .J:-a: -j-9y
,;T-,15 gLa.r!+ L- .rLy" .. . .Il4i1$ G. )t )l-?;tL3} ,-r;ta*t>
;.=-; c.:y-: JJ:5 dr--lJj".:- YtS.t or^-c rlj1 6.li:t #; ".et* -.r."q 4i 3:; cWil;U s,-j" 6 6t(*, yl.'rjlo-r.-l
:ly JlL..r13-. -r-113;.r*l c>s-j' ,a;. c^-rGt *ii- or 6;J,lf-,'L^71
,-Jnl -)14;l+5 c^-l: --tj -,r J--q; lJ 4j<j;-lccli; "3)t-".trK.e) )l +5 o:y t3:1-cSt^u"[tu "5.r;l 6ta+.; :t * ]ty JJ4.*
L-/_re g;L-oc-*r=* i'U c.-; j oJ-"i >3a1! ;Q -il ,;JU dt^gpli
,-;; Lac.*[- .f-13 oJ-i;L:clg L^,-pli Jdl 5 s"K:a.+t-,-f ,-i;3tnry'
el..>l $li'a -* ,aV J..lr* r"qt-.r"
1. Temporary National Economic committee 2. Concentration of Economic Power
3. Final Report and Recommendation of the Temporary National Economic Committee (77'h
Cong., 1"'. sess.; Senate Document, No. 35 [1941]), p. 89.
4. C. Wilcox, Competition and Monopoly in American Industry (Temporary National
Economic Committee Monograph, No. 21 [1940]), p. 314.
WWW.AEL.AF
Ji - ol , I l 1r
63U o-t.tU*tKt f s2->jn b"l; es_: aloJolj-e u-yr,..5--: .::.,;..\-i 1V 6ly.JtJtrt^4-.il )\el oS.r5r^.c*lo,r*; ,rgL:",cc--l orr5 olal*l*." | >r;,Jt^JF rtrrs ,:J1jl c4_7;: c.Jy: 6;L-,;r+: iir-g yl ;r 3l:.-l-liu f ,=" Cf ^5
-r-.iq dl, _+ *lig.:;lJ
6UV';l 't.:-r y crlir J;t ii r, 6 ;-rU C; t) 6; azi Jl.,.|.A)cr-o Jlrp Jf'U :1r"i4* c,l^a)csr ,il*I l) ,J; Jk gl,a;_9-5;r
ll!)'t lyL A)Jl JJa-* L".r<jrJ* 6Gc-^er*1 d+j LaJTJ<l
.-ably.iS -,r L-! l.lil 6 )r€ :lV-"| o:s+ r,l 1.r c,rir-2 n6;1:a,Lr*Laoi,cii-;) .-\i:^*a J:tor.&. &*zr:slfb y-y*,.! jl aS ;Uy' ,rUU-,-;;",^-a UL^2rs r) J f^)jJ- i-p -i\JL.r- s> sL 3)216lyol:u ya5oLJi;: .j,_y t .*
Q . I6S_;uV,, d;j-t"UeLj-l
rJl.-ty;t pL;,li;r ,-S 6;$,3r ol3,-c a1 .rUT;t d^ -a ji :t 6 .*"lJcr) )J->..1.fu y-;c.r i*,t Jl{.-ilJi d1& dr+i./!- J ufLd.l
\
.-t-:.," >L .'r,-L:rL
9 o> *, .'rrL .)) ,*; ',-l pLo! 1r .9 u-lrli-rL:>l jljr" Jo +A t, +5'p-1J J 9-- t J s- \ '
v)r | .
,-#rf Jtfti.r"t(^ cor;4;U. co-L.-.lg c*!- +a;i ojl$l+1U +5;1
,L, ;:i ;t ,s-, &Fo-tre o\_F J \ qr \ JL u ou*JKt .: -^"-i3, a, a5
..1.o r) I r r -o9 .:-L^--.:*L- r. -i 5- i Utjj ., Ji ,r 4l; ^,;l!l9 - t J r L> J L-J - J - - -r. - \ "
jla5 ry,r-,-" i^t:-o J+ 6l*-11.-t,i q 3:U;i jlJL -ue W $f,p;r..ru^*l-(;l ,-a-e cJ-iry *f :l; c.1t"- c.e.] u+- [4.:r"\ tY . a-ar * ;r +5l+f y.c*lo.:y.r1G; ,6-&)ot i J^ J:" *-U
:lrJl Jy- 3 La:r^:-.: ,yJl f 4J,r*ti:.U 6L-oc*L- jl o.Li a-,
Jt* o-.: , +-6LaJL" * 1-: J!l.r-- Ll.ry,r" 6,; .r;Sur St-:1bta:.c*lori \ tY. +t.: )l t*. gs* c-JL, y Jti-*t c-:*;J \ qY q
0r3,, crk^JK;l 6>La:31c.*!-,.# JT C t J 6,lf .>'-V- \ "ry 4;a- 1;oL-JK;l c.';+ J drt-,-,'!lil 6;*:z oef U LaJt-,a;lrit 5
a*l.r--t.i,.li+l c-*l a;jly .rtr ! 4*"1- 5 4rL oyK J : 6-t-
;r-l p ,, df o-t_r- 6:_St* 6tac-^rr-"1" ! JF;1a5 JY.u-l
.rLJi1r.rjJL.rf ..rijrr* t1\o-ssse 6..*ly o.ry -tLi;l-l) o-ry)
JL.rli ;U-Ktlr \ lY, 4-a) J) c\A1. j \AA. 1gLaa-ar * tt,L- jl# +! Qql +5 c--=; tl3-3,15t-crl Ul )l ;ajlF rL;.-t;10.t--i
jl ;4:rJj?--------------, ,# .li or.; 45 lil ,-S e -l \ e;,g.:l;i 6trtl .lL
!c*lory JJ. r{L d.t-j
J !-lG, --,i; dS -.-b e"l ,>-#e b_yy.tU*lK;t al a.5 Ltoi U
gtjJ-> U -uiliir-" cJ5.r-. c---j ;U- gll.r-":r- tl"b-e tac*!-g a:iJ.>yJ.e (S-& oYy,-; jl**"a c-L ft; cJ--lL a:..11; *-;>6 t-J JY.r:-l ;r;a dl3ia rss,?-ljl.c*1orr5 c.*J At at
l. Reinhold Niebuhr, Moral Man and Immoral Society (1932).
WWW.AEL.AF
j:rr ol; U \?
,tF rJ! 45 c-+> U-l €* tr;q n\lf )14-;1,r-a.rot ;L,k :6:F e dls +t l; r,Ll.c.*l 4riL -t-.i; ob,r^ g=. y l1 c1G,
p.koUi ;.* cc^ir.1 U-l rS_&lr.:-^^,., y 6 :_*eJt-(.ii,r,t<:ac*1... 4,r"Ll_e e,.G: ?_f r ta.-rit, 6 c.*r,lr dli..J F e*o1 oi;t ,JJI:SI 45 GJti 4J c^^J.- c*{- J) 6 :y, a-r-.i ,gysanVr, ,g>l_11
| -* | ss cS f rtL-r.7 1: .4f pt+,l op., rU- rr.gl;a,"Uy r ,sl j;,cjl dS .,lJ" ff t-rt.x^^ 3 La;UT,..r*i 6t_:u|t"y"tS *"t- 6e-t*bp U;Jb 43 J:l&;.r! t, l: 6-*'$_r^o ,,s;:Su, €a_.i t6,)iJJ"t- c.-4i 6# *..rjtorr-S gy;r clL:_lra ,L^;Ui.;-e t : ,"a:rr;crL.r7;.r +5 c*lc,-4i Al )l Aj-t\a-;l6ily;: cx.J,,K JL rb:,r
.c-+ ,j,U.akrl;* d ft :at ,j-t<;;tU.f L..7 | \ 6 ;s au. r, ccly,r".-r(,jrJy5; .St^c^.1.t 6 tr.: I ;, !
)Ja, )*,;-l c.*l;(-".rr5 .i i _&, ;l."-S q.rly.f c;jL,r,crJ-_J?.:>\(..:*" fu_7' ,.L.-oL L1tt-r- p dl*oj JJ:"r, o5 r_#.rr5
"!U" -iy :* c, t-^diU olie ef -r cSt-:bitq !;; "S
:_*eG:l +5 t*ai J -r* -. a-i .r:,-, y - c,*l c.4J) _rl .i" jl "*l _r
jlrs1L^t rili.,4j ctU_r 6 c.*l c-i*.(-..*lcJ[".t13.-" q.:F.ff: .:>K..:- jlg-,t*r -uiL.-6 a5 l_2
\r.11.r, -5r$.i-_,f .yU .:>\(":,
,.,1,--.r-"irS ,* -.x_t-r-t;U .,;ti t ;6)r-L.; o:y e(1ri jl a5
a,r^i o5 J:4 Jt--- dl.r+ 3 rra-,u-Jlpt-c rr,l,r "[t*
il,_]t- t"l.J:5jl1Ur c--$-J),rJY,u*l blj:.o a- d_r-L" d.Loj ,J4,jlaS l;.g:lr-ilc*l;,1-tx.Ss":ta:^:^n t"oT+;iLr r J.JS6" 4-tl Af -r tSlLbVl./L-lrcr.lLr-it}"S.r.ii; jf r":--- .r-td S--tbl-i u-;-r p.rr 6,j--! c.:.i .:yU l^ss )r)* 1: ,rcL^:-l .:!- f+lf € -516 S,.f
.r3.i.rn:,.lLl- Ja;-, F,, 6 jl 1e"l pLj
.gl.t7 .c.* I _2 13*l c-rG1 rr(t"," j I,J.6 .,*{.r+.f Ll ; JY.r:-l 3rl
l. modern town
WWW.AEL.AF
1V a 67 .et(l ts;t{uoL:'r-l
r.J:ti:!*r 6*,cc-l,-*[:,0 o,L"b*i \li d:ll-k.:: 6JJ-lil
;t"4 ,t;:; J-l-t y,.rL{"i a- l1 c-[i1 +5 c'*ldJJ,. Llly' c^'*i Jts-llS
6r.so,-,U, l+ Jr:5 o-r!-r: 6l6l-it d.rjL.f J-r". "r(^t-"^
6>|t r.)L* t+ t e;3 r.,o +5 >3r o;t* Jt-," J.,.l-*l3 c-i'l.r,r^l :3'73
45,r"t<:a L+J.J:5 .f)J.li-,t5 t-r l-, t+r- .rl--!19 fl.j c*jli.,^, t"+, ot5-r.-, &-.tr,1yi cr) tu 6 Jj-# JL"^fs, ..rL7 aaf ,-[U ,J,tf()
.r--.J ,e J-FU e-lt)f * e5 c*l ,>-tt' yl;r.,-:rJ dr'fu'U t"oi;t
-ujg.Ji-,,rfuL^,r, al"t*. .:*l 6)J-P ,J-\;-* +5.r;t-j cLl
.,,l#l-9 a1 l1 clt :"-Loc!Li 1,; r;1j5,r" .:lji lJ .<;:" cSl.l:t+ 5 ,51,r("t","
jl lJ stLi:, J.l-*; .51 ??, r/J-i 45 J5 J"J--i Ji:il:,rn l^,ji -U,a, 6
6t1p abjF-,; dS J+Jt ^.J:5.," a,oli clt--:aa i ,:-r,5Laa'Uy
y, Ly.-t .>lb)\, ft.; 4jt6t<i rli,r.i .rSe 6 #, ;,,1 a, c.*1 o-t.x
'iL c--,; 7 *J -.r(^U^^cJ:S <;-aL,o l.,1 :lilJL"*:.,, et^.-'r;Ja (_J J r\
)p -pq 6 r;I../;l;;Q-; jl .!; o<L: ,;,r-*;lrJ \r,+;t-"t3iJr5l
c*l;3.--.:k a.a; ti ri! a:-il.:;t-=l-r: 4! 6 $t-J.," lJ iteyllcrq-fcol ai t+.lirtJ .r:5 J"rJ i-,5 :* a' \ blfl: sLra^4j 4r
f g -;lS- o);^o-., +)y JQW \l; -/. -;y'qL: .rlr=..'i
a-, J-lJ f -r &- L-r: tli.*"A.r U-,r-# A:rt-i >t"S ltr;;t 6.:*1,r{.tK:-: uey o-lpt) q-io3"i
'}.::e J C:- .-,it5 oilJl
f;tx r r-s L; l-t t9p6Lar5 L.4y el-,-:lp!.j -t6tr s*..ur!,Sr-p .:L$a.rj +",o,51;al; Jt-JL," ; s,9 t-oo I dt^J"q
gte;l ,r1tj, \l-J c--"; c-""c ,'t^..1 a5 c.*1g;;.11.'"'Ui'r ylll.li;;; o-v3 .r:> e-&t f+ 6-a o5 t>*l 61>tlL.a v f,.fdl..iW d-2..7fi ca*rUe;;3:o.r3J:,,0 a;tn,*"j oS7 dLiW.'u:,r^jL; :jt-,r- -,rLi 1-, ot-Ly1t5 crstJ:4t,{ l-i >ju' f ,6 -r:-7 clL-r
,r-".6, 4j<j.J:5 "L&j:-ia
dL-L.-a dt^sJt- t c^* l; rlt-x6t-ar:^Jti
l. conscious control
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jt, J, n 1A
r^ly, J;zsb +i-Lj 4l,r1U1 ,:--.- 6 c*lcli.:;lr r,1-.3 t--ylyr 6.:lr; ! l_r rf 6.ri .t;SrJ i ;l ,;*-d-:t f5t"- .>.G, Jtk; ,-5y )-#€ rok*" f r-ri:a .J^5 Jjs lr La.ri-tilij J o)-5 d;k" c-+Lrl.-ic;t, 6 f -rl ;r*$:lilo!.,ilr ."r;,rio, L.jl$loL.^s b-t.:t-c)\llcJL;:;l,5tt 6e;; _* :Si*.i" &"rt ;ldU.(d,
.t_*e K^t*^ .-+ fr-- fU _,, l, 611.7!*"- ol-".;'c-c ,:-"=- $5 6\.U ;l e-&45 c-j yigt;lc6)A(t-*jtoa-,r oi a' $;ac,,*,:3, o.rrS tS;lclatfl6y, gtLbtt;r1l! +--Li" 1t.g,-Jyt.,*, c*l0:r5 JJ4- a56rj,;t!;l S J47O.r,;l.S;j> *(-U^" a.il^,rl c, ,-*l:)f :; ol.*y q 6rL^$l dL J,- ,i_r,_& )ll4t-r:,lr,irL5U C-fu )) y ef -r s.ilr^ jrr ojl.r.;toL^ ql; d1-t-",J.Loj 45 c*l o,I*; 6b\ tt5 g,*a eSyl .c.*l r9J>.." a:rlr
a.ll o-\-l-j rlnta.;tatKid a*-^ d;gJ, c..-*il3 alq L l1 :jt-,r,;K.-"6Lac..:3.t--." )l Jl; JtS f...jj diu"LlJ" oS o>;ji 4y;j:t q,-rL;t,oi J .tvra,i+ J*:,r t _$,*,.-*l_lQ .c.* l a:iL,-) ;3 os,.X 6 1; a,V
re.
jlr-f# j1, lt .XlcJ5,r-" l9)Jre l: Sf -f i:u;-tr 6;.,,1j1,gl-q4il.^t<iJr5 a- a-S g.5 o-rLi:*,l.rJ.j<J _jl{q U 6 ra:,r,..rL:; +:-.,"
.;t-iLi a:*13
si_r:+. ! l; .rl;t-e-*-;lJ*:J dS r-r1r .:_9,-,-3 S&t a--rL: dia,ti,,ilt;. L ru S J:S,r, o.:Li:-l .et^JY-rr-t )l _s "r -S I y &) _) -r*r3J,r-; d! -rU-: ,* t e^lo|5 J+J^ ic.*L 4t-y";;y* JY-r:-ll1 ctli; rJ;J, .(5j 6 c,-;...ri JY.r:^"t .c.-..1 a:-.ll.r i C;""^\,,;jlcS-,L*t jlorLi:-*lai c*l.r+lJY,r:*t ,o^{et c+5! .r5.r_" :3,U
&6,,, c--1.- Lt Ji ;- :3r .i,olr; dF.U J,"J- .r<Jr;* .:UfK"lLrl Jl.rr*f @,*l .t;-.J,fu Jt4;1,.r-:,: c.::-.i ,_*"-.aj c.G;
:ly+:.t--iL a:i[r -r,,t-.i ri:, oJ\:.Jl_j.- 45 4ilJL.A cc,,,. ^i +jl;t-(lc:
--+L;l-., t-,5L,oa:*lr-- or_tsi-tt5lr .r-:-rt.(;* ,K" -Sl aS - 6is:
WWW.AEL.AF
11 l-1, < :,uLi -, c .I[.]uL::>lvJ-u J, v)- . 1 .
'-l 45 L , (.> 'l d 4-!L --;-L c-ti ' LLi,o ,: ---1,L r:Li J-L r,,.:*l
v- Jv JJ \'- 'u
-.G-* r:;l;* jld-,L-.f J) J,-)ic, -.La;"r+l ft, S.r. o:tjlJ!.r:-l
Jriq,j- .r--"J,e *f :6 t go,Ui J7l h- y r."Ul"prl Jl s1-* .JlJs
Lfr4J *i A-hfijl ,r.(r<J e-tt o* Jft'i t,, :-'lu^:-r .ti rr
.c.*lf 4 fl:" I 4*"t -b :t dry i-,3lt" J q-b)-*t dp'+-JJY-r:-lt-^,ti;r 6 J-it"s"c/! r;ly" )1,€^J; ,l"l
.t+! Ul:"-t LSr)f cs:-e 5 c*l 5r, .JrU #l.t.- dU" r,rl_2-o a, .r;1.>
.rYL-I1: o)Li:-l.r;y,,6;G"[-_r,1jl ,+ j ]bl)j lJ J:"]l-t-iL;rGL-,r5 orLi:-l&.-_lt L, .(" il,)t:J<l -), ,-# -f ft S Gso ol,=:n
)G \&*JA:jl;,JljJl *li't r,?l;, u.a ,51; cr; ;1 o.:tc-l +5yl
,6>:l-f "r-?:r
.-t5 o.:tL.,1 O,t )l L A c*jli d F -* ft *\,.,rl-ju.il;:-.:l.r o:f -l) y oS -*.C * (J c*l;(^"('*lc-*rc.t:Ss"i ./B-il o-{*^ cSrl d 5.f"1 Ll - a-,or 6 t l -t -1,-J+,-^:,-py
!;6 t*) .rljrl Jaril 4 jl u a-.,o -!L ! a5 c.*l Gz i *uli ifr,J/Yt-.: .-+ & .i- ! t^;.a
d,ril dt " .*"! 6,-.*1 t" g15 .rtl-l (ct;o.rl.: r;9-. y)-,-a t: ;r{lLi6
";b,r^; i/.f",t, d--:b -rkjl 4r^.Sl;
.gyl-r;l.UL-l L c*l ,iK"" o-5 c^r;!, J."q irl .+; ! c*l 6* oJ'.l'
ry-ry t-o:* ) rf tr.r c.r*o a+-rr.i- Al:s U )l6;-b t-gtlalcllr-g o.t-::S-i ,,eu .-'l-*;'l c.-.r3.t-*-" U +t".illl .,it5 JU.i," jl j+iL*;l45 t-S o:t* J,"J- d;rl &-6-t-t +5 c*l.f;r
"[U '?.rycs-,L*l );) tu 6;3,,i orLc-l(J.;t"j kJ 6;1Ll J-xt ljc;:" J,-)ris, ,JT
.ts3,.1. Lacll a..-a t" p:r* ;t
r-u--iLi ti r:.iU slrs-o J.,Stl:\rt(;U c-=.,41 )l 6:sl3e;;-- ol3.-
s<j<J.:rr^:"i.:3-i, L-crl U* ,* y^5,u:4 6tsl-f't-:..f" Uoi
c^r" .(.- JJe-;,"..,i;-lli!r.e t-"oi..:;L C lfUl: Af -r cr-yrr
,L* ss.Q - t;,li,lr;yi .' -"', a- a-i -tS.r-. 6syf 1r lt*?l )l OoVc^i-":?, a'*,i o5 ot3,tT.r;lr 6;.aL; c.*.,t1 ,l^j.:1,9ic.*) o c:113-o
WWW.AEL.AF
Sttt-tD \"
dt-Ac-*iJ'" g;a )t 6 c*lc*;).-r-iL o.r."i;E.r)\(:" J #Jjl (Ul - ,*is l,r-i ,1L.5:l-,1T c-{ olyc a, l-,2 ;(, irg *,;,t.i- +! t"
l):- +5 Fl: +1 .-r-j6L,o 4,'4tJr $tL a:a.lj t>y'e )l rrKt 6j-6Lac-; ;":a,t.:r5l-r.i L U f-s..f ./ti+l$;1.:;k;l;r rt_y;Sla-o
J) +r^ .f5.f L; * t,. s.ir^:=,, dll f^ b ; )>-,,;5.-" .glQc-*l;-(" ,*,jlr* i/tj-il 6:l;i j p:; ,gly+! a5,r:..i r.:.r,.ti3S
-,LnlF a*els U:i J-tl4-.16)t, cr,.k,r:- e-u.r:J,;r c.l.-iL Y!.*K;ar .r.:;31a,^lr-r -:Lj Jt<-.i1 cS f^5 *""-.l fdli r"j f -*U ,s34 ts3,.
6rbi L;- 6 t-5l.crlitl3;.r^;r,dJl.+q +r-,/ c*,1;(-" c--"r- ! Ysr^lJ, ,.itr! r;l;r a-.-a;r t-. gyJ 6rL oU; t rJr3jil 6-tlJb eQ y6.rLe:il t),1 61r-. J--q U a5 c*l.tT"U;, 6>l;i 6l1.JY.l-tLl.c-*Ll:.r;1, ,sL*; ,,-cl-rt*r .g:[4 ./! l-, p;Y "6t+ A.r.fu,"[,u -; :r1i
l; .4Lac-;t+; tlal d.:;l-rj 6.:,1_rl,5 Lyy C_l -&t ,K,ti,t, ;;.*i6.lful3..:*lJ<-" rfG t:_r "(.;: q-Slc$.r-
a,oly.JrjLi
oljlrl,ri35 Co.,1:
;1:131; L" e5 c*1, jlCJti 6k G-S 6 tFe upr*,g3^, a.,V
c+;) J+f c*Jl.g5 o.:t-*,1 nV uis:4 q ay ,:.:b jlU S.fq5 c*l 6-LJ )k+ rrl cJ-a:.r," ,j-SJ.:;.ri L a, .:t-olr:;l 6 c.*l
jlJidlrLi.A +q d L)-\Oi f"^lJ;=.i fl S c*,t>"ol.r, yl,t"l.trs
o-5 .Jt- ,, .d! oi 5j.g1t51-ri .rLT.l-L J f*L*; .s_,lL[, ,ti rt +:-.ac^s 4J lJ U 45 r;lri r3,--3.UL,FjIJK .ir&
-t> 6k 6?.:Lt-c-" (+);) 6tLu\tg_r,Li cJ-a: gl_ry.5r1, tl yV Sl_suVS
.r-,L.f -;SV -b.:"-k ..e lJ,ii a5 r;l; :_,,79 6tsbil.tS_* l.* f a5 c.*ib .t--;; cll3j,r- tJ 6 Jf _,, cdLr.,Io))t' 5* c6;,ly l:*l ol-1"$lEl"iil t" 6r-,; uZS kf tSlLuEt
WWW.AEL.AF
\.\ n, < i,*"li .,< .J"UuL:-l
-u..*Xj1l"Jt-.idr,-lJ) d-:t<s..t:5 4F dU, lJ t a5 r;l-r.i tFs ,?:V++-r 5.lr r) J--! ,r*<J Jt*t-iJls )l J:t c*; ;; 1; 6 c*lJ, € e-+lJ 4 !"Ur*, .J--{ dr,-l J...i .-tj;r- c^iL-oI;;+"lJJ dY!.li3 -r*U n:-il: ;-ai -rr rr! 4.Lca cltj.;a-"Li,, dU-.a:. 6 c*l-tLi;la;LaJT.,r,-ltt .<,-f L-r- +5 r;1; :3'--3 o;t ;--l;r,r5.i,l t'-^-=., :6yl> $ o;^'.r.r-.ti3S'b*i,)t"j .(" ;: c*llyi,r" \, bLe-a;;",r<i<Jg;:3J;..ot] JL.*:, .J*:,U c-+Ljl y e-C "(.5 c-<-r 1r [a,tl.t, g\c-*> fl.r<-" J ? P..:t-"Jldl, ,-llr Jr+ a-*a L 6 :;l: ) _trJ F :_fl )l-:3J-r-" dl; 6 ilj+l gJ! tl:.!,,1 r+l:r..ri c5 -Lu*a 61j'l\l cJi.:--A
-.,[*r k, pJ! rlr-q+l r*l-r,.r" d..el ! gr:i *, y b\"Js; J* -,t-1,: -i +ts i ,: ^ :l-:o , <La, < il o ,d -[SLl .- ' ci -e c*l er IrtSU
a) J -JJ l) vrJJa .(J t'{Je Q
;l;,..i t-.J5 3 t * ) e? +! et)J [,t- r: E -tS.r" ;lrly 1; yl 6 c*ll'. J (J l) JJ J.J \ Q.
&K*. f^ J./3It,,f^ r,;* -r,-! +S,rJy a, o-ui,1$51y JJ,l +5 frilJUj dt"^;r .l'ilj.r^; ,--a t-a;tS yl6yl.JJt '.. ;iq o.1;;pt-!l .u---a
,-r,-T.f cd) tu :_fl lV.Sl-r; .Jk a, t3J L^.ti jt 6f +5;,1 .r3,-f pt+.t
rl-5 lr 'n-tJ uo*-; Ap p "S t-yj o-Lnt-i-o *ty }tJ q J.iliLt
4arA-c*lr,-r-i; &U c^i:-, .JF u,iX- 4*: t \i e:;l-Ku,4ilri-, J:6 -,, U J5.,- .<."r.";lJ [" r.:U a;.11: :la: G*, c-i.:,,-#g orlr gry*, c.rl"l L _,t5,Jl^_lrl ilcS_,L* a5 d* )--"l )l6lg:3.tSu'"[-r,u -r:*n V,S:,p CU" rt CrV 6 G\&t ]6 -,, lr taJTJ
*\fr^sU prot-^ a1
gysuVt 4*"t? .d y) i*l fu,t5. _b -,r:r.c, .l; t_rl fldl+Jl ! o-5 -r5,_f .:lq=,-l d;-Ja"Vt Slt ;U"t- ..cl ;r {i c*) 4r or.i
6la-uV;,i+ ! ,.a|- -i.ta $):l >-tf ;: 1; clLir,-:y -u.alr;;:[ic..rt- $lJr.iJi; *-:rjg t",rirt €t i:ls*lJ.r:5 lill j 6Sc.aauel; r:3, jlri..t lJ -il.r-^l ;;"k L o.s-X612aniy e^"t-7 ,51rrr;q
1. Specialism
WWW.AEL.AF
6rr tt a \'Y
elf ,-!1.:L.e-" 45 ,*5;tSllc*l 4jE.>1.-llr,r. \ ,;V Jt-- rr1: 11,_aL-n,5J3--iJJ -*tid L 6 o.ui.gy;uUy+*j U o-r*l,5y;a,Li,,
! y"LS t^JJ5;*lfrr, 6 e-#-r1,lcJ-ar Jlri t, JL l;: J--19 r.rT
tJQl y,-rLJi ;.r J i f LrGo:t-- .Jb .St^ "- .-t:a)r/ c.*i sg;,;a.,Ur,
)l ey t^.li.r-Ara-J::5.,-.,[ii:*[cte5.r::*a _,f b::y, orr*a.J-tt !S.*. -tll. :* t Jl; 4*"t .(1;r 6 .t-:.ar,r.j aslll\ ,g7sa,"Lr;
151--aq"j;r.rK5; ,Stt :l ul5tl-a.";; c-*l4jLi.",-l )r' ljb *l,l
# J-A gtsutt d j*e eit 6\,- gtaly:, bl3:.c e-.|_t gGb-l; jl erti.6-r--*K.;* tsty. ,_r:< e_& 6 ry rat3.- r;c.*;rJLJI.JLr.5L-ao.rt--;: +5,rJra.c.*l 5U" ..:,JJ, ,J* oU< L€r*4it- OU*JKI;r p:rr 6:!r.jl;.5 l, .!ol; )lJ;.. J c-*l oJJl; j-iL.rS,uil e-7y". c.l:.:*i ), t' 6Le -rl.ial nS +.;i [i c6 r;l-r.i .5*-r; c.*1
6,er a1 rtly;+"1;y a5 :3f .tt?JT r-ry, .rl U-i aS;*t .c-*-ilr .:3*y l-aoi.gly
.-Jl-.,Ll.\c-*l eA, Lf y -vtf ,**' torSr 6t- a, r,L^&;,r
.r;t.r r3>. j oi1,l6tlx) J c4L> 9911.;$.tl4;lr.x., cL 6La:11-r.jb-l
+y t l;n o;.i1g1;a"V1d-Q .(,. i 6s 6 o+.e;;, e;r adl
d3l .tK; p\ tru,o.,oA*, f94;.-..rclLu; ,l ,S .-^f- p-e, -il.r,al *.11 ,g;:)a
,JU,rili e\W -r &Xr tr cStLry *JL q-a.c.*l 6;-Slt,*-*,'Gr* G 6p;j cEta.rj-,I + ..5 f*s.r. ,n +*a , .d*^ oad;r-t-oU:, 11 blfl: c6)/.ic rlr.il itt"" ;r .rl;i t'-,--, .<, ;: +(L c*1; 6d;jl.,+ S ,pl*r.,-l:^*-6 c-?-t: d;LA(J*jJlL 6Lajj;1 d f5.r)l J*V.SG.yUJr y ry' L; -# uf p r3--j Jal3,-,r" +",o
lJ LA4*15 +-.a +5 g ,..1 .r:.),* 3 c.--:l.ra, ;1:13,-a .oJ) d,;l oi c^r:*a
-t--t ,r*,l,t.61 p gq-.l_l,JL^4s n5,_Jt-;: -t-a1_j,-,_r" .iU!j J ,-r-i,-:,t-3,L.311 G:_#,5t-ao;t-a +sa rJl) i:i 6 L5lo-u.jl; !,-rj_,.l 6jLJ!
2. specialist
.c-l oJ..lt, .y'- ,tUi 61..:Q ;l d;li- ;6 o5 J zrv; -r"L Ll .1r (--
WWW.AEL.AF
\ 'f J 6;,y-ly g;rp4t,oL:al
dr c*i U -t-alr;.r- lJ JJi-,l;t<" J rs# F[- 45.rlJS 6s:fi-r-- Li lt,JA"-. ollc,.:-a r^lf.f c---e;,J au3,, ,5ly.eS *:-!i-t"t-L^lF 6i:v 6r.sasu-t ! L+, L^.ti;r^ 6 .ujl.:,rr ++a cJ:S L;- j<^..jt-jtl ."!1 cLl ..u-alr--,r-.
"pr oL*^ a-t\ 5:,:-:+t'} €*tnoi3 --r;
l1 oLl-ilral Jt-" ol-4:,' ))f J. Lgs -r:^*a .rc,r" La.li 6 ._rcL*7l 6Js4,VJ.
...r5"r";t(iiaS c.*l d3a-t" c1ni13;,-l a,"l:r.," l_, ,f GF \>' \SJ)4aU/ !r:i-.--^'l-"p cc-l 6jlyyJ+ .<{ ; r:^'U-Ut 6ysa-Vya5 JL- ;:4-+J .<.- a. l1 oLiJ-r-;j .5 ;Uj :,-rl:, ..^ .
t,j-^i.(; .gtac*!i4l
cg-ts+-,Lrt +, La.li,.51l3.L-t ct-l .J-s.,- J-:" lt c!lo:l: ual-a:;l L-13
:V-. G-S J4V"V:; "<! c--? a*"ta o,;Lrr JUi et? ,i-S; J*Vb|ji 6y, ;t "t-Xab -it.r-olc-."^aloyLlr r.il3 ol;lA+i:$ly:3-lar.:lji a*"1-- .(,-;r l"a,tL*il 7i .tt 3 2;.5lfJ"e g)):l o;13i;;-L ;1 .c-1
oL-a:-i,O e--eL l-l ;S;tA1.\ G?-; J* oS c--...i crL.:j,-.r*:L
e- ca.r-ilr ollal .>1j-,".1r c-Li;l.r lt +*"1+ GySbVt,JL+i^ 45 .,Jt.5,SlirS,ust-Ut .# 1Jr,>l: j--j".:{;-L*j
'l1U r+ j- 3"t:SU};.<-i U,rjnA;.(-; J t),L;) c**"li-qt .i- jlcsf Ll.;r:rJ J4 -otfi,a- 6 c-l p6U 6l f ua-e;;.gry;-=t, o.- ft .c-*t ft< ...(1 Qt; i.lr.i 3;tui
,J-"-, ,F.G * 3Q?.r:-ti t tJ-ar,rr Sy S:i tstsblt6lyVlLL!) r^; tSl*-^e*' ,J-JqJ.e, a5.:;1.: >3zjOi;t--;G)e -* S-.;; r,,r(^t a,r.IJ/ .ri. q JF,J-r{ >_r- g;t^Ji4l ui; 19} JA) ojt--l
ntJ"e+;;.<+ -Uli,r; c-t::S,-r- ;3+: ol;saaLt )l rf t 6Ot"Oi
,Slrr ftY ,Fl.: r5.r- L-erl ai c-*1 .rJ ,r-r,-iol:;La:il ..t-i! -r--.r-
13,,b(-r.(" q jt"J d3-\, ceS ,>-.1uls,s ell sl6VW..:;1.: l; "J:.s<:^t^^g;LAJrs.:;61:- *."Grit;rl Ll ..:;lj(.r" /.rfut*a 6< J.Jl:;;+-a,-tiL aU-*;;. a--a e5 c*l.gri.rt^.,.i)\: Jr;*.UfuU J 6e;; *
..[;lr 5t-(Lal
[. single-minded idealists
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
0 **#wx**;**JC*a. l; u.et*;:lr-!1 -t5 .f)t .t-! e5 gg:rJ3rr
osf tS \l_s:rUlrqLr ti rar c^g?dJ,^.;
L*y,l-t,s:st* -* *l: ,;):y ^<9 &e'oS r:L;.f ,f j\ gzy 6\c.t5,-r" .-i Ja*
^-"-a,) q-r--iL :L".:gl) ru rtl- q 1,.-i ^-a ;c_- , - . Jt e J rr (L- e.
); ,rS.rl:-r ;,: "5 -u..iq; .SU,Ja, )Jijit-j5.jl!l ar 3 o:r5 n--*,,Srrnu
^-S ;-r(-.
.orJ-.,;*; or "rt[5
! t-, .rr-rc4-l gbT
a.1 .r1k .51 ;: .lly,r" b lf C-?-.gtta:.-.- p[; .$; AGJ ]:drr* ,-fL^:?l -i.r-a .i- 61; a-'-"t- Jlf )l-5:ljT,r-a:6t";t- .ll-2-c
a-,-L- o5Cr,-1.c*1,-^;l-i ;Lj,-gLac-!V- *./q 6 :tS -;,.at:o5if-13 r:*l.r--13;J-a G-* l r;t^t{i 65.>g;..7.tiU 6 -r;Vc-a4 {r:.--,r, slr-ilcSL^!J-, -l Gcfyi l; .5la*"t--;r* 6tacJt-,
.{-l o.:y -*Jt"-r ;,r.a; &t e.l,l.Jf jl .-$1 " "ir"." .ua.:,r"
t l; L &-f,-t.:jL.l ds:l-t Jpl e-,-'.rka g-rtrt jlr,.lyl
U-b {i;l':jlr-,r.r drrr e)J Cf r gtPdrljii\U 4-t'i;
-r-:alr--.,., o5./.r- ,U ;tLS co.r-i> 3 f+U,f-***.5 ,6'-l; Cq
WWW.AEL.AF
5',r.Jt 3 \'P
r*A t^JT Lil ..rj;l.: .r-Ll o3Gj rl:ar )lj Oi c."$ J) l-, c-.t? .51^.,.)L
.fU y o*.t.7 f .rA),Jt,jL t }L"i s" u2l3, oj f;l; ti dtJJLij
6bl-j,r-a:oL;L- 3; 1.: i*:+*a ) L>l1j-r-a ;--l c--{> J.: Oi-t-:"L^..ti,+5;-l g)\5 ue)\- .Ji:^--^,rJt c .-elrnl .5t;b .:lril +5 c*l,rU:*"c5f-otrt* Jpi eU 6 +J- e.*15 .-et .:j: dU*" t (,1-:..:*a 013;c-*"1^;
,f..U.f Glf f.i--,y- .btJ q "3.T-r$.U.tt+ f * )j, b-- ;.glory;l5 a,
.r-ar..tL;t* Ji )l; +r +.-"t-r 5.rr.Sr:,i,, .jJa) L- n.rcL-7l ,lL;Tn
L-c,n*"3-.r oU;l ctr,rry-o-o ,;t,Sl3:.o 4-.t qrc4".o -r* *.1Jr"*" :_*,*
cl,-los J-.p olJ;64 f- rtj ,J"'1, ur+ .rF,_* qet rr,rr3,".c 6iL-rr
j oU; ..r-l;1-r.; G>,ilt>t"tS *r- cu-,oV "|-."
a+ ,glr. ,>V-)L-eloU; .-r>-:* ,:^5 L" _,rl'1 tL- "(" q k:; dli,rJ lr I ta,)A .r.:t*a-5 -:;l: grLj -,t-r6La-!.r,o *.;*4)-p 4 .>:t* J r;fJt fr,rr,_/5 t* -.dli.,J 1;oi.ry-:,r" c--ot_.:!J; jl6r3.u-"U Ly :,oQ L^jttl jl ,r+lr1 4L-J- ol;.c a,.t6:: d! or5 jlyl -r--13 --i-ra c(Op -* t4 -_S ,^tri;.: a5 b.-rjrt jl ..,L6 r eq tV,r--J ,_ta-"LJy .(..rtoUgtaclf .rLoj I cl.rl: c.aa 6ly...:;lr.r.,rl-- otKL-
;: u-cV +*-, oL.*ta-,U jlpl.tsr-a 45 f;5 ort ;.;!.l.1.r:-*U c,r--13
..fL*i rty, )t C; g.-a: c4, ,r;[5 _,-r; q +! +5 .r.i1l; ,i:_,ldl"i .<,-
4i.-i..x! et- y "[,t5.c.*1,-/kil
I s* tsu\td c-,Jt j cSL^.jfaJ c.*l j}il J/6 A},.V.i- ,f.: ca, aJ u1l & j&,ro-a:.rV 1jb
.t_*,C orl: :9i ooC "K-V 4;ri,1,>jlb,dt^,ijJl t*t a, ,-rT;:
61l,xi. ! jU e c*lcrl"iitj alr" (,rr)\rlJ$tS at,tj &_p1*b.l-* 6-r!-r: J-"'U .-.1:L; L .s;_eils )p ll1,bi rgli:""-U r;lr r,x)U
:* y,U 45 c^*rll;r_l.g;l-r_; .:rG "f,l5
gi*t.S \r)y? q,_/)[i1
JrtS-? e5.rrL^-71 ,L,.L) &- o_l-r: c-n-J;i. 6t-o,}JJl .,6-1 ,p3l.L,
)jt-,j.J :-.n-c." ! U -:*a./kjl Jt- yr cJ5,r, -t--d l: s"lrl -,t-;.jl
WWW.AEL.AF
\ 'V tr .r-'.f s,t J s-rs*lr.
a-j 3 rtJ.-; a; l- a^"t7;r .c*l ,rU l, ./Ul AV 6 *-f eV y S
./! -rr .5;i- 65j -3 -r*! grr tr.; a5:;l-r.J .l;rty o-rL..;,lJ).!)
45 t+JiUl..u-a: a-'*,:p l-, "r:.(1 -rr! -,6ot ciUc^.^ry 3;;.r 6;,1
.L>13 c"Uy 4.fLl; y Jl:.".l yV o:) co:Li;,1:;j,.6t-a;1;111[^;
;--q r,^-r--!:!;: rr.rcL^:7l,r J-fr J1.o1,J ,-/ *J :S *.:L pU.
c-t- f.^ly- -t> tS>l) t ,.tti: .rt t: .-r-! t^,sr5 F*, pLi 15t"-'ol;
.c*1 .-it(: _)l ,J.-. t" .,iYrl 4W 6ee., oylr ;) cc*l -'!L,.,i)\;l 4V *;,*1: t-i 5 4J'l- dr,l
o I +> ptJ-o , LJjj L ) s7.l a- U ,t.r..; -i..i,-, 5 "tu-i -5ir. .l-U .-rr5; UrJ \ (,
6 Al_*.r.r*1 or_9- olr-..4 cc*l .:-t-i.t-clri a: )3J>vo 6 olr.il "l^-cjl .J-;loJ*:, l,l_* : ,s eJ$ q c*l;b lJ t" 6r:':," (J;yrl 4Lu
:ft 6)Lj ai- l. o-t)ss.Jl^qJt.r .<i.<i 1r 3l +5.,4J.r1 dt*il Jt"J
LAc^Jl.i ft-3jl6 sS :o3r o-t-.l )3J>.-r 611"*i.,, oVP il s o:,:3
a-, o!"i)\il ,>-5,* e5;.: e;Jj +1 l: :;- elt-e::^.a jl .r3U:, dtt *.
alL :1.r.." l; :lil .l3J: :-t_f F s:F S.r,J ,-),-+ .31-4.:"-:y-t-*"
6-:La:il a-"t y .(1 3"a; 6ly aS u"j^c .li}jl .l"lU ,{ J3p.c*l.r56, d-S*""1"S t, &"lf d.,il -r'..l! Cl- .,i6lri a, J--13
.r;l.r-i r-e,--3 .,j}.-l 4\W ;r;7 aS,.:*l ;--l 6 elt 6yri a:9-
- -f c.t--l:r arLl, "<i ;.l 6:l-,":31 dt^dJt* .r"k; c.-l-t'a,Sl; r*$
,gl-.,, u-o');l oJ-eli .i -r GIF 45 J^: J,alJ, ,51L"-1'u' A6Fl C)rr, .olt * 5 *r er rlrj, .i-L z.^a gG)[itUlccr.; ,f: J,l5 Jir-45
-, C_- e .(:_-
dj 6Jl*, o?< ))JrJ) f)r-.:;lri rJl-3.lilr :r5 +q 4" SalV!oi;.: t-" aS ,5>li a-"ta trllj.r,L; .rl--tj a-J 9I;1.: u:9," ol);dL*A t 3:;l-Li ":-9.79 L^.ti);jr-o;) J,;; 6lr- .P-r r-s.f ,J":.:3'--y L^.rir )-f )) ;;:- o\b JliJ 6U 6-# +a"j j3"a co;lJl
..r;l-:
7j; S;: d;6 :g,;lJ; ;[:;1 y.: l1 t-ojjrljl ._]t5 .r"p a,1:3 kroj
WWW.AEL.AF
6tyJtP \'A
gtG: ./p) J, CU" ell6 JL;4;tartL;l ir3U:" 6l^j! :3$.,.U
J-fu" r*.+) -P 6lt,1"aJiit"i:l .(";" 1d.*" csy a;Wl t J;56.c*l J-lr; .))11bi 5ly )-p _p 5.rrl.r,ol U-i f d'; d./l &U" ;: .c*t*o t l5._t; tl;l .5t^jt; t^,)i t"i 6..c1 t- .:;b +7ei isry ,st^_,ll q t+I y-*-;1> ri tii 45 t-:*. C.rr-l +-f -.J-a)ura ,.l.-..l4 l; ;y.l crL-olro.a
+.:(.c*; f.6-l e ol.r:.a ra,; t" c--*r sL*15;,1.9.:t-a dt*" t .*pU)
oU=" 4 dJ{)JiJ).iuli L A )/ ra 6 c.*1.-r"Ll c.:rl3 irl f.6,dL^jlr, ;l 5.:3.t-- :ll'.,; ,>yr.c q ,rjly,-f t^L; , c.*l1l: t; 6r3.t--,,r"L.i oG_, t ! r-:L .t+ai)\-c tf 6-p 6L^jt.i *. df ..r-iL ,-ci13:3--
a-"a.gGjt"; )l &_f d:*i t<jJ c-r--lL a:--ib d>\r .r*L.:,,r" a5.grlril
..uiL a:^il: ); t, r'lis^\ *...lT.4: t+ dio.t-1,, al-|tt 4i*l! JS 6 c.-..1g;)t+ c-:rt3 6-.xt,--1-l _e u;; t>*l ol.i rtt ,l H t:ly -^Jil ;r 45 JJ,tit".a .s*l o-u.i
r.^l:+ Jt.-l! +! lS,_xlU-3 c*l Jrrrl )J,*)F:r! 6 c*;6 t-J'1.:,'L:; rt<;t ,y.6 * c^anily 0._l jct'r"l;lg-y' o*rJl ,r.i+ a5.t-nr,r-. L ! l_,..t1;;-l l4s t, 1r-a; o;.ri,gt-ac.,-)9J>er
t<i .f-,-,lcSL$-,!- lr.-l ryLsi1,) )J,> sp +-, l.,2 cuL' "!S
UUj!d .-ab;!*" - L^dT Jl ,s^-;. f^ di y r.iL :y'73* rlr.il elLril ;r .rili,r."4+j,it-ilJ ) j, _P rrl jl .,r-:*a -&-t<"! 1t(rt-U -J;1 r o3U:,'1.:-b.,jrrt U Jt:*l! jt+" --n" 4;l-ac"-.r3-t---" 'oL- i.l-t :lr.il 6 S-S gcGoj,j,',-rl t)._r-- ,l-, -&t t a^:,4j J J;5 ,SJ"g?,\ )f4;t-o.ll.^7; 9
.S1., .,*;L .:l--:t-oJ I -JL c-^-; J o)-H,Jt- .r*,-! ri --i l.r-al f"-.-"r<". ^5
t+oiU d..*1 q r3L cfl-r-nl.-at+:ylr ol_* *)-,e./HjqCe-r o-P-*+ qi c.*ldL.a,..r^iL
",ijLrl)-,tAlt *-! il6la.r:'f; '>*l
.sr../ J<,]; \ alf :SU- ';t*^" ,-&, o:V a, t-,rct -71 -il.r,al ,r-L*i, )\ .)_3 a,1l "!ll. coincidence
WWW.AEL.AF
\'1 tr-rr.f s"t sst-:bll
L--ei t^JLil,51y t^,ti:+, 6V6S1 -hV ". S et; *rlral Jrli
)3J>-r 6>:l_f +,.\ u,1-"-o ":-S;"+ Ul ..r;1j3,r" -,t5 I lt ,>Fr-/
r,rcL"-71 -!l.ulrr *i.syg;*t- t"oi;: 6rj 66d-6 6 $,sjl.r,al t-*rliljl 6-,! ,JL-a ':l';altre jl c--l g-,!, r3".i.r," o.r.r.U
or13irr.1: a5 ,r(J JW -,, t-^.li o, 6L-c*r ;: J;l> '|1L;
:lil 6 c-*1
J*", c,-^ij ;.r- .Ju-:U .("r: cJ5.r-o,.:*iU; rr..rtl""laa:-lr; ;;L6Jli 6F-.-il.r-al f l.l)-f a5 t-yg.rtA{--j a; )3J--o 5;:"
! d! :_/.r* ?_p rlil4tal -ila (6J:,3." -ilral yl.-Jil..r;rl:,-lirt -u,;tr;- JJ:; .-il-unlLgl; ,ilS=. :lr-il a5 'u:*a 6;1;1l a,E"
15.tj;l; r.Lj .it-cjt 6 P,F -,r :&lfrr" cc..i..i> -,: .I-y' -r:ro '(t,ll;'1 ,li.1.."-, q 5 lJq 6;1,1l a51, J-:ti tGJicr$ -r-r-^ r5r:5 ,-i..r.a
.c^iL. c*.: erlt V.-il-tal a,
cJ5.r- j)U.tf'-.fr:i" -i1.r"41r,-;; 12b:- *.rlil aS url<:^
-hG yLlJi45 cJ3> -lujt, dt^,Jt iL o, t-^.rl6t-o;l;ly --il.ulfr^"r."
t+i.rJ-.: 45.rt jt- racLll .t-*.Jg o.rlr c.-L3)e/ J-(.}.i -i.t-a;,1+5.lE g ,trf uo.f-;L oF -rr trua>.-i'tt 6 t .l*-tl o-.-€ JS,l;Vl z----,a -,1 ,'',-l .c.*1 olf, jl 4,-^ jl i-u*jJ$ l-Jl;" a; d3.:
L_- r e'
.J::.*-A JE.lt+. * oi-;lr^l.li;r a5 aly- i )-9J->-t r)f \d+*ao2l;.-il,r-al ,gss tlpl c.-)iU" olj* ol.-"y \ o)f ;1 ,5t-4.:"-r3.t*,
el_y y,J", fl-t-rl o?l-+ F 6-D l.^,ti oS;at JL":-t st>-r,-* del y, s -* -qtly .tt-.f ",:a[5,J^e ;;,;.1.r &l ?l l."l: I 3 r.e .t:* r1
d!*;r uJ""e '>,t-r-, L^JTJt"r! 5-f + 6 c---il; J-413> rg9 cJ-.1:
+5 c*.i.lr r-al9, )frJ i e-&t.+tly..r"i.rnl4 t).J n ols-, *Jl
.il.aq,j ol ot,-lt+ l rs*e^3l:3,, J:.alya JilJ* Jit.r^a, c--ri5l
ol[" q'\-p ,S,i =lLi 6J*., il. eJ3r .:;l: .J"-L; ,; r^ J+J! 6 fo!,
J-lJt :,g.3 cJ3: a,L!: otL:r -* ,Srtj g51.."0t(-qr c.-iL*, Pt' )tr-9.c.*.i1.:
WWW.AEL.AF
6,rt-,tr \\'
,.5 "5.(: <J[Jl3lr ,pli e:: flly,,-f t<; cJyr c-Jt*i c,-tra.gly
Ul.J-lU dl.: r:r.l .pli oJ r_r& atljf tu )3J>ar 4Sb1 j L2&
'pl-; ;rr4 Ji 6 a161r dtAojJ-- tri- J;5.:J3: 6 G,l<b Li,iu;
oiJL>=A;j 116:ljTc.*l1r*-, ,Sf t;c- o.r4-c 4i lJ rJlI )j-JJ-# rjJ>.rU :* yl: ,;ye jS 'o)f
f*1,1".rJ CU-L.:jt*d:+ 45 u,l36..*,Jli< rt;i.rt--ir3; f7.f )) l; :lil,J+.^ J f+,
"lS rt .;.*" c.*i jl r:5s- J-S t-,t o;l;l pL; .:Jy: rti;: aS c4j -c
o- f I . s, u, ; trJ 1L*J lc,-; l1 a:^,".- f .ri .5t^qjLi ; l ii r.r-5 ;3t-.1
-,Lii,.r5.r- Jr*:S t, CL^. jt 6*bel.r4 aL+, ^..l4r* cJ3:
3 1;. ,gl")l.t-l a- ,5.rt-a;il f*-" .Jjt""rll h A_s_, 1ta6rK Oa:;:,J15 bl3:,c a-..t1jiut:r tf J;S g2.i lJ k ""^'q"-l 6 ,_*rS
,* -.;i* r Sf -e,5Lne1,.r-i \ qYA Jt- &lrlJLJiJ.l a-5.rJt-
tF sv) t_ssi-*,&t-t"),rj, .r-i;, ir: 11",+ jlo:Ll-l..J*,Jt;ft*'!"r- d- * t* + c$:rS,r." J-5 tr(r*,r, Of .JUiJ-lJ; )J>-r 6)p *-r- .i- cr-,..J,::-.i,lr J;S c--; lJ c^L 6:l+$l.fL":-l.J,l tion y .t.i,! c.J3r :r(!.c jlJ-i:*r,Jl+ s,U-c,*r d c--.lt:
ls 6)p -il-lallL.; ),t"-e.r--!.t:S.f c^ilr^ 11 cJy; J* 6 rrt-ag*jtl
.-lar .i--l -l) Jr
ciilJ, &lr+1 aS | ,g;2a-V1.6r &. el-|_r: a5.r"LK-,"
c^.,rl3 1r a-5 a-allq + ol6_:st' .gt-aJ.t"1 oJ-aLi",l,-rJt.,.' 6tJ:5 &li o.lu-Xc-l,ta ,g>La:3llllj .<," e Ss *V p-:r"".c.-*j;|y'.: c-*"a
ua-- aS;-+ ;: .J-.X "r,olr* 6:" rtj 6t "tS a, 6 rllo.Jt-.-i J-cti:" ctr3
oU;r ctl3;r c,-J ,5lojly A+ )l cslsb\l *i,r-a :ri,r" e-5 g^-o: "-il.t ol 6, u;lJ dFrli,JlJ-i! t<:j 45 J*x J-61J; *"--i (GaJ_4e
a'. aS ,g_s6_91* 6ss Lii &li cr.:i^i>;r .s;l:,r.c d, ,q;1 \ 61so-Vr,.!.Elr L A 45 c*lg163rl* liUl ,*ie J* q t_*eory;l5
fL.i ,ii -* -. +5 .,.ijr *r-ra al't*" _t$_r'f o:y ;t5 a, eSr:; -ira
WWW.AEL.AF
\\\ tr -l
5M) q,(!14r[JO J U JVJ.J J.
J*:U JJ.-^.".r11;le;.ri 6 S.f )JJ 6,K^,tt- rlf J,"li t^sJt*
;t(*ii.r* .S &+ ueV u114 q 1-, r7c.- a"Uy .-!,gly L;Uj
..il,t+l Ss-t,-*li a!*y o-.: tStLb\tc-19lL" e_t: dli +5.t--i,tal_r;
.(- r p- e rC e ) p) -. , ,-El ri .i'U J J, -.i ,ll c--:L-- )) jJ tl-oi j- J .JVJJ\ J v J J- J- 9
g:-S 6 :y .r,al-e.- ;l oL a, r-!l.t-ol es-t el-r i4x. f yt 6tLu1to..r"-r Cli y Je-;A 6s-s 6A.ld3J- -u-.1,[ A*lK 6p rU e Lr
aS -l-lt. 6F \ J":' )t^.o c*l ;K.*. 6 ry J-al-9> dr,l 4+1i t-U"-:t
,ssid :rzs I e-r cStLbjla5rrl .c*13'-,r^, t-rtJJr ">t-t t^*1";
J Al; -l*nf -,l5 t 6 CV_r_r;16:U;;L-.x g931.;!ljj,rl;-: e5
.-*"+.r.i":S f*li..r*i ls.tr61sar!1fr*.- .(,-.,1: aSrrl 3 rl:+l 6-ss-t'
)-* J# d Pli Ji r' -s, glr.s 4s ,*5:3J>-r ,*-V: yl;o:tJ "sp a.. )^c r^ o5..rllU 95.:taql eli 6k -f r t fyrrft^-* &- J;t in* 4-{ aJ i: .,l.Alaa-r;-:," jl.r3,- o;j
.-u.Ss".(5 ,+ J *.cos)61sa-V1..! a;lrl a-,;1rl31r JL^I-iLJ;U- .5 -t-lt{ e> e J dlJ;,> "rl;lc*l;(*"S)Q o:-*;-l ;.r.ttK.qL*j oi y pr-* +i.U-6..-".qL.i.g:L.o:il fl+ +"1,,
.Qtrsj*.: e},sJ .,Jliu .c^--il.: r^l,; u.zV o-lr, -* -* t Gli ".gL^rU.-r*L.rtU c--e,|. J-fl; cc*l prr'- rf -*
"<- .-;i,t-il.-glrr
<<Talking Shops> dJ+-^a or31 .il.r, ,Jil ;l L,".tU :L,.rtf g.!1-5yr,..,tj;jl L^Jirtti y 6 eU: p[+;l 4J J,:*, L ;.rl.i +5 S_ye drlrr -r-L rs r) r*i pt-,Jl -)y e-t:*UJ; +5 .l-.iL tlS fl.J:+ Jlor..i
J ..J. J \
r3,-- .gt art-6j t" ,.Jl, .11-u";l5 - JLLiJS ! y ()_# 6tt.> l:*t* c*:
ol - t ?-,...*r o.r-.i 4rtj ,r \t.rif;ffj*L-/)Jel-t fl* cr-l+. oJur-l;,r;l;iL:r jl(Webbs);;3 cr-15-i dt j jl
:c.*1orr5 Chl e^a, yl,r<-Y )-*Jl,J;t.rrKu, \r,j1t5
l. Sidney and Beatrice Webb, Industrial Democracy ( I 897), p. 800 n
WWW.AEL.AF
6'rJtn \\Y
:l-r:i g;- ?"-yd c--1-T L*V..,,Utt otK:*, +5 c*l gilgtel*lrLi,.rj- c..J3.: cail3lr..r*L.i.f \*U"U oJ.=- J;li 1l,g:Ujt-.t
"<1i C-* uJ-. , Ll-?-;. e-.--, I a,] t; ,!.rL $l 3 6l*r;.rLl.rilUQ gS.f )p.c-;r, \oJ*.!o:l:
Jrr-U, o'.6j3;s;$# ,:.^=-
..,-J+" -*l ,-A..:-l o-t--! o)t6j 4:^^i.r, yl c*9 ,SS-t'6J:5.:Jy.r 4:*ir;lttia.rao )l 0*) J-^) L.6 Sg )yJ>.r +i-I: j 3s yl: dy.J-l+.,_rl4.rl!..li.9to1t* e_* Jj"el )l e.--r J .rt_t.(.: y,J+:ll: #s LrL-6c.,;.Li 6 t-3.t rJ- 4-.t l_, ,# J-f S.<-- Jfup c\s.) t;i:-t a- L-a.:;..t-i;--l 3 t.t-:S,r- t-E-cl cJyr .--t:r.gt rr:.;1o,)^- >1j-.r1+" y:.lLo:rl lb 6ltll ort-n:-l L cd;y ,*rlL. osf:* yi;loKu-U; t-i bjt; gc: Jj1,t _t o)rt' ;_$e _ttS
c*.1rr.i-U..rt-:".-10i 'Aui J o.r-: .r.,L o-,l..lJr tt1r_tlr i:-.5 Li ,S-*
+t31c>l.j.as e5 rl.t*jlJ3l.r-:" 6l-asis: !.lr-5 .,.-l!-_r t*-lj ;l.nrrf L1JJ; c.*l;l: l-,,.,lUr!
cJy, 4 6;l cl.rrSlt(:i c.a; d:l4Jti" gl*ll _rr ,ri-Y )-*Jt,C-b I : Jl3i- yl oy' :3.t,...,J.- .<* t-sy"r a,-y_r tt +! c^-J!-f.<*.J ,.11,1.' -!t."- q JES|o;3: .( _:: 6f sS.:J:, .51 qi,r+S:;ot:"-i u"j-"o.rLl;jl +n j 1r dn.Jt^-,q- C;lK 1[5 a, .gly clsrS
t.rt'1r, ./l;r.'t;t LSll:G-, ,* l1l;oi j -n.r1l: l;4J,r"t<:^ .l.AOUJt, I _* t, -r.lT_,[5 l& ..cl
"[Yr .51:, Ct' J r.
1. delegated legislation 2. Labour Govemment 3. Donoughmore Committee
"rL. .1 ,cJ J ed3. dlJlr*:-f- .n,r*Ll o.yG _.e ;L5 cS:,.:rr ,(H.J. Laski) ,j<-Y .s- .d .fr [ \ lYY] slr* 1:,r--l -5 :"t) VLs 4 -,1: .YW .re . \ lYY . \ . r."!-, (.1-.q .5r*) zr \
.r- e)^ -r:l .rrs errlrLao-r-l ;l si;:L^-r* J*\ t:*u:t,45 (Av a^;roi)r.-Jt-r 3ia.9tr...r*1. s;Jg.:.jt+l +1, -sd:L. -rtf :":6:3;y jL iJf<-:TfG q Goidl, t-.; j:rKu" J:sl: rl:-s.gtau-,1.tirr.^-J!-r cJ3:14.;a.i:ral l,;:ls +i".<:1l.,rr,-iL lt Js*..r_r:-:j,*l .{->{5 J;*}r t.(Srl G)l-Sb),V JL.t J15 r5 :-2b rts4-Eit*. ?? )l Gf -rl5 -J3: ,r;1),J .gLr,=*a; u^J o jUlt1 -J3.:a5 .g;j,t4La !(r: rAlt-; ,j* ,*-,b ;: , - -(.; pLill r 6:l: l;l- I oi 6;Lg i3 J:J,!*jirrl Jjliui 4j<j;11 .9_23i:! i.16) J-t* ,s--t\t {:-.5 JlJ.jl !,Fy )raJ)i
.:t1 al ;ttf €ty ;t.,d CJ'* e a;.S 4r ,;' ;-\ )r*3rr 45 r:L.
WWW.AEL.AF
\\f ou-tf y:23;;+"lt
4j t-t .c.*l c.*.-ol 1-V c,sSu" -t .S*.g:L,a:il )JA J+a;i o1l.:1 e, ;lJil;: r;a4l .:L;jLi -,r 4-+ c*ljLJlU gl^rk, t> +j J q5rr.i o15-qL-;r
.-pli t+r^ 5 r3.i,r* {-l-r t^.ti;t.rr;,r" aJrL t-".lit 5 c.*1 ,AV:-.-L gU 6r$c-aaJS-;.a a.* ! r:.^i.r lu-,l3- a(! qL"; J"", r:5c---;51 J * ,5r"3 fr"-e' a*". ,6,,+),$J &;h;l cSll .Ll .l-iL ,-!-il3*
tt -,-F.<-,,.atj-al4-i jU o5 -rir.,, Ch ,lV t-^c-rFl.cri ,*[,u. -* a-+-o;) a5 c.*l ,-tli.:U:rl .-d;l Ul r.r-.:,L ) jJ>.t 6Ua:,J,it 3
):zs -rl.r-l;.#, 6* -r.-!;[*i'.,l c4Fl>t'u Jt.r:u -"FlJUr.:-,:",.[-o.cl-q-l:;,
"<* cSL^::- jl .i"f t-1 4t --;51
l;5 r;l.ii
.! c-rl-r" 611.\ u,cV a.,L:y -t t^.i c.i" .:i"^ g;L*lrl 6*.-u! &ly"c-*1;5." clj-6., i.uo gr1ca'Vrjlai, cJlr- q c.;*, qSrLa:ilc.1Jt i
.-t-; -b t ./rl!,'>'*t d\ J*ts jl$, q + (----;51 6| 6la'Vr, 6a
);al o-..lT -; A) )l il3j.-"j lJ'cr^?"r. *U;t ef ig6 7+a
.$t*r ,Jd. J-t-* o loi uel;r1l-e.-" 6;L;.r e#e\:3.jJ:;gi+ a-.t,r, .51 o-,L" t .:-rLc 6)L.al J r;,*z3.(;lr5;*: e#el:
6-" .-uil.f (.,ujl J j "-. o-.,) .(- ;, o3-i *; ,rr)q-..51;r 6rLr:ilJ-,-! cc*l.r:"t &) +5oL7-rir,6.:t-,r:ilLU;4 .>1lx ueV ,j$
,?J tSs-t c*jli.,-. U1J-,t, &- ;l .,} .r:q ,s-l-e 1e.p..{ qgl;b
ar-J 4..!.c;l-..r-- lLil l; .# .-"t+ g'tt:^L, J5 .pli 6C)jl$-r* (-:^t , &J.5-"! .ir, -,,t-"-.:.*-tr "l;1;LJ.ti;: 6 o.-r..i.-,
a-Uy .51 '?l-b.t-*'J
e )-cV c:La:,61^J-S J. a-Jl4. rte.il,-l"rt
,!*t .ff ,r:S.t:l a-Ly c--i,it1n"y, q .."- ;-- rsls-t yl a, qSrL.ail
.ry' o.:r+ c.ll:115 a, -,t5 +! 6'lPl )JJ, J).r;l: Ot("lr:J.rT3:;l: )fiJ ,iin j3tlj .Kr+.lt.r-" 3 rl,.a:il;-, o;ry3;lL
* :t 6 ,#,g o;1.: ,ri.t-a -r.C^J "Jjt", *:*"Jl;i -.Ka;r c6;,1
.-i.r;;--l -;iJl) t3;iro^u J'13a -'xr,"l
c-.--;,-[rl;* pL*; ts,-AJjl .rgLl- cr-)y-\-r 6:^,,rt.r--^ j ')>\ .i-u^ it 5 Jt- t: -u'-L'j
6o^ Jtij .tF C*s 6>V:31 tL*VJ..glr1 -r+U'tJi,-[Uy y.r[til
WWW.AEL.AF
,-{t,rJr l \ \f
sl el::irrl.-rli r<J<., Jlp _,, )ic--, c>3L;;, -!l.r.al ttt " cljl3j rrq.1l t cg-,!rl
,-a L.qr)Lr:il +-[iy .!.r1.r,ol oS Jt* 1:..:;ln fJ JG .-ir"L^ ,5,, l"a;
sgrL.a;il di- .<,l;; .c.^.."i tjf ", J,Li ojy aaNS il 1:ltzcr'tTrl .r:;*:La; -!l-tal cJt"" -,t*Il , J":i" .g;L ^il *[_l 4 crL jl c*l c.,;Lcc-t-.i:L -*L; ;,i";,1l 45 jlr^l1.61..:3U:. :lil .:3U:" dL^jli _:+_, t-
at j cro j) ,;\j +lr 5e c.*t 51K-, *!l-r_al q, f*l3+ t't oS;U.^t
"t"t LAJid+;l +5.r:-*-a f"tS-".SU^i,:6t-e e5,rrlrrl ca,-,o\; ,rb3 i-r-'.Ki.:Loilj J5 o: *S -lu:*-o or--1 4rt-i jt.5 eltWc,*S.,E.ildL-*-J ))-f )) J*:il,rr.,-" a.5 -f:*-a ,#-f ; t,=,a--a)*..r:.1 .t-^,-li t6;
,- l; t j; g;bot--1 ,-/[.4." d^4q Ladi 45d,,l .J;;- F."-, .,iL; -i[at.c,*1 ;iU-,lral .Sr"l (-u.5 J*"*j .r:s.," 6t_sl,;J.., Oi rglS. +5 qglr-l-
Yr* -,Vl 'A* J )Jj.,.- o:l.r ,..adi-i; #2, t +":**a -,,1 ..rl
L"6, 45 c*, lj*" dl-L J,,l Ul .ry',r" *y -,t5;,r(;<J J,, il*, y.
*1-> eS;> jlL.aJtJrt,..tliu ca5;--1.+ q ,_*,l ,tjStj;i-S;,;7.i ;r" jiG Jt t* ;r .:lr-;; rlq.1t .ttil .\c*1
"$:" 4.iJ .,(;<j
:;y- l;,f,L- irl -71tl .gLrJ! ;: a5 f:r;:L--.i e, re:; ;1b *.*l p;y.Jtlr;rl ;:.\.g;L-:lj qt^;lr- ;U--t(t .,S.J 1 ;; ".;=: JU orjr )rb ;l ."-5 ";Lil $lo:l: ;lj ca--Lz-jl
45 ).11 oJ:-._, .glal;.; r ").J .g rlj.(;G .91r.:;-r!i .r.t * -u.JS,_r5 La; l; .g:L --.!l
G))ro ! *rL oiu c-?"Sl- ;*"'[ .Slr u,-L^.;L*; qrr 6;,1 ";L;: .;.i; ^+.5.<?(Repon of the [Lord 1y1,1: e-:^S ,_;,r\; ;-l ;: .r.i.,- ol_4 6;1ri, ,t*:;a,",1 ;: l- e5 :b gL:i Chancdellor'sl Comnittee in Minister,s powers, Cmd. 4060 tl932l)-t*\ | : p- t" ;l Ul .:3" .f J- 3- t ra:; ) )+ _: 3t(-o -4 ra J*, . ;LJ ;lr & .,1;
,,r-.5.6\) r _e*U:L*il *i 4 otl" q (f..! "r: )Ui, f :l-u:-l .gU, j ;: L 6];l.--:
"g:l;i.9lr. C+)e )),J5; j,t y.e_*,5.*.! :--._,: ;*t'!t:-i e .:j^;:lrJ!;: +5 .rIY: .rf-,l tl .r! .: j, ,t) u,l)|.r"!L ;" a ,: .5rll1l1l- a5 c..,1 u, +t- "<tt-r5,rr u.:*aj l1 .9:t;;;1,! +JLro.rU;!n 6 ::f u^5.:*ilx gr! r.",1^::.;L.l ,l:rl;(j."\ ;l3l.(4 .r,,LJrt* .:L *U. +5 l:s .r: ;;r",i JL ..4 ;t .grtr".rr 6;l jt:ru:1 C,r jl (d;r?) t-V q-r*lv as :;\x.,:3-r i.cl-rr yU, 5a t,*;*rlr lLiurLJ;! flii ,c.*l 6;ra.
"p: ,:rlr" jl cart *.i ,, \L"r-t
^+J .;l ;f .i . +,r, I f\ A> ),
l, l,r- j! ))Jj eeJa :lt;" s L?:3*.i;:G.J:5 ",..i3"i lr.5rl-r(l;U; c,tr; (*-lF.,^j
G4.s ;C jl..:-;ryl;* jl cS-,Lro oS ,y-../ rt<;i"U; d.:-,ql ; o{sL- a,,u;S' =zj* fl .: ".[* 4-i 4i;r-;,1 .ro -j,r- u-lrl dlJ- a:-t*- 15:rir5o. f f 6-i, I
,E ;: 1o:-9=i ri[ J:*l e^ L r;l.* 45 .,jJr; -e*-.l .g;l-:;l ",;J,U dl-Lel liLs!l:ri -r^;" .r:". J ,.61, ."r,clrf r rilgi.r^; uultl
WWW.AEL.AF
\ \A a u)f 3a: J 6st-t*L,
Ul!,J16L^J-! lL"; _)lo.:Li:-l6ly c*l-iF}." 6yl ai -r,_r<a<J r^5dLUjrt5 q -r,-! g-,Lr(oiU 45 c.*l0)t$ )++. eE -:* a'. u,-S )3a
d\* )lgb3oyU cLn+::"j r-rrl-rr a-5 c*l;lc---ilj .:;, tlKl3;r c:31,r+irilr.i cc*lo.t ic*.l q s"-Fl dl: Slt &li )l6 cu,jn-o
r;$ )g )l* r--! nS L,*rU. c6rLa-J11.gt^c.Jt- Slc*;.l +5 Jt-'€-l+" d+ -,: u-t\3'p!i .<-- *1 .r1Qc*r cJ -u:*^ l;lJ )$o1
..t-L*;.f 6". * l;,-f;1r53^:
GrrjOi 45 c*+ e* ejKoell.i .r1.ri AE oS ci;r. -r,-[ rLl
Ai)G L- dt^- L c^jJl; +rE" q r*"-r, ! .-ilts, .*1. y\u;tp.l"r-jl-r.." 45 4jJSJL"i,.:*lal't*, +,'r ljl' a' it eV t (J;J-)+l'U-";--t 61.r.l-13:4..rJ- cl,))."*! -6, A;L^c-J," e:s-e bV,
dl-? 4-.t,rj"-." e;-r-r L*t: -r,-! ,,.3lf" ;n:A l-* 6 -titi d,l: r:f. y,> y|'\-r r-e co.t-J, ri.. S-.ii.:tI! dr,l 5 J$l)i ( $ y Co -l G f t o : Ji
a*t u;"-r; +5 c*l ,:i ultS.t J"?U l^-..-r*"!.f1r -clg CaJL*;;ttt:o;1r.71c,*: :t L*y rslI|p rc*la:-aly 61..- *,>lijl;.,
\c.-.l.r, ;^r* ,,--b jl LiA flill,K! ,f Cos ol-t-p,JS ;;1,.e
A* r;;l-*o .ll -;t .)_l-./ k J?V >-:ty, t Lyy SGS-S f-^.'jl45 d.+io
"13 6Ji ! b r3ti.f o)l) sJ$ .*-f a, 6 e*L*";,1a,
.ll4o -13-"-" ^5 "?Ji) .l-:.a) fLllr.[---iL 6.:l;l.rL*.-.aj ]tJ r-
.(rr.f J:€i trro3o elKi,-*--y L*y./!.,1: ,>jWitt
.5 Jt-;: r'Gor(- ..t:r5l;,7" :-a7 ucV,r<j<J *VS 61li3l3+. a-5 c.*1 6-a"itrr 16.-rJ;tt<j,_.,rlrya: L cc.*l 6rV ;fu q:j'-- .r;ri't-n; Ji cJ5.r.. 6 ll uE t ". U f aS 6l al rs y,r,,li,-.73,a--a aJ -\-i!,-ll" LrrU J;li,r^i Cl.rr, o^"tA.uij..u:*" c.*r jl l;
-A*.-usLr" jlu' tAlf;*r jl-;iU JF -,, l, g.ta tst-;u5-t,i!.t-{ 1.;L-c--r yly;r d+J? it c,J,i;.- Jltl$ )tS \ r)pv,-91^.:;-r.i
1. discretion 2. judging the case on its merits
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5'-.,Jtl \\P
f tStLuVt ; u*lr$ ja: Jl ,;- ))Ji€ )JrJ yJ-lJ <:^L^ a,"U,
sgGa-"Uy aHlt-!l JKi" t jti 15 J* ,g_r 6>Lc:il c-JU jld:+rL; "(j:"" 6L-a,-"[Jy..r--: .ualr; e-11r" .K-:at*a J5 r=ly .51;.r l;.,45oL+*A cjl31.: -,J-a) 4+j lJ oJ-.3,rg;sa-,U-i J5.i";Ut,;;-ql; L-"..tT..r-;J*l-, L*y dr-lo5 -t ^i!.rLJ CJyr+! crly;+"Ur,
.:-r, c.(;l;r. > rgrltKy1 Ut.J:5 J.r;+ uUy,tl-rii cJt- a, c.*jt^lJ, J--:y tr ,.rq- J"-t*. ',1Lg 6r$ 6.-a, jl.tt^_, tSlll: dJ,-.r"
rtry*i aali.UL-y pt+.,1;- ! f-^l_,.J_,5;ri" 4J;rioi3 c,t-lyK$J->J;,--ltr..rf "i,olr*;(-. _* 6tS ,;K, tS f cgllg.lq e;l+"U:t
It-7." .t liu L olr-"a tc.*l 6 I j r.c 6 ts au! t dCf-l o;L1 r .ijly;ie-* s tSp 6t-ot-,;U: 5;3t, ?y ,+"Ur, .(,.1+ _rr .!lJ_f.crrt-icJy:**",*Llr c:l;l;, Q cJ;r q oSr.cl J Lt.r -r-: .r,alr;
-tlS _51caS :yi,u, CU ,r:,i )s-t t )s:-,Jq ;fl .r3,i orl: "!.-e
e;.ri.,j:-, cgL^c--r3J-u tt.;--! J;* €ly sy' ft#lL-a;6 c ,,1
.r,# b,.,.!lf;",6t- \ c^S f s: o?J fL< .<* c6:t 'il ,;L:(,-: .<-: t p:." jU
o--t 5 y") jl .,51 eS : ;J3 u-oL.; ;i rl t^JLo35l .c-*l tS 1,sui tA ;$ c:y-; .:t4-t-,,'g_lb uJ;l Trt ru*Kt &,tVcrL;7-ilr))r;L-l elji : J*_r JIJ*I 6Gi r41 .r!yr, Jl :Sr" 6J-F-citi q41y- L^.ri;r lr .-tr*- 6,: U_l €e &,4_&l e-,5Jtt 6rL,r:il J*ti -(- rr Lr:a5 r::.--a u,K ;r.-t..;!13" t-".lia,.nY.r,6;e;L(-> 6:4: u4- c-->; & f"- tar ji jlfll_r,,ri t de-,* y.l; rreJr, iy,ilr 6l5,J 1:.LaJiJJ *: 6 S>-*t.rlil rl.r.;
.c*1a:iL- riJ dt-j ,ti ;t 6$*^4 :* y,J-6).,aj J*!,r-LlrjJ> Li ,i* s-,-lc.l.-,, .)-,r! t ,1+ 45di jl ull,;--r.tLJi;:1. Elie Hal6vy 2. Lord Eustace Percy, Sir Oswald Mosley & Sir Stafford Cripps3. <Socialisrn and the Problems of Democratic Parliamentcrism>, Intemational Affairs, XIII,
.501 .
WWW.AEL.AF
\ \V a.r-lf s", rG1-:a,lr1
jl .}-i j-r" crtUi 5 c*l f.6, ^J'L" y-l15;3i)U-.)y o); c.ir;e, gr[2
o;l:16;9it5-)e)f ! d--q o-5 rl o-t*;4;1+l>r" tr,\ qff JL*
J .t5 Lt;-, u*lf y>./t-"j a5:r5.r*; F "Je.-I-iLr-U.'F.il q s.:- -u.-iLi;rti f-t | 3i3, r;t- ,"j,:V,5La.:1r53*.:
l) c*l;Jil ,i s*n}:^a.J:5 c-jS-.!lfy", t* y,t.f.U. u3o
cat - jlcrJlra., ale...J tr J ;J. o)e s.l-|-f t Jgt 1-Vn -91 f.:r- ;+ jl
jla5:-9- d)r-, W e jJ-.lLl,l; -J+^.S:r5 or[i:-l6taoi;tg-,l-r)_f )B)FJ tart5 ft-7.il6ly.r!5.:;-ii
.f-l t-l 1-, t-" -1-i;1: .+1f* clli:+-"Uy ,Ji,,"L-lJ-, a5,rJ\u"l
biot.rt# Jr:;5 u-1153":6 CU) ti.q5.:*1;i.r:S *\i:a a*;:Jd-:)cA i"+
ttrk U J:6 .r-5'irly rlL c-,-i Ji.:Llll...r5
;L^:",r"^)Jid.p o*"1+ il ol'-J,61so-V1. +*.1-a cll;r +5,r.ol; tgjrr
cpLT-it ,- e t ,;.\ s &,rrtL^:-l J f t.gL-^.;r,-- 6 c-*l .ti rp.r"\ u J r -.Jr
.t-#e :ly Jst Jp , ran c.-,=j,La,)i,r"L.i 3 La"-ly,- "eljl
6fr.r*iL.rjLJlq c-Jt--.rrt l^: c-i"j J-li.,r 6))_t' 6laj$ JtUl.r-# :lp;Urt J;5;.r xl_r't g f -t1.6t^Jj5 jl rS-,!-r ,el-tQL- ; r3L*-oLi
'> : F a-. xl y u, c."o5t* c.(-jlrSy*.: c--F 4 -,.r6 4 - /-t / t 2.t . --rl ,-.t.::rS Sy 5-!l-{_r, JF :t e-r".J"< o3.r, .jJrl, Lrt^g1$
.l-li,_S;1-J_r!r,oc^Jl..ta.:; -tlS -b -t" l; ,*4." iW 4 oLi:-clr,1
d.4Lt y ra.r tllJ, ,-*t eGSjc-a; "r,lja d al- y c\ y"l6117lct;S js?ljl.>L3.a- Jr; ;L*'13t' J bJ,-*l_r y-!*t^r J Ull
9 u-ili Ali {;€ a5 c.*l Ai 6jKte#, o5 ul6-^.r,"t^j Jjs,:*l1y.- 6ysb\-tq f6,, ,J-5 6 6"K^c;llli:3;3.-i[al:;3*J rilJ. -rUujl 4J c#) o;l.Li ,r-c)\ll ,sJ- 45.,,U:! yL. -il.r-al ;-6 t-b a, 5 c-*1.51+.Li; asl;lpt+;lrj4 -Ul_jj,_r.. +3;Tar"," 6 .,"K:-a
1. Briining 2. Schleicher 3. von Papcn 4. Karl Mannhcim
5. Man and Society in an Age of Reconstruction ( 1940), p. 340.
WWW.AEL.AF
6'r.Jt n \ \A
,g:Lir^il c-*t ;<*" 1t^:-l .c*1,:yU:" >i"S .*;r r: > -S r-l Jfp L_ r,
A-r5l 6_a oi dL?.,r Ul tc*il: -r-al3.- )_f s s.r-iL a*i,b :fs i,.ublr--ol r;3-".gLari-i1J 'r.5.pli ;f&4 *[r .(- es_t xli.r*,tic.:y*i ajl;l a-"[Jy J.5 .5:i!) 6L,ar:.;1olro q t;l_r,.f +l^^-oi*raiL+Jl V!r* .i- J13,-r t a|Jt! f-^-1.- 4tJ, .tL .rntr; jt, >\"tS
,r*) 6G3. L.rui a-hjl+5,r>1; oL,: .(" ol-* y:** rs,-: t*e)- )l c*l ;r-(.*" ,s:-.rr^, a:-il: rK; crj--X,r-." c--K o!t(*i a-,
t* -.;r[- gla.rL^;: e) J. J r;2i ,1"o \ 6;-1:- c*ii.glaorl.e^*l
,i;e.;r .rar e # c*.e+ .-r-Jli.-i,-rT Ul ..r-;r, )l )41 6 ;r"ic-r;A r-f ..!;l: JJl"
'|_", .:tri
"5 *L.r" .pa *rE;l--,I-.:jl c, cc-Jt-
OT;r 0.5:;1.: \.rr-*o-c ,lli r--r--,6;3rt:(,-) c*u \ &l;,*--,,JL,- r, :t)e c-": f)r, sl: Li _&, dU) t .rLj jl c.J3: ,...s;.:y "Lal3> r;4-T , rllli5 t-y Az.A, l.i.:;1.r ;L:;l;r l; .:;ri fL*i oS
.J^lJrs, Jl 6a: )3-Laer 4jLat<iJr5 LgboL<"| a5 c*l u*l-S_f>.SL+ ;*l;3,"1cLac-; L_?J, y -t-! c..ilr::ry g$,-*li 6 tjirS.-cl^{:"jo: jr-5;L5 -bG ^: a5.gla-^"t-- 1r Ul ..:y*i JJ-"* ,jLj, 4-i J--!
dl3- n: lli.,*j Jr::S dr{lcc*l.r-(:" .,*!!*r f * 6y-:b} ,
6.:y ,raly,- 6r-f .:Ll.ril,-^lelr.r-:L a:..:lr,rK:- Gli elt c-"-Fl
U._t 3 : -t c+l J,l l ls,r _y &"*J prr, o:1; l J. Sa _f c.Jil .! .rllld---..'. )))A oVyy olL;r o[-.1:y- d!:t J;.:t! 6:rr .r.al1- g:f.:*lorr5 f* ,"_f c,r:1".j U J,dF c.(;lr53r.: cJ3r.Ju-y G\i *.
a: )-9J>r.ocor-ia-:iyj,L j -o a-t.*lr, €.-fLlr-l ccJ3.: *-US +S
o:j, Jy-a- "|,U.:ljT4:'t*,4t-l3
1c--Fl &li 6 c*lo.r^i.rt^{."jLS \ GG);3, u,b a5 c-l +jtol-e,-6rl;i 1tf 3:t u*L Aty fi:*tiVU^r-t+5 c*lo.:1r
"f-l-i; Lyy.i- q c*t G)Jre oi >_ty-,, ..il_l
l. plebiscitarian dictatorship
WWW.AEL.AF
\ \1 D,s-l,|s"t s GJ-:blJ.
4X *)il .r-rl*-. J-pl- dJli 0i 6-rU: ..:l;i;lr-il ,g1;l-: +--,1- 1r
;: rrq5;1.>oLr*,r ,5t .rrU;y 1_.2 u6;lra,L r*r cu*lr$yt +S >j-),u"
c-sJt ;; a;1.:l1i;l-;;l ,-. u-:n..r^.rU-r 6*y *i-,gL- ! t+;alJ) ki ,rs*l_F.f) *5 r31 .r."l1, € rlt 6 ,11.5;r IJ,-I,L u^ca*>-.<--
" .tx- d.---j 45 .r"6 cu*lr$ -9t>.c*l ;5.-" fr-.r." ;1 O3;.:
.:r5
c.*l;S.".1',-jt*l ,* s-l-|-r) )JJx;: eS r:*j;lL r.ai.Ll
.;tae.,jtl:;l_5*;.> y,.:L;,r[ ,elf yr 6;L1.: L J.J 45.:uiL c*;.:Ji--$ls- : 4-S rs".,;* r,..S ,rl^i ,c.*t-l.-ri c--.g F uJf j': oS
6-r!rr ,JlJis^r ,r_$ e.grlyi orL;: G*i I oJ51 :] 6 asot7-*a
oi.c*-;.Jk.r-L- -i-r^ 1.-,1!c*: rglr,,gj1h 45 c*i< rrl-F-f>?_f ete c4rr-1." -hV y..:-l ,r-1r." *-t^ if-y.JV of G3f {..il"t-al J";JL"..-L J 1r i":-:."1 -bL; *. +(l c*ljt! ,ty, 45 c*+*L*y .<." Ll;Jl .r-1r5y": .(
,,, J."jLj al$ Gp J4; 6 t; ::,rrr, a^,1-
4n 45,JL"."^ .g:r-u rg>11i3.r1--1: e* ,*O 6l; gti. {-9 cc-lJl 4-S f5 -r"r"t; *U..r#.c--t ;".- ti U, jl j9a +sEg41 c...*, */5t.>6Lac-;K* tr d:LU -,Vt gS: j uK:^l rgtlric^-..i 45 c,*l 5;r J-U #lY 3 -c*l a:^.l,l.r .r_i*y lau-lf j,: 6>1.dJ*.-$A,.(;1r53"r c,.jK- curi:;rj aJ<*^ .,J:i c--Fl .i" -^"FcJl--- r-,o a...t-5 o-:-+..S-K* cc-l;5..".-S;yL!r c.,$.- ;J-J+4j<j 4<1, cJ5.r^ CrS--, l; g.:l;i ,,-$l r6;1plS--) 45 c-*J ,,lL --;;gty,L!, lr-,j r:r-i,r-, g:;,S-,ft{r a,15r;" tsl-sull +5 c*l;1aS ,;;3-^e J) J.*j---aA cj c*LorlL;i 6lr-7lJ lf ; -,1;l U-t j j-tS-ts_F 6;3iLi-r ,rrJ JS". r#J.r"l-i." -t: F:e tst-:u}l.c-.JlJ J."l )l J<tL- y rr,l-Fy: ) tSlpaalr,.,-rt"" 4;;t5rLU.r:^i.ft- grc-a; Ul-i jU :;e" 4;>l)i -tF r (U ,_r"lf .*> oS >rK u, -ri..J^J
WWW.AEL.AF
6'yJ-,tr \Y'
Ul-e nili,r*i u-lf yo o5 t+,.,iU Lil.c.*16rLa-ilcJti cr-U^
.i".J-5 l-i -,. :y-*,6r1-t^:--lg-j: .:,.-; .,1.(,.i t +tj -t.-iq 6>S 6!)i
.(;lrS_.e*: -,^U; q ;l r;-c.r:*{L,r-il3 6nL;tJ3y 6;jbi-rrr,trk.o.l-4r 4-.i f * -t* y,1;6r1,^ilfr^".* .,^.lc-.&- q"lr"r,-t..iq.>-" 39.- r,a a5rlL--.^a c.: j t-.r-" : y L;'>\" 5 \ Gd-r.g.r t, T lL.:.-t
.c.*l o:r5;;-7 o;13*a.r"Jt ."f 6a."lS: ji_be(riJ# ))_f
'kl.fjtlotE" * ,-*l-5-rt t 6! f *
+5.r"1:l-" ce-5 r:*t.J:,5.1,J J ggLl6 JJtl &l J_*"U-,."..1i.c-;. J*i U 4ilu*" f lis*j .:t -L! rc.* I c.--f I orll I cl)1..Li .iL-4, 5;f<- c^L &- u j,-t rtj-.cl ;-l jl f)y jl c5-rlrt 45 ;d& e_frt,'#i 6a.rtlr :ll\ ess & +5 c*l ;l);61L;,> u, j c.r^tiiU.5;1r53*r Gs:,5-"! .>-,-r-i 6.tU-; [J c6 ryl"ri ;9r3 rt-i:cl ,:tl,Slt4n< ^Jq ir-ilt-i oS ;1 JTJ"U" el"+ r.i-"! ejlr:*. Jjli,r*i t$ *lLel
+5 c.*l .li c.,-r3.t--" <! .*+ .:l-ri g:. :c-l c.*;.rU ]"t5 ,:-rl.!r+ -;tc*l;S-" .!l_5_:", J-.5 .t_5e l; rl.r^il.1,tT;.u.grl-'Sl1t S .uit .,l", \ f* elf _rt Jt .-rS 613 -J*..:l-u-l t srri.,i)c-<- J:U .rtj e|* *: y 6 t-S e Jt) l; Gl| )l o:Li:-l
.rtJgLg)U-:-l .::Ji I "l*.rl
,.-.-",
WWW.AEL.AF
? .JJrlg cr.*.qs> -q li#Jtul-r;
-,! 4 eJi> 6-UJa*E:r ,.;l 6lau-;2tt6'r.i*, ci3*-;:[ J*l 6 tsu' 4-l: S1:
.r-K lL<-l ;U;--! -cV s:s, ,l,.,i ,-L1.,
;<* .r- l: aS :r$ ;lr-3::jAL:;jn,-4)tirA6o.:t,r:, I 6-:, J )J-ls oEL:il 6111:
r;tal.ie=1b1ji3 a)5) lJ-)";: QJ c..r::^*a jtgr, t F./ t";^<- 6 :l> *-V f
tp:l+L JrK
4 -,r )-tr_f L-l; )l1; :l1i a*"t-7 .(-:.l )r. y, \li 6* €i$a J_9-al c--G) jlri.rtii cqg:l.t-:-l .>-"JEeg5l! r:-"; a^"[
.,rL*i jlcSl.r+.ur,-;;*; cJjl t-.1-;.r Y..ry;U .>"35.- y f-* -".
r3J-*r .il"a+Jt .t 4or;) r.:J3.: 6 c.*L-" .,,1* ott* d/l,.,+ "[t*"q 11; ,-*..r+, aS 6,tolj'- c*t ..r-iE)\-cl ,+, jl J eJtj e*lg y
l: ./;Lx-i eG s i ;l ro;-r!
grlrr ;rLi:-l oFi jl ;4'.>'-V t,Jq"llar<*. l; ,:ilr ,y-l e4 -*. g;:. t;tp s_fl Gtsb\t J e-* AUJ
1. Karl Mannheim 2. Rule of Law 3. authority
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtr."\t; \YY
4J ()J--: Ji,.!,J-6ryt q q ;F*" f *dU)TJri.tu--,-a\.:;L.r,:Fu- )l.l-<ls Lartl.r- olG q91r;145 cdLA.Ji; J Jl)li<;J;l;6;lrlrc--1;"i:r./15 r- t *i ,,Xl ttfJ ;jl L r-l.::^*a *tliJl;ta6t-aol;1,uscr" orLi:.-l ;1.:J esijl 45 dlr.-l6l^,tt(;1 a, "-u:rij-(ly .)lJtj-;l +5
6:l)i 5.s- U,;iti r^ o5 Jt- _,r"t! ui^t5 dr5.*, -t> JJF..I U._+-_!
slXt t9i -!l.t--ol t-+,J;r c*"ll.(.o" l)r" 6.-ILy r.r- ti l_t 6)jjl J-.e ! r,,lyLi c-^-3-(-ir ,51! c=; rJ5.r" )3-b"-r cJ:,or ,lr! orLi:-l
cJj.: -b-;6:i,gGr,t*i _f dt-J )le. )l tor-:
Lr or-iji..,j !&Li c-*l rljiri c6)L .*133 \ (f _f ,r=lri,ty;: s:.:s),_* c-,jl.,6\st o5 -ui! G^b. : tS e-Se,l_s )F ca>J 6t-aa*13- 3 -il.r-al
.1.-: xalJ# *-S _rS 4J -14, :* y3l6Laj$,J),^; sl=.glr, cJ3.:
,-rio9;.r ;": +5 ill .r--lr -,1-;E ,ta"il JrJ y! 6 cS;1U ,rcl;Q
S#c-+ 3 c> jJ4 i:,-l.r-a,S.rl gL*-"c_: .rLlf 6ei f;lnt1i-,.i\;: c51o.:r5 f?"; ef t.r-,-l.i 4. 6y t.5:Lail €Jt-ic--aj.c*1 .grl.r;-*l c.-y,G ytJyU .*.j,(- 9t"" ,,pLr;Lj jl u--VdS r-5.,./,riU,rcly a, )jJ>."r lt )_r- cJ3r,(o;U c-JG) JJt el-)e# 5"-*' j JSu-".6- l-r d-p) ,, Cb jl o:t-,.:-",l .ttil Lllfy,l: L _5;lf ".:Ui*,l t;1t ,L^,oliu pl-r5 c-.(.- J) Ctr, ,ti 6;l o;L;:
JL_, jl orl i:-,.1,(4;rl.r*:*l c-"J<-) e J: el_l c--.i .r; lj(,r, 13 :lr!l
-+l-;i ,J-elg JJI L_y.)r*./ o;t: c---€> eV *![a163* t !i,JL-a,lq;3 Loc.-ly-- a+ia oS rF a:;L rr**; .r.olycr r[-(..i y tlie.TheLawoftheConstirtrtion-l5;:tA.V.oi.."y,@aJ;- JJL" t^i-; ! .iy-.51:,* u J3l dry ;:n er3,G t-ri- i\1,1 .r- ,{a':^:-^ -f-;t i- t,;L-l ,:l,u-l S ls o\1 9.r:-L .g:lr^il cr;r! :l ylS ;: 6 c-l .g;,.- q fi-; -,L) sy1n -;Lo ..r--) _,L5 J!, +- L:l .<:..ru- Jy: ,:;- t "r aj J,-J,),1-4 ctJL-.9[a .c*; I ,E rrs, l+-;Xl ;, 6 :--l ^:sf : j> *.6yj;].rr 6tl*'Ur*,tt _.fJ]t
"u ,l *r .r4;tu +* q,tU-LK^;t r_, d.oiU clL t c-,9(-- pre- ;r-",s s tg,,-:,f]: ;*-l ! L U c-l o-r.; o:1: f* y,l5 ,*, f ,S .r4l; ,-<l-q.* d J fl.- ,--- 6- r,
.rj- 't -l l; ,51.;L; "i,L-
Rcchtsstaat e-aL 6;L;: o[.(;: ".o:;;
j,-o .[ljl e ;: a5
2. ad hoc action
WWW.AEL.AF
\ Yf tr gliG e-J<> s GJ-:bli'
J Pt' Lro 6rP.-i1r-ale*i:i;: 6i;)Gra t-^,li.c^-; u*V -&6J^., il LJ:r; A j +! t-c-u;*".r $5 -b r-,y" .l\y' 6l.ao13: 6lrr
6;L-olr-(: jl .-r+. acV p t !i +5 c.*1 j*. * rrl ;1 ;:il: 66lij(*-6--J).t"Lar,i,.it' ,-tl1:.e a, d..rrl,St- a, tali.(a; t-)lLt.f
L^JiL d*iq 45 lJ .silJ -,t i-, U -iS..r" "(J prr" * 6 *:f ,*"*i.-i.-t*;.r*.r*, *-i fU" .51F
u.-l!1-, c5r,-S dJt; l-lJll; C^- L, )l6tW.:31GtsuEt.):'- f^lr, o-l )-rJ->so l-t,t; J.:.ili..r+J 6tL*"1t..:LGr.r;lr oJ'L-
iti/1" a;.,a La,:*"a,; ,.-ri ;t U .r+L+ 4:iL*lu pt' 6ll..4Loc^"ei
ef J e) ,s-olg a-.\-t )i J\-jlirr^j "r:.,"L+..Ju:5
o-:Uil c-l4sjtj"JT | : p y*il3 6La;t";,r:--t I
jJ . J5 :9J--." r lr;* I 6rJ; l.rjL
"l-"! ..r-"t^; -rti:il t^oT ;a jl 4jLat<i,r? J ca;:iL aali .r5.-r" .-,$11
lJ L^Ji -. a;K;*! dlyj €*,) Jr-l! G-* os l1 .atar*r, "t"11:
:1116L-ajt"; .-r:-.a;--!cLa-,e-l-* dr#, .il;.:3 cJjL oa;-:, $Jl$
-r+! .;!r,--l;: cJyr 45.r"L(^.Jjy' JU.5-lu*ij;l .rl;1L.; -iL;d-Hil rl-t-'i c-- U" -qU- e:s;,d--! 313:l.r-; q 6 t-& 5*-*L" .rj3- 451$loly a,.r:*--L 3;- JV:r.r:t*" pl"rS,.r5 "r"i3 dt .r--!.rJi,r^i .,it^:*.4J ;r.- r.rj:*! a:;si Lac^+ il G,-L- +7 t).t^,loS
-,* +L-^oi.r:.:J orliir-, ! 6u::*t L-.*,) Jj--cljl"ir,L:-+,,.,rq"-ai;*q rG;l ;) y Jr.::.^a c.-13 ot j .)!,^-;" a,5r,j,Lj-rL:71
L.:9La:" et^rsj s ocZ-:'l iLr" U c.-.-ll: r^l1, o)JF o;l-9*r
6 ,5., F=*a:4U '*r^r;,:, JL^jF.;,-1.6j sr.$, 3 ;t)t* &K-r- '\' i' \
aJejlsi+.i-"! 6;;a;-llr-J 3 ic-*lrrf-#.rL.S "" Ct "&"*J pr, r..:Jj:;tl-i ot-(--,
^S o$ GW 1-L;,'tU;y5.J.:.5.,"
l- somebotlv's views
WWW.AEL.AF
,5tr"\-, I \Yf
rl.5 ! 'aQ;; blp _t ..*) oJi-! cJlrr J- L;i oS6iLd
-,lFr rt* ,F;r,ti,_+, J-t+: rJl-,- u*-ot) y (f4, Jt"--i {.*l+:rJ.:_lt-i.c*1 orL-./tS J- 4J d.*., ::-f .l2e ,)-cl c>j-3;l U.c.*1
J,jL":Alr ell ju ge: b* a5 c.-.,1.;;Lc,tL.-a c.rlri 1r _* oLr.
)J-7J )1-4) )JJ-? ! fr- '?r ;-a y Loort-- 6qJS J-it, (J$lJ3 e*l J*\ I .4L;al; .rL^_ilU ^.d o+ r:3Uj cr:g clt , + L- i:;l:
1r c-J3: nS y_-$efrr- q ,u*cV:lit3Jtl"Jdt-j 4n L*)cS:S ) c:s-Xu-, -.iJ*, d_* L,-l-i
-J 5,;x+" Lgl^c-.rJa
.*S -* e5li;|.: ,11-),1ucy6Lac-=Jr* \ el_p oi.:l: .ral;,- pt+jljl,5:L; rl-r-"t 61; Lsbl_f q> )fs ::F >;ls [a,ti,t3;.r y :.JJirs
c.4lnc^o-,a J *;r a5;-l yl ,raLfl.:;r, SlJ, s-.i" 6>ro -il'r-alo-.1 f)J- +5 c.--ll.: r^lF tt+ ! rt' -ralr-
"1u.r e- Js-t a, .:*3(-
.gGa-"t; 6lral6lr.lr;- l; S.f ely 6;l;1lc-rS -t6: G-* .y*;,1 a, .r::-*a' 6rl ;lG n u*, Jrli (i*-rri ;.r, .,r^:5 orGil.'-li ;t rr;pr,-" +5 j[al6t*l; 1r caSL:.-iLii+*a p-,'Slt tJs€;tl^:;t oS U-;t.J.1
"[G ,j- !,h 6 ,Alt|;.: 3 ,-r::5 o:LL-l L^.Ji jl .tJ;b g"^^,ai
+5;--l ca*[J.r- t-r L,aoT .r;." ;l l- 45j-,1 c6jly ;-r .-u',i,t +L c-+,fV ,J flJi t L-.$_l.f & l_, ,r-*V.-il.r.al +7 *lg 6,-l a11r,r*,:_#,e orlr.rL(.i Gn 1*t;1 [^,ti+ 6.r,1cJiL; r^lJ, c5;L- p.:r*;l
-,L.+ "ryf+".riL-r, d ta,)i jljL rlilfW q # rr"t a,1t :-tUjA. t-^ttT.,',--x<.r- -,[5 +1 L-;-l ;.: a5 c-t ...+l*" t cu*1 J-o133
f*ly.r.j Ui, # r1L l;; *,:-; o?Vrlilt rrl-- -rl-taldL"./L-il.:r5.r-,olr; o:Li:.-ttaol1t .Js: \lt y.t* +a aS p."<*
J<-. cr;lr ;y-l 4jt^t<TJr.:S Sl-* 6 rf C; ! *J;, cG ,.as 9c^-,.i ca-5 g:5 L"rl sJ.-, 4 oly* +, a5.l-; ): * ua\l:. c-*l
l. sttbstantive rules 2. instlumental
WWW.AEL.AF
\ YA D jite crJS> : 6y-;*"1;t
f"^tP Ji.5 lJ cJ3; 6rli:-.'l ,-,y- gL^-,[* Ei-JJ )l:l.pU;; "(, ;rt-J-.5 6t-,J (f.*t U"rD 6e-l s,J-> Jlslr-o,SL^IS c..--.j U c;L-;pl.i 3 vaj.jii.:,91a-r-,L ;lL 3lflp- #, t.r:.--?!.fL:?l\--- JL-,t - u- v -tJ u \
*e J-pl > j-*i u'\}s "!r c6j13;r,4t-)\" ,J-l )-trs U .ry".i .-:r,...-:
a-"1:1;-l^.r ..5 1-, Jl-r:*t 45 6.13;^3 .il*l u.-r9iU c="f-r Jlrf;tf e *-htoef y F t:-r rrrU ata:,r"
t-,-Xl;: y c+l6rL.a:ilJ!.r:-t J-91l2:)Jl) 4^:> yr JY-r:-l;,1
LS-Gli f t nal-t t-i d--q c^J3.:.r:--i,r- r-r! +^eX; t* *.&
Gt'l -f i J )Lc/;t5 +, -.iJui, eys.gLoc*iy* 1.r 6 J5 )3J>.r
c);L+-.I,al-a lt rlil.g:lji-r*U c-il; J"-.l& t,r;Uj ullr- o 6j asL-i l: \li J',,ly"t5 Sly.f (g)-f :^:: $yt:lilta;a51r;j3-" a>lir*l.rUli r,-q lj Jl..uar .!.J; LaJTt lr dlx)Jo 6L^d!t-'.ru.-.iL;rli -r*! .f. cJ:---iL a:-il.r oL"ii5 t)u!J-l: ly.lL-i,-'1.i1; jl..r5,r;rlx. ,-,16 jl t-o.."t y ,,1y e-l j(" 5 1-, cJy, ,JL^4t-J cnlj ,:-e-lrs L-r; -r--! ,-,-,.-u-iL u:a&,j,lJ cJ3r .)t"l$tJSlUl
&U J+ jl .j y "r-;1,r+& J"U 4j a5 lr ;*; G{" Ltl.; jl ,J-i:^-""
.r3r 'l-^1-9 Ga ;!,"1":U r." .rt^sJt* k e }s ;lli 3 :.r:-iL.r" .-f ) Jt, a5 .r-:5 crl.t-a Lr*, ! l-t 6)p g;L^c^Jl.^, d1t ft r-6, ,S-y sl
jUj J-tS L'"\-J SQ 1,.-r-"!.f ..-,:^l-t cJ,L- c*> :y"- ,'rt-- -il.tal
| lpt.rL-;t* ..:y,, roly,-r-.r:i-;t'" jG * -cllQ J ,y- tt-S tr*dL.^ 4-.1 cnJ5 6 i r+o[-f , r^X* at-,^ cJl: 6 tS,3g.(".1;; u^;i- yl
t .ttf C ;c^;* s\ ell6l;+"lJ; o;l.rjl
! 6rdt-. Lt ,trl ;:'> cc*l ,r-t^'.' t" J)\;l 5 JY-u-l f-e) +;
lr, ,l,-LAc-J-J ? yos"Li^ir c*l;lf .:Jj: jt.r-,t, d-^-: r;3-, +:(irl) *
.s,Lj-il 6- L^.littjL :lr-rl s\-e 6 c*L-' .-r,-l q .li,'r*S;.'1",:r.
lr J-.r,[r+ Ut-o.5f -,V-l-'Wt I13a cJ3.: o5 c^!; g.>;lKu*, GVt
1. The more the state <plans>, the more ditiicult planning becontes for the individual.
WWW.AEL.AF
u!>; 'l1n \ Yz
c-*l,rJ9: d,,rj?^^ cJ9: ;,1.+trJ;*,_,.,i l)-f -,1 4V F eS: I,5L,tc-*"ei f.^lJj1 jt.n),g .7t-*jl 4r e*r *ii*" --il..r-al ;,",,rl aS
-i-jlrr 45 g,Jl( dtj,Jqrl-,r,Jt+. -r g.-S t! Jt<*^ 6)_) \l-r d*--r+.tr19i cyly[..c..*J,r*riii
.J.:U .;,e, 6.li.-rJ,^( _,t5 t 1_, tj>,-,j)L,el-s. C-l,4\ Jr-U c.l::^-a J-l"b o?g o1;9:-r )l4S ja;2- ;",1g caj*-e,
-.r rrj )+b +..:.-..J+, J-U,ii ov-r I *L'-lrJ 9 r;_,.KlS*
-*l ,Sl..r3^:, a=L: '|^!:l.r:lf,.r- ,cV :lSl! -rl-r,rl, t^JT;l .f-l-r!
*-Je.u! -_,t.t JU<oiG e*l ;(" Lt*t oS c.*ti." ..,1t t L6.;
! --l...xq {--il.ti ;-.*",5Ln.rL- l,{. r-?-L,6,o aS c.*L- yl a, O:y,JL-id,;;",J) i-S g1^"^, rJlJo;L;r 7-r :*" Jt rS A6fut, Ly&U
"t"*, k ,*.oL4-1 :t jl f,S ,*-^, a;r[jl ^L q (,'-sC\ *)e3.La) pt-ajlcS;15 6-a c*;ly:,r; eJ3r d-Xti,r*,,&
'sL.rrr q-.i,r" 4rL-i u-*V tl1ll rsSs;f cJ_l: c-*!* .l: .:ljl oS t+ai.rj li,r-i J:5.," .5rtj(;-r,^ l1 ,glo11.rljl ;;; "l*b* cJ_e.l 6 t-7.tT
Ltlt ctr, .u\ *-hc$ti,r*: ..*l;e r {t- .(s Jtji;t c.;t3 a6;l.Sta t _r .t"L*: &.-.] pt Jl_s )_f cSt ,.rFj:! r.r5.g;l.r-lQ -r,-L
t .*J t oli.5ly 1; .r!l.rnl $f-r cS_,! .rLx:r* jl-irl r-!,, ;s tasT a,
,l;lrlcc-*l.r+r.:o, "f,G
oi.;_e rUi,t;U &" (rftK:-a q +5..tirra.,
t_Frl6:l;.l t,j"4 ef r:3,rlL,r"jL d.:y p:r* 6:la-l ))y -i-F.J-5.,- o.:Li:*tLaoirt
'fuf --il-r-al cSly.l fl)y jl u*,rrl-xld;G aS
clrrs .f-tS;.: rlil ar r;b Ja-J 45 ry-, -r-alrij .tj, otK;: 4 cJ;,\r,i)\;lu rt+.<,- 4-i j,"q J J--Lj.(Jdt-.:,Lg:y c^ra;) cjr+.)JJ(r- -,l.5 or rr.rj)L-l -*, ,,[;W;: nj)\ih *i+,si;> 6 -::f u"j)\.-l gll.fot {-a 6:L;r ,.!b.K.r,-r d S.r *-*i l:.Srki,(L
-jjrtr g)L1]b.t3*.lr,lol3'- crS.r, &., :f 6Lb-otlH r: l-.,
l. moral institution
WWW.AEL.AF
\ YV tr,t3;1J c-r$- ) tSlt;anls.
et-S Cf c--"JS> f t+,SjL; rAJi> c6 L- ;.xl q..p1-1r." rf-t.c-*i sryrl.Jll c.- i9- oS,Jl- ; ) cc*l n"ri)\;hr,r.(:
rr t;-i cslj-l*.-* )s+t +:dJ+ JK:" r"l.flJS 5 ry' ".l( +Ut 3 *-^*:JL-.lo 1L r) JgL e rY,e>La:!l i r+,11,, cS .,1^. i* t f--.1- -.1r. J. I U ,rl!
r:"-U-A &re LS56)Jl)d+* 'rlll uS -uq a:-xl: -ql- -9;llJi 6V el
;--1..r5,tKlc*l Jt;-" t a:l;a. *i g* oG,-l; Jjly.r" L:I.:-e"i
a-.ra- u-eV r:11": 6 t-.j,t caL- .gjL5 +t? jlfu:*.',aJ:[-.,.)J:*-r 6;!tr.*t
"[U f 6:l-"J, @^ +5 -u**r.f 3 $-ll: 6tsbV;.
c+Jl .":;lI >_2-nj J;S ;ilJ A;V,eb lJ,jiJll*.d)\r:"*^ 6 fr*^43,-( 4,
d..*., :1y* t6iL"rr./kil c-r56i .:L3l 1; GR € *.r2-' 4-16;1 "p.r
.t.--.J r-l )3J-*.r .*V c-a:.-,a.(-- t1 t9..Lu}l4-5 ftfu oT c*l
6iL-- ol;yl.: ,Jr+.et1rnV.l-,"".<" &iC. s *bl:dlr."dy,s"lK^:*,&,-JJ tr l: eG"1,t5 rr, .(" -t::--n 6 t* I 4'"t?
.rEt-:- j-t t -t -t-*.; c*L- f J W 4 -,r -,t5 6si s *"Gf 63--') eo*" c15,.,;t^):-l b dl<-Est-et' a.r*i l) s bs€.FlJ, qQ-*JQJ
j);;.:;lri r3,--.3;-"L-,.:rl*-Lc ! :*b trl= **;J 6;L;-:.rlK:">1j-" ,;>-l;41tn1J-"^, t-i'l ff;*A,JL.JItalr*" t-,-r1;l;o Jq, 6
"!.ela4U f."l3;=.i -Sl.t-,-t 4E->{" srtSu y"t5 \: t-Se )l} d;;
a, .5>L,,a:i! tSp-V-t;.: 6,rLL*. (/ 6tU, e# 5.-*;.: 1; \t-it-,ojln
,rLj 3.:y- 1.5 trsJL"rlFf yl+ llcrlr-q,fF t-\,,)l \lu, >3>i
a., ..iLa.jlJ-^rlJJU J)al rlJ" d-l :> s f5,-f .tK; ;U; y;l; {r !,Jt.*" -.-iti ) r*A.5,_r"t-(^.r-ar a-5lrt lJ cr;-t rjli.,4j u--11- l-
y' ctrl;L3 tgl; ">;*3 sL-ti J dtK.li t- dlJU-J, ,Sl; Y! ,5t-a:r^i.:
Juil t- csj-,yl:S j4 blf )lS elt. r+61-a.:;:-r J be 6U -*i*,4-r c#) cJ.r..r.--a J"LJ J+ jl a5 r.rL;i6l_t -+,qgL^:ro:-: L: ol-,E-.t
'{*lJ;.ri;r +5ll_^.r"jtljl }t5 fu* bst 6-* d ,f*; ./kil.c4 LrJt' 6-q a.rrq dly cr.iL aJt: .;.*" ,tKrV ":J t- r-p f
1. faimess
WWW.AEL.AF
6"Jrn \YA
c.+5 .r :,.e : q-.x.rr ; r: r:3 d _t ruit _t 6 l_: uV t 45jU>.".6 .6i13; r
;-lt.qL-,r- o_tJF na.jU r '",r t- rrJ;-r )-fl tLf.tl ! all-e o\riut-i,.+u f Li-r \.* yl lr ;^ .*q-* 6; 6 c.*L- rll.r,;;-cntrgjLi c.*;K-,r Jpt;t .,;JU ol_r,g ;:J'* 6_)J.e lo; ,:f" 16,33 e5l-rt CrrlJl-ro dr fJ.cRechtssraar.dlqU)l ,j*V;[JtU y .r.it a; y; rlr;-l \lr :, j ejlii j 6rt6o;li-,1;14 ,h|*..r+l:r o-5 cii,.li;t6r ,*rc. J,S-5tlr3 ot-(:tr
,&, t\c+Je,l1 ;l-,r .-ui,! ;;; c.*.;ly;.,*i d Jt- r, S"f .r-!jl"}-i 3.ILJT;.: n.te;G c.-35-l Jyl .riT; irlf-F lyi:! aS c-l a*-.+5r.,lJ )31 dl: fJl$ crlji<J _,* y 4K .,':'-y.:_r$ t rL-a 4SJJI
,_S.ls 6-fl(J,ljl# r_l ci!- t* +;t"r";*" gtLblt 6y il..S.i[-.r; .J"ts ,J*"^ a5 t_y atf
.rl-" A;-r-^,,; H f,r*" et16;r*ljy a5 c-l,b cll_/6; 4:r;lJ 4--..;TU J-arO.jt--|,r".:iq 6,_.,*l_l c,*,t.jLi. >lSl ueVdL^jf*o.reli &.rLlr d--! ..ra:;tajl.ry-: a*ilr;U,)iftrl ;t 4U.6$.,,.jJ,:; rlr-il3 J-:t 4jJ<" *y ,_eVp:r* a.r.-i6 r_9..i o+;h C;*j-;* aJ--l.-t-,or Et-:jl.r--! cS_,ts +_;3 -r-iL c-.:,lr ,.r*jjt+., l-t 6-* \*5-r>l *fec.:*l
\:_i,-a y (Jc--;S- *.c-,:3;U 6V-r gilrr,c*l :l ,Ff crll;Sl;rr
tirL .Sr- y .|sfu * td Yr,-9
,.L' gl3-jl cJ:f.a1L"i-l(,oiLi e.-9G rjl3,2r .n!:*l or3: ;b;lf L. )r,4JA
.S tfy CeJ t>"J|.>.*l: '!16
aLi; olJ:e a, J,-U c.rtr;l_ri *^f.-.rljt=:"l cll,J-ii c,r. *-, 1)yU c.-3(-,g[ :-., +, rrtg]l.i c.r3(- Ul .rtfr'li
^5 r,"-:.,-.o JL.rl c-;iu- S-*jl +5 c*l ual; >l;l 6lS up,G
J;*;J cc-,,1.9r1,t";-lc-rS- JnU" ^t.i.J n5lJ Jil6 olK.t-. g 1gy)r,
J:S,J"
LS1U +5 e*lJr-lJ;-- U"l;-*loooL; lJt-(.-i,iJ rr"lrl4+"a .(-
l. rule of status 2. movement of progressive societies 3. Sir Henry Maine
WWW.AEL.AF
\ Yl apiE (,JS> ) 6ty',lJ
c.Jti U-F -*U rt3;;U c-i+;>;r 3 rl-,aj;r cr-l-e,JU otK.L,;r ,r*;.iJu; :lil \,r*.^"
U-,SrL tSl.ll. y.r.-o .(J c.{+ J) eJs> ,-*lecJl.rp ./L1 o;K:l - ..o:.- .(J.5[-l; J) .r-L- 7 c6;1 3 c*l6lr-, *a;;r*-a rlll AG.ttJgr+:",JiU c.39.- ?"F lresi,gl-a.>-,"S.5Gt1.,-;5 ))FJLa,Jit .,iJU:" 3,-i a, c-*1pj).Jl:i, .:lr'il
dl9i,-oJ 'c^*i taji t oL*<,-.+, "riL-l
qStlel c'-i!i" rlr-il a, oL-i-.r:'c
ol:..S ot-ifLj -c*l 6>l-a,31 SAtVlJy cclgl[i c-3L- e5 rr5 ;t*l.Jrj .51 o-. rfW rl,-il,. 61tt3)t 6lr, 6)1V;16 c-l;1rr5 brl
J) L^c*;!- J- 45 c*l g-g., ll--,!- .:1r.r*; st LlJ ,rVo-,11;-a .-t.j1".:r5 ClPl u*: e:-r-e * nGr*, cJl-i-c +Jp ";l,ra (La6;t,
'f p r;l-t-l rr,,ti rlrllc-9-.e3 Jrt+ "-,\-,t d-& 6,4 eS GyC y,
::sul: e jViJ>,U:-t .ory rrrdglG orr5..rckaln,lLal3'- t!-^ y cJllo:y
e5 Freiechtsschule JijL citAc^SJ.- fLoj jl Jt--,lL*o;) 3 c-[lo:l.: )lt A^-
..rJlorr5 cr-l.-- $Li ,--:-ioyU c-y5- a,
r q*i ,,:l s ) p,r lU c--.j(- aSyl6ly tF uK c*l;K'-".r"-ollj-o-a o5,r..1,! a-*b ::rt,-riG +! crlglG yld+ t 6 c.*lJlJ(..6-"
jlJ;lrrleiLi r--l Gp dl-rrr.ryj JL-"r!61*-le^ s2z3 c[-\.
JL^rl;L{- *- tt rt9;U;"",o ^SAi 5, c.*1-t1.:y3-- J. r;*l c.=*,ol
o:l.-7 c*l; e-] )l ;<*t" 5 cri fs:e+f eJ A JE" a, .:y";
Et-=jl l-r ,rjt*1,- t* 6-"^ a5.r"bl- ...1i,-.-7 *-J )l ! ,,"S -(*:tt
pss a.l bl$1>;l:i; .:jL,r, ;.:1.! l; L dil, a5 c*l ,ti f-e .f"^r,-/
-.:y' JL^-e!.:;lr- fS -,, diu 45 c-*t,-riJ:"jLj al; fF J.i.ri.c.*1 aiY.rt-c,U F,5 u*L*-\ 6 sel; cJl.-;: Jt,e
1. material or substantive equality
L (Carl Schmitt) +"--:l ,.1rLS ,-J[-r Jt-r-U S2;- ;l:ya-1rL; f ;U:,r':lr,.t+.YnJ:Lr +,9(-r r,*J[-r Jtj-r-[ oL-j -, (Rechtstaat) L;t!lJ+)ljl o;,Li.:- ,*<1-eS ,r:Jl-r,c [r a5 :.,1l: :3,71 e:* irl q;; - c-i l.t, .]**i Jiu" cajl>* (gerechte Staat)
..:*l ,al,*::l ,)ta.r# 1** rrrf CP o*, Jl.tc "|,1;";:
3. socialization of law
WWW.AEL.AF
6ryJtn \Y'
jl rclg;G "t<L f e*:,SAt. S,r*; cJl..r-cr,tl., :Li; c",alca
)l Sy,llr '.r*=- cJl.r-e o3U:." 6t-^.tu;i ui; 6ly.r)c y,,.^4jle- orLi:-l *y J
Yr,;L--ln fr.€i, o;!;: el; cS)ry r-&, e_r
+. rrjL;"ll ojl3 rr,;5 45 cS -U-!,J_,_rTrL- on>A..t5..,- a.-y cl;,tic:<Jt ;lrJu" Jlj;-o a-..c*lorti-l *y ;;lcJt-..,lyf.e. c.-.iL4*K:.: a-SclL>-.,a cit*.y oeLa-*lLa, ti -rl,-:l ol$1,, e,;l:;."j,> ;l c-lrL:.l j .J-),u-.rr*i ;L:"1 ilrr, cc*l o.:_2 & eKi"a- c.-""sf S_r )l dS G^av.:lr-ila- ocl-* rl-:,1 ,rX9rt L" rJ,,gtljK*V Lt .r;l: Oll+, 1-, ,as;: 6oL*..,o cx.\ ucta:;l Uf ,gol3:,.o "-r,.rri..f (;!r 4r JL{ ;ili c-*J,r<"^ S cu.a j*a;s$Jt""jlJ ($J--xu- pJ. oi JF-- , ,?J. L A 45 JJ, "*l !
.jq:"I 6.-u5s" ,rp.6 ,ti 6l:-.;l l; njL:.ll
Itg.(- .r*: 619 7l^:e a+;",* rS 1eV.:ljt.grr-j"L;d.i.r+,uS )tf J J-* dJSt* ,-J 1-s :t l, L lr,, i:;1.: c="al i cc-*l .rl;i
oa;tu :rSy; a5 o-L*ip yl:.i.5*" d_,! pUi; ;1 c-.at"./!;: S_&,q[.j t-i -r+! cJ;, t-j+S e..."=, ;--1.c*lcJyr.rJL; L;r;.r-,CT.:rtL* j cJJ"Sg o!1-,.r--rrU L*.-[* c-r:S rrcJtirr L ncJLinc*\ )teljl.q,J 4ei 4 -, ga7 .:Uldli.tnlt5 _e .-J 6:l;ilri qJLi -q! J_rr r^<,4t.c.*l;1_r;ll.AJi, cGty;-rljic,*l*, 6,rJ-"rl{<j ylUl.:j"-i,r" -J t* 6* ^-ll;, ccJyr tS_r jdLi f ,,
J Ju:S.r*,.ft 1; cJ3r J* *li,1ry t-T45 c.*loTa*-.rL*.c*ja-5 cJi o:Li:-l Gtf qgG+"Uy a, ,r,".1"$:; ;.: o:lr ,Slj;.-o a,. il.: ;l jl:r*i 3 .r5 Jr;:S lJ r;,-- l:Yi,;t" Jt"-{.-l -uil3j,r-i c-ly.r a--*-;J 1:L cJ--i -r--al1, c---1.--,;1f; .:Jt-.: .-[6 -,, oljr" of y'l+t a5 -r.ll.r,r^
(r"+ t*) -u,5 crl:i l-t 6)i.51^.r"rg 6 c-*a ps";.: cJ,.: U-i asyr
gg;L(lc: 1l r9r31: -p t q t") r5,./ JF t, G.jl$l y L^djy d._Jr,
I . substantive justioe 2. privilege 3. laissez faire
WWW.AEL.AF
\f\ trrlE(-j6= s6j_:bls
Jy, oi JG -,, .c*lJt e cJ3: "L& (rS.r 6fu,e->Q-t s
JL* * d3r cJ-a.r,r.o \ '-'L.o*l ols *.c^;JF= Jt"r!rjt?la'>U"r,nS
-ru:S.," c"-[.ct lJ Jl; J1+1,->J3> 6 c*lJJldJt-;.:,Jt--;lU .c*l
+rl.ri+ ! ".t1l; ;r d*l )*p.-*r -^rb; ylr;-r) .:Jl.-;:3ol;/t J-jt r5,r- g*:4i a:
6.7l-: .:Jyr 6.r-lr;, -/t e ;,|1_f
d'aB c-Jl"- 4 -,: 35..' c,1tp : e\*;--1 :a-jt--;t5 #l-9-! L- ciL
e *.J -t-i[ .-ira r;_9.r r.l[^id:y.r^ll) a5..r"l:L clil J-iL j)\.!!eU t" 4DJl,
c+;) .r-3*-; )lj Jl; J_*l\>Lij.)r :jx Jl^el.Al,- rlr.il )r4\,Ui..r-:t,r;ara
"|1U ri a5.:-r".i;1, tei 1 ):Sy c.:_.113," ,,1;.: 5 c-l
-u*iL o-L^i 43L-.i, af J + c-l ar5.*" 45 uaV:l;l 6, Ji .:r""1;r5
UK^t, L:* ;jlt-* Ly :clU.rr".l;35 rUi 4U-)".Ul.r-:L ail: r:rys> G:F J A;!.'|-G.:l!l;-la5rrL.".*a.0-q; +! Jits t) c*";
tfie &-tt dt t; o:,-t*:!.f 6fr. c-.al.r-t"-uJ".:ljlt a*114"
.tt-Sg oel:" ikl! .h" ;r ,ayJ ,kl st -e r,;L.] 6,J1: *t- ).lSs 6>l;i ras J) W.jt^t<i o:t' qoiU c.-3K-
t-Jr r) tf Cb
t-u "lritol
6 rljt*a .c*l di ;3;-f--+, fL;"Jj"jt Jt c*trl;i.lL;lu r(r;*;;tallirl- ;t*S-"c,1-,!e ! .-S-r jl #4 f6 ;r crJeJG r:"st - Ul .rr;il9i j- r-q; e-&t
".Se* jl c..cUl
$-iS.t,-r -r-A J* tt 3 i:*1 a:-.!b r-1;3 La,rr-l-r dl'j jlcg4-" oLrlr-JJ# ai-l )J-fli.S c-*l csf; _,1/ {-r+ :ty".lLt 6+ -,* y f -*)fJ )lL<OyU gL^:X 6lr- ;>-9.s--u 6a oS a-:"..til,.rr1..:;1.: :3ry3
,-rl .c.*l J;l-r5y,".1 jJ3.:3 torrr, c-oSt- a-,aj d>-9J> LJ c:1l-tj
a- c-.y(- JL"rlf*^ 6 'lU:
l,i r,e5 c.*t o-u.i c..-;*i rU:cl yl q .-:,--Ul
L;- 6;t3 cT.SL- :Fa-,t^Jb j1.+, 6ttKo;G L*; au-L:, Itbc-^5L'.c*1 oglG c.T^st-- c5U- jl ,r:-:.:U Sr-r iUS yl Ul .-r-i, ral-9.-
C;*6L- +, j-.,C cJy: JL"oia-*^ tqi+5 ryl-r-i ;,1+,.5;t5 rl9;Li
I - Emmanuel Kant 2. Voltaire 3. popular sovereignty
WWW.AEL.AF
,,5't Jt a \YY
ot*-A J J^Lb )ya s -ui!.jiU c*l;(*. .:J3: Jt ri.(c t,) .r::.-,t
.Slr J*5 Gtli Jl-uil(.,J.<,- e5 cil: ;1.;l*U diU c-T.st"- t
.>-rri ela, rlglli t-T.r,"r; ,-i-ei.*lt.+! 6,-o:;l: ittlp:,!".er{! .j-5" 6 S.f -r--* g-e t* y,d..xlt- sr./ lr 4jU-:- J.,)l'G.irl; ,sX>j.s--tJ o;.r-! -J+a eS -,*! -,:!..c1 c-*l ;(^".J:5 J."e6Lr* +, -Lar.r: fL+,Id5,/". r.,Cl;Q; r-:! d; c-l-l OJ;G
.>y5- o5 r_5 -t413,- [-o:l ].: ot*^ \ 6 a-1 $l .-t.-lt G-;G ,G;*f.:;1.: a".l-:l cl[J I ;.r clLa"a ;;6
J,iU JiU .>-"jS col,.lsg !;t lir, a*"t--;r a5;i- yl cr,lyt-
Q r_1. .r-al3; .,Jiu ccJyr JL"ri6 cai aF- galJ.rL" c-+ Jt^rlbL:-Ga j;- d/l.)J, ulJr,Jitj rrG Lt;t,5to-"t7;"q dyl)l Jelg q a.,xf. j )jJ*afr,c*J_9r 6:e tSlastjlo.:L::-,td c.*[:.,$rt* ,1q..rt5, t Gl ;. : c.Lilji.r-",-rlG ..r3- J-lJ; \
o J*i j.-.^i r.i..-:
--il.r-al 1s-cb A^a c;lf lJ d;iJ1L c6.:L,^:ilc.JL".i *)-et 6r$c-aai,.i" 45 +-S- t:y6 Jt.-* r:-UV r-T.,,. -,L*i, a, ejl-r-:.-," J"r;_*d -i., y' rra) pta.,l r^tg- 6 J-,tS --a $13,.r,.rt* L" ,>yi gfJ^h" ..riJL"rlL^L J+r"-g*t.=,j;li ra: pi+.jl;;s g:., L-,,t a
ar,-,+jl,f;*" ccJ3.r +: rjJ>.rU .:;Jj 1.9Grl !.c*-+ diG c-y(- tc-l;r5.-" s*l-f y:.<,"..-.,/ ;*lq jt>tJ;itj $li.,, oJrU
Y.r 11 ,il p I I ; e-a:, f,G ,Erl.r-:-l ,-. jS,-d/J,J"tS
1. pre-established rules
,-g:lj,"r[" -i>{:;l .c-,1 or; ,.:r, 'r- et), jrs e*t" ,, iJl, 5 ,ytob ,:-*,, ',* .Y
rfli.r- ,:yU .r3.r- L9:lri e-a .)y 1:rLr .r-rr'X"" 5! JL- 4-tjtj+-a ..:-- 11 jiu J
.:l;ri ! a5 o3[,i:" ,rt- ;iU -(-l oiG -ii:i" dJjl o+ .urjrl .-l".:L c:l: :.:r_r
i"r+.5 *S J:*\,c^-l oiU e:-ri.-JiU,.,!::l:;lf uL*(1 Al* a>i olic^ut{a :)t> 614 "K:-> 6 l5,r;r-=,. L; :;Lr" ;:[! l; :lil 6 n.Sj! -lclir .-u .+gta;l .l;la." )jSJ" L-l)- 9l,1 .,L* o-.it:.a.r[]l *- j 631-.t; r^\i &)< )S LS.f -* 6 l, 4a-1 gh-l c,tr! .*r" f ."i,* ;: .,tyE ,-(: Lr .sr.r" 6h"ll ! ,r."rJr ..Uliu; ,ary) n .,t;U:-r(-,:^tf .rJ. .Ls6-lLel,-ua:,.t-a.;l c-l a:-L.4<! ,o-r-i fJj; H-i eS 6;sl5i u-Ll ,:4j ,i) iL, >l;: uf ,a j:* 45 6lu-l'S j,t
.-r5 Li- , F rS ,J<o o n;t^.r*-t- ,-Llyn
WWW.AEL.AF
\ff rgj;G i"f> ) 6|--t*1,
r.*jli .g)L.o:;l Juts-a)c^-(-. +,1; e;$ Cal-r" -,,-!
JiU t'l.Ul,_fLlr J A,rfu,"lG r+ L*l-i -,, c-5 ra) G-t;,-J L^,ti+.r:*,.1L,.r5
c.*toi Jav.r:s l,'-tr ll;l t1;k""-a: c*+,rtd &sG_r s ,)-*la. rg j-G J ;tj .gL-o.:; ri o^"-rdc*!,_f ; -;3 6 t-: auL, 6.)tj-,a 45
3+ :t.r.=1, .-!!.f 1:J .+l; 13L *. -t3G;',-SL^-rL^ 3 .>;ti, g-\y6Liic:y- "r;:-la tf \l: lf ++y '..:;l,,o r; .S -t-(ro.p:,o5 r-r-t o>rS ,--s.,ai r;J,,K JL- -,) lji.tLJ;Lr :c^K'&)11,
"r;-q-,1: ctJ-.xL lU-,t, ,f )l ;&lplr[U.$ r3+ cJt-r 1.:
r.g,1;3t5.:L
.!.r i ,rrz s;L jt-j ji )l J:.:;,1 J-,rrU -,l5 jy-a -,l.5 _et.pt(:^;,t
€ly r:i g:1-r-" -,* y.o:i ,t"tS;i.c*l..* j.{ alljjz -:l-t3-l
'q,-r" *:q cl[.rfly a1 .r"4" +Sji; aS e,al)" c-iS..r, j,411 .:;.ri .l-.4.r.i;l: prr* c-:Jt*i,tit ;,-t Alt e\* (, ,t glr3-rru[i
"[-c 6rlji
6tt-t3r:;13 qi.l: -r-.i ,314.:,-:3.t-*-" j"b.tllJ g*yK- ciJLrr-L
{ p *u * , r +.e "rt l ll L_f _y *.tt 6ttKo;13 a:"lr cc^"yK>;t :c-l'\J J t) J J
+1 "t"+:*. L- a5 oy'.r- ,gtt-tK,:;l; CL y 5.f )3J>.r ..,'*J rrtl,Grl',_p jl orl"o:*l ar ;rU l; ",Jrr
t*; ,t:5 .(J p:r" )l gV -*,-a 6 c**! tir-" dU, U;* ;rtl.J:(,.r;.4;->.-i-ta rJLl-,;r cJ3r
S:4 rp 6 c*L^" g'-l o".ru-S*1d! rr"f x.aL,.V o9;G t.5;.:-lJt*c!.|,li r-r-,-f .-t-J,i bj,l; L-; # rt.S G::l_f ;r lr4:,J cJgr
J-lJ, Jt^,ll^;tKa "-f Al );,_;t'..,ai olie +5 c*l,rJt--;;;.:3.:;UK, ! yi l-,, .Jil, cr"sL- xlig ueV o'ya- 6,:+y ,-.rr{ .-Li
;: at ditj c.-.5t-- 45 r:5 JY.r:*lJ,-ti -r..!! 6k G< -fu .t -*,L^-,1e;bi-r U-ioS c*t.-*lq *ll-r t*il i \ JS! el, UqtJ JUi
#,:" :t'"",,,1,:';;,:.:' u..rt':..;J!":;'ri
j Jl.yl ";:La a) ::-f ,6tlS,-t;G L-i jyG c^Jt- *. r;ti 1l 65" ,9f*11.\oe;- ,: diU +.5E tl,J<j..:-l -i3r-;U.tK,t 6,rU ;:6 ul ;r" oi- 4-
::y;., l:l ;r-,yo ,l.l *;;).tl1 trtrr* :f-tgljz>iai JS S,9a; l;tl'U-lra ,S ;yV oi-! .r,l;Ly ef .r+ - <<nulla poena sine lege>>
oS S5r3 "tK-:; ;, u,9-.s otols..(1 jli" * *L t2L! 6; .r ..ri.o-tpl!;l *aL.:;[i
WWW.AEL.AF
6,1.Jtr \if
tF Ch Gt* ^*:Y -i";.r iJlU .:tJL- )-al ,gla:1;15 6r,lcr:*l ;,^> t^-,y5 € J, a5 gly"toL*a c.r-Ll ctg;G t"L"l-lz, .i- _,t tl
c.**al ,* )+ cJ cJ-.:L t-,1! .;- )* tuG,* kl.r,l 6;l t- 9
ilu-)yJ=c.o -_6 -*JL.rl 45 :_*r-; oJ-a[-j-, ,r---L +, Lil .r;1.: LS4L
.rs:^L- jPJJ? ff' ,:jl; ge:y 5t-a.:l.ii tSy )l o.*.c.*l ttLil ,j,tj.rtJ o3i-- u:*-r:;
t-,)lr<,ii3J jlg-,!-1.-ricty;: a, 6 c.*l Cr*,i 4jLI UlJt..-q.*'U
:-2^1gt-t".(, e5 Srl: rG:cl9 t'lo>yji 6314;,L2:""61^.tL;i oJ-s r.
+-^cU-r JL- clLa -r:,_;-*f,r tJ-l
.f d-u;t t'r*" Gt-:+.Vy. AtyV6lSi oS 6t; $je--.r;-e'i;: JF {;) a, l; rtt*it ,it:* )la[; :iy,&,b tsys*Et C;< gY -r;.7 Ll- c-*l oi Li- * :ls*l )st-. cylrrLf -, "t*! o.u*al l; L"*. ,_5-:3.t-- ti Jl 45 J*s,! ); a, .>;l,K u"L-; : r+ ! Cy- J CU dLtl_, 6y cJrk:^l-..
\ r,ra 19yi-- a^JL,:ly,
d-s at'! 5 Jt-;.rcJti olj"o a,. )Je t-;.jllJ )15 c--6,1pL.'i 6.*!.fc-.2:-9J-*-r ^i-6€ oy.! U c*il.: J-al3-.i-,r.srl;lr-a r;1r,r, p)\-el
ri rJ*iU GsS _t J,"r, ,-l.lG GyC :* t 6 l_, 6h -f 4yiu;4orL 6 Lf A"l ctrr5 +iL*;lq d-rUa ,c.-l f;t"dr.*"-J aS .lt^i,yriy j.G, L rt(rL a5.gyt-i.rL7,rr:LLotlr
"r::c s *f61; LL; )-f b
.raLi:!.rL; :t Gs-ru rl{y;6 ;: 6 qt-(:a,i.uU o:.::b )JzJ )r- JLr! cs_r cslr {!aS : f ;:lz
"(' (Bishop of Rechester) ;*J ) , ;z .l ;;i q 4t, r: oLJr! .,-*^ d rb
crJ ":Li:-l LJ,.jjsiGVs:;bl ,t <S;ji.r:, r--: -L^IJF oriL.;ja S r- b r [ ;; :;la.;n.-"SE *5,r1- ;: .-ui pt-a.Jl diG crJl- c,*j J.*,.,,-1 a5:f -talr; c: rJ6a;),,i-r or; J1ri o,y-1:t;l SL^-,rs lk ;. J,j+ *jf ) S.,sr- r:-e.51 a1 oyU(Ii. B. Ashton) j*l .r;..qrl doLq-s .Lar;-S j'i 2: .::rS Li- $li--j.9:l-r-:-l .g[an,j;nullum crimen sine r::r5.r- ;tr(i- J)*\ J.-l ti ;l; ";_e-i.c-l "r; j! e.r a-
a, J,9: .9r=)) .J-:'<; ! J5 3r^ l:,:\ i;ts olJ, .rL.rJ c,ljt+-.-a n.r1L-r e.,o
_ poena
".:;b ;1 .-1!*.gla l-,u- ,8 o=, n+-i _,1 ut- .::r3; r- oU(:;iG c,tjU:
t.ltL-, JLojU , ,! k- .JiU , Jr;* ..rL" oi .,' d - :3;ut .sD; f tt *t g; j )
.t2*r/ u"{- ;r)J3 e-l), }-i "+tt c-l <.rcL-a-l
I . H. G. Wells 2. Declaration of Rights of Man
WWW.AEL.AF
\fO Edlgc,6-:Gj-:bll.
jllLJur L-!l.rjL-,r- oJ,-G.; l1 o;L f cc-*lct)Gl"|,1,i n.L.:,t .-f t*6k P Gs; J 4r;l oJl1r*a +5.4Lac-1':Y-l'h-" c'$a
"Jl oS aL7oi
cg!lj;: cc:,*l619nb €-* "Li-, rtE y rf p a-, t- .:y',r" Jt r!,gp ,j,- 6f I r;b ;ll;,:i 6jy J,=, t q ;l a5,r^1:e.r.*." lJ-S€
.>;l-li.:y--3 ,F; 3ro;: oi L-r: SL:Su- -,kllolQ,f;5 4Ly" l: s-fr-t.r-Ll.u 6;2j.r 1r cL
-sl6s, dr*ly u:: j ;;U S;-l ,-F p ! Jrij-" -rilri,r"rr ,rs -*-.,t-i:jljlcr-iU a:^il: ry+y sl tSs-t.id tr Jtd-:l U, "l< y' J c)j^:.,)
aS :-K. f "a +!./ ot q5 r,*i.-r- *.K Ut p_*e j>yj-y >l)i
*ovl ",e-: ;r-l3 c-\*lL nlL.tt uc j.a)1 Lra^-, Gss u. rs4p. J;;fL-'a- yr l; jlail,- J rat #j ,t-$-+ ttf 6j ,tlju" 631 6
Cir" ILL -s> rls6Gl oS I^)s-! r1Lj-i rr.r5:t L- );* ,uf p ;:
rr;l>yj-;yt c*.re9" .<-1 jl .rJ 6 t-5.l'"r"*"J 6 li-$l.," srJJi6,;l l.s:../ U-. J,;j .:1;i-rti:l!;f f- )* a, a5-:_9*f !.:y,-f:-#,e e-U t-i<(s;aQ, 3 o;l* 6rl;in ".r-i6 t-:+"Vr..ll-6.7;rg;L^e,:-;..i Jtl" 4<t ,r-)rj -,r cgbJr,, : *V:\"[:L; te"oi 6 ett_#e ;x^i: n6.<.-r! a;rl;Td".*l! o_*r-/ J;s y os,J,1gilanLy
t>->j 61sa."tjy ot,l,-i" Li eli 6LaJUt5 fL*; J &15 et 6 ,?tcr-11;;a,"Liy yL o3,-..-a ,)1 6Gi qi -r';,-,a.Ab.,,L:* ,t-S g :l; JrS
.$rl$ oLi"-l-r )F));.-t,rqllc)t al )l s*.;L*l, 6y- ;l ,g,K;L ;,"r::.1 c+Ll; ;-l ;rrr,ri;T.:"r 4-:-J-;1 q #q-f u,!+ jEi jl d*-a 6 t_*g ornLlr
a-j ,\o-r--i,J:-" ">Ur 6-r -, 1.: 5 Jlo:rS ,J'U y .S J--r, 6ti ,isn-,;-S; r-,1.c..*lr .i-al3, )fJ 6)p -.i.Jl5; -t-ir 4Kt a;:rt sj.}-4-i c.a- 3 r:*lo:3, L Yt,JLK.i.-.
)t a)\Lal \ )$s; A;;l;.gt3;rcJ:Sg ool-*l "-.iY.i" "-b
t;6y- )l )aX u.t-lJ:rc 6.rJl-
l. rationally ordered world 2. progressives
WWW.AEL.AF
,j'tJtn \l'P
.$-lt- !r l, 64;; ory',6ajr'" 3i ^S J:-,a 6jJb.,JJrl6$lo-5 ,y-.: 4*K Jt- -r:A ;,-." .,t J: c-...."y_S JJU ,Jl; ala, ,;-*f ,\6 dr-t a-+a a-:l- c.:iL rt-*iu ,slllsta.5y;ty clc6:1"r^:-l cJ3r 6jl.t-il ! Ji l-u \--t 4:*",6 .fu lr53,"r cJ3r rr .t-i.:3,
.Jt-i.(+1t'J", J Jqt-j aa23 6,siArr-iL c--il-r \u3I*",pU
Ubyr*
rA c.-*i +5.r;1.[ :_fs 6;] J_* t6_SL.-, cr) ty €.J:5 l-tt l_)
6--a.-t*l! o-ui.j +-!lrJ ol-t- c.Jj: t^ ".; e-lfl :jtl g ,Al-3L*; -t*! -r rjlj.j 45 >;lri :3,--3 cr.St - JL".f o_tJi J.,ri:3J-+L*; lJlK*ri,, y"tS, -t-.!L o-L-i -btJ p.:r"" :^i*" ,;1,o1,i,*"-:ljicJ;.:
t,..x:,L a:of;;lr.i rLa;jl t;;r" oy,*j3rt .i-jL 3:l;ir.a; u"- 6 Gl4 t&.2 oL;;.: .:*l,(*. +J't*" ,rl,a:JlJ) ((4,:-4a) a-"5 cL.ll .-t-! ;{U:L>l cry',r" )3J>..0 J-t,t' *J.osst' 6 qtj" a, l;,ti g*fi-6 45 c.rj ..ri jl Jt- '$Ji J. dt .l
c.r---l.r ,Le 4lf -,, .)-3 C"t cld."," ..r5,r" ,P ,*oLj Jt.;'U.grl-r-:-l '>"j9* q
F.o:^*" )* 4.3 i:*1rtS;t-U cl9;U c-3K- -E; t6st 011:lcgly 1; r:J3: 6 JtJ lL"j 6 -*l ,;_fi c[.il.:y*i.r".ra:"
.-t-iL q*ilr rti:-el r-tl* .i-"! .bly- af 6rl-,a:31
y.r .L-acJ!l t\ 6_h\,e> j o_h O*U c:*_r a, ,r:- 6;,1
c--alft^j 4jts" ,S€ 6tVil Jt;t,J"l5 Jrs1 .:::ty aS ;lj>rJ[._l;I.-cE".5ta;35 \d Li CS t* +r cJ-a.r,r,o c-*r 11 l: >Fc-*!- -+;6 c*lo:1: dtjj t6JJ,.l5 oi 1*.c.*tolX oVl615_r"
q5L-ac-*!*,5Lapral j l o.:t-"'-... 1 t-i,--t 6L,oc--Jjl a-b +;[^-ro Ht-i /j tlc-+t o_*jls.it^- ;-/G ,:* As}i,stc*l;icrK"l.grL,^il
J*.j c-JlJ drlq -;j*6>Lailc*t=- nl.."y q rS.ll .tt; *lSL,.
4-.:.U-.,:._"L.=Ut .(- c.*r ;: [iro-c ,ft- UL^c^.Jt*i J CU- 6 S.f.<-," o-l
"[-"-o;: > j-. o-],rb L" c-.:.,a 4 q], fU; t 5 6lerqY 6 ,S:-*
l. in posse
WWW.AEL.AF
\ f V o ,JiE crr5> _s ,.S j-:btJ
'd c.*!". 4 glr: ryJ>.."1t L-a .:Ut<"! lil .ry JJL',,,L *,Ut
a-, 116[:-,, 4-,*,i ]y J-S\,*V gg_r,,a/ttK;i JtolU 6.jLli 9
yr;fitKa.l.;.ry '|-,L
+5.tL;i,51; Gls s CS :-* a, c;eiua >1rr
..t-i r>Ljlr-t-:,-L-i oJ-aLL." ,F t: \ 61so-L1./q- ,Jl^J"q
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
,:l****.*-.ll S #dLffii$$ #_d;S
.)U*;tJ.r;; ti J;S l.;L-a.ojj !i JF,,rrC-l
to+,rr^
a-!lr" r;3-" lJ Jt-iJtS J* -1_r- c-"-F ! aS u;l7sa.l.r' jlg-,t"-t
.-J&LJ d--! Yo-t--ic-*l
La .:t-,r:il "i- 45 JjJI;.j crJ--)/ .r-ilo.rl: llf+:-l9.5Lrc.Jt-.r oJ^7..* pG; 6;1.rrJ o;lr16rl-r.:-1 6:" L; t\lt)l6s--ljtr[5 t ..y -r--ti r,J.*"t;, .li o-;t Ki Ellsl.>13-.a;: cg+ ai
dL*.r;: d--q dLp 4F*" s o-tli, d.l-l-,cr:J o;1:lALti,Jl'S
l-,Lr,c.*l .(;1153*:.# 4i r"i" r:JL""Io5 Jt".1j! r,rar.tLi
t+-J .-=l-,J" jln-5 c*l f * 6ysuV_r.i4r!* 6Laa-aJl;ri-r-rrri.tu.ar,;r" L" or L., rrlra;a-.Uy I ,;6.l-fi:.c,--1; -slt:f J L/t*.J-: ralJ, JL"cf A;.:L,"51 .r);rr" , (W) (4jtlJJLuil s.ilr^ yl 6 c-ly r\,-'.4.:; 14* l cggLa:il.l1y; uL;r, a.t : S* )l 6"cJ1i,crly--o a,
coJ-X4;r:2LeUy a-^"t-- &-;r ,JV, yJ 4-i cd .l-a:,r-r ..Jl-+Jl [-o
.:YJn hlj-F.4-4a a-, l;:3.-- aS u;:ye;r,.r*L- u*liS j">tt
ct"L^.,ii=idllJl,".j-- .tr -u-l,L a:--i 1.r pl-9.: Ul i,-* cJ:5 .:3-t^" 6:La-il
l. Hellaire Belloc 2. directed economy 3. commander-in-chief 4. Stuart Chase
WWW.AEL.AF
6rrJtl \f'
a5 o--7,ti1r .grlji,t>;5 L^-, ! ri .r::^*a "lr-*a >k'; ,i .J._l L <yJ-"*"
r--i-rj;: 6*,.9:l;ir-uiL {! t- cc.-"^a 6 6X::,l,rt;;r;c="at-S4 1,-$1 jl a.5 .,jtJ ,"lJr ;*.,o a: .r-,,ri f*ly; c*) 4J Yl3 .gt-a;rrlc,--L-- 6:l*r:il ai:+-r -rr 6& t-l.,s tlLJG .lrl, * e.V;l-t il
.-LS.,"
:Jl-,.S J*:t" ,-lti g:6"tf j-r+ yo>[L-l.r;3,.6LaJY-r:-l
jItJ U "t-;t-9 6;so-"\ J|.J::S.,- t1j,:,"aa lJ Jt-aiI",,-r-J:i.<.Jl.a
3 o;L- ,_5t::.<-i l- tJ+J tu. a-*;J ;r S JSr-l Lal r;ly* ",ljc -.**al,r,
J-lJ- jJ:i;*:1 ory' )lJ, dt^lJ, -*S q ,S e Url YIJ +&.r.Jl
rt!g-!-, f-: c*,:,1y+ *. Lfi,glj1:.L.g:La!l,Jt^c-Jt- Jf S,r;
61y,,_*l: a:.t!:-r.5lr-, .rUt-ilfW t +! qJl,S.-r, Ly.-* 6X)Jl- r, s 6t-5.* j)L g;rL jl-r-al-r;3* 1: upWl ;t-& :t ry-..eb:1; r3.--.lLa!1,",-r:c/ gc\; l"aoT.-,L :t C\& ilJu.".:y-.gto;t;lU 6
.trrt',-r :\ 6s: JJYIJ Jr41 cS-y \c*l ;-l -u-,sir_t (#) 4r >G:.cl ;1 jl :l,il J{l +5 ;qJl r+iLr.-L
c*l ;Yp J- .J-: JLr! .> ; ti, c6>L4i,t'5 x, J .-r-: JL"r!_ .r;.ri 6lJ L^Jiai c.*1 dy d.f-ly cI-ll.:-llf ..:**alfJr d+;: -,: L<j 5,- ,l-rK GE l: L- 6;L.a:ilqgtnc*Jt* ,5:l;i q-ra; 6 S.f )FaJ c*l-tlp rL.i:cl J--l J4l--t;t-.oltT.c*.i or-l J"*;j F ,*,li-<.*" .-tjrl: :;r+-l,J - t -il.lal ,rl* jl l+G -e.grL,^ il -il.r-al)_trJ tS* d,,13 ,("r?-i) jyr;l-,, ,tl*il .-r=tS -- ,",i ,1_2," )l Fe:*o! t .-r**t qg.:La:il f * r,jC ,>ls j>r,,Jt^cJl- 6Qi ot1l,-c ..:11.r:
6l.5rL ^ it ,F\* L{J "<! .:;lli ryr. -.r \r,d:L,o:!l ,13t,,6*.;.p:
..rU -,r ei.l:S,_y -in ,-!l.r,ol J-t- -bV tt_,t, ;-,; -; e5 -ij;l::3.-3
A;l-:." a-. "8,-* ,t--.J ,; o,L-U ni5.rL^ $l r;At,tcgl".-t..1J t* *.Jy*-il..t-al a1 .rl+-) 6ly ,> s.l-i a-1 _UL*j L-*-,€-* j^-.a i +1 &t^iI . economic molive
WWW.AEL.AF
\f\ I :l-t":-l j ,g:l^ai\ J;-S
cJj,, 15 r:*lp.: ;,1 a, cg-.:S,r, ,-n>[ J* -bo yJt t.c-*t oa;"--ii
)lj jt"Jlirl ;: uL--t-ar,.),t.gLo.l jl,lr.,.: .:jJ ;> l; .-,[i*:Jl l;gt:oU,Jyl6t-^.r-i;> lJft.i A) )d;rr a-r-"E;: 5 6t7.li jl.-r-a:,r,"
oJ Js,r" &"-.J tr r,l+*a,Jt sr.j -P 6l:6t-ac,-.:9-t-*-" 6 c -,1
c;--lUl..t;L--a;1;; Lac-.-rj.r-*." ;lrL*f plc" J) JJi jlrs-,!tr,trsdl:
'rr_f j; .<{ ,?} ol;1 a5 c*l 614=*j ! -rr^,1.:r5 +;i
U;J,fJjlF" Jx g-& q5 c.*t,ri;c*;r.::L.r .,"+;r a5 c-*l Je ,-,-1l .c*1 o.:r5 ;J.- o:SU * 45 c-l 6:l;i6la1l;.11
.glc,"lr -+t3(.f l-p ,5s,, a, l; -rti;Jl tt 6$;lc-4 +:,1r oy.-.3, a^.L-
J--q U...t.j.ry oJ*rj oU; olJ- ^*K dL^,F jlc5-,q*i q;irtr:":o
a&t+ )t )*b -;t.r- (;t, ;t € 5;r l; J;* c--".r; ,al c-*al
,t-tc-;q-r jlcs-,!n p ,,tnJy, S1ott I rri5.:La-il * St^"f,,Jfu -r )J*i dJlJl cJj..>yj-c a, 6oiggt-7 a,l.ajlr[ "* j\.c--*.a
A<,.-" Q rolrd: i o;$ Jt-rf 6t^c-;3* cel;L:"1 t".-fr* .:1jr1.;
G_* c-1,$./ orl: to o J1riL-otb ,gLac.-e; c;p.1g\.&\ p.qS -*3 r.i;I.[./kjl ,)Vl -&t JtSr::S(iUJ: a5.:y ralr; L^",11*
6 \ u,cV J* i".+-^ a(! oi.rlll Le;j. ,jyt f*t .."^-r" ,li a, 6.J:5.," W t JL-/.:j.l,.li ;t
dJit, 3 :;1J )fJ LS1;IA:A.5>L.^'jI S f*6a Fr, G. 6 a,KA.:t$ ;r dL>-+a +5 c.*1 cJE tr dLi L- dJ.-t, Gr.c 6;l.a.il ,Jti 1,.
J^lJ= i ,jc..--l; ,c-*l oLjL 6Laa:*13,- -r t^jt* o;L1: L Sj f**:Li3 6>l--":31.:Yt;" a5alq ,gt e ty! t) 1; c-ij> gg, a:*a 6:3,
| ,gllj; J $; o-tal.j--. c,s-ylK uu |l Jf t.:.=-at"S -il.r-al;L*" .(11 i/-1.trs 5;: -rJ-Ln:u.tl q, .-Ipl 6 6rLa-il oGr*, gl.t')\,d.tL-, U .rl;irt,:il 4 -,.: l"ii 1"1 -:F,_l qi -t1.\ rLa-il ,511.:
Lionel Robbins, The Econornic Causes ofWar (1939), Appendix
2. pecuniary motive
:L q2;-.\
WWW.AEL.AF
,J't J, n \f Y
6>Vr:il,)Lj ,g,"J$;L;;l;r lJ 0t JlJ".lpL.j 3 ,r.i;r pL"j a:l.:Uia.;lr,!
,f.- La'rTu:;3ir, a, -;:Li a5 -r\L^j ;.;;=.,af-S jl tii lJ L o;ly*a
,il;.: a.5 c*ljt-16:L^:i1 uGr*rr.rLj c9.r.y dr+ r-5 J-^lJ; pr2-,,
4 j aS Jt- r, c,,,;Ij.( _2t5 l; :-9,- c-^,tt-s LSL^jt.J f*l:,.f jJ- dT
oiLgrL^ail J)-tl )l-,:** rt"*t rulo:l: c*.r )l6 ek ;;1t 9.-_6,terl-r. yl ,rtf tyir, gg.:L.a:il \lss -*t. $li.r*J ;^- aS1rl !.c*l;: c*l )*,,".oJ.trs Se; Lr;* ctLj;r l;otj.l-! t, cS c.*L*"
; La" 1_9-.* Lg)L,ajil .:lr-; ,r!-: olLo e1 .15:Uajl cS{1, 4 r-.,_r,
CU q.".- yf<" dta;" ;);.r)1.;,56.;'U t* dt^-,[i njr,.l 11e-iL-
.L(t J eltd -uq a:xlr rJral c.*l;(" )lK,l6>Q$l.d,aoui 3
s--i 45 :1ir: Jxl t1|l.o_s-tt' _,1cS_,!*r )l .f3 e$ jtigrjYly
o:r.-r,\r. i,'-< J-9,-l clt-c"" -t, ;-5,l;lr.i L5)1,-SldlA?:.lj : )lS it*J c.-^rt jl ,y-! L- c*l ,;4, L ga_s S:ldl ,b tt qi +S .l't- yt6 ek r- "ti*! a:-,t,l: :U:pl py )Fe e-! r"lyl.c-l sltsf J.a-, .ril3;,r*: ryUK, ,-3l rg>l-a:il.)\L.; 1"las 6:';rjll,gy;+.1;y -$L
.-r-! Jlt rr6)h dtl"/JJl CV S+ -,*-i:jc-^at"S L LSly .9:L ^'il 6Lau.rl .c-t ;it-E; 6r3,"*^t ;r,_l ,Vl
+5;-l o;Lyr e# g*' elt.b c6sla:3i .)Y9i" 1: 5 p: f,cl q "t *,1*< a-5 6;_/oL",a,t*.f--.:ljir,c*lJc.'*alft t" rf* (Sk \I Al,u,?u;6rLa:il
"lit- 5
,-;;*.a nLrr dl G_# n*"ta;r +5yl "}J.r
a,
d.t-j Jr:;S a;L^" a-., L" 6rL.a:il ,Jt^c;l.s 1: dJ.i Jrs.r-.S J- +!fK:^ - ,Jya.1* g-s rt;t l1 :3,-- ,Jrx.nra 6;,1 -fu *l*<i-"^,^ rt"t-;le-,LtU q ,n-&.;i o.r-ioLil l;oi4t c,sVra;:' -iJ^ Jlrl
.s r.^tr Jrs e*45 c-+ ,l)G-e 6rLa-il tStLuEt L*3: ,x37h ol';c;trU:^J,J ,Slr 6.i"t y -S UUjt; olj:.o a- lr Ai-i p;! r:U +! [i1. <filthy lucre>
WWW.AEL.AF
\ ff n :lr;-l y 6:Lz.5l JrJ
-5 tri! LsjtJ J-"q U Uj+S c*tr-l4J't*..fS t"rt,.5"7 ,1r.1,
c-.ataS l- gl_* 6k q 3 r:*1 f.6- L ,S1; 6k q tf e 5'*.t#e ^:tf ,a-.- 6.:t-,r:i1 ts*lJ L-; -*l e-l a5;lL- c,*-1
W pt-(- - 6 U,.tt+ 6t.^jL; jta:-.: oi_i kj g;rLe^il ;tLu|t.c*:U< J-lF il r-:b ..p! t:6:L,r-i1 G,* e6tV "1*2: ;*"i;;g1-it a;-b "Jt+l+U f.-t rttltif .,r 1" 6 c.*lL*" jl-r, yl.6il9;:
.fs.f .,lt;ak,\.*,<6 f&e-uilf.f t-{;jdj $,r" ,.:"-l.t-a l; Lg)L,oil6L^s;t- ua aS .,it ti"+lL c.r.:.5 Jr;:5:yl.: -t5 s -e *, tJ-l! d l-, J Ju: )l ,s4y .-u.[^j,r-. J-# It L --il.t-ol +.-a 6ly )3Ja..c 6t-a11;l o4d; d,,1;3.o-a
+-*,o,g1; l; L-a;111cJ5.r- Jr:S tr 6rt-a:.ildt"sJl- r*a 5 ,# *or23i_r.,QEt.rS 6 t-K F*-, $-!
-,at.qq -t S,-l J;S i [, -il-ral
qg.rt-.":il Jr::S .c* t l)\5 dt+ . g!13 ; r ;rl .r:5 r, I ji rlc<,{U5 J . J-f
.-t--:t l;4" ta":;. -3-t )l * .^*;.tt*;lJ-u, jl.,i;.i J,;S e;.: l; Ln;l;l J-iG-* ^5,r,J 3.r:*L -il.lnt a.*a.gly l,o;l;1J-5r.rlri *J :6 a, il-r,alflls q 5 J.5 Jr..i;,.*,r:*"{U );l) Jl,^rlca-.p)t- t* y,-r_21: rj,,-L ftj" .(iflJs:;Yly lLi" LajjJlllJ5gtsM\t.J:5 )Ui srlral 4" 6G s J:";,\ c.-xlr -t-U Abty! +1t-a,tL;l
J- Ll..:7l Li ,r j 6q \c,-!U 6rl,^il .l't*" cS r:*L*, a4 tsf -rJ-jq._J c,tio-u,-L-i U-;r+"^ *-! 1t":rt 6 c*I..)ifjL-- .rrl$l.r_.e,-l
., jy *.*' JL; dt-^j$ 6- c-"alo;L;r 5.,,1J-:
"Lr*, Jl:.r^ oJ-ey [* a, clll;+"U; a\Lpl *. "S 6!.a:i,l .5.:1;i
J f:-iq or3*iol-.rj;6:La-illL- J- o:st'jl{q U +5 c.*L^"
-$ f -b;r L .51; c.*l .li ujY J;l 45 c+li LgL!-.,t-*jjl a5yl
,-41-a;l1l L.6k i-qp AtV,t-,.r" Llly' c-ftj 6la,;irt.r_d.s"c.-lJa p:aY A:Lail611a,Ly.cJ5," frly U JqU"^ 6 6.*.4 a:-13
dl.aJq; 1l cclT;l .,4->9,>lua, .c.--llr .r^lf ,si ;r l; L 6 ": S'qr"
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jt_rJrl \ff
V u$-S L _,t5 c..-ot, jlcclk-3r,e o:l9jti !t- 41_t_, V $-S U qJyl
l; :y; rCt "tfl J;5) r I ra.o[i; a5 :_2b r3*. _9 cdLc..clr! ,.rGyl jl o:l l:-,1
'.*.<; Jt rtJi JL^l,l.;l ),, r^lr; j"6 t, dp G6t;: ,; ;;aui1 ,>yJot-1rgr,2a-"Uy a--"t-- &-qft..r:-*,-,ti:jl \ r)e. J-# *: y.:rri ,d-S r^l1, -,5 ! l: qS .5to2l;l J 6+ofrdJ- lr lt"r-t_5t t *\a::,lr,r**,;l+, .rlyi,rJ l, uer*; GGx: J.6J-:uV..,cJ..alJr-s/ ,!, o5 tlli r;;ri;: .r.rr5 e-? glay'U -rr oJ5-i.,"a.o
^S J)e- ,F -,:,.:t.Li d,.-16.- ..:y-, r-olr; -)y o:-u a-,.r-iL r1_,1i
6tt oi Jr:S c.*il: J:,a13,-;t^=l 1: us)61;ari1.4r"t- "(-;r .rt ti,.:y .tolr* rJ;
c.*t yly:-l (kilJ yl ,,Lly ,_iU-1 a*.te 4 _rr L ..rk;l .grl-1i
Ass C&) -.€lie r:5 rK;l \1,61-^j11i AVst LF.: ,K- -St 6.(1j .r3- f"^ty; yl rtl:;..r-i gJ! ortr f tt*;l.i- ti Jl Ul .g,;-r!
)f) J-.li f tt*;t .-/-Ji.lu..jJ$ JS.r, o;lrt l; .5rL,^:it fllr Js 616a- l; .:1J-! ,-,-,-l.fE in+ 45 g"..t c-.--; 6jU n5 Jt-;.: .:y J-o13,>
Jt-r, 3cJ:Sg &'re_p f tt*;t&-6 t-Se 16 a' 63;o:Li ce:*l JU .S.r."b -Fl.;e- 6>Vl p;uia,.>:f *. Oi -t*; Sorlr Lo
". &-l; "a P s 6k q 6 t-&f*-^, [i e--:l: J^lJ, sLl.Sg \ s.;t J;J L-6Yg +-a e5 c-j ;-l m,*-r- t<i.j.r_1.x.f
a::"_t i ,Ss*. c))Ja L..r;51"a .i;5,r" JLs! cS.:Lail J;S 6 .5n) ,f l a.-a J;5 .r- .\G. tS- JF _it ,t ,S;* € b2rr- ,.Li ol l.t+l :: .> si.su ;.*: .ra-11+ 4;La jtlGs\ct troi ;y- lr), *. j tllJ.3u; jl u*t* ,jr;, -, ursV )sl;: c,!,L,lK-xr oS.:-l o:br!!iJ^, p:7rg[;L! Al":tS .A*.*Vt.r,;g Frr.l"5-rl .el-l;: .-rS ,;J; ,g:; .g:lr\ 15 - J .r+lJp.:.:.L, ;-- ,.!U J--i.,-:-i o|.:. o l;il-t:^i1i ,51r. I ;e o. - sl i 6{a;l,,1 ua ,}S ,S_f yc-, .15- :llil o ,i ,J"l5
"}:J*JL yL:5 .i.."-; :l;.[,.r5 .:,;L- -^-; :t;i f: :r: +5 .r"tK.,a .c-l - rJ,.o .91r, l(,J* ,;s- q9Lo11;,1 a.:y"r* ,rarLi g*L^i qg[a",;l;,1 *^: 45 .,"t<:a c:r;1 ,r>;l- o]auo-lje ;Jr JrS ,sF-":l.di urSr; +5 c*,1 .rbj.= .glr- L c -l cs*_) ,J;e
.-u:,r" JLrl .-r*r 3 o.r,Lo rtjj 6lf dL" 6lacJ3: L-_i 6 c-l JF jl ir.-.l.]
WWW.AEL.AF
\fO D:lr;-l 16:L4l);S
,f|re; [a.li ei trJ-ol3a -l>L! +(L o;r blf C r: ;> glyrti.o
n5.5la-.-.;r r.-a L ,,a8,*1,-r* -r..x! ljY 113 J5 i:rr*J." \l-aoyJ 9L-r: tStsu|tl* 6 1r:i ); r, fl.t3,- Jl;- L,i{,; r;1; r.:-3r
,glr. oyi yl6 c--.:l.r .rr-rri r:-! dig tj.r-#,-f .:,-[.- p-f -*.:.+,J _iliU J t1,*,,-* $y._rlLi"
"5.r*:, .r.alr; *f -,6 a,,ril.r-al
f:rls Jl 6 ,_*,5 GeU^l
..:-l:y-r-,.."U t+rd t_ye JL"ef t^c^+ -,4y JF tl 6 G15S gt,,.,jl:l Gk q.S\; J,"! 6 dt^c^+ ! ,,-ilit c,,t ..(1 -,:jl6yrtj, ! q ,t#1,5-&t ,g;-a 61119l-s 6-* *;13;,r" rlT.l.:
c-+ J-"1 .ft5.f dSU
lJ ',-,17 6llcl 1-l- ,>r$ u" t j 6 -fl-,61^j."e-r ,-rr!:-: jr, ,S-- rSt t .t-*r-*.f.=a, .Fr^ +jl-aKi..:l;1 ol.."y q
.d A-rti l; Lag,."-r-) r,t- g,:l;ir-# fL.j olf :Q.b rSlt.rL-.il.ulttJu;1.)r-, 4 -U-i..it -rl.ulJ;as l& q t, p tSss &, glfa>,lr; jt*<? 6[a1l;l i -&, c9t+ -rr 6 ttf ,gt qil9
,..,r1 q dltl-t -&.r;y-" ,--ilJ-ol .rt-.ti" +5 t-7.ti*-r--:c--l.t-o rL,aJl .i- -r: .>-/,-s,
6-fu.9 .-il.ul r?J \.(J s5ly l-t )f6La.r;.ti Q;,.r:s.r" .;U;;
+l! .L t-.* J-&Wt .cr-S .r:alr, tS y -&t -!l.ral;y 6i; )l.r,:-.il: c.*-r) J{ta U".r-"! l-t tS* of 5..*l ollg 6rfu> 'f ,* },&.rrri .:>[-t-r." a5 EAi1t J i$.r,-! 6j* g 6 $,l J..{ dtV o)e- i.r.illr l;clT4L"--alr11 u;s:,* glrr ,.xS "_S -* it:rs ;s4i6.< ly .tL.r-i;: "-#c r,K V
". a.-S 45 r5.," Jj:S JU" L* tt
€er.ri;, Lt-t r;> L J dKJ::S.e ).s oljo q U c.+rt ;: tgJei cLl
.rr.r5,r- 6L;alyn I o;b ,f,i.l l;6 ora)-91 jKt;:.:Ltn 6:11lr.:=ir.b
Cr-1.:-,5l-lJ,,1".c yq.r- ;j.iKJ:s! i ol* a, L c.r.'.i,;," -f P.L rl.g;t.- 61y 6ol:-*.*a y i-r..i! U- e jl$lidi l, ;K*; qJ J)
3 J-a.r,r-o Js"iJ l, t,;t(.u, )S )l;+d}.i".1Jl'S ,3ly ot'^l'-!r,.a bl,)
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtt,lttr \ft
il: €e Jt:: tiJTL 6 ,-lt-t_eoti')3,"*" t" J,;j 45dti,-.^jlr:c^=*aly;-"VUur-tcclLll5 -,t-.:it 9 6:\i 61lri, (JScr, !.",j
.c-l oL..g.rli, ,1c>il;.rt-eL d* -,t..rL.r,i;, C-r tS>lti
1t '.*,6:Ui;l Grtt-6.7 ,J-R,, r;>+5 c*l c+;)r,J--)rc.r.l
f.6r Ul ..[;l: ,$ ..,ti:jl jlsl; c$f )JJ,.o d*.r.:,, -tolr-- :_9.r-,."
d d*o a-ily .r--*V JU q -'t;lU,t,6.gtb
s,B.-tl L 6 c*l ,tiorr5.-.r[jiJl a*K;: r:*l ;fu. 6.f.iJ t" cl:*l oJ-..l ./liil V Slllr JU--E Jt U-r,*:q J."-.J J"U,.c y"l5 qr_r ,K-;lc+Syl 3 g.":,t
64 \, a5 r;lr : j--3Vl; pi Sly,r-al; a-,-",tLj,f++ G&, yplz L-l; -* 6:^..r-"r 6j, a,6;[51-ri 6,;ltin _*r-r,a a,.r,!.:*rlrT-r:tr;; L" e -* jl .,.x$ 6a aS rjL,r^, ,rrtfl;t jl jJ.",.J J"U
J;rt* 6)2p glr .-#! ,.ruli f f Jt.r|- _e r-r-^r E, b L,-l;j ,.>..>*, 6)u1; .>yye J) falJj./ aS..ratSi j,l ,fJq a*il-rj ,5',l[51.r!
Jrti l, &"-.J ,j.li *,5Lac-ir* jlcS-,!*t -&t e-n jt c,.,5 r1, ./5.rjL.r".-fe;
d-4, , -* * t" jJS o16.7 ;.: r,.:Jt-- ,,1 ;: 6 c^*i dJcl #*,gl-a,,>.--"5 r_:.+ .(:,_1 3.c.*l ory ,..:> Jl; {.-:i< 1: L .:*l s 3> *)-t*;L L7;l.r.;*i, fl+;lcJli,r-'J dt-lrl..r+ f -t' tSs_t &.:ti-;jli aGi ;$ \ *s -,* y xlie c--39-,,grK, aQ -*c--yS- ,# Lf 5 c.*l Ji {<j l,l .-u,5 .<"5 5r,;
",i1}13 .:t-c)\!l
t6'-,:a-,U;r l-oJtj- .4t :* il.q* sr../ .rilll l r>-ayk\ Srrl_',;a-"Liy -,1cS-,!* .t_#e
"f^r 3 flJ.: Ltye * tt JJ5Ig 5 c.*l
rlji-rtj;jl c-U-J? o-r--i.5;l;a."li-r dk? ;.: 6 J:-a:..r.o oJ-ca c,r:r;.: ar L
dL<"l jl &.,5 * l.ali 1"l .c-.!! .r,alg ",illl ;--
j Li,- a.lLi:La r"!i^:
-t .pl-- \ sS;._t -l-L r-r5 glLMVt r^l_r=.f Jt.*,"r.r" oJ.o3 ,j,in:t'Q*.lu;S Jr:5 t; y).*A L-..rfr;bL ql-r: t- ce3U:," .5L^,.)Jlnjr.3Lac.ryJ.*-"; bJF ,fr &llJc6lsa,. 1o.l*ia31j-j r;13* +o-a
WWW.AEL.AF
\ fV E )l-t:-l r, d)te:ll Jis
e" Li ,;;rS ;rra jt .-tJ &-S -,t5 t 6 ,y .-*l^tL," u)sl sre:F 5ll(,.r-l(J-, *-S _,6 q y Jt^rf dt(.?;: .r>t3.5y;uUrr gU"
.5.:l1i,r..r*r -r;lr; q )_*_fn"[i-: rl;T,-,t-*:jlrr ' U rf,-f j!
.ty.t-: ,F elt. G-* oJ--ca crJ-.1 r^l3, JV ";^^ ,* *. rrot.,;il
d.4L+ J )_# Jt^ct rp4 -i--! :ty".ric-*^L 1: 6,-5*t+ g u,b.aptn rLi:.cl ts-+- J -U.^.il^ LrU4-:."j -f LE*./[iil ry ;13-L"l .ll-:".f
.-uiL.5y;+"Liy
,!){; -, or_;-+i :3J>.r Jt3;t tlly',rl:.tLL q t-, )f )1,anVJ. jsl.c.-.i!.:,r" )Fl jt:t r:3Gj J5
".t:; t, :l.t-i cL-l,.i d./1"[J,J t ,-5..r
La.r;t-; jt d-,t.-i ! frr- )t e:f e:.a )JJJ 1lc,ra.:ril:U j_dLF, 4..r5 CiE lr L-6jT Lf;.* -t* y 6 ,-tSl U -r..x,r^j c;1",Sly,l: .;.Jl 45 ,s;n* ,*-14 c>j) *f,3S -r^lf,-f S ,lV"\*J t* a: i cc-*l "t; ;i t-,rt( Gyr jr.i r 45 .,Li--:Ltj-r*..r*j -ij-,r1li; 4^"t- .(- r, Ltlt ,,-*[:,U t- 6$l tri(,.i,iOUtr;
L .:_9- ,r-:alr;,rL! l-a;L t:;S 611-K:,j_,1 .pS J> 1r l; .-.=...eJi t^.JiJl
;":a l"r-rl1.r a5 6Las ,,5 ,r") )lbrq y o.:,5 jGiJt" 6;L5l.re .(-L^&"Ji gttbVt fU" oS u.K^Ul.rr5 .r:-al3, !i lts r::-l #_r:J_r)i S\ L-i a5 6ta1.r-1.u5 J+ jl..,t-"-:11 s l_*.Si JS 6lt.l:
(c*;:;l-rJL-l Ay )l or4llj{:-"V 6 L.e;;.-t: .ral_r; "ry' S.rjl
L. s4l; .:$i a, :y -rnl3,.j;.:G f: cc--- J-9""r" 7y :t e: 6!\:-t*iL r.:rr,-- fl-;,_rtij[j !:*b jl -J,:a
o-S J- u t-r.e,2[5.i-
4 ! 1_,.Jt*r r -;V,ir )_*r p q *rU .rt-eL 45 6e;")s,ti"-ilf: rar,rr erJ P 6sr,.\*. 3:*L,l; -r,-t-i 3.5Sl.r,i;rslJr rliL;.,,,k7l ,_kl; bA et.jl.t-i:-11 L,lrJ .c--.:l: r^lJ;
W fJ! T-,l5 L.,-5;)l.ir d+ )ljiF: L ic*-xlr ralF ,rr 6J--s
WWW.AEL.AF
6'rJ_,tr \fA
;i.4tor;l$t-lq *"! ""^
L rr;b .i):l €e fS 6.tta y g6$c-r:l:y,.- +i&S e)l*o.rt* 13-L, q.,:.4q 6t_sultt dt"jL 6 f.^,: L^.+rt ff .rjL cu;,tr .f,U l; "-t-l,or -* "*:;16;lcSl;.Sy .tar ,[ljJ &-t,-.[,l.i 6to.t-l_9;1 613.r-" .]YJ.i." a, l1 j[*;l .:\k;
..:f o.l.:Lj \,re}-r.-c,r! .gt o.r_98 i.r-,.;
-i-* -,1;16 6_h 6 ry .r.alr; yl61sa.L; rt(:i;"r," +7Jta-"Liy ;r .9:i .:\L; .trrS !t.^J o5 L+.ti jt- dlrr, ,trKl dt j,c"rJi 1r a5 .r_y talr; -Jt'a _,1;1 4 jl
"fu 6k ) j _c,*l dJS-.U
.r[-"t-i, L*t: +5 Yr,LL":a-l
i-, q \r,*rL.:t| oGll -i:JL,./t^dil ir.+
.tFe *-S _,5 t 6t_:u}1lJl "u3ra- -t-j;l: .:*".r t-t; ); r;.G14*"t- 4;: 5;l.*:..^al t:_f :> 6 c*l .it sl-, -c*\L +j[.-;.,, .*,jl:* 4t 6,r:*;.4-(l c*:i,-,t-i:jl ;["t5,5:lrTrrpJ, cLl.:3*i ol]l oli6,;;* + .lisl3io; *:1 ,tfi LJ )_# c--eUt J,-q 5 .:*l 6Lac*.r _f t o113:-r
.*l,J-*c*l ,*arK: c.l elt ,* oV*r" ;1 a.*a o;L;r
6_ql; uS gr-;Bl jir;.-+ .! jl rili,r-. (sk _*Lrx ,;.V, a,,t-- .(,-;: 6-,r
tuJl !*i, o-.,,ra- !Y13 cSb.fj-,1 ,;;l: )l6 u,;r," ft.-rl\*-t a:Jlr "jt+lJ+! t 6 J-X[ ;l.tlJ;;['. klr tSn:E:l,r(S1j,{ l,r-i l; oL;c-*ot"S UUjt! crjYl3.gLar, ;rl Li- IrL:. a, aS
.-,1*-- ! d-"ti lJ L;Uj ;.-l r>rK e)y b ,Slt.r:--U ..r1;:ll 6ylJ.dU c.r:")\- J;-\ +5;1.r1 u/; ;Sr.t'li q 9V j ucV pl;>lL;>.azj,[,G qg.:L 4-_r^ .5k q k, +l;e.: rilli_e;[i.:ilcc.J."+iic.*l;t(l
"l.rlJ rp.jlJldLs eJ cr:5./kjl+! #* 6.111,., ,t{.t
Ji Yi- 6lr. ,gtJ 6ss_f .gLa.91t5l.r-i o.rt-,T oli3l '?JJ
a-o-a 6.r.:--r u*i xf y"[16 -,, illr dl-Ad/rJl
1. social welfare 2. the good of the community 3. Cash Nexus
WWW.AEL.AF
\fq n:llil j 6:ta5l Jr:.S
ely sLj1; *.; fi*jli..r- L ca:Jl'f5.r ei {s;4 q te-
cr:; ir.r jl l-t l-, +--r"o a;-14 .f ;l f.-, J+ii ,w L.tt J;-ltt_,-l ;r"^ _r .gJ &"*J -S-&, Gs: 6+ ,:lt;i uo; q - LaJ.."il
..1c.,.)iL* t Jst"*t, U t-^,ti;.r +5 c*l ,3>V f1: r;3," rtl-lt; o-lL-lr
a-, 1;.rL..rl.St*,Sl^.J"j_,|I ctL.:y; gta.fj_,l ,7s-t *--h dt$../J;l d^-a
oiU" c-.r 6Virp o_tf ni Jt- sL*a;.: l, n+"lU f,jl$!,_r" ")l;*Jjli,r^i H S-$-t J"fu.f-i) L" de *_r :li rg>G;-bl- 3 t-t::S,r- --UJ JL-<,",gG;l;l ell.G -
.5tt Jt tr \A '
O.:t-p[ f- S.f W rr.fL ;9i3rr o;L;: 5 "Sr^
+5 r;L c-*l
,-a 6;l-ufl4-i Ja."l;-,1clja*" t.+-$,-t p le'jl e5 l.ib.rJ ga; c*l.c.*l-tLc -t-^r.rf tStLbVt ol; a,1; lr S 6k
L-orl ;--l oJ€ t3- L)i. rJ! a.rl jld+-a €)f .,+ +5 Jt- r,
JL:S 4J't*. dU;-"," *. L*i 61..r--1;i )* L.cJ:S.r-, 4_lr.*Ut
JJ-:'5lf- Ilo.:r5 .-JU" l: Sf -r tSy1aul.; '|1t*,
C+ :* o.. 6dL*A ! lt ,-ilit fr^-* .<+..ilJ[-S o.tJ,gi;+"U J. &V 6I;l_e.L."l
oi -tt6)Jo)+, -bG ytst ,ul1- )l -&" L-ooiic.;l:..r-alr-'.,l-r;1
U rjL.rr;r!,i 1; ...lUi.t;q J:5.," l:..1"-- #, ..*lt 4<! -u.ss.j c.-1.=
6l; J!-r:-lk;,_r-lc6il31.:.S CrnL I,t osljl,5rjdYrlc s tll' ryt,rJ )-S rlr" -r-S'U ))J-o 6J-- 1* -.rjly,./ cS c.*l tStsuVljl:;l-rib-l! V-b l_t os) eJJ, f.^l;r- €6 -Sl e5 c.-.i,b.Jli.r.J
F + f"-& f* 4jt^t<if.^lr.r -St,d;-'u."r-;y,; ra;.,-ll-l .{ er;*Uy l; L5)l ,^'ilf:^r- JS +! c-t--iL .u--il.: 6k \eJl-i-e jl.ll -,a Jir,rt";; g1; .i,-! t" 6 u:""i t-i+S c*qrt, i-rl.:lji6jt ol.-j q +,4*a 5 c*:i ,j* -,Lli -r ..*U-,Li I lp g,jb*
.& l.-f ) fi J 4r.6.:La^il g[a-9; dt"-iti
;l ,r5, ,(Colin Clark) 5;15 uJF -,1 3lt *-, eE frl.9l.f ,-ui -tl,iJl ;-l +r;.51r. .\uL:5 ;: .r-1r "+t ;,5 .s .5:1- 6ls,l3.t: .:rr e(; urj-! -9 g;:L-a:!l oU:rl,i;,;-i3r-:.):3-. -\- :t * S).*.:,l-Lp,:J -lr.:*t "f ,S-" f tff . ) g:La:3\:-s,;1 trr-t;;l-;,s+ rit ! !.lu:r "UJ: "i: rl 6:;;r oJt- f-e Lb a)1+ f 15 +j, Jt-.(- ,or*r" c,)!l ;: L;o 64 y c-* * -t\
S-rJl .9;l:70r.6, . . s f .s Jq ,_r;-r-. .gt"or:=lsc=*al u;!,-i y rLji,F cSlQ;t;, ,* ;*..9LoJL;: -ri7,c-l .--r,.lrG c-6,.J'L-",.Jy" CS ):+.l ! 5 c*l ji ,,ra- .:*!U I L; \.5 ok+ -,1 ,s;l-l 617 .[1] ,c-l +-l:blJ, "q! ,Jl- J., ;: y srY_rt ,t[.t--a ,:]-i .-$ .Jjr'!r" ;rul J"ji ,.f"15 Jti-ll ;:;: r,L; ):':& cil'.." o: t:.r, Ji- .Srl..i J{.- ;: S6:<j9G r." ArK"r -5\ ... ty'S-"SG/.,f .(- di 1oQ4 p ;l Ll .:y,r, t-!/"-r-*" .:,)Ll c*.r(-[r:rlJL-l:;l-tJk-l .! Jjt 6p )3 ! --:- oQ+ ,r*ly -ti;: ,L-l;rl y3:t t\*.J'L. r .rs-ul
.(Y-\ .oN) rr:1,r" +f!;l
WWW.AEL.AF
\A\ D rU.j-.1 J d)Lzil J 5
,-,.-lt:,r:-ly JLr La+*al; i/l.!tA" t, fl ,--*.1; .tL.r;* J,"li U?
c,rl;i :t*ai\ .SJ-;l,JIJJ) )l J-,.; G ; )4 tS ysMV lit.*jl 45 fr.-^ 4!.-)t"
;: crrL,ailc;t i i dL- ,>12 ,i":ltss o-.c-3;U.,gl* *|'llorc
15:l;iu j-s$ c*-+ cSjt-",a|-rQ 6e.l scc*l a:-i,i( )leel J*.Surt, f^j- "(." d.ill..Dq
\r,5r[.r:il.gta6:l;i,r fe )l j:*.,s,er*
qg.:t-r:il,-5 t: t caqf:-*aj 45 .r"tK:,l t 1 I 3: U jl .rJ l;3.r ; ; .r,-- .c-* I
-t--ol9i,r-*rlru* _t gt* ?J-Jq .51,h,-ljl.r-.1 6k \c.r-.l ..r,.r-.Li
;.r Jr-:S oK:-r cr-..c--ilr t#) 6:l1i olr--lli1r rr-i oJ +--,_e .i.:*l .:3"; .ri6 e_f :Q. e\Sjc4- _;-* &.-,.J 6lt ,-t-b)r)a;:,.tL.ac!t* jl air .ti n*^ Qs ,-r+ &5:!*r J_;5 6 .rt- .;.-.J:5.,- cJJt:" ;15..reL"-7t *-; :, ,-y--h Ai ;t g, oS cj! ,-J;3,-rtf oYy,.a---" ,rLlr jL+-a 4;j ji ;t 6 Slet: os_F ;t ;,-,
..r5 J,", -i:S,r" ./B-il 6 6+ _f c.*l :l;ic.i5 e ,;J;)f-,"-,,Jl-J bly> Jp;r .c+l r:3U:" >t"US .^.-; : o-rSljl .i-r-'L;: oi tt qJ c*l "rr5:t-,..,-l l: '*s_,15
ori3;r.j:-,eJ c.*l J-*;-l .c.*l .fL.:al r+i/ .<," jl s:;.i U ,5Lac-Jt rc-+.r f*lye t" 6 c*lJJ, .rl q t<., ly.; crll:J 1.lr,ti-;tr;;c,Ul .d L;- ;rS.gto:;l.rlL-l JJt" sJ- _,A:: lr 4iq,,,'!l;.ilq-J
ef ":" .,^)c.-6a Ju."Jt , clG-, c5l; ,Sf y,Sl-sbtt A"&laca;.-i;:.f-tfe diyj dr:5U 5 c*l.tl"j 1 c--i 1- CKs, j3;;.;i-;1-iit ' fs.f ,r-iJ[ clt-".g:t a-il ,gL,oc-Jt^r 6l;-c +, L.. c-'JT:: ip_l
sgt-ac^]t^s +1oUJ;: j j I .,ij"i "* qp $ r,.,-: j-Sl lr-j ry',r*;<rl- 6t-a1L;,r^^7 c--L,a ;t 6ly. e*:_* t.aO- t*ls ol6t 6:L'a-i1
I . laissezfaire
.r.o'uL;L ;"F-<.JL ,!l.il ! JLJiq *-:_t #.9:lr;-l .5lo;_e-:5 ;: 6 r-----i ,r:La .\t u*6 jlJ-:, 4J'L- .el Glr L";t-Ji .c*l oJ-3, 6 S luL r,.JL r(. 1:r. c-li oG_el
,rtrb ,(1:y :lj ';3 sJl;j5 o ,ra:"$*: :.r:1) ll.:r5 L-r,l
l; Freizeitgestalrung ,, ,6..c-l n:lric^ljrr uU+* a_5 ))) a)e,.a crLti., r3:-) q t! _51 a5
WWW.AEL.AF
6rt Jt n \6Y
L- jl: r::Ss- orL-"i1; .r1.r-:-l F Gf t Ji! L.gtnc.*J!-,ry 6J* ^-.1
y oJ-ir. d ot-j;: l; .lt-"61-ajt i;;3 L-ao,l-J J-:^lJrsr
./lr" ,-il_ri :l.'.J 4 qti" ! 6ssb U dJl a5 ,yS >yir, o,r-.:y.,.7i
..,tj*jljllJ U "V:s-* "S 6;sa-"Vr, .:t-.lll 4-uj Ul .:y:,u^ 13L-^
*U; !,-*L::, +l C-*,1 dl-r +it" a, [i.:*-a i Sg pF.-t-a.1, c*l o,r-i 63{ arJ.Jy L-g (# dt"j J) J o)y
;-l.c*L*" g 4;>L,a:il.grt;ict34./q- 6>l)i:yig "-8 ?blL-r: o-,!" ;r-l "+it-i .jJt; \_* gr* e, Llc*l .:-1, ">\,t5
6>l1i a-f g-lta",+.6 6rL,,:i1 cr\i.r_#,-/ *f :5 +, L rrty;+"Li;
J*xt t-6c-*JV--. )-*-r 6>L,":il,-:gl-," r1,grlrTslr; u,;.>-l f1>&1., -rB-il .)J$ Jl Jt-,iL*^ st s o:sP jl .:rr o.:r5 c-^=l; L L;3 6c-,l.;ill.:: ! piy 5 -t..iti ,!,6>W3l cJt 3.grlji,r:.at ic.*lgL:-.:
...r-:,( si3.: J tl-t.;-.tic;r:*. y .(---,1 6r**UVl+l :* y
WWW.AEL.AF
qiJ S#5 d* f $-srS d+
soJ-.i o:lr,tLer q dJ;SU 45 ;.-."5 6;arK,ltt1; 6rlji a. .sal 6r)1. o:3 li r.l-i a:>lril t-::
.ir:.9^i d^rtar.fl ,-J
a5 c*l C-l t# e o)p c^:U-, ! 6 dt^ciJl';" At6[ ;t ;iqJ^..r3,, c.Jl.r-c 4t J7:g-.,-f JLii*, r.Ll;:.c.*l a,\iS-1i5 .>'131
a--.9 Llc-u--iL c*!1.:,rSJUll5jir -bLii c.*l;5-" cJl,r.o j c-l!y 6
a-r c-Jl.t-c cc.*l ;..,*i )t;" c..:G-r 6 ojtJjl .tk^ q 6 c-"'1 ;al ol5r:;Jli,-.j a5r1l.-r.:".".: #U rr" Sly, r-*l-?t6+ Jl c-lr!t*
"|,U:-*iL-A il ,r*S +e L- ry: r-lj, ,-/V,-;-i 6 q 6 ,-5
"*,_r!,)-s-f :),rJ,gLr"l5.r--: ,*Lly ai t-a.:1-,1Q." 3 Loril:[ d,-,*1 t" "t,-) J^lJ,
gt.j JL^id,-Li J Lac+rD,-rLl-r 4<l'i Jl:i rlr-ilij*; !.:y -tLa
! os",cl Gd;:, Ct*;.,lye ;;r-ti J) 5 )Jli c-*"-ol "tl"tjl.lL, t :-rgr* Jiq cJ,-r -ualr,-,Jtj .,jtJ q J *J.l r_e-;u q dl-tt 6116lt7l
s c$-f c.4G1 v2p;r lyj o;l; e.i^.i> yl u1l.,>-9a2 Jil t .rrt drS.-.
rlr-.il c^ .l9ir* c.ntJ t: A616:.:tL<. ojlll a-, Jl -,;'-- lt-
1. Lord Acton
.:1ll l:*.,tl
WWW.AEL.AF
Jr-r,l-, tr \AF
r.ri;.: e5 ,s,l-L; drii J,-! 45 c--+;,1r;lr :llV 6s_t.r+,5 .,,t.-ilc* jl u> 5 4r,-jiJj^-i.lk+ y .!,!" .5Lat;tJU-l .,>, .fLl; .-,*S fd.,:lr,-;'U c-; ,51.;1$1 U rlyl gyi- oT;: 6 CV s ,-ssir_l cr) 4J
d .rE ;1* J,-t: 4 rg"f -r.lr .,! ,L_*A ir.:- + t- Vr "r-Li,
t-
t;3iuu cs) 4J -,UA.rJ o< oJf-l )l eG >lr-ol ;y o;l;l r-tT;>
,lL:."ta6L;1r; t c5:yJ- U J!l.r-:lilgt-t.ri;: 5 eW so>y oJ:S;."*i.(" al.f5.:t*St l-,.,{ ,>1l,: u$:*" o$,;d.r:t" b-l_* u.gj:3J> U 3(J::*; fl_t b." -f, y J o;l:,,riU; ;lripG; .i- -,: lyj c*l c-il3JL*^ I,i oj J,"t-) J 'e9
.:-{.Jt ..,.Llf et} eU in- li6l-s ,i*,lt ;yLb' 6l-a'>-cS )_i 6 or_e,r;1:;l c.il-r:; (ottr*.Lar.r-r .jt-'l .,jl),5La.:3U; o5L7Oi U cgil3;: .rl.: ;ual:r j ri >l ;ljl45 lr eu"i; Cr* c-:dA 6 *rJ a, c*6 S)tV a.,Jljldli,r"3 o;f t--F Jite o F{..1 )JE> 6Lac-JJr. J .-r-U jl .:lil Ai a_bOl-&, -r--Lb -,-.:
c*l -.,3J!, J y a-,.iT otLt.: ,l1ll ,;1.,5t-^ot(-r,.:.r*:Li rU<;'U
-t:.i9j rlilt a4ti" f & :ljl6.91ri..1..-5[ac.-.arr a5 c^.JlJ j,l;> lran aS : js3 u- +r,-e ,al yl ; oryr 1:3,1>a -,!t .riU_, Cl:+ t,Alf -rr -r-:1-,^ .u6-t 3,,lfdl;u.;3i jlri)ljiJtr- ,?lf Ga)l ;-S -,[* -tlt" c*r rrl3lr.i r J-; tu t )) & l_r;3 45
Otl Jt :-l .r1lJ;l;11.5 r-,lujl;,.f l-* k:o; t,l.r.jrr.," .}_,lq l_t osj e5 c.*1,5:lil:lil; Gr-c c-.G;uri;: a5 c.*l..r,t!i ki,.rrUt ftll ^<li
c-u-a: Elajll;.:i r:l3j.r^: ..Se* j o:y ji:-l -L..jJ; rlitgt-.-rLt-r dr J r:oJ
(.g.:lriu) {r-)3J>er p& 6 ta,ti;ty:;l:j[:j--,5toeirn 1o-!*t jlri t 45 f,-$ e oJ,.rU l; ,l(ii c.4+ yl Jl Alor;,- i_rt; yl-,jl Jirlji JJ*:5 c,.-l _r: ;--L r;^:-r ! ,^L * ,S:S 4 dt: f t&YL rr^:*r ! ,tl;.r- 3 irL-r:6- U- y oUitr .(3,5 JLjirtS jl g_,[^-t
,;.:1; r-^;jK- ,F * U Jrj F ,flfsrrt-r:.-ul*a *J: :s
WWW.AEL.AF
\AA ! 91, LrJ a3 9.rJ a;
Y!,SL^o+f ! r-*-r^.ol3J>.Jf;" t c.olr3 oli-91o$\JJ< t-.ft-.t"ti"l;l.^,ri.5.:l1i3.tt+ c^r-l 6F\dL, elJ' 6* Jy co.:y.lLi.:lr-il61y
.J:5.,,*l ;l>lj u,"V L?- J -,6 tl-, t^.ti.Sfl S:i 6fJ.)F +J#,)rjt t---rL t J q<Jt" jt.,.lU d-t'>.r"i1: .-ij-- UGy Sg't
.,S1Ji4t sJl-p r-i-[:i, :lil .,r-i,-*.5.gt-".i"i1: F t-fff 6t-4.:jU;
Jyl;:lilylo1.i\.c.*1c-:^il3 6 J*i J^IJ> Gi>- bc-Jt+r(-Jyr).licJ3, t !i 11;le c^KJL,r4L; Jti::l1 6 c*lyl-r]1.rr5
,3p 6l-o.t ilr lb; ilrrr..tia;t^c-lt*r 6 J:-a)Lrl ylj, giy, 911cJ3: e5 t! .,,-l J t-#.-/ t!-cl c-J3r a, 6 ,;13 cjsgl )\.:;tj( ,j'UUl-r."! cJj.r a5 c.*1.;- i.,iJn r:5 o:Li:-l 6y-:ui1^a;l;.ti;tqU
.J,L*l ort-n:.,l .:;.ri 11 L^-! yljl ,f"ts,rnKi.c-*loE-i1-!t*-r JLo^lleJ3r yG-r Ol-&tjl.:;'ri 6 oJ-.i-o r',1
.-"L7 4;.r 6 ,-:*1 Gssi s o-t^i :t .-,-lir,-r- oS c*t ;r.ii ;,t r6jl3;.r
.:.r-':" rlr-il;; c^"<lt" o5;U-; U...:*4 Jr;.0 ,(-i,tT;lrJ6a,riU,
.:rri -r5.,- sJt*i J-*. :* y 6 tlJi jlfl.t56.1a c.ry'.r" g**a* .,3*a e ri ;l$ | 1,,,oli:l jl c--i,n e lni;r;tra, )-p \ P,t) (:_- ,u / - J r
rl6_--jl.J*lt-brl Lily' a5!Jl -fu -*o a:*$ ueVjJJt" jl46a.-r-.:t .rlr.(r L"l; )l ;e.
,-rl;,a. t: o.9LI ;l ;t'U-r-"r L^rjr: .gr,lyL 6 f"r&. o-t-:[i l; a-5.i ;-l L +l ;5* .\
)l i lJ orr .gLr.5r,lyLr jliu" LA.dlrli ;l ,;L; .gLo-r."ir: Ji- L 6 o:jr i-.(JL y La.r,l;l:
:-; .f-.*4 !!.f S*l 61;-;: L^-t i;: pi "* rl .otr>tll 6;,1 .-:l:r, o!.-u!,f ;t-., Sr+" s 3L u. g ;t:a!n ,- 31a 2 ;"5 t -1"- S al rl
"t O [sT ;: 6
,\1YV) rru;; -,: r.*Jl.-y*,rL!n;lr;c ! r;-:t5 1: (Max Eastman);r":^--il ",.5U
;-.1*;l ra:.rr rJL:i 6 S.f ail,l +:-st.r*) CL".;l ,Ji.: lt .,;teyll (.-ff .u#.:r)Ql ;: ol-;r1;!5r.gG:,-;;: n.l1u a*3.;: ".t-.lCil:y )-;.:-),rtrc!:
"Cy)!L .glalU." ,*Ll ,: ,(Leon Trostsky) #: t dl l(,ln r 0. :JJ: ,:) .t--iL,r- ".t-".:"Ji J- si ,l (James Burnham) lGorr :^r oS (ff u, , \ qf \ ) rr.,l;r! o)Li.ilr 413-=
-*.g)L tl)Lturs \YL \\,,a5:3,0:5:.,sit. jii \qrqJL ;ljl s:,:y":f;l .;=.-i)\:+l ;-l ..r:a:-, .)zlail s j- t\1 ). *i;: -t+;:0. )JJ> )) )tSl e S:-y-;: C1*+ 6!L -GJ" &;) o) gl 2: .5 c-l ;-r,r: ;) oJ>;e -Y!l ;.: :_9y .JX5l
,S.r" -.5
l, -1" -uI2: Ia;: \'O :y-L>
WWW.AEL.AF
6', J-,1 \af
A-t€ L-t'_t'> {-$Jt" fUj 6 c*l;,1 ":f ;i,_e,l; U F a3-i
6ly ;!.t;l.r3r> |.i 4fu (d.$Jt" Jt=t- eltW{ 6rDi L,V r UV-rJ_*
"[t-y J;S 6 ta.ti rt y c-.-^a ; -\:^t s."(Jt" ?-V 5 .tlr.(.r
U J {*llj U J- J-11".}lJ "*Se"^
,r-r,_/ fxij J!;:1.-ilr-)r" 4 c*) ;) ,Ji &Uy ft^; Jt .55;$; ol3Js o:t' t g,,:t;icl3ik(,.: ,.51 c.*r
-ts g: JS "(" blj* ,'.";-t o."q (*);) oa,J-.i,lf
.c.-,llr .:oJr- $L, o;.ti L y cJu5 Jt^rllr J;S,*l 6 "-Sr^L-,Srl-l c-Jil .<-i y 6 S: j 5 -r.i! c^il: .r,.rrj *l_r,-l ,# q
,JT..l-Jf-a 6 CU: U c*-+ -slts3- J c-.(.lt" r-S € 113 r;lr ..;l;.rr,ulJr,.rUj jl;:lrTr,r5 fhi;*t l;313 o:3r,r".(Jt" u.;.> c->V jl.-r*15- 4:-t- j
_s r_* a*,1:; JV jl 6pJe; c-=(L +5.ry
J<-" +5 c-u".;yj -;A-.<.- 45 .,;_,,r-i daltr .r--* ;l_#1 f;Jl"jl ;.5 Jq*.t t:5.,- JL.elcr. , r*! tt' 6V j)S J,-ti y e,t**^ c.*1
J $y. slr1 -il.li;t \r,6 *i .:L.g J:5, "<.- 45 ry -ialr; ;;.ri
4.i-)ta f J.45 C)Ji cJ5.r" JL"r!cJ3.: LS$ o)JJ ,slj;,c * l;oiulie ,_F q !4j t" r-: ral3> orl: dr" q d); J", U rt5.jl-ltiiJlR. )yb J:;:.*a r2;.r.! .gl;l: ol;u^;yj..lilr
^S,.,,t<- +5 -r51t-*1 l; yl
!.u,1.1 c*: o_lj y -Ju.jl-:r.f dl.u.jJli L;i ;lr, q5 c*l ,-rt-6+ jl.*L--,, 6 es.:y-, J-al3>.r5.i-3; JG e;.r y o.t5.t*.11i
o-,,t-.:J, lJ i.:*;lJ 6-l ;^*,-l ,Jt, Or..-"a ,gla:-.,71.J 6"i-$ c*+joS:.t:S,r" -i".1,5
jJl Ul plo:5c-5,-"1 ,io*-::',,1 a,..lJ*r r)sK*tl:.>-a,,ll-v..\....'..tJ
c.*.l ply AJ,*l_il,_'(1 e _pcasJt" .:1.6, 6.r.i rt(^l,i fl,q rlJi .ry-,;13.r--l F_,V a5 \ 6)y j 6>l;i ;l5j>j,t>o ol; oiaS
oj't*".c*1.rr5 t-t-cl * yc-t-ar ar*"Ji loi are; c,:Sjl" -ri-ol .lK ! yl.r,1 .r*,.1i or E t-t.,St j #3t ,*5-,1" +5 c*Qyl #l. fonctionnaire
WWW.AEL.AF
\AV tr Slr,# na !.rJ nt
.5;lrqt ,- ft-JiJ J-t* J ))+ 5 rlr ,r,^tii *i ,rl .5-r: t lJ l" dJ<,gL,r.grl;ipL; J-"t* s:s* L-r3,-;r,.:1;i;1;[ oiolr^,a t J._*fU"l ;l o5 ,F t-b ,_i^3 q oJ't* ,lt 5 -* Ll .c*1 or3, &1153,":
jl;l 1--o6:lji;-.lrl1T;l;! "ii- \ ost* yl;: -r--iL +:.-:,lr c^.^ile r"l\.r,c.i1 .r^lf .x
g>\(..- .:',1l-r-! :3,--3 S;*; l; :lil6la-r,iy: +! i--,-L;-t lr.- 6j,l,t<;i ruoi,rj, -u"i1, jl,-i.I; :l;l g+- .,"-_*,.--! 3,rct-:71
;: l1 615 6;11yl '[1e
c-*l ;S*"; ollsa,L1 et-*6,r> 5.u:*a4J,#Ji"YLd>l.$J*l J--)J/ JL?r -r-^a.: ;lri ,g>rit "s4-c
q olql: ..*l15 :1: .t-a13.- ef ; c-*.i1.: raly,- A,:: .5*lf at -rE ;l u; oa+Strpl:.-,a, jh" ,t L r L)o 9511. '^zi s o>f )3J>.r ..t"Jy q \ ,glsarl;ti L-,
G;* 66sX o-, l1 t-^.r-,i;: 5jf rlt5"1J- U y orl:;1r.6 orLi:-l r;3,"
f+ I Gl;C JL^r!.13-q ed-p r:;1 c--l-r-a -t:-,r^.J5 JU<IJ
nJ"i*".ry- J-lJ; ,-FG S;r*U,4 ef J{-,^ J$)y 6* * et;-u.atr; gry )t^:-1l-a.li+-^ LlcJ:S JU<IJ JliU LsJi g.LW t, a3;*-S dl-* dJ. d;l_e *.! Cri 6 S f;L *( ..*l a, 1; r-1- Li :lr,tts A$ * r- jl .r! ,51o.9;l;L; -,1 ; d;{ o-tt+ cJl.r.a s 6At,Sly ;-)-*;#-,a!, d3J: cer"E )-cl oW 6Lar;:-r ,* o\l: scr-i;r 6jt3eli 3 4lJ:1+>.;r Sly. s0ti4 03;r;.r ucV 7>-f
..uiU dYrtp c.:lr.il,e *-f Al^,tff""tS-"e-,5:L^,a:il .-r--4 pW .{ri F,.ly a5''*,lor 5 .-r^Li')Li
.ry';ly*i.: .ly-iJ: a,-bli :s tsy;u5ylrr-S.jj;. ai oJ-i -_f4-t.ij .<.- -,: -,ljtr nJlrlli:r5l^r 45n ,-l jl eri 6lor; o-toLL :*,e
ls ,f g;t-aJr-:S J*: r-alJ, )p t)u5Jcog . i ir:," oer-).rt-t-)\, ;-,-1..t-a: -tlp tf '*e(>i
lJ -l-la pLJ ti orb ,j;3[. Max Eastman in the Reader's Digest, July (1941), p. 39
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5'1. "\r l laA
c:jt-,r-" F." ;, b "l,iJ: +-t-ij ;.: LaJrS Lilt*-;,;p a5.grLail
.i;3 ! d.r!- L-*cL"-al ,g-,,-kl; .?J.;:v c^-;i.r,-r-;.S_l-.t c-u;"oJ cJu-ar,r." )Sl.l_: )J, d+, jl .r:d 6lSbVl
dT.a:,1 L*r: d rlrjl ryy 6 or.-l o:r;r, o-r^ic ;l 6r,1 jl r-i)[&A*ai;'U c^-; e-(L olrd.: .iG-r 6f.-oc.]t r jl;.: +J J Gp! r::- rlr-ilot(-r-.: $_irf J.fi c--Jt-- !.:;,-ui ely LSJ-$e
6La6y lyL; d*"^ .(-.rli tal r- -;;'L s s -e,ret^:7l lE,r, .lL.i.r*i;"{te 6,:SeJllJu jl 45.rLaJi;J ;.: +5 c..--il: t:alr; :r-*3t* y a-5,51a,-t-;: La; ;1 5,r"tK-a Ll cr-X -r,alr,- ;b JluCrJ,, J^lJ, .,lt j jl e3U:" :t;l ,513 J.il.," dU;l :-*,_l c-_t.in +;t^6i
.J^i! ,JJ6^ ail^t<i -,t.*il .:liEl yl a5
o-:r;{ .>:F *3;* eGsi;'U c--; e)tV Jt +r-, ut+;.r .rl: "lal_r-- rlr" ,jL c-.,-j ,:"5 t; ri cJp 3 o.ry j"!.-..i
"l.iU -l-.iq
a*l-rl .gjl; 6a Jl .:t,.i; ". 6 *_& , j L '$r Jt aV, *"ta .(-
o*;,J r ); \ ,*i 6* c*-t-; )k+ st 6G 6;* J;a $li,r"i li.rlj'Ur,jt<"l g-,1511;YJt g;t-ao;j.:;r 5 c*lc+;) .c.*.,1o:fi 3l
)l ,"o ,gr:a 6l-auis-t Ll ;3-, .t..oly- a,L:- rlll jl cE-,!*l Ss: -*, Ji! g-,LA fl .:tl>.ryq3
"$; c.l :tt :t s# _b ett 6f -r c--t-ra
LU.r;U c.-Jt - St* )lor-:J*.2=i tu J .,*iUJ, 4++ ;rj-t, )j,q:.r')
.(.- _.,: t-.1 c*l d yU 6 ,S-,t.(.t J+r^ .:3., ra13> yi..U; po.t-),g;sa-Lir1 a*"t-- J).),'1 r^\Jr; /+ ,,--lj o.t*l6y;+"Uy a*"[-
,-r'-l I +-(L -u:".r pt-;l1: u--*V;t5 -t:*a lrG 11l 6J,l d.L*lr, d .:lr"il
s c,4-r s *_*,t Slg*--, -r:..*.o ri AsS Sl1^\41;) 6 u.Ll.>3* ua;.-:* -&r tj I-i +! .Ss:;r rr.i "L(t-
c^-*i lJ -&t 'i -* c*l ;5."" d.eL.A s)J. i rlr.it 6 Jt- r,+4"1 +5 6La;;1-r- *L;.r-.-t; a-, t-.1 .:y*,,r- .q! -fa: ,lS iba-"1-- .<";t *QrS j-;s t:*l;S.-" .-U r^l3; criL c*o5L- ,n'.o-*
WWW.AEL.AF
\ A1 tr Sl, d^5 "< S.r*S *e
J* ^r L-.r-l 6tt- oi jl f*lr. oS c*l ylJ/+ t l J*i! + ,-tt,y 311.
jl.:lr-rl c"-L;; p..r-c,rl1o.:r5./Uril G eltJl-fl_t 5 dt a4l3 6>lril3
f r :lr3l .:t^.*a; o.:l :r c4 J" JJI 45 {<j ;rrl ;1,r,"tfl t .Jtjir^iJ.
.cit- r^U'- .rilil6t*,U:t+l 1p *.,> j,cJ-ar,r-r pt=;lc-Jl.i-c 6i; )l; atl; gsf)aJlj; cJyr oS CUjJti 4jt*: rlil+*a c..,+-f t{ ci,}J*, JQ _,, ,f 4_fu"j1$li,r^jJ c-,-; j c*l ;5*" o.r,*i6y;+.UJ 4^"t- 4 -,, 6 -t1r a-,o13--
..i5
6--,t- U l_# :t 6 ,Al-rJ -hV ". +i r,-\--xL olrfu: *sJl i+ li r {rorl;l +5 JJ, .r*la1 {+.);.r+.r+,lJ l-a.)ic-:*tU U,-rly,^J 9 or3,
ryy )J+# c.^fi;r L.gtor")\; fE y .S,-f ,.(> ;rO.tL.St-;,J-,rS -it eW L"l; el-s 4 *y ,ftJi s a.'fo,.ir^ ! * tF;: l; .:;-ti *.; o5.:-y raly> #t- y,grtjKll; --r, ! +(L,rfoT;.r a5 dl:*Kl erji o_p .rL- dl-u."-!-$l dy.S..r;1r ryi 1L^$l
a, \nc.--il,tl :-9>.3 cJ3.: A-b ) & fA -t os-) tS_y *..flt efD
45 dl.AJJjS -rr J<y' J:r5,r^, \ .,)r*: f -* S c.^rt" J&.J ,Sli-F.c*lo:y le:e l"xzf ;l,u-la,
,:-Jg o;-gs ,1 l;6rL,a:il-,-,"11* 6t_:bVl;6 cJ3r 45 c,l<$6;.r,li-rl.:;7l _,* -."r-_t JJ:; Si,sj J rl;il,s,3lJ rt(-t-..1't*
.rr;-riQJ o:f ;l;: c-t--lL a:il:qg; q 6 q 6 ,-Sg eoyt-3;4lJL".c!r, dryi fr3* c^-.Xlr J-alJr ll j-:-il: J):l oS
j 4;>W:i,l6LrF:l J JL. lV o s_y-;,1 1r .:_2 -r.alri o.t5c..-l"t-a
"t1_9 Lag-t, 45 Vi;" ir+l +-.r ;y Ji:-aly,- r*.ft -6t^F;*,rct"-71
cJ5,r-. JL"o1t, .lJrc,*Lj .r1-ri;,1 5 6rlr.il y.iror-- t^.ti.gL^r[-
.c.--il.: slJ, 6*.?S:;r rrl; ,rJ q 1# \r osf .rtk d tf ;, :U:cle,
l. The actual words are those of the young Disraeli
WWW.AEL.AF
,j'tJrtr \P.
Jt--- 6_t_:_i c--"jte y;tri6Ldl.- 1: a5 j:V-cJJ rl5 4-.t
6ly. u..,5 o? t.r31 o-r-.i +.a)t'- .rT;r c*J!- y uq "(- J3'"iOk-
\ _el _e o>f ;lf-{- ,# + t F a-1' cr5u' 6tLb\-t 6 qF q J Sd c,,** lt 6n:;r ,tlr"(.: 'tK"+; +?,r5..r c-.-l-r-a
..r"Ll Jt*" ,r<"^ Layl-.r*iL +r.:1.: cllfr bi tr rJ, fjY f-6- ,,-li
;_*e e# g**, tt o:t3.(- !-i b :e :) 6 .rj:3r
L-.r lr OJ ort " dV p* $: 2: al(--yi 6ja;1.l .<iirilg rl: 6? \ 6 c.-)) l5 c.*l yl tac--y(' ,$*. a-*b ;t4tl e orlr
..t...itr.t=.:.tIli,r^j or-,i-c;-lp..(, jl.u:-,13ic* > * AjKa J eyc^-,.; a5;l s >:lS,g;i, JL; Sl^,sf .,"-i.t<-t y.:J3:6ylc.*l;r5*. >lSl Jtlrla*:-.<-i 45 $l.f gUil.ry.ri t./Uij r^
-,i :*y C-\ s c*t c.*;r'y"tS,.r;U cJ3: Lrl.^c-:Jl,r -J'U c--;6k q .,J ot, 5,-.r-lrt .+^^ JTqJLi .r-o.r.r^ /+jl eJ:: d.S_,tS
.:y .t-oly.- ttK 1\: r.:ljic-*: a; x jKl s (f \l:c.*l ;3.-. ilrt ."-S lr? ,<-S-"jl .,-Ll ,* y4L l; ;3r cLl
:lSl;r, $J<<.:Ll.rilarilfrl+ 45didr+ a^a: gta;l |-: eV.:-,Ll.rit
drr-l;t+tj.-hrr5 e^.".,;"yi l; u( yl.rlr -L.rl:r ,tS ib c..^i lJ
-f t> sp ,-a r,S 6k _p S.f C^*,6 c*lc.J3.:6t.cJLj, #dxl q ta! aT;'u t-,.l.-l! c-xt: ;$:- c1t t:_tsi,-t c.*: a, .rL;
;: 3 r--iJ:i.o 6L-a._t-i +f lt Laj* u;r' :lrtl 'it
6.:.:--i r3.t-,...
.5:l.t-:-llS y:l;ipt-b; .<.- Cr"t .r:Ui .u_rsi c.#r 4J ,at--,5taitL-,;.r:-l c,r6.; t+;;l;: L[";
3.rL.a-:il *#.41.t--rr rlt-oc*J!"3- J t^dju .5;:" .it-_,I.;
aFJ a-, :L,a:il; r:*t-. r:.>.-= rl 4-i J)y' 0t5" &lJ 3 tc.+t-,o.t)6:,asaouJ, y"LS
l[-Lj .<. y Jll ftt; .sl c* dLa.}JUi o-L-a:dki
:Lle;-.\
M. Muggeridge, Winter in Moscow (1934): Arthur Feiler, The Experiment of Bolshevism(1930).
WWW.AEL.AF
\t\ trtlJ.,Jo+t.,.5nt
cSLay; W- -iV Jl.-- 1: 6 u--& "r:al;;..r- La.:-,t"" yl.c.*l.:*L*.- ra-,1-+ )l r)\-) q-5 .t::.--a,rll-t--ol J-b; cio J) 6>lc:il) .Jt, t" (j-
.'J3: ,.:u-lra jl #:*" olir-* l; 15.:Lr:il .r;-ri ;-.:-*-"-a 4<l $lc-*J<-
o;L7 o1; t"l .crj JJIJ" LaJi ! .J-.,, 6 .iJ;l5 a, ,-ril.r.al 6i"; 6\ 3
e5 c.*lr,l;.r a-(L -r*lL +:.i1.: )_fJ o:$.*" Jr"! L)i 6 c-*j yl;:,KE t ofu u. : rlil .gt-a-i"r-o l[ ,a .l-! ,fV ":f ! cr.-13 .:;-ri yl
.-t-.iL a:il: JF o*"t- -r: U -,4
6:t-e:ildt-oc;t*.r^lf,-f S o,_* 6 c*l d*. 4:( 4 alcJl-r-" se;; JUJi t- Jiat .p; 6l t ) y. sal r; t r^^-" "r5 c-.l.r-a l;
.rrr! Ul )l nJ<,< s tly.l d6,<t"1.J:5 o:li-l:3,- e1.t! )1,*ii
.:"-l-ta {! t- -r .r--i -r.o1r; c*l.r^ ._Jy*"l J d.Ll +t; f:-5 J413,- o.:l-cil
u.* 6\ly o;!l: +5.sr-t-:' oYlj-* L u'a;'' PU, Ui S.l-:Lj !r;l.r > _e->j c-u y,tr F "r.o- -,* *{! ; -Uy-.f C--b St:^-lyr,-r-jrL aJlr .;-rlj oi Ss: I & e:t' a, rlil 6 ,i)tt:t- 4c o: 5 . L-,-a i L r[^:-l.,jU.t +J- y+,i.ll3a 6 S:V r:;b :3agr J ' J
!:jL o:lyiy l; c.Jl.r-c u;,.;,>14),,',-lpl-oi a- -r.Jlei, 7 5 r;lr rg3 o>L jiU 4 t{ -S J-l-( -ti6(-/-\ . Je
lU o+F"* J ,j,15 ,g1lr'. cr51ly.:J-a.r a51;1 p,:o 3- t, .<," LaFr*JK..a ?lL,6y,lt Jt.-v,^.it-ilJr.S c-.-i 6 6JJ"lfLi-,1.: rlr-il
cJl.p gar-" o"i1l a. c*11-f,r-. (c U- c*t ,-L" l"-f +5rr-l jl l"r+) ,-r
Gs-t e)*.b,se"A $!^-,.(-,--r.Ji; ,Fs: dl.-:,".<i e)-rGI)J. Ly U-l'l-,t* lr;- oS ..:--.: JJlc^ .tiIJ lrt.-r-a: llri 1s,-V1.
.5r'la ui; c4;r eS #L-r ";.1.+ Ci^.-u'Jlr.r" '-')L' lJ .r<jt<'
,*!t *r "+i.r5 .:l.411 6y ;lrj," 4 ,f G\ t;li co:-2 ,f,6;y illl3 aJYrLr 6,ii.<-i "$ -rlr )\"[5 CUi.51+i rlr.r," o-t-ey
6s,lt sv ,* 4i {<! '--15 JJ-t" .5L^^ ;: n s)t,.li.rLet ;'u.)d #
WWW.AEL.AF
6'tJtr \2Y
3 r.rt-i"lJ> U L"lr,.ru.'iq f^.....l, # c,*lJS-. JT"4l3: arlr"r".5 Jf- 1) .-[ll--n -&"5-";l .:jU:" ,)F../ Ly.-r 6 n]'t- q 45 t--. ,iT U
tSs* il. 'nl-S
cJS,r, drr,j Jl-fuir * yl-, .^-tuiJ. i-L j $L. 6)1;:*. e* 6-a.5.i^" a,rla, c*! ;* &lJ &Gr* A ejt€.& f.lr.i o5 .,,Uj Li y c*J )-fl )fy c*s )t F pLs;I er cc+l ?lL" c*S)-.<i,-J"tS Stlt * g c-Sr- t,6 -et_#,_* +--l_j, Lo,tl ! i;*U-r 6
"tbF*:t 4f ar c*llj f"^if'f"^'C"q
aS -*o StS-t cSE.J't- .i- t t".c*+ .:[-15 6S-s Jd,r=, t-]l.:yt-i o-5 JL-;) .r;b K Ot.6:1 lloic*l ;(-" .:l;Lr 3 .:[^15 a,L.l.;
r:u},. o5 -u! Jt- l; 6Fa!. $tr.r ,bS ettt o*t tss_t t;t.<,-6-a t )1..,c *, SAt r-fi-s-, t.lcJ-o.: e*t .lUl:, I t-ooia, 4U
Ct^-", "l-lls
rt .,rl:L* jl r:;.i-J 1 oi.:[-r;,." .-t^)saj f! Jb .,*t
U"t +_&,L" a, ral-9,-.r" eifU )))e yl;,tuc}2.lotilrrL rr5r:*
et rYrts 6.i"1<.^ t"1.tr5 f*' dl-u.ijj 6.1;l: jl.lt(,1 .r.- U aS c.*l\t\StlJ. Jyt,t aS tt*t c*l,jt ,-f GV- Jfu cJ-1,un t-^r"i;r
l; L .rJ 13a aS r**a .rrul 6La.: ; 1$ ,.,- I "r?::
. )
t;"{
#t- ,,FS :* \ {;t_)jl- .:)t3* ;*lq of;*U a.1;rLi
[-. a-o-a l.1l.c*l sli, J_a)(J_r gla-,!;lJr lU; qll jlid:+c4t;Jiro L. flt,l".ri L t{lS,.,Jl$ u+jYrLe );,Jr),r U ua.;Yrt-e g*i,r ;l .r5;:q"1r,*, ,J.ts _,* *.5 5t;-, ff.S;1":-cl rlr,;l <;Ln1r;cJl-r,c.gj;
pr ;l L"T,,,r:^l,t, a:*:1$ ,J": .;ut c.*.1 d)rLe oev c€JJ" 4:r! Gj-l, \lb etc-l::*il.: l;:f dLaJl.-t+tt d+.:; ui; c--c;
!.r*i,rJ .J:+ a;.<*- 6La:;l-[L-l \ 6;s)6tl.:; l-r.ik- I ..:; 1.1-l .:3--j l 16; l3.l""l .f-l .ri Jr .J:"
"!.: 4jU-L
,fU 1; La,tic-l.i; ds ,s* )l oi^A ar 3 $l;l.i; f$j &! g,;l; t a5
WWW.AEL.AF
\ 2f D Slr uJ 4? S.,J 4--
.,<"" g-;l:,-L:1r +j!.rt-c )ts) [- cY.:Le c-+ ilt, qli.J*: -u.alJ,
c*ili.,-. "5 -L.iq d)j^.:-!) L" c-*i q J'"*" )j^:r) t- c--".i c*l
: i,> I j-.,a ;> 3 .I-iL p:-r-" .:lrl l^-;l 1.^.---J {*X K ur;t=.i .t') jq.gLerlc,*4 61u:-lLer,,.i..i! a:-il: :3,--9 lF)U-r;lJL*.-l l_S *,-.cF: +rl o:- a5.4t-o:l c:y trtt-.i;L5 J"\S JJe-*)) 4J c*i Jlf )\SAl _e,r5.r:1,5Gc---JVy otst'lt-.1.c.*l 113-l oi ,' -*Jt*ra'1 LW .qL c--,i.e r- .)14i .,*Jt..r" 4*.t 41: 6.rjloJ-.i-c
J, &l..i Jlf )lS o)f ,y"l * -rr l;j o_i,.i g.*A tt::-e Ai otf ,S
6L*e ;r JiL- :lrJl )l *.,1j:^--^ L:eor-&1r:.:..1 qt r,- )l6 o-_U-?L,ac*;q-J* jlg_,[*t _b _t, aly:-5 slJr.r,"l;: uJ ql"rdLrrl ;--l a-5 c*l oJ*l uiJri, gl.:,9J-> L o2jrul3.i:+l dY.:trlJ,rljLl .ry o:r;{ o)y ry o-L.i J* q &Li- Jl d.r^t *l )*W o,l*l),) )_#d UJ
".r--rU nylrr,qly; JS q .--J f tS $,gLo>la5.r"t<b
Oi-*a.J--i JK:" ,_*,_t ,-*;J Jl6t5 fU.* _r> qt r orjL pL.j
., F,_*,../Ll ol't*..tt"^ jy; d^"!
ucl; c-^"o-t-i .(, rr+iY.:G )1*\:r)) \.fV .AYK .(1 neiY:l-e c.".in
;"+ ut+Cls:* t -t-iq c^lU jt", t)y )l$A 6 Gst*;r ol3;,r" l;
c*l;S-" r,r..iL or-i o?*"A La*-r^ U$f _b_rr dlt _r:G- 5l.t;JJa-* dHl 4i Al:t 6 -tu-:,L,5:r;*: t- c-*"e .pt" Jtr, ! t_:u}l-LU\15 ?* J ll )l$, a2{5 J5.,-r*L ir+"Llptrt ..:*l ,e ts,i
l_/ J J r r v!- -. J{ J. VJJJ
a5l;,5laJYrLc.r;^:-r t- YtS a;Y:t-" c^"j ;i:ly ?_/ rr+ -r:l 4_r,:1.t-;6 J^) u,a:;*:i J)iv,LJ._St.+L.j ,...J o,2-l c..-l:y JrtS q J,-tl
4-.: J! ,;1-l ;l J J::*-6 jU ,-,y- jt-orL t- JL"-. cr".r:.6a 6a:jt .,
t>)t';l ;r o3,.1 ;,-i; c.r5 rE .r*t, );^i) q [t"t 45 dt^,)i 4]*J
-il.r-al *-; c-",41 j".rJ ftfu J)MlJ..:y J-alye;--L +iY:t-o )J^:/)nS t*,:l jl .-r5.f d i lJ .4i:; )l;bl -91-^"J;3,,"- c-^al c,-il:*.a:--xl: .-Li ;.r l; ta-t t a,,1l
J,-q ,t;9;. 11.t o4: *.Gr* rlrrl a, r;h.i J-e!
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5'-, J, n \2f
r_1> r:L+c.aj,jL^J-q.fLlf l; -rLi. .-il.i,ol c*.al ,S-,Fy^ ! y.ji:;":lil t*l; : c-i-r te:) el6 c.*lr# dl+ oiUt..ro:*
."t:5 Jt^rld:*. Jjsc*11oy. y:_#g L_yy rlyl,r-*; q+J" a, 5 o;U,lr-rL*a + ;leS r*-S,-r tr+:J'Uf .c.*l by,r,,* ,-il;i, 6jS 6u*iJ ur;.9G.:3t-a; L,l.c.*loL<,- ,_*,: € ,yV df 4,5t^.r,i1r.ll;crlti.il ,t--t,-*-fV s a.-sd-r 6l.o-r."T;: t6i4j (t^r"iJ) ,-ri tr )-tr-fa.,.:7oa +(L citl;[5;13* rG;yJy ctad.";r c.tt5-r:--; c;[^*" ir.-J:.6."ni,Jl..t!; t{ lYq ,UJFli cL^r5.J, ,tte_rV J J-;,9-f.9t"r"T;:dy! a+ $t 3.c.*t h*J _& J J*;Jj.rG-t &. )Fy .:3G ojl-til
fJ
o:t' dL^g.t1o.qt )te.11&Jt jl.g1LitL-i" c^$? J) 6l,oi!i; "t-.:r;
r^l,, ,-p! ,f dt+ t: rlil ;., .4 Jl"c\oyp l,l ,$J -l^l3,:lil,trlr -,lf e.-h;lL torr^*:;:-il: K;.rU A) ]q JL- c.rjL
.-,iL; 6l-^o3f ;:cSy )l dL^Jr::S in"a ";l:ar,
JL^:-lo;L1: ,,1-11.J-d c*-l cSjtjL^J-'::5 ,*1 .r-*t ,>:F;: Laoi,-rr-it :lri l,- rljT a^"t7 ,511.l ;lilo+, JL- J-p )JJ> '"[- .:r'Pl ,tt-7 a3;Tr,e-.*-, .:"15 1.: .dl/ aF-
:c.*l 9>t-., i )Syl.o:rS o;i--il .ti +,
dJ..t, dli.,, l-, ,-,-f t-*C* ) rgJ.lJ.dil,, J:t",^ cc.l,,i ctgiG .-(rr
.:-,,lJ" ,ual:nt ot*jl ;l.u ,-(- 6rel Ut c^rj* J+ t e*; xf Ua\ J A,F- ^-t
>3i c> jlr; ! y :y- ol3iJr a: 3 J:5 ;rr"; l; :l,il
Gl,t lJ :lril ;-l ^-S Ji ;*.:3,- .r;lr2j .'3J!. r,Ju-a{
-^S 6 J-->Y.r,-u-.lL d^J clyU 6L^.:y.r! c,-k-- e:,n 3o.ry g!.rt-c q5t.o,tLll
ot**A'U"a t )yJ=u "J; ,S-- iu-,l.'1,- l"a "!L-f
45 .,jt j ti
> r-- ls ry -sloj ;,1 ."r:"$; ;t(:,i sgLnr-;-, l*; q *-! .r)\(:, r.,1 cc.*l
l. John Stuarl Millf u.ii: ,Y ,J., ,Jrl & ,.rL- :La:!\ J3+\.Y
WWW.AEL.AF
\ rA tr Sl) uJ. na SF na
c!_L> L.:;l.r -t-ej *r*J!",*" c-*L*.(- 6.uar,r" Jt*I .,*iJo t-ii lJ
c.r:a), / , t".(-l; l, e ,, .i- qFl f1-r^^ t 5 .jL; 4ll*sf jl g-,[*tI 9,- -\J
r."jt", ,9_f 6tL*Uy 6 t-7oi;l.ry"-: a-lK l-fl t:_f t -k t* y,
.grlji,tlrS )3-b-r cc.*l .r-Ll 6b.r"jJl o;U;r .5r:.i* o.t^ir .(, ry,-g
.r1: J-a13.- Jlr;'U c.^.*j lJ V uzs-t 6:l;i-'t*}*.6r1, ,gLo;.- a,
eJ -u:.-a &:,tl"Ur; ;rr(!- a.,; y.rJ13 6 dt-a,iictac-;[-3-,F '):-*iL
lr JKi- d,r,-lo5 -r.t;13-r^"1 d )* e, cJlorf !; t^,.1i
,51-: +5 d*-5:Q"t*^1" fc---=7 e:_ri:IL^JTrj-E:. t-.l.-u.t
6$t\jl ,Jlj-i 6:^ q r:5 J-); dr--r-.l)\;lcSb.rj;l rjlicr4j+5.gll),l>l Jl*" ot!:: .5;:- *_t-i-o ;-*i1.: 6y \ l1 .:lr-ilrUli.r"j
*y 61,.r-, q!r* (-l-:i*a,rrk-71 hly; fU a.:Lrl5i.g.l-U-E..ql;
6ss-* oa*r.r.,i.<." cr"r!, ^<!;rG":U:cl +j ucV a.Lt' '51
oS ,S:IS -t-ir-l,y-i a5 ri:y 6:lr-il drJJlta&JL.-r gl3;, e.,.:*l)l rg -. S--' nrQ- g.t+ +;--Jc, .i.J5 .p-,*{ .r^" jU -r;lorr5 1yr,-:
e-* 4<.- 4 :t-1l6ly taoT,5taj)i; !L tr .c-*l uaVcSL^.-,r'ii-,l
.gG1l;ljI ,S_,!.-: -\:*;li o5 rr.l Jr;ot-4- .+ .i" c."-L-- c...*;
,* -.LAc*iL-i _r Lagjl_; a5.4Lo;lyl ,t ;ji >yrs *\ 6)l>y,_),:
-iK 6tr,rsrL-j -!;- QeIy oLJi;r t*:'ir';:t},:r""L--
J-:.gGa-;- lU r 6 *--re c/qr ,5Lnr:.;7 r-5-,L5 oJ;.r$,l$o.r*l +sl;lLlc*Jt?i.3- U;-t 12J5 j: rA r) c;, 4rl$1a,-L :lr-il
U -Ui pt-(:"o;trrr .5b46lU 6.rL-.aF.i".r--L 6+t.)y
;)_SV-S .J,t*. t c*j ri ot5.r,-: e5 c--.xt: lprl s *J e t,,t l: 3 ycJ5.r- oj_l_, l_,1 Weltanschauung qr;> JL.fLj S $€ c"[a 1,
s^",^.Jt ."r oJ:o.y .-(-i.r-x ,-& Lac*;V-r Li -,! #-91.S1_r
Jt-;;l \ ,-5.t ;l?* ,_it:- S .,*'J!-r" ,.l;> o;L;.: 6 &--;l
l. Weltanschauung
WWW.AEL.AF
,JttJra \?7
jl dr -f 6l_e. a-5 c.*1 f*J!-- el, ,F r: J-l) c*:l)s" rktl\.r,.t:S,-r^
r,.=."'U 6lojjJ 61-ad[,jL.Jt-t J,rJS -9 blf )ls.rt^c-.Jt-sorr5 L5ylo:Lj o+j ,_.,11:, ,rijl6t-oc-!!-3*, c.*l;r<*. -t4raL^s*Jt+:- ..*l.r-r* rr-9U:" oU+; -6r.St^ta -,, L-lr LlcJ:-iL
,51-artL;l- :;l3.rJt*.1r.- jr* jl l; rt5:35 a-5-Ljry L-ac-*jG 4i J
ar,-l jq y .-rj-r:! _tL. ?f cgL^-,LJrJ o:f a, 1; L^..tT [ -U:rS,r" ./q..s ,i):s,ra.tiLjt- fJ ,-. e5 r:y L^,-**JL-y- 4<l t^c*+U ai
d..*t* rl:Lil 4f 4;l-aol(.;L 1.:6310:L : JVy "|.*
rt.aL^cSj!c"-a jl ,J..i .Jtjl..i,-"j ,:r-.;" _3-, *W L-;._r-!- .-,p *liclscV 5[-a.r.-i ! +!.:; 6V-el.r-:il:;lr.ela5 -tjry L^c-;!-rL^.:*J!-r .$jl* ;t :" .llf-r )l l: rfrt.:rS .:.^-r-.e s aa,Jljzljf-4-l"j :l;l gt*; ,Jnt J_i t.:-,[lJ g[-a;l;lrt"-,_lti 5 $ry,,
.*rl-S: r-r-,r\r, ,t.r3-rlr- r tyJ!.$r*x
,5:lr^:*l ?l_rl :st.(,L::*-^ ,srl-}i,r1i rr1"*; f ,--L- r/)dtrjl* aS d l4S g3>
'.ulo*,K #t.,r 6t-aoL1L ^it-.J"I( Jfr,-<*.(1it ! .,(1r;,* *.r-*s 4.,.!t*r d:n- 6.rUj u
.r-1y," .r-1l,r:,i.a ,gLar:.;1 gl-" 6lf ,6 "tJ Ot'\r -, 6 ,uaV ,3feG"sj .-'yJL..U(I- ot!_r: .5p- ot(,u-, .! rt-l-\--i,L or;3->
"J; S-_.t("t t, l.r:,1 ,:;.:y ralye JLi--U.; _,tS 6 a^,L- .jl:;,,a t"l.c*La"_tf l-V q,Kt? yl6t-b-clciti-i-r.o 3:11.l;6 J r ,_pVi\* .>1j-e,f5,-* cs? -b y :: AV-y 14 )t 45 J.ti"GJi.r-K .:.",rJ,3 L^.r*"i;: 6 ,_#,-*rt(:T.ttK", t s S,_l #+-f -t^;ly.f C:_* 1.: rlil _t )_i,-S;.r,,J cJ3: oyi j;l L-g,r;lya 6 -r-.iL .5la:i!o!)V ,sf *e aS r:5 -E; q,.r.li1 Gi,l 1; :3,-
.r5 Jr.S ,J.- eL" g<- J) l;rti3 o:y ,tS ,Jlt: c-J-rr
_,1
.Y \ .jz,( \ qr^ -.,-:;! r . t qrf t lfrr GFI .f i. SrroL-ry
2'Ba,,a 3 Hitredusend,,,,roj]ffi:r-,,,j.fTl':3[#L,^"*r.,.,
WWW.AEL.AF
\ PV ! Sl) .,J oA S.r^.5 .a
a; cJ-ar,r-r C tW JI;" 6:.lusJ C. Gy;,l;r 6.iUt -,,
:ly _& -,rGo:j o'-;)l&l J ,J";_p i1., "S s*-t' {*-r! 4-r6f
aS 6l^- jl -.,,i-l-;L-l 1* : aj:"j ;al -r> d);l ;\::.:: ,lp-**^ .)Jlrt-fui d pt-r ,-'llzl lgls $l_i.r.i -r-! .s-r,- dl; )S r:+ r;3.a
J.l.a,)i 4y.-uiq jq:.l.<- r-5.,- c,-1"-- eV,sJ .(1 gU;ta-:ly 'r;r$ -rJl; Jt-ra 4 )s+J U;rr,j.J"S ,i;{ ala,si rl_,et
-r-it,r,-l;l-: os*,3 st..:Le.-t a-(L ,ll'llrqLr- 4i ,-4Jl; oL-; ;113 c*l.rs., r-r+ 1-, t^,.ti; Wy & Jlf )lSJt<; c-.r/t a5
.4bry-i,5._# F+^^ t, #t+r ,glauis: : AV-y- ,"hy) a; a--r,.ot> f,*a r- J.jlo::-j #tU '(*=.;-)dr;'t c-fti 45
r,.r.:1 c-+1 o:3-,;1,;;*l .:L.a:, Jl- j*;r y 5r:.1*-" €6a."tjL- j- +)^b aS r;r ;l3I-"1 p-Jt ."r .L;,L-p dl; )lS 3 crllba,Lr*J--J- t -.J:" d+ .(,- 6:r5.r- ::^r:"\*t 3 c)1r^lf .-* jl .r"rSJlf )lS,t-a.:*-U 3 .:1;1.:l ol.r:"16 ;16rLj rL.: +5 6l+ ,.t;S yj$La.:-t-- V .*f g l.i l: JL--i J cftl.u dLJ- s 31l-rl s5la.r:;.1
a-, L,l .r-;rr5.r- 13-$ .>G,J aril dL" )l Sf -t.5 cr[-; ctl.,"a; jl g_,!^l(c.-rt" JF p dlf )lS W_r a- .:[j.-t jJl c^rrJ," aS;r1l u;*._-Lj -rr l_s tf c-*U+ Irl -t---t.7 L-y" *.U .",--rfUl 6 dl-a,il,J I
lU jt J $y -*Jt -f L-^clT o-^^ oJ.Jt-;r ..:l.r c-*r jl.,rlr{>ta.lT "r,,Gr Ll sr_r, .:3j +;Y:Lc -*a ;L:."fr- y c.,.11: ,> rii 6i,+-Gr*
.r!:y .:yU.:. --*JL-f ,r-_-16 -rl ',-l :.S'I*c o3--J 1> el I *U" !;.: c^*ii_9.e ! -t-iry d*jli t^c-!!,_,-".r^,-Ji -.rl;l 5.41-a;1;,1
,[-rjJl jl )l &t!o ,riy --r;r*, o-#, L-pC "-lf 5.c-x+.? 9-r+ c--e+
cr-;L , y6":J 6L*; c-_[^-- 14 Sla-u;li,r*;.'tUTgg:Le-il -ps
o5 r_,5 -ualr; t:4 ,;*4L*r :^*_, cSL^dL"r- o:t';1y: l;;..:Lil ,-t- el ol*:+y" a5.r"islf-e .;6"sf c4t^- u,-[7.r.L,a;:
I " dogma
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jt, Jr l \PA
.5{.-t" g-*JL-r J 1**+U * G', o-tV;l;r,5rLj 4[L.c-*l::i:L- L ;i;j dJ-?:1r.r.:+1c.c$ cr:--,o L-j.. tqt dt* _f Ul-* t 1r -r+.r+ sL-r.a 3r ;-,-l ol;l.r-or.t ,)LJiJ UEt -,, 6 ;-{.*.:t-p,L ,-f F.r;yi-,L*-- +. L*i;^ 4 t*sgrLail *: )l dli,s.qgt-oc-lt*o 4,.J d;)!u.l- L; sS 6s* Gl;l oU+ 4" pF +b
)y G,:-a al; )ls j+.::t---- d*-- ojlll a- 6>L,e:,iJ"t" e 6;y1: :g3,rJ.t_.:;
- 3,r^t(:-:l; .r),\...a--i qgl;b rtUlri3i-' 9 ctL-r:4ac..Ff"U itlrlt5:lilG&r|sf!.lUl,,y.ry"r( q c.:* \r,,g;lrl.gtor:.n
olJlS,t ,F t-bfl; .,cJ:< crtJ:;":-.r a51g;t--i.51-a+,-rt-*;l U";G_p 6Lisl ,'-t- 34>l -t*e.-r*! j;" L,:a- jJ-l -i-,+.;: a:*ily*i,:3r l-aoi)io:r)
-.rr djU ufir rgL,*l L.-r,,Jy,gLar"i;r -ttJ a, +5 r-2lr )-*J 6t+,S-,t=;6Ga-:t;l I ". jb 6l;cl )l ;.* -,;
"|-(-; .iJ_rlg;t^JL
U-l -bV *..tTor3, .5[i.r1: 6 G*;: "t.J:y rj,r^,-.ri c^*Jt."r:lfll: dr s})s-t J;l(,-5jU
",+ 61"*t) Jtl,s-S o-5 rj1 r4]>e5,LirrS,r- 6t;: dt.a-t-.*..;.l ga;rrE Jt- 1: J $ry: $; 6f
.rr "rL!f ^*K..li o4)J-gb JJ);: a5 tu.-jo a- c-:3;t GW r:(:-5rr dr{L+l.s.-.il: o;t--il
"j':.r f+. ,# "a- .(,- tu )y o-r-.x Gl; Ul:,"t tr gl iU
q5Lac-*Jr*- ,* r rb.r!L.r t-.i "- -iU:lplCx ,_f )A c6i131r
;.t c*lj-fu. ,S &)G .f i 01* 4-1d)Lj:3J> [i 4L 1;.r^,-.ri
o;l:la5 ot'U-;,t"1L;.: L^,.ti.:r5;lI$ r,J-a.: C -it.*JL-r ,Sl^r:f1r t-l .i::-Xl"rj f- ! ./Xrl ei^ ,S.f d,.ri:- 4*"q;.: l; .:lit .Kt- -Jy,-r:*a Lrgl.l5 GI;".:La.l ti,s$,_+t-r.L(-[a 45 4J't-..*l! o!l-r
J-lJ, t-frJ A o-ru,j;r 45JL+^a c-".il: r-9,13...#Ll.5L^rai.-r)rl.c*.ilr
2. 6 rehours
(J"i-^{ Alf :S = ) White-Collared Proletariat . \
WWW.AEL.AF
\ 11 tr Sl, Lr^.S oA S.r-5 ot
)* \L-o.li.rl;.--t r::--i,I.: tprl a-i*.l 6 s^,-$ c!Li"J- dlr"^;
dr-"l &i* al c:y -r.:.al3> fJt-- ,S-f \ ,l-* ,>S TjEL1 ,r*Jf- .r-Jq- - 6laoas: e#:Sy ; Ll;l 6 tt-{,-s.S;r l; al't-
.,--ri ./lj-l *5 Jl- ;.r Ll .c.;-(:l .r.al-4y l"AJi qJ," t l: * .>Li-t
5;:- Lr;t<^^ p) eev gL-.a ;r {rtijt jL sS 6st t-..^*JL-re-f. -b "lLjlJ'J Jt-
"f"lL Ll.,r:.:y o.:r5 5;.: l, CU JlJt-t irts t
Si"sj L-,#y 6:-o dJJi .iuip 1: .J5 :^lt l: 3yy 6ls,jj\.0-r--x;[o.iil +i-t U .nilr,;L; f tta'l an b *. Sf :S,-r* t L; : ]
Jq- r y a*-^:lioiql- y 6 L*i>.+U ,-rl"t .9la,3J ,-;I - - J - I r v--r , ,
.r-r-: r:{"i-;lL c-rS:& rf 6\ 6:ls bU$).[:3r a*il3j.-rL
-6 Jr; -,*rl s> 6ltlr LaJTJt-:iy.4^J :,-ily"ios cit"
:l,.i-Ji J*.+;^b 6LnclJl-* yls >9-t-^.ti3 ry $; Jp--#,St,a;l:
.gLa"1_r,-i;1pt-dt ! Lsc-;!-r dl9+ JJ oJ Jt--;r .rl:r5.r-"
l-\b );t r ,P* Jrl-:" ,G-tsi)-y y uric J. A ,*)V-,-) $-H, -sl>:Py c-[i:r^:-.: jl+5 JJtf ,y./L;Jl1r.JrS J $;G:fi3 rio:r: 6,I.:y -^Kt- JLjr L^.li,rr5 e @ l; La.l'[c-;l
.5.Jt-- 1r ..t5;a'U .tU:1t; :y rJL:.i)\..e.j c--Ll JLirJ ;.: 6 l;
.r'Kt? )lblf +.*"t-- ctLo-a 1: .r::-.il: :t-i=l a;iLpt jL o^"t+ a, t.ol
,li ,. J ttS a.J.-b aS.r*l,U qgla-"ta ;: o-Lit!-el .Kt- t-, i:3U:," 6 -[Jry
1.: l;,r^,-,.r*i f!L-y- 6Lasl,s:L; $y .rUT'yrtS t-".li.c-*1"5t-
orLi:-l -&, 4.<." it c.4+ ;r t^,JTJl .t::-'lt>nL"l.$/ J[^:il
0t*irl9^ e* e5.r5,-;r; )f \ l; 6rlil dlig d:+- n{l.J:5Jt<; 6 Jiry,rrl.r.al jJti,,6rL,a:il.Jt^c-Jt*;L.j; r:Jyr lJj t.J*U- c*.: .)U, dt-X,r-lr- .)J$ jl o;Li:-l L -i:--Xl.r l-as ;l-e Olf )S
.--"J!-y- a:*qr. olf-;:. ;l ,r(, ,(Hendrick de Man) oL -9: .(,;-ur ,+ JL- o:jl-9: .\
,l ,--: -.,t-r jsl 4)4 a5 :r5 o-raLi-. (ilr: L^.g;U ! .rJ r ;l j o:1: oJ-& *; "5) ti.1rl
AVy ",:.":1
ti c-.iJU'" )- ;l 6tl:a'Vr+ J*b 61:^l:i.SL^oL"f .-4Vy- -,:*.(t .u, .'\qf \ .fl.r-*;3i ,,-]
"-:U I fJ\-- ul:S) r-uLr.Ir:
WWW.AEL.AF
,_5ty J, n \V'
.)_.r: r: ,;" ,1JL:ag;l;b Llj_er J) -LiJ..,.*1Jlr,-;!-:ajl: :y-: dt- -ui-, Jl; .<+lt'J".r L.-,.-" .(,- 1: sf -t6 "*Jt..rf-!t;.gL^oL;ljlg-,L*r3 o.:1.: c-.-att-t d'lt lJ ry- cJLa.-r: s ts:cJ.l
,-* t34 +-5 -u:-ll: .:Li=l r_r- oToUGre .r_n, Af :*-S ,-,I,J f*+1, ,rK: 61-jl.);5 IalJ, J- 1, .:)\(L" fL.;.r^-..l[..,*..:t-..llcr3-, ,*^"ta .(-- g;l.r ,f ./;t+; 5;: jl o.r-rT; Ij ^Jt-*,\"t
.-llJt.rrt 3.(.ilrSy^r f..J!- e5 -r.J:y c^i.L C_l S_t- a1 ..r-iJr5
J:st GL^.;r G..ti.gL^ cs: .rjty.rt(rLU 6L^gtL;i.!-iJ .3*:rlT;t;U .:1-**- -1,.s*:Jt -r" .:*1r,. !L*; c*;'-XS
^S rf o:rtr
r:"jqj 5 .,;y.('.1"" .!1_5_r", J- dK"l t s:- 6+)J 6^ [^oi.-r;ry
.ruli +1 c*; c5r,_)/ 6* l.,r-:l.t.j cc*lrlil e i -b eli tftgtsu\t L*5:,-u"7h.:Yl3* pL;," 6jK;*t cSlt ot*jt ,Pei, : * q*.-t:.-X l.t,J .j1:--. :l ;l 3 La" j J .gLoc* 13; +l't*. c^ -^l o;L1:
.:Y13-* y; CFa[ c*ili.," etlt J_r] 45 -l*i$ cS-q)y olcsqfrJ rsl y. | : 6:U;o!L- 6.* : f ,il C A.t::*ib,r" l-^,ii .J.ita*"t-- of ;"L +, lyt(-ii3 J*)r/ )f r, i-i, J) rr.,t-f .:J*-, GWo>:_f s*:lr!1 pLj c--1"-- c*ili.,, F| y:lr.r" .:l;L:"\ 6lL-ol o,-tey
,, L^.tT,rJ-r c;l:.r-o S;ly a.r-"y Lo,ti \lys.t:S:.la t-r a*"F J",lU y
ji'" L,6il rc+.a jl;YL.-ury .:oV "sF 6;-:* pL, .,.r'l; -L^U l-.,, -.L_ e- u
(Weltanschauung) L-ojjtl )l e-t.<." U" *-J- 4 .rir_r {;li lyj $.:j,..u5 *._r lJ,jtjjlrl$J.b er ol-i,o:l: qgLaoJ-o3 c*;\is" d.r:5 *lrl
WWW.AEL.AF
1 s;Jlii g^*'jiol
L .t-13 4jEJts.<iJ l-13 o;l:1 4 ot ^-la J5,.tr..i -ta13-.[.t1 .:;lrrr tSs.lt s tS ,Sl.lt.
(\c\v) \jJcc*l cJ3: et-(,51-i;t5 e3 61.J3 -1>tt
,["el .c*l fl)i ;<rf L.3 y 6V* +, .=Jl*".i- L o;3J1 .t--! .t.5.,-- ;L5 a5.rJ:,-r--.ti
c--cUl +5.rJ:.:*l ,# U&t J,-J. J.Pl.rr:;3i1 'I1la -us.r;
(\ 1rv) ' ,r*rt; ;rP
;1ri+;YrLe J:-7r+ crr,5:La:il ,5:l;i, *s-,t oJ,l Ji:i[^n ggrLa:il c-;l
)l j c:S-.),4 o.:1.: ctLi-i u'el3 rg>l;i,Sl; fjY .tr: .<, ol-* y .-J.etr,oi
flK>e-"l J 6_& J>,t;tt..i-"1*:.f f+" f- j c*-,1) a-4,}t-*J .i-6ly.l:011 ;3->,i)U q ;u.ilis-i +5 ig:lil e1;; .:;J L (G;f;,+a;u
il a--.-a +, , <>t-.a-:il i-:.;l o.ir-l cliX*-".;y',r" c.rl.l $jL o;13^a:y,-- '-a_:
J.-*A ! J .t:...3 ;#ttt-Xd J yc-*at"S fr .91^..r,-l jl ,S-,!-*
.r-rl t""?ip;6>l1i glr. [lie c^"-la, jti !.fy*.:.jJly," c]:
€t e g*)L c-r--:t 4.15 JJ-t",#.St*" a, c;.t ilt 5J) ft,r1tjt,l. Lenin 2. Leon Trotsky
WWW.AEL.AF
,j'rJttr \vY
a.<L ,:b r^lJ; .r!1i1 l; grlli t .l*,t .J-Li kj4i ,-ri a1 o.r"-; gly..r,1 -ualr; ;[^--x a, itl sgly *t4 alS:t
a5 cr3J.-*." c^=-l :a.5 +--ti" 1; c-;1 Ly Jt c.*l ,:e 1-t-:1 ;:c*19 +5 c;t;l ,! C ,el_it+ 9 c-\--!L a:-.il: .r_1-3 +*a.gly $ly.r")1>J a-a^,51y .r,13;,rJ rljTa^"L- 4 -,, 6.-[r[5 c,--;l y .:*l U*3 )3J*r >l;l ;aa' cr3*i L.leol:lil +,;t;lolrr.c q J,-t.J _, .r*iL a:^ib
)B)J;J. oL:--l; Sl"?s c-.*aljl"l"ts J),ti:*l 15 c.,t ,;; ,li :l uet;1,.-s"-...; $-J--:6L-oc-:,, JF JlJ.;: c-:."1iY3tcc.-;t Ly st rrl.c.*1r;l,rJL-l .<1 c-.-f <,LU j or_e, rlrrlpL; Slt GG fl.r-;-'U -,-rt.-*1.: .rjlyi,r-" ,:J \ o?;:,.i_ cS c.*l 6i c-t'iJ\,JX: L9r*ca+'ju; -,* -..t# ;lt:_ft,:i ;t J-: eu,"s-! s ,sal;Jl! -*La".r-i;.r;yJir.*a : bi-t> #l-.i-"! c^ft LJ- 3r ,,lcj( Jlygf.^lF oJ-a[-i-, L+gsl ;: .+L.j
"""L c.:*l rti a:--t-i )] _f 6 l1 u.cV
;r o,t-ia,oli c.-;l;- ai c*ld;1t '; a:r- 6:tj ojl$lU;L.; rrl.rr5I 6 J )lil €t tSlt kji 45 ,-*l : c.*l ol J*<" 45 ,lj! ff jl ert
.:;lr r3>9 o_*d ltelJljt .-!J- t" Jr:S tl
oJ; )l -S *- 4 q 6c5l4*"1- stl-fi 6 rll-r.j:r,13..r!:6+
.grl;i;;l.r-;l ); +" o3J- :lr.il ,gly. *13,,u^, c -*.-lJ3l fr.dl* c*r>l;l rglr,. *_L +5 rr4: r;l.r.iL-lo;L;r.grL; oYl3,- .r- 3r";; e-f;--lcoi: a-.c*111y,-:r t-o.li o' O,K;*U 6 -tilb )FJ r*F J;*i:,rit5- 6:1;T;1 J{U r5.,- ,-.t +.^"te r-, 45 dl^JTU"i ^S f<" ,-et,ll-r,.f t-'i-*; J,lt G*-rU 5)FJ '.ry' :lr:fJolr.(:.rJL*a.F e l-l .r_e--:,./t - 6U-b cf J6.r-7 e1(:- ):t *\Li,- 6ly 45.51*i3u ) fu cU.-c Jil.r-- olyrt ei c.*.it.r dli,r.*J
4 -U:X*: uro ft a5:;l:;3>3 "}-LJli*,
1l3; ";f r) r9,-.9-L= -:i.(^-.,;":*-o.\c5l"fz- _,, ts+s" ;$) & jl ilt aS l; *!t ; & -<" )l 6s\t;it ,j- o:3a ,e:Sa:f -<c-: t "Q f * a5 ;>t<-- .-r-j r-i-z--r u , -l ;5.* ;5 lul :i q -u:! ts,
.J" ,J,
WWW.AEL.AF
\ Vf r 6:l;:i 3 *-;1
cgil3;.: .r,-5 ;ryL rl,.ilgt,j ,Slt\s -\-i! ./t5 o:r5;l5..*Ul-r, y,ri,y-o-r-.:
a,atr-i rl.-. [_o.:.t-" c^.-t1f JJI,JU*KI.:.*^+ lact ,);16tr''t:*l
l.lJ -s> rlrjl a, .!! cJy, l* 6 r;lIJ rj'--3 ..rU, 6a i,x;1."-a
cr;lri l-,1 L^JiL oJ:, )t)) Jrt-i,.lt*,@l6"r,c -hV y"S Gl);cs-,t=*A dTJ) 45 o[i:La-j.J-,L*t y d-rL"* &".; )l Lsrly;r."t5.(53l,51-aj)u J L-\ U-l )l C-:st Gly. tP o;bl s-t--i, i4; e^rL cJ3r
.r-tr,tt ;t- 61y cJ,9.: cS;f*^ q jFc:F..r- t-^oi,5t-ar"L t * elt;;6La+5; .:_#.t d,t-.--1u:.,, jl.rc: fU^:-l ""* etr ftlt ..(1
,Ai gf-t-- rrlrl,.,r-i,l s &G: (\-L: L;- dlr[eJ.t a5 Ji;lr )J.J 13;ruj
"-"* fU q:.-,.i c.*l ;5.*" .c-.-:1.: l:-olJr r, -ryrl to,li.rE;7 r-, ;
,l-"1..r-at-i c.:G-, j4;lil.r:d : € : t-S o:-* .,jt l$l,ret"-71
3 cJ3.: G-r )\.y' ;l! -& c".-1;*.'U .r:,)-y*trU;6^'Yr,.elJUli a. .(5 ! ll-,,.f cJe:;yD;**^.;;lJ .:y--3 6>; ,5:l;i Li-45 t+p.:3*i, c*;l.,il,-il e.-! J:+ -s
l):,J-.i jl d* 6L-\L^OiJ-,\rr;).r3-> jllili.,-" - rrP d.lt"\ jlJl3a es."+ t5tt(-ac-r.-ot.(1 c-u.,-iL a:-it.: l;oi.gt-a.r"L ! d-u,l, :yt J rii i s or-F c^Lit --"
.>syu *>13^.o..4Lo6;t-(-a Jr" {q .("i oy.l,
6rLa:il c!t-i ,rE ..:UL; 1r .j-,t* cga+ .:U19ii ,.1K:. ,.;YL 3
;--l .gii3;: .:;tr :1>. 3 ci:*l cli r"q 6 g*l d-rtsvr G,, G y'fl :Jfu ip-l J-- .l:;r^ cLl .c*1 U oUj Jfu At3;t J i/JJ,..i.i
o?l; LF Ji.["Jqi Ll cc*l ,li c--:" ,JL*" q C4) 6J)bU-i J-t!.s-.^i;1;Lo:r5 ;j&\q Ut*a,iiJf"l* p 6.b 6 ,:,-a 61s'-V1.
{f s> lj JKi- ir+l.St^J- o1; Sll3r-ltlUl>;L.":il-,1d-,!..1c6i13;:
i erri ;; f*Jt*J q -+ ,9>\-): i-S € "5 +L: .rJ* -*t=-jlL{J .,ilJ e*y }1, u--rl rli:ela, 6 r;1r c-.JlJ;"1 ;13 -ryl$
et-;l J -, ) , Je , *L1e" -:> 6 e-r* dG-,t5 .;=ir 6..turcrl-" ) A-p\ Jr 'e ' e
WWW.AEL.AF
u!:1olln \Vf
J) tsr+ ylf )st d.-eL c*l o<-" dr+l .-ui, J^lf JeV rJ.-*r-rgt-fK:-l-," -r+! -,r,- ,-:.-ltr ,:Sr>16 al,1Q c:y), ,>,1i1 a-cS
J G;r# a;6:l*$l,Jt^sJt* pLd.r7,;.i; ;**ttjlU fr-xq )J=aJ ;.' :U:.cl ,. s ,F.lj ,iK +J yl cLl gS S# * cJl.r 6;ti. g-',-a 1.: .c*l Lg)L^a-il c.-..1 -r,.r4; C}S:t! o<al-," c,F "lJ }jd:;1-L-l.li a-, .:UL-; C-l tlt ;r c-;.1 ;*"'U ca; ;.: .:Ll-til g-j6yr-a cr.ljV
.r: J^lF ,a;- c>2J,u"6.:ljirl.:kil E ycoq .S CtL*tt Ly.:11.: .5:l;T,g3 ) -/, ;4,;L .fu" e5 c-;"1 ,glr-.,g;-;a--"lrtjl c^il^-- c6'4at!r; Ly U_l -ira.c*t c--:-l ,K: U: LSIJ 6i-:+"Lr..riLi; a-*t- .i- _,r .t:3,.^ co*[ar;,il ,i,,"5 ilJ :> rlll 3 G"s]t-ral \ tP 6l-t lr;>\(:- +5 c-*l .5.6:,* 3 c.uil,r*J dUrl 4-L.A
;-..:.-e,r1U; fLtr q J[-;"-r J) J d-il$ j)\>l *i € oS r:)Jis,
-c.*la-iYrt-e )iq:+) ! jU -&t J<l cc-;ol e, -,U .,*lca;;ljl..i::.--a31cgLaj)U L# e-t-a
4 J ) j.r-a! .gt^**--"U .,.LlJ, 4U e5.-gr;*:-rL-; S;:,/t;rllr 6rlliL cJl.r_e t- c-"al Ly Al b1lrt q r*!
..t-"! ,*s,U.,..x I tS :3;L .jJ:;" rSL-att5 J :# _, J.c[." ,,- rlr-il Cri S..fB _,^ t,.5lr- Laoi.:.1+" q J-itr -, La.r}":,r ,-Sg o:f )f tF./ti--il;t-b":lril ;"t> 6lau!;*-e U$f F ,t os* p a.-V 6l-n-ol y_l-c-rjrlr.il.gl-a.-i.La J b,J")L &U" sEl o;Tc*sa, Ct i 6 r>,ra ..r*.it1
;) ro i-tj ! .-t-q y.gla*"t-- Ly e -rr y 4s rilj;.rJ ,r-l cLl
,*'U c--; uaL; 6lae.,,Le. t- &tL ,-?J. ot-y,+ 6.5:J::" :11-y
tl,.ll #ileJ c^;r \UJ )lL u-a.-riL.,r,,r::; o.ur,r-tr+, hlr:;r lr o-t-.la;i f lS 6lao)W ,-itl.rt{ t O aO*,. a!t"..r,-:;rr"ia:i;c.*rjlcc*lJ:.o.rg- +^"t-- rlril ll Slt.6 GGlFl 6f 6. -)ldt S r;1r y;r l: Uy ,lljl 6rU > jj, ca:)K qgLaoJ- 61;U .-u.lr.f
.$lorlr :lS -iL c,-hj lJ ro rl;,oLor^e La;irt
WWW.AEL.AF
\ VO n .9:lj _e --;l
e: a:3i-, i:^15 6 S*:< )* \ 6 tF 6t-ar;*-.r jlrlil6yl-u vr.
C* ) t_i *Sjr".t'q:-:la5;,1r13.i, \s sf dt^Jflff -r $;.f,J:*c./ a:i1c.*:jl r"t il.4l*l:-l 15t-a.)JL6., \*W 3 ..:y r-:).i; 6rrlqgLac*ly,- J L^jUi.rjL-.f jL 1, L al-ol,;cJl* u-- {ry o:t
4:;tAp* ol;tl:;ljlc."-1"-- c*a ;.: .:Je: c-Jt--: jl;: 6 6rlil.c.--Xlr -l-alyr..t, J) lJ pf"r .:-.te 3 4l:;Io-a d/Lpl
-'l:l"Lr rx1u"
c--(+ J) L+J4j lJ jt,l$l 1-^.:J3: 6 o-\--i e-! l^j! A.l ,lyo ,irar,.rua: pt-,..Jl Lac*.yr..-, 3 e)\(i- l.l J i ;!,:r-i : lil jl c.Jrl"-"
;r t-"oijl-, o); c,il:, L-^oi a. fb -,* *.lt JLrLr$ oh &t..t::S .,-1"- JljU .-^:I -t )lt )l-#> j c,->*, b-lr A,t
)id,) ..(1 dli,r"j c-u--:U rlji,F-i ',l;Jl ;: :lil c.*1 1!r! ft c-l
.glr- r;^:-r ;-r'l aS u;-t_t' -s: s )-f e";: a^.r,gly G*. J oeelTttr:3,-- c--;,1a5 6rlil e--,a q jqrl
L;r, 6 r_r c,ilry b.r;1: :lr-il .9r11i -J* Lr olf.f +5;-,1 .:3- .-L^lJ, ,Ju':.lcl a:i1c-*:;1
et"lllu Fl: qc>15 ;r.;: +.-o 61r, lJ .,,t*<,- )j^:r) crlli .:tijldl-.Ji .i ol 3:,.e *. ? J -'i..rl;t-t.il aS VeJ J+r^,
311 s 3r s U .c.*1
a:-r- +7;i.-r:-l\;ti &.r,1L;t, rlil 6 ,:*l 61.-- Ll .;,*i.r" rl,rJi
J )_#elL-elG"J; €J i1,r,.eU c-r-lyl+5 c.*1 ylr-/,r" gta.:l
Q:v.:lil) .r-;l-,r";! Ur;: o1l3 -a 5 61113lS c.*ldr',l, A+ri
c--ul j-l-ll.li t -p 1: +5 c*i F e .)J,, Jsl;r- ,r-l[i 1: a:^"y,"
o5Cr-lU r*i r-l3, u.t----l o:st' t di jqi J a:rt- cr"il}l.,+, jl",+
;r-i; c*: jl c-+ y &.,.1i o1 ;*L c.*r ,51r, 6\*.? 6P ft'dlr.)y J^lJ;:L;r,6.:l;i
J G*k J-iU,+ L"l;x;'U c-^'*;.lt^l'oryJ'!):l- 6.il'AJTt'l
4!ai fl J r;..-* c^t t"-" tartj ,Sl^-,y," jl +t*-r ":"15
Jis "|1U
,.r^Plan for Reconstruclion, Jli&\))-.:5 -,: fW n@o.:r5 a-51-ll Jll +."t-,!,1-9;; )t )-tt)a,Jt^c,* jl a;-15 ";11:.rJla r?,;],r[;i
WWW.AEL.AF
,jttolrn \VP
r:4) 4J jlJ-.it_,r-. .,!l;1 Al,-J,,ji-"^;'U c.-ri rtt-.trtryJu."r_ry 15
6:a lra:;;- ) \>)J*a ci-l -r: ,J'--,j L* c*11'-:U 6la:3*, cl.:13i
ol-5,*Llf [-a:;^:*: .c^-ll: f^l3; U,ilj,S: j,. -U..)3- lf cSl.lql_,
.r+.J+, -t "! l-, j.t n> co>r$g q! ;[Sot rr.i 6yl o;L-rr ctLo5t--.r-yiLi;l .J-i J^lf C?i t^Jts ft+l;: rt,il q ey J 4 F r or;eJ4l J--l a# -t5y.J-! 6;Lpl _s 6>p Julicr-,j .,lt :"-4J drri"6La.r1;-: c..Lbrc/ pt+t ;t--<,_;t5 +5 ig.:lil J^: JllF e-eU.'l:)Le:t-,=,-l 6lr- l; .:lrjl 'ft t"":;^:*: o:3-, r)3Lb..r5 c-iU_J: r:3U:,"
c*jli -U.alF +-n;j ;r 3 :r-r J--al_9* ;,- jl .rcL^:-l ,rlLr.rl-;a:-il.r ,rti r."'J "<.",J1^J-! 3 .r)\-(i.-" ! + r# o3li;
.Jju\ ,St* Qtt tF €.S) J* .gt1.r.:1rt--"r ! nLrri,l:Ll fl,Ut&tj- rrri J) rlrll6,j;,, oJ,,=j -l ijlij (-Urt.l :r-i,r-.ai 6L^,,(;--tiJ5..,ilf$- ol;9-.r ,,* )l *1. os_r+;l;: cJ:-o.r -,r+ l-, .il:;-.G-* $li,ri o$e J{e; rre .(- -uT;: 5 u,l<6.:y): c>1j.,c
.l3iJ5 *ls 65):6 ! sQ;!..ri;r c.r;l: c*3; l_, ,*:5 6 "p: ;,1c.:_21I.r.iJ L,-a)dLj \Arsir_r;r :r.i r3,- +5 t-7.tT jt.-r-a.r
Et-*.il:3.-Sl rSl,,..r,-L .rj;l.r;L;;1_2: ls ::.f ,5t-.-r."i;.: Cry ,F l;rS 6.il"Alli
.J5..rLi-:il,-6,; rll e.-., t1_9,Lj o ,,x3 1b ta;t 5 .,it5 .i<l ,J't*"
)y.- oli Fl-r= d*t Jl'S y gl ^rlrl J"t"i * Gr*, 6 c*l..gtaJ'L*. ly;
& _s.t't*. rU; Llcc-*lga, :lilJ)Lj oS JiJ" .: rj,u, L j,,r"
EL; :l;l r.^ly-.r Jt s c-*+ al b "[<*.
.c.,,"i ,ri o; ,lt€tff.J't- .,.-, !a* t-a,ti.gly l: \lr r,-q ,$;5 -,15 t l-, ,;r .;i)L4 +! .5-5 tlj3l: L-n1li rr-- a- l; -,li:il f+lf.f ft S ,>; ;r,.1
.rl;-r" .ti ol.-: o-r L; ,*a.r Jl; JL:Jqrl ;r 1; 6lort-"i , uo;-* ,t-,r 4.,
.gLa.;Sl d.R. )f.-9 !.r-.J:d--.t lJ Jl:;" &U",rrt"-7lc=",ol
WWW.AEL.AF
\ VV n.g:lj 3 c*;l
crLJcr:y.ru*r y d.,rJL .hl, 6,a:lil 6 C:t*-lr dt6-7 i )Fy<, a:t^KT-,lljl cJa-r.i ,m;e .J; .<,-;r o-t-.lt!-ol e\ly s a.r,"E 1r
:y ,.$i &- {..j ;: a5 u( yl el;; 6lt ;y. ralJ, aF. * FA-&t L?.* Jtt5t-.: l;i.tiy o.:r5.ff 1, .r3* olyiJ: L?- J-,6 +!Jl-* s +*"t-;: Ji,t-*" J-,-l ,*tiriii * ,i):l c-*lgjY ,S ,Jb_f
.r- ua;* c-t::S,r" )kl+, +5.;t-ar;;-r.l.Ili,r^J :lilrtta7;.r grL;: d S.f ,* ,€ u,l<s J.(..:," c*Jt
,.Jk -.rr x, rJL.j.: ; ,jY"t*it",, 6 c"t & J:5 Jts c---ra ! ",;),.t .:J, t
! U r-,- JL"r!31,a3.; ,_tr-tG cSb_,L:! 4! cS:Lj ;lilgly Jil-r--..r*lt
fi..'..;lr Jfu ,*,J;Kl n:L, ,_E jJljl .r:5 _,t5 s,--ril t,:$ fUJL"rl .J:5.,- .yJ;.r:,-rr.r- c^Jti o)f s> g^ -,.J_r* ,Sb-,l5 o)f :>
d.,-"^; 6t*'u!l )$r' c5- a*"t-- F es: t. t/+,gLo.<.s;.rrc*l,ly'r tlJiJ.-, 6 t--irs e.iL lJ *V;1.:)\5-irr-c.*lo 1 e-> 1.r i*- g oJ a; ,9111: 45.itlr-J"i d4.<-- dS -,fl.lt_^aJJ J ..J
.J:5.," ct! co.:rS oJ-at-.l^." lJ JKi" ayJ r 3 e*l ,JS>6t:*Vyo-t-l-i.gp-_,1a-"Li y 4;>V;i'l c-Jti cual;g -,t5 t.(1;t+,1 Ul;rl :\f u, sl
U -*tl a:-.i1.: r:r+-r J--t .,.aj=-:, dt-.J:5 4!l-l lJ -,tS +!6:[ "b*;
.r-! .r_d.r" l;t f :S ..(. ^s ..rG r L_y .r+ ,y.-b ai ;t dtf tS
C+ 4,.-? r3'>y ogJ: .ry'-:, +:.:,UK :6 aF cil:; c*J ,t J Jts jl
,[:" c*;r .,.tr-i +; jl o:t-i:-l \ & t"5 :ltllt & utr; ,6:l;i)otfu, o:t' t-oo:y L 6 6:Vios
$.t SSa a. .:lr-ilcSL^,,tt-ta a=J .J't "- i .Jfl ;l5 oj3+;r.rLr:il .i- _,,t 6 .:-l ol'^1, a:K gt j.: a, .c--l a)* c."-,r+..rt-a t J,l,JE -r, ;-,13 c*l t-o.ti..lri ;1: c:lr.il q:-, cglt 01, y-;io.r-i tsl-su|l5 .,1rr;.Yc.*IJl3rlo;.rt,a-o clt-(al; c-ri r;V::t",r:il.{;r 5 c,..1
.004 .d, ,(\CrO) Fl ,;al^ o1+" .gb 61-:*Lt Jysln,(o. C. Coyle) Jrt..,,- .o, .',
2. W. Roepke, Die Gesellschafiskrisis der Gegenwart (Ztrich, 1942), p. 1'72.
WWW.AEL.AF
6'tJ-tr \VA
.(t -,r ct-"I .r-e- -r.-al3, 4-E-)\" "!U
; r_/ ltcl +U 4jl,;)t5 -dr" l(1 tt1c--a, *.G-e d-t" .(- .--,c9r 3 -r."i;, o-u;grpaair; i-g:L,a^ilpLE
ta:;3[--.r j c)p; oS ta.-ri jt .c-*-r, al-13 sl Gp_s c.-"j.gla;t5 c.--*,f 6etJ 6L-ao3L.aj .fLlf Jli,rJ oy-:,rr.-; Jl ,J"ti fl56aeFg".*r: o-\-.ic.*i *lg Ar"6.,-rLl-t "i,-q "<! ra.r p$llJ La1ts
+KL cc^.-; se^:,.qil ..(1 L;t J5.it+l .rirt *U 3l a5,rat*il .-r5
.tUj U .)J- qJ JiJW -rr e!,e or.l 6r,. *"ta qb aS c.*l u,7;r clJlgi,_r-. l.5.,- 6f )f e o$,Ua-.-3,"" -qtl-l ,".--;.: jl a5
ct-.| .r3*i, -;lt-t-i;, ,S; jrJA a;* :t,;lra,Lr- Ali:6 4 ! *-tLjljJ-i :-l-r" a. -t5,r-" !"J+ b:t5 d**(,.i '>_:t';: l;3! S e-Wr,r;lr tKJ c;t\ tr,3g|:lr.il.[1y"1 Jlr.5 GG)t .c*1 .#::;,--l rl:1.: c*.: jl c-""i +. c-.--l ;--l t-"1 cc.--!l: Jalg>,g:Lail c-;1
.*-i.r" c*: l r;Jr;r {-1.r3J>-r :S* -S StDi
Ly rt .;* Jd)q-.. ..f )W .! gJ J.- lr.li+! t" a5 esV c6il-e;r
+, t^,rT;l 6-fv dlu,J j:}tJ q 6 c-.*n:t.rr.. y"ts;1"-aldt jL(f,-Uru.51"4.j13 tayl"t-t-: .>-#g r!.fH o*"te: i5_,t+; arrtT,tlj"-c
a^"-$ utljKL* Jo.:lr gty,* tg_ts_* * oK tlt L 4.-i lr-; -u.-xL
! c*l > jr o;-gs J, oll;* f^: .lL;u;t e !.,*1r( -b :t f^ tt .frLl ,ys> FL"L.j .>Lfi cs-r!-: jl d:irl c6jly;.r .c-*l :ljie:r-a;l
g:i J*.{ t-i f tS t' -r tK f^ oi;: eS .,jl-jL cc*l rtt-";t-
;t-;l g<* jl :1;l d-ql (rJ.>J.o .5La; l;l rt.:y"-, .riSl i o : t' ;) _9 ori6:L.r:it c--;1 clly,r",ri;.r a5 c*l .r"tE tfi .,cl .sy J:-al-9> _tlr: fl;l l; rlrJl**; dlJis- o*"t= JS * ,ti ;r:3 ! _r .:_5 lLcl :; q .,Lst+/ ! y .r_r5 )3J>.-r l1 .gr1;T 6 c*l ,r--l ;rrl cLl .c;L .uror.61 .ti
;.: a5 c*1.#lq, i c6-rl9;r -c*l tr.r.t Ll 6t:; GW. t -* g t'--rt-,)ljtr- .gl-aol53.:1 I
*s.lL;L l; :lli a^"L- ..<r- 6ttr:.;1 c"[-,al ;l .-*Ll; ,)lis" .{.Jl
WWW.AEL.AF
\ Vl n 6:lj 3 c-;l
.5Lac-1r-c.t-*." f -*,J") Ly Al l,> a5 rzi-Li ,yay JJ, d.r-5
..tTrtlatr* aS 6>lr-ol4-a^ r -r,-!,.r5..r Jt r!r; d.rl-l rSs-t t 6 eE1.: +-j[J131.: .,}l- -t-- dL^_,S6r- .! pl +;l .6j13, : .: ri LLel c..tu:*,a
Jlja l;.ru-iL c-J3: S\ u-f 3-j,-,|L. r d-j+. xlie c,lL: L;L;;-ljt,r;lrta*", a5yl..:;3ia-oly an eU\ -r."iyr Jil..r-- j jS ,>-altqi c*l c^aJlJ U-l -hG a- *lo;cr? :lt Gl*:13e a:^1,5;r
"[*cJ:.S r3-t-*.." c^.."1;;--:b JQ -,, 11 :3,--.g:lj1$!..r^i -;V aS 6>lSl
I dlr$t )l os-x4 -l- t, ;l 6:l;i fl6 rilo.:y JJIJU-IJ, d.-*a.c.*1 .g;ly'r ;t5 [-c:l A-l eG -fu *i d.pq r,"Jl .rJ- :^L J,"q
*W * J"t4i.(_ -tii,Jl-jL ./V Ly c-;l:,r." 45 JJ"LJ[*^ ct"i
JS q cal ;;3 o:.t';r "l.Jl9ir.. 5 ra.:,r, a5l;lL + l) Jb,l; )l.r"l-Ej J-eli o"L.l_e *t7 )l c*). Lli 6.rl"J U .qi trs t 4*"1?
AL*IJ ! ../U;; dt"jL 6l*1,5:lji,-l:y )3-re.-c ,tl rt_*€,rr:r.rL;L6l;o.S-"+, Lac4r3J-*-" J:J)) t>sy,a;.: .t:jli,r" rlil a5 cirL jrl! d l_,61a-"t-- \l-J f.tf,-f -St.-* -ra!9- e-t5 *6 6f i>Di4-.: J-"q g5 5;: r:-+-i,r.-" ,r.a:.tL;I,- 3 tl. t -rl3 +it--rlS 4.9-,f*.rLJi a-t* e$ dU.j,;, (.:rFltr) tr,U;L-l,r
-<j-cJ:r ,1 ft- trt;ai -.L;; J_#l *;",1;.r c.Sr- p a- L- yr
-,1 .r-, 6 f-fu .;-f.C-l o-L*;
6.rL; .:lrJl asr-,-t JL.:-l cc*l orr5 .:rL-c 6>l_si o,6 ggla*"Q;:Ll.c*lfS r-,rTcr) 4J.rkl d.,1* L l1 c--*"l4jl)lji.tJt J"rt--+5.-u:*a 6L-oc*!- ,u_f g JL-c!, F+",o;-r ct_951a"a 5 ciLac*l"-4i U# cr:*5*-" lLrll J-t ,J; \,tG t "Jf 6.*. eg l; c.;"1
:l iA_* c-;l.gl; s+)U,.lT-1r 45 JL_ri6, )J.J il.1: &\r \t-er.i .1"t5 6>\i 6lLcl L 6 c-*l d,cl; Ji#.: ..r5,r, ,;[ gg:l;i \ &.i" rl ,riU .i- ;: ft .+l,c
'kl?lt^"s-S ,1L c.-;l le *:-S 6.1. Sparta
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5rt,l-, ! \A'
't*: "r-:UO jt-..lJlJ<-) Sl-t 6,r^-6-.{5 e"-A b.f-r 61y 1; "$.:-r-l;r- sc-;ol pj)'F 3..:y -Lr13>rJL-y-1r .<"5 J5 "illljl ,-iiir^lJ, j,* jl r:.-, il .ri'.1 or-i,,r- oi -* &lL fU .t-i 6 cLrc-. er.i
.C^eJ
a-. aS ,9;2a-Vt U ol b"-b jl L A JliC l;, c-;"lc;ljU ptJai.,r";;t
-e .gt- 6 ;-ya-"LJy EL.; ,q*
+ f) c* I I y y t 15j L c,-r3r-,.-, ))
r,Jr5,r .>f 3r,;; u-cV 4:G"s-S el; (lt_*ej,t*i l, .r^iJL.r!jl tu-t"-,- -b >-t_f c*S;U. b^-): )J-bb ! .l-.Ji 6jL:3"t-.r r.r:a-
jlJ.jli,r",5;l;U rL,a:ilr.: jt(.r:S.rJy; a5 c.*1..+1t t<i cl.Ac-".; ,-it--
,_,:^l.5 L. )-1,bLt1t ,S ;--l ct-.l .$F: #U dt " .r."i;, 4 q .ri..r.,!a;- or5rJ;r.i ;l c*l -,ly Jl .t_i e,:lr31t tSu efo, 61a,.>-a S6_* )l o-\-i:t-6-i.-.,
"*-L. AL^--.g JIJ tt - f -,5 at _l -r..l,! C-;i:S
1r dJ-.l ,'.+- .,1 , ) &:lr-il a5 c*l ,r-" arf "f-l cry' c--l^=.llr.(r-t'"
a5 ,r:1:3,r.- t_$ -+..r-i -u.alr; p:;e=. .o;r--i,J ,S eV g;Yt "U*; ;3,;: a5 6rljl pL; c-"-l c:jL
"$:," l-s ,S-sS : -S t{ c=,tJ ao. >91j 6:\i
6tlpl.:l.t*j y e5 ojl$l .tL*^ t J.ra)L/,_,:^5 lJ .t::.".a c.Jt*o J,l jl eJt>6Lac--a S o _i d o.:3;il cJ5,r- &"4; |
-s t _t' I"T;: o ri-.:, ir-tl q a5
ttFg )3Jar J:a;,rr C,*) jl 1;.:-g.:;+:-: a5.5:1r.il GS-: &, U"6"la
,JLi c"rlraj, € ;:V o\r',.; J tr; )l6J:,-UJrU :_* y 6 6L^oi6ly 345 4jJSJL*a ,fl:.tssC ar,.ljl;; )j^:-r) 6Uj^-J',:^[5 ! el.l-i"j a71r*
_sl:yyir, )Ja€.: 4i :: \l-i;l a5 sg;[5 y :J y';) cr.:+l ory J_1-"
L- r_l- aJ. )f Li orr5 gL; a:^-a )lb bl;.i a5 ;u.lq jQ-" :lr!lcc*l,tS:f cSbtl5 y :J;.: JLi >lSl ,>yy*a;l 1.: c-r-L- c#) iYU )idr)
g& stQ J-r t -# *-F * y*.i;r+ -e t.:*i'l-: r-:^lF.-s=.16,o
;*'U,Slr j),\.i +-.="1 1> e5 c--1, 1.: ol i C*J .r,-.:; .c--.i l.r J-alj,- .3, 1.r
;) c---:,"1 p-r-c,li i *. SrS-,8:;;l ,gt-a+a.:1) 6 o)y Lo"f-f ;l ! c-*-l\ (_'
.c-*1 a:r! ")alyl6laL-y" "!U
JJt t s:*.? llq5lo-r^-c dtauir..1 J-L*g.:L,l-t J orJ a1 5 4Lac.-)-9J-*,o *K"yi :oE*L(:1r,
WWW.AEL.AF
\A\ u d;)ljl J i--"j-cr
J) 6r:rl *f tf y *lit*;,tlry, -f ,.f# rt*lc:;lj(*n ,j'U o."t+
6Ja"lLi.p{.51; l; L-^..ti6Lou! fW ft-.jl, .}t.Ll a-, L 6,rJt--
J $; J*!J o[:,J-u, .<ii .-.-"t+ 4 -,r ..*t;Q 6 lJ crLaJi ;*jlcr.r3', isj.a- 45 &j.51;1r rliljllJ t^,li 6 6la)-cV c*y t***JJ.r:.r-: iyl6lr. a;ic-.-c;6ln ;!xl GI-S; U or.i €.e! clG;lJ.1i45J5 c5;: Mlie.JL6JT L ;; lJ cc.*lorr5 U.- (J.iU {.^,i1)
Alrt<- +;l >t; cgt+ JJrtj 45 c.*+;lL;tL;l.-r:*:L o:r5 a,ra.l
t+ r-r-,gta.:;:*r jl ;:--S tr +! L^Ji 45 c.*l ;lGr* oSJ'. rtsx.
g:<- olr(: )llKt' c--.;J i 5f ci,+,5la;lsla-Q ililf:".l".irr JldJ-, 1B_1jiy.crr:;l-tik*l ,Jt)r r:-.:b ,J.f jl.#,.l:fL- 3 c,r-ilr,r-" .li;Y t; rj'-- &t*f ,lr-rl a,S qgl+)r>-t-,i;rrr L rr+i).:tp
-r"l.xl Ji; )liu J:5,r-.:-iL;.: c,J3r tS_* )lL^,ii45.r^1L.-
{y, y Jtiil o;51 olril ,gLar;^:-r J Lac*"J eV y,oi g y.x_r-r-t
J Ji4jUt-E 6;L^::-l jg.c*l o-t-i, l,l-.i .:ULr; J;or d c*lrL*.-lri-u,.;r$ e.4t .<." L-; ;-;*a 4t 6 e5 o:yf a/l jli+ojlll a-,6;Li @.crGt it:rS.r^Jr;G q F .J.lJ * e ,t-l s t_*jl d.g;t---f cc+l orJ-i Pr oel;.gLo.:;^:-: t" tac*+ c+J Jt-jb b\3* J a-;J" rrKt 63* rl3 o:r5 U"*AIl-,,:f .{.r"i;: J-4
.r_rL.r -*{:*T o:* jl .r+A-P )l
"f-l5 c^r."t.r"U cEl-l t,.gl,oriX 6 ojl$lo1"^ q,..r-l;Q
caS'-l iJ- c J-L. - 5l '.-il i ;lli c: o-.X -o *, ,l iL ptE ': cJti:9-J .€ t)-J J-e J eJ r.rr.\
3 -LJloJ--i l!lj.-1jl"ll 4 o:f u.l,Jirt 6 6rlil c^.-l;." -ryrln5 ojlrlloL*^ q J ;-*c.l tyt rbi 1l pr*" ttst G-# t -r-r ;11;.>l);45 6jlrjl dL"a 4i J )_#d tl.cljLi"l .<{,JlJ-:" c- c,i"l
oer^b r;! .g: l;i q-r j: I .-r-U-.r- .ril; I ii ;l p r--. rlil .,.u5.1-'ra;
;61 j}:;l ,-);3 ! 3 c.-"-l -tl slt1 -Ft >lrilrl-r-; .J&lll! .r-d.r
! J{J? 1"S;1il1.gL-a,"xJJl 6r* ,S--.rtl,dr ;;lU: t^,.1i c^.-l
WWW.AEL.AF
,_StrJtn \AY
lJ c*iJ," J ftr, 45.:*l c.;.1 ^<ir JN;:..t * -&t _t ):-r-l rat-b 6,ls
f-lrjl 6ly,b,l1y+ "i- 6 c*l c,l.i 6r^:- i;jb j -r5.r" t-E-el.:i +,
JG -,, o"-1.-&, o* ydr.i -u".j:;;r ,..,; a, rL*:cld S..f [+.llol.ioril;:lrjlc^**;3 oLl:.5lr--; c*s.i- q,r-lU 5 c*lJ-l L-- cri a-, .r-jla:^- ly Gl*;.: 6 6t"oi 6 "F't &+ 1t--t
.:y .i:-alr; ,- *,si 1> n^-.^.Sl; cJiy' r;lj (r"i;., Li }.l, .i)a5 o.t5:31'.-".:Ll.til ,,* ) c"r-! +, d**t 6_r t €je d);J=",i d--q iSl-,) -tSy u. >-*'*
Ela.,l r.ttc--L*- c...*i J cJyr o;1,-l L
J $yjt -l"i oLJToil, 5,J* ,.$ -c-*l or-l a-.-"E ..,#J.rj JSjr, o5 .;^![- -r cS6{_ri ;t f1r,r(,..r;10:y ,tT_e;+lL;: I^JFS ,,L.-=-^1f5 jl c-*l o_tV d*l ory )lK;U J_F ;) t d+i; c.-e)4
+5.4Lar3*, .,ixil & s ,,-*".(-, 6:L,r-!1.gt^sJt- pL-i,-r.:1.:.3J>
g>yJa oJ.-p d,*.: ar L a ,y- .tl J: $l-e *i l:,g;q.(*-yl-, clt.l -r.,i;:,51;b &l,.1" 6 #, ,cl1 lt:3*,rlJl-9a f*li,rj .r-:,c-t
; LAjTlr-j.fi -F)r r^).sr e-.-t;1q.(-r y rl;T j,oLi a,
J"4-i "l_i_fi, J lJcr-"ll; &ti- d,,-lo-5 qlc/ l_t ss,t-t,JUl3'-
J 61lJut-ri1r a-5 c*la:iL J-\ cL-* -f )J)-,iol9r p.J::5s^6r-^16yi>j- J $; a3l1J6 ,t dL^c^.Jt^, )l ur^" 6J-p .>VrL.
-S-,5 y;,;-c lU;:-I,-ri-lr +5 oL^.cc-loJ..i, .-"-.i y'].]ol] *6;[5 dt*jl :l.t-.; ;=-a q ,J$lJ f- -, r.lrl: ;3:*r .J_l .-r; cJlj Jt^::-l
e-G3:y,l ;--l tlu*,:til c*,1 ;(" .c*l oJ.-i o.rjLL*j Ajl-U.dtly'
,-.S'U.f-lr-ot*t-fuI) o_f)J).)q.lF Llc.r5 # ,fy c*s45,Ji jl i-1,.* --"Li
b.rjrt.qg;l:a,Lr* r; sLi'l"i a-n;J;.: +5:1tr
oJ't*".-r-;t..r*: Jy.; u -# ;_**: cra.: -J L-6dt jt*;r;1r..4dFt- osl3ir- q.7;r La..lL;L- -,lt t* J:J ti a5 c*lr7;--l45lJ dLaorjrl,fj! +i. i : j;i541o_r* J,"! cJ,b- 6l-nc-*lr;
.g5:;,.tU 4jLa[<iU tu fr* L,Slt j:*^
WWW.AEL.AF
\ Af n,5:l;i,e .:-;l
;r c-:,l oJyi61j*jl;: a*"1-Jl:;L -s>
*f o:t+ clrr..J
.;.i- Jt- c.*-=l L- o> v-.1_9> rJo e--[-i" !.tly,,_f jr^ 1: J>ti;lrt,v i! (_
Ll or3-, rL; oLJi,.,F J) .r5tl ,l'U J+J^ .rr5 5;: JLJTJ of;lif+, L ;i lJ ;LJia-"ta 6,1-J!i c,ad* L^.,*JK.]| a5 c*t d;r-" oL*l
c.*1.ti;l ;,h*,Ji *"tqJ) &lcrJ .:yGi.J5 d.ryr rlrl;Le-+a;) i :,-rii 6:;lJ c.*il3 al.r-5 rf )j -b ,ltjl -U, lJ,Jidl3'i 5
"$ ,r o.t-.x ,r-a:sL )l- 3+ 6t; ,rLJi s-:*"a Pl ;+Laot"jcS-,tr*r t o*:61y.lL-(- s J-|",Jt"jL .i rtt-ooi+5 c.*l.tTc*;t,,tLJi a-.-.t-- u.6k?J 4gJ lfl;,l 6 .r,:r5,r" o.:Li:-l fr 6La-o-ra ;1
Jrt eA jt- r1gr31, :-# ;ljl..r+ IILJT+-t-- r).)-r.: o-u.j.iu
.-..*o? ,*-Url c*; y )3,: o.t-l ,ra:.lL1L oJal t* *. Y! -jl.gX-:or;LJ
'4Vdl-^4-+*" a, 6.5.rlril 4fl ,-|-c:*" 6:ljl * l; r3"- ..,tT
_,t:;t* oo} s!,J 1: )l &r.r.i".; cl s *>_5,_* rl-r.Ji .r;lo-r--i,
,-r-J;l:;lfl.tiq f- LAJLJi t-*- 6 rrLub.ryoUi;r"lS.ft^:-l: t'Q* tSJl 6 F,..:L-r--,il;l ;; Q,;+j oi ;: 6 ;YJt .:r" .oLJi
e*nJ J e dL-.<, L-r: :l/l.t.(t-, t iy rJs;.:Uy,- pL;t
'.l^i.r'tr at+r^ st oliet, 6>l)i 1s: ,S c-i< bli.l J,-)/ ! 6,rJt--;.r
llj :);ljf_ea ;L ,-^.>-K,Jt+Jl ! dl_r-i Ll oy J. )l t) Jl"eL
.,.r-,5.llri,ji ) &, -tl e-rL CJ-r_; a-.tLJi;.r "+i *;.it^-ulii
fJ;*, 4 qt-;r L & e ;: rrW3 c-**aloS Jl.-;r.J5 c-"31L
co.lr-.XJ3,-=--^ -qlly pL:-rl : J-"t/ Cs) 4.J CJ3.l O:t- Stgt;-..5,Jt-- )t J )-i,.-S,r,o1i.l:;a I:r)Jr oy,rj..rt-;jl )l jf;lJJd
"gL-e:lL1{.il$ ,5sl>l6t;'aiJ , sp;*.K'. 6a 4t dLa,ts.r"L"-;yir*;.g1.j1.r-Jl U .+ J JJU 6r""1cc"ti ag- ljl dr.l :lr_s7J;t-t:jl.r'-ar g'7--, c^;"1 a- l;6r11i,rlila-SJ-lrt t:il.rF.-ra :lrJi
$;tr." l[ Beamtenstaat .jl3 L (t*;J jrl jl ta;t*ji.\
WWW.AEL.AF
J't J-,1 \ Af
il "r+ Jr, J.b )t )34jn c^a,:"l 45,_JE r, 3 .r3-, -rrl3,-,5rtj
-. .1c-*--(.i, J W_f gl ;r a-5 ;Eti" .c.*l .rll l J-tL , )Fy .>l);at jt3 Jlt -t> uli.l,rJ rlil Lb ,> jluo Jly A 1U :-* a, rlil\ +i L .-u,5 c-,jt-i, .gsl;ir.trlr s*) Jl JF -,, .:;.1 d)r_ri cr) tu
.rr-,5 "tt-:y
q L{jJ d.Jr-., -J'qra ! gly;: ,g:l;ic.r*i ,6 *i.r-olJ,
"hq ,c-rq c,*, ..tT y bli,-t Jk- drl ?f L1.a;jl cS-,trt
J;a14 d/t*"-lif-l q d-,t *.i .rlit c*; r3i.*1-; osf yl;:.-t!c.*3;;,ljl3 rrr-,1l$ l; i,:.il.: ,.i,jrt, 6:l1i r6>L,a:il c.--l ;:.il.r rt3-r, 5cLl.J:5 ;L.jl-t tt',5.:lji,c-;lal.l{+-r JQ -,, Lr}*La,)i+5
6l; JY.r*l ;*",t;l .rilY -rJ-.ub )_*Jl,f"..ld ;iy c-l Jt.i-'Ut.-u.lr,
orLi:.-l or..i6:l;i o:r5 G\; yoUi prr" i=[- .:t+"
sgLat>-ujr"-" lll:t;t5 c"r-l,J":,-:lr 6 c.-.:lr cllyi.r^l F e+r,r.ri1t,.1"."t"- ci\: W 6t-a;t-iat; ./k?lll;.gta-r"L jl d,i-ts J r,-S
dr,-loi f"^ly-.r jt rt-t.l-t c-*!- ;-,-l*-Ll -il-r;l-,t*! +!-,: r+tt c-^-.;lc-Ui g,- jllt 6tlt 6>l)i 3.r*: #U 4-r q t^.r"yJ
...t.a; a"tllr3"- rr5;5 q.,*Jt 6a,ty{ crU_, y o.t-l a"rli;ljL jlrl3;6)J-f i c^"-ljl.i* ol? trsc-t-:U;lr.iy 6:ljia--al3'- € -Sl6 *-J o- \ 6:l;i 1) tf y S*, Xr;V:lil jl .9r!-. lyj c,.:-l
;r-il jl +U f -* S Jt- ,, .r:5 J**j -r.:t* J-,i J- jt .r+ .(-; ,,-l
,.Jl ,+) dt+ .rr n _l ,1 rl--i:cl jl -ioJ:-l5 '* *J [-"1 ,,.2 # , pE c-il3J. - r J y-r (3_- t--J c)
J;5.,- ,r-*J*j l;,5:ljirt:l: c.*: jlc-."s a, c"r-lr*5 eS ,g;SL:,31
c.-i^.0.-;r-Jlq +q 6 f-,J1r! l; ci ylo;L3.: c.*1pj!.r-:t Juli,r^j
.("dlf *. j t1-e1c-*) 4J
'eV C|.a,l;.g.:l;i olie 6 g._i tttt
.rr". .\1\"V .,JL{L) orl- uJ3: 1: 5:\j,tl..e'r ! rf :5 ;: (H. J. faski) .r(-).6.!.\
.ri;l:,r" 5l LnJ jl l; 13> a;*"n.glr,6;tr3L-, Jt,, q lll ,g2a:-.,a 1l 3l-a,ti,rfl;l; ;;-1b i):\ Stl)I ,6:L,a*l c --;l ;:b,tyat d c--i! -r::rlj>;: Gf 1-,-U;b 6)J"l
.o,;ll.i
WWW.AEL.AF
\ AO o .9:l1i -e ,:;.1
jlcs-,!*r :j-> 6:l)i -E; JU.,1r 6 gJ! u-l,b 1; 6tui yl.r,-! rrlLjl
r-iq.r"iq r.*!:u=t;.*lq f"^lr € -Sl.F5 .-,,q,,r ls )f6:t" g[-:3- 113;*lOit ,:rXU -&t,SAttS;: ,5:l;ic--" JS* 45 t ;tel bi.i- ot-r,;." 4-.i fi 3 :r-r *i- JIP *.e.U JSj )t 45 Jt*ol.,*:S,[-l;--.- l;.lT'AJ<ti .r:"t=:1 43 J4lc;--.xL a:-.il: )J',1t5 "Utr;,r"cc-Lc-:rl a- dJr-: j\j lt )-lo 6ts-F 6>l1i 6
"4tar.til:S.-7 Jf i
.nl1o.;,.1$U oj 3 Jjllr \ rg>l1iciu oj .rijL.f 6$l J Git"
1. Benjamin Franklin
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
Ir t$;$st',1!.F .l.t- ;l Lau*y*,!*
rL*i i;l-t" r,-;1-t .:;.Li 3 :11r >L-i 1 "l:"
crr.r;
nS./\n;r ;5t s J,
d-,!*l ,;l a.-": ;r a5 -.4.r,r" ;lj' a-:i. ,:y l-s 6loxi-o t+g;l ;.r
,j*lri a- cJ5,r-.:l.r-Ji;qU9L:71 6r-ll; rl.u:*l tl* 6:lil;lc^--aL,[-[5 6;: jl.n ,S I t{: g-,fr r:*,eLL 6 6l,,t-is cJ:*1un
:L;:pl,tT..r5 6, -;n;:i"l-r-x .rirk*-lc, oi JIJ;: r);ri pL*i U rl-r.*l
s &:V f.,:13.-- ril ;: ,g.:1,r:-l ,gt^g,jt eGJ,: A;+ 6 c.*l ;,1
;"-q La,r.;1'V*b.c-*l ';af J* :t<--l-t J )J-; at^":f Li-r-L 6s1r-il,6.rl.u-l g-j-, ..(1 JJ+D JLJi :t jl45 r5.," JY.ul
- l, uL^r:,-y--rrL^;'U^rI"-.,oL^y-t^ r
tt^J .rl-^;;*i5 r tt^r-",-r-I
r< :_# a-Syl+; c*t-"otJiJ rK- r ;; * f;tx -r.iL; .:;.ti
lU Ly J*"^ jlorLi:.-l+! l-,,a .-r^iL,5:lr^i'fUi, 4.r^-"- r"L ,5:lilJ JS 4 dl-i:e t a.,17 c--J-a- -bV y-r
1"<* -il-tal t d{*t e'(7;rfr3.lj *-." cc-"->)Le.g1;lr rlil t-rr;
l. Lord Acton5. Fleines
2. Streichcrs6. Himmlers
KillingersHydrichs
3
1
4. Leys
WWW.AEL.AF
,jtt"\tr \AA
L_ o:l olf j-":C:):f rlr.itpLj 6 f+, t-Jlt ilLr3,- -uLi
45 c**i .,(-..i e. .J:*f L c*lr c.-;5- J) is.# +5 .r-i;l.r lLj)Jl-:,h a- a5.tuS )li3lJjt*S 1 l; _,t5 Jd-a:,rr er; tl1llljlg-,L*t4j(j ei t-.1 c-t-.xL GIL:- * _t6;-l c*l F*. ,+r^ ..r::."^a;;Y
ftJe+-lcl..:yl.Li )trs?F:lril.5;y;L:() 6f aprJ,, 9 uitc---&- J) .gJu^;;-ti 6t-E:
ltr;- rl.t*:-l 45 J-56" JY"r:-t ;r; rlila_L A lJdl :j*il.3 -i-i-a ilcp-ljl c-t-iL -J s *..il-t-al a: itJ:+_r
fS ,y;11 .gla--al3 .t-Li .t-i11.: rU:cl 6.rt^O I J .S,g r,..- JJ,U{)o;1:l;3---X :l;l L*t' c-l;5-" ll_t; o5 c--ilr -E Uljl{t, o<!l*il ;; fUai 5 h c-tL.\ *; yl a5:y' uyJ c-l ;r(-. ,g> c:j.i,
.J:;. oJrrlj ro-t--i ,-r-*'U ,-'32 >lSl L-;d-rL*t 6[a.r3G; .*l*tt.At(-r"in,r:.*..lGr ptL .(" c.-+ ,r*.:rri JtJl;1 o5 q F e- j.:;b.rqJb-tt";Ui,5tnJ.r" t1: l; .:;.t-i 6*. p::3r;l3.t...rl oli.* r;rS olye c^i3*i,; o3J,
.r5 J-u; #u fuij .S-r -,, d! )p 6:.t fty .rf .- *,:U" *;(t .i- .t-i 6 fs J n:..rt!; _r: :t.r a-at1- Ca;.(.i ..t;.r,
,!e t+U U,rL*jU ftJal nS c^*tr,.;,,.t1* ylLl.r3.i oll:14lK,-rri
,r+<*" pr.r;l, .ul3- oi;p1 cSt^Jl jljJ€.J "[,li
3 rj.r3g:"
lV eGJ,: dJ+ f _b ".+ir5:l+, 1r t-. .rili.,, 5:;l: .r3,-y
+5 -u:.--a.eLa.!-{ +<l .x4 ;>l-a: J dq ,>lr3l cs-1u,6:l.r-:-l45 JJ-LJL-A (+y).cj!.t-1a14 y4b 6:lx;-lfU, 6;: ry-,;! rr:ctS 6;sa-[iy l; r-l= qg:Lr:il .:[- ral_r; e 6 Gl-|_rr ;1,r.:-!-orLir:*lg-,y,tK-r o;.ri jl+q U 6 J1r Jal,1>;,1_;r l; _,t5 o_,h @t t;=i 013+c:^L.j _,y16-, 4 :+, oL"a q cl:S1-a1 lt )_r- cSt^grt t-.rS
c*-(.i J (p-f .:tj)Bl i;1ff -,t:5 .x-t :y -r,al_e* )F &, \;r .rilyi*." Ity,C. t./Ul * tl1ll eS c.*l #, ;*^ y.*f t l, ,_$1
l; ;"1.t-lli 45 6*5.-u.*:U ley c.r;lr "f,L^i:lr;-l
a, 6.gla*"1-7.!
WWW.AEL.AF
\ Aq D \$;6, :l j :Lo;: Lrrrr;..r, lr.1
gj-, 4 3 .:1r-:-l a* .ryrl d^, d-ili j;na e5 c-*l prb c-t:S ..5;:
;l;-31e:!U lE -,, )-tr-f .,i)\;l 6l^AJ 4 ot13 -e)\:-l t" Jl;..t5,-f;: l: ?y elf tS dl.j r
j d..-*., ,yju or13 )-b l r*K ; r,glJ g,-7 .,!)\il rlt lrr ca:Jl
O!r! oj a:--ll.: Jr;":" )F 4.t.7;11.:lJ t" t.JiUl ,,--\ a:sf -tl; &t,dL^4*./! -rr -11, e^--l- t-l .c.*l Ji iyrl Ct-; ^<1.r
,Jl .,i)lrl.l)\-l gLaty! Ui aS .r-rtr .;t-.:l ,l*y ixl t JlFl c-..(Jt" .,i)\;le5 c*l -,1-*
jl L- frijt-,r" 6)J-p \ ;l;;l ca5Jt, >1+J c>-fff
jl1r r:l;U=l; t^-,y! q oF f* )lbtl )rJ" dL; q Jl-$lcalt'.lir, L^'t(.r--:
El"r5 L"-, *t- :l* eq o:-t' 1 4,."q,.r4:cl6;L
i'u,r-l-rjly.r brk, -, .,!xil 6;\a,1lf ;d ,J"l,J.:r5 'r:-alj'- c'-iK-t-i,r<*^ ;l;;l c-"$Jt" )l U.:tj)BloS Sti +:.i1: .,r. s> ,5t;,- *.11
o-etj:. ,x- r-S g ;St;-:'lc^$t" ::-4 y 45,r,X;lg;t^JiJ'-l
c--5J1" lG o-l J-- 45 t-a.lirt 45 ,.:5 )ta * c-*l;5'*" .r.-:'t
.r+!.yG 3;a oj-i,u-".,-..itj j)\-l,gYt.gta.f I s3zsjlsslFl
, J: z-^ c.--0.^r-- -1r t-"1cJ-.lL ./)\ilJt* tt l .1+:si, t J'X) J'-(J - (:_-
;: +5 J-o.r ,-;;*31; ,-gLa.t( r-- rL:) +! ,-rE -*l* 6 :;lri :;rt3,l^, )l f J tS> :,)>U df- .,i)\-l 6L^oK4-r .-uq dl; .li -;t'r'"t c"."r.-
U 3 cJ:-a:,r-. O-* Jlril L-,5rl.u-l ftlJ ,51;: i:--e!y* a, l; :i 6.:y 'ual-r--;13:-1.g:lu-l ot-(:-s oLlll3 t-aa:-.U J L* 6)J'6
*f r-il J+ o5 € f t b"t-3 +-, jLLJ 6lr q! t-e;l 1':
"rr-l-rr.c-lo.:y-, "5t--.9r1-r:*l g,jt 4.f'U 9 .$lr5;*r ,SL^rW
o:3- oJ5;r*i ,,a:"-o cc)y € Sg;;-5c cJt--: \ et"e jt1i tol-;"
c.Jt-.: d c.*1 .!l-Sy", oU"ra -JU,3 il*) I S ts: 1l ;-Vll 3
Et+,jlcSl;.r!5 o;-r-i )l6 efL. rr.i.t3oi.r t;u, )U-lj;l; cJ3r
)l )J-b, ia./-l1: .c.*1 ;1.:;3-- t c4t* dr,:.i.1 jl o)y Jl)rf-r b:t5
eSrsJ d),- r"iJt5[r 1l p.:r-" - 4 6)Ji d--Fl Lfi rto>y 63itt
WWW.AEL.AF
,5,rJrl \1'
jla5 c- ",lg;:i.u:-.n oTJU;r +1 q:i.-r:-*^ .*l-,V;.tUtt, c--Florl;1 a-..Jiy,-u;1y".1 ,,-jj q-:L.:cl L Li ory,, _tlrs_Fl 1-<"-" dlr.:^1 .!-\ j'S.5- )J+ +4 ?? Ly.(- 6.:*ta;l;r.-tiLy pQ;l t ,5,-/
.c*1 oJ--! .ra.:.lL;L,r"Ui;,5t t.r; L; o.l-l J. "S! 1r f).1- o.r3-i cc*J!"r".:l;--lrrSf -t 6\p:l6ta;y-5;.:.-\b :lr:l u.cte; Jt;: J-# Alt6.fl!;n * ,/V qgt-aitL;L: j-3 l-Lr;l,J ; 6 *. jL".:;,ri +5yl 6l r; .tsl- g [:.-li crJ:y o-r-.i
c---;51 6l-t ;t +i .r1-ti 6yt'*..1T3 r.u5 J!; l1 J-t .<i:y pjY -t-a;
..:3,, !a:it1ot"jt* y"lS J_t ;*-f ,J; -5--&tS ..rt"-;: +(! prr,"a-'."1"- JS ^a
l;.grl-i^:-tg-jt 4 -uJtrl oly*c-"L.; olr"-a1 6;,1611a- a5.u:5 Cr )f -ts>ls .*sf l.r:l;r a5 c.*l
')S bi,.r-:S
"[*;+51; -:l,r:*l JJol i.lJ. -t>,JJ-i d*J : 't-tu, *3tUi a.l[J!3lr;,9-t
..r-iL a;^ib (J:5 J*"-.j olrfl: q -,_rj ti .rj;I.: .r-ai ctlr a;
;: Ll -r::--ilr l.,1 d-,[5 p pt+;l .:t-L! c*Jt -r -,1;-l 6 J+r^;:1;.g;l5.t-il,4 H tf a5;-,-tclj.r, t-^.tT.Srr,.r.:;.c e;Jj jlorL*,|Jt-at 5*,tK L,,-j o.:l-,T..5 JJK* rlil L :; e5 -r-iry, ^S; ,-L-,
.-t,".r gta., I lJ d I .ujlis, (,J::*A ./)[>l oJ*: a;iJ, J,
c-"Fl dS ciLa.J. -i L t_,i! bl_re lt #!__,_ ftJ 4-5J_.t
45 .'-".1 dr,c*ili( l.r>l :13," tu cJ.::*a JJl;!* ,liL t-^cJlr",r?l pl ..:"jla-S ; I ; l r,:i ^* K I r,rcL*>l Jt<r-uSC)Lr I j | .S_,t".*t
,-li;t, rJry .:y-i &;lr53,r g;L-ao1-.;T;'U c-.-; s.ir; c.Jl..,J-3crLJi;:.Ir;|i -tlrs-fl c.:3-, pj),lt-.:c.;3,"L pt+,ltSl; aS ,j3lLicJ3.r 6L"c.J _# rit_L,;I c*Jt ."r :lj-l o-fi,--ljI .*,, ct ,lt:l.--eJL;. ry,-79;W t t^,)i.citi c.*: .-
"iirr q f:*U cJ:r5.g;l;:y,-
-/ l r:j c---Fl 6 .rj:_.9,, -,lyJ.ll d+-a .J:3,, laor".l g,-l ,g,r$ $0,a oltK-: .-t-J ,*ly y+*ta
'p .rar.tt lL aglr' ua;*e a+ e"e-r=, ,K1r co-rl-.-i,5 ?tarli -/. @q.(- _1, 6 S>r,. a*f lS l: ,_ri d.Bl
yj
WWW.AEL.AF
\q\ D I J. ; ,j, :t S ste -,, Ln..,;4;e* l-,1
)J-b,' 6 c*ldrl a(! J::--^ Jlly Gh q ! frr" c--Fl6 c-4 J,l
F d r J GS ,s- * oi 6;llcla5 c-.""^^.2 JelJ "Jj< c-tS:t )l>j->1 7)-e o-tF 1.: L..-r-;;b ,j-rli f- t ;t*" -,-,"1 fW 611. r9t'-13
J-B lrJiJlri d {-fu..i:S,[*; l-t )F.il.c.c "r;13.1 6 e:-S *.:y J-a1_9,- e_r b\.rf -,: 6 q s ,f
L,g-uJ;Ji 3;L*x; ,J-S Ga 6lrt 6 r;1r ) j73 o& #, -,* ;-r Js"ij o*"r,a 4 Arl A-* L-g t;l;o; a,l-i'L-; -r,-8"
Lr;; rt r- ;r-F *-L.,g:f ;r"q t^,ri,.*Ll-,t 6,):*lct 6t-o-,1"*"
.;y -u-alr-- ,;*,5*^-r +;-.n
'# t* a, 6 :;b d-tJl3 yl 311 6>-et- ti cJel6aLa3 ;.:
&-y* r ,lb; ojl$l .rL.^ I o-*€.r3i1 :lil ,-i-* : ;|yioly4 f r,, c^jli J:-alJt;^S ^tr^ 3 o.ry e3U:," f^ t, * a;r,^ L^.li
r^lJ, JJI i Ji,sJ r.+j.r;, ,-*ti yUjrrt )l €e;** 6t-.,'e$
? * t , rLrta a, -r,L c.r,-t-i-c tL:i -.r cb-JjlaY! o1; ip! 6U S >yU 't c'>'
J GJL. rrA-l-p J or31 Lr*U. gL- - y eF t.,i)\;l6t-a.r;1JL-l 45 f5.ttJ ;t p:r-" r:--r5l 45 c*+ .+,Jl+ ;1 .c,*1 g;11; l.ocli 1: rr
631; rr
c*l;*' A, L;3 a.(l c.rjtl: -,1;.-r*-! * -,t.l};l6t-oryl-tlL-l;1 5 -r::.-a 6.rlr.il c.r::,.^a e qt*- dl'-.:d;tljj-,1 6 ,;:f ;tlS:1.6.lu-o+-oLc -t1G"
",al cgil3 l.: ..r-illr ;lf drr-q e! ;r t-a:;l-rjL-l -ttJ
-r .:."',"'. J "J; Jqt jl.*1-l -ijx r^ a, l1 :lr"il a/"i* 6 -t:.*a
tl: ,5u)cSta-,[- 3 Lojjtts;L,;: >y+ *-l.i-c.t]134 O aO^- rilx;Ajl45 d -*6.:lilcr-i tr l1,ti"r--t"; r"r5.[a..; ^,'.Q >l;l f1>
6:lil;- -,: *! a(! c.!:*a "&.r<")l j.>jli:, J ;e*,&-y- -btJ
a5.g:lr-il cJ:a:,r." Js..lj d,"15 J:" 6U." q lt l)_f o:,9i 6 d *.xa-l &, q .:1f tl.:y JL"^:, jlo:lr-r-'"'l! }i' l-, :j"- 6L^''lLli
oA-l-p 6 r:5 qS S>ljl t >t"S .r^t-r;-, dV riK-, .-<,* t'l .,t"l
.):r a. i t-a,liclrr rL*-ly,,*:q 6r.(" q"i,# l.a.lio:L s,St*
WWW.AEL.AF
6trJtl \1Y
)y J-6lJi tLtti ylJ .-Ut: dUJ,-Lir 6l;. u,S,^,,d1_;t c-ili J^lJ,L-^,.lirl.u;;a rctL*-{ 3 o.:L- dr"ii 4 +. lrr- ;* nt:^ oJ,J; \ rS
.{l}.1),- J-6lf 1:U jl ::Fi.,-, C-b ,_p-F -U )*l;-;3r rt35ly .rj;l..tj clt--xr3.- )l rglo-t-j.c 6-a o-5 l_, -,y!r;j 3 o.rL .rlr.ilpLj sJ-L>.:y3l r.l-.r 4J (-l-::^--a oJ-jG-l) &,Jt i):t fV Af -* r.;i ":t"iJ a":iti H; Gl-i q rll-rrrU J 33 J-lU" 45 J::.--a qg:lr-rlL,o;_l
4,. r-{a ".,11;Q
6 ,-.jr-1.<,-rr;.lLiq }) bl:,-;LlJe3 oLL--l.:-*g.g:1.u*l r-r; r:L[,i,. :l.U ,!lil
>Fe;^U;lai,,:l _tt &5 kt,;*,-r ,J_;(# -r,_Li; t-f _r-11 c*.ti-: tJt*-a olJl$/ crrt-L*>l.i_-rr; ! y.r_.,k" ! r+: "<,-
a5
,tc.->l rlrJl +5 c.*lrtL*il.:li r;jrU aligV.J5.,, Cl- )y- t::t+ I ;.Jr .i- jl or- :kDl
"|.j )l- uab r"l 6 l. agl3";: rjlji,r^
.c.*l.rrl.<-i t-i *\r;: Lj.r*-iU..l=,i.of^ _bl_&t q + ort--a-(.r.:---A ,sJ sl6.:B eS dL^!i "J, .j-,1* ,r.^,- rl"".tT,r j nLrr ;; rr3Ui
csb_,6 pt+;lUlr l-t,tf .i_.rily.r 6 c.*l ,t) -*;: pjy "l.l.SlLdioj o5.rt-AJiq.^ uJLr-iljl..uor $X _fr-*"q s-r.i ai .jr:--"
J-t5 .rL-./J+.t,';: +5L ..r--l_l c*!- 4 .*,-t"- :^1e Jt+,i/l(t-A0ilj ,Lil )l.J::Srs" orti:-l kl l,,ljlc..u^-,a flrr" F!".gtooryjt^.lir, e-&t c-.5 a.U, r^ jl .r..1 r,dyl ..rT3 :;lr 5;1 ..a,-j" 6 J-l*'SY-F L-.Srl+- -ujL"- -r..:t,[.-b;r ol3> cr^-.i.:..r:=.f )*s,g:$i
.c.*l"t:..- -,.^'1 4i-yL-: dJ€ c6ttitr ol;=
n-\ s1i S4iL.*,. oS t"iu"-rL-- 1 ;,...1r 6)J+-clUi;.r a5ylc-t-^.x ..,L*jl rr.5Y_95rr ?ss;: 5 ojl.rlloL*^ q r,.:l: r,I.llflr; .:.";S-l
L-; gVe;y*La sL(JLo:F 5)J-5.(rr.:-:-rJLr- -@; stii el+ 3 c-l;b l, f .t r-a )*l u,Uli 4-5 ,-.1 s slS nl, t4 6lj: 1 S;y
2. plutocracies 'ri:-'' L-j;
WWW.AEL.AF
\1f |9r;;6. :l-p :r*;: l.l;j.r,lr-7
ptl- ..r:,-L; ta,Jr:+- ,.kJl J dUl-r).)11,gllrqlr"r- .r; ot5p a3;
Lrt-"YS jlc^ ?"^? 3-s;6\-^,1f ,p #ly) -uj:y 6;1:a1Lr.*jf e:J c/p) 1> .;-\ a-, LaY6;lU ry, ori d--cL 6ylralLr-,
.-,--.r.i rlL*l: ,Jt^^ !,1 J .$)31 1"4;r5 ;5[- c^.*.a jl"),t", 6 -i;,F J J-:,ar,r.o olJ gijJl1*5 dLatlS J :aJ;: LA l; l"a.,tlV 6 c*lr.rLJT;.: q5 c^-e*L ,y-l.i9-i.S €ls o* );y * ta;15 yl -bV y.t>lg a:-, .i- 1l sgll:qGr* s; s l9t:-:s+-l o'./L 'Wtt ,>6 r;Llr,r:*1.;".al;t- oUi;: o.rl.:3 .r$|,j;ltj;r;.: ,x-Sg "*f
.':.-l azJ llj .;r1V;tllt; a7, :13, 1*S 6 c*l &bc.+lr,, .(-- r.+ c-_3;;: J3 ;gLa.. ,Al; .i- q Fltr:-1,: rr dqJl *--s q jt"; #, y,G-e,-'L .-L- -<, a, ctltJg.+.c*l,K> t€ J-.b.<-1 Uf ; oJ.-.rLi ggL^" 4-1.f)J-
"!,[5 c--t--
.<1;t*1".c )* \ Slie F * 6 t-F JY.u-t ;*q crl;r;"r,. c6il31:
t-i J-5 o:Li:-l:9J-*r ,tj ,S--6iU- c--ary i h\.rs\r:-luUyJ*.r '-a
-*Ua:-.il.r r:r+_r,Jfu, _,it) illi,; e"lf efa-..L7.! q 'v,ll.G!t;$\,stf 'ti,ctJJ )t t't-Gl;rav)-*J -Sqrit .5r::r Cb -r -il-utl6111: :lr-il .li;r o5 JlrjILSrlr-il *jf gglacl J-; -Sl.c*l.:lrilc,.1 -r: qLi., qgt-^ot(4s -2,>lfi,:o;U: J l.-" -ujl^-a t+ -t:.itl U OLrilrtl u;7 )l.t-! fl-t- c-u-xL ,.Litj.gr+U& L^iTt lr tr f*lyeSrrl U,-t:5 F J * S ;.J..dL^j."
1.: eSr--l J* ;-la rb' r" 1j*:"}1U -'f ,.yt<,t.f!fu g Alf g,7l.r* .:>\(; )st *yd'U- ;.t.riq dtr .<"-F ,J-S !e.,JiU Jjrl$ JyW t^c-J[-r jl .<,-6^ 45 r*i J.alJ, .,i)\;l J/f-6-. {.! jl)l 611>1ji1j> JU-t<l f tS *+ fl,Jt-- olyo y.$r-x rr,rr tlJi
"t; Jr::S -,*e s t--5.SrL Cb )l ,j*V 6L^-r."i;r , JIJ f#Itnj J*l ;=^^ .,"l*l -/.,p.c.r;b,r-o bJ;^. )f GlllJ l^.)i ')t1c'l. Anti-Semitism
WWW.AEL.AF
6'sJ-'n \1f
"-;; boi6 _Stsy. oyJ 9 a(! Ut ;.gL^-r-"i;: _,r l+jd ; b.S.r.-^
cx-.1t: )F-fe,-LJ- CU,4jY)1, F-., jl;ffff,"'t 4<! c..-r*,. JS q c qLr 6 -l.i:U:plJ.,l, t^JTu,t fc-*-..1tj, frr"-r-;;* *-AV,rJ :lyl ; c-L iJy;) 1: .r- J+ra -:;lr .;l*j .*L.<-5l,.,or u. e"-b J-ljlU fit: 1-tr.--\l-r ,f ..,jl$_t dU:oi:-i 6a: J-:a:,r-e r,9-- iJLj-K.-a a-, l; a-".;TJ4 FV t^-*Jt ."f .rf
U-l ;l J-+J^ c,":*l .r:!y..l1 y"t5 Jt.6a Ct" .r.r-n" ,-; .917 t-"iinc-ru^i3j
"[J, .jtr:t a; c,tJlor3;r.tT rU-tr; +5 6L"oir,>y,.i JL*t f"-
+-j 1; :y>.gLat-crl 5.u:*o .-^ilJ" )t g l.aoir,3;yljl.)J, -uAlJ, o$jL
yt*.r-a:rrLjt- t: .l1,- (-,)! igV u,jl1:, 4<.! 6y1..,, JyclrrLl-r.*jL;t3*lplll
o5 JL-;r 6 r:*tj,l ,ililJc"- 4i-JJ ,r*.-*a,Jb.r*rtjJ jl._J(1
cr;L-,r-" lli:*l,t-l_!r; ;t otf .>V.tUl-s .,i)t;l J_*l tl: )fU C-*J[-- a-5;--1.c.*1lr-1 J'U .<"-6 L* sA"tJ,-r3y;;.r liir_,r_r,r 4-.1 aS6-l u2*- t 3 r;1: ..,.tIJt.,1 ,-5_,6 c*l a,-rE 4 6;t"jJ r-5rl,S cr$ q c,-rLJi;: \ ) 4:,j)1": +A JL- oy3r_ld$< liljl rS-,!.^-l aS ^;tKai,dlrJ g*JL*r, qS c.-l J-Y, jf .ri c,t:S,r^ le-
^5Jt-;) cc*l .5"--,FG-e yl.(, (J:5.,, -t_F ,*)*r* dLr;,"t, \ ,alf6*7.'r;l: ."r-;: l; rl.t-:-!,."CFy';) flt ^"-r- 6191 3 Jl*cl,
{*:l$ fJt,.J a;1.-..y.:el*il $ j:-3.5ta:rS;6 s} ;+-b e"-^ Wd.c,*l;lr l; ;l-u^"l.x6-_.,1r 5;\l; oev qgta:r5;6 4) Lir 4fl
jl,J"a:.*. L,".ti;t.r-^t -St t t:\ )p _* (e :-.:,S L,Y1L:-t, Jtt+ n-,"1* ai tas Lg:l)-elp ost*;,1;-: li[ f.a;i;trir,,3:ri ,-!l-r,al
Franz Borkenau, Socialism, National or lntemational? ( I 942)2. Community
y-;tx1r"\ aa t +2":-.\
WWW.AEL.AF
\ 1A tr lr-i;J.r" zlS le;: l.ar,rl-r, lr>
I*U;J 4+j.J.5 JLi-r l; a-"t-- -il.r,oldt*a 45 -raT,r",-,L-- a, 13,J5
f-;.tu c*l ri; 5,- tas rS 6-1,-tr-c 4-.1 )-p 45 c.*1 yl oL(-r,r yl.-il.l-al +1.Ur--r s4? J) oS ,,jU; tj J.j"t<laQi,.,^,l try',r.. o>r*i
, c-l1^tao foL" -,.: t-g- yl .:*t*;l: oP a.'.-il tr _l $g.f)g *tt.c*1ot*jl.i- 45 -bC e-l -.'\)-* u j >1)g o>-*; 1ja" osf*-6 -^ "Jylf"^G ;*-#3 c{l*;l-Jylf*G rcjl;,;:;-,-l ca;.r--l jl 3 c* t dt*il jl ;\l -S
t ; ot-(.lr o-r-tj LW .-;U:.."Ur*-t'..tlri.,: ,;\lf fUF fl!;:r.*t(-te 6a f+ti"
-u.-iL ,":-.i,1: plj.r .-r*Jl3i,r,. .,Ji,j U l_S f a^"t- 45 c^q+-;l1ll"r-7
,il|;.u.ily.f J-b ar+ c.:;lr :3.>. y :l,rl;*,;: u-i,t-a.:-l-J 5jlF-.r*; c-.,a lr Jr*: 611-e-;l s alJ,_ec.-r fJt-:,-,* y,Jf 6.4. )f ,.r.rlr L1 t )-p .Lti 6 c.*l c"l J"ly ,lt€L-ac*l,i* a*^:i;: J o)31 L*d53> Lf .(_;*lr:5;;.gy_j"U6l-r-'
.4LarSr-t ,o3J g c,-J*br- 6 *-t-g ot .3ir1u,g$k, yl,Sbj!,l
;-l -r*1..r-, -b y.+tS.-r-S.f t-t l Jlr ,,Jf 6:t- rlil a, .:*i l;lJ tA.iT ojJ oj; tr {! -tJl.:.ro :y 6
"$; tS.l*t-f aS uA", c..4+
-,l.5 q ,J; )l A:G ri.<," -U J J ^ii-l;< r^z J*..!;r,-r5 Jr:S
\ : j-> c.:d.j oS :yiu. f^l; ,rp ,Sll.l: S_&, ";Kl r:y:,u" o:e J!y+r, ,-:t5 ixl bl3:-o ,> ,j-fu c.arlJ .r5 pGrl "jf c,.a;*:, L.
L i-i 4J .r:;_,^ - c-*l dd rj)\r\ * a*E J $p)\r\ b\;\- tor_ro
;: 31 +5 4jJSJL*a c6il3;r .c";{ blie l _el 6la6r34+j jl g!:3J*
a-\ :r; 'p s;:--.:Lj).-lL,6.JTlr-j:;1.: r3--7y r:f .r:b o_/.-
:1aeoGJ;l;-roySl;n :t _-$.1 c'jirj dLij jl n+: 5 ':--l g-lf ya CJJ r)')L.tS j"l .l4 ;r" .:llri :yre; irf -tlp 6li 6r*-) ;rs ,Gl .:9.e" py :lp.glr, ul a:-:l:
Fr ,:3'. ,t" -. €.5 -r-lr ..r /i**A .l-l .:,2lr ..rL;i oL,:*^ ;Ur .:;lll :;:-: .rL:ln!rF.-rJ t'.;U:t :yo L-[-:,y n-( c;U;l ;Uri
2. .Reinhold Niebuhr 3. Moral Man and Immoral Society
WWW.AEL.AF
6rrJrn \tP
.<.- dlj-= e, l; t-"tti ggL"tLit 6 -w, -s t!.J"i +,
\.rr,Ilo; b ; 3 I ; Su.r s -S
.:-,L.f l-o-,-.r S..+ J-i ,tf dj;r;r;idr--ljl.g.*JUJr..Ur::,-lt t'--i- ol;;a,Uy Fl ,-iJt,- *S
';-Si,,3j 5..- L-/J*.gt-t..r[ lL; ;J5.lt-6;: 6 ,_rC rt-fui c-;t,.t :i13a dl d3:r ;.: +J r:.--a 6J-,-& -iy e ;-_,a) Sl*,r*jl--
. 4,,4jJSjL^^ o5 s*-+.rr:t-ai )ta!.3;r,l -il.J:5 a'ra: ls g!U,9.""U;lo;!t: o-e J,>;3-c L-..- slJLb" ,J"; eq jl,,S"JU*\JJ 45
?Jt,* b\lJ -U coly;+,Uy ,5lrr ca;!U;; $:*,, 6t*"1[ U 6;a;a,tjy.(J::.,^A
ojlr.jl a- ..:"-^ .-*J!--r .rly;ul;; $!-r"t : * eA &tf.glr-, rtt-q9!L,:,Ia5 or-: ,i j*-.,-.J t,St-.r,tU
:l At eJ Jt*=,S i3:y.,-/lf .gl.a*--t3 a1 c-- ..;"",c plr"-l .r- 4 \ 6ls*Lt.c+10:3:.1 *"a;(7y5 AG,sf t + yir;;.r-.(- s t6gJt- J-6; 6 ,s,l<$ct-a,-..,3 o-l!-lr r-i,.- qgt-ac--it>L- -2r Ssr rb tSi6 )lr; y"t5
ftJ"i 4 t^Ji f;q-3., 6 .r;l;,r." ;ktl ,c;t* lr ta0T d"!..-,yi ortJl r9i L^,)i t ilr r, 9 .r.-:.1 lJ o -*
7 6S : i ;l t o.li .:y !lr.!34 9.rr1,1 jli v.-r,3,*rt'
-1,; t c?,, eJ 6l Lt,-ri:l
?-f qr-b JL- -rr +5.g:lr-ilg-o -r a:ii*.,5toJlrJ e d ry n-i-l
a!!:1; g*Jtra.t "[6 t^j-t rt5 rr c+L*;l 3 .5:lyTpU I r;oy j< )lS
..rjr[:.*1l;1-5,q3L..i r;L:y r,L-^,ti o+3) J ?) p ;aGl .J:r5 G!l)i-;eq -f .5t o; 3.5 J),ti:-" I ..u:".1, 1:,-i*J t-J- | *-Lie .9.,1 t(-t i rp " t^.lT
.glr. t-"1r*:U s-.21, l# J p.5l;l: Jlr,.! )p,Sl-t c-*l;5",dJr-, 6 fr)rS e rJ-.r-iL 4ilI.rt:-" 6a l^JTrE ;\tJ fc-J3r oi;.: 45 (urt,,Jt jt- .5L"i o: .-r+i S *-6,t.f q \'./-t
.Y.Y ..r ,(\lf t ) dLc-*,,. i\r-..rtS .e\ .61 L-; -,* ,f t.JLL ;l ..t-:$; .\
Findlay Mackenzie (ed.), Planned Society, Yesterday, Today, Tomorrow: A Symposium(1937), p. xx. 3. Webbs 4. Fabians -5. Elie Hal6vy 6. Tories
Gladstonian Liberalism 8. Boer War 9. Bernard Shaw 10. Sidney Webb
WWW.AEL.AF
\ 1V ar.r,;d :lt :r*;: Lar,r;J, lr>
c9t+,rr cdrl.-a .r;lr .;! clSu- )lt'J\ ,*J., "+ J $; JIF,-
s 3:;,6lacJy.: ,tt ;lLt7 Li.:rr 5 ,S.r. JJ .3L; :;Lir, Vf :l rf-,$-5,:l; t+li,5t-.;r" o3;:;r r,"q q r<"_6 6LacJy: 3 o*1 r*jJ$
t.o*i-# .6-1.V a:.x-ajt+! q
G>*bly")\,l-5.,,--*o-; Layl.l-, i iplo:rS J-lt b.E CIL:* ,yr.!y- -!Ur*U a,l; g-J!-3,- 5 -u-a:.r." dL5 lJ .:,;-ri 41J.5;;;l;'U .-; lJ jL"lJC^.
fL.; jXrt,gL^ot5.l: 6kt-# r;D a,3 o.:l:
.rJ-,U ;-#e L-yy S<-f .5ta13'.1'5 }t* ye5 t+il;..r-t:,r";l,i
.l.:7r^ a5,-4La.tK"r--r 3 rilor3r Jt-llJC^"- rL jl rig. g:3.t> l: d<iL J
6Uac*!!-r- ol3-u., a*:, :ySu,4JlJlrt-o",;U-d U- tU^.<- ey )1,!6
r.c.*l ,-eL, ,Slj *
, ) rb erjioj c-!lr,3,- Sl J, t 3 I ;. a;,)a el -r. 6 Jt- r,d J*t, $l1
1, -# )pG.q9tac.*!f=- -f J? e)W).r./-fU-, o,)j,:Sl
-rt---- u.3-t-t dI*-J^l .(, 0",1r*-r" cl);$ c,[ito.:; &-,1 q l; ,rJll C.*or-1 j-lr-a
"i- r-t- 6)f al .rt,L! ct>,)*r- Jt-l-SC:a gsly cJ.-14
+1 ",|-;"
ta:iei c.uS..r- e;: +^i .Sf Lt H ,*ll:45 4jJS,ft".a.u.:-l
?; r* 1l r e-- cJ>l e e-oLirr .i".fLlf .rrL^-al o!-,r-ar,lLlLI!JJ
Jtil-sc1.5 c*l,rTc^*;tr a/-lr"q +(L oy',r".r-:Ll ..:;-ri ". &|5
L-t: ,S 6,>lSl t C:t3--i5 rlalll: G-:JJ crt*Lira t cr*"t )-fu l.45 6* +, ca:--ll-rri ,f :"'N J -* S -,-LJ uJ-| -,5 *. ?f :1131 yL
.c---!tr tatt- u!:-. G:ti &. L^oi.,,!e*r.ll; a, G.ti W-t'Jt-.J Ltt-^c*Jl.+;- jl A-,V:45 6^6io,r> cc.+lc.*;r yl3uel;:lilo:r5 p.F\ 6 t-5,* iS ,r"ia,7ls f^J, drl.S'U c.-;
l. Elie Hdlvey, L'Ere des tyrannies (Paris, 1938), p. 211 , and History of the English People,
Epilogue, I, 105-6. 2. Czechs 3. Poles
:L r-;*.fKarl Marx, Rcvolution and Counter-Revolution, and Engel's Letter to Marx, May 23,
5. Lord Acton 6. Jacob Burkhardt
7. Bertrand Russell, The Scientific Outlook (193 l), p. 2l I
WWW.AEL.AF
6'rJ-,n \tA
.a-"[+ al .:rtli 6al JU:;l L y .m*a llb lrK;]t lLtr .5? ;: a5 j;-ri jlU-S e o.r,rU l;oi rl,it ;,1 lL.; +7.ji .$x .r,t jl l; .:;-r.i *.ili,r" ta,Ji
a* S-";.: oi.:LJ-; jl o.:l L,.l c.<r? J) .:tri F * [ 6 c-*l ;1-":* -r r;.i1 ry-r-.a"V :* ! d<! :y'.r*: ,J-tuGf o;I! rJ--ly
3 t-J,4 JL*"f ,-j-U; :lil -E-r; "X" ^S ;y3 o:f C"- ! J 5_r,_/
Oirt-*o Jt"*i 45.rri.r" )r.J \ G_tti cJ->13 a-i-ru .51a, ..ti.gt-tcl
t-"..Je JY-u--l k ,tg eS;l .c--il.: ,f: "X.i 6 ry ral3-- lgjtiu
")\,5.\u.rr*: a Jl*ynF4i s'+ L*r; d.5 c*-i G)J3 )l *.rtJ.i jl er:*i.-r+J-;13i6; .rSe*.iUt a^"ta.-(1 ;r ..:*l oL:.il
f t t tli. a:-ilr 1; #!-r, cS r_t +.V t ;y.r" .:'t"^ .(,- ;!;l c--;jlor[c-",l ,1- Lii cJi orLi:-|.]_rri )l ^:l^l<i )* t $lJ:
"Se*.'c.*1u1l;lrqL.,-;L;;t;; s;-Li fL- tr5 [-crl a5:y J-aly> crL"JS
cf -F ay-r,.:'[a Li * -t* *6;;-ril o;L;: r.r.rr5 Wcl:-i,L oJ-j.j pErl K:at*l J., .4 6t+,lUl; LaJT+5.rt j U <:y' JL"rJ
:s# s c-rU-, o!t*.St* t i irl ally ,-r -t^lJ, .lL*15 L.6\G-estri jl.abJrsr,; L- s;-r.i gy;;.ry ralr; o.r-i,5 -tLa"lr rLaj;l .{lS yt.r-lyl_9 r:*ilr -ulJ; ci, t) U .;J-t o;ri ol; .r*at-SL3Jstr! c,r-1.:;r5r^; A+ )l Jig ctict:t.l ;: a5 c.*l .ff teJ .rrU:
.:lr ".i.a6
l: e-St J )Je .i- -b-r;."UJL"cf-ril-l.r .i-q- -9 4;>l-a:31-!lral "(l,i; nJ+ a5 gl.rr5.$L:" "y:i
pL;:-.+^ r;j-" "(^(,i; J,-l iJ<Z 6r*l-r -ui! grr.5rllT..uS;**i;
l. B. E. Lippincott, in his Introduction to Oscar Lange and F. M. Taylor, On the EconomicTheory of Socialism (Minneapolis, I 938), p. 35.
.tL;11 ;: pi*:irr6..5l;* ;l .gl-r- t.i;,.r,!l "jlj +5 -rr: rai l, L c*;lJ ..,1l .,JU<, rU .y
.riJ":^i c-Je ir< t6ll i (dqlfjLjl tr-JX ti),r€r.^i- r* 6V* ,S- ;,;L ,rr' U
[,* .el ! : J5 "".-
l) ()it Jl- -i t s^ 5 :;l: :;rJ ,s,"2 .l* .a^Jl .:3;.r, ;6 rI-; +:rrtSr clatfl urr.! o;L;: ;-l l-l .J-:L ;L*! a^:*"a ;>-t\ :f r c,)ri )lrL
.c- ,r (,:Lr ;L-il )lll
WWW.AEL.AF
\ 1 1 D \ -L ; 6" :\ i ;r* ;: L^r,rr.l tr>
.);-ui aFQr +5 ,-;5 +sL;l *-t ilr c* ,*t.ry*i.r itr Jt"lt'C"-
.gL- a- L31 .*tolpr :;3," Ji b)"15 n.rf- s-,,ri ! 6;Lail6>L-":31.:tIi a3;i.c.*1 o:y,, .;1-t .:tli L .:3-t-,.-" o )b A&qd* -,!:il ,, ,51 ,.r;U ,_*_6 -ti;l;l .rrl3:,r" 15,Jt- y: c.rj*i,r^ o-rJl3.-
,5t:: F -*..r-iliF 3 ory ,-e1t" U-6;t-e-*.11$li.r*; _5f r-"! ryc> j-i ,Sy:'.j."q- .:;-r.i 11;11.(1..1\yo y fl JJ.*(l.i qL r; 6)l Gt* ol n5 r-r5 ulJ, lLcl:S a, ly J>\.;:-l j 6:l;i ;l.rl;..tila:
.ry ral3e r)4;3 ,_16 Jtl.fl..Iii 5*'(* )ff3 yj!.j*i ,rF e* fU ,^.-/Ll ,J:"t tt r3;r .11
crr.Li.t!; ;;.:^-1 ebl y a1t++*o "[U,t,g
: f -il.ral o.t^ic!y-j,
-r-.i1 ,r-s)\-l s d):l J-l-t" ft*Li .i-,-ilral t d*-r c^(? J) "sJ y,-tl_r' ,il.J) J 4:.-:1) c;tl" U ,f )rt 6U; U.r;1y,. c?J. )r 6 S.fa-5 c*l eyG:. ,ii q p .i- jl lU Ll .c*,1 :t-aj ;: oiL .:.r-: q A,,F L- f."Q 6itttlr t^,)if*l-r.r e j1*^ t1i6 r;1:.r"ly.l-.>y tl-, L-t5 Jt"r!lr t_r el_* U rllj(; r1;Tl; :i JU--r LA.)ifLtr;.,+Syt.ri3
Ll *: pLoj ,> .:*l it-" L r:1" ) -e 45 l' " ' ' 4- \J * g,$ irl, 4P6*.f :
caG.,jjJl uS t_#.s c^r[ J-l.r-*.r*: c-*J +r c.t:S.:--tr;
,)-*t dl3a;;* t 5 -Liti .:31L"" U.5Lar*111! g-,-ri a, +;t"lJg"a
.J::-*A lll> \ ) 3.cl +5 -r+r^,;iL- t-^.ri ;.:
;, ">t-; +5 c*l ;yG;oL*a 1L:, .5rU; t!-: -r-- l: Jj.A ;.: t)3Gi
,a.\lJ:;j)L;l Jyel Alj:.a.l.:r5 o-LaL.X:,tyr;U c--,iS- ! nql-,
Ll r.t--iU .;jrl; .:1.a.7 e:Q. yl c*l .;(" *+*, ts* ) arili JJt*a
:;;- 4;r a5;-,-ljl Lrtir,ll ,rl5 J* U.51t-^.til,-r:.^-," dh. J JSr.grj.: ! s-l,t;..,ru.s-r- Cj. t" J"_d,:riq + \:f .3l-c -ira r,rt--r;l;+ J) dir*ljlLtj cc.*lc.-.11
"|-"r.(," q^^r,d!i t" 4+:<j
c."JlJ;--laj..t*XL 4:il$ U J a-l:.t r) i Clrb c*l;r5.-" c^pvYl3 --i..r-a "(.- ty-3 +J 3 c.--ilr J.^lF c/. t: yl 6l_rt .;lr*t.:i .-1.,c 5
WWW.AEL.AF
j:r;ol;tr Y"
cc*lc*i,j ,F At 6lr c-.irL J,l$li,r^; ,k t*..,l-*;l6lr,A €ly L?J )t gf :* c-l 9(-" t" J+f .J-or llrj;'U c.r;
.r::.-^ .,:.ij JU-clJf r^ q Vt,g-f t l-, .,(1.:3U:, c^ij Jt^r[,a-\lJ >S.l)\;l lS t, cJ5"r- *i \ eJ=*3 j-r.a 6 Jel J'-lA:\lf e*-.rr}.>llS r, l-1.:ri,r- .,,aI; oL;y;lpLj ;5J.4rUt<'. r,pa"c srJL) c;l.rLi3 6lj f 4,sl; .c.*l grrl JiU 4LJ,.:.ry pt+.;lJ,-! t-i 4WW slgltrrf;nr o,r.,L,r lr,,j cc*l s-fl s*st ls 5F ,F C-ti:q lU-tt'e+ .:tjX;l oi;r 6 raison d'erar .cslcSss )lJj'"ld+l cr.)3.btr )l ,.i, ;;1>3.s- 6* cc*lorr5l! dTr-r3;.:
.j.t ^ "(.- Sly, eG J^" ,51 d:y i-*t:* ;+ -.:;l-r.j ) j7J o>J-aa
dt.,.jl:; gt^-,,r.1.5 ,X L):-t ! olql-, J) raison 6'sh1a*;ij .-h tr_f
;tj tqlUii .! rtyl: 1: -.AJ:; :lil .r,- L)t, sr't-i-i: .:;l:,r,.:;,-- Jt .oi o)f s> ci:-s1J.>-." 6.acrl-[:-*j ,,gA cr-? -rt..l1lr ;y;l56 *.J a- o *-.i JL-"i.r153;ljlit, -r.;li.jj; L^dioU=. _r 3 r;lri.:lll a5;-,1 l-i J $l.J-X drr- d."t- ,f Li 6 -t".iq ,r!l-tal c*"Ji t)
.J,U- c-*r -il-r-aloiq 6 "tj! orl.r;y-: :S y tjgG1r +5 c*i t-*" ;,,'..t 4\l; e?.rtj)Elr) Lr*r #li 01$i (d.Jl
S--ro tel"Wr.Sy'.-- e_# rrr^. .:l.:Le;;ilr t rlrJl ,r"t-E;;..--.gly.c.*l-i:"+i)\p >lSl Jxy.rl.:[-c + lf tt fU;.i" -il..rL tJe- fU.(.- -r--! ) F: , Uq I S ,-.. pt-Jil *<-- ,1.: lL -rb 6t $l.91 :i 6r,l- -. J t)- . r L \
."ri c--yi; lJ LA,)i *j4 sl$ !; o),1 l;b\ ucV );6t-^r>";45 6r.a. L-",-li jl .r;.-l.J ! I g:r.L;.r-
tn't-L .:lrLc,r l; Loc-LS c-ll* 6;rrl $:
;-,1 r;l-tj ,1r!l f *.:j a5 c*l dr,l (f,;5*" rq e(..j .,i)\.'l 6L^r,.j1l.ll3;,c
6ft-..r-o.:.;l-;lto,lTa-, L 3 orlr tl; ,fV.:l;3;-.: €J )ljYt lJ J.Jli-il-r-ol .*ti-*jl;U e;l.a,)!- -H; t".ti."Ur; a*"t-7 -!l.ult rr*_ra->1p\.:1.ri.lL-t-.o o;l;1 L.:ejti" -$li.r.J f -eUtcJ5,r,. f,ls ,fV
.JJ.5
1. useful habits
WWW.AEL.AF
Y. \ n \ J; ; Ga )l f )b ;: Lrr,ri-t, lr-7
.r"alr, 61lt3a')iblJ e-7 fttr "<i d,Ll +5 Abu+j-,1 ,i. c,slis
L- L,"JLJi +5 dt^u-:irl ar* a--U" ! ,c^i: J:llJ, dJ rl 45 .at-o.li 3 :r5
1,".:i;t1-; cclL:J[.*:: y-rjc-;-;,- rll-cll \.f I n,frdta"rr-yJ)
d-f:> J $1L^JT$U t^JUi1J,"*" +5 6l-oe*::13 J::.--a :lt:f J.
,rJ :lil .Li J-61J, F s : c.t::S,r- Jt-;:il t-^..lT ;,*,t.t +, t ".-r*JK;t
J J+) crb.- c;;c;- rlr-rl 6^+" ;.: t-^.lLJ I 6 r:5 rt.(.Jl .lu,li,r"
J c#) t;-S eo+ t S 6-sS )n )t ) "r)' Jr<t )l,gla-yl: S3-rlt,
J o*lJ,Lr+, 'r5; ee "r- .i- jl LA,Ji.JS*" J* ,Slttf Jt- ;.-" 1.:
:J;ly to:-2-. sl>s3it JtJ '>lyi>,> )ll-* J o-*-' rJ3J: c.-clll
Cf-l fU ...,r-ijlIl ); ,- 1; :3,--.-rt+ y .r-rJ .-,jti-p l-t tf -i-'bW4rl* oJ*rJJ.-* gt^-,S pta.,l rSl; ,g.t i ,6;l;l jUi '5'111cre'-l..";t;lt
J trr; 4:-l.*st.:J9r.lt-"; y ua,)-a;..el! ..*l;! 3.e*1.<-1 "+i.rUlaiL-
J--:J G.f \cr.i:y b..*-ly, +tL c---; 6 +.qs,S-t\) l J=! jt G, p GS rii;l *:*l..li .uU 1r-"*"' n e, 3ui,6tVi t Ge,:' c-3ls,c.dF JU:-lr,t-^..ri.4t& j:lilr,L t Elr.-lrrL-cil; l^..tUi.r-j,-13,.*" 6 -tl e-tsi 6. At -f )3> -l-tic;l
1t-i-r
o+y .g.,"u.f l1 Zivilcourage l;r.li;Ui,rU, ,, 6 cJ::*.rr .li "r;U SrlrL :i +5.cli,t:r*I, 6):lC, s o-tJ| *. r-s<zig.3 cll3;1.; J #.rlila,,Jt--;--l L .-r,:.--a ,i),_t )J..7J *.,g>S ,g>l)i a.$ c,;- .(- a-t- -,,
e. L)s-t d r+ k J:.<"-F ,ra-l-?; ,-?J. P;t5 a,1r la.lT
.r4--14;tr$)Lr-! dt-ji r"iJtSU cJ5.r^ r-l--<j rl-li.-"F 41:1-l :l;il
J t:: rlrr*i l--">., t,.,al-jo .-/Jt ,s-+a-r- -l j\:g "i;i -it
.,.tt(U^a J.- sF a, :U:pl J .se-pcEu.}jrli.r,-l o5 €A jl t-r.-r-olr; yila*' cr*'td;--lL
-"r-r-1,r" uL.> q i,-fLo:al.g!13 qgtau.,j;lcJt-- ,t' :>..grr.i j)\;1:lyl61- jlJr::5 r $; J"-€-J l-2
"rcL.:71 6.5>:f t +5 4Laijtl
1. typical Prussian 2. Reich 3. typical German
WWW.AEL.AF
*!ts. "l1n Y' Y
b.rjriLAJ,I.-r.JjL.," ;r;*)* J; W f J 6)jr4 -*5 lJ dJjt"ylr t& ! y o.r-i l-ry(i .;9;t-.; \l-St; Cl:e -,, 6.i;:-^a -L"t, ti
JL;6tar:J1;- 5 c.*1.rJUi,-./-l s bss.l.-* jl.-rtE tl tjry-U
"[rl.r- .c*1 o:y olaLi.,
"[:C :f oV 5u6;: €J. J oUTrr;S
oJ5o,J-*:o 65s_t oe-r* 1; 6 rltJi;l cdl.ac**; iJi;: cr.-l9l ;*-aJ ? re J ? _t-r .,.?-U 6 1l-*:,-gG.'4-.l c:*" * JJ ; .l :l -*.:1t5i j*"1 +' L^c-*; .i-l t: ,,,lS .,i)\.il J,1al r,\rr.-,*ila) .9t^-+j .,*r*,K, 9 d9il aS.l.-d;l J_*l yU ry ,:(:i U):-*.1L.:r, ,.,i)\-t
.-r:: -*a 61; jUi.gl-ac^*,
a- ly ,5;l-r.^:.-l.5l,optE g:r," 6Lao:yi fl t_r. -ralr; +;Yrt-oU JL- trl
fL^, ;pr< o.r,:U i"J; ! L cslf 45 u;u.:S..,^ c,-L^-- ft.ti jl a5 #, ..*lo;!rr,4-(L.,"jlL j)\.-l u/1.."_.-l -_S f -r.ili c.- *,lj)Lrl6L^r*j-,1)try .,i)t.-l.:Lt-.p-t.:-u,i :"r5,.r" g* ai
"[U" ati; ta.ti,tcr_,!..r
.:LL*--l U -ta1U:-l f*r.S U -t f;t-;* Ju.jL.^ ,& e,i r)
.c.*la---Li" Jqti eJti u--t 3y;.g;L-ac.-; (: €-, )) )tr_f.,!)\;lu. iS )trsn.51*!l..r.al 1 o.4-: eU o\-s e; :_,i f."t{ 6,j"t<^)Jlf ) 6GJ 1: jl cS-,!*-r otrp,_'*l _rr ,c- *l c^L t+ *i+ fU,,4ililJSC^- oK.u., _;l.-t..i -r.:-al9.- rat-t oi.,, -,rLs) 6rl.r-:-1.gta,,,j;
.;L:L.: t 6 J-) ,rS US-S oJ,rU cj"dti,. tuLeJ." :_f :* I g_rlr,,U
c.*,1 ;-(, tf f .<,-.$lcj-Ll *t,-cl VL+l "liU
r; .:L; c.:lr.it
ctlyr a5 c .,l,r"t-tj )l ; 1.rlfG -r_;5 GrlJf irp 1r 3 a:iyj, l; ;,1.Slq o*"ta F t;-f *Jlral _[.15 #ftj jl gt" r:tr1 r.*ir .,r^ai^i,r
6iL,*l: S>t,r;Lrt-,: a;.ilr c;l; j)t, olt' 4, .,juioUJ*Lo 45..r"lK:-o
cJu.il>,_r*. rr,a; tu--t-X b iJJ.* -qtj: ft-aill*J J $; rl_rJ; j)\,la5.gt-aoTa5ll L*y r,1 t5;r J+J^ (lu:^"^a clrta.tt--l-a tK ,r'1*S
WWW.AEL.AF
Y ' f n 9s f u, :li :Lo;: Lor, j.r, 1r-7
S\y 4V ,K> ,s*:'U +ilr ::ray yg 6 -;* *-i^ 4 6l-J^
LFy J*l &,..1t-.;;; rJ, L..It" rab;,-/q JS u*lg : e$)rl.!1_5_,"r.gto1j5;r Ll.r:J olj.+ t J+J^,,'t.s.f \* ef \l:d*t+r t-$ss 4::* t W .rt+r.€, j ,>l); a-tS:t 3 .Ka ;o-bG yb,irrt,4L +5 orlil q9tc,l .:t$ 1 j oJ-X ,7;'a rl-t';-l1 s:--!.r-a,u.7 45 t+ri Ul.-u.-:U .J-: a:-:lj5 ;t5.t=13 .ir^ 4 t d.4..-r
;l.^".jl * J;t'l u--r, ,1ii41t :ji +tL* c-.-;1-, a*t+ F eV5..-'>.;1-.o a. c-*l j-<"" Jl-&, t d),5 fD tr, .ral_4;i[,.-,L:-71
Jj-: GiL't 1; L .:LL---l ll-.; 45 JL"r1i.:y-.i :ldi ^-.bJ,.rl-,L.* 3 ol-r^Jt* ii-:S 1-. JI-^JG JJ Gy 4..<"U J# jl c-r;jt-,r."
6s-t )l L ;;5;l-,1-<rr145.r,y' rl.l-Ji Jt"-el a:f a, c*l;r(*.4-.: r-1q .tL*;l ; l;atn.-r-^a cS_,!rl JU:t _,,tr lr 6ts t t _* e gta";t c-"--Lr-
F4-.a dtK*A JJ*r*:;3-o i ^r-r;; o5.l--:t c*[- c-rJi ,> 6tl1.l Oli:.c
| €U eGsi ! duj u1\--l;r "!rp
,t aL^rk-k L- ic-l iti!-ptlr" ,lJLa j d--'.: >1t-, ,5J-7 -r* -.*lig (r-r4 6lua.:1j*lrlL-
;xllk 6 r;l: >t72 ;)V" -i-r^ 4 4+*a.lt'C"? 6 rJ , .t-Srs-Su- uzi l; JL"r1 jrl d^i JLr" ;.ra oi j ory oT c-.oJi ;; JL^r1
) JJi- o)3-> ;s,r!ry-re.r 6a.a-."Lt S p- -i.l- o-l O-tl--.r lfj.-t-ti,/:lil6taurj;I
,51[51.r'i ;-l c.g:l-i-:--l fl-h .<,- dl$J ,€-: 6L-aoryi elt 6 Jt- r,t^Ji 6 c*l L 611 - ;Kl.> * JG:i -c.tL;i .-{ r c*i (I*QV6ly .t lj:u; Ll rr5,r-;lr13,rjL^,ci rn"./l.SJ-lt 9 ;;r;-q f lt
:t -)1,.-oJ"6." 6 J13a rr.i 6;'-l61r,.-r-! fl-r: "lU fE,tiotrtjK;!."dt-U *i G*, J>G\ qtl kid -r.,iL.srl,u-lftl, 6 c:Sr- r.3;
L .e ?-e ) o r r*r;: ..r-J13.i J-iq; ,J, o<Ll ,t-iL a:-il.: l, -u*-U Jt"-e1."\-t rr r J. -.J- J
! i t, j)t-l;tly fk c-lo.t".l, ;-,*; yl ,Slt 6 -!-t^ 1 o*-t -bC.r- 1-r -il.lold+i a-l,,:^t c.5.:l,u*1.St^lG;: 6 loi;l.111.tK,1
WWW.AEL.AF
,-{tt ,lr n Y'f
jliYq .).1- r-6lr; )b)rJ./)\;l Fi € jl i :l6La;111crS,r"
f$lr+, oe;:, ,-i -bG e- L :; J J-.tS :* yJL.-ci;-,-1,,-.-"
)l AsG -r--L La;l;1lyl 6 c.*lj,ld<j U;€ u.tT-,;, oy)\.e Ul.J,Ji,s",
..r:-.iL +r-"ilr 1; ,-t^" -,l pt+;l c.-+U r $1..j)\il Jj*l e ,6 _*
.J :5 jXJ ;:i 6Z; Sl_t 6.ru-iL a:^il.r ,f )1./r^ 6a *! ctl.I3 +;J) ra^J J-iU" q +V e-*-f.i--r:Lj ! y,_i-rr q c.:- La.lT4l,,c-a y
oS 6>l;11E 6la ;r;l,F;l c,r;$ ?46;r c;;;rl ;l .-r--lL .rL;i
..:;l:.:_9.>3 (.:u:*a J-"-t,,.1L,_r-,1J.!.1*t+.x t) etlt .3ixil J_y*l yg>9Je* c.-?;3 ory,, .-5Jjl Jtit *, b: jt ;r"ils Jtj -,, L^.tTqgt-l;,"
.iujli,r4j ?46;-,-l cyl;L, .r;b .:y>.3 ,r:-!LJ,-t .r\Loj oVll 4;lr,
r 6eF Jt::.:UJ ;y U$; oJ-:[i 3 JtSl &ti r+ .<*Jolr-.7 c*l u;,a 31;.q5t^c-J_4*. .gllb ,--.aL, ;r 5 1; g;:r, J),\.i-l
3 IJL.X g;13 c.-ct-El slj-, cu).bo.;.l*; )J*i..r- W)l45 6-- qJj.J:5
fJ**; Jl Jqb -,, -t-"q j* a-^a e5 c*l g.:y .:;-ti ;.:L 6 )l C?'r3'i
J,r-Jl "f;l *_t-,-l:lrJi -,3,- rlilL cSt-o-,q* ! 6 6rlil,lja-"Jr<- iSl6ls Llc.[;t;,5.rl.ulAl.aff -,, Jb \.46 v-l-a: 6l_,,
e5.rj;lr .:3,-.3,31a;t5.:;l: ;-1'73 6k3'2 6|at>-e_p .,!)\il Jj*"|tilt 9
c--{+ J) La;[S ;*",o rLrl tr-,;lli L-".li,t:3,i **.U tr d!.); ..Fe*J ,p 3 ,.:-i: ! b-,t5 J,L $L-a J JL:, *.u 4 J:rL os13i1
plr-*.;l cjl-t-al ol a, o.1r-1 ell, 6 t+,lt ;t j .Jcalua pt+-,! t 6.:U; 611t5c-*i c.r::r j)t-lft-L] rtjL rlrrl.S Jt*i- c-*lpjY.r:-,U JL..ci
y Ur-rlr1*" l:--.li JL.rlft+il 61r,. u!:i-.i--r-i;1.: r-r; LacliEt-l tcrl11: a5 ,FY" c6:[^:-l ftlij 6;:.:jL,r,";ly -a 1_2 .::li q,JJ:,_r
tsljlr-i c>r3,g rllJ.i jU 4 d-yq s AtQ.;,..,t-c;l J )il Jl-e\S. A. 4j J .)LiJJ o sl)s +i ccll;l-u-,1 .gLootKj:;l * 3' ,V:3 a.i .$;lr :y>3
l. Gestapo
WWW.AEL.AF
Y . A 1 l$;6. t\t :Lo;: lar,ril, lr;
drr5 o:L elt eid;ta,Jt<" (tt.li,r*-r-r t"aUQtdt-ab-a t) s' s' t-
driYt-.t ! dJr"-r t4-;,6:l.r-il gllj ;.r Ul .'\:.-+ ejL-jrrJlil'rLL-l
t #ti" !.;L-c*: -.:*l ;-r-,rlt5rl t^,Jt"jL ,""^qr-;} jl '--^',aL"
cL-ly ;--l 1: .c+1 ,a.i.,clt5"l Gol1 yl jl Qj,5-:1-r-;l,51"4;U;'; t: yY!
.i- oUSt"-.gL-arr5;6 s qLbsil ,dt<,-r"i '{*7J.tll'j1:rL.a:il jl ,,(1a:-.ilr c*Jr atl; -rK ylt-^oi,r 6 Se,5$^a;;r; lJg'7 -J3'r
.:-r$.91y1::lil aS;lJt^..-lj.:l: -ualr; ft".jl-r;..iq a-l't'; t7 J .l:..l!
)r" .<{ ei c.*lojl-tilr-la- -u*iL +:--:b rj; e-;'ii JL..o!.3;*'b jlo.t-6r 4-.i 6;1:o.rr:6L^0133>;l;: lt ojcf$ 4.etly o!r.6, ':Ulj;
\.r,.r-.iL a:iJ
,-;-"f jfu .rr5 e.--., )-u- ,-pJ;r ;,1"; dl-tj..-.J t+;l1r Ll
f r*t Q.-r.-L* ,tJl-t ,-i1"F t,t-# J*" q 6rL; -r-- l'i ,llr"a1
iJi JL-- f '.-rya.\ e:6 )L elt )f J tV\.rl;" ,-Llr' 'G--&;l.t:-l j)\;l ,si,J 1: ,J--/f+jl .F" ! lr U ;-,-l y .c*lt-ae,.}i
J P-n c.*i 4s.r<J Jt^"1fLi J Ji,it s bV-:l:>jL,-.r d-r"a-r
J.."3 qr:"iti 5 c.*1 6l*;3 ,k tyy;,ly.J;1.: jj c*>3lt"c
.c-la;t(I.r.>
1. Professor Frank H. Knight in the Journal of Political Economy, December, 1938, p. 869
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
il ,..LJLrdl.ri.ri -
e rlr; , aLt ,1: +l1ril .r, JJ +5 c-l .-4r ylr.nr..rL +^".:j( c-'c-a l>f .rU r' O c*l cil1
\u ,l5 .-t .,.1,
al.l$"-r c*4.7;r c^Jt-3 a- rlr-ilOrr5;1.:13 6ll o#' UJ-;?+5 c.*l 9-1 coJ-.i orlr dJ,- LAJT.-iJt * ,rcL"-71 t1tLu.J j.6,r!l'ral
fLJoJ .! d;r-t6lr-.-r*-iL a:-i,lr rLi:cl.-il.i-aloia- :lr-ilg.5 d15
-il.r-al t rtJ*t .St; .l-! rlrll ,r"1.; 6..f1 t+" r.l5;15 aT-,t5 U .gr1-r-:-l
:y.--..il.i-all, -il-r-alar{lJ+! :1i1..:y J^lJ; .,i6.J:5 ,.i,>L "5-;-:"
J*"*J L^Ji r-, 9 o-L--x Yti-i l >l r:l 61 1. J,-t i {ti" a5 .tu'-. 7 .-r5 .l lrJi4-i J-"q y -r-j;* rr;.-il.r-al ,slg,-e a- lJ t^,Jii;3e:lil+U t'lc$y'
-riL o$ d;I,.xi 4.ost* y.,F :* t J J,--b) b,li6t-^;3U o)t'
-ilu1J..l_9iJ: c.^(a t> J )f 4.:3,- L-,r*-7 -r:t t rltit -u b.:lr.il a5
)* y,.lFc.+L"i qgLa;y5 c.rt-:r,;rri J, d$ d.L..-l ft.-"rS cS7Jtr.J 6L^1-i,.1.5 oL:r, dF tr )-tr-t' ",/L-l
:l t&:€:,1r" q ,-J5
rila:*ili,5rL; .ro b .lr;c-"."L;,5Lac.J3: 6 c-*l #, C.*l a, .li,c.*l.glq ,;.iy" .r,j,- ol3Jr c.,(- J) :1r!l;Kil e"-l-ta;:
l. E. H. Can
WWW.AEL.AF
,j'r.'l-, n Y'A
tr3Jl..:yi d r1F eL'"!i qSU_S Jt-ful,i-r; jtJ,tdr,lc{.Jl
rrTolL;; .;.:,* c.* .; djQ {5 s*,.^ oJ--iarti J$JTt^Ji r-'J- -&,+1 sqn a-j a-i c*lirlr-5.r5'U Oi, J,-! oS dla:* t-6:;.nJ c,-*-rol_r;c^-rL.; .SLrfG oebo r#u$-$ 1[5a, 6l"ao-i-i i j t3; 6; 3;fl-.E; .<+ y oi 621131\: t;:i c^-,aL o-,;i,6 ee-l ;,!, a:S:; .-r::*;1r r.ltilj *.j o5 c.*l ;l .La).,-o ,.# J-lS _,* y lJ otJrc..-L.i
c.<+ J) .,iL!.l.j 6L,o,2l;.1llL.i n5;al-c.*l 6-rL, i-r, "(- g,oJ.-
,5.l,5 r: rt+:l: J>lJ .,r/ ..(..sr n :lr.il (Otaig rt<il *.; r.r:l: 9-.9h1y.51r rll-i*LJ j"U .a--;; -.,r .ri-J..* .K:^f.^ Gleichschaltung
,.)l..iJ"i L 6jS |ll: LU bJjl f- r .r.r^: -bt--J 1t a.o colr;rr"L;
lL- lt.r_9- ral3>.:9U:,,.iG_r , ,)L,cSt^rt+ L*; aJ,.>y"c,-,--l rr c.r^l,L ,uly ftlJ ..51 J;5 c^"; ,}S :* {. )Fy .,;t X-tl CU"rlJ,iil+ _,l.5 .l-l y'b-* t; :lit d ,,,1 J^ty; dr,l 4J't--" &, orr*y.: 1; :lr-ildLail c^*jli "L^tJr r,oL,r-7.rtiJj rs:,/-l;t.nJ:t+",- fl:t;t U"J$* J d-J;_*|.,r> y -rar oSr*.r3,- ol_jJ.r c-g?c*jli J-:Alr; r-iL or*i pP;Le).tlCb;L" jtjY}t.)&
.JjjL t-al .:LJ'j ;r1t 6,rtK|\;jl,J"6 :-b yts )f-p.r_2-ti .rt* J,ft dril olJrc-.[.j ,5LrcJ3.: y: 6,rJt-- ;r;"U UtcJa)rrl ltr.i .rlr.il -L-U" Jj:S gglr, .ll:r^:.J3: 1t^=l1r l1 sg.:r! <,
.:_#,_* 6^rl; di "# J .rr^ jlo<! .)LJ"r.# rl a, cbi uaVj),[-l6 d)tt et- fU ,.il-L,a-, rlilorr5;1.:13 4J L :; .:t-$ Jtcc>;3-,o;rl ;r r_9*i )3J>-r o$rl C-iU^ O1 ,S-y q,rtL"--l q5t^,.l)S
;)Bl Jj-"| ual; 66rF 1: :l ,.eV,Jt i 4 ,>_tf a, -ti.i .:e;oT;"r- jt.ui tsl3;;: c,-lo:r-S o;Lil LartlJ, Jt-c,U 6 $;\l; eq,>sf yl ;r c,r-.lL rlil a, P;" J etr .,i!l _,y! 4 ,i)-ri'b-r*JJ! g+lo-:3- r^Li ")\j ..:3r J-al3> r-r! .,.-1,))l { t-.:f !;i .JLJ.t*tt J!-Li;.> 6 A\-rjli.rj.lr.-c-*"k; o*.ta "i- ss )-ft-f ,,i)t;l
WWW.AEL.AF
Y.1 Ec-iJ>,jtt
)L.d;l j;l )l o.:Li:-l \ re -s.G S-tlpt gl-,r .f ! ._r:> 5lory JaLl,
J-.tK-t- rrr.,a, r+-- 6*) *, eGStllV )st q LL; co,t.i.-rl.ra
J-lJ, r-+i, - tJ-.l.- GW fll; .(-.rLl-r : tt e:fi 6 I-i ,rp
crrL*-il o!r-',l:r,*i fr* .J.p ;l t" .rt"r}--l .,jt-Jl :[-l r:.:1 f t t SJ-<-. J*"J^.:i; .r.-alr; ar"i jlf"l t* y>i a, plr=l ilrb * ,il;>l
lr jy;lcSLa-,lr- ra* q,^ _r -t--itj rlilr5l q[--x3.- r""l yl c-l6J lt )l et.c.4 f^ ",i)\;lr; ,J,tS ,* ,]Ess-e Llc.r^l!.r,
.-i<"ttt1tr(J>L-l g-r: r.^;* -.,-, qUJ-,r"= c*l ;5'*" .r"tl ;;3c-=*21 Jll a*"t7 4;glX" cSta-,[- t c-l- j o>1t 4;llSa.Lil.>,t
.-t i[ +:*il.:
a--.3i L-acll.t-, f,-! d9:5l a5 c.r.al3ec-,"["j .:U,$./Ul .:LjcLl
-il F- lyt iltd a,;1 jl l; ..:tj)\--l lL.j t^d l lc,-" ^ i -iJ,-J- ,,-,5
rjli,r.i.t'lJ-c^."W .rt* coi6;15 c.gt" .ttJ q."rjjL.f JJ-r-0..,V t
"}..1, d 6 c.,i)\r.lcSb_,y! r G& Jl* ctldrj;l a, l; :y*
a5 cc^=*il3 y L-f.-t cEL^,-t*,:l I J,-! 4<! .t5 r3,i-*-" (,L::",^A t ,.,i-*<t
:*1".o-9 ..:jl:r., c.rjL.r, J;-:" )f \ e-&, ,t-,h y l1 ctL;l ,.,-5n
,,.=5 9t+ b._rjrt .y;{ a, l; rlril f.^lf.r ft lltt ly; r.u ;it-lt: a5,,,=a.: .tt=irt ,lt .:-.i -l+Li, n-i L 9 orl: ,|-7 +7 j^.1-U l; I,oi
drr.a iL"ic"qU..U J^lJr 4.-. i i ^b:J .iJa U.,* aL,.\,>1j,,,
S ,;f ai $gcoia, oJy; .51.a11;l s P >s_r J* d--;1;113 jt-r,ol
.51: "|-11.i
: # cJ5.r- )t.6:l.;, JL-.-.f-lo: Ly.-t,,l5 e.-t*a-il; ciil:p ,-Li >_sf 4l-ai -rl.tal! J,-! t6rc rlil._e.,;yljt J.c*j45 -t: rj- l, , iYL^:-lJ t^c^.JlJ *. Lyy J,-U.c J,-! ;;3^a *+ .t:-itlJ' r' ' e
..r::*a llj*,l rsi ,t ,al-- .rtrl.ril
el* fU ,JT ,J-"ts j)t.;l ,:! oT ! c-.;iU, a5 .-lo>y r^tj "y.;
,rJ3 :;l.rJ )ffs i_t I o.,ta;) cc*l l;^iry 6:Vil a) 4 ;: ,S u},):l
WWW.AEL.AF
,-{rtJr! Y\.
,-"ljl,raGi! 1---,*tj,1 45 .*:5 r.; +\; L cLl.riL a:.i,lr :y,-j J,L
.*tJi;U A.-l )l ;1..;--c+5;ltr -rjL-, ral3; pt--rl *.ls )r?-,t5,jt"jc-iJa-"Uy .S ,fl-b J+ JllJ.*"t+ rJ! ,r;" t-lie c-r^iL a:--i,b
5 OtKVt{ 6L^jU; e, )_*_r 6\aubl|; -q! .r_.u,_/ -h y 6d+*^4-S c;rl.SLa-,y! .t-S 6$*"*:6s2* dly" rr 3 o:r5 5;.:r;t-tj \ t.r1ti rj,>jrr f"d il;.il jl Ji,S.f c4lr^ l1 yl .:1."*",r;
d.p-l o-5 5lo:3r -r-at-i c;3-t;-*a .J-lt,.g :-nS il. o?V ot*""-,a t +(ti-ol cucl; ilL&!"aj jlL^u"jJl ol L_y._r,-15 JL-" _*^j tr.rliua) &",-+ oq? 51r il n5,-Jt- 1r .(.(jlrS;*r) ,U .(1 6 or-i
.S ;".- t;,tT ol:5,-,-l-r.a g;taj J-, I .r;li cc.* I ;.-La))_f )) U rl .r--alr; ):*""Lsl:,5y;*t-;y .:LLi, 6,rJt -;:3ce.*' j)\iloj;U 6:r oLio;L;.r 45 r:5 S# g"-* f-6-" ..15L"
L- -t-ar ,j)7 aa3, pf P;: l; .r3-> .rta"$-pj r,-! Ul r.:;l-LJ .:3--3
..r-JiU r.11: tt! lt L^.li.rt^.-.r: G*:: oS -r:,-L-; yl:19 1; taCi yt.r-! pl.rJl ceL".,a-ri i'U c^; L A c.*l F". aKS$ n"*:,J+y'JIJ -t;4j)t, ; eU UF t 4^"t- J:^lf.f ,5t Ut ,.r:S 6$ f**,J3-cl 6-.<- l"! c-iS,rjt ;i, J .- rL"-- 4jYt--i JJ"t a, ly 1-aoic.:Ll-r.il
.trl: o3-l-* _-iLb a1 jU.-U_** J ot; p)\rl.r"_y'"r -r* *.1;6:r"-ol;
eit-i"-43 jlcS-,!*-lr 1-l -'q:a-"UJ J+tl 45 t^r,-l*iJrU 9 to.u,"t-r;.t-- L; 6 ,gla'jS I T*4:.! )tiil ,|"Yr p)\,cl o)2p j cJ.5 ,.4L:-oly
L; c;t- .t-alJ- ;,t:t3 l; sl r>-J )l; ,lpljl ,J_,!t **_ r;3.. ;K.-.&LL .r* sSF-,l or C-1, l1 JY.r;-*l ,F_& J$ :* q [-.l-ocStJ-
.J+lrr e_* c.r-Fr.(4Y oi;.i .(,.,.'. 6 S Ch.:--6+l: 3 olrie*"L*i --^t .i" ,Sy- :l rreit*ill -t JJ, -t+l-p
"rlc^-aj t a c*l;rK.*" coty,-c.--Loj -,.^: .J*:! ctatfi4u ,ilt".i o.-,i,
,rti-* y cc*l o:r5 l.u- l-ff-f *J )l 6 e;-* ol .i-;'l;
I . in abstracto
WWW.AEL.AF
Y\ \ U !:@ LJLL
S*3 r"-:.c---a Jl 5-rr ! &tL" o5.+J- .,;l"l"t fEj 4 ;t- q "t""
lE ,, La,tl ly; r11> .rf t.a,Jry+ jl 5 J:5 )_p tfr c*l ;5.*" ..l5L-.Ilo:_e-, ,F_f # o,-;
'|-:li sl elt u:";.c'-W1.t(-t- nS GW
crl;3r {-51-Ao[:-b ilr*l o--4>, L)_p.y rrJ:L >r- p)G c*l;-(*.r-al,, l; .;L-F AjUU:- 3l g1u--l jl .Ji .r="-*J l; 31 3 os3t c,_jljl3t
:JG y 31 3- S p.:L^.a-.; 6lr. u-;,b.. o#y Ii lya a5 c.;!,jl ,rij.{ .>:F \ *e * ""P.{ ,-,tt,ll _il .-Ul.r a:-:lr ,'iL:faaLl .-t:5.f c{l-ta l; :lil pL; JL-el
"& , d 6 I l,r";> .,*r J*l 4
! c?,- .(+t J oia" y ,# #*J U i-toj t c.:- o.ql; .:re,
uel; "ijtl.:!tr (c-*1:U1L":-l).-r.-1.i- ! .l ,-^ ,4t-s: J"t
+5r,rr,".r3; J .Sti dlill :.r-6J..r, \ -&t ail-rt .4,Strq! ..4L-3; rlilJJJ." 3 oJc o',1!,.rr eil; +U, fl"i a.(li.rk,.JL^.r"j-,lkJd.J:SJlii+*l- .,5.Jt-i o15,.:,-l-La g;t-.Ji.r,-l o:f t oS..cljl
'*. +5 cc-l
.$r Cl-: rXh rr-r" -qt-J o+:6* +.lil,i;.:.51^,i)L f * : qU^ .5h 6j1.1 o\-e *. e.: 5G;F.: a,i+q jL;
ol-, j- ,lr ol .--cgLs; el-h )-IJr:! ( g'ta...- , ,5 L- st r +o 9 ar c-rl .ile -.v -r J - \ Q- {J J IJ J .
JLj.: l; .,rrA 0L^ ,'J-,y..grG+;Liln y t.l:,!>,\rt Yrrr.ilirt-a
c;bp_.rrl.c*1
-,, od9-y
cS-r!*^ ,>)3> ,gr;s tr -r L^,SjU i:*yrl! ,-p-rSr a5 J:s.,^
!.,y e5 -s^-a ji:*l rsav \W -s.L:s-e L^Ji,r<".^.c-*l,tT,_ri
.-85.r" *il: oJ-:;..ri s,+, jl 6J..ar.i- -9 o-r.T;r -^ir.rtrli.i .>sf
r--q ^5.rLa,.ijJl rL, "l .r;! n- rlil *i 6l-,.. "_* C"t j?'Lr*, t^",.jrlJ--l 4J fi Vt*" lJ LAJi q5 c*l;1.-r*5,.a"J, LadlJ,
J-*t [-a,tl.t, a-1,..a .,La.ti.tt(;; "tr;t.u-
t-,t"JT 6 *:--.a ,rsl.aj;;l .r:;L-a
./t+." )lJ-il .JJloJ.5*dLU-! y 5-rr *L, .>-tt' t .t<6a Ll c-titory
\ ursi Cs-r..r+.ra.ltrl.g a- 3 oJ.l>J d-.u .,,--S .tL-l.u )l 45 J,r:,u,a-l^.-^ G.ri6L^.; j, 6 t*dl^!L$ ktt qt d[-Ut 6 yte: 3l
1. Blut und Boden 2. noble lies 3. Plato 4. Sorel 5. Mussolini
WWW.AEL.AF
,JtrJtn Y\Y
orr5 orat-i*, lJ La.)iJti j or7 t>,j.,o q .t,ii y., LlJla-i,l: .r5'U L^,:t"r,
J,r--r; .:1..l5 jlorLl-lcj-ta yl t dJ*-r 6ly "2-.1, ,jJ-;y J.$)J.t>l rJrl 6l r. ol -->c-=.oL.; 6La5jt eC rJ 1:.r-; . c*l-a.li ;t*" r;;3.c*lc-."t- ,tr ,S# rSV- FQrJI: g*;) 3 oJ^**,o,rJj 6.:tat-^.ri;rt jl 45 ..siLJs GV -"; J .rt-.ii ,J.s ;-r c*l ;3.b;^",r
.S_rg dt* J,-J- 6t^,,,jt qgl"al.tL;i
;--l-9.c.*1r,,g:l;il o--15 c:U--yt ar,-l.,jq-e oJyl of t>*l 7il3 yJl.5 4-.t dlrl)i )* a, i ol3>c.","1*j 6l-ar:J3.: lt rr{t dtar^ JJt" 4".I5
,tT;.: l.- 6 g-*b.-, r,6:1;iL-- ,-^ --;,K oly..f c6il31r .t_y.e eJ6l-"rg>l1i 6lL-ollU oa .-:".^
,q* tS ylcrlL cit .H rl cr*--,;l.l {r
c6yl.t L-a bl;,.o +,.4.:".^ -i*! 1: al 9- r:*l *J o:t*.rlil + -!..g
,gl-a6slj 6t+ ol -r-.-r+,gL-o,5:l;i il-oj nS ,-sl-S*_yy ! 4LA",SlrtJi;l.r :3,73 gg:lr.ilL ,;c -f ,-i--f",i! lu,Jllt G-$;) cJ.:.A.r,r.o l, tJr..l
i.t.:lr)Lr+ | t"jj ,glr- u*7.5r1;i,r o.r-"3 6 LSrlil .,-u;^-a ucr:lji C*, S4j<j J--l ,. aiottt;jp 6 ,-Se .r'U; c;o= J,ljl0ic-*aL e5 6l6i;i.9L- a-, o.l--i.g-i-:a-.Ll y.6>t;i ttabu a5 .rljl* JrU:" lJ L 5 .r,1lr -rfLl; .r)-^7 ;-l 6,6Wt" J1t5 r5r .ns*i ;*,-l 6t^6:ljiJt-*l p[;;1,(il.Jl**a 3 a--Li.,r 5 .r^r../ Jl*-a t, 1 "!!l.r-.td.f "!oi
-ll c;La-rL5 jl .-r"
.l"t- ;t, 5.lr jl Cl- ;r" :=,. .gLa.grl-li L J--J- t:;ti6) Vi V$" Jt ;ci c*l .J::S.I,J "jl$l ol-a a, r,.g.rl1i,r 4.JS jt jl o.:Liit o3"*J cLl t,>F,/
-,..b >yju 6Ln.g.ll;T-r-;L^ .-l-ir,,r- o ,+ ..ri rl olr;c-L; c.rl1l.t":-1,,.
+K[ a-"t+ rlr-il .5:l-,1i a-i -ta:,rr a:lrl 31 6 ,5lrr"r*-- igtljin c,tlatj,-s:4l.j
^-la C*,;) ),9,>.1-9Jr -r--U-cttrr.S..r! 6l; J)i*UJ. r9-r*rl.l .5.:ljT
.c*1.:1,ri l6r\i chljl U$-5 "1,.;:,1ue .et Clyrr rrl3 rc.*l
.YyV .op,6;Lj, ,"ar 1: 1L:=\ : urU\ .Y Ctt" ,t.Jl J1l5 1l c.-l 9l5 rtlyc .\
uy-.:: g. (Vf .rr,5:tr:3\,iLj\ Jt-L ol3rr a,*i )J-:rLs ri) {PeterDrucker) fl;: r:1 .Y
.r*lll -r-r.r-.gG..g:lj ;l c-w "jU.l dL^ r .tu-iL c5$l 6>l;i ,tiq yr a5 .r5.r, o-iaL;-
>y o:f 5,): g:tri ,r Jt-fuU !; .,r .a.i qt^; -;iLi 45 *' j ;V +ri J)tjT ;rr Ll .:-:L r"lf..*l : / t t- -f' pr; gl;;r .rr 5J., !r -,1 r, os JJ,-E J)l ji .r:j.r"J.E lr
WWW.AEL.AF
Y\f trc^i;dL-[
JUJ*P -,,1cE-,t"*t -t-y +"-lS,Jt:-" -.-F ,opv ))_f d-l -,, 4lL4.; n.g.rljirr t-l .c*l o* f ,> ; j-e .*J[--r* r-r1-,11:;a-,] J .,lLJi.rL-i.lj;r o:Li:*le-.€- J) 6:l-*,1ol3:,c a- oT6t-.- 45 c^4 6l+"15
.,it".l5 r J. CUJ;I+7 6 ,,lory J^t-i "y.i .c*1 a:rt- r",*i.tta1r*c-."'L;lJ c-; ;-,-l .c*l o:L!l 116;l; t j n$3)>t U- 3 n,t3:[irr y teJl.t-crr J# ,tc;t+.ri;: l-, .*VJ .,i)\;l .:l'ytpllL";"!--,ij j ":l> ,p13 oli.l
f. F ir,-l o5 ,.*l-f ; .ti jl .y'U ,St^..rS;:rr cillol5 eU* 4.f"t+! .rf J-lJ- 11,:--1,: c:1j14 )3-7J a:..-ri)U, J ;;Lb e"ot*" olt f6ss 44 ar-r) 4 | :>l-r.3r jr.r5,- Jt r-* 45 f5 5;r l; a;6 ,_f.-uly, tgE_6 a- yl ..:L*15 y oU .+U-iS gJ-" jl J* ,rtll-tuSgr-;-,-l..:--t- .t-alJ, F"" rj,l1ta.ti;-,r.ilJ -bli1l *-S *.r-q- 6-aol-1i f;t it d5 ;L"JS .,;L^" ra.,; l,-i .i-: J^lr -;: -;+L- 4itat<TJJ"t a, 6 c.*l (SW-Xr,"l/ ^+ {*j o.rL cltil.!.r::."r6 JJ"tJt"s J e)fi q .r-9..i.f *-S :6 a, rlr-il .:,-[a r].(-7 1: 4jl.at<iu
q5LA&Ji '>s.t' +, .}Lls 3 oJ) Jrr;n,iu fW $))L! ri1.t--ly 4lriyl: l-2 *JU ,+l y o:y o?;.' e6 A-F -* rtU 6 -r---[f:, u"aV
.-l:: 'l.ajl
l-t tf ,lA" p4.'14r 6)U;j\+tdF J)ti:-t;*1.: jl.,"t+.!-t" c.lrlSlj;;L
f JFy* .rr- o:,,i,\: oK cit* J,-! ,"J -U;tr rLi:;l .aUly 6,r+lnTt,l .c.*+
arUrl d.t*l 45 jyrlljt-1 .rlY3.i ! Lgi A_i:i +5 glo.ry Jal-.i
jl .r,#,-r* )3J>.-o cJa:"r.0 J-<5 l;,rct -71,Jl-acJt- gL*j o..t5c--1.J-n
e-p L- rt-fui o)f y f -*.,l)LrlJrq i,il A7l )lu-,[*l 5 t-,ii
1l-.,., A;--ltl,S-,L*t o-5 t+oT;tJ.* )jJ->.-o J-: l--6lJ,J dt-.t
s3a9 a:Lrt;r o-r-iy -'* L- G* o:-y* t tii L^jj;l0.t5c.*1.to
.rl:
..:Jj: Jt*ci ft^; cirlir-;.r 3 cJ1 oV? gL.; L a,Uy .:3,- cc-ib slJ,
WWW.AEL.AF
,jrt"|ttr Y\F
.5r.-)/ 6+ drr-.i :lyl fl.uL- oJ4- ,:Jq r )Liil e-$rr jt +!o.5 IJ-i JrU:, Jr_q (J.::-*a,_r*.? ri)^j "t- jl .el.+,,3 c.rLo-:r^a1)jl.,r:--o U* J-*;J or.l.-,ti;il3l;l+-(L jt.' ,:,r, -!.r,a t4.:c
pLJ c.r3*, c-r-J.tu oTa-, 6;lrUJ J 6+-q J.-q o-5 tSls*: ,*-i rj1s.-l
-r..al,, JU l-,, +"LJ.q .-(1 _,-Ll oJ:.a:"f^(i^i;Li- o;L;: 5l;.5Laot(4:d,rl Jle-rt lA u_#:_f r J,-tt11 L^qry e\ s trt-*irLljt.-r--!p )_f_f *S rl La.7-r dS 4jJS,iL^A .St-r-l ,lt* c."_L--,-, r-r
c*l gla.;l Jt- -,) -,L5 o5.r"tK:^, :I1l:,r, il! ,;r^J-r 6tac5r- pL;
&"" lS-i oi.l.:y-, e_fU )l ty.ri- q oia, c*; -r,-ry -,ktl t,$ -*;'U .ltSrS JL ,.i)L 3 o:l;1 y c-*1 ;r(-" lT t: j;ue *rJo ;.."igq,.<," c-a, J il rdJ ! .l-ry -,kDl ,,rl 45 .r"l<$.r,tr;lj-(, 6qJ ;;t*.,:-1 t.: c.:,/,,r-. b_f-t,reL"4l *tj_t J5 c-ireJ" J 4<! ucV ar}r,
))f JoT L ojL<*irtS J ,-ilrt<,\r, &-" .<-" bl* y{ti .-;> o:t'
,l11lclasrj-rlo;t ;: Cl; +U" ojl$l a, -t"t .rt"rb s ,)-W c_91u1. 1l
crs,ll.s-,J--i jl- * J;3 s F _:t,,tft:.-r-:! rs*r ;-;5.: .(,L- c.*1r J--ti" r^l.j crJ; gi,r-u q! -o-,t;l s -y->l:
raVyL,,JL.S[-- t-r: ".r;iL;l .:L*--^p:.-tsy,, .:*;r a, :G:pl +5 -tt:! ,r;1;[i.5; o.i,i )yzJ tu €.cL c*l dJS.*. 5,rit y-tlpt*; j.-r5,r" &-_rfil;L Jt-:-iltL* L# .ri:-.i ,--.i,lr *Jf ,kl {! JijJ- :lril o;lrt _rr J,-ry y
. c* I pt! e, :lr.i I 6; l:t!3 6il JJi Jt^:-l e l..i'U r.rt-s)\,tl ;t-:; I p.r)) )fy c*iy,., .i'ij^i: olric---.L^J f[_tl ..(1 _s> )ff c*+S
.rL^J,-)i 3 "(i c*l;5^" 6 e* r,a.c*1,(4.tU',;;r fr 6L^t--
fuy cl-oL.q l-.il.t a:-.1,1r ol -^,o a-, c.J3r JL.-"i.t:_9, .rjyie a, e*j l;
"_$ -*.ry' a:*ll: &:s, (_f d_r-ljl+q )Jj rlil;- 1r.r1L,,a;Li
U"F-"\+ si*f 1l alKi,f1) .5L^t? )t t_try ql-x q.:3JLti r--Ln"
l. Sidney and Beatrice Webb, Soviet Communism, p. 1038.
WWW.AEL.AF
Y \A tr d^ip jq!
cJ3: .,,ljU Fto **t dr<*" +5;Lc>,ttl *_$ * 3 or-iltijlgL^.:J
-..t-.iL LVtl )-*,6ly.tac-.ai jlo:tiilU- LaoJ-o3 jirL o>;yiy.1t
a5 c*l,lr rAlJ; )FJ GW.!) 6ar,oi.jl,*:" .$-*:-ff J,"ti,5*
cS-,L.al oJr-i*i r:,;,ij -l-Gc .:.r--3 3 ."Li.JJL*-c!ot yll fE:, J;5,1i;.,
.J^:U
osi plb o5 r *-i, .o o-t.lS:*.*b.jf \ 6> otp)ltl JtS C"l(:_-JJe
\ L-* frb fk o: r)?G t* *.e cri;l$./q- &X" ! *Q:tt* y 6 ,_+"r)";r rlflcol3->c.--^rl.^j lG -,, 45j,l.t^dl Ayel*l+t& Fi:*. ,,* y s:r1.-l tl y dlr :S s r JL*JIJJ-lq f"r^,-ojl--l c:[.a:il\ J AJi>catL: .-|*i jl ,.r:^r..r" rlrp ,jL g--i lJ 6"f-.t-_t& o:l: ,k qy rla;.: dtJt-- 6..xly cJill-ti 1; e!j13 GF*.c*1 o-t--! olr+, -,!*t J $_+.o-taLl.o ,!.G 1*t tu (.!^:^*a )f e)); rglr1or-; 'prJ.lr:*.fly! ,-,--tc,grUu-,!gl^if lU -,, Clf t,:lr-il o.:111J JtLil c^11-t--a !:--(+ J) di jl dulr.<- ei .rilo.r..: .,iLaJt<AlJ
.r:= t-a.j3"-;l ;r 6:y ,r,alr; yi-^*: .t1,.** o)e )F +tL c-"-:
dLJt-- J )t)o*;t-(Jli.-L:*a c-rJl3 .-,,/, J) Gdi 6 ,-ilora.31l 1-r-a:
..r-iL_;lu-l y or-i, o.:tr f"E ,"! ,_fl^,_f-F, q 6 i-S rf 5^-*,-);3 H jC-*t" q CfG .r,-lt: "qLir.9r1..r';-*lJ;5 cLl
.-u-i[ a:^i,lr .r"!- c.**al n-S € -L"Js^; -E y J:l iloy ;.: 6 tt-.f3 o-L-i 6-i 6*) -,* y,"r--t toy-r.S: €J.l-fr 45J'-l G)i c^KJ l..a.,-r- ;i-l oi .*l u-^..-.s 3 .c*l ;ly': .r;3,-X &,F +t -&-t .f ,4J..r':*a f- ttfu.gl.;l-rJl U"q*.1Fc-:"L.i.StTf lk -,, tl&L;
Jtfui a-1c.*; {.r.i .}-,- "r- 4;-:.i1:;: t^ftli }l 1l;,ua;l;}crl-u*:-ilr jl ,S-,f*t i,-a -rr 6 ;ra iJ.::*A S p-" dl?l olJ';t,1 'b../L- p;r-n oU,n t c?- qrb 5;*t.r-#.f oraL:^,. itF f!, oJ.jJ, .xlc{ ! -e
,-#,-e.r-i[ rr&-.:y t J c#.i-] ..,;+
l. Scmitic
WWW.AEL.AF
,JttJrn Y\2
);j-o {o)J..,. rt-,aj;: .,.*={JU (.-+;) €, t,r<;(JL*) --tU;U,rJ r*p.c.*l +J't-*- dt"^ FQ'\"-* ,t-J e rlj c."ij&d:131 .:;.--.3 a-, d,.-cLrr lU $_yg Cl, fr*^ )_t3r u,,al, j $i gg\V;
cr;.iJU ;*; Jt*^, J.-u.Fjri{lcst^j:" tr ..ljEt 6tALi(5-\-14 -b y.(J::*-6 y|.:a,Lr* "}b l!l:3as olj:,-o ! .:l*rL-_r
4-i + oav -L-lb ";jb .r:- 3 r:*l.tqi 4 ;r*. &*r e!it-_,
:U:-el c-.:lr g*i rr;l:arLr- 'a;,-b,>l--a;t a' blyg\;!,*_9-,>gl,l-",r :c-*l b-,lJ ;l,Syt- r# -_#-,t" * f * a,L*. .1a-,J
6:_# r.rr-9- ft-; -rlfi_b t-.,,":.-_a.:t, ;[ i ?p jfi-h.g.:L; .r-- U c-.--*;r; .lUi;: .(.'.:.*^ ,glft) cr:;;J -.ry,S-,i"tol'itr-JL; .-Jt ."r-*t" 6U^;^r;l +lr="rr.c-*l c-,*'..;J drr"^ #pU a, jUTIJ(& JUU<,} )l &.rr.:t*)U; , tl?t)-,t..i jl ,.:*lyg\ >j->roc cll:yr cgta-,l5 pL.j,-*lo-t.i ,4 .Jry.;t+ o-tir,, 6 \r.;LJ
.r:*l o-:r5 4-?i\; r,"il.7 -rt<a;r oUI.i; r Jl3:,^e c.-J .,,lslJ jt*;l J* a_F -* 5 c.*l .+l.i,-c-f[.j F 1sr;Lt" >t"S ;,tpt+jl.rj31: "S;t t -r"r-a CrSOa osu. sJ.", Oi ;j-- )V a- aS
oilIl,S-i ! (rA -hV *.r-_, & -bV +.&.rS.r lfu.-t_*eJ.^.J::..-A ,1io-* t6c.+jJJ Lac-Jt.. J,* dlf,;*J., ct-aq5jli qgly
..l.:S
"J ,ret"ql 4jtlt<i i-r^ 4 ,-rll t.I,s )f *2* "r,-! J""
.r-(""lrj U! c-.il: r3ryy *-L;6lo-r:;c.rl.u 3,.:,r-.r3,4tJ 6aJ>l-.i c;s,-[iy 3 o.:3-, .*& .liE r] 6 ,F ,r,.,b a, ,:u, l:*1o5 ry' p 6+'lo.d1.aj." +, c*ldr(*...t.:t 4-il$ IJJTU ,-lssL-ss
Pl e.l..r-iL a:-il: -Uli ri .:y,- e,iJi -,1r r.1i11 63*: @p i:c"lJ;>1i oJ4-o a.tl t; j,-o C_l.tfig,J.t*; l:6,g_Sf ; t^gjlq
"ft* yJljti6, ,l.- .5 r31.rLJi;r Ujru; db 6 plKO ".r.slr'-.rt+t,l: e -b t d-be...:"".a Cly.:\4 +! .r-:^il.: -rSii.r*1
l. Lenard
WWW.AEL.AF
Y\V ni:i:Ljtt
,-i -bC \ e F J3"; r4*a eG t t\ 4.t-! !0.-_r-, ;r U- r,..ar
..-Jl.l( -,t5 r- -hV *. -* J_r; $[^.6 lJ e -Wr-"t: Ul.J*L :-,! J.1U * aC* 6-l )l u--.1. c-l;(" r+r^
:l.t-Ji crllI ol_2>-c--.,oL.i [ .-uiqg;;uUy gtJz; .! .,ili -,t i-, ! 6)Jt'.51:r.-(1 ,-t\l-e.;3".1 1^-a .:"-l-ra t J[a JL*A flr."- :.+.j t^,Jl.,*-<j
ol; ;: -qL rlr-il a5 jl:t-c=l q dq! a, jL; c,23!;".a J uC1+ )l r9t->13
o>y 6j;l \ dp:L,rl i-*j c! e J:.ar J3 Jf*K:fjl t"ocli
oS G,l3s.J::."J! cJ->13 s!J-a 4 q o-r.--, 6lr'.:llrl ol:U:el : g,5lr
.:Jy: .i- I oib oJf 6 it- s.$- J) <! c;.r- c..oJ.-;r +i cgJ"e
J F eg 1: JY.t:-l 3 .].=.-, 4j-UJ L+J o-sf ;r'l g ,>1$ g sli45 4jlJt".A.J:SLr" c,-lra lt a-.ta.r[- Jt a5:y.r-aly,' ,St-lb *ijl!-l..t J.-q * *h g aS u,*a cJ5,r^ dt, tadju 613:l> ,'--2j
fJt-r a- a-.[-- J.5 c.i:" -h; y.r" U-tr:6 c.*l yl..t-r^, .:3,-
fr,gs.f s-Jr.'Lnc^i*i.-rr ...:*l o:1.r gr) Jl ll .r-.li ,St-* -&t rtrc*.i^i>n 0,.J5:f6 tSkc.ry--i cJU- 6>p blqs ,r"-h )1l5 c-+ g6 4;V,*., y -3"t,*i b.-t..or 4 $lie.ta13,.: cr,.at-- ::_f -f 1.: 6 J5 ;ryt: X\at:j-i,ut i.,r+ c.=o5l,- Li +5 c-l 6;9 6;l:-" y, -&-t cc*qi..l5
* y. 6 eh c,.:.,-.-xl: rU:cl rll.t, )1 ,-rt-.-: -hV y +! a5 cS;*.rls r*i; llolrll-9"i j"-e oso3 d.l o:*e
;, J-K *,y 7s: tty'e iV -*l dr,ljla5 A-* g*661gl.-";i, ;rn )l s cll.t-ii c.t..:S,r-" rt-7,-l .rlL;" +5 c..i^i- 1^15 r13".
: ut);c JY.r-ls:ri u. -ts\ t $;# 6$*; C: ,p:.r," jlcc.^..i19
"tr{ .f[- Jt*. +1 ,,-"1c *1- ,-a ;r J-,t-i-o -e)Url a;J+ 6 J'-l
J::.--^ t1>:l-r 6*c.riri 6#r*.-- c.*Jt- !-i qq 6 x_ye
WWW.AEL.AF
Jr",l-, I Y\A
c5 c-*1 ,-,-l c--J13 otjol-:a:rtt '1 c-!t -i .J5,t1.1 1; La.li.;"r J el..i
It-Lj Jlri--ljl.r: L+J 45 4 6k 6fS rgili b:l: o;J-- ,i):\,s,;lf.L-Lil .,* tr t++ca;: -[lj,r,. *<! .r^ill o-vi >371o ol3ic-*"L"j
;5 P,S jl;LJJr.ri! c^.it: :Jrt .lJt"xjJ al5 f ot5l: . 6.:l.t-Ji a-*t-- 6-& dl--a_).Jl; g+j; .(-".r1t Ll c,^-;6to;y*5
"j-^F,r;_J ft-+jtf*Jq--i* fU t _Sl *.,,,--eJ,-,ui t+"l..tj_d.fqgLc.:l +5._5rlr-il 6y )l lJt-fui 013;c-L.i ft!; .4 J"('iJ J,L_rs;.>-q--.:,j Cl: c-rt -:13"" -ti;b lJ Jl;.SbfH,.ll-uJ^;lr 4lic r"t(-;l.<." 45 r-lor,=; r^t- i;tt*T.rF.f ,1..,*J trt(:i; gglLryl; ,K!
rlri-a:-ela,l,, j f.rs, c ?13> *"aj." "*a;
)1cf a!b;.ru..-i-jl: o.Ju*-JJJ .J{ e L
r-xJ Jt- -t>'+]& rl sit"=,.i, r, & oS.rtfu) .*l d- g q ;*1,
s :l)i y l; LnigjLr o.5,raK.i--r jl & .bt-J t ot(.r,r ;1 c.Jt .r,'(-i-:U
dl.u.&-til;l-ti.i-a d)i .rtt )l J *)e s5 d$ljJ* c,*-l,o a1:- c--;1
.c--;;Lj "[,G
o1.: OJ- ^LL c.-;,5Lac^L
.rl,r-Ji t:i)J# tl,.li,5lr. 6 ,_*-i cl-L,e,:lild.,irL;l:13 a,,[-i:*l.t-.t-- 6 ,Sk Ul.c.*; U dt"j \ _e t- r,"-t+ 6* )_*Ll
;-:> -r-i;l.:.# U Jlf,;*iljl6_,L*t jio.t-lJ, 6 c*l,rJY.r:-l
6>l;i a-f *t Cly-,, 6 t--. ,-r uK -,*,tl.xS qi 1r dLas,.r)li
e-h )l frf lF &-),t- J !-Ur l *j c:;l.r-i )f:Lu +."1.r -rr cjFa- l; .:lr-ilrfu,5;LU.at+l )* u.aS ;b* ,bl_* t"; J .)LJ.j
;;-- cll;r:.r+ ;-Jg,[-(i c-L,o:,r," Jy- u*-fi J of)il.tl:te jr.b
L,"l; A) )lq-^ 4-"t c"--;51&X- J J,.l-@ ft S t; 6$^aa{-*4-71.: .}_rI! JJ"l jl dlJi.,+ e:p crrl rr .l+U-.* J* Jj:5 ,-}.,U
.rr5 o;Li:-l ol3Jl ,.*" J) f)r" ;Kil c-.-l-r.a
f.; t:t;* st-tj t *"l,+ c-.Fl 6 c-l lr*;) JJl..l &1trt"r-t
"i:-," -)l*."Ur Lar-.1 )l &Va ! "<+1_r";r y -u-.!L a:-b ,Ji:-*"
.fff .u/ .(\ 1f \ ) de .rrl.^"+1 C;t^I,-,(G. J. Growtherl t : -5 ..5 .e.\
WWW.AEL.AF
Y\1 tr&i:L,'lL-q
c*?til .(a cglf L4:J 6rSa 6>l;iq-gle-,,t-- y' :: .I;{,r," ly o,rio:LT
:11: l1 c+U J{l F -* 45 c^4 G ,*+ ;.,1Ll.c.*1r:*^-oljlF l5Jjl
j{l--tJ- s.t-.J t,.c-*l b9i.*- t-^.ti.gly ,gf.i 6:l1i 61; 6rlr.ilaS
1; rlr-it:tj:-cl9 -& :*;"-';,5t-c.:l-r:ly.f ,_*:J y' 5l-, orj&,e) -o,.&- * S *c...,.i d * *-&.6,'/-l .J:S,r^j a=7yi c-r-iL +t-it:\ J (, - J J -J " \'--r v-
c-.r, .ll*i- r"o, ,, )l ;l J:S,r,J .,iyGJ ..f. Js,-r.' c-:i.i ,,.AJ .<," Jl
,g>lyi ;;tl cl.rr,*! c.-^^1f5.c-*lrSu J-6 Cft'io.u.^.:ot-:; 15
)l -tl_r.o!r"" &- olil ;t.; ,51; .[l3i.r^; f -* S #, ..*l yW ,e#e."! a5 c*l.rLl3.o y
"[,)r &f "qt! gL., t r:5 t-bel \ Jju* fJ3
.<^S.gr<;.9.r1;ia- Llie *i.u-re U;A 5tt,iOrl: orl> jj-,ltr,-l c.r5 ,!* ,:- 6Lo.rr5;6 t 6F.:r* S 7- j:l o13;-a + U .t5
c*l ,',.1 ofl, r: r rL "li t U-.r_5 _* e* J^ t -f,i!, rlrJl a.*a 6 c-j9. --.,\.
d.,,t j tj .J,itj<, "Xh
y &a c, 1; L5lorj, t" c^le J^ -t,l3,:1 :lr.il :.-a 5>:_f l: dt- r-"U, o5 r,'1 -u.olr; 6Jr-ol.:.^^ ,l_#:_f -r arJti.
.JiLi<, JY.u-l s fi 6_y. t1-r .!-b -t-Lir, orl> llr.i ri-yot--- o.ru.arr!"-*^l -iL; *W sr:jl.:;.-1: : &-g-"t rlyl"f,t,;
u.;.> >-e-7j; a5 c-*l,reL"-71 Jali 4 t'; ,J"l* s fi-s.c*lr5Jil; o 1 6la.t-"L J 6[;j +5 c*l ;":a o I c-*.oL .c*l ;l-9;-l,.4t-a.r9t c;
l--x;,--le-.i Ju.ilJr.r- qLac pl.r5 ^S c;< dli.r.i s t-5 e*-fodli.,*J
dli,.r*J l: S-*j*K y -t-it c+.a)\.- t* y-$li iiaU [- "rr5.(5L- u,Ji;*lJyrr .trS )3J-->-r ll- j^-e yr 9 cy-t-,o j-rs -L,"U" q; a13 uoo\ U-.i- ,.JS pp t.i.:",, t";^; -r--x-l tr..rar,.lL-lLl
c^ir^:?, 4:.ll1<i )* q +q.JUl;a! oS or&;l )il€tt*j, q bojly
.t+, +. +5;;),Gc ,J;Su, ,3:; r lr OL-il c+)ti, .J:5 Jj:S l-s )ffuy e,-oL6iJr:5 L.rr.t:S Jr:S ctat(i yr-b -1 t;; +*a -rily.r
.--L,:;J,r-3i )-f ::S)L--,+) 3 o,Li.lic.srq ol: r, i eUu
WWW.AEL.AF
,jrroltn YY'
;J >J+oi l-u,l;: o-5 Jt-- 1: a5 c*l yl ;: ..r*.7 fjS ,g:)lr;ll .g.rur-ly l f) l JS 6, ?ra, l; .lT .cata;,2 : Ll cc -* l c;jxie o: l: orJ>
cgil3;.: ..ul l5;: G--t> q .tily..-r- rc-l 11-:il dl , c+)\-l.e $_, 60lj! J .,Sl_,ilcStaa-Fr lE -,, )Fy ,53r1;U ali5 o;'3 olie,a-" ,+l.r-le-.1L:) 6 c*lrra-il.rtii,t,gr-r;o-V1L r+jtaL(irr JF q
t--5ys-t L+r 45 Jt- r, -r-iL dtr *t- t 4L. eV.:lil 6 :_#ecSLaf_,1 6:s l.rt-ti t.l [- +f 6 c*l,_rft"-7l6Lao-!-J,, *. i\lJtSv);.-ljl.-'.Js-" &"5 c.+)ii, J-t<J j r-tr10.tJli-1.1a &pltJl$4> 4l;o,.|...*;;
"rrL"-.71 .r--ly .r-l ,[6 -,, Uli cSL, q C.lf tt
jU.J*"1 .j,--, 5.:;1.:;l,'i 6fi :sfL- 'n.rro "rrr "[,LL
+ta: 9'14, j.c*l,rcL.:71 .gLa.t--li gt+ +l-ta t
WWW.AEL.AF
r--tt Jl; 6 e* f qt" Jt-J t*e 613j e^at
.rli..-i r a>,Li\.53;,1,
oU J.r J
c4yie 4-1, .,,)G;l c-Sr 4 tr.J f
,Jtt"ltl YYY
y t*J :-".r<i J ;-rr.; o;l;;-loi*r^.,',.,1,Yrts ,.-/ui.Jiio:i
..Ula:*ilr uii a:-37,J+ii d.dl ;r ta;lJio;l*,l ar ,t J;r d*)_f
tf d:t-,, orlU! .6r.ri"t;tl; olJi.r3;: _t> 6_ft E u,lc-.ir:.,.
€* Ll.c.*lort.r ot-t j Li_F a".r.,L f;q-r,SL^o.t--,r.lly;-c c.--;c- a-5 c.*lJt* .t-T!. j t e ;l ,+,jLJiJ, 6_fu b ;l:_i,-3 a5;lLtrc. ..,1 $Jntp,g>j-\-> Li cc*la:rU,*J3 o-riL *!! *U,t-<-.c.*1,r>l; rt5 \ 1\ Y Jt* jl# U oLJi;, "r,-Li" al,.:*..a1 ,-;eS:tt {U 6.u-r-"i,r" -,1--- * .:L 4
"x _tr6$-tr.! -b,A; *-tic;rlL i c*ll..- ))y 6 69x, *.Jilory {Lir;L )t ,;7;*,rat(.r,-r }t-*J
,-ti tidT jt prr- c-,-fl t6JrS fr -r-;L,a y u.-itr rlj ,r<", d+l..u:--il:
l; ;5l1.+l .(1 oab- a5 6t-^ot(-r,.: irl .r.i, e-.cL 6;.7 +7 cLl
gL*;.i-L*- ,k :* a,3l"o,r;UTc--Fli:.-L*.- -r:lf c.rt+;: Jjryrdt-i jotlr; *)-) cc--*s-,, Qs rr-lJ fJ-:s:^1r l_,.jLJi,)ulJe-
".5 )*Ji.-)c :*x*..:-3 ,a-,[^oTc+;, q 6::l ,-JU]..Uf- f!!r di7.:i a-lc.g;!.:qL f j:Slr crJ;lr;31f)y jlcr-r[*t6:- )l't$, 6 ry,r:,-L.= -r.JL; ol.ri q l_, {$p 611a;i ru^{oJ. )-r'*irL > j--j 4j Lt*" .J*ic- Cl31 La.t-[6J* t t]41-* j- oK 3:;l.:t.ui a-;:.l.:oi;.t! ,gjs*lr,- l4t .(1 >y u-,5o1+{ c,g;lrqt r*"
.t y. -) ? Lart I rl.t -;orr5 c.,-l.t-o l1 ..tLJi;r dU :t;:l *,K.-|*; -,r 6 6tor,.,5:JJ, o-., 4.(l dl) ,*.:41-;) a.Jo; f!t*- d;rlp.: ar +i c,$ycisi 1> slajn elf -ft3.lio.:3-, #f,-r"tlti;r JlrJ -tl7>-l:j-j
f - -;r"a U.ir 6 "rJ c..:l.i.J.*, jl.J::: 6,r"t<;.a l.:uf ;l.i c.ilt*r 5r,! -S* -: F*\S*.gt^,*!t1rr,u*a ftq+ y 6s>61t.-,t;l
l. Thomas Carlyle 2. Houston Stewart Chamberlin 3. Auguste Comte4. Georges Sorel 5. R. D. Butler
WWW.AEL.AF
IIf rg-*jtl ",-4Vr6{aa:-1
,g;lra,-Lr-. ,;-) 6;La3r7.rl--i1 :.-gl;: 'Ji-\-.i -!lr; Lalr(c-*l-t tS-y
;, o3-ir^ c15+Jait .,,9 JtK-rl-2 g-JL-r ,r!"\F.*J \^? 9 r:*11
c-rl..rjl y> u r.J-Xut ?-p Jl; r"l .*-,:Ui
,-5-ri.bLirt#Ur*U -r g- JL-r;; oLJi.1r itJr:,ljL-a jt
)\- -b f!t-- :l-r-11 yrj..5 )-t d c*l ,r^-6, Li
,-.,11 .t-y :ltt
f^:JL-- 6LaoJily*-rJ, ,Jt-- ;--o ,, -tJLY s r' ,,-tiJ,l:"o:;; .p,bi ;;-..-*1t" J.fu \ GP f,!t*- nS Jt- :> -il-t1.e -,t* q ia-, L-as,t U.Ji.r:*JU ,*V,1-*,>-Fd c.-lla l; ol^Ji 6J115 a'k-
rJ3;r jlr,.r'1 1 \ q \ Y JL jl.r+:<j J* ,6 ylLl..ry o.r.i orJl; a*'iL-
4-j 4-5 -r-jr-S t:4 d)Li,JL.l, c"r:^**J;L g-;!-f a;t :^L
trtfd;ri ail_r s jtrt$* bl; )ts.<! 0t"1J,",513 3 rrll5aLit-."
f*JL-- oS r;t Jt f ta;;ljl.-u:rS dy.dc; .:,L g-JL-r 6v il.
,J;r^-.: j,-q tS>J: u.9 -r-.1,;l;;3'-- I elslfc-*o-al )l {\lJ,}
-,t *.r(r" r-^.rUi &*fu -hV *k, 6 \ q \ Y <+ d:r .r*1 6J:r^
-.r- ,-ff*Jt-- c-, aS c-*l ,-?i c3.J" ..,)Vir.-t'i-j.lL;'r "|"6
.,*-r;6t-oc*!t*,3-, gLo.(o5 rSlatu-L J) d)Li -i-- U 6 e-t* Y ti
,'13, r-it) :psy,,ol+:a yIo*-,.j "ij,*I]]}:rfj"i
"Vk q \ q\O JL;.: rr.rUt ,4-l y-,t+i, cr;Fsfil6 c*lor.orFrr s j , J)t, -i<".--lt*_l-.(-r.llyo \l-t )ftS otFf .-1.."tl:J t)
d:+ 45 rll: p)LclJL*;lL c.*ili.," rn 1 \ q'q JL jly :y o-:;5
...:*lorr5 .-op 65$ J;t5 -r,-l;-" F c^<+ 1r 1; .:-9> Jut :t 151oroc
e : n)L-r .r--li" ,-);3 r:-(.7;r ;r<*" .r- E ,e-&., ri ,'a "r:jt-'
l. Fichte 2. Rodbertus 3. Lassalle
i--li ,c,\; )-, J!-r :f o\r"^t il .r(1 ,J* c*rSi.tlf f JL ;: .g:v.r- U -Hi J 'f:^r<" ,51 oL-Ji.r-t;rr, JVy- 6.r..::L .r.tt-.:y*i llr:u, l*l;t-t +f-. S tL--* u:
tl*l ,5rS gV.gly .g;L.:Ll5. Wemer Smobart, Hiindler und Heroes, 1915.
WWW.AEL.AF
J:r, ol; l YYf
-,)LijljlJ+ u JLJirSr jt 3*r-,.r-S u"rtj..,rtJT.,r 611:*-Gr-U r.:3-,.r:; a;;*"i.r:--*SJt +Uo U ojl$lylU 6;yJ5 6p Jr 4.-JJ,slj:,-o * 3lccrLj jl *,1 .(,-;: .:y osV_t-.gl^j)t tu-L _,: .9)U J-1[*-.i a- alt "y- Af j;.a!l :;3* JIJ<,a.iJJ o.r:r-Loj i#a:*ty,r^tK:-;t, d;.(- rr oJl9j JK-rl_, .l_Lic ;,:.-il.: #, q a5 c.i_rc./
+. 3l ggL-a1t5;'U .<j- d,/-Fi.Jt+t, tl .r* .f _, ..t--i,! n:-il.: r3,-.glyc*"{t ,6:rS-j1 }tJ q a5 dUT eJt- : "[-lr -,, Cy.(_.tlf,rJ; c:3*, 4if 4"<,l5 Lr:r6L J,-ti" jl c.*!-. o)f , Ll c.-[L jUa.6--ri : .-aSKtr.rl,r;a-"U; jlcs_,[*:-1tiT;.: 6 ,s_t* * , j, ,_rf;
asu a.-.:,t J4b JS,-l W_r t^,r*J<l.rtj)l-l,rl,,lrLj ol_* y6il l.l: )-t' ,G-,5-, c*l;i*" L>-19 o.r3r t-i
Cij a, c*l;fu. Orl
a.pi .i- jl )t - ti 6 c*lcj-rt,-i 4-;ljipa*t sl P -tt_u"r;l_,-t( ,-x"jL*t: +5 c.:J3: a1 c*l La;Ui.t54r .nc*l o..lu.i o:;3i,.lL : I e:V.rlr-il L "..y c-l_9r e5 c*..1;-l cot-,J, u--l) ,-t-r.,pl:y Jt-Y ca-:i*jotlji,1.li;r.a L- 6c-{ ;JSl 1l ,glae _2 -x, [. c.:3,..:,r^, ,?l_b y ,J_,U<q!c.*lVolksgemeinschaft "(- c-J9.:.J-i!,j*i )lJrl iU, jl .i-ef ;;>L>3--
'-a'-Lbj q J,"ti .t.ii y or3,
"|sLi >f 6ll. tqj,,.i.- 6a rliltlilr +5
.gt-aot(-urn.c-rlo:y cg-,ta; 3l: 6 r"qi d**^.rlil,g[-at.c:l.J:5 J.,-,* y ;* -4.s>l-*. t 6-e)l r6J;i .1*,_-n \ VAl JL- o-r L_n-rSG eV6\ly ;rr*: )l * Cb 6a 5 -r::..^n,51t-a; r,-t-;e od,-,
.J:s,ri JL;: l;.rfril
WWW.AEL.AF
YYA tr rju ;*)V;-,JL^n-*r
J t;:.<{ jl t-6;tJi Att 6LnJi.r."l gLi c \ q \ f Jt- jl J+ u
&Liy.G;cl"o,r*J-(lg-,t+, qUr g3l.r" c-iri?i ! o.e+ly" 1r r+il.jLftp4j t.a,,"=l<l.r_,^:.f .r,..t+ g.r+ :* yt^,r*J.(jl ,i):-s, U^,r--t-*t
otJ, a-rs 'r;t-irt;;*Jrr;.r 3 orr5:t*i 1L7: FS t* t lt )-r-
fr-, 4 t-^.)i 45 .r:Kj ifli U J5 .<"S ts;Ui a" c*;l;u, 3aoi*s pJ t-6&Jt , fL.j L^Jip-,1: o5;L (.ri*A :t4bl.,alL;t3c.*jlr.r- .:.,1F,f .xt-Fr-l c-:*i .,rtJii,5b.-i.r-a 1l c.grL il dL^cJt.es13t cJ;;54 rl.r-Ji o,L;' r-l 4 b 3* +5 #, yla, La;tJi a5
3+ at; & .Ser*;l ,)i a, 3l Ll-.r.j1lr tl; -&-r 6t"c^L .rl.i-.c*l.gJt-ri .gL-^.1.(.r--.: .J.,-lj L-s, J
",,Lil * ,F.(-..lljo q
'4s srJ.S oW s*L .:[- cr;b .:3>3 d)rp .]q-;l;li .r[>3.4 tt -Lj -,r J5,-rLii )13.:!-;-,-lo1;;.: l; r-1> a5 c*l i.xlr-pt-a*-"tK:t ri J 3* J r;L)jl 4jUUr$, .t3-r,-, o-uLJ c.:l--i I ;*-s 6:p L5:1ji a. c*,*. 6;t4; ot5.r,-: L tjJti, a;l-nJi.-ql ti OJ:*-,r:-"
..r*JKt.urut-";UT;t e:Q, CU e ot-j jl,.rta.a-r s> o-tVy -S f -Sl,L-^oK.u-: cll*,t +-., .,juits1.l,u-..i.jl: .51cry-,-/ *ltl J- il .r+ e;-;y JJ, f.^ L. J ty. a:iL- c*r ;-* s tu*V r^U ! J+J^
.qGc.".*;;;r co;L..y+, ojlrJl a,.tue* dloyl;3*ij 1,.:-9 ,ur rj)-
d-i*;r )Vi-r u,$- l rJ;Lr,-rlyo ! -rlVE .>r, p),*-V #:Uc.*!.gJa: J @)dli,ji j c-*l,t-,t" dl'["-L-$l J.')5 u& Lty,Lii.r-t -,11.c.*.:b yl#!-r'-lt;b a}t c--,tL d:3,: r-;Ll a:
.rly- 4 ! o.5 yl VL:5 ;-fg<, y oli.t ,.-?,,-- blyt -2; 31 LlL;kjl! *.fL- rft 6-;U yr yrL-J 6L^Jt- : \ t \ f 3 \ VAtrr.,o+y .JrE
j d--.-, >yju ot13 t* -.45.<--J,r,[5 irrS olt--ll cJ.*; .-,t-7
l. morass ofcomfort 2. Johan Plenge
WWW.AEL.AF
,$tr"ltn YYP
6Lao-tr-1n &. )-ff-f e)G d)J t ./t5.r,1.c.*1 *-S :lS e)JJiJ,_t .r:,i t \ t \ Y JL -t, sgLaoJ,lrr 3 .grl;i Ji.l-l .;-- rr \ VAq JL elJ
.:11.:-, ,r"ot"jL y L _y-f
A-b )l1, fJ[-r" 45 dLac*JL-r pL; r-iL*a '63 Ji ;dl'jt- r,.i-llo:r-S 5;; a*t- cy<:/ Jo t, ,r^1, dLaJl-ul pt-- .r,,;[5
di t H c;*^;: a, 6 cf,..rt*a )J);"lLo^t a, f!l*- -l f s ry_top J-_lJla*:lj t: ar!d:; .,*!l.-r "r+ a.iJ dt jL..:;1.: .r5i;
j nL-a-* 611:l-:'-a !,**;rU s eF:J.J-i)6-;L*^i +. f^rjyjc*iq- g-Jt ..r 6)+i 6-!l ;-l o- 6:;1;i u-"ljil ar--lil 4it-lJJLric.llJi;r o?S y!l:*l oI-: [---l o;L3r ,Jt-jt- 'rxl trK> rl9sl trl ..iilo:rS
ol_f g l; ;l .c*l or..X .],ia ot(,l -r-- li 3 o"t^i ,S g ja-' e;* t 45
&"t ,* *.5 r,t-(-rril: o.i---hr.-,,5 f:r5 oraLl, 'Jr.O.f Vt.S-l,jlf1 blj:o a- lJ JIJ--: e--..e[;;1:;lf ,;'U c-.-;1, 6-! )-*Jl,;,-.i <j- dlrr,.r5 rl-uJi;it f*JL- _r {*qJ.sgt-ac^."aj*:,
JLr.-t^r,r,,Jt.ij tJ r[:. "lt-rT,
) afr )try ,_e,t6 c,tLJT3 JUJ<I4i -FW 1_;U t> .-J-).r:<"-i.5 31;. o12" (f -y tr.,jt€ 6:L,r*il..,,)GilJ to.i,
C)L^rl c^-i$rL"qf^ 6.' r+alltJ q 3 c.r3-l.rr;1s.,-x
c-* I,r:-(5 .,.:- I I l.: qL--. "a;b ut al t; 5r I ji -.r)\ij I J n\l f irvla:rt"a-*_9;6rt-c-:il o!-..u1; o5.S{-te dln:; 6_ssy, c..6-71: 6
.jl-jL -e g;t.-f .r*-.-Ula-arj,.J rtj
gL^U--r-, f G Cyr- ;J-; Ju,tc-,.rLJ l cLa+:"--,J"1 o s j> 1 : 6 t--rt l ;'l l
C) U";r.;-:ri H ,j* ")r )t i )ilrt';[.-.l, +- #!r)l 4*'S.ft -^ -"1
,l; ;.: L clySl-.r-2 .grLr:;l pLE ;,;c.el.l.JL"jL.# rJl.jr* .-L U ()r!, clL-L c*l-K"" i6<K>.us;r-tPV JL-;-: -.:f J-:^lF F+J/ lJ .,jlJl .rt,- -!l.ral cL .gl.aa-:"-sl
o'\oi ru$,u) )l3-t;.r---rr.-r,-1 .i aS rl; ,sJ, dl*j-ryr ..tte,r elUl. H. G. Wells 2. Reformation
WWW.AEL.AF
Y YV tr e- rU ,L- * g;Lo+:.,\..-9
1: a-5 c.*1 Jt-- r, ;--l 3 .J.:S,r- a:,.3j c-tit*; -Lal3> .a4 e)S:+,.rrc:*l jt": -) JV;; Elejl;,- ,Jt-6; FJU Jj*l ;t*! oU-Kt
:-l ,-):l c,s.^; y4b La:-, *..lLJT;r \ q \ f JL;: 6 J,:= rLr:il
Jfu -, U;'-,.;r1.6i19;: ,bi as:3 c.:J!-3*, a*"t- 4 a:t-&..j
*-JL-r o-L-lc-.ii {-iL <q- o|s;b.g*1"frJ[- -r aJ) &-Jt- .-q1.L c-L jl
1G.r (J)dljl3 c*l".Li dLJldrLail oL^-;r
a.*"ia oJ-h c,rjLJidt jt* o-t-l t.:ty'i ,tL-r;l a- c..rL-1 .g1; t1 \ 1\ fAi +-y' ,FS t* q-.1L rf 6ylct3.r, J-f!t*-;:
\rrjLil
+.:!L 'liJlyY! ar-,, .i_ a, c..i..a -r cJ_l: _rrtr.f!- .rt- JS,fJli
lU f .- .,1 c-ll) dU j.JtS c-Jt i 'd"* e5,5:L^ :il c-JF-qg:L.zil o\- 6-/ J G_p JK.i,.JKils" ,"-V 4 j.a-,Jt^.:=Ji-,-r-yY!,rtc.*l
""aiU J s7;N rr- e+, )_*Jl.:U:.ela, 6 c.tlJi.l-.r-a
.rc-loJ-.i 4:;t-i V) "; LSilJ Jt--a,lr 6 c*lcJ3: ot-- "$iJi.qt e .grlli JT.ql ;rd $l:* .:y ller-.! jr- e+. )-*Jt.l-rrl ;r
.i^XilJ-S jl :i Lt-l-b3lr t-"1 J."6 ca{ A} )l(jr", .i=.r^ cclLjLL;.-*_r cil jl.Jt di jlr3j.rl;.JtrJ.St^"1$lJL:it"l .S -,lSt_,, J-K )* ysJr; a-;1"--;r l:*l=., _, g!l.-f ;-,.:t-Jl \ q \A Jl*.r*Jt-"r d-l-*"" J) .K-e- JUU a-r olL .rJ..:y 4-SF SS;31 ;-,oi
i,La.:,rr )l; ?lL; tt_f l_s:;e dLl_: a t_$ Al.,tr,5fig.r,rc,.r-..iL .:;-t! c.*!-. +! g--J!r a5 cg.-ij.-;rlL; o-r,-;li,rig;,. ,
-t--ti f;1.- ,*.5?. -L^lJ, jUjL* .(1
'*Jt*r 6.r,l.glr, gr5 .5t: l:
..r5 ryLj \oi o:5i5)iS t* y+!;Jr^:.r--lL a:.-ilr;t-=l;r l; .:.1,r!
L,"c-L .(+oU; :) f*J[-r LsilU bt,,];6+ J 4j€ J
,-pslysl),/../ oIlJrlJ.i .r:ti t ai3- .c-L 61.15:6 c*l ;rllLjJ
rgc*toc^L dt jL;r qgl+;,^j
c-LJ:3, ,L.^ -r,--t+ JF") 4.-i g.:r c.-t+ ;: 6 l; .4Lao.U lk yl _l
1. Volksgemeinschaft 2. Die Glocke
WWW.AEL.AF
,J'" J-, n YYA
.;-- Ljcc*IoUjt* d,f*Jt-r- ot(.u-: jI c,*-lrn:S.f ,j.l.J+,9c^*; ";\lf "S
)14:il G-" r C-pG.,!-r,:_fl d elt rtr;ty'*"tL,rt 6$ *"-c: "f-t5
o;,Li .:i a, .5>L,a:il ot r r: +5 ,;.-a "tit" t"T
L+i lJ JJ-,1 ;r rJ-r.--i f3- ;- ) p L. xlirl tl!-t, f-Jt -;r- ffs.tr.t:S t-Eclc$1o-t-.1 J..,i ;-JU .ttJ q 6.-*b-lr* el: g.ti ,f\l-t
3 r.rtJu..-.Xjlr 'pV &A er*;.: cJ5,r..)! lJt*TdJ" 6 dl,^,)t Ji
6 a:,gt o+:.- 16 e f y.r,orot ;l* 3 c,-lla ,21.:l3a 6 ;UT.lL.rn,.t_t:4-S s"U-; t-,ti )l4.5 r*K c:134 u-- {L: y c.*i,b 6l:u .-tirl;) yl dL-6r.ti -,t<}l jl rJi 45, \.rJlr:-3!
d+t-: .;LJi rr4:" dl+". "i,
6 tF,_* o:K ..>-l:lilyljL:n,.c.*l oJ*1 u^,oV or4-:' q.t!..,11
oJ:SU cS c.*ldtytt*aroL;L )re;).lUi,r +5 c.:lr;taDl trt-(,.i,Trt
6ly,l:oUi J1; )lfl )l 6- tlfC t+;1 ;.: .r.:*l o.ry ,rUjL $U
Jt- r, .r,lo.:r,, .,i ,Jt/jL c=.,ol a, cjUirljj i,-U t"cL :pjL ,.iU [..,i
a1 d+, t-a.:,r,1, Llc-r.j;b :lSlf "S gj-, 4 c=; jr.a l^cj" -r{L 6.tr-la;iL c,*>tJ,:Lt - gjt
;t50;Li;3iLi-: ,\9Lil; fl9 .r111:l;.t Lo;-l *.i --l;.gLa+.!.[leGi )J'-- d)U-:rlrt-a:il *\* )l ;l4.5 LrrJ-i.c-ib !-r:,.rrUi.l*i; .-'LK 3;tr t, ,Jt-- 7 +, Ll,-ij^(, c-r t..rijtr;1 Jfu c.:-ib
F *jl .r+, yl.c*l -tl>:fJ6l4L-y" ,-J-,U.Kt- jl .-ju lbi J
jl q ,-|-j r &? rrl;-e: "}*i
L5:Uail o\E (&t^4ii ,,.) )1,-5-tyl-,1.l.1 L i-i tlJlJt<*a.-/-J..<,-)-/ )l u;13.r:*t .:r5 ---,,; l;ctT
.r-:a"r, J.fu, lr'34; ilL6.i e-lrl'^-"UJ Jt4lrt3;- Jlc*llr;45dt-i
'*L\S fU nr,(, &t- c.*"J-,L 4,51^"yy"i,;,;-,..,"
;r o-!J..i-L" 6L^VE rc t: l; Jt<JL"*f U-;.J'..3 <<Mitteleuropa, -r[5t..il, c--al"i : ,6tt3l .gtaa-i,--ul+, ,rlj cc--rl: .tLJi;: J;.-.llrj,
l. Wilhelm Ostwald 2. Walter Rathenau 3. Gtiring
: n1\-:-.r: tr,* f;; oS lliiearich Naumann) oLy .;_rt_p.gGol-(.1: ;l .91a+)\; .f-l(R. D. Butler) _I! .S, .rl il .,-L f4!-- ,5Ga;.-; uLS _2: ,tl3lrr" l; ,*l g-!lr;,yl
. (Y . r-1 .rr.." , I lf \ JL- ) c-rti
WWW.AEL.AF
Y Y1 ! f*jU ,-J!-r ,JLnu*-r
"! a.t+; ,-,iJ:; 6L^q 1: L-o+,J.--.rjl U-l i: 3 au3,: rl5 Ul
olf _r, Jt *r ?_f fr CV P J Jt^r;-J!-3"";ll-:-L*,tlj:,-o o- 3* :tr3,-- 6L-o-rt5 -,,
"}.i c,-# .h .J.: )lSlJ r!11 ctl;-9r
J o5; rL" r-Jt.. y,'4bij1,-k.lU*J(jt,51l:a1t r*, '+;b ;lir-lCpi t)Ji *)<J f * i 6:t;i ;)!-r Ji+l U. )-try osti..-.,)Ujl Jt- a*l,lly- ! r3'-- 9t5 d"fe-f J t-t'y;: Ll ..ry o:1r
J-S t+ ! c);a e* -"b r;'U c--; 6 il ueV.gtaa-!-rjl*.rLe+
c5-r!*l jl J (Jt? J:r t.i-.-fLl; l-t >fa;talY-r:-l "rd.'r*,
C-* )l.r^1Le c*l=' ,l;;l a:J+ o-Sir--ljl;uJU.;jr cbtJjl e5 r, .:t+ Ui t, t0r*,t;J jS j .;,:-a f :- ,S-t- t $-,"',l.3, ,.5-rL*.,'t
-# cr-r. L#q'Atu'i Jldr,Yq P FU cil.g*---S1.L ot-("1.:
.diL,a-s $d,.l.ijJui6.ry r,l \AVq JL -,: .5-,L.-* f"*"aj;.+.:J))6 -i; or4 11; f3: ,.3jil,r11>.:-,k \tre-S 6W j.lJ,r,y;jl
J iYq 6rLe-il ltliJ ,.<l a.r--t^f aJr-" a, ttcJ3; JL U -bUJl ;r 3l ot-(,L7
.lLJi<.tla;.lrS:)\ijlr.r,6 g*U-.f;.: r:(J ;1 .5;: U.:y ria:!r:.,-,
1L:-- a-r-i-L.;.,.11 :-*JK; 1 .;*,- .)i .jJtj- C -t S s l. J .5;),e; l a[:- ;-r:,-L*;
-E*r* ,_t35.i- -,1=L 6 .tar,r" ,Jtji c^4ia- yl .nc*l,r,yJl J*a
;-l.,tJl3i*- c.n-iL L5y9il.:(,-> 3 u;:L)*\"lfA:*zJ Jl,*l 5;ljl.r,-t l; ;r.5 ,si ,6;--*: aui .ttJ ;t 6 .ta: -,t; ib c-; lr
'*t,
t-"*--.t(t e;\lf ,S.9L-aoK.l-.r jls<-a or-i, i r-*l-Fy>,f*Jt;-r-i,L a:.-:lr k cJ3: 6 e:_# di ,* t 6,rat("r,-r ,.ula:oJ .rL;JL.r!:lil 6>l)i ,. a-5,rar3.l-." f J ,-*,t ?p JlrJ ty; 4
tr:3)uo ,F ,Sf gV y g-rytK-r ;.r-11 ry'.r".(\ql^ .jd).fl ..sl ..rr tt:Ku:n,t-i ,;:,r€ (jk+ -)\L\ JL a-,(Paul Lensch) ,J
"f, .l
..r-:.:Ui;Jl;r) )r 4 L-;3:- ab ;: tl rl u*13t4;2. Cartelization
WWW.AEL.AF
,frt Jt o Yl"
cc*l 6rLr$l .rt = ;t ,F J,l,FJtj e*f t 6J-lL-i 45,oLJi;r
fS lfj tc*lo.t--! .IU-L".J ro)L- o:LJld3s g*=l!*r.gly,r.:.(-^5LLtb;,s-tu.ljl 3 .Jllor.i c. --J Q..ti;.: ;.,, _iI flt -- .gLa-ty';.;: 6la*il.t^"j s*, -,* t J,"ti dui 6 c*l al 4L-r 1Ua ,a .rl^et
-t> tt's;Ju c-sj,L ! .i.ilJi li ".rr5 c-J;ilr=" tf )l,tL-.:,>
"|,U."&,- rS c-*t,_Ur ;,-*a 4i.J:5 J*-, iL{-'lS arrL-,ri),UjlJL;ol;y.: d;l:ql.f \ib J-J3-L. glu*sJ ,iX- q .,oUT o.J.a
\r;,.I*:,n
.:;1: c-.at,i ,J;'4+ eLp; :t e$*6ly,g_2ba,_L r )l G*,-t* y 6.a ;t.Ij .5, a,Lr-.r.orot jL JJI a5 r;tr,r, tkDl .riorl; a-,I:l a:*lj->j> -,* y i &z * :t 3:y oJ-.x U; {*lJrUJ &l; tfs )V a, a, !c.^iL- -r.alr; +"1.:l & ,* ".
C^zjl ,- c-r--i
olj:-c a-. fJ!-;- 6 -hv..*l q oj e c.jL;L 4Li a-S * 1 .liUJ:> o)_lt'l AS GW.c*lo.t-.i a;: €i,rcL.-71 '4r*i ),J,j-*l6-ruii..t[*i,: .(--,:" -DtJ q ,*_yr-t ?_p fJt-- Jf.Kj:j ,J.",
)# Jl-"-;, g-*Jt .,r.rilo:y-.,,ti.tL;r r,X, i ta.r.r.".Jt- r.a a,c[-
.ryr-t f*ly-,.,-- -6, U lyj cc.*l iuu\:t* -*,Stss-U 6i13;:3 l:*l.t*5 J:ur oT
.ri:^*^ L^Jl; o3r J:alye- .jjti, &l-S a.dl! iJ:^ S .*:f V;
.gLar;l-r.;l:--.ly "i+t*.-rLlr.L(L3;[r :* o:e5 olr-il )l "J; dlJSjJ l;.tUi".:r(l-.r-; lbqLr- .*t fH cJ5,ro J!.r:-lL^,r*J<ljl cn6-r;3-*-^i o -;-r 3 nq5.: l;irr j l L-aJT cr--q- c--x Ui .-l-:.a).,--a
*_id;U JLfi o-. +'\lrK>; olK ;1 .t,,---,L,Utt. st alJ y;;4 -*-tL.):-f s d! f*o; fJt; p G:-! ,* y.s.r^t(;uof :l; f^)ji orr rLan J j-a;.ota.-i 6taca.: "r! ;:.tUi;l:a,L.*fJt; 45 J+,JL-a c-r-il..rj!:;r y or-.i.-r^,.Li L^-,t - ;l Ll .c-*lc*l;,1r1: pt+jl+q dr51^a"i.r+Upy 3> at;1, ,s)<;1s^,_ri
[. Entente 2. Constitutionalism 3. PiLrliamentarianism
WWW.AEL.AF
Yf \ tr r--:iu .r-{f.:- ,JG-*r
-c-j cJ-i'a, co-I--1, ..a)tj jo,* -L*,<La*fil '"1 "i il -LU6
Q_ul J J .J l) ' C>JJJ l> - U- J
f*JL-r l* cJt' yl ;.: ..:r5 .(J a*"t7 J )-# jl +q fJ+* "(-4., .4j-^!rc-6-i W)_5 :lS.4Jt; J.-l.iti" aLi :> ct^tfl;r,t a, 4t
S F :5 .:ur L, \ r,,-rct-7;11,r dfLA 1,-rLJi ;.: aS c*l ;,1 -bLl; I yl ;.>
.Kt- rl4:*jli e-;\t y oL*JK;l sf :5.:L;"t ! *_ti" r> a^,t>
.J:5 q{. >f tSl-t )t:S 'l"J".J) uaK}.:d J -u"oiJ$
&Li- gl;l: +5 ra)ur-! +,bl -K: ,-fis-t 4 ! l-, Lyy Jdl .,^l:J
:c*lrf"'U tu---U J J!*.r
6U;,Y;Ua* S1; ,?j-1.<-J L La.rlrS3-"r J[-r +5 t7oi;l,r
:..[= Uta.K:l: cLa.5-ll.: ,6--i, cctLJ-rL "[*
jl,-folt 16-r, )try c;tAs*"i
cA,^s. )* \ Il{**jli c-r.irrS:..-|*.aj l: ot' jc4;}ai .>V2U ,J-at
oi agly. J)s jt 1j4" LaJi 4J.-r-Le Ul .J:5 jl c^J3r L-r, rJ31: ;.r
tSs-t y. J-fu,.:l;".i'U cs-2-> \3t l.qL;- cJ3: 5 )-f; arlJ5.:;b,L;:s l#!-r,,SL^;LI l-n;i ;r,"LJ-*" .t -J Jt*l,S-S tS oW,.rLfi SI-t e' ,sV', +S e-r 6--c\APV JL cJj.: xjL fr c.J3>
* e\|_rr J!-r cl-l.c*.; c-ui a-iiS l-rl r:_r q -,! ",J-,1.91;d.r-.i .r!-i* r.-lJe.(--,,rS c^*:,i,:^t 'rl-f -rt J!-r Ji f."t
.rrc*l a*i,li( ,- c,-l,, lJ dJ*l ,* +t; 4. e\S -r. JL-r" yt,.
,,rs *. r* fJL-- oly i:,6ly -i;la*;l-2; )f \y t ,! -r 6{.t.rJrr3i g^l;;1,-.gl-a..ql r.5sl -r;,..rU )-f ,-rti rtrt-(*t.rtt-1.(--o13-,r- ojl-iila-- U lJ (l<*lJ1,--1) gJrlas;-l -/ 1..:1--Lio,'^;L-
9 sl L;l )) ) ,> aJL,1 ;.: 3l ;l c-l .:3U:, .:r5 :lrJi a*!!"f\' ' ' Jr. J
l. reactionarv 2. universal suffrase 3. Oswald Spengler
.i-jrl 6:lr:l .:r, 1L;I:'1j:sz.sa.1\-:f*"ijl;6t:);6*elr^a;,tl3i.r"+Ll;.pl ;:.f;15 u -rJ Lszt r--*41;" ,S\t.f;rc-;tl r c":*::l J)lS ,rli d*rG .;-l Jt-Jl
-iJ, ;*l or :5 .rl J+ji .(\ qf^) JL .:f +. <r.- pli L (Aure1 Kolani) .rlY35 Jl;jIi-tl* c.; Liil")i j{1,&t oS .glo;;: ro:r5 > :J* &- ;l .t- i;9: 6- ) J | \ I : 1; aS
.*l or.: JeE L^Ji -^JL- y- -:\S x , itt a tr i' .):r "-r-.i-': L^;,..Jur*L;5- Pmssianisnr
WWW.AEL.AF
,-{tt Jt I lf Y
u t-zl ) , ;12.J ei r-l+ ) -rt4 a-, \ 1Y . Jl* ;r a-5 t,*JV r S,(_. -s - J - J , i r \- - - J
,t*i or;Sl e.5 r 1) +:11 I,r;LJT 6t^c,.^.-J!-r ;rr -.rr 6,J-r,5Laa.i--r.;1
.,.ir; CJJD:"ijq,rrl'5 Jllis" yl,51^JY,.u-ljl .dJ,^i drJ+.-lJ slJ,o-il -$--S--jl .,1.rlr: p r)a,6jlrjl a, 6..,.!L-r ss\ s G-*st,,tt(.r:,-L.; JL-^ t+ coLJiLgLaJlr! .r,.r::."^a t7bls 3 oL(- jo .i c-r.j;b
&,r;t J-i JyI,U a5 -r::*a.lU*lKt GyU ,i:lrr,,tlJi;, ?re dt^,
J-.* ;t ';B-r,[Kyt-Jj 1: .rrc.-ili( ,s--.;.oLJi.Sl,i 1: \trL-:,n
o,r--JK;t, Jl; JlLtc)L.rlr,l- .r"L"j 3 t.JLr^
3 t.3;orrLn
Jt-;.r +5.ILJT-r>\;;l p p u**K:t, U: a.l t"l.$J-i,r" ?_p.J*i 4rl$l yt * c4>f jt;i \ q \ f
o3$:.";lo*i a- ! o:Ur" Jn:7j a- FU-U ?-p -*lc^L o-,
dll g--;EU;U .r."q- 4;bJ<-i ; : 6 61r$ | c6 11 1 16r l;i :.tilo:y
U-.;Uic;r., .. . .tllo.r-l ,sU r:-*" f..'Jl*- s ,rlf y>J!-r
'i *. . . .;;1r .l|-'j * t .:tJi :6 c--l C-l ,r*sl, r€"_& rir:*;ror-e jl u.-l 3.tS4c.rt-bl L- -r-r,-f )J )rr.i.:yt: se;*r .(.1V
-r;,JlxJ Jt; ;-Xt;r o)3,1 -r;.-" rJL-r- d* J-tr f^r+.. . ..:*l s-#lS.r.-lF, t *lKt fJt; .,il1-; y .5;lr5".r.5E 1: Ul($J*lcrr €ls u-* r;3,..1[Ji;: 6,r::.-,a.g:U;.gto;
;-*e €ls o*:-,l-r,,.tt<i t f-11; JUi;) 3 cr.:+l ji;*l * s-u";3j dri j,L., , u*t<;t c^L rtsU,S.:_*,_t 6lLa'-1,.:^-"Ut J )Jp.o drd;L.i r.fVlt -,l.iL
".r11b".,-"_l-,1i:3ti "&gL 69la-L-; r_b y )r^S F ,> ;l;rL;L; cst ",.-*l;Q,tr€*l
l. Jena 2. Hardenberg 3. Humboldt
tte 15 ,(Carl SchmitQ 4"."--:l JrLS *2r* alzLjLl ;l ,r-(, ;: 6SK:.-t J:-f ,::lA>y a*;: cJy: .1-t* .ri ,.U-t, 6 +!.r uU;L ,,r-Ll c.r;rG -,.: .c*,1 611;'a:.--.y.,J> / l: eJ?- J eri^ .5La,Jl ;: ,.r:-9- ;Jl" i- y ;\::Jj-,rr Lps *. qr<":nLir.:;.ni F.S.,! *E- I -J-e: ,ri ;: e5:I...ri":-l il'r. U .Jll er,i oi ; i>y -itlu,
.(Vq .f ,Der Hiiter der Verfassung, [Tiibingen, 1931] .cr-rl J-,;tS) l;-
WWW.AEL.AF
Yff ! n- lU :Jt- e- Jt^q)\--J9
:r e+lr.iU-,16 "111
)F-t'../Ll ,>3\it3 -i,-ai )l ,*,r[K:r'tjl..r-. (;J rt a-.^l?i 63r-,!),.r3rl rr6:L,r-ilo;trln plLJ j ok^JK;l
.5rL.a:ilLgL^.-aJt, r+)dt"jl'- ,.5t1"-t )l o-, $ j+ 6yl tl-rl: .lt-Xj
:J-a;.r.o a."bl;;3 *f tfq .,l^^a!t.,f .F-.n jl..J&
t* yr.:-1 'lt5 ;- y. aAS,rilJ y"ls qSL^" q 6 ,-lt, Lo"-ti :ott
.-r-i,[ a:-il: :3>. -9 r:*Jlr,-.i G)p J e-r#r-l6a 6liltK;*,:-f ,t11.5l:.oL c^i; 6jl.[1 *.6 t-Fe 6t:,r."l.tirJy-rr;r F-,]co;f-7.i €-* JL--,a .:,-l.t-a ,l:U.ljl .rf !Ll-,lJ) diL G-* \Oi..r;U .:lrjl1t-=l;: c*;lyj,r^f cr:*!51; g-;t;jLJ;U 1: a5oL7.li
o:t- Ju.";t5.<r- tji ,)::. ";l,r-iL*r.li;.: 5 ry 'o,rJ3, ;Lziln .(-.0s../ ?_p.F:tfuy s6:_#
r:-J3: JiJ,;5 4 -t "! F * 6 Srl.:Qel ;r= rtj.+3y o-Lll
o.r.;,j cJ3: .:y' ;r.y; cJ-9s J.*r; .r,-L Grr;-r S O je- l[*j "1.- JJ!
+5l,.ttJTqglf Lpo; oJJ.Sj"''j ,.fu? Ll:3,, Jal3.- Beamtenstaat r51
c.*l ;-l cs3--i orb g*! t.j, .gly y toiUi A*i J,-q 6.rlaa "[5
Ulyf.rlt-; r-, eJy; Q:r5.ul-r+ .-ri{,- cJ-l:; o-,tq.j,".u,j1r t1i:6
.. ...t-J;lr ;-* ot(4: ,i-y .,*l! o<,tl;"-r, f^JL-r y f--lL-yy,.(r::--A .ri JL-;, ,rk*.lK;l \ ,.bVJt- t) fJL-- y f-*rL-_r_p.
,.5J- f*J+ -r ,lG 4-.t J ,.,5 i.,4*l; trG Jr" 6 >y. 11r;-s 11 3
-,, L) ,r f*Jt1r I g-Jt; bc 34 J:l GV (:.r g;lr :U:pl
fJU t-r o<+ly;, ,'-*J!-r (g+l"rrr- c----* ?-P * ,<4c.r; l:,r-o rkEl f- f,l:*t 45Jl-+.^ L, d-l il .\ n c.*l o r s f d^--(..i
c-+> 61 0.. ,S j1...19 ,lU Jr" .-qi"r^ ,-'t -- !'uS -sl.li!-i' fJt;l. ArnstThird Reich: Sozialismus und Aussen (Moller van den Bruck) 5yr: rJ: Att )t- ,; j .ly. L s..y Jli" o;-3 r rrlloJj :/tz ":!_r, ta-6al nS ;YU" .Politik (1933), pp. 87, 90, 100
3):l elt.J:5u- ja l"1 uLS-l: d-Sc,.rs- a;trJ),-r:-l -t> tl-j*a,6,<;;f -e;Jr..lu.i:-"r .lE a, llY\'-e \1\1 .91aJL ;a t!
3. archenenemy
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jr, St I Yff
jl c*l ;., ,tLJi.r;l $ tf s.lLJT;r Jl; 6a {J)AI 6 -r5,r" ;L*lljl ,5la.c.*-b f!t; fd**J Jll ,;-, .ol;ra;tS+til,.. j ol37 rt;a$l! + *; .r"a>l 6 ! y g^:; cr; t (JjuTJulJe cs c.*1 .5x:a-.3 _t,,JlL..i lJ f'.tt; (;Ui,JUlJ+ co)jrel.$l.Jbr( 631 oi ;l r,tict6;r, grilltr olj;-" c-.-*; )J- ./1.5 -;t 6 sJ..-r.: .l[i f9. .nssig -rL->tK)a LaJTd-^*-t ! 6 J5.p;-.rUTq l-,.rqJ!-;,- c^-ib*-
f-:*;"^ -r -ui! o-r-i.i .!, G-f ;*ill,! r,_G";b i-e.i _e o)y
6.\ qYY JL,1,-l-rl;r.riri Gj;- )l glLqiep*,ot5-r:4; jilLi +5 n.--7-o ,Jjl -)n:,, _s> e dV 54* 6 jlrr c.-."ilj,r.. *-be -bU
! .<r? coJll ;-.1 ,fLlr:.-US ,:. ^-a c)y o.t.-i faL:" JUTJr OL, ..ti
J +il CX- t-.: J ((oJJ-2.:.)) J-) J. &,7 +"1r1c6i13;.: c6;1.:qLr- ptlJ., tacrLJlprr-.3 oJ-.X .d" J"t f.!!- 1 u5.-r^lt .ly.6;l-.a:il dt jL*
\.r,JJ;l>f u,1rf ,.ittl! 3 -rli L5t^.:; oL"a t o;L3.: t1
o,l.;p c)Jp orb c*-L.! lJ,iLJi45...tiJt-futlH -,,, -;l; ti ),*.(_;:-" q.- .(1 r, f^ ! 1r JlJt54!Jt---. y L^c^*Jl-, _y LS )_y ;*y .:L-laJl q-p 6;Ui,iUlJe- r::> 1r
"L;.r,*e,1.r:lJ) .)3,1 a:rL J-d."
3 o-L.; "iy-* 6r- L^"--.rll ;-l 6 t_yc,.\::..l,b .,*Jt."f 6L^0134r
J \ qY . iar r.-l3l -rr.Jr.-r , 1"153 -r- q ...-JU t*V s,*
YfO tr n- rLt ;Jt- * g;Loa-i-,\--l9
J^l-; t+oi;, ,3 rlS--yi jiU*t(t;) Gl; .:t ,rl+*i jt;rl;*,1:4-i c?"- yS )Wl )*p -e r:*l; J:^" d;t-a(*JV"-y Alfug.*J!."1r- .-i--:[ oJ-::S Jl -S,.*:-*o .Ji .r^,r'u; I # ; I -J llc^-,.i 45 ry-,6;lj (.+j, f!L-;."r,#t^" .?J )t y)tlSel;,gt"-"
q-r t'-.-cL 4J.lj;;3Tr3-- s ll-t G!.V-t Ot(.r:*:y;16;[*-,tiU jtf ;; 5 c-*1rri5;tS+t-it ., f!L-f , coy;51.-r-.: rrJ f!t*f ,
cSL-o;* L <j? oF U; ,)*1.<4 6JJl jl qJ:, t1i.c-t dt- d:tf:y o.r,*rj G)S*\"qrt rr6.rL,o:il,)t-jL J *il 3)t- tu,r,r;
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
tf L. At*, J.r 0lalgii1111L6i
,)l.jL- ,i::l|1.1 >j-> oS Ot3arr:lJjr)_ftJ gcdLa,)J*tl ./5 -,'t-i a-, rJal"r"
",!!-ic, :lji :lr-il .rLcL":-l .I:-ui ,Slr eS > 2 9-lu-
.t c*t o.r*rj ol3*c-.rLJ,5L^c-3"G
'(,:r:);^.t,
;t pic;t > gb-,tS ./K-.,1 clll- tlL.-o +5 r;b c,i..n.- d,/l 4t'i
,fr )J+jlU c.:--J e.rL 6rrl AV *.lJrc-.i"Li 6t-oc-Jj-: g5y*
c.*l or;-9i ) _fr t llJ,itj"".tl yl oy' ;-ul;r^:-t-r .51"4;;l.}5 ;-: 6La;tli.K; qgjf;.lUia,
^S s,gs.r9*: J-<.1;1+;l;: "tjli,r.j.r"G'r ;;3 aS
e5 c-l Cr--r t-uirli..:rS l..q -&l*jl lJ 1," 6 G?J, 1.-td f5.f.-u:L +r..il: l+;11.:.5;'U t, ;1 F.lit: o*je,gi:\
CGJ J^)"5^j oJt-l
;-:19,,t a:jK g ".$, ;,:13 6-:-ri t V & ttr-r r:3UJ 6 c-.i^L ,,1 3
45 tr$ ,-)-flS Ll.c*10), ,-r,tjl1; +t:- -P i L;*'by g-ti
J+i )-t, tSl-t L+J4i,)LJi -t> 6k ,fr UPJ JL.:-l.r,i1Jt-":;jL
.)j-,-j, :-* ,jc -* ,trtV J"-bu -,1,s-,t* csl; o<! l-a,r:Ul:l>
L- c** JLJI 4<l jJS J[Ji +j yl c-r-i "Jl'-:l ;
"y, .S 4jJ50L"^
l. "TheTimes" (London)
WWW.AEL.AF
,J'-, Jt I YIA
l; .-5;lr5;,r,JL^gG i )f _r b"l; c*iliLr, 6 ry "&
JL,.rG;, oS;oi;: o.5.LJ,lr r3.-.3 cs_,q-n ,S6J j:..rs; *i;: & jl&1a1 ;i oU*13;l;: .,Jt:, ,* yco35l 6 ,_s-u,J 1:rrJ-r^x,rr .ri[
\t;UT+, n5 -t-j11.: >93 6sQ. eS r_rta* .-u^*A or.le:iL*i "j[_il o[.^
dtff ! )[j -lj;b o;L-.llr*-- clL"-a;r.tLJTr::n 4"r^ $-,rl,.5r: -" c.ijt.*." s plt J 6,-9rt-a:il6L,^ot(.lr &. )try c,.6tri
J-*^J lJ ,iU^*l<l g;Lac*!- jlrstt t .r,t-l 4j cr*Jt; L tlJi4s )) rt+El d{l -hV y,,t,:r^tr(i -rJ_r-,1^ .sGi q .,- tr-S o1[--il c:l:,r."
)l't.j ,r<*^ Jts4-trL*-. .-,1-- >lr:1ff-rr;*.rr ;l _)Sa&;l^rcJy: ;.:.rjL^ +5 c-"X.lr *r; Ali,ra -6 :f.^r./.!> crrrJilo:_,9,, s*J!-f.SF.*^ JlJ[-Sd.tlt =" t-.r r.:* t^c.*Jq-J- _,1,S_r[*,La;-Li rK)s,!t+-,1 -el Al L 6 srlr )Fr 6_&, :Q. AGJ 1:.t^Jl; U l,j .r;;tr,rJ:t. -bV y, 6rt. ,.t1.ri ;*-..; cc.Jy.r ..r*lrp f-F.-r;1lr .ri:ir (g:r"L;O tr6;-;a-"Lytltrsi ";tnt 6) :_rlpL*; rr,r-or.tL_,L, t Jr"bje u-- +5 rr.(*;t(rl.r.:,,, t+ tlJt<Jl .:_rJi t 1r"l6llKlj;.: jlyil.jrr
*<"" c:I3i4 r-fplt."qlLJT.y'; o1U c-q:a- t.<*;
f-+ ^. ;^5.JLJi ! + .ot:*Kjl s, o)sfl a5 l:.--a .rt^njli.*:_f€
j* )fy ,5L"a.ryU; ottitr d;J. g>L jl,?t *JU" I,1 blig3t hr 6 j)|.-l s eV"pL- o;L;: .tUiy *^=tKt.9t-^ot(-r,r.:*:t ,-t;) l> +-7 U .tLJK;l 6 c^iL;r .Jit- JJ+L dtj*Kl s, Fle"& Jt c-*.t c.*;.r11.:-l.c*t "rk, fK t^JUiJ,*.:.: c-:i( JL,f;-+J i, t+.r3Ui U-l :s-eljl .r+oU*KI e _*rt-(.;toU; .lTr>)rr +i -p ..:.:r 4J clt-"J ctir: dU^*Kl l);, 6,Jf _,, rLl .:r5,r^
ucl;.-rL; .lir: 6.r-!- o\E ,ti ;t f.,> ofu,el cJ.>f u,;tiil :3,-
l. typically German 2. Harold Nicolson4. von Treitschke
3. Spectator, April 12, 1940,p.523.
WWW.AEL.AF
Yfq trUJFldGl_jtir."[
4-.: c-* t^.r*J<l6 $lo$L,-l! gr;ly, e5J,tcJiri..r, ;[.!,r*Kdlll$r*xLr-i F lJJi 6 g6 -(t.--:! /$t$ fr "rL^.-lo1\ r:ft1) oLj oi;, o'u'-; .<+ t.rra -* 6 e& Jt r rJ"lJ;;r 011-LilrlL^a +, ois--,lcg.-.11.r *-;<t 't-fi e$ly.r"L- "l5bAe I J:-r ,; .-b.at oc"rrj* 'c*l o-t-'i Jyl; )f :tSblj:o a-Lt, t, ..lt-1 ,li;r o5 r,r--b .6s .cglt+
to:rSl , : 'Sat<-"
dlj Jt^"--j:;;,- Jlr-l dU^*J<l dV c-"<- a:*J.SL^d-ryqt*..r+i.r -,t-*- ".ayu.gt"y;j5y Liio ):yl S-; Slt.c-ti-t--i.r"
.5 JL> ;r a5 J-ar Jl; 1f : yl-t # Jl .jl$l ,,l U $lF -nA 6*Ul c.511*-1 ! ,-+".Jtjle : 6-*t'jl c.*l ,t*" .lU.-t(l ,-rt*" .:!:1.:!.i)Bl oSirrl os* t:si,-l oU; l; o3*,.:1( pU .:;$ a.i,JlJ,? ol*j
.#\ d-$FJ r! q lr 3l l.lt--3J.rt* cl; r$Jl"ti : Ly4-Jt-t" jl ;.:3.-- 6Lac-i1:y .-tlfbL dr-r:.7 1: ,:^-;lri.rr 'it5
Ul
,-a +5 *1.<:.o;3r rJLJi;r etl: l-U" o;L;>,r*J(iljly'r'7.;ir,r-iL a:-j,tr >116 7*sq i,.IU-JK;l j-rS.:Lrll: -til:,"r Jir'.15
.:!;t,rnU; d;" &" L A t+o*l-,r.f^, a,tl,l.ritS3 a:--t-i :* yl-,
,Ui;t F- -,r oS ll ru*yt5rr \ 1 \ O JL* ;.r 6 .rr5 f^ff *1rl 1, 015
*"-€i 3l:.:*l o:r,> g*i cc.--il.: )fJ o)goi;-, ;UioKt;'.r,? Cf dl13: ;.: ,r:-rr '.riUi oJ':*;r '51 .:1-rta}1 ,rL n-fu 6 S..fjl Jl 45 c-*l 61> crL.a ;al .('U! ,iL..rUiJt-- -rr s-! u;,:-c el.**J -:l-* c/)J s-t-t' 6 ,5r:1olp\? uJ ;.:-o oL- ,5jL.r"tJorr
6r* S-...r-ra ..rQL, e-1 .!"t5 -,* -.+\ ,Slf ,t 'J:5.," -;-.cilc*lu
nioq ,-ur-r, e5) >lyl(.5)U d,llll o.: .ri;.rn 6 .LF J*,J J,"! ,>l-t*o-r-.i,rautrJt- rt-Jl cr-Ja, J,"! a.(! (a.*l: ,t-6.tt l; yl .rlr5 * AGrC.
(Leistungsfiihigkeit) .ry,-- .4l;t5cll; ;6)t-1 a1 d.r"--r c--6;1.: cJ3:
l. Lored Morely5. Lord Keynes
2. Henry Sidgwick 3. Lord Acton 4' A. V. Dicey
6. militarisation of our industrial life 7. Jaff6
WWW.AEL.AF
,jtt J-t n Yf '
trF.l.r-l-.rl .r..alJ, d* * H.rrr" eLr 1;:i p\;6,uitt:t-*;l,r S-;6j- I -L.tt-.r../rfr ,,..'Ji ql Ly.i" +U;: c,-.ijJ--ti 5:;l:;3L o,tyil6 J-t, J^lJt clL"a 6i191:9 oJ-i o.Il; r,.(-.>y
q..-iT"r:-lti t * coj.--l a.1 .<Der Mensch im Grossen> -;n c.t".iL
J-lJ, dL;Jl { t>i.,,* 1s ,.:.Jg: +!1.u oJ-,| ,.:*,-3fi 6;r .i-:_f6L^Jt- y 6 .g,:,.," c.*t* s ofW rgr:V 62l,Ka,-Vr- .. .rtsir- jl .fu c-*l a:sf -E ::J--lJ rljL &- os_y*q lt l"i: ft"j r.;l.,;,, r:*l 6.:y1U Jt- ;: o)s-tl o5 Jr+. p pUi; ..r::." a .SU_E
g** ,li s.i)t"a s o:fi jl o5 cS.r--.ra JUTJ .c.*l 1l_i;-l c^,ir6sl>*-V-t fG o-r c,.:.,,i:," Unf -*b-rr d-r* .rrli.l c*l;l:lyiyiJ-,ljllr-
\.nl-^: r-rL-U cc.*lo-r-.x .r;l3,il:--Kljl.J+. Jl* t-c 6
ol***Kto.ru.y 6,o p;b dlf C, 6 t.=.rTU Jr;5U 6 q,ilr
+5 c.*,-a tagal;:,rJl," !ir,-r^: .lt-1,.j c..^ot"S ls tSs ;sjL:Li .rr.(f J-:, U o-tj^i,.rl,u".
"&t ycl,r.r 19: I I tiT,l I,g;l="".t ;.)
\l-J -6, .St^t- 3 rlLJiy: CIJ cit^4^L-51 L;;4 .(,.i .13.r, t,3
t-* ds--ljl cE-,t"*t cr-^7o.a +3J, rrJ osl,.-i 11 ,rrly,--r:-Ls:y j>s_f J c*U-
-,1 -&r,gta;,e,.i.5 jl cE;t-* ;: 6.ral9,c=aLjjl 16:lr-ol )3J.-r.o OEJ*I -r) r:?y' .- C,, -)y ;t-t A.Sj(: 1.:
J $; f-aJb lJ ,ral;r-c.ytJ JS [i .rj.:yl "rUT1t-":-t cJ::..i1: :y.-,9
{-*a-f .ilr, JSI L-.f 6 Jiyl: ,fJ ,-d6; }J .5$l ["] .-rj-**r: a5 gitr l-, _,L"^ :t:5 )l 6 tdl;,..rr .r;$ q c6il-e-,1r .JLiL oJ.Lj
oL,1- a.-,o1,' cft-";y.- -il.f-al q-;: o.:[..:-.,1 6lr. lK-rti j,JU^*Kl
,J:"o,rfu*$ oL.--i: +5,5:liljlcE-,l..*i cSlS. o[_s a, _r,.1 ;,1.-r-iLt o6;-, jg-[+ .fL, 6 ,-,:5 ]-rlS +V f -* .rsc, si.r*, .r::*,".lr;coL; -btJ a-.a )l6 6JSljlcStlt c*lo.r-_1, 1^7J" -Jta1. Economist Joumal, 1915, p. 450. 2. anti-semitism
WWW.AEL.AF
Yf \ trU oL" 2: slalj>;rL;
Jr* ytr-r[.-.i,: ! L-; ":r5.rr,7t-6a )r:S )l ro:y tJljtJlly t:t.r-*:
e.)_ff_t' rSL^c*^F.rL" t* y.;.jli,/ # di €drJ eJ.F 5y 6 6i3i 1 .;Kt e?-l: ,-*V.rt,rlf;rl c**i,-jU 4-r 6ltl:pjY.+i :6-* \lr : c*lo-ui.lUi;:,r,;c.*l jt*-
"f- t r-K-:t oy'*-i;r .;-L,, .:ot.i ;;l ..t5 u.rl.,,..:;yl a,olrs
;i*S.i.glyoL--( ,-5tui L_r 4-.-r; *-S :S \,-fV JY-r*l;.r l;
&€- -.r) La1l;1t 16 S-S-,9\ r 4*K \ *<*;6ti,F*,lr *"i.sttLlj s: oS ,gsl3ijlg-,t*t,.'rLJi.uL*^ .o?l;1r+, 4 Wy.5L,oc.lL*o JoV r jt*..f
-, 1r* .ral1-c-.aLj Sl l. | : .l; .{ilrS;*r
,..,11-rQ .,,u:*^ *trfi:" rlr-ol :$1 y oL"lJdUriU" toc-.,"Jiat
;r.,t.:7 jl er; pLl -rl;b tt5 y .tL-.(- -t-Uc _p 6b 6 .Jt- -r) J:t-,^
J-;y a?y' d.rl: ot-:J,51y e,&t olt ef Llc,.:*1 y\;a eV tjo-L*r*y 1/.,l.:3 4i (4jj- 6ly ..:;l.rj t173 c-Jtr.ia, -t+l-p
"fl J3-c- Jlr"
Ll.ryl-r.j )_fJ y.lg)J e^ l.a,iirrrrt et t r>i,lse;.: 6.:r5 a413,- ";t-xl
t ^.ri lt c5 sLo"t(,q.: i$16 e, uL:; ;lri .y--b c-tjl p;l:-ryl r+r^Jt-;.: t)e * t -i1 t7.ll
-t> -fV JL-;r ,:$,--l.r'$ .ral-;-c-"Wo)F , )-tr-f
,.-<" UL^.--^t- eng;, fs.r- F Ul(J.::^*A ;;3it).>l;: lW q J*, oK 3 u-;r;.f! o;^:tr.grL; c.i!r" ;ibva,t-L-:l-r-3; .*(1;yr.rt-ti y.5t.: cglt oU : -# ; uif olj,e
'l
q c*l <. f# o" rE ;: rl-ui .g11, 6 11 4Jl 6L^--J!" t- * a5 .r"lK-^ .i-l q .\:l.r-:.f5 L c ,lr,t-[ 6 :_y-rs'.raL:-. ;t j ki c*-- ;,1 d,J: .:..-Al 6
-:t uli: ,tt-
L-; 63^ q L,",ti;",j ,*; {5 f-5 L-:tL ,,LJ :lr:r ! "<Ir ."J-,1 gL"-*J!"r
,;t-.li;l .r*!- ofW ,s-V a;l^"*;-*;t .,-i ,*;.";;:.c-l "-u; r:*il* jL:JU
:-Lri*, . r'i. :: 4-.5 gL.Ji -5L:.* L (Lri,-g, .5 ;--l ---a ttJ-r:aL: ,1";:-.:K, :l-u:
,nl "/-lri5 -2: a5 J;,r- 1Gi ra; .t! ,atr .,,l11 L 6 5r-cs- t, ;tJI ,.^^.- .5l-^o^r-r"
dJ&-rll .:- jrl a5 r5*z:3\ S r; dL6l9.:.:"t*ic(;S; 6L^r<7_3 I ;l .91L-: "ri ! ..-b,StS ? -L-.,rd^i J.)) .c-l r^o - c*+ .r" Jt.1t ,4^ u[afLcr :x-:f ;r* <:;l:
.n...Ll ,r- =; ,'" Jl.4l ,L=^ :Unlt lr- a5 :;l: :;,+-l
WWW.AEL.AF
Jrt "\t n Yf Y
c.r+-,t ;: rt r: :Jr. J o)Jt' jl 5.g:lr31t dtiT/ tr..t,-L*j.-.r 6)Jt',fr q na-illl"iirlrr y rrl;:,.--hr -ft -r&L- y t.(-35 s 3:trcrt^o-r,_l
) CtJgl .tK; J) q-T 6 c--iUJ) .tl-r.r cJ5.r, W rr3t-6.au J (ti,i)
;.: +5.r-.xL,it*4 eF ,F:_t.i- ajL:; -rily,_f -L-sc-/ _E *. o*.s.cil> ; *al .- .J I , CLar .*.1 , q ., a, L- ."1
rl \ - J J rJJ r . U-
rl.t :--lL r*5-$l "<{ jl ;1 p ); f^tr- 4ilJl 6 dt^4jJi ,Jl.c.*10:r5:l. rf tS_y 4.l;6:[ ot<+3, FIJt- + ] +5 c.*l45 J.iL a:-il: r;=.3 JU.*KI t'V..:t*rt 1: i S&r 6tA4j,^i -rit*x
, gj lr;-.-s- [aJT,r.,r-, t 1+911 I r 6 LnoLJi rr|-,-91a";--u l rj'l;,lT ;.:
;l t&
}z,-\,.}, -, 'o\--*.,-r\r-.,.6La-.rti -LJLA .IloJ-.! ..u;[-L.;
"..,s.el .61 syaJJ,.^:("n j-*,6 r1l.r,r" ,tl.rtl a*: a, ;6 caJ\-c-*.*. il\r-.,. -.,t5;r:s* s J,-X1 j.:-ir,.ILJT.ti.t(:^"8 +5 rri<" cc*ll,oc.*!t-t1 n.ri;bJl -& a,.rl; c*i o.rrr,-
t' SfudJ+-$A Jr;.sf^fU a,.tl9;.r, l;,ti3 rro:l: ;lf c.*1..- jl ,_*U lJ .,jyrl Jyl "S c*l,5:r-irr
-*.Jts_, 4,sJL:* -,* *.1; c-i.^i- )l * ,)):l_,!r- 6-a Sl9-r,6 c.*l6ri;ly a,o.4,r ,t;? a:U-tf At"ri .fi
"liU" *t-cJ;.r r,-Jt:;l Ly U-|.()J*
q ..rSJ,-r-- : '+-S*" t-6:..; lJ ,JLjl s_r* 6 c.64 ylrlLLt,r d .r;bL ol_-"a qJ.:taX;lLl.n-u-.:*- ?plf >S c;rSu,:l;.J!-l3,1
J t* >lljrlJa'ra;.:ir ly; J,st &.jl.r,.L ol*1n.rcl;l: F J_9*l,t
a. .rr.l5.r-. L-/ ) J rri.-.:cr:i dU : ;<:*n}.-f Ll -,r I acl r;l .b;,.-:" U +1y;;lli c-=^,ol,r.:4.Ulc-..,-J*a- jl * * d.-'(, osV,_/)Bl .l-l ,.(-1 pacta sunt servanda clyUrr cJ c,*t oI-1 orlr dt+Jl.rl-r-Ji 6tp -fl.(,. -U!,5r-.t-.1 t;l;l 6 J-*trr3J, 6yl.rrc.*jj)\...lflj:Jl6 Gt* 1.:,rllJl;-.gt-arl.r;lr.i _, .)U+^i 8r.tl s:_re
l. Twenty Years' Crisis4. I{egel 5. Marx
2. Conditions of Peace
6. Utopian3. E. H. Caru
WWW.AEL.AF
Yff trt-jt")),JGlF.r[-;
)*JJ" a5 -t--r; ); a..cc--.11.: f^l9; ../)p 6a c.lu-iL a:^i,l-r;
..r-iL orf olfl l; rrltSrr
r;1r rtj:clLlcorrSj Jt? lJt-fuir * yl-,;,ln;L(r )'*eu,J+ratl-4bl ";jr-t +5 rJra.c*lo-r.K:- &! .<.- ;r,3:,-;,11r oLJK;1
ort-.:y:lr Jj JU 6^.i J .*-"=1 &- 1.lU*t(t-.ilrala, Lyy e6,b
aFJ a-, -ru.5 +""*t-i." rr;t5rr :*-lt,rLi.gLn.K.r,-.: U l;.ti3.rr5 arJU"
o;51c-r-i.r-' ?_*;LJi.t(.1-r rrt r dTr) *i t-5.lalr; o.r.al:,
;.r +5,r^itr; .gl-"ot5.r,rr,31 JY.u-l .rLl; 5 c.*l tlt5r ;y*i9; .lt-i-c
Jt-#ld--l.rlry.lU*-l-(t G.rg JJ4--,.r1^ Sr- cr-*I- .,F C-l
tlS;l;:51; c;taJi.r,-trc 4;t-a.)J[r 5 -r.a:,r, dE.;f tu Jl -b6-ujlojlr;l+; L; -r-:10.i-: ,F iJ-r" o"..,;F juirr 6.,LaJL-r,-le
l*^.ql. 6l; *.**tjt ."-r* .<-- +5 u,l<:^ 6 c*l d*1) ;h :c.*1
6* --aJ o)3'.1 li.-;r J-ft JLJi ?t f ?a c' 6 SkTn >1lr,r,;t4Dl.\/L
! -U gU .x l$tl dL.a Jl Clyt, .rrc-l c-*;:U $L, -...i U^.rT.
,-) J ,;,t-_r )_*J1,r,'o3^J-: .;-r-j,1 L-i ,YjlS lr .,jk-j-(oJ.*r c=r. +:.iLij**J<l,gt,o;35 eU -&,:lr.il6;1"* J
tJ--
'u$.s C)'.rJJ-*Jt.r"t JL- d)J a: t;[5rt 1*U,,-SI-:S.5 t+oi jtorrl-j..-. lr LA,)i oov &|S diA o)F al;, Lr., c-ula:iL_ uct-e:;l+, -t-:.5,r-" J_* {.yl +5.51.;u,-T a*"F:[:it q Jt"?l .t( "<- t Ll .rr5
el,, €;a.-t^i,L c*;r;,rnl3,-c.=r"L; J.t" ! ohl_, _rt 6 usg -br,JL:" ol3,--c a- !qg.r-.-e L- c*ljt-i;l a,t-- L-i.l*r*.f tf )l tt pr,c.J-9.r,r y ta-*rt-71 drn iLoj ,K: > jtu^;t4Ll rr;L51 )_*J1,6 ,srg$t_*e +p sl U-lc-t--:U 11:L- :L; Juli.r^i e)ji rty.:llJ.rLl_rc.*jl: {*qt )lty--F,rc**-.i1 J13 tr*;r;.f-;S.li-ijr ;la5.raly,-c*L; )l -;ly a5 c*l a"r; +LJ3;s ilrrr 3 c,rol3+c-*Li
l. Wilson 2. Toynbee 3. Lord Cecil 4. Carl Schmitt
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5tr. S, a Yf f
r"k q 4.-a;; 4;-$l t JS "tot {-rrr 5.t(.r,-r ;,16..clt- !-r5,r, clrl
i ,J-fl .:q, 43 ar.; y r:-,yt-irrr oi g t 3 tc*l )tS .;t .l=J;
J-# llt;r c^r9U." 11.:" 6rL;.u [;;31,r" )_trJ \:lil,g11* 3e:
: J-;5 -hG y dlf :to Lr- S* Cl:r, !i *--l o-,ta.j i ji.,of.:*lo-r-.i,r" Jt"rlta.g1U Li S c-*l6*y )l _# 6jL.:3-r--"
!.& tr\f Ol-l*" c->.i o3>-:L:5.fj*--\>;) t;[5l )PJl,l-,./5 ,?-l ii "P Ji\6 -r.ar,ro ft, Jt;- ;l16.rU; A..;r
.a,1.:r5 G;*fJLJI-, c9-t-t--,,3 3I;l.r c*) jl \ de $;y or-i )s4S.it^Jirr4) (t e)e.t-- Ll g ri,t e-.1 $: 5 ? S * JSI'iu-> lJs($)JJi.:*; e, l;.li.rg,
.rUj 45 r11i,g;l:ql-r*, J L^c-L oy- y L-y,-ri5r,ali.l-l "i* tt5
r, 4jL^t<T+5 pl: u*t rr.*, cSy :t.'rui*a lf ,&rUt .ti:y r-:.,"1s ly oL6-7 L;.t*:.:rS,r- j1jr,,t-:i;./ k, n-t fr.1t J; C_f rSst
J:e q j* J;s t 6tsblt. c'--i r t3:t,5l'a'r-le4t o r; -*JL-r .aXil ;r t^oUT.r(1 ;L"j .,r-,l[5, : -* s t,;: a5.r,)\.iJlrr:Jlr,r^ >y ua:; c.:y jk":*, OUioil, aS \ Jlr) .:ri,Jt- c-*; *\ eV f+, dLALi"4 fU y r-: Ui ;t,* *d:r tr db e:1, 6Laa-:-$1 l-b y.ian.ilcc*lo'i!l; -h y 4*,5rlli:t-r:.il 3 ui. ,grS 6ts6$ *a: ,u*1.,5 y> Jt-,J ."-- ,erji.-,t--71J-iU r+ q*r r$,g r-r!.r;;: \ / )r yl +SoL..*a.rrc*l
l-,.fG trl6_*oLJi;, .r^arj;,;ori rSL^-,-s! q ":lq
a jS 6l rS >3'
*-lKl 6U^W -3r a^a +iL-\J,.^- +Li" fk -r) $:"i-i yl.r,'uiL a:-il:
gl-r5;.: ,lL4a -;b,r- t-.rr:c*lo;r-.i o$LL.i ./t:.:zl"!U -'i ,u",S2V I
4.^-? L- ..,- r-^ -J-j ji tl .t t: -r,-! U-,,'xl yL, .-*l e57 Jt--;l ,.--"-\'-J \-- J.J.J -. - e-r. .
.,o5 5; lJ
6>La-il 61;,gta,r.:".$let, &l _S yl or;a ./Ur-I,'6 * .r;"r.t 5$ -l t* 6tac-rr-.y. o.;i ; r .: l; t-'a-*.J I o ) J t' .r"*,- - ..:* I I 1y;- I
WWW.AEL.AF
YfO tr U 3k r) ;t^lrr.rL;
;-,1;16Lau,l5;r a5 511; 6La;t-i ,rL fW J o_f y r,.r'nJL ;1-91;r
a;L^JYx--lca;yljlJ ..^^.a,-r1.:>L.a:il tlSt 1s*itiy .$-y,-f or^Li" "}1"irU:-cl;l i J c,.,;lJ r,laj Ll.J--: ralF o-f :i S+ ,* + j\,g>\-a-il
..,:^5 Jt- f J-crt q "ft^:-l
sL- -r.: 6:La-il.St^-,-tSU c -*.-al +5 9l
-,,L:.-l tti -.e , (Lac^i -j.- il r o-, <La , .i pL*i ql qS oJu.ll ^iL
s!:*l. u. J- v - ) -tJ J g..u-:\ - L
.-f.# il .*l-5-r., 6L^.9l"aoLyi t- -r5; .g;Ja,-! csrL,"Sl 6LaJ!"r:-l ; l;
.:rK; "$;
J p 6>1.-t3lG.l'^-o .rl;Lc .rLl-r l; r,,5:1;T, j r,61l1tt
.J.:U
yl:;l.r i'el jl6) Jl; oLil:rL.a:ll+U" fW jlrr;t5,r -tyrst, Fu*lj lyb y j -*.tLJi.r-;1:- d-, J+r^ c,r"b ,r+-a:j jO; I t4'tic
ylj-*!, >:-t' S o: 5 cSr.- ,)-*tc!,.,1 f^)jJ, d/ J 8.{+ tJ Laji
J;- t r.)i jl k, ,P;: a5 jLJiol1t*-9:t 6;^ ojlJJl a, (l:*ao5 r;-r--.-r;lJ \c*;
,-r":rt +p ,rl Jl 6:-.c-*1;4.r-1r,',Jl;dl:r dU*Kl o?l-;- iL:. 4?.ri , Lii o5 rl ;-q- .rl;i.:;t-*;
.r+l!.rr -*E Cb.-clt.l4-: Slt -* lz; 3 sy.o-u c!: erjiP ,Jt:,slr fjl Lr-:, rrg>l,a5lJr.a-*l 6-tlrb s:l;to;5lcJt--e-* )1. .;L6- oJ--ioJ5ty J,lr"eo-,Q.i .i" a, c-JrU .c*l,rcL"---l
lb t*;a .r^.a:j! bp JJ+l,Vl a-h -,1 L" y cS-,l.+j e!)y
";-ibr,jl Grossraumwirtschaft a- oJ+i.c*lt; r-.ai.!U r.", :-fl t> cJ3: cJt--.:
)l J,liG" !.ii +! c*) 4r g;rb .:*:r: 6 ,glaa;::;b .;l'i;l.JTUlr>2-1, -r*.:l: pta=il -Jir^ a3Ji t---i cLytl .rt .- Ct-at5T,raroL"lL ;.r-b.rt--jrr rll3'-c l* ofu G4"<-- 45:y .f-413,'.1 ,3i,-a; sd.^;l L
6la-lyr;," )* L.t, 1,[Sr ;1*i,jr, oi y: aS .L-iU e-..ilr tj-.9 oK:7.l)\-lJiU";L c^-"j (dLj .*1<1.9t-a;y:5 , ofu
^-.:) a5 .g:lr-jl l-.t
g;,J, o.L-.--lc-r.j;l: -t5'L .-(.7.lry -!-r^.r y t-",r, J .f^r-f Aj, .eL.:zlpl--*Jl ,l'pl ,'6*.; gi olr:,c " ,3^z 6
"/r^ y [-" jlJ o);
9 \ 'J' 9
l. Friedrich List
WWW.AEL.AF
6r, Jt r: IY ?
o-t--ic;Li J t-ji-<-^ La;l.,ul,t a:ilr,r;L:Li c,-L*>lr,J:Scr" JJ,.*S*tdl,u..j"-$l;t.iT;.r Go6-u_r ;l eS c--.l.lr Jlliil ,Jli,r^i Ll--r::.*,o
.-U,: cjt-r-?&;.r er[Ji;r LSf* I|;..SGJ l:jl,-$1 41dr:SU1L.:-l
,lqj,r*$l,9t,o;;;5 -,: a,L.i- ,q*
F 4 q ; {r)At 6 {.-!r< JL
"ra.rtlL;L r, Ol-f*i.Jlr .<r"rr; (.,:!-:c#l o.L..l,.J .,i[5 +y c: j,:'u, gV
,!6 t* t ,Yt-.i jl .-*"ta "|-6,.r-a.r.tL;t*
.-r-11 .rr[Ji;.r .a^"Lr,r^.L"
€<:l-rSj t ge c:Le-e;;' oS 6>; ,, P crl..i'U jlr.: .slat>}"d\,) ;3,{>-5,t JU^rl;U"-;l y .*!- aW 6J S9; 1 aiJiil*l..iuir-^ol*. eJU;.: 6 c.*.11: slJ, -bV *.6.:lil:3.t*".c.-",1
di-l;'U '.-r-;lorr5 Le,-l 4-i1i ./!- 6)\.53 ,i.c.i a,Li-" ,,.:Jj --!- E:b:c-*1 o.rj-i er\i S-t-tri :J;l ,-.-l .gLaJt*;.r .r:.*i.jlr,-rl;[.:-1.",.trrS; )^; c>;n orat-.L," ,r.b ;:U-.X" _,, QE 6' Jb caJl.i)JU
J )_#d o-tnl"i-," ;r a5 r-l> 6r[-c rlil 6t:r,gLa"*i,>lrtl L*r; tjl^l<i )* t 6 6k ra q c?", ,>ri; u,,-*-l rjL;J-*^.*L^.Jt*,r(-^,.r;U or.I ,rarr-rLjL --1" oraLi^," 4. r:,"*;ly , ;,), -U ;rr:7,61,- cr^iL cib c-.cal;U^*Kt ;r 6;,ljl} 6 -U.ry
)l * e&t JJS ef *-Li y.$:y oJ-aL5 J.U t^.jui,rct"-11 .:t1c*; a-it--a-*r r""J ;'U .r;l,F (\ qf . J \ Af .,5LaJL ; ;r)oUilJ c^L ,S-- 6j1 ; d$ (* *.;u-r E;,b )t ,r i)r"i f\b; C,llY'l^''
ol-:;
if q 6L::-l +,r,,-ri .ll.u*i-jl: 3 ot*.*:-- J;l 4: J<3 c,-t4i ; r 6;rly-rjo-u5.r.rlU jl ._$1 c.rjrb ;lri {J.otJL- 1L5l15 l: tf 5* r_l
:! J.+:-i .1
Franz Schnabel, Deutsche Gcschichte im neunzchten Jahrhundert, II (1933), 204.2. intolerance of reason
.r,L La.(-)tS o;_yT:-e* :14..:-",- ;LJyl 15 :y. (Leviathan) ,Jl-:t-,! -;Jj. .rl l.rj:- j/ Y
.S rS,jr":t ff 1; 5:111 Sl rL; 7t -t I t-: ) -t- : -S r
WWW.AEL.AF
YfV trui+)rJLalrti-:,L;
l: r4. J J.-J? .,lL{- .S-- ,g j-' L. 6s*: +.clr 6 AL# J dlI-*,i.jl)t.J-t-:
$ +-r+.:lr.il Jl1^ ,s S&t 4r^ jl ,&. +;rK7 -r*l:Lr,"l .ral3,--c-Lo; gr- t 4*"t+ ,F *;:,t1r.(c*:3) 6 ct)! yl:5
"5 "t+ .!:+ gU a16lo-u--y bi , -&-t ,-# *(,-;.: JrrS
€ef c--*nl jl Jt-}"-al jl.-f, JL .:jL,-rj51 Trahison des clercs iJlJip
6 ;;!.r s jzj o j-5,-& .i"r,.-,t:5 yl ;r .c*l oLX o1[-ll ,ic-:S 1l>;3oy.
.1 ***lftt ol-i.:,.-i-ilr :^Sf )l 6+VgL^o;-r- a, o;Lil J €.)l ?fu1..r* . ,5Gi c,,:r=i a/l ;: .c-..ib -hV *J o)-5 .|"'U .ti1, .l-t c*!". ,5r-U3rS co!61;1 .-}=j jl ,L^q.j d+a;) *li,l ,-te, 6 lr.E rJt j,-1 jlof JJ4-- r€rg;1r5i o;L9.: LLS cL)t y3L t-r:S,r-, :t Lilrr.t^i!
45.rLaiit-:ioS c*t hl,;rl t 6-! )J-?)t J:- ;,l.c*lar-rjy;:-l;i u1 ;t'$r-o ta I;l: -* )JL..ti a- -i-ilorrS thl::.cFr.,cl
"-u;.rr:gLJL- fi" ir-* u3; L c'r aJ *: ,u.,J-! ,t!-L- ": ol.u"-:-il: Sf :- .\
;t ,5- -u:.rrl:-.;1-..1i;: ;LJ3l ,:-l 6;L; 2: ,rl9,gLo;[; tss, ")sf'6 ..f -S-,(Emil du Bois-Reymond) tr:":r
"r-:l_r, J*l ,;LJl . '-))r*.rl.u*-:ll: ,ttts*-'t:5" , *t";,, 1* "r-*:rt.r,rl5i*!; _i
"J;a "lK;;S.:*11;oL;;: \AV. JL;:A* bA,:;-:l-,i J:- &-lt oi..r^Lirq at5 -nE, ,r,, "K-ab ,Ln 6:y*: lta-tl,J!Li - (Yl ...p ,[\ AV. ,,t.rJ] ,oUJi ,K= uU ;: jlr]-) rr-;s House of Hohenzollern
a, ,j;L; ;-l .r*--tK:t ;tr-, )L:-il 45 -r-:! ".rS F +! LJ^-: -,s--s..s: a5 c-l a-3r
.(rr*l -*LsJ LJJ ,)lf ,il ;: (R. A. Brady) 6:lr, .61 .;\::y -r.al;l- .sS !-rl,' $U 4 -;t Jy J- .Y
j-l L lr.rjtJ'l <:":(5-[;t-a1 _,: u3j o;L;::,o Lt-.- G3,;Li f*-+\! rUiL-); j:,jK:at^a t C-r.7b" -t Li ,u,j; ,-u^.iJl: ,crL-a!n oS trSu. a+=:i .:,;l-s'; olK-:-;,: yJ- +L-r j' Jrq-i .+)jr.t .Log;L; ..r-;L J;-u <-i> _tt ,fG "4:;-tf;l a:-: ,)i JL- ;t
'U-U-t .ut-t t-l ..r,:r5 :j,L; 1; ;Li^i; .5La;l;lrJ rl d)!-t J -I,$lj,-.jl d ,Jj:-ili .5yL ,5lrul-;7 jl dirl+! ul:l ;'jl J ;:-.. u^g +5 ri:y .r:L::-l jl-r:-;;t:ri.-u ;3,1 a/, ,+,);,1 ;: 6 L^oi.c*l i.:^i- d:Il si ; 6 ut* p;Jr rtl.r^*:;b o!.)t ,* I b;'l! l5:u:l ,*c ,;-.r-*.1-*.)..!y qst^a=; I .r,Guj:-l ! l;y .9:r9 L "LLt
4 ! 1_, ,t1-u,*:-j1: s oGi* ri:y ;:G t^.Sjl- ,ni=.- ;: - .c-l .9;L; .gL^"t(-r-: -ijl;"LSJ^lL a, o;L;: l; ,tl-.;or;+L> ;rLif .-+; ,,J- y J5 3:^t"^ ,j cJ*-
.rIrr-:u* --; t ;tJi.-uo:l: f-t .l 4-i.Il J {ll ;+3. Julien Renda
WWW.AEL.AF
J't Jr r YfA
.uilr.r-. H tf o5 Jt- J) (J.:.:*a s*le fl)b ! ,f J ,.rLt-*-l
3-:U aS ,{t ,f-l +5 c.*.ib rtq q -r,-!.c.-.,; oLL--l;,5;17 to;l.g>l"u:-l c,="St-- rtl;bl_j.-a L-i --*V ,* *..c*l.r^L #li C!.op U-*J".,..45 lr si.il3 ss lJs cc-*l uJ >t"S ;t y .rr.f Cl*
.:ri i.,;E .rr5.1"." -l .r;L;l 6>l;i crl*'-cJ5,r." ,t(;l Srt.r t^di jl lJ
6ll .gl.rr5 o;t^.il c-r Ul )l ,s)Kl jl .<i \ '#_f .i- -,,
"X"i
,#-tt 4.Srrp .el4;61; c.r*Jtt" q& .(1 .rLl; .li;: 6tJ d-L-jJ )l;-. u,.rr-dr.j 45 LSk -f U"p :t * ,*"r01_1-c'."L*!
"r.a-i.c.*l ..r-i *i.r,-t&.,,l.;iJ.g[a.-:, ]*,L cJ-ar,r.o "-h ttL-f gtt- ,l:6)l: g,jl:,-, .eV >:_f an+.i" a1 ta",r-I1: g;lri.-*q U ) t4i,Ft*L*J -*, : o:y llslj)s ogi J"U .)ti:ti jl 6UJ,-j rili,r-" t,r^l" rA:-, oly- ! 'o3;(i-rt-e.d.,.r .t_f :tSj $yNature )pl, a-"Ua:i.a cak> .>.i GpV -,* *.5 -t.l,!.rffjl;--;ic^1t^- L 1;,-rl-u."-.1-il: 4-i r::1,./!- st.l.! 6lLsl,5l-c:l,Y ; J ;.gGi .11-r,l *,s iSa;ljF, -r+r^ .J:Ss, o:;-i oX 6 ts ul l.Oi1to-73-^ a-, L"luorrSJ W 6:l;ir c*i .rr"cl:kll-,llJt-S'.li_ ."(:_-
a- yl .c-*l o3Li:.. ly,- rfi*a,tt("i:-; -,1 g-,L* ! yl .15,r* c-.g1.-
J-S,r,caL"- s ry i Jl +5 dt-a.-,llf 4l:+'U .f s *rt af J
;.r--liy} clt g-" .U-u, r7- .5rl.u*l ftl; 6 t d-,1{U.7t+l :* y
c-: j 6la-t-Jr":l dJ-*irr Jl;.o a-.tT;t ,r; "iJTL?
a.--I.-i.o ;r sl rsll.t>*l ;g-rl cJ5,r^:L rr,r-aL,
e-"t- .(-- erl:l e,.-)L.a ;u-.-i-jlr +5 ccl3;(i-:ly 15: L5t-c:l ;-lrjl-rr.f *, d c*|11_/-l sl u-h 6--l a"l:.t"o o;b l-1 .lr;c.--L^;a-"Ua:,ia +5.41-e:l-(-U! +:-.i1.: i)\;1,> jL<i jl*;l ,5tollit 6t!-r:
3 ll111-r^*t.. ca:Jl.c*lorl: pte.il oi As: y,-gl+li-)L .f,ti .:t-$ Nature
1. C. H. Waddington 2. Scienfirtc Aftitude4. the present ferocious monkey-house civilization
3. Crowther
WWW.AEL.AF
Yfq trUj1.,,dLal,;c-",L-;
'rts-t .u--I;l3 .rjla;-i,t: .4t*,i,liU r,i.rr, l.a.:-r, jI Lriuidl-u.J^jl)bj;K--:ljF, .-715 jl c.rj djltr, 453 yl .5;r .gly .c.*l +!lr:, crg,
;u..-i-ilr Aly, )*f)J) lJ# .(1l6:1Ji.r;b.7 tkllyl.t'r 6tt-./tq-" jy-,ALg J-J*J J \-F jl
"f, lyj rc*l d)J j t1"r=' 6,,1
r:*lo-t.i t;'K V r clj-6,*-".ri-ti[ a:-.il: >_fs tlyg 6k & 45 o-U^j
:ri 6.grl;l yl Ll c.t-L^ic./ c,"*-r a, 1; 6;111 U Jl : L! Al fb, 5,s*le jrrl4.. .-\-.:q c-i,l: .:eUi ;)l-&t ! y orl Y:+, uliaJt-t" o3;(ir13 F, o5.dt+r^,jt*il f*i*tb.r:,f..-s- ?_pJ F ,-i)yi:t 61">;3 -,* yccJl: cl!.lTo;L;; cE-,L*r ;-ij-uij
!"ut.:; "lr< \L.6;1.:;,r--o cs5:t*,a:ilg.rcL"qlcSLaF:* \ *l-r;.r u-rt-S ;-,1 a5r-,1
)L- 45 c-*l61--ol^-o c.t:S,r-" it;l,r-"L :rS-j1 jl * SrFs:.9la-:-..[5 g)i-.a fS 14, -.,!.-i,! a;--xtr rUa.jlj!.rl;; )l ;,licc;+r;-r-.U:Ual'kl-S -l.l! ,_SltlS o;L;: r,Llg 6\AC"J<JS Jl*\;r 15 .r,-nfar:?"5t-- 4-Rr e5 l+f c.*;^.a -raLi l1 Otf tl+;t 6-ipt S $lorl: slt-i.j a,.ra' u,l-ly r;.;-*.J ,-* Cr" L^JYJj-1;,1jl.i-k--d*Jtl"" o5 Jt- J) cJ::.--a ;Kt*tq,-"l"
"Fl*" ,./qn 6LaaJLl
.:-*,-* a:;r(.-r,-.rl; 6tK:,i tr! t Jt*" of^.s.r+
:lcsL-aJY.r:-t a.:. a rat--x .:*: ;aljl .g;tliEL; 1: L; 6du*-",r
.jqru./t+lJiu r+ ,sl1-ill; a- 31.:tj:cl )l uzf t.g:L-; -r- l;
a.,iJirr ;l a:sJ.>ll;,, o)-5.j-1.5 lJ t^.iid." c;lSl;r, )_p\ (,r::.,A
4*i (t-6oiL"^ {;l,q"ra.li.r-uta-,rG 45 'ujlf*J-rL n,r^.lc
3 JJ-ar,r-o J55 lJ c^-"-t +1,-"1r ,-5-s-t.r"t*l e5.x^-.a,.r.rAt4"
;r 6 c.*l.rl.aj..7 pL; ! a*,-1..a"-,1r c-i-iy. ue 3t c,>3Vi elt sl.ruli,-ll,Ul3i,r,. Pl J+J^ OiKa->tt .r5,> cyg-l;l.c-lorb 3 4*K
J..*, \ q \f JL,JUJ<I! o*lU" s> 6)syl dt:-]<l+5 r:5 Jt<il lJ
l. J. Benda
WWW.AEL.AF
6't Jt n YA'
a5 c*l 6rl.o:il f[-LJ .<-, _,1 Lil t, 4jliUi- (c*; Jn, 6\ ur,l,
l: 3:t sbVu ,g:l ,-tl ci ;., LgLa+.:+ eLoi e o:y ol3>c*L*j S f -r*e_l el-;. J ); r^lJ, 6lLuVt..uly # &_o:t* a,. o,\aKi ,r! a,
t e-& 6:11T.lr;c,-"U fS ,_,,-l:r aS ,jl LlK.jlJ1.* ,*.Gf;rlj-:;l$.5ldl-;* 6f -rl6}l r_,d:r.7t5 -uiq a:^il: r3>.3 *liec.;lr rjty ..[* .,*t 1l .4Lor,L-y o;L;: 6-t:--XjJl .LAIJ*i +tf 5 JY.u-lcrrf:|.: d,-,lrl S# 4:l.e$i 6lLclL l;,rolj,-c-^-L^;l rtl3i,r, qir,+S ;t-.i,ft
Ja-@;i.<J c^.-",pjY taoi *.6r**.U y 5tr 6l-t )j 6 dtad:-J.J-rL
cdti-*l<jl1.:,rrl3>c,.oL.i gf a, ,.-iLi, gt^&l_S _j,J.tS L-f )J.
f*Jq-r.f-l,E=:l ,5ly o:.tf ,>tj* sJa;-.gl^u,lrg CJ -E :rl.a:Jf .>yj-c a,Ll-",5Lae^ir!,11610-r::5.rlf c-.at- S ,,L-r-, "a;J
f"A F.f-l1r ,-;-ly,-,r, -Stt.-rl.ralr; ** c.:;l: rJ:a jl o+. o[JT;,!.-+;i.p ttU+-i+.'5LooL"}L -r,.! gjl:*,.r-t"- JL^-+ tF no.
l, \ r;..,t:5 "iJ_;" rrlSTrrt-*.,,
-y t;t(.^ o:j t-
t.-irJo.,_g-
y.: a-5 1; ' Jr*-e.G .cl,-gl.ii t \ 1Y \ a:-.Srr .JL^c^rJt* U e"r,(, _b _,,
u€y,u..r:.7rr cLl.c*:b .rqf^ r-lSir;t-.,-1l ! dLj jl6Lo+ny
Jl_f e ,?* lrr>-l ui,L:- * tS-tS Lao.r,_-q J.j,*161a;L:i c=*ala,
A) )l S e-&.:1;'U llt-r--.rr5.rtrJi,_r-L* f+,6by* l1 Layl
c.4,. l; ,r,a13=-c--l; A_r" y cSf ^S 6l"f;lcr-,rb ot^Lj t)-f ))
\6-*::-#e '*V 3,y,e*o+
CL:." ti osj I 1l-Lu-" &.f
;l*S ,g - ;l tS u, c-- j;; l -t r*- _c\ , t^.F-It' \tL:,I K:- n,l _,1 .r.. o5 ,g ,*: ,*- .\
,j;\) 45 Ja^-d -i.llJr -i -q.h.r*^lf \: S* JrS.gGu;r! "y,K:a J9t _2: a5 c_l:El jl J:lll .69, K:- ) r-,. ^- ;t..:-l )rr.:) f t-t * SbF .gtr*r r ;L::9 ::r5*l: -rl 6;'^:4,-rt..r:+ !:- a/> i1t-,"^l:; ".rJr.')Lr-l +5.r.:jr,:!;;riji*:)s: o:)K JL .:--** (: ", .ll Jyt ;: :lil ;,1 ),?J $ ; ;: .J;-;l*i ;3*5 r,1 qg:Lall,.tUi,.SF .SU .L-,"5" .,: rd t ;:LJl --i;L;Li J-L>t ))S;al :) -r! ..,Jr, ,Slrr .5
.e: 5 o +i l, .-Lj -\Je
2. Forward-March 3. Common-Wealth5. Unser Kampf 6. J. B. Priestley
4. Sir Richard Acland
WWW.AEL.AF
Y6\ trt" Jq", dl,6lrrc-:"1*;
,al otK^,. cslr J+J+ ,t--t3:-t'\t"i-l .dit-dLrt- ,[5 J {rtoUjL,.>Sr- J>ty r-".(r-;:.lu^i;.fi oSf S: yl i-gt-ac.*t,.. eS c.*1 c-4i>
.Js.J"
.,-A)dLjl* jl <-:AL*^ j S;^> c-iL-- ,.U) )l lr rl5 J-lLa,)i*1-W U"J3;11 a.5 c*l &lJ ;l 3 'uar,r.. pla.,l c-*-.a 4\l; )14;lc*S ?dr,-l tr5 ;yL :,llJ )fJ.-!) 6a S Jf -,, .c*l aJ3l -)d :)J; c-SJ> *. ;1+5 c.-.il.r qrl cll;i.r" r.5 t lcg*I,-.rL>l"[1U -,f
.* f.^l- orlr 91-,rrl3'-c."aU a, (f.a) +"1r1 ,r'l.i -* -))
.:lj!r-l oKr:^.rltt ;L A-r;l Gr*," ,5t^e 1p a, ,>S r- r,l .a:Jl
3 : y Cd jl .t t-"oi,y-,;,l )l : t -5.1,> -) f 611:a,Lr- G:Le;l--i.r-a aJ c,ij.- drl;'U c^*i t^.)i -);* .S-ye ?_* );'-baJ c-*l ,F; *.lz L? .(1 rtaqlc+(l,d:l-u-lftli 4 rta.1l+j rt-aol
&-t-L">f :,p:-++,g[a.4l;b oste + 6 cilr.tL;L gL., r,rl;r)J.; ;UidlFe ojl$l a, ; taJi t,l .c-rt" r^l,; -j; c\,:,u. ylLr:5 d-lr lJ Lrd.*?- i,.j" kJ4-i .t-i;l.: ojlTl$Ji:*. +5 -u:-.,o ,y$_fc.rty.t- 45 .,it.".-.a,, Ul .J:5 o;1rl l;,li.r:13,,,r" .t^alj,-1 45 dt"j ,^ U o<!
r^ oS l4 .,;t-y."41rJ5,r, '51;lLf-,51a:otclLrL c-;u* i113{
d J-,, .J:5 Jl.J.<lJ 6€re;lril a, JYp '>,t- 6j -[lya 5la-t--ojl-"l-tjlicr^j cJ-[ J-.i,1 s-,;ri )l G*Le gt-ac.-iL;l;f ra:,rr ojEl
rili.,^i J-,-1;*:,=*a .J-;1. oeJ4; )l,1Jj:5y, LL;.:;.r.i yl,rarjl;l+ .)r-, qlrL,;TrS ,&\J c.r? r) 6 -r,^iq eb -* -,y! 4}'U c.^-;.iU-, n^"|e.(- )t ^S J4l; c$_9j 1b;9-;.lr;Jr tllrj5 +t*-f c.*.: c*i-ir," n ,5:1il )J.t*o La 6 t:-C a.zj: e" i2. > al45 c-+ t ji-a;.:-rt-,-r" .rS*" \ rg y-L );.ti a- .t.1.-.1,-,it*:
:lr-il ,r1Li; 4*"1- .<.-;.r +5 .aY! .r-i1; jl a-a
J;lr (*3) .rL,-yir6
Sl::61; ,-r;"1 g-a j o:y: 1l:1jirt.-f-f[r- c-*, r.li a: OL:.lj-1.
)l ,j:t d:-& 45.rUi U '-,u--lL a*il: ,>-#r./ a,oli c-Je-: ,Ju:.rts
WWW.AEL.AF
6,Jotrl YAI
3:lJ.:-l -":-lr c.,L5,r- d.-its .;)3> c-t-a S-L 4ta; gl*ol-,-.a t t UI"V; &L1" i ,-?c)L
"6t-^-r,i;-: ilie6;t5.:U; .:-,k"
! JUil A-;t * s, c*l ;5-" oL:,;irS .5,Jt--;: Ll .-r-.-iL a:ib
45 JrxS J^lJ; J* rry-,-* o:ry-{ Laoi.:l;t-tu:Ia5 -u.iL sf af.grlrJl "<! ar, ctl:L-l 4i t"6,ii c-.rt- .ual-r;l: r,; ;Ui.tltt(*a .UU
cJy> 6 d)j"dr) s o:fi a, ry ;u-al3; )F L^*.", lU -,, 6 "u:^-a
.iy ,*l:rJ5,r, t-t"l t".lia,
ici cSf;.: l;.'ll;l:a1L-,." J.-F r;1.: r5i;l+sr-l;r ."r;rtK; 5;,1
..r1;lra,-L-,- jl Jl 45 c*rj t-:*" -*.rr .p*l.r- f;, Cllf )l-aril 63- ,"
,r-# t* qr,./15 r,1;: o.t--la5l;t6l,alY.r:-l45 j'"1 f*cJ5,ro cS-,I-rtt+
Lyy i *u;,1;-: c5; + L^oi,rJ ,-fu1-5.-u^iL or.i r-.j.q:^il.ry' J-r-. ;*t-,uycr;I! .<r.:.iLgJ a-. t"lyu' +i 3 o)y 6J,-J-
..F-r^ grLj St^,sF c--L- .--la t.: L-aJi e5 )J.r a.dl ,JSJ|$; Jfi.r:5 ?17 ;"l 1; cJ3r c,-1"-- rlldli Laii.(J ! y o:-:r
yL- o:r5 ft. ,-*) jl ! l; c---L-- 611o\lf ;V;1 .rka ,?J )l- L-".-ri j;-t* .?L+ h* ).qlu .+ +L- U 3 col;giL," y\-^o3 3
Ll .$lo.:)yi cd) 4J c*l g:r^r ( t 6:61 .:li[:"l 6] tr(; S At
rr:s4 to;V; J{,:},,,i t ej6i'U U **-;tr; 6 cunl ortK-rl,;;
-t-,; .:L{; 4 6k --^ jl.,:- c-t-:[ c^ir:.,_. J]; ] bV C-lgitj=;l it"lJr lp-;l a)e 45 ;Ul.rJl,_r:.- J;l . c*l oL-1r5.-.+ .iU-,.r-*J.e g* ,;,lJ 1\4-;1.:t$ r]+;"cr a- L :; c.-44;r ry',r-"
) t eeV s6":f Cu ,tl- \ q,cl-S:Lz;t itj" e, +[^-- *-S -*a1 45 +q Cr-:i 6La.3r( :s* y,.JS.i- Jl-* *cJ3: ft" -bV *.
cli;.: a-5 6,1-b:.r* -r-alr; ,-{' cJ-;;Su-" 35-"5 C:lf )14--:l c.J-J-er
a-, c-*l ;-fu. "r-;y..r- ,)- GIJ )14;1 iL" jl J tt gg, e.l,sf
W. Arthur Lewis, <Monopoly
l 943).
:,r:; yi ijU. ! .r"a;.* .t
and The Law>>, Modern Intv Revietr,YoL VI, No. 3 (April
WWW.AEL.AF
YOf n L Jtx" J.: glalJ;ca,t-l
)-9J*r.:1i1a, L;i La),-,Ji1.: +5.r-!.,,E )l;SU);./!- .blJ
i-u.^irri iJ*. H ctl;)14;1.r8 c.ri r: *Jly tt*-+ o?l*",1J\lf )14-,;1 45 dYt-1 ,gLar,^:-.: c*l 7.;\i ql .,t-'1 .:y -t-a13'-
;-* +: 3 c+l Gtf tj-- t*rP 3;Ll;l 4'-'i J:5.," c;lr;cl-.lc-r--i J-lJ, fi:i Jl;LoJ--rit- d! AtStS,-ty, tdi4i,JJ-:
.iUli't:t* o)J-t'|,-, -.^ett-(!l d! *ag rr- oi;ta5 5>lr-iltas+;
jlc,.--t^-- t, U*JY.r:-1"i-olj'- ^a1l Y! 6Lo:;;-: c-il:r'.c-lciyj" G!l;)le;l
L-aclil: 45.dtAJJS )t 6:> a5 r-rl: )J-J {)/ 61y,r^K"=" }:o?\psl,Ji Jr::S 1glr. "sj, er.r.g c*l ./t+1
"il$ -a9 G!l; )14;\
;-..;lir-t t-:'l a,bl;-=. c,.:-c.<i -ti! Jt.c*t cJ-r: t.-rlo:l:ea' ))J-" 6-:*, >J:;e 4);W-il CU 6 6,lg$ cLl .-r--lL .*r{-:l jl a-, r-! ,,.a> ;ll .:Jy.r t-13 J;-S ; Lii lr l-aJi 6.tl 6F a, c-l
J . -.\ -
L_.tly- 3 61orL7 .|-a; : &"- ,6^i atU; ft ;- .{ :lSlt JL;.fu.r. iJi:-XL
"5;\-a-,;l6.,lj-u.rti--l :* y # :6 : Ol4-f
u(:^L^^, tSlTiL<Jl .<- L*t: t^Ji 45 .tur -,1 i4 oJrSJ)'aA
\ 6e_p )W;l.r_y J-al-1- -tlttFJ,5r;.t^Jy-ti Wy )l t:t;u,
c*rU: rlr Q o>j. 1l>:1iJ.tY/ 1te )l e t".J"6 'rjlil,r'" o;'ti
1) 3 -o)-1r cJ3r c.-1"-- c--J 4i,^.,6 ,lS: :l-e;l t l .J:5 Jt<jl li 'J-aJU
o1.r- ;-lr;ly+ r51 st .r-*.J rl d^t.it -, oJJjL rln^il3 "l! .+Ul "l'rLi,"
.r-13a +5 tFe -tl>-t_rt,rJr; )l ,-*-r )W>)l L,45 c-*l[-
.rr5 orli-l oi ;t ot;.,- q"-;a 6 3t-ti - J:S ;);*A l-t ) r + -f6l;5lA-.J ! .r*i,t.t :-rl-," J $; J;5l-, )lc;\.t"! 6 .fr-$ Ff.-rl5$rtr.;*; !t*:- L^-Jl,r j'J,,L-.: ,<-.- .J;l^J!} ,--'.:^i<, j- -f-1\) j:^L.
"5t"o-r-i!. j*"-2-: Ln;L Ladi I iL-lr<rL.*ll JLjL 45 !o:.; ,lL":J *) S o\tsl
;l l; q:rl! itr, oS IL;< J-jil ! l; l);. +! )r q Lool llrrSrrS i4y4> 6;,1 ra:.r"
itr, "r-< ;:* t5l;l) )la;\,;--: -r-l{ :1- ;\ ;otJL" #Yl -, ;Sat );
f;;- jUiU:; ,,rr.:Ulq9;1- jl .r! ,J;tJ* a-oS al;-2\ o!-L, f .=; Xt 1) "IjJ+-;j.sl o:kil JU:I .r:-:,r< J- J+ J) 45 c-U;jJl
WWW.AEL.AF
6', J-, tr YdF
o:Lir;-l *_2-. )l 6.3 -+ 45 t-,-o o_*d Jr." .ti,tt -t- jl 1Gr j ,Jrb ot:,
jl rLcjlcst*" t ellf )U;l.gto:r(!".c jl rLi:ll 45 t-ra 3 €*l c.J3r ei-t3
,I* *tt 4J (*.r> ; alf ,la;l+5 c-i,b dli.," r,J -u,lcc*lc-J3:.rL:-;,r$.rr- b-- lU -,, 61la;l.r[-ac-5r- o;lrl ;.: +5,rJy:..r5ar c(*l :lttsll rl;l rl.qt' gatr c51t pj! cr;-i! jl 4t Jt-;) c.La:,rr
ot(--, .t_#r-t ?_* N cJ3.: L-ac.*L- ;-yJt; r:.g:lri-bt=-le5 ,5.:lr-il Ct " ! .,.:.i jl ,-r+ cJ9.: .:y,- 3 o-t-l d3: otK:-r a--i f ,t*;t
.lr;" f:r*o it " U c-ib ralr.- e_t6 )l J:5.,^ ollsl l_,1 _.1_9*1
-,t-;l ,yG *L;t,,t*-,;lt=rA a5 c*l;.,1.:;b )trs 6,Jt^r-lc)s: 6_yjl +"r..x Jrs Jt rl,,r^n cc-t-a.41K,-r"i -b u 6 G-;L d:Ljl jn >i- 1,rt .j;1c-,-V: Cb t 61,,,-l Jt^r-t LueJa;,.>lsl-,o-il 1cJyr t+/ 45 J5.l.r-"e t-roi;-;li6J JSiJ->;13.c-l ,rJ9r c--y.r,Jujli,r; ,O\lj )14;l ;lr,,o cr56,o ,5,! JF +* :* yls tlc^+-r*iL a:-i,l: l, _*L.f-l _,-l U-l -Sl u>.t;j* fi#- d).i cAL^rJ* t>
".r--;." .:>YL-l :t $f j ui u*r,*;LrL^c5r- t €ly uir, 45J+.i)r> jlrj,-,:i..ic+L."rd 6j-,a;l eb ey;l o-t^i*l;l .:L.s 6 (a-lrqgLa.r1,-ui -i_y" J-#.Sl,-r-r+! d r3q r^l3, aLe .,,";J J-iL rL.4;lLa:-9J ,Sl.\f-r.-" 6-t Alei":,..r;-.i c-;lr, 6sl-a-.,)l
JU:.gL-a"-,, : urt-,Jt".jL )14;l a,or o_,1t7laSrrllr'; g-! .r:t, e-tlK)t*
+J" c.e.* o- o,S ,6,1f lt"arl! ,;y-f elss q<.J-S J;S lfklA ojlrJlo.:r5 -uly,,- , +,); Cb-r-eirl5 \46 u,f;l-lr lJ Jrt*;t* 45:y' r9-t-r." .3L-a.rr,-- a- Lli )l*a;l6 -r^i ralr; --^-j^ rgrl-t
f^lr, crG-, e--b )l n5 rr^:,.tL^i.,*-6lt -,s* *1.3 o.:3,..,L:-1.pl.i
oJd)[*x -*+-f q:.i l-., f tt*;t+J" -&t -,U..<11,a; .x-r.t,51 e>-o_r* 4i ! 45 r-.i J=^lJ, 1^.3,i" u"j-.r.tj;:.g:1 ,--il i:*t*l; c-r[i; ,-51.:i e\* sJt- or.:3,-- a-i)r -3-t ,\-/.t:,';li Jt:,jirs
!cj!.u,ol-4rtc-t-.I,L,.g;1.:a,_V-* ,_s.l_Srt-4.,ilt ojlL L:i *tf ,t+;t J'j. ;l
WWW.AEL.AF
YAA trU,Jt" )) dtil-rrc-:^l!
c-r--i o;l-.xl; X* 6 4jJSJt^^ Ll.:y J,6l1l;;iy'; cc*ldll45 itKai.r-.- ,gLaj)r-; -bW y, d cc*l or,i;; ,b ,S-"J<- q G!l; )14;l)-iir l) 6 g.:lil tS-y )lL^,ii6,_r1toc--l.- #, q o+.gli"i -,trqLf./1"?." oS S$t r,L*t rlil 6y )l t*e 3 c.l-ilo,\-.I ,-i"y' ta,)i
;&- 3 /aJY.:b 4-"t- .<." rt-*,-l a, Gllf )\4;l;1 c-"-L-' U $1.r-:
oY1-; g,JJ* +-Jai; ;,;.5U ); .t" ;l: u, .:.iL; : c.rrS "r*a13'- .(J
*J .,t.., ,,i1.VU c-;t: J4'3 4S ,r&, c,la- 45 url<b 6 ,y ,-tl rty.4,.
: -i-S :lp A.Gs t; 51lC"-/) c-..*i LJaJ. )f 113 -il-tol a., .:ljL:"l
C ,Gtl; )V-;l Fl r-rJ .*X :6-5 j!"1 :^J 6la ja;*7 rn ), )_fdt*-lt jt* JLS J 4iit-,)l,jL qLr- ..,:l 6:i 61t(*a en;i 6:[ .t--
+1 ,r 1L":71 &: e,jl c-+ t ,jq:"l 6l;b .g;t5 e.l,sJ,ri;.: 6 c-lj Jr:.--a _,l.5 ! J;.- dl"t- J rC, $e;r +5 g.:lil t_ii ljl "1p
.u_re g ,alf yV,;l gL, ;: .;t(3 :lril
.* "! 45 --l ;--l J ,K )sr.gtojl.ula^:7 U;6lt' jl ._$1
,*l-Fy) Ft e.jl q-.. o5 J:Ss, c--L-- J-q- )l 3 -tt.(al-Sy",3..ry-, J-aly* )JL-p cJ5.r, c.et^= oi1t +S ;*l6l; L:; J or-: r+:.lJ t-6JT cS c*l G!15 )14-";l e-* ! t-.ril-S jl tllJ.-.-? c--1..- 4lo5;Uj U.c*14rL .<,JU t, .-r:,-i6LorlJijlf.:" J $; r1j,t,c.-yti"Dli:-ljl,r5rlol; Jil.u,tT;r 6../Uij ki d: ,-* )l4; ;)S 4+.r--lc3il3;r J:5,,- .(J rc*l oJ^r J".-ij Jlf )S.fLj gl_r erDi Il){.-el,t+ 6ll-c q.i,sl 6 ef -t6,tlr^a;.c*il: .;*J q dli.-," sS-ril\n,-r*jlr:--iU(
-,t5 l-, 1l3l;;l1:.r:Ut ff +t-^ rJl; y -,,! 6, 6 ,tJ;I.:..r,
6-&t JL^:=l6-^.r!,1 c----(,i t f35-." gg>; 6i;i 6 -u;b,r" p)\-ol
)l)L.6a;J -* olsp L-i lA t" o5.,*ljlr/ c-lr Jal'ze ).2>.J
u;- dYL ,^JlriS ar--! : }<a A\1.:_ie +il;l ;^: (H. J. Laskit .r(*) ..;- | ;tu-ty.\j-I .,r<--i -bGbrFrsi*l a:""1Lj.(\\\ .r,,u"tl]) \qfY.,-lt,;-tJdJ,f tS;o,rir"tt nJ;" q K,r- s J:5,l o-i*il p:r- Alrl; P n5 c-l ;G; a-;ly: a:^--.-n
.4:-:r< JL .l++ I l-a! 5ltU ;1 +jl-9t(+;5 ct"i;l;F .51 - n.:-l
WWW.AEL.AF
*,3:r,. oll tr Y6t
+5 dt-^oi,i ) e/-l )1.)F .:.-l.t ^ eV > j r> orl;l .rLl; L 3 o-t-i ollrl
,-(5.r-.3r :t-11 a- c*lfU l-l ,;*lf .m*n,rJ3l d), rr,.t jl ;J-e;.1
oJJ, s<"-a s o>t :l>s-f J G._b c#3,i r_ft J,-[..i J:"J^ .JSc"+5 c.*i,lr -ti)Ji dli.,, Llo3, -t:.al,,
"[<-"11.t.x.^ *"ra pUi; ,rl-,1r _!:r;
,l--i : +5 c:3i -# s -, ctlr"-a; jl c^lt+ _.r r _*lKt Ol ; )lS,*,-;5l t_T
); L l1 L^..ti.g.:r-i .g:l-li +5 or-l3i4Li,;t e- Lo.li.51y lt .s...Jt *y-.rr5 .r-at-4 rS-ij ($jl$ls"
31; 6La1j.5 a*S JL e r q 3-:U ! +5 ot-a"rTpL; .gl,rt+rlq dFl6JU*KI f ,S:r ,"-l a.l1a.jt-t .-r.J;b OL:it_rtl,,.4n.,.:*l -.-* C*#lg-o coJ*: -t4::, roJ--l.gp;a*"1;y a^"t7n .-(_
6 t_#,_* aal3,. iJLi" C) 6U rr.r^:-r! gtjtr; eVl cSlt;)AJjl.-<aft ,t6 *;j .:1"5 e s oVrrr +("l.1.rS Jft -,rt<idait- jLJTd.^-L J G1,JL e. J s** a5 c-.,l.,-.!t."r dtaL_y_,
.:k;1.1 1: +5 cLrjt-l+ s u-;-j Jrp;tcSLacS-r-"jU l_4:;+;.rr,, o.u(il
,Sly 6 C.4 bl-);r cJj.r Jfi,t Li,- J r )!. a-b 6*\ )-*rt,fL* "+ cc--.il:,-r-.5L r,,.: .,ljU r_,y- (ra oU; yr,rj, Cb ef-t\Oi >jayJ3sl,r<-Y )-*J1,6 \r,J:L:.":L,^$ln
"[*o jf jt!,5ta;!;
yclf -r r* *.!i +5 \n,r5lr*.:,l Jt'autiL c$l:,r." 6)J-t t;;L; cEl-r:
.,t*l a:sf .:L: ;[JT dj ;,4t )t J<"&,t;,! e,.l.u bi,-t)rtj:.ol;-_le1 .5+,-t,.51;61-aa-;Q +t* d,!-i Jt* 6i, _1u-:.<r- jl .r+ -Uly.f *t)61suLr,. a.rt+1.(- d c;lr :3,-.3 +lt--3Jo:L
! d+-q L"l .Yn-u.lL c--ilr ol,r^a e, 6.rLail 6:l;i rlrll .gly ,r1G; a,,t--
d,p-l05 g:l{,45 rSL^_,y! r-r-:-.." r:1l.rji s t,* JL e J q jl.,-, JiJt-;: oL"r; .li.gt^.r-.la ! U o5.JE -,, 9 o-t--i ,r5-" t..li .o. ar4)
,J:t:r 6 4J't*" yl .c*l Jt'i &$ * GitJ .51 ,f- .r;t .l. balanced economy 2. community consumption3. The old world and the New Society: An Interim Report of the National Executive of the
British Labor Party on the Problems of Reconstruction, pp. l2 and 16.
WWW.AEL.AF
YAV D U ,Jtf ;.: rtLalj>r:.-*Li
6s*,./lj-l U-frlq6rLj r3.t-- V e_*;t(il 2r j clLJ;U ;r 54i;-,i : S, +or ,, pli ttJr:st,
"r;";7 6 +l! l-, )3* cor..i 4*K
- J I /.\
F rt *; 4*4f j orb i; U ,JL"j 1r 5 ,.:*1 ,J:;. {f ,S€)l4*'S .5Lls.tr.:?, o5.r+l.J:5.,-.rrr+ l-, JtrJ,St^jj;l 6 c*l.l-tj 9 or31 Jt-4rl fL.j o$-I c:3,-i,r,"..r,-.L6i c.*l; 6lJr>* GlaS* G-l-
* s .*,f 4:G")r;: a7 c,-.olti.o gt<.t(-t+ JtUt..rS Jlfi\U.rrj J.r.7 .*-, et-S Fls ?r.-1Jt-4;l I a.l'^,a 6ly crrLJ;U ;.:
.$t- ral ; iL , <-u"l ^-a r.: r o--a 'ul r)J t) ,v - e_- rJ J- r
[. reactionary movement
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
I F ,*dk*i uil*l S m*uo @lr*L
.J" -,!^t,5Lrl-r-"2 c5 c.*l .i>\rLe t- iY.:tl lin
=-l 11 >11i.:lil :1.r^: ,,rJ ,cJ3: .rLel .-ira
J:t t ,,S jt oS c.-t-;d-j))Le .qr;,r.9.r5.J5.<,-rr-j t+l .Sl-r lt,Sr* 1l*: gr:5;L--fo-i -L-q; 11".La..rie;>lji.L^.tigt,- $liJ 45
-, 6;ic*;t^l :* y 6h;L^- a5;,1 6t>6ly \ ,g;"5 >1.r-: rtL-:,.r(,1-j; ,>t-) )l;)q 6-* cs-i -rr 6 tt,ji.J-l5.(-3; dt-:;rro5,oli-r -l> {"t-.-",J+ ..rL-i:r- +-;!:Lc.g:l1i
,--(,-: cr:-L a:--il: .:,1.t-i otJy rJ-i1ls,) r .i.rr:-9r Jaly,-j tl,--: f :^.-,cJ& ,5Lolr.2
tuy'.r,itt
.>LE-'y, p ,f Jt"!+, jl ,^5 oS J! tf $. r-ll: c*3: t" ijJtsl j--c +'. G-s> a-, rrgrL ^ $l clLil -!.i-an .c*l o.r + , ltili .**..o1 .grt-a:il
U" 5,a* l;.lio.S;--tjlJ+.c.-..1o"t i;r V rac 6;;,gtoitjljl.-,!,?J.€ e,.-.., dl G*:: o;L;;;1. 1,r.S *-!,fJ
""--r., lJ trii d/l
a-7,/ cJ:-ar,r: Jl; -qs'U ts-f ls.fL^:?lrt:>L *16 6taLcrla,
l. John Milton
WWW.AEL.AF
.|tt olr tr YP '
g;ll-,a:5\ J lt.<--;t t-^,:i,rK-^ J*1u-e -b yy'S -,, ,f5.f
./q- 6L-n.ll-.;i,5:t-.o:ilr-ra" ---i a5 glory J^ti ")\.i -t,;b13)1
J) (45 J::*A 6rlilor"-a.gl.aa;-l-9,- c{*;al3 6)r, r6>l;i J# rt {*li<rLj ol;j.r^;.-lu-a).,i Jl,i .t-!'U s:-f ltggrLr-iloL*Jl.-i-ra ,JV u,-e
jl :3,-- eGi-ti sLr-,-r! 9,a:)K -il .r+ ,6)-tyl dLil 6 c-.il: .r-,-.rri
.,[-. .g)Lail ptljory s/),ti, * y :-t\ ;l 1p @ c6i*:3l6t^y"F,
, kl S olJg 7-.*-,oU oL}j y crr.fL 4lilstty t:*;.r[i .:l.rf'U rl9 -J L_-
,-fj jl.*-Uy o;i ;: 6 ,9 j-a: J GllF )W;l6y \./l+l.liU;aS u<li,s cc-lol.i ,r-:U c-,Lcl;;l:_f f ! gt-:lr. ral.-!.-r:-r5:yULa;-I,.r-7r,t.c*la:iyi }'U,"r:S.-,+ f+:"1-, c-rG; l,".li ge: Cll_ilkJ "<! -[,-:t: a:+-'r LgJ *..+u-' jl;r r"lj,r^; 6.u:."r.*U_l
t.Jr.*^ JiJ,,dt<"l *f st :l-o;11J,"*. 3 j-a^;l gp
jlr*5 *V J; 45 c*lc*1.r .(--i .t3-r- ,rK: u,jalu *.Gl
,l-L o+ e2--a L r,-ua.:,r-li u,133 6:t-a:sl.:t-t--)\" \ )F JI<*Ku-o.u.[i g5:tr$lgL^J!"r:-t 4i -hV t lt )-ro 6t-aa-lr-- J l^jti crjLJ3lqgt-aa:-l3,- ol: f J 5_tr_f il3, $lirr^i U }.J.J5.r!/ :_t-,-l
,-f- ""- | s .t-# +; g;rt-a:rl ,>lsj7c JlJ. i J $; "1.-.;
l:l r3'-
+51,6:t-" oLSt a-.1 + J-cJ Jt<}l 4j ,5./;1":".1[.:.., )l\ )]V! .f:l.^l t_Sf iijU<;l.5 e c6fL *-S -* J}U.i c*v; 0",u.,5.-"1
c6>Lai| A y .i sV r-l r* l: tadi -elr^l 1 rlJ:+-r 5 c.*l il.r-ol yL#-e *"-; faAa5 <r6.:t4:il.rt*il-!.u,6r5.1;J ;fLet tl;4,4ilJ ,-*J €e c.5r> c.li;.: L 6 er- :, f -* 6 c.*1 ;-r,1
6G-l* ,,ly F -t^lf..r dtJl.J:5 *-.il: tli1s: yl.Ilyi,r" cc.*l
Gf ir:* -tU; qb J)-u-t ;tr= tu o i* ) , tP ,lS "6o s "K .9:3,1J ;l ;r-(, ":Li:-l . \
,rrUr ;lj!,51 ;: n5:l: -tal3>,rLj. J-u ;!t'llg,c-l Jl.t-l al ,U.sF ..5.-r:li 1l
f"J:a= J:- .:,LelFl .+;rt! )))a )t\sN;-i; Losi.g:yU :r 31E!;r"q Slt" 6aUr ",.ot,li1: d ;b'l;,1"\ t:f e iL5.;lJl I c--:l::L c!.,;: $lj:.r^; -9 +l45 Jji-r .41::-l ;l '* slt d.r.1t5 a1 .1i1: .qt.reL."al ca;b 6 t:Su. ;il:.yl:
"r:.*l ;-14:; (4" ,)J" _"o ,: OL:11:
WWW.AEL.AF
YP \ D ;Uj e-iu.al J drl- til.,^l
.gLr.J"S fL.; o-5 ..ab:-,* c)-9r o-\-.x t^Ji fytJ {-1K :> 6 e>} *..r-iL a:.xl: F s,t_F fLi ,f alL a713* c.*.(,.: l\ jl,g> jt
!"ra /."a .(* sc*l -;S:y.-,t-* 6*.{ .{ rt .9t+;*; fW al* t-p rglr',:i jb"' 45 G ssf t- diU * -S *"!6 -,, r.Jj * c-;,15 \ tS> j.:1.-. ,5t-o.;3'- jl rS-,!t ;: 1; :3> .*I, .-',J .c.*l 5;: .-f,U
t-.1.c*l b; ,j6 ,_i-{;.<i +El s:)Le.tt-tJ e[e)Bl'o)r :to-f -tily,s* .lr3: ;r,f.p,Sl; gi$ ;1 cLaol ;: aS,I;l; )FJ crt\^o)ft* y 5;: .$i */ r^ ;,:J{.Jt--;*r -s>
Ls )_*,V)l J"\S )*oL4,7 tl-t*: -,joJ.?*, ! -t+r^.r-r ralJr r:-:" La,lr.r &: *.jl t t't- 65a*y jl.r-ol L 4:-J,^J 6.-aby; ,'12' ;s L c.-3lJ",L.l;*l-r.,
.5;r crl-Cla5 c*l \li al -,r ki t l.+t".f ,_31l?l cJ5.r" 1"t- ;[LurL ct.L-i -Lj 61.-r^,.." rJr.j..:-9*i,rr ;S :;.5 rlil tS-r )ltAJTJ*tS
)-p ,Sl-s,L^,ri c-^aL y c-lc .5;r 6 G|;; L >S ,91K;L lV:sr*aJ,l:.rlf> jl,..:* t";"5 .q! r-p lr7 6a-l:c-l;1-r:-l,c-+ dr.(.-.
q 3l .;1-1c*: lr.- c.t5 a-fW f-t ,aUt.(1 a, c*l ;j,*-" lr-- c'L.iU
.t1lri ! t.q.,o cc-*l f-> dL^j." t 6L-c*: ;l ;;lyi: r!,.-* dt
..t5 5;r l, t 6tii.rl-{i a- -r-lj.r;.-+, 6oa 45.:*l ,}-,a." 6t.-r.2.a
c^lr.<, ,u-5rr tly -ib cp.j 6.it^,)i6 c*lyl ttia-lt: ".5;
.tLtrt o-5 Jt-- J) ()l) "t-:alr; :lC g- l; -,L-71 J:U -, oa;,
..gy-r,LJ-,L:71 ;* * o_f ,_/.:tr*1i J,1l J-^r! 5 "610J.2.-
Jr*g^r,jt *xe6;2e-1.:;'>1"l5 a-."t- .! -^t u-- .xlru'./! "$y,f
q y s r i osr.. t'---ilis^i .+t" r#J yl .:;^:-r +! l_,A [-:_9j c,-l.u-.r rl_r
iXlt: e5 c*L., &J-.a ;1 dr,-l -:Jla5.lar pt=jl lt.ll c:3;'arV1 )S
s-) 1 ca:--)"K,': -'1j! E :firl;:t ilf;*e-h )13 cc*l 4:rL dr<-" c$U- a*3i g*iliu^;
,-.*l cly+ 5 lJ .,JroJ
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5t,r,l-r l YPY
U .l-l5 5;.: jl ;li "S 6j." )le=il \ :_t_t f e5 c.*1 d-\-i fLi dr**a
o):-.,"l o5,S-t"U" -hV ". ts)s* dLil 45 .-...1 (.-6* f{.f .(.5 c.-:*l
,r",.r" (s:'*-jl +5.g-r--U-c ci*l o-t--x ,ry1;.:3"-:.r" .: j->o Sly..t_J e n :af qJ31 ,rl.i1;:L,^tl .5t-a"1r,T q J- jl ,-.,l.; ptr.--t U- Uti,..*b-l* tlJ:>,J.t-.l dJ o-)Jt';)\.i, e5;r a5 c.*lylf-& {<j
;: dr".i, *,U rt l:l-rr ---U.-rt,f5 *.+ Laoi:r5;t5 jldli,.r"j 45
cgL^&r:S, !;t;..-l.r:- t- ;--) jl aS c,>r,.> s pl;.-l tSs: )l l^,ilrl,
-St S >.rS 1-*e.: ;1; e:13;A cgilj;r .c-*l r>r3u- pt+JlcS:LrJt
lJ t-6Jl a)J-f 45 cit-6J15 gleJl,tl-1, \ oG;JS oJ.2.r" rJr+i f"^lf..fo-5 ,u.i,! +T-,ty-,Fy^ c-r$.l .1,! ,y r" .tr5 Ji! caS.r^; 5;ri J fss. c5;r 1; t-"..ti +; d..*byrl
"[6 -,, ,JJ-:j fLJ .c.-.*a ,Jj51
,g.="L-i"f .:.*J a: -r!*l:^ )-ft-f .<* Ut^tKTsL.a-4i ,s\:.o a-
l/i c*l ues| a,lJ:-a dl.c.*l0[-i1 s sa:V,_el-{t75-"JJ*-*a*.t-- .(i -,: ogtj:." .5.:rr ,i)l-i J+ .rfuL*^ SG S,-f;.: .r:lj.r^;
-,* y, $!i..r- 6;:/ 6p 5 rlr ;lrj *i ::_r t l: &W J,-L coJ.*-,.
;: d-\-.x 5]*;,S1; ,..^J.]Lr. +i 5 r5.5;: Jly;3.r5 5;r .-|,t5
e:i -tlt;.: dJ--i ..1;crt1U u/yi, ri J sp;": f SGsi tltd"l *;s.,.:+1 Grf J-# J-iU r+ ojU-jl,JL*a a, 6 g*l:lr.ilyLAly )_i -'llil -t5 ).p.J"j! r^lf fi jl o.t'e.-,, a-t+.fl tt>)J-,a
Cl_f S l5 5;r rjli.r- uJ5.r,. J.L".--l S S-SI,J c.*) el",A )l )li
u:-rr-uf -r-al3, jr-i oll _/ f.6J-4e -r* yo-S,S.l--.l.7 ^.St"*..:y J-aly* ,',;-rl:t:
c*-t rJL^yx y 6$;tc^;,K*.r.- 1; t, J5.," JY-r:-t 6.dl.^.)i
6;15.*a.:L;l("l :l Aly o.:Li:*t.o!j,,-*; ,iU--L Ll,g,1o,r.l -t1*"
orl: ,11.ri 1: f F ,rl 5,r"K.," L"l .+-S r-l d+1) ,,.j! dl.: ,ret"-71LL"-" €--rL SGs-* ,6 uis: oL.^ q f:l-l.f 6 f5.f J).u-t,! ki.j ;1.-t:5.r- .L-ilcg_:j tt*";.rrL"--alc;Lay;* ,,g,-Ii
WWW.AEL.AF
\ ?Y tr ;t"j.--r1.ral J Grt" LllJi
o.qT;rl-, c"iril, ol;3 o.:r5 rf[ i lJ Lor.j o{ ,f.f ;;,.:1-r-:-1Jt,i.j oLi.--L.2E i-.^ ! -r::5.f t-rl,o; lJJi 6.at-a..ti.rr5.t-41-9--.:3.t*"
*<aU*^;a.ti6t-a.:;3L-:;l c--EU= oS1-, .-*! -r.jla:*ilii jya -r*^r.f
."t5 .5;r .)Jc{r/ o:t' 6e;; * Slts i,_rLl;,gri igLaj)uSa-l-gtf J.,_/Al tu<i JL*A *. a-,"'); t-b y c*lpjYt+gal;:
! J-"! a*,t- *.j 5 c-ulj u-ira .!orr; tt\ $li,* 6:; ,g:l;i
e-l ely,,t:j:-l L+J .-Li! +--il: jjL ,:y' oi fL; **l : # t*t-L s 3:,- ,>3-1' -t--ly -!-t-a Sl *l; -i--t :l;i a-rt? .<i a5 jil;
44,6:P -ft 4 )l :-rl pW c-.4 6 ..r"tK^a c-*l ;Sr,5La;!.r,dl^- JJI .fS L;- sJ,$ ;.r 1; ;j> 6:lri gtr;,r" cli6l;1;.: aS c.*l
61r.. jla:sf )L- o5l: aU .>l.,-)\L.al S:Q,jlorto:-ll; -Lar.rr
-,* -.:c*lor::Sot # 11* r-?w 5ty,g$ g * u,*,7 r-cl;A
1.-lcrr5 ;\j o.-u,i;r ci g";: r;".'u -hV y\ Grl)i olic. GsJl.c^K tt
";,1c,.:*1CrL. t"t,,Jt jL 6.Jlf q o5.fU o;L;r..lly;,r^J
-il.r-al -tL -s.,Jl9i,r*j 6b-ls J- 6-a Ce Jl4;.: 6 "|-,r1;,1
-;l I11.: J-r4 otK-^ o5./-r-^ oi t G- cJ^.xL a:--lb .!G" c^."q;l
-t-L '-l eJ ) 'l-tJ
) o.> q, S-l n^.r 1t: : p 1[5.6-2t-(- J + (.,:!-:cdl-.t)- r J.J.-> (:- r J.J
,-ri.-r-:,U o^ : *; tl 5t etriL t,Jt^,i)s ;i-;'J,1-. -t ;-yS yy.'-osa'l rJ v+ J
a1 i)ri r-7:" .-il-t-alrrl* .-tir- ! J-"!./..t-a ar+ 6 c*+ L- ol.t,
o 1 e>- ,',-l r; cpll e )) .)J-^.: {^XIS lr.-1 +, rr..r:""i JA 1rr -lr-la ,rK> .>;luJJ t)-r l_r-
c-*1;-il" trf-ts JU*lrr"f"p jls*,-1: Ll,'a." el;Lc ca1b- 6 c-lp )-t-a;-,1.j;;-ljl.ry' r-7:. aJt'*+;F -,t--.r .rLl-t!l a'.,_1-\ al
c*r dl-t- L#,-a ar .l-!r 6 SItf c.*JT.J,-t.51 ..ilt, 3 +l!-j:*"
.J5.:;ly LL.;;I J.ls 1-t' ,lt3:-t c*l ;(-" r.rrc-it1
ual 9 S:--jl .r1 6 S:yl \jq jL"i,.7 L 6 c-l c*.,ol-ff -,!*rJ.."1 5 *a-i-,^ .-tG.3, 1r! q {! y g-ft';: f.^tf 3;1y; ta,tiL o13o
jlJ* L"lr-: "t-.c 6lsj ?: ),A.f-rs 5;r,g,;1r lt.r1a1,;3L-c*r
WWW.AEL.AF
,_5't J, n Y2f
6_r \l-r ):- 3 crj ;l;La.u-, 3-> nt;(.,bjt", +5 c*l Al r.Ka(&t-:- oi;: L^.ti.(:; J* -," a5 c*lo.:1;4r3*, 6lu,a-a; &t.x",51y,rjtil 6a .::l:r, jl U-,!*f ;: .Jilo:rS,r,",.:.iL;: .iYq f-j )F),j--q .c-.--Xl.: L^lJ; t3--1 u,"V &[.1^" yl ;; .rlr.il :l.k; ,.JL.A -rqjlcS-,[*t c],>yy,o.p-lt: 6 r-5 -W -S-t JlcLl^" a, l;6;l--: :l,il.c-rt- "r:,olr; 3q blyt
"l-*1, .r;^:-.: jlro5l; {.r+
"lil rr,"*: t-^lti
c: y-x ,.-rl-i Jl .-J -lt+" .(,- .f Llf +t L.L a5 rr-b-o t)-ri ,*:*s Gs*,:lrilj,+*.J5 J.,- lJ JKi- ;,--l J-15 ,* y $1i.'-;ca-r.rt> 6ly JJ)di-1r crtJ-lL -t- .))tl ,yLl-* jl S c*il: J.al3.-
! + rttJ6:t- L_l-! .r:^t5 ! +! ,.fE ;,a;: cJ:;S ,.:iU.;: )i..:r).-*t: eU olr.(r t,t ;
t_S f J.IJ. :; Wy ! -r^;lr 6:4 6lrqrt-;l Jl,a;3* 611 y
, k,*.f st t-i:i c-rS c-,-.jti" cueli SSryf .g[4.:;^*.r ri..atS
)* L..t-"!.-""E:lrJlr,,r.-^,) ry' or; -,l5 +1;-rj -t"! L-:;y .ral_9-
-r.ili,-.*; -&t 6,.rt.Jit- (u- ,y:";aU r;:-: ! J"L*" q 6Jq?lJjj-i J,-:" r-r,j:rS.r, c."iL;: ,K+..lU;;: 6.4YU "L*;.gl.a:;:-r L
,J*- yl3..r5 J*t-,;X-t, ri"-, ti -Eti" aSylU c.t-it^1;UQ .t-!
rl-r-;3 r-t-a)Lr-. e Alf J{l- jl.).:-.j*JL- y elF;r 6 c*l,;-rS 61,o.:r^:-: Li c*il.: .r-:nl-r;,-*5 &E"Yt":-lJ1JJIS jlcSrU
uel; -iq; JJ, a., +5 .t-:5 b".il..rbJi q + u*1, :_* \l: )fcc*J[-f e-t- .(1..r-;t..r; YL s5l"a:;^:-, q .,Ie[5 ?4 34Ly-f t- nf o5..gla,:* ..:r5 .r-413,- orLc-t ;3j jlcc-.r*i3, ;l ,2; LJ*"
J $; 6; -b cstL{ jl ,r:"j / t 1.trlr- rl ;16 c.*l a"l >Frt
f"^ty; c*r.9r-1,.$ ! cs-,Etj 6s-s )1,,."5 o.r[.i:-l :i )lJL-;--c;:- *K.^: dl: otr^-a a, G Cll*fu-"^.r:"-Li$li,r^; pl-t56,o +5:j
-hC -..r--! .f_: a-, ..t-.! .ua1_4 dt"CU" )l _;? o:Li:-l eV e+ :*$.. S trL.-,1r l.,1 JKi" dr,l el: :* q IU,j- J* *t* 6 c-ib
WWW.AEL.AF
YPO !;U)i.rlrAl J 6>t" t.l;;
c.*j lJ t^c*+ j Larl.:-: pL; .!lya 5 64L-y" .J,U prr & ,.--h :t
e-p )l L:A ;.rlir+l.,>.r^) ,il;el,r4 J:^t5.!U 6 .3to,.tia,
y-t* .r&l-;"1 .Jt- r-l ! ..r.+-, J-lJ- .1-9i!: e-tj t..,,k-,,-Et ti6;'U
a:6:v F try,3J c-",*3" ti $t-,'1 6 jl* a,.Lo-r..T;.r y La:;^i.:
3.r)\.(l- ;K*;i ^S rl.: Jal-1> J;3 6r-> AJ.ls ls-t c-t-"lL a:..ilr
jl lr JT Jlj+ 5 :y ..r-al-,-,-it^.Ji jl J,J,--ti slr,JT jl..r-:U .gtall"r,cU
.) u .'o
o5 ;Uj U r,-tS.r- l-! JJJ erV s* * 3a jl .r, 6 JK i" d,Jl
t- L d--"^,.,r5;K1t- 4L4)) olr-$ t-1 l; r3'-- ..t-iljl 6rl"a-il ;tLie--h )lJtiildF."" b.f-ri-r crrJ..eoLi35 J) 4-+o^.:3r J-41,2>
elr, .J* Lql &-b -,1 .;rt.-** .3 ;(*" Jt ,^ ; >l;l 6131lS*.
t uy, ./)y *i ,r"b )l olis, t.ii lJ Yt rll; ylcLl.-t.i .tal3,-
..r-i;I.: .rJii ;:i y 4; JL- tr 4l;6,gL-e c,111 -,l: -rl5 .1U3r 6p;rL cJu-iL .:l;irr.--.JJ VU;l ;:olJ15 6 CV:U 41y' t>f Li,-.c.-.ilr J-lJ- olr-or a-, l-, cS-,LQ jl dl;, .(,- y *r! ttl; ;\: ;St;: +5.-:*l.;-t - c.rJ3. L5L-6;l,l ,r-h jlJti"*lJ.- JJ-r*.i t rl.!+-r
-r-,rJ c-*!- Cf-l lfi .-u.i .r-al3; )z;i )f .-il-r,ol c---(.i t i^i*" l6;t
cll ;t5 Jt--;r c^--e-o-7 ,.:*j !-{j ..rrt I o:l: ,5[5 l; ;l5 6;3op :;1.>
,:-.:1.: ,,Ki Jg-:- ,;!e;,51a11;l e* )lk" y,,Li dt-6:j^i-) L as
.rA) dl1lil ,t_*e1j) r>'-;-,t-.;J- c*.*a| 3-1jl.r: 5 c-ib -!.:ri,)li,r";.5oli +'.:--t-6J 1r l-"o*^; d'J'f J o$ ;So)-> "e
jlr*1a;.:Lr:il
fl"r.-.c.Jl.r toitt- *!u t.r-i a--a13,- st.ss,si!. oS 6>l,aJ,lJt.- J-
J<.:.- J -* k el:tr o3- J-al3-- J.ll l-r-1l;, 4ljtlri 4 o5..*l
jlr;;13,-r rr-J qgtib,; 61r.. >lr-sl aa JS: * tt-*J.rLittry;t3J-l oliedS J,", -.;Lb fl.sy J-nt-e+ ,&" A6t,# cSr!".:
6jt-jtt y )f dt^.r")L jlLrlor"-e j5-'. o?l4slJ;JSc.;- t 6
WWW.AEL.AF
,-!tt"lra \??
ctL*a a, JL -r+ ,-f -p :> .t-lja;*-c 6t-"ot(i.:3 L^.lLyL S)Vy I,f-l -*r* .-r,-lt-.l..r-i3; ;lj Ai )1.-':- t- ciL .:*.: ;r**, Js; ,_L-,u-alr; ,*l-t J:l-*" J)p- , rev Jl- t) LajT45 ':*l 213:-l u;Spl;l6T.ara.ldCxl ) )_# >;13 a."L*e djLj! J* q eSji,t3.l r;t+..ri LSly 6..*1 -9
.r5 .:taql ) -F -f ojlJJl jl ; id ;-U"jrta, 6t at o:1 .uli:lr-il oU; r:*-6.7 ;r J _f cf-&. a'.11 s j- Cb .f Lj 6 c*l f-e ,#t-"Ji 4J c*l ;-,-l r;b c-*.-al .jlIl ,)1.^ a, a5 .51a:( 4L: .\-uf ,l5 a,
a-i 3 r'rar 3)i o,--h -l r-& dL;r c-.6.7 ;r +iL-ai,9S cSt^cJ'i>U tr i,"!o[:-"--i: a- l; L-aoT3 o:rS ,-it-.i l-, f S ,y, rSArsJ cr,itr ,ililtsr 4-5 ,-S ,i-rt; +V f -*.$jL;[q ,_t-.5 ,yV EtJ":
c^;*-):yK-yi:.JU^J<1;: .a jla 6 cL3;1;.: .:l-u-l :sS p ;? ,yC
.c-*l oJiUL-j J):\.s.i;\ 6 c*l311. L-3-,'4 ,*:;r+3 coiiLi
,5:Lj :3.t-- U +! <,;i+ r"{ c;i/. ! .r-tiJ sts: ,SltL 6Lal*1
\-*_f i5-rL.":il cir.! t ot[r f*ly.f 6 -L.x!;1y-1jl,ula":q;1r,,J-lJ, t:5;-)! q 1-, L e5 c,.:*l .1r*.r*-U. ri,t-, ! ,:i pf oS .r+-,^
q! U J-^ e-5 c,*l J.rl $-+ .rldl.r )*t L; J.f*t- c-) ()l)
+5;--l .g:-! a:lr l; Eij JL- .,,, .L-^ jk- ti gr S:6 ;V JrUiU ,-# d.S .E;r r,-F eV 5.l.":.5 lyf sV Sl:.,_gta1;>\" 6*45 it-CL:" lU o: 6 f-&rl* -6, -,! +! ln 2,:>J,-irl:l,rt CL1: +5;\-U .itf )\ J:5s- t-. r-a dri ri-u.d3j a, .r;t"t^:, .<^5
_;.:* ry J^lJ, jti r;3*,tLa.J3l,Sla-,t - )l d: llS s u'.LsL..>1j.,"ra-o.: pt+;l t;-G :t g)t:p 6 13, rll-9,ra,t*. ),*; ;f g )tr.r-7
"f,.r.,,;,al.:Lllljldq :+V S> j t* y.L -,1
.i"f JtW t:l-j 5l ^
-;l 4 t g r :5 ;L .9 3 r rI .rJ :-r -S- -t--- * -S .lJir r r'*. *i, Ot l- t
cR €.r-1q <:'-,lL-l,.9t-oc-1ry-r- !;,a et-.gL- I $lj,r^: r,l l-l,l .r-i[ u^il: l;)L.:-' -r:.ra- --'fi -,;; j J-t- -sV.S. : "rtu-:E
-,1 ; l; :l;l .r-ll\-,S c- ll-1,;*r:! l-,
"r"'"-- (r - ut\::S '; "r:,i; ,: +5 c*l ,tt ..1'U*, .-rS |p\u1 -c^1'y l jL a..
45 ,GJF c*-1-,}; csjLGr .#, *!- ! -r,-! .K,.a- ,11"; ar'".- a5;,1 d ,-a: )li r-t6.::rK J-r+ ,J;r.s--l. u+i 4 t ,c.!.," ;;J tlu.r" .:^*L
WWW.AEL.AF
\7Y tr;Uj.-rglt J 6rtr' Llli
c)y,-*-oa ,{ :* i-;r o-23r .(-- jl 13- -.413--;.:Li "5
tS)4,
#lr- &- -r.r@ .&-F et l; ,.rt*,r(.r-; -t Jss tf 6 .,,lrr":l;ia,Hl +5 f-Jd* *--,1-tK1 "V; riltttf yL +.,4 6ty .rUl5,1 +-a jl c-lil"! .f B .:U, L .5jq:"1 c-"al,gl; Lna-13,- t*n,r-Ll J! l-t- ;r*";;jl -rr--r+,gl-^-r.-"i;.: rt:r5 6;L- 6lS.l-ar3f g;ia.dk +..4 6 c>2,X u^h):.
G>?:'f )l 64V.:;lJL-l L;- *.aa;r ot--i.r,*; Hf f*;.rJJ.,c sl rf
- u .,jLt o;**iU,_rls" )IJK. L G).rLr-ib fn & -r;! L7 a..l *-l.-
L cc^*n 6JU"J1t"Jk- q.c-*l.rJrl. G. f )lGt* ,1,lc6i131r t[.il
k;,tt- Ue J,-! taoi, t+;l 6rL \l-.J" 6 -t-iL o-\-.1 rr$:. 45 'i -*
osy ,_s.re * r*.f*lr os c.*1,ria:--[-i .,jk-;:iL,-r-Urr5.r-aly-,-[-.-.j Ji)J/c.t o)J- 6-l;y) 6 6k.,1*Xi..p;l.ri lt
\ d* oL, ;r J' :*,;3, ff :frfi:? ::: ;?l) I *,,iJe.,EJ-J# C-#._#L- '5brj-:-r
Sra-l,,.f +5 6rl.ill- - t'-
l; 6r;!13 .gLaj jtl,-rL-.i6r["a:il .:lrjl e] i J Js.r" rt-n-l 6>La-il
L a5 .t-:r.l,r- ---j l-t.,tt-r;*1t :-1 ,J+*a cJlA)sf ,l; i'U c..;ct-l .a;a 6.:t-, ,gL-a61t51-ti a, FV t;V)T;t.r^t drl3i r:*r il.61J.
, .l S n"z +. eJt-oL,; t fi-s , L-i +S r-1lr : 173 *+j .,1l s> ,.SjlS t)tLr-rC- ' a J rr J
s'€-- J) q* o;JJ 5r,r1! 3 c-*10)l) euiJl lJ t",J)\,ldt^:vl$t'-l
*cL^ql ,r^L(i.yL; > 6),ts-sst' 4i l-" J:.7J^ .c*l o:3-, ' ajtj'-
i;-r1u J". q -,--l
+5 * -ijt o-J6a 4J cfJl) .:,-:Lc OL;;.-oJ-e ))-- fS -,r l- J**j cu-i-u t-3- )l .t--,,j .*,f,.t-; dUs5:r-;
.(-^-+ r^1;,- ci1. Jt*+ -,td-,t" -i jl..rcL..71 )-tr-f p,St^U;l,1U
col ";)L;1(+;) a:.lj;: ot-"c^-:" g5Lar;1.r,L-l I csfdi;lLily Qlr" J*6 -,, 1r ,rj>t;l J;,^el oiL U 45 uiJ+ I s c65-P c-tJd-t"
.,.:*1,:-,3U:, :\* rf -*-f.,-s.f e- Griw?lr1.il" oLl;Jl
WWW.AEL.AF
,-|tt "lr l YPA
ar.lf ;* q .-*tp;.) 6 $lori "r:'SeJ ota n+j ,,t ;.l ,[,L"45 c*4 J,-lLgJ4j c-*l.ticlrb c.4.: Jl )L, )r l-- J*j "+i F6c.*j eo ',-t 4<L c*l , <: -i c- ,J, ,ll'x .>r7re -hV *..)t"!yrl- \- s- J -J- r - |
t-6# g*-r::r )-p o5 Ju*iq a,:.-xb ry>. -r xlie g-Vi s> -E; L^.li ss
.( &,; ,Sltl: tf se^; iU" 4jt-Lb9lt s_* yy -u!! :ljl:3,-.gly+i y :;1: )_trJ 6+ a' qg:rit c4-* 66 )l6_;t=.,-u.S l-G j>\.-l ..t-o[i
cSlt+ oL.}l o^jt* d 3 r;1.: r;r.3 lX;l * eU c-.-,a j 4 ,r_iyL6; .c-*1 t!*;) Se _* +i q ca;:, .r\L^J o:r5 f.i! ol; jl .,J6r.5 lri lr t""Jip"l! :lji: r.j! ,lu'tgul &-1p J::*" r-i,- 6 t-7,1i
e-&, oe*:, d,--ts 1 O a*-^ o";d +j L.:;1.: .,i)\;l ,i::lt, *.*,rr-c J) dr+ r:*q 4il$ t',tj-il € fl.6yl +J, rJq .lr;rr;L;Jd-*,* ria:il*n :-lya lU -,, 6 o*"la 6lbsl.r;lr rg3 ,-+lftfdjrL.45Ot-:"-^^.IJI-ti .,,!U* el; ,el_* ff -r:-a: gt+l15 rt5 U
; -,L*l c-"-*i c-*l ; \ r";,!! ,; 4 -,: d ,s:S f f l,,t:xJ u,q .'it - o7 .t(.ti.p[ 4;.:y ral_1- ^q d",;; o3,.! :W : t--dL-cJl.t-"15-,F- r- )l6r{; u-cc.-ilr .r-nl1r 6l\K:*g rbl;
ufc-:l: tal;621K yy,6;:L .:!,: :i" 45 CtV-t -r> rJt-";3-- -rLi-r +l ,-+rgJaj 51y.6>l;i,:t- J u ;.r!,jJ e\,. c) i*- j cJ,:4, u-, :l ; V tst:..,Ii l-, .,,tiJll;;.li;y:r L+" j)\;l ,t' 6 c*l,r^.i oy*,-r1.t73 ! aU")s-t P.:i ajlrlli.g # e""*t.lL--,+;.: l)rl,glajj;l j sSu-cll.t-7, JtE -,, 44 tJ. st$ J:6 t, d.c-lq:*. .t-r.t !y:t.:o5Cxl orUr 6# f**- e:sf ,-,!at r )l n tiLbJ ;l gKi ,6tS
"-**c.r,r gr"^,a;.5t^-bq,.[-".*J y n"-S S-&t 6lri -r,-t1LajjJlllJs
.,J::*a Jt-.:pU a:^--U 6 c*l.-rtj)\rlLlS 'J-L; -1 3* il r,<:i '1i,,<l)i '-l ':e5',1u JJ . .-J 9-J L . J v J l)- r l)-
(f ..^* (Benefit) .:*L 6[- *.\^s] s.:--l 6r* ,!t^ l-i als;,1 ,l .:l,i:-l) Interest .'\
WWW.AEL.AF
YPq tr;Uj.--rl.ral J 6)t, L.ly'
o.\-c-9 aS ,k.c*l/.i,UJKl e: r*J,,U.:t+l a,o c-*l or.l -"'ri''
j),[;l # J;\d-=- jl.r.jlis*j c*l tc!r:.*- jlaL,t Ji JelLj..lr5.r ?---*" ol.t- l, ,"xJi 6 -ryl: qt*rLi 6t-"oL;il:>.r-a c-t'iL
cL-a6;1;U dL;: aJ *4;* flrld.t-*-l5 r:* 4>t oli,-l idljl",LcC-l0-\-.X )^--Ai(c4J;i tSV *.cJa;.4.jt--ll^ GdJ.:;"ri 6 tTOi
L",St-P /-;^LJ blie o,i,r^Ki ar o)l;1 t'^:.--l-l- "l^'; a' o':111 gr 6
.f-l ;*l !c*l oJ1r.-..-.i,r- -P )* \t-,,tjail 'o3*'' 5:;1> 6\1
L- ry; J-4V o1-r!.-rl^-Le !-i +q tA:-M c*s 6 c-19..?ii ft+jl 6ty. ;! >Gi r o-.: pt+,t ;t--<- ,lS s-&t ,t -* eU G-€_r"e-,15i1! lq;l-f;; J,-t-i s )f .>)A,-L; o:r51.$ 6q L. )Pl-' c-i< dll.f .;>l; er.r;l: )-trs osi ltl-u'".f u. ';a\c'"-o;;.: L-a,5;1y1,: ! d-?- s ct:-p r"at-- i5taorLc-l r-f ! c*i 6il9;:
G:\;x">t"S ar-* Jls >f.JL*i" trrj cg1-lo-t-r teslLr-5,6>i >:l-f
.IA)L,, :lf >f eQ fc.-;) l: tS-&ra.:-i5-,-li;: e5 gla:;3r
S! ,-ry-, .f^- ",5 t Jq:^ilc-l ;K-",ri> cor'i a'K S rrt'b
firy. e f )L- o.5 rr?\-i)-i.ri ;,.-r^.-7 t * yJ .rL^:i. d3J, L 6.f*L*i -tlJl .f5 Jrt<. .,5r:t
,bt t {^xK L-^,li +, 6-# 6;l or51 6 cit^.s<J 6 c*l c*;)6ty J>t-i,La.(^-; ,-|-^; o-i J+L; c.4L-*l:y.-,J>\;:*l- :s]r-lL +Jt-1!31.:.5;tK.-o t o.:t;l 3 c*'-r:Sl.J.:6 r, *-S .>-,35*" jl.;lq,+
yS--> lral-e-c--,l.: .i f!!"J- oS :.y'r/ rf(:i r::o s t---:. ./fu Lj- J" _a/-l \
,:."-.**1Kir g-"fL-r Jfu jii4;Lal;,c-*l^; r iiA uli;r 1: r-LK;t ,: s "J'snf )-.1.J,t s, s-- u- 7t r:o Cl a,.r:J5i :;L2'11 nCommon-Weallh ue jx a
-9 i tt
3 ;*J o;!;: ;' ;--;S Jlt F ) 13 a LL'r-t ;i ;: +5 ':-l ,^l. "ra:.r" oe t 'Ss 6 ;i
o-. oS ri!.15 -r: .fL^:-l {qlr ,o+*. ,, .n:Jt .n-lt4 !:€j { lJ )-iP r(.))Jr) ,Fnt -rS
.n-r5 ;t5 {! .r.:t aa ! : .r:t"; oa t ;|Ka -e ,:.i*! L :/ El.u;-l L 5t- .5lr' +q .rJ
.rr-r5.r-, t-:;t ;t6.l.l.:;"t"\ ,5\r.11 u;6,K 3:;l .f.-;t)'Li rl=* \lf ;:n 6 e-l ,ft"4l J
*r 4 -X qU +l--: q.-<--,s .F t LJ,,,4^ "5 *!",",r, -n? 6 --' .2ii:-;K;.:Li:-l ji rl u*lb ;ti \) ":rS :;3;, nr:-l ;U ))Ja.)-)-.cSlrr anl+ t> rl\ ;\ uzV
.(fY J \fo,\Y2 ,\TV u#.[\ctl] .-,:.] u,1,,-u15i.;1.2"; r) (S'i:5
WWW.AEL.AF
.5't J, ! YV.
l.a,ti c- lJtS a--"1- .<." :r<L*," +5 .r::*o dLa,r<j Lflf -,:tK*U-^^3 J-a.r ;ll crl-6tq;s U :;l.l.-j 6k 6l Alf ge.c-*l ,r-(:"S|t r-"i )l Gk 6).c*10:r5.:ylj l; l-6,)iJJ;5U 45 LTJJ,!,JLA
./J- 4i-i ft+.;l glr :lil ;t--l j c>-c!l 6l1VW 7 ,.>-l+ili<a5rcll5.r--L-i ,gloljt "/L;il ;-*e,:tf a"-a: f bi6i,-,ryjU;lc:,lr ui^ti !
"liL"i r:*: F<, qe crl.r, .ri .,i)\;l./t-..:l
:* yrl 6 c**j .rt? t_ -u:t .,fu dU, ,.l.,i)t l ,gtajj;l 6 c4lr-i L lJ :3i aor> JSIJ-? _9 J5 .:LilJ ,q-l l; o!t^.,.i_,_,t "t'(ta c^:tj
J l; ,jYl-, cSU,.ij-, 1 ;l --,,-rt-L, 6J 1.9qc,-J3l 1.r e5 6t oj;;l ct:rS
;j& o_$i er- *. ,-5 rtc*|.r,"- :lSl L-r, c*-e& s sVi_s ait ,J"t( tclr| 6.St,tdbc>3)u." d;:" ,Jlcl3;: .rj)Bl 6t or;l.tjk-*l jl s*^-./q+ .,l;5 45
!,Srr, c--1.1a 6l"arll.rjL-l,5jL-La; fl t_, talr- ,jic^;K: Cl_l_,,J -fu .rtr-5,Cy J 1 .Jd.f .lr^a,rel":'l,5 6La:11IU-l,LiiJl
-pY! l-, b,.xjrt .-?J. )F 0!'-i-i a1 c*;.,Li r^ a:Jl.c.*l.rkilqeGils-;l> 6:,;l-L, .Kt- JJ:Slf- 5;l-r,al .Ll .ra.:.r, :l; -t,;.-L,\, ,-rl s1;,.,^lt c-l;K-" b"fjrt,4L ! ,;f,1 ett';.: La.J,Xj;l;1-t5 3 -u"15j ol1x*-r, L ..; cL "td *-.; r, .glr,-ij;1 L, * f-ua: oLli L a,
f+Uf f-eJ l" cll;-i,.51a.r."1 y [^[-y_, ! .-.t- )5 (',))A ol;1r;-i J ol-",rsJ'1 r;l.rlb-l ,t-cill +i (c*; ,g>V .g-11 crl>\1 Jl'|:",|,.i- t1i.:;l: -lp tS-s,t-! oor;.: a5 qgle^"i.-:: c#, J:,e_, b"-i:t^,)i+5l,f t^.r; t o)-5 o\ra S r;b ;3,7y u,>y ol;;- [-..r:-r;1: r"r:-lt-,.Tfr:5l.t-i crjUJi*-r-^.(-- s*rr ,Sl;l:.tLi.grL "Li-, e!,6>l ;i -j1;l .sL-^.,. jJ I
f L"r L.i f c,**+ J- : pt 1")\"t-'.,c.-u-
-r: )-p ! plr;-l 3 ru*lr$y: J * ,6rS.s c^il.t-." 3 c.}-i>r,J>t-i:-l
.il..o;" Oi-uoUpU;L "sJ &-,t: i-t bty j,)c eV q.rt-jt d;fSf.f .rlr ,-:j3ri u'f^rji ,-rrr o[--ayn .ll_:o q 45 J:*i
I -tr.t.."th ..rtt*). Ilr'rrt r^
WWW.AEL.AF
YV'l tr ;t j ell-Lol j d)t Ljlrj
t-6,)i 45 JJ, .r-l oi .r-q 4i1$ l; L-ool.l 6jL-c*: eI7 6J;l'*l7 l rJ;-l.gl ,, e-LJ t --S -pJ) .t--q cJ ..t:.*^ cS;J-,UJin eG)y(i-- ' vr ' r'
j -Q-* : tss eilz 13>l;i ': jo 6tl1i f': L^'li f*'"t-rs cr:3"1 a:ili(
$J;.JiL- J--l ol-ie--L- s5t-a:;l,Ik-l L-tji -J:*+ g;3 oLa .5:lji
.J::---6 crtt*1,tt-c;^,t,JL^jU .Syl.u 1l ;)l-&r,t:f ;Z*" 6l; ,ll-.itr.!--l
,g1"a;y5.gt-.+ a-i ca;* eG,sj 6l;z-ol ,|' 1,|-isl e u4*:,
.5Lal l"r-ct-; l, -#,-t -tl t : f J 4-i,Jt"t-r c-=",41 j I i-:,.: +7ra cei.L;
4l:aln "! t-i *J; qf t cJ3r ot,l"ril L-i ,Ul;4..t^:r$^ijl.:UE; ,ct:.liK;; J$-*,-* 4il<loJ,;U c,ro>;., jliL"i ,j6 *.-Ely;.:4 q,a cLac.--o.- S:Vl JU:t ,U ,:t ,3-h dirr.riql
.t-ir-S;qj.:", -,-f b 6t^Jlrl L*i ,f15L- 4-l ct-..ri)\;l f- 6 c.*1,liJ^r../ dti rrlaJrl i.jifL.iiiiiiLS ,srlK$c.:LilgUjlG-,! -, L^Jt, 4JJt-+*a..:*10-t-.1' .t5 ccl$;e)J->rlc.*Ll(t iLrf-..i j:.*.(.i o3-u .r-;l-p,r*j *rS g-y-.-,f lllrt"lJ LA,)i # J- , !, 4 6 .r:-a ei )l ".^q-,a
a:*<i gblr"f-.lLr.+t+ +7 3.-IJrj,*,,r."..rilJ.ll-:.r;r" JS: LS-)-\t',St^qt, ol-* y
L-t: cJ5.r-. .g)Jr+^ L^0i45 6tA {*l yc.*i cl-a.:;Ji L*if.:*lo't--i i*f--A els lt".gnt-"Jlf ,) i^hal I JldJl-1
e)f eo c^ir.:?, )l 6-,j1;lcSb(,n,jrlrr ;:# jl o+y .(+
;-l.lii.rS,r- f^li rft 6lr' u"aV 6ltb ,)V Jt-;.r +5:;l: r3"-.3
,L -#r-l J-./L-U a>.-:l t: 3 oJ,-1, d,\K el ;.5 a5 dtA.,<i 6 c-l'l-" t* 3 -\:i l:.r-" dt*x J l;;1 i;j : La.l;J L- tKl 5 -u:"-^a 6t'^.lt^-^
"Uj :
.r::-il:1t-:;l;r ..rLr/ ,al 6.att,r$..rj;l.r loclllr oLi6rly a, .:U:cl
4"*r,.4t5iby"- y D,\.i:-ljl .r-i.:y .:-rlf -lul^ : t*-* -#
WWW.AEL.AF
u!:r, o11o YVY
.rKJ-i -r 6eir -t .3p q-r elrol cl.aal- f 3 JlSt I l;1.r, 3 a,L*.-o;[5
j)Lrl U as.-aL^rt+ J p.^^ !1p .JU:il J .::Ji q c,*i dLcf p:s3 a:--!lr l; .:y.-- c5L-:_r- ,Jf * L--^.ti;.: e5-;l-r53a.>
cc.+lo.:lr JK*: lJ K-r"i3.:U*Ktj)t;l ,SAi ,F : rrl" c*;;a-,.ri;1.: {\t;Fr;.:)L_L.; r dt-S ea $r+, 6'u*a dt^,)1.^
.c.*lctt-.i.grJrU Jt"- -s> rg*l+; I1!c-5 c.*l -)y G\,' ,;, te,ilJ oJ-ot j.-.;r,_rz.;li:Ul3a:1,ratS
caS u^3 Jl t .c-*t a:-l-r cllJ, *t .<i .,!)\il a7 uc:-,. ,S66JJ6k & ji< A-.rt-,=" clL- ,i)V +^:,**a.gly 4U ccl_/G
^n< 6"Ljl dlj-., 4? f-1 L; c.*L .lt-; 6G.tK; ;-;o.r5rrJ: jl,r5,- .r-t;:.-ry5l c*lo:l:ot€ 4-.i ,Jl* 13L *c.1l:*lK;l 6.lt^j.t AJo"r-J.d
6-;oe;: e5.r-i1l: jl.:Li:cl&, d ,?? )l -bur*,J*,,;r.Jui3U:. Jl$tjlojlll o-7l; r_#.f a=Li fJt; .rl_2-" a, ,f*tir*=K|."^L-rA & JL c-1i,"".n ,;K, otrrrrr:,! t a4E"j .-u:--ilr .r_rLii 'e.? f!f; p jl dU.5J!*r .r+;^ -.ri:3r Jlrj.Jl; .! .j[jl .'.lL",o +-., (c-Jl.+f L- J64l,rL""
";Kt ):yl ,b
t* "[YrS
dL^.-iy -e t-ae-i-sl .:-l;(, .r5i .:ii--" 6:t- f ^?-U"
;: cdt.-aty*r:*rL.i;t* -l LacSjU .rt* -r.: l_t )s .A.! U-:r: ct,ljlr;,,.K,. jl ;1,-!L: .f)_," 1t *.t c.:11.: ,rSIl .5F- oj--j jl45 dL^"jJ--t" J", .cl .eoyrX( y
Ya;YyBt" c.:* .t,*^-; os +!r a& ,trt>*t+-p,ltrj 4, *. Jtf J& n5 \ ,gxjLL-9; fltl.,.:*l Jtr bV
ar{l oi 6t-^.lL;i 1l c.*l drK-. } t r .l:-, y' - .Lrli -r.olr; nl::S,r,
+:-.ll:,.r;Ui,;+ r5,r- J:t*._l L^JTrtt t,fV :* yt-a,)t-il
.r-XU
; oa;"-b l> 6ra .ll *tr-; cl-u+i,"ati cSL^.J, jt l +, .:tj:cl rtLj
1. pa(y liberalism 2. Disraeli 3. Macaulav
WWW.AEL.AF
YVf tr ,,:Lj,rl.l.al r SlU r,)r
il,aUQ; .:LiJ-i 4jli.",-lo)Ji;1u, a1 c*; e t- e y :-1.x,_r-
j+.J*i "ljl.c-l
d*1$ 0t,4L*ls,-s.3 r-t .!J^ ,y+.i t 6t:--.r*'U -;tc.*le;L.c 6.t p,6y 4.;b.:.6.7.!q!i g c-iltj,,glyy ;25 e5 6;L^:" 6l-ai-a--a; J oa;.^* gL-aJj-,l yitt;St.)l-1!;,-r.>3,. r-il.r. J4l c,Je.-r5*- ,i)U Olr<-: a-,..tio.rit-Li
-L-sclrE a,.ri:l:,r, c-a-71;,-lT+5 JLJ 5 c*l,tipU, t1;uf(t-:*)
jl45JJ-ll-r Jlo:l: c.#) jl b 6)<jlo-tJ e"at- 6lag"jtl r 13>:lu-l
.rilor3-, JiG y"t5 J:5.,- r.)yU'"" Jl-&rjllJ LaJT ,S Jql.rl-'"-"-b y ai !loJ.:- t l: ,l:V dt-lJ, oJ:SU ,*-.-? Jlj(fr ss r€ls:)
oe;tuLgb.:,i- y LarU;: l;,r5^l *-$-*.rJ:3"1;>[i L* urngL^.f-,-,!!;* J$li,ri L^.-*JL-r drl4l.J:5 oJ-oLl, *-t<;t+5 c.*l .lL^rt+ J )*-*-G y-",A,..u, ) f {. Lo..tT ;t tS-tQ. +5 .,iyrldt-c*Jt -3-, J+! :yy,- ail.l*L > rSy I ;-,-l 3 .-U.r*i,r-" rf L; -r,-!
y*S o:J,/o:FOLaol-t ,y!l_t.o3Vi jt.-+ Pl,"6roj 5 .3tn**-t(t ,$ e rt2=11 c-ito^:, ./q- gtl+ e-.-L- y gLJ*
3 rlL^1ln d.,x# a(l n.:rS.r,. W ra-ft 6 J:5.," W.rqj trlc.tiloJ*1 )L+a d.L-* utCr.ti + rrc-i,l.:.Jr!" +5 -r::.ilr l; "/tjyrlk. : 1-5
4j;-^, .5tr**J33t 2[o; o,;L;: r,-l +5 :y -,, lyJ.rt +q J+r^
..r*:tj o:t-p.:"-:li,_t t-{s:;--lrrLly o-u-irt-?.il.:[i'!; Ly 6al a, rU:plLl
.<l+" .t^il .<.- -r-.l,U a;-1,1.: l"oJU I I oj-s a, j L rtt:"--i.r J G.!L, ;lr--.iiU *-l-,!y .G-f ! J+r^ ,l;lS1r"i j,JU.J<l,Lo;Ui.c.*1.(;lr5;*r J a : Lf-tu.i!..lUr"jJl -u.jU, +5 "u-L.x..r" .ri[5lJ I"AJJ"1.5 crL-ail ..u-li -,* y .ii F ary) i)J.. y,6R 4? J .---.?orl.,.;.: Lroiorr5.r-eU:. 6i:i :, L6:j4j J+q;l.r:*lo:r5;L^:"
l propaganda
WWW.AEL.AF
,.5', s-, I YVf
-L^lF Lajirft g---* t jliq:"lr.rrl.:.gL* a, ;,lca--a>t<:5, J:W.IF
f*Jt=-r- g-l".rr5 "r$l L^ji jl t- a5 otJll-u 6;bo-t-l "r=Ji;! ! .rr
rri lJ-.-.i -r.5,-tJ6rt(*^ \\ rt u,a-a;: t rg i1 +,1 r,. c Re alp olitik' Jr,lt ,-^l:L.* 45 f:5 -r-cU:. 11 L^,li c.*;t; f"^l,; L .f.^, yir; lJ LaJi
c:y,-- t-a,r-lf ,.: fl.J;;-..,!-l, >s:,,_r d, Lpl;e-c^.4Li q o5
45 J,r* u* t* *. f t ,sS 7r:", \:lil 6:t-x y ,5:l1i,gYl3 .rLyi
6r- )l ;+. 6k 6?.u:1* 6r,13 -r;l.t.t drj l; jj;l .rLior.;.r:aly; ;iK ,gly.6h € c;J>.;) cliloJ*; ,Jt-L t"6,)t"Ji45 c-+c.5 J::.--A a*,K 4:C gL^J;!. G_r-* t-;r--t +*^ la.rlJi6ly .c*i,lr
,:V e-y t,.,,al,r J*, t-* t-acri j -rila:i; t!; ol: q LW.til; t"JlrJt.oLJT..r;! .5tj-r^ c*l ;S.^" oi ,lS oljr 6 Jj:*^ dJ{J- J ;{.i: .lUtr--t -l ulS--r"i 6L-a.:;* ,sl3:.e +' La,tT;Lp-;*a a-,..;T -u:lr.r-J -dL,U,-#i eS'i-$"U"t-t "r:S.,-. l j,ci csLXt,.- -1,-l? qgl.a.lL;i
-,t-i:jla5.r-al; Ju-i[ o*.l J-c,lto c*,i;<*"..r:*a Jt:..t rt<JUUt+ t-AUb; oi ,r5 -t-oly; ,tLi.tal"n:, 6k € Ll * 13, Lt; Jl.:t'
.J::-*a .)Ui J,*. olLl: .5r:E dt-L-:AlJ t^.rt<,-J"i
.^-:k, -rr 45 L: f+l:; J** L^jUit c.,+i Ly st1.S.-:L-^,:i.gL,^r.:,; sllr'-: f5 -rt*- Ir! !-r;r,rL*jl..ldly dt*i.<J d3;
,-*l:-t l; Laoica-r3i 15l*.J;^*A t dt^e}iri t t^jiJl ;/J4)i.;l-rl5 o: ; .(j .)qi 4j 45 J;lAnJ .:L- ta,ti:c*l ,>f ;rsjl*. : tlv: d.grl;1a-5 .i5 !;.rd*?*;: l; rc-$ .t.jli,r-i dUjt*.St-.*UQl J ti)LJi a-,.;T.c-*l ca)-;1u e1 3; rli ;r 6, p 4 -pcgYJ.^,-!li" r, cat -- jl c*l .r-,!e +*a jl u-; cJ:-at_9,-..r" *Jo*
"<!,r.f" ./L.i" 6 .lr oLjL,Jt,q yU J ?lJ,s\t) d -c.-35-.0l.^: .q-F dt.adk- o;L3; ;:iL ,9lr;6>l;i .-^^.-.J t *i* G*t
1. state sooialism
4. decency
2. <<scientific>> planning GJ:..-: i jl JJU) 3. corporativism
WWW.AEL.AF
YVA n;ujdu^t r GG \t/;
;1 c^,ot-bl o-: L^alQy L- L^.llK--,"l ;l c.rt-bl .l-i'r.i:,." oyq cc^ ^ri ,ti
"(;l-53*r 4;L^ot-;T^5 .,jk- 1: -ti.rii^ r.r;q t-.1.>;b grl b.r-.r,6J* L. tf eie|fi:=U Jl-c a ry Ju-al3> ib ;."5.Iilol.i ;y*,6la4:s 6toc-,L .?J )l c-"1L-- | f)ig c:r5 "u-al3'- cs-a *
'gj! ;t.l.i*"I ;^'-:ra>|ti r+W rlJ i r iP il-*Gei}_fr-"t k"- r, jt\ .1:* rSLau.ij-,1+-, r[l:-sl-t--t: +^a rlJ-el,1.-1".i orjr: ;*--i:61-a;y'.1^5
J o+ et;,si ! +! -r ,'1-rr5 J-ru--l LajTrtt- \ u:K:, d r*tjLr! "l tr:S1U: -rJ":y d["-- LaJU, LgrL*.i: 6 ciLa,]l,Ji jl.,iyrl.:rt-.X;U a5'/-l '# d,j c,a2,r J) 5 7)\el 'ri; U a.jco.itj*<. *:,6lo,r,rl3,-;j-cv- v--. L:, / (e v-
a-rLnl9c."1[-; J,-J? .5t^Q$lJ Jl; .+ ,Jl^,ij;l cr! **TJU: a,
..*bry.e U;i,* d.f-F oJJy clL.- J e a, rLc-el-r: *-!.f-:^*a
c5ljl .,-Ll .:3U;,Ulr;,r" aS c,*,lo.ll: ?:t_/ dL,_fL-^-l .3t r:tai;r L 5a- L" ;Ll;-r;-f uU",t &t "<! c-\-.iL a:--1,1: 6t:: rt-a:" ,i:-r yr t-t
3lrl-u" "|-rlr.;**"
3.:l;il-l K.r"i, "--t<t6ta;35
+5 6Lnc.;*.{i.f tL.*i c, aS c,*l dj.",JL-n prr," c,.:*l or,,9i;L #r*"
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
l0 duw@su;x*uf-JlJJ, ,u-lfyr6L^.+r* pL-; .:*l lln,J11$ gt-h;...c*l $t d-;elL, : a-tlyr-r:b ,"at-,a:;t j oi r=*a A* )l l1 .!G" .:;-ti:3-l+r cCJ3.: ar oJl-.ir.cr-l ,3J-- e-JWL+;"; -,L<. 6lt- c*l d :.t W r,l 3 .:jL,r"
.nl)J" J5 .:;.ti,5J, qJ51
AySlr-J
UF **,r #* rli;.:a5 el4r6jlrla: ,slo)r 6l r,d:;U3 -,t5 or o13 )* yjj:^lrt{.,"[1JlCr"t L rl31;1..t^inS u*:t )l &; j4 Lb clj-6*".c*l a;l.:i erji J/ ,*;l;-)l"r:* t-"f-l.,1r 4U..:-loJ-.l ^rJ-Sl-J
i;J"is- L q .4! qr+,
rJ.r.:*-A ;.e J-rjJL' n+i-lt6,116Lac.--fby 3,'..4U" &, AVe
J..W'rJ); +, c*ldJS.-. 6 S_r'S ?p 6t-ac---il.:r, C: )l )_*.:y:' St-," cJ:nr..r,o .-fca La.lT a;T
;;3 Jt-yreJr, *.3g11,".6;l'a*K .,,J) jlol+JiJ }L- -,* *.5 q.grL.":il GaLuVl flrl-,,t e:V.6 .:-l ;l c,c.*l
>US -g 4-t.iJ .<.- )l u-- rt-.,j e "f"-c
.:1ly * ,-*V.(- .fLl-,t
WWW.AEL.AF
,jrt Jt n YVA
J+.:"..'1.LJ19; 15-r+.)G)Url a- roi ,. o3)U c,9 Vr ,a 6>l-a.3,1
45 \ G*lil f tl)i _t* t tS:-#-,^ *5.rt j U 45 c-;l3 C_l.i-t-.solr.(; AU 6 r"r^ cJJl:.r, ,-' j)L. GtfJT it " t oJ::._r c^(- r),l+! C! t" JL67 ,b; S:tSt | ,_# s-.1,:$ u,;[5 a, .c*t ,3ioU;
drt ;t g-,!.: .c-*l,5, :J -,-J'U rr*rtl, jJ-:Sl (c*ll: -ualri :re-y
6tsult.:L"Li" 6 -u..-,o Jt r!J"U G:t* trQi sg.:La:il tSt-:b?1-+=*; c;lyLr !.r-i;!.:y 0+ jl l-, 4r"1.:1..i'U fL; j;" 13b ,". t;.|r,,.
c-S)- -lS: f. $_# 6t-o.:,-r3.t^, )Ji tSysuLJ kJ,i,U,rl.;:?l..:3,, rnl3,- taYK y .:lit
u-elj 14 o+J6l + Ll ry'.r,. o.lak" ayJ + -;J 6 e-f _f
G\V cl:a)c/ :lS it c-..*i lr *lr1 _t Ce 45 -u-*a ;\rE c,-:*-i
-,rS 5- ir-* p[^; ir,1 oJu.i AJA ,r,:,a; t* y.g.:L.a-il.r(**^ ;t .S
r * cSttME-r. L.;j ;r :tJ,:. gL- ! +l+,JLo5_il )1,:*q* s
AL-a)y +5 c*l ,-'lL, +, s 6-tst' u .*_*g.r^:U c;t _,L- 4q cr-jL ,_5t::'ry"-J., 9.;="-c.5L,a.:,A -fra: ,;--l ,g3.5 oj9;-\* 6LZ*l.5L"1j" jl.r,JLd" 6t+l_F *V ":f .(,- _r) t>,_j.Ac a36-l
6l.a,r,l;lr.l1-r:r a, -iJ:i. .5t-a;J.5 CU ft.-r-i[ a:-il: 4:tl^o:fcSta t <,,rllJl;., q5.:[.a-il \l:t fl J ril3,.J":l.r.Ji La;y.1'5 6! 4511a;l
1gj-^: gL^.rt+ ,slj:c a- 45 J-t ot !'rL1l t -u-q :lrJl;," A}"l-r +5;l't*".gyj,U./h-l ,* ,.e:t' yl;r c-rj3.i ,J:-r+ r,.r:t..r; ,ra.[LjLa#..ll-6, jlF- r--1.-r-i -u,atf L^c^L JS,,..1,r:*-.:r: -i)L;ls_a':j L- Lac-Jy-: a,.-1 "J51i-., or;;r-(La L a5 c-*l .,;t ^icpL; rl_9-" t* Lr-,I-,! or;3ie*: ! c-.-6;;; crli; L or-i.raJLjl-l; .:;'r-i a;L*-" L, 4 G-e C-l.cjt- -ralr; di^t5,pJl; .:U>\=t+f
-.1 or-,5 o_*e.-tjlJ, c-:G; nr:(-"l^Srr6;L:-l :* y *i U"F"q
ab er-c,.le;ti 5:-a t 45 -\*i .talr,- Jn" ef s -u..jrJi 6Lac.Jjr
c5L^-,bi_, urU Jt-- op i a5.r:J9r gt^rl+ a* e;:L.a:il .r)\"t- .-t.;* i
WWW.AEL.AF
YVq !;k- gtr ,sL*;r-i,
Sk e:^., L-^,li oK-u-L*i ,e oJuli dJ .iit" jiU d ar..$ y. ) );.r+u o;.ri 3q
^. ,fU,';'^,-:q-t, ,r Ly:- gt^cJ3: gt- jlr,;t.r:' r^t-r;
a,:lJ!" l:g 1.: f-" roG61,' )l (5R 6.:Uit e.o 45 ,y. :l; flJt-;t S*o a;6 Syl,g,;-rU &* *.: p U-l:: e-1; Gl^&\S
.r-lq G-*l-,-t f!l-y- L 6 rsL;: rr ,,(* c.:y rygL" \ tYl
dj-tr 1-, d-,!*r -U gbf-l[-r jl.rk- a5 r,1.rlr c*.(..-: .prcol;.--,.:*L-j.jl}Jl,li y,):r:3U:e a^ ! .:fta -r: I?-,^ ;K.-^ S
5u;j,.a ; "r a ,'r-(.*, La;tJ .-r:""^,^ -&.*! *y*, ,f )A -tt : lf ,*-l r'v
.tJ* C.rr-t t^.f-e ,ti -,:; dJ5145 4jJS.il^-a c.Uy' rl,r$ 6LeeLJ +5 r;r,-'5,, lr, Jl-r a5.r-J:y,;L;rtLa,)i6 #, il-l *.Gr*\ 'J r' Je
.-r:.,r...i oi6L*l; g cSro S 6S*,tu :3.q.-c"-k, t: fr 6t^c-L1J--*. J-56- o.L---l \,>lrL;;,,-l qgr3-t-- U fl.r-- 45 LrLa,)i
ft+;l t;t-* , ,-* -..1-L .5:La:il 6t:an}-t +5 J:5.," 613 *i e,1.5 .l-l qJ-a L"l ...rj"1, .*"5t- UL^:k, ,;1. "a]-- s a: c.rir- ots
t *;; i',r;+rli,t jl.+U )ti:i '>l *h; ,-f t (i: il'r;li.rr.51+,1j13;-rJ sGC) i,.:? jl 6.5:li1 r-1! Jd q t,l ,-uS aj *6 eF -t; *-,1_," y, 65gly,> 3 '>l); Jl ..,5$l eS;.r .-r5,-r,.
1Urc--l-la 3.-gi ;r +5;).<-"- .rJ11.: cc-*-.ilr .t-alf .ri :, Laoi )l.6:..l.;"
d,p-lo-5 u,lK^cJ.--1./ )-ffJ 4,.-U *,51;r ,5rLe^ilJJ".l tut^Ki
tu 6lg*s rL-l,5;.i,U.-rVl:* qr'-\.,lq 6V e:t+ 4. )-fl s,-lla
grlPli,xi J) b.,irrt-, Lr-,!- tLii oty 6.r"t<^ .$; sl-r=,.9-
S iSt:+,,ll e, e )G ')JJi .)f;': jl cJ::'*r r*t, -r'-t, a'"LiY 'i- +' a5
3 o:lyjL.> &- 6rL,o:il o!- G ts uV -t.-u! .-S-ir*t+ *tr.r- g;rljT
VL5 t r;5 "fl,."-r.: +=':;, Laul at t* r'- J ,ts@.(\ CfV) JIJ\ j- d; : g:l-":gt 6y-ru\,, dlrj, lr ;+l-, "j,r) ) j-r))i
(1 lf \ ) ;-y-r-. -Aj:\ jlre L (James Bumham) 74 -,t ;"* fe" .:tS ,ra;, t P * .\.J"=rl;
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtt ol, tr YA '
.)3- JilJ; aa|9t;!.t l"b*;61^,5;1r, !.<aF 4."t ,51 )*pJ 4rt- o:^5 il-i-nl?+i 6, J uel5: t:lr9,r*F, rt-r.-1r51; !,Ll.gLaoL(.u: "<-i_6 A*.t-? 6 -,, .tL-,-r
",ilil;tji y :i ,". ,F-y p)
oJ-i+:i,r-L ,i):l cSl^_,t+ 3 oro-c c5L^_,15,r--; c.-al t + !5j5a-,."1+ J;S L 1-"1.c*il: J-aly+ r_9,'3 6*. _t
"..1.,
uV_f:,5_r!_r::ja: 6r:*5 rlaj c;Ut .5|-a..tT jt3 tJ-.I J^lJ, -# tr:J La.li:1"r,;
.c.!! "talr;.ilil_,Lli y :i y ,Fy o)Jt' c,.:^.xl: J^lJ,
;!*'i3:t-;145.rjy' ./t+* .-,,t-ir c*lF* r-rjS y' frJ,cc*l rrrlL-l,r 1;t,gyj)S L- n,tLir3,-l 3^i r>.:* *i y..r-;l.,1 U "r:5
Ct- .i" jty"X! jl,jrJ"x5 r, ,-56,a U r.5.(J a53,lU_ J5.(.5.:t-:L-e a5 c.*1.g.:lil a, .(o5.rlpl .l'U- eS.rt"j tj .Sf, a*" 6S;l* y g-,t5 \l-J ),.e L-cc*Lii L" SltJLif,c;61.a.*: t- oUJ;i:;,t'\:ta lJ t^Jif*l_1,,-f Gf L.aSgg:lrilrs t: -uTl: U)i rr*,q+,Jr!".i .tlJ q,)t*i,-*L" ryJ, e1 +.rl^ioK-ur 6 6>lj,la-, 1-2 La,r(- .K : jz)l 6-- 5--f# PV:\ r"*cc*L,gta.t34:)) r;> i5.rLe:il GyLuVt jl;U .r)\(i c*l,rrl5 t"l..t,JJiJ,",
cshdq! 6 f-- 4.J:" U fJ! n*t, -b st\ C.-f gl!,::l # 6laih-,tS ;r*: xlig ,# q.r;lri r3--3 # q.gr.€d ,* 61t../)t;ltJ-iL a:-il: : j-> 1 s-l
_2p ua.$ i .:Jl-r-" a1 c.*; ; ;b.gt o,.lLri 6cjL*jry.: jlU J5:-la 1; e3sy J*t- c.rtJ_.r .r-;l_e1 n5 dL,"Jt"JiL-,-t5 .(J r_j,-.Jfy, ggb.,a a U o:r5 -E*.*:3,- 6.1L,^il c-i,&a- L; .t5 c^il.ry tf U*s.: c-ti 6*. Jr-,;t;i f;l5 a-5r,1
Gt;l;jJJli-S o-5.,,-lL-.-r.i! ..:r5 .(J t,-gi-rt-S -,, JiU .<rK,
frs.(.5 t]b-l,i.r.l, ,s-+ a, tj:jb; 5;:J*-sUt,5 c.*l#, ixl* Lr., r-tJ;hJ.:)\(i d+) t._IL; frr" ,51 -Sl
dr-ll J--li +5 -r:^--o La..tir3,--;--l l5,r- ,4 ca:*jl-ti L a:*jl.: ct-arti
l. Coventru
WWW.AEL.AF
YA\ tr;k- str ul^;ry:
oLi;r; c,-j-bjlt6JT15 #r..,*1q t-y S J* olf-; cSltl:.r>\(i,JL:" .ll,i',-" q. .IloJ-: ./[q-" qiYrLe j *lit"d." :* yrl5 ..xl pla.,l,Sl;
.5;: l;6Lae"Uy & p* J p dlj*)jl*l J,-U d- ta,r-t(to-S.f-lt-i J -t:-.xt .:.-lillr gJLuV. ^rW -r: i-"oTc*ldr<-" 6 J;5,s.
.<{ }-i ,.:-l ;-il" r"5.SQb"-rl ;i 6>\-ejll'4tu,i at"e trL*
.:t^."-a r;PfdE*J<l i f -r-a.r;,ery gt ,;Fb--r * u,51c-u--l,L ol*:, !L;l .(jlr53,"r
'* -.qJ^r,1-, ,rllJl;., dtr rte, 4ljf-t oYl;-alCU.a sr- c.-,+:l J. & rilya a5 5rl4; tS,.1.ll
*.6s-r CU# 45J,1 U J5lrLe \ u2ja ): gt-* -ir+, q +t ;i 6.r*l t- y -r-! ,ra'u' oi 1l ;,1J ,SFb; 3 ty ,S,,:".lLJi;r .:-lLr L; r- pl-4pLoj e o-t--x-r:L-a rJ.s!t; u oJ)a)taj X"U ir;. .J LJ
t;y' +:.:ff or5-rJi .9Ll;;5 )W;l_, -,[=1 ;r nT ri)t.j-l:; rJl.-.:r.",Jr[-i ^5ls .*-S UL* 6rL,^-il.rL- 6;r,-l tt+:c4l,r.a s 6tsu\t.fulr5y,": 6Loo_9.i ,h) )l bl_y,g :_*rt cS-r!*r
drK-. gysu\t & 6 c*l;)\(5 -il ,J.tS u^\Ki p* -S.:;.r;jl r"l* ..r:--..r1lJl,.,. * .*- 9 ,gilonUr .-u,i! a:*ib 3,;r c*le>*l 6rAtc"ai -,Lxi ; si oyG )l t eA rJ" C-, y 6lsanlr,
a,,i:i 45 dj* W ;_#e r.,q", olf-": J *,S "); q Li S-t-ii cltory ..ri6, t: l.a,rjui 6 Grossraumwirtschaft cd c.*l ,,,1 .:*1L a5,-9rl! c.!L-.r: ui; 6yl+-f _,* *. it tU 4 al.+y q
c.*l .1"*l .J:5.," &"*J bl -&t J I s > F 6tno-r,l 3 -i[al pU,_r*:,_,1
I L-^-r-,-,io-, L-^..ri o+i lb J t-"Ji,JK- J dJ"> 6 f:5 :s* flJ c-,+;r--tic.*Lacri gV6*.+ aLiJ -[.a, ;5'-'-f ,1f g;6bl,1i
c^tl-t-a.,.:*l a:;L"./l-:?l"l.tU r+ l-,t j.t yl +5 c.*t-a,1i..1."o .rtiJy+ -r-:":t", l;lJ-t"l-S 6U.r"jJ1J LaJUriL l)Jr 6)t.ajl.:L.-4\ rS+_f irjL,re )F;3j jl"rLc-la, 11rr-i 15 c.*l6tac!_r:^-Jl^ei;r..,G;jljlll :i rl,:; r-.rl ,; y-;41..1i1r +5.:_2.: it-;l
WWW.AEL.AF
,_5't J-, n YAY
J> jl d+ r,L c-[loJ.i I'U ta,riJt 6 crLa,)i;; ;.r 5.rJt^r[r:;1.r,;L
.'-r;U;>Ut;rtK"l.r-- U tl*- s-rri 45 d -,:u, jl,r:--:;1: c.T*il9 jJlr.-iLj oly.--: f ot.;-i oi aS;t JL":-l t,l .J-:U Jftf , ">,lf OVri
*<-"U gL^-,,L^" ur.. -:U:cl a, !.l::-.-a 3:; ,k b--, J .-SJjl .,l;-11 ",L $_& Jt,aU;*t ;r ..,.rllJt;- ty"l ! dql-, _t; olJ +, r,.:Jl-t-o jJl:*l<l1):- d t#ecrYl,r"-.c*l )L L^iiart-r,t +, ct-a;y.i^S yL-,, d ,---* "te.,Alf ;I-.-<a ::6)-t*,d/1jlJ,"! +5.tj;l.:,r";t4.Dl
cc-l a:iL 34 J-b ,t 6 urV6t,a11jl1jl-r*i!;rli tjb-r1 c--:-c,:i.:t-y-J. t-r oS rr c"-l-ta 6rr-t {! !:rlJjLjq s t;-,ls,}"l5 5:U;.1
l, F ;y"5 rlilfU.Sl; -r "r.i! a:ilr 6:***a;U*Kt eb eVoJ:.A)JU,j-a Lpy..l-il.r, oi6lr-, ;-r-,a:--L.i l-, tP r; 6.r5;*.'U4J s-ryrl c..--G ;1 3 o.:r5 rl-t$,rJ ot-ra .(- .:l:Q:-L, ;,1 6;U;.r
d}l.; i1,5c:;1., L/, J) .,el-Lala;< t cl'!-: 611 ey3 e#:tr,y,.tJ:*
oW Sf y g"-l-t-a otl"l a- :Li=l rl-=,-1 -,, J*b dl6_* Ltc-*1 o.J*l5 e_l .xl c.i;lr53.r,5t-a;l;l t-,r;,-;.L; oL:r" LgrL,rjl
45 c-l o:l: sl ;: L^r! .rK1, .SL^Q- rl cEr!.t UL _"{ ,SUlirt ;: .9;t *il ,5li} a,.r"3' .\
)) olli ( !r-:l: iq:- cgtL.:-l *; ol;,c r La.r*JK,l eS 6r,-1+,ly p:X" Jt(:;l .r-:-uor: Ln;io5;-"1 ,l-aa-:-.l-il 3 La;rrl ,_|-.; f _|;:-- .-r-il"i L -LjL 5 S:: j
.c-l o:f ,r_,. _,t.r olr^':- nJlJl.r, &-_,r$ 4 61,\r:"^ o;,L;r l; ;[.-:-l":l;l .5ril t-t
^5 +tl .,L;;:! a.nl ! ! riti,tl;U,r:a G.5;ll: oJaLi* ;:4t.Jrr ft .V
.SL^-JU, 6; )" ,j$-^-4':5G-J): -S .,* aS "l:s-e
r: .-uI -u"l; uG ,Sf,lly,.r" .rl jl
"! t] .:3 i rol3> .(S ;i.rs S$=\,, "rkr .*!L ;: :;r;t5
"f,G ,5:La;l
,,L 3 c*l r+- JL-jl ,LL ,:"*; .91r, rlst<i.r"* J d .r)L .st* t i.rl 6 )J'- {r}riL J-4:^" St-z ;* o.., d fa! l) *G r2;;5 ..tL j U SIrIJ-lcr" ;-- ;- + Lr:l;l*l-"r t "Ui*"; cJF= at 1 olfl;:;lIl.--l -l*: ;lJL jl: lrL !
"*!-:rl rSb:li
trl .filFn 6tt<o ;z 6;* l; 3Lau[ir, r:." .elJi'*i .J-i JU-alJr.tk oLJr! 4.ri)(--&? rt l!."a-r, i):-ye ;s
,-ij 6 ,,seV,SL^)!- ;l 6 c--a, ot ;t 3U ;,t .UiL.:l -1L* SV :* tu,)r -l:lrJi a:f ';Lri:! ,,t*-
WWW.AEL.AF
YAf n jk- p! ut*;;3:
r- d.l#U),t JrS + it ,> j.1, iji\ju.^L,,3o *. ol^*c: Jl Sp:.r/ J-lJ- c-J; orb )J+J dE oVb d3;:;: 6,_4Lo.:yG;
-# J d:fut.,_rq- 6t-sMVt. q fJq a:-il> ;t.t5l 6 ;11.r )Jp. J d)Uir-i,73 L^c.L tf 4:^ 6.lLa:ilc*f*- J)y q dJ:St 5 6rl ,^:i16jLr
, [5,'p 'jlu., 5^5 o)p ! di-q-t-.l Jfu.r c--\i>;: c:;lr() rJ..L l) rJ .vr - u
-,l.rf J-lJ, J-.)iti yyj jlo:L,o:-l! kr a5 c.*i,l: Jal3> rya_e Lac-J-
J reau uri , l-- tJ La,li J,"t: *it-6.7 tstsb};- rU "(1 a5 dtac,:-, ,Jq:"v
r ) dr_!,U?L:?l r+ +-,-iJ:i"6La;y5 S J -t-5 .rLi-t,g[a.t(.r,-r
J*.ti a.iY.:t-c S- rSlt. et"e y o-r-.iciy-L clQ -l :l .r:alf e)AJl .t;,J)L* ,gt^,o.gUG; L).,|D )J-5.i- ,, &U f tS elt.)J,r J^lJ,
"lrl- dil, .-"J-a.i jlo":li-.I!
"*"t )io:r) tlJ.:t cJit--",51;
.gl; ,i*;t--: t+; jlyl$rl- pF d-.6;;r 6j;l )l _* 6h r6-h
-;dr*t Jt* ! or-5ttS qL 9 u,,b ,p-6 J.ql; ! ,f \lF tt*sl F :> 3 ..ry J:.al3ij cJ;Suo.:.iL;r IIJJ,iS,aL ;.: Jl ,)lil:*a ?i )lJJp'- a-, l; ry,--;t5 c..cL" o: 5y' t:*l 1j-.* 3l a5 c.--i-.i--;--l
ojlll jL*A o c€*l )44, Gk,.:rYi;pU t 45 .ra+ e f :6 eL6^i.),1*.f pt+jl.Srl:+-L -r -p Ly 6 c*ln;Lalilrr
6La;35 ,GL*z 5-l-i6;l+"UJ ftlJ 6 -,, d r>-l ua;,*"\.Sdldl Ili,r- rlji.:t,:il 4 -r: ?i jl oL -,L-: iey j ;t*;ij[- c.*;: ,t-e.$J,_l :tS t-*.914135 c.iy.?; J o-p.:;y,. c,-\:L
sujs t3;.lyJ: &t-E^ -l::--;li e ;la5 Jlo-t^i ./t?=" ,5.^ cc*;:Ll
6)pt Jt,gt3r:.t! rr.e :;1i6, tyr rq-.r L^Ji ttlrj (J:5
, -;JU, -[Jf,',- JL-.:Lai L,t"-by -,iL;" 6t^.-.L ,sa1,: esi cJl-rp(, t (J-.\'
,r*J!r U"jS, ;1yl,U.;[;al j a:-3- ui )t -* 6h ylc-r;'i
ef tS.:tj^t ir"i ,-;(*5 .5.-,.>13-," \ GW;q 6 c^4.)y J^lJ; JL; 6l-ay*S
g--€-? J) 4j.,:sa-e}1t 6-r!-r; .5rL; L;G.--l ,5t.a-ir,- ,JeV Jt- -r)
WWW.AEL.AF
6', St I YAf
jl.-$1 fl ty.r^lJ+ t.i<rt5.:;1:;3>3 o6$6Lar;l.rjL-l J-\- JIJ--U4,
f"-* U f.^, :l* ozi )s-r i:*.r5*!.:$r; L l; ol:kr-i.,.;,1
,5.t*".a-i)G oli;c"Uy FV Jt-;r 6 6laib-.r;lr r,;:..d1^-;- 4"
?* dL,sil '9;rl, >s,t"o)fc.LJ;l: ryi.5La+:A; JUrlf ,fV)l A-;b"A.r+l :: 6:L,,-i1 \lF t-y* o)J-f J y.q)J d.&l .lrq.5;u,a-i)\c .tH q u*b^ 3 6>l-,":3]13 aiL-3.:dLjleU;1" p
-rr L+i -uili,r^i -,5..r:lJ,x;;.o-a sr;l-Li r.o>3 !y;l;, Ji * e :lpl;-lLl..r-t".;;; r.:--ib )fJ {:,K J.: 4?"Tq t>yU*"./f- r:*1 4LU; .i-.rLl-r \ ,ib^^;,16:L,,-il oL- f+l,r-.t 45 c^-.+ L-;1.5jla-"UrJ 4,,-Llr-.: l; ,-c1:i"" gl:-a a*j: t"r,tr5 c4U^.t--13.r15
"-;* ! .,J.=." c+)\, c$-r ^S ,g* q f.^r 6,-:;.-u:jt:- er*-
c.-Jl-- i.-.LJy rJy;.r tt di Cj -tlS : Sf -r c.:"SL- 6y :l,ti,t.r;Y',)f Sly l: '.--.y c.*i: c.*.St-- a"U, oli.,+icJE" ggly.-r-iL c^-13
A;Lb J'li.,sL .jl:; 6La:li c,"r/i ,'<- ..r1;..r*-,.ly* .,ryjl: :3;a, l; :lil tS!s.,_sl s t9 j cSta_,;! lL^j 4tJJl.l_rt t- J il cfu,c9LaJt- tr
.r3^i JL.rf c.:l; dr a"V1 gl63*.)UU".gLa--3J31 :-*-r -q.,- L.4L.'Yljy Ly :fl sl6''2a,,iy6Lar;l"tjL*l o.L.a..:+ S)Atlt i:.47 y: 6f_:b\l.ry Uf "il:-"6\4.1t^:jj:l ,y\ltJ,"t .lL; sut!" 6 c-L^" U-J". J*)+-f W.i,-t t^..ti3 a;--i,I.: c^e..2 )l Jlj*) ; *-! t^.f; +5y13 "U-e*:
o:l: o3J-- ,irtlf5 dt*:i[. e5 6:lr-il c-l ;(-" J+r^ --ujL"i .:J,
1: L^.li 9 o.r3-, rllfr jl ,,:e L-^,li.r!t-L" 45 -u--:L c.-ib Lc':l t-rect:-.1,1: l-t rP6Lr6L;lj s _,1?.1,-*Llr ,f-.,c.5rlji 6 *;:.1,+a5:1lI tfJ ,r-l-l y --t d.e; :3-- --il$l t p, -\:*jli.,,U-;c^*"atg a!Ly-, -.i; ,ret-xS .:QU" p5 JY.i-t ,il d.Ll,.5lr*l o!;a dLjjLj t l cc*t ,.rqQiii, jJ3tj-S jlr:c..-.,olL
l. Danube Basin 2. Tennessee Vallev
WWW.AEL.AF
YAO tr;q- gtr tst^;r3:
6t-or; IJJ[- l rL-nJ; I ] t Ul.c-*l yl al.iyrL I,JU"^ .5l ^jLj jl rjc**41 t
12,-l fU ,St-l; Jr-! o-tt'.r',l;r c.:yj,.r." /'U -i.-l-9 LU-r .i- :t JX:6la.ly i,i1.7 oS ggs 3;j e3Vit-"oi; : *f -b -,t 11.:UU"
,tT c*.-s -,r !-! -.-ti >-tru M CU _(Lj cJ-.i $lK lral'i-r^ *
a-'. s:;11e4 c..i*:S,r- d/L-.--l 45 crt_aJl6lr, .;L:*l 6a r u! +"1";
;.t LalrT.)!tt" 45 6'13$.c--ilr -ualy; )f J cJ;S J* ;e .tt+a5.grlr.il dt-aj!, ,W;l6lr,:y Ju-a13> )F ,$f ,l; y.r*! .>t+-r:
.Ju:5 ,'i)U cJ'is12>y c-J3lrl
-r) )-,5 .t.al,, d/L,.--l G*:> ol ',-rJr^ clyl )l c*J i,r* trjliJ-l r;', ;5*" tSs *3cJ.X,r-, i[j;lrK1-: LU-t 4 6 u;-tfyla5 o.:-9: il.eGo.-ri c.*13- t f*a 6r-t"l s.t-i! ryay, *J3;A 6lSl.g*1*-.U t-_- -&;; a5 orr5 l15.*.*L(-F ol l-,
4jGUi- ojl-r'jl dL*A t 6l.r5y 6 .<"-6,Jt^.:i" 61;1: ;tL" ;r s5l+"[iy
a5 c*l ut*c ,5lral'iJ;. a, cJ;l': )\pl Jl$, t &r- >f 6tt tJ*t g:al3; ,li.1 ,!^, 1: a3.li..:3"-:, JiDs J'li6, y3; ;l o.:Li;l ! kJ4J 15 oe*-J"r+! 5;,..1 c;L^c-L strj 3 eta+-,a-i a-5 c*l;--1
c9t-A:;lJti-t t+ +U- ,\:;tl 1"r-.rr! Ulo*-r-U" ,JA.S 6Lar;lJL-l
,;.-f e-,.r-tLriU-l c. I ef i-lq .<" ;L(;.t*" 6al t" y -,L! jr3l5.rtil c.-1.t jl .-!t5 ib 5 s*"r djqj .6;11a,;tir-" t- rr 6ry,'.':-* U c*l,rrl5 ,Si SL,::lp.:r-. jl,r5;r:lrilr d! ,*;! .t:t,1U"r-f J d)[j:lilc.t.;L $ly,-1.-ur"[.-.; f"** q-ir^ )l F*,*Jl*r;.<it^OirJ;>,r-illijl..*-i +5 c--il: rnlr; tfy A--51jl -t-:.7r^.1; t-^,ti c-:, yf aS G)$q c-1- [alli6:3; I J $-f. $jLs
.-r^i, *,alr; jt::e co:) p: rebes tSs-t
-,.Ji ;l l;l.a:*" +il.irL,a 4' -rj;l: )J.J d)Ui rlil.ii oyt J-t-,a
rl-rJl y cJl.rr L 1; .:1(.- fLi -t:*;li,r" c-\::31.: ls Unl pt+l;jt*l
l. everybody (.-L--.ri jl Jf'U)
WWW.AEL.AF
,Jtt. J-, I YA2
cr1.-.X:3-- a: c*i,tl,.(: * : & *y )16,_5:lilc-u5 J.- tS);srf ftlJ. -t>
45 Ju--X[ S* C):l:3',,5-".:t,il;*.a Llcriri,r"JJ<*">t S t, :3> I or-i J-* y) ay t:Su,;t"itj L^di jl +5.5:lr3l
,--l r5.,; .5;.: .SU,.E; nL-lt'dt ri U" t.att'JT.r,-t ;,1 e-.;T..ua: ,tLLj
lJ jytt .g1.-aot-(.1: 45 4rL f,t .py;t *J_+*" 1-,,a., oK ra +S c*lc*l;5*" d_* 3;< )r,a: or5,f-"-; &.t dr ;t _,_rj ! _r,-!
..r-^l! ,;-:t.r::36y j)\.-lJr", Jt<"loT1.: 5.r.o.r;lrj .#-r 1: ly rr.i
c*l ,r-:"-t" ol; rjy =i 6tic.L J fur; .,!).;l,-[", ir-t J""-"J
.L^,ti;:;U -,1"=1.t 3 dJJtS r[*i a,.gly
,li j j Jirt* 1r 1; --ii rlilrjl3;,r-" oi t+..,iU dli ft.j ! *!.Jo; atri,#t.x c.."5E rW ;t.fr^, cE-,1- at:;!s;.91-a.:;tJl-l)lrel-r ;tt-Jt;.r^;1y-1prr," U rleif^ly l-, &l;3 a:;L :lfll:.(J.g.:t-aildUJS-j J..ld)Uj -t- U;..:r5
"!..c qjY:Le.rL; c.r::;
gS rlla or lr lB ;ly .r-.al_ji1 eF-x +.St- ,4 -Sl Ll c.:rS r^l',):;-r -t--! dftf c-Sf -,^ t- rjt* oa;b lJ LarljL
-9 $; e)?jl
f iF JL^-o!oy-t- J.jli,r-'; -;.7 6-a : *J rly dtr rk, t.r;*rlr-il a, rtrlr o;t--l S Or3. ej):t-e ott';,1;.: c.ry' pt+.,t -U :t+ cgf
.:y -t.o13> e<"- * ol3iJ: Jn:;*il.:.51y"tJi; r;l-l-; ,;:sf .;'! 6-; J-,,sr) {rJpt+l.g[ae--a,1l,r*,
cSl^rt+ \ opc q5rt-,r:il.gl-a.r;ri ,glLclL.ul$'-an.Jli.rj 6 f;54 .-*l o5 -,_rt-t 3.-l .,s--l 1 .>)\(-:, ;1 ;.q.c jt .,jk- +.Sl- .jJ:;.6rL'a:i1 Gl-:bN;, q5 c.*1113;-l c.*;.rU _,y! ..,lly r:*1,_J., JIK^IJ
J^.J-tl .r"q- .JLSI"-;L:il1: jJ:^ .,itr- kt, ,rt 6,-ll srr;j, pta.:l
-f ,.? - c^4 C!.. "/tr. tt osti 6l q 6 ,,rllJl;- 6rLr:il :ta;
* {lie ,*ls a1 --t-! oJ-.Ir3r-., opv *j 4 q 15 G1*Yts 4 ,gsl-e;lJF.J5 Jt r!lJ o:ti, ,l-ttSrl.r-il3..ricY::.-"
WWW.AEL.AF
YAV r;ka sb .sl^;r::
jl F- ilrr, (.rl_,- F y .l* -riL .JLi" 6ly.) S-ts-p.rL.u t1
)l s.:-# t-trl,;.51-- -* y tlig 6 c.*1 \.31^.r;-ri yric-*r1y;
z-s aStu, 3 oL-r3,.'a,r L l; ii;fr: 6 :;b t-trt $h.);Ii t oS t-iiG_- e arJ
c;LaJ\.u*l ! .+ !- r-5 as3: c.r:i "lQ'
t ll"ri -utr;; G:x -hu
.*.^1d eu'tf .rJ dUjqi 6;U;: +iGrL.a >t"S 4U j aj[-3:'lLJl
J-.5 eltss$l JL.:-l-rr5 .(^5 l-^,1i. ,Jli..r*; A-&r 6yJ ef q es
.i"t -r 95 Ul--a:W c.-r-i dt-&- gt*.,rr-Ut"jL U.r,1b r1-y o;ri i-rl
,-;rar,:;j* l-acrt-(, 6;$;tc^;K; ; 6lo>;3 -,* yoJ51a5 (Jj:--
L5L^cJ3r pL.;:-r-*.,.f;r* ))y 6 gV e:Wl plb..>Sur :l;'p il, +, ,6 riLi-,L:-l , b * m: e^i p1.t52.^a .,\=l ;r ltl {of )lt Jt^.J-J -. -.vJ- . . JJ . J. \ (:--
r;3....1L.ic.;r" a5.4G.ti -Sl ;--r: r^lJp ,k4 :-* "|,$
6t-o--;o.:b ; lf L^di Jl-+l ;.: a5 .-ru-.iL,r*rL:. JUt{< r,jyl.:U3 cc.*l .rL:cl
.c-l of-l'
i:^u;.9t rta::o, irj" J-s dL^-L"k s+ :* a, c-l ,-Js brl,r-Ji ;i,g>Vit ,.,b at* 6l*1,61">13 :* t.6 5 );G.*i >:-r-pt--:13, .rJt' Cti" ajt^t<i e)iJ Jis
"[.*l;l- Jlori
j)\il ol); -r .ftJy^ ,-/q- .:r)\(i +7 t-a,ll 5 ,-U-.,r:
U a--a: ;li
c113Jlcr,; -b eV rly 3 5L" *f Jr,S I e:-#..r;el.rr t! t
L c^*i I o:iL-, ,l,-lpl ,.,tj" 6aJ,,l J?ri -r).)1l.1 -talr;31 c*);) LaJJS-v-J L
\lal613*S 6 $-S "ralr- r="-a ;1.tL. ul^15 Jt<-u.S,!;; rr,"-r
C.- Jl ^S.rJt- -r) .)-# g- ,li;t t- -r-.x! a:--Xlr l; -LJ> *::r:^a e- U-rlr-rljlrJ-r!*: cJ-a:..r-r rGi;lcJ::.-n;b[i9 31 Cb t 6 1; 6:lr.i1 J":Q: qt- ,p ):3,- 6t-^Ji411l-ri;l: :lS et* c-*)s 9 6 \ f-:J-S 6rrn lti :13-. fL"; ll .cit- r-l3, p7.ri reg ;t--ldlojU ,!yj Ct' t- c-r"T r^lJ; )-trJ! 6J,-J- t>rp 6f gle;.r c"r;r:
1. far-reaching powers 2. technical necessities
WWW.AEL.AF
,-5't Jt n YAA
6i.a q c.iS pl.r-il r.tic, dt<r5J;s a;L7f d3-1, Ju.il3a _,yS K. f):, 6
La.li t.g3;3 L.;j tl cS c.*il: .l.AlJ; s_fts Js_*,1 a:-,_1p ,SU C-b#tCr-t,.ra"[LjL ! ohl-, J, jrL ;*-a..l'.xt oJ-.i^i a--l_e* c-**.(,.! tH 6-* gL:. a,*,r; j 6jSa,-l"r- J-S e_l b_,ljlr Ynp4-;,r.51r,
.:_2lr e.".iilj
Ot;$c,;* ttlge a-1, >r; +5 6rlil ,iJ+*;t.r, c*l Jt;Y ua.tf 1-x, e; ,;*J 4,.61J.1: & .c6* -9 orlr ,Jf-r JtilJil-,c-".) jlr.r-l;lr 13L .-/q- .,.JlJtC* dI .(".r:;a ;(*" a, 6 .3t_n.li
.k,Syl l; -iJ:; rlLrr,. Jtt;: +;)y*".,, cJt-: li6o" cJu.as.r^i
)te: )-13;c JL-a.U 6 G)$ +5,r"t<^ -tj.ri:,." oL,l..r5..r, rl.l,Ji.(1..ry-i ;.:Li.r:-- d,.lr, o-:-.X t-trl#tCr1 cJj: .(.- ! rrr-* o:_* y -t3:-',.:;.ri ;l ,> jK lr.-t a, l; o:L n,t9j[! c-9(-l45d,cl & -rl .$; r,6lF Jlj o.rLi:-l :1y, +jY.:tr y,tS, r;l.rlr*rr;r,J:--iL J:rt,.,r-:.Fly -*t C.rfl:, o-t t-c-L c*l;(. +fJt-;rU^lJ; & :) c);l) ,:;r ;t*7.grL,a-:gl 611arLy. eS \ ,gr,.-, f ,at-.1 c.r*iL c.-,:,1: Jl l_, gj! .rrlri l.arti c.*l 3(" oS Jl- -,r _uJdL-i,c^iJi+, Jl-* s G.ri.gL^;! .tK-ta,tir, 6 l1 t-oc-i:J3t *t f *cp.:r- l.r:,1 _tt Jl,r;.-.c.-.1,1.: l,^lJ; J2] r:ran J.fj c--Fl.9iJ t;.-7 Jt;lcjl:k-i ,i ffi f# 6_r1-rtr .rL^.ar;,r-y --i"U.>;cj!.u,otr;:> 6>s) t,Sl.r ":r;{ lr #JlJ- dt-.{ ar.4t-or:1Ji
g ,JLr.:tli aS.L.er-c u-o 1lS.(, +; Jlo:r* blrflt o, ta.lia1;T
.c*laoTr_e'- Js; er;jl45 rsJ"e * a\tf el: )t esJ.:lrfi;.ri J) 't*;* Ai6L-a.:1.Li Ldinj o-5 c.*l;rlc.r;l: :3.-,,9 J:5.," cr-L-- a\a) *.gt--a.r;.i-i J-ljl 4<t djJ*:.,^j d-J,_/JrU .:-rri 6l + 3 _tf.'+)Lt, :: ,S (S;5.<JS.gt^.:L Jls t1.-6:l;l,e orr5 o.:Li:-l,,llJlar-
2. sharing 3. utopianism 4. unpracticable realists
WWW.AEL.AF
YAI n,;k-pcsL;r;:
-fl C-l;.r .grL; s!.l!ly ..rr5 -r:alr,- &"-.J r.tJ;l.: llr.i l"A,iT -U1; c...i
ol_f r-l yr:'--.\ t6lsa.o5y cSL^:l+ ,.rrb rl[,i.j t,rilJl;-rr ! 5 o-l da;..ujt: J"r,-iki.-i .,jq? g;-tu(.;^.ti;: 5 c^iL- c.*: &lr ".-r-olr; -r"l l-, c^.^rl9 yl or.6.1 -# C-l cLl.,.!tt" .>-.,Ji .i- L*i e-*-iL-u.a d$ dJ 6,St " q arlr.q-f qrLa.:Jy: ;Li 6ly 6 :1r
,-r-:,Jl'l"l Oi ,t , J) .;l ellu v-a e5 I ,- J-al9, dJt.:-,1ri .i- agJ- 1- - J.J.' ts - C-- J.
- J
t* *.Lr:L4il .t-.q & .i-,.11;b13o dJ)_yJ, +5 c.*l *i ;VJlijtJiJ .*L .SL.-FI J-iL^ !"! L":;| qglr- or-.:c.*l-v Af t.5t-^oKqr..t,.: cttj.j -5o.-f .tt^.:L J-f : al-|tS q,J"tS ,Jsic.a.t:,-L-;
"#t, c.*t:", 'lu..^,) )l '*
p n4) ;ral -2r 15 crr;l5n )pJ,eluf JlJt<..^ )l ,-51-$)3', dt:*J<;l y.: .ral3ac."."U cgy- ". &\S,)*.gL-"cJe.: lt t^.sju s-\*x -Slr:a5 a:--ibl: Ft;,la,l; 13+
n'fc-.*-r- 6ly '3a o13e yl;.r c-r--iL elt 6yJ 6 c-l tlt *-fL^.r-* ;-l o;L1: *1 ,56-b -rWl 'f t
a5 $lo.rr5 oJ-at j.,o 5 dl^JT
;) J-> *l;'N", Statesman i bl) Times.J"f jl .jJ:i, ,5[-aa.,l.jj3; :rr
.-rJ.r.-:; coJ-.! ,-. , ", l: -hV "oiJi, s,-r,lJiU t" j.<"r t,.rlr-*rr r,
a/rQ)i o i >-tf o)s-tlr> 4< V 'tl; ap-l o5,.:-ib J-.al-i'-
C,,"r jl,fl.S cSsy,islyl,* Jll il jl c-:y J413,-.rLIa- 9 o:3r L.lt:--r)
.r*,lory3i !:r) 4J & J* -,, 6 Jt, .rt"J .lr;
-,, oi.Jl lljjK ! r,j l-, .<i-6.9toc,J3; op spVd crta0i
C*\gU ^r -,l;J*l .9g;t.r-, fali,r.J l":t--tKu, c*11;6.ir9J-:.,.[ J>l.i:-t t otlyr ,3 sl "< J *-f +1ct-^c--Jjr Jt np! ;t,4
:-:,.\ -t-ts. do-(;r .,1: -;S -ty..ss.t, C- Ut* ?6 -tGtty rrK;t" .4;1 .6 1-1*sy-.\.l tf Y j:j .n(Intemational Affairs Review Supplement)
"[J1;-,t.E5t ;'>t*;r ,.r-1:r5 "ra[- Lnutja-:ta ;l .-( 1: 45 6*o*a.:*l .i[ r* c'.t-- ,li Jl .Y
<Four Winds>) r,i5 ,+ Times t:.J,* New Statesman oVLz ; l-,1 r;l5r ;y-*y7 tfil! c-::l:
.(\ lff qlel \, ,Time andTide 93. Allies
WWW.AEL.AF
u,S:r, "11 n Yl'
c-J3r .i- +. a5 c^..,-l L:*" ,-11"r- ;-,-t t-l c.LiL c*: 6rL ^ $l 3j*j -,r
4 -,r ,r;> a;l;L*i -* :* a: g+la;^*;lr:; o[-".:3-- LS \ G)Ji t3:t.r--! .#tir.t c.r"sl- 4 oif-l L-.*5 t-trl cF:S o.:Li:-l
-U *-drl ..rS c4lr^ iLjCU" e #:5".'o3z=t 1; l; t-ac-J3r ti -r.ill a*ib j;-rijllJ t-Ac-L Ilra a-5 -r^i,U u^il.: )fs G:J|{ti 5 i:*t;, ,**Gr*6g aS 6Lao;.r-i .tS S-S -& )Jp,JKt*-a 4-.td.r.jL-j :-i-*ioi X,-a jl.r:- tJt*a ,p" L-r';t"U-r^c c.*ib.u-alr,- jti lj ..,+o5t--
..1_f ncrr o.rjlb;L fl$lLi J^ q $l;* J,-q
;r a5 g;-a,-lIJt"* 6>l-.";il c,?.5t"-,-(-;*t, -I.:"JF t -r?r^
sl>stit r3J>uU./q- Jy.a-ljlJl-- o* i x;l3a t-ac.J3r..tT;t:S
J ,'-:lr j+,JU-a t-. +.,=ii.:;1.: c-.JlJ..Jilti" 'rJ;;-'l;-i: Llr.r*:,U
1-**u:dtJt' ! r+ s-rr! qgtl"l g*t- c.*r .r'[a, 5 g_.2ll-r-l
l;6:L.a:iliLr" "5 c-*l rg;r'./t." e;.ti +(l c*+ dt-6- 1g>l-"":il
pL(i,^;: :3-i,r*; ,-Kg 6>Q;51cSj! -,: .:_e.-- 6 t+oi;t J o; l-#.::ri.(a 4J,-;lr jl-* .J-S Li-b {)l), -[l-j"1tn..li;^, ui:L; )sl.s"-l.t-a !:--$> J) .rtr! JLc!g3-u 6,t..iq c-11: :y*y,rllJt.,..1./q-a-1 d$L-J ?.-,i jllr t^Ji-ulr +! r.r.a: pta-l+q +T+ -d:; rlr!1
.rs s-S _b otfy;6L-ao;,.Li ,r_# ob"* J[Jl.-* c.:"st- .i_ q +! 6 4t-a.:;-riASJ. Jiltif .:9- _.;t-:;l i Fl6t-ao;3: 1; 1; t-acJ_9r 5 J:.-i dJ,-J..l* ; '*i*l- \ls: S:|p,,,.;'[ J3-r- a5 c,*l .;La.r;-ri #loU J- /- L .Jrvi-rj- -J--
r:ljT:l.-a:ilrr \ 6J^5.51-a.r;ri J-il d c*l ,g3'] c.;-r- c-UL+i,rr
c-jS- L-;o* 1J,-ql,,L ,!*,t &,_f_r .l.i! JtrJ."rUlcryt_#e;rt-C,i;U, ilr r, ,r-l-i .>st3 g.;.- t jlj .$r )rJ*.4 dil6
J-EU Asaril AV *. s.;r.-i "|1{
6rLa:il6G.r-13 t -fi*, s ;:*t6JJ.5 45
dL<,lJrJ--l-,1-r -urj J \; {,2--." al -3)\q "ij-! 6l'.a:31'x--".o .t;e{i.f -r,.* tac.J3.: ir.;r d! rlr3l;- 4j.jy:;l *_F_* ):t
WWW.AEL.AF
Yl\ tr;k- p uL*;r::
il.r*:, n- .g[-a.:1-t-i si', ,J I c--..j 45 #ti* c-.9<- Jfulk t, o5,Jt- :r-$_*r-t Ja:" *ttJt;- cTo5t -.( a, orie-0,-r.*i
J.fu u.Jl-J::*-^ :_r.--.rll: :y"l J3:* taJJS tf -&r,5to+;-6r!;r l; +-jl:r:qU J L.n.1U ,5Lat-c:l a) a:U-*l L_l.i .Utl Jr! JlrJ-iyl o:l.r JL5 JU j orn c>g;: 6 .3l,-ot-c:l rg:at ,Jl-6a JIJJ-i ,ra$Ljl-JJu;.gt^.*L c,-lF.eJ<- t+
--Jlr.re 6 s_rc Ch c4tr
r,J).;:-tggl; t-^c.*L j*U -i t-3.gLac.,-:JJ-*r tJ.rl.: -,1/.ly+ +5 c*lJL.r1;i e 6k f=Jtrr;co:Jl
\.,r.: slf .=- l-, ,,llJl.x C .("
h"i*.:1, ,,;; rLn-l;1--:, l# y c*j .,llJt.x _r;r"1;r .rlf _r:">\"5.:r.r-; L,r*1r53*: )l €y.e*l o:;3i )j-7J +telL*jt +5 c.*1
;r e,iJ:ie .gt-a;35 .-r.:lr .tir- -1". *.lt ;T jt l.r- .c*l oLXr3J*..
tdic(.*+ ,is:..,ti.lr_e- ?lL,.S)F_,*" J->13 c-l_e.: & rtyt.r
d- Jlr 4.r lJ,JlJlJ, Jil, Jt riJi a_b )l oli,s,6 c*l.,^i31
-,k r tr*lp 45 6,13;a ^*K;: a5 r".-ar --pl-r
)J= +q;.r-5.-[J.i6i-ti.<.- Jql j ;lj 6j*,F+U,r-.JIJIJ- diU lJ ,r-Ll.Jf,-x
f"tS-"di5 jl l1 rtil f.^ly-.f d5.r"t<,^ .,'.r-5 e J* ,-tec*l -u,*,.1i 6yl ;,:S 45 f5;rL.a 6la=iL f.^lJ-**J cg*s c-^^;t*"
('\+, c,f"^ t .-us aj-b,liJtas r5.r lLs,l G;)r3 ct"sl- t 4<!
.t-), 1ya.*;TJt-.o|.rr,-r-i a,:-:l: d_rt 1-, ,rJ,ut.* JiU €n^ dli,j*J
.grL; "l- Li cc.--Xlr rj,-.3.rllJl;- ,:.,;-ri ;.:-- rlq.,lol-,1 f t 6 ,*6ip-y- g;t-^c-J9.r a5l; g!:3$."tj,r.L,o.gto.:;$ lk J,-! 6 rr -.,y! ,-xl
;lJl;ri ptli c.-; .:1.ti ,"*A U Ll.c--.il: J;S c--; r.r.i;l: 1t-!l;r.41-j,-r- 6)J-f +<56? | /
(or/ lJ$ U ,. ,il 6L^JL- 9 nS or):>, uj*Jlr.rl rdJ* d c*l ,-_r*il .r--.1 gl+.\itl-; 9 ucl; -,r.t q q!.5,r-(1.,- I asrf "4:Ult o+-i, o!L" l rU"U,.1"U,,+ rS J^t_r*l+ F, .<-"JS : LS ;l ,- I .:;Lr :ri .93l5lj c-;: r !y-11 .rt"- tL;U 4:"|K-:
AFederation for ) ,r.t;, 6L-:_,\ 6\,- .;r"-\:li,Ulrr L (W. IvorJenings) ;K4.7 ,tr-t. ('\ tf . ) (Western Europe
WWW.AEL.AF
.$rt J, n Yl Y
)-Vo\-c ! 6_/J-,U?C.\ )* ! Jt- ,t' :; o1"ti,,.*i; yl..rr5 -r-al3o J-", LaJJS jlpl.tsr-a ,*r."-a I f .r;-ti 6J5:jJ,.."trU"r-t ry ;5*" -\:-*a 6lr,JJ:SI 6 tst-:u$ l. y'-tl ;lg-r!* c6ilelr
.-r*i!,-Si--,*Vt elts,JL c*jli.,*j o?Jd a, Ll \..tiL ,y* *
"Jl -t-jli d 6 c*l .J l; ri 6.r-.-c 6\l f j I F" ;--l c5ile -;:
'-'lL, GysuVl Sly.lt oly y orr5 J<-:" 1;;11oL; 6l-a,g;sa-lr'.
,S rS _* I : e-l J -t, 3 -t--, ()yl j I .s-, q*i "rj ly.f -.! tr.rr .:; l.r( ;U
..li;.: a5.t5 r3.t-*-".4Laoj_g,-- a, l; ,rlUl;- tSlLbl-r.lilyj..r" 9.-r5
drr.r +.(li -E tr-r rr6fL,l ln ki4j .pli --r.iq "ui S^o a,. u;le sslg;
J ;.* t* y, JJl,yC aS ,glsa^Lr; -'|L, Jts.:t ..rT;t jL :lil fo.:1.:;lrj 4t-^.lirq:;.t;-:3 >ljir:y* fldl..r1r3-l-*.0 .:Ll.ril q iU dy{s -t s t-/.r*l ..xl,r> .I;1r 0i
f tq=il Sl t | : **-"U j-&. 6 c*l o.t-.i
t^ry5 J:iL r..iJri ; #, -&, Ai -tt 6r'Jl-,$ ftlzi .<,- rJ,elr 1: 15
bl-; ,s--J. )l,JJS )l*"Jl d"l-S Fr;.tu,-li o;t-ti :3>.3 rlt(rlJ> tj
.ry' ;<*".rL";t-5; t cJyr jl.:;-ti JtiJlJ "-ti .r.y(,jloLfi dJ:*"-r ,-r:.,lJi J * 4-.i 6J+l d erj ;3irl1c*l c-Li! J,-f- y uJl-,-ri 311:.4;LaojJ u-rtt a, +;t(l-4 6l-^cJ3r :+ ,-*-b
eLoi L{rd Jl-.)i l-jlJ)) cc*l "jU q-,^ r,I>lJ dj.*lJJ-t e(-- rf3;:\''v-L_"
Jl5J-iJ6;L- oK.r,-r 6tY.t,.-s,Jt"j jl.)f f^)j-r.J, Jl; jlts;:.
,;i ,oS;i l; ,c-:lr gr, t.l !1 t^c^L jJ,-lJ$ ot5.l., - rr,lr-^ ,.Ka, -
&ir.:+, -:r .5'i+ 3 t -t lG -;--!br, *. 6 sl jt4l JlrS jL" jL- :;,9t:-r
45 .rl-.i,U ,Gi"l*US c-*1;5-" e)rioy a;LaJlrJ.c.*lo.:y c.lJ^i
s J_*l Glt 6-:s:+ J"<" .<, rri" ,i!; 6l^:_# Jll.tr .4.!LjL.:U:cl c5 ,.r::.it; ry"--3 L,"oT cr* -r: ,r*5 :1i1 Ll .Yc*l a=L La..ti -r,-Gc
Economic Conditions of ) ;.;5- &i dJ*,lrri ,5:L=:!l t-rlrJr JlJlr q lr "-u^*i oJU" +..1.(\CfC ri"l+-)0 -tI-,Neru CommonwealthQuarterly a."[:la! r: n(InterstateFederation
2. Tennyson 3. Battle of the air.$ a,-717 YfO-OV .u* ,pl, )rJ)J" "I.:.}l'yri uk5 r :;3, g,l -2:
WWW.AEL.AF
Ylf !;q- str ut^;r::
L -Ei, 3 .'-u*:L .:r-( .JL1 l-, .AG -i.r-a .(-- ,sl-2:-o +'.,1i a- ;y-dr.ilos r3-r Realpolitik Ljlr,jJr- ):+ )1.,,.1..,, y a:",1o1o{*tl;p
.$-r.i, Jl 611:r,Jp r kf t^r.41
Gtl4j qJ€ a, ..:*L f."lFjq GtJ dV 4 -,r 1-r dr^j l"
.iU.<-, J--tj olr- 1:.5rL; -irl*: aU U*;: 6 .:*jl^di lrj c^..ilr ryz. 9 G;:*. g,-1."-, J d)[J -* 3;t
"l.W .r.t -l) 3 o-L-i
d-J ll,r5;-,-la-.-a tl ii..r't-y o*f 613: dlf )Sr;6r:5 d-ei jl
tl ,tlS o5,t^i!,-tt jL 1t-=1;: a6" .:t1-"e; )l c*Lel rl1,9.:;.tilJ.iT J-:r t+ .r-r5 L-;- b ,gl-F -*.r,-! t" tjc.r-! ,Srto tsl;l ;r*; s>
,S-t* :l o-. i "!1,
fl$l .i-,1:* l.7 6a r, Jt-a,U elf yt.,*o: 6-r_./
;i.:lr*a; :*e J pf,./!- ,r)-ri 45.J-.." ;ki..rj'- .:Je:
a5 o)3a JjJ," t-..')l , Li).c-*lo.:fi ,-W ,ey $)Jle a,oli 1; l,acll
(r::. -A t-*i,:TU f)r" Fl 6 S-:t"l -tt s df r! l;6,a{-J i* ft-,"jl.i--,y- .gl-aril.: €J n y;; a1t**a gKi S Eoi;r ! r.r5 JL"r!
4 JUl9:1 6:t-c..tlr*jl 6;,1 tl:S,r" .:,-1.u 1; ri Jt^c1 ol,il y-L dL.jL;
Jl45 jLfi \:-rl d.p-loi JJ, ir+ )t-* rtyo :_rl i glj fi31; gt,:i,./q+ .:Ll-rildL.jtyr 6 t?J^.J;b;l5 j y, tu*l:Juo
.:Uti"),-*l-S ssl lL=l ;.: 6j-a;l -,*,.1*r. 6;Y r:^;b 6 "-r e
..r- .rrlr; .4* J !.:# rl;l .91$ 6t-^"$;l ,r-S g :lS (dy:;lr y1:.5rL;;U= d"r J r:lA rJai -<"-f Sl^:-# t,- Er;:r".'ri;t "r-;;tr;.,- :J.EUt:",a "!"j
jl 3:t r:l^:,# c-:,u;$ ,? 66\ay"..s 6u: et_e 6 *5,-;-tr1:,_tka f*ly+ jt.u$1u"1'
,51 .gL"ca:3-i* ;l ;lSt ;,1 6 tf ,s * S---6t* Gia *:)-t, Ji ;qq qgUJL ;r-."4 .\
";rt e\,s-tl q5t".:-yS- 1 "r-:j.r,trK.*n c-l ;(* .5 c^4 .J,J> d-il ,slt .r*GlC.+ r .r-: Jilr, JUr U.?rJ dji- !t-t-l -r-r,r" -b y,tt"* J9tjil ;r+ Jl J J:i* (,u;l
.,-\-,rJ c--\- ,*;) c-t J -r-alre ;$-: tl;-t-s c*f- 4 .sL"" r J-rJ+ .r"!"(ffq..r, [\C'f JL- 1: or.i,;.:-::-.1
WWW.AEL.AF
6'-r.tt n Y1f
l-jly.f ,4t: C-h dJaj ,Si r.)3;r;r L+J .qr6ta;y5 Ll
6-u5r##r 6.fE t,sc:S L)- lJ sllJlr- :,*'vf :r )1.-J).i:-t
;r l1 ill el*l st$ 6 d:lil j o>y u,eV j"ili J,J,UF; dlj.lJl- r, .Ju:S o.lli;.1 f: *-rl,rnl ,gly .>1x aJ,l
jl "lr:Jlicj^i c-[i;l-U c*r1b13i1.9lL; .:1-r-j )l,Sf t3i* 6lr-lcSl; r_! -blj +.5t-- 45
.!r+ _;t-r-;13.1 a5 -r-t a"-.;";-ri.li.r,-[ dirt:;L JV ,y;r Llc-r-.iL
.-uS SF_&.5:1.t-:-1.)-rri 4 q,,!U!,1-, ,*,5toc=Jt- it-r..i
r:-<-J) tJ.Ji.";lF u-- aS e-t* ! f5 )3J>.r l; .:;.ri €l; ;loT;l .-rt-i:-l *_e- )1." *".ili f+l3; f * rn-n -,t5 or V-- .-il-ual
;-l c"*ilr f"^t_f 3+ ;r.-t.tQL. .r, U 6 6:; o-ro j .{ ,S# *)_r 6 Alg ff q ,y; ;:;L dr ! ,rd3 )J.6Lae;.ri 6 c*l.glr- .-ri)Bl J: .<," jlJL- E st c*l ;(" c.tJ;!.: l;,-ri6lr,-t oy"ri
.*3i, j:1j;5.,-tlrfls J dlpo[-^,.t:r5 J""*JGs-t tlr5 61.a..:.,:u -)? :* y $lya e5.l!t;- c.:"St-,51.ly;U c--y5-.ry J-aly,- d* uU*< U--e )l,r<, d5 ),9J>.," l; :lilJ:U^--l:lr-!l a-, -)st eF), JIJ;; 6 o;l$loL-^ ! +! -Lut.r*'S ,SG"t j r-.1 r,-J. cJ3r lr-i &- a_S:ijl ; ojt$t oL^ 1 cJ5,r,
)l -;n;:1--.;1.(- 4; J dL.1:li cJ3:li 6 d t" -i.r.o.-r5 6;*.-*ti J-,! .:l;T6la.rL*ll L L^cj )l "s-S "<-"
..<Jy .ol;i,-gLoilol_eiJ.: -,* -.rJIJlar- )_rl'v-f ;: drrS rt-$J t'la:.a( .1.r." ,51a.:-r,
& j.rj,j drli .c.-il; .r:alF Jg troi;:t$,-, lyj c*t A<* *Lac:r3-r.^, jl*a f-lt- 3 o;y et:t-r L 45aJrl o:lr o[-i.i sgl; :3,, .i-alj,>
,Ji J* 6J;i r.cJi J*.*j.tlrdr ri J--q € reiL:. r) 4i lJ
.trr*:-'li,g cr3-i or; -,[5 o-.:4j)Ut, t-b yJl;.ri,ra.[lr" )l- kl fl-,t.*t -,l.5 ,:i 6.K;lSo' t,l..u:U,.rta;.:>\(* gt 6ltJ*.1,
"r-r+dldjLJlot-? _t* *. *5 ,'91 F^lJ, ,y_r C:_* _,r ki 3 cc.*L ;Iy':
WWW.AEL.AF
Y16 tr;k- gtr,sL*;;3:
r eqJi 6-rir-i u&l,S YL^i-l.g*.ar J;*3 ,-#* )l ;ltl)oi.i" "tl3lc^--ib r^lJ, );at.t-.la #t,..,1 dt jL r^ Jrl.- .tk-31; );.t.ac-L -!.g a1.:t-,.;l 4 t-,g"t+ dt"jL ;; t Atr )VlJ dL-AJtS fL"jc.rl-{-,Jt"jL .f-lt -r- jl ",-.1
rL^:cltr ft S c-*t 6rt
jl at.4;- a-t c,L-t1,ut J* q *UJtra itLjL .(- -,k-l ;: oi,-lrb :l; 64^^;-. c^-.:b;.+-r -talF gt+,lt ,JIL" t* yilrrr.1,,;1j.(o5i;l ic*l o:y La.J.b.t- a-F Al,t^-^L qrl.-;l Jbi'Lr) 6 o:y ;1
"(-- 4J,'pl .,*5 -r:--,. l;oi.r-.L cctT;:;L .lka q (ur-r,U) ,-i)L -,,L;- Al-c GX,'|*-: .l-li.t ir.ir$ Jt- ir: ;.: e .(7jS tu-r[-*il
o5;r-l 3 -L:*.1 ;.;t f-:P .>t-b.-)L .f-l a5 p:lr :ta:el .,r*t gt^a
: lrrl ?-f Py !b--t S-,*ltl")\l J* cr;t<*a )l GIP .l;li,-t.li,tt(,t.rL{,- & .(.-;.: a5 -t*iL o:-.i.lt r:r+J o.i-*:" .:YLllt r-f;.r Jl;-ui L--:l-Jl .<+ 5 *tri'l*; rt .;1 cJ-,.iL a:-lb >j7j c-al;,,u*t
jl,r:+ J5 *<"J5;.;L^ 4t- u-"> )l;lr.i l-trl ;: -r;l3i.r^;.:;b.r1
.>l: ;i;31;oi 6;-ri I ol:r.f Ul .r-:U u)^-e a j ,9L jll;3ra tlLi"l ,6l,+i,L:n 5Lr'ry,*l;'ri;,.i" J.fu L a5 c-*1d*;)
J.P[S eil- .a5',,1y cil: -Laly>:,0>3 iJ:^ ilr; dit^.5-+ jd 3*a:--rlr tlrl ;Jd4 s tS tt tu-:l^;l 6; {! ,rrl(,"1 -r-- U rt }l jl,Sly, r*J *V A6-t dl"jt- r,.+ q jt"; +5 c.*1 ;t;..t(4.l .gj!a, La:;1.[L*13 ot3-r.1: d.t-*i ]t-.J or +5 -t..i,! dt^JJ5 rj,51:;j r[-;1
)l 6r"3 -& oL-("l -r-- U -r--Ll L -ir-r 6 Jl-;.: .$;l.r c*aL--i -&-r<"
€li€ '.:S 71.(1 tl 6 f=:! o*t, -,-r! +t; t,l cr-iL ;i ,91a3;q yy">t"tS t, dL+- jl eL;; ,,s y 3;-- ));a aS fr-a) Jls.:J lt .i[ dLjLj-("" "+ ..=.-i! e_rt.r$ aA -rr LcJd c*l;.(^" rj[- j<*.Ujli lt 1>g->-a'+y.(--;.r.r-r-i clr" 6ll tF;U1t":--t c-tcc.*l q9:L.a 3:e G*--Jll.gt-a;ts ,&r\ o!]l:
->) 6 rJ"bdt^$ .it ;/.F-" cr:it- .r<-.,=."..u,j;.: \ 3.4 di a-b jlnli.," 6 crit Url
WWW.AEL.AF
J't J, n YlP
y r..--45 ;}:;l ); ;t el* ft.r*:t <+ )r L.?jl ir, \!,1,* -. Flye a5 c*lg;;.7..,igU;l!=, yl c,":al51 ,>3,iu, ,Ka
.OJq,:ta, .-5lL-c.*: a11l9.t 4lJri,"
WWW.AEL.AF
l? Ltfs4-i\$i
o-,l;"';l ?-b /;: aVb-* LU-r.! ,-?l-b -.,t5 yl-i.t-a.rigt" Ltl t;tts jl,r5!l,#t..x;3*l;-i1: -.,h -,, ! fl.c,-t.'t4,*L-f | :p 6)t L'. c*l ;5-. a5 o:3-, JJ, ;rr-., cr-la;\ ;llts: k:, glrt ,>tu 6lr, a*"L7;i.r-; oTcly;.: ,.t a5 g;J C.-*:1)l {-*L" a5 c--.:1.: J-lJ, -?* i,,-lal -,t5;-16r".4..r,j5, cS; *pt+;t aa;tra )l #-:* 6t"l .,*.:5 o:lc-l ,g;11s, !:s) a''.6 4lao--aSy.:-r-j)y-b cJ1.r.7 -ur-lr.r 4.Slr eJ; L Li riliq/;-lca^.-a:.ra
,-;-B .,:k- eJg t pJ! tl:.ryl flly,.y ".^.oil;: a5.t.iU JUsi-:"o-c -#lJL 6..3 J .^.^":: J* tt o5 -Lil.r .rk- jl e3U:r ,t-i 6 frs
.firti,r"& L-* C.b -{-" by C-l ;: !i eS r;1.: :3>3 J,-)i J,l #l-r.-&p p 6J,,lt--J-:U a:il).5:U; :f1[5 -tily.f a*Q,r,,eyr -rj)L.lj*"|u--16il J.L +5 c*l.rlf<, +t't-" OrSt.J:5 4rlJltrOistr;,r^
-U*- U t. -#l'4;-j,K Jr 6 6rLAk^il ,iljl 1; .:3e J o+,J ,-*ly y
jLril j:j? r> o< U o-Sif-l il *:e f .cit- f"^tf rlj I r$lo:y
-&t t\,.! t" <+ drljl J* 6 trrr* -qU Llc.r--rL r!-L-irru xly,*AiaJ: .,J +,. oS uolj-";"uib; dt=" jlrri;: 6 F)34 oly-r ,9l{>'r,, *
WWW.AEL.AF
Jr, J, n Y1A
j:rL* La-, -,ft.,** 3 :3r or;5 F" lJ t" c^r,& JJ3; elL*Jld;);-iU
6ly ;Wl .:lTJ*-rU itry3i aall )l ytr;t"- ,.rlil c!X- i5jjlllL. hl-;.rr;3ia,alr-i ,G:V a. -c*Looit6L;.^t-,1n J (crlra)
l, >r-; a.5 c-*t ,rt iia"";);J3l .r*ir-,, gy;+"ly,t * 3 c-e ,.:"461y.45 J5./t+" l1 t-. c-;l: *, aS y:l >l)i :et-",r&.ljl.(,JU,JT jl
"liG -,+ L- ;)\-i" J saLb6;t5 g,lo;b ft+l r*l a*iS r: L a*;i6L*;
6 *6.r! 6r,l -fu +, -,alF 6F L*.a, L.c,*lo.r3r e;t::>l
.c*1 o.:y ait-a^>l c,r,lo.rlr pl+,t a; t jl .S-,!-fl; o;!y: jL;i.<{ er c-rlt4 Jel.ic{-jLn C}glV c.*l rlS Jl,- ;ll,;-"lJ a, 6 .t;:*i ,-rt^Ji -r.i;l.: 1; c--et*--i yl +5 i_g:ljl .f-i! nttt,
6k 6 r:SJ &]1'r,-r,J> *.i,51 6.dLajTL cri;I.: r3li yi::-lJ"U)l 6;+, Gk \ aS 6>lSl cc*J r;l JL J.ffi C!'l&l-S it.:|.: ,tLLJ
_.11 ,.cu-!.glr*a L a5,r,;1: l; c^ct=-i ,rl L5:lJrl .J5rrj -< rlr.^ jl o:r5,r-J-c;
n5.S-qU, jL c-; t; C-lbS + a56Laoi<,J;i:,3"rL-r.e l; UJ C3La;1-r- jl cS-,t --: ,.,:'U c--: )*b"A j -vlo>yi tj-j o-.|l rK:7J)t{; _,51 uJ r-s{tio y 6 -tj;l: J- JUIJ- .lJC er diJl +5 -rilo.:y
J::*a ot":.il 1r GoTcLl .;u*iL a;--il.: .r5r;1 rkrl c.:;lr r3.- '")* c*J l).r;1: 6[*ii erji J-e Jl; {ti" ! p t _tJlr J*i +5 -u-S _5s Jljl c.."*ilJ J {.:3J 1-ll ! e5 5;1.: l1.ri.:;ri - s s_ssi +i L -u.-.ra
-f--rl.: l1oi6L-^oL,i: L^JL,r+l S;>;.-,a; L1(f5.5;.: l; erjt,--l;r e5 f;5 d/L---l .-:lr J-- t,.$|");aj ,i)rtO J -;L d,_d[aJl,Ji
L j-|45 € ,y-rl; -,.,-! -5., J tf#..rL.11^5;i; ta )l r:. *)4:, j_* t-aOit't .fl+:;J f+1, * +^.a e5,,l-^,ti c a cglo.:y to,r*s g;Llc.tjll: pjY.'tL--r3JL Jk?.,1, cSlt 6* +5 ri:y ey,t* bS :*Sly. 6y-*L' -t* 1 l; L .r,-!
,*,lor;3i c#) 4J t^,Ji,Jt"j jl L 6 ely*.:l;i.5La,tl*jl:lrl .,,kr rt-7.1t.51y ,J, ,i,)L #yl:, ft .tS ".:Li1t5 ;,1
.g.:l;i c*!*, +5 qgr_,,-al; ,l*l Al d 9'i$ .,,!-r, e! .1',*ty- c^*S*i,
.r;l: c-il3 erji,Ji ojl$l \ t o)stlcc+lo-[i3;rL1c."",!* Qi.:1i1
WWW.AEL.AF
.+L.il.lt5.;l 6,i,lccQ
t-(:;.,,tjtco.:y"J ?_b f )* a, La.:.l." 6 S_b ALii W Jt.-
Fo Oi ,t-.1 o-,Ur c-*l ;K'*" 1j> ,.>3J-,a ,F * , 6 )l€ e )
^-if JEJ 6t-^ot(.r.-r Li y"t5 .r+, #l +5 61".l.J1,9 qglr, .r*; e.>,
5;:-" +-^."j e5;1u c.l-rl o)y,: A* {*XK JL Y . J* -tt a5 c.*1
./1.5..,c-J-!" 6l^ot(-qs Lll.r3,..r-nlr,*j .,ils J"t f-.--L- 6lt :V ,ty-t.:.-,rA cc*j .(-;l-y ot(.u:t3,- ,b yc*l;.(,*. 4501:.",ii,J"rt-
Jt-;., 11.--: .gL^j;y: rtL.-o GJ ./*lr5L-j-r-l.r .c-i a"o 61; .t(4r
:* yl,.t[T.tt-.l.:ULb" 6 c*lLa;3.5 :l 6:Q.;, ot("r:-; -r-:;q ,.:* .rti I J!, q +5 ggloJu.Jl3* .c*l o.:b ,i_r yl* etj t ,y*.-r;ga,.*J rt ulir-* c.*l-l-l.er qUJrU 6Lcrl3 a:;EU
"f,L-a-a>-:"" Goi;.: 6 c.*1 ,Sjl ;"*j"U 6 )X ote, Ly U"lilti rUi..uj.r3-l-t, a^"t-7;L;L .;[;r r]rf.6 C--*., .<, \,i; aSlL. ;tpld-* b-* &:r-l t i;k";tlir,l C"t€ )* s 131.r3"",r".-[^^.*
.atJ p, \ qY Y JL ;: ;UJ3l e5 c.*1
Cassel, G. From Protectionism through Planned Economy. CobdenMemorial Lecture, London, 1934.Chanberlain, V[ H. A False Utopia: Collectivism in Theory and Practice.London: Duckworth, 1 937.Graham, F. D. Social Goals and Economic Instituitions. Princeton:Princeton University Press, 1942.Gregory, T. E. Gold. Unemployment, and Capitalism. London: King,1933.
WWW.AEL.AF
6rr."t,tr Y"
Hal6vy, Elie. L'Ere des tyrannies. Paris: Gallimard, 1938. (Englishversions of two of the most important essays in this volume will be foundin Economica, February 1941, and in Intemational Affairs, 1934.)Halm, G., Mises, L. Von. et al. Collectivist Economic Planning. ed. F. A.Hayek. London: Routledge, 1937.
Hutt, W. H. Economists and the Public. Cape, 1935.
Lippmann, Walter. An Inquiry into the Principles of the Good Society.London: Allen & Unwin, 1937.
Mises, L. von. Socialism, trans. J. Kahane. London: Cape, 1936.
Omnipotent Government, New Haven: Yale UniversityPress, 1944.
Muir, Ramsay. Library and Civilization. London: Cape, 1940.
Polanyi, M. The Contempt of Freedom. London: Watts. 1940.
Queeny. Edgar M. The Spirit of Enterprise. New York: Scribners, 1943.
Rappard William. The Crisis of Democracy. Chicago: University ofChicago Press, 1938.
Robbins, L. C. Economic Planning and International Order. London,Macmillan &Co.,1937.
. The Economic Basis of Class Conflict and Other Essays inPolitical Economy. London: Macmillan &Co., 1939.
. The Economic Causes of War. London: Cape, 1939.Roepke, W. Die Gesellschaftskrisis der Gegenwart. Zidrich'. EugenRentsch,1942.
. Civitas Humans. Zinch: Eugen Rentsch, 1944.
Rougier, L. Les Mystiques economiques. Paris: Librairie Medicis, 1938.
Voigt, F. A. Unto Caesar. London: Constable, 1938.
"q -6K, ot-fu.:l, i:l;ti;i1 bi t) 'o.rr , c*!* ,5LaaJL;n
:.l.jlo-t-i
Simons, Henry. A Positive Program for Laissez Faire: Some ProposalsFor A Liberal Economic Policy. 1934.
Gideonse, H. D. Organized Scarcity and Public Policy. 1939.
Hermens, F. A. Democracy and Proportional Representation. 1940.
Sulzbach, Walter. <Capitalist Warmongers>: A Modern Superstation.1942.
Heilperin, M. A. Economic Policy and Democracy.1943.
l. Public Policy Pamphlets
WWW.AEL.AF
f t \ l,r-L;ol:S r,,:'"1::L-
L +5 .:; b r,e,7j dL--(- a-e;-:.' ! .;Ui y .-r!1;"l f# ttii,'*i-*^..ry J-nly* dYrtp f ,JLrfU q ldsl La.ll oUJy \ qi
W yJl;.-, )l ;&.6 €e +itil,.,t5 ol-* y.^*J ;l a, ,*o.r5l.4,-gL-aoyU;3 t-" clL-.-.ir J dl-,51-aa:"-r;l f+ J:5s" "(.5
,*".6:1 lr L JLa)ljlt^.)lJt^il
Ashton, E. B. The Fascist: His State and Mind. London: Putnam, 1937.
Forester, F. W. Europe ancl the German Question. London: Sheed, 1940.
Kantorwigz, H. The Spirit of English Policy and the Myth of the
Encirclement of Germany. London: Allen & Unwin, 1931.
c*lr;^*,-t-x 4sJtj?.Ji..tLJi.t;,r-. e:U otUr Fl qi "1.:U
jly:ilc*l o:V c- -l.-l-ia:>L-:
Schnabel, F. Deutsche Geschichte im 19. Jahrhundert' 4 Vols. Freiburg i.
8.,1929-31.
;l-iilr arji cr-c\-n J"t*. )l .alotU: G,-dLd.AlJ air^+i J'-U
Jt ,,o95tr-J L" .|,-F-13.: .,Jl J ,eo 3yy,r-q- dtti)A ;r.r,\cJl;ri,r .rYLL J tS Jl..i-j3*.:l cc-.jL-J arf L7.i ,fit S ;?bL^oi61r- ,5r1;i +5.iLa,-|*i --r*i ral3'- .:J[-
t.-r J d]Lta cJ3*-.-i'"
oL-a t: G,5.:l;i d .-.et- c.:yj 1Gr
.t-! +5 c-l y'jtl 'ti-- .i- ty-.:y'- 6;,1 +i 3 r:*tJ )l -W 6 t*-l ,;^4' -t ot)e .f ; /*" dU1
.JSs, t-a; :;1.rj1.r, ")l;* a, 1; L^,li aS .aLogr-;S.: jl lt
1. The Federalist 2. lay
WWW.AEL.AF
WWW.AEL.AF
bffel^ 9 ts;U qk'i
\AV,U-rJ- ctx-j-lA\ ,Jt(3:,o;1,9*;l
\'O ,42 .A'\ ,OA 1$,&=*lY2Y ,\. ,J.tS Jl-i-ll??,JU_J<.)rrlYff ,J)t5,c:^ilYf . ,Y\\ ,i+y3l
,\VV ,10. ,A\ *J;g;r.,;+"Liy :L,a$l
\qA
\ft ,f\ ,Gc^$l
\ f2 ,f \ ,c--- ."9rS\
\qt.Jtr-r\t0 ,\v0 ,\vf ,\Y2 ,J,i--: -,t-ul
,1A ,lf ,qf ,q\ ,q\ ,AA ,?\ ,1L."-Jl
YA\ ,Y2. ,YoV ,Yof ,\0r\ YV ,-iL.a-il
\qV ,o!JJ,i,r*t(t,\\,\.,\A,\0,\Yol'; c-,)Ll,Y\,,\'t.qf .fV ,Y2 ,f0 ,ff ,fY ,Y. ,Y0 ,Y0. ,Yf\r
V\ ,0q ,\A ,(J.6lJ+)lil
\A 1g:i .r-olr.*:lj\\"f ,.9 .y:1,b-*i
\0' .:;ta.l; ,- .-dsi
Y2f ,124 ,15;t".i dt^4,:l-il\ qY ,2V ,fV ,\V ,A ,V ,ui-il
,qf ,q\ ,V\ ,2f .f1 ,s57.t-1,-rL-.71
,Y\A ,\0q ,\0\ ,\YY ,\\q ,q0
,\Ar ,YVq ,YVA ,\2\ ,\0r ,YfA
Yq\ .YAV
qq ,rA dFl0q ,d*J*l)l
\Y7 ,gf ," 6\321
Yrr ,YrY ,Yr\ ,JlJ-i ';K;'tvr ,vY ,\ Y ,r-JU-l
YV. ,.r(.r:; rrllh-l11 15;L:;lJL-l
.(.ralyrc-*"L.;) :l-t^il
,\ff ,YYr,\f\ ,\Y.
YAq .YVf .YO\Yqo ,Yof ,qq
WWW.AEL.AF
\ \V di ;rl, ,a!.\YA .YYV ,YYt .YY0 ..JLo s ,2,J,
YT\ J;YA. ,\f \ ,10 ,\. ,J:rql Uj-JyS &!_,-:rl
Y I ,c.,rt5rL ,roL;
YfV,Jd j-\i,\f0 ,lrv .l12 ,\YA ,rf ,cr;,*|
YV\ .\2f .\TV
YVf ,YVr ,(.rr15!:;+) drLiJiYYO ,Yff ,Yff ,Y.\ ,2. ,c;;l+.i
YfO ,24 ,\1 ,rl;io_,la*i
\ .Y ,\ . \ ,olf -*ax\V\ *)f 1#:t
qA .qv .)15 r*J;\fA ,Yf \ ,t0 ,0q ,04 -,,Jr dr.i
YYl ,c-,:.a ;5;1\" ,,_5:L,a:.il ,-rl3 f *
YlY orji ,br*aiYAY ,.5;t s;l eul'
't".1 ,f . ,yl i3r JF ,Jf ;,40 AY .Vq ,ff ,YV .\ \ ,\. ,4J;.lr\ ,.\r. ,\Yr ,\YY ,qr ,1Y ,A2
,\0. ,\fq ,\fv ,\f0 ,lff ,\rq,\A'\ .lA. ,\2f ,\0V ,\02 ,\00
\02 ,\0r ,Yf f ,YY \
f \ ,;j3,1 ,,-/U_f
Yff .-J j,+ I _t, ri,G.r__y
,jttolrn f'f
,W ,?, ,02 ,0f ,01 ,ff .YY y ,UIAI
,\1. ,'l 2A ,120 ,\\"\" ,l .Y ,q0 ,Vf
YA.
\A. ,Y\V ,u!;-eK:r-;l ; _,81
\ 02 ,Vf ,VY d*5L eg^:-l
\?? ,,JU)<\, .lUt 61..t<j!\r2,)tJt
yyr ,c*JS[,J[-yry ,(?r:5) uf*. u,r-,
\2 ,oU; ol-r-,\YA ,Vq ,Vf ,V. ,fV ,Y. ,\A 6ylr,,\2\,l0v,\02,\0r,\r.,lYq,Y . q ,\ qf ,'\v\ ,\v. ,\ 2f ,'\ 2Y
Y2. .YYO .\TY .YYf .Y\T
0A dt7.C-_lr1
'\ qV .\q2 ,612 ,sl) s:\r,.
\ \q ,s-lJSJ"t j,5ysanly\\ 315+*L-.5G+,1:r,
\ \V ,r!;ta ,&*sy\fq ,J^l..a,5r"
Yfq .YfV ,..,J:a- ,l-r..r
?, G)lsis::,\qV,./JSL ,J1Ws-y
\ | 'E--fr ',r t\ff ,_*;r .rr- {t.,
Yrq ,Yrr ,\Yq ,Ji J,srt-*,lA' ,\VY ,l0A ,\Y ,\ \ ,\. ,c9-.rt(::
\20 ,Y2f .Y2r
WWW.AEL.AF
Y'6 n t^p:xa 3 l-apU a,t^l
,f \ ,f . ,rA rv,r. ,\\ ,f ,s:r\02,\q2,fY
YYA ,;t5ali.il-- ,...1-
\f2 .\fO ,\l"f qg;i clyrr>
,\Y\ ,f \ ,f0 ,YV *-r;rG c*r(=,\rY .\r\ ,l Yq .\ YA ,\ \0 ,\ Y\
Yqf ,Yq. .\AA ,\qq ,\Y2 ,\rr
l1 .;y: ;3t-\ t ,+i[-;31>
A0 .;L>l ol"J,
Itr ,,-_-r-t.7 ,KJrl,,\V0 ,Af ,Y. .\\ ,t ,Jyr cJli:
Yf0 ,lAq
YtV.[gl .-\rwr- ouq)o- J -, Q -J.t
fA ,ff ,YV ,ot-r; J3:\Vy .,Jt*i.}!1;;,
,\ \q ,\ \A ,l \v ,\ \2 ,f \ ,c5;jtj<,:
\Yl .\AA .\ \.
\. .q .^ .Jr) .;*1.,
YYf ,YYf JrK iL^,, ,,.ryJ)l;\ qV ,$\riJ, .J*1,
Aq ,4-;[- 01,
\r0 ,\ \ , c\,? cuayo o5l
YfA,YYo ,01 ,fLi;,\vA ,l \? ,?v ,7? ,r/ ,\r N ,ar^_t
\fv ,Yrf
,\0. .\.V ,AY ,A. .Vl ,?d ,o3;,\ A. ,\ VY ,\ tV .\ 0q ,\ 02 .\ 0f
vV
Y0\ ,.r51; a-"t-
\ \ *t:r;J ,dj;t-.rq .oq .Y. ,\A .\v .\r ..rtf f,\qf ,\qf ,\Aq ,\.2 ,\.0 .A\
.\V \ .\V. .Y'A .Y'V .Y Y \ .Y \ A
yff ,JUl-i> ,;i:_,\Y .\. ,\q ,\2 .\O .\Y ,l \ ,V ,Ko,f I ,rq rv ,rr ,\'. ,Y1 .YV ,Y0
Aq ,0v ,02 ,0. ,Yl ,fv ,f2 ,ff,\Yr,\\f .Y.r ,\Ar ,\rt .\\Y
.YTf .YTY .YT. .YYV .YY' .\YO
,\f0 ,Yff ,Yfr ,Yrq ,YrA ,Yr0
,\vq ,YV0 ,\20 ,Ytf ,Ytr ,\ 0tYqA ,\qv ,Yqt ,\q0 ,Yqf ,\Aq
\\? ,;y &:-4,.*dk-
Y\Y .;rl-9;-"' ..,Jr*t\Y ,j+ l)r*
Vr . -t ".l*. .:J.-tc_J0 \ ..--r;l*;-l o * :",rJr^f
\\"1 ..;;l9il ,r.:z
\ff ,\f\ .\Y\ ,iiG c#t-
WWW.AEL.AF
YAf ,YA. ,12\ ,\Yl ,.r-;; cJl-rc
\f\,\f.,o!tpYAf ,Ytf ,lV\" ,+-Lo
Yl"A ,\q, ,bar*G
\q0 ,Yq\ *-ry*l;L-r
Yft ,\f \ ,\ft ,tq ,2. ,\A ,4*;lr-i
.0q .Y\ ,lq .\A ,lv .\o ,rsl-5t;
.YY\ ,YY. ,\qf ,\.A ,\.' ,?L ,?\
\Aq .\rq
\V. ,\tY ,6r1l1J.et;
YYf ,IL,.:r,i ,-!r.i
Y\f ,Y\f ,.?-yS-6 it^," ,4:;*i
,lf\ ,\YA ,l\0 ,\\Y ,.g;lj5rty;G
\rrlYf ,\Yr,\YY ,s*, Jrli
\f \ ,Jl,il .il ,."its;
\ \2 ,:;yi:-l yt!-;YAf ,l2A .JLi-t u;<.5
\ 0. ,jJ_f ,.Srys
Y.Y ,f \ ,\Y ,-.:rJ\ .0 ,ff ,f-":iU J -
YY\.c*f ,c5YAA 1g;lj5a,L f J;S
\ff ,-iJ.z" JF',i"'\ ,j-t-; ,(l[*5
.5t-rJrn f'P
\\ ,JtKjlr_i ,:)s)_s-t
\Y. ,\\2,1 \Y,a,3;
Y.f ,\Af ,l0Y ,\ \Y ,r<-JY. ..tl[i_9; ,,J[<-;
\ q. .Jt'r" .5!:tl .r,.lL .5LasL;Ltf\. oJ ,,.k_
tv.YV.JjJ-
Yqf ,YV\ ,\". ,1 ,s*jJ-,f. ,YV .Y\ .Y. .\Y ,q .dly.y-.0. ,fA ,YY ,f \ ,f . ,\'2 ,ff ,ff,v\ .v. ,?\ ,?Y .0q ,0A ,0\ ,0\
,AA ,Al ,A. ,Vq ,V2 .V0 ,V\" ,VY
,\tv ,l?? ,\?\ ,\2\ ,\fq ,\\Y
,\qt ,lq0 ,\qf ,\v. ,\rq ,ltA,Y\Y ,YY\ ,\lA ,\\V ,Y.\ ,lqV
.YT. .\Yq .Y\A .\YV .Y\2 .Y\T
,Y0. ,\r0 ,\rf ,Yrr ,YrY ,Yr\
YVq .YVf
\?L ,L-i. ** r4V:-.YYf .\YT ,\\ ,?? ,,,5: ';,:Vr
Y\O
qA .qV ,c_-"=! _^-=-01 ,3;*
! ! ., ai\. \ .;Ut .Srtd gL^X-
lqf ,(J,lf,r"L J,.,
Y\f .\qf .\AY ,.g;l:a,L )- L)
WWW.AEL.AF
f 'V l tapx- l Lapl, r-u
YfY.YY'
YYq .Y\r .YYY ._*J)t"\VY .jjK;L u-Li .c5!Jisl"
.lf . ,\ \ q ,Y. .l \ 'u^a -+.a"; \:":<t/
\02.\0tY\Y .\ \V .eV .r9 .JJt5 .ft$L
\YA.Jp )-.j"G\\A ,Nuture aJru
YfA .Yrf ,YYf .ft .jlr15..ii.it*y9,\ .gljc:;3..r-
YVO ,YVY ,lrlr"Ydf \.C - r.' r, rri. ,./t* c*
\v\ o] ,*J_rf
Y\\ .10,Vf ,r;;,G4*r"Y^(t Zi r .r^_^l __i) r_^*J .u
.YYf ,Yf \ ,)!J ,S )J.,J) ,JU ,JJ.Yrr
0t . q: -i "-il l-- . i-i -, t' , ,.Ua- U )
\2f ,0. ,;;lyil Jq,J."Y2A .0q .,Jt? .,jJ:lx"
YrY ,i+[,0r ,0Y ,0\ ,fq ,f*J!-r Jtj*.-[
VY
.\ft.\\\ .\\. .\.q.'\ .. .qv.J5YV. .Y'q .Y'A
Yfq ,\\" ,\Y ,\ \ .1 .:;L jq ._#
Y.f .ruJYVY .\rq, .j;.:11 eLl:: .;r-:)K
- J' \ '
5. .j:, l<\:.;f\YA,gL,a ,3+.r_$
\cY*'!Jr
YYf .YYf ,rL,:i .JL!\0, ,\ lY ,\ \ \ ,..5a- JJ)La ..,<-)
vf ./,Jlr).YVV ,\qV ,\0r ,\\q .r\ t-r;51 :]
r.\Y\2.9=la.:;U
\v\ .\t. .\01 ,vY ,;*J
Yf2 .j[t,,AA ,AV ,AY ,A\ ,VY ,V\ ,tf .LaJlf
Yvf ,YVl ,YrA .\r..eY .0q .0Y .Yr .\-e .Yl .n .r*1,;.\.2 ,Ar ,v, .v0 .vY .tq ,?L ,?\
.Yr. .\Yq ,\ qt ,\ qf .\vr .\v.
.YVY .YTA .YTO .\TY .YTY .\TY:1.\-
Yq. .YAV ,YYt .Vr .p[YY ..d.(li ..-:tj
Yt\ ,Yz\A .JUl.o d-\qA .-L-lp ,l^i .YYo .YYr- 1-
YVV
Vf ,ll;.j^JYfO ,2t ,_,1141 .-*!
.\qv .\02 ,Jrl5 .-JtL
WWW.AEL.AF
lAV,;;La.;G.rye -rt-.{l fIaJ1, SrrS .Jfu
\f\,YYo,ttYqf ,YV\ ,i\ ,J.La
o' .o I .-k!r .Jr."r^-\-fY .rL J;a;a-[:;, uL
.\\t .Vt .VO .Yq .vV .*:J::i.,I:a
.YTY .YYV .Y\T .ITY ,\YA .\]V
\qA .\0. .Yf 0 ,Yf .
V0 .# Jr-a\ "! -
\AV,;,:1La,_J*o
\l"f ,:J ,-;;lJ+0A .-L +: .a +-a
Yf l ,c--i)l .FJ,
Jt,"t-,5 Y'A
YYA,i;4/,oL,rr\10._d14e;.;r:
\-Y . L.: *l
Yfq,YfA .d.o-,,-r-i5l,:lj\12 ,.r,-\3 ,:,J
yvy .\ \ \ ...,-:fe .}t\0. .\fq *_4\ ;9_t
\r\.ri)J\v\ .YY2 .\Y0 .\rf .rr .1,):
Yfl" .3;:33 .l_r*!_r
YrY .ji .c\ .;.57ur:;La\ qv .\ qe .\ \ t .Jr .JrLa
V0 .:;i3-:l .;-Lo
WWW.AEL.AF
