27

y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

�������������� ����������������������� ��������! � ��"���!�$#%�'&� ( ����)�*�����+ ,�'-.���*��/)01%2�35476 /98;: 47<�= 0>@?A1%=�B�C>ED<F47GIHAJLK M@1%>@<�BON�?P>@QFRF1TS�>U3V47WYX;1ZH\[�K

]_^V`ba�cedZfhg(i�j,k*lZmon�prqLsutOgevOwyxez�z|{bgI}\s�~�ceqLdZs\g�%�r�;�y�hs���p���zezhwh��ce�hd%��gIs\d!�os\pO�,l@{bm����ezI�U^]P��`bkopr�ZgIqL�Lnprde��c�~E{�cen�h�y�Lprqo�yt�s\pOdUt�p�w@�%��g�dy~�c�q�f��odhs\��pOq�vLs����7wZ�%��gIdy~�ceq�f"lU{bm����e�eze�

�������O����� �� e %¡�¢ ����£�¤V�¦¥y��§r¨�©�¤V¥y¤O£��«ª�¬�­ ¬®£_�r¯e°\¤r©_±h­ ��±e²

³µ´7¶�·�¸�¹»ºV·¼  %�«¬½��©¾£���ª����¦¿e©���¬¾��¯À£�¬b�µ¬®Á�¬®£����Â�«¯�ÃE e��ª_ ��µ�,¤r¥%�«�«�o©�¤r¥y¤r£½��ÄI²e�«¿%¿y��±�ÃE�Å£� ���©_�O¯%¡V�o¬¾��¯e¬¾¤r©���Æ,ª�����¯I£��ÅÁ(¥e²%�«��±e¬

¿y¤V�ÅÁ�¡V¤r¯»�r�%�Ç��ÁÀ¤r²e£�¬È¤r°Z�«¯»±�¤À¤r©F��¯�ÉI�Å©�¤V¯e�,��¯À£�¬+�r¬��«£�¯»��ÉI�«¡5��£���¬�­+ÊA£��«¬��O¬¾¬¾²%�,��±¦£� %�O£È¯%¤½¿�©���¤O©F�«¯e°\¤r©�����£���¤r¯��r¥y¤r²e£È£� %���¯IÉI�«©�¤r¯%�,��¯À£;�«¬½��ÉV�O�«�Ç�O¥%�«�V­ ¼  e�¦�,¤I±����FË�����ÁÀ¤V²�£LÌE�«¬Íª�¤r¯%¬®£¾©�²eª�£���±(ª�¤V¯eª�²e©¾©���¯I£��ÅÁ|�O¬b£� %�o��¯IÉI�Å©�¤V¯%�,��¯I£;�«¬Í��Î�¿e��¤O©���±Z­Ï £����rª_ Ð¬®£���¿Z¢Ñ£� %��©�¤r¥y¤r£*±e��ª���±e��¬ÒÃE e��©��£�¤'�,¤�É5��¯e��ÎI£|Ë�¬¾��¯%¬¾¤O©µ¿%���rª����,��¯À£�¿e©�¤V¥e�«���µÌÓ¥»�O¬¾��±Ð¤r¯Ô£� %�(ª�²e©¾©���¯À£¿»��©¾£��Ç�O�«�«ÁI��¥%²e�«�«£¦�,¤I±e����­ ¼  %�«¬¦±e��ª��«¬¾�«¤V¯9�«¬¦���r±e�,¥ÀÁ��O¯Ô�O�«¡V¤r©��Å£� e��£� »��£¦¡r²%��±e��¬Ó£� %�,©�¤r¥y¤r£¦£� �©�¤V²e¡V T�(¬¾��ÄÀ²%��¯eª��¤r°�ÕA¡V¤À¤I±eÖ(ÉI�«��ÃE¬�¢7ÃE�Å£� ×ÕA¡V¤À¤I±�Ö|©��L°u��©¾©��«¯%¡£�¤*£� %�Ò��Î�¿y��ªL£���±'�r�,¤r²%¯À£��O¯»±'ÄÀ²»�O�«�«£AÁ�¤r°F£� e�,��¯�°u¤O©����O£��«¤V¯!£� %�O£½ÃE�«�«�¥y�o©���É5���r�«��±��O£b���rª_ �¯%��Ã�É��«��ý­ ¼  %�«¬Í�«¬b£� %�o¬¾¤r��ª��O�«����±9ØhÙ¾ÚrÛ�ÜAÝ_ÙLÞ�Ûbß�à�ÙLáâË�ãbä�å½ÌÑ¿e©�¤r¥%�«���¢yÃE e��ª_ ��r�«¬¾¤�O¿%¿y����©�¬Í�«¯±e¤r���r�«¯%¬Í¬¾²eªL ��O¬oæ�¤V�,¿%²�£���©Íå��«¬¾��¤r¯'�O¯»±�æ�¤V�,¿%²�£���©�ç�©_�O¿% e��ª�¬�­ÓÊA¯��,¤r¥%�«�«�o©�¤r¥y¤r£��«ª�¬�¢@ %¤�ÃF��ÉV��©�¢h£� %�«¬Í¿e©�¤r¥%�«���è��¬ª�¤V�,¿e�«��ª��O£���±(¥ÀÁ|�,¯I²%�¦¥y�L©�¤O°��«�,¿e�����,��¯À£_�O£��«¤V¯(�«¬¾¬¾²%��¬�¢Z£AÃF¤µ¤r°ÈÃE %�«ª_ ���©��¦¿%�O©¾£��«ª�²%����©��«Á|ªL©�²%ª����r��­oéb¯e�Ó�«¬b£� e�Ó¬���°u�¯»��ÉI�«¡5�O£��«¤r¯,¤r°y£� %�F©�¤r¥y¤r£�¢I±���¬¾¿%�Å£��F£� e�F°��rªL£�£� %�O£È�Å£�¬�êI¯%¤�ÃE�«��±�¡V�E�r¥y¤r²e£È£� %�Ñ��¯IÉI�Å©�¤V¯e�,��¯À£"�«¬��«¯%ª�¤V�,¿%�«��£��r­ ¼  %�E¤O£� %��©�«¬Í£� %�Ò¯e����±(£�¤¿e©���ª���¬¾���«Á��O���«¡r¯'¬¾²%ª�ª���¬¾¬¾�«É5�,ÉI���LÃE¬�¢"±e��¬¾¿%�Å£��Ò¿y¤V¬¾�Å£��«¤V¯e�«¯%¡²e¯%ª���©¾£_�O�«¯I£AÁ|�«¯% %�L©���¯À£Í£�¤��,¤r¥%�«�«�¦©�¤V¥y¤O£�¬�­¼ ¤,�r±%±�©���¬¾¬E£� e��¬¾�½�«¬¾¬¾²%��¬�¢e£� %�«¬E�O©¾£��«ª��«���«¯À£¾©�¤I±e²%ª���¬Ñ£� %�ͪ�¤r¯%ª���¿e£;¤r°+�µÞ�ëPì�Ù�í¾Ù�îrà�ïrئð,£� e�Í���O©�¡V��¬®£�©���¡r�«¤V¯(¡V²%�O©_�O¯I£�����±£�¤�¥y�o°Ç©����Ó¤O°�¤r¥%¬®£_�Oª��«��¬Í¡V�«É5��¯£� %�o¬¾��¯%¬¾¤O©b©����r±e�«¯%¡r¬Í���V±��o¬¾¤,°u�O©�­ÍÊ�£b¿�©�¤V¿y¤r¬¾��¬½�,ãÍä�å)�O�«¡V¤r©��Å£� e�ñ¥»�O¬¾��±(¤V¯(£� %�«¬ª�¤V¯eª���¿�£�¢eÃE e��ª_ �£_�Oê5��¬Ñ¬¾��¯e¬¾¤r©����«�,�Å£_�O£��«¤r¯%¬�Ëu©_�r¯e¡V���r¯%±��«¯%ª���±���¯%ª���Ì���¯À£�¤,�Oª�ª�¤r²%¯À£�­

ò ó+ôõ�öÑ÷|øTù'úbõÑû�÷*ô

m��h�Lc�n(gI�Lsut�nc»fhpO}oüZ�hsÇ}ufys\dhýþsuv|gY~��ZdZfhgInprde��gI}o��g�vLÿþs\d)nc�üZsÇ}\p�qLceüUc��LsutOv�� �ylÍ�À���®�����hpTüZgev_sut��hq�c�üZ}Çprn suv|prgev_��Lcþ~�c�q�nµ�h}ugÀ��p�âm½~���pOq'ü@pOs\dhý fypr�h}\cÀ��prf×s\d%�Lc�gId �hdhÿ»dhcÀ�½d pOd»�»sÇq�c�dhnprde�Vl�g q�c�ü@cI�Vl�c�q!gâ�LpVgIn cI~�q�c�ü@cI��vOl½n*�Zv_��@pOqL~�c�q�nñvLpOdZvLs\dhý�c��@pOq�gÀ��sÇcedZvEgI�;nµ�h}Ç�Ls\�h}\po}\cytOgÀ��sÇcedZv;g�dZfs\de��pOýeq�gI�LpÍ��ZpÓg�t��%�hsÇq�prffhgI��g,s\d%�Lc�g,qLpr�hq�prvLpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d�cI~"��ZppOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%�r�FkopVv_�Zs���p���Zs\vÍvLsÇn�h}\p�~�ceqLn*�h}\gI�Ls\c�d+l���hpÓ�hq�c�üh}\pOn suv;fys� |t��h}Ç����c*vLc�}\��p�s\d|�hq�g�t��Lsut�pe����s\q�v_�rle��hprqLpÓs\v;��Zp�hq�c�üh}\pOn cI~Ñt��hc»cevLsÇdhý(g�d!gefyp��%�ZgI�Lp,q�pO�hq�prvLpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d�cI~���hp,prd%�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��� p�� ýZ�\ly��c��@c�}\c�ý�sutOg�}7ng��Zv�� ���®lh�Uce}Ç�»ýec�dZg�}}ug5��c��h��v�� ���PlIcytrt��h�Zg�dZt��,ýeqLsufhv������®l����¾k×nc»fhpO}uv�� �����Pl�c�q�~�prgI�L�hq�p��®üZg�vLprfµn(gI�Zv��Ç^�^��®�E�»prtOc�dZf"l5���hp½q�pO�hq�prvLpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d�n*�Zv_�ü@p(p��»�Lq�g�t��LprfT~�qLcen s\n��@pOqL~�prt��µv_prdZvLc�qÒqLpVg�fys\dhý%v�� pe� ýU�Çl�fypO�y���YqLpVg�fys\dhýevÓ~�q�c�n q�gIdZý�p��¾vLpOdZvLc�q�v�n(g5�! Z�Zt��L�ZgI�Lp|fy�Zp�Lc|t��UgIdhýeprvbsÇd�vL�hqL~�g�t�p¦��p��»�L�hq�prv"� ���®lZfys�#7pOq�pOd%�ov_pO��vÍc�~F�$�®k v�tOg�dZvbnµ�Zv_��ü@p"%Os\�h�UprqLpVfY]�v_�LsÇ��t��hpVfZ`"� �����®lZgIdUf!trgI�y���hq�prfs\ng�ý�pVv,nµ�Zv_��ü@p�gI}\sÇýedhprfYg�dZfYqLprý�suv���pOq�prf&� �h^Il;^5���®�'��s\dZgI}\}Ç�el�sÇ~Í��hp�v_�yv_�LpOn s\v��Lq��h}\�ÔgI�h�Lc�n(gI�LsutIl���hp|q�c�ü@cI��n*�Zv_�fypVt�sufyp,c�d!s���v½cÀ�½d���hp,dhpVt�pVvLv�gIq��(ncI�Ls\c�dUvb�Lc(t�cedZv���qL�Ut��Í��hp,ncyfypr}(� �hl+^rz��®�) g�v_��q�prvLprg�q�t���sÇd!nc»fhpO}"t�cedZv���qL�Ut��Ls\c�d*�Zg�vbn(gIs\dh}\�(~�cyt��ZvLprf�c�d!fypO�epO}\c��hs\dhý*�LpVt��hdhs+�e�Zprv�~�c�qÍp��»��q�get��Ls\dhý�qLpr}Çpr�ÀgId%�

~�prgI�L�hq�prv�]�p�� ýZ�\l�prfyýeprvrl�t�ceqLdZpOq�v�`o~�q�c�n q�g5�èvLpOdUv_ceqµfhgÀ��ghl�gIdZfÐc�dYs\d%�LpOýeq�gI�Ls\dhý'��ZprvLp(sÇd%�LcTg�vLs\dhý�}\p|gIdZfâtOc�dZvLsuv���pOd%�ncyfypO}P�,���hpOq�pÒs\v½g�}\vLc��hqLs\c�qÍq�prvLprg�q�t��|ced����hp�t�cen�h�y��gI�Ls\c�d�cI~���hpÒdhp-�%��Pü@prv_���»sÇpr�,lhg��hqLceüh}\pOn ��UgÀ���Zgev½gÀ�_��q�get���prft�cedZvLs\fyprq�g�üh}\p|gÀ�_��pOd%�Ls\c�d)]�p�� ýZ�\lÑv_prp.��^elÈ�Ul;^V�ylF�h^Il��/���`��9��dh~�c�qL�L�hdZgI�Lpr}Ç�el�nc%v��µc�~½��hp��hqLce�Uc%v_pVf1032b����prt��hdhs+�%�hprvgIq�p(�hdZvL�hsÇ��g�üh}Çp|~�c�q�nc�üZsÇ}\p|q�c�ü@cI�LsutOv,~�c�q,���bc�qLpVg�vLc�dZvr�*��s\q�v_�rl���Zp|qLceüUc��µnµ�Uv��µdUg5�%s\ýegI�Lp�½sÇ��hce�y�*t�ce}Ç}\sufysÇdZýT�½s�����hdZt��UgIqL�Lprf�ceüZv���g�tO}ÇpVv½]�v�gÀ~�p�dZg5�»s\ýegI�Ls\c�dU`����»pVt�c�dUf"l�sÇ�;nµ�Uv��;ü@pog�üh}ÇpÍ��c,qLp-�P}\cytOg�}Çs4%OpÍsÇ��vLpO}Ç~7�½sÇ��(q�prvL�@prt��;�Lc�gÒ�Zg�q_��s\g�}Ç}\�5�üh�hs\}Ç��ng��â]�s\ng�ý�pÒq�pOý�suv_�Lq�gÀ�Ls\c�d@`�����%�Zs\trgI}6032b�×�LpVt��hdhs+�%�hprvÑfyc,dZcI�Eg�fhfhqLpVvLvFv�gÀ~�pÍdZg5�»sÇý%gÀ��sÇced*t�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de��v�üUpVtOgI�Uv_pb��ZpO�*g�qLp½fypVv_s\ý�dZprfµ~�c�qEvL�»v_�Lprn(v

��UgÀ��üZ�hsÇ}uf�gµnc»fhpO}@cI~Èg�q�pO}ugÀ��sÇ�epO}\��vLn(gI}\}Zceü67�prt����ZvLsÇdZý*g�q�gIdZý�p�vLpOdZvLc�q�n�cÀ�»s\dhýµg�qLce�hdZf���Zp¦vL�UpVt�s\npOd+�;{�c�}\}\s\vLsÇcedZvrl�hcÀ�bpO�epOqVlUgIq�p�dhc��¦g(n(g$7�c�qosuv�v_�hpµ~�c�qÒv_prdZvLc�q�vÍ��ZgI�Óce�Uprq�gI�Lpµce�y��vLsufyp,��Zp�tOc�d»��p-�'�»�h}\}�c�~Ñ��hp�vLtOpOdhp*cI~Es\d%�LpOq�prv_�r�98¾dnc�ühs\}\p¦q�c�ü@cI��s\trvOlyü»��tOc�d%�Lq�g�v_�rl%���hp�v_prdZvLc�qÍdZg5�»sÇý%gÀ��prv;:=<?>?@6<?A(��ZpÒv�t�prdhpB v½t�ced»��p��C�»�h}\}P�,���hpOq�p�~�ceqLpelhvLgI~�p¦dUg5�%s\ýegI�Ls\c�dt�cedZvLs\fyprq�gI�Ls\c�dZvbn*�Zv���ü@pÒ��g�ÿ�prd�s\d%�Lc(g�trt�c��Zde�½���hprd!tOc�n�h�y��sÇdZý��hp,dhp-�»�D�®üUpVv����»s\pO�)~�ceq�g�ng��6�®üh�hs\}\fys\dhý(q�c�ü@cI�V�

Page 2: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FEy` ]FG�`

]IHr` ]IJ»` ]FK5`��sÇýe�hq�p�^�L8¾n(g�ý�pEq�pOýes\v_�Lq�gÀ��sÇced¦�ZqLceüh}Çprn!�Èm q�c�ü@cI��p��%�hs\�h�UpVf,�½sÇ��*g�}\gev_prqÈq�gIdhýep��NMZdZfyprqÈvLtrgIdZv�gov�t�prdhpÑ~�q�c�n }ÇcytrgÀ�Ls\c�dUv]IEy`Òg�dZf ]NG�`�w�prget��Ôq�g5� s\n(gIý�p(tOc�dZvLs\v_��v¦c�~Íg'vLp��,cI~Í�UcesÇd%��vÒsÇdâvL�Zg�tOp!]FHO`�wFsÇ~����hp�%s\pO��v,g�qLp(vL�h�@pOq�sÇn�@cevLprfÔqLpr}Ç�»s\dhýp��htO}Ç�ZvLs\��pO}\���Z�Uced���hp*fhgÀ��g(�hq�cÀ�%sufypVf�ü»����hp*qLceüUc���B v½pOdUt�cyfypOq�v½���hpOdÔgn�suvLngI��t���cytOtO�hq�vµ]IJ»`�w"g�dTgI}\ý�c�q�sÇ��hn ��ZgI�gI}\s\ý�dZv½vL�hqL~�g�t�pVvÍt�c�dUv���qL�Zt��LpVf|~�q�c�n ��hp�fhgI��gvLp���vÍsuv½gIüZ}ÇpÒ��ctOc�q�qLpVt��b��hp,nsuv_n(gI��t���gIdZf�npOq�ý�pÒü@cI��'s\n(gIý�pVvÒ]IKÀ`��

��ceqLprcÀ��pOqVlÀg¦�Zv_pO~��h}O092b�×�Lprt��Zdhs4�%�hp½n*�Zv_�;gI}uv_c,t�cedZvLs\fyprqÑsÇn(g�ý�p��¾gI}\s\ý�dhnpOd%�FqLpVv���qLsut���sÇcedZv�� �Iz��®legÒ�hq�c�üZ}Çprn���ZgI�Es\v�Zg�q_��s\tO�h}\g�qL}\�,~�gev���s\fys\c��UvÑsÇd|gÒnceühsÇ}\p�q�c�ü@cI�Eü@prtrgI�ZvLp½cI~"���hprpO}ZvL}Çs\�h�Zg�ý�p�]Av_prp3��sÇýe�hqLp,^5`��Fm�}Ç��hce�hý�(s\n(gIýep�gI}\sÇýedhnpOd%�suv�g�ÿ�pO��v���pO�'sÇd!���hp�t�cedZv���qL�Ut��Ls\c�d!cI~F�»s\vL�Zg�}"n�cyfypr}\vrlhsÇ��s\vogI}uv_c���Zp�t�}ug�v�v_sut¦qLceüUc��Í}\cytOg�}Çs4%rgI�Ls\c�d!�hqLceüh}\pOn vLpOprd�~�q�c�ng�fys�#7pOq�pOd%�bg�dhý�}\p��P8¾d(~�get��rle~�c�qÍg,n(gI�Q�Püh�ZsÇ}ufys\dhýµq�c�ü@cI�E���hprvLp����bc��hq�c�üZ}Çprnv�gIq�p�p��%�hs\�ÀgI}\pOd%��g�dZf|gIq�p�q�p�~�prqLq�prf(gevÑ��ZpR <?SUT6VW>YX$A[Z�\�T R V�\�]�X�V^<�_�X$>F<I\$A1X$A[`*SaX�bdc�T6<?V4`�<?A5e�]A�QfÈmo�Ô`½�hq�c�üh}\pOng��^VxylÈ^V�ylO/$�P�½�Tg�d»��s\ng�ý�p-�®g�}Çs\ý�dhnprde�Í��prt��hdhs+�%�hprvtOg�d ü@p�~�ce�hdZfâs\d ���hp�}\s���pOq�gÀ���hqLpelÑüh�y�(gI}\}�c�~½��hprn qLp��%�hsÇq�p�g9n�s\dhs\nµ�hn cÀ�epOq�}\g��YüUpO����prpOd pVg�t��âdhpr� sÇn(g�ý�p�g�dZf�@c�qL�Ls\c�dZvÒc�~;��Zp�prd»�%s\q�c�dhnpOd%��vLpOpOdÐü»����Zp�q�c�ü@cI��gI�Ò�ZqLpr�%s\c��Uv¦vLpOdUv_s\dhý'}ÇcytrgÀ�Ls\c�dUvh�Ç^rx��P�a���hprqLpO~�c�q�p�l+g!ý�c»cyfi092b��LpVt��hdhs+�%�hp,nµ�Zv_�½ý��Zg�q�g�d%�LpOpÓ��UgÀ�ovL�Zt���cÀ�epOq�}\g���ü@p����bpOprd�s\n(gIý�pVvÍcytOt��Zq�vr�8¾dÔ��hsuv,gIqL�Lsut�}\p�l"�bp(fyprv�t�q�sÇü@ph�hcÀ� ���hp(vLgI~�p�dUg5�%s\ýegI�Ls\c�d9g�dZfÐgI}\sÇýedhnpOd%��jÀ}ÇcytOg�}Çs4%rgI�Ls\c�d��hq�c�üZ}Çprnv,trgIdÔüUp(vLsÇn*�h}W�

��g�dhpOce�ZvL}Ç�Yg�fhfhqLpVvLvLprfÐü»�Ô�Uv_s\dhý R XDk�Z'lZYe$<I\$A R �.���hpVv_p!gIq�p��hp�}\g�qLýeprv_��qLprý�s\c�dZv,ýe�ZgIq�gId%��pOprfÔ��c9ü@p�v�gÀ~�p|ýesÇ�epOdY��ZpvLpOdZvLc�qÍq�prg�fhsÇdhý%vÍc�üy��gIs\dhprf!vLc*~�g�qr�,2b�|�Uv_s\dhý|v�gÀ~�pÒqLprý�s\c�dZvrl»s���suv½�@cev�v_s\üh}\p¦�Lc(sÇ�LpOq�gÀ��sÇ�epO}\�|üh�hs\}uf!g�n(gI�'ü»�|p-�»pVt��y��sÇdZý�hdhs\c�dþc��@pOq�gÀ�Ls\c�dUv,cÀ��prqµv_�UtOt�pVvLvLs\��p(�»sÇpr��v�]�ng�� üh�hs\}ufysÇdZý%`�lEg�dZfY�ZvLp(��Zs\v�vLg�np|n(gI�â~�ceqµncI��sÇcedâ�h}\g�dhdhs\dhýþ]AvLgI~�pdZg5�»s\ýegÀ��sÇcedU`��ÓmofhfysÇ�Ls\c�dUgI}\}Ç�el+vLgI~�pµq�pOý�s\c�dUv�tOg�dTüUp��ZvLprf'��c�g�de��s\tOsÇ�UgÀ�Lpµ��hp�cÀ��prqL}ugI�'ü@p����bpOprd�~��y�L�ZqLp��»sÇpr��vÓg�dZf'��Zpt��ZqLq�pOd%�*�UgIqL�LsugI}\}Ç�5�®üh�hs\}��µn(g�� ]�s\n(gIýep�gI}\s\ý�dhnpOd%��`�lEgIdUfâ�LcÐt�cen��Z�y�Lp�}ÇcytOgI�Ls\c�dZvµ��UgÀ�(t�c��Z}\fâ�@cI��pOd%�LsugI}\}\�YvLpOp!}ugIq�ý�p�hdhp-�y�h}ÇceqLpVfÔg�qLpVg�v�]�dhp-�»�D�®üUpVv����»s\pO�o`��a���hp(tOc�dZtOpO�y�,cI~½v�gÀ~�pqLprý�s\c�dZvÓc$#7pOq�v,g'v_s\dhýe}Çp*~�q�g�npO�bc�q�ÿ'�Lc�g�fhfhqLpVvLvÓ��ZprvLpvLpOpOns\dhý�}\�|�hdZqLpr}\gI�Lprf�suvLvL�hprvÍq�gIsuvLprf�ü%�|��hp�tOc�n�h�y��gÀ�Ls\c�d!cI~���Zp,dhp��»�D�®ü@prv_���%s\pO�,����hsuvog�q_��s\tO}Çp�suvofhsÇ�»sufyprf�s\d����bc|�Zg�q_��vO� ) g�q_��8½s\d%�Lq�c»fh�Zt�pVv½��Zp,~�c�q�n(gI}�fhp�MZdhsÇ�Ls\c�d9cI~;g|v�gÀ~�p�q�pOýesÇcedâ]A�»pVt��Ls\c�dÐ��`�l

gIdUfT���hp(t�c�n�h}\p��ysÇ���TcI~Ít�cen��Z�y�Ls\dhý!��hsuv,q�pOýesÇced�~�qLcen vLpOdZvLc�q,fhgI��gY]A�»pVt���sÇcedÐ�%`��m���hp(ý�prdhpOq�gI}�~�c�q�n cI~bc��hq�092b�gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��Zn�s\v�fhprv�t�q�sÇü@prf�sÇdT�»pVt���sÇced!�U�8¾d ) gIqL��88�lI��p�fhprv�t�q�sÇü@pb��hp½s\n�h}ÇprnpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d�cI~"gIdg�t����ZgI}yn(g��6�PüZ�hsÇ}ufys\dhý,q�c�ü@cI�Lsutbv_�yv_�LpOn'��8¾dc�q�fypOq��Lc�get����ZgI}\}Ç�

üh�hs\}uf g'}\g5�ec��y��c�~�g�üh�hs\}\fhsÇdhýUlFsÇd gefhfysÇ�Ls\c�dY�LcT��hp�tOc�n�h�y��gÀ��sÇcedâcI~Í��hp�dhp��»��Pü@prv_�µ�»sÇpr� cI��ZpOq�ce�Uprq�gI�Ls\c�dZv,n*�Zv_�gI}uvLc���gIÿep(�h}\get�pe�'���hpVv_p(ce�Uprq�gI�Ls\c�dZvÒs\dZtO}Ç�Zfhp|�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdZp|ý�prdhpOq�gÀ��sÇced9~�q�c�n q�g�dhý�p(fhgI��ghlFgIdUfÔncyfypr}�gI}\s\ý�dhnpOd%�µg�dZfnpOq�ý�s\dhý9]P�»prt��Ls\c�di/%`��;���hp*vL�UpVt�s�MUth032b�èg�}Çýec�q�s����hn pOnµü@prfZfyprf�s\d9ce�hqo�ZqLc��LcI���»�@p�]A�yprt���sÇcedn��`½suvÓg�}\vLc�fypVvLtOqLs\üUpVfs\d����hp�vLprt�cedZf*�ZgI}Ç~�c�~È���hs\vogIqL�Lsut�}\p��=���hp�vL�»v_�Lprn gIq�t��hsÇ�LpVt��L�ZqLp,gIdUf�p-�»�@pOq�s\n�prd%��v½gIq�p,fyprv�t�q�s\üUpVf�s\dT�»prt��Ls\c�d�xh���sÇdUgI}\}Ç�el"sÇd �»pVt��Ls\c�dÐ�!��pfyprv�t�q�s\üUp���ZptO�hq�qLprde�Òn(g�7�ceqÓ}\sÇnsÇ��gI�Ls\c�dZvÒc�~�c��Zq¦�bc�q�ÿ7l"g�v¦��pr}Ç}EgevÒv_cen�p�s\n��@c�qL��g�d%�

p��»��pOdZvLsÇcedZvb�Lcü@p,sÇd»�eprv_�Ls\ýegÀ��prf�sÇd!~��y���hq�p,qLpVv_pVgIq�t��+�

Page 3: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

Sensor

observable portion of wall

τθ

��sÇýe�hq�p,�Q�P8¾dZt�sufypOdUt�p�t�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de���PoÐg�}Ç}+vLprt��Ls\c�dZv½g�qLp,vLpOpOd!c�dZ}Ç�|sÇ~�p�qCp^r&s"�

tvu ö�õ ó

8¾dÐ��hsuvwMZq�v_���ZgIqL�,cI~Íc��hq�g�q_��s\tO}Çp�bp(�½sÇ}\}Es\de��qLcyfy�Ut�p���hp�t�c�dUt�pO�h�Òc�~Ív�gÀ~�p(q�pOýesÇced+�(m ÿ�pr�TqLpVv_�Z}���suv����hprc�q�pOn �Z�Ç^el���hsut��Ôv_��gI�LprvÓ���ZgÀ��g�}ÇcytOg�}ÑvLgI~�p*q�pOýesÇcedTs\v¦dhc'nc�q�p*tOc�n�h}\p������ZgIdÔ��hp�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ����qLprý�s\c�d9tOc�n�h�y��prfÔ�hdZfyprq,t�}ug�v�v_sut�hdhq�prv_�Lq�sut��LpVf�»s\vLsÇüZsÇ}\s����e�=���hpo�hq�c»cI~"cI~"���hsuvE���hpOceqLprn g�}\vLc,�hq�cÀ�»s\fypVv;g�tOc�dZv_�Lq��Zt��Ls\��p��Íg5�*c�~+t�c�n�h�h�Ls\dhý*v�gÀ~�pÓqLprý�s\c�dZvr�

�ygI~�p½qLprý�s\c�dZvFgIq�pb��hprd(�ZvLprf*�Lc,sÇ�Lprq�gI�Ls\��pO}\�µtOc�dZv_�Lq��Zt��;g¦n(gI�È�P���Zs\vEg��h�hq�ceget��µ}\prg�fZvÑ��prqL��dUgÀ�L�Zq�g�}Ç}\�,�Lc�g¦ýepOdhprq�g�}gIdUfC Zp-�ysÇüh}\p�032b� g�}Çýec�q�s����hn'�P���Zs\v½g�}Çýec�q�s����hn suvb��hp�tOpOd%�Lq�gI}+tOc�n�UcedhpOd%�½cI~���Zp�v_�yv_�LpOn�fyprv�t�q�sÇü@prf!s\d ) g�q_��88��

x ygz�{9ô�û�õFû�÷�ô ÷}|�~ u |$z���z���û�÷*ô!�

�»�h�Z�Uc%v_p'���ZgÀ���Zp�qLceüUc��suvp��%�hs\�h�@prf��½sÇ�� gÐ�Uce}\g�q(q�g�dhý�p'v_prdZvLc�qnprg�vL�hq�sÇdZýÔ���hp�fysuv���gIdZtOp'~�qLcen ��hpTvLpOdUv_ceq�B vt�prd%�LpOqo�Lc|ceü67�prt���vÓ}Ç�»s\dhý|s\d9ga�hceqLs4%Oced%��gI}È�h}\g�dhp�}\cytOgÀ��prf�gI�9�hprsÇý��e�w�9g�üUcÀ�epÒ��hp} Zc»c�qV��2�pVtOg��Zv_p�g�}Ç}��»s\vL�Zg�}�vLpOdZvLc�q�vgIq�p!}Çs\ns���prf�sÇd�q�gIdhýep�lE�bp!gevLvL�hnp!��ZgI�(c�ü67�pVt���vtrgId�c�dh}\�âüUpTfhp��LpVt���prf �½s����hsÇd gÐfysuv���gIdZtOp'�������5�&8¾d�gefhfysÇ�Ls\c�d+lncev_�½q�g�dhý�p-�FMZdUfypOq�vÍtOgIdZdhcI�½q�pO}\s\g�üh}Ç��fyp���prt��ovL�hqL~�g�tOprvÍc�q�s\pOd%�LpVf�gI�Íýeq�g%Os\dhýgIdhýe}ÇpVvÍ�½s����!q�prvL�@prt��Í��c��hp�vLpOdZvLc�q,]Av_prp��sÇýe�hq�p�e`��*aopOdZtOp�l+�bp(gI}uv_c'g�v�vL�hnpµ���ZgÀ��vL�hq_~�get�p��UcesÇd%��vo���ZgÀ��fyc'dhc���vLgI�Lsuv�~��'���hp(v_prdZv_ceq�B vÓsÇdZtOs\fhpOdZtOptOc�dZv_�Lq�gIs\d%�tOg�dhdhc��Íü@p,q�pO}\s\g�üh}Ç��fyp���prt���prf!ü»�(��Zp�v_prdZv_ceqr�=�Zc�q�ng�}Ç}\��lyce�hqÍ�»s\vLsÇüZsÇ}\s�����nc»fhpO}+suvb��hpÒ~�ce}Ç}\cÀ�½s\dhý��

�'���P�������F�O���L�I�����'�I�����P�I�F���� �¡¢��£���¤*¥��¢¦��I£��§�¢¦���¨Q��£ª©«¨Q��¬O�®­}�[���-��¤�¨��I�¯����°®± Z->a>?@�Z1\�b�Z�A R T�c R Z->"² ³µ´�¶`Z R ]�l�<Ic�Z!>�@QZ':(\$l· R b�X]�Z!V�X$¸\�T6>�¹ ± Z�>�º¯² c�Z'>?@�Z»c�\�T6A[`�X�l�¸n\�kh²¼¹�½¼b�\�<?A�>�¾À¿Áº¯² < R �»suv_s\üh}\pmk�l�\�SµX«b�\�<?A�> ¿»²Ã< k">?@�Z(k�\$V?V�\�:=<?A§e»]�\�A[`$<?>F<I\$A R X$lZ�>Nl�T�Z�Ä

Å ¹�fÈsÇdhp,c�~�vLsÇý��%�½tOc�dZv_�Lq�gIs\d%��ÄmƯ@QZh\�b�Z�A®V^<?A[Z R ZYe$SaZ�AO>�ǽ]I¾�È Â `=É-\$<?A�<?A§e  X�A¯`"¾Ê`�\�Z R A[\$>(<?AO>YZ-l R Z�]->Pº[²Ë¹Ì ¹�i�g�dhý�pÔt�c�dUv���q�g�sÇd%��ÄnJ@]  ÈD¾!`nrÍ��������Îa:¢@QZ-lZ!J@]  ÈD¾!`.< R >�@QZ»Ï�T�]-V^<I`Z�X�A�`$< R >�X�A¯]�Z®c�Z->F:(Z�Z-A  X$A[`.¾»Î«X�A[`�������9Ð�z»< R X$A.<?A�b¯T6>�]�\�A R >YX$A�>�¹

Ñ ¹�8¾dZtOs\fhpOdZtOpµt�cedZv���q�g�sÇd%��Ä3Ò¦]�ÓwÈDÔÈ`9rªs¯Î�:¢@QZ-lZ;ÓÕ< R X*Ö�Z�]->�\�l�b�Z-lNbQZ-A[`$<I]�T6V�X$lU>�\Uº[² X$>P¾»Î�ÔvX«Ö�Z�]�>�\�lh\�l�<IZ-A�>�Z�`k�l\$S×¾µ>Y\  ÎØX$A[`}s*¿1� zQÈDÙ¢Ú����(< R X$A.<?A�b¯T6>�]�\$A R >YX$A�>b]�vLpOp"��sÇýe�hqLp��e`-¹

o sÇ��hce�y�;gId»�,}\cev�vFcI~UýepOdhprq�g�}ÇsÇ����lÀ�bp½g�v�v_�Zn�p���UgÀ�Ñ��ZpÍvLpOdUv_ceq�suvF}\c»trgÀ��prf�gÀ�Ñ��ZpbceqLs\ý�s\dµc�~U���hp½t�c»c�q�fys\dZgÀ��pbvL�yv���pOn]����hp¦��ceqLÿyvL�Zg�tOp�tOgId|g�}Ç�Íg5�yvÑü@pÓq�p��®n(gI�h�@prf���c*g�q�p�~�prqLprdZt�p�~�q�g�n�p¦t�prde��pOq�prfced(��hp¦v_prdZvLc�q�`��Pf+p���²Û³ª´�¶ofypVvLtOqLs\ü@p��Zp,��ceqLÿyvL�Zg�tOp�l»gIdZf!}\p��3º¯² ü@pÒ��hp,ü@c��hdUfhgIq��|cI~P²ñ�,���hp�v_prdZvLc�q�B vbc��h�L�h�y��suv½g�v�vL�hnprf��Lc(ü@p�g�vb~�c�}\}\cÀ��v-�

�'���P�������F�O���L�+�&��©*¨Q��¬O�.ÜÝ�§�¢����¤!Þa¡¢�-ßP¡Ý��° Ư@QZm\$T6>^b¯T6>�\Dk�XClX$A5e5Z R Z-A R \�l"< R X$A®\$l`Z-lZ�`CVW< R >Pà"ÎØlZYb¯lZ R Z-A�>N<?A5e>�@QZ R Z�]�>N<I\�A R \�khº¯² Ö�< R <Ic-V�Z�k�l�\�Sá>�@QZ»\�l�<We<?A�T6A¯`Z-lhâhZIã(A�<?>N<I\�A Ì ¹ Å ¹&Ï�Ö�Z�l�¸'�y]�qhw�EOÈ�G�`'¿Áàä< R X«b�\�V4X�lwk�T6A[]->F<I\$A`Z R ]�l�<Ic-<?A5eåX R Z�]->N<I\�A�\�k'º¯²æÎ*X$A[` R T�]�@.k�T6A¯]�>N<I\�Aç< R ]�\$A�>N<?A�T�\$T Raè q׿ ]IE[È�G�`nX�A[`&T6A¯`ZFã,A¯Z�`&Z-V R Z�:¢@�Z�lZ�¹éà]�\�AO>YX$<?A R X�>9Sm\ R >w\�A¯Z3k�T6A¯]�>N<I\�Aê`ZFã,A[Z�`}k�\�l«X�AO¸aqi¿ ]�ë�Ù=ÈÙ¯�hìY<I¹?Z�¹�Î;A¯\!>F:(\}k�T6A[]->F<I\$A R \�Ö�Z�l�V4X�b�í�Î�X�A¯`»>�@QZ«V^< R >9< R\�l�`Z-lZ�`*]�\�T6AO>YZ-l�îD]-V�\�]�·$:=< R Z�¹

Page 4: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]FGO` ]IHO`

��s\ý��ZqLp,�Q�,ï,#@pVt��½cI~Fs\dZt�sufypOdUt�p,c�d'v�gÀ~�pÒqLprý�s\c�dZvr�

ð s\��pOdÐgIdÐc�üZvLpOq��ÀgÀ��sÇcediàñn(g�fypü»����Zp(qLceüUc��ÒgI�,g!}\cytOgÀ��sÇcediñ»l+�bp(fyp�MUdhp��hp!V�\�]�X�V R XDk�ZClZYe<I\�A�ò�ó�]FñI`Òg�v¦��Zp}ugIq�ý�prv_�½qLprý�s\c�d!ý��Zg�q�g�d%�LpOpVf|��c|ü@p,~�qLprp,cI~Fc�üZv_��get�}\prvr�(oª�hs\}\p�q�g�dhý�pÒq�prv_�Lq�s\t��Ls\c�dZv��Zg5��p,gId'ceü%�»s\c��ZvÍs\n�Zg�t��oc�d�ò�ó�]FñI`�l��Zp*p-#@pVt��ÒcI~;s\dZt�sufyprdZt�p�s\vÓnc�q�p*vL�hüy��}Çpe�;8¾d®��sÇýe�hqLp��Z]FE»`�l+g�vLpOdZvLc�q¦fyp���prt���vÓ��hpvL�hq_~�get�p�t�c�d%��c��hq¦vD�hcÀ�½d9sÇdÔüh}\get�ÿ7�m dZgIs\��p'gI�Z�hqLc%g�t��ân(g5�!7�c�s\d ��hp�fypO�Lprt��LpVf vL�hqL~�g�t�pVv*�LcÔ��hp'�@pOq�sÇnp���pOq}\sÇnsÇ�|cI~����hp�v_prdZv_ceqrl�gIdZf t�c�dUv_sufypOq����hs\vq�pOý�s\c�d*~�q�pOp½~�q�c�nèc�üZv_��get�}\prv½]����hpoq�pOýesÇced*suvEv�hcÀ�½dsÇd(}\s\ý�%�;t�ce}Çceq�`���2bprtrgI�ZvLpb��hpÓv_prdZv_ceqEsuvÑ�hdZg�üh}Çp��Lc�fypO�Lprt���vL�hq_~�get�pVvc�q�s\pOd%�LpVf�gI�Eý�q�g$%rsÇdhý,g�dhý�}\prvrlI���hs\v;qLprý�s\c�d�n(g5�µü@p�dhcI�Eü@pov�gÀ~�pel%gevEvD�ZcÀ�½d*s\dT]FG�`��Ñm×�Lq��hpov�gÀ~�p½q�pOýesÇced*suv;v�hcÀ�½dsÇd�]FHO`�l~�c�q�g�d�s\dZtOs\fyprdZt�p�tOc�dZv_�Lq�gIs\d%�½cI~¢s«ôv�Àz�fypOýU�

õ ö ÷U÷ùø�ù�õ u õFûO÷*ô u�ú öñ÷h÷ûø ú z�ü!û�õ¯ý ÷U|ç~ u |$zÊ��z��*ûO÷*ô!�

f+pO��º¯ò�óZü@pÓ���hpÒüUce�hdZfhg�qL�(c�~È���hp,qLprý�s\c�d*ò�ó��,º¯ò�óZsuvbtOc�n�@cevLprf�ü%�|vLc�}\suf�g�dZf|~�q�pOpÒt��ZqL�eprvr�Fm R \�VW<I`«]-T6l�Ö�ZÍq�pO�ZqLpVv_prde��vgId!c�üUv_prqL�eprf�vLprt��Ls\c�d'cI~Pº¯²èlhg�dZf!s\v½tOc�d%��g�sÇdZprf�sÇd!��Zp,}Çsuv��3àµ�ð s\��pOd|����c�v_ce}Çsuf|t��ZqL�eprv�þ���ÿ�]�qhw�EQÿ�È�G�ÿ�`�È� ¶ ]�qhw�E ¶ È�G ¶ `����êà�l§� ¶ suvÍvLg�s\f��c R T�]�]�Z�Z�`3��ÿ�s�~�dhc*c���hprq�pr}ÇprnpOd%��s\d*à s\v

fyp-MZdhprf|sÇd���hpÓsÇd%�LprqL�Àg�}�� G-ÿ�È�E ¶ �®�Fm t��hq���p��F]�qhw�G-ÿ�È�E ¶ `¯7�cesÇdZsÇdhý�g��Zg�sÇq¦]���ÿ�È� ¶ `ÑcI~ÈvL�Ztrt�prv�vLsÇ�epov_pVt���sÇcedZvEsuv�trgI}\}ÇpVf|g3k�l�Z�Z]-T6l�Ö�ZbsÇ~���]�^5`;dZc*�hdUfyp���prt���prf!c�üUv���g�t�}\p¦s\v½tOc�d%��g�sÇdhpVf|s\d����hpÒ�Uce}\g�qÍqLprý�s\c�d*G-ÿ��&q��&E ¶ ü@c��hdZfhprf�ü%���whg�dZfÐ]A��`;���hs\vq�pOý�s\c�d�s\v½��hp,}ugIq�ý�pVv��Í�Uc%vLvLs\üh}Çpe�8¾d�c�q�fypOq��Lc�tOc�n�h�y��pb��hp½}\cytOgI}hv�gÀ~�pÍq�pOýesÇced*gÀ�,ñÓ��pÍdhprprfµ�Lc�tOc�n�h�y��p����hpÍ~�q�pOp½t��hq���pVv���ZgI�¯7�c�s\d�pVg�t���v_�Ztrt�pVvLvLsÇ�ep

�Zg�sÇq¦sÇd®à s\d9ceq�fyprq���c�ü@c��hdUf'��hp�q�pOý�s\c�d®ò�ó�]IñI`��;8®�¦�L�ZqLdZvÓc��h�o��UgÀ�¦��hpt�cen��Z}Çp-�»sÇ���'cI~�Ysuv���]� �`��;8¾dT~�get��rl"g|~�qLprpt��ZqL�ep��9tOg�d�ü@p�fyprv�t�q�s\üUpVf��ZvLs\dhý(dhcnc�q�pÓ���ZgId��*~��hdZt��Ls\c�d'�hq�sÇnsÇ�Ls\��pVv-���� �§��¤������Ý�I�����ݤ��§�i­U¡¢¤��O�§��°�� T�bb�\ R Zm� ¶ ]�qZwE ¶ È�G ¶ ` R T�]�]�Z�Z�` R � ÿ ]�qhw�E ÿ È�G ÿ `'<?Aê>?@�Z�\�T6>Wb[T6>wV^< R >3àá\�k!X R Z�A R \�l\�b�Z-lX�>N<?A5e'T6A¯`Z-l;âhZIã(A�<?>N<I\�A Ì ¹ Ì X�A¯`*V�\�]�X$>YZ�`!X�>�>�@QZm\�l�<We<?A[¹��Ik3º¯² < R ]�\�AO>F<?AOT�\�T R V^¸!`�< �3Z-lZ-A�>N<IXc-V�Z�Î�>�@QZ-Ai>�@QZ�k�l�Z�Z]-T6l�Ö�Z��F]�qhw�G ÿ È�E ¶ `h]�\$A�A¯Z�]->N<?A5e"� ÿ >�\"� ¶ ]�\$A R < R > R \�kUX�>�Sm\ R >�>�@§lZ�Z�b[<IZ�]�Z R ¹3Ï�X�]�@ab¯<IZ�]�ZU< R Z�<?>�@QZ-lUX«V^<?A[Z R ZYe$SaZ�AO>IÎ�X]-<?l]�T6V4X�laX�l]�Î�\$lmX R Z�]�>N<I\�A \DkhX*V�\�e5X�l�<?>�@§Sh<I] R b[<?lX$V,\�kU>?@�Z�k�\�l�SË�aôç���+p��y�+]! �"�qe`'ìY:¢@QZ-lZ�"iô ��g�d�sêX$A[`h���*< R X]�\�A R >�X�AO>Wí¹0�c��Lp���ZgI���hp!��ZpOc�q�pOn g�}\vLcÔg��h�h}\sÇpVv����hpOd ��hp�vLpOdZvLc�q�suv}ÇcytOgI�LpVfþgÀ�(gId×gIq�ühsÇ�Lq�gIq��Ô�@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�ddñ§� ð s\��pOd ��Zp

c�üUv_prqL�ÀgÀ��sÇced'à*]IñI`�lZq�p��®ng������hpµfhgI��g���c|gqLpO~�pOq�pOdZtOpÓ~�q�gInp�tOpOd%�LprqLpVf!gI�3ñ*g�dZf'tOg�}Ç}"���hsuv�à$#P�%�ÓdUt�pÒ��ZpÒ~�qLprp�t��hq���pVvgIq�p,t�cen��Z�y�LpVf"lhgI�h�Z}Ç����hp,s\d»��pOq�vLpo��q�g�dZv�~�ceqLn(gI�Ls\c�d|��cp��y�hq�prv�vb��hp,q�prvL�h}Ç��vÍs\d!ýe}ÇceüZgI}"tOc%ceq�fhsÇdZgI�LpVvO����hp��ZqLc»cI~FcI~,���hprc�q�pOn �h�\^,s\vo}Çcedhý�gIdUf!�LprfhsÇce�ZvOl@gIdZf'suv½���hpOq�p�~�ceqLp,s\dZtO}Ç�Zfhprf's\d���hp*gI�h�@pOdZfhsW�"��2b�y�o���hp�n(gIs\d

t�cedZvLp��%�hpOdUt�p;c�~Z���hp;���hpOceqLprn�s\v����ZgÀ�Ego~�qLprpbtO�hqL�ep&�;7�cesÇdZsÇdhýw��ÿE�½sÇ��U� ¶ suvFg�~��hdUt��Ls\c�d�cI~Uc�dh}\�Ò��hp½vLpOdZvLc�q�t�cedZv���q�g�sÇd%��vgIdUfT���hppOdZfy�@c�s\d%��vÒc�~(��ÿ�g�dZf.� ¶ �m���ZgÀ�,suvOl'�Ys\vm<?A¯`Z�bQZ-A[`�Z�AO>ÑcI~���hp(t�cen�h}Çp-�ys����Tc�~E��Zp(��ceqLÿyvL�Zg�tOp}² gIdUf9tOg�dü@p*t�cen�h�y�LpVf�s\d9t�cedZv���gId%�o��sÇnpe�38¾dZfyprprf"l@sÇ~Øàµ]FñI`otOc�d%��g�sÇdZv)( vLc�}\s\f9t��hq���pVvOlZ��hprd.º ò�ó�]IñI`ot�c�d%��gIs\dZv�dhc�nc�q�p,��Zg�d�*( g�fZfys���sÇcedZgI}�~��hdUt��Ls\c�dÔ�hq�sÇnsÇ�Ls\��prvr�"2bprtOg��ZvLp���Zp�tOc�n�h}\p��ys����'c�~Øàµ]FñI`ÓtrgIdhdZcI�Óü@p�}ÇpVvLvÓ��UgId+(Ðl@��hp(tOc�n�h}\p��ys����cI~,ò�ó�]FñI`bs\vÍ�½sÇ��hs\dTgt�cedZv���gId%�½�hq�c��@c�qL�Ls\c�dZg�}ÇsÇ����~�g�t���c�qÍ~�q�c�n����hp�t�cen�h}Çp-�ys����|c�~Pà*]IñI`�����hp�hq�c»cI~;suvÒüZg�vLprfÔc�dÐg't�c�d%��sÇd»�hsÇ���TgIq�ý��hnprde�V��mo}����hc��Zý�Ô��hp(v�ZgI�@pcI~;���hp��ceqLÿyvL�Zg�tOpµn(g5�Tü@p(gIq�ühs���q�g�qL�el

² qLpr�hq�prvLpOd%��v*gT�Q�»�yv_sutOg�}�vL�Zg�tOp�tOc�d%��g�sÇdhs\dhýT���%�yvLs\trgI}�c�ü67�pVt���vr�®8®��v*üUce�hdZfhg�qL�1º¯² t�c�dUv_suv���v�c�~og9vLp��*c�~�,ec�q�fhgId

Page 5: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

1s−

r 21rp

2

p1

s+1

l 1

l2

τ

τ

��sÇýe�hq�p¦�O�Ñm�d'p��hgIn�h}\pÒcI~Ñg*~�qLprp�t��hq���pÒt�cedZv���qL�Ut��Ls\c�dÈ�

t��ZqL�eprv�]�sA� p��\l@tO}Çc%v_pVf!}Çc»c��Uv½sÇdT��hp��Z}\g�dhp����hsut��Tfyc|dhc��os\de��pOq�v_pVt��½���hpOn(vLpO}\��prv�`�l7gIdUf�pVg�t��-,ec�q�fhgId't��ZqL�ep,s\vosÇdTsÇ��vLpO}Ç~g't�cede��sÇd»�hce�Zv,t��ZqL�ep��m8®~�g�fhfysÇ�Ls\c�dUgI}\}Ç�T�bppOdy~�ceq�tOp���ZgI�,��hp|tO�hqL�eps\v�fhsW#7pOq�pOd%�LsugIüZ}Çpel+��ZpOdY��p(trgIdâvD�ZcÀ� ��UgÀ�,��Zp�hdhceüZvLpOq���prf'vLprt��Ls\c�d�cI~(º/. }\�%s\dhý�üUpO����prpOdTg|vL�ZtOtOprv�v_s\��pµ�ZgIs\q�cI~;vLc�}\suf�t��hq���pVvotOg�dhdhc��oüUp�gIq�ühsÇ�Lq�gIq�sÇ}\��t�}\cevLp,��c|��ZpvLpOdZvLc�qV�=�Ècs\}Ç}\�Zv_�Lq�gÀ�Lp¦���hs\v��UcesÇd%�rlZ��p,vLÿ�p���t��*�ZpOq�p¦cedhp,tOgev_pÒcI~���hp,�ZqLc»cI~��f+pO�C��ÿ�]�qhw�EQÿ�È�G�ÿ�`gIdUfd� ¶ ]IqhwE ¶ È�G ¶ `�üUpÔgÐvL�Ztrt�prv�vLsÇ�ep!�UgIs\q|cI~,v_ce}Çsuf�t��hq���pVvOlÍgIdZf×vL�h�h�@cevLp'��ZgI�(��hp9sÇdZtOs\fhpOdZtOpt�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de���Íg�v�p��ht�prprfypVfÔs\nnprfysugÀ��pO}\�ÐgI~��LpOqUq.ô G-ÿ�]I��sÇýe�hq�p|�%`��'���hprqLpO~�c�q�p�l���hp�dhc�q�n(gI}Ñ��c�º[² s\n�npVfys\gI�Lpr}Ç�

gÀ~���pOqw��ÿµsuvÒc�q�sÇprd%�Lprf9gÀ��g�ýeq�g%Os\dhý�g�dhý�}\p*�½sÇ��Ðq�prvL�UpVt��¦�Lc���hp(vLpOdZvLc�qV�"oª�ZgÀ��trgId9�bpvLg5��gIü@c��h�¦���hp��hdhc�üUv_prqL�eprfvLprt���sÇced�c�~Pº/. }Ç�»s\dhýüUpO����prpOd!��ÿ¦g�dZf'� ¶10kÓp�MZdhp���hp!�@c�s\de��v$2 ÿ«ô ]436ÿ�È�G-ÿO`�g�dZf52 ¶ ô ]63 ¶ ÈE ¶ `�lÑ���hpOq�p3Qÿ«ô ��ÿÀ]NG-ÿO`µgIdZf�3 ¶ ôé� ¶ ]IE ¶ `�]�vLpOp'��sÇýe�hqLp��%`���»�h�Z�Uc%v_p���UgÀ�¦��hpü@c��hdZfZgIq���cI~ز tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hprv¦gÀ~���pOq72 ÿ �½sÇ��Ðs���v,v_�Zq_~�get�pµdZc�q�ng�}Ñt�c�dUv���gId%�L}\��c�q�sÇprd%�Lprf9gÀ�«Z98§X�]�>NV^¸gId×gIdZý�}\p's×�½sÇ��×q�prvL�UpVt���LcY���hpTv_prdZvLc�q�B v�}\sÇdhp-�Pc�~?�®vLs\ý�%�r�ê���hsuv|t��hq���p's\d×�Uce}\g�qtOc»c�q�fysÇdUgÀ�LpVvm�Zg�v����hp'~�c�q�n�� ô���"p��y��� �"�]�q"ë®q*�O`��Pl7���hprqLp�����ô:3 ÿ gIdUf»q*�wô�G ÿ �;���hs\vÓ}ug�v_�Óp��%�ZgI�Ls\c�dTfyp-MZdhpVv����bc�vL�hsÇq�gI}uv��Íg�v_�hs\q�gI}�ò�; ÿ ýeqLcÀ�½s\dhýt�ce�hd%�LprqD�¾t�}\cyt�ÿ%�½suvLp|~�q�c�n<2 ÿ ô ]43 ÿ È�G ÿ `']�ceqv�hq�sÇdZÿ%s\dhýât�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLpV`�l;gIdZf�gYv_pVt�cedZf vL�hs\q�g�}�ò*=ÿ v�hqLs\dhÿ»s\dhýÐtOc��hd%��pOq�t�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLp,~�q�c�n>2 ÿ ]�ceqoý�q�cÀ�½s\dhý�t�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLpV`��¦�»c�~�gIqVlU�bpµn(g5��t�cedZt�}\�Zfypµ��ZgI�wº¯² nµ�Zv_�¦tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hp�~�q�c�n>2 ÿ s\dT��Zpt�ce�hd%�LprqD�¾t�}\cyt�ÿ%�½suvLp¦fys\q�prt���sÇced�prs����hpOq?LgIü@cÀ��p�@Uò ; ÿ c�qA?LüUpr}ÇcÀ�)@mòB=ÿ whcI���hpOq��½suv_pel»��hp�s\dZtOs\fyprdZt�p�tOc�dZv_�Lq�gIs\d%�½��ce�h}\f�dhc���Zg5�epÓü@pOprd!�»s\c�}ugÀ��prf"�2b�y�*º¯² trgIdhdZcI��t�ced%�Ls\d%�Zp�üUpr}ÇcÀ��òB=ÿ ~�c�q(���hpTp��hg�n��Z}Çp9v�hcÀ�½d×s\dê��s\ý��hq�pT�U�å��cþvD�ZcÀ� ��Zs\vrl�v_�Z�h�Uc%v_p�º¯²

t�ced%�Ls\d%�ZprvÓüUpr}ÇcÀ�×ò =ÿ lÈ���hs\t��ÔsÇn�h}\s\prvÓ��ZgI��º[² ü@pOdZfZv¦�LcÀ�ÍgIq�f'��hpvLpOdZvLc�q¦sÇnnprfhs\gI�LpO}\�TgÀ~���pOqw��ÿI��oÐp*ÿ»dhcÀ� ��ZgI�º¯² fyc»prv�dhcI�Ít�q�cev�vÑ��ZpÓceqLs\ý�s\d+l%pO}uv_pÓdhcI���hsÇdZýµ�½s\}Ç}7ü@po�»s\vLs\üh}Çp¦�hdZfhpOqÍkop-MZdhsÇ�Ls\c�d!�h�Ç^ÓgIdZf*à)�bc��h}uf(ü@pÓprn��h�����=���»�ZvOlº¯²À�Zg�v��Lc�ü@pOdZf�c��y���ÍgIq�fhvrw%g�dZf|sÇ���Ug�v;�Lcfyc�vLcµü@p�~�ceqLp¦t��y�L�Ls\dhý���hp¦q�g5�DC ¶ 7�c�s\dhs\dhýµ���hp¦c�q�sÇýesÇd|�½sÇ��D2 ¶ l»cI��ZpOq��½s\vLp� ¶ �½sÇ}\};ü@p|cytOtO}Ç�Zfhprf"�'�»sÇdUt�p«º¯² suvµfhsW#7pOq�pOd%�LsugIüZ}Çpel+��ZpOq�p|nµ�Zv_��ü@p�g'�UcesÇd%�$2â���ZpOq�p��hp|dZc�q�ng�}Ñ�Lc�º¯² �UcesÇd%��v�LcÀ�ÍgIq�fhv;��hp,ceqLs\ý�s\d+�P���hpOq�p�~�ceqLpel»��hpÒ�»sut�s\dhs�����cI~E2'suv½g��%suvLsÇüh}\pÒ�Uceq_��sÇced�c�~�º¯²ñ�=2��h�½��hsuvÍ�»sÇce}\gI�Lprvbce�hq�g�v�v_�Zn��h�Ls\c�d��UgÀ��� ¶ vL�Ztrt�pOpVfhv�� ÿ lZvLcaº[² nµ�Zv_�ot�cede��sÇd»�hp,g�üUcÀ�epwò ; ÿ ��hce}Ç}\cÀ�½s\dhý*gvLsÇns\}\g�qbq�prgev_cedhs\dhýZl»sÇ�ÍsuvÍ�@cev�v_s\üh}\pÓ��c(g�tOtOc��hd%�b~�c�q½pr��pOq���Uc%vLvLs\üh}Çp,tOc�nµüZsÇdZgI�Ls\c�d�cI~�pr��prde��vOlhfhpO�@pOdZf§�

s\dhý�c�dY���hpO��hprq,��hp�v_prdZv_ceq,}Çs\dhp-�Pc�~?�®vLsÇý��%�Ò�Íg�vÒcytrt�}\�Zfyprf+lÈ���hp|q�gIdhýeptOc�dZv_�Lq�gIs\d%�,�bgevÒp��ht�prprfypVf"l�ceqÒ��hp�sÇdZtOs\fhpOdZtOpt�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de�Í�Íg�vÍp��htOpOprfhprf"�=8¾d���hp�g��h�@pOdZfys��"lZgI}\}+tOgev_pVv½gIq�p,fyprv�t�q�sÇü@prf�s\d'fhp���g�sÇ}P�

F%GIH J&KML�NPOQNSRUTIVUWYX[Z\V^]�NSZ\_`TINba���hp�qLprý�s\c�d}ò�ó�]FñI`+suv+��c��@c�}\c�ýes\trgI}\}Ç�Óp��%�hs\�5g�}Çprd%�È�Lco��hpÍt�}ug�v�vLs\tÑ�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���ÒqLprý�s\c�d+�Ý8¾dZfypOpVf"lÀ���hprd,��hpÍvLpOdZvLc�q+q�prv_�Lq�sut��Ls\c�dUvs\d!kÓp�MZdZs���sÇced'�h�Ç^ÒgIq�poq�pO}ug��yprf+le���hp,vLgI~�pÓq�pOýesÇced|ü@prt�cenprvb��Zp¦�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���(q�pOý�s\c�dÈ�����hprqLpO~�c�q�p�lyvLpO��prq�g�}U�ZqLce�Uprq_��sÇpVv�g�dZfgI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��ZnvE��ZgI�Íg��h�h}\���Lcµ�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���qLprý�s\c�dZv�gI}uv_c*gI�h�h}\���LcvLgI~�poq�pOýesÇcedZvO���hceq�p-�yg�n�h}Çpel����hpÒv_prý�npOd%�btOc�dhdZprt���sÇdZýUñ�½sÇ��c2�suv½pOd%�Ls\q�pO}\��t�cede��gIs\dhprf!s\d�ò�ó�]IñI`b~�ceq�gId»�d2»¿.ò�ó�]IñI`������ZgÀ��suvrlOò�ó�]IñI`½s\v�gnprnµü@pOq�c�~����hp�t�}ug�v�vÍcI~ R >YX$l�lZYe$<I\$A R� q�pOýesÇcedZv���ZgI�ogIq�pÓprde��sÇq�pO}\�|ceüZv_prqL�Àg�üh}Çp¦~�q�c�n gI�½}ÇpVg�v_�½g(vLs\dhý�}\pÒsÇd%�LprqLs\c�qÍ�@c�s\d%�otOgI}\}\prf���hp,q�pOýesÇcedLB vbÿepOq�dhpO}P�f+s\ÿ�pr�½s\vLp�lUg}ÇcytOg�}�v�gÀ~�p,q�pOýesÇced!suvog(vLs\n��Z}Ç�'t�cedhdhprt��LpVf'qLprý�s\c�d*� g�}Ç}+�UgÀ��Uv=7�c�s\dhs\dhý�g�Zg�sÇqÓcI~F�UcesÇd%��v^2¯ÿ,gIdZf�2 ¶s\dZv_sufyp"ò ó ]IñI`�gIq�pw@�\�Sa\�>�\�b¯<I]����Í��c*�ZgÀ���Zv^eTg�dZf�e/#U�½sÇ���pOdZfh�UcesÇd%��vØMQ�ypVf�gIq�p3�Zc�ncI��c��hsut�sÇ~SeTtOg�d|üUpÒt�ced%�Ls\d%�Zc��ZvL}Ç�

Page 6: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

n+

n−n −ε

+ε visible

−ε visible

cornervisible

π/2

π/2

{

{

]FE»` ]FGO`

��sÇýe�hq�p*�6�½kÓprgI}\s\dhý|�½sÇ��ÔtOc�q�dhpOq�v��Ó]IEy`½��hp*dhc�q�n(gI}+��c*º¯² gÀ�¦g�t�c�q�dhprq�s\vÓý�prdhpOq�gI}\s4%Oprf'gev½��Zp�g5�epOq�gIý�p¦cI~,Ó ; g�dZfÓ = w,]FG�`*sÇ~Ó�bp!gevLvL�hnp���ZgI�gÐt�ceqLdhprqU�Ug�vf?����hs\t�ÿ»dhpVvLvg@hlEg�dZf suv���ZpOq�p�~�c�q�p�fhp��LpVt���gIüh}\p'ü%�Y���hp�v_prdZvLc�qVlF��hprd�g�d%��bprfyýep��¾vD�Zg��UpVf|ceü67�prt���s\vÍ�»suv_s\üh}\p,s�~Psih��%��fyprýZ�

fypO~�c�q�n�pVf|s\d%�Lcjek#@ü»�|gI�h�Z}Ç�»s\dhý�g�t�ced%�Ls\d%�Zc��Zv�n(gI�h�hs\dhý']�ceqb�»sut�p-�P�epOq�vLg%`��¢���Zs\vÍgId�sÇn�@c�qL��g�de�Í�hq�c��@pOqL����l»ü@prtOg��ZvLpÓs\dc�q�fyprqÑ�Lc}MZdZf|g�d|c��y��sÇn(g�}Z�ZgI��cebl½ü@p����bpOprd�2 ÿ gIdZf�2 ¶ ýesÇ�epOd|vLc�np�c��h�Ls\n�s4%rgI�Ls\c�d�tOqLsÇ�LprqLs\c�dÈl�sÇ�bsuvE�@cev�v_s\üh}\p���cµgI�h�Z}Ç�vLsÇn�h}\p�fypVvLtOpOd%��np���Zc»fZv�cÀ��prqÒ��hp��ZgIq�gInp���pOq�s�%VgÀ��sÇced9cI~%eþs\dâc�q�fyprqÒ�Lc9tOc�n�h�y��p|c�q�g��h�hq�c��»s\n(gÀ��pje l �*8¾dâc���hprq�bc�q�fhvOlyg�v_ce}Ç�h�Ls\c�d|��c(gµýesÇ�epOd��UgÀ����h}ugIdhdhs\dhý�hq�c�üh}\pOn ~�ceq�MQ�yprf�pOdZfy�@c�s\d%��v½trgId�ü@p,fyp�~�ceqLnpVf|s\de��c���hp,vLc�}\�y�Ls\c�d�cI~gh�ZgIq�fyprq½�hqLceüh}\pOn�~�ceqÍ��hp�v�gInpÒpOdZfh�UcesÇd%��vr� ÿ�hceq��@c�}\�%ýec�dZg�}+pOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��v�tOc�n�@cevLprf!cI~nmâprfhý�prvrl�º ò�ó�]o2@`�tOc�d%��g�sÇdUv½dhc|nc�q�pÒ��UgId[��]6p@`�vLprt���sÇcedZvrlZ���hsut���s\v

��Zp�v�gInp|�h�h�@pOq�ü@c��hdZfþg�vÒ~�ceq*�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���Ô�@c�}\�»ý�cedZvO�!8¾dâ~�get��VlÑ��p�trgId tOc�n�h�y��p�g'��sÇý��e��pOq*üUce�hdZf"�.fÈp���qÓ]FñI`,ü@p��Zp(�%suvLsÇühs\}\s����Ô�Uce}Ç�»ý�cedÔtOc�n�h�y��prfYgÀ�}ñ»�CfÈp���( ü@p��hp(d»�hn*üUprq�cI~b�»s\vLsÇüZ}ÇpT]Av_ce}ÇsufZ`¦prfhý�prvÒs\drqÓ]FñI`��a8¾dÐ��Zp(��ceq�v_�tOgev_pelZpVg�t����»s\vLs\üh}Çp*prfyýep�s\d+qÓ]FñI`½suvocedh}\���Zg�q_��s\g�}Ç}\�!�%suvLsÇüh}\pµ�ZdZfypOq¦kop-MZdhsÇ�Ls\c�dY�y�\^������»�ZvrlZ���hpµü@c��hdUfhgIq���c�~Øò�ó�]IñI`�s\vt�cen�Uc%v_pVfcI~S( ]��Uc%vLvLs\üh}Ç�(v�hc�qL�Lprq�`FvLc�}\sufprfyýeprvrle�h}\�ZvbgÀ�;nc%v��U(�~�q�pOpotO�hqL�eprvL7�c�s\dhsÇdZý�prget��|v_�Ztrt�pVvLvLsÇ�ep½�ZgIs\q;c�~+v_ce}Çsufprfhý�prvr�Ó�»s\dZtOpµprget��'~�qLprpµt��ZqL�ep�s\v¦t�cedZvLs\v_��vocI~;gÀ�Ón�c%v��Ò�|vLprt���sÇcedZvrlZ���hpOd.º ò�ó�]FñI`�suvotOc�n�@cevLprf'cI~EdZc�nc�q�p,��UgIdT�s(vLprt���sÇcedZvrlyprg�t��!cI~����hsut��'trgId!üUp,prs����hpOqÓg�vLpOýenpOd%�rlhgt�s\q�t��h}ugIq½gIq�t¦c�q�gvLprt���sÇced�c�~Fg�}\c�ý%gIq�s����hns\t¦v_�ZsÇq�gI}P���sÇdUgI}\}Ç�el�c�dZp�nµ�Zv_�;dhc��E~�c�q�ý�pO�Ñ��ZgI��ò ó ]FñI`Fs\v;ý��Zg�q�g�d%�LpOpVf���c�ü@p�~�q�pOp½cI~"ceüZv���g�tO}ÇpVvO�P2bprtOg��ZvLp����hpo�bc�q�ÿyv_�Ug�t�pbsuvEdhc��

ÿ»dhcÀ�½d(s\d�g�fh�5g�dZt�pelesÇ��suv���pOq���sÇn�@c�qL��gId%���LcµprdZvL�hqLp���ZgI�����hpoq�c�ü@cI�b�½sÇ}\}UdZcI�btOc�}\}ÇsufypÓ�½s����|�hdZvLpOprd|c�üZv_��get�}\prv;üUpO~�c�q�p��ZprvLpÒg�qLp,fypO�LpVt��LpVf"�Ei½prý�s\c�d»ò ó ]IñI`Ít��Zg�q�get���pOq�s�%rprv;��hsuv½c�üUv���g�t�}\p��P~�q�pOp¦qLprý�s\c�d+�P���hp,q�c�ü@cI�½�½sÇ}\}"dhc���üUpÒs\d'tOc�}\}ÇsuvLsÇced!gev}\c�dhý(g�vÍsÇ��v�n�c��Ls\c�dZv½g�qLp¦q�prv_�Lq�s\t��Lprf��Lc«ò�ó�]IñI`bü@p����bpOpOd�vL�ZtOtOprv�v_s\��pÒvLpOdZvLsÇdZý�ce�Uprq�gI�Ls\c�dZvr�

F%Gut v[V^ZEW)NSZwa

{�c�q�dhprq�vÓ�Uc%v_p�g��ZqLceüh}Çprn pO�epOdT�hdUfypOqÒsufyprg�}Çs4%OpVf9t�cedZfysÇ�Ls\c�dZvr�µ�»�h�Z�Uc%v_p(g|q�c�ü@cI�Òsuv¦vL�hq�qLce�hdZfypVf�ü»��c�dhp�c�qÒvLpO��prq�g�}�bprfyýep��¾vD�Zg��UpVf'�bg�}Ç}uv�ceqLs\pOd%��prf!�LcÀ�ÍgIq�f!��Zp*vLpOdZvLc�qV�3���hp�v_prdZv_ceqosuv����hpOd9�hdZgIüZ}Çpµ�Lc�vLpOp�gId»�!cI~Ñ��ZprvLp*�bprfyýeprvrlUg�dZf��Zp�v�gÀ~�p�q�pOýesÇcedYs\v*pOn�y���e�i���hsuv�suvµdZcI��g�~�gIs\}Ç�hq�p�c�~½c��hq�n(gÀ��ZpOn(gÀ��s\trgI}�g�dZgI}\�yv_suvrl�üh�h�g����%�yvLs\trgI}�}Çs\ns���gÀ�Ls\c�dþcI~��Zp�vLpOdZvLc�qV�9���Zs\vÓ}Çs\ns���gÀ��sÇced9suvos\ý�dhceqLpVf'ü»�'kÓp�MUdhs���sÇcedÐ�h�Ç^el@g�}Çcedhý��½sÇ��Ðv_pr��pOq�gI}ÈcI��ZpOq�v*]�p�� ýZ�\lU���ZgÀ�Òv_cenp*vL�hq_~�get�pVvt�ce�h}ufÔü@p(�@pOqL~�prt���}Ç�9�Lq�gIdZvL�Zg�qLprde�Òc�q�tOc�n�h}\p���pO}\�TqLp- Zprt��Ls\��p5`��aoÐp|tOgIdYcedh}Ç�Ôg�v�v_�hnp���UgÀ�,��Zp|gIdhýe}Çpü@p����bpOpOdâg�d%��Zg�sÇqÓcI~ÑsÇdUt�sufypOd%�Ó�ÍgI}\}uv�suv�}ugIq�ý�p,pOdZc��hý��Tv_�Zt��'���ZgÀ�ÒgÀ�o}\prgev��Óc�dhpµvLprt��Ls\c�dTgI�ÓpOsÇ��ZpOqÓvLsufyp�cI~Ñ���hp*tOc�q�dhpOqos\vo�%suvLsÇüh}\p,��c��Zp¦vLpOdZvLc�qV�M�Óq���UgÀ�;���hpÒt�c�q�dhprq;sÇ��vLpO}Ç~Ès\v�dhc��bv�ZgIq��|pOdZc��hý���Lcµq�pOn(g�sÇd|�ZdZfyp���prt��Lprf�ü»�*���hpÒv_prdZv_ceqÓ]�sA� p��\l%��hpÒt�ceqLdhprq�Zgev�?���Zs\t�ÿ»dhpVvLvg@e`��

��dUfypOqµ��hp!gIü@cÀ��p�gevLvL�hn�y�Ls\c�dUvOlF�bp|ý�prdhpOq�gI}\s�%rp��hp!t�cedZt�pr�y�*c�~ogTv_�Zq_~�get�p|dhceqLn(g�}E�Lc9sÇdZtO}Ç�Ufyp�tOc�q�dhpOq�vO�����ZpdhceqLn(gI}�Ó �Lc�º¯² gI�|gât�c�q�dhprq�suv���hp9g5��prq�g�ý�p�cI~wÓ ; gIdUfdÓ = lÍ���hprqLp!Ó ; gIdZfdÓ = gIq�p!��hp�dhceqLn(g�}\v���cnº¯²s\n�npVfys\gI�Lpr}Ç��gÀ~��LprqEgIdZf�ü@p�~�ceqLpb��Zp�t�c�q�dhprqÍ]F��sÇýe�hqLp��Z]IEy`_`��P���Zp�t�c�q�dhprq�suvF�»s\vLs\üh}Çp½sÇ~@��hp�tOc�dZfysÇ�Ls\c�dUvFcI~"kop-MZdhsÇ�Ls\c�d|�y�\^gIq�p(vLgI�Lsuv�MUprfÔ~�c�q,���hsuv,ý�prdhpOq�gI}\s�%rprfiÓÒ�*���ZgI��s\vrl�g'tOc�q�dhpOq,ü@p-�Zg5�eprvÒ}\sÇÿep|gId»�9c���hprq,�UcesÇd%�µs\d1º¯²èl�g�v,}\c�dZý'gev,c��Zq�»�»�Uc���hpVv_pVvb~�c�q�º¯²Û�hce}\f��Lq��hpe����hp�vL�yv���pOn�fhprv�t�q�sÇü@prf�sÇd ) g�q_��8D8Íp-�»�@prt���v�g�}Ç}�t�c�q�dhprq�v��Lca�Ug5��p¦��hsut�ÿ»dhprv�vrlZgIdZf����hpOq�p�~�ceqLp¦�Lc(ü@p�fypO�Lprt���g�üh}Çp,ü»�

��Zp�v_prdZv_ceqr�Ñ�odZfypOq���hsuv�vL�h�h�@cevLs���sÇced+lhsÇ��s\v½pVg�vL�(�Lc�epOq�s�~��(���ZgÀ�¦gId»�|�bprfyýep��¾vD�Zg��UpVf|ceü67�prt����½s����hsÇd'q�gIdhýepÒs\vÍ�»suv_s\üh}\psÇ~�sxhþ�»��fypOý�]I��s\ý��hq�pµ�h]NG�`_`��y�z|{~}/�������7�!���'�!���4�!�u�����u�����%�u���g�k�u���'�u�I���!���k�!�������'���������!�^���9}/���4���*����������� H ���1�u�����u�b�I���������/�*�'�����u�I���u�����*�����9}��^�!�������'� �^��� K�� �u������u���^�!����������� ó �I�����!�������'��������^���������S�������!���7 �� ¡7�������������!���~¢

Page 7: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]FGO`

]IHr` ]FJ%`

��sÇýe�hq�pC/Q���»�LpO�Uv�s\d g�dhp��»��Pü@prv_�µ�»sÇpr�ñtOc�n�h�y��gÀ��sÇcedL��]FE»`µvLgI~�p(qLprý�s\c�dâgÀ~���pOq*�'vLpOdUv_s\dhýTce�Uprq�gI�Ls\c�dZvrwb]NG�`Òcedh}Ç�Ô��Zpq�pOý�s\c�dUvE�½sÇ��hs\d(��ZpÓ�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���q�g�dhý�p�c�~ÈgÒ~�q�pOpÓtO�hq���pog�qLp¦vLg�n��Z}ÇpVf �b]FHO`E��hpÓ�Uc��LpOd%��s\g�}U�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���ýegIs\d|c�~Èg�tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��pñsuv����hp�g�qLpVgc£µ]FñI`�ce�y��vLs\fhp���Zp*p-�»�Z}ÇceqLpVf'qLprý�s\c�d!��ZgI�ÒtrgIdTü@pµ�»suv_s\üh}\p«>�@§l\$Te�@��hp*~�q�pOp*tO�hq���prvoüUce�hdZfys\dhý!ÇS¤5]Iñ�¥�`�w]IJ»`���Zp,üUpVv��otrgIdZfysufhgI�Lp,suv½v_pr}ÇpVt��LpVf'g�vb��Zp,ng$�ysÇns4%OpOqÍc�~����hp��%�ZgId%�LsÇ���£*]IñI`»p-�»��]�ë$"E¦o]Fñ§Èñ1¥À`L`��

F%GuF §�¨%_�ZwKM©�_\T9W)RªJ%KMLgNPOQNSRT�VUW�a«LgZwVU¬ OQNSKn­J&NbW�asVUZQ®¯K�_`K

���hp�ng�sÇdâ�Zq�get��LsutOg�}�fys� |t��h}Ç���Y�½s����â��Zp�q�prvL�h}���v�c�~½��hsuvµvLprt��Ls\c�d suv,���ZgÀ�*��hp!v_prdZv_ceq�c��h�L�h�y��s\v*�ZvL�ZgI}\}\�Ðg�}\suv���cI~�@c�s\de��vOlZdhcI��g}\s\v_��cI~Ft��hq���pVvO�Ñm �hq�p��®�hq�c»tOprv�v_s\dhý�v���gIý�pÒn*�Zv���ü@p�g�fZfyprf��Lc����hp,np���Zc»fZv½cI~���hsuv�vLprt��Ls\c�d��Lc|t�ced»��pOqL���Zp�q�g5� fhgÀ��g�sÇd%�Lc���hp�ce�y�L�h�h��}Çsuv��;à��Ø���Zp�v_�yv_�LpOn fyprv�t�q�s\üUpVf�s\d ) gIqL��8D8Í�ZvLprv�g�ý�prc�np���qLsut�jÀd»�hnpOq�s\trgI}@�LpVt��hdhs+�e�Zp�Lc(tOc�d»��prq_��g�}Çsuv_��cI~��@c�s\d%��v½s\d%�Lc(g�}Çsuv_��cI~F�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhpVvO�=ï,�yg�n�h}ÇpVvÍcI~���hsuv½�hq�cyt�prfh�hqLp,g�qLp¦�hq�prvLpOd%�LpVf�s\dT�»prt��Ls\c�d»/h�

° ± ² z�ü|õS³E´ z��+õ¶µ û-z7· ± ú �*÷µöEû�õn¸»÷

8¾d'g�v_��gI�Lsut¦pOd»�»sÇq�c�dhnprde�VlhgvLgI~�p¦q�pOýesÇced�q�pOn(gIs\dZvÍv�gÀ~�pÒ�hdZfyprqÍ��hp,�ZdhsÇced�ce�Uprq�gI�Ls\c�d+�ÑaopOdZtOp�l»��Zp,}\g5�ec��y�Ínc»fhpO}+tOg�dü@pop��y�Zg�dZfypVfs���pOq�gÀ�Ls\��pr}Ç�e��m�MZq�v��b�ZgIqL�LsugI}h}ug5��ce�y�=�.g,}\c»trgI}@vLgI~�p�qLprý�s\c�dU� s\vbt�cedZv���qL�Ut��LpVf�~�qLcenÂ���hpÓfZgÀ��gµg�t-�%�hs\q�prfü»����Zp�q�gIdZý�pv_prdZv_ceq¦gI�Ò��hpq�c�ü@cI��B v¦sÇdZs���s\g�}E�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d®ñ�¹%��mb�,pVg�t��9sÇ�Lprq�gI�Ls\c�d+l+��hp(gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��Zn �h�@fZgÀ�LpVv¦��hp}ug5��ce�y�ncyfypO}7ü»�|t�cen��Z�y�Ls\dhý*��hp¦�hdhs\c�d�cI~+���hp¦v�gÀ~�p¦q�pOý�s\c�d�üh�hs\}���vLc�~�gIqb�½sÇ�����hp¦}ÇcytrgI}"vLgI~�poq�pOýesÇced|ý�prdhpOq�gÀ��prf|gI�����hpÓdZpO��@cevLs���sÇced�ñ1¥»�.���Zp�dhpr� v�gÀ~�p�qLprý�s\c�dâsuv,��ZpOd �ZvLprfâ�Lc9vLpO}\prt�����hp�dhp��»�v_prdZv_s\dhýT�@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�d�ñ1¥ ; ÿÀ�i�Èc9tOc�n�h�y��p|���hs\vdhp-�%��Pü@prv_�D�®�»sÇpr� �Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d+lZ��hp*�hq�c»tOprfy�ZqLpwMZq�v_�oý�prdhpOq�gÀ��prv�g(vLp��¦cI~Ñ�Uc��Lprde��s\g�}�trgIdZfysufhgI�Lprvr��0�p-�%�VlUsÇ�opr�5g�}Ç�UgÀ�LpVv�pVg�t��tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��p*getOt�ceq�fhsÇdhý|�Lc�ü@cI���T���hp*p-�y�UpVt��LpVf�ýeg�sÇd9cI~Es\dy~�c�q�n(gÀ�Ls\c�dT��ZgI�¦�½s\}Ç}Fü@p*vLpOdZvLprf9gÀ�¦��hsuvo�@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�d+l"gIdUf���ZpncI��sÇced!tOcev_�Íq�p��%�hs\q�prf��Lc(ncÀ��pÓ��hprqLpe�,���hprvLp,v���pO�ZvogIq�pÓs\}Ç}\�Zv_�Lq�gÀ��prf�sÇd»��sÇýe�hq�pw/ZlZgIdUf�fypVvLtOqLs\ü@prf�üUpr}ÇcÀ�,�

Page 8: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

º)GIH »¼V7½)N�­c¾¿­IT�RW$¬ÀNbW_rKMW�½Á»¼NSZ\RTIW)Rf+pO�jÂ�¤5]Iñ�¥ = ÿr`"ô¶ÃIà�¤I]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`�È�ÇS¤À]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`9ĦüUp���hp(�Zg�q_��s\g�}(e$V�\�c�X�V"ncyfypO}EüZ�hsÇ}Ç�µgÀ�}ñ�¥ = ÿI�C���hp��pOq�n ÇS¤À]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`¦suvÒ��Zp�hdhs\c�dµcI~Ug�}Ç}%}ÇcytrgI}ev�gÀ~�p�qLprý�s\c�dZvÈ�h����cÓv_��g�ý�pÅ¢ë^������hp�ü@c��ZdZfhgIq��¦cI~OÇS¤À]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`Èsuv�tOc�n�Uc%v_pVf,cI~y~�q�pOpbgIdZfµv_ce}Çsuf�t��ZqL�eprvrl��Zp�}\gI�_��pOq�q�pO�hq�prvLpOd%��sÇdhý�Q�»�yvLs\trgI}ÈvLprt��Ls\c�dZv½c�~,º[²ñ��f+p��;à ¤ ]Fñ ¥ = ÿ `Íü@p,���hp�}\s\v_�ocI~EvLc�}\s\f'tO�hqL�eprvÍs\d'��hpµüUce�hdZfhg�qL��cI~Ç ¤ ]Fñ ¥ = ÿ `�����hpEq�c�ü@cI���Uprq_~�ceqLn(v+gÓv_prdZv_s\dhý½ce�Uprq�gI�Ls\c�d,c�dUt�pEsÇ�ÈncÀ��pVv+s\de��cog½dhpr�Y}ÇcytOgI�Ls\c�d�ñ ¥ �¢�ZqLcen ���hp;}\cytOgI}enprg�vL�hq�pOnpOd%�Vl

fyprdhcI��prf)gev*àwó�]Iñ�¥I`�lÓ��pÐtOg�d t�cen��Z�y�LpÐg }\c»trgI}ÒvLgI~�pTq�pOý�s\c�dÁò�ó�]Iñ1¥e`~�ce}Ç}\cÀ�½sÇdZýâ��hpÐ�hq�c»cI~�cI~}���ZpOc�q�pOn �h�\^�� f+pO�(�ó�]Iñ�¥I`(ôÆÃIà;ó�]Iñ�¥I`�È�ò�ó�]Iñ�¥�`9ÄbüUpÒ���hpaV�\�]�X$V»n�cyfypr}ÈgÀ�3ñ�¥»�

�»�h�Z�Uc%v_pÔ��hprqLpÐp��ysuv���v'gId g�}Çýec�q�s����hnÈÇbÉ~Ê6ËbÌ���ZgI��tOc�n�h�y��prv���Zp9��q�g�dZv�~�ceqLn(gI�Ls\c�d¯Í g�}Çs\ý�dZsÇdhýÎ(�ó�]Iñ�¥I`��½s����Â�¤5]Fñ1¥ = ÿr`�ü»��n(gI��t��hs\dhý���hp,}\s\dhp,v_prý�npOd%��vÍc�~Pàwó�]Fñ1¥I`Íg�dZf!à�¤À]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`��=oÔp,�½s\}Ç}(A[\�>+gevLvL�hnp¦��ZgI�½��hsuvÍ��prt��hdhs+�%�hpÒs\v�@pOqL~�prt����^ÇbÉ~Ê6ËbÌÐt�cen�h�y�LpVv½gt�c�q�q�prt��7Í c�dh}\�|���hprd����hpOq�p,suvÍpOdhce�hý�!cÀ��prqL}ugI��üUpO����prpOd�(»ó�]Iñ1¥�`ÍgIdZf5Â�¤5]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`���ÓdZtOpcÍñsuvµtrgI}ut��h}ugÀ��prf"l����hp|dhpr�ñýe}ÇceüZgI}�vLgI~�p|qLprý�s\c�d�Ç ¤ ]Fñ ¥ `,s\v*t�c�n�h�h�Lprfâgev,���hp|�hdhs\c�dâc�~7͵]FÇ ¤ ]Fñ ¥ = ÿ `_`,g�dZfò ó ]Fñ ¥ `��.���hp|dhpr��nc»fhpO}& ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `}ôÏÃIà ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `�È�Ç ¤ ]Fñ ¥ `9Ä,suv�q�pO�hq�prvLpOd%�LpVfYsÇd g9t�c»c�q�fys\dZgÀ��p~�q�g�n�p�t�pOd%��pOq�prfYcÀ��prq,��Zp

q�c�ü@cI��gÀ�½sÇ��v�tO�hqLq�pOd%�½�@cevLs���sÇced'ñ ¥ �

º)Gut v[KnW$½�TI½$K�_`NÑпNbW)NSZwK�_\TIVUW���hp!~��y���hqLp'�@cevLs���sÇceddñ ¥ ; ÿ v�hc��h}uf �@cI��pOd%�LsugI}\}\�þv_prp�}ugIq�ý�p��hdhp-�»�Z}ÇceqLpVfþgIq�prgev«>�@§l�\�Te�@����hp!~�qLprp�t��hq���pVvµü@c��hdUfysÇdZýÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`Ò]��hdhp-�»�Z}ÇceqLpVf!g�qLpVg�vÍtOg�dhdhc��Íü@p�ceüZv_prqL�eprf|��hq�c��hý��!vLc�}\suf!tO�hq���prvÍü@prtrgI�ZvLp¦��hpVv_p,q�pO�ZqLpVv_prde��vLprt��Ls\c�dZvÍc�~Pº/.�`��a�cÀ�bpO�epOqVlU�bpgIq�p*t�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\dhprf�s\d9ce�hqÒt��hc�sut�pVv�~�ceqwñ�¥ ; ÿI�����hp�qLceüUc��;�Zgev���c�ü@ppOd%�Ls\q�pO}\�'tOc�d%��g�sÇdZprfTs\dZvLs\fhpmÇS¤I]Iñ1¥�`gÀ�(���hp�dhp-�%�(}\cytOgÀ��sÇced&ñ�¥ ; ÿIlÍ���hs\t���nµ�Uv���g�}\vLcÔü@p�q�prg�t��UgIüh}\p�~�q�c�n ñ1¥9ü»� gYt�ce}Ç}\s\vLs\c�d6�P~�qLprp��UgÀ��È���h�hqL��hprqLnceqLpel��Zp�~��hdUt��Ls\c�dÎÇbÉ~Ê6ËbÌ×n*�Zv_��vL�ZtOtOprv�v�~��h}\}\�iMUdZfþgT�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�nÏÍ gI�*���hp�dZp��»���@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�d ñ�¥ ; ÿI�®��cÔget��hsÇpr��p�g�}Ç}���ZprvLpt�cedZfysÇ�Ls\c�dZvrly�bp¦�ZqLcyt�prprf!g�vb~�ce}Ç}\cÀ��v-�ÜL���5ß �[� i�gIdUfyc�n}\� ýepOdhprq�gI�LpTg vLp��!cI~,�Uc%vLvLs\üh}Çp9dhp��»�D�®ü@prv_�D�®�%s\pO� trgIdZfysufhgI�LprvjÒxÓD�D��³äÇS¤5]Fñ1¥e`(�½sÇ��hs\d ��Zp

�»s\vLs\ühsÇ}\sÇ����q�gIdhýep,cI~Ñ���hp�~�q�pOpµtO�hq���prv�üUce�hdZfys\dhý'Çb¤À]Iñ�¥I`�]F��s\ý��ZqLp}/U]FG�`L`��3���Zs\vÓv���pO�T�hq�pO�epOd%��votOgIdUfys\fZgÀ�LpVv½~�q�c�n üUprsÇdZý�hdhdZprt�pVvLv�gIq�s\}Ç�|tOqLpVgÀ�LpVf�s\d�gIq�prgev;���ZgÀ�og�qLpÓ~�gIq�g5�Íg5�~�q�c�n����hpÒ~�qLprpÒüUce�hdZfhg�qL�|c�~=Ç ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `��ÜL���5ßæ� � �hceqÒprg�t��®ñ!¿5Ò ÓD�D� l+�bp�tOc�n�h�y��p*���hp*�LcI��gI}Ñ}\pOdhý���«Ôh]FÇ ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `�È�ñI`ÓcI~E���hpdhc�d6�P~�q�pOpt��hq���pVvoü@c��hdUfysÇdZý

Ç ¤ ]Fñ ¥ `,��ZgI��g�qLp|�»suv_s\üh}\p|~�q�c�náñ'�hdZfhpOq*kÓp�MUdhs���sÇced��h�Ç^9]Av_prpi�Ç^r���b~�c�q�g9vL�hq���pO�ÔcI~�np����hcyfhv�`��rÔ�suv*g�npVg�vL�hqLp�cI~��Zpµp��y�@prt��LprfTcÀ��pOq�}ugI�!üUpO����prpOd9g(dZpO� sÇn(g�ý�p}àwó�]IñI`ÓgIdUf!��hp*�h�@fZgÀ�LpVf»�hsuv���c�q��'à�¤À]Iñ�¥I`��38®~Ôh]FÇb¤À]Iñ�¥I`�È�ñI`½suvoýeqLpVgÀ�Lprq��UgId'v_cen�pÒýesÇ�epOd|���hq�prv�hc�}uf"l»��ZpOd!ñ�q�pOn(gIs\dZv½g*dhp��»�D�®ü@prv_�D�®�%s\pO� tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��p��=���hsuv�MZ}���pOq�sÇdZýv_��g�ý�p¦pOdZvL�hq�prv���UgÀ�½��Zp~��hdZt��Ls\c�d5ÇbÉ~Ê6ËbÌÔ�½s\}Ç}+vL�Ztrt�prv�v_~��h}Ç}\�CMUdZf'gµ��q�g�dZv_~�c�q�nªÍ��ÜL���5ßf�Ý� �»�h�Z�Uc%v_p���ZgI�����hpOq�pbs\vFg½~��ZdZt���sÇcedjÕÖ��g×oØÁô¿Ù�Ç`Ú/ÛkÜ9ÙwÉBÇbÌbÌSÝ\ÞF]FÇb¤I]Iñ�¥I`�È�ñ1¥§È�ñI`È��ZgI�FtOc�n�h�y��prvFgotOc�}\}Çsuv_s\c�dQ�

~�q�pOp¦�ZgÀ���Ô]�gevÍgµ}\s\v_�½cI~È�@c�s\d%��v�`Eü@p����bpOprd'ñ�¥�g�dZf«ñ»lyceq�q�p����hqLdUv;���hp¦pOn�y���|}\s\v_�%ÕUÖ��g×oØÁôàßµs�~���hprqLp¦s\vbdhcvL�Zt����ZgI��+����hprqLp9g�qLp�n(g�d%��s\n��Z}Çprn�prd%��gÀ��sÇced)t��hc�sut�pVv~�c�qxÙ�Ç`Ú/ÛkÜ9Ù\ÉsÇbÌSÌSÝwÞË��^5���®l�gIdZf×�bpTn(gIÿepTdhcþgevLvL�hn�y�Ls\c�dUv|gIü@c��y�!g�Zg�q_��s\tO�h}\g�q*cedhp�����cÔfhprt�sufyp!���hp����hpOq(gÔ�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d&ñ�¿QÒxÓD�D�ñq�pOn(gIs\dZv�g9dZp��»�D�®üUpVv���P�»s\pO� trgIdZfysufhgI�Lp�l;��p!qL�Zd ��Zp~��hdZt��Ls\c�dÙ�Ç`Ú/ÛkÜ9ÙwÉBÇbÌbÌSÝ\Þ��Lc,�epOq�s�~���sÇ~LñosuvÑq�prget��ZgIüh}\p�~�qLcen×ñ ¥ ��8®~ ñÓs\vÑdZcI�Eq�prg�t��UgIüh}\p�l5���hpOd|vL�Zt���UcesÇd%�EsuvEfysuvLtrgIq�fyprf+�

m½~���pOq�p-�yprt��h�Ls\dhý���hpVv_p¦��ZqLprp�v���pO�Zvrly��p�g�qLp¦}\p�~��o�½sÇ���g*~�prgev_s\üh}\pÒvLp��UÒ5ÓD�D� c�~�032b� trgIdZfysufhgI�Lprvr�

º)GuF §�á'Kn­9â)K'_\T�VUWãV^LxvfKMW�½$T9½)K'_`Nba���hp�v�t�ceqLp¦cI~�pO��prqL��dhp��»�D�®ü@prv_�D�®�%s\pO� tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��pwñU¿cÒxÓD�D�)s\v½fyp-MZdhpVf�ü»�(���hpÒ~�c�}\}\cÀ�½sÇdhý�~��hdUt��Ls\c�dÝ�

ä ]FñI` ô £*]IñI`»p-�y�È]�ë$"E¦o]Fñ§Èñ1¥�`_`�È ]�^5`���hprqLpi"þsuv*g��@cevLsÇ�Ls\��p�tOc�dZv_��g�de�Vln¦o]Iñ§È�ñ1¥I`�s\v���hp�}ÇprdhýI��� cI~Í���hp��ZgI���ÕÖ��g×oØ�t�c�n�h�h�Lprf ü%�Ô��Zp|~��hdZt��Ls\c�dåÙ�Ç`Ú/ÛkÜÙ\ÉsÇbÌSÌSÝwÞ�lUgIdUf�£*]IñI`ÍsuvognpVg�vL�hqLpÒc�~����hp��hdhp-�y�h}ÇceqLpVf'gIq�prg�cI~���hpµpOd»�»sÇq�c�dhnprde�Í���ZgÀ�osuv½�@cI��pOd%�LsugI}\}Ç���»s\vLsÇüZ}ÇpÒ~�q�c�nñ!]�vLpOpÒüUpr}ÇcÀ�o`��,ñ1¥ ; ÿ¦s\v½vLpO}\prt��LpVf!gevb��hp�v�gIn�h}\p"ñ}¿�Ò5Ó��D� ��ZgI��n(g��ysÇns4%OpVv ä ]FñI`�����hp(t�cedZv_��gId%��"Ð��prsÇý��%��vÓ��hpq�pO}ugÀ��sÇ�ep�tOcev_�Òc�~;ncI��sÇcedÔ�½sÇ��ÐqLpVv_�@prt��Ò�Lc!��hp�@cI��pOd%�LsugI}Ñ�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���Týeg�sÇdÈ�D"1ôèz

s\n��Z}Çs\prvÍ���ZgÀ��nc��Ls\c�d!s\vc?�t��hprg��w@hlyg�dZf���hp�092�� g�}Çýec�q�s����hn suv½gI}\}ÇcÀ�bprf��Lc(vLpO}\prt��½��hp,dhp-�»�D�®üUpVv����»s\pO� üZg�vLprf!v_ce}Çpr}Ç�s\dT�LprqLn(v¦cI~���hp��@cI�Lprd%�LsugI}F�»s\vLsÇüZsÇ}\s�����ý%gIs\d+�"8®~%"«æ�ç)l7��ZpOdÐn�c��Ls\c�dÔüUpVt�c�npVvÓvLc�p-�y�UprdZv_s\��p*��UgÀ�Òc�dh}\��}ÇcytrgÀ�Ls\c�dUvdhpVgIq�ñ ¥ gIq�p,v_pr}ÇpVt���prf"lhgevÍ}Çcedhý(g�vb��ZpO���ZqLcyfy�ZtOp,g*n(g�qLýesÇdZg�}"ýeg�sÇd�sÇd'�»s\vLs\ühsÇ}\sÇ�����

Page 9: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

­U�E��ß�¡¢��¨6���I�[�Õ��èié ]4ê+` oÐpTnprgev_�hq�p'��ZpT�Uc��Lprde��s\g�}o�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���þý%gIs\d�c�~,prg�t�� trgIdZfysufhgI�Lp�ñYg�v|gÐ~��ZdZt���sÇced cI~��Zpg�qLpVgi£*]IñI`¦ce�y��vLs\fhpµ���hp(t��hq�qLprd%�,v�gÀ~�p�q�pOý�s\c�d9��ZgI�,ng5��ü@p�»s\vLsÇüZ}Çp!>�@§l\$Te�@|��Zp~�qLprp�tO�hqL�eprv¦ü@c��hdZfhsÇdhý�ÇS¤I]Iñ1¥�`]I��s\ý��hq�p./U]IHO`L`��×�Zc�q��Uce}Ç�»ý�cedZgI}Ónc»fhpO}uvOl)£*]IñI`�tOgId üUpÐt�c�n�h�h�Lprf)ü%� ��ZpÔv�gInpTq�g5���¾vL��prpO� gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��hn �ZvLprf×��ct�cen�h�y�Lp�tO}\gevLvLsuto�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ����q�pOýesÇcedZvw��^V���PlZ�½s��������hpÒ~�c�}\}\cÀ�½sÇdhý�ncyfysWM@tOgÀ��sÇcedZv��^������hp¦v_�bpOpr�hs\dhý�q�g5�*n(g5�t�q�cev�vEgId�g�qLüZs���q�g�qL�*d%�Znµü@pOq;c�~"~�qLprpopVfyý�pVvEü@p�~�c�q�p��hsÇ�_��sÇdZý�g�vLc�}\suf(c�dhpe�����ZpOq�p�~�c�q�p�le��ZptOc�n�h�y��gÀ�Ls\c�dQ�A��sÇnp¦cI~+���hpÓq�g5�5�®vL�bpOpO�(g�}Çýec�q�s����hn üUpVt�c�npVv7��]4p ��¤r¡hË p Ìwë p�ì�íA`�ly���hprqLp�Å í suv���hp¦d»�hnµü@pOqbcI~È~�qLprppVfyý�pVvÍüUce�hdZfys\dhý«ÇS¤5]Fñ1¥I`��

�y�����hpoqLpVv_�h}Ç��g�d%�E�%suvLsÇüh}\p�q�pOýesÇced�suvEtOqLce�h�UpVf��Lcµv�gÀ��s\v_~������hp�q�gIdhýep½qLpVv���qLsut���sÇcedZvFcI~7���hpÓvLpOdZvLc�qV�¢���Zs\v;c��@pOq�gÀ�Ls\c�dtOg�dü@p�fyc�dZp¦s\d+��]6p�ì�í�`O�

º)G6º îDNSZw¬>TIW$K'_`TIVUW¶vfVUW$½�T�_\T�VUW8®~����hp'üUce�hdZfhg�qL�YcI~9Ç ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `�t�c�d%��gIs\dZv�dhcÔ~�q�pOp't��hq���pVvOl���Zp����®k�}ug5��c��h�*suv�gevLvL�hnprfâ�LcÐüUp't�cen��Z}ÇpO�Lp�wbcI���hpOq��½suv_pelÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`�suvÑ�ZgevLvLprf*��cÒ��hp½dhp-�»�;s���pOq�gÀ��sÇced*c�~U���hp�n(gI�h�ZsÇdhýÒ�hq�cyt�pVvLv½]F��s\ý��ZqLp�/U]IJ»`_`��Ñm �bprg�ÿ�prq���prv_�Es\vE�Zv_pVf�sÇd(�hq�g�t��Lsut�p��v_�Lc��Y���hprdY��hp�}ÇprdhýI���âcI~½gId»�9q�pOn(gIs\dhs\dhý!~�qLprp�t��ZqL�ep�suvµvLn(gI}\}ÇprqÒ��Zg�d g�v_�@prtOsWMUprfÐ��ZqLpVvD�hce}\f+�*���hsuvÒ�LprqLns\dZgÀ��sÇced�hq�prfysutOgI�LpÒsuvÍüUpO�_�LprqovL�hs���prf��Lca�UgIdZfy}\p,t�cen��Z}Çp-��pOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��vr�

º)Guï ð*_`NSZwK�_\T�áUNàñàN/¨%_~ò�ó«Nbas_�ôõTIN/ö÷¾¿­IR^V^ZwT�_`ø�¬���hpÔý�pOdZpOq�gI}9092b� gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��Zn suv�vL�hnn(gIq�s�%rprf ü@pO}\cÀ�,�æï,�yg�n�h}ÇpÔqL�ZdZv9]�üUc��� s\d vLsÇn*�h}ugÀ�Ls\c�dUv�g�dZf s\d)�Q�»�yv_sutOg�}p��y�@pOq�sÇnprde��v�`Íg�qLpÒfypVvLtOqLs\üUpVf�s\d ) gIqL��8D8��é«�F¬O�O¤���� � � ��>YZ-lX�>N<?Ö�Z�ùUZ98�>Nîuú3Z R >dûÝ<IZ-:¥��¢ß�¡¢�Bü ^�� �(���hp�tO�hqLq�pOd%�½�Zg�q_��s\g�}@ncyfypr}� ¤ ]Iñ ¥ = ÿ `Íg�dZf�g�dhpr� vLpOdUv_s\dhý�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d!ñ ¥

�y� �(���hp,}\cytOgI}+vLpOdUv_ceqbnpVg�vL�hqLprnpOd%��à;ó�]Fñ1¥e`�h� �;m�d's\n(gIý�p,g�}Çs\ý�dhnprde�Í~��hdUt��Ls\c�dxÍÁôPÇ�ÉsÊ6Ë�ÌÑ]6(�ó�]Fñ1¥I`�ÈgÂ�¤I]Iñ1¥ = ÿr`_`�Z� �;m �ZgI��'�h}ugIdhdhs\dhý�~��hdZt��Ls\c�dxÕUÖ��g×�ØvôÆÙ�Ç`Ú/ÛkÜgÙ\ÉBÇ�ÌSÌSÝ\ÞF]NÇS¤I]Fñ1¥I`�Èñ1¥QÈñI`�y� �(���hp,�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ����t�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de��v;þ���������ÈDsk�/h� �(���hp,d»�hn*üUprq½cI~ÑvLg�n��Z}ÇpVv%(Ôlhg�dZf'g*�bpOs\ý�%��sÇdhý(tOc�dZv_��g�de�)"»Ð×z

Þa¡¢�-ßP¡¢�Bü m dhp��»�D�®ü@prv_���%s\pO� �Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d»ñ�¥ ; ÿ^�� {�cen��Z�y�Lp¦��Zp,}ÇcytOg�}+vLgI~�p,qLprý�s\c�d!ò ó ]Iñ*Åh`��;�»p��UÒ ÓD�D� ôàßy��y� {�cen��Z�y�Lp�Í�ôÆÇbÉ~Ê6Ë�ÌÑ]6(�ó�]Fñ1¥I`�ÈgÂ�¤À]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`L`�lZg�dZf���hp,�hdZsÇced»Çb¤À]Iñ�¥I`,ôò�ó�]Fñ1¥I`«ý�͵]FÇb¤5]Iñ1¥ = ÿV`_`����»pO��Âþ¤À]Iñ�¥I`9ôÿÃIà�¤I]Fñ1¥I`�È�ÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`9Ä�l+���ZpOq�pmà�¤À]Iñ�¥I`Ós\vÓ���hp}Çsuv��

c�~�vLc�}\s\f!t��hq���pVvÍüUce�hdZfys\dhýCÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`���h��i½pr�UpVgÀ�½�hd%�Ls\}"���hp�v_s4%Op,c�~�Ò5Ó��D�)suvÍý�q�prgÀ��pOqÍc�q½p��%�ZgI}7���ZgIdx(®�

]�ge`ÍiogIdZfycen}Ç��ý�pOdZpOq�gÀ�Lp,gv�gIn�h}\p,�UcesÇd%�3ñh¿�ÇS¤À]Iñ�¥I`Ís\d!��hp,�»suv_s\üh}\p,q�g�dhý�pcI~È���hpÒ~�q�pOp�t��ZqL�eprvbüUce�hdZfys\dhý«ÇS¤5]Fñ1¥e`��

]�üU`µ{�cen�h�y�Lp���hp|}\pOdhý����Ôh]NÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`�ÈñI`Òc�~����hp(dhc�dQ�A~�q�pOp|tO�hqL�eprv¦s\d ÇS¤5]Iñ�¥�`��ZgI�µgIq�p��»suv_s\üh}\p~�qLcenÍñ»�C8®~Í��Zs\v,d»�hn*üUprq�suv,}ÇpVvLv¦���ZgIdÐ���hp��hq�prv�hce}\fqLp��e�ZsÇq�prf�ü%��ÇbÉ~Ê6ËbÌFlhfhs\v�tOg�q�f'ñ*g�dZf�qLpr�UpVgÀ�o�%�Lpr���h�

]�tr`{�c�n�h�h�Lp|���hp��UgÀ��þÕUÖ��g×oØ ô¶Ù�Ç`Ú/ÛkÜ9Ù\ÉsÇbÌSÌSÝwÞF]FÇS¤�]Iñ1¥�`�Èñ�¥§ÈñI`��.8®~����hp�ZgÀ���!fyc»pVv½dhcI�½p-�»suv_�rlZfysuv�tOgIq�f'ñµgIdUf�q�pO�@prgI�o�%�Lpr�'�Z�

]�fZ` {�cen��Z�y�Lp���Zp��»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ��� ý%gIs\dÑ£µ]FñI`YgIdZfÂ��Zp�}\pOdZýI��ñcI~���hp×�ZgI��ÕUÖ��g×oØ*]Iñ�¥§ÈñI`��Emofhf'ñÒ�Lc*��Zp¦}\suv��½cI~�vLg�n��Z}ÇpVv'Ò5ÓD�D�×gIdZf�qLpr�UpVgÀ���%�Lpr�!�Z�

�Z� �»pr}ÇpVt��Í��Zp�vLg�n��Z}Çp,s\dDÒ5ÓD�D�×���ZgÀ��n(g��ys\ns�%rprvb��ZpÒ~��hdZt���sÇced ä ]FñI`(ô£*]IñI`»p-�»��]�ë$"E¦o]Iñ§È�ñ1¥I`L`Íg�vb���hp,dhp��»��Pü@prv_���»sÇpr�åñ1¥ ; ÿÀ�

���hp,ceq�fyprqÍcI~F��hp�v_�Lpr�Zv½s\d!��hpµg�üUcÀ�ep,gI}\ý�c�q�sÇ��hn �Íg�v½vLpO}\prt��LpVf�~�ceq�t�}ugIq�s������h�hq��Uc%v_pVvO�,8¾d�g�d'get����ZgI}+s\n�h}\pOnpOd6���gI�Ls\c�d!s����½s\}\}+üUp,nceqLpÒp� |tOsÇprde�½��cqLprc�q�fypOq½vLc�npÒcI~���hpVv_p,v_�LpO�UvO�

Page 10: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

tvu ö�õ óFó

8¾dT���hpUMZq�v_�Ò�ZgIqL�Óc�~Ñ��hsuvÒgIqL�Lsut�}\p*�bpµs\d%�Lq�c»fh�Zt�pVf'��hpt�cedZt�pr�y�ÒcI~�v�gÀ~�p*qLprý�s\c�d+l7gIdZfÔfyprv�t�q�s\üUpVf»�hcÀ��sÇ�,trgIdTü@p��Zv_pVf�Lc*�hq�c»fh�Zt�p¦t�c�}\}\s\vLsÇced6�P~�qLprp�ncI�Ls\c�dUv�g�dZf(dhp-�%��Pü@prv_�Í�%s\pO� }\cytOgI�Ls\c�dZv��hdZfyprq�s\n(gIýep��¾gI}\sÇýedhnpOd%��t�cedZvLs\fyprq�gI�Ls\c�dZvr�¢���ZprvLp�LpVt��hdhs+�%�hprvrl¯�hcÀ��pr��prqrl@�½sÇ}\}FdhcI�Ò�hq�cyfy�Zt�p�g|n(gI�Q�Püh�ZsÇ}ufypOqÒq�c�ü@cI�¦c�d����hpOs\qÒcÀ�½d+�w8¾d9c�q�fyprq��Lc!üh�hs\}uf���Zp*}ug5��ce�y�Óc�~;güh�hs\}ufysÇdZýZl»v_pr��pOq�gI}yc���hprqEc��@pOq�gÀ��sÇcedZvFnµ�Uv���g�}\vLcÒ��g�ÿ�p½�h}ug�tOp½üUpVv_sufypVvÑ��Zpot�cen��Z�y��gI�Ls\c�dcI~7��Zp�dhp��»��Pü@prv_�;�»sÇpr�,�����ZprvLpc��@pOq�gÀ��sÇcedZv�s\dZtO}Ç�Zfhp��@c�}\�%}\s\dhp�ýepOdhprq�gI�Ls\c�d+lFgIdZf n�cyfypr}bg�}Çs\ý�dZn�prd%��gIdUfânpOq�ý�s\dhýZl�~��hdZt��Ls\c�dZv����hsut��þgIq�p|�hq�prvLpOd%��prf�hprqLpe�8¾dÐ��hsuv�vLprtOc�dZfÔ�ZgIqL�,��p|fhprv�t�q�sÇü@p��hp(s\n�h}\pOnpOd%��gI�Ls\c�dYcI~Íc��Zq,ng��6�®üh�hs\}\fys\dhý'q�c�ü@cI�Lsut(vL�»v_�Lprn'lÈs\dZt�}\�Zfys\dhý'��Zp

vL�UpVt�s�MUtÒ~�c�q�n c�~����hp}092��ègI}\ý�c�q�sÇ��hn prnµü@prfhfhprf's\d!ce�hq��hq�cI��cI���»�@p��Ø���Zp�v_�yv_�LpOn gIq�t��hsÇ�Lprt��L�hq�p,gIdZf�vLc�np,v�gIn�h}\pp��y�@pOq�sÇnprde��vÍ�ZvLsÇdhýce�hq�v_�yv_�Lprn�gIq�pÒgI}uv_c(fypVvLtOqLs\üUpVf"�

� t ÷ ú ý«�µ÷�ô u�ú�� u ø!�

f+pO�*�Zv�g�v�vL�hnp(��ZgI�µ���hp�q�c�ü@cI��s\vµp��%�hs\�h�UpVf �½sÇ��þgT�Uce}\g�qµq�gIdhýep�v_prdZvLc�q�nprgev_�ZqLs\dhý����hp�fysuv_��gIdUt�p�ü@p����bpOprdâ��ZpvLpOdZvLc�q�B v½tOpOd%�LprqD�®�@c�s\de��g�dZf���hp�ceü67�prt���vÍs\d'��hp,prd»�%s\q�c�dhnpOd%�og�}Çcedhý(v_pr��pOq�gI}7q�g5�yvÍqLprý��h}ugIq�}Ç�|vL�Zget�prf�s\dTgm�hc�q�s�%rc�d%��g�}�h}ugIdhpÔgÀ�«�hprsÇý��%�'� gIü@cÀ��p'���hp� Uc%ceqr�ç���hp9vLpOdUv_ceq|fyqLs\��prq�t�ced»��pOqL��v(��hpVv_pTnpVg�vL�hqLprnpOd%��v(s\d%�Lc gâ}\suv���c�~,�UcesÇd%��vq�pO�hq�prvLpOd%�Ls\dhýY���hpÔtOqLc%vLvD�®vLprt��Ls\c�d�cI~Ò��Zp9pOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��gÀ��g��hpOs\ý�%�'� sÇd)gþt�c»c�q�fys\dZgÀ��p9v_�yv_�Lprn gI�_��get��hprf ��c ��ZpvLpOdZvLc�qV�}��sÇýe�hq�pa�h]FG�`¦v�hcÀ��vÒv_�Zt��Ô�UcesÇd%��v¦~�c�q,gÐ^rx�z$�®fhpOýaMZpr}\fÐc�~;�»sÇpr�,l+�½s����Ðz�� ���®fhpOý'v_�Zget�s\dhý!üUpO����prpOd9pr��prqL�'���bct�cedZvLprt��h�Ls\��p�q�g5�yvOlÑtrgI�y���hqLpVf �ZvLs\dhýÔgÔq�g�dhý�p�v_prdZv_ceq�~�q�c�n �»sut�ÿå�Ó�y��s\t��Yï;}ÇpVt��Lq�c�dZs\t��ioÐp�ncyfypr}����hsuv�vLpOdUv_ceqµ�ZvLsÇdZýkÓp�MZdhsÇ�Ls\c�d9�h�Ç^e�P8®�os\vÍdZcI�ofys� |t��h}Ç���Lc(gefhf'gId�gIdhýe�h}ugIqÍ�ZgIq�gInpO�LpOq��þqLpr�hqLpVv_prd%�Ls\dhýµ���hpwMZpr}\f§�®cI~?�®�»sÇpr� c�~����hp�v_prdZvLc�qVlsÇ~�dhpVt�pVvLv�gIq����

�Ó�hqÓý�ceg�}+suv���c�t�cedZv_�Lq��Zt��Òg(�Uce}Ç�»ýec�dZg�}È}ug5��c��h�ocI~F��Zp*prd%�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��~�q�c�n���hpvLp���vÓcI~E�@c�s\d%��vÓtOgI�h�L�hq�prf�ü»�!��Zpq�gIdhýep*vLpOdZvLc�qÒgÀ�,fys�#@prqLprde�Ò}\c»trgÀ��sÇcedZvO�j�Ó�Zq¦�ZqLpO~�pOq�pOdZtOp�~�c�qÒ�@c�}\�»ý�c�dUgI}�n�cyfypr}\v¦suvÒfyqLs\��prdTü»�TgIdÐgI}\ý�c�q�sÇ��hnsut�suvLvL�hp��2bprtrgI�ZvLpÍcI~@��hprsÇq;tOc�n�Zget��ÑqLpr�hq�prvLpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d+lÀýepOc�npO�Lq�s\tb�hq�c��@pOqL�Ls\prvÑtrgIdüUp�tOc�n�h�y��prf���prqL�µp� |t�s\pOd%�L}\��~�ceqÑ�Uce}Ç�»ýec�dZg�}ncyfypO}uvO�,�Zc�qÍp��hg�n��Z}Çpel»tOc�n�h�y��sÇdZý��»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���|q�pOýesÇcedZvE~�ceq½g*�@c�}\�»ý�cedZgI}@nc»fhpO}"�½sÇ��xmTprfhý�prv½trgId�üUpÒprgev_s\}\�|fyc�dhpÒs\d��]6p �«¤V¡ pU`F��sÇnp¦�½s�����g�t�}ug�v�vLs\trgI}h}\sÇdZp��¾v_�bpOpr��Lprt��Zdhs4�%�hpe�U�o��hprq;q�pO�hq�prvLpOd%��gI�Ls\c�dZvrlevL�Zt��|gevEcytOtO�h�ZgIdUt���ý�q�s\fhvrl»fyc�dhc��gI}\}\cÀ� v_�Ut��!p- |t�s\pOd%��t�c�n�h�h��gÀ��sÇced+�) c�}\�»ý�cedZgI}@n(gI�6�®üh�hs\}\fhpOq�v��Zg5��p¦�Lq�g�fhs���sÇcedZgI}\}Ç��üUprpOd�g5��ces\fypVf�s\d'�hq�g�t���s\trgI}È�6f�mo� vL�»v_�Lprn(vO�,8¾d!���hp,�Zg�v_�rlUv_cedZgIq�v

�bpOq�p���ZpvLpOdUv_ceq�vocI~�t��hces\tOpµ~�ceqÓý%gÀ���hpOq�sÇdZý�q�gIdhýep*fhgI��g|�½sÇ��Yg�qLceüUc��r�"2b�y��v_cedZgIq�vog�qLpU�hprg5�»s\}Ç�Tg$#@pVt��LpVfTü»��dhces\vLpgIdUf��hq�cÀ�%sufyp�}\cÀ��q�prvLc�}\�y�Ls\c�dTfhgI��gZl@vLc��@c�}\�»ý�c�dUgI}Èn(g��Zvo�bpOq�p�ce�y�Óc�~E��hph�%�hprv_�Ls\c�d+�w�hceq����hs\v¦q�prgev_ced+lZncev_�Óc�~E��Zp�Zgev��;q�prvLprg�q�t���c�d�ng��(üh�hs\}\fhsÇdhýU�Zg�v;t�pOd%��pOq�prfc�d|tOc�dZv_�Lq��Zt��Ls\dhý,�Lce�Uce}Çceý�sutOg�}hn(gI�ZvÓ]����hsut��|t�cede��gIs\d(}ÇsÇ�_��}ÇpÓý�prc�np���qLsuts\dy~�c�q�n(gÀ�Ls\c�d@`ÍgIdZf!cytOtO�h�ZgIdUt���ýeqLsuf!qLpr�hq�prvLpOd%��gI�Ls\c�dZv,]�sÇdZtO}Ç�UfysÇdZý(��hp,�@c��Z�h}\g�q�b[l�\c�Xc-<?V^< R >F<I]«\�]�]-T�bQX$A[]-¸hel�<I`Àl@���hpOq�p�hq�c�üZg�ühs\}ÇsÇ�Ls\prvEg�qLp½�Uv_pVf��Lc�prdZt�cyfyp½���hp��hdUt�pOqL��g�sÇd%���*cI~+gId(ceüZv���g�tO}Çp�B vF�hq�prvLpOdUt�pV`��=2��h�;q�g�dhý�p-�FMUdZfys\dhý¦�Lprt��Zdhc�}\c�ýe�}�Zgevü@prt�cenpÒt��ZprgI�@pOqVlync�q�pÒ�hqLpVt�suv_p,g�dZf�q�pO}\sugIüh}\p��=���hsuv��ZgevÍn�c��Ls\�ÀgÀ�LpVf!�Zvb�Lc(q�prtOc�dZvLs\fhpOqÍ�Uce}Ç�»ýec�dZg�}@q�pO�ZqLpVv_prde��gÀ��sÇcedZvO�

� ö ÷*ô!�Èõ�öEù'úbõÑû�÷*ô ÷U|çx)³Oy � u ý�÷*ù�õP�

8�fypVgI}\}Ç�el5��hp����¾k�}\g5�ec��y��cI~Ug�dµs\dZfyc»c�qFprd%�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��suv���hpÍ�hq�c$7�pVt���sÇcedw� sÇd%��c¦g9�hc�q�s4%Oc�d%��gI}��Z}\g�dhp,� c�~h��Zpb�@c�qL�Ls\c�dUvcI~½ceü67�prt���v�s\dâ���hp��bc�q�ÿyv_�Zget�p���UgÀ�*prs����hpOq�üh}\cyt�ÿ9���hp|q�c�ü@cI��B v�nc��Ls\c�d+lÑgIdUfOj5ceq�c�üZv_�Lq��Zt�����hp«MZpO}ufâc�~Í�»s\pO� cI~�sÇ��vvLpOdZvLc�q�vO�Òa�cÀ�bpO�epOqVlUfy�Zpµ��c!vLpOdZvLc�qÓ}Çs\ns���gÀ��sÇcedZvOl7���hp�}\g5�ec��y�osuv¦cI~���pOdÔg��h�hq�c��ysÇn(gÀ��prf�gevÓg«�hc�q�s�%rc�d%��g�}�tOqLc%vLvD�®vLprt��Ls\c�dt��h�_�Ls\dhý*��hq�c��Zý�(���hpÓprd»�%s\q�c�dhnpOd%�ÍgÀ�bg*ý�s\��prda�hpOs\ý�%�V��8¾d���hpÒtOgev_pÓcI~�gµnµ�h}Ç�Ls��N Zc»c�qbpOd»�»sÇq�c�dhnprde�Vl����hp¦n�cyfypr}7ng5�t�cedZvLs\v_�½cI~Ñv_pr��pOq�gI}"���¾k�}ug5��ce�y��vÍt�cedhdhpVt��LpVf�ü»���Zg�v�vLg�ý�p-�P�Íg5�yvO����hp½q�c�ü@cI�Eüh�ZsÇ}ufhv;gÒ�@c�}\�»ý�cedZgI}y}ug5��ce�y�Eü»�µncÀ�»sÇdhý¦���hqLce�hý�(g,vLp��%�hprdZt�p�c�~7vLpOdUv_s\dhý,�@cevLs���sÇcedZvOle���hsut��g�qLp�t��ZcevLpOd

ü»�,��Zp�092b���Z}\g�dhdhpOqEfhprv�t�q�sÇü@prfµsÇd|�»pVt��Ls\c�d*�Z�P���hprvLpÍ�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�dUv�tOc��h}uf�gI}uv_c¦üUp½t��hc%v_prdµü»�µg�dhcI���hpOqÑvLcI~����ÍgIq�p;ncyfy�h}\pc�qÒü»�Tg'�»�hn(gIdÐc��@pOq�gÀ�Lceqr�"8¾dUfypO�@pOdZfhpOd%�L}\�9ced.�hcÀ�Â��hp(vLpOdZvLsÇdZý�}\cytOgÀ��sÇcedZvÒgIq�p�vLpO}\prt��LpVf"l7��hp~�ce}Ç}\cÀ�½s\dhý�v_�Lpr�Zv,gIq�pp��ypVt��y��prf�gÀ�Óprg�t���vLpOdZvLs\dhý|�@cevLs���sÇced!ñ§� ) c�}\�»}Çs\dhp,ýepOdhprq�gI�Ls\c�d+lZv�gÀ~�pµqLprý�s\c�d�t�cen��Z�y��gI�Ls\c�d+lUn�cyfypr}�g�}Çs\ý�dhnprde�VlZncyfypO}npOq�ý�s\dhýZlhg�dZf!fyp���prt���sÇced'cI~�vLn(gI}\}+c�üUv���g�t�}\prvr�P���hprvLp�gIq�p¦fhprv�t�q�sÇü@prf!s\d!fypO��g�sÇ}+ü@pO}\cÀ�,�

Page 11: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]NG�`

��sÇýe�hqLp}�6�Ei�gIdhýep,v_prdZv_s\dhýO�Í]FEy`ÍvLtOpOdhpew+]FG�`ÍtrgI�y���hqLpVf��@c�s\d%��v½�Uv_s\dhý(g�q�g�dhý�pÒv_prdZvLc�qÍ~�q�c�n��»sut�ÿ��Ó�y��s\t��Yï;}ÇpVt���qLcedhs\t��

��sÇýe�hq�pÒx�� ) c�}\�»}Çs\dhp9Mh�½~�c�qÍ���hp�fhgÀ��g�cI~=��s\ý��ZqLp}�y]NG�`��

%GIH XxVU­�)­9TIW)NPÐQNbW$NSZ\K'_\T�VUWf+pO��¦ ü@pµ���hp}Çsuv_�Òc�~;�@c�s\de��v,g�t��e�ZsÇq�prf�ü»�'���hp(v_prdZv_ceq¦gI�wñ»�D¦ suvÓ�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�nprf�s\d%�Lc'g�tOc�}\}ÇpVt���sÇcedià;óÈc�~;�Uce}Ç�»ýec�dZg�}}\sÇdhpVv�tOg�}Ç}\prfCb�\�V^¸�V^<?A¯Z R �����hp,�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdZp,p��»�Lq�g�t��Ls\c�d�g�}Çýec�q�s����hn ce�Uprq�gI�Lprvbs\d!����c(v_�LpO�Uv-��]_^V`bý�q�c��Z�!fhgI��g�s\de��c|t�}\�Zv_�LpOq�vrlgIdUfþ]A�e`�Mh��g��Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhp*�Lc�prget��9t�}\�Zv_�LpOqV�"���hp�ý�ceg�}Èc�~�t�}\�Zv_�LpOq�s\dhý�suv���c�ýeqLce�h���@c�s\de��vÓ��ZgI�ÒtrgIdTü@pµ��q�get�pVf�üZg�t�ÿ!��c��ZpµvLg�np�v_�hqL~�g�tOp,c�ü67�pVt��V��m vLpOdZvLc�q½�½sÇ���s\d6MZdZs���pµq�prvLc�}\�y�Ls\c�d!��ce�h}uf!trgI�y���hq�p�g|t��hq���pw�y]�q%`½s\dZv���prgef'cI~Ñg|v_p��%�hpOdZtOpcI~"�@c�s\d%��vr�P���Zs\v�t��hq���p½�bc��h}ufü@pÓfysuvLtOc�d%�Ls\d»�hc��UvEgÀ�;p-�hg�t���}Ç�*��Zp��UcesÇd%��v;���hprqLp½cytrt�}\�Zv_s\c�dUvEcytOtO�hqr�P�hceq;g,q�prg�}Zv_prdZvLc�qVlfysuvLtOc�d%�Ls\d»�hsÇ�Ls\prv½gIq�p,fyp���prt��Lprf!�ZvLs\dhý���hq�prv�hc�}ufhv½vLpO}\prt��Lprf!g�trt�ceq�fys\dhý*�Lc���hp�v_prdZvLc�q�B vÍg�trt��hq�g�tO������hp��@c�s\d%��v�sÇd�prg�t��(tO}Ç�Zv_�Lprqbg�qLp�MZ�_�LpVf|�½sÇ���g��Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhp¦v_c���ZgI�;pO�epOq���fhgI��g,�@c�s\d%��}\sÇpVvE�½sÇ��hs\d�g*fys\v_��g�dZt�p �E~�q�c�n

g(}\sÇdZpµv_prý�npOd%�VlZ���hs\}Çpµn�s\dhs\ns�%rsÇdhý���hpµd%�Znµü@pOqoc�~Ñ��pOqL�Lsut�pVv½s\d���hpµ�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhpe�����hpµtOc�n�h�y��gÀ�Ls\c�d!��gIÿ�pVvogefy�ÀgId%��g�ý�pcI~Í���hp|~�get������ZgÀ�����hp�fZgÀ��g�fhpO}\sÇ�epOq�prfYü»�Ôce�hq��@c�}ugIqµvLpOdUv_ceqµvLgI�Lsuv�~��YgIdYceq�fyprqLs\dhýTtOc�dZv_�Lq�gIs\d%�µgI}\c�dhý'���hp|dhces\vLp��P~�qLprpq��¾t�c»c�q�fys\dZgÀ��p���2b�TgI�Z�h}Ç�»s\dhý���hpn(gI�h�ZsÇdhý��nôètOcev6q5ÚÑv_s\d�qQÈ���ô ^�Úy]I��vLs\d�qe`�l"���hp�hq�c�üh}\pOn suvÓ�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�nprf�s\d%�Lc'g}\sÇdhpVgIq�Mh�ÓcI~���hpÒ~�ceqLn��môÁE��dG�� ]����Zs\t���n(gI�Uvb�Lc«G���� E��aô ^,s\dT{bg�q_��prvLs\g�dÐ]��ÝÈ��y`��®vL�Zget�pV`����»pr��pOq�gI}7�bpO}\}W�®ÿ»dhcÀ�½dq�prt��Zq�vLsÇ�ep*g�}Çýec�q�s����hn(vÓp-�ys\v_�Ò�Lc'MZdZfÐ�@c�}\�%}\s\dhprvÒs\d ]���È��y`Y�¾v_�Zget�p!� �e���®�m2b�9tOc�d»��prq_��sÇdZý��Ò��c����hp(�@cevLs���sÇced6�®fhpO�@pOdZfyprd%�pOq�q�c�qÒüUce�hdZfnK*ô���� � ]IE§¶!��G�¶O`,sÇdÐ��ZpT]���È��y`Y�¾v_�Zget�pelÈprget��ÐfZgÀ��g'�@c�s\d%��sÇdÐ���hpT]��¢È��h`Y�¾v_�Ug�t�p(suv,ýe�ZgIq�gId%�LprprfT�Lc�ü@p�½sÇ��hs\d"�¦~�qLcen ��hp(tOc�n�h�y��prfÐ�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdZp��h8�vÓs\n�Uceq_��gId%�Ò�Lc'dhc��Lp���ZgI�Ò��hp(�@c�}\�»}Çs\dhphMh�_��sÇdZý!�ZqLcyt�pVvLvÒg�}\vLc!get���v¦gevÒgdhces\vLpÒqLpVfy�Zt���sÇced«MU}���pOqV�

Page 12: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]FGO`

��s\ý��hq�p,�Q�Ñm nc�q�p,t�c�n�h}\sutOgÀ��prf�p��hgIn�h}\pÒcI~Ñg��Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhpwMZ�r�

��sÇýe�hq�pbxÒv�hcÀ��vFg¦vLp��Ñc�~U���hqLprpÍ�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhpVvFý�prdhpOq�gÀ��prf,~�q�c�n ��hp�fhgI��gÓ�UcesÇd%��vÑcI~¯��s\ý��ZqLp��y]NG�`��Fm×nc�q�pbtOc�n�h}\s\trgÀ�LpVfp��hg�n��Z}ÇpelIsÇdg¦t�}\�y�_��pOq�prf*c$ |t�pÍpOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%�rlÀsuvFfys\vL�h}ug5��pVf�s\dh��s\ý��hq�p½�h�¢���ZpÍg�qLpVg�s\d*}\s\ý�%�Ñý�q�pO�,s\d!]NG�`�s\v����hpÍqLceüUc���B v�»s\vLs\ühsÇ}\sÇ���|qLprý�s\c�d!�hdZfyprqÍ��hp�tO}\gevLvLsutOgI}7}\sÇdZp��®cI~?�¾v_s\ý�%�½nc»fhpO};]���hsuv½q�pOý�s\c�d�s\v�dhcI��gvLgI~�p,qLprý�s\c�dU`��

%Gut J&KML�NPOQNSRUTIVUWÁvfVU¬À]�â7_`K'_\T�VUW�ÓdZtOpÓ���hp,�@c�}\�%}\s\dhp�v_pO�3à;óUsuvÍp��»�Lq�g�t��LpVf|~�q�c�n ��hp�fhgI��gZlhg�v�gÀ~�pÒq�pOýesÇced!ò�ó�]FñI`bs\vot�c�n�h�h�Lprf+�=8¾d��yprt���sÇced'�hlOò�ó�]FñI`b�bgevfyp-MZdhprf�g�vÑ���hp�}ugIq�ý�pVv��Eq�pOýesÇced�ýe�ZgIq�gId%��pOprf*��c�üUpo~�qLprp�cI~+ceüZv_��g�tO}ÇpVvÑý�s\��prd��hpo}ÇcytOg�}ZceüZv_prqL�ÀgI�Ls\c�daà;ó�]IñI`��,���Zs\v;qLprý�s\c�dsuv½g�~��hdZt���sÇced'cI~È���hp�vLpOdZvLc�q�B vb�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ����ncyfypO}P����hpÍ}\c»trgI}Zv�gÀ~�pÍq�pOýesÇcedhò�ó�]FñI`�s\vEüUce�hdZfypVf*ü»��ü@cI�����hp½ceüZvLpOq���prfµ�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdZprv=à;ó�]IñI`�leg�dZf�ü%��~�qLprp�t��hq���pVvÑt�c�dZdhprt��Ls\dhý

��Zp��@c�}\�»}Çs\dhp�pOdZfh�UcesÇd%��vr�U�ZqLprp�tO�hq���prv¦tOg�d9ü@p(t�c�n�h�h�LprfêZg85X�]�>NV^¸µ~�c�qÒ�Uce}Ç�»ýec�dZg�}��bc�q�ÿyv_�Zget�pVvOl7gIdZfÔgIq�p�tOc�n�@cevLprfcI~ÑvLpOý�nprde��vOlhtOsÇq�t��Z}\g�qÍg�q�trv½gIdZf!vL�hsÇq�gI}+vLprt��Ls\c�dZvr�,���hp�tOc�dZv_�Lq��Zt���sÇced�c�~�~�q�pOp�tO�hqL�eprvbsuvÍ~��h}\}Ç�!fyprv�t�q�sÇü@prf!s\d!��hp,�hq�c»cI~cI~=���hprc�q�pOn �h�\^ÒsÇdUt�}\�Zfyprf!s\d!��hp�g��h�UprdZfys��"�=8¾d!ce�hqÍsÇn�h}\pOnprde��gÀ��sÇced+lh�bpÒg��h�hq�c��ysÇn(gÀ��prf�gIq�tOv½gIdUf�vL�hs\q�g�}+v_pVt��Ls\c�dUv�½sÇ��Ð�Uce}Ç�»ý�cedZgI}�}\sÇdhpVv¦�Lc'v_s\n�h}\s�~��9vL�hüZvLp��%�hprd%�,tOc�n�h�y��gÀ��sÇcedZvO�U���hpOq�p�~�ceqLpelU���hpqLprý�s\c�diò�ó�]IñI`ÓsuvÓü@c��ZdZfyprfÔü»� R \�V^<I`Z�`-e5Z R ]�fyprqLs\��pVfY~�qLcen ��hp!c�üZvLpOq���pVfâ�@c�}\�%}\s\dhprv�`�l;g�dZf�k�lZ�Z�Z�`�e�Z R ]�fyprqLs\��pVfâ~�q�c�n ��Zp!g��h�hq�c��»s\n(gÀ��prfÐ~�q�pOp't��hq���pVv�`���ÓdZtOp*���hpqLprý�s\c�dnò ó ]IñI`¦suv,t�cen��Z�y�LpVf"l"��Zp��UgIs\q�( ó ]IñI`wôãÃIà ó ]IñI`�È�ò ó ]FñI`IĦü@prtOc�nprv¦���hp!V�\�]�X$V@ncyfypr};t�cedZv���qL�Ut��LpVf9gI�}\c»trgÀ��sÇced'ñ»���sÇýe�hq�p9^rzÔvD�ZcÀ��vµ���bc9}\cytOg�}Ív�gÀ~�p�qLprý�s\c�dZv�t�cen�h�y�LpVf ~�ceqµ���hp�vLtOpOdhp!s\dd��sÇýe�hq�p!�9~�c�qfys�#@prqLprde�(�ÀgI}\�hpVv*c�~���Zp

n(g��ys\ng�}"q�g�dhý�p;� ����� g�dZf���hp,s\dZt�sufyprdZt�p�g�dhý�}\pws"�

%GuF »¼V7½)N�­c¾¿­IT�RW$¬ÀNbW_f+pO�� ¤ ]Iñ ¥ = ÿ `hô ÃFà ¤ ]Fñ ¥ = ÿ `�È�Ç ¤ ]Iñ ¥ = ÿ `IĵüUp���hp!�Zg�q_��s\g�}�eV�\c�X�V�ncyfypO}Íüh�hs\}Ç�gI�*}\c»trgÀ��sÇced�ñ ¥ = ÿ �âmov�vL�hnp|~�c�q*��Zp�Ls\np�ü@pOs\dhý(��UgÀ�ÓvL�Zt��'ý�}\c�üZg�}+ncyfypO}+p-�ys\v_��vr�Í�y�h�h�@cevLp�dhcÀ� ��ZgI����hpµqLceüUc���p��yprtO�y�LpVv�gdhpO��vLpOdZvLs\dhý(c��@pOq�gÀ��sÇced!gI�}\c»trgÀ��sÇcediñ1¥%lÈp��»�Lq�g�t��Ls\dhý|���hp}ÇcytOg�}�ncyfypr}n(»ó�]Iñ1¥�`3ôÿÃIà;ó�]Iñ�¥I`�È�ò�ó�]Iñ�¥I`IÄ��*mèüUpVv��,n(gÀ��t��9suvÓ��hprdÐtOc�n�h�y��prfTü@p����bpOprd��Zp�}\sÇdhp!v_prý�npOd%��v,sÇddà�¤À]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`µgIdZfY���hcevLp|s\d�à;ó�]Iñ�¥I`�lÑ�»s\pO}ufysÇdZý9gId�ï;�Zt�}\s\fhprgIdY��q�g�dZv_~�c�q�n gI}\s\ý�dhs\dhýTü@cI���þv_pO��vµcI~�@c�}\�%}\s\dhprvr�����Zpbn(gI��t��hs\dhý,gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��hn suvÑv_s\nsÇ}ugIqF��c,go�hq�pO�»s\c��Zv���prt��hdhs+�%�hpÍ�ZvLprfµ�Lc,fysuvLtOcÀ��pOqÑg�dZfµg�}Çs\ý�dv_�ZüZv���qL�Ut��L�ZqLpVvv�ZgIq�prfü»�(���¾k nce}ÇpVt��h}ugIqbv���qL�Zt��L�hq�prv9� x$�P�=���hp¦gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��hn vLpO}\prt���v;�UgIs\q�v;cI~+}\sÇdhp¦v_prý�npOd%��vÑ~�q�c�nËà;óZgÀ�bq�g�dZfyc�n'�P�hceqprget���ZgIs\qo]��Lÿ�È�� ¶ `�l%s��(MZdZfhv�g,�ZgIs\qEc�~"vLpOýenpOd%��v�]���ÿ�È�� ¶ `Fs\dCà�¤b�½sÇ��|��hpov�gInp½q�pO}ugÀ��sÇ�ep�gIdhýe}Çpe�����hpÓt�c�q�q�prvL�UcedZfypOdUt�p�Lÿ æ#��ÿ�È$� ¶ æ#� ¶ �%s\pO}ufhvbgÒ�Lq�gIdUv�~�ceqLnÀ͵]��¢È��¯ÈDq%`Ñc�üh��gIs\dhpVf(ü»�vLc�}\�»sÇdZý,}ÇpVg�v_�D�¾v�%�Zg�qLp½p��e�UgÀ�Ls\c�dUvO�=���hp¦gI}\ý�c�q�sÇ��hnè��hprdsufypOd%�Ls�MZpVv����hp*vLpOýen�prd%��vÓcI~(à;ó+gIdZf.à�¤Ò���hsut��Tn(gÀ��t��T�hdZfhpOqÓ��hsuv���q�g�dZv_~�c�q�n!l7gIdUf�t�q�prgÀ��prvÓg|dhpr� t�c�q�q�prvL�UcedZfypOdUt�p�Lÿ æ#��ÿ�È%� ¶ æ#� ¶ È$�&�'�-È(�*)1æ#�+)IlÀ���ZpOq�pE��Zp$� ,�B v�g�dZf-�+,B v�gIq�p;dhc���dhpVt�pVvLv�gIq�sÇ}\�Ófhs\v_�Ls\dZt��V�¢8®�Fq�prtOg�}\tO�h}ugÀ�LpVv"���hpE��q�g�dZv�~�ceqLnüZgev_pVf9ced9���hs\vÒdZpO� t�c�q�q�prvL�UcedZfypOdUt�p*g�dZfÔpO�ÀgI}\�ZgÀ��prv¦���hpa�e�UgI}\s����Tc�~(Mh�V�C���hp(gIü@cÀ��pv���pO�Zv,g�qLp�q�pO�@prgÀ��prf9~�c�q,pVg�t��

Page 13: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]FGO`

��s\ý��ZqLp^rz��;{�c�n�h�y��prf'vLgI~�pÒqLprý�s\c�dZv��b]FEy`���������ô ���I�*t�n gIdZf*s«ô ��z*fhpOýZw�]FG�`���������ô ����z*tOn�g�dZf«s«ô xe��fyprýZ�

]FE»` ]FGO`��s\ý��hq�p^�^��Í]FEy`Í��dZg�}Çs\ý�dhpVf��@c�}\�»}Çs\dhpVvOwÈ]NG�`Ít�cen�h�y�LpVf'gI}\sÇýedhnpOd%�r�

�Zg�sÇq�c�~Ñ}Çs\dhp*vLpOýenpOd%��v�v�gIn�h}\prf!~�q�c�n à ó l@g�dZf!��Zp,�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�n �½sÇ��T��hp�ü@prv_�;�%�Zg�}ÇsÇ���!s\voqLpO��gIs\dhpVf"��8®~Ñg�}Ç}�v_prý�npOd%��vs\dnà ó gIq�p(gI�h�ZqLc��ys\ngI�Lpr}Ç���Zg�q�g�}Ç}\pO}Pl"���hp|gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��hn �Zv_pVvÒpOdZfh�UcesÇd%��vµgIdZfÐcyfyc�npO�Lq�s\tvLpOdZvLsÇdZý'�Lc�gI�h�ZqLc��ys\ngI�Lp���Zpns\v�vLsÇdhý�Zg�q�g�np��LprqÍcI~���hpÒ��q�g�dZv�~�ceqLn'���sÇýe�hq�p�^e^e]FE»`Ív�hcÀ��vb���bc(v_pO��v½c�~��@c�}\�»}Çs\dhprvÍü@p�~�ceqLp�g�}Çs\ý�dZn�prd%�r�(���hp�tOc�n�h�y��prf'gI}\s\ý�dhnpOd%��c�~����hprvLpÒ����c(vLp���v½s\v

fysuv_�Z}\g5�eprf�sÇdY]FG�`��

%G6º »¼V7½)N�­c»¼NSZ\RUT9W)R

���hp�v_pr}ÇpVt��LpVf!�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�nãÍ suv¦gI�h�h}\s\prf!�Lc!ÇS¤À]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`�l@g�dZf'��Zpµdhpr��ý�}\c�üZg�}ÈvLgI~�p�q�pOý�s\c�d.Çb¤5]Iñ1¥�`½suvÓtOc�n�h�y��prfTgev½��Zp�hdhs\c�d�cI~E͵]FÇS¤5]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`L`FgIdZfhò�ó�]Iñ�¥I`��=���hpÍvLc�}\s\fµprfyýeprv�üUce�hdZfys\dhý�ÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`È~�ceqLn ���hpÍdhpO� �Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhpÍvLp��,à�¤À]Fñ1¥I`�����c,g5��ces\fprfhý�pÍ~�q�gIý�nprde��gÀ��sÇced+l�t�cedZvLprt��h�Ls\��p�vLc�}\s\f']�q�prvL�@prt���sÇ�epO}\��~�q�pOp5`FprfyýeprvÑs\d��Zp�üUce�hdZfhg�qL�*cI~ à�¤À]Fñ1¥e`���ZgI��gIq�pÍ�hq�g�t���s\trgI}\}Ç�t�ce}Ç}\s\dhprg�q��ZdZfypOqF���hp½v_prdZvLc�q�B v�q�prvLc�}\�y�Ls\c�d�gIq�p;~��ZvLprf�s\d%�Lc,gÓvLs\dhý�}\pÍprfyýep��P���hpÍdhpO� n�cyfypr}wÂ�¤À]Fñ1¥I`,ô ÃIà�¤À]Iñ�¥I`�È�ÇS¤À]Iñ�¥I`IÄsuvoq�pO�hq�prvLpOd%��prf!sÇd9��hp�t�c»c�q�fys\dZgÀ��pµvL�»v_�Lprn gI�_��g�t��hpVf'�Lc(���hp�qLceüUc��ÓgÀ�¦s���vÓtO�hqLq�pOd%�o�@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�d�ñ1¥y�9���hp���¾kÂ}ug5��ce�y��s\vt�cedZvLs\fyprqLpVf9tOc�n�h}\p��LpsÇ~bdZc!q�pOn(g�sÇdhs\dhý�~�qLprpprfyýep�s\dÔ��hpü@c��hdZfZgIq��TcI~�ÇS¤À]Iñ�¥I`Ós\vÒ}\c�dZý�pOq¦���ZgIdYg!ý�s\��pOdÔ��ZqLpVvD�hce}\f+wcI���hpOq��½suv_pel�Ç ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `bsuvÍ�Zg�v�v_pVf|��c���hp,dhp-�»��s���pOq�gÀ�Ls\c�d!cI~���Zp,ng��h�hs\dhý�hq�c»tOprv�vO�

Page 14: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]FGO`

]IHr` ]FJ%`

��sÇýe�hq�p�^5�6�Ñ��prqLýesÇdhý*~�c��Zq��ZgIqL�LsugI}7ncyfypO}uv�gI�½g�ýesÇ�epOd!�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d+�

��sÇýe�hq�pâ^V�Yfysuv_�Z}\g5�yv~�ce�hq|�Zg�q_��s\g�}oncyfypO}uvO�����hp9qLceüUc��|s\v�gÀ��vLc�np�}\c»trgÀ��sÇced����ZpOq�pTs���qLc���gÀ��prv��câ~�g�tOp'~�c��hqvL�ZtOtOprv�v_s\��pÒfys\qLpVt��Ls\c�dUvbvL�Zget�prf�ü»����z�fyprýZ�,���hpÒ}\c»trgI}"ncyfypO}"s\dâ]IEy`��bgevÍüh�hs\}���gI�½��hp;MZq�v��½ceqLs\pOd%��gI�Ls\c�d+�=���hpÒncyfypO}s\dþ]FG�`��bgev½c�üh��gIs\dhpVf�ü»��npOq�ý�s\dhý(���hpµncyfypr}�c�~½]FEy`½�½sÇ������hpµ}\cytOgI}�ncyfypO}�ý�pOdZpOq�gÀ�LpVf�gÀ�����hp*vLprtOc�dZf'ceqLs\pOd%��gÀ�Ls\c�dÈlgIdUf v_cÔc�d+�1���hp�nc»fhpO}ÍsÇd ]IJ»`µtOc�n*ühsÇdZprvµ��hp'fhgÀ��g9tOc�}\}ÇpVt��LpVf gÀ�*��hp�~�c��Zq*ceqLs\pOd%��gI�Ls\c�dZvr�.8¾d�g�fhfhs���sÇced �LcÔüUprsÇdZýgId's\}Ç}\�Zv_�Lq�gÀ��sÇced�cI~Fn�cyfypr}ÈnpOq�ý�s\dhýUl���sÇýe�hqLp(^5�vD�ZcÀ��vÍ��hp*gIqL�Ls�MUt�p,prn��Z}ÇcÀ�eprf��Lc|prnµ�h}ugÀ��p,c�ndhsufys\qLpVt��Ls\c�dUgI}ÈvLpOdZvLs\dhý�ZvLsÇdZý'g'vLpOdZvLc�qÒ�½sÇ��YgÐ^rx�z$�®fhpOýCMUpO}ufÔc�~��»s\pO�,�a0�c��Lp���ZgI�,��hp(n(gI��t��hs\dhý!c��@pOq�gÀ�Ls\c�dYt�cen�UprdZvLgI�LpVvo~�ceq�gId»�TvLng�}Ç}�ÀgIq�s\gI�Ls\c�d�sÇd!��Zp,qLceüUc���B vÍ�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d'g�vÍsÇ��qLc���gI�Lprvb��c(g*dZpO� c�q�sÇprde��gÀ��sÇced+�

%Guï ®¿NSKn­9TIW)RÑöåT�_`ø<J%¬ÀKn­I­/.#0�as_`Kn©/­�NbarKnW�½<îDZ\KnW$a�T�NbW_1.#032sN�©�_`amÕ�Zc�q�s�%rc�d%��g�}Et�q�cev�v��¾v_pVt���sÇced9���hqLce�hý� g�dâsÇdUfyc»c�qµprd»�%s\q�c�dhnpOd%��c�~��LpOdþsÇd%�Lprq�vLprt���v�vLn(gI}\};ceü67�prt���v�]�p�� ýZ�\lÑt��ZgIs\q�}\pOýev�`���»�Zt��'ceü67�prt���v½gIq�pÒfyp���prt���prf!ü»��g�ý�c»cyf�q�g�dhý�pÒv_prdZvLc�q½gIdZf'�hprdZt�p,g��h�UpVgIq�g�n�cedhý*��hp,�@c�}\�»}Çs\dhprv3à ó ]FñI`bp��»�Lq�g�t��LpVf�gI�gv_prdZvLsÇdhý�@cevLs���sÇced»ñ�]Av_prpw��s\ý��hq�p��e`��,2b�y�rlZfh�hpÒ�Lc(vLng�}Ç}ÈpOq�qLceq�v�sÇd�g�}Çs\ý�dhs\dhý�@c�}\�%}\s\dhprvrlZvL�Zt���ceüZv_��g�tO}ÇpVvb�LprdZf��Lc(ü@ppO}\s\n�s\dZgI�Lprf����hpOd���ZpÓ�hdZsÇced�cI~È����c�vLgI~�pÓq�pOýesÇcedZv;suvÍt�cen��Z�y�LpVf"�U�o��hprqbncyfypr}@nprqLýesÇdhýµ�LpVt��hdhs+�e�ZprvÍt�ce�h}\f�üUp¦�ZvLprf"lüh�y��ncyfypr}Çs\dhý(v_n(g�}Ç}7c�üUv���g�t�}\prvbü»��tO}Çc%v_pVf��@c�}\�»ý�c�dUgI}7t�c�d%��c��hq�vbs\vÍÿ»dhcÀ�½d��LcüUp�fhsW |t��Z}��og�dZf�dZcI�½��prqL�(q�pO}\s\g�üh}\p��P8¾dn(gId»��sÇdZv_��g�dZt�pVvOl»g�n(g��(s\v�nc�q�p��ZvLp�~��h}@���hpOd!v_n(g�}Ç}Uc�üZv_��get�}\prv;g�qLpoc�ns��L�LpVf"lyv_s\dZt�p���hpÓ�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�dZv�cI~ÈvL�Zt��(ceüZv���g�tO}ÇpVvcI~���pOd �LprdZf �Lcât��ZgIdZý�p!cÀ��pOq���sÇnp��)�»cUl;�bp'�hqLcytOpOprf�g�v*~�ce}Ç}\cÀ��vO� �»n(gI}\}½c�üUv���g�t�}\prv�q�prvL�h}Ç�s\d%�LcYdZg�qLq�cÀ�¼?LvL�hs\ÿ�prvg@�@c�s\de��sÇdZý|sÇd%��c|��Zp*v�gÀ~�p�q�pOýesÇced»ò�ó�]IñI`oc�üy��gIs\dhprf�gI�9ñ»�3���hpVv_pµvL�hs\ÿ�pVvotOg�d�üUp�gI�y��c�n(gÀ��s\trgI}\}Ç�'fypO�Lprt��LpVf"�3���hp�gI�@p��'cI~prget��9fypO�Lprt��LpVfÔvL�hs\ÿ�pµsuvÒg�vLn(gI}\}Fs\vLc�}ugÀ��prf��@c�}\�»}Çs\dhp�l"���Zs\t��Ôs\vÒv�g5��prfTsÇdÐg�vLpO�Zg�q�gI�Lp R SaX�V?VWîD\cIÉ-Z�]->3SaX�b7�µa�prdZt�pel"��ZpMZdZg�}�ncyfypr}�tOc�dZvLs\v_��vÓcI~;g|ng�sÇd9}\g5�ec��y�*]��Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdZprvÒgIdZf9vLgI~�p�qLprý�s\c�dU`�gIdZfTg�v_pVt�cedZfhgIq���n(g��þ]�vLn(gI}\}W�®c�ü67�pVt��¦ng��U`����sÇýe�hq�p|^r�(v�hcÀ��v½���hp*vLn(gI}\}ÈceüZv���g�tO}ÇpVv�]�g��Up-�»pVv�prdZt�}\cevLprf'ü»�'v�%�Zg�qLp,ü@c��yprv�`½fyp���prt��LprfTsÇd����hp*v�tOg�d!~�qLcen ��s\ý��hq�p��h����hpVv_pÒs\dZt�}\�Zfyp�g�d'g�}Ç�Zn�s\d»�hn trgInpOq�g*�Lq�sÇ�@cyf"lhgdZgIq�q�cÀ� ��c»cyfypOd!üZg�qrlhg�dZf'g�vL�½s\��pO}+t��UgIs\qr�

Page 15: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

��s\ý��hq�p�^r�Q�E�»n(g�}Ç}+ceüZv_��g�tO}ÇpVvÍp��»�Lq�g�t��LpVf(~�q�c�né��s\ý��hq�p,�Z]NG�`��

��prqLýesÇdhýþ�ZgIqL�LsugI}Ón�cyfypr}\v�ü»����gIÿ»s\dhý ���hp9�ZdhsÇced)cI~�vLgI~�pTqLprý�s\c�dZv«�Zg�v���ZpÔg�fZfyprf)gefy�ÀgId%��g�ý�pTc�~�pO}\sÇns\dZgÀ��sÇdZý�Lq�gIdUv_s\pOd%�½c�ü67�pVt���vO�;{�c�n�Zg�qLs\dhý�prfyýeprvÍs\d!vL�Ztrt�prv�vLsÇ�epÓ�Zg�q_��s\g�}"nc»fhpO}uv½gI}\}ÇcÀ��vÍfypO�Lprt��Ls\c�d'cI~Fv_�Ut���ceü67�prt���vrly���hs\t��'tOg�dü@p�qLpVt�c�q�fypVf s\d�gYvLpO�Zg�q�gI�Lp'v���qL�Zt��L�hq�pâ]�s\d g9�Íg5� v_s\nsÇ}ugIq��câv_n(gI}\}½c�üQ7�prt���v�`�� a�cÀ�bpO��prqrlE��hsuv(tOg��ZgIühs\}\s���� suvdhc��s\n��Z}Çprn�prd%�Lprf!s\d!��hp�vL�yv���pOn fypVvLtOqLs\ü@prf'�hpOq�p��

4 ² ´ µ t×ú-u ô�ô!z�ö óL÷ûø ú z3÷ zoôõ u õFûO÷*ô

���hps\n��Z}Çprn�prd%��gÀ��sÇced9c�~;��Zp�ced6�®}Çs\dhpm032b� �h}\g�dhdhprq¦suv¦üZg�vLprf9�h�@c�dÔ��hp(gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��Zn fhprv�t�q�sÇü@prf9sÇdâ�»prt��Ls\c�dÐ�Z�}���ZpüZgev_sutÓg�}Çýec�q�s����hn�suv½gI�h�h}\s\prf*�hpOq�pÒprv�v_prde��s\g�}Ç}\�(�hdZt��UgIdhýeprf �½]�^5`;��hpÒq�c�ü@cI�½ncÀ��prv;�Lc(g��@cevLs���sÇced*ñ1¥*gIdUf|��gIÿ�pVvÍg*dZpO�c�üUv_prqL�ÀgÀ��sÇced+w+]A�e`½g}\c»trgI}+v�gÀ~�p,q�pOýesÇced'àwó�]Iñ�¥�`bsuv�t�cen�h�y�LpVf"w�]A�e`b���hp,�Zg�q_��s\g�}+}\g5�ec��y�½ncyfypO}'Â�¤À]Iñ�¥I`Ísuv½�h�7fhgÀ��prf"w�]��»`gµvLp��ÍcI~�dhp��»�D�®ü@prv_�D�®�%s\pO� tOgIdUfys\fZgÀ�LpVv;suv�ý�pOdZpOq�gÀ�LpVf"wygIdZf9]A��`E��Zp¦ü@prv_�½tOgIdUfys\fZgÀ�LpÓs\vÍvLpO}\prt��Lprf�g�v;��hp¦dhp-�%��Pü@prv_�Í�%s\pO�,����hpÑce�Uprq�gI�Ls\c�dZv7s\d»��c�}\��pVfos\d�v_�LpO�UvÑ^��¾�ÍgIq�pÑ�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdhpÑp-�»�Lq�g�t���sÇced+l5vLgI~�pÑqLprý�s\c�dÒt�c�n�h�h��gÀ��sÇced+l5gIdZf¦ncyfypO}%gI}\sÇýedhnpOd%�

gIdUfn�prqLýesÇdZýZ�¢���ZprvLp�c��@pOq�gÀ��sÇcedZvF��prqLp�fhprv�t�q�sÇü@prfs\d��hpo�hqLpr�»sÇce�ZvEvLprt���sÇced+�P���hp�ý�prdhpOq�gI}Z�hqLs\dZtOsÇ�h}\prvEüUp��hsÇdUf|v���pO�ZvE�gIdUfþ�'�bpOq�p�p��y�h}ugIs\dhpVfYsÇd×�»prt��Ls\c�d �U� ��g�dZfâ�U� �Zl�q�prvL�@prt���sÇ�epO}\���.���Zp�s\n��Z}Çprn�prd%��gÀ��sÇcedþfypO��gIs\}uvµc�~½��hpVv_p!v���pO�Zv�gIq�pfypVvLtOqLs\üUpVf�s\d!��hsuv�vLprt��Ls\c�d+�

5 GIH v[KnW$½�TI½$K�_`NÑпNbW)NSZwK�_\TIVUWm��@cevLs���sÇced�ñ�s\d ÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`,s\v*g'ý�c»cyfÔdZp��»�D�®üUpVv���P�»s\pO��tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��p(s�~½sÇ�*tOg�dâ�Uc��Lprde��s\g�}Ç}\�ÔvLpOp�}\g�qLýep��Zdhp��y�h}\c�q�prfYgIq�prgevcI~Ñ���hpµ�bc�q�ÿyv_�Ug�t�pe�o�»prt��Ls\c�dT�U� �(�hqLce�Uc%v_pVf!�Lc!t�c�dUv_sufypOqÓc�dh}\����hc%v_p*�UcesÇd%��vÓ�½sÇ��hs\d���Zp*�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ����q�gIdZý�p�c�~Ñ��hpµ~�qLprpprfhý�prv;üUce�hdZfys\dhýaÇS¤5]Iñ�¥�`;g�v��Uc��LpOd%��s\g�}@trgIdZfysufhgI�Lprv=� v_prp3��sÇýe�hqLp;/Z]NG�`��P8¾d|ce�hq�s\n�h}\pOnpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d+l%���hpÓvLp��bcI~+�@cev�v_s\üh}\pdhp-�%��Pü@prv_�D�®�»sÇpr� trgIdZfysufhgI�LprvnÒ5ÓD�D� suvÍq�g�dZfycen�}\�|ýepOdhprq�gI�Lprf��ZvLsÇdhý���hpÒ~�c�}\}\cÀ�½sÇdhý��hq�cyt�prfh�hqLp��

687$9;:=<?>A@=B 9;B 687DC(EF<?9G<?HJI+7$>/KMLNBDI^����»pr}ÇpVt����@cevLsÇ�Ls\��pTt�cedZv_��gId%��vPO g�dZfÎ3UlÍq�pO�hq�prvLpOd%��sÇdhýâv�gIn�h}\prv(�@pOq��hdhsÇ��}\pOdhý��� gIdZf×v�gIn�h}\prv(�@pOq��hdhsÇ�!gIq�prgZlq�prvL�UpVt���sÇ�epO}\���

�y���Zc�q�pVg�t��Ð~�qLprp|prfhý�pCK|s\dY��Zp|üUce�hdZfhg�qL�ÔcI~3Ç ¤ ]Fñ ¥ `�lF�hdhsÇ~�c�q�n�}\�ÔvLpO}\prt��QO3RÑ}\pOdhý���Ý� K��;q�g�dZfycen �@c�s\de��vµg�}Çcedhý»Ke�ð q�c��h����ZprvLp,üUce�hdZfhg�qL��v�gIn�h}\prvÍ�ZdZfypOqÍ���hp�vLp��!S¦�

�h���Zc�qÒprget��9�@c�s\de�72�¿"S¦l+t�cen�h�y�Lp*��Zp��»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ���Tq�pOýesÇced+qÓ]o2@`Ós\dZv_sufypaÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`�l+�h�h�@pOq�P}\s\n�sÇ�LpVfT��c�g�q�gIdhýep}�������~�q�c�nã2ÈlÑgIdUfY�hdhsÇ~�c�q�n�}\�Yv_pr}ÇpVt��d3TREgIq�prgO� q¦]�27`Y�Eq�gIdZfycen �@c�s\d%��v�s\dZvLs\fhpiq¦]�2@`�� ð qLce�h� gI}\}E���hp�s\d%�LpOq�s\c�q�v�gIn�h}\p�@c�s\d%��v½�hdUfypOqÍ���hp�v_pO�UÒxÓD�D�Ó�

���hp�t�cen�h�y��gI�Ls\c�dZg�}½t�cev_�(cI~����hsuv(�hq�c»tOprfy�ZqLp�s\v��] Ë ì*p ëVU(ÌI�«¤V¡ pU`�lb���hpOq�p5Å suv*��hp'��cI��g�}Íd%�Znµü@pOq(cI~¦üUce�hdZfhg�qL�v�gIn�h}\prvrl`( ��hp,d»�hn*üUprq½cI~�ý�pOdZpOq�gÀ�LpVf�trgIdZfhs\fhgI�LpVvOlhg�dZfmÔ��Zp,d%�Znµü@pOq½cI~Fprfhý�prvÍs\d���hp,�Zg�q_��s\g�}"}\g5�ec��y�3Ç ¤ ]Fñ ¥ `��

Page 16: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

��sÇýe�hq�p�^r���9���Zp��@cI��pOd%�LsugI}Ñ�»suv_s\ühs\}ÇsÇ����ýeg�sÇdÔcI~Íg�trgIdZfysufhgI�Lpañ(suv¦��hp(gIq�prgi£µ]FñI`¦c��y��v_sufyp���hpp-�»�Z}ÇceqLpVf�qLprý�s\c�d9��ZgI�tOg�d�ü@p,�»s\vLs\üh}ÇpÒ���hq�c��hý������hpÒ~�qLprpÒprfyýeprvÍü@c��hdZfhsÇdhýCÇ ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `�lZfysuv�t�q�p��Ls4%OpVf'�hpOq�pÒü%��tOg�v_�Ls\dhýq�g5�»vr�

0�p-�»�rl��bp nµ�Uv��Ð��pOq�sÇ~��)��UgÀ�9���hpþv�gIn�h}\prv9sÇdõÒ5ÓD�D� g�qLpâs\dZfyprprf ~�pVg�vLsÇüZ}Çpe� movTp-�y�h}\g�sÇdZprf s\dè�»prt��Ls\c�d��U� �hlgþtrgIdZfhs\fhgI�LpT�@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�dÁñâv�hc��Z}\f dZcI��cedh}\��ü@pÔtOc�d%��g�sÇdZprf s\dZvLs\fypnÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`�l�üh�y�'s��!nµ�Zv_��gI}uv_c ü@p9q�prget��ZgIüZ}Çp'~�q�c�nñ ¥ ü»�èg tOc�}\}Çsuv_s\c�dQ�A~�q�pOp×�ZgI��+� �Zc�qþtOsÇq�t��Z}\g�qÐq�c�ü@cI��vOl���hp)s\n�h}ÇprnpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d cI~!��hp×~��ZdZt���sÇcedªÕ Ö��g×oØ ô Ù�Ç`Ú/ÛÙ\ÉsÇbÌSÌSÝwÞF]FÇ ¤ ]Fñ ¥ `�Èñ ¥ ÈñI`ÍtrgId!üUp,q�gÀ���hpOq�v_�Lq�gIs\ý�%�_~�ceqL�ÍgIq�f �

KN7DC(WXKMLN7$9;9=EY93@^����§�ZqLs\dhÿ1Ç ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `,ü»�Ô��hp�q�gefysÇ�Uv�cI~Í���hp|q�c�ü@cI�*�Ç^V���Ò]����hs\v*c��@pOq�gÀ��sÇcedâtOgIdâü@p�fhc�dhp|s\dâ}\sÇdhpVgIqµ�Ls\n�p5`��Ô�6�hqLs\dhÿ»s\dhýsuvo�@pOqL~�c�q�nprf'cedh}Ç�!���hprd���hp*qLceüUc��oncÀ��pVvÍ�Lc!g(dhpO� vLpOdUv_s\dhý|�@cevLs���sÇced�ñ ¥ l7dhc��opO�epOq�����sÇnp�g|tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��p}ñs\vpr�5g�}Ç�UgÀ�LpVf"�

�y�o{�cen��Z�y�LpÍ���hp�vD�Zc�qL�Lprv_�Ñ�ZgÀ����~�qLcenæñ ¥ �Lc�gwñÓsÇdUv_sufypÍ��Zp�vD�hq��hdhÿµqLprý�s\c�d+�����hs\v;t�c�n�h�h��gÀ��sÇced�trgIdfyc�dZp½sÇd��]6p*Z�`�@pOq"�%�hpOq����ZvLsÇdZý����hp�%suvLsÇühs\}\s�����ýeq�g��Q�9np����hcyfd�Ç^V���P�}���Zpm�%�hprqL�'��sÇnpelL�hcÀ�bpO��prqrl7tOg�d9ü@psÇn�hq�cÀ��pVf'�Lc+��]6p@`ü»�'t�c�dUv���qL�Zt��Ls\dhý��Zp R @Q\$l�>YZ R >Fî4b�X�>�@.SmX�b�~�q�c�n ñ1¥}� � ) � ]Fñ1¥I`������hs\von(gI��suvÓg(fypVt�cen��@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�d�cI~F���hp*vL�Zg�tOps\d%�Lc�t�pr}Ç}uvOl�v_�Zt��Ô��UgÀ�Ò��hp|v�hceq_��prv_�¦�ZgI��Zv¦��c»ñ1¥�~�qLcen gI}\}Ñ�UcesÇd%��vÒ�½s����hsÇdâg't�pr}Ç}Ev�Zg�qLp*��hp|v�gInpv_p��%�hpOdZtOpcI~ceüZv���g�tO}Çp��epOqL�Lsut�pVvO�P���hp�n(gI�!� ) � ]Fñ1¥I`;tOg�d(üUp¦t�c�dUv���qL�Zt��LpVfsÇd���]4p[Z�`Ñc�~"�hqLpr�hq�c»tOprv�v_s\dhýÒ��sÇnp�lyg�}����hc��hý��~�g�v_�Lprqg�dZf�nceqLp,t�cen�h}ÇsutOgI�LpVf�v�t��hpOnpVvÍp��ys\v_�µ]�vLpOpa�Ç^����È~�c�q�gv_�ZqL�epO�|c�~�np����hcyfhv�`����sÇdUgI}\}Ç�el�~�ceq;prget��|tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��p3ñ¦��p¦t�c�n�h�h�Lp�ÔZ]FÇ ¤ ]Iñ ¥ `�ÈñI`�����hpo�LcI��gI}U}ÇprdhýI���|cI~7��ZpÓvLc�}\s\fpVfyý�pVvEs\d(��hpÓüUce�hdZfhg�qL�

cI~UÇb¤5]Iñ1¥e`���ZgÀ�'gIq�p��%suvLsÇüh}\pT~�q�c�n ñY�hdZfhpOq���hpÐv_prdZv_ceq�B v(q�gIdhýepTgIdZf)sÇdZtOs\fhpOdZtOp9t�cedZv���q�g�sÇd%��vO� Ô s\v���hpÔnprg�vL�hq�pcI~¦��Zp�p��y�UpVt���prf cÀ��pOq�}ugI�þü@p����bpOprd g9~��h�L�hq�p�sÇn(g�ý�p»à;ó�]IñI`gIdUfþ���hpTt��ZqLq�pOd%�a�hsuv���c�q���à�¤À]Fñ1¥�`��ª8®~Ó���hpTt�cen�h�y�LpVfcÀ��prqL}ugI��s\vbý�q�prgI�Lprq;���ZgId'v_cenpo���hqLpVvD�Zc�}uf"l%��hprd'ñµqLprng�sÇdUvbgµ~�prgev_s\üh}\p¦trgIdZfhs\fhgI�Lpe�^�o���hpOq��½suv_pel§ñµs\vÍfysuv�tOgIq�fypVf"�=���hs\vMZ}Ç�LprqLs\dhýv���gIý�popOdZvL�hq�prv���ZgI�����hp¦}Çs\dhp¦ngI��t��hs\dhý�gI}\ý�c�q�sÇ��hn �½s\}Ç}7�bc�q�ÿ�q�pO}\sugIüh}\�(gÀ�b��hp¦dhp��»�Í�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d'ñ1¥ ; ÿÀlygIdUf(��Zpt�cen�h�y��gI�Ls\c�dZg�}+t�c%v��½suvÍc�dh}\�x��]4p ��¤r¡ pU`b�@pOq��%�hpOq��9]��Zv_s\dhý|g�q�g5���¾vL��prpO��g�}Çýec�q�s����hn|`��

5 Gut §�á'Kn­9â)K'_\T�VUWãV^LxvfKMW�½$T9½)K'_`NbaïE�epOq��(dhp��»��Pü@prv_�D�®�»sÇpr� tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��p"ñµsuv½pO�Àg�}Ç�ZgI�LpVf��ZvLs\dhý���hp,q�gIdhÿ»s\dhý*~��hdZt���sÇced��hq�c��@cevLprf|s\dT�»prt��Ls\c�d'�Z� �Q�

ä ]FñI` ô £*]IñI`»p-�y�È]�ë$"E¦o]Fñ§Èñ1¥�`_`\� ]A�e`kÓ�hp¦�Lc�c��hq½t��hces\tOpÓc�~È�h}ugIdhdhprqrl§�hprqLp�¦o]Fñ§Èñ ¥ `�s\vÍvLsÇn�h}\�(��ZpÓ}\pOdhý���!cI~+���hp,vD�Zc�qL�Lprv_�Í�ZgÀ���!tOc�dhdhpVt���sÇdhýhñ ¥ = ÿ �½s����'ñ»����hpÓ�ZgIq�gInp���pOq%"|�Íg�v�v_pO�;�Lc�Iz�tOn = ÿ sÇd(���hpos\n�h}\pOnpOd%��gI�Ls\c�d+lygµ�5g�}Ç�Zp½��ZgI�b�ZqLpr��pOd%��vÑ��Zpoq�c�ü@cI�E~�q�c�n cev�t�s\}\}\gI�Ls\dhýüZget�ÿ�gIdZf�~�c�qL��'ü@p����bpOprd�q�pOýesÇcedZvb�½s����'vLs\n�s\}ugIq½�»s\vLs\ühsÇ}\sÇ�����@cI�Lprd%�LsugI}P�

mov�~�ceqF��hp½pVv���sÇn(gI�Ls\c�d�cI~Z���hp½�»s\vLs\ühsÇ}\sÇ����ýeg�sÇd�£µ]FñI`�l%�yprt���sÇced*�U� �¦�hq�c��@cevLprv����ZgÀ�EsÇ�ÑüUpÍ���hp�gIq�prgÓcI~U��hp½�hdZp��y�h}\c�q�prfq�pOý�s\c�d(�»suv_s\üh}\p�~�q�c�nËñÒ���hqLce�hý�|��hpo~�qLprpÓpVfyý�pVvEs\d|��ZpÓü@c��hdUfhgIq��*c�~�ÇS¤5]Fñ1¥�`o]�s\n(gIý�s\dhpo��hpÓ~�qLprpopVfyý�pVv�g�qLp��½s\dZfycÀ��v�`��8¾d(c��ZqEsÇn�h}\pOnprde��gÀ��sÇced+l~£*]IñI`Es\v�t�c�n�h�h�Lprf�Uv_s\dhý�g�fysuv�t�q�p��Ls4%OpVf���pOq�vLsÇced�c�~U���hp���prt��hdZs4�%�hp�ce�y�L}\s\dhprfs\d��»prt��Ls\c�d(�U� ���

Page 17: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]FGO`

]IHr` ]FJ%`

��sÇýe�hqLp^5�6�=ï=�hgIn�h}\p^ÒcI~�ncyfypr}Èt�cedZv���qL�Ut��Ls\c�d!s\d'vLs\nµ�h}ugÀ��sÇced+�

] <?>/K%^$C_7DC(EF<?9G<?H £*]IñI`^��½mvMQ�ypVf�d»�hn*üUprq½cI~Fp��%�Zg�}Ç}\�|v_�Ug�t�pVf�q�g5�yvbs\v�trg�v_�LpVf|~�q�c�n ñ»��y�½mo}Çcedhý�pVg�t��Tq�g5��l7t�cedZv_sufyprqoc�dZ}Ç�!��Zp�vLpOýen�prd%�Ó�½sÇ��hs\dÔz�gIdZf»� ����� ~�q�c�n�ñ»�w8®~Ñ��Zp�vLpOýen�prd%�Ós\de��pOq�v_pVt���vocedhpµceqnc�q�p,v_ce}Çsuf�prfyýeprvrly��pÒpO}\s\n�s\dZgI�LpÒ��Zp,�Uceq_��sÇced�ü@pO�ec�dZf���hpwMUq�v_��cI~���hpVv_p,s\d%�LpOq�vLprt���sÇcedZvr�

�h���Zc�q½prget���q�pOn(g�sÇdhs\dhý�q�g5��v_pVt��Ls\c�dÈlht�c�n�h�h�LpÒ��Zp,}ÇprdhýI���a`ÒcI~���hp,�@c�qL�Ls\c�d�~�gI}\}Çs\dhý.\$T6> R <I`ZÍ��hp,q�pOýesÇced'ÇS¤À]Fñ1¥I`���Z����s\dZgI}\}Ç�elhprv_�Ls\n(gÀ��p�£*]IñI`½gevb��hp�vL�hn c�~Fg�}Ç}7���hp�t�cen�h�y�LpVf�`$B vr����hp*prv_�Ls\ngI�Ls\c�dTc�~U£µ]FñI`�suvos\}\}Ç�Zv_�Lq�gÀ��prf�s\d.��s\ý��hq�pm�y�Ç^e�3���hpv_�hn c�~;gI}\}�v�hcÀ�½d�q�g�fysugI}�v_pVt��Ls\c�dUv*]���hpb`$B v�`½suvÓg�d

gI�Z�hqLc��ys\n(gÀ�Ls\c�d�cI~���hp�g�qLpVgµü@pO�ec�dZf���ZpÒ~�qLprp¦ü@c��ZdZfhgIq��|c�~PÇ ¤ ]Fñ ¥ `����ZgÀ��suv½�»suv_s\üh}\pÓ~�q�c�néñ»�

5 GuF §�¨7KM¬À]�­�N:OQâ�W$a��sÇýe�hq�p(^V��vD�ZcÀ��vÍ�ZgIqL�LsugI}"ncyfypO}uv½ýepOdhprq�gI�Lprf!gÀ�ovLpO�epOq�gI}"sÇ�Lprq�gI�Ls\c�dZv,]AzhlU�hl�/hlZg�dZfÐ^r�%`Ífy�hq�sÇdhý(gq��hd'cI~���hpµ�h}\g�dhdhprqc�dÐv_s\nµ�Z}\gI�Lprf9fhgÀ��ghl+gIdUf���Zp*�ZgI��9~�c�}\}ÇcÀ�bprf�ü»�'���hp*q�c�ü@cI�V�����hp�}\g5�ec��y�oncyfypr}Ñ�bgevÓtOc�n�h}\p��LpVfTs\dþ^V�|sÇ�LpOq�gÀ��sÇcedZvr�2bprtrgI�ZvLp(�ZgÀ���Y}ÇprdhýI���âs\v���gIÿepOdYs\de��cTg�trt�c��Zde��s\dY��Zp|ý�c»cyfydhpVvLv¦~��hdUt��Ls\c�dÈl����hp|q�c�ü@cI�,~��h}\}\�Ôp-�»�Z}ÇceqLpVv¦��hp|ü@cI�L�LcenU�q�sÇý��e�¦t�c�q�q�s\fyceq�ü@p�~�c�q�pµncÀ�»s\dhý(�Lc���hp*}ÇpO~��ÒtOc�q�qLsufyceqr����sÇýe�hq�p�^�/�vD�hcÀ��vÓgIdhc���hprqÓvLpOq�sÇpVv�c�~;v_dZg��Zv�hcI��v½~�c�qo��hpv�gInppOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%�rl7���hp|vLg�np*s\dhsÇ�LsugI}E�@cevLs���sÇced+l+üh�h�ÒýeqLpVgÀ��pOqw� ����� gIdUf.s"�a���hpncI��sÇcedÐv_�Lq�gÀ��pOý��'suv,v_s\n�h}\pOqVl+qLp��%�hsÇq�s\dhýc�dZ}Ç�'�µsÇ�Lprq�gI�Ls\c�dZvr�

c ~Cý*�+õPz3÷ ± öÑúU¸�û�õPz�úbõFù'ö=z u ô'øedÁü'ø®z�öEû�÷ zoô�õP�

���hp�n(gI�6�®üh�hs\}\fhsÇdhý�qLceüUc��¦vL�yv���pOn �Íg�v�s\n�h}\pOnpOd%�LpVf9ced9g«0oc�n(g�fhs\t�»�h�@pOq��yt�ce�y�Ó���ZpOpO}\prf9�h}ugÀ�_~�ceqLn'�"���hp�qLceüUc���Íg�v�p��%�hs\�h�@prf��½s����(gÓ}ug�vLpOqFq�gIdhýepbvLpOdUv_ceq�~�q�c�nñ�»s\t�ÿ��Ó�y�Lsut���ïE}\prt��Lq�c�dhsutÓ]F��sÇýe�hqLpVv,�y]IEy`Fg�dZf*�U]IEy`_`������Zp�v_prdZv_ceqF�Zv_pVvFg

Page 18: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]FE»` ]FGO`

]IHr` ]FJ%`

��sÇýe�hqLp^�/Q�=ï=�hgIn�h}\p��*cI~�ncyfypr}Èt�cedZv���qL�Ut��Ls\c�d!s\d'vLs\nµ�h}ugÀ��sÇced+�

�Ls\np��®cI~?�N Zs\ý�%�E�LpVt��hdhs+�%�hp½�Lcµn�pVg�vL�hq�p�fys\v_��g�dZt�pVvO�=���hpoqLceüUc���B vÑc�d6�®ü@cegIq�f��hq�c»tOprv�v_ceq�] ) prde��sÇ�Zn �����,�T�VfÒ`Eget-�%�hs\qLpVvg�/ez��®�UcesÇd%�,^rxez��¾fypOý�vLtrgId!sÇd��e�*n(vÍ���hqLce�hý�'g(�»prg�f+pr��pO}È��z�z�gÒüZv ) {Ø8�vLpOq�s\g�}+tOgIq�f"�Ñmb��prget��!vLpOdUv_s\dhý}ÇcytrgÀ�Ls\c�dÈlhg�/ez��¾fypOý*�»sÇpr� suvÍc�üy��gIs\dhprf!ü»�(��gIÿ»sÇdZý��(v�tOg�dZv,]I��s\ý��hq�p^V��`�����hp!c�d6�®ü@cegIq�f �ZqLcyt�pVvLvLc�q*s\v(tOc�dhdZprt���prf �LcÐ��hp'}\cytOgI}��¾gIq�prgTdZp����bc�q�ÿÐ�»sugÐ�Ð��üUv*q�g�fhsÇc�YïE��hprqLdhpO�r� ���Zp!092b�

�h}ugIdhdZpOq,gIdZf9��Zp(dZg5�»sÇý%gÀ�Ls\c�d9n�cedhsÇ�Lc�qÒq��hdÐc$#[�Pü@ceg�q�f9sÇdYg ) pOd%�Ls\�hn�8D8¦�%��z��Ta3%|kopr}Ç}EtOc�n�h�y��pOqV�h���ZpvLcI~����ÍgIq�p�Íg�vÍ�½q�s��L�LpOd!s\dT{��-� gIdZf��ZvLprv½ýepOcen�pO�Lq�s\to~��hdZt��Ls\c�dZv½~�qLcen���hp�f¢ï;k�m��®�Z� x*}\sÇühq�gIq��.�Ç^�/��®�

h%GIH J;)as_`Nb¬ ¾QZw©Eø$T�_�N�©�_`â$Z\N���hp!v_c�~����bg�qLp�tOc�dZvLsuv���vµc�~ov_pr��pOq�gI};n�cyfy�Z}ÇpVv*p-�yprt��h�Ls\dhýÔvL�UpVt�sugI}\s�%rprfY~��ZdZt���sÇcedZvOl�t�c�nn*�hdhsutOgÀ��sÇdZýT�½s����þpVg�t�� c���hprq��ZqLce�hý�'�o{ ) j�8 ) vLc»t�ÿep��½t�cedhdhprt��Ls\c�dZvÍ�ZdZfypOq�gtO}Çs\pOd%��jIv_prqL�epOqb�hq�cI�LcytOc�}P�����hpVv_pÒncyfy�h}\prv½g�qLpÒvD�ZcÀ�½d�s\d'��s\ý��hq�p^��y�

m � <I]�· R Z�A R \�l R Z-l�Ö�Z�l9�ZgIdZfh}ÇpVv¦tOc�nnµ�Zdhs\trgÀ��sÇcedZv¦�½s����9���hp�yprgfÈpO�epO}ÑtOg�q�f"�"8®��g�}Ç}\cÀ��vÓtO}Çs\pOd%��vo��c!gevLvL�hnp*��ZgI���ZpO��g�qLpÒt�cedhdhpVt��Ls\dhý��cgfypr�»s\tOp,qLpVv_prnµüh}\sÇdZý�g�d�sufyprg�}ÈvLpOdZvLc�qV�����Zp�v_prqL�epOqÍc$#7pOq�v���hpÒ~�ce}Ç}\cÀ�½sÇdZýtrgI�Zg�ühs\}ÇsÇ�Ls\prv���;t��hces\tOpÒg�nc�dhý�v_�@pOpVf�ncyfypVv-�½^elZ�ylhgIdUf!�ez*v�tOg�dZv�jÀvLprtIl�EüZgI��t����Lq�gIdZvLns\v�v_s\c�d�cI~Fnµ�h}Ç�Ls\�h}\p�vLtrgIdZvÍced�q�p��%�hpVv��Vl�;v�tOgId'g5��prq�g�ý�s\dhý��ZvLs\dhý��hp�vLpOdUv_ceq�B vbc�d6�®üUc%gIq�f|pr}ÇpVt��Lq�c�dZs\trvOl�Ec��@pOq�gÀ��sÇced�s\d�t�c�d%��sÇd»�hce�ZvÍnc»fhp�l�Eq�prgI}��P�Ls\n�pÒ�@c�}\�»}Çs\dhp;Mh�_��sÇdZý(�½s������h� ���®tOn pOq�q�c�qÍüUce�hdZf"�

�»s\dZt�pÓ��ZpÓ�@c�}\�»}Çs\dhp9Mh�_��sÇdhý*�LpVt��hdhs+�%�hpÓsuv;~�g�v_�bprdhc��hý��(�Lc�ü@pÓ�@pOqL~�c�q�nprf(s\d�q�prg�}h��sÇnpÒ�hdZfyprqbg�d»�vL�@pOprf�nc»fhp�lysÇ�suvÍpOnµü@prfZfyprf's\d%�Lc���hp�vLpOq���prq�B vbt�cyfyp��,���Zs\v½q�prfh�Zt�pVvb��hp�g�n�ce�hd%�½cI~�fZgÀ��g*��q�g�dZv_nsÇ�_��prf��Lc���hp,t�}\sÇprde��vO�

mËA¯X�Ö�<We�X$>F<I\$A®Sa\�AO<?>Y\$l�gI}\}ÇcÀ��vog�Zv_prq���c�v_�Z�UprqL�»suv_pÒ���hpµp-�»�Z}Çceq�gI�Ls\c�d!�hqLcytOprv�vO�����hp��ZvLpOqÓn(g5�*�%�hpOq��|���hpU092b�ncyfy�h}\pÓ~�ceqb��hpÒdhp-�%�Í�@cevLs���sÇced!g�dZfOj5ceqE���hpÒn�c%v��½q�prtOpOd%�bprd»�%s\q�c�dhnpOd%�bn�cyfypr}Alyceq½v_pr}ÇpVt��b��hpÒdhp-�%�½vLpOdZvLsÇdZý*�@cevLs���sÇcedn(gId»�Zg�}Ç}\���«���Zp|�ZvLpOq,n(g5�Ôg�}\vLc!�LpO}\pOce�Uprq�gI�Lp���hp(qLceüUc���sÇdâtOc�d%�Ls\d»�hc��Zv�n�cyfypel�q�prtOpOs\�»sÇdhý�v�tOg�dÔ�h�7fhgI�LprvµpO�epOq��9zh�\^vLprtI�Ø���hp,dZg5�»sÇý%gÀ��sÇced�ncyfy�h}\p,s\v�g�}\vLcqLpVv_�@c�dUv_s\üh}\pÓ~�ceqogI}\s\ý�dhs\dhýdhpO� fhgI��g�½sÇ��!��hpµ�hqLpr�»sÇce�Zvbn�cyfypr}A�����hp,ncyfy�h}\p

Page 19: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

��sÇýe�hq�p�^��§�P8¾d%�Lprq�get��Ls\c�d!gInc�dZý*���hp,ncyfy�h}\prv½c�~È��Zp,dhp��»�D�®ü@prv_�D�®�%s\pO� v_�yv_�Lprn!�

MZq�v����hqLp-�®g�}Çs\ý�dUvFdhpO� fhgI��g,�ZvLs\dhý,��Zp�qLceüUc���B vÑcyfyc�npO�Lq���leg�dZfsÇ�bgÀ~���pOq��bg�q�fZvFsÇd»��ceÿ�pVv���hpÓn�cyfypr}Zn(gÀ��t��hs\dhýÒ~��hdZt��Ls\c�d+����hp�tOc�n�h�y��prf��Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�n suv½v_prde�½��c���hp�092���ncyfy�h}\p,�½sÇ��'prget���dhpr� v�tOg�d+���sÇdUgI}\}Ç�elhgId�ù�úcû Sm\�`�T6V�ZÍtOc�n�h�y��prvb���hpÒdhp��»�½�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d!ý�s\��prd|���hp,t��hq�qLprd%�bncyfypO}"c�~È���hpÒ��ceqL}uf"�P���hpÒn�cyfypr}"s\v

�h�7fhgÀ��prf!pO�epOq���Ls\npµg�dhpO� vLtrgId!s\v½q�prtOpOs\��pVf"�

h%Gut i�KMUVUâ7_õv[VUW�aB_`Zwâ�©�_\T�VUWÿöåT�_`øY_\ø)N:OQV80�Vn_\TI©:J=)aB_`Nb¬��sÇýe�hq�p9^rx9vD�hcÀ��v�g9vLp��%�hprdZt�p�cI~��Zg�q_��s\g�}�}ug5��ce�y��vµüh�hs\}��ü»�Ð��hp!n(gI�6�®üh�hs\}\fhsÇdhýÐq�c�ü@cI�*vL�yv���pOn s\d c��hq�}ugIü@c�q�gÀ�LceqL�e����hp�q�c�ü@cI��suv�s\dhsÇ�LsugI}\}Ç�'�h}ug�tOprf!s\d9gnprv�v_�!c$ |t�p,�½sÇ��9ng�d»��vLng�}Ç}�c�üZv_��get�}\prv�]At��ZgIs\qog�dZf!��g�üh}Çpµ}ÇprýevrlUgIdUf!trgIüh}\prv�`�����hp�v_prdZv_ceqo�Zg�q�g�np��Lprq�vÓgIq�p��������;ôÂ���Iz�t�n gIdZf�s»ô xe�|fhpOýZ�;���hpµ�@c�}\�»}Çs\dhpVvop-�%��q�get���prfTgI�o��Zs\vÓsÇdZs���s\g�}�}\cytOgI�Ls\c�dgIq�p'vD�hcÀ�½d sÇd ]IEy`�l�gIdUf ���hp�vLgI~�p�q�pOýesÇced s\v(fhs\vL�h}ug5��prfþsÇd ]FGO`*g�}Çcedhý9�½sÇ�� ��Zp!dZp��»�|v_prdZv_s\dhýÐ�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�d×t�cen�h�y�LpVfü»�Ð��hp!032b� �h}\g�dhdhprqr�n���hp'vLgI~�p�q�pOý�s\c�dâsuv�üUce�hdZfypVf ü»�Yn(gId»�Ð~�qLprp�prfhý�prvµ~�c�q�nsÇdZýÔvL�hsÇÿeprvrlFüh�y���hp!tOg�dZfysufhgÀ��ppO�Àg�}Ç�ZgI�Ls\c�d9~��hdZt���sÇcedÐg��y�Lcen(gÀ�LsutOg�}Ç}\��fyp���prt���v¦��UgÀ�,}ÇsÇ�_��}Çp(gefhfysÇ�Ls\c�dZg�}FvL�Zget�ptOgIdÔüUp(vLpOprdT��ZqLce�hý�Ðv_�Zt��9~�qLprpprfyýeprvr�{�c�dUv_p��e�ZpOd%�L}\��lÈ��hp«092b� �h}ugIdhdhprq�q�pO}\s\g�üh}Ç�Ðv_pr}ÇpVt���vÒ��hp�dhp��»�*vLpOdZvLs\dhý��Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�dYdhpVgIq,���hp|p-�»sÇ�µfyc»c�qµcI~b��hp|c |t�p����sÇýe�hq�prvb]IHO`���]FK5`�v�hcÀ�Y��hpÍv�gÀ~�pbqLprý�s\c�d�gÀ~���pOq���Zp�q�c�ü@cI���Zg�v�q�prg�t��Zprf¦��ZpbvLprtOc�dZf"l5~�ce�hqL��*g�dZf�vLsW�»���*vLpOdZvLsÇdZýo�@cevLs���sÇcedZvOlq�prvL�UpVt��Ls\��pr}Ç�e��mb�Ó���ZgÀ��v_��g�ý�p�l@���hp*}ug5��ce�y�¦tOc�dZvLsuv���voc�~E��hps\dhsÇ�LsugI}Fc$ |t�pel+g�vLprtOc�dZfTc$ |t�p']�s\dZt�cen�h}ÇpO�Lpr}Ç��n(gI�Z�UpVfZ`�lgIdUf|���bc�UprqL�@pOdZfhs\tO�h}\g�qot�ceqLq�sufyc�q�vO�

m }Çcedhý�prq½qL�Zd�suv�v�hcÀ�½d�s\d»��sÇýe�hqLp^V�hl»���hpOq�p¦��hp,q�c�ü@cI�½n(gI�Z�UpVf!g(vLprt��Ls\c�d!cI~���hp�i½ceüUc��LsutOv�f�gIü+�hgI�o�%��g�dy~�c�q�f��dZsÇ�epOq�v_sÇ�����h���hphMZq�v_��/�sÇ�Lprq�gI�Ls\c�dZv,g�qLpv�hcÀ�½d9s\d�]FEy`��(mb�Ò��hsuvÒ�UcesÇd%�Ò��Zp(p��yprtO�y�LpVfÔv_�Lq�gÀ��pOý��'q�prvLpOn*üh}ÇpVvÓ��hpc�dZpv�hcÀ�½dTs\d.��sÇýe�hqLp�^rx|fh�hpµ��c�vLsÇns\}\g�qÓs\dhsÇ�LsugI}Ft�cedZfysÇ�Ls\c�dZvr�¦mb�Ó��hpt�ceqLq�sufyc�q�s\d%�Lprq�vLprt��Ls\c�d+l[�hcÀ�bpO��prqrlZ��hp�q�c�ü@cI�o~�get�pVvnc�q�pµt��hces\tOprvÍ���ZgId�s\d���Zpµ�hq�pO�»s\c��Zv½p-�hgIn�h}\p�üUpVtOg��Zv_p*gId�c$ |tOpµfyc»c�qÓs\voc��@pOd+�30opO�epOqL��hpr}ÇpVvLvrly��Zpµ�h}ugIdhdZpOqoce�y�LpVf�Lc(tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hpÒn�cÀ�»s\dhýgI}\c�dhý(gt�ceqLq�s\fhc�qVl%g�}Ç}7���hp,�bg5�(s\d%�Lc���Zp,cI��ZpOq��Zg�}Ç}E]NG�`�� ð }ug�v�vÍs\vb��q�g�dZvL�ZgIq�pOd%�b�Lc���hp�vLpOdUv_ceq�B v}ug�vLpOqVlUvLc��hp*qLceüUc���~�gIs\}ÇpVf!�Lc�fhp��LpVt��Ó��hp*ý�}ug�v�v�fyc»c�q�s\dZfysutOgI�LpVf'sÇdþ]NG�`���mb�Ó��hsuvÓ�UcesÇd%�rlU��Zp�c��@pOq�gÀ��c�q�cÀ�epOq�qLcyfyp¦��ZpfypVt�suv_s\c�dcI~@��Zp3032b�)�h}ugIdZdhpOqVlI���hc,s\d%�LpOq��hq�p���prf*��hpo�%sut�s\dhsÇ���µc�~U���hp�ý�}ug�v�vÑfyc»c�qEgevF��Zp½��hq�prv�hce}\f*cI~+gId�hdZp��y�h}\c�q�prfc��@pOd gIq�prgh����s\dZgI}\}\��lÑs\d ]IHO`�lÑ��Zp�q�c�ü@cI�µncÀ��pVfâfycÀ�½dY��Zp!vLprtOc�dZfn�Zg�}Ç}b�hd%�Ls\}bs���qLpVg�t��hpVfÐ��hp�}\g�üLB v*}\c��hdhýep��.���Zp�h}ugIdhdZpOq�fypVt�sufyprf���ZpOd!�Lc(vLpOdZf���Zp,qLceüUc��b��cp��y�h}\c�q�pÓ���hsuv½dhpO�½}\��fypO�LpVt��LpVf!c��@pOd�gIq�prgZ���sÇýe�hq�p���zâvD�ZcÀ��v(gI}\}½��hp�ceüZvLpOq���prf �@c�}\�%}\s\dhprv|gI~��Lprq(��hp9qLceüUc��(tOc�n�h}\p���prf×gât�s\q�tO�hsÇ��gIq�c��hdZf ���hp�}\g�ü+�å���Zp

�@c�}\�%}\s\dhprv¦vD�ZcÀ�½d�sÇdT}\s\ý�%�¦tOc�}\c�qµ]�qLpVfZ`½�bpOq�pµtOg��y�L�ZqLpVfTgÀ�Ó��hp*}\gev��¦}ÇcytOgI�Ls\c�d+l7gIdUf!��hpgIq�prgs\dZvLs\fypµ��hpt�s\q�t�}\p�s\vo��Zpq�gIdhýep(cI~Í��hp�}\gev���vLtrgId+��0ocI�Lp|��hp«MZdZgI}�ns\vLn(gÀ��t��È�����hs\v*fysuvLtOqLpr�ZgIdZtO�Ðg��h�@prgIq�v,ü@prtrgI�ZvLp|n(gÀ��t��hsÇdZý'�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�n(vgIq�p�t�cen�h�y�LpVfnV�\�]�X$V?V^¸,��c�gI}\sÇýed!��hp�t��hq�qLprd%���%s\pO�çà;ó�]Iñ�¥I`Í�½sÇ������hpµtO�hqLq�pOd%���hsuv_�Lc�q��*à�¤I]Fñ1¥ = ÿO`��)�ÓdUt�pµg���q�g�dZv�~�ceqLnsuvµt�cen�h�y�LpVf"lFs��*s\vµdhpO�epOq�q�pO�»suv_pVf"�'���Zp|ns\vLn(gÀ��t��YcytOtO�hq�v�fy�hp��Lc'��Zp�}ug�t�ÿ9c�~�g'ý�}\c�üZg�}Ec��y��sÇns4%rgI�Ls\c�dÐ~��hdZt��Ls\c�d+�m�}Ç��Zc��hý������hsuv½s\vÍdZcI�og*~�gIs\}Ç�ZqLpÒcI~Fc��Zq�092b��n�pO��hcyf"lUs���suv½g�}Çs\ns���gÀ��sÇced!c�~�ce�hq�t��ZqLq�pOd%�ÍsÇn�h}\pOnpOd%��gÀ�Ls\c�dÈ�

Page 20: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

]IEy` ]FGO`

]FJ%`

]FHO` ]IKÀ`

��s\ý��hq�p^rxQ�=ï,�»�@pOq�s\n�prd%��vÍ�ZvLsÇdZý*���hp,s\de��pOýeq�gI�Lprf�qLceüUc��LsutÒv_�yv_�LpOn'�

Page 21: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

10 mts0

after 6 iterationsAO position

Open door

Glass door

(a)

(b)

(c)

Next−best view

��sÇýe�hq�p*^V�Q�Fm q��hd�g�qLce�hdZf���hp,i½c�ü@cI��s\trv�fÈgIüÈ�»gI�½�»��gIdh~�c�q�f|��dhs\��prq�vLsÇ���T] ð gÀ��prv�2b�hs\}\fys\dhýUl%�½s\dhý!^��¾mÓ`��7]FEy`E���hp¦ng��üh�hs\}Ç�bgÀ~���pOq�/,sÇ�LpOq�gÀ��sÇcedZvP� fy�hpo�Lc*vLs\n�s\}ugIq;s\dhsÇ�LsugI}@t�c�dUfys���sÇcedZvrl����hpÓv_�Lq�gÀ��pOý��gÀ�;��hsuv;�@c�s\d%��q�prvLpOn*üh}ÇpVvF��UgÀ��cedhp½~�q�c�n��sÇýe�hq�p�^Vxhw+]NG�`���hpÒq�c�ü@cI�½ncÀ��pVf��h�'s\d%�Lc(gv_pVt�c�dUf«�Zg�}Ç}PlZgI~��LpOqÍ���hp,�ZvLpOq½cÀ�epOq�qLcyfyp¦g*�Z}\g�d���c(n�cÀ�epo��cÀ�bg�q�f�g�ý�}ug�v�vfyc»c�qVw�]FHO`Í���hpµq�c�ü@cI��n(g��Zv½���hp*vLprtOc�dZf!�Zg�}Ç}��hd%�Ls\}�sÇ�oq�prget��hprf'gId�ce�Uprd9gIq�prgZlh���hsut��'��hp*qLceüUc��ÓfypVt�sufyprf!��c|p��y�h}\c�q�pdhp-�%�V�

Page 22: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

��sÇýe�hq�p¦�Iz��n�ÓüUv_prqL�eprf�@c�}\�%}\s\dhprvbgÀ~���pOq���hp¦qLceüUc��(�Zgev�tOc�n�h}\p��LpVf�g��Lc��Zqbg�qLce�hdZf���Zp¦i½ceüUc��LsutOv�fÈg�ü+�=���hpo�@c�}\�»}Çs\dhprvv�hcÀ�½d(sÇd(}\s\ý�%��t�ce}ÇceqE�bpOq�potOg��y�L�hq�prf�s\d(��Zpo}ug�v_�;}ÇcytrgÀ�Ls\c�dÈ�����hpoqLprý�s\c�dsÇdUv_sufyp����hpotOsÇq�t�}\pov�hcÀ��vF��Zp�MZdZg�}Znsuv_n(gÀ��t����UgÀ��q�prvL�h}���vb~�qLcen q�pO}\�%s\dhýp��htO}Ç�ZvLs\��pO}\�(c�d'}\cytOgI}"n(gI��t��hpVvO�

j ��z3��ù ú õ�� u ô'øk�þû-÷ û�õ u õÑû�÷�ô!�

���hpTp-�y�UprqLs\npOd%��v(�½sÇ��×���hp9q�c�ü@cI��vL�yv���pOn'lÍüUc��� s\d)v_s\nµ�Z}\gI�Lprf g�dZf�qLpVgI}�prd»�%s\q�c�dhnpOd%��vOl½v�hcÀ� ���ZgÀ����hp.092b��h}ugIdhdZpOqÒtOgIdÐt�cedZv_sufyprq�g�üh}Ç�!q�prfy�ZtOp����hp*d»�hn*üUprqÒcI~;ncI��sÇcedZv¦gIdZfTvLpOdUv_s\dhý!c��@pOq�gÀ�Ls\c�dUv�q�p��%�hs\qLpVf'~�c�q¦n(gI�9üZ�hsÇ}ufys\dhýZ����hsuv�tO}\g�sÇn suv!fysW |tO�h}��!�Lc&�%�ZgId%�LsÇ~���l¦g�v�s��'qLp��%�hsÇq�prv�cI~µnceqLpTp-�»�LpOdUv_s\��pÐt�c�n�Zg�qLsuvLc�dZv(ü@p����bpOprd ce�hq��h}ugIdUv�g�dZfv_�Lq�gÀ�Lprý�s\prv��hq�c»fh�Zt�pVf�ü»�(cI���hpOqÍnprg�dZvÒ]�pe� ýU�Çl»��q�g�sÇdhpVfC�»�hn(gId!c��@pOq�gÀ��c�q�v�`��n�Ó�Zqbp-�y�UprqLs\npOd%��vrl§�hcÀ��pr��prqrl5�Zg5��pÒvLcµ~�g�qv�hcÀ�½d9���ZgÀ�Ò���hp(�h}ugIdhdhprqÒ�hqLcyfy�Ut�prv,v_�Lq�gÀ��pOýesÇpVvo���ZgÀ��trgIdhdhc��,üUp(pVg�vLsÇ}\��üUp(ce�y�D�¾fycedhpü%�Ôg«�»�hn(gIdYce�Uprq�gI�Lc�qV���Ó�ZqvL�»v_�Lprn g�}\vLc�fypOnc�dUv���q�gI�Lprv¦���ZgÀ���@c�}\�»ý�cedZgI}Ñn(gI�Uv,gIq�p*~�pVg�vLsÇüZ}Çp(q�pO�hq�prvLpOd%��gÀ�Ls\c�dUvo~�ceq�s\dZfyc»c�q,n(gI�Q�Püh�ZsÇ}ufys\dhý'��gev_ÿyvr�mov�s����Íg�vÍgIq�ý��Zprf�sÇdT�»pVt��Ls\c�d��yly�@c�}\�»ý�cedZgI}"ncyfypO}uvÍc$#7pOq�vLs\ý�dhs�MUtOg�d%�½gefy�ÀgId%��g�ý�pVv�cÀ�epOqÍcI���hpOq½q�pO�ZqLpVv_prde��gÀ��sÇcedZvO����hp'ncev_�|c�ü»�»sÇce�Zv�}Çs\ns���gÀ��sÇced�c�~Óce�hq(n(gI�6�®üh�hs\}\fhsÇdhýâvL�yv���pOn suv��UgÀ�|sÇ�|c�dh}\� üh�hs\}ufhv|gYt�q�cev�v��¾vLprt���sÇced cI~¦��Zp

pOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��gI�g�MQ�yprf��ZpOs\ý�%�r�1���hprqLpO~�c�q�p�lÑs\n��@c�qL��g�d%��ceüZv���g�tO}ÇpVv�n(g5�YdhcI�üUp'vLpOdZvLprf"�å�ÓdZp��Íg5�Ô��c9s\n�hqLcÀ�epvLpOdZvLsÇdZý(s\vÍ��c(pOnsÇ�o}\gev_prq½q�g5�yv½gI��nµ�h}Ç�Ls\�h}\p��hpOs\ý�%��vO�����hp,�LpVt��hdhs+�%�hprv�fhprv�t�q�sÇü@prf!s\d'��hsuv�gIqL�Lsut�}\p,�bc��h}uf'v���sÇ}\}Èq�pOn(gIs\dgI�Z�h}ÇsutOg�üh}\p¦�½sÇ��Zc��y�ovLsÇýedhs�MUtOg�de��t��Zg�dhý�pVvO�

m nc�q�p�~��hdZfhg�n�prd%��gI}�}Çs\ns���gÀ��sÇcedÐsuvÒ���hp(}\get�ÿ9c�~bprqLq�c�q�Pq�prtOcÀ��prqL�!tOgI�UgIühs\}ÇsÇ�Ls\prvr��mod%�Ðv_prqLs\c��UvÓprqLq�c�q,s\dY�Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdZpp��»��q�get��Ls\c�d�ceq¦fh�hqLs\dhý|s\n(gIýep*gI}\s\ý�dhnpOd%�ÒtOgId�q�prvL�h}Ç�Ós\dÔg�t�c�n�h}\p���pO}\�'�hdZg�trt�pr�y��g�üh}Çpµn�cyfypr}A�w�hceqo���ZgÀ�¦qLpVg�vLc�d+lU��ZpcÀ��prq�g�}Ç}��hq�cI��cI���»�Up(fypVv_s\ý�dÐsuvÒ��pOq��Tt�cedZvLpOq��5gI�Ls\��pe�U�hceq,sÇdUv���gIdZtOp�l+c�~��LpOdYn(gId»�T�@c�s\d%��v,fypr}Çs\��prqLpVfTü»�����hp|v_prdZvLc�q,gIq�pfysuvLtrgIq�fyprfÐ��cÔg5�ec�sufÔýepOdhprq�gI�Ls\dhýTs\dZt�ceqLq�prt����Uce}Ç�»}\sÇdZprvr�i���hsuvµn(g5�Ð}ÇpVg�fY���hp�q�c�ü@cI�µ�LcÔvLpOdUv_p(���hp'vLg�n�p��ZgIqL�µcI~og�dpOd»�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��v_pr��pOq�gI}@��sÇnprvrlQ�hprdZt�p,�ZqLcyfy�ZtOsÇdZý|g*}\c�dZý�pOq½nc��Ls\c�d'�ZgÀ���+�;��ceqLprcÀ��prqrle��hp,s\n(gIýep��¾gI}\sÇýedhnpOd%�Í~��hdZt���sÇcedgI}\�Íg5�»vbq��hdZvÍ�hdUfypOq½�ZvLpOq�vL�h�@pOq��»s\vLsÇced���c(g5��pOqL��v_prqLs\c��Uv�q�pOýes\v_�Lq�gÀ��sÇced�prqLq�c�q�vO�

�TgI��t��hs\dhýÐ�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�n(vgIq�p'tOc�n�h�y��prf�}\c»trgI}\}Ç� �Lc gI}\s\ý�d ��hpTýe}ÇceüZgI}ÍncyfypO}o�½s����×��hp�}\cytOgI}½ncyfypr}�ý�prdhpOq�gÀ��prfgÀ����hp'qLceüUc���B v�tO�hq�qLprde�(}\cytOgÀ��sÇced+�Q�ÓdUt�p�gT��q�g�dZv_~�c�q�ná�Zg�vü@pOprd�tOc�n�h�y��prf"lbs��(suvdhpO�epOqq�pO�»s\vLprf+�d���hsuvm�Zg�vsÇ��vfysuvLgefy�ÀgId%��g�ý�pVvO�'8¾dþt�ceqLq�sufyc�q�vÒüUce�hdZfypVfYü»�Ð�UgIq�gI}\}Çpr}Ñ~�prgI�L�hq�pO}\prv�v,�ÍgI}\}\vrl�}\s\dhp�n(gÀ��t��hs\dhýTc�dZ}Ç�Yt�ceqLq�prt���v,�@cevLs���sÇcedhs\dhýpOq�q�c�q�v½sÇdT��hpfys\qLpVt��Ls\c�d9�UprqL�@pOdZfhs\tO�h}\g�qo��c|���hpµ�ÍgI}\}\vr���¦fhc�np���qL�'tOg�dTüUp*�ZvLprf"l7üh�y�Òs\n��ZqLpVt�suv_s\c�dTs\d����hp�fhsÇq�prt��Ls\c�d�Zg�q�g�}Ç}\pO}��Lc����hpb�bg�}Ç}uvÈýeqLcÀ��v+ühsÇýeý�prqÈ�½sÇ��*fhs\v_��g�dZt�pe��m �Uc%vLvLsÇüZ}Çpbv_ce}Ç�y��sÇcedÒ�LcÓ��hsuv��hqLceüh}\pOn s\vÈ�LcÓ�Lq�g�t�ÿÒvL�ZtOtOprv�v_s\��pE}\cytOg�}ncyfypO}uvµg�dZfÔ�Lq�gIdZv_~�c�q�n(gÀ�Ls\c�dUv¦�LcTprdZgIüh}\p(���hp|�@pOq�sÇcyfysutc��y��sÇns4%rgI�Ls\c�dâcI~�g'ýe}ÇceüZgI}En(gI��t��hs\dhýTt�q�sÇ�LpOq�s\c�d+l�prvL�UpVt�sugI}\}Ç�gÀ~���pOqÓ��hp�q�c�ü@cI�9�Ug�v¦t�c�n�h}\p���prfÔg|}\c�dhý�}Çc»c��ÔgIq�c��hdZf9g|üh�hs\}ufysÇdZýZ�"���hsuv¦tOc��h}uf�ü@p�get��hs\pO��pVf�ü»��g�fhg��y�Ls\dhý�vLc�np*cI~��Zp�}\cytOg�}Çs4%rgI�Ls\c�dT��prt��hdZs4�%�hpVvÒqLpVt�pOd%��}Ç���hq�c��@cevLprf9sÇdÐ���hp|�6fÈmÓ� }\s���pOq�gÀ���hqLp»� /ylÑ^O�$�P�a�hceqÒ}\g�qLýep*prd%�»s\qLcedhnpOd%��v¦vL�Zt��ý�}\c�üUgI}yc��h�Ls\n�s4%rgI�Ls\c�d(�½s\}Ç}Z�hqLcyfy�Ut�p½nc�q�p½�hq�prt�suvLp½}\g5�ec��y��vOl�g�dZfv_ce}Ç�epÍn�suvLngI��t��hpVvÑ}\sÇÿepÍ��hp�cedhp�v�hcÀ�½dsÇdC��s\ý��hq�po�IzZ���sÇdUgI}\}Ç�elÍ��hpÐt��hq�qLprd%��v_�yv_�Lprn v�hc��Z}\fê�Zg�dZfy}\p9n*�h}���sÇ�Z}ÇpÔqLceüUc���v(�½sÇ�� qLpr}\gI�Ls\��pO}\�þns\dhc�q!t��ZgIdZý�prvr�ç8®~µgY�LpVgIn

t�cen�Uc%v_pVf�c�~8l qLceüUc���v½suvog5�ÀgIs\}ugIüh}\p�lZg�dZf!��ZpOs\qoq�pO}ugÀ�Ls\��p,�@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�dZv�g�qLp,ÿ»dhcÀ�½dÈlUg|vLsÇdZý�}\p,n�cyfypr}�trgId�ü@p�ý�prdhpOq�gÀ��prf~�q�c�n g�}Ç}@��Zp�tOgI�h�L�hq�prf�vLtrgIdZvr�Ñm�t�pOd%��q�g�}¯092b� �Z}\g�dhdhpOqÍ���hpOd't�cen�h�y�LpVvb��hp,vLp���c�~Tl �@cevLsÇ�Ls\c�dZvb���ZgÀ��v_��gÀ��sÇcedZvb��Zp

Page 23: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

�LpVgIn ~�c�q½���hpµgIýeý�q�pOý%gÀ�LpVf(dhp-�%��Pü@prv_�o�»s\pO�,��aocÀ��pr��prqrl»���hprd'��hp�q�pO}ugÀ��sÇ�epÒ�Uc%v_sÇ�Ls\c�dZv�cI~���hp�q�c�ü@cI��v½gIq�pÒdhcI�oÿ»dhcÀ�½dÈl��Zp��hq�c�üh}\pOn ü@prtOc�nprv*t�c�dUv_sufypOq�gIüZ}Ç�Ðnc�q�p�fys� (tO�h}Ç�r�.8¾dþ��hsuv�tOg�vLp�l����hp�q�c�ü@cI��vµg�t��*s\dZfypr�UprdZfypOd%��}Ç� ]�fhs\v_�Lq�sÇüZ�y�LpVf�h}ugIdhdZsÇdhý»`�l@gIdZf!�@pOq��ZgI�Zvot�c�nn*�hdhsutOgÀ��p,c�dh}\��vL�@c�q�g�fysutOg�}Ç}\�������hpÒ�LpVt��hdhs+�e�Zprv½�hq�prvLpOd%��prf!sÇd'���hsuvogIqL�Lsut�}\p"�Zg5�epÓ��c|ü@pq�pO�»s\vLprf!gIdUf�p-�%��pOdZfhprf!sÇd'ceq�fyprqb�Lc|t�cÀ�epOq���hsuv�trg�vLp��髦nmL���poa�I�§£¢¬����§�¯���sü ���hs\v|��ceqLÿâ�Íg�v�~��hdUfyprf×ü»�þk�mÓi ) m;jIm�q�nµ��t�c�d%��q�get��(k�mom9ï;z5���®�ex���fÈz%���»lEmÓi)� �T�Ói�8ý�q�gId%�ok�mÓmoaÓzI�$�¾�/$��^-�®zez5�yl§0¦�6��ý�q�gId%��8D8_�§�®��/h^r��/e�e�ylhgIdUf�g(ý�sÇ~���~�q�c�n a�c�dUfhg|i�j,k*l@monpOq�s\trg�vr��oÐp*g�}\vLc(�½suvD�'��c��UgIdhÿnfE� ð �ZsÇüZgevOlP�Ò� �â�����Zq�g�}ÇsbgIdZfYi,�����hq�qLs\p���ghlÈ���ZcevLp�t�cede��qLs\üh�y��sÇcedZvÒpOdZqLsut��hprfÔ���hp�sufyprgev,�hq�prvLpOd%�LpVfÐsÇdY���hs\vgIqL�Lsut�}\p�lhg�dZf'�7�Nq;gIc(g�dZf!ï��h�Tg�c*~�ceqÍ��hprsÇq�gevLvLsuv���gIdZtOpÒfh�hqLs\dhý���Zp,sÇn�h}\pOnpOd%��gÀ�Ls\c�d!cI~���Zp,qLceüUc��½vL�yv���pOn'�

��z�|$zoö=zoô'ú�z��

�Ç^���,U� ïo��2ÍgId%��ghlnq*�sr[�hs\pOdÈlnf*�trF��oYgIdZýZl ð �sr[�ZgIdZýZl5�â� �Ò�I�»nsÇ��+legIdZf�� � mµ�Vmoühs\fhsA�ymÆ?Ldhp��»��Pü@prv_�D�®�»sÇpr�)@�gI}\ý�ceqLsÇ��hn~�ceqÒ��hq�pOp-�®fys\npOdZvLs\c�dZg�}EvLtOpOdhpq�prt�cedZv_�Lq��Zt���sÇcedÔ�ZvLs\dhý'q�g�dhý�ps\ng�ý�pVvO�m8¾d �Nu ��ÏblÈ�ec�}\�hnp|���Ixexhl"�Zg�ý�pVvÒ�Z^rxwvy���hl^V���e�h�

� ����i,�h{Ø�ZgI�Ls\}\g�g�dZfc,U� ) �5fÈgI�Zn�cedZf"� ) c%v_sÇ�Ls\c�dq�p�~�pOq�pOdUt�s\dhýµgIdUf(t�c�dUv_suv���pOd%�;�bc�q�}\fncyfypr}Çs\dhý,~�ceq;nc�ühs\}\poq�c�ü@cI��vr�¯8¾du l�\�]�¹/�Ï,Ï(ϯ��AO>Y¹;x,\�A�k�¹(\$A�y3\�c�\$>F<I] R X�A¯`h½9T6>�\�SaX�>N<I\�AUly�ZgIýeprv¦^r�exzv@^r�e�ZlU^V��xe�h�

� ����aµ�Ñ{Ø�hc%v_pO�*gIdUfr,Z��2��Zq�fysut�ÿ7�9�»pOdUv_ceq�üZg�vLprfYnc��Ls\c�d �h}ugIdZdhsÇdZý��m���hp«�hs\pOq�gIq�t��hsutOg�}Ñý�pOdZpOq�gI}\s�%rprfÐ��ceqLcedhc�s;fhs\g$�ýeq�g�n!�;8¾d+,U� � ) �¯fÈgI�Zn�cedZf9g�dZfT�â�b�Ó�epOq�ng�q�vrlZpVfysÇ�Lc�q�vrl u l\�]�¹ Ì A[`|{»\�l· R @Q\�bª\�Ai½9V e�\$l�<?>?@6SU<I]�}Ý\$T6A[`X$>F<I\$A R\Dk!y3\c�\$>F<I] R �Zm�� g� ) p���pOq�vOl§oÐpO}\}ÇpVv_}\pO�elZ�Tmµl+^r�e�/h�

� �$�*{Ó�68��@{�cedhc�}\}\���=���hp�fypO�LpOq�nsÇdUgÀ�Ls\c�d!cI~�dhp��»��ü@prv_���»sÇpr��vO�P8¾d-�Ï,Ï(ϯ��AO>Y¹;x,\�A�k�¹,\�AJy3\�c�\$>F<I] R X�A¯`U½9T6>�\�SaX�>N<I\�AZl�Zg�ý�pVv��%�e�zv%�e�%�ylU^r��x%�y�� ����2¦��{��hq�}\prv�v�gIdZfY�â��f+pr��cÀ����m���ce}Ç�hnpO�Lq�s\tnp����hcyfÐ~�c�q�üZ�hsÇ}ufys\dhýTt�cen�h}Çp-�Ðncyfypr}\vÒ~�q�c�n q�g�dhý�ps\n(gIý�pVvO�*8¾d

u l�\�]�¹L½QxT~ � �w���8y3½ u8� lh�Zg�ý�pVvb�ez��wv»�h^5�yl%m��hýe�Zv���^V����/h�� /���aµ� �b�ÈkÓ�hq�q�g�de��Noª�»�%�Lpel��â� o�� �â� ð ��kosuv�vLg�dZg5�eg�ÿ�p�l"g�dZf ) � o�� ð s\ühü@pOdZvr�*��cÀ�ÍgIq�f9fypr�h}ÇcÀ�»npOd%�,cI~Í}ugIq�ý�p(vLtrgI}\p

vLsÇn*�h}Ç��gIdZpOc��UvÈ}\cytOgI}\suvLgI�Ls\c�dµg�dZfµn(g��µüh�hs\}ufysÇdZý]Av_}ugIn|`�v_�yv_�Lprnvr�68¾dj,U�Àa�ce}Ç}\pOq�üZg�t���gIdZf*kµ�+gÒcyfysÇ��v�t��hprÿ@lÀpVfysÇ�Lc�q�vrly9\c�\�>N<I] R y9Z R Z�X�l]�@!î}Ư@QZ�ù�<?A�>�@c��AO>Y¹ � ¸�S�bL¹\lh�ZgIýeprvÒ^�/h^\v7^�/§�»l�0opO��qEc�q�ÿ7lQ0�q*l@�Iz�zezh�h�»�hq�s\dhý�prqr�

������mµ�Pï;}�~�pVvO�â�»cedZgIq�PüUg�vLprfYq�prgI}���ceqL}ufân(gI�Z�hsÇdZýÔgIdUfâdZg5�»sÇý%gÀ��sÇced+�f��Ï,Ï,Ï��6¹;y9\c�\�>N<I] R X�A[`�½9T6>�\�SaX�>N<I\�AUlEi�m���U]��e`�� �I�e�wvy�$/%�ylU^r��x§�»�� x�� ) � o��6��s\dhd+l6f;� ïo�pg,g5�»q�gIÿ»sPls,U�Å{Ó�§fÈgI�Lc�n*üUpelyi,�y��cI���ÍgIdhsPlh{Ó�y�6�hpO}Ç�Lced+lZ�7�»�ÑpOdhÿÀgI��g�vL�hühq�gIn(g�dhs\g�d+l»gIdZf|mµ�pq;gIcU�

i�g��hsuf �Ñi�gIdZfhc�ns�%rprf��Q�ZgIq�n(g�tOc��Q�hceqLpÓs\fhpOd%�Ls�MUtOgI�Ls\c�d�~�c�q½fyq��hý�fhprvLsÇýed+�=�6¹P\�k�x,\$S�bL¹=��Z�\$SmZ->Fl�¸ÄaƯ@QZ�\$l�¸«X�A[`½�bb[VW<I]�X$>F<I\$A R lÈ^VzQ�Å�$/e�zvy�5�I�hlZ^r�e��xZ�

� ����aµ� ð cedQ%%�g�}Çp�%���2bg�dhcevrl5m���ïÑ~�q�gÀ�Vl�,U�«{Ó��f�gÀ�Lcenµü@p�l$ïo�V�Tg�cZlÀgIdUf��Ò� � �5�T�hq�g�}ÇsP� ) }\g�dhdhs\dhýoq�c�ü@cI��n�c��Ls\c�d�v���q�gI�LpOýesÇpVv~�ceq�p� |t�s\pOd%�¦n�cyfypr}�tOc�dZv_�Lq��Zt���sÇced+��8¾d-,Z�@a�ce}Ç}\pOq�üZg�t���g�dZfTk*�[gÒcyfysÇ��v�t��hpOÿ7lZpVfysÇ�Lc�q�vrl*y3\�c�\�>N<I] R y9Z R Z�X�l�]�@�îhƯ@QZù�<?A�>�@c��AO>Y¹ � ¸�S�bL¹\lh�ZgIýeprv½���%�nvy�e�e�yl�0opO��qEc�q�ÿ7lQ0�q*l@�Iz�zezh�h�»�hq�s\dhý�prqr�

�Ç^rz���aµ� ð cedQ%%�g�}Çp�%���2ÍgIdhc%vµgIdUf�,Z�«{Ó�=fÈgI�Lc�n*üUpe� ) }ugIdhdZsÇdhýÔqLceüUc��*ncI��sÇcedZv*~�c�q�q�g�dhý�p-�Ps\n(gIýep�g�t��e�Zs\vLs���sÇcedþgIdUfþgI�Q���c�n(gÀ��s\t|�efâncyfypO}Ít�cedZv���qL�Ut��Ls\c�dÈ�»8¾d u l\�]�¹�½3½9½)�Q}¢X�V?V � ¸�S�b�\ R <?T6S � Z-l�<IZ R Î$��AO>YZYelX�>�Z�` u V�X�AOA�<?A5emk�\$lm½9T6î>�\�A¯\�Sa\�T R ½(e5Z�AO>P½9l]�@§<?>�Z�]�>NT6lZ R lE�ÓqL}ugIdZfhcZl6��}ÇceqLsufhghlE�¦t��LceüUprqo�I�������|^r�e��xh�ymÓmom�8 ) q�prv�vr�

�Ç^�^���2¦�+gÒ�hs\�Uprq�vrl�i,�$�ZqLc»cen!lo�� g�fÈpOpel�gIdZf�k*� ) s\pOq�t�pe�Q���hp½v_prng�d%�LsutØ�ZsÇprq�g�q�t��»�ÒsÇdq�c�ü@cI�Ñ}\prgIq�dhs\dhýZ�68¾d�,U�e{�c�dhdhpr}Ç}g�dZf!�"�Z�Tg$�Ug�fypr�5g�d+lyprfhs���c�q�vOl�y9\c�\�> ± Z�X�l�AO<?A5e���gÒ}\�%�bpOq½mÓtOg�fhpOns\t ) �hüh}\s\v�hprq�vrl62�c%v���c�d+lh�9m�l+^V�����Z�

�Ç^V����,U� �_{Ó�QfÈgI�Lcenµü@p��8y3\�c�\$>8~.\�>N<I\�A u V�X$A�AO<?A5e��$gÒ}Ç�»�bpOq½motrg�fyprns\t ) �Züh}Çsuv�hpOq�vOlQ2bc%v���c�d+lh�Tmµl+^r�e�h^e��Ç^r����,U� ,U�§f+pOcedZgIq�f(gIdUf|a�� �b�»kÓ�hq�q�g�d%�D�Yoª�%�%��p��È��ceühs\}ÇpÓqLceüUc���}\c»trgI}\s�%VgÀ��sÇced(ü%����q�get�ÿ%s\dhý�ýepOcen�pO�Lq�s\toüUpVg�tOc�dZvr�b�Ï,Ï(Ï

ÆQlX�A R X]->F<I\$A R \�AJy3\c�\$>F<I] R X�A[`h½9T6>Y\$SmX$>F<I\$AZlO�h]��e`�� �§��/wv»��x%�ylU^r���Z^���Ç^O�$��,U� ,U� f+prc�dZg�q�fTg�dZf9aµ� ,U�Å�7� �hprfhpOqV�µm t�c�n�h�h��gÀ��sÇcedZgI}\}\��p� |t�s\pOd%�Òn�pO��hcyf9~�c�qÒ}ugIq�ý�p��¾v�tOgI}\p�t�cedZt��ZqLq�pOd%�Ón(g��hsÇdZý

g�dZf�}\cytOgI}\s4%rgÀ��sÇced+�§8¾dD,U�Àa�ce}Ç}\pOq�üZg�t��*gIdZf�kµ�+gÒcyfysÇ��v�t��hprÿ@lÀpVfysÇ�Lc�q�vrlsy3\c�\$>F<I] R y9Z R Z�X�l�]�@hî3Ư@QZ&ù"<?AO>?@���A�>�¹ � ¸�S3b ¹\l�Zg�ý�pVvÓ^�/��wv@^��$/hl50�pO��qEc�q�ÿ7lQ0�q�lU�Izez�zh�h�»�ZqLs\dhý�prqr�

Page 24: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

�Ç^V����,U�À�Tg5��prq�gIdUf*i,��2Íg�7_trv_�e�w�¦tOt�}\�ZvLsÇcedZv�g�v�goýe�hs\fhp;~�ceq��Z}\g�dhdhs\dhýo���hpÍdhp��»�F�»sÇpr�,�w�Ï,Ï,Ï�ÆQlX$A R ¹ u X�>N>�Z�l�AU½9A¯X�V^¸ R < RX$A[`�~.X�]�@6<?A[Z���AO>YZ-V?V^<We5Z�A¯]�ZOlÈ^5�h]P��`�� �Z^��'v»�e���Zl��Tg5�T^V���e�h�

�Ç^�/���g�V��p-�h}4�hceqLd,gIdUfµ�%�r��0og� �pOqV� ± Ï,â3½�Ä5½ u V�X�> k�\�l�S×\Dk�x,\$Smc-<?A[X$>Y\$l�<IX�VOX$A[`���Z�\�SaZ�>Nl�<I]�x,\�S3b[T6>N<?A5e��»{bgIn*ühq�s\fyýep�odhsÇ�epOq�v_sÇ��� ) q�prv�vrlh{bg�nµühq�sufyý�pelh��gl"^r�e���Z�

�Ç^�����,U� �"� 2¦�y��sÇ��t��hpr}Ç}P�F�6�hc�qL�LpVv��b�ZgÀ���Zv½gIdZf�dhp����bc�q�ÿyvO�Ý8¾di,U� ïo� ð c»cyfyn(gId!gIdZfi,Z�w�UB i½c��ZqLÿep�l%prfysÇ�Lceq�vrl � X�A¯`c�\�\�·C\Dkâ}< R ]�lZ->�Z}X�A¯`�x,\$S�b¯T6>YX$>F<I\$A[X�V;��Z�\$SmZ->Nl�¸Àlh�ZgIýeprvÍ�e�%�nv»��/�/h�»{bi�{ ) q�prv�vOlQ2bcytOg�i�gÀ��c�d+lQ�Pf;l+^r�e�5�»�

�Ç^rx�� ) �@��c��y��gIq�}Çs\pOqÓgIdZf�i,�+{Ø�ZgI�Ls\}\gZ�o�%�Lcyt��Zgev���s\t,n*�h}Ç�Lsuv_prdZv_ceqL�!fhgÀ��g~��ZvLsÇced�~�c�qon�ceühs\}Çp*qLceüUc��o}ÇcytrgÀ�Ls\c�d�g�dZf�pOd»�»s��q�c�dhnprde��n�cyfypr}Çs\dhýU� 8¾d�a��y��s\�hq�g�gIdZf|�"�»moqLs\ncI��cZl%prfysÇ�Lceq�vrl�y9\c�\�>N<I] R y3Z R Z�X$l]�@Cî"Ư@QZ��$>?@���A�>�¹ � ¸�S3b ¹\l»�Zg�ý�pVvx%�nv»���Z�»�»8�� ) q�prv�vOlZ{bgIn*ühq�s\fyýep�ly�Tmµl+^r�ex��h�

�Ç^r����,U�w�UB i½ce�hq�ÿ�p����osuvLsÇühs\}\s����e��8¾dx,U� ïo� ð c»cyfyn(gId'gIdUfi,U�E�UB i�c��hq�ÿ�pelepVfys���c�q�vOl � X�A¯`c�\�\�·«\Dk�â�< R ]-lZ->YZUX�A[`�x,\�S3b[T6î>�X�>N<I\�A¯X�V8��Z�\�SaZ�>Nl�¸ÀlZ�UgIý�pVvb��/5�nv%�6�À�h�y{bi�{ ) qLpVvLvrl62�cytrg�iogÀ�Lced+lQ�PfEl+^V���§�»�

� �Iz���i,� ) sÇ�LcZ�|m�vLc�}\�y��sÇced9��c'��hp(dhp-�»��üUpVv��µ�»s\pO�è�hqLceüh}\pOn ~�ceq�gI�y��c�n(gÀ��prfYtOgef9ncyfypr};g�t��e�Zs\vLs���sÇcedÔc�~�~�q�pOp-�A~�ceqLnceü67�prt���v¦�ZvLsÇdhý'q�gIdhýep�trgInpOq�g�vr�U��prt��Zdhs\trgI}Ei½pr�Uceq_���%�����I�hl ð iomÓ� ) fÈg�ü+lÈ�odhsÇ�epOq�v_sÇ���Tc�~ ) pOdZdZv_�»}\�ÀgIdhsughl+�Tg5�^V���e�h�

� �y^���i,� ) sÇ�LcU�Tm v_prdZvLc�q�üZgev_pVfâv_ce}Ç�h�Ls\c�dY�LcT��hp�dhp��»�µü@prv_�*�»s\pO� �hq�c�üh}\pOn'�»8¾d u l\�]�¹U�Ï(Ï,Ï ÅÑ >�@f��A�>�¹�x,\�A�k�¹3\$Au X$>F>�Z-l�A�y3Z�]�\eA�<?>N<I\�AUlh��ce}Ç�Zn�p^ely�ZgIýeprvÍ�I�U^\vy�hl7^r����/h�

� �����"o�� a�� ) q�prv�vOl7�7� m�� �Èpr�hÿ�ce}\vLÿ»��lOo�� �Ò�@�Ñp��L�LpOq�s\dhýZl"gIdUf�2¦� ) �[��}ugIdZdhpOq�����ù�T6SmZ-l�<I]�X�VDy3Z�]-< bQZ R <?A1xF�Ò{bgIn*ühq�s\fyýep�odhsÇ�epOq�v_sÇ��� ) q�prv�vrl@^V�����Z�

� �I���µ�7�¢�Èpr}Ç}\pOqV��m��h�Lc�n(gI�LprfÐ�hq�üZg�dÐncyfypr};g�t��e�Zs\vLs���sÇcedL� ) q�c$7�pVt��,q�gÀ�Ls\c�dUgI}\pg�dZfYv���gÀ���ZvO�«8¾d u l\�]�¹ Ås�s�s� â3½�y u ½��SmX�e�Z��¢A¯`Z-l R >�X�A¯`�<?A§e#{»\�l· R @Q\�b7lU�UgIý�pVvb�%���zv%�5/e�y�»k�mÓi ) m�l+^V���exh�

� �À�$�µ�7�L���ZqL�hdÈl�k*�Ý�hc��"lÈg�dZf®o��Ý2b�hqLý%gIq�f"� ) qLceüZgIüZsÇ}\s\v_�Lsut*ng��h�hs\dhý'cI~½gIdÐpOd»�»sÇq�c�dZn�prd%�Òü»�9g!nc�üZsÇ}\pqLceüUc��r�m8¾du l�\�]�¹/�Ï,Ï(ϯ��AO>Y¹;x,\�A�k�¹(\$A�y3\�c�\$>F<I] R X�A¯`h½9T6>�\�SaX�>N<I\�AUly�ZgIýeprv¦^V�I��/zv7^V�e�y^�l5f+pr�h��prd+lQ2bpO}\ý�s\�hn'l"^r���exh�

� ����� ð �5�È�hq�ÿ*g�dZf(�â�5f+pO�ecÀ���Mr@s\�h�UprqLpVf�Uce}Ç�»ýec�dnprv�hprvF~�q�c�nñq�gIdhýep½sÇn(gIýeprvr��8¾d u l\�]�¹O½QxT~ � �w���8y3½ u8� lI�Zg�ý�pVv�Z^�^\vy�h^VxhlZ^V�����Z�

� �$/���f;��o sW�hvLc�d+�h�ÓsÇpr�½�UcesÇd%�;vLpO}\prt��Ls\c�d*~�c�qÑ�»s\vL�Zg�}hv_pVgIq�t��+�68¾d u l\�]�¹\��Ï,Ï,Ï�x=\$A�k�¹L\$A�x,\�S3b[T6>�Z-lAûÝ< R <I\�A»X�A¯` u X$>F>�Z-l�Ay9Z�]�\�e$AO<?>F<I\$AZly�Zg�ý�pVv½x�z�zwv»xeze�ylU^r�e�I�Z�

± � ¸!z ö ÷U÷ûø ú z�ü!û�õ[ý ÷}| u�� ö=z�z ö�ù'ö��Uz û������N������hsuv,gI�h�@pOdUfysW�YfypOncedZv���q�gI�LpVvo���ZgÀ�,���hp|t�cen�h}Çp-�ys�����c�~Íg�~�q�pOp(t��hq���p�suv,t�c�dUv���gId%�r�|�»�@prtOsWMUtrgI}\}Ç�el+�bp��ZqLcÀ�»sufypm�hpOq�p��Zp,�hqLc»c�~È~�c�q����ZpOc�q�pOn��h�\^�

��� �§��¤���� �Ý�I�����ݤ��5�!­U¡Ý¤��O�§��° � T�bb�\ R Z�� ¶ ]�qZwE ¶ È�G ¶ ` R T�]�]�Z�Z�` R ��ÿÀ]IqhwEQÿ$È�G-ÿO`�<?A'>?@�Z"\�T6>Wb[T6>�V^< R >Là \Dk9X R Z�A R \�l\�b�Z-lX�>N<?A5e*T6A[`�Z�l}\Dk}X R Z-A R \$l}\�b�Z�lX$>F<?A§e*T6A[`Z-l3âhZIã(A�<?>N<I\�A Ì ¹ Ì X$A[`«V�\�]�X$>YZ�`'X�>�>?@�ZU\$l�<We$<?A¯¹)��k3º[² < R ]�\�AO>F<?AOT�\�T R V^¸`�< �9Z�lZ-A�>N<IXc-V�Z�Î(>�@QZ-A»>?@�Z,k�lZ�Z}]-T6l�Ö�Z)�F]�qhw�G-ÿ�È�E ¶ `�]�\�AOA[Z�]->F<?A§ew��ÿh>�\w� ¶ ]�\�A R < R > R \�k�X$>,Sa\ R >(>�@§lZ�ZØb¯<IZ�]�Z R ¹�Ï�X]�@Ub¯<IZ�]�Z< R Z-<?>?@�Z�l!XiV^<?A[Z R ZYe$SaZ-A�>FÎ"Xn]-<?l]�T6V4X�l'X$l]�ÎU\�l*X R Z�]�>N<I\�A�\�k'XiV�\e5X�l�<?>�@§Sh<I] R b¯<?lX�V�\�k«>?@�Zwk�\�l�S��iôé���7p��y�È]� �"Qqe`ìY:¢@QZ-lZ�"*ô ��gId�sdX$A[`����a< R X*]�\$A R >�X�A�>�í¹8¾d!c�q�fypOqÍ��c��ZqLcÀ�epo���hs\vot�}ugIs\n ��pÒdhprprf���ZpÒ~�c�}\}ÇcÀ�½s\dhý}Çprnng��

�(����� ¨-é��F�1���*���O�����5¤��[�§£ÁÞm�P�-��¨Q¦�F�5��°®± Z->P� ¶ ]IqhwEQÿ$È�G-ÿO` R T�]�]�Z�Z�`�� ¶ ]�qhw�E ¶ È�G ¶ `}<?Ai>�@QZUV^< R >=àU¹ ± Z->?�Íc�Z R \$SmZ\c R >YX�]�V4Z�Î9X$A[` R T�bb�\ R Za>�@QX$>�A[Z-<?>?@�Z�lw��ÿ*A[\�l;� ¶ X$lZ9b�X�l�>9\Dkh>?@�Zac�\$T6A[`�X�l�¸�\�k���ìY<I¹?Z�¹�Î=�Í< R `�< R É-\$<?A�>¢k�l�\�SÕ��ÿ!X�A[`� ¶ í¹�Ikغ¯² < R ]�\�A�>N<?A�T�\$T R V^¸m`$< �3Z-lZ�AO>F<IX�c�V4Z�Î,>�@QZ-A»A[\�b�\�l�>N<I\�Ai\Dk3� V^<IZ R :=<?>�@§<?AiXa`$< R >YX$A[]�Z��������Øk�l�\�SÕ>�@QZ�\$l�<We$<?A.<?A>�@QZ�bQ\$V�X�l�<?AO>YZ-l�Ö�X�VOG ÿ �&q��&E ¶ ¹

Page 25: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

� ¸ �_�p¡�¢ �»�Z�h�Uc%v_p����hp(}Çprnng!suv,dhc��¦��qL�Zph� ��ZgI��s\vrl"��ZpOq�p(s\v,g!�@c�qL�Ls\c�dÐcI~3� �½sÇ��hs\dn�������µcI~b��hp(ceqLs\ý�s\d9s\dZvLs\fhp��Zp(�Uce}\g�q,sÇd%�LprqL�Àg�}�]FG-ÿ�ÈE ¶ `��Cf+p��)2Yü@p��hp|tO}Çc%v_pVv��,�@c�s\d%�,�Lc!��hp(ceqLs\ý�s\dÐsÇdÐ��Zp(üUce�hdZfhg�qL�Tc�~3���C2bprtrgI�ZvLpaº¯²�s\vfys�#@prqLprd%�LsugIüh}\p�l���hp�dhc�q�n(gI}ÑcI~�º¯² gI�)2 �@c�s\de��vÒ�LcÀ�ÍgIq�f9��hp|ceqLs\ý�s\d+�«���ZpOq�p�~�c�q�p�lE2þgIdUfÔsÇ��vµ�»s\tOsÇdhsÇ���Ôv�hce�h}\f®�Zg5�epü@pOpOd�c�üZvLpOq���pVf"�P���hpo�»sut�s\dhs����c�~w2�n*�Zv��b��ZpOd�ü@p¦�ZgIqL��c�~ÈgId|pr}Çprn�prd%�bc�~¢à��=2b�y�b��hsuvÍt�c�d%��q�gefys\t���v;c��hqÍg�v�v_�Zn��h�Ls\c�d��UgÀ��� ¶ vL�Ztrt�pOpVfhv���ÿ,gIdZf���ZgI� � suv½fysuv�7�cesÇd%�½~�q�c�nÕ��ÿÒgIdUf«� ¶ �;£���hp(t�cedZvLp��%�hpOdUt�pcI~�f+pOnn(g'm��\^(s\v¦���ZgÀ��sÇ~b��hprqLpp��ysuv���v,gIdÐc�üZv_��get�}\p�]�c�q�g!�@c�qL�Ls\c�dÐcI~ÍgIdÐc�üZv_��get�}\pV`Ó�½s����hs\d

��Zp*vLpOdZvLc�q�B v�q�g�dhý�p,s\dZvLs\fyp���hp*�Uce}\g�q�sÇd%��pOq��5g�}�]NG-ÿ�È�E ¶ `�lU��hprd���ÿ�gIdZf[j5c�q3� ¶ q�pO�ZqLpVv_prde�og|�Uceq_��sÇced�cI~F��hsuvÓc�üZv_��get�}\pB vü@c��hdZfZgIq�����8¾d�cI���hpOq��bc�q�fhvrlhs\dTc�q�fypOqÍ��c�t�cedZv_�Lq��Zt������hp��bc�q�v���®trg�vLp,vLtOpOdZg�qLs\csÇd'���hpµ�@c�}ugIqovLprt��Lceqµ]FG ÿ ÈE ¶ `�lU�bp�tOg�dg�v�vL�hnpÓ���ZgÀ�½���hp,�bc�q�ÿ»vL�Zget�p3�Ug�vÍdhcm�hce}ÇpVvOlZg�dZf!t�c�dUv_sufypOq�� ÿ gIdZf*� ¶ g�vÍü@c��hdZfZgIq��|v_pVt��Ls\c�dUvÍcI~���hp�v�gInpÒc�üZv_��get�}\p���hq�c�n �hpOq�pÒc�d+ly}\p��!¤iô�E ¶ ënG ÿ l\3 ÿ ôê� ÿ ]FG ÿ `ÍgIdUfi3 ¶ ô�� ¶ ]FE ¶ `�wZgIdZf�}\p��$C ÿ gIdUfiC ¶ fyprdhcI��pÒ��hp,q�g5�yvÍt�c�dZdhprt��Ls\dhý��Zp,c�q�sÇýesÇd��½s������UcesÇd%�n2 ÿ ôÂ]63 ÿ È�G ÿ `Íg�dZf!�UcesÇd%�n2 ¶ ô ]63 ¶ È�E ¶ `�lZqLpVv_�@prt��Ls\��pO}\���ï;get��µprdZfy�@c�s\de�Ñc�~7gÒt��ZqL�ep�s\daà×qLpr�hqLpVv_prd%��v�c�dhpÍc�~Z��ZpÍ~�c�}\}ÇcÀ�½s\dhý¦pO��prd%��v��+��ZpÍvLpOdUv_ceq�}\s\dhp��®cI~?�¾v_s\ý�%�Ñ�Íg�v�cytOt�}\�ZfypVf

]�fhpOdhc��Lprfgev�trg�vLp3þVc\�À`�lÀ���hpÍq�g�dhý�pÍt�cedZv���q�g�sÇd%�F�bgev�p��ht�prprfypVf�]AtOg�vLp9þrp*�À`�lIceq���hp½s\dZt�sufyprdZt�p½t�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de�F�Íg�v�p��ht�prprfypVf]�trg�vLpwþr���5`�����c�7�c�s\d�2¯ÿb�½sÇ���2 ¶ ��hprqLp�g�qLp�g¦��cI��gI}hc�~¯/,fysuv_�Ls\dZt���trg�vLprv��,þV�@l ���el6þV�7l cw�el6þV�@l p*�%l6þrpel pB�el�þrcZl c\�½gIdUf«þVp�l c\�%����hp�trg�vLprv9þrcUl pB�el[þrcUl ���,gIdZfiþrpel ���,gIq�pÒn�s\q�qLceqbs\n(gIýeprvÍcI~�cI���hpOq�trg�vLprvr�

­U¨Q���¦¥~�?§ ��¨�ü ���hp's\dZt�sufyprdZt�p�t�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de��Íg�v�p��ht�prprfypVf s\nn�pVfysugÀ�Lpr}Ç� gÀ~��LprqmqdôÍG-ÿ�g�dZf s\nn�pVfysugÀ�Lpr}Ç�þüUpO~�c�q�pq�ôËE ¶ �«���ZpOq�p�~�c�q�p�l+��hp|dZc�q�ng�}F�Lc»º¯²Û7��Zv_�*gI~��LpOq"��ÿgIdUf«7��Uv���ü@p�~�ceqLpa� ¶ s\v�c�q�sÇprde��prfÐgÀ�µg!ý�q�g$%rsÇdZý!g�dhý�}\p(�½s����q�prvL�UpVt��Í�Lc���Zp�v_prdZv_ceqr�E�»�Z�h�Uc%v_p¦���ZgÀ�½���hp,üUce�hdZfhg�qL�Cº¯² tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hprv½gI~��Lprq���ÿÓ�½sÇ��'s���v�vL�hq_~�get�pÒdhceqLn(gI}"tOc�dZv_��g�de��}Ç�c�q�s\pOd%�LpVf gÀ��p��hg�t��L}\�Yg�dþgIdZý�}\p«s �½sÇ�� qLpVv_�@prt��µ�Lc9��hp'vLpOdZvLc�q�B vµ}Çs\dhp-�Pc�~?�®vLsÇý��%�r�i���Zs\vt��ZqL�ep|sÇd �Uce}\g�q�tOc»c�q�fysÇdUgÀ�LpVvv�gÀ�LsuvDMZprvb���hpÒ~�c�}\}ÇcÀ�½s\dhý�qLpr}\gI�Ls\c�dZv��

Ó �ô ë���©�q«ª¬ ) �X©���ª¬[­ È ]��%`Ó�®e]Dë��*ª¬ )½`&ôÀ�Qp Ó}p�tOcevO]IsZ` ôM¯ ^

�©��©�q ô �"ÝÈÍ�½s���� " �ô×��g�dÈ]�sZ` � ]��»`

a�prdZt�pelh���hpµt��ZqL�epB vÍp��%�ZgÀ��sÇced's\v3��ôÁ� � p��y�"�� �"È]Iq"ëiq � `��¾lZ�½sÇ��»� � ôõ36ÿÒg�dZf'q � ôvG-ÿ5�����hp,p��e�UgÀ�Ls\c�d'dhcÀ� fyp-MZdhprv���bcÐvL�hs\q�g�}\v���gÐv_�ZsÇq�gI}�ò�; ÿ ý�q�cÀ�½s\dhýÔtOc��hd%�LprqD�¾t�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLp(~�q�c�n<2 ÿT]�c�q(vD�ZqLs\dhÿ»sÇdZýÐtO}Çcyt�ÿ»�½s\vLpV`�l;gIdUf gÐv_pVt�cedZfþvL�hs\q�g�}òB=ÿ v�hqLs\dhÿ»s\dhý�t�ce�hd%�LprqD�¾t�}\cyt�ÿ%�½suvLpÓ~�q�c�nÀ2¯ÿ|]�ceqoý�q�cÀ�½s\dhý|t�}\cyt�ÿ%�½suvLpV`���º¯² nµ�Zv_�¦tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hp,~�q�c�n>2¯ÿÒsÇd����hp*tOc��hd%��pOq�t�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLp�fys\qLpVt���sÇced pOsÇ��hprq[?�gIü@cÀ��p�@!ò ; ÿ ceq+?LüUpr}ÇcÀ�)@.òB=ÿ w�cI���hpOq��½s\vLp�l����hp�s\dZt�sufyprdZt�p't�cedZv���q�g�sÇd%���bc��h}ufâdhc��U�Zg5�epü@pOpOd'�»s\c�}ugÀ�LpVf"�

�»s\nsÇ}ugIq�}Ç�el+~�ceqÒ��hp|ce�h�@cevLs���p(pOdZf�2 ¶ l�}\p������Cô>3 ¶ gIdUfiq*�aôËE ¶ �*���hp|vLc�}\�y�Ls\c�dÐ��c�p��%�ZgÀ��sÇced�]��%`ÒdZcÀ�èfyp-MZdhprvgTvL�hs\q�g�}�ò =¶ ý�q�cÀ�½s\dhýTt�}\cyt�ÿ%�½suvLp(~�qLcenÿ2 ¶ ]�c�q*v�hq�sÇdZÿ%s\dhý9tOc��hd%��pOq�®tO}Çcyt�ÿ»�½s\vLpV`�l�g�dZfâg9vLprtOc�dZfâvL�hs\q�g�}�ò�;¶ v�hqLs\dhÿ»s\dhýt�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLp|~�q�c�nÁ2 ¶ ]�c�qý�q�cÀ�½sÇdZý9t�ce�hd%�LpOq�¾t�}\c»t�ÿ»�½suv_p5`��1º¯² nµ�Zv_�|t�c�d%��sÇd»�hp�~�qLcenÁ2 ¶ sÇd ��hp't�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLp!fhsÇq�prt��Ls\c�dpOsÇ��ZpOqc?Lg�üUcÀ�ep1@mòB=¶ ceqc?_ü@pO}\cÀ�)@hò ;¶ �©«����¨Q¤nm1� �Pº[² tOgIdZdhcI�Et�ced%�Ls\d%�Zpbü@pO}\cÀ�&ò =ÿ ���hprdj3 ÿ p��y�È]Dë$"_¤�`%�å3 ¶ ��8¾dcI���hpOqÑ�bc�q�fhvrl$º[² tOgIdZdhcI�;tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hp

ü@pO}\cÀ�åòB=ÿ sÇ~È���hs\v½vL�hs\q�g�}"t��hq���pÒt��y��v%C ¶ ü@pO}\cÀ� ���hp,�UcesÇd%�M2 ¶ ]I��s\ý��hq�p��y^%]IEy`_`��P��cvD�hcÀ�)��hsuvOlhvL�h�h�@cevLp"º¯² t�c�d%��sÇd»�hpVvü@pO}\cÀ�êò =ÿ l%���hsut���s\n�h}\sÇpVvÑ��UgÀ�غ¯².ü@pOdUfhvÑ��cÀ�bg�q�fµ��hpÓv_prdZv_ceqÑsÇnnprfhs\gI�LpO}\�gÀ~��Lprq,��ÿI��oÔp�ÿ»dhcÀ� ��UgÀ�غ¯² fhc%pVvÑdhc��t�q�cev�vb��Zp,c�q�sÇýesÇd+lypr}\vLp,dhc���hs\dhý(suv½�»s\vLsÇüZ}Çp,�hdUfypOqokÓp�MUdhs���sÇced9�y�\^,gIdZf!à��bc��h}uf�üUp�prn�y�����;aopOdZtOp�l[º[² ��ce�h}uf«�Zg5�ep�Lc(ü@pOdUf'c��y���ÍgIq�fhvÍü@p�~�c�q�p�t��h�_�Ls\dhý���hp�q�g5�C ¶ lUcI��ZpOq��½s\vLpw� ¶ �½s\}Ç}�üUp,cytrt�}\�Zfyprf+�b�»s\dZt�pUº[² s\vofysW#7pOq�pOd%��s\g�üh}Çpely��ZpOq�pnµ�Uv��F��ZpOdüUp�g¦�@c�s\d%�k2���hprqLpb���hp½dhc�q�n(gI}%�Lc"º¯² �@c�s\d%��v��LcÀ�ÍgIq�fhv���ZpbceqLs\ý�s\d+��2�pVtOg��Zv_pÍc�~[f+prnngÒmµ�Ç^elÀ��hsuvÑ�@c�s\d%�2�suv½dhcI�Óc»trt�}\�ZfypVf�ü»�!gId»��c���hprq�v_pVt��Ls\c�d'c�~=º¯² ���ZgÀ�Ós\v�fhs\vI7�c�s\d%�Lprf!~�q�c�né��ÿÒg�dZf'� ¶ �Ø���hprqLpO~�c�q�p�l»���hp��»s\tOsÇdZs�����cI~k2suv�gµ�%suvLsÇüh}\p��@c�qL�Ls\c�d|c�~ݺ¯²è�=���hsuv��%s\c�}ugÀ��prv;c��hqbg�v�v_�hn�y��sÇced��ZgI��� ¶ vL�Ztrt�pOpVfhv,��ÿÀ�=���»�Zvrle���ZpOdA3Qÿ@p��y�È]Dë$"_¤�`%�å3 ¶ l��ZpwMZq�v_��v_pVt���sÇced!c�~È���hp�t��hq���p��a7�c�s\dhsÇdZýh��ÿÓ�Lcm� ¶ t�cesÇdZtOs\fhprvÍ�½sÇ���ò ; ÿ �

©«����¨Q¤nm�� �*2��Ðv_�»nnp���qL�elÈ���hprdr3 ¶ p-�y�È]�ë$"�¤�`D� 3 ÿ ]�sP� p��\l=ò ;¶ t��y��v�C ÿ ü@pO}\cÀ�à2 ÿ `�l���Zp|}\gev��µvLprt��Ls\c�dYcI~b��Zpt��ZqL�ep��9t�cesÇdZtOs\fhprvÍ�½sÇ���ò =¶ ]����hsut���ýeqLcÀ��vÍt�}\cyt�ÿ»�½s\vLp¦~�qLcenÆ2 ¶ `�����hp½�@c�s\d%�S2 ¶ n(g5��}\sÇp�ü@pO}\cÀ� ���hp�s\d%�LpOq�vLprt���sÇced*c�~ òB=ÿ �½sÇ��AC ¶ l%gIü@cÀ��p���hposÇd%�Lprq�vLprt��Ls\c�d�cI~Lò ; ÿ �½sÇ��AC ¶ l�c�qÑü@p����bpOprdü@cI��(s\d%�Lprq�vLprt��Ls\c�dZvr��fÈsÇÿepO�½suv_pelI���hp��@c�s\de��2 ÿ n(g5�µ}\s\p�üUpr}ÇcÀ�����hp�s\de��pOq�v_pVt���sÇced�c�~Ýò1;¶ �½sÇ��AC ÿ l%g�üUcÀ�epÍ��hp�s\d%�Lprq�vLprt��Ls\c�dcI~=òB=¶ �½sÇ��xCIÿ5lyceqbü@p����bpOprd�ü@cI���'sÇd%�Lprq�vLprt��Ls\c�dZvr�P���hpOq�p,gIq�p��Lc���g�}"cI~���t�cenµühs\dZgI�Ls\c�dZvbcI~�pO�epOd%��v�~�c�q�trg�vLp}þV�7l ���el%üh�y�c�dZ}Ç����c�~����hpOn gIq�p¦s\dZfypr�UprdZfyprde���]FE»`3ò =ÿ tO�y��v�C ¶ gIü@cÀ��p72 ¶ �����%�UvOl\3Qÿ@p-�»��]�ë$"�¤�`�ÐQ3 ¶ l@gIdZf����hs\vos\vop��%�hs\�ÀgI}\pOd%�½�Lcc3 ¶ p��y�È]!"_¤�`)�¿3Qÿ5�����ZgÀ�suvOl�òB=¶ t��h��v7C ÿ ü@pO}\cÀ�þ2 ÿ �

Page 26: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

1s−

r 21rp

2

p1

s+1

l 1

l2

τ

τ

1r

r 2

l2

s2−

l 1

+2s

s1−

p1

p

p2

1s+ 2−s

p1p

2

1rr 2

l2

l 1

p

]FE»` ]FGO` ]IHO`

��sÇýe�hq�p(�h^��ï,�yg�n�h}Çpc�~Íg!~�q�pOp-�®tO�hqL�ep�tOc�dZv_�Lq��Zt��Ls\c�dL�|]FE»`Ó���hsuvµvLs����ZgÀ��sÇcedÐsuvÒs\n��@cev�vLsÇüh}\p�w½]NG�`¦sÇdY���hsuv�tOgev_p���Zp~�qLprpt��ZqL�ep�suv�tOc�n�Uc%v_pVf9c�~����hp�vLpOýen�prd%��7�cesÇdZsÇdhýc2 ÿ*�½s����52âgIdZfÔ��Zp�v_�ZsÇq�gI}(òB=¶ 7�c�s\dhs\dhýc2Y�½s����52 ¶ w½]FHO`;�hpOq�p��Zp~�qLprpt��ZqL�ep¦suv½t�cen�Uc%v_pVf�c�~È���hp�v_�ZsÇq�gI}Ýò�; ÿ 7�c�s\dhsÇdZý�2¯ÿÓ�½sÇ���2TgIdZf���Zp�v_�hs\q�gI}Ýò =¶ 7�c�s\dhsÇdZý�2!�½sÇ���2 ¶ ]��hdh}\prv�vn2�suvÍüUpr��cedZfq�gIdhýep�l»sÇd'���hsut���tOgev_pÒg(t�s\q�tO�h}ugIq½gIq�toc�~�q�g�fhsÇ�Zv��������os\v�gefhfypVfZ`��

]NG�`�ò ; ÿ t��y��v�C ¶ ü@pO}\cÀ�Î2 ¶ �����»�Zvrlw3Qÿ@p-�»��]u"�¤�`)�¿3 ¶ l7gIdUf!��hsuv�suv�p��e�ZsÇ�ÀgI}\pOd%����cA3 ¶ p��y�+]�ë$"�¤�`9п3Qÿ5�����ZgÀ�suvOl�ò�;¶ t��y��v)CIÿÓgIü@cÀ��p&2¯ÿÀ�]FHO`9ò =ÿ t��y��v�C ¶ üUpr}ÇcÀ�¿2 ¶ g�dZf.ò�; ÿ tO�y��v�C ¶ g�üUcÀ�ep)2 ¶ �"���%�UvOlk3Qÿ@p��y�È]Dë$"_¤�`��õ3 ¶ �à3Qÿ@p��y�È]!"_¤�`�l+gIdUf���Zs\vsuvop��%�hsÇ�Àg�}Çprde�¦�Lc�3 ¶ p��y�È]Dë$"_¤�`��à3QÿD�:3 ¶ p��y�È]u"�¤�`��U���ZgI�¦suvOlÝò ;¶ tO�y��v�CIÿ�üUpr}ÇcÀ�õ2¯ÿ5l+g�dZfiòB=¶ t��y��v�CIÿg�üUcÀ�ep2 ÿ5�

f+pO�*�Zv�gIdUgI}\�5%rp(��ZpCMZq�v��v_sÇ�L�UgÀ�Ls\c�dÈ�+3Qÿ@p��y�È]Dë$"_¤�`«Ð 3 ¶ suvµp��%�hsÇ�Àg�}Çprde�*�Lc[3 ¶ p-�y�+]u"�¤�`i�ª36ÿIlÑ���hsut�� sÇd �L�hq�ds\n��Z}Çs\prv���ZgI�$3 ¶ p��y�È]�ë$"�¤�`)�¿36ÿÀ�Ø8¾d�c���hprq���ceq�fZvOlyü@cI���'��hpµtO}Çcyt�ÿ»�½suv_p-�PýeqLcÀ�½s\dhýhò =¶ g�dZf���hpµtO}Çcyt�ÿ»�½suv_p-�®v�hq�sÇdhÿ»s\dhýò�;¶ tO�y��CIÿ�ü@pO}\cÀ�¯2 ÿ�]Av_prph��s\ý��hq�p(�y^e]NG�`_`��U�ZqLcen i½pOn(gIq�ÿ9�yl+��hp}ug�v_�ÒvLprt��Ls\c�d9c�~;���hp�~�qLprp�tO�hqL�ep�� t�c�s\dZtOs\fypVvÒ�½s����òB=¶ ��f+pO�U2�üUp���hp*sÇd%�Lprq�vLprt��Ls\c�d'ü@p����bpOpOd.òB=¶ gIdUf5CIÿ5�����hp,~�q�pOp�tO�hqL�epd�«7�c�s\dhsÇdZýa��ÿ¦��ca� ¶ s\v���»�ZvotOc�n�@cevLprf!cI~F��ZpvLpOý�nprde�P7�cesÇdhs\dhý�2¯ÿÓ�½sÇ���2Tg�dZf|���hp�vL�hsÇq�gI}Ýò =¶ 7�c�s\dhs\dhý�2'�½s����D2 ¶ �m v_�»nnp���qLsutgIq�ý��hnpOd%�,gI�h�Z}Çs\prv¦��c����hp(v_pVt�cedZfÔvLsÇ�L�ZgI�Ls\c�d+l+���ZpOd«3 ¶ p��y�+]�ë$"�¤�`UÐP36ÿ!]�sA� p��\l�ò�;¶ t��y��v�CIÿµg�üUcÀ�ep2¯ÿO`�lhp-�ht�pO�h�½��ZgI�oi½pOn(gIq�ÿ�^Òs\v��Zv_pVf�s\d!��hsuv�trg�vLp��

���hp�c�dh}\��q�pOn(gIs\dhs\dhý!vLsÇ�L�ZgI�Ls\c�d9suv(]IHr`��*aopOq�p�l/3Qÿ@p��y�È]Dë$"_¤�`�� 3 ¶ g�dZf+3 ¶ p-�»�+]Dë$"_¤�`�� 3Qÿ5�U�ZqLcen i½pOn(g�qLÿyv*^gIdUf*�yl5���hprvLpbsÇdhp��%�ZgI}\s���sÇpVv�sÇn�h}\�Ò��ZgI�����hp�MZq�v��Ñv_pVt���sÇced�cI~��|t�c�s\dZtOs\fypVvÈ�½sÇ��aò ; ÿ ���hs\}Çp���Zpb}ug�v_��vLprt��Ls\c�d*cI~��(tOc�s\dZt�sufypVv�½sÇ��®ò =¶ �wf+pO�2ÔüUp*��hp�s\de��pOq�v_pVt���sÇced�cI~Øò ; ÿ gIdUf.ò =¶ �98®~S2Ðsuvo�½sÇ��hs\d.�������5l@��ZpOd����hpµ~�q�pOp�t��hq���pD�Ðs\v¦t�cen��@cevLprfTcI~��ZpvL�hs\q�g�}(ò ; ÿ 7�c�s\dhs\dhý�2 ÿ �½sÇ��x2âgIdZf9��hp(vL�hs\q�g�}=òB=¶ 7�c�s\dhs\dhý�2Ð�½sÇ��x2 ¶ ]F��sÇýe�hqLp|�h^e]IHr`_`��A�o��ZpOq��½s\vLp�2YsuvÒüUpr��cedZfq�gIdhýep�lygIdZf5�Ts\v½tOc�n�Uc%v_pVf�c�~FgvLprt��Ls\c�d!cI~,ò ; ÿ lUg�tOsÇq�t��Z}\g�qÍg�q�t¦c�~�q�g�fys\�Zv�� ����� lZgIdUf�gvLprt���sÇced�c�~=òB=¶ �

­U¨Q���°¥~�?§4�M¨kü mov!s\d)��ZpÔ�hq�pO�»s\c��Zv!tOgev_pel����hpÐtO�hq���p.��ÿ9�bgev�s\d%�LpOq�q��h�y�LpVf gI�*qçô G�ÿ�ü@prtrgI�ZvLp9���hpÐsÇdZtOs\fhpOdZtOpt�cedZv_�Lq�gIs\de�E�Íg�vEp��ht�prprfypVf"�=���hpot��ZqL�ep�� ¶ l��hcÀ�bpO�epOqVlI�Íg�vÑs\d%�LpOq�q��h�y�LpVf|gÀ�Øq�ôÁE ¶ ü@prtOg��ZvLpog,�@c�qL�Ls\c�d(cI~Lº¯² üh}Çcyt�ÿeprf��Zp�v_prdZvLc�q�B v,}\s\dhp��®cI~?�¾v_s\ý�%�V�*8¾dâceq�fyprqÒ�LcT�ZqLcyfy�ZtOp(��Zp|cytOt�}\�ZvLsÇced+lPº[² nµ�Uv��µü@p(��gIdhýepOd%���Lc[C ¶ gÀ�µvLc�np|�@c�s\d%�$2�±ü@pO}\cÀ�å2 ¶ ��oÔp,ÿ»dhcÀ� ~�qLcenéfÈpOnn(g(m��\^,��ZgI�½��hpµ�Uceq_��sÇced!c�~,º[² �hq�c»fh�Zt�s\dhý��Zp,c»trt�}\�ZvLsÇced'trgIdhdZcI��ü@pµfysuv�7�cesÇd%�LpVf~�q�c�nÕ��ÿÀ�,���»�Zvrl�2�±�s\vÍ�Zg�q_��c�~È���hp�vLg�npÒtO�hq���p,g�v���ÿ5�º¯² trgIdhdhc���t�ced%�Ls\d%�Zp½~�qLcen×��ÿÍü@pO}\cÀ��ò =ÿ �P��c�v�hcÀ����hsuvOl»vL�h�h�@cevLp3º¯² tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hprvÑü@pO}\cÀ��ò =ÿ �=���hs\v;sÇn�h}\s\prv;��ZgI�

º¯² üUprdZfhv¦�LcÀ�ÍgIq�f!��Zp�vLpOdZvLc�q¦s\n�npVfys\gI�Lpr}Ç�TgI~��LpOq;��ÿI��2b�y�¦�Lc�trgI�ZvLp*��hp�cytOt�}\�ZvLsÇced+l º¯² �Ug�vÓ�Lc�üUprdZf9ce�y���ÍgIq�fhvü@p�~�c�q�p�sÇ��q�prget��hprvF���hp���gIdhýepOd%�;�@c�s\d%�b2�±��E�»s\dZt�p;º[² suv;fys�#@prqLprd%�LsugIüh}\p�le��hprqLpÓnµ�Zv_�;ü@pÓg,�@c�s\d%�����hprqLp���hpÓdhc�q�n(gI}y��cº¯² �@c�s\de��vÍ�LcÀ�ÍgIq�fhv;��hp,ceqLs\ý�s\d+�=2b�y���bpÒg�}Çq�prgefy�(ÿ»dhcÀ�)���ZgÀ�½���hsuv½�»sÇce}\gI�LprvÍce�hq½g�v�v_�Zn��h�Ls\c�d���ZgI��� ¶ vL�ZtOtOpOpVfhv���ÿÀ�ð s\��pOd���UgÀ�3º¯² tOg�dhdhc��½tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hp¦~�qLcen ��ÿÓüUpr}ÇcÀ�çò =ÿ ly��hprd»º[² nµ�Zv_�ot�cede��sÇd»�hp,g�üUcÀ�epwò ; ÿ ��hceqotOgev_pmþV�7l cw�elhsÇ�Ósuvog�}Ç�Íg5�yvb�Lq��hp,��UgÀ�;ò ; ÿ t��h��v½���hp�q�g5�iC ¶ ü@pO}\cÀ�Q2 ¶ gI�ÓvLc�np��@c�s\de�2È�$�o��hprqL�½suvLp�lZsÇ�o�½s\}Ç}�ü@ps\n��@cev�vLsÇüh}\p¦�Lc��hq�c»fh�Zt�p¦��Zp¦cytrt�}\�Zv_s\c�d!gÀ�n2�±�lyü@prtrgI�ZvLp;º¯² tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hprv�~�q�c�nË��ÿ¦gIü@cÀ��p;ò ; ÿ �,���»�Zvrlw�'suv½t�c�n�@cevLprf�cI~

��Zp�v_�hs\q�gI}Ýò ; ÿ 7�cesÇdhs\dhý�2 ÿ �½s����D2�lhgIdZf����hp�v_prý�npOd%�P7�c�s\dhs\dhý�2'�½s����c2 ¶ �

Page 27: y` - Artificial Intelligenceai.stanford.edu/~latombe/papers/ijrr-hhg/paper.pdf · suv;fys |t h}Ç c*vLc }\ p s\d| hq g t Lsut pe s\q v_ rle hprqLpÓs\v; Zp hq c üh}\pOn cI~Ñt hc»cevLsÇdhý(g

­U¨Q����¥��?§��[¨kü mÓv;ü@p�~�ceqLpele���hpos\dZtOs\fyprdZt�p¦t�cedZv���q�g�sÇd%�;�Íg�v;p��ht�prprfypVf|gÀ��q}ôÁG-ÿÀ�=2��h�;��ZpÓt��ZqL�ep3� ¶ �bgevEs\d%�LpOq�q��h�y�LpVfü@prtOg��ZvLpÓ���hp,q�gIdhýep¦tOc�dZv_�Lq�gIs\d%�Í�Íg�vbp-�ytOpOpVfyprf'gÀ��q}ôÁE ¶ �,���ZgÀ��suvrl`3 ¶ ôª�������À�3Qÿj�v�������,ü@prtrgI�ZvLp����hp�UcesÇd%�%2¯ÿ�s\v¦�½sÇ��hs\dÐq�g�dhý�pelU���hsut��9s\n�h}\sÇpVv¦��ZgI��3Qÿ@p��y�È]Dë$"_¤�`�� 3 ¶ v_s\dZtOpj3 ¶ ô��������5����hsuvÒs\v�p��hg�t��L}\����hp(vLs����ZgÀ��sÇcedâfyprv�t�q�sÇü@prfÔs\dÐi½prn(gIq�ÿ ^�~�c�q�tOgev_p*þr�7l ���e�a���»�ZvOl¢º[² tOgIdZdhcI��t�ced%�Ls\d%�Zp�ü@pO}\cÀ� ò =ÿ l

gIdUf|���hpwMZq�v��ovLprt��Ls\c�d!cI~^�Tt�cesÇdUt�sufyprvÍ�½sÇ���ò�; ÿ �8®~�ò ; ÿ t��y��vÒ��hpq�g5�-C ¶ üUpr}ÇcÀ�à2 ¶ gÀ�µvLc�np��UcesÇd%�)2Èl+��hprd«� s\v,tOc�n�Uc%v_pVf9c�~;���hp|v_�ZsÇq�gI},ò ; ÿ 7�cesÇdhs\dhý�2¯ÿµ�½sÇ��x2ÈlgIdUf!��hpµvLpOýenpOd%�=7�c�s\dhs\dhý�2T�½sÇ��c2 ¶ �7�o���hpOq��½suv_p72Tsuv½ü@pO�ec�dZf!q�gIdhýep�lZg�dZf-�TsuvotOc�n�@cevLprf!cI~Ñg|vLprt���sÇced'cI~,ò ; ÿ g�dZfgt�s\q�tO�h}ugIq½gIq�t¦cI~Fq�gefysÇ�UvØ� ����� �

­U¨Q���²¥§�*§4��¨kü ���hsuv�tOgev_p¦suvÍ�Lq�sÇ�»sugI}P�=���hpÒ~�qLprp,t��hq���pÒsuv½g�tOsÇq�t��Z}\g�q�gIq�tÓtOc�dhdhpVt���sÇdhý�2 ÿÓ�½s����D2 ¶ �

­U¨Q���5��¥§�(§��%¨®¨��¢£³¥§�*§4�M¨kü ���ZprvLp*tOgev_pVvog�qLp�s\n�Uc%vLvLs\üh}Çp*üUpVtOg��Zv_p*cI~(fÈpOnn(g�m��\^��;8¾d9trg�vLpCþrcUl cw�elUüUc������ÿ�g�dZf� ¶ g�qLp¦cytOtO}Ç�Zfhprf"�=oÐp,ÿ»dhcÀ� ~�q�c�n fÈpOnn(g�mµ�Ç^¦���ZgÀ�½���hp,�Uceq_��sÇced�c�~Pº¯² cytOtO}Ç�UfysÇdZýh� ¶ tOg�dhdhcI�Íü@p�fys\vI7�c�s\d%�LpVf|~�q�c�n��ÿIlhgIdUf����ZgÀ�½���hp,�@c�qL�Ls\c�d!cI~�º¯² c»trt�}\�Zfys\dhým��ÿ¦trgIdhdhc��½üUp�fysuvI7�c�s\de��prf�~�q�c�nÕ� ¶ �,2b�y�½���hs\vov_sÇ�L�ZgI�Ls\c�d!s\v�sÇn�@cev�v_s\üh}\p���hceqÒ��hp�tOg�vLp!þrpel cw�elݺ¯² nµ�Zv_�µü@p(��g�dhý�prde�,��c-C ¶ gÀ�µvLc�np(�@c�s\d%�$2�±ÓüUpr}ÇcÀ�:2 ¶ �'2b�y�}º¯² tOc�d%�Ls\d»�hprvµgÀ~��Lprq���ÿ

ü@pO��cedZf'���hp*n(g$�»s\nµ�Zn q�gIdZý�p��;���hpOq�p�~�ceqLpel[º¯² �Zgev½��c�ü@pOdZfT�LcÀ�ÍgIq�f!��hpvLpOdZvLc�qo�Lc|~�g�}Ç}FüZget�ÿ��½sÇ��ZsÇdÔq�g�dhý�pel@g�dZf��ZpOd�üUprdZfþce�y���ÍgIq�fhvµü@p�~�ceqLp'sÇ�(qLpVg�t��hpVv����hp!��gIdZý�pOd%��UcesÇd%��2 ± � moýeg�sÇd+l;��hsuv�»sÇce}\gI�LpVvµce�hq(g�v�v_�hn�y��sÇced ���ZgÀ�a� ¶vL�ZtOtOpOprfZv,� ÿ l%üUpVtOgI�Uv_p3º¯² s\vbfys�#@prqLprd%�LsugIüh}\pogIdUf���hprqLpÓnµ�Zv_�;ü@pÓg��@c�s\d%�;���hprqLp½���hpodZc�q�ng�}h��c}º¯² �@c�s\d%��v;�LcÀ�ÍgIq�fhv��Zp,c�q�sÇýesÇd+�ÑaopOdZtOp�ly���hs\v½trg�vLpÒs\v½s\n�Uc%vLvLs\üh}Çpe�oÐp"�Zg5��pÒg�trt�c��Zde��prf!gI}\}"�Uc%vLvLs\üh}Çp�trg�vLprvr�����Zs\v�tOc�dZtO}Ç�UfyprvÍce�hq½�hq�c%c�~�c�~����hprc�q�pOn �Z�Ç^e�