WP 1 Stakeholder involvement through a co-creation approach

Rome 15-16 February 2017

GIULIA PRATO - WWF ITALY

This project has been funded with support from the European Commission

Deliverables: D.1.1 Stakeholder analysis D.1.2 ,1.3 Formal institutional support letters D.1.4 Introductory meetings - 1 per case study D.5 Multi-stakeholders workshops at each case study D.6 Final meeting

WP1 DELIVERABLES

g.prato@wwf.it

1ST INTRODUCTORY MEETING: MAZARA DEL VALLO 6 SEPTEMBER 2016

NAME AFFILIATION CONTACT

Ilaria Rinaudo AMP Isole Egadi i. rinaudo@ampisolegadi.it

Antonino Bono CREA Soc. Coop. sigane17@hotmail.com

Pino Gullo Legacoop Agroalimentare pino.gullo@gmail.com

Fabio Giardina AMP Isole Pelagie fabiogiardina2@gmail.com

Leonardo Catagnano

Dip. Pesca Regione Sicilia leonardo.catagnano@gmail.com

Alessandro Iannitti Dip. Pesca MIPAAF a.iannitti@politicheagricole.it

Giovanni Basciano Agci Agrital giovanni.basciano@gmail.com

Giuseppe Pernice Osservatorio Pesca Mediterranea giuseppe.pernice@cnr.it

Ignazio Piazza Soc. Coop. Pescatori Sciacca ipiazza@libero.it

Bartolomeo Lino Tumbiolo

Conf. Imprese Pesca Mazara (ad. Federpesca) tumbiolino@libero.it

Salvatore Braschi Federcoopesca e Cogepa Trapani braschitoto@gmail.com, info@cogepatp.it

Giovanni Didia FLAI - CGIL Trapani giovannididia@libero.it

Domenico Asaro Conf. Impresa Pesca (Coldiretti) asarodomenico64@gmail.com

Emilio Sardo Fiume Mazaro Soc. Coop sardoemilio@libero.it

Roberto Falcetta Fiume Mazaro Soc. Coop

Salvatore Ajello Cogepa Mazara ajellosaltore@inwind.it

Marco Toccaceli CREA Soc. Coop creacoop@gmail.com

Ilaria Vielmini Oceana ivielmini@oceana.org

Roberto Ingargiola Fisherman, OP siculpesca siculpesca@gmail.com

Vito Gancitano Captain and shipowner 360652385

Adamo Antonino Fisherman

Marie Louise Pace (skype)

Maltese Ministry for Sustainable development, Environment and Climate change.

marie-louise.pace@gov.mt

Christopher Cousin (skype)

Environment and Resources Authority (ERA), Malta

Marco Costantini WWF Medpo m.costantini@wwfmedpo.org

Giulia Prato WWF Italia g.prato@wwfmedpo.org

Fabio Fiorentino IAMC-CNR fabio.fiorentino@iamc.cnr.it

PARTICIPANTS

g.prato@wwf.it

PARTICIPATORY MAPS – HAKE, RED SHRIMP

SPECIES VITAL PHASE

POINT ON MAP

DEPTH (local U.M)

U.M DEPTH

(m) LOCAL NAME REFERENCE POINTS MONTHS HABITAT

FROM (Lat-Lon)

TO (Lat-Lon)

MID POINT (Lat-Lon)

Hake Nursery N1 100-300 fathom 180-550 Secca Capoduono 1-12

Hake Nursery N2 100-300 fathom 180-550 1-12

Hake Nursery N3 120 fathom 220 Scirocco 22 miglia E-SE Lampedusa, Capo Grecale

1-12 roccia

Hake Nursery N4 120 fathom 220 Fondaletto 1-12 graniglione

Hake Nursery N5 90-120 fathom 170-220 Scivolare 1-12

Hake Nursery N6 80-100 fathom 150-180 W Curva 1-12

Hake Nursery N7 fathom Da Grecale, Levante e Scirocco La Galita fino a Levante Capoduono

1-12

Red shrimp Nursery N1 320-330 fathom 590-600 Fino al 32° parallelo 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N2 300 fathom 550 40 miglia Est Lampedusa 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N3 320 fathom 590 25 miglia NE Linosa 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N4 310-320 fathom 570-590 46-47 miglia Sud Malta 2,3,9 35.01

Red mullet Nursery N1 80 fathom 150 Scivolare/Ponente Testata

1

Red mullet Nursery N2 70-80 fathom 130-150 Fondaletto a Girare Girare (Zona fondaletto) 1.2

Red mullet Nursery N3 40 fathom 70 Sud Ovest 29 2

Red mullet Nursery N4 35-40 fathom 60-70 Zona Ponente, Capo Ponente

2.3

Red mullet Spawn. S1 150 fathom 270 Scirocco 4.5

Red mullet Spawn. S2 140-150 fathom 260-270 Fondaletto 4.5

Red mullet Spawn. S3 140-150 fathom 260-270 Scivolare 4.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery N1 120-130 fathom 220-240 Secca Capoduono Dentro la batimetrica delle acque territoriali

12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N2 140-150 fathom 260-270 Scirocco Testata 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N3 100 fathom 180 W Fondaletto 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N4 100 fathom 180 W Curva 40 miglia Nord Ovest Tripoli 1-4

Rose shrimp

Nursery N5

Rose shrimp

Nursery N6 110-120 fathom 200-220 Scivolare 80 miglia Sud Lampedusa 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Spawn. G1

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito1 90-140 fathom 170-260 33.52-12.07

34.16-12.24

34.08-12.12

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito2 37.22-10.30

37.20.5-10.36.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito3 A Nord di Zembra 37.17.00-10.42.30

37.17.5-10.52.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito4 Canale tra le isobate dei 200m,tra la piattaforma continentale di Capo Bon e il Banco di Auria. Fondo sabbioso

sabbia

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito5 Nursery lunga 4 miglia e larga 5, circondata da isobata 100m, si estende da 14 a 18 miglia a Levante delle Isole Kuriat. Circonda una secca a 73 m.

g.prato@wwf.it

PARTICIPATORY MAPS – MULLET

SPECIES VITAL PHASE

POINT ON MAP

DEPTH (local U.M)

U.M DEPTH

(m) LOCAL NAME REFERENCE POINTS MONTHS HABITAT

FROM (Lat-Lon)

TO (Lat-Lon)

MID POINT (Lat-Lon)

Hake Nursery N1 100-300 fathom 180-550 Secca Capoduono 1-12

Hake Nursery N2 100-300 fathom 180-550 1-12

Hake Nursery N3 120 fathom 220 Scirocco 22 miglia E-SE Lampedusa, Capo Grecale

1-12 roccia

Hake Nursery N4 120 fathom 220 Fondaletto 1-12 graniglione

Hake Nursery N5 90-120 fathom 170-220 Scivolare 1-12

Hake Nursery N6 80-100 fathom 150-180 W Curva 1-12

Hake Nursery N7 fathom Da Grecale, Levante e Scirocco La Galita fino a Levante Capoduono

1-12

Red shrimp Nursery N1 320-330 fathom 590-600 Fino al 32° parallelo 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N2 300 fathom 550 40 miglia Est Lampedusa 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N3 320 fathom 590 25 miglia NE Linosa 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N4 310-320 fathom 570-590 46-47 miglia Sud Malta 2,3,9 35.01

Red mullet Nursery N1 80 fathom 150 Scivolare/Ponente Testata

1

Red mullet Nursery N2 70-80 fathom 130-150 Fondaletto a Girare Girare (Zona fondaletto) 1.2

Red mullet Nursery N3 40 fathom 70 Sud Ovest 29 2

Red mullet Nursery N4 35-40 fathom 60-70 Zona Ponente, Capo Ponente

2.3

Red mullet Spawn. S1 150 fathom 270 Scirocco 4.5

Red mullet Spawn. S2 140-150 fathom 260-270 Fondaletto 4.5

Red mullet Spawn. S3 140-150 fathom 260-270 Scivolare 4.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery N1 120-130 fathom 220-240 Secca Capoduono Dentro la batimetrica delle acque territoriali

12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N2 140-150 fathom 260-270 Scirocco Testata 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N3 100 fathom 180 W Fondaletto 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N4 100 fathom 180 W Curva 40 miglia Nord Ovest Tripoli 1-4

Rose shrimp

Nursery N5

Rose shrimp

Nursery N6 110-120 fathom 200-220 Scivolare 80 miglia Sud Lampedusa 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Spawn. G1

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito1 90-140 fathom 170-260 33.52-12.07

34.16-12.24

34.08-12.12

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito2 37.22-10.30

37.20.5-10.36.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito3 A Nord di Zembra 37.17.00-10.42.30

37.17.5-10.52.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito4 Canale tra le isobate dei 200m,tra la piattaforma continentale di Capo Bon e il Banco di Auria. Fondo sabbioso

sabbia

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito5 Nursery lunga 4 miglia e larga 5, circondata da isobata 100m, si estende da 14 a 18 miglia a Levante delle Isole Kuriat. Circonda una secca a 73 m.

g.prato@wwf.it

PARTICIPATORY MAPS – DW ROSE SHRIMP

SPECIES VITAL PHASE

POINT ON MAP

DEPTH (local U.M)

U.M DEPTH

(m) LOCAL NAME REFERENCE POINTS MONTHS HABITAT

FROM (Lat-Lon)

TO (Lat-Lon)

MID POINT (Lat-Lon)

Hake Nursery N1 100-300 fathom 180-550 Secca Capoduono 1-12

Hake Nursery N2 100-300 fathom 180-550 1-12

Hake Nursery N3 120 fathom 220 Scirocco 22 miglia E-SE Lampedusa, Capo Grecale

1-12 roccia

Hake Nursery N4 120 fathom 220 Fondaletto 1-12 graniglione

Hake Nursery N5 90-120 fathom 170-220 Scivolare 1-12

Hake Nursery N6 80-100 fathom 150-180 W Curva 1-12

Hake Nursery N7 fathom Da Grecale, Levante e Scirocco La Galita fino a Levante Capoduono

1-12

Red shrimp Nursery N1 320-330 fathom 590-600 Fino al 32° parallelo 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N2 300 fathom 550 40 miglia Est Lampedusa 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N3 320 fathom 590 25 miglia NE Linosa 2,3,9

Red shrimp Nursery N4 310-320 fathom 570-590 46-47 miglia Sud Malta 2,3,9 35.01

Red mullet Nursery N1 80 fathom 150 Scivolare/Ponente Testata

1

Red mullet Nursery N2 70-80 fathom 130-150 Fondaletto a Girare Girare (Zona fondaletto) 1.2

Red mullet Nursery N3 40 fathom 70 Sud Ovest 29 2

Red mullet Nursery N4 35-40 fathom 60-70 Zona Ponente, Capo Ponente

2.3

Red mullet Spawn. S1 150 fathom 270 Scirocco 4.5

Red mullet Spawn. S2 140-150 fathom 260-270 Fondaletto 4.5

Red mullet Spawn. S3 140-150 fathom 260-270 Scivolare 4.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery N1 120-130 fathom 220-240 Secca Capoduono Dentro la batimetrica delle acque territoriali

12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N2 140-150 fathom 260-270 Scirocco Testata 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N3 100 fathom 180 W Fondaletto 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Nursery N4 100 fathom 180 W Curva 40 miglia Nord Ovest Tripoli 1-4

Rose shrimp

Nursery N5

Rose shrimp

Nursery N6 110-120 fathom 200-220 Scivolare 80 miglia Sud Lampedusa 12,1,2

Rose shrimp

Spawn. G1

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito1 90-140 fathom 170-260 33.52-12.07

34.16-12.24

34.08-12.12

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito2 37.22-10.30

37.20.5-10.36.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito3 A Nord di Zembra 37.17.00-10.42.30

37.17.5-10.52.5

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito4 Canale tra le isobate dei 200m,tra la piattaforma continentale di Capo Bon e il Banco di Auria. Fondo sabbioso

sabbia

Rose shrimp

Nursery Nvito5 Nursery lunga 4 miglia e larga 5, circondata da isobata 100m, si estende da 14 a 18 miglia a Levante delle Isole Kuriat. Circonda una secca a 73 m.

g.prato@wwf.it

Name Organization Contact

Giuseppe Nardone O.P. San Basso, Ma.Mol.Ab 3393709835

Emilio Caselli Fisher, Ma.Mol.Ab 3334246436

Fabio Fiorentino CNR-IAMC

fabio.fiorentino@iamc.cnr

.it

Enrico Arneri FAO-AdriaMed enrico.arneri@fao.org

Giuseppe Scarcella CNR-ISMAR 3387043071

Gianmaria Barducci Progetto Blu Soc. Coop. Fano 3383124081

Fabio Vallarola AMP Torre del Cerrano 3481401966

Uriano Meconi Regione Marche 3316875651

Simone Leoni CNR-ISMAR s.leoni1985@gmail.com

Giulia Prato WWF g.prato@wwf.it

2ND INTRODUCTORY MEETING: ANCONA 18 NOVEMBER 2016

g.prato@wwf.it

PARTICIPATORY MAPS - ADRIATIC

N1N2

S1, N1

N2

N1Hake (N2 – only in 1990s)

Mullet

SoleScogli del tagliere: spawningsite for other spp.Scogli della Puntonata:

spawning site for other

spp.

SPECIE FASE

VITALE

PUNTO SU

MAPPA PROF. U. M. PROF. (m) DESCRIZIONE MESI

Nasello Nursery N1 60 braccia 110 Scogli del Tagliere, tra Ancona e Sibenik (Croazia). Quantità inferiori alla Fossa di Pomo

1-12

Nasello Nursery N2 20 braccia 40 Solo in passato (1990-91), di fronte al monte Conero

4

Nasello Riprodizione

Non su mappa

30-40 braccia

Zona Sud Ancona, fondo sabbioso 11

Triglia Riproduzione

S1 <30-50

60-90 5-6 miglia dalla costa 7

Triglia Nursery N1 10-20 braccia 20-40 Oltre le 3 miglia 8-9

Triglia Nursery N2 50 braccia 90 Oltre 30-35 miglia dalla costa, al largo (meno concentrati)

3-4

Sogliola Nursery N1

Nord Adriatico, d'accordo con mappe CNR

Scampo Nursery Scalata della fossa di Pomo. D’accordo con mappe CNR

g.prato@wwf.it

Full protection of Jabuka Pit (including longliners) + a larger area managed through rotation of fishing boats

Protection of the coastal zone up to 6 miles + management of the fishing activity after the trawling ban (reduction of fishing days in order to avoid market saturation and keep prices stable). Specific regulations are needed to avoid the issuing of exclusive rights to fish within the 6 miles.

Anticipation of the biological ban to June and July to protect cephalopods with high economic value.

Protection of the refuge area “Zona Barbare”

Protection of the area North of Ancona important for the reproduction of sole and the spiny dogfish (spinarolo)

SUGGESTED MANAGEMENT MEASURES

Ma.Mol.Ab. request: establishment of a technical-scientific table of researchers and fishers to develop joint fisheries management proposals and get Ministry’s + GFCF attention g.prato@wwf.it

QUESTIONNAIRES – NUMBERS

Questionnaires N.

Artisanal fishers 5

Industrial fishers 4

Fishers association respresentative 5

MPA 3

Fisheries/environment authority 3

Producers organisation (OP) 1

Researchers 3

Total 24g.prato@wwf.it

0

5

10

15

20

25

MPA Authorities Fishers/fishers association

Scientist

Fisheries change in the last 10 years

Improved a little

Unchanged

Worsened a little

Worsened a lot

don't know

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

MPA Authorities Fishers/fishers association

Scientist

% o

f re

pso

nd

ents

Fisheries state at present

positive

acceptable

negative

very negative

FISHERIES STATE

g.prato@wwf.it

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Most important threat Second important threat

Threats to fisheries state

Ecessive fishing effort

Illegal fishing

Bad fisheries management

Lack of transnational agreements

Pollution

Climate change

Other

FISHERIES STATE

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50 Conflicts with other marine users

Moderate conflict

Strong conflict

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Most recommenable Second most recommendable

Recommended management measures

Enforce existing management measures

Increase the minimum reference size

Reduce fishing effort

Introduce seasonal fisheries closures

Increase spatial fisheries closures

Reduce spatial fisheries closures

Other

MANAGEMENT

Other suggestions: • Eliminate illegal fishing • Enforce bans on recreational fishing • Management plans • Control/reduce fishing effort after seasonal closures to avoid overpredoction

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Has been involved in co-management

initiatives

Believes it is important that his

category is involved

Is interested in being involved in co-management

initiatives

Involvement in decision making

Yes

No

Doesn't know

ISSUES AND NEXT ACTIVITIES

Issues:

Partners’ help needed to spread the questionnaire to local fishers in case studies – if deemed useful.

Next Activities Multi-stakeholders workshops at each case study – to be organised depending on partners need; - Intro meeting in Croatia May – June 2017 - Collect more management suggestions? 1 more meeting per case study in 2017. Ma.Mol.Ab interested to meet again. Chioggia? - Share and evaluate scenarios with stakeholders : as soon as scenarios are developed,1 meeting per case study Communication support to WP6: - Press release to be developed in correpondance of next workshop/meeting - Posting on meetings/results n WWF Italy FB – to be shared among FB pages of all partners

g.prato@wwf.it