72
ENVLRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL POLE.Y & PROC P pp) :11 ATTAC, _ _ E215 RevsedVolume 4 ';,\0~111 ___X F-IILE COPYI ENVIRONMEINT& SOCIA, NIANAciEMENT tOWEIt GRID CORPlORATION OF INI)IA lTI). kA GOVT OF !NDIA ENTERPRISE) ESMD/ESPP/FINAL-98 APRIL.98 Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized

World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

ENVLRONMENTAL AND SOCIALPOLE.Y & PROC P pp)

:11 ATTAC,

_ _ E215RevsedVolume 4

';,\0~111 ___XF-IILE COPYI

ENVIRONMEINT& SOCIA, NIANAciEMENTtOWEIt GRID CORPlORATION OF INI)IA lTI).

kA GOVT OF !NDIA ENTERPRISE)

ESMD/ESPP/FINAL-98 APRIL.98

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Page 2: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

ACRONYMS USED IN TEXT

CC Corporate CentreCCEA Cabinet Committee on Economic AffairsCEA Central Electricity AuthorityCPCC Corporate Planning Coordination CentreCPR Common Property ResourceDA Disaster AssessmentDFO Divisional Forest OfficerDHO Divisional HeadquartersDOP Department of PowerEA Environmental AssessmentEAMP Environmental Assessment and Management PlanEIA Environmental Impact AssessmentESA Electricity (Supply) ActFA Funding AgenciesFP Forest ProposalGOI Government of IndiaIPDP Indigenous People Development PlanKV Kilo VoltMoEF Ministry of Environment and ForestNSCC National System Coordination CentreNTPC National Thermal Power CorporationOD Operational DirectivePAP Project Affected PersonPIB Public Investment BoardPSDP POWERGRID System Development ProjectR&R Resettlement and RehabilitationRAP Rehabilitation Action PlanRHQ Regional HeadquartersRSCC Regional System Coordination CentreSA Social AssessmentSAMP Social Assessment and Management PlanSLDC State Load Dispatch Centre

Page 3: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

LIST OF ATTACHMENTSAttachment 1 Salient Features of Electricity (Sup,'ly) Act, 1948

Attachment 2 Key Authorities and their functions as laid out by the Indian Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948

Attachment 3 : Forest Clearance Flowchart

Attachment 4 Right of Way in Forest: 400 Kv

Attachment 5 Approval Format

Attachment 6a Category of Proposals for which Cost-Benefit Analysis Applicable

Attachment 6b : Parameters for Evaluation of Loss of Forests

Attachment 6c Parameturs for Evaluation of Social Assessment

Attachment 7 Specified Project Categories as listed in Schedule 1 of Environment Impact AssessmentNotification, 1994 (MoEF)

Attachment 8 Comparison of Indian Law with World Bank Directives (Environmental)

Attachment 9 Relevant Sections And Criteria In Key Environment Legislations

Attachment 10 : Gazette Notification

AHtachment 11 : Tree and Crop Compensation Procedures

Attachment 12 : Typical Plan of Transmission Tower Footings

Aftachment 13 POWERGRID's Social Entitlements Framework

AKtachment 14 Comparison: Indian Law and World Bank Directives (Social)

AHtachment 15 : Recognition of Project Affected by Some Salient Documents

Attachment 16 : Nature and Extent of Entitlements Recognised by Some Salient Documents.

Attachment 17 : Comparison: World Bank OD 4.30, National Draft Policy and POWERGRID'sSocial Entitlement Framework

Attachment 18 : Summary of Key Trends in Indian Law/Policies

AHtachment 19 : Electro-Magnetic Field

Attachment 20 : POWERGRID's Future Investment Programme

Attachmen' 21: Details of POWERGRID System Development Project-lI

Attachment 22 : Detailed Process of A Typical POWERGRID Transmission Project

Attachment 23 : Key Milestones of a Typical POWERGRID Transmission Project

Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects

Attachment 24b: Format for Comparative Statement of Sites for Substations

AKtachment 25a: Checklist for Inspection of Transmission Lines

Attachment 25b: Checklist for Inspection of Substations

Attachment 26 : POWERGRID's Monitoring Plan

Attachment 27 : Case Studies of POWERGRID's Transmission Projects

AHtachment 28 : POVWERGRID's Baseline Data and Experience

AHtachment 29 : Illustrative Disaster Control Plan for Fire Incidents

Attachment 30 : Guidelines for Preparing Resettlement Action Plan

AHtachment 31 : Indigenous People's Development Plan -Recommended Content and Format

AHtachment 32 : POWERGRID's Public Consultation Process

AHtachment 33 : POWERGRID Centers in India

Attachment 34 POWERGRID Organisation Structure

AHtachment 35 : Existing EMD Structure

Attachment 36 : Present Organisational Structure of Regional Headquarters

Attachment 37 : Present Organisational Structure of Divisional Headquarters

Attachment 38 : Departmental Profiles

Page 4: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-I

SALIENT FEATURES OF ELECTRICITY (SUPPLY) ACT, 1948

Objective: An Act to provide for the rationalisation of the production and supply of electricity,and generally for taking measures conducive to Electrical Development.

Chapter IThis chapter deals with the jurisdiction of the law and important definitions

Chapter IIThis chapter deals with the aspects relating to the Central Electricity Authority

Its ConstitutionPower and Functions

Chapter IIIThis chapter deals with the other authorities constituted in the Act. This includesState Electricity Boards, Generating Companies, State Electricity Consultative Councils andLocal Advisory Committees

Constitution and CompositionTerm and OfficeJurisdiction

* Effect of Inter-State Agreements* Miscellaneous

Chapter IVThis deals with the powers and duties of State Electricity Boards and Generating Companies* Supply of Electricity

LeasingInvestigations

Chapter VThis chapter deals with the Works and Trading Procedure or the Board and the GeneratingCompany.i Preparation and Sanctioning of Schemes* Submissioni of schemes for concurrence of authority etc.* Concurrence of Authority* Power to alter or extend schemes* Powers to place wires, poles (Sec. 42)** Provision regarding transmission lines

Arrangements for purchase or sale of electricityGrid TariffAccommodation and Right of Way

* Rating Committees

* Sec. 42 ( I& 2): This Section says ' The Board/ Generating Company shall have, for theplacing of any wires, poles, wall-brackets, stays apparatus and appliances for thetransmission and distribution of electricity, or for the tranamission of telegraphic or telephoniccommunications necessary for the proper co-ordination of the works of the Board/ GeneratingCompany, all powers which the telegraph authority possesses under Part IlIl of IndianTelegraph Act, 1885 ( 13 of 1885) with regard to a telegraph established or maintained by theGovemment or to be so established or maintained.

Chapter VIThis deals with the board's finance, accounts and audit

Chapter VIlMiscellaneousSchedules

1

Page 5: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-2

KEY AUTHORITIES AND THEIR FUNCTIONS AS LAID OUT BY THE INDIANELECTRICITY (SUPPLY) ACT, 1948

Authority Key Functions Key Areas Under Its ControlCentral Electricity * To develop a sound, adequate * Approval of Electricity SupplyAuthority and uniform national power Schemes referred to as the

policy techno-economic clearance* Arbitration in matters between

State Govemment or Boardand Licensee under the act

* Promotion and assistance intimely completion ofsanctioned schemes

* Advisory capabilitiesState Electricity * To arrange for the supply of * Operation of generatingBoards electricity required in a State stations under its control

* For the transmission and * Formulation of perspectivedistribution of electricity in an plans for generation andefficient and economical transmission of electricity inmanner the state

* Exercise of control overgeneration, distribution andutilisation of electricity

* Preparation andimplementation of schemes fortransmission, distribution andgenerally promoting the sue of

_______________ __ __________ electricity within a stateGenerating * Establishment, operation and * Establishment, operation andCompanies maintenance of Generation maintenance of Generating

Station and Substations Station and Substations* Carrying out of detaied

investigations and preparationof schemes; with the StateElectricity Boards

Transmission * Establishment, operation and * Establishment, operation andCompanies maintenance of Transmission maintenance of Transmission

Lines and associated Lines and asssociatedSubstations Substations

* Preparation of transmissionschemes with the StateElectricity EBoards and relevantstakeholders

State Electricity * To advise SEBs and * To review the progress of theConsultative Generating Companies on work of SEBs and generatingCouncils major questions of policy and companies

major schemes* To consider such matter as

rules prescribe* SEBs must submit their annual

financial statement andsupplementary statement tothis council and take intoaccount their comrments

Local Advisory * To advise the SEBs whenCommittee consultations are required

2

Page 6: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-3

FOREST CLEARANCE FLOW CHART

|TECHNO-EC POPOSLUEMITTECLEARANCE FROM CEA BY POWER UTILITY TREE ENUMERATION FOREST

YE NTRETHES

PROPOSAL NFIT ANALYSIS I77I FORMULATION P

1 L 1 I LAN~~D IDENTIFICAkTION I.F R MCOMPENSATOR

ClDFO RE.COMMENE C FFGREVT;AT i,F

YES NO

AD. CCF RECOMMENDEDr YES I NO

MIOFICER RESOMMEDPD

LI PCCF RECOMMENDED IYES NO

NSECT (FOREST STATE GOVA. RECOMMENDEDCMYES I ANN

MFOEF RECOMMENDED~~~E NO_

DCOMPLITTEE RECORT BYYES IN

S GOVSTER.S APPRO E4 YES ~I NO

FINLE APPROVAL ACCBM ED

N INFORMATION TO POWER UTILITY LRF THROUGH INTERMEDIATE CHANNELS

1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

TRANSFER & MUTATION OF LAND FORCOMPENSATORY AFFORESTATION TO STATE

FOREST DEPARTMENT

COMPLIANCE REPORT BYSTATE GOVT. TO MOEF

IFINAL APPROVAL BY MOEF

NOTE. fOR ANY CLARIFICA TION SOUGHT A TANY LEVEL CASE ISREFERRED BACK TO UTILITY THROUGH PROPER CHANNEL

3

Page 7: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-4

RIGHT OF WAY IN FOREST: 400 KV

A B C

3m 3m 3m

52m

DURING CONSTRUCTION

Area where trees are lopped

g Area where trees are completely felled

A B C

iB~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ,/a

3m 3m 3m

52m

AFTER CONSTRUCTION

Arm Area where trees are loppeid

m Area kept clear of trees

Area left for natural regeneration

4

Page 8: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-5

APPROVAL FORMAT

Form for seeking prior approval under Section 2 of the proposals by the State Govemmentsand other authorities.1. Project details:

(i) Short narrative of the proposal and project/scheme for which the forest land isrequired.

(ii) Map showing the required forest area, boundary of adjoining forest anditemwise break-up of the required forest area for different purposes (to beauthenticated by an officer not below rank of Deputy Conservator of Forests).

(iii) Total cost of the project.(iv) Justification for locating the project in the forest area giving altematives

examined and reasons for their rejection.(v) Financial and social benefits(vi) Employment generated

2. Location of the project/scheme:(i) State/Union Territory(ii) District(iii) Employment generated

3. Item-wise break-up of the total land required for the project/scheme along withits existing land use

4. Details of forest land involved:(i) Legal status of the forest (namely, reserve, protected/undassed, etc.)(ii) Details of flora and fauna existing in the area(iii) Density of vegetation(iv) Species-wise and diameter class-wise abstract of trees(v) Vulnerability of the forest area to erosion, whether it forms a part of a

seriously eroded area or not.(vi) Whether it forms a part of national park, wildlife sanctuary, nature reserve,

biosphere reserve, etc; and if so, details of the areai involved. (Specificcomments of the Chief Wildlife Warden to be annexed).

(vii) Item-wise break-up of the forest land required for the project/scheme fordifferent purposes.

(viii) Rare/endangered species of flora and fauna in the area(ix) Whether it is habitat for migrating fauna or forms a breeding ground for them(x) Any other significance of the area relevant to the proposal.

5. Details of displacement of people due to the project:(i) Total number of families involved in displacement(ii) No. of Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe families involved in displacement(iii) Detailed rehabilitation plan

6. Details of compensatory afforestation scheme:(i) Details of non forest area/degraded forest area identified for compensatory

afforestation, its distance from adjoining forest, no. of patches, size of eachpatch

(ii) Map showing non-forest/degraded forest area identifiecd for compensatoryafforestation and adjoining forest boundaries.

(iii) Detailed compensatory afforestation scheme induding species to be planted,implementing agency, line schedule, cost structure etc.

(iv) Total financial outlay, for compensatory afforestation schemne.(v) Certificates from competent authority regarding suitability of area identified for

compensatory afforestation and from management point of view. (To besigned by an officer not below the rank of Deputy Conservatory of Forests).

5

Page 9: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

(vi) Certificate from the Chief Secretary regarding non-availability of the non-forest land for compensatory afforestation (if applicable).

7. Details regarding Transmission Lines (only for Transmission Line proposals):(i) Total length of the Transmission Line(ii) Length passing through forest area(iii) Right of Way(iv) Number of Towers to be erected(v) Number of Towers to be erected in forest area(vi) Height of Transmission Towers

8. Cost-benefit analysis9. Whether clearance from environmental angle is required (Yes/No). If yes,

whether requisite details for the same have been furnished (Yes/No).10. Whether any work in violation of the Act has been carried out (Yes/No). If yes,

(i) Details of the same including date of commencement(ii) Officers responsible for violation of the Act(iii) Action taken/being taken against erring officers(iv) Whether work in violation of the Act is still in progress.

11. Any other information12. Details of certificate/documents enclosed13. Detailed opinion of the Chief Conservator of Forest/Head of the Forest

Department concerned covering the following aspects, namely:(i) Out-tum of timber, fuelwood and other forest produce from forest land

invoived.(ii) Whether the district is self-sufficient in timber and fuel-wood, and(iii) The effect of the proposal on

(a) Fuelwood supply to the rural population(b) Economy and livelihood of the tribals and backward communities

(iv) Specific recommendations of the Chief Conservator of Forest/head of theForest Department for acceptance or other-wise of the proposal with reasonsthereof.

Certified that all other altematives for the purpose hav,e been explored andthe demand for the required area is the minimum demand for forest land.

For POWERGRID Signature of the authorisedSignature officer of the State/Govt.Date AuthorityDesignation

Approval by Group Manager

N.B. I While fumishing details of flora and fauna the specifies should be described by theirscientific names.

N.B.2 ff the space provided is not sufficient to specify any information, please attachseparate details/documents.

6

Page 10: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-6a

CATEGORY OF PROPOSALS FOR WHICH COST-BENEFIT ANAILYSIS APPLICABLE

Sl.No. Nature of Proposal Applicable/ Remarks

Not applicable

1. All categories of proposals Applicable/ These proposals are to beinvolving forest land up to 20 . considered on case by casehectares in plains and up to 5 Not appicable basis and value judgementhectares in hills

2. All other proposals involving Applicable These are cases where aforest land more than 20 cost-benefit analysis ishectares in plains and more necessary to determine whenthan 5 ha. in hills including diverting the forest land toroads, transmission lines, non-forest use is in the overallminor, medium and major public interestsirrigation projects, hydelprojects mining activity, railwaylines, location specificinstallations like microwavestations, auto repeater centres,T.V. towers etc.

7

Page 11: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-6b

PARAMETERS FOR EVALUATION OF LOSS OF FOREST

SI.No. Parameters Roads, Transmission lines & Railwaylines

Loss of value of timber, .fuelwood and To be quantified & expressed innminor forest produce on an annual monetary termsbasis, including loss* of man-hours perannum of people who derived livelihoodand wages from the harvest of thesecommodities

2. Loss of animal husbandry productivHy, -do-including loss of fodder

3. Cost of human resettlement To be quantified & expressed inmonetary terms

4. Loss of public facilities and To be quantified & expressed inadministrative infrastructure (Roads, monetary termsbuildings, schools, dispensaries, electriclines, railways etc.) on forest land, orwhich would require forest land if thesefacilities were diverted due to theproject

8

Page 12: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-6c

PARAMETERS FOR EVALUATION OF SOCIAL ASSESSMENT

SI.No. Parameters Roads, Transmission lines &Railway lines

1 Increase in productivity attributable to To be quantified & expressed inthe specific project monetary terms

2. Benefits to economy Value judgement

3. No. of population benefited -do-

4. Employment potential -do-

5. Cost of acquisition of facility on non To be quantified & expressed inforest land wherever feasible monetary terms

6. Loss of (a) agricultural & (b) animal -do-husbandry production due to diversionof forest land

7. Cost of rehabilitating the displaced To be quantified & expressed inpersons as different from compensatory monetary termsamounts given for displacement

8. Cost of supply of free fuel-wood to -do-workers residing in or near forest areaduring the period of construction

9

Page 13: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-7

SPECIFIED PROJECT CATEGORIES AS LISTED IN SCHEDULE I OF ENVIRONMENTIMPACT ASSESSMENT NOTIFICATION, 1994 (MoEF)

Following project categories are required to obtain environmental clearance, prior toestablishing an industrial unit.New projectsFor industrial units in the following project categories, if investment is > Rs. 50 crores:- Nuclear power plant & related projects, such as Heavy Water Plants, nuclear fuel

complex, rare earths;- River valley projects including hydel power, major irrigation projects and a

combination, including flood control;- Ports, harbours, airports (except minor ports and harbours);- Petroleum refineries including crude and product pipelines;- Chemical fertilizers (Nitrogenous and Phosphatic other than single Superphosphate);- Petrochemical complexes (both Olefinic and Aromatic) and Petrochemical

intermediates such as DMT. Caprolactam, LAB etc. and production of basic plasticsuch as LDPE, HDPE. PP, PVC.

- Exploration for oil and gas and their production, transportation and storage;- Synthetic Rubber- Hydrocyanic acid and its derivatives;- Primary metallurgical industries (such as production of Iron and Steel, Aluminium,

Copper, Zinc, Lead and Ferro Alloys);- Electric Arc Fumaces (Mini Steel Plants);- Chlor alkali industry;- Viscose staple fibre and filament yam;- Storage batteries integrated with manufacture of oxides of lead, lead antimony alloy;- Thermal power plants;- Pulp, paper and newsprint;- CementFor industrial units in the following project categories, irrespective of the investment;- * Pesticides (Technical);- Bulk drugs and pharmaceuticals;- Asbestos and asbestos products;- All tourism projects between 200-500 meters of a High Tide Line & at locations with an

elevation > 1,000 meters with investments > Rs.5 crores;- Mining projects (with leases of more than 5 hectares);- :;Highway projects;- Tarred roads in the Himalayas and/or forest areas;- Distilleries;- Raw skins and hides;- Dyes;- Foundries (individual);- Electroplating.Note: Small scale industrial units intending to manufacture any item of the project categoriesmentioned above, with invesb1ents less than Rs.1 crore and which is on the reserved list, areexempted from environmentcl dearance.Who Requires Site Clearance ?Site clearance from the MoEF is to be obtained in case of the following projects:- Mining;- Pit-Head thermal power stations;- Hydropower, major inigation projects and/or their combination indcuding flood control;- Ports and harbours (excluding minor ports);- Prospecting and exploration of major minerals in areas more that 500 hectares.For obtaining site clearance. application is to be submitted giving the location of the projectalong with requisite details, to the MoEF. MoEF will convey its decision about the suitability ofthe proposed site within a maximum period of 30 days.

10

Page 14: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-8

COMPARISON OF INDIAN LAW WITH WORLD BANK DIRECTIVES (ENVIRONMENTAL)

Comparison Criteria Indian Law (Environmental) World Bank (OD 4.01)1. Type of environrnental Project specific Plus

analysis - Regional and sectoral2. Basis for categorisation - involvement level Plus

- type of project - sensitivity- location - nature and magnitude of- scale of project potential impacts- altemative sites examined - social assessment

and reasons for sites componentproposed - resettlement

3. EA Outputs - Outputs required Outputs required- Detailed Feasibty - EA Report

Report - Acceptable EAMP- Questionnaire - Acceptaible RAP- Rehabilitation Master - Acceptaible IPDP

Plan- Risk Assessment

Report- Disaster Plan

4. Public Consultation - Public Informed at follow- Mandatory ating stages of project cycle - preparation of EA- preparation of EA,(lf - project appraisal plus

required) - project design- project appraisal - project implementation

5. Disclosure of Information - Not mandatory - Mandatory- Summary Feasibirity Report - Summary of project

(if required) description .and potentialadverse impacts

- Summary of EA ReportConclusions

- EA Repc,rt

11

Page 15: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment 9

RELEVANT SECTIONS AND CRITERIA IN KEY ENVIRONMENT LEGISLATIONS

MANDATORY REQUIREMENTS:Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 is attracted when any of POWERGRID'sproject activities are within forest land. This is an Act to provide for the conservation of forestsand for matters connected therewith or ancillary or incidental thereto.

S.2. Restriction on the preservation of forests or use of forest land for non-Jforest purpose -Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force a State, no StateGovernment or other authority shall make, except with the prior approval of the Central Government,any order directing -

i) that any reserved forest (within the meaning of the expression "reserved forest " in any lawfor thetime being inforce in that State) or any portion thereof shall cease to be reserved.

(ii) that anyforest land or any portion thereof may be usedfor any non-forest purpose;

(iii) that any forest land or any portion thereof may be assigned by way of lease or otherwise to anyprivate person or to any authority, corporation, agency or any other organisation not owned,managed or controlled by Government:

(iv) that anyforest land of any portion thereof may be cleared of trees which have groDwn naturally inthat land orportion,for the purpose of using itfor realforestation.

Explanation: For the purpos. of this section "non-forest purpose" means the breaking up or clearingof anyforest land or portion thereoffor -

(a) the cultivation of tea, coffee. spices, rubber, palms, oil-bearing plants, horticultural crops ormedicinal plants;

(b) any purpose other than real forestation, but does not include any work relating or ancillary toconservation, development and management offorests and wild life, namely, the establishment ofcheck-posts, fire lines, wireless communications and construction offencing, bridges atid culverts,dams, waterholes, trench marks, boundary marks, pipelines or other like purpose.

PRESCRIPTIVE REQUIREMENTS

Resolution on National Forest Policy, 1988

A landmark as it stressed on maintenance of environmental stability through maintenance ofenvironmental stability through preservation and restoration of ecological balance, keeping inmind the intrinsic relationship between forests and the tribal and poor people living in andaround forests. Key portions of the policy are:

1. Preamble

1.1. In Resolution No. 13/52-F, dated the 12th May 1952, the Government of India in the erstwhileMinistry of Food and Agriculture enunciated a Forest Policy to befollowed in the managementof State Forests in the country. However, over the years, forests in the country have sufferedserious depletion. This is attributed ro relentless pressures arisingfrom ever-inc,reasing demandforfuelwood, fodder and timber, inadequacy of protection measures; diversion offorest lands tonon-forest uses without ensuring compensatory afforestatton and essential environmentalsafeguards; and the tendency to look upon forests as revenue earning resource. The need toreview the situation and to evolve, for the future, a new strategy of forest conservation hasbecome imperative. Conservation includes prese;ivation, maintenance, sustainable utilisation.restoration and enhancement of the natural environment. It has thus become necessary toreview and revise the National Forest Policy

12

Page 16: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

2. Basic Objectives

2.1. The basic objectives that should govern the National Forest Policy are the jbllowing:

Maintenance of environmental stability through preservation and, where necessary,restoration of ecological balance that has been adversely disturbed by serious depletionofforests of the country.

* Conserving the natural heritage of the country by preserving the remaining naturalforests with the vast variety offlora andfauna, which represent the remarkable biologicaldiversity and genetic resource of the country.

* Checking soil erosion and denudation in catchment areas of rivers, lakes, reservoirs inthe interest of soil and water conservation, for mitigating floods and droughts andfor retardation of siltation of reservoirs.

* Checking the extension of sand-dunes in desert areas of Rajasthan and along coastaltracts.

* Increasing substantially theforest/tree cover in the country through marsive afforestationandforestry programmes, especially on all denuded, degraded and unpzoductive lands.

* Meeting the requirements offuelwood, fodder, minorforest produce and small timber ofthe rural and tribal populations.

* Increasing the productivity offorests to meet essential national needs.

* Encouraging efficient utilization offorest produce and maximising substitution of wood

* Creating a massive people's movement with the involvement of women, for achievingthese objectives and to minimise pressure on existingforests.

2.2 The principal aim of Forest Policy must be to ensure environmental stability and maintenance ofecological balance including atmospheric equilibrium which are vital for sustenance of alllifeforms. human, animal and plant. The derivation of direct economic benefit must besubordinated to this principal aim.

The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 (Act No. 29 of 1986)

This act came about as a result of decline in environmental quality has been evidenced byincreasing pollution loss of biological diversity and the need to protect and enhance theenvironmental quality. Some salutary provisions which will guide POWERGRID activities ares shown below. These provisions indicate the rule making power of the government in relationto environmental standards and guidelines and the object of the act

An act to provide for the protection and improvement of environment and for miatters connectedtherewith

Whereas decisions were taken at the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment held atStockholm in June 1972, in which India participated, to take appropriate steps for the protection andimprovement of human environment.

And whereas it is considered necessary further to implement the decisions aforesaid in so far as theyrelate to the protection and improvement of environment and the prevention of hazards to humanbeings, other living creatures, plants and property.

S.3. Power of Central Government to take measures to protect and improve environment.

(1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Central Government shall have the power to take allsuch measures as it deems necessary or expedient for the purpose of protecting and improvingthe quality of the environment and preventing, controlling and abating environmentalpollution.

13

Page 17: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

(2) In partclar, and without prejudice to the generality of the provisions of sub-section (1), suchmeasures may include measures with respect to all or any of the following matters, viz.:

(i) co-ordination of actions by the State Governments, officers and other authorities-

(a) under this Act, or the rules made thereunder; or(b) under any other lawfor the time being inforce which is relatable to the objects

of this Act;

(ii)planning and execution of a nation-wide programme for the prevention, control andabatement of environmental pollution;

(iii)laying down standardsfor the quality of environment in its various aspects;

(iv)laying down standards for emission or discharge of environmental pollutanits from varioussources whatsoever; Provided that different standards for emission or discharge may be laiddown under this clausefrom different sources having regard to the quality or composition ofthe emission or discharge of environmental pollutantsfrom such sources;

(v) restriction of areas in which any industries, operations or processes or class of industries,operations or processes shall not be carried out or shall be carried out sibject to certainsafeguards;

(vi)laying down procedures and safeguards for the prevention of accidents which may causeenvironmental pollution and remedial measuresfor such accidents;

(vii)laying down procedures and safeguardsfor the handling of hazardous substances;

(viii)examination of such manufacturing processes, materials and substances as are likely tocause environmental pollution;

(ix)carrying out and sponsoring lnivestigations and research relating to problems ofenvironmental pollution;

(x) 'nspection of any premises, plant, equipment, machinery, manufacturing or other processes,materials or substances and giving, by order, of such directions to such authorities, offlcers orpersons as it may consider necessary to take steps for the prevention, control and abdtementof environmental pollution;

(xi)establishment or recognition of environmental laboratories and institutes to carry out thefunctions entrusted to such environmental laboratories and institutes under this Act;

(xii)collection and dissemination of information in respect of matters relating toenvironmentalpollzition;

(xiii)preparation of manuals, codes or guides relating to the prevention, control andabatement of environmental pollution;

(xiv)such other matters as the Central Government deems necessary or expedient for the purposeof securing the effective implkmentation of the provisions of this Act.

S.6. Rules to regulate environmental pollution:

(I) The Central Government may, by notification in the Oficial Gazette, make rules in respect of allor any of the matters referred to in Section 3.

(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such rules mayprovidefor all or any of thefollowing matters, namely:-

(a) the standards of quality of air, water or soilfor various areas and purposes;

(b) the maximum allowable limits of concentration of various environmental pollutants(including noise) for different areas;

(c) the procedures and safeguards for the handling of hazardous substances;

(d) the prohibition and restrictions on the handling of hazardous substances in differentareas;

14

Page 18: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

(e) the prohibition and restrictions on the location of industries and the carrying on theprocesses and operations in different areas;

69 the procedures and safeguards for the prevention of accidents which may causeenvironmental pollution and for providingfor remedial measuresfor such accidents.

The Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972* (No. 53 of 1972)

This act deals with management of protected areas and lays down schedules for ofendangered species. This wildlife regime does not apply to POWERGRID activities butrelevant provisions of the law are:

An Act to providefor the protection of wild animals and birds and for matters connected therewith ofancillary or incidental thereto

Whereas it is expedient to provide for the protection of wild animals and birds and for mattersconnected therewith of ancillary or incidental thereto;

And whereas Parliament has no power to make laws for the States with respect to any of the mattersaforesaid except as provided in Arts. 249 and 2S0 of the Constitution;

And whereas in pursuance of Cl. (1) ofArt. 252 of the Constitution resolutions have been passed by allthe Houses of Legislatures of the States of Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Gujarat, Haiyana, HimachalPradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Manipur, Punjab, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal to the effectthat the matters aforesaid should be regulated in those States by Parliament by law;

S.8. Duties of Wild Life Advisory Board: It shall be the duty of the Wild Life Advisory, Board toadvise the State Government -

(a) in the selection of areas to be declared as sancturries, National Parks, game reserves andclosed areas and the administration thereof;

(b) informulation of the policy in granting licences and permits under this Act;(c) in any matter relating to any Schedule; and(d) which may be referred to it by the State Government.

15

Page 19: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

awl ., . t,aw,lss,vixob~V*I vi

POWEIcE CORPORA7TON OF INDIA UMnIT

(A Govt. of [adia Eatexpric)

19. j ictmkunt Chamba's

Hchru Plac,. K'. Ddbi 1t1 Ol9Rcf. CCOS/1302!4169

WeYter Region Load Deipatcb and C.m.cdoo Scbhuc lat6ltion of &mc U'odcr :t,oa 29 olf tie [:c(toncit)(SepplY) Act. 1948 s aleneda .

Wbcrcu. in excercise of its power usndr swction 21 ott,c Ekecricit) (Supp!y) Act. l9J6 as amcr.dcd, the sc$cOCctcbting lo :hc cstablishmcnt. coDsrructi operation and maitcnancc of the Wcstcn Rtzion Lead Dcspatch .ra.GCnmunUt,i1on Schcmc has bcxn prrparcd by Poter Gaid Cotporation of India Lid, Ncw rCclh[ for.crlv kno.n asNat:onal Powce Transm'ssion Corporation Led.. havlr.g its rcstercd cflicc at 10th Flocr. HcKnkufnt Charnbrs.S9. Nehru Pla-,* New Delhi 110 019. a Gencacung Company get up by tnc Govcrnment of India undtr tlEc aorc3.udAa (hcretnaafcr referred toas FOWERGRID) ma coa%ultanoa wh othe conmialuents oi V 'estcrn Rc;uw.al EOccuscs-.vBoard (WPlEB) vir., Madhya Pradesh Gujrat. Mabarshcra. Goa. Daman znd Decu. Dadra and 'sz5a li?!'Ctl.NT°C. YCA,. NMC TEC. BSE-S. A EC (bonos;ter eolkclti-cly caikd s 'corstiuentls') with i-ac to ach!cvc a slablettrflsusson sysem to the rcgion tbrougb computinxcd d3ta proccisinp and Real ionic sysitcz contro:.

And whereas, under sextion 29 (2) oUthc said Act. the POWERG;ID. bjftwc finj-hsuion oi tbc scher-c anasubmission Ibercof to the Ccntral Ekcthicai Autbority for onc ccc. is rcquited co cause such schc.Ic to be pubh:..cdin thc Official Gazelle of the Statc(s) cnneocd and in such local cwspapcrs as thc POWE-RGRID tiav cons3icrnecessary so tbat any licensec or otber pacos cstrsted may makcpreserfs.t;tions. if neces%:tv. on the schcr-.:

Now tberefore che POWERGRJD baeby publishes tbc sche in tcnts or Secetor 2S e' tekc zfc:c-.:d Ac: asoilows

ride :The Scbee sball clle - Uoided Los" Dcsparh and Camacataio Scbme for Westueo R:tIv

Stunt Ftermes:The Westeri Region comipnsci of tc cttaituaet po sw tems ot tt:c S&ates of Guir:t. .tadhra Przc

Mahubtm aod GOJ and Union Teriotics of Daman and Dic asd Dadra anid N;agar Ha%e4t. Cctntal Sector -rp-fiJULoCs of Power Grid Corporation f India Ltd. (POWERGRJD). Nuclear PC-cs Coroorauion (%PCt. Notta@i40Thema Power Corporation (NTPC) ad Narmada Control Athority. The !eheme shtil .I.Cdudc establishment ofbicrarcy Ld lDespatch Centrs witb RionAl Systcm Coodiion Centre (RSCC) at th.tisrcby and St.ue LoadDcspatcb Ceatres (SLDCs) forming biesUchy-1. Mabanrshua Stae Electricity Board is -lot participating in taisproovtt Each State Lbad despatch Cnmc (SLDC) shall bac wder its controls cluster of 5 Sb-LDC at bicrai 1a4Each Sub-LDC will tke care ofa number fRemote Taiinal Units (RTUs) at *te lowest l ! of proFoeO hicrxai;.The Central gencrating st.tiofV'sub-statid s be Controllcd b RSf:C. Tbe function ard fac.ltaics rc.lAttcd fecthe RS CC SLDCs. Sub-LDC am cowcred under tbis projcL A well kniU communsnuozionn netorkt supporls,a hirarqy sstems of Liad Despatch Centre sall f(orm part of the ScIeie whicb shazl iocludc PLCC. diCital aactr.'-:and optical fibre commuoi:atioo *ystcm..

Locadtoo.* Tbe propo*ed system invooes cooslactott of RSCC at Marol (Boinbay) and State Load Despatch Ccnucs atJambu (Guirat). Jabalpur (Mp..) sod n" (Goa). Sub-LDCs sball bc loated at JIctur. Soia and Vav iD G;runt.Bbilai lodorc. bopal and labp in C.P.C.C wil bc located at Jabalpur (POWERGRWD) All thc equipencSand (adities are propmed to be instaled io DM eaistig loezoon and as sucb no new lad is required to be acquirelunder this schemc for thc time being.

Jostl!lcadon nd Beefits:Nb c xistiog load despatcb systcm *rc over 10 ycars old. Plaos arc underway to augmcnt tbc systcms life (Or

0Ootber 6ve yeanm This is coosiderd an itetrim upSr3de and cannot be expanded to accommodae *bc growhb of20w'e sYstec. Tbc Unificd Scheco: is being planned and dcigned for growtb, upgradability and expodabtlity.

The Uo;6ed Load Despatch and Coaatocation Schcmc wil rcsult in fcwcr sysco disturbances. tasect rcstorat"0nfolltwinC disturbsoccs. bcetcr frequency und voltaces conarol. lks cquipencot damlage ddec to aboormal condtCSand a moWe depcndabk powcr supply rclicumg consumers of thc cost of outae and standby fac:lities. In the absencc ofthe Uoificd Scbchc, tbc supply cooditioe of Westcrn Region %ball necc:sarily worsen as facilitics to cflectl%'eilmoonitor. control and managc the powcr system wiU net bc availablc.Date of Commncncmet:

The work on ebc Proicet would coarnccc during 1996-97 subject to various Go'crn.ncnt of India clkr30Cc3 andtbc bene6ts from the Project would start becoaing avialabic frosn 2001-0! on-3tds.

Estimated CostThe CsUmamcd cost of the prorosed schenc is Rs. 55.51 Cteres ba'cd on IVtI h t:tric: *-i t -9 ; cr:c tc cl T %"

includes an IDC of Rs. 115.73 Crotes

totice is bercby given under section 29.9) of thc said Act xtb any liccnscc or ot!:cr ;:sp ' aa::::cicJ era' :--31:rcpeotations in rspect of thc ab3ve schm within Two facalhs from shc dagc rt po i:liiao ,: 1la> notici.i.'o3ftCr wbicb no reCpescnation will bC considCred

FOr *ad On behalf of Po-er GOid Corpoation of Id'sa L 3 i j? n TLTlUX!,.-

C.'n,. ao S1e,

Page 20: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

a ,- -- D ; =`TEE)

[A GOVE Rb.ht(1 0N INDhA ENTE(PNI5r

Regd. OKice : Hemkunt Chamoers.101h Floor. 89. Nenru Place. Nevv (N!hwt 1 10019

Rol., C/COS/n3028Weetefn Region tLoad D.epatch Communiceton Schoene kolflwcatlonft Scrwmn UAo4f Sclon 219 of tho Electcity(Supply) ACt. 194. en amended.WHEREAS. ane.esetc l As Doo*wriie seCt.280o 2 of Et.clEtryf (Suoty] ACLt 1948 as ameride0 NW sctne" 1e4fQ tOvNe oltJct,su itmn1. conandcor, ctir. of da we rr fo Ac a 0orjrCn A Co- Scrrha% 0been D.afed bty Pvf"e GAd Corporalon of iaO&S Itl. N DOtN ltdny kuio- as fato Po- Ttan.sCorDoration Ltc. lAvv_4 as r"risewc orlcCe at tOQt Ftr. Keml,u"t Chano,nc 8t9. 9N.ewu Place. tie0- 0exm*t 0O9 aGenerating Compeny set h by tte Govt. of Irv" uldf eth alcifetad Act Iveeunre retefrert lo jS POWEREAIiOl inCDosutu lICon tl moQWCDotttIu edlleiNd atuafR.Q.n Eletiy Bomn g d wRE B2 Ia' Sz .on,a PraoW C G.,ars MaI'a'a sn:IGOt. OJIIYl £ 0g. DOnea 4.Nagr He.esktsPC NCA.IrIPC.rEC. OSES.AECt hXte ecoecu.eycaae12tis Crn1bkn0.'I_mf 5 view to 1aCtwtv c IIJbIot tiefawmjdf Is5et1 mrn1 190fl lIOIt WVYlxqnccOfs OtU proIItII Wd A.S tt uftorr 1rsrerCONr04AND WHEREAS. Urae t Coon 29g Of the urd AMi . POWERGRIO. belfoe lnakut.1A ol VWg r0w'e naC SaorlS10onff.oof go Mg C4ent al leC1ncty At*a to' ConcXitrwCo. a reQUd id CJtuJG n OIenW e be OC0

1rO 01 VW4 O"f Ct

C.jette of Ihe Siatlsii conric t*d and in n agcn t-zi ne,tstoe ls p. POVVERGRIO mar consoet necesla' so 5: Jny6COnSee Of 04"e perSonnsZ 4¶t16st,eb y m l,6 e S tep IeUOon,, 9 C, 4I, j. an the tt%ernaNow THEREFOAE ftro POwEAGRPC hrsoy puOasltes the wsie mon letmrs of Secton 29C21 d4 Phe ato*gt4 ACt aI aso-,-s

Title* The Scheme chall be Cased UndM Load DtesptCh A Cornetimsmet0on SChenw telow W*tw' RaqwoniSaiatnt Fealure.Tne We s:.m Regosn COn"o.sna d4 twt consut u nt gooi-e lsysuma d4 pr Sut ee ot G4.j,ar t UGhta P,ate*bn U au'atlJlJ ancLos aria Un.onlTevnton.1 ot Dar.ntn Di uian D^adr £ hNagar Have_. Central sector o'ganr..Jt onl d Pe.se G C.c COp# r1tono0 'i. Lid (POWERGRIOI. NuCIeN Pofe' Cottpo'son (NPCI. MatI.3r% Thnert Pf'o-t. Covorta"on tN PTC. Jas *U-C.a

Conioo Avironlryfy. The scheme snilt kWruae euo.aJierit d It'snuany Lo.o ae Osoa'cn Ceno-e . n qe-.cnae SystemCooro.rnton Cenumcel rSCC]altwerclFny-larSiattLojadeso.tcoICwtitC tSo cs) toniCrflatinc . tIafaatlaElecInCty Boaro is ro, trrnc.atrig 013 o'o,eci Each Sam.toed a. satciCenCtve (SLO DcnurtUtS burnoe ts c tmr Oa cr..stOI SO-LOC at nriatcnyAll Eacn SLLDC we as ca d a inoT of Remoie Tev. uInt tATUsI 1e et .s: 'r.e 0DIoCcsc Cdr.errctry Ttht Central eriuatna slar.ovsuo.t %atrt shaMs be Cnu'4. by SCC Tne Iuv~.n ari nanc -tn ies 0u.'Clot tne RSCC. SLOCs. S.o-LDC aft covecea ugooc wts protc A wt tt corm n.caiiton nctvOn lux*oew%g a nerarCfrtSYI*n dof La4 Oes-atant CtNe. tta tormpant of d Scfe'ro wnJI 4JS 4Ae PtCC. d9Ut J.orI asnooootlJ tiDeCOmmun-calton sysIern.Location:TJie Docosea sysiem eois cona1n ot ofASCC at Ltart (8 trI asnd Sutae Lba OesoaCth Cers atJmouJs(Gulart). JJ30a0w ( P.I ancr Pona IGOa. S.ofLDCOs tt be tocited st Jetp r Sos asd Vivin Gulgrta2 8'a.. rlnCce.Bhta, -.. : Jatalpur WIU P CPCC we be located at Jatats.s POWERGRI,10 AS Isa sote and tcste *are PDooSedso be vs len U l ie e tu g loclion n as Lxt ono nw nnd is eQW lo iD te iqud utvno ,4 tdier tis It 1or vie kle bJustika lan 4 841ie0flte:The e*trsig toad deso. tc sysienms hver 1Oy0eau oId. arn wre w rwatyo sugrTwi tV*e syrtomaU lotr Wa ietF y4s*IThas is Couidered an YriV r IoQUn r ae aid CanI De c xsrw t d lao 10COmodatle VW oro-tn of Pow strremr rise UribeaSCia a bowig puanned anto re.gne tO, gnw. sdgfra6abay Ldno exanldawiy. The Unifiwd LAd DOesaCtd ari` CovtuejngcabOn S_euir..a 'eSAn b ww en serade taaen r4swidl b<eostulbances. bette (Irquency esno vofe corto. Asia aiyimrn Gaege due lod a0fnonncoiamtio anol rnore deOtrefldpow. IUOOA/reSwQ tLdI%ef ci ,l coeOd o.Q and trY ta~et In tre aosene 041he U".f-e S; Vie slb

CndtOnIot Weste*rn Aegion LIta riease worsen *as tKc. 1O e fn7lY0ecvy Prio. cntrol CIahflg. p_e; sr lyieni-i not be avartsb4eDate ot Commenu cemnThe -orn on tIo Ptofeci -Ould comnwc ounrng 19697 a.1; ttio vsnou, Coi. of ndOs ceatarces anoi the berems ttmthe P#C,ecl wouLd sUn becoing a.&Mable trom 20010 02 orrw- .Eslme-led CostTh estimated, COat 4 p prooed .twasee 517.51 C~rora ajon tvntrr O'a,4 tCd9 l1.r.i 14 ' IS VC.cetOC of Ra. I15.73 CNr.

a NOWir is h.oVrD gnwn undtto' joaon 29f2) o0 VW o4 A .r r .t oycu.e or oerw, poeww .eeosivd mar .1Jt `1WPesnLeonA intesp-oe o tie aisodschemew _^w Touorws Iow"n wbe o o/c<l L dflt M n,ohAcLaiIttwn e.- ei.C .o0 SE,Use iSt -o gy be CvUdefed

Fot ari! on Denad of Po-e. Gta Cospormon of Inas LUd. Son -iIP D TU7EJA1

_, ._ Conoe C' eeny

17

Page 21: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-11

TREE AND CROP COMPENSATION PROCEDURES

Statutory Requirements:

As per the statutory requirements (IS-5613) all the trees and bushes, includingsaplings coming in the ROW limit i.e. clearance belt of transmission lines must becut and removed. The procedure for clearing of trees and crops is as illustratedbelow.

A. Trees

Tree EnumerationPOWERGRID submits details of the route of the transmission line through the forestareas to the DFO. A joint inspection along with the forest authorities is conducted toassess the number of trees coming within the ROW and likely to be felled. A CostBenefit analysis is conducted by the forest department based on the informnationgathered.

Tree CompensationCompensation is calculated on basis of tree enumeration, tree species and anestimate of the yield. In case of fruit bearing trees compensation will be calculated onthe basis of 8 years yield. Market rates of compensation ;re assessed by therelevant govemment authorities. The total estimate is submitted for approval to theGeneral Manager of the Region. Payments are made to owners in the presence oflocal revenue authorities or village head/salpanch and respective acknowledgementsare obtained

B. Crops

Crop CompensationThis is the case when installation of towers impacts on agricuftural activity andtherefore marginal farmers. The impact is reduced to the minimumr. POWERGRIDmaintains that further marginalisation of these farmers will not occur. A detailedsurvey is conducted looking at existing crops, general crop pattems, seasonalparticulars, nature and extent of yield. This data is compiled and analysed to studythe extent and nature of impact. Format for crop compensation is similar to that oftree compensation. The compensation is in terms of yield/hectare and rate/quantityfor prevailing crops in the area. Basea on this, total compensation is calculated inconsuHation with revenue authorities. Compensation is paid to the owners and theiracknowledgement obtained.

18

Page 22: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-12

TYPICAL PLAN OF TRANSMISSION LINE TOWER FOOTING';

x

RANSM

y ISS

0N

L

NE... ............... ...X........ E

INDICATIVE MEASURES

X & Y = 10-15 METERS

a =300- 450 mm

19

Page 23: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-13

POWERGRID's SOCIAL ENTITLEMENT FRAMEWORK

POWERGRID's prime concem is to rehabilitate and resettle people affected by itsoperations. Its endeavor is always to avoid hardship to PAPs and their families throughoptions like land for land as far as possible, assistance for adoption of Income GeneratingScheme and training instead of cash because it has been experienced that cashcompensation does not fully achieve the objective of rehabilitation. POWERGRID whileimplementing the social entitlement framework gives special attention to this fact andexhaust all options before arriving at cash compensation.

POWERGRID's social entitlements within its Resettlement and Rehabilitation framework willinclude the following categories and compensation packages

(1) Loss of Land

This impact affects families' access to space for housing (homestead), agricultural landor land for shops or institutions.

(a) Loss of land for homestead may impact owners with valid titles, or customary andusufruct rights. The beneficiary unit is the family, and entitlement options offeredto PAPs will include provision of equivalent area of land subject to availabilitywithin a radius of 25 km or cash compensation. Land for compensation will beacquired from the State Govemment or willing buyer sellers at existing land prices.In case PAPs opt for cash compensation for loss of land, they will be providedcash compensation as per Indian law and rehabilitation assistance

(b) Loss of agricultural property is envisaged to impact persons with valid titles orcustomary or usufruct rights. The beneficiary will be the title hiolder who will beentitled to choose between an aHtemative land of equivalent productive potentialsubject to availability within a radius of 25km or cash compensation. The land forland option will be open only to agriculture based PAPs, rendered totally landlessby project activities or left with landholdings that are not economically viable as perthe state/district directives. Maximum limit of land will be the land ceiling limit.Land for compensation will be acquired from the State Govemrnent or voluntarysellers at existing land prices. Persons opting for land for land will not be eligiblefor any other rehabilitation measures. POWERGRID shall constitute a committeeto decide the availability of land and its purchase. In case PAPs opt for cashcompensation for loss of land, they will be provided cash compensation as perIndian iaw and rehabilitation assistance.

(c) Loss of shop or institutions land is envisaged to impact persons; with valid titles,customary or usufruct rights. The beneficiary will be the titleholder who will beentitled to cash compensation and rehabilitation assistance including preference inallotment of shop in township wherever possible.

In case of tenants and leaseholders beneficiary will be entitled to reimbursement ofunexpired lease amount and transition allowance equivalent to 1 year income asfinalised by land purchase committee.

Availability of Land for allotment to PAPs: Availability of land for persons optingfor 'land for land' shall be decided as follows:

(i) POWERGRID will take up the matter with concemed State Govemment forrelease of Govemment land for allotment to the eligible PAPs.

(ii) If Govemment land is not available, POWERGRID will purchase private landon a willing buyer and seller basis keeping in mind that the purchase of landdoes not promote any indirect displacement. The land will be purchased fromvoluntary sellers at existing rates finalised througb' negotiations.

20

Page 24: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

For purchase of private land a 'Land Purchase Committee shali be constitutedby RHQ comprising of representatives of POWERGRID, Local AuthoritiesPAPs, Gram Panchayat ur any well reputed person as rnutually agreed with thelocal authorities and PAPs

In the case of tenants, sharecroppers, leaseholders and squatters the individual willbe the beneficiary They will be entitled to choose between minimum economiclandholdings based on local standards or a cash compensation for minimumeconomic landholding + reimbursement of unexpirecd lease amoun! andrehabilitation assistance.

However, land for land optior. to tenants and leaseholders shall be made availableonly in case where owner has not claimed for this option. In case it is opted byowner, tenants and leaseholders shall be entitled for rehabiliitation measures.

(2) Loss of Structure

This category of impact includes families or units losing their houses or othercommercial, industrial or institutional structures.

(a) Loss of houses will impact families with valid title. customary or usufruct rights.The beneficiary unit is the family which will be entitled for cashcompensation at replacement cost without depreciation and rehabilitationassistance.

In the case of tenants and leaseholders the beneficiary unit will again be the familywho will be entitled to a lumpsum payment equivalent to 6 month rent to re-establish residence as finalised by land purchase committee.

In the case of squatters the beneficiary unit will again be the family who will beentitled to cost of structure on the principle of replacemnent and a iumosumpayment equivaient to 6 month, income finalised by land purchase committee to re-establish residence + rehabilitation assistance and transillion allowance as percategory-6, If they are living there 3 years prior to section 4 notification

(b) Loss of shop or institutional structures will affect units with valid titles, customary orusufruct rights. The heneficiary will be the shop or institutional unit. The beneficiaryunit will be entitled to cash compensation and rehabilitation assistance.

In case of tenants and leaseholders, the beneficiary will be the shop or institutional!unit entitled to a transitional allowance equivalent to 1 vea,r icome as finalised byland purchase comrnittee. In case of squatters, the beneficiary will be the unit andwill be entitled to a cash compensation for structure and lumpsum paymentequivalent to , year income as per state government norms finalised by landpurchase committee + rehabilitation assistance and transition allowance as percategory-6, if they are living there 3 years prior to section 4 notification.

(3) Loss of LivelihoodlTrade/Occupation

This impact affects individuals access to wage/self employment.

(a) Loss of agricultural, commercial. industrial wage employrnent impacts specificindividuals. The beneficiary individuals will be entitled to a ipackage for starting aincome generating enterprise and a transitional allowance equivalent to 1 yearincome as finalised by LPC.

21

Page 25: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

(4) Loss of Access to Common Resources and Facilities

In this category of impacts, the beneficiary is typically communities (in the case of ruralprojects) or households (jn the case of urban projects), and the losses include loss ofrural common property resources or urban civic communities.

(a) In the case of rural common property resources, the beneficiary units will behouseholds or the community entitled to replacement of common propertyresources/amenities or provisions of functional equivalence.

(b) In the case of urban civic amenities, the beneficiary units will be the households orthe community entitled to access to equivalent amenities or services as perNational Draft policy.

(5) Loss of Standing Crops and Trees

This category of impacts includes standing crops or trees for those with valid title andtenants or lessees

In all cases, the family cultivating the land wil be the entitlement beneficiary. In allcases again, the beneficiary family will be entitled to cash compensation at market ratefor crops and 8 years' income for fruit bearing trees. Payment for crop will be made tothe landowner only if there is a "no objection" celtificate from the crop cultivator.

(6) Losses during transition of displaced persons/establishments

Losses in this category include those during shifting/transport, miaintenance, andconstruction. In all categories, the family or respective commercial, industrial orinstitutional unit will be the beneficiary.

(a) For shifting and transport, the beneficiary family or the unit will be entitled toprovision of transport or cash equivalent.

(b) In the case of maintenance, the beneficiary family or the unit will be entitled tocash payment to be decided by LPC.

(c) In the case of construction, the beneficiary family or the unit will be entitled to acash payment for transport of materials.

(7) Losses to Host Communities

In this category of impact, the host community, particularly in the resettled area, itsaccess to amenities and services has reduced. The beneficiary host Community will beentitled to augmentation of resources to sustain pressure of project affected persons.

Rehabilitation Measures:

When alternate land is available but non-acceptable to eligible PAPs as per aboveprocedures or in cases where a PAP is not entitled to 'land for land' i.e. eligible only for cashcompensation as determined by Revenue Authorities, the PAP may exercise one of thefollowing options for his rehabilitation. A variety of income generation enterprise will beoffered on the basis of:(a) consultation with PAPs and local govemment(b) the socio-economic survey establishing the need for such schemes

The following are illustrative:Dairy, Poultry, Handicrafts, etc,

Dairy and Poultry are one of the most viable rehabilitation options. Such a project offers agood market for dairy and poultry products and this option is expected to prove beneficial. Insome areas, people eam their living through handirafts or other income generating schemes

22

Page 26: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

(Table -1). To encorage the PAPs and their families for taking these useful avocationsPOWERGRID will provide Rs.15000/- per family for said schemes. Howeiver the monftoryassistance will not be directly disbursed to the PAPs, but channelised through banks.

Table -1: List of Income Generating SchemeAllied agriculture Manufacture of pottery piroducts

Vegetable farming DecorativeFruit orchards Earthen pipesSocial forestry Pots and pans

Livestock rearing Fruit processing and preservationDairying Canned fruitsPoultry Chips and wafersPiggery Dry fruits/vegetablesGoat rearingSericulturePiscicultrue

Processing of cereals & pulses Carpentry and blacksmithyDal processingPapad making Bee Keeping - wax and honeyBakery productsBharbhuia, chana, dalia, manufacturing

Bhani processing of edible oil seeds Fiber productsBullock ghani Rope makingImproved power ghani Ban makingPortable power ghani

Village match Industry Bamboo and cane productsAgarbatti Manufacture of cane Gur & Khandasari

Bullock drivenHanidloom Power drivenManufacture of Laundry soap _

ShopsShops also are one of the viable rehabilitation options. A limited number of shops inSubstation area if available will be earmarked for allotment to PAPs after appropriateconsultation regarding the PAPs capability and aptitude. The capital required for operation ofshops, not exceeding Rs.15,000/- (subject to regular review and adjustment) would be madeavailable by banks as loans. Any assistance needed by PAPs in formulation of schemes forprocuring loans from banks and stabilising the same will be rendered by POWERGRID if sodesired.

Award of Petty ContractsEligible PAP will also be considered for awards of petty contracts on a preferential basis.

JobsJobs with POWERGRID: POWERGRID projects do not envisage significant jobopportunities to the local residents. However, if there is any requirement of job then PAPsshall be entitled for preferance, subject to their meeting of job requirement and specification.

Jobs with Contractors: Contractors will be persuaded to give jobs to eligible PAPs on apreferential basis where feasible.

TrainingSome members of displaced families may qualify for vocational training courses.POWERGRID can arrange for imparting suitable training. Such training will be impartedthrough the existing and available training institutions of the State and Central Govemment.The project authority may meet the cost of training of the persons who are selected fromamongst the land oustee/evictee families.

POWERGRID will ensure that all plans are approved by competent authorities; that publicconsultation takes place at necessary stages; and, that grievance redressal lis a priority.

23

Page 27: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Definitions:Household: A household is a group of persons who commonly live together and wouldtake their meals from a common kitchen.

PAPs: People who lose land, livelihood, homesteads, structures and access to resources asa result of project activities.

Family: In relation to a affected person, means,

Such person and his or her spouse, minor sons, unmarried daughters, minor brothers orsisters, father and mother and other members residing with him and dependent on him fortheir livelihood.

Nomination by PAP: The head of the family shall be asked to nominate in writing fromamong the family members whom he/she will like to get the rehabilitation assistance from thecompany. The nomination made by the head of the family generally will not be allowed tochanged except in special circumstances. But in no case, he/she will be allowed to changethe nomination more than once.

Economic Landholding: In view of regional and State specific variations in the landownership pattem, productivity, etc.. POWERGRID will adopt norms of the respective StateGovemments which will be finalised by the Land Purchase Committee.

Existing Land Price: Due to regional and state specific variations on productivity of land,land prices vary in different states and even in the same location, depending upon variousparameters. The land purchase committee shall finalise the existing land price based onnegotiations keeping in mind revenue records and other land market information.

Customaiy or Usufruct Rights: Several communities in India, includinig tribais, havetraditionally enjoyed the benefit of using, without impairing, items like land, trees etc., whichthey do not own. These customary and usufruct rights vary across the country and are welldocumented by State Govemments. However, its determination is in built in Land AcquisitionProcess, In case, they are not covered under the records for want of updation of records oreven due to ignorance, POWERGRID through its process of Land Acquisition Assessmentand Socil Assessment may be able to recognise these lapses so that interest of all theseperson are taken care off through Gram Panchyatl local authorities during assessment andsubsequent compensation. POWERGRID will adopt norms of the respective StateGovernments as per the provisions of LA Process.

Squatter : A person who settles on public land without title or a person who takesunauthorised possession of unoccupied premises or person who gets right of pasturage fromgovemment on easy terms.

Land Purchase Committee (LPC) for rehabilitation shall be formed by nomination in thefollowing steps:

* POWERGRID representative from DHQIGHQ to be nominated by the Regional head.* Representative of Local Authorities to be decided by District Administration.* Representative of PAPs to be identified and selected by themselves.* Representative of Gram Panchayat or any other person of repute as mutually agreed

with local authorities and PAPs.

Grievance/Redressal Mechanism:A committee will be set up comprising of POWERGRID, representatives of local authorities,PAPs. Gram Panchayat or any well reputed person as mutually agreed with the localauthorities and PAPs. This committee will address the grievances of the PAPs.POWERGRID will be represented by a senior official from Region/Corporate Centre. Thewell reputed person will not be same as the one in the LPC.

24

Page 28: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-14

COMPARISON: INDIAN LAW AND WORLD BANK DIRECTIVES (SOCUkL)

Comparison Criteria Indian Law (Social) World Bank(OD 4.30 & 4.20)

1. Scope/Applicability Country Specific General guiding principlesState specificProject specific

2. Schedule of SA SA loosely linked to project cycle Strict linkages between SA& project cycle (pan passu)

3. SA preparation Not specified Mandatory4. DA Outputs Not mandatory Mandatory

- Master rehabilitation - R & R planunder LA notification - IPDP

5. Definition of PAP Limited -> Inclusive Inclusive6. Tribals (Indigenous No special status regarding Special status regarding

R&R R&R7. Extent of compensation Adequacy -* Replacement Replacement cost and

Rehabilitation benefits8. Nature of compensation Limited -- *Comprehensive Comprehensive9. Public Consultation Limited -Participatory Participatory- extent Sporadic - Entire project cycle- status10. Disclosure Not required - Not mandato,y Mandatory

25

Page 29: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachmront-15

RECOGNITION OF PROJECT AFFECTED BY SOME SALIENT DOCUMENTS

Documents Project Affected Groups

Document Name Status Scope and Displaced Person Losing land Persons losing Persons HostApplicability person livelihoodl depending Persons

trade/ on CPRs andoccupation forest

resources/rno°mads/

Homestead Agriculture Agricultural Others

With others With Other (usufructlvalid valid customary/ pattatitle title holder)

1 Land Acquisitlon Act, Legislaton Acquires Land for1984 (Centre) Public Purpose' * * e

2. Naharashtra Project Legislaiion IrrigaUon and canAffected Persons (State) be madeRehabilitaton Act, 1986 applicable to * * * * e

other projects3. Madhya Pradesh Legislaton Irrigatlon, Power,

Parlyojana Ke Karan (State) Public utilityVisthapit Vyakti * * * S(Punshthapan)Adhinivam, 1985

4. Draft National Policy for Draft Policy Public Sector.Resettlement of Persons GovemmentDisplaced as a Sector andconsequence of Private Sector * * * * * *Acquisiton of Land Projects(Ministry of RuralDevelopment, 1995) _ 1 1 1

5. Orissa Rehabilitaton Policy Water Resourcesand Resettlement of ProjectsProject Affected Persons * * * *Policy, 1994

6. NGO Response to NGO Draft Public Sector,Ministry of Rural Positon GovemmertDevelopment's Draft Paper Sector and * * * * * * *Policy. 1995 Private Sector

Projects

26

Page 30: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-16

NATURE AND EXTENT OF ENTITLEMENTS RECOGNISED BY SOME SALIENT DOCUMENTS

Document Name Nature of Entitlements Extent of Entitlements

Cash Land Trade/Occupatio,n/ ' Homestead Grants/ CIvic Others Adequacy Replacemen Developmenlivelihood/training Allowances Amenitles (community t value t beneflts

benefltsresource

________ ____________ base) _ _Agricultural Others _

1. Land Acquisitlon Act, _1984 *

2. Maharashtra ProjectAffected Persons * 4*Rehabilitaton Act,1986

3. Madhya PradeshParlyojana Ke KaranVlsthapit VyakUi * * * * *(Punshthapan)Adhinlyam. 1985

4. Draft National Policy forResettement ofPersons Displaced as a * * * * *consequence ofAcquisiton of Land(Ministry of RuralDevelopment, 1995)

5. Orlssa Rehabilitatfonand ResetWement of * * * * * * * * Project AffectedPorsons Policy, 1994 _ _ _

6. NGO Response toMinistry of Rural * * * * * * * * * 0Development's DraftPolicy, 1995 , _ __

7_ POWERGRID's Sodal | * *Eiititlement Framework

27

Page 31: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment- 17

COMPARISON: WORLD BANK OD 4.30, NATIONAL DRAFT POLICY AND POWERGRID'S SOCIAL ENTITLEMENT FRAMEWORKType of Issue/ Impact World Bank OD 4.30 National Draft Policy POWERGRID's Social Entitlement Policy1. Loss of landa. Homestead

i. with valid title i. equivalent land or cash i. equivalent land or cash i. equivalent area of land subject to availability (Statecompensation at replacement compensation at replacement Govt./ Voluntary sellers at existing rate) within acost cost radius of 25 km

or cash compensation + Rehabilitation Assistanceb. Agricultural land

i. with valid title i. alternative land for PAPs based i. alternative land for PAPs I. alternative land of equivalent production potentialon agricultural practice only or based on agricultural practice subject toemployment or self employment only or employment or self -agriculture based PAPs (rendered landless byscheme or cash compensation employment scheme or cash project or left with landholdings that are notat replacement cost compensation at replacement economically viable)

cost -availability (State Govt.Noluntary sellers atexisting rate) within a radius of 25 km-maximum limit is land ceiling limit

or cash payment + Rehabilitation Assistanceii. tenants, i. alternative land for PAPs based i. alternative land for PAPs i. local standard for min. economic land holding (if

sharecroppers, on agricultural practice only or based on agricultural practice not claimed by owner) or cash payment andleaseholder, Squatters employment or self employment only or employment or self reimbursement of unexpired lease amount+

scheme or cash compensation employment scheme or cash Rehabilitation Assistanceat replacement cost compensation at

replacement cost2. Loss of structurea. House

i. with valid title i. alternate structure at i. develop plat of 60'' 90' size i. cash compensation + Rehabilitation Assistanceresettlement site or cash or 200 sq.m. with cashcompensation at replacement compensation to rebuild thecost. house + transportation

charges for building material ii. lumpsum payment equivalent to 6 mont rent asii. tenant, leaseholder ii transition allowance for new iH. transition allowance for new finalised by LPC to re-establish residence

establishment establishmentiii. Cost of structure + lumpsum payment equivalent

1ii. squatters iii. basic dwelling unit as per iii. no specific mention to 6 month income finalised by land purchaselocal norms or cash comp. commiftee to re-establish residence

28

Page 32: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Type of Issue/ Impact f World Bank OD 4.30 National Draft Policy POWERGRID's Social Entitlement Policyb Shop/ Institutions

iMth vaiid title no mention, but are covered ino mention, but are covered i cash compensation + Rehabilitation Assistanceunder PAPs I under PAPs ii transition allowance equivalent to 1 year income as

finalised by LPCii tenants. leaseholder ii no mention, but are covered ii no mention, but are covered

under PAPs under PAPs iii Cost of structure + lumpsum payment equivalentto 1 year income as finalised by land purchase

iii. squatters iii. basic dwelling unit as per iii. basic dwelling unit as per committee to re-establish structurelocal norms or cash comp. local norms or cash comp. ._..

3. Loss of livelihood/ trade/occupation

a. Wagelself employmenti. agriculture/ commercial i. job or self employment scheme i. job or self employment i. package for starting a income generating

+ cash allowance for loss of scheme + cash compensation enterprise anl transition allowance as finalised byincome during transition and as per one year income LPCreestablishment

4. Loss of access to commonresourcesa. Rural common i. replacement of CPR/ facilities i. replacement of CPRs or i. replacement CPRs/amenities or provisions of

property resources or access to equivalent services/ access to equivalent services functional equivalenceb. Urban Civic facilities or cash compensation or cash compensation as per ii. access to equivalent amenities/services

amenities as per market value market value5. Loss of standing

crops/trees for either category, only the cultivator will geta. With valid title i. compensation against damage Not mentioned compensation at market rate for crops and 8 yearsb. Tenant/lessee at market rate income for fruit bearing trees

6. Losses during transition ofdisplaced persons/establishmentsa. Shifting/Transport i. provision of transport or cash i. provision of transport or cash i. provision of transport or equivalent cash

ii. cash payment to be finalised by LPCb. Maintenance ii. no mention ii. a lumpsum grant as

assessed by the committee iii. cash for transport of materialsc. Construction iii no mention iii. cost of transportation of

_building _mierials7. Losses to Host

Commilundwisa. Amenities/Services i. augmentation of existing i. augmentation f existing i. augmentation of resources of host community to

resources to sustain the resources to sustain the sustain pressure of PAP'spressure of PAPs pressure of PAPs

29

Page 33: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-18

SUMMARY OF KEY TRENDS IN INDIAN LAWIPOLICIES

Regarding the inclusion of persons within the definition of 'PAP': The Land Acquisition at oneextreme only deals with people who lose land and have valid legal iUtes while the Draft NationalPolicy (Ministry of Rural Development) is now moving to a holistic understanding of what R&Rmeans and who a project affected person is Attachment-i 3 provides details of the same.

Regarding the extent and nature of entitements: While 'adequate compensationr was initiallythe objective of laws/policies, replacement cost and even development benefits are nowfavoured, in order to mitigate the potentially disruptive nature of project induced displacementand other adverse effects. Correspondingly, compensation has now been re-defined, andincludes grants/allowances/civic amenities, establishing a similar resource base. Attachment-14provides details on the nature and extent of compensation recognised by some salientdocuments.

Laws/policies now provide for resettlement on a community-wide basis and not on an individualbasis. Integration into host communities is also an important consideration.

Most policies now view R&R as a tme-bound activity

Cut off dates for identification of PAPs, and the formulation of eligibility criteria are! now specifiedin some of the laws.

National Acts and policies have little provision for public disclosure, consultation andparticipation, whereas the Orissa Policy and the NGO policy do.

Reaardina grievance/redressal mechanisms: The National Draft Policy provides for the seftingup of a Grievance Redressal Cell including organisations of displaced persons. Orissa policymentions constitution of Lok Adalats (altemative dispute resolution) for speedier disposal ofgrievances.

The requirement of social assessment is not mandatory under national law. Preparation of R&Rplans are required under specific State laws and some policies, but there is no parallel with theenvironmental clearance required under the EIA Notification, 1994. There is mention of a MasterRehabilitation Plan under the EIA notification but only so long as the project has adverseenvironmental impacts.

POWERGRID's environmental and social policy is based on recent and progressive trends inIndian laws.

30

Page 34: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-19ELECTRO-MAGNETIC FIELD

Power Technologies, Inc. has been requested to review POWERGRID's 132 KV, 220 KV, 400 KV and 800 KVlines with respect to conductor to ground, phase to phase and circuit to cirCUit clearances and theirappropriateness in light of present practice.Based on a review of POWERGRID's designs, we find that the phase to phase and circuit to circuit clearancesare consistent with practices used for line clearances throughout the world. The values used byPOWERGRID are generally in the middle range of that used throughout the world and are expected to providesatisfactory performance.The conductor to ground dearances are within typical limits and meet or exceed the recluirements of theNational Electrical Safety Code, American Nabonal Standard Insitute, C2, as shown on Figure.

16

14 Rule 232C\ y ~~Rule 232D

12 _.1 \g/ bt8u12~~~~~~~

10

68 >° 400 220System Votag (kW) - Clearances as a Fundon of System Voltage

Analysis of POWERGRID Transmission Line ClearancesThe analysis was based on the following data as supplied by POWERGRID.800 KV S/c Line

Configuration - HorizontalConductor Bundle - Quad CSR Bursitis (35.1 mm id)Maxm. conductor sag - 14.56 mPhase to phase spacing - approx. 15 m.Ground clearance - 12.4 m ( as per IE rules):15 m (maintained to limit max. electric field to 10 KVlm)Right of way - 85 m

400 KV S/c LineConfiguration - HorizontalConductor Bundle -Twin ACSR Moose (31.77 mm dia)Maximum conductor sag - 12.87 mPhase to phase spacing - 10 to 12 mGround clearance - 8.84 m (as per IE rules)Right of way - 52 m

400 KV D/c LineConfiguration - VerticalConductor Bundle - Twin ACSR Moose (31.77 mm dia)Maximum conductor sag - 12.87 mPhase to phase spacing - 8 to 9 mCkt. to ckt. spacing - 12 to 14 mGround clearance - 8.84 m (as per IE rules)Right of way - 52 m

220 KV D/C LineConfiguration - VerticalMaximum conductor sag -approximately 9.8 mPhase to phase spacing - 5 to 5.5 mCkt. to ckt. spacing - approximately 10Ground clearance - 7.015 m (as per IE rules)Right of way - 35 m

132 KV D/c LineConfiguration - VerticalConductor - ACSR Panther (21 mm dia)Maximum conductor sag - approximately 6.6 mPhase to phase spacing - approximately 4 mCkt. to ckt. spacing - approximately 7 mGround clearance - 6.1 m (as per IE rules)Right of way -27 m

31

Page 35: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Affachment- 20

POWERGRID's FUTURE INVESTMENT PROGRAMMEFuture Investment Programme

(RS. In Millions)Project Name Lengt Project Financial Implications Total %

S.No. (KM) (Rs.) Forest Forest A+R+O A+R+O Total No. Total Total EAMP+Involvement Comp. (Length Comp. EAMP of families SAMP SAMP(Length In (Rs.) In km) (Rs.) Comp. S/S Comp. (Rs.)

(1) (2) (3) (4) km) (6) (7) (8) (Rs.) (Rs.)_______________ _______ ___ _ _ _ _ (9-6+8) (10) (11) (12) (13.9+12) (14

1) Cogentrix' 625 3530 10 1.0 615 24.6 25.6 2 100 20 44.6 1.26

2) Vlndhyachal TL 1271 9837 11 1.1 1260 50.4 51.5 4 200 40 90.4 0.91

3) Nathpa-Jhakarl 805 1101.4 52.3 52.3 752.7 30.11 35.34 3 150 30 65.34 0.6

5) IC Shauour - Moga 300 572.7 30 3.0 270 10.8 13.8 1 50 10 23.8 0.4

6) Kathalgurl 800 768.8 9 0.9 791 31.64 32.54 3 150 30 62.54 0.8

7) Gandhar 555 206.5 4 0.4 551 22.04 22.44 2 100 20 42.44 2.05

8) Ranglt 182 47.8 9 0.9 173 5.92 7.82 1 50 10 17.82 3.72

9) Uri-Srinagar 104 294.7 19 1.9 85 3.4 5.3 1 50 10 15.3 0.52

10) Dulhasil 270 227.1 79 7.9 . 191 7.64 15.54 1 50 10 25.54 1.12

11) Chamera-Kishanpur 180 126.4 24 2.4 156 6.24 8.64 1 50 10 18.64 1.47

12) Tehrl-Meerut 384 508.1 36 3.6 348 13.92 17.52 1 50 10 27.52 0.54

13) Doyang 313 119.6 72 7.2 241 9.64 16.84 1 50 10 26.84 2.2

14) Ranganadi 170 149.1 39 3.9 131 5.24 9.14 1 50 10 19.14 1.3

1I5) Balipara-Tenga 90 26.1 85 8.5 5 0.2 8.7 1 50 10 18.7 7.16

16) RAPP- B 432 173.9 42 4.2 410 1e.4 20.6 2 100 20 40.6 2.33

17) Kaiga 100 42.8 46 4.6 54 2.16 6.76 1 50 10 16.76 3.91

18) S.Asam 4B8 95.31 52 5.2 436 17.44 22.64 2 100 20 42.64 4.47Augmentation I __ _ __ __ _

) Kopi 80 25.7 17 1.7 63 2.52 4.22 1 so 10 14.22 5.53

20) Agartala 110 25.0 59 5.9 51 2.04 7.94 1 50 10 17.94 7.17

121) |V;ndhyachal ll 1827 733.6 131 1.3 1814 72.56 73.86 7 350 701 143.86 1.96

32

Page 36: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Project Name Lengt Project Financial Implications Total %

_ ________________ h ___h_I

S.No. (KM) (Rs.) Forest Forest A+R+O A+R+O Total No. Total Total EAMP+Involvement Comp. (Length Comp. EAMP of families SAMP SAMP

(Length In (Rs.) In km) (Rs.) Comp. S/S Comp. (Rs.)

(i) (2) (3) (4) km) (6) (7) (8) (Rs.) (Rs.)

(5) _ (906+8) (10) (I1) (12) (13-9+12) (14)

22) Jeypore-Gajuwaka 215 696.8 3 0.3 212 8.48 8.78 1 50 10 18.78 0.3

23) Dhauliganga 300 241.5 89 8.9 211 8.44 17.34 1 50 10 27.34 1.13

24) Kayamkulam I 130 129.2 - - 130 5.2 5.2 1 50 10 15.2 1.18

25) Talechar 11' 1930 2651.2 91 9.1 1839 73.56 82.66 7 350 70 152.66 0.6

26) Rihand - II- 2065 418.9 58 5.8 2007 80.28 86.08 8 400 80 166.08 3.9

27) Ramagundam lil 1070 494.9 27 2.9 1041 41.64 44.54 4 200 40 84.54 1.7

28) Nippon Denro 900 3800 18 1.8 882 35.28 37.08 3 150 30 67.08 1.76

29) CEPA 9070 78470 498 49.8 8572 342.88 392.68 11 5500 1100 1492.68 1.9

Note:-

1. A +R+O - Agricultural + Revenue + Other Lands2. Forest Compensation - I lakh per Km3. A+R+O Compensation 0.4 Lakh per Km4. No. offam(lles per S/S - SofamUles5. A4MP Compensation - 2Lakhs per family6. * Forest Area invoivment is based on bee line. For rest theforest area involvment is actual.

33

Page 37: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

*-* efd60-Jess!H 1J 0111 I 4

o:oi. - zqe__feund u! SIS eN-indlel' .016 -LL . 009 we6Ljeaaep6eN-!sJqEl ';

0 98Z OSS OOS *. 'ell ss a/ eipauualul 'a a

s/s, , ,epe.uelul - ndeH .P

09L 0,08 . 0&ZL indier -AlleAql a

0 1.6 SZL OS . indiej -AGIqeA q

t'0b 0~~~~~~' 0z Ae,GIPA qI-SdJ.Vd30 '................. I . ................................. . ...... . ............. .. .. I .......................NM 099XS) -. e;S Vd33 JO walsAS uoi

............. ...... ................... . .. . . . .... . . ,._ ,, ............. , . ................................. ..... ,...... , ..... ...

Vd3DI!N . I!N . 00£ ajoe6uea-4oo -

I' j j i'N 00-- OS---- oi ogpeqea.H

9 86 0 00 peq8e HA-JfleipU8 e. ~~~~~~~oluea-uoddIN *

8 9t 0 6 . LI. .86BS eunUe6eN-wewwue4>1 iIN . I.'N * 00£ GJol8§e9..fr4o( *.-i

iiN IiN oo0 A.qooj-peqeJipAH q

9 £6 08i 00 p8q0i -flBp U64 j .. . Ilp~~wepunBewrn. .

I!N I!N . 91. ledleWflpfl-WGeS. a09Z OS * LL uu ieS-eaoe6ue8

80 ot * LZ seJpeI"d4deppn3

t 9Zt O Z89 . OO eIOle6Ueg-18L4318J. q

............................... .. . .. . . ., _ ~ .. . .. .. , .. . . . . . . . _ . ... . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

......................... . .. ............... ,_.. .._ .. .... __. .. .. .

-. ... .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~".......

IIN I~~ ~ ~~~'N OLI, !eIeS punwe6eN4-weww43I8 eIIN ooe g~~~~~~~~~~ioBi4- oej

pOAIOAUI 4C1A15 S tsJoS *~ IO 4tB 'e U!) OJd jO OWEN . t °NS

seR lseioj oqX 5u,sn (Aeuns Gull 009 0141 Aq pae;snalea uooq Ga814

SI!BlGp JGaGMoH ~ola Se mno peweouee aq iou GABI4 sauil oseq1 .ioj salnOa IM JO sAeMns

PIaGI GOUGLI Ga lIaUGI 018 seuql poleposse pue MGU a e s13erold uoissiwsueWI 5u!Mol,oJ Gui.

:sia,Cojd MON 'Z

Lfl6uei ainolGIIIuG SI! U! pUIBI ISGIJo paeiepep Aue G6UUJU! lou Saop 1! 18141 ABeM e 4aons U! p0138189 uGGq9814 ioofoad sai1 Japun SOUII uolsslwusue.i 41oq ai.g sO olnoi GLQ :sn;u;s ezuejee: lsoaJo-

W)1 99 1416uGI 'uoWp3-W8IrnIWBjA8)4 qSW)1 S9 LI1§uGI 'woIIed-Wo eqneAPe> e

i3a!oJd welnMlweAe)4 Lfl!M PGie!ooSSe SGU!I UO!SS!WSUBJj: l9(OJd uoisslwlsueJl wueIrbiwBAe) L

:MOlGq palsii aJe cOOZ .ieaA Gill oldn 11 - dOSd Jo SI!BIGP 8141

(Il-dasd)

11 -1:)31O)Id 1N3VddO1A3G3 V431SAS U:11I19J3MOd bIO S1IViBG

Az- 1uOwqwJJev

Page 38: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Sc

I1-dGSd Ul4Ml s)o8foJd atl1 1o dWIVS PuedWV3 a84l lo Sisco uoilesuad woo paTew!isG lo sp!e1ap sapnfluI M8!JGAO I4J OZ luaW4oellvU! UA!6 Si sjao!ojd ajninj jol awwei6o0d IUDWISaAu! s,al8gIN2Aod J0 M8IAJSAO tPV

,paWwqns aq ilm 096 L 'pv (uoile,jsuoo) isajod w4l JapunleAoJdde s,eipul Jo IuOeWWAoo 6Suluelqo jol lesodoid isajol e AaAjns a41 jeuy paleilpu!ueaq seR UO!1eo!-1UeA plaLi pue AaAjns paeeaa v -(sisaJo; Jo eq 909C Al8ew!xojdde)seaje isajoj 46nou4l ssed WHM a8ul Jo swuu V69 Aluo 'SW 966'SI J0 4t6ual au!l leloi e lo ino

IIN I!N 3.Dld3 . LIN - lN . 3UD1uM *6I!N I!N 96£ .pe6l4qe le - indue): jI!N I!N indue> - pueq! . a

....................................... ................................... .... ................ ................... .. . .... .. .................... _ _..._.

8 &0Z 0 ' OZ .ioieueg - qedeppno p...................... ........... ..... ...... . ....... ..... .................................... ......................... ...................................... ...................... --

09S . 0 . OS indiapue4q - indieH o........................................ ............................. ._.... -- -----......... ...... ,.

9 E6 0 81 . 009 . WRSqGG - eP5eN --U-- q................................. I.............................................. .............. ............................. ................... ............___ . ....................................... ...............

Z,6Z 99 0t le4OeSt4PUIA - PueqiH e....................................... ........................ ........ ,,... ........................ ;._4._ . ;..................................... ....

11- PuV4! . 9

I!N . N 001 ajosAW - WeSseH I........................................................... .............. ...................... ..... . ... . ............ . ... ........ .... ............ ;..___ ... i_......... __._......._

IN . .N - OZ ajosAVy - uesseH a....... if................... ........... . ............................... - - --- -------------------.............. __........ .....

I!N l091 aJoleSue8 - uesseH t P............................... ....... ............................. ............ . _._ . ... ...... . . . ............. .............. ..........----- i--

0 9Z O'S . 061 uesseH - xplua6oe 0................................ ................... . ............... .................. .......... . ....... . . . . ................ . .. _. ......... ..........

OIN OIN OZ jewaw) - xuJuaIUoD q............. i .... .......... .. .. . .... ..... ........ .. ... ~. _........ ... ,_.... .... ............ ... .. .. .. .... ... .. ......... ..... ...... ................... ........ F--. ..... .

I!N . I!N . SC iole6uej - xu4u96o3 ae............. -0 ^ x!iua603

.paglu9p! ION u0I6a uWa4lfnos pue UJW41JON uw sMiutPu3 o........ ................. ........................ ........... ......................... ,.................. . ._ -, ..................................8 ZL . 0 tL Q 9Z . [OS'-8JOpu( u

b88 . - LOL IOvZ ep6eN -!sJeBl wI!N IN 09£ we6480 - ePIeN

......... I................. ........................ . ......................................... -..... ---. .- ....................................................

988 . OL . o0z ep6eN-!sJell g................................................ ............................ . _._. ...... . _._ .. _.__ .L.............................. ......

0 989Z 0 99 009 !SJBf1 - SJS a9eipawJalul....................... .............. ................ . ........ .;............. ....... ........... .. ... .......... . ... ....... ....

S/S aleipawialul-indie8 .i....................................... -. -............................................. . ..........................................

09Z 09 OS81 epuOd-Jnde41-OA '.......................... . ........... i.......... . j.._............ _..4__....... ............. .. - -j-----------------------

tVoL o0Z i inde84o>-lndelo0s 4................. .................... . .......... ......... ............. j.. ............... ....... ............... ................. ............ .......................... i.......... ...... ;

V 9£ O L 98. JndeIo4S-JndeJpue 4 I

0991. O O os8 jndejpueLjo-jndie8 a................ *...................... .......... ................ +;.......... _;

016 SLL OSZ Jndieg-AaneA ql P....... '............................................................... ................ .. ........................................ ...... ..

9 1£ O.8 00K1 ajoIe6ueeA.loog-Aa,IeA ql a0 9Le . 0 08 . 0~0 L indie-AaIleA ql q.............'' '''''''''' .................... ......................................' - ---''''''''-------------'i- -*....................- ... ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,j

MIN I!N OZ AalleA ql-Sd. Vd33 ) e..................................... .......... fi i Y G i. " ..... . . .. . .. ......... . ..... __..... ._ .............

(MW 099 X 9. ) O6e1S OleuwIt n uVd3Z) Jo0 UleAS uOIssIwsueli 9eH ul W)4 ul . u)A U I

POAIOAUl 4OP4SS PJO- 4)6u0a OUfl -1od 0aWiEN O °N S

Page 39: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-22

Detailed Process of A Typical POWERGRID Transmission Project

Milestones Objectives Process Responsibility ProductDecision1. Project Conceptualisation

1. Project Identification . To identify & conceptualise the * Identify project in consultation with CEA/Plg. * Engg. Dept.project studies Comm. I REBs/SEBs, etc.

- Demand-Supply Analysis- Beneficiaries/Subscribers- Technical Configuration- Approximate Costs * Engg. Dept. * Brief Project Report

* Prepare Brief Project Report* To attain consensus on scope and * Discuss with REBs & SEBs individually & collectively on * Engg. Dept. * Consensus on

extent of feasibility studies modalities of line maintenance scope and extent of* Interact with Funding Agency for posing the project * Corp. Plg. Dept. feasibility studies

2. Feasibility Studies * To prepare the project Feasibility * Evaluate feasibility of project * Engg. Dept. * Feasibility ReportReport - Need & Priority Assessment * Corp. Pig. Dept.

- Technical Options * Env. & Soc. Mgt.- Route Options (BEE Line Survey) Dept.- Environmental & Social Screening & Scoping- Economic/Financial analysis- Implementation Schedule

3. Preliminary * To obtain approvals from the * Submit FR to Internal Management * Engg. Dept * IntemalApprovals Intemal Management, CEA and FA - Final approval of projects < Rs.50 crores * Corp. Pig. Dept. Management

- Approval for further processing of projects * Env. & Soc. Mgt. Approval> Rs.50 crores Dept.

* Submit FR (with Internal Management approval) to CEA * Conditional Techno-* Issue of Notification under Section 29(2) of Electricity Economic ClearanceSupply Act by CEA subject to:

- Forest Clearance- Complience under

Sec. 29(2)notification

- Concurrence ofconsttuents

- Identficabon ofFunding Agency

* Submit FR (with Internal Management approval) for pre- * Corp. Pig. Dept. . Appraisal ofappraisal by Funding Agencie- Funding Agencies

36

Page 40: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Milestones F Objectives Process Responsibillty ProductDocion

II. Project Planning

1. Reconnaissance & * To finalise the most optimal route * Reconnaissance/Walk Over survey * Engg. Dept. * Map with all routes

Preliminary Survey on the map - Walk Over all optional routes identified during BEE line * Env. & Soc. Mgt. Verfied and optimalsurvey Dept route validated

- Record salient features 5 km on either side of routes * DHQidentified

- Verify critical issues eg. river, hill, rail, road, power line,telephone line crossing etc.

- Finalise optimal route on map * Map with final route,* Select optional Sub-Station si!hs * Engg. Dept. tower points and all* Undertake preliminary field survey . DHQ details

-Fix angle tower points on topo sheets along route delineated 50 m on either sideduring walk over survey of centre line

-Finalise angle tower points on ground and map- Finalise type of angle towers (B,C,D)- Record all details 50 m on either side of center line on map

2. Environmental * To prepare environmental * Prepare Forest Proposal for forest areas * Env. & Soc. Mgt. * Environmental

Assessment & assessment and management * Undertake environmental review for other areas based on Dept. assessment and

Management plans for the project environmental screening and scoping and suggest appropriate * Engg. Dept. management plansPlanning management measures * DHQ for transmission

lines and sub-stations

3. Concurrence of * To obtain concurrence of all a Negotiate with beneficiary SEBs individually and Power * Sys. Opr. Dept * Agreements with

Constituents project constituents Generating companies on final agreements * Corp. Pig. Dept. Constituents* To obtain Forest Clearance * Submit Forest Proposal to state Govemment * Env. & Soc. Mgt. * Land demarcated for

- CCFINodal office/ Secr. Forest Dept. compensatory* Forest Proposal to MoEF for conditional approval afforestatlon

- Approval by Advisory Committee * Final Forest- Transfer of land for compensatory afforestation Clearance by MoEF

* Forward Compliance report by State Govemment to MoEF forFinal Forest Clearance

37

Page 41: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Mliestones Objectives Process Responsibility Product/DecisionIlI.Project Approvals

1. Pre-PIB * To obtain approval from Pre-PIB * Submit detailed FR to Pre-PIB * Corp. Pig. Dept. * ProjectRecommendation - J. Secr. Min.of Power Convenes and checks concurrence of * Engg. Dept. recommendation by

constituents notification under section 29 * Env. & Soc. Mgt. Pre-PIB for- Pig. Comm. checks consistency with 5 year plans Dept. consideration by PIB- MoEF checks environmental (forest) issues- MoF checks capability to mobilise resources- MoPI checks implementation schedule

2. PIB * To obtain approval from PIB * Submit detailed FR with recommendation of Pre-PIB to PIB * Corp. Plg. Dept. * ProjectRecommendation - Chaired by Secr. Expenditure * Engg. Dept. recommendation by

- Represented by Secr. Power * Env. & Soc. Mgt. PIB for consideration- Represented by Secr. of above Ministries Dept. by CCEA- All issues finalised and firmed up

3. FA * To obtain approval from funding * Submit detailed FR with recommendation of Pre-PIB for * Corp. Plg. Dept. . Project approved byagencies approval by FAs FAs for loan

- Techno-economic scrutiny effectiveness- Environmental scrutiny- Social scrutiny- Financial Scrutiny- Concurrence of constituents

4. CCEA Approval * To obtain approval from CCEA * Submit detailed FR with recommendation of PIB and * Corp. Plg. Dept. * Project approved byacceptance by FA for fund to CCEA * Engg. Dept. CCiA and- Chaired by Prime Minister recommended for- Represented by Ministers President's order- Economic scrutiny of the project

5. GOI . To obtain formal approval of the * Submit updated FR with recommendation of CCEA to * Corp. Pig. Dept. * Project approval byGOI President's Office. GOI

38

Page 42: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Milestones Objectives Process Responsibility | ProductJDecison

IV. Detailed Deslgn & Tendering1. Detailed Surveys * To freeze route alignment and fix * Select survey contractors and award work * RHQ * Survey contracts

tower points awarded

* Undertake detailed field surveys * DHQ- Mark ground profile on topo sheet- Check ground profile with field surveys using dumpy level

and mike necessary changes on topo sheet* Fix spots and heights (attachments) for tensionand suspension towers

2. Social Assessment * To assess SAMP and appoint * Select and oppoint external agency for the SAMP, If required * Env. & Soc. Mgt. * Agency appointed

and Management extemal agency, If required Dept. for SAMP* Cont. Ser. Dept.

Planning* To prepare social assessment and * Negotiate, finalise and document compensation and other * Env. & Soc. Mgt. * SAMP for

management plans for transmission management measures Dept. transmission lines

lines * Ext. Agy.

* To prepare social assessment and * Notify under Land Acquisition Act * Env. & Soc. Mgt. * Social assessment &

management plans for sub-stations * Undertake land acquisition census Dept. management plans* Assess social Impacts of acquisition * Ext. Agy. for sub-stations* Negotiate, finallse and document compensation and other * DHQ

management measures

3 Design, Estimates & * To prepare designs and estimates * Design and estimate transmission line, sub-station and other * Engg. Dept. - Design and

Finalisation of components * Cont. Ser. Dept. estimates report

Specifications -Typical components * Corp. Mgt. Group-Special components * DHQ

* To finalise specifications and . Prepare specifications and tender documents for various * Engg. Dept. * Tender

prepare tender documents packages 0 Cont. Ser. Dent. documents- Tower package- Conductor & Earthwire package- Earthw1re)conductor accessories package- Sub-station packages

4 Tenderng and * To tender, award work to * Issue Notice Inviting Tenders d Engg. Dept. * Contracts awarded

Award of Contracts contractors * Proponents submit bids/open bids * Cont. Ser. Dept. for execution of work* Evaluate bids (Technical & Commercial) * Fin. Dept* Negotiate with short-listed parties * DHQ* Obtain Management Approval & Award Contracts

39

Page 43: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Milestones Objectives Process Res onsIbil ProductlDecislonV. Project Implementatlon1. Check Surveys * To pegmark tower points on the * Undertake check surveys * Engg. Dept. * Peg marks on

ground - Peg mark on ground location of towers * RHQ, DHQ ground for towers2. Execution of EAMP * To undertake environmental and * Execute EAMP a Env. & Soc. Mgt. * EAMP and SAMP

and SAMP social management works as - Clearance for transmission line ROW Dept. executedprescribed in EAMP and SAMP - Ccompensatory afforestation * Auth. Agy /

* Execute SAMP EXT. Agy- Pay compensation to PAPs of transmission lines * RHQ- Deposit compensation and take possession of land for * DHQsubstation- Execute R&R measures

3. Tower erection & * To erect the towers and string * Construct Foundations * Engg. Dept.stringing transmission lines -Soil Investigations * Cont. Ser. Dept.

- Foundation classification * RHQ-Excavation, stub setting and Concreting * DHQ

* Erect Towers * Engg. Dept.- Transport of materials * Cont. Ser. Dept.- Erection of towers * RHQ-Tightening and punching * DHQ

* String transmission lines * Engg. Dept. * All towers erected-Hoistinging of insulator strings * Cont. Ser. Dept. with tr. lines strung-Lay out Earthwire and conductors * RHQ and accessories- Final sagging and Fixing accessories * DHQ installed

4. Sub-Station * To construct substations * Construct core substation and install equipment * Engg. Dept.Construction -Control room * Cont. Ser. Dept.

-DG set & FFPH building with water tank * Opr. Ser.-Switchyard & cable trenches * RHQ-Auto truaisformer/ shunt reactors * DHO

* Construct support infrastructure * Substation- Staff quarters, Admnistration and non residentialbuildings constructed and- Water supply, sewerage, storm water drainage, and equipment

approach roads, etc. installed- Switchyard- Township lighting

5. Testing & * To test and commission the * Test all project components * Opr. Ser.Commissioning transmission line and substation - Lines * RHQ

- Substation . DHQ* Undertake appropriate corrective measuresCommission the . Project tested &

project commissioned

40

Page 44: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Milestones Ob ectives Process Responsibility ProductlDeclslon

V. Operation & Maintenance1. Transmission Lines * To ensure efficient and reliable * Continuously monitor transmission lines and sub-stations for * RLDC * System availability

and Sub-Station operation of transmission lines and proper operation * CPCC / DHQ as per POWERGRID

Operation sub-stations MOU signed withGOI(> 98%)

2. Preventive * To identify any defects in the lines * Patrol the lines and towers, regularly to identify defects of * RHQ * All defects Identifled

Maintenance and substations components: * DHQ and classified- Foundation * Opr. Ser.- Tower &Hardware fittings & insulators- Conductors & Earthwire- Electrical clearance

* Maintain substation components as per schedule * RHQ-AC plant, Battery system ,Bus Bar * DHO-Capacitance Voltage Transformer * Opr. Ser.- Curcult Breaker, Current transformer, DG set- Flre protection system- Isolators & earthing switch-Lightening arrestors, LT switchgears- PLCC system, Protection system-Shunt reactors

* To restore all defects * Restore non-shut down defects as soon as possible . RHQ /DHQ . All defects restored. Opr. Sor.

* Rest. shutdown defects within min.shutdown time- Request for shut down- Mobilise material and personnel-On receipt of shut-down, repair immediately

VII. Project Review1. Monthly Review * To monitor project work * Monitor project work * Engg. Dept . Monthly review

- Supply of material * Cont. Ser. Dept. report-Type of material . Env. & Soc. Mgt.-Construction ,Erection and Stringing work Dept.- EAMP & SAMP RHQ H RHQ/

2. Annual Review To review performance of project * Review performance of the project . Engg. Dept. * Annual review of. - Technical evaluation E Cnv.&Soc..Mgl. projoct as part of

-Enviromnitiental evaluation Dept. POWERGRID-Social evaluation * Fin. Dept.,RHQ Annual Report-Financial evaluation

41

Page 45: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-23

KEY MILESTONES OF A TYPICAL POWERGRID TRANSMISSION PROJECT

Milestones Time Required (Months)Minimum Maximum Most

LikelyI. Project Conceptualisation

1. Project Identification 1 3 32. Feasibility Studies 3 6 53. Preliminary Approvals (BOD, CEA & FA appraisal) 3 15 9

II. Project Planning1. Reconnaissance & Preliminary Survey 9 18 152. Environmental Assessment & Management Planning 6 15 123. Concurrence of Constituents 3 18 15

III. Project Approvals1. Preliminary Public Investment Board (Pre-PIB) 3 18 62. Public Investment Board (PIB) 3 12 63. Funding Agencies (FA) 33 33 334. Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) 3 18 65. Govemment of India (GOI) I 2 2

IV. Detailed Design & Tendering1. Detailed Survey 3 18 122. Social Assessment & Management Planning 18 30 273. Design, Estimates & Finalisation of Specifications 3 18 124. Tendering, Award of Contract & Monitoring 3 9 6

V. Project Implementation1_ . Check Surveys 3 9 62. Execution of EAMP and SAMP _ _ -+

3. Tower Erection & Stringing 12 24 154. Sub-Station Construction 12 24 125. Testing & Commissioning 3 6 3

VI. Operation & Maintenance _

1. Grid Operation -2. Preventive Maintenance -

VIl. Project Review1. Monthly Review _ _2. Annual Review _

Note: Maximum and Minimum time for project milestones derived from POWERGRID's pastexperience.

42

Page 46: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment 24a

ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES AND ROUTE SELECTION CRITERIA FORPOWERGRID'S PROJECTS

(a) Transmission Line:

A transmission line system is developed along the guidelines issued by the Central ElectricityAuthority. The system is designed by the System Engineering Group of POWERGRID inconsultation with CEA. While designing the new system, the existing transrnission systemand available options, i.e.upgradation of existing AC transmission lines; and adoption ofMulti-voltage level and Multi-circuit transmission ines; are considered based on cost,reliability, energy losses, down time, ROW requirement and anticipated environmentalproblems.

The System Operation Group of POWERGRID develops a transmission systeem comprisingof different lines, voltages, type (single or double circuit) and their end point based on:

- Power flow studies- Short circuit studies- Stability studies including transient stability, voltage stability and steady state oscillatory

stability- EMTP studies to determine switching/temporary overvoltages.

The scheme is then submitted to CEA for approval. On getting an 'in principle" approvalfrom CEA, POWERGRID initiates planning for implementation of the scheme

Environmental and Social Issues

Besides information on technical aspects, POWERGRID also conducts a Reconnaissancesurvey (Walkover survey) to collect data on likely environmental and social issues. Theaspects on which information is gathered include:

- Nature of terrain likely to be traversed by the transmission lines i.e. wetland, hilly terrainetc.

* Likelihood of buildings of historical/cultural importance, airports, railway crossings, rivercrossings, etc. near the transmission line route.

* Presence of access roads/ field bunds to approach tower locations.* Likelihood of forests, National Parks, Wildlife Sanctuaries etc. in the transmission line

route. If so, the likely number of trees to be felled. species and age.* Possibility of setting up extra high towers to avoid tree felling.* Likelihood of the line being routed through community lands or public utilities such as

playgrounds, schools, etc.

The inherent flexibility of route selection enables POWERGRID to avoid environmentally andsocially sensitive areas or to take necessary mitigation measures as elaborated in the ESPP.Construction in forest areas commences only after approvals from concemed StateGovt./MOEF.

(b) Substations:

A sub-station site is selected after careful scrutiny of data from at least two to threealternative sites. The POWERGRID utilses a standard format for obtaining information onsub-station site altematives.(Attachment-24a). Different altematives are compared and thebest possible site with a minimum number of project affected persons is selected 'or sub-station.

43

Page 47: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-24b

FORMAT FOR COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF SITES FOR SUB-STATIONS

SI.No. Criteria Site-I Site,Il Site-lIl

1.0 Land1.1 Size (Acre)

(Mtr. x Mtr.)1.2 Govt.PrivatelForest land1.3 Agriculture/Wasteland1.4 Development1.5 Approximate cost1.6 Type of soil1.7 No. of owners1.8 Environment/Pollution in the vicinity1.9 Location with reference to nearest town1.10 H.F.L. Data1.11 Diversion of Nallah/Canal required1.12 Slope1.13 Extent of levelling required1.14 Land acquisition feasibility1.15 Rate of Govt. land1.16 No. of owners1.17 Exten. of approach1.18 Plannec. unplanned development1.19 Size of sites1.20 No. of families displaced1.21 Required Govenmment value1.22 Level of site with ref. to road level1.23 Distance from sea shore2.0 Approach2.1 What are the Obstacles in reaching site2.2 Approach road2.3 Length of approach road2.4 Distance from main road2.5 Unloading facility at Railway Station2.6 No. of Culverts required3.0 Community Facilities3.1 Drinking Water3.2 Drainage3.3 a) Post Office

b) Telephonec) Telex

3.4 Market3.5 Security3.6 Amendability3.7 Availability of construction water3.8 Availability of water3.9 Nearest EHC line3.10 Length of line between

this site & nearest substation3.11 Length of line estimate3.12 Additional crossings3.13 Frontage for line take off3.14 Telephone/Telegraph line4.0 Others

44

Page 48: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

A ttachment-25a

CHECKLIST FOR INSPECTION OF TRANSMISSION LINESNON-SHUT SHUT DEFECT MONTH

DOWN DOWN DATEFOUNDATION

A 1 Soil erosion/uneven settlementA 2 Any crack/damage to foundationA 3 Any crack/damage to retaining wall/revetmentA 4 Missing/Damage/Earthwire/StripA 5 Earth Cutting from vicinity of foundation

TOWERB 1 Damaged/Missing Member BWL

B 2 Damaged/Missing Member AWLB 3 Damaged/Missing nutsbolts BWL

B 4 Damaged/Missing nutsbolts AWLB 5 Danger plate missingB 6 Number plate missingB 7 Phase plate missingB 8 Protective coating disappearedB 9 _ Step bolts missingB 10 Foreign material on Tower viz birds nest

HARDWARE FITTINGS & INSULATORSC I Surface pollutionC 2 Unusual deflection of stringC 3 Flash over/Burning markC 4 No. of fitting damageC 5 No. of disc damage

CONDUCTOR AND EARTHWIRED I Strands cut and openD 2 Loose jumpers of conductor

I___________ D 3 Hanging earthwireD 4 Dislocated/Loose VD of conductor

I__=__X____| D 5 Missing VD of Conductor|__________ lD 6 Dislocated/Loose VD of earthwire________ _ ~ LD 7 Missing VD of earthwire

_ D 8 Spacers MissingD 9 Spacers Dislocated/LooseD10 Jumper/Hard Spacer missingD 11 Jumper/Hard spacer loose/dislocatedD 12 Copper bonds missingD 13 Copper bonds dislocated

ELECTRICAL CLEARANCEE 1 Details of trees causing/may cause problems

E 2 Infringement in clearance of bottom conductors to grcundE 3 Infringement in clearance of earthwire to conductor

E 4 Any new construction seen within the lineE 5 Well blasting below the line

Patrolling done by -SignatureCounter Signature by Line Section I/C

1) Comments with signature of Line Section Incharge Date

45

Page 49: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-25b

CHECKLIST FOR INSPECTION OF SUB-STATIONS

SL. ACTIVITY TEST RESULTS TO SID PERIODNO BE APPROVED BY1 AC PLANT1.1 AHU1.2 Compressors _

1.3 Condenser Unit1.4 Cooling Towers _

1.5 Electrical Motor _

1.6 LT Panels1.7 Water Treatment2 BATTERY SYSTEMS3 BUSBARS4 CAPACITANCE VOLTAGE

,TRANSFORMER5 CIRCUtT BREAKERS5.1 Air Blast CB5.2 CB Operation _

5.3 Control Cabinet _

5.4 Measurement5.5 SF6 CB6 CURRENTTRANSFORMER7 DGSET1 8 I FIRE PROTECTION _

8.1 Compressor8.2 Deluge System8.3 Diesel Engine8.4 Electrical Panel _8.5 Fire Alarm System8.6 Fire Extinguish8.7 General8.8 Hydrant System8.9 Jockey Pump .8.10 Motors8.11 Pumps .8.12 Strainers .9 ISOLATORS & EIS9.1 Earth Switch .9.2 Main Contacts9.3 Marshalling Box .9.4 Operating mech.10 LIGHTNING ARRESTORS11 CT SW. GEARS (ACDB)12 PLCC SYSTEM13 PROTECTION SYSTEMS14 SHUNT REACTORS15 TELEPHONE EXCHANGE16 WAVE TRAPS

46

Page 50: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment 26

POWERGRID'S MONITORING PLAN

POWERGRID Monitors all its activities continuously. The corporate monitoring group reportsto the Director( Projects) on a monthly basis. The Board of Directors is kept informed aboutthe progress of various ongoing activities.

For environmental and social components of a project, an environmental and social monitoringplan will be developed based on baselinedata and impacts predicted during the environmentaland social assessment process. Monitoring of impacts on ecological resources through whichthe transmission line traveses is done by the concemed forest department staff as part of theirduties. POWERGRID associate concemed officials for timely implementation variousactivities such as compensatory afforestation, ROW maintenance, preventation of firehazards, natural regenaration of vegetation etc. The Environmental and Social Monitoring Plan(ESMP) will be integrated with construction, operation and maintenance. It shall be monitoredby the ESMD on a monthly basis in association with the corporate monitoring group.

POWERGRID does not acquire land for the construction of transmission lines. Howeverabout 20 to 40 hacters of land is acquired for the construction of substations. Area of landacquired is minimal. POWERGRID rehabilitates project affected people in accordance withguidelines laid down in its social entitlement framework, the draft national policy andrequirements of funding agencies.

POWERGRID is not involved with activities that are polluting in nature. POWERGRID aimsfor zero pollution and does not use chemicals for ROW maintenance or PCBs in its electricalequipment. Hence, the requirement of a pollution monitoring plan or a PCB level monitoringplan does not arise for POWERGRID.

47

Page 51: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-27

CASE STUDIES OF POWERGRID'S TRANSMISSION PROJECTS

Vindhyachal Dhule

Vindhyachal Dhule is a 400 KV transmission project consisting of three stages:

i) Vindhyachat - Jabalpur - 320 kms.19) Jabalpur - Itarsi - 245 kmsiii) Itarsi - Dhule - 430 kms

This transmission project involves construction of approximately 995 kms of 400 KV lines and also includes expansion of NTPC's existing switch-yard / sub-stations at Vindhyachal, Jabalpur, Itarsi and that of Maharashtra State Electricity Board at Dhule. The estimated cost of the project is Rs. 313 crores. Theproject was designed by NTPC and later taken over by POWERGRID. At its inception by NTPC. a major of portion of the line was routed through DryDeciduous forests. When the project was handed over to I IOWERGRID, the later took advantage of the inherent flexibility of re-routing transmission lines anddesigned the project such that a 40 kms stretch of forests along its linear length was reduced to 13 kms. Other projects wherein POWERGRID has used theflexibility of routing lines so as to minimise the length traversed through forests are:

.P ROECT . ...DESCRiPTION E I : - :;KERN1.Kayamkulam a. Length 76 km 77 km 81,5 kmEdamon Llne

b. Env. ImpactI. Town in ali nient Nuranad Kayamkulamii. Houses In ROW 56 105 60

iiiExtent of tree/ 35% in paddy fields, coconut, banana 35% in paddy fields, coconut 35% In paddy fields, coconut gardens;crop plantations; 65% in rubber plantations plantations; 65% in rubber and other 65% through rubber and other timber

on hilly terrain. No RF timber valued trees. No RF. valued trees. 5% RF Involved

c. Compensation cost Rupees 7.5 crore Rupees 6.0 crore Rupees 10 crore including afforestaUond. Remarks Route length comparatively less. No Env. impact more due to route RF present. Alignment through NTPC

RF. Tower locations placed from hilltop alignment through town and large no. plant. Route aligned throughto hilltop to avoid cut:ing of trees of houses in ROW Kayamkulam town Aamaging -rre no.coming in ROW of houses.

_e. Route selected Altemative I has less impact on environment, so it is selected

48

Page 52: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

2.Kayamkulam - a. Length 35 km 42 km 47 kmPallom Line _

b . E n v . I m at................. ...I................................................... ............................... ... ............... ................ ................................................... ...... ...................................................... . . . . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. .. .. . . . . . .. .. . .. . . . . . . . . . I -- .. . . -.. . . .. .. . . .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . ............................. .. . . I. . . . .. . . . .. ,.. . .. . . . ............................................ ......................i. Town in alignment Harippad, Edathua, Chingavanam.:.............................

ii. Houses within i60 70 45the corridor

iii.Extent of tree/ 50% In paddy fields; 40% in coconut, 60% in paddy fields and marshy area; 65% In paddy fields; 30% coconut,crop coco, rubber, cashew plantations; 10% 30% coconut, rubber plantations. No coco, rubber, cashew; 5% In misc.

through misc. fields. No RF. RF. fields. No RF Is involvedc. Remarks ROW problems in thickly populated ROW has to cross through 6 EHT lines Tree compensation and disturbance to

towns of Harippad, Edathuva, will affect 20 to 30 houses. inhabitants minimum. Route crossingChingavana NH 47

e. Route selected Alternative IlIl has advantage of lesser environmental impact, so it is selected

S.R,pP.l -s. a. Length 403km 455 km 563 kmb. Env. Impact

i orest Area 70 km kii. Wildlife SanctuarY 19.5 km 19.5 km 3.5 km

c. Remarks Forest stretch more, but route is along Route length increased by 50 km Though route length increased by morethe 'B line and minimum. Route Is approx. but forest area reduced. than 150 km, but forest length reducedalmost parallel to existing RAPP-A line to 31.5 km.

d. Route selected Alternative IlIl has minimum env. Impact, but due to Increase in line length by 150 km, It becomes economically non-viable.The forest area Involved Is maInly thom scrub with a low and sparse canopy and does not Involve lopping of trees, The linepasses close to a defence Installation. Hence Altemative It is selected

4.Badarpur- a. Length 118 km 124.93 kmKumarghat _ _

b. Env. !m pa t .......................... ..................................................i. Forest Area 6.45 km 13.38 km

......... ...................................... ............. ................... ..........................I............................ ......................... ........ ......I........................ .......... .... ................ ................... ..... . ........................c. Remarks Less forest area 6.93 km more forest area. Route also

passes through two additional RFs

d. Route selected Alternative I is selected, because less impact on environment

. Route selected .-. _

49

Page 53: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

S.Badarpur- a. Length 185 km 208.49 km

Kolasib and b. Env. ImpactKolasib- Alzwal i. Forest Area 15.36 km 38.85 km

c.Remarks Less forest area 23.49 km more forest area. Routepasses 11.7 km of Katakhal & InnerlineRFs in Assam and 46.5 km RF inMizoram.

d. Route selected Altemative I is selected, because less in act on environment

6.Jeypore- a. Length 228.5 km 215 km

Gajuwaka b. Env. Impacti. Forest Area 15.5 km 2 km

c.Remarks _ Less forest area

d. Route selected Altemative II is selected, because less impact on environment

50

Page 54: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-28POWERGRID's BASELINE DATA AND EXPERIENCE

POWERGRID's transmission pojects are generation linked projects meant for powerevactuation and grid strengthing. They include creating and reinforcing inter regional links,augmenting RLDCs and construction of missing links.

POWERGRID at present operates about 27,000 Ckm of EHV transmission linets consisting of440 KV, 220 KV, 132 KV along with 53 substations having a total transmission capacity of22,749 MVA. The EHV transmission network is spread across the entire length and breadthof the country and is one of the largest EHV power transmission systems in the world.Presently 9394 Ckms of transmission lines are under construction by POWERGRID consistingof 566 Ckms of 800 KV; 7489 Ckms of 400 KV; 750 Ckms of 220 KV and 589 Ckms of 132 KVto be distributed over 10 Substations. POWERGRID 's transmission lines are shown in themap-1. POWERGRID's transmission lines and substations under operation, maintenance andconstruction are shown below:

Region No. Total Ckm Total Ckm Transformationof Under Operationn Under Construction _Capacity (MVA)S/S 400 220 132 Total 800 400 220 132 Total O&M CON

l____ kV kV kV kV kV kV kV STNNR-I 8 5751 1700 - 7451 - 476 594 - 1070 6829NR-11 4 1220 962 - 2182 566 1930 138 - 2634 1895 945ER 14 3259 1158 - 4417 - - - 212 212 5745WR 4 4542 869 - 5411 - 2379 - - 2379 1260SR 15 5908 64 - 5972 - 738 - - 738 6630

NER 8 766 342 770 1720 - 1966 18 377 2361 390Total 53 21446 5095 770 27153 566 7489 750 589 _9394 22749 945

POWERGRID's inter regional HVDC links will facilitate integration of regional grid systems intothe national grid and establish an inter-regional flow of surplus power thus avoiding freaquentgird collapses. POWERGRID has drawn up a programme for inter-connecting the variouspower regions of the country through these HVDC links.

POWERGRID has undertaken implementation of state-of- the-art Unified Load Despatch andCommunication facilities in all regions of the country for economic despatch of power betweenregions / states and for effective grid management.

Transmission Lines:

While routing its transmission lines, POWERGRID avoids all environmentally and sociallysensitive areas. Most of POWERGRID's transmission towers are located in agricultural fields.The detailed land use classification of transmission tower sites is shown in the table below. Atypical tower base spreads over an area of 10m x 10m. Construction activity however takesup more space i.e. 30m x 30m for a tower base.

Landuse Ckm %Forest 1,620 6.0Agricultural land 17,388 64.4Other Revenue land 7,560 28.0Water bodies 108 0.4Plantations and orchards 108 0.4Mountain/lice caps 108 0.4UrbaniResidential areas 108 0.4

51

Page 55: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Sub-Stations:

Presently, POWERGRID operates its 27,000 km through 53 sub-stations. POWERGRIDavoids all environmentally and socially sensitive areas while selecting a s,ite for its sub-stations. POWERGRID acquired only one homestead in 55 Sub-stations. POWERGRID sub-station sites typically occupy an area of about 100 to 150 acres. Land acquisition details of 55sub-stations are as shown below.

Total. Total Type of Land No.of No. of Families whose TotalS/S Land Families total holding acquired

whose partAcqd. Govt. Private holding acqd. Land + Land Home(Ha) (Ha) (Ha) Home only only

55 2144.23 757.51 1386.72 1021 1 1501172

A sub-station site is selected after considering three to five options. Land acquired is usuallyagricultural or wasteland since POWERGRID avoids environmentally sensitive areas. Most ofthe private agricultural land is cultivated by landless leaseholders who subsist on agriculture.Hence, usually project affected people are agricultural labour who loose their land andlivelihoods.

52

Page 56: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

MAP-I

POWER MAP OF INDIA 9(POWERGRID LINES)

mou avu"U

r~~~~~~~~~~,Z < <;

B~~~~~~~~~~~~~3J1 ,2 Ith.U_ Gvmmamig - ~ ~ "a

t wW < X ~~~~~~~(UP) t v W. w

1. IUUAX--= WUPA M BARZ ?BA

= CgnSoItThAwOm-B , -y(EYch ;A~L MAZT O-~ - jz3. ARaA~ AAU= - AP

*_~~ > ,- Uas o \ A w S.W ze

.~~~nj . rM JAApV e IBA17 VD><t

i oj6) D~~PAGKW ~Z~) ¶AIfiXPZARFUlt "i TMI / [TRU&YACWhr,.

is iwv SVP 4 DrsI BPAD A,

, .- _~~"Ws UlmD&

EXISNG/UNDEt CONSTRUCTION

----- APPROVED/PROPOSED

0-0 --0- ao80 xv LINEs

400 KV LINES (19496 KUdS)

220 KV LNIES (5257 1-XS)

182 [V INES (770 KSS)

'i t~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-

Page 57: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-29

ILLUSTRATIVE DISASTER CONTROL PLAN FOR FIRE INCIDENTS

Group - 1 Main Co-ordination Group

Group - 2: Fire Fightina Group

Group - 3: Vehicle Group

Group - 4: First Aid Group/Medical Group

1. Responsibility of Main Co-ordination Group

In case of fire in areas other than switchyard equipment

A) Operate alarm system

B) Inform all fire stations

C) Inform fire brigade what material is on fire

D) Inform Senior Officers

E) To ensure that hydrant pump operates during the entire period of fire figlhting

2. Responsibility of Fire Fighting Group

A) Fire fighting core gang employees to assemble immediately near the spot of fire andstart fire fighting v.:th hydrants till the arrival of fire brigade

B) After the arrival of fire brigade, fire fighting core group employee should be availablefor the assistance of the fire brigade

In case of fire in any equipment covered by emulsifier systems

A) Follow step No. A.B,C,D, as above of 1

B) The concerned emulsifier should operate automatically, if not, then it is to be operatedmanually

C) Fire fighting Group shall ensure that the above steps are taken in time

3. Responsibility of the vehicle group

A) To call all drivers

B) To ensure presence of all vehicles

C) To send injured person by jeep (s) to hospital

4. Responsibility of First Aid / Medical Group

A) First Aid core gang employees to be assembled immediately near the control room

B) To inform C.M.O. govemment hospital

C) To decide priority for treatment among the injured. Restoration of breathing &stoppage of bleeding to be given top most priority.

D) To render first aid on the spot where ever possible

E) To arrange for shifting of injured to identified nursing home in co-ordination with thevehicle group.

54

Page 58: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-30

GUIDELINES FOR PREPARING REHABILITATION ACTION PLAN(Guidelines: World Bank)

The Resettlement Action Plans will adhere to the policy objectives of POWERGRID's ESPP. Inadhering to the Environmental and Social policy, the RAP will incorporate all resettlement andrehabilitation measures necessary to ensure compensation for assets acquired at replacement cost,and nitigation of loss of livelihood for all Project Affected Persons (PAPs). on the basis of the SocialEntitlement Guidelines which reconciles the policies of the Govemrnment of India with the OperationalDirective (OD 4.30) of the World Bank, and shall serve as the basis for preparation of the RAP.However in its past experience POWERGRID has acquired only one homesead in all its projects.

Preparatory Steps

Preparatory steps will include.

* Determination of extent of adverse social impacts through a Social Assessment andManagement plan (SAMP) for each project as the basis for detemining scope of the RAP.

* Preparabon of a detailed Terms of Reference for the consultants(ff necessary) on the basis ofthe specific R&R issues emerging from the SAMP.

* Make available to the consultants a copy of the ESPP, SAMP, and the project design withdetailed maps of the project for which the RAP is being commissioned.

Resettlement Plan Objectives

Preparation of the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) is being commissioned as an integral part, and oneof the major components of the Social Assessment Process described in the ESPP. The need for theRAP has been identified by the preliminary findings of the SAMP and the analysis of expected socialimpacts which require appropriate mitigation measures for all PAPs who, on the basis of anestablished cut-off date, will be losing land, or other assets or livelihood, as a result of projectimplementabon. The RAP will incorporate all R&R measures necessary lo ensure o:mpensation forassets acquired at replacement cost and mitigation of loss of livelihood for al PAPs.

Outline of RAP:

i. Project Description

* Physical, social and economic characteristics of the projt area;* Major features of the proposed project;* Relevant maps of the project site (s) and the project area* Summary description of the extent of land acquisition needed for the project and its

expected adverse social impact - results of the SAMP;* Analysis of major social groups likely to be adversely affected, and their special

characteristics in relation tot he project;* Impact on archaeological sites and cultural property;* Overview of the R&R steps envisaged within the project

2. The Social Assessment Process

* Preceding stages of the Social Assessment Process leading to preparation of the RAP:* Consultation process with different stakeholders used during the Social Assessment

Process; if different forms of consultation have been used for different stakeholders e.g.govemment agencies, potential user groups, PAPs and NGOs, the consultative processesshould be described separately.

3. Census Data and Social Impact Assessment

Socio-economic data of project area and expected social impact of the proposed project based on thecensus and socio-economic survey:

55

Page 59: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

* Details of land and other assets to be acquired on a temporary or permanent basis for theproject;

* Data on occupation and income levels of PAPs;* Access to benefits, and negative consequences on different social groups - landowners

vs. tenantsJiandless labourers, large farmers vs. small owner-operators, owners vs.squatters, males vs. females, local vs. regionaVnational beneficiaries - equity issues;

* Changes in the tenurial status and pattems of resource use by different social groups as aresult of the project;

* Extent of relocation of PAPs required for the project;* Data on the proposed resettlement site (s) and host population (s) including existing

pattem of land use, existing infrastructure and services and economic opportunities forthe additional population at the resettlement site (s) and host populatbon (s), includingexisting pattem of land use, existing infrastructure and services and economicopportunities for the additional population at the resettlement site (s)

* Access to social services prior to the project, and after completion of the project;* Impact on poverty in the project area

4. Policy of Entitlements

* National, state, and local Laws and Rules on land acquisition and resettement applicableand relevant to this project;

* Eligibility policy and criteria for different categories of PAPs. cut-off dates for eligibility;

5. Participation

- Previous experience of the local population (particularly negative experiences) withdevelopment projects and resettement;

- R&R implementation, and R&R ronitoring;* Insttutional mechanisms to facilitate participation:* Expected outputs of participa;ion by stage of project cycle.

6. Consultation and Grievance Procedures

* Major R&R issues to be discussed with PAPs;* Process and time table proposed for project affectees;* Public information, and informabon dissemination program to ensure project affectees are

informed about process of project implementation and R&R issues, on a continuing basis;* Mechanisms established, such as Grievance Committee, for redressal of grievances.

7. Implementation Mechanisms and Due Process

Implementation procedures proposed for delivery of key entitiements and the process for establishmentof adequate replacement cost summarize information in the form of a compiete entitlement Matrix (seeTable 1 for format), and add explanatory notes to clarify tile following points, as relevant to the project.

* Land-tor-land provisions, including the location, quality, and present economic use of theland being provided in replacement of acquired land;

* Additional incentives provided to supplement land-for-land provisions, including cost ofrelocation, subsidy for inputs to develop the land compensation for need to create newnetwork of services and inputs, etc.

* Determination of replacement cost, form of compensation and modality of payment;* Provisions made to compensate tenants share-croppers and others with temporary tenure

or lease on property .* Acquisition of resources managed as common property (CPRs)

- Replacement Value of CPRs- Compensation for CPR among its multiple ownerslusers- Access to CPRs after project completion or altemative arfangements to avoid

depriving PAPs of the benefit stream from CPRs.* Measures proposed to provide additional services to PAPs (e.g. special measures to

ensure that they are included among the beneficiaries of the project through access toproject related services, employment opportunities, or public social services) in lieu of thepersonal loss they are incurring for a public good.

56

Page 60: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

8. Analysis of Altematives and Assessment of Resettlement Sites

* Altematives to project design identified during RAP preparation, particularly thosealtematives where minor modification to the project may reduce adverse effects, resultingin significant R&R benefits;

* Provision of improved services to the host population (to avoid future conflicts with theresettled population).

9. Income Generation Programs

* Existing skills and employment pattem of PAPs;* Adverse impacts on employment pattem due to acquisition of land or other assets, or due

to relocation;* Feasibility analysis of income generation programs at the resettlement site (s) or at the

existing location during the life of the project, and in the post-project period;* Training needs of PAPs in context of employment opportunities and market demands of

post-project situations, and describe how project will ensure fulfillment of training needs;* Access to credit and micro-enterprise support to meet the PAPs needs for capital and

other inputs for rehabilitation of livelihoods;* Institutional arrangements to manage Income Generation programs on a sustained basis

- initiation, implementation, handing over, sustainability.

10. Institutional Capacity and Responsibility

* Which agency will be responsible to implement R&R activities?* Previous experience of the agency in undertaking R&R (the previous experience should

be described and evaluated);* Organizational structure to manage R&R activities for the project.* Resources available for R&R, including staffing, financial resources and other facilities;* Budget for R&R agency, including extent of financial authority;* Capacity, experience, and resources of PAPs organisabon within the project area;* Capacity, experience and resources of NGOs active within the project are;* Coordination mechanisms between R&R agency, local administration, PAPs and NGOs;* Technical Assistance needs and plans for staff capacity building

11. Budget for R&R Operations

e Assumptions underlying the budget and Total Estimated Cost of R&R Operations- Estimated cost of land acquisiton and resettlement under the project;- Initial capital investment for rehabilitation activities;- Recurring costs for continued provision of rehabilitation and mitigation measures;- Cost of administrative overheads implementation management;- Allocation for contingencies;

* Detailed costs with identification of all major cost item for expenditure during the firstphase of implementation (minimum two years);

* Sources of funding, and financing responsibility by component;* Budgetary process and timing of expenditure;* Authorisation process regarding spending, and devolution of financial powers for R&R to

the field level;* Financial accountability process - the audit mechanism.

12. Monitoring & Evaluation* Procedures and organisational set-up for intemral monitoring of progress in R&R

operations - M&E structure within implementing agency;* Monitoring and reporting procedures and formats to be followed for reporting progress

with R&R;* Participatory monitoring - PAP responsibilities;* Provision for extemal, independent monitoring mechanism of R&R;* Project supervision - Bank responsibility;* Funding sources for M&E.

57

Page 61: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

13. Action Plan for Implementation

Prepare an Action Plan with a time line for R&R implementabon, coordinated with the proposed timetable for project activities, beginning with a start date well enough in advance to make the landavailable for project construction when it is needed.

* Summarize coverage of the plan (time period, location of sites);* Draw up a list of key tasks to be performed to deliver the entitlements provided in the RAP

(use the Entitlement Matrix as a checklist for activity list), ensure that all activities relatedto the following are included.- land acquisition- resettlement- rehabilitation- Income generation programs- consultaton processes- monitoring of R&R impacts

* Incorporate critical activities/events related to project construction implementation whichwill have a bearing on the time frame;

* Prepare a Plan of Operations for R&R activities, for the first phase (minimum 24 months)using the following format:

Activities Responsibility Monitoring Indicator Time Frame

Table 1: Entitlement Matrix :Compensation, Relocation and Rehabilitation

Type of Loss I Definition of Definition of Applicatfon Additional Implement- Organisa-Impacts' entitlement I entitled guidelines services I ation tion (s)

right personlunit benefits Issues responsible1.Loss of

land _

2. Loss ofstructure

3. Loss oflivelihood _

4. Loss of accessto commonresources andfacilities _

5. Loss ofstandingcross/trees

6. Loss duringtransition /displacement _

7. Loss to HostCommunities _ _

1 The first column of this matrix is indicative of generic types of losses. There are likely to bevariations between projects. In preparing the RAP, the boxes in the first column should beexpanded on the basis of the first column of the R&R Matrix in Section 4: Policy ofEntitlements of this RAP. If further sub-divisions are called for, based on different types ofagricultural land, types of tenancy contracts, or types of wage employment, the matrix shouldbe expanded to specify entitlements for each of those variations.

58

Page 62: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-31

INDIGENOUS PEOPLES DEVELOPMENT PLAN - RECOMMENDED CONTENT & FORMAT

If initial scoping and preliminary assessments have determined that indigenous peoples or vulnerablegroups coming under the purview of OD 4.20 will be affected by the proposed project, the Bank's policymandates that:

For an investment project that affects indigenous peoples, the borrower should prepare anindigenous peoples development plan that is consistent with the Bank's policy. Any project thataffects indigenous peoples is expected to include components or provisions that incorporate sucha plan. When the bulk of the direct project beneficiaries are indigenous people, the Bank'sconcems will be addressed by the project itself and the provisions of this OD will thus apply to theproject in its entirety. (OD 4.20 para, 13)

The IPDPSection I: Background Information(1) Brief description of the projects main objectives, components, and time frame.(2) Description of how the project will affect indigenous peoples and special components required,

outside and beyond the main project components, to ensure the protection of indigenous people'srights.

(3) Assessment of the legal status of groups as reflected in the country's constitution, legislation, andsubsidiary legislation, and; description f their rights, entitlements, and vulnerability.

Section II: The content of the IPDPThe following information should be included but is not exclusive of other pertinent information to coverspecific conditions and social groups.(a) Maps(b) Description followed by analysis of the social structure of the population.(c) Inventory of the resources and analysis of the sources of income of the population.(d) Technical information about the systems of production.(e) Relationship of indigenous groups to national groups.(f) Examinaton of land tenure issues including lands under customary rule and assurance of

continued use of these resources by the groups involved.(g) Strategy for local participation including mechanisms defined with the assistance and in

consultation with indigenous peoples for their participation in decision making process throughoutproject planning, implementation and evaluation cycle.

(h) Technical identification of development or mitigation activities. Detailed description should beprepared and appraised for proposed services such as education, training, health, credit and legalassistance. Additionally, technical descriptions should be included for planned investments inproductive infrastructure. Whenever possible indigenous knowledge should be utilised andincorporated into these activities.

(i) Examination and analysis of the institutional capacity will describe the govemment institutionsresponsible for indigenous peoples' affairs, their capabilities and an assessment ol their capacity tocarry out proposed plans and activities. Organisational issues will be addressed including: issuesof funding for investments and field operations, adequacy of field staff, local inidigenous andlorother local organisations to interact with govemment institutions and ability of the executing agencyto mobilise other agencies involved in the plan's implementation.

j) The IPDP will include an implementation schedule with benchmarks to assess progress. Whenpilot projects are proposed the plan will demonstrate where and how these projects will assist inthe provision of planning or phasing information dealing with indigenous peoples.

(k) Monitoring and evaluation, including specific indicators will be included in the plans, as will adescripton of the process and agents to conduct both monitoring and evaluation. A proposedschedule of reports should be included.

(I) Detailed cost estimates and financing plan and sources of funds for the IPD`r covering thoseplanned activities and investments should also be included. Programmes involving revolving creditfunds should also include a description of the accounting procedures and mechanisms for financialtransfer or replenishment

Section III: Processing and Documentation(1) Plan for development component for indigenous peoples should be submitted to the Bank along

with the project's overall feasibility report, prior to project appraisal. Adequacy of the plan will beassessed at appraisal as will the suitability of the policies proposed and legal frameworks andcontents of the overall plan as mandated by para 18 OD 4.20. Appraisal teams should be satisfiedthat there has been meaningful participation on the part of the indigenous peoples as mandated bypara 14.

(2) Appropriate anthropological, legal and technical skills shall be provided for in the supervisionmissions during project implementation.

(3) The borrowers commitments to the implementation of the IPDP should be reflected in the loandocuments. Legal provisions should provide Bank staff with clear benchmarks that can bemonitored during supervision.

59

Page 63: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-32

POWERGRID's Public Consultation Process

Public consultation forms an integral part of POWERGRID's project cycle.

Transmission Lines

1. When planning a transmission line, public consultation is used as an integral tool forscreening, assessment and finalisation of route alignment. When lines traverseagricultural lands, a gazette notification of the transmission scheme is made in theState Gazette and details of the scheme including location are published in dailynewspapers of the area. The notification invites objections from the public within astipulated time period in writing or through meetings so as to redress theirapprehensions.

2. During initial screening and walkover survey, POWERGRID's staff meets the publicin the route of proposed transmission line. Observations and problems arising fromthese discussions are given due consideration while finalising the route.

3. During the survey for tower spotting, POWERGRID's ste officials meet the public i.e.people coming in the route of the line. This enables POWERGRID to guage publicopinion. At the time of construction, every individual on whose land a tower is to beerected is met with. People coming in the way of the ROW are consulted and theirviews and suggestions are incorporated thus allowing for public participation.

4. During construction POWERGRID pays the compensation for any damages to eachland owner and obtains their final acknowledgement.

5. During maintenance, POWERGRID consults the individual landowners, obtains theirapproval and pays compensation for any damage to property.

Substations

1. POWERGRID identifies location of the substation and notifies the area under LAA.

2. Public consultation is a part of LAA. Under Section 4 of LAA, a notification ispublished in the official Gazette and in two local daily newspapers (at least one ofwhich is in the local regional language) about the details of the project. Anyobjections related to the land to be acquired are made to the collector in writing.Under section 5a, the District Collector hears the public objections by calling a publicmeeting, if so desired. DC sends report along with recommendations along withdetails of proceedings to the state govemment . DC issues notice under section 6only after he receives the state govemment's approval.

3. Under Section 6 of LAA, the DC issues a notice informing the public about the landto be acquired and invites their claims. All effective people inforrned individually.Compensation is paid to public according to local norms. .

4. Besides publication consultation as an integral part of the LAA, IPOWERGRID iscommitted to assessment of all probable impacts associated with land acquisitionthrough is social assessment and management process which includes a socio-economic survey of the proposed substation sites. The socio-economic survey willassess both adverse and positive impacts of the project on aspects such as thenatural resource base, developmental potential of the area, economy of the affectedarea, social structure, norms and traditions. The socio-economic survey will includea complete household census recording members, property with legal rights andresources which are in possession or in use. Appropriate methods such asparticipatory rural appraisal and questionnaires will be used where necessary.

60

Page 64: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

5. POWERGRID assess the social impacts of its land acquisition based on the socio-economic survey and designs its compensation packages in consultation with thepeople. POWERGRID organises meetings with the PAPs to evolve thie RAP.

In order to further streamline the above process and to facilitate documentation of the same,and to discussion the following:

complete project plan (i.e. its route and terminating point and substations, if any, inbetween)

* POWERGRID design standards in relation to approved international standards* health impacts in relation to EMF* measures taken to avoid public utilities such as school, hospitals, etc.* other impacts associated with transmission lines and POWERGRID's approach to

minimising and solving them* land acquisition details, proposed R&R measures and compensation packages in line

with POWERGRID's policy

POWERGRID uses one or more of the following techniques at various stages. Theseinclude:

(1) Public meetingsPOWERGRID will hold public meetings during its EAMP process at appropriatelocations along the length of the transmission line. Public meetings will include one toone meetings with land owners during transmission tower spotting. Larger groupmeetings will be organised at strategic distances along the length of the transmissionline. These will consist of all or atleast most of the people to be directly affected by theconcemed project and their local Gram Panchyat leaders.

(2) Informal small group meetingsInformal small group meetings will be conducted during walkover survey to find out localenvironmental and social issues along the proposed transmission line! route. Thesemeetings will be conducted by ESMT staff at appropriate intervals.

(3) Information brochures and PamphletsPOWERGRID will make available information and project specific details to the publicthrough Information brochures and Pamphlets. These brochures and pamphlets willcontain information on: the overall project plan; design and construction standards:prudent deviations from design standards from transmission towers near schools,hospitals, human habitation: potential impacts and generic mitigation measures:resettlement and rehabilitation: and, compensation.

(4) Operaffng field officesInformation regarding the proposed transmission line can be accessedl by the publicfrom operating field offices. Informnation will be provided through brouchures andpamphlets and any further queries will be responded by POWERGRID's staff.

(5) Local planning visits and site visitsPOWERGRID staff will visit field sites. During this time informal contacts will beestablished with the local people. Reactions of the public to the project will beinformally gauged.

(6) Response to public EnquiresESMCIESMT will respond to public enquiries by post or through notices in local newspapers.

(7) Press release inviting commentsPOWERGRID will publish details of proposed transmission routes in two localnewspapers. Public will be invited to comment in writing or by meeting concernedPOWERGRID officials within a specified period. POWERGRID will thien incorporaterelevant objections and suggestions.

61

Page 65: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

(8) Project coordination commiteesPOWERGRID will set up grevance redressal committees to adress the oDmplaints andobjections that PAP's may have regarding the project, its impacts or mitigationmeasures.

(9) Ombudsman or representatveFor building a consensus on the project its impacts and mitigation measures, the PAPswill be encouraged to elect or appoint a trusted ombudsman or representative.

(10) Public DisplaysPOWERGRID will show their model projects to public/small representative groups.

DocumentationThe proceedings of the above consultation shall be documented. Details recorded willinclude date of the meeting, venue, number and possibly the names of the people attendingand the outcome of the meeting.

The manager at DHQ will apply combinations of the appropriate techniques at variousactivities of a proiect depending upon the field conditions as shown below:

Milestones Process Techniques1. Environmental * Screen &scope Tis from an environmental and social informal small group

&social scrning perspective meetings, local planning&scoping for TLs -spot verification visits and site visits

2. Environmental * Screen &scope SS from an environmental and social Informal small group&social scrning perspective meetings, Local planning&scoping for SS -spot verification Visits and site visits

3. EAMP * Tis & SS Public meetings, Press- undertake environmental review and formulate release inviting commentsappropnate management measures

4. SAMP . Tls . Informal small group-negotiate compensation packages with revenue meetings, local planningauthorities and PAPs visits and site visits,- finalise and document compensation and other Response to publicmanagement measures enquiries

* SS Public meetings,- finalise SS site Ombudsment or- notify area under LAA representative, Public- undertake detailed LA census display- final negotiations and documenation ofagreements

5. Execution of * Execute environmental management works Information brochures andEnvironmetal - appropriate clearance for Transmission line ROW, pamphlets, Operating fieldmanagement etc. offices, Response to publicworks - compensatory afforestation enquiries

6.Execution of . TIs Information brochures andSocial - pay compensation as agreed and documented in, pamphlets, Operating fieldmanagement SAMP and execute other measures offices. Response to publicworks enquiries

* SS- deposit compensation and take possession of land Information brochures and- execute R&R measures as prescribed in the SAMP pamphlets, Operating field

offices, Response to publiceriquirses

7. Environmental * Monitor EAMP measures Information brochures andand Social - maintainence of ROW pamphlets. Operating fieldmonitoring - progress on compensatory afforestation offices. Response to public

enquiries* Monitor SAMP measures

- appropriate compensation and other measures Informal small groupduring maintainence of towers and lines meetings

-- progress on R&R measure

62

Page 66: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-33

POWERGRID CENTRES IN INDIA

SAIG SAGARAG

a~~~~~

mSEPUls C :.tUF \

mm~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~c

MA "LERKOT.

fi N Av GAR GA)

IL ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H

a f HIWA^* DDH

b h~~~~EERAPUR J,IPUR GRA; _ J

< 01 H(4t > DURCA~~~~~~~~~PUR

t ~ NOA SA NSCCj

\ 4 /TRI AF

\bA *S- RCJSECUNDERAEAD

\\ BA%A2E uADRASH J GHO

No ._ & SALEM NSCC T"C "TIRUOCHIR ALI* RSCC

M _ rAOURAlfl CPCC

ttL 4SSERY # SLDC

63

Page 67: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-34

POWERGRID ORGANISATION STRUCTURE

CORPORATE PLANNING VIGILANCE|AGM |||EXE.DIR|

I I I . IFINANCE OPERATION PERSONNEL PROJECT CONTRACTS &

DIRECDIRECT OR DIRECTOR DRTOR EL

.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~M .D ENJ , ,, .

OS & SO LD & C COMMERCIAL CMG B ENG. & OA&I

EXE.DIR EXE.DIR HRD EXE.DIR EXEDIR EXE DIR EXEDIRGRG HRM, EXEDIR

ADMN.ARBIN. COMMERCIAL StS& COST ENGG

AGM &RP.COMAG & SYS PLNG MATL.MGMTGEN_MGR GEN.MGR CP.CIPP G GM -

I GENMGR IGMP T/L ENGG.OPN.SERVICES 0 GM GM CONTRACTS

0GMLAW ENVT.MGMTb ,A&ICONST MGMT AGM

SYS,OPN. -EGMM 1

FIN 8 ACCTS S GM

COMPANY SECY

I I } EXE.DIR I } EXE.DIR | | EXE DIR

I I _ I I . I I I I -ISRTS SRLDC WRTS WRLDC ERTS ERLD[ NERTS NERLDC NR I NR ii NRLDC

64

Page 68: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-35

EXISTING EMD STRUCTURE

DirectorProjects

1.{ ~~EDl

Commercial, IP,Env.& CM

1.I AGMEnvironmental Management &

Construction Management

.1I DGM

-7.Manager

Dy. Manager

1.Dy. Manager

The following are the responsibilities of EMD

1 . Advise field offices to carry out surveys for new projects and coordinate variousactivities in this regard in line with Corporate investment plan.

2. Optimise right of way in the areas based on altemative routes worked out by site inconsultation with environmental experts considering effects of biodiversity, kind oftrees likely to be affected etc.

3. Assist field offices to finalise routes of entire transmission lines taking into accountimpacts of rehabilitation, mitigation and other social factors and ground realitiesenroute.

4. Help field offices to follow up with Forest and other Departments under StateGovemment in expediting forest clearances of various on going and new projects.

5. Act as a focal point for interaction with MOE&F for expediting forest clearances andfollow up with DOP and MoEF regarding Forest Bank proposal.

6. Preparation of technical report on environment aspects for Funding Agencies.

7. To impart training to our field officers on environment and forestry aspects.

65

Page 69: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-36

PRESENT ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE OF REGIONAL HEADQUARTERS

General Manager(Region)

Sr. Vigilance/Vigilance

Officer

Dy. General Sr. Manager Sr. Manager | MManager DyGeeaHuaSeirOeain& Cnac

Planning & Manager Human Manager Maintenance/ Contract &Systems/ Finance & Resources Commercial Testing & Material

Engm. Accts. Management Commissioning

Nodal Officer DHQ DHQ DHQ(Env.)

66

Page 70: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Attachment-37

ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE OF DIVISIONAL HEADQUARTERS

DGM(Divisional Head)

I (SS) Acut M,& trsHM(L

Mgr./Dy. Mgr. Mgr./Dy. Mgr Sr. Engr/Engr. Sr. EngoEngr. Sr.EngsEngr. Mgr.IDy. Mgr. Mgr./Dy. Mgr.(O&M) ~~(Const) C&M PMS Stores pO&) (Const)

I Sr.Engr Sr. Engr/Engr. Sr.Engr Sr. Engr/Engr. En.Sr.Engr./ Sr. Engr | SrEngrt r nrT&C. Malntnance pShift Opration Const. (Clvii) ConstE(Elec) Engr r.

67

Page 71: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

A/tachment-38

DEPARTMENTAL PROFILES

Corporate PlanningThis department plays a pivotal role in deciding the future course of action to be taken by theorganisation. The important functions performed by the department are:

1. Strategic planning, long range and short range planning, avenues for diversification/ expansion.Private Sector & Joint Venture participation.

2. Intemational fund mobilisation, Project Approval, Technical Services and Coordination.

3. Financial projections, Computer modelling, Policy issues, Monitoring of funds utilisation and debit

4. Coordination with ContinentalEuropean Intemational Financial Institutions.

5. Developing Management Information System/LAN support & maintenance.

Engineering:Responsible for design, execution and commissionig of Transmission system projects. Thisdepartment is broadly divided into three groups viz.

Group I: Substation Engineering;

Group 11: System Engineering & Feasibility Study

Group Ill: Transmission Line Engineering.

Each group is further divided into subgroups based on Regions/Equipment'functions. The mainfunctions of the department are:

1. All Pre-award & Post award activities related to substaftons such as:

- Technical specifications for the equipment & Bill of Quantities;

- Technical Bids evaluaton & Pre-award discussions; Substation layout;

- Civil Engineering activities related to substaton construction/expansion & infrastructure;

- Detailed Engineering (Approval of drawings etc.)

2. Feasibility report preparation & doing operation studies.

3. All pre-award & post-award activities for the transmission lines.

LawThis department is headed by Chief Law Officer who reports to Director (Personnel). Main functionsare:

1. Advisory

- Vetting documents/correspondence done by various other departments and rendering legaladvice to various officers/regions of POWERGRID.

2. Litigations

- Looking after the arbitration cases and court cases.

3. Transfer of Assets

- All legal aspects involved in the transfer of Assets.

68

Page 72: World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/205511468750264791/...Attachment 24a: Analysis of Altematives and Route Selection Criteria in POWERGRID's Projects Attachment

Contracts ServicesContracts department is pnmarily involved in Pre-award actvities of projects. Major activities include:

1. Release of Notice Inviting Tenders

2. Receipt of tenders

3. Tender evaluation (financial bid only)

4. Award of contract

5. Monitoring of supply contracts

Regional HeadquartersRHQs coordinate and control functions of the various Divisional offices, substatons and transmissionlines. RHO functions include finance, perrsonnel and adminiration, vigilance, etc. with the

organisational structure closely resembling that of the corporate headquarters. Major aictivities include:

1. Coordination and control of ongoing construction projects

2. Engineering and Field Quality Assurance and Communication

3. Coordinating O&M of substation and transmission lines

4. Planning of shutdown for routine and planned maintenance

5. Coordination with the REBs on behalf of the region

6. Grid control of the region through IOCC

7. Environmental and Social management, coordination and monitoring

Divisional HeadquartersDHQs are field offices coordinating activities of two to three substations. Organisatiornai structure atthe DHQ closely resembles that at the RHQs. Acivities inckide:

1. Construction of transmission lines and substations

2. Operation and Maintenance of substation and transmission lines

3. Engineering and Field Quality Assurance and Communication

4. Testing and Commissioning

5. Implementation of EAMP/SAMP

69