34
With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting: I. A Definition of Terms II. TMI III. War in the Open IV. The War You Cannot See V. The New Battlefield

With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

With

Emerson T. Brooking

Presenting:

I. A Definition of Terms

II. TMI

III. War in the Open

IV. The War You Cannot See

V. The New Battlefield

Page 2: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

I. A Definition of Terms

Page 3: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

What is LikeWar?

1) A contest of psychological and

algorithmic manipulation, fought through

competing viral events

Page 4: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

What is LikeWar?

2) A new mode of political and military

conflict, premised on the command of

attention

Page 5: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Disintermediation

Page 6: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

II. TMI

Page 7: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Secrecy c. 1944

Page 8: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Secrecy c. 2011

Page 9: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Secrecy c. 2019

Page 10: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Secrecy c. 2019

Michael Sheldon, Digital Forensic Research Lab

Page 11: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Secrecy c. 2019

Michael Sheldon, Digital Forensic Research Lab

Page 12: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

III. War in the Open

Page 13: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Theater Is Everything

Page 14: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Everything Is Theater

Page 15: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Performative Violence

Page 16: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

All the World’s a Stage

“The street is no longer limited

to the perceptual horizon

of the person walking down it.”

- Gordon and Silva, Net Locality (2011)

Page 17: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Diplomacy as Theater

Page 18: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

War as Theater

Page 19: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

IV. The War You Cannot See

Page 20: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

The “Russia Thing”

Page 21: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

The Russian Revolution

“Extremist organizations actively employ modern technologies, including…the Internet, to spread extremist material, to attract new members into their ranks, and to coordinate illegal activity.” - 2013 Concept For Security of the Society

“[The principle threat is the] combined use of military force and political, economic, information, and other non-military means that are realized by extensive use of the protest potential of the population and special forces.” - 2014 Military Doctrine

Russia 2011

Ukraine 2014

Page 22: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

The Russian Revolution The main directions of information security national defense area are: a) strategic deterrence and prevention of military Conflicts that may arise as a result of

information technologies; b) improving the provision of information system security of the Russian Federation

Armed Forces, other troops, military formations and bodies, including the strength and resources information warfare;

c) forecasting, detection and evaluation of information threats, including threats to the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation the information sphere;

d) promote the protection of the interests of the Allies The Russian Federation in the information sphere;

e) neutralization of information and psychological impact, including those aimed at undermining the foundations and historical patriotic traditions associated with the defense of the fatherland.

- 2016 Information Security Doctrine

The Russian RevolutionThe main directions of information security national defense area are: a) strategic deterrence and prevention of military Conflicts that may arise as a result of

information technologies; b) improving the provision of information system security of the Russian Federation

Armed Forces, other troops, military formations and bodies, including the strength and resources information warfare;

c) forecasting, detection and evaluation of information threats, including threats to the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation the information sphere;

d) promote the protection of the interests of the Allies The Russian Federation in the information sphere;

e) neutralization of information and psychological impact, including those aimed at undermining the foundations and historical patriotic traditions associated with the defense of the fatherland.

- 2016 Information Security Doctrine

Page 23: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

“Troll Factories”

“We wrote about 200 comments and 20 news posts each day…

…I bought myself a Mazda Six.”

- Anonymous Russian Troll

Page 24: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

War By Other Memes

Page 25: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

On the Outside

Twitter Retweet Network Graph, #BlackLivesMatter + 2016 Shooting Events

Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018

Page 26: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

On the Inside

Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018

Twitter Retweet Network Graph, #BlackLivesMatter + 2016 Shooting Events

(plus Russian IRA Troll Accounts)

Page 27: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

The Goal

Page 28: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

V. The New Battlefield

Page 29: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Digital Empires

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500

Christianity

Facebook

China

India

WeChat

Twitter

United States

Population (in Millions)

Page 30: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

The Vision

Page 31: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

The Reality

Page 32: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

President 2.0

Page 33: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

Through the Looking Glass

“The goal wasn’t to create an online community,

but a mirror

of what existed in real life.”

- Mark Zuckerberg, 2004

Page 34: With Emerson T. Brooking Presenting...Kate Starbird, “The Trolls Within,” October 20, 2018. On the Inside Kate Starbird, ... Through the Looking Glass “The goal wasn’t to create

With

Emerson T. Brooking

Thank You!