14
Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers by Roy Gregory, February 16, 2015 © www.theaudiobeat.com rickle-down is perhaps one of the most interesting yet misunderstood aspects of audio design. The justification offered for flagship components at eye-watering prices is so often, “Of course, the technology/experience/performance will trickle down to the rest of the range,” generally delivered with that smug, just-dodged-a-bullet air of self-satisfaction. It all fits so neatly into the accepted, apologetic approach to the prices charged by the audio industry -- the same logic that constantly wheels out the law of diminishing returns as an excuse for poor performance. Well, just in case you guys selling this stuff haven’t heard the alarm bells ringing, that sort of BS doesn’t actually wash anymore. If you make a flagship product, then these days its performance and material content had better justify its price tag. The best recent example of this that has come my way is Wilson Benesch’s Cardinal. This is a speaker that delivers remarkable performance from a package that includes an imposing cabinet built entirely from high-tech composites and extruded aluminum, stainless steel hardware and six different drivers, with every last bit of it built in-house, yet priced in the distinctly non-flagship, mid-five-figure range. It’s a package and performance that literally shame much of the six-figure competition. But it’s not just the performance and engineering that are impressive; it’s the thinking too. Which brings us back to the concept of trickle-down. If you want developments at the top of your range to be applicable at lower price points, you’d better be sure of both the integrity of your design and the integrity of your thinking.That’s because there are two ways to trickle down the benefits of a flagship product. You can take the overall concept and execute it with more affordable engineering (the Wilson Benesch Square Five is a perfect example of this, a Cardinal writ 1 T

Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

  • Upload
    lykien

  • View
    214

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

Wilson Benesch Endeavour

Loudspeakersby Roy Gregory, February 16, 2015

© www.theaudiobeat.com

rickle-downisperhapsoneofthemost interestingyetmisunderstoodaspectsofaudio design.Thejustificationofferedforflagshipcomponentsateye-wateringpricesissooften,“Ofcourse,thetechnology/experience/performancewilltrickledowntotherestoftherange,”generallydeliveredwiththatsmug,just-dodged-a-bulletairofself-satisfaction.Itallfitssoneatlyintotheaccepted,apologeticapproachtothepriceschargedbytheaudioindustry--thesamelogicthatconstantlywheelsoutthelawofdiminishingreturnsasanexcuseforpoorperformance.

Well,justincaseyouguyssellingthisstuffhaven’theardthealarmbellsringing,thatsortofBSdoesn’tactuallywashanymore.Ifyoumakeaflagshipproduct,thenthesedaysitsperformanceandmaterialcontenthadbetterjustifyitspricetag.ThebestrecentexampleofthisthathascomemywayisWilsonBenesch’sCardinal.Thisisaspeakerthatdeliversremarkable

performancefromapackagethatincludesanimposingcabinetbuiltentirelyfromhigh-techcompositesandextrudedaluminum,stainlesssteelhardwareandsixdifferentdrivers,witheverylastbitofitbuiltin-house,yetpricedinthedistinctlynon-flagship,mid-five-figurerange.It’sapackageandperformancethatliterallyshamemuchofthesix-figurecompetition.

Butit’snotjusttheperformanceandengineeringthatareimpressive;it’sthethinkingtoo.Whichbringsusbacktotheconceptoftrickle-down.Ifyouwantdevelopmentsatthetopofyourrangetobeapplicableatlowerpricepoints,you’dbetterbesureofboththeintegrityofyourdesignandtheintegrityofyourthinking.That’sbecausetherearetwowaystotrickledownthebenefitsofaflagshipproduct.Youcantaketheoverallconceptandexecuteitwithmoreaffordableengineering(theWilsonBeneschSquareFiveisaperfectexampleofthis,aCardinalwrit

1

T

Page 2: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

small)oryoucanmaintainthestandardofengineeringandreducethesize(andbandwidth)--whichbringsustotheEndeavour,aspeakerthatmightplayTyriontotheCardinal’sTywin,butwhichshouldn’tbemistakenforaTVdetective.

SeetheEndeavourinthefleshandthere’snomistakingitsclosephysicalandtechnologicalrelationshiptotheCardinal,fromthedriversandsurfacefinishtothe“aero”capandcharacteristicconcavesculptingofthespine.ButwhereastheCardinalandSquareFiveareconceptualtwins,theEndeavourisnotsimplyaCardinalthat’sbeencutoffattheknees.Itmightusethesametechnologyandsharemanyofthesamecabinetelements,butthesmallerenclosureandreducednumberofdriveunitspresentsadifferentsetofchallengesandmandatesadifferentconceptualmodel.Infact,forthosefamiliarwiththeWilsonBeneschrange,itmightbetemptingtoassumethattheEndeavourrepresentsmoreofanupdatedDiscoveryratherthanadown-sizedCardinal--temptingbutwrong.

Aswe’lldiscover,noteverythingabouttheEndeavourisquiteasitseems,norasitsounds--makingassumptionsadangerousbusiness.WhentheDiscoveryfirstappeared15yearsago,itdebutedanovellayout.Atwo-and-a-halfwaystand-mountwiththeforward-firingbass/middriver

placedabovethetweeterandaugmentedbyapairofdownward-firing,isobaricallycoupledbassunits,itwasacomplexyetremarkablysuccessful

responsetothechallengeofextractinguseablebandwidthfromacompactenclosure,onethatwentontoconsiderablecriticalandcommercialsuccess.Soperhapsit’snotsurprisingthatWilsonBeneschhaverevisitedtheformatfortheEndeavour,whichsharestheintegralstand,two-and-a-halfwaytopologyanddifferentialreflexloadingoftheDiscovery.Italsoflanksthetweeterwiththemid-bassdriveraboveanddownward-firingisobaricallyloadedbassdriversbelow,soperhapstheassumptionthattheEndeavorrepresentsanupdateoftheearlierdesignisunderstandable--butthatiswherethesimilarities

stop.Thingshavecomealong,longwayintheinterveningdecadeandahalf.

ThedriversusedintheEndeavorarethesameSemispheretweeteremployedintheflagshipspeaker,alongwithTacticIIunitsspecificallybuiltforthisspeaker,sorelatedbutnotidenticaltotheonesusedintheCardinal.Thecabinet

2

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Page 3: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

usesthesamecombinationofheavilymachinedaluminumbaffleandsidecheekscombinedwithcarboncompositeACTsidepanelsandthemassiveextruded-aluminumspineinheritedfromtheflagshipspeaker.Infact,thesubstantialuprightfortheEndeavour’sstandisbuiltfromtwoCardinalspinesattachedfacetoface--ofwhichmorelater.Theinternalspacehasevolvedsignificantly,withthebass/middrivernowenjoyingitsown,dedicatedandseparatelyloadedenclosurevolume,whilethedownward-firingreflexportsarehelicallywoundcarbontubesthatcomecompletewithscrew-inDelrinplugsshouldyouwanttosealthem--adefinitestepforwardovertheeffectivebutlessthanelegantalternativeofsocks!

Inall,theEndeavouremploysfourdifferentformsofcarbonfiber,eachchosenspecificallyforpurpose.ButifyoureallywanttounderstandthedifferencesbetweentheDiscoveryandEndeavor,looknofurtherthanweightsandmeasures.TheDiscoveryis43”tall,witha15-litercabinetthatoffersa-2dBpointat45Hzandweighsinat57pounds.TheEndeavourstandsoverafoottallerat58”,reachesdowntoa-2dBpointof38Hz,hasa22-literinternalvolumeandtogetherwithitsstanditweighsinat220pounds.Sothenewerspeakeris50%biggerandfourtimesasheavy,goesdeeper(andlouder)andofferstechnologythat’sthreeorevenfourgenerationsmoreadvanced.IftheEndeavourisagrown-upDiscovery,thenit’sbustingoutallover.Or,toputitanotherway,theEndeavourrepresentsanF22RaptortotheDiscovery’sF4Phantom:Theyweredesignedtodothesamejob,look(sortof)thesame,buttherethesimilarityends.Whichisjustaswell,asthepricecomparisonworkstoo.At$49,500(£25,500)perpair,theEndeavourisn’tjustwaymorecapablethantheDiscovery,it’swaymoreexpensivetoo.Compareittotheuniversalbenchmarkforhigh-endspeakerpricing(thatwouldbeWilsonAudio)andintheUKitsitsrightbetweentheSashaW/P2andtheAlexia.That’ssomeprettyheavycompetition.Howdoesthenotionofastand-mount

stackupagainstthesefloorstandingalternatives--especiallyastandmountthat’sjustasphysicallyandvisuallyimposingasthosefloorstanders?

Thisiswhereweshedthesecondsetofassumptions--theonesthatgowithso-called“minimonitors”.There’snothing“mini”abouttheEndeavour.Onceyouactuallystartlookingalittlecloser,yourealizethatthisspeakerisactuallyquiteabitlargerthanitappears.Let’sstartwiththequestionofinternalvolume.There’sahugedifferencebetweenthevisual(external)sizeofaspeakerenclosureanditsacoustic(internal)size--andthatdifferenceconsistsofthecabinetwalls.Consideraconventionalbox,rectangularinshapeandbuiltfrom30mmmaterialwithadoublethicknessbaffle.TomatchtheEndeavour’s22-literinternalvolumeand9.5”bafflewidth,thestandardcabinetwouldneedtobearound15.5”deepand19”tall--actuallynotfaroffofthedimensionsoftheEndeavouritself:exceptthatassoonasyoustarttoshapeortaperthatcabinetforacousticadvantage,thosedimensionsstarttogrowalarmingly.MimictheEndeavour’salmosttriangularfootprintandthecabinetgainsaroundsixinchesinheight.Andsoitgoes:Eachmodificationyoumakeintermsofslopingthefrontbaffleorintroducingnon-parallelsides,internalbracesordividerseatsawayatthatinternalvolume,makingthecabinetphysicallyandvisuallylarger.Buildawell-braced,acousticallyoptimizedandmechanicallycontrolledcabinetwithagenuine22-litreinternalvolumeoutofflatpanelsandseehowlargeitendsup.

HowcometheEndeavorissolargeontheinsidebutsosmallontheoutside?It’smainlydowntotheminimalthicknessofthecarbonsandwichsidepanels,aluminumbaffleandsidecheeks,elementsthataddverylittle

physicalvolume.Butit’salsodowntothecomplex

curvesthatthesematerials

3

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Page 4: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

allow,whichoffersignificantstructuralstiffnessaswellasnon-parallelwallsthatrequirenostiffening(andvolume-consuming)braces.Thatstiffnessisfurtherenhancedbythebeefyextrudedtriangularspinethatrisesfromthestandallthewaytothetopofthecabinet,doubledupbelowthecabinetitselfwithasecondsectionofspinethatlocksintoandcouplesthemachinedaluminumbafflefortheisobaricbassunitsdirectlytothestand’smassivetriangulatedbaseplate,againsimilartobutinthiscasealittlesmallerthantheoneontheCardinal,althoughitstillsportsthesamestainless-steelcouplinglegsandcups,withthehugeadjustingwheelsintherearcorners.

Bynowyou’llhavegatheredthatstiffnessandmechanicalbehaviorloomlargeinthethinkingbehindtheEndeavour.Thisisn’tjustaboutmakingaspeakerthat’ssmaller,cuteroreasiertoaccommodate.It’sallaboutmakingCardinalquality,technology,constructionandmaterialsavailableatalowerpricepoint--andthatmakestheequationeasy.Youwanttodroptheprice,usefewerpartsandlessoftheparts.ButWilsonBenesch’slogicisthatifthat’sthecase,whynotturnthosethingstoyouradvantage?So,don’tjustmakealesserorcurtailedCardinal;makeaspeakerthatisinitsownwayandonitsowntermsbetterthantheCardinal.Ifthecabinetisgoingtobephysicallysmaller,itcanalsobestifferandbetterbehaved,fewerdriversmeansthattheacousticcenterofthedesigncanbemoretightlyfocusedandthereducedsizealsoallowsyoutogetitawayfromtheintrusiveeffectsofroomboundariesandbassreinforcement,whileawell-designedstandmeansthatyoudon’thavetosacrificemechanicalgrounding.

Let’stakethosepointsinorder,butlet’sstartwiththedriversthemselves.TheTacticII7”unitandSemisphere1”soft-dometweeter

featurerightacrossWilsonBenesch’sGeometryseries.Withtheplethoraofexotictweeter

diaphragmslitteringhigh-endaudiothesedays,theuseofa1”soft-domemightnotseemallthatexotic,butaswithallthingsaudio,it’snotwhatyouusebuthowyouuseitthatmatters.Thelatestsoft-domedesignshavealottooffer.Buildingtheunitin-househasallowedWilsonBeneschtotailorthetweeter’slow-frequencyroll-offtosuittheirpreferredfirst-ordercrossovertopology,eschewingferrofluiddampinginfavorofaclosedandcarefullyoptimizedrearchamber.

Dispersion(helpedbythemachinedconcavewaveguideinthefaceplate)andextensionarebothexceptionalforasoft-dome,thecarbon-bracedsilkdomedeliveringa-2dBfigureat30kHz.

AlthoughallTacticIIdriverssharethesameelegantlysculptedbasketandmotorassembly,theisotacticpolypropyleneconesusedineachdifferentdesignareindividuallywoventooptimizeeachdriver’smechanicalbehaviorandacousticoutputforpurpose.Atthelastcount,thecompany

producedover25differentdrivers,allbuiltonthesamecarefullysculpted,minimalistchassis,withitsgorgeouslyslim,low-reflection,low-turbulencelegs.Themid-bassandbassdriversintheEndeavourareeachpurpose-built,addinganothertwodistinctunitstothestocklist.Theforwardfacingmidrangeunitisrunwideopen,relyingentirelyonmechanicalroll-offtoblendittothedriversaboveandbelowitintherange.Boththetweeterandthebassunitsareintegratedusinggentlefirst-orderslopestoattenuatetheiroutputabove500Hzandbelow5kHz.

4

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Page 5: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

Butthecrossovertopology(althoughnominallyatwo-way,first-orderelectricalbuttwo-and-a-half-wayacousticalfilter,itisactuallymuchclosertoathree-waysysteminpractice)isn’ttheonlythingthat’sunusualaboutthewaytheEndeavour’sdriversworktogether.Havingaseparateinternalenclosureforthemidrangeunitisfarfromunique,butinthiscasetheexecutionisdefinitelydifferent.Therearwaveofthemidrangeunitisenclosedandrear-reflex-loadedbyacriticallyshaped,bell-likeenclosurebuiltfromcarbonfiberreinforcedwithnanoparticle-impregnatedresin--orCarbon-NanotechinWB-speak.Thislatestdevelopmentincarbon-fibertechnologytakesstiffness-to-weightratiostoanewhighaswellasdeliveringsuperbself-damping.WidelyusedatcriticalpointsonFormula1carsandmoresparinglyintop-flight(andseriouslyexpensive)bicycleframes,thisisthefirsttimeI’vecomeacrossitinaloudspeaker.Hereitperformsthreefunctions:thelimitedvolumerollingoffthelow-frequencyoutputfromthedriver,controllinganddissipatingtheenergyinitsrearwave,whilstalsoisolatingitfrominterferencebythelow-frequencydrivers(aswellasmaximizingtheavailablevolumeforthebassenclosure).ThisoptimizedrearchamberaddsconsiderablemidbandclaritytotheEndeavour’sperformance,helpingpreventunwantedenergyescapingthroughthedriverdiaphragmbutalsothroughthecabinetwalls.Oneoftheleast-understoodaspectsofloudspeakerdesignisthedamagedonebyunintendedleakageofenergythatescapesfromthecabinetthat’ssupposedtotrapit.Inthiscase,anysuchenergyhastocrossnotjustonecarbon-fiberboundary,buttwo--theCarbon-NanotechmidrangechamberandthenthesandwichstructureoftheACTcarbon-compositeouterenclosure.This

freedomfromacousticintermodulationdistortioniskeytotheEndeavour’sclarityandtactilecommunicativequality--butI’m

gettingaheadofmyself.

Placingthemidrangedriverabovethetweeterwiththebassdriverspositionedbelowputsthehigh-frequencydriverattheacousticcenterofthedesign,whileachievingaremarkablytight10”spacingthatspanstheacousticcentersofallfourdrivers.IftheDiscoverywaslaudedforitsseamlessintegration,theEndeavourtakesthataspectofperformancetoawholenewlevel--helpednodoubtbytheseparationofbassandmidrangeenclosuresandthelackofstructuralresonanceinthestifferreflexports.Butalsoaddingtothatlackofmuddle,congestionandmusicaldiscontinuityisthedirectgroundpathestablishedbythecabinetandstand.Thedriversareallbolteddirectlytoaluminumcabinetelements,withadirectpathconnectingthemtothespeaker’sspine.Eventhemidbandenclosureisbracedbetweenthefrontbaffle(anddirectlycoupledto)therearspine,providingadirectgroundpathfortheenergyitcontains.Meanwhile,theenclosureitselfisconstructedfromanACTsandwichsectionandthemolded“aero”cap,bothincrediblylight,rigidelementswithverylowstoragecharacteristics.

Thus,spuriousenergyisactivelyencouragedtoleavethecabinet,ledawaybythereadilyavailableground

pathofferedbythesubstantialandfirmlymated,interlockingalloyparts--thefrontandbassbaffles,thetwo-piecespineandthetriangularbase.Thethreestainless-steelpostsonwhichthewholeassemblystandarethefinalpieceofthejigsaw,theirincreasedcoercivityandrigidcouplingtothelarge-diametercups

5

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

Page 6: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

theysitonactivelyinvitinganyremainingenergynotdissipatedinthestructureondowntomechanicalground.Overallit’saclevercomplexanddemonstrablyeffectivesolutiontoriddingthecabinetofunwantedmechanicalenergyandallowingthedriversanacousticallyunpollutedenvironmentinwhichtowork.

Theotherbigdecisionfacinganyloudspeakerdesigneristhebalancebetweenbandwidth,cabinetvolumeandsystemsensitivity.Thesmallertheoverallvolumeofthespeaker,themoreconstrainedtheoptionsbecome,placingevergreaterpressureoneitheravailablebassextensionorefficiency.Balancingthesetwoaspectsofcompactspeakerdesignissooftenthemake-or-breakdecisioninanysmallspeakerproject.You’vegottoextractenoughbasstobemusicallyconvincingbutdosowithoutcreatingamonsterthatneedsmassiveampsjusttoraiseasmile.Theworldofaudioisfullofcompactspeakersthatcangrabholdofmonstermonoblocksandsuckthemdry--allwithoutbreakingsweatorintotheirmusicalstride.Theymaynotbebigbutthey’renotclevereither.ThisisanotherareainwhichtheEndeavour’sthin-wallcabinetscores.ItsTardis-likeinternaldimensions(andifyoudon’tknowwhataTardisis,thenyouneedtocheckoutDr. Who)allowwhatisremarkablebassextensionforitsapparentsize,whileretainingreasonableefficiencyandgenuinelyaccommodatingdrivecharacteristics.IachievedthebestresultsfromtheEndeavorwiththeEngstrom&EngstromTheLarsIIandtheBerningQuadratureZmonoblocks,oneemployingapairof300BEXSoutputtubespersideandtheotheranOTL!Ofcourse,theeasyimpedancecharacteristicsassociatedwithfirst-orderslopesareafactorhere,butevenmorecrucialisthedirectlyconnectedmidbassdriver.Althoughthesystemisratedat89dB(itselfaremarkablefiguregiventhe-2dBpointat38Hz

6

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

combinedwiththecompactdimensionsofthecabinetitself)itseemsmoreefficientthanthat,duetothelackofanysubtractivecrossover

acrossthebroadmidrange.ButthesuccessIenjoyedwiththeseampsisnoaccident,andas

muchasittellsyouabouttheEndeavour’seasydrivecharacteristic,italsorevealsalotaboutitsspecific,veryappealingmusicalstrengths.

earfamiliarmusicontheEndeavour andonceagainyouareindangerof fallingpreytofirstimpressions--andtheirassociatedassumptions.Thefirstthingthatstrikesmeaboutthisspeakeristhelean,unclutteredneutralityofitssound.Thesecondistheharmonicwarmth,colorandpresenceitbringstoinstrumentsandvoices.Byallmeansreadthosetwosentencesagain,because,

yes,theymightwell(probablydo)seemcontradictory.Afterall,speakersthataregenerallydescribedaswarmaredefinitelynotneutral,thatwarmthcomingfromathickening,cabinet-generatedcolorationintheirmidbass.ButasthedescriptionoftheEndeavour’sstructureandmaterialsshouldmakeclear,thisisalow-colorationcabinetparexcellence.Sowheredoesthatwarmthcomefrom?It’srootedinthebeautifullycontrolledbehaviorofthedriverdiaphragms,thewovenisotacticpolypropylenebass

andmidunitsandthecriticallybracedsilkdomeofthetweeter.Theirinherentself-dampingandlackofresonantpeaksallowsthemtodevelopafullrangeofharmonicsfromeachimpulse,withoutemphasisorexaggeration.Theresultingbodyanddimensionalitytheybringtoinstrumentsisremarkablynaturalandconvincing,andit’sthisthatinveststhesoundwith

H

Page 7: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

7

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

itsconvincingpresence,whilethelackofspuriousenergyclogging,congestingandslowingthemidbassiswhatdeliverstheclarityandimmediacy.

Oops--thereIgoagain,usingconfusingandcontradictoryterms.Imean,whousesthewordimmediacytodescribetheperformanceofapolypropylenecone?TheanswertothatisanybodywhohasheardtheCardinal--oranybodywhohasheardtheEndeavour.Sitdown,closeyoureyesandlisten,andthat’sjustwhatyou’llhear--soundwithanalmostreach-out-and-touchpresenceandimmediacy.IwasfortunateenoughtohearMaximVengerovplaytheotherday--anexperiencethathasleftalastingimpressionandasignificantcontributiontotheCDcollection.OneofthosediscsisanApexlabeledTeldecrecording[Apex256467300-5]oftheSibeliusandNielsenviolinconcertos,withBarenboimandtheChicagoSymphonyOrchestra.PutitonandthefragileopeningoftheSibeliussoundsquitedistant,withatypicallymidhallbalance.Now,startitagain,butthistime,sitandlisten,eyesclosedandconcentratingandsuddenlythemusic,theinstruments,theperformersarerightthere.ThephysicaldistancetoVengerov’ssoloviolinisutterlyconsistentwithmyrow-Fseatattheconcert--closerthanmanypeoplefeelcomfortable.Sowhythediscontinuitybetweenhearingandactuallylistening?

Havinglivedwiththesespeakersforagoodwhilenow,usedthemwithalotofdifferentsystemsandplayedthemforalotofdifferentlisteners,thereactioniscompletelyuniversal.Walkintotheroomwiththespeakersplayingandpeopleneverremarkonthesound--untiltheyactuallysitsdownandreallylisten.Thenthey’reimpressed--andalittleconfused.Thereasonliesinourexpectations--thewayweexpectaudiosystemstowork.It’ssomethingyoumightwellhavenoticedthefirsttimeyoulistenedtoadiamondtweeter.Itprobablysoundedalmostdullandabitflat,but

whatyouwerehearingwasthelackofedgeorexaggerationinthehighfrequencies--theaddedsparkleandetchingthatarethe

resonantsignatureofless-well-behaveddrivers.Onceyourearsadjustedtheystartedtoappreciate

justhowunforcedandnaturalthosehighswere,howcleananddevoidofglareorhardness.TheEndeavourpresentsuswiththesamechallenge,onlyhereitinvolvestheentirerange,notjustthehighfrequencies.

Firstimpressionssuggestthatthisspeakerhasaclassicmidhallbalance,fulsomeandwarm--sowenaturallyassumeitwillpresentamidhallperspective,rightuptothepointwhereweactuallystopandaskthequestion.AsI’vealreadysaid,actuallylistentothisspeakerandyousoonrealizethatthatwarmthisgeneratedbyitsnaturalinstrumentalharmonicsandtonality,nottheaddedreverbofthehallinwhichthoseinstrumentsareplaying.Wearesousedtoassociatingdynamicdefinitionandtheresolutionofdetailwiththepared-away,etched,fauxtransparencythatpassesforhigh-endsoundthatwhenweheartherealthingcomingfromasystemwealmostdon’trecognizeit.Theassumptionisthatifit’swarm,thenitmustalsobesoftanddistant--yettheconcertexperiencetellsyouthatisn’ttrue.Yes,aliveorchestracanshockandevenhurt,butitdoesitwithlevelanddynamics,notedgeorglare.

Page 8: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

8

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

AwhileagoIscandalizedsomereaderswiththesuggestionthatagoodsystemcouldoutperformaliveorchestraonabadday.Itwasaconclusiondrawnasaresultofdirectexperience.Incontrast,Vengerov(ablyassistedbyYuriTemirkanovandtheSt.Petersberg)ablydemonstratedjusthowfarwehavetogointryingtomatchagreatliveperformance.ThesystemthatpromptedthefirstpiecewasbuiltaroundtheCardinal.ThespeakersthathavehadtosurviveintheshadowofVengerovet alaretheEndeavours--andthey’vedonearemarkablejob.TimetorevisitthatSibeliusViolinconcerto.

TheseWilsonBeneschspeakersthrowabroadanddeepsoundstage--anotherreasonwhyit’sworthshuttingyoureyeswhenyoulisten,toescapethevisualdiscontinuityofanythingsoexpansive(andpowerful)emanatingfromsomethingsoslender.Thequaveringdimuendoviolinsthatpresagethesoloentryarebeautifullyfragileanddelicate,aperfectfoilfortheconcentratedenergyofthesoloinstrument.Theyspreadfarleft,eachadditionalvoiceaddingthespaceoccupiedbythewoodwinds,violasandlargerstringstotheorchestralsoundscape.Thegradualstepsbuildsonaturallyandeffortlesslythatthesuddengruntofthoseearlybassunderpinningswillsurpriseyou,whilethefirstshort,sharpcrescendoarriveswithashockingweight,authorityandvigor--justasitdoesplayedlive.Evenwithyoureyesopen,there’snosenseofthesoundbeinggeneratedbythecabinets,notelltaleaberrationstodisturbthefabricoftheacousticspaceorcatchyourear.Insteadtheperformancehasaholisticcoherenceandpresence,anaturalperspectiveandscalethatstandtestimonytotheseamlessintegrationofthevariousdrivers,theircommontonalityandlackofdestructivesignature.Howhasthisspeakergottenitsorightwhensomanygetitsowrong?

ThemoretimeIspendwiththeEndeavourthemoreI’mconvincedthatthewayit’sbuiltandthewayitsoundsareinextricablylinked.

That’sactuallytrueofallproducts,butherethereseemstobeanalmostintuitivelinkagethat

connectsthethinkingdirectlytotheperformance.Let’sstartwiththemidrange,wheresomuchofwhatismusicallyimportanthappens.There’snoescapingthefactthat,forallthebenefitsofcontrollableself-dampingthatcomewiththeuseofisotactic

polypropylenecones,they’reheavierthanmanyofthealternatives.Toreapthosepotentialbenefits,youaregoingtohavetoworkhardtoovercomethathurdle--whichisexactlywhatWilsonBeneschhavedone.Inrunningthedriverwideopen(thuseliminatinganysubtractivecrossover)andworkinghardtomaximizetheefficiencyofitsmotor,byusingalarge7”diametersweptareaandgivingthedirectlycoupledamplifiertheeasiestpossiblejobacrosstherestofthebandwidth,theyscrew

everylastounceofadvantagetheycanfromtheirmaterialof

choice,displayingthebenefits,amelioratingtheweaknesses.It’san

objectlessoninsoundengineering.Theresultisamidbandthatistonally

naturalandrhythmicallyanddynamicallyarticulate.It’sunforcedandexpressive.No,itdoesn’thavethealmostsurrealquicknessofsomeceramicdrivers--ortheirleading-edgeemphasisandtruncatedharmonics.Nordoesitdeliverthepart-your-hairdynamicsofahorn--butthensofewhornscanachieveanylevelofneutrality.I’mconvincedthattheoptimizedrearchamberalsoplaysitspart,intermsofitssuperiorshapeandstructure,factorsthatdealmoreeffectivelywiththemidbassdriver’srearwave,butalsobecauseofthenestednatureofthecabineteliminatingspuriousenergyfromthemusicalpictureanditsactioninrolling

Page 9: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

9

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

offthedriver’sbottomend.Itsclean,clearandunclutteredpresentationiskeytotheEndeavour’smusicallyconvincingperformance--anditisfoundedinthatmidrangedriverandadesignthatmakesthemostofitsattributes.

ChiefamongstthosestrengthsistheuncannilynaturaltonalityandbodytheEndeavorbringstovoicesandinstruments.JustasitinvestsVengerov’sfiddlewithanutterlyconvincing(andcaptivating)senseofpresenceandpower,familiarvoicesarealmostspookily

natural.JacksonBrowne’shuskysingingisinstantlyrecognizable(Love Is Strange [InsideRecordingsINR5111-0])asaretherangeand

sheervarietyofDavidLindley’svocalfireworks.Thecomplementarycharacterandintimacyinthe

performanceisclear,theeasygiveandtakebetweentwosingerswhoarealsofriends.Butinitsownway,theEndeavour’sabilitytoseparate,tonallyandinspace,thevariousacousticguitarsthatfeatureonthisrecordingisequallyimpressive.Withanythinguptosixdifferentinstrumentsinplayatanyonetime,

Boring But Useful

WhenitcomestohandlingandhookinguptheEndeavours,thereareafewthingsthatcanmakeyourlifeconsiderablyeasier.Thefirstthingisthatalthoughthesearenominallystand-mounts,thespeakerisasingle,verysolidconstruction.Thatmeansitcomesinasurprisinglylargecrateandisalsoheavierthanyoumightexpect(becauseofallthataluminum).Youwilldefinitelyneedtwopeopletounpackandpositionthese.Eventhen,it’snotquiteasstraightforwardasitmightbe.

Forstarters,thetri-wirableterminalsareontheundersideofthestand.Theseacceptspadesorbananaplugsandcomewithsolid-silverwirebridgingtheconnections.Attachingcablesisdefinitelybestdonewiththespeakeronitsside;makesurethatyouhaveasoftsurfacetogounderthestandandsomethingpaddedtorestthehigh-glossfinishofthetop“cap”on.Spadesarethebestoptionwhenitcomestoconnectingthecablesandmakesurethatyouareconnectiontherightcablestotherightsockets--thelayoutislistedinthemanualbutnotunderthespeaker,whilethepositiveandnegativeconnectionsarenotcolor-codedbutannotatedusingengravedsymbolsthatarenotexactlyhigh-vis.ThisisoneofthoseinstanceswhereitpaystoRTFBandalsohaveasmall,brighttorch--asseenonCSI--tohand.Ifyoubiwireorbiampthespeakers(andI’dhighlyrecommendthelatter),thenyou’llprobablyneedtoretainthesilver-wirejumpersbetweenatleasttwosetsofterminals.Ifso,makesurethatyousupporttheterminalevenlybywrappingasinglelayerofwirerightthewayarounditscircumference.ThemechanicaladvantagedeliveredbythelargenutsthatWilsonBeneschuseontheirterminalsmakesforreallytightconnections,butissufficienttosnap

aterminalifitisleftunsupportedononesidesothatitcantiltasyoutightenit.Learnfrommymistakeandsaveyourselfembarrassmentandinconvenience.

Onceyouhavethespeakershookedupandthecablesdressed,youcanstandthespeakersuprightandthinkaboutpositioningthem.Thisiswhereyoudiscoverthattheonlyhorizontalsurfaceonthespeakeristhetopfaceofthestand,andallthesidesarecurved.Levelingiseasyenough,becauseyoucanplacethebubblerightbetweentheadjusters,buttoe-inrequiresareferenceofsomesort.Iusedastripoftapetomarkthecenterlineofthestand,betweenthefrontpostandthespeaker’sspine,againstwhichIplacedthelaser.Whenitcomestoplacement,theEndeavoursareseriouslycriticalofpositioning.Tooclosetotherearwallandtheygetmuddledandcongested,toofarawayandtheylackbassweight.Thisisonespeakerwhereitreallypaystoworkwiththenodes--specifichumpsanddipsintheroom’sacousticmap--inyourroom.Iendedupwithfourdifferentsetups,each8”apart,beforeIwassurethatI’dgottenthespeakersintherightplace.It’snotjusttherightplacewithinthenode,buttherightnodethatyouarelookingfor.It’saprocessthatistime-consumingandawkward,becauseyouneedtohavethespeakerstoodonitsfloorcouplers/protectorsinordertogetthebassjustright,butonceonthemit’salmostimpossibletomove.

Laboriousitmightbe,butitisalsoessentialifyouaregoingtoextractthefullperformancefromthesespeakers--inmusicalandsonicterms.Don’tbetemptedtocutcornersanddon’tthinkthatcloseenoughisgoodenough--itisn’t.Butonceyoudogetitright,theEndeavourswillbothloveandrewardyoufortakingthetimeandtrouble.

-Roy Gregory

Page 10: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

10

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

theeasewithwhichyoucanlocateeachandidentifybothitscontributionandthestyleofitsplayerisparticularlyimpressive.Butperhapsmostimpressiveofallisthewaythespeakerhandlesaudiencenoise,applauseandtheinnerdetailsofthesoundstage.Notonlydoesisprojecttheapplauseandthemultiplesing-alongvoicesforwardofthestageandaroundthelistener,butLindley’sHawaiianguitarisclearlybeingplayedflatonhislap,afactcaptureddespitetheindividualmicsusedoneachinstrument.

AtthesametimethisgreatliverecordingrevealsthattheEndeavourcomesupjustshortoftheCardinalintermsofabsoluteimmediacy,leading-edgeattackandbite.Althoughit’sonlyratedasasingledBlowerinefficiency,thesmallerspeaker,withitsnarrowerbandwidthandmorelimitedsweptareacan’tmatchtheattackanddynamicauthorityofitsbiggerbrother--orofcompetitorsliketheWilsonSashaW/P2orFocalScalaUtopiaV2.It’sanotherpartofthecontradictoryauraljigsawpuzzlethatistheEndeavour,contributingtothatinitialimpressionofmidhallsoftness.Eventhoughinpracticeit’sthesubtlestofeffects,it’scompoundedbythetotalabsenceofartificialhardnessoredgeinthespeaker--whichiswhyyoustartbythinkingthatit’ssoft,onlytodiscoverthatit’snot.Howisitfelt?Inasubtlesmoothingofinstrumentaltexture,orinthecaseofLove Is Strange,aslightlossofthesheervigorandintensitythatcharacterizestheperformance.Puttingthatinperspective,it’ssomethingthatvarieswithamplifier(farmorenoticeablewiththeQuadratureZthantheLars,forinstance)andwhichisreallyonlyapparentwhencompareddirectlytosomeofthebestandmostexpensivesystemsaround.Butitisthere,anditdoeshelpexplaintheEndeavour’salmostschizoidpresentationalpersona.

Doesn’tthatflyinthefaceofmyearlierdescriptionofthespeakeras“immediate”?Perhaps,inthegeneralsenseoftheterm,it

does.Ifyoutakeittosuggestsuddenimpactandinstantdynamicresponse,thenclearlythe

Endeavourisjustoffthatpace.ButI’mthinkinginslightlydifferentterms.WhenIdescribedVengerov’sviolinas“rightthere,”Iwasn’tkidding.Lackofgrainandalownoisefloorareattributesthatarenormallyattachedtoelectronics,buttheEndeavourhastheminspades.

Itssoundstagehasacalmclaritysimplybecausethespeakerbanishestheclutter,thelow-levelnoiseandtheblurringthatcomefromacousticintermodulation--thesameasitsharmonicsarenaturallyscaledanddistinctduetotheabsenceofmechanicalintermodulation.Theendresultisthesenseofinstrumentslockedinspaceandtime,withareach-out-and-touchstability,nothingcloggingthespacearoundandbetweenthem,nothing

betweenyouandthem.Inthiscasethat’swhatImeanbyimmediacy:

theEndeavoursucceedsinincludingyouinthesame,seamlessacousticspaceas

themusicians--puttingyou,andthem,rightthere.Inonesenseyouaretradingthecrispdynamicimpactofmoreefficientspeakersforthe

WilsonBenesch’sinclusivecommunicationandunobtrusiveneutrality.Therealquestionis,isitapriceworthpaying?Whatvaluedoyouplaceonthespeaker’sunobtrusivemusicalcoherence,itsexceptionalneutralityandremarkablemusicalversatility?That’soneonlyyoucananswer,butthelongeryoulistentotheEndeavorthebetterthecaseitmakes,themoreyounoticetheintrusiveaberrationsthatbedevilthecompetition.

Whichisasgoodaplaceasanytoconsiderthepowerandimpactofthisspeaker’sbottomend.Considerforasecondthat22litersdonotexactlyequalalarge

Page 11: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

11

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

cabinetandthatessentially,whenitcomestomovingair,you’regoingtobedoingitwithasingle7”driver(withabitofhelpthroughthemidbassfromtheforward-firingunit).Whatshouldyourealisticallyexpectandwhatdoyouactuallyget?Well,theanswertothefirstisprobablybassthat’sclean,quick,articulatebutlackingweight.Theanswertothesecondiscleaner,quickerandwaymorearticulatethanyouexpected,deeperandwaymorepowerfultoo.Thetrickliesingettingthespeakerpositionedjustrightsothatthespeaker’stight,quick,clearbottomendisallowedtoreachdownasfaraspossible,whilegettingallthehelpfromtheroomthat’savailable.Theheightofthestandkeepsthingscleanandmaintainstheunclutteredqualityofthemidband,theseparationofthebassandmiddrivers’acousticenclosurespreventsthesmudgingthatmightotherwiseemanatefromsuchasmallenclosure,whiletheisobaricdrivermaintainsleading-edgeattackanddynamicrange.Onceyou’vegottentheEndeavoursinjusttherightspot(seesidebar),theydeliverbassthatbreathes,withrealpower,scale,impact,pitchandtone.Onagoodorchestralrecording(theVengerovagain,orthePhilharmonia’sMahlersymphonieswithMaazel[SignumSIGCD360])thebassfloatsconvincingly,ratherthanrumblingacrossthefloor,anacoustictrickthatisnormallythepreserveofmuchlarger,genuinelyfull-rangesystems.

OftheEndeavour’spricepeers,onlytheKEFBlade(anotherspeakerthatperchesitsbassdriversonhigh)matchesthisperformance.ThegruntingbassarpeggiosthatmarktheopeningofMahler’sSecondSymphonybelchforth,fulloftensionandpurpose,roughtextureandbustlinginsistencethatbodeswellforthemassivescaleevokedinthelatermovements--andyouwon’tbedisappointed.It’sthisabilitytomarrytheairanddelicacy,thelyricalsweetnessofMahler’smelodieswiththedarkforebodingofhissubtextandtheexplosivereliefofhisredemption,thetransparencyandclarityofasmallspeakerwiththescale,weight,dynamicandmusicalauthorityofamuchbiggerspeakerthatmakestheEndeavourreallyquitespecial.It’saneattrickonanylevel,buttodoitsoconsistentlyandapparentlyeffortlesslyfromacabinetthiscompactisborderlinemagical.

Theseamlessintegrationofthelow-frequenciesgivesbroadbandinstrumentslikecelloandpianoawelcomesenseofconfidenceandstability.

Combinedwiththeinstrumentalbodyandmusicalpurposethatcharacterizesitentireaudiblerange,thisbringsmusiclikebig-band

Basievividlytolife,theeasyswinganddensetuttisthrivingonthesure-footedrhythmicflow

andunimpededdynamicresponseoftheEndeavour.Evenwiththismanyinstrumentsplayingthisloud,thesoundretainsitsclean,unforcedsenseofpatternandorganization.Butifyouwantanobjectlessoninwhat’sbeingplayedandwhy,looknofurtherthanJohannaMartzy’sfabulousperformanceoftheBeethovenKreutzerSonatadrawnfromtheCoupd’ArchetMartzyradiorecordingsbox[Coupd’ArchetCOUP003],aliving,breathingexpositiononnotjustMs.Martzy’smasteryofherinstrument,butheramazingrapportwithlong-termaccompanistJeanAntonietti.Thevividdynamiccontrasts,rapidlyshiftingtempi,pausesandswitchesintheaccentanddirectionofthemusicallinearedeliveredwithanaturalweightandauthoritythatbrooksnoargument.Asaperformanceit’smonumental--bothfromtheartistsandthespeakers.

Whenitcomestolong-termlisteningsatisfaction,balanceisoftenanunderestimatedattribute.OneofthethingsthatmaketheEndeavorgrowonyou--andgoongrowingonyou--isthenaturalnessofitstop-to-bottomweighting.Oneoftherealadvantagesofbuildingyourowndriversistheabilitytoreallybalanceandshapetheirresponse,somethingthatbecomesabundantlyclearonceyou’velivedwiththisspeaker.Onceagain,integrationplaysitspart,helpedalongbythecarefullycontrolleddispersionoftheSemispheretweeter,butit’sthetonalityandsoniccontinuitythatreallyhithome,thepresence,body,rangeoftonalcolorsandthatuncannynaturalness,bornoftheabsenceofedgeorexaggeration.FewspeakerscarrydynamicintentthroughtheirupperregistersthewaytheEndeavordoes,notjustacaseofspeedandattack,butsubstancetoo.YouhearitinthesheerpresenceofVengerov’sinstrumentandinthevitalityofMartzy’sperformance.YouhearitinthebrasstuttisofbothBasieandMahler,andyouhearitinthevocaldexterityandcloseharmoniesofDollyVarden,thenaturalpresenceofvoices,theshimmerofacymbalorthecrystalclarityofthesleighbellsonShawnColvin’s“ShotgunDownTheAvalanche”(Steady On[CBS466142-1]).WilsonBenesch’sbracedsoft-domemaynotgoashighassome,butitdovetailsperfectlywiththeirotherdrivers,investingtheirspeakerswithasatisfyingsenseof

Page 12: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

12

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

seamlesscontinuityandanattractivesenseofpresence.It’sabalancethatseemstostrikeanewhighintheEndeavour,andthatliftsthespeaker’soverallperformanceanothernotch.

Whichbringsusfullcircle,backtothemiddleofthemids.Historyislitteredwithspeakerdesignsthatexhibitedfantasticneutralityand/orseparation--oftentothecompleteexclusionoftherhythmicarticulationanddynamicsensitivitiesthatbindmusicintoasinglewholeandcarryitsexpressivepower.It’salmostasifthecontrastingcapabilitiesaremutuallyexclusive:themoreneutralthespeaker,thelessarticulate--andthelessinterestingitwillbetolistento.TheEndeavourmightwellbetheexceptionthatprovestherule.Thanksinnosmallparttoitsdiminutivecabinetandmassivestructure,itexceedstheCardinalintermsofsheerclarityandneutrality,butrhythmicallyitssavinggraceliesintheinsistenceonaminimalistcrossover,andinparticularthatdirectlyconnectedmidbassdriver.Whenitcomestophrasingandshiftsintempo,theshapeofasongoroverlappingrhythms,pausesinapieceorameasuredpace,thatsolidconnectionbetweenoutputstageanddriveunitcomesintoitsown,theamplifierabletoimposeatemporalauthorityonmusicalproceedingsthat’sresponsibleforleavingthelistenerinnodoubtastowhatishappeningandwhen.It’swhyanamplifierwiththemodestoutputoftheLars2candeliversuchacommandingperformance,whythe

quicksilverdynamicsandtransparencyoftheBerningQuadratureZ’sissoeffective.It’snotaforcedorhectoringquality,justanabilityto

betterreflectthechoicesmadebytheplayers,theirpatternandplacementofnotes.Youhearitin

thedrumpatternsbehind“LittleTriggers”(ElvisCostello,This Year’s Model[RadarRAD3])andCostello’stellingvocalhesitations,youhearitintheshapethatNarciscoYepesputsonhisplayingintheRodrigoConcierto De Aranjuez[DeccaSXL2091].It’swheresomuchoftheemotionalpowerofmusicresides.

ButperhapsyouhearitmostimpressivelyofallinthegraduallyunfoldingmajestyoftheGorecki’sThirdSymphony[PolskieRadioPRSACD2].Theslow

openingandoverlappingphrasesofthesplitstringsectionsareneverponderousandneverlag.Thebeautyinthepitch-perfectmelodiclinesandslowlyevolvingharmoniesgrowswiththebreadthandscaleofthepiece,eachlineheldseparateanddistinctastheybindandswellintothatfirstmassiveclimax.Itisacaptivatingandcompellingperformanceoneverylevel,andagaintheperformanceoftheorchestraismatchedbytheperformanceofthespeaker.Forwhatisnominallyacompactdesign,toachievesuchapowerfulanddramaticmusicalimpactisremarkable,speakingvolumesaboutnotjustthequalityandclarityofitslowfrequencies,buttheireffectivenesstoo.

ItispossiblythemostimpressiveexampleoftheEndeavour’sabilitytoreproducethestructurethatunderpinsmusic

--andtodosowithabsolutestability

andcoherence.Anycloggingorimprecision

Page 13: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

13

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m

inthebottom-endpitch,anyvaguenesswhenitcomestotheplacement,spacingorcenterofthoseelongatedandoverlappingbassnotesandthewholepiecewilldescendintoaturgid,shamblingmess.Theabilitytomaintainitsgriponthescale,thepaceandthepatternofGorecki’smassivemasterpiece--andtodoitfromtheconfinesofsuchasmallcabinetisalltheproofyouneedthatWilsonBeneschreallyhaveexploitedthepotentialbenefitsthatcomewithasmallerspeaker.Theemotionalimpact,thebeautyanddrama,thattheEndeavourrevealsinthisperformanceareallthereasonyouneedtotakethisspeakerveryseriouslyindeed.

heCardinalgoesheadtoheadwithsome ofthemostexpensiveandrespectedspeakers outthere,competeswiththemandundercutstheirpricesignificantly.Thatstunningcombinationofengineeringandmaterialcontenttogetherwithasurprisinglyapproachablepricetagguaranteetheirvalueandshouldguaranteetheirappeal.TheEndeavourfacesadifferentandmuchmorechallengingmarket.Itfindsitselfrightinthemiddleofthemosthotlycontestedhigh-endsector.Thisiswhereyoufindtheproductsfromallthosehigh-profilebrandsthatcustomersactuallybuy.WemightallwanttoownWilsonAlexandriaXLFsorFocalGrandeUtopias,butformostofus,SashasorScalasaremorepracticalandalmostaffordable.CantheEndeavourmatchtheappealofthoseestablishedproductsandsurviveinthelongshadowscastbytheirrespectiveflagships?Onlytimewilltell,butifpotentialpurchaserslistenwiththeirearsaswellastheireyes,they’lldiscoverthatthisisaspeakerthatisbothverydifferentfromthecompetitionandveryspecialinitsownright.Itsmaterialcontentandengineeringvaluearefranklyastonishing,especiallyatatimewhensomanycompaniesseemtobe

lookingbackwardsfortechnologicalanddesigninspiration.WilsonBeneschhasalwaysadoptedaresolutelyhigh-techapproachtotheproblem

ofreproducingmusicinthehome.AsI’vealreadyobserved(manytimes)it’snotwhatyouusebut

howyouuseitthatmatters.TheEndeavourdemonstratesthatWilsonBeneschismorethanjustclosetothetechnologicalcuttingedge:Theyknowhowtoexploitthosetechnologiestomaximumeffect--whichmeansmaximummusicalbenefit.

TheEndeavourisaspeakerthatchallengesassumptionsandthestatusquo.It’sdifferentinitsapproach,itsmaterialsandthewayitpresentsthemusicalperformance.Itturnsacceptednotionsoftheestablishedaudioswingsandroundaboutsontheirhead,surprisinganddelightinginequalmeasure.Butmostofallitsucceedsinachievingthatqualitysharedbyallreallygreatloudspeakers--theabilitytoputthemusicfirst.Self-effacingtoafault,thisisinmanywaysoneoftheleastobviouslyimpressiveloudspeakersI’veheard--thatisuntilyoustartlisteninginearnestandringingthechanges.Thewayanddegreetowhichitrespondstoinput,whetherthat’sthemusicalsignalorchangesinthedrivingsystem,underlinesjusthowlittleofitselfitinsertsintotheprocess.Itgivesperformersnotjustavoicebutanauthenticityinawaythatveryfewotherloudspeakerscanmatch.

Whichbringsusrightbacktothequestionofthecompetition.CastingtheEndeavourinthecontextoftheSashaW/P,latestiterationoftheiconicWATT/Puppy,theundisputedmostsuccessfulhigh-endspeakerofalltime,certainlyreflectsthecommercialrealityitfaces.Butthenitalsoreflectsitsstatusasapotentialfutureclassic.Itreallyisthatgood.

T

Page 14: Wilson Benesch Endeavour Loudspeakers is where we shed the second set of assumptions -- the ones that go with so-called “minimonitors”. There’s nothing “mini” about the Endeavour

Price: $49,500perpairforstandardfinishes.Special-orderfinishesareanadditional$1795perpair.Standsareincluded.Warranty: Fiveyearspartsandlabor.

WilsonBeneschLtd.FalconHouseLimestoneCottageLaneSheffield,S61NJ+44(0)1142852656

Associated Equipment

Analog: VPIClassic4turntablewithSDS;VPIJMW12.7andTri-PlanarMkVIIUIItonearms;LyraEtna,Titani,Scala,DorianandDorianMonocartridges;ClearaudioGoldfingerStatementcartridge;AllnicPuritasandPuritasMonocartridges;NordostOdinandValhalla2tonearmlead;Connoisseur4.2PLEphonostage.

Digital: CECTL-3NCDtransport,WadiaS7iCDplayer,dCSPaganiniandVivalditransportsDACsanduClock,CHPrecisionD1CD/SACDplayer.

Preamps:Connoisseur4.2,CHPrecisionC1.

Power amp:BerningQuadratureZ,Engstrom&EngstromTheLarsIImonoblocksandVTLMB-185SignatureSeriesIIImonoblocks;JeffRowlandDesignGroupModel125stereoamp.

Integrated amp: JeffRowlandContinuum2.

Interconnects and speaker cables:CompleteloomsofNordostOdin,CrystalCableAbsoluteDreamorUltrafromACsockettospeakerterminals.PowerdistributionwasviaQuantumQRTQB8sorCrystalCablePowerStripDiamonds,withamixofQuantumQx2andQx4powerpurifiersandQv2ACharmonizers.

Supports: RacksareHutterRacktimeorQuadraspireSVTBamboo.TheseareusedwithNordostSortKoneequipmentcouplersthroughout.CablesareelevatedonAyremyrtle-woodblocksorHECCPandaFeet..NordostSortFütunitswereusedunderthespeakers.

Acoustic treatments: Aswellasthebroadbandabsorptionplacedbehindthelisteningseat,Iemployacombinationofmicroperforatedacousticdevices.

Accessories: EssentialaccessoriesincludetheFeickertprotractor,aUSBmicroscopeandAesthetixcartridgedemagnetizer,aprecisionspiritlevelandlaser,areallylongtapemeasureandplentyofmaskingtape.IalsomakeextensiveuseoftheFurutechanti-staticanddemagnetizingdevicesandtheVPITyphoonrecord-cleaningmachine.TheDr.FeikertPlatterSpeedapphastobethebestevercaseofdigitalaidinganalog.

14

REPRODUCEDFROM

theaudiobeat.co

m