Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ACDSWILinScience–LeadershipinWIL
WILinScience:LeadershipforWILFinalreport2016
AustralianCouncilofDeansofScience
ProjectLeadsProfessorJohnRice,ExecutiveDirector,ACDSProfessorElizabethJohnson,DirectorACDSTeaching&LearningCentre(ReportAuthor)
LighthouseProjectLeadersDrTinaAcuña,UniversityofTasmaniaDrRowanBrookes,MonashUniversityProfessorMalcolmCampbell,DeakinUniversityDrJo-AnneChuck,WesternSydneyUniversityProfessorPeterMeier,UniversityofTechnology,SydneyAssociateProfessorSusanRowlandandProfessorPeterAdams,UniversityofQueensland
LighthouseProjectTeamsUniversityofTasmania:DrAndrewSeen,MrsNicoleHerbert,DrShanePowell,DrRebeccaGehling,Mr
RobertKingsley,MsSusieHaley.WesternSydneyUniversity:DrChrisJones,ProfessorThomasMillar,DrDavidvanReyk(UTS)MonashUniversity:DrChrisThompson,LisaHappell,DrTimConnalonUniversityofQueensland:DrDeanneGannaway,MsRobynEvansUniversityofTechnology,Sydney:DrBlairNield,ProfessorGrahamNicholson,DrDavidvanReyk,MsShima
BaradaranVahdat,MsVikkiBanksDeakinUniversity:DrAdamCardilini,A/ProfJoColdwell-Neilson,DrSharonLaFontaine,A/ProfStuart
Palmer,MsShannonRogers(Intern),MrMarkTolson,DrKarenYoung
EvaluationDrSivaKrishnan,DeakinUniversity(summativeprojectevaluation)DrTrinaJorredeStJorre,DeakinUniversity(formativeprojectevaluation)
ACDSWILinScience–LeadershipinWIL
SupportfortheproductionofthisreporthasbeenprovidedbytheOfficeoftheChiefScientist,Australia.TheviewsexpressedinthisreportdonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheOfficeoftheChiefScientist.
AcknowledgementsTheprojectteamacknowledgesthegeneroussupportoftheOfficeoftheChiefScientist,Australiawhichhasmadethisworkpossible.Theprojectteamwishestoacknowledgethesupport,expertadviceandknowledgeofallthepeoplewhohavecontributedtothesuccessofthisproject.Inparticular,wewishtothankthosewhohavejoinedtheWILinSciencenetworkandparticipatedinitsactivities.Wegratefullyacknowledgethecollaborationandcontributionofoursteeringandadvisorygroups;notablyDrRoslynPrinsley,wholedthefoundationalworkonwork-integratedlearninginsciencefromtheOfficeoftheChiefScientist,generouslyrepresentedtheideaofthisprojecttostakeholdersandpushedusintocollectiveaction;DrMichaelWhelan,SouthernCrossUniversitywhoconnectedustotheleadingWILpeakbody,theAustralianCollaborativeEducationNetwork(ACEN),andhelpedwithbroaderdisseminationthroughACENactivities;andMsAnneYounger,AiGroup,whogenerouslygavehertimetoalltheprojectactivitiesandprovidedaninvaluableconnectiontoindustry.
ExpertAdvisoryGroupDrRoslynPrinsley OfficeoftheChiefScientistProfStephenWalker President,ACDSAnneYounger AustralianIndustryGroupMarkLawrence MD,MarkLawrenceGroupAndrewCSmith UniversitiesAustraliaDrMichaelWhelan AustralianCollaborativeEducationNetwork(ACEN)
SteeringCommitteeProfessorJohnRice ExecutiveDirector,ACDSProfessorJoWard ACDSExecutiveProfessorJanetHergt DeputyDean,FacultyofScience,TheUniversityofMelbourneProfessorAndrewParfitt DVCAcademic,UniversityofNewcastleProfessorRossSmith Director,HydrobiologyProfessorTonyPeacock CEO,CRCAssociationProfessorLizJohnson Director,ACDSTLCentre
ACDSWILinScience–LeadershipinWIL
ExecutivesummaryWILinScience:LeadershipforWILhassuccessfullyinitiatedanationalmovementtoshiftpracticetowardsimprovedemployabilityforsciencegraduates.ConductedbytheAustralianCouncilofDeansofScience(ACDS)andfundedbytheOfficeoftheChiefScientist,theprojecthaspromotedsustainablework-integratedlearning(WIL)inscienceprogramsasameanstobuildgraduateemployability.Thisfollowsuponthe2015ACERreportWorkIntegratedLearninginSTEMinAustralianUniversities,commissionedbytheOfficeoftheChiefScientist,thatshowedhighereducationcoursesinthenaturalandphysicalsciencestohavetheleastindustryengagementamongSTEMdisciplines.WILinScience:LeadershipforWILhasestablishedanationalnetworkofscienceWILleaders,createdanationalconversationaboutwork-integratedlearninginsciencedegrees,begunthetaskofbuildingcapacitytodesignanddeliverWILprograms,andtrialledapproachestoWILprogramdevelopment.Ithasraisedawarenessamongstfacultyexecutivesandinitiatedpeer-to-peermentoringbetweensciencefacultiesinAustralianuniversitiestocreatethefoundationsforawidespreadliftinWILleadershipandWILactivityinscienceandmathematicalsciences.Itisthefirststepinanongoingprogramtogrowandsupportwork-integratedlearningininscienceandmathematicalsciences.WILinScience:LeadershipforWILwasconductedoveraneighteen-monthperiodcommencinginJuly2015andconcludinginDecember2016.Ithasworkedwith35universitiesandthroughitsalliancewiththeACDSTeachingandLearningCentreprovidesanongoingactivityhubforwork-integratedlearninginscience.Specificprojectoutcomesare:
• establishmentoftheWILinSciencenetworkcomprisingFacultynomineesfrom35AustralianUniversities,informalWILleadersandWILspecialists,
• 2nationalforaonWILinScienceandthreeregionalworkshops(Victoria,NSW,Brisbane),
• self-reportedinformationonthecurrentstateofWILleadershipandWILpracticeinScienceFacultiestocomplementthefoundationalreportcommissionedbytheOfficeoftheChiefScientist(Edwards,Perkinsetal.2015),
• 6action-learningprojectsinsciencefacultiesthatexplorekeyissuesinWILimplementationandprovidecasestudiesforpeerlearning,
• follow-onfundingsecuredforthedevelopmentoftailoredresourcesandsupportviatheOfficeforLearningandTeaching,
• aroadmapforcontinueddevelopmentandintegrationofwork-integratedlearninginsciencedegreestoimprovegraduateemployability.
WILinSciencehasdevelopedfromaninitialprojectintoanongoingprogramthathasbeenendorsedbytheACDSandexplicitlyidentifiedintheACDSstrategicplan.Continuedcommitmentrecognizesthatdevelopmentofwork-integratedlearningisaformofcurriculumrenewalandmustbeapartofalong-termintegratedviewoflearningandteaching.WILrequiresthedeftinterplayofmanyfactorstoachievesuccess:aclearanddefensiblestrategy,alignedinstitutionalpriorities,processesandpolicy,investmentinbuildingcapacityandindelivery,culturalchangeleadershipandmanagementforallstakeholders(staff,studentsandpartneremployers)andclear-eyedevaluationandreview.TheWILinScienceprogramfocussesonpeerlearningasasustainableapproachtobuildingcapacity.ItrecognizesthatScienceFacultiesareatvaryingstagesofdevelopmentforWILandusesthatdiversitytoprovideappropriateandrelevantadviceandmentoring.ItdrawsontheconsiderableresearchliteratureandexperienceofotherdisciplinestoguideadaptationtoscienceandmathematicalsciencesandtofindtailoredsolutionsforScienceFaculties.
ACDSWILinScience–LeadershipinWIL
Tableofcontents1ThecontextforWILinScience....................................................................................................1GraduateemployabilityforAustraliansciencegraduates.......................................................................1Work-integratedlearninginSTEM...........................................................................................................2GrowingWILthroughcurriculumleadership...........................................................................................3TheWILinScienceproject.......................................................................................................................3
2WILLeadership:aroadmapforgrowingWIL..............................................................................6Meetingfacultieswheretheyare............................................................................................................6AmodelfordevelopmentforWILinScience...........................................................................................7EstablishingtheWILinSciencenetwork..................................................................................................8Buildingthenationalnetwork................................................................................................................10TheWILinScienceRoadmap:actiontogrowWILnationally................................................................11
3Casestudiesforchange|Lighthouseprojects.........................................................................13Creatinglocalaction...............................................................................................................................13TheLighthouseProjects.........................................................................................................................14OutcomesfromtheLighthouseprojects................................................................................................17
4Impactandnextsteps...............................................................................................................20ImpactandEvaluation............................................................................................................................20ExtendingWILinScience:SuccessfulWILinScience..............................................................................22
Appendix1|Eventsanddissemination.......................................................................................23WILinScienceNationalFora2015and2016.........................................................................................23Facultyplanningworkshops...................................................................................................................24Projectpresentations.............................................................................................................................25
Appendix2|LightHousecasestudies.........................................................................................26UnifyingWILinScienceattheUniversityofTasmania..........................................................................26ProvidingWILacrosscomplexinterconnectedsciencedegreesatWesternSydneyUniversity...........28ExploringalternatemodelsforWILinScience:LinkingWorkwithLearningattheUniversityofQueensland............................................................................................................................................31DevelopmentofprofessionalskillsinsciencestudentsthroughaworkintegratedlearninghonoursstreamatMonashUniversity.................................................................................................................35Scaling-upProfessionalExperiencePrograms:developingaframeworktosupportbroad-basedWILattheUniversityofTechnology,Sydney....................................................................................................37LearningtoWork,WorkingtoLearn:CurriculumdesignandteachingpracticeforWILintheNaturalandPhysicalSciencesatDeakinUniversity............................................................................................40
Appendix5|SummativeevaluationofLighthouseprojects......................................................44Evaluationapproach...............................................................................................................................44Interviewthemes...................................................................................................................................44Findings..................................................................................................................................................45Conclusion..............................................................................................................................................45
Page1|ACDSWILinScience–LeadershipinWIL
1ThecontextforWILinScienceGraduateemployabilityforAustraliansciencegraduatesGraduateemployabilityisamatterofkeeninteresttoallstakeholdersinhighereducation:students,universitiesandtheirteachingstaff,employersandindustry,fundingbodies,andgovernments.Graduateemployability(isthegraduatepreparedforwork?)isnotthesameasgraduateemployment(didthegraduategetajob?),althoughobviouslyrelated.Graduateemploymentisinfluencedbymanyexternalfactors,forexampleeconomicconditions.Graduateemployabilityismuchmoretightlylinkedtograduatelearningoutcomes.Universitiesemphasizethecentralityofgraduateemploymentandemployabilityintheirmissionstatementsandinthedesignanddeliveryofcoursesthroughlearningoutcomesstatements.Longitudinalsurveydatafromrecentgraduates1showsgraduateemploymentoutcomeshavedecreasedoverthelastdecade,despiteincreasingparticipationinhighereducation(GCA2016aand2016b).DataforgeneralistdegreessuchasBScience,BArts,BCommerceorBHealthSciences,generallyshowsloweremploymentoutcomesinthefirstyearaftergraduationthanmorevocationaldegrees,howeveritalsoshowsahigherproportionofgraduatescontinuingintopostgraduateeducationfromgeneralistdegrees.TheemploymentgapbetweenvocationalandgeneralistdegreesreducesconsiderablythreeyearsoutfromgraduationbutBSciencegraduatesstilllagbehindpeersinengineering,IT,healthandeducation.Thesefindingshavepromptedconcernoverthevalueofgeneralistsciencedegrees(Norton2013)andcallsforbetteralignmentbetweenuniversitysciencedegreesandfutureemployment(Chubb2014,PrinsleyandBaranyai2015,PWC2015).Universitiescancontributetoimprovedoutcomesforgraduatesthroughteachingandlearningapproachesthatexplicitlybuildgraduateemployability.AllAustralianuniversitiesarenowrequiredtoconstructanduseclearlearningoutcomestoguidedesignanddeliveryofcourses2andmostuniversitiespublicallypublishlearningoutcomestatementsfortheircourses((Bowman2010).Thesestatementsgenerallyalignwelltotheskillsandknowledgenominatedbyemployersasthosesoughtbyindustry.However,graduateemployabilityalsorequiresanorientationtofutureemploymentorcareers(Oliver2015)sothatstudentscanexplicitlylinkandadapttheirlearningtotheirsubsequentcareer.Graduateoutcomesthatsupportgraduateemployabilityhavebeenstudiedfrommultipleperspectivesincludinginstitutions,graduatesandemployers(Yorke2006,Hernández-Marchetal.2009,MartíndelPesoetal.2009,Velasco2012).Typically,employersseekwell-developedcommunicationskills,analyticandproblem-solvingskills,andprofessionalandinter-personalcapabilitiesinadditiontofoundationaldisciplinaryknowledgeandskills(Hernández-Marchetal.2009,MartíndelPesoetal.2009).Thesecapabilities/attributesalignwelltothosenominatedbyAustralianuniversitiesastheintendedlearningoutcomesfortheirdegrees.However,thereareperceivedgapsbetweentheintentofuniversitygraduatelearningoutcomesandtheexperienceofgraduatesreportedbyemployers(Jackson2010).Newcapabilitieshavealsoemergedinresponsetoachangingindustrylandscape(Bridgstock2009).Work-integratedlearning(WIL)iscurriculumthatisdesignedtoembedtheworldofworkinsidestudentlearning.Work-integratedlearningwasrecognizedasakeymechanismtobuildgraduateemployabilityintheNationalStrategyonWork-IntegratedLearninginUniversityEducationpublishedcollaborativelybyhighereducationpeakbodies(UniversitiesAustralia,AustralianCollaborativeEducationNetworkLtd(ACEN))andindustrypeakbodies(AustralianChamberofCommerceandIndustry,AiGroup,BusinessCouncilofAustralia).Thenationalstatementmadeadirectlinkbetweenwork-integratedlearningandgraduateemployability.
WILfacilitatesthetransitionbetweenpreparingforandoperatinginahighskillsworkenvironment.Itempowersstudentstounderstand,adapttoandapplyskillsintheworkplace.Ithelpsensuretheyareequippedtoplan,instigateandnavigatecareersinanenvironmentwhereconceptual,adaptive,personal,technicalandvocationalskills–theirhumancapital–willbecontinuallydrawnonandchallenged(p2,Commerce,Industryetal.2015).
1DataongraduateoutcomeswascollectedandpublishedbyGraduateCareersAustraliafrom1972-2015.From2016datawillbepublishedbytheAustralianGovernmentQILTwebsite
2HigherEducationStandardsFramework(ThresholdStandards)2015,CommonwealthofAustralia,availablefromhttps://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/F2015L01639
Page2|WILinScience2015-2016
TheNationalStatementcallsforactionfromallstakeholders:‘(a)nintegratedframeworkisneededtoaccelerategrowthinWIL,asisashiftinculture.Whatisneedednowisnationalleadership.’Advancementofwork-integratedlearningrequirescollaborativeandco-ordinatedactionfromuniversities,students,andemployers,supportedbyregulatorsandwithappropriatefunding(summarizedinJackson(2015)).TheNationalStatementrecognizesthatwork-integratedlearningcantakeawiderangeofformsdependingonthenatureofthedisciplineandindustry,placementwithinthecurriculumdesignandtheintendedlearningoutcomes.Itusesadefinitionofwork-integratedlearningdevelopedbyPatricketal(2009):
(an)umbrellatermforarangeofapproachesandstrategiesthatintegratetheorywiththepracticeofworkwithinapurposefullydesignedcurriculum”(Patrick,Peachetal.2009)
Work-integratedlearningcanalsobedefinedintermsofitsrelationshiptowork.Oliver(2015)definedwork-integratedlearningaslearningtasks.
Workintegratedlearningoccursatvariouslevelsacrossarangeoftasksthatareauthentic(thetaskresemblesthoserequiredinprofessionallife)orproximal(thesettingresemblesprofessionalcontexts).((Oliver2015)
Thisprojecthasusedabroad,inclusivedefinitionofWIL,andenvisagedWILaswide-ranging,integratedlearningactivitieswithexternalstakeholders,notonlythoseactivitieswithanarrowindustry-specificfocus.ItusesthepremisethatWILsupportstheroleofgraduatesasbeginningprofessionalsandpotentialchangeagentsratherthaninducteesintoanexistingworkenvironmenttoallowforadynamicandadaptiveemploymentandcareers.Graduateemployabilityrequiresrepeatedlearningopportunitiesthatreinforcelearning(YorkeandKnight2006,Smith,Vinsonetal.2014,Jackson2015).Anisolatedexperienceismuchlessvaluablethanintentionalintegrationwithinacoherentlearningdesign.Hencework-integratedlearningrequiresconsiderationacrossthebreadthoflearningdesign,deliveryandgovernanceofuniversitycourses.
Work-integratedlearninginSTEMIn2015,theOfficeoftheChiefScientistofAustraliacommissionedtwostudiesintowork-integratedlearninginthebroadareaofscience,technology,engineeringandmathematics(STEM).Thisgroupingincludeshighlyvocationaldisciplines(engineering,informationtechnology)andgeneralistdegreesexemplifiedbytheBachelorofScience.Edwardsetal(2015)reportedonthenatureanddistributionofwork-integratedlearninginSTEMdisciplinesisallAustralianuniversities.Thestudyfoundthatwork-integratedlearningwasdifficulttoidentifywithincurriculaapartfromplacementsinworkplaces.ComparisonbetweenSTEMdisciplinesshowedmarkedvariationintheprovisionofplacementsrangingfromacoreplacementrequirementforregistrationofengineeringgraduates3toextra-curricularaccesstoplacementformanygeneralistdegrees.ThestudyfoundthatstudentsstudyinginaBachelorofScienceweremuchlesslikelytocompleteaworkplacement.
Basedontheindicativedata,thefiguressuggestthatalmostthreeofeveryfourICTbachelorstudentsinAustraliaundertakesanindustrybasedprojectduringtheirdegree,comparedwithaboutoneinfouragricultureandenvironmentalstudiesstudents,andaboutoneinsevensciencestudents.(p66)
ThesecondprojectcommissionedbytheOfficeoftheChiefScientistexploredtheemployerviewofwork-integratedlearninginSTEM.Atitscore,work-integratedlearningrequiresanactiveandconstructivecollaborationbetweenemployers,studentsanduniversities.Atkinsonetal(2015)reportedfindingsfrom74in-depthinterviewsandfocusgroupswithSTEMemployersrangingfromsmalltolargeenterprises.ThestudyfoundthatAustralianemployersreportedsimilarissuesasinternationalstudies.
Astheliteraturesuggestsandourfindingsconfirm,twomajorchallengesinimprovingemployerengagementareconvincingemployersthatWILisworthwhile,thenfindingabalancebetweenadesiretobemoreinvolvedandhavingtheavailabletimeandresources.(p10)
Thesetwostudieshighlightedthechallengeforsciencedisciplinestoincreasework-integratedlearningingeneralistsciencedegrees.Despitesomeexamplesofexcellenceinsomeprograms(Edwards,Perkinsetal.2015)andacleardesirefromuniversitiesandemployerstoimprovegraduateemployability,growingwork-integratedfacessignificantbarriers(PrinsleyandBaranyai2015).Thelackofexistingwork-integratedlearninginscience
3EngineersAustraliarequiresallregisteredprogramsforprofessionalengineerstoincludelearningactivitiesatleast‘equivalenttoatleast12weeksoffulltimeexposuretoprofessionalpracticeintermsofthelearningoutcomesprovided’(EngineersAustralia(2008)G02:AccreditationCriteriaandGuidelines).
Page3|WILinScience2015-2016
degreesiscompoundedwithinstitutionalfactorsinsideuniversitiesincludingarelativelylowpriorityplacedonwork-integratedlearninginsciencedisciplines,theinexperienceofscienceteachersinworkingcollaborativelywithemployers,lackofexpertiseindesigninganddeliverywork-integratedlearningactivitiesandprogramsandperceivedlowengagementwithstudentsregardingwork-integratedlearning.Similarproblemsareseeninotherdisciplinespromptingnationalcallstoimproveleadershipforwork-integratedlearning(Patrick,Fallonetal.2014).Theurgenttaskistobuildcommitmenttoandleadershipforwork-integratedlearninginscience,andtofacilitatetheeffortsofScienceFacultiestogrowWILatscale.
GrowingWILthroughcurriculumleadershipWork-integratedlearningismosteffectivewhenitisembeddedwithintheformalcurriculum(YorkeandKnight2006).Improvingtheprovisionofwork-integratedlearningiscloselyalliedtobroad-scalecurriculumrenewalandrequiresthesameholisticapproach.ForWIL,thecurriculumstakeholdergroupexpandsfromstudentsandteacherstoincludeemployerswithconsequentincreaseincomplexity.ThedesignanddeliveryofWILprogramsisbasedonthree-wayrelationshipsthatmovebeyondtheuniversityenvironment(Patrick,Peachetal.2009).Supportingsystemsandtoolsmustmanageadiversityofemployersandorganizationsand,asforallbroad-scalecurriculumrenewal,mustbeflexibleenoughtoaccommodatedisciplinaryvariation–notablyaccreditationrequirements.GrowingWILisdependentoninformedandeffectivecurriculumleadership.Patrick,Fallonetal.(2014)proposedamodelforleadershipforwork-integratedlearningthatdrawstogetherthecomplexrangeoffactorsthatmustcombinetodelivereffectiveWILprograms.TheauthorsdescribefivedomainsofactionforWILleadership,settingtheagendafordevelopmentofWILleadership.
ThecapabilitiesrequiredbyWILleadersaresimilaracrosstertiaryinstitutions,disciplinesandindustry,andcanbegroupedintofivedomains:
•shapingvisionandpolicy;
•communicatingandinfluencingWIL;
•creatingsustainableWILrelationshipstostrengthenWILculture;
•fosteringengagement,expertiseandlearninginWIL;and
•drivingoutcomesthatservetheneedsofWILstakeholders.(p5)
TheWILinScience:LeadershipforWILprojectwasestablishedbytheAustralianCouncilofDeansofScience(ACDS)tobeginthetaskofbuildingleadershipforwork-integratedlearningwithinscienceandmathematicalsciencedisciplines.ItwasbasedonthepremisethatScienceFacultiescouldachievechangemostefficientlyby:establishingexplicitleadershipandexpertise,learningfromeachother,andbuildingonexistingcurriculumreforminsciencedegrees.
TheWILinScienceprojectTheAustralianCouncilofDeansofScience(ACDS)isthenationalpeakbodyforScienceFacultiesinAustralia4.ItreachesintoallAustralianUniversitiesthatoffersciencedegreesandformanyyearshassupportedcurriculumrenewalwithinScienceFacultiesthroughfosteringleadershipinlearningandteaching,andfacilitatingsector,disciplinaryandinstitutionalconnections.TheACDSspecificallyfostersexcellenceinlearningandteachinginsciencethrough:
• nationalmeetingsandconferenceforeducators(AustralianConferenceforScienceandMathematicsEducators)andteachingandlearningleaders(ACDSTeachingandLearningConference),
• targetedprojectsandcommissionedworkand,
• theACDSTeachingandLearningCentre(includingmembernetworkandwebsite)
TheACDSTeachingandLearningCentrewasusedasthemechanismtodrawScienceFacultiestogethertoworkcollectivelytowardsbroad-scaleadoptionofwork-integratedlearninginsciencedegrees.WILinScience:LeadershipforWILwasinitiatedto:
• establishanationalnetworkacrossfacultiesandschoolsofnaturalandphysicalsciencesthatwouldbuildcapabilityandsustaingrowthinprogramsofwork-integratedlearninginuniversityscience
4TheACDSmembershipisconstitutedbythenomineesoftheVice-ChancellorsofeachAustralianUniversitythatareconsideredbytheUniversitytobethemostappropriaterepresentative.Forthisreport,ACDSmemberswillbereferredtoasDeansalthoughtheymayhavealternativedesignations.
Page4|WILinScience2015-2016
• developanapproachandstrategiesforwork-integratedlearningforsciencefacultiesinAustralianuniversities
ProjectdeliverablesWILinScience:LeadershipforWILaimedtoestablishnewcapabilitiesandactivitywithinScienceFaculties,notingconsiderablevariationbetweenScienceFacultiesinthereportedpracticeofWIL(Edwards,Perkinsetal.2015),andthewidespectruminleadershipforWILandreadinessforchangeobservedbythisproject.Throughthenationalforums,facultyworkshopsandtheACDSTeachingandLearningCentrewebsitethenetworkhas:
• identifiedandsharedtheexperienceofaspectrumofWILactivities,andanunderstandingoftheirkeycharacteristics,andrequirementsforsuccessandoutcomes
• identifiedandsharedacademicstandardsandcoursestructuresthatmakeWILsuccessfulandsupportjudgmentsofquality
• examinedorganizationalstructuresneededtofosterWIL,suchasleadership,administrativesupport,centralversuslocalaspects,etc.
• providedadviceandexamplesofeffectiverelationshipbuildingatavarietyoflevelswithindustriesandotherorganisations
• providedapointofcontactfortheACDSwithpeakorganisationalbodiesforWIL.Ithasalsotrialledmechanismsforpeer-to-peerlearningandopportunitiesforprofessionaldevelopmentfornominatedleadersforWILinSciencefacultiesandschools.ProgressagainsttheoriginaldeliverablesoftheWILinScience:LeadershipforWILprojectispresentedinTable1.WILinScience:LeadershipforWILwasconductedover18monthsfromJune2015toDec2016.Alltheactivitiesidentifiedinthegrantproposalwerecompletedwhichhasestablishedafirmfoundationforfurtherworkatnationalscale.In2016,fundingwassoughtandgrantedfromtheOfficeofLearningandTeachingtoexpandtheWILinScienceprogramandcontinuementoringandsupportofScienceFaculties.Thissecondproject,SuccessfulWILinScience,buildsontheinitialWILinScience:LeadershipforWILprojectbyestablishingregionalcommunitiesofpracticeandcreatinganationalWILresourceforScienceFacultiescomplementarytoexistingresourcesandtailoredforSciencedegrees.
ProjectGovernanceThisprojectreportedregularlyquarterlytotheACDSExecutiveandwasadvisedbyanExpertAdvisoryGroupchairedbyDrRoslynPrinsley,AdvisortotheChiefScientist.TheExpertAdvisoryGroupincludedrepresentationfromindustryandindustrygroups,UniversityAustralia,andtheAustralianCollaborationEducationNetwork(ACEN)(seereportcover).MembersoftheAdvisoryGroupattendedprojecteventsincludingACDSWILinScienceFora,projectworkshopsandFacultyplanningworkshops.TheProjectSteeringCommitteeadvisedtheprojectoninitialsetupandassistedwithevaluationoftheLighthouseProjects.MembersoftheProjectSteeringGroupwerealsoactivecontributorstoprojectevents.
Page5|WILinScience2015-2016
Table1:Intendedoutcomes,outputsanddeliverablesforWILinScience:LeadershipforWILproject
GrantProposalOutcomes,
June2015
ProjectOutput Deliverable
1.Establishasteeringcommitteetodevelopthenetwork
Steeringandadvisorycommitteesestablished.
ExpertAdvisoryGroupincludesrepresentativesfromhighereducation(includingACDS)andindustrypeakbodies(seeProjectGovernance).
2.IdentifyavarietyofpotentialmodelsofWILinscienceFacultiesandschools
CasestudiesofWILdevelopmentinscience(LighthouseProjects)
ModelsforWILdeliverydevelopedthroughLighthouseprojects(action-learningprojects)
3.IdentifypotentialleadersofWILinsciencefacultiesandschools(June-December2015)4.IdentifyandassemblerelevantpartiesresponsibleforworkintegratedlearninginSciencefaculties
WILinSciencenetwork SeniorleadersinWILforScience&MathsidentifiedinparticipatingScienceFacultiesandformWILinSciencenetwork(95participantsfrom35universities)WILinScienceprogramembeddedinACDSTLCentre
5.HoldaForuminDecember2015withtheserelevantpartiestodeveloparoadmapforworkintegratedlearninginSciencefacultiesinAustralia
WILinScienceForumDec2015WILinScienceForumDec2016
WILinScience2015ForumconnectsnominatedWILleadersfromScienceFacultiesandintroducesthenationalWILlandscape(75participantsfrom31Universitiesand8otherinstitutions)WILinScience2016Forumpresentschangeleadershipmodelandpathwayforbroad-scaleliftinWILwithinsciencedegrees(53participantsfrom24institutionsand5otherinstitutions)
6.DeveloparoadmapforScienceFacultiestoachievethekeyrecommendationsandactionsarisingfromtwostudiesonworkintegratedlearningcommissionedbytheOfficeoftheChiefScientistandalsothoseoutlinedintheNationalStrategyonWorkIntegratedLearninginUniversityEducation.
ModelforchangeleadershipdevelopmentforScienceFaculties
ModelsforWILdevelopmentguidesinteractionwithScienceFacultiesandprovidesmechanismsfortailoredpeer-to-peerlearningSecondstageofWILinScienceisformulatedandsecuresfundingthroughtheOfficeforLearningandTeaching(SuccessfulWILinScienceGrantID16-5420,Jul2016-Jun2018)
7.Prioritise,implementandevaluatepilotactivitiesandinitiativesforfundingfortheimplementationoftheroadmapdevelopedin(6).
LighthouseprojectcasestudiesSuccessfulWILinSciencegrant
WILinScience:LeadershipforWILactivitiesandresourcesdisseminatedviaACDSTLCentreContinuedfundingforWILinScienceprogramtoAug2018
8.Commissionasuiteofactionlearningprojectsthatestablishtheoperationalroleofthenetwork–toidentify,trial,disseminateandsupportmodelsofWILinscience(Sept2015–Jan2016)
Action-LearningProjects(LighthouseProjects)
LighthouseProjectscomplete(seeAppendix4forindividualcasestudies)andinitiate(1)localinstitutionalchangeand(2)partnershipsbetweenuniversities
9.HoldmetropolitanworkshopsaroundWILactionlearningprojects(June-August2016)
FacultyPlanningWorkshops
FacultyWorkshopsheldAugust-September2016inMelbourne,SydneyandBrisbanewith60participantsfrom19institutions
10.HoldanationalforuminDecember2016todisseminatelearningandattractnewchampions.
WILinScienceForumDec2016
WILinScience2016Forumpresentschangeleadershipmodelandpathwayforbroad-scaleliftinWILwithinsciencedegrees(50participantsfrom24institutionsand5otherinstitutions)
Page6|WILinScience2015-2016
2WILLeadership:aroadmapforgrowingWILCurriculumrenewalisachallengingandslowtask(Oliver2015).Sustainablechangerequiresshiftsincultureandpractice,andcourserenewalusuallyrequiresdevelopmentofnewexpertise,trialofnewapproachesanddata-drivenevaluation.
MeetingfacultieswheretheyareSustainablechangerequiresrecognitionofthecurrentstate,sinceitisthefoundationfordevelopment.Intheircomprehensivestudyofwork-integratedlearninginSTEMdisciplines,Edwards,Perkinsetal.(2015)foundconsiderablevariationinthepracticeofwork-integratedlearninginnaturalandphysicalsciences.UniversitiesreportedvariationinparticipationinWILfornaturalandphysicalsciencesrangingfrom0to100%participationbystudents(Fig1).ThiscontrastwithotherSTEMdisciplineswhere‘(o)ngraduationthevastmajorityofengineeringstudentsinAustraliahaveundertakenaninternshiporplacement’and‘almostthreeoutofeveryfourICTbachelorstudentsinAustraliaundertakesanindustrybasedprojectduringtheirdegree’(Edwards,Perkinsetal.2015).Work-integratedlearninginengineeringandICTisstronglyencouragedorrequiredbyprofessionalaccreditation.Sciencedisciplinesdonothaveanaccepted,dominantmodeforwork-integratedlearningnordotheyhavetheexternalimperativeofprofessionalaccreditation.Figure1:Variationbetweenuniversitiesinstudentparticipationina)industryprojectsandb)industryplacementcomparingnaturalandphysicalsciencesandICT.ScienceFacultieshavelargevariationinengagementwithWIL(bluebars,notingdifferentscaleforprojectsandplacementgraphs.DataisderivedfromEdwards,Perkinsetal.(2015),self-reportedbyuniversitiesandre-presentedwithpermission.
Edwardsandcolleagues(2015)alsodescribedconsiderablevariationininstitutionalapproachestoWILvaryingfromstructured,institutionalprocessesandsystemsto‘unstructured’activitiessolelydependingonanindividualacademicordisciplinarygroup.
Ininstitutionswhereoverallthereisan‘industryoriented’approachtoWILacrosstheuniversity,centralizedsystemsandadministrationofWILwaslikelytoexist.Themorecommonapproach,inwhichWILis‘bolted-on’tothecurriculum,ischaracterisedbydecentralisedapproacheswithlessformalstructure.(p73)
Universitieswithwell-developedapproachestowork-integratedlearningcanprovidemodelsforpeerswhoarebuildingtheircapacitytodeliverywork-integratedlearning.
Asmallnumberofuniversitieshave,orarefinalising,highlydevelopedprocessesforcoordinating,administering,andsupportingWILactivities.Inthemain,thesestructuresrelatetoplacementsandinternshipprogramswithintheinstitutions,butinsomecasestheyalsofacilitateprojectbasedwork.(p73)
However,variationinfundingandsupporthasaprofoundeffectonthecapacityofFacultiestodeliver
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 5 15 23 30 50 75 90 100
numbe
rofu
niversities
%studentparticipation
a)Spectrumofstudentparticpationinindustryprojects
ScienceIndustryprojects
ITIndustryprojects
0
2
4
6
8
10
0 5 15 23 30 50 75 90 100
numbe
rofu
niversities
%studentparticipation
b)Spectrumofstudentparticipationinindustryplacements
SciencePlacement
ITPlacement
Page7|WILinScience2015-2016
WILprograms(Patrick,Fallonetal.2014).Thebestmentormaybe‘accesstoa‘fellowtraveller’inthesamerolebutfurtherdownthesamelearning(i.e.change)pathwithwhomtocomparetactics’asdescribedbyProfGeoffScottinseminalworkonleadershipinAustralianuniversities(Scott,Coatesetal.2008).FindingsfromnationalreportsonWILimplementation(Patrick,Peachetal.2009,Orrell2011,Patrick,Fallonetal.2014,Edwards,Perkinsetal.2015)haveguidedthedevelopmentoftheWILinScienceprogram.ThevariationbetweenFacultiesofSciencepromptedapartnershipmodelforsupportingFacultiesthatrecognizesthecurrentpositionandcontextforeachFaculty.WILinSciencetherefore:
1. recognizesqualitativelydifferentissuesforFacultiesatdifferentstagesofdevelopmentofWILprograms;
2. recognizesvariabledegreesofpreparednesstogrowWIL,notablyvariationincentralizedsupportandstrategy,specifiedWILworkforceandleadership;
3. valuespeer-to-peerlearningcoupledtoadaptationtothelocalcontext;and4. aimstoassistFacultiestocreatetailoredsolutionsanduseresourcesappropriatetotheirlocal
context.
AmodelfordevelopmentforWILinScienceTheobservedvariationincurrentpracticeofWILinScienceFacultieshasledtotheformulationofachangemodelthatallowsFacultiestoidentifyandlearnfrompeerswithsimilarinterestsandissues.ThevariationinFacultydevelopmentalsobecameevidentwhenFacultieswereinvitedtoproposeprojectstoexploreimplementationofWIL.TheLighthouseprojectsweredesignedascasestudiestoillustrategoodpracticeinWILimplementation(seeSection2:Casestudiesforchange).ProposalsforLighthouseprojectscouldbecategorizedintothreephasesofdevelopmentandpromptedthemetaphorofajourneyofWILdevelopment(Fig4).ThisdevelopmentalmodelencouragesFacultiestobuildcapabilityandexpertisetodelivereffectiveWILovertime.ItisexploredfurtherinSection2.Fig4:DevelopmentalmodelforbuildingWILinScienceFaculties
SettingupFacultyWILprograms Ideas DefineWIL:whatcounts? MapWIL:whereisit? Possibilities/SWOT?
DevelopingalternativeapproachestoWIL Ideas: IndustryPartners Studentsaspartners Usingexistingstudentwork Usinghonours Entrepreneurship/start-ups ExtendingWILand
buildingcapacityforthefuture Ideas: Limitstogrowth Orienting&engagingteachersandstudents Co-teachingWIL
1:Intention&planning
2:Build &trial
3:Refineandexpand
Page8|WILinScience2015-2016
EstablishingtheWILinSciencenetworkTheWILinSciencenetworkwasdesignedtobeakeyconnectorforFacultiestodevelopwork-integratedlearningthroughcollaboration.TheobjectiveofthenetworkwastogrowunderstandingofandexpertiseinWILforScienceandMaths,provideopportunitiestoarticulatesharedstandardsforWILactivitiesandoutcomes,andtosharegoodpractice.Identifyingnetworkmembers
Thefirststeptowardsnationalleadershipforwork-integratedlearningforsciencewastodrawtogethernominatedleadersfromFacultiesofScience.RecognizingthevariationininstitutionalsupportanddevelopmentofWIL,WILinScience:LeadershipforWIL,viatheACDS,askedDeanstonominatealeaderforWILforsciencedisciplinesfromtheirFaculty.Thisapproachwasdesignedtoraiseawarenessofwork-integratedlearningamongstFacultyexecutiveandtoidentifyacontactpointineachFacultyforfutureactivities.WILleadersandspecialistswerealsoinvitedtoparticipateinthenetworkviaprojectevents,theACDSTeachingandLearningCentrewebsiteandtheACDSnewsletter.InDecember,2016,theWILinSciencenetworkcomprised95membersfrom35universitiesandafurther9membersfromindustry/governmentandhighereducationpeakbodies.AsurveyofWILinSciencenetworkmembersinAugust2016showedthatmanyFacultiesdonothaveadesignatedleadershippositionforwork-integratedlearning(Figure2).Representationmayrestwiththe
AssociateDeanTeachingandLearning(orequivalent)orwithaWILspecialist,eitheracademicorprofessional.Intheir2014studyofleadershipforWIL,Patrick,Fallonetal.(2014)argueforastronginstitutionalsupportforadistributednetworkofleadershipforWIL.Theynotethat:WILleaderscanbe,andusuallyare,drawnfrommanylevelswithininstitutionsandorganisationsandaredefinedbytheactivitiesinwhichtheyareengagedratherthanbytitlessuchasdirector,managerorothersimilarterms.(p4)
CommentsfromnetworkmembersconfirmedthatleadershipforWILisveryvariable.Mostparticipantsdescribedsharedresponsibilityamongstvariablecombinationsofthefollowingroles:unit(orsubject)coordinators,course(orprogram)coordinators,otherdisciplineorWILspecificrepresentativesfromschoolsorfacultiesincludingWILcoordinatorsandadministrativesupportroles,representativesfromcentralteachingandlearningorcareercentres,andleadershiprolesincludingHeadofSchools,AssociateDean’s,PVC’sandDVCE’s.Severalparticipantsalsonotedthatstudentssharedresponsibilityforseekingandsecuringtheirownplacementopportunities.WILinScience:LeadershipforWILsuggeststhatexplicitacknowledgementofWILleadershiphelpsFacultiestoprioritizework-integratedlearningandcanalsobeinclusiveenoughtoacknowledgedifferenttypesofleadership.
PerceptionsofWILpracticeamongstnetworkmembers
WILinSciencenetworkmemberswereaskedtoreportonthestateofwork-integratedlearningintheirFaculty.Thegeneralpictureisthatwork-integratedlearningisconsideredvaluablebutthatimplementationdoesnotmatchtherecognisedvalue(Fig3).
Fig2:ProportionofWILinSciencenetworkmembersindesignatedleadershiproles(29respondents,21universities)
21%
21%34%
24%Assoc. DeanTeaching&LearningWILacademic/administratorNominatedFacultyWILleaderOther
Page9|WILinScience2015-2016
Fig3:Perceptionsofwork-integratedlearningpracticefromWILinSciencenetworkmembers(29respondents,21universities).Respondentswereaskedtoratetheiragreementwiththestatementona5-pointLikertscale.
TheWILinSciencenetworkmembersurveycollectedinformationonthepressingchallengesassociatedwithbuildingwork-integratedlearningprogramsinScienceFacultiesandexploredhowdiscussionwithpeersinthenetworkcouldassist(Table2).Thisinformationhasguidednetworkeventsandpriorities.Table2:WILinSciencenetworkmemberperceptionsofchallengesandopportunitiesforpeer-learning.Starreditems*werealsoidentifiedinfeedbackfromWILinScienceForumevaluations.ChallengeswithgrowingWIL DiscussionTopics:learningfromandwithpeers
Managingstudentperceptions,expectationsandexperiences
• Gettingbuy-in
• Managingexpectationsofthetypesofopportunitiesavailable
• MakingWILmeaningful–e.g.engagingstudentsinreflection
• Providingcareerdevelopmentanddeterminingcareerdestinations–severalparticipantsinferthatstudentsneedtochooseacareerpathsothattheycanchooseanappropriateplacement.
• MakingWILmeaningful–encouragingstudentreflectionandintegrationofWILwithotherlearning,learningoutcomes
• EntrepreneurshipasalearningtoolassociatedtoWIL
Identifyingappropriateplacements
• Atscaleforlargecohorts
• Qualityofplacements(e.g.alignedwithdiscipline,preferredmode)
• Constraintsimposedbystudent’sothercommitments
• Constraintsimposedbygeographicaldistanceorregion
• Supportingstudentstoidentifytheirownplacements
• Debatepro’sandcon’sofstudentsfindingtheirownplacements
• Negotiatinglegalagreementswithpartnerorganisations*
Managingindustry/stakeholderrelationships*
• Gettingbuy-inandcommitment*
• Findingtimeandresourcesforrelationshipmanagement*
• Legalagreementsandprotectingstudents
• Managingrelationshipswithexternalstakeholders,findingplacementsandpersuadingemployersofthevaluetotheirorganisation(includingnon-scienceorganisations)*
Engagingotherstaff*
• Gettingbuy-inandchangingculture–moredifficultinsomedisciplinese.g.physicalsciences,puresciences,mathematics.*
• Coordinationtoavoidrepetition,gapsandinconsistentpractices
• DevelopunderstandingoftherangeofWILopportunities
• Instigatingculturalchange,engagingacademicsandimplementingacrosscurriculum*
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
WILopportunitieshavevalueforSciencestudents
UpscalingWILinthecurriculumisdifficult
InvolvingemployersinthedesignordeliveryofWILactivitiesisdifficult
MyuniversityprovidessupportfordesignanddeliveryofWILinthecurriculum
Myuniversityhaseffectiveorganisationalprocesses/infrastructuretosupportWIL
WILiseffectivelyscaffoldedthroughoutsciencecoursesatmyuniversity
StronglyAgree Agree Unsure Disagree StronglyDisagree
Page10|WILinScience2015-2016
Programdesign*
• Makingtimeandspaceinthecurriculum
• MakingembeddedWILmoreovert
• IntegratingWILwithothercurriculumelements
• Identifyingappropriateassessment
• StreamliningWIL
• SharingleadingpracticesandcasestudiesofWIL*
• Opportunitiesforsimulated/virtualexperiencesandauthenticassessment
• Modelsforworkingaroundrigidityofteachingcalendars
• Informationmanagement
BuildingthenationalnetworkCommunitiesofpracticeareapowerfulwayofbuildingcapacityandareoftenself-sustainingonceestablished.Theyaremaintainedbycommoninterestandaremostsuccessfulwithcontrolrestingwiththecommunity.TheWILinSciencenetworkhasbeeninitiatedbyapeakbody(theACDS)butaimstosupportmembersthroughpeer-to-peerrelationshipswiththeACDSTeachingandLearningCentreasafacilitator.Theintentistobuildalong-term,self-sustainingcommunitythatisanintegralpartofteachingandlearninginscienceandmathematicalsciences.ThefirstactionsfortheWILinSciencenetworkhavebeentoconnectmembersthrough:
a) TwonationalforathatbroughttogetherWILleadersfromFacultiesb) Facultyplanningworkshopsthatbroughttogetherregionalgroupsasafirststeptobuildinglocal
nodesfortheWILinSciencenetwork.c) Aregularnewsletterthatprovidesinformationaboutthenetwork,andteachingandlearning
events.DetailsoftheprojectdisseminationarelistedinAppendix3.ACDSWILinSciencefora
The2015WILinScienceForumwasheldDecember11,2015inMelbourneasthefirstpubliceventofthenascentWILinSciencenetwork.Seventy-eightparticipantsregisteredrepresenting33universities,CSIRO,UniversitiesAustralia,theATNnetworkandACEN(AustralianCollaborativeEducationNetwork).RepresentativesfromOLT-fundedWILprojectsinHealthandArts/HumanitiesalsoattendedwhichenabledconnectiontoWILprojectsinotherdisciplines.TheprogramemphasizedinformationaboutthecurrentstateofWILinScienceandindustryengagement.TheworkshopwasopenedbyDrAlanFinkel(incomingChiefScientist,Australia)andfeaturedpresentationsfromindustryrepresentatives,theOfficeoftheChiefScientistanduniversityleaders(seeAppendix3).Feedbackfromparticipantswasstronglypositive,emphasizingtheneedformodelsforeffectiveWILandsharingmoreexperiences.Theobjectiveofthemeetingwastoraiseawarenessandtoconnectnetworkmembers.The2016WILinScienceForumwasheldDecember2,2016inMelbourne.Forthissecondnationalmeeting,theprogramemphasizedactiontogrowWILwithpresentationsfromtheLighthouseprojectscommissionedaspartoftheWILinScience:LeadershipforWIL,andlearningfromotherdisciplineswithpresentationsfromnationalleadersinWIL(seeAppendix3).Fiftyparticipantsfrom24institutionsdiscussedplansforactionandchallengesparticularlywithdeliveryoflarge-scaleprogramsandeffectiveintegrationinthecurriculum.Subsequentfeedbackfromparticipantsnotedtheshiftinthetenorofthegroupdiscussionbyparticipantsfromtheawareness-raisingevidentatthe2015Forumtoamorenuancedandactionableagendaforchange.Again,participantfeedbackwasstronglypositive.Facultyplanningworkshops
RegionalworkshopswereheldinMelbourne(Aug18,15registrants,6universities),Sydney(Aug24,16registrants,7unis),Brisbane(Aug25,14registrants,6unis).Thesesmaller,moreinformalmeetingsweredesignedtofostercloserlinksbetweenFacultyWILleadersandtoprovideavenuefordiscussionandreflectionoflocalorinstitutionalissues.Theprogramincludedreal-worldideasandchallengessurfacedthroughtheLighthouseprojectsandsimpleplanningexercisesdesignedtoidentifylocalissuesfordiscussion.MostparticipantswereinvolvedindevelopingWILprogramsintheiruniversity.Feedbackfromparticipantsnotedthattheworkshopshad:
• increasedmotivationtocontinueprogramdevelopment• helpedtoidentifythe‘nextstep’fortheirownwork
Page11|WILinScience2015-2016
• initiatedcollaborationswithpeersinotherinstitutionsFurtheractivityatregionallevelwillcontinueaspartoftheOLT-fundedprojectSuccessfulWILinScience.ACDSnewsletterandnationalconferences
TheACDSTeachingandLearningCentrepublishesanewsletterapproximatelybi-monthlytomembersoftheFacultyofscienceteachingandlearningleaders(notablyAssociateDeansTeachingandLearningandotherinfluentialbutinformalleaders),WILinSciencenetworkmembersandparticipantsoftheannualAustralianConferenceforScienceandMathematicsEducation(ACSME)whichisthepremiernationalmeetingforuniversityscienceandmathematicseducators.Thenewsletterispostedonlineto1,714membersandisamechanismforthesethreegroupstobeawareofparallelworkandideas.Cross-fertilizationwasalsoachievedthroughpresentationanddiscussionatnationalteachingandlearningconferences.ScienceFacultyleadersattendtheannualACDSTeachingandLearningConferencewhichincludedpresentationsonWILinSciencein2015and2016.ACSMEisapractitionerandresearcherconferencewhichattractsawidediversityofparticipantsinvolvedintheleadership,design,deliveryandevaluationoflearningandteachinginscienceandmathematicalsciences.In2016,ACSMEhadwork-integratedlearningasoneofitscorethemesandincludedapresentationonWILinScience:LeadershipforWIL.Theprojectalsopresentedatothernationalfora(seeAppendix3).Alignmenttothebroaderfieldoflearningandteachingforscienceandmathematicalsciencesisparticularlyimportanttosustaineffectivework-integratedlearninginsciencedegrees.Work-integratedlearningismosteffectivewhenembeddedwithintheformalcurriculum(Patrick,Peachetal.2009,Orrell2011)andbuildinggraduateemployabilityistheresponsibilityofwholecurriculum(YorkeandKnight2006,Oliver2015,Kinash,Craneetal.2016).
TheWILinScienceRoadmap:actiontogrowWILnationallyWILinScience:LeadershipforWILprojectsoughttocreateasustainedinteractionwithScienceFacultiesthatmaintainsactionforthelongertermandisresponsivetoeachlocalcontextaswellasthebroadersectorialview.TheprojectanditsnetworkcannotmandateactionbyUniversitiesbutitwillcreateanationalvoiceonWILinSciencethatdrivesnationalstandardsandfacilitatesaction.Toachievewidespreadchange,work-integratedlearningmustbeintegraltosciencedegreesasanormalandexpectedcomponentofeverydegree.Thisdegreeofchangeiscomparabletotheshifttooutcomes-orientedcurriculumdesignwhichisnowmandatedaspartofAustralia’sHigherEducationStandards.Courserenewaltowardsthisprincipleisslowbutinexorable.ForSciencedisciplines,thecreationofnationalthresholdlearningoutcomesforScience(Jones,Yatesetal.2011)wasaturningpoint,generatingactivityatdisciplineandinstitutionallevelsandestablishingnationalstandards.TheACDSproposesthatworkasaguidetosectorialadoptionofwork-integratedlearning.PrioritiesforWILinScience
EmbeddingWILneedsasophisticatedviewofcoursedesignanddelivery.FacultiesandcourseteamsdevelopingWILwithinsciencecoursesneedtoaligncontributingfactors(Patrick,Fallonetal.2014).Sofar,theWILinSciencenetworkhasidentifiedanumberofprioritiesforitsmembers.
1. sharedintent:WILmustbeapriorityfortheFacultyanditsstaff,studentsandemployerstobeprovidedwiththesupportrequired.Thisisaculturalshiftwhichwilloccurovertime.Itneedsconsistentactivitytoraiseawareness,buildexpertiseandexperienceandmakethebenefitsofparticipationevident.
2. supportivecontext:institutionalandFacultysystemsandprocessescontextmustfacilitateforcurriculumredesignandprovideadequateresourcesfordelivery–particularlyforbuildingandmaintainingrelationshipswithemployers
3. professionaldevelopment:courseteamsneedtobuildtheirownunderstandingofwork-integratedlearningandtodrawupontheexpertiseofWILspecialists
4. changemanagement:whenwork-integratedlearningisthoroughlyembedded,itbecomesthesharedresponsibilityofallthosecontributingtothecourse.Facultyandcourseleadersneedtobeabletobringcolleagueswiththeminasustainableway
Page12|WILinScience2015-2016
5. accesstotoolsandresources:althoughmanyresources,examplesandcasestudiesarealreadyavailable,studiesofcurriculumchangeindicatethateducatorsrespondbesttopeersanddisciplinaryexamplesthatcaneasilyberelatedtotheirownexperience(Johnson,Birdetal.2012)).
TheWILinSciencenetworkhasbeguntoaddresstheseissues,butitisinitsearlystagesofdevelopmentandwillrequiresupportforsometimetoachievesustainability.Foratleasttheimmediatefuture,thenetworkneedsa‘home’andfacilitationtoensurethatparticipationisvaluableformembers.TheACDSwillprovidebothacentralhuband,throughtheSuccessfulWILinScienceproject,fundingforbuildingresourcesandnetworkeventstogrowproductivecollaboration.Roadmapforaction
WILinSciencehascreatedaroadmaptoguidethebroadscaleadoptionofWILinScienceFaculties(Fig4).TheprogramwillcontinuetobuilditsactivitythroughtheACDSTeachingandLearningCentre(Roadmapactions1and4)anditssecondphaseproject,SuccessfulWILinSciencefundedfromAug2016toAug2018(Roadmapactions2and3).Newprojectswillbeneededforfurthercollaborationwithindustry,regulatorsandotherdisciplines(Roadmapaction4).AfuturegoalisthecreationofeffectivestandardsforWILdesignanddeliverywhichrequiresnationalconsensustobecompelling.Oncecreated,thesestandardswouldunderpincollectiveactionandcouldcontributetofutureregulatoryrequirements.Figure4:NationalRoadmapforWILinScience
ACTION DELIVERY1. ConsolidatetheWILinSciencenetworkthrough:
• localandnationalevents(ACDSWILinScienceforum,ACDSTLconference,ACSME,regionalworkshops)
• newslettertomembers
Ongoing,supportedthroughACDSTeachingandLearningCentre
2. Fosterpeer-to-peerlearningthrough:• Regionalgroupsandcollaborations• Sharingofcasestudiesandexemplarsinscienceandmathematical
sciences
SuccessfulWILinScience
3. CreateandadaptresourcestoinformanddevelopWILinscienceandmathematicalsciencesastheWILinScienceGuidepublishedviatheACDSTeachingandLearningCentreincluding• WILbasics:foundationalinformationaboutwork-integratedlearning• WILcasestudiesfromscienceandmathematicalsciences• StoriesofWILfromstudents,graduateandemployers• LinktoInternationaltools,resourcesandperspectives
SuccessfulWILinScience
4. Increaseconnectiontoemployers,regulators,otherdisciplinesandstakeholdersthrough:• CollaborationwithAustralianCollaborativeEducationNetwork(ACEN),
employerpeakbodies,highereducationpeakbodiestocontributetosectorialactivity
• Collaborationwithotherdisciplinestosharegoodpractice• Collaborativeresearch&evaluationforWILinhighereducation• Cross-disseminationtodisciplinenetworksanduniversitygroupings
ExistingcollaborationsContributiontoNationalWILstrategyNewactivities
5. SetindicativestandardsforWILpracticeforsciencedegrees• CreatenationalconsensusforstandardsforpracticeofWILinScience
buildingfromtheeducationalliteratureandtheevidenceofpractice
Newactivity
Page13|WILinScience2015-2016
3Casestudiesforchange|LighthouseprojectsExemplarsandpeersclosetothelivedexperienceofteacherscanbepowerfulforcesforchange.Thishasbeenobservedincurriculumchangeprogramswhereteachingandlearningleadersandtheirprojectshavesignificantimpactastrustedcolleaguesthatunderstandthedisciplineandpracticesthatcanreadilybeadaptedtothelocalcontext(Johnson,Birdetal.2012,Matthews,Cramptonetal.2015).ExamplesofgoodpracticewerecreatedforScienceFacultiestoshowcasehowtoembed/assess/delivernewcurriculumbasedontheScienceThresholdLearningOutcomes5.AparallelapproachwasundertakenforWILinScience:LeadershipforWILtouselocalprojectstoexploresignificantissuesforFacultiesviathetrialanddisseminationofmodelsofwork-integratedlearninginsciencedegrees.
CreatinglocalactionTheWILinScienceLighthouseProjectswereshort,localprojectswithinScienceFacultiestotestandexplorelocalimplementationofWILinscienceprograms.TheprojectsweredesignedtodeliverimmediatelocalbenefittotheirhostFacultiestoensurelocalsupportandtoillustratepossiblepathwaysforWILdevelopmentforotheruniversitiesandthesector.IntendedoutcomesforLighthouseprojectsandcriteriaforselection
1. makeastepchangeforembeddingeffectiveWILintocoursedeliverywithintheFaculty(local)2. createeffectiveleadershipandorganisationforWILintheFaculty,includingaclearpointof
contactandpathwaysforindustryengagement(local)3. linktoinstitutionalorganisation/resources/policywherepresent,andpromoteimproved
institutionalcapabilitytosupportandfosterWIL(local)4. identifyandleverageotheropportunities(industryresearch,philanthropy,etc.)wherepossible
(local)5. informdevelopmentofWILinscienceinotherinstitutions(sector)
Projectswereselectedbycompetitivebidsandwerefundedupto$10000byWILinScience:LeadershipforWILwithmatchingfundingfromthehomeFaculty.BidswerereviewedbyanexpertpanelofdrawnfromtheProjectSteeringGroupandtheExpertAdvisoryGroup,andevaluatedbasedonthelikelihoodofachievementoftheintendedprojectoutcomesandrelevancetothesectorasawhole.Projectswereexpectedtocompletewithin12monthsbut,interestingly,allfundedprojectshavecontinuedworkontheirinitiativesandexpecttotranslatethemintobroaderapplication.Lighthouseprojectswereaskedtostructuretheirteamstofostersustainedengagementwithwork-integratedlearning.EachteamincludedaFacultynominatedWILleaderandatleastoneotherFacultystaffmembermentoredthroughparticipationintheproject.Theteamstructureandfocusonsustainabilitywasmodelledontheexperienceofaprecedingsector-widecurriculumdevelopmentproject,theSaMnetscholars(Matthews,Cramptonetal.2015).Sixsubmissionswerefundedfromapooloftensubmissions.TheselectedprojectsexploredthethreespacesintheWILdevelopmentmodel(Section2),intentionandplanning,buildandtrial,refineandexpand,thusprovidingthreealternativepointsofconnectionforpeerFaculties(Fig4).ThesixprojectsalsoaddressedkeyissuesidentifiedbytheWILinSciencenetwork:
• mappingWILinthecurriculum(UniversityofTasmania,WesternSydneyUniversity)• alternativeWILdesigns-usingWILforhonours(MonashUniversity)andusingstudent’sexisting
workcommitments(UniversityofQueensland)• cross-disciplinaryWILunits/subjects(UniversityofTasmania,UniversityofQueensland)• scalingupindustryplacement(UniversityofTechnology,Sydney)• buildingWILcapabilityamongstcoursedirectorsandteachingteams(DeakinUniversity)
5ThecollectedGoodPracticeGuidescreatedforimplementationoftheThresholdLearningOutcomesforSciencearecollectedintheScienceTLOprogrampagesoftheACDSTeachingandLearningCentrewebsite(http://www.acds-tlcc.edu.au/science-threshold-learning-outcomes-tlos/science-threshold-learning-outcomes-tlosscience-tlo-good-practice-guides/)
Page14|WILinScience2015-2016
Fig4:LighthouseprojectscorrespondtostagesintheWILdevelopmentmodel
TheLighthouseProjectsTheLighthouseprojectswerecommissionedinMarch2016andwerestillrunningatthecompletionoftheWILinScienceProjectinDec2017.FindingsfromtheLighthouseprojectsaddressed(1)designanddeliveryofeffectiveWILprogramsand(2)advicetoScienceFacultiesontheimplementationofaWILstrategy.Primaryreports(casestudies)fromeachprojectarepresentedascasestudiesinAppendix4.
WILdevelopmentstage:Intention&Planning
1.TheUniversityofTasmania,SchoolofLandandFoodProject:UnifyingWILinScienceattheUniversityofTasmaniaProjectlead:Assoc.Prof.TinaAcuña,DrAndrewSeen,MrsNicoleHerbert,DrShanePowell,DrRebeccaGehling,MrRobertKingsley,MsSusieHaley.Projectdescriptionandscope:ThisprojectcreatedagenericWILprogramforSciencecoursesleveragingexperiencefromallieddisciplines(engineering,ICT,agriculture)anddevelopedafaculty-levelapproachtoindustryengagementviaanAdvisoryBoardthatfosterscross-disciplinarylinks.TheprojectillustratesdeterminationofcurrentstateinstaffperceptionsandcurriculummappingasinitialstepsrequiredtoembedWILinaSciencecurriculum.Theprojectdescribesfactorstoconsiderindevelopmentofagenericprogramforonandoff-campusWILinScienceandrelateddisciplines.KeyFindings:DesignanddeliveryofWILprograms
• Designofageneric(Faculty-wide)WILplacementsubjectmustcaterforstudentpreferences.Teachingstaffandstudentsnotedmanystudentseitherundertakeorpreferplacementoversummer.
• Industrypartnersappreciateflexibilityinplacement/projectstructuretoaccommodatecapacityandavailablesupervisionintheworkplaceandalsoseekflexibilityinplacementtiming.
SettingupFacultyWILprograms UniversityofTasmania WesternSydneyUniversity
DevelopingalternativeapproachestoWIL UniversityofQueensland MonashUniversity
ExtendingWILandbuildingcapacityforthefuture UniversityofTechnology,Sydney DeakinUniversity
1:Intention&planning
2:Build &trial
3:Refine&expand
Page15|WILinScience2015-2016
• ScienceWILprogramscanbesuccessfullymodelledonprofessionaldegreeWILsubjectsandexperiencesfrompartnerUniversities.
ImplementationofWILprograms
• TheprojectfoundsignificantvariationbetweenscienceteachingstaffinorientationtoandunderstandingofWIL.PoorunderstandingandskepticismwasmoreapparentindisciplineswithlittlepreviousexposuretoWIL.
• AdefinedprojectiseffectiveatgeneratinginterestwithintheScienceFacultyandcreatesapointoflinkagewithotherFacultiesandwiththeUniversity
• IndustryengagementrequiresconsiderableconsultationandanopenviewofhowrelationshipssuchasIndustryAdvisoryBoardsoperate
2.WesternSydneyUniversity,SchoolofScienceandHealth(ParramattaCampus)Project:ProvidingWILacrosscomplexinterconnectedsciencedegreesProjectlead:DrJo-AnneChuck,DrChrisJones,ProfessorThomasMillar,DrDavidvanReykProjectdescriptionandscope:ThisprojectmappedWILactivitiesinordertodevelopopportunitiestoembedWILinthecurriculumofanentiresuiteofSciencecourses.Theprojectidentified,categorized,andcompiledcurrentactivitiesinthesciencedegreesthatconstituteWILandusedtheanalysistoidentifywherenew/existingactivitiescouldbeexplicitlyincorporatedintotheBScprograms.TheprojectworkedindividuallywithteachingteamstoplandevelopmentofWILactivitiesappropriatetothediscipline,course,studentdevelopmentandintendedWILlearningoutcomes,andtocreatespaceforstudentstocompleteplacements/volunteeropportunitieswithacademiccredit.TheprojectalsoinitiateddesignofagenericWILplacementsubjectthatcouldbeembeddedintomultiplecourses.KeyFindings:DesignanddeliveryofWILprograms
• DefinitionsofWILneedtobedevelopedinthelocalcontextandwithconsiderationofdisciplinaryvariation
• Detailedmappingofexistingcurriculaidentifiedconsiderable‘hidden’WILwhereteachersaddressgraduateemployabilityalthoughtheconnectionmaynotbeapparenttostudents
• MappingshouldidentifytypeandmodeofWILactivity,explicitvshidden,authenticityoftheactivity,scaffolding,skilltransferabilityandalignmentwithlearningoutcomes.
ImplementationofWILprograms
• DirectlinkageoftheFacultyWILstrategytoaUniversitystrategycreatesstrongimpetusforengagementandaction
• Individualconversationswithcourseandsubjectco-ordinatorsareaveryeffectivewayofbuildingengagement,capabilityandconfidence,althoughthisistime-consuming
• Mappingprovidesthebasisforgapanalysisandcourse-levelthinkinganddispelstheperceptionthatWILisonlyachievedthroughindustryplacement
• PartnershipwithUniversityCareersServicescreatesvaluableresourcesforFacultyimplementation
• AvisibleprojectatFacultylevelprovidesamechanismtoinfluenceUniversitystrategy,supportandsystems
WILdevelopmentstage:Build&Trial
3.TheUniversityofQueensland,FacultyofScienceandInstituteforTeachingandLearningInnovationProject:ExploringalternatemodelsforWILinScience:LinkingWorkwithLearningProjectteam:Assoc.Prof.SusanRowland,Prof.PeterAdams,DrDeanneGannaway,MsRobynEvansProjectdescriptionandscope:ThisprojectdevelopedaninnovativemodelforWILthatacademicallyexpandsonextantstudentworkexperience,thatis,thecurrentpaidworkinwhichstudentsengageoutsideoftheirstudy,withtheaimofbroadeningopportunitiesforengagingwithWIL.Theprojecttestedaprototypecurriculumwithvolunteerstudents,priorto2017implementationofaformalelectivecourse(unitofstudy)inmultipleFacultyofSciencedegrees.TheprojectalsoprovidedanopportunitytoidentifyandbuildrelationshipswithcommunityandindustryworkplacementsitesinordertoexpandformalWILplacementsinthefuture.KeyFindings:
Page16|WILinScience2015-2016
DesignanddeliveryofWILprograms
• Transferableskillsderivedfromexistingpaidworkcanbesuccessfullyembeddedinanacademicprogramtosupportgraduateemployment
• Transferableemployabilityskillscanbesuccessfullyappliedtosciencecareereducationthroughcriticalinvestigationandreflection
• Sciencestudentsmayhavehadlittleopportunityorencouragementtoreflectontheirownskillsbutareengagedandenthusiasticwhensupportedtopresentthemselvesasprofessionals
ImplementationofWILprograms
• Academic’sreactionstogenericskillsprograms(includingcareereducation)aremixedwithsomeconcernedthatexpressingWILprogramswillnotachieveacademicappropriateacademicrigourorthatcareereducationskillsshouldbeco-curricular
4.MonashUniversity,SchoolofBiologicalSciencesProject:DevelopmentofprofessionalskillsinsciencestudentsthroughaworkintegratedlearninghonoursstreamProjectteam:DrRowanBrookes,DrChrisThompson,LisaHappell,DrTimConnalonProjectdescriptionandscope:ThisprojecthasdevelopedmaterialsandsupportedcurriculumdesignforaWILhonoursyearinaneliteundergraduatescienceprogramwhichtheFacultyistriallingasamodelforafutureimplementationintheBachelorofScience.Theelitedegree,BachelorofScienceAdvanced-GlobalChallenges(Honours),willcommenceitsinauguralWIL-focusedhonoursstreamin2017.Thestudentswillcollaborateinteamstodeliveraprojectthataddressesanauthenticworkplacechallengeprovidedbythepartnerorganisations;theoutcomesofwhichwillformthestudent’shonoursprojects.ThisprojecthasrefinedthecurriculumdesignandresourcingfortheWILhonoursyearandcreatedthreeonlineskilldevelopmentmodules,specificallytargetedtoareasthatemployersandstudentshaveidentifiedasimportantforsciencegraduates.
KeyFindings:
DesignanddeliveryofWILprograms
• SkilldevelopmentmodulesforWILshouldbeco-designedwithindustrypartnersandstudentstoensurerelevanceandfutureengagement
• Wherepossible,learningactivitiesforemployabilityskillsshouldbedesignedforre-useinmultipleprograms
• AlumniareanimportantresourceforuniversitiestomodeltransitiontoemploymentImplementationofWILprograms
• Dedicatedresourcesandexpertiseareneededtobuildandmaintaineffectiveindustryrelationships
WILdevelopmentstage:Expand&Refine
5.UniversityofTechnology,Sydney,FacultyofScienceProject:Scaling-upProfessionalExperiencePrograms:developingaframeworktosupportbroad-basedWILProjectteam:Prof.PeterCMeier,DrBlairNield,Prof.GrahamNicholson,DrDavidvanReyk,MsShimaBaradaranVahdat,MsVikkiBanksProjectdescriptionandscope:ThisprojectdevelopedanintegratedFacultystrategytoextendWILactivitiesinscienceandrelateddegreesthroughcurriculumrenewal,scalinganddevelopmentofindividualplacementprograms,andthecreationofadministrativeprocessestostreamlineandsupportinternshipactivities.TheaimoftheprojectwastocreateaflexibleandresponsiveFacultyenvironmentthatcouldaccommodateinternshiporinternship-likeexperiencesforallstudentsasrequiredbytheUniversity.Theprojectincluded(1)restructureofdegreeprogramstoensuretherewascapacityforstudentstotakeasession(semester)freeblockinprogramstoallowforaminimum12-weekinternshipplacement,(2)constructionofasuiteofFacultyinternshipunitsofvariablelengthtosuitemployerneedsand(3)mappingandcurriculumdesigntoembedauthenticassessmentlinkedtoWIL.Theseinitiativeswillbefurtherdevelopedin2017.KeyFindings:DesignanddeliveryofWILprograms
Page17|WILinScience2015-2016
• Large-scaleindustryplacements(internships)requireaflexibletimingtoaccommodatevaryingemployerneeds
• MappingofWILactivityacrossFacultyprogramsidentifiedbothexplicit(directlylinkedandassessed)andimplicit(indirectlylinkedandpossiblyassessed)WILincurricula
• MakingWILavailabletoallstudentswillrequireinnovativeapproachessuchasplacementsoutsideconventionalscienceworkplacesoronlineplacements
ImplementationofWILprograms
• Faculty-levelstrategyandauthoritativeleadershipiscrucialtoremoveorganizationalandstructuralblockstobroad-scaleWIL
• DevelopmentofWILprogramsistightlylinkedtootherformsofcurriculumrenewalandmustbealignedwithcurriculumdevelopmentinitiatives
• Large-scaleplacement(internship)WILrequiresconsistentsystemsandprocessestomanageorganizationalissuessuchasinsurance,voluntaryvspaidplacements,academicassessmentbyhostorganisations,workhealthandsafetyrequirementsetc
• NationalstandardsforWILimplementationwouldenableFacultiestobenchmarktheirprogress6.DeakinUniversity,FacultyofScience,EngineeringandBuiltEnvironmentProject:LearningtoWork,WorkingtoLearn:CurriculumdesignandteachingpracticeforWILintheNaturalandPhysicalSciencesProjectteam:Prof.MalcolmCampbell,Assoc.Prof.StuartPalmer,Assoc.Prof.JoColdwell-Nielson,DrKarenYoung,MarkTolsonProjectdescriptionandscope:Thisprojectcreatedresources,exemplarsandworkshopsforcoursedirectorsinordertobuildleadershipforWILandachieveacoordinatedandbroaderapproachtoemploymentopportunitiesforstudents.TheprojectestablishedaFacultyWILSteeringGroupthatworkedwithcoursedirectorstocreateshareddefinitionsofWIL,howWILshouldbescaffoldedwithincoursesandwhatconstitutesappropriateassessmentofWIL.TheseinteractionshavecreatedaWILcommunityofpracticeandhaveidentifiedandrecognizedWILleaderswithintheFaculty.KeyFindings:DesignanddeliveryofWILprograms
• MappingofWILincoursesrecordsintentionsratherthanoutcomeswhicharethetruemeasureofsuccess,howevermappingisausefulactivitytoinitiatediscussion
• WILcanbedescribedbyauthenticity(howcloselythelearningactivityalignstotaskswithintheworkplace)orproximity(theclosenessofstudentstoexistingpractitioners)
• IndividualWILactivitiesmaynotachievebothauthenticityandproximitysoWILactivitiesshouldbeplannedacrosseachdegreeandscaffoldedtoensurevalueforstudents
ImplementationofWILprograms
• RecognitionofexpertiseandleadershipofWILencourageschampionstoinvestinfurtheractivity
• Communitiesofpracticearepowerfulandself-sustainingmechanismstoembedWILforthelong-termandspreadgoodpractice
• Creationofdevelopmentresourcesforcourseleadersprovidespromptsfordiscussionandafocusforaction
OutcomesfromtheLighthouseprojectsCasestudiesforWIL
TheLighthouseProjectsoffermodelsforWILdevelopmentanddelivery.ProjectteamshavepreparedaprimarycasestudyreportsfromtheirprojectforpublicationthroughtheACDSTeachingandLearningCentre.TheinformationcollectedviatheseprimaryreportswillbeeditedtocreatesixcasestudiesdevelopedforapplicationinotherFaculties.Theobjectiveofthecasestudiesistoprovideinsight,promptnewthinkingandconsiderfactorsinadaptationtolocalcontexts.Theprimarycasestudyreports
Page18|WILinScience2015-2016
arepresentedinAppendix4.EditedcasestudieswillbepublishedinQ2,2017viatheACDSTeachingandLearningCentre.Emergentthemes
ThemesemergingfromtheLighthouseprojectsreinforcedfindingsfromtheWILinSciencenetworkanduncoveredinsightstoassistScienceFaculties.Thesethemesalignwelltotheresearchliteratureonwork-integratedlearning.ThefollowingobservationsaredrawnfromtheLighthousereports,keyfindingsandpresentationsduringtheproject.
DesignanddeliveryofWILprograms
StudentpreferencesandengagementarekeyfactorsincreatingsuccessfulWILprograms.Programleadersshouldincorporateconsultationandtestingwithstudentsaspartofprogramdevelopment.(Projects1and3)EmployersshouldbeequalpartnersindesigninganddeliveringWILprograms.Therearelargeadvantagesinengagingindustrypartnersthroughoutdesignbuttobesuccessful,partnershipsmustallowforindustryconstraintssuchasavailabletimeandcapacity.UniversitycurriculumstructuresandtypesofWILmustbeflexibleenoughtoaccommodateavarietyoftypesofindustryengagement,andFacultieswillneedtoinvesttimeandresourcesintobuildingandmaintainingrelationships(Projects1,4,and5)Broad-scaleuptakeofWILneedsinnovativeandvariedsolutionsincludinggenericplacementsubjectsthatcanbeembeddedinmultiplecourses(Projects1,2,3,5),useofnon-scienceworkplacements/experiencetobuildtransferableskills(Project3),modelsfromprofessionaldegrees(Project1).SharingideasbetweenFacultiesassistsWILleaderstothinkoutsidetheboxandtesttheirideas.EachinstitutionwillneedtoarriveatalocaldefinitionandapplicationofWIL(allprojects)thatalignstolocalconstraintsandintentionsandcatersfordisciplinaryvariation.ConstructionofashareddefinitionisausefultooltobuildengagementwithteachingteamsandisparticularlyimportantforgeneralistdegreessuchastheBachelorofSciencethatincorporatemanysub-disciplines.Facultiesneedtodevelopsharedunderstandingofpriorities.MappingWILacrossthecurriculumofadegreecanalsobeaveryusefultool(Projects1,2,5,6).MappingWILactivitiesandtheircharacteristicsbuildsapictureofthecoherenceoftheconsolidatedWILactivitiesandthegapswhichleavestudentswithoutaccesstoWIL.MappingassistscourseleadersandteachingteamstounderstandscaffoldingandthecomponentskillsthatcontributetoavaluableWILprogram.MappingalsoassiststeachersandleaderstomakeWILexplicittoteachersandstudents.However,mappinggenerallyonlyrecordsintentionandshouldbeaccompaniedbyevidenceofoutcomestoevaluatethesuccessofaWILcurriculum.WILbuildstransferableemployabilityskillsvaluedbyemployerssuchasself-management,teamwork,communicationorcriticalthinking.Theseskillscanbebuiltthroughsciencecareereducationactivities(Project3),re-usableonlinelearningactivities(Project4)aswellasreflectiononworkplacements/internships(allprojects).Developmentshouldbescaffoldedthrougheachdegreesothatstudentsbuildtheirconfidenceovertimeandcanrelatetheirskillstovariousapplications.ImplementationofWILprograms
AllprojectscommentedonthevalueofalignmentoftheirprojectswithFacultyandUniversitypriorities.Inallcases,visiblelinkstoinstitutionalstrategyandinitiativescreatedcredibility,encouragedengagementandsupportedlong-termefforts.AlignmentalsohelpstoensurethatuniversitysystemssupportWILprogramsandthatprocessesencourageWIL.FacultiesshouldensuretheyworkcloselywithotherstakeholdersandresourceswithintheirUniversity.
Page19|WILinScience2015-2016
Similarly,visibleFacultyleadershipfacilitatesinitiatives(allprojects).Inparticular,Facultyleadershipsimplifiesapprovalsandgovernancearrangements,andhelpstomakethecaseforinvestmentofresources.Explicitandendorsedleadershiprolescatalyzeaction.DevelopmentofWILprogramsmustbealignedtoothercoursedevelopmentactions.Coursemappingisoneexampleofatoolthatdrawstogetherallelementsofthecurriculum.DevelopmentofWILprogramsisinherentlycomplexinvolvingmanystakeholders.Tobesuccessful,courseleadersandteachingteamsmustbeabletobuilditintotheirprocessesforcurriculumdevelopment(Project6).Projectsreportedtheimportanceofworkingwithteachingstafftobuildconfidenceinwork-integratedlearningandacknowledgeandaddressconcerns(Projects1,3and6).LimitedpreviousengagementwithWILmeansthatteachingstaffmayhavenegativepre-conceptionsaboutthevalueofemployabilityskillsandconnectiontocoursecontent.Specificprojectscancreateaspringboardforbroaderaction.Informalprofessionaldevelopmentoccursascourseleadersandteachersengagewiththeproject,particularlywheretheprojectworkswithindividualsonlocalproblems.Facultiesneedtoinvestinengagementwithteachingteams.
Leadershipanddissemination
TheWILinScienceLighthouseprojectshaveachievedmanyoutcomesbeyondtheimplementationofaspecificWILactivity.TheyhavehelpedtodevelopanewgroupofWILleaders,prompteddiscussionacrossuniversitiesanddisciplines,andcreatedpeercollaborations.BuildingleadershipforWILprogramswasakeyobjectiveofWILinScience:LeadershipforWIL.TheLighthouseprojectsweredesignedasaction-learningprojects,thatis,projectteamswouldlearnandbuildtheirownskillsthroughprojectimplementation.Action-learningprojectshavebeensuccessfullyusedtobuildleadershipinlearningandteachingaswellassubjectknowledgeandskills(Sharma,Rifkinetal.2014).ItisclearthatLighthouseprojectleadersarerecognizedasWILleaderswithintheirhomeinstitutionsandarenowactivecontributorstothenationaldiscussion.AlignmentofthefocusoftheLighthouseprojectswiththeissuesidentifiedbyWILinSciencenetworkmembershasensuredtherelevanceoftheseprojectstoScienceFaculties.Lighthouseprojectteamshavepresentedtheirprojects,findings,challengesandinnovationstoscienceteachingandlearningleadersatWILinScience:LeadershipforWILevents(WILinScienceFora,Facultyplanningworkshops),promptingrichdiscussionandtestingassumptionsandideas.Lighthouseprojectshavealsobeenpresentedtobroaderaudiences.PresentationatACSME2016(AustralianConferenceforScienceandMathematicsEducation)reachedabroadrangeofuniversityscienceeducators(210participants,Brisbane,Sep2016).CollaborationwiththeAustralianCollaborativeEducationNetwork(ACEN),thepeakprofessionalassociationforwork-integratedlearning,enabledtwonationalwebinarsforWILinScience:LeadershipforWILtoreachacross-disciplinaryaudience.Mentoringandconnections:criticalfriends
TheWILinScienceprogramisbasedonapeerlearningmodel.Lighthouseprojectteamshavecreatedinternalcollaborationsamongstteams,havedevelopedcollaborationswithotherUniversitiesandhaveactedascriticalfriendsforpeers.Theroleofacriticalfriendhasprovedvaluableinothercurriculumdevelopmentprojects.IntheSaMnetScholarsprogramtodevelopcurriculumleadership,criticalfriendsfromapartnerinstitutionwithteachingandlearningexperienceactedasmentorsandcreatedareflectivespaceforcriticalevaluationofprogressandplanning(Sharma,Rifkinetal.2014).Acriticalfrienddoesnotneedtobeanexpertbutdoesneedrelevantexperienceandagenuineinterestintheprojectbeingconsidered.WILinScience:LeadershipforWILcreatedacollegiatenetworkwheremembersfeelempoweredtoseekassistancefromothersandaregivenspacetoreflectonprogress.Peersfromotheruniversitiesinthenetworkwhoareworkinginthesamespaceandexperiencingsimilarissuesareappropriatecriticalfriends.Thisapproachwillbecontinuedviaphase2forWILinScience,theOLT-fundedSuccessfulWILinScienceproject.
Page20|WILinScience2015-2016
4ImpactandnextstepsWILinScience:LeadershipforWILhasachieveditsimmediategoalstoestablishnationalleadershipforwork-integratedlearningwithinScienceFaculties,createanationalconversationaboutwork-integratedlearninginsciencedegrees,beginthetaskofbuildingcapacitytodesignanddeliverWILprograms,andtotrialapproachestoWILdevelopment(seeSection1,Table1).Alloftheseoutcomeswilldevelopfurtherovertimeasthenetworkgrowsandextendsitsactivities.
ImpactandEvaluationWILinScience:LeadershipforWILusedformativeevaluationduringtheprojecttoguideimplementation,andsummativeevaluationattheconclusionoftheprojecttopromptreflectionandadviceforthenextphasesofthiswork.Twoevaluatorscontributedtotheevaluation:DrTrinaJorredeStJorre,DeakinUniversityledthecollectionandanalysisofformativefeedbackfromprojecteventsandmembersurveys,andDrSivaKrishnan,DeakinUniversityconductedthesummativeevaluationincludingareviewofprojectactivitiesandinterviewswithLighthouseProjectleaders.TheevaluationstrategywasbasedonevaluationresourcesoftheOfficeforLearningandTeaching6.Itincludesevaluationofimmediateoutcomeswithshort-termmeasuresandposesquestionstobeconsideredoverthelonger-term(Table3).
Surveysandfeedback
FeedbackwascollectedfromattendeesateachWILinScienceforumontake-homemessages,suggestionsforaction/resourcestobuildandexpandWILandsuggestionsforfutureevents.Emergentthemeswereusedtorefinetheprojectandguidethefuturedevelopmentoftheprogram.SelectedfindingsfromsurveysofnetworkmembersarepresentedinSection2.ParticipantswerestronglysupportiveoftheWILinScienceprogram,thenationalforaandparticularlytheemphasisonnetworking,peerlearningandpracticaladvice.Onerespondentfromthe2016NationalForumnoted:
Thankyoufortheforumandforthecontinuedsupportofthisnetwork.Itisimpressivehowfarwehavecomebetweenthefirstforumandthisone.
ParticipantfeedbackwasalsocollectedfromtheFacultyplanningworkshopsandusedtorefinesubsequentactivities.Fortheseworkshops,participantswereusuallyalreadyactiveinWILbutcommentedthattheworkshophadprovidednewcontacts,resourcesandmotivation.EvaluationoftheLighthouseProjects
EvaluationoftheLighthouseprojectsispresentedinAppendix5.Theevaluatorconcludes:Toconclude,theprojectactivitiesseemveryappropriateandtimelytobuildgraduateemployabilityoutcomeswithinSciencerelateddisciplinesforthereasontheprojectteamidentify.Thelighthouseprojectsinparticularhaveprovidedtheimpetusforbuildingcapacity,todesignanddeliverWILprogramsthroughcollaborativediscussionsandsharingofstrategiesandpracticethroughthenationalnetworkofScienceWILleadersandpeer-to-peermentoringactivities.
Discussionsduringtheinterviewsandtriangulationoftheinterviewdatawiththeprojectaimsandintentions,anddatafromparticipantsurveysconfirmedtheformulationofarenewedcommunityofpracticetoraiseawarenessoftheplaceandimportanceofWILinSciencerelateddisciplines.
6See:http://www.olt.gov.au/evaluation
Page21|WILinScience2015-2016
Table3:EvaluationapproachforWILinScience:LeadershipforWIL
ProjectOutcome Short-termoutcomes Longer-termoutcomes Evaluationquestion Evaluationdata Evaluationquestion EvaluationdataSeniorleadersinWILforScienceandMaths
AreseniorWILleadersevidentandactiveinFacultiesofScience?
SurveyofWILinSciencenetworkmembers
AreWILLeadershiproleswidespreadamongstsciencefaculties?
NumberofformalWILleadershiprolesinFacultiesofScience
ResponsibilitiesofWILleaders
NetworkofWILforScienceandMaths
DoesWILinSciencemeettheneedsofitsmembers?
SurveyofWILinSciencenetworkmembers
CommentaryfromtheExpertAdvisoryGroup.
DoesWILinSciencetakeacollectiveleadershiproleinadvisingonWILinScienceandMaths?
CommentaryfromExecutiveofparticipatingFaculties
Action-LearningProjects Whatistheimpactofaction-learningproject?
Interviewswithaction-learningprojectteams
HaveWILprogramsderivedfromtheaction-learningprojectsbeenembeddedandsustainedinsciencedegrees
CommentaryfromAssociateDeansTeachingandLearningofparticipatingFaculties
ProfessionaldevelopmentforWILleaders
DoprofessionaldevelopmentactivitiesmeettheneedsofWILinSciencemembers?
Surveyofworkshopparticipants
SurveyofWILinSciencenetworkmembers
DoWILinSciencememberscontributetodevelopmentofWILintheirinstitution?
CommentaryfromExecutiveofparticipatingFaculties
NationalreportonmodelsforWILleadershipinsciencefaculties
DoesthereportoffernewinsightorideasforWILinscienceandmathematicalsciences?
Commentarybyexpertreferencegroup
DoesWILinScienceprovideusefulresourcesand/oraforumfordevelopmentofWILinScience
CommentaryfromnetworkmembersandACDS
Page22|WILinScience2015-2016
ExtendingWILinScience:SuccessfulWILinScienceIn2016,theACDSpartneredwithfouruniversities,DeakinUniversity,MonashUniversity,CurtinUniversityandtheUniversityofNewcastle,tosecurefundingfromtheOfficeforLearningandTeachingforthesecondphaseoftheWILinScienceprogram:SuccessfulWILinScience.SuccessfulWILinSciencebuildsonthefoundationalworkofWILinScience:LeadershipforWILtocreatetailoredresourcesandadvicethatwillsupportFacultiestobuildemployabilityskillsforthefutureforgraduatesinscienceandmathematics.ItrecognisesthelargebodyofadviceandexperiencewithWILfromrelateddisciplineareas(e.g.engineering,ICT),fromcompletedOLTandpredecessorbodies’workandfromthelearningandteachingliterature.ItwilladdtotheseresourceswithauthenticandintegratedcasestudiesofimplementationofWILinscience,andtheexperienceofstudentsandrecentgraduates.Theprojectwilltranslatetheseresourcesintoactionbycreatingtailoredtoolsforsciencefacultiescoupledwithinstitutionalpeermentoring.Atthecompletionofthisproject,sciencefacultieswillhavefurtherdevelopedleadershipforWILandtheWILinSciencenetwork,willhaveanexpandingsetofresourcesforWILand,mostimportantly,strongerlinkstoindustryforstudentsstudyingscienceandmathematics.SuccessfulWILinScienceisfundedfromAug2016toAug2018.CommitmenttotheWILinScienceprogramwasstronglyendorsedbytheAnnualGeneralMeetingoftheACDSinOctober2016andexplicitlyidentifiedasapriorityareaforFacultyDeans.TheACDScruciallyprovidescontinuityofeffortandreachintoallAustralianuniversitiesofferingscienceawards.ItscommitmenttoWILinScienceisanintegralpartofitsongoing,andfunded,investmentinlearningandteachinginsciencedegrees.SuccessfulWILinScienceProjectTeam:
ProfLizJohnson,DeakinUniversityandACDSTeaching&LearningCentreProfJohnRice,ACDSProfCristinaVarsavsky,MonashUniversityProfJoWard,CurtinUniversityProfMalcolmCampbell,DeakinUniversityDrJohnHoldsworth,TheUniversityofNewcastleDrTrinaJorredeStJorre,DeakinUniversity
Page23|WILinScience2015-2016
Appendix1|EventsanddisseminationWILinScienceNationalFora2015and2016
Universities Attendees2015Forum Attendees2016Forum
AustralianCatholicUniversity 1 1
AustralianNationalUniversity 2
CentralQueenslandUniversity 1
CharlesDarwinUniversity 1
CurtinUniversity 2 1
DeakinUniversity 5 6
EdithCowan 1
FederationUniversity 2
FlindersUniversity 1
GriffithUniversity 5 2
JamesCookUniversity 2
LaTrobeUniversity 2 4
MacquarieUniversity 2 2
MonashUniversity 4 3
MurdochUniversity 1
QueenslandUniversityofTechnology 1 3
RMITUniversity 4 2
SouthernCrossUniversity 1
SwinburneUniversityofTechnology 4 2
UniversityofAdelaide 1
UniversityofCanberra 2 1
UniversityofMelbourne 2 4
UniversityofNewEngland 1 1
UniversityofNewSouthWales 1 1
UniversityofNewcastle 1 2
UniversityofQueensland 5 1
UniversityofSouthAustralia 1
UniversityofSouthernQueensland 1
UniversityofSydney 2
UniversityofTasmania 2 1
UniversityofTechnologySydney 2 3
UniversityoftheSunshineCoast 1
UniversityofWesternAustralia 2
VictoriaUniversity 1 1
WesternSydneyUniversity 2 2
Attendees 65 47
Institutions 31 24
Page24|WILinScience2015-2016
Industry/peakbodies Attendees2015Forum Attendees2016Forum
ACDS 2 2
UniversitiesAustralia 1
ATNUniversityNetwork 1
CSIRO 1
OfficeoftheChiefScientist 2 1
StandardsAustralia 1
AiGroup 1 1
CareerLounge 1
AMSIBoard 1
JudythSachsConsulting 1
Attendees 10 6Institutions 8 5
TOTALATTENDEES 75 53
Facultyplanningworkshops Participants Universities Industry
Melbourne(DeakinUniversity) 14 6 1Sydney(UniversityofTechnologySydney) 16 7 0Brisbane(UniversityofQueensland) 13 6 0 43 19 1
Futureworkshops:AfurtherworkshopistobeconductedinPerthandoneonlineinFebruary2017.Findingsfromtheevaluationswillinformthese2017workshopsandwebinar.
Page25|WILinScience2015-2016
ProjectpresentationsTitleandVenue Presenters AudienceASystematicApproachtoWorkIntegratedLearning2015ACDSAnnualGeneralMeetingOct19,2015,Canberra
ProfLizJohnson ExecutiveDeansofScienceFaculties(~40attendees)
ACDS:WILinScienceLeadershipProjectACENWebinarseriesNov2015,online
ProfJohnRice NationalWILcommunity(~30attendees)
WILinScienceLeadershipProjectCriterionConferences:AligningSTEMEducationwithEmployerNeedFeb17,2016,Melbourne
ProfJohnRiceProfLizJohnson
WILinScienceandtheLighthouseProjectsACENWebinarseriesJuly52016,online
ProfLizJohnson,DrMichaelWhelan,DrJo-AnnChuck,DrTinaAcuna,DrSusanRowland,
NationalWILcommunity(~30attendees)
WILinScience:Anationalprojecttodevelopwork-integratedlearninginFacultiesofScienceACDSTeachingandLearningConferenceJuly222016,Sydney
ProfLizJohnson ACDSTLCentremembers(65attendees,Facultyteachingandlearningleaders)
WILinScience:Anationalprojecttodevelopwork-integratedlearninginFacultiesofScienceACSME2016Sep292016,Brisbane
ProfLizJohnson Scienceandmathematicalscienceuniversityeducations(210attendees)
WILinScience:implicationsforgeneralistdegreesACEN2016,Sep302016,Sydney
ProfLizJohnson,DrMichaelWhelan,ProfJohnRice,DrJo-AnnChuck,DrRowanBrookes,DrBlairNield,DrKarenYoung,MarkTolson,DrTinaAcuna,DrSusanRowland,
NationalWILcommunity(~50attendees)
Work-integratedlearninginbiosciences:why,whatandhow?ComBio2016,Oct42016,Brisbane
ProfLizJohnson Bioscienceeducators(~40attendees)
WILinScience:Anationalprojecttodevelopwork-integratedlearninginFacultiesofScience2016ACDSAnnualGeneralMeeting,Oct192016,Melbourne
ProfLizJohnson ExecutiveDeansofScienceFaculties(~40attendees)
…
Page26|WILinScience2015-2016
Appendix2|LightHousecasestudiesUnifyingWILinScienceattheUniversityofTasmaniaNovember2016
ProjectLeader:DrTinaAcuna,FacultyofScience,EngineeringandTechnology
Projectteam:DrAndrewSeen,MrsNicoleHerbert,DrShanePowell,DrRebeccaGehling,MrRobertKingsley,MsSusieHaley
Objectives
1. developagenericprogramforon-andoff-campusWILinScienceandrelateddisciplinesattheUniversityofTasmania(UTAS)
2. developanetworkofindustrycontactsforWILinScienceandrelateddisciplinesforTasmania3. createaFacultyAdvisoryBoardforindustryengagement
Background
TheUniversityofTasmania(UTAS)iscommittedtoprovidingrealworldexperiencesforstudentsandequippinggraduateswiththeskillsrequiredforparticipationinnationalandinternationalwork.WorkIntegratedLearning(WIL)isonemechanismbywhichstudentscanattainsuchskillsandexperiencesandimprovetheiremployability.ThecurrentUniversityWILpolicy(May2011)providesforstudentplacementinindustry,butalsoforon-campusworkplacesimulationslinkedwithauthenticassessment.TheFacultyofScience,EngineeringandTechnology(SET),comprisedoffiveschoolsand11disciplines,offersageneralistBachelorofScience(BSc),with17majors.UptakeofWILisfarlessintheBachelorofSciencethanotherSTEMdisciplinesatUTAS(includingICT,Engineering,SurveyingandAgriculture),manyofwhichhavearequirementforworkplacementforprofessionalaccreditation.Thisdisparityisconsistentwithnationaltrends(Edwards,Perkins,Pearce,&Hong,2015).DespitepocketsofWILactivityintheseotherSTEMdisciplines,thefacultylackedagenericWILprogramsuitedtobroadimplementationacrossitsdisciplines,oramechanismbywhichtoidentifyandengagewithindustrypartners.Projectdescription
Academics,studentsandrepresentativesfromindustryweresurveyedorinterviewedregardingtheirperceptionsofWILandemployabilityofUTASBScgraduates.Theywerealsoaskedfortheiropinionsonagenericplacementorprojectunittobeundertakenforcreditbyintermediate-level(i.e.second-year)students.ApprovalfromtheHumanResearchEthicsCommitteeatUTASwassoughttoenablethepublicationofprojectoutcomes(H15699).TheprojectteamalsoliaisedextensivelywithcolleaguesinotherfacultiesandatotheruniversitiestodiscusstheirapproachestoWIL,especiallyinrelationtoadministration,coursework,assessmentandindustryengagement.Outcomes
AcademicsdifferedinthebreadthofactivitiestheyclassifyasWILindependentofdisciplinaryarea.TypesofWILcurrentlyofferedintheBScvariedfromlimitedtononeinMathematicsandPhysics,touseofauthenticexperiencesinpracticalunitsindisciplinessuchasGISandSpatialScienceorresearchprojectsinChemistry,PlantScienceandZoology,typicallyinthirdyear.
Severalacademicsstatedthatstudentsintheirdisciplinesundertookvoluntaryorsummervacationworkthatmaymeettheprofessionalworkrequirementsoftheproposedunit.Consistentwiththis,46%ofBScstudentswhorespondedtothesurvey(n=76)preferredtoundertakesuchaunitinthesummersemester.IndustrywereingeneralsupportiveoftheproposedWILunit(s).Ininterviews,genericattributesofcommunication,teamworkandabroadgeneralknowledgewereregardedasimportanttograduateemployability.Theflexibilityinmodeofdeliveryoftheunitwaspositivelyreceived,withlargeorganisationsmorereceptivetostudentsworkingingroupsonanindustryproject,whereassmaller
Page27|WILinScience2015-2016
businesseshadapreferenceforhostingonetotwostudents.ThetimingofsomebusinessactivitieswasinsomeinstancesnotedtobeoutofstepwiththeUTASsemesters,whichneedstobetakenintoaccountwhenplanningforWILprofessionalplacements.Subsequently,theSTEMWILunit(intermediatelevel,12.5%creditKAA205)wasapprovedbyFacultyandUniversityLearningandTeachingCommitteesfordeliveryin2017.Theunitincludesoptionsforstudentstoundertakeeitheraplacementoragroupprojectforanindustryclient,andwillembedanewonlineresource,ResumePLUS,coordinatedbyUTASCareerServices.Additionaloutcomes
InadditiontothedevelopmentoftheSTEMWILunit,theprojectprovidedanumberofextrabenefitsforthefaculty.
- TheprojectprovidedtheopportunityfortheFacultytoaggregatewithin-schoolactivitiesinWIL.Allstaffweremadeawareoftheprojectandunitcoordinatorsinvitedtoparticipateinprojectworkshops.
- ItprovidedtheimpetusforthenewFacultyExecutivetoconsiderhowitengageswithindustry,includingthepotentialinceptionofaFacultyAdvisoryBoardtofacilitateconsultationwithexistingindustrystakeholdergroupsonissuespertainingtolearningandteaching,researchandcommunityengagement.
- TheinceptionofaFacultyIndustryReferenceGrouporanothermodelwillpromoteconsultationonindustrylinkagesinlearningandteaching,researchandcommunityengagement.
- ThegeneralsciencesarenowrepresentedasadisciplineintheUTASCommunityofPracticeinWIL.
- ThedevelopmentoftheSTEMWILunitalignedwithanewWhitePaperoncurriculumrenewalatUTAS,whichincludesacommitmenttoexpandingWILacrosstheuniversity.
- ThecoordinationofWILacrossUTASisproposedtobeundertakenbyanewCentreforExperientialLearningandincludesadditionalinvestmentintheplacementmanagementsoftware,InPlace,toconnectstudentswiththeworkplace.
- Theprojectpromotedintra-facultyteamworkandprovidedanopportunityforprofessionaldevelopmentinthescholarshipoflearningandteachingofjuniorstaff
- TheprojectleaderreceivedfacultyacknowledgementwithapromotiontoDeputyAssociateDeanLearningandTeaching,andhersecondmenttotheUTAS-wideCurriculumRenewalProject
Recommendations/advice
AkeyobservationwhendevelopinganewWILinScienceunitistobuildontheexperiencesandresourcesfromwithintheuniversityandotherinstitutions.Thishowevermustbecontextualisedtothedegreestructure,studentneeds,industrycapacityandavailableresources.Nextsteps
TheintroductionofthenewSTEMWILunitisjustthebeginning.Theprojectteamiscurrentlyworkingon:
• Complementaryunits,includinganadvanced-levelandextendedduration(25%weight)units• ThesystematicembeddingofWILinthemajorsandunitsintheBScthroughtheCurriculum
ChangeProject• UpscalingWILinSciencethroughfacilitationbyanewCentreofExperientialLearningandthe
adoptionofplacementmanagementsoftware,InPlace–outcomesofthecurriculumrenewalWhitePaper.
• FinalisingtheprocessfortheFacultyExecutivetoconsultwithindustry.
Reference
Edwards,D.,Perkins,K.,Pearce,J.,&Hong,J.(2015).WorkIntegratedLearninginSTEMinAustralianUniversities.FinalreportsubmittedtotheOfficeoftheChiefScientist.Retrievedfromhttp://www.chiefscientist.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/ACER_WIL-in-STEM-in-Australian-Universities_June-2015.pdf
Page28|WILinScience2015-2016
ProvidingWILacrosscomplexinterconnectedsciencedegreesatWesternSydney
UniversityNovember,2016
ProjectLeader:DrJo-AnneChuck,SchoolofScienceandHealth,WesternSydneyUniversity
Projectteam:DrChrisJones,ProfessorThomasMillar,DrDavidvanReyk
ObjectivesTheprojecthadthreespecificaims:
1. IdentifyandcompilecurrentactivitiesinthesciencedegreesatWesternSydneyUniversity(WSU)thatconstituteWIL.
2. Determinewhichnew/existingactivitiescanbeexplicitlyincorporatedintotheBachelorScience(BSc)programswithaparticularemphasisontheappropriatenessoftheactivitywithrespecttocurricula,studentdevelopmentandWILlearningoutcomes.
3. Provideanopportunityforstudentstocompleteplacements/volunteeropportunitiesandgainacademiccreditfortheactivityviareflectiononWILoutcomes.
ContextThereareeightsciencedegreesofferedatWSU,throughtheSchoolofScienceandHealth,andonlyoneofthesehasanexplicitWILrequirement.ThisWILcomponentisa‘masteryrequirement’whichhasnocreditpointvalue,andiscompletedoutsideofsemester.ItishighlylikelythattherearecurrentWILactivitiesbeingundertakeninmanyofoursciencedegrees,althoughtheyarenotexplicitlyarticulatedorscaffolded.Inaddition,manystudentsdeliberatelyseekpart-timeworkintheirprofessionalarea(eithervoluntaryorpaid),whichcouldalsobeconsideredWILandshouldberecognisedassuch.Othersarecognisantoftheneedforworkexperiencetodeveloptheirworkreadinessskillsbut,withoutanexplicitcourserequirement,lacktheincentivetoattemptthisbeforegraduation.
TheprimarypurposeofthisprojectwastoprovideaplatformforintroducingWILasaclearlydefinedandidentifiablecomponentofsciencedegreesatWSU.TheprojectlinksdirectlywiththeUniversity’smissionstatementandtheUniversityStrategicPlan‘SecuringSuccess2015-2020’whichstatesthatWSUistobea‘distinctivelystudent-centreduniversity’thatwill‘transform(ing)itsteachingandlearningenvironments….withinnovativecurriculaandworkintegratedlearning’and‘developmoreemployment-basedandvolunteeringprogramsandexperiencesthatpromotepersonaldevelopment,industryandcivicengagementandcareerreadiness’.ThedraftTeachingandLearningPlan(2016-2020)alsoexplicitlyarticulatesdevelopingWILexperiencesinallundergraduatecourses.ThesedocumentsandtheirtimelyreleaseindicatetheprioritygiventoincorporatingWILinthecurriculumandtheexplicitsupportforthedevelopmentofWILinscience.
ImplementationToidentifyexistingWILactivities,wereviewedthelearningguidesfromallcoreoralternatecoreunitswithintheeightscienceprograms,usingthedescriptorsofWILactivitiesoutlinedbyEdwardsetal.(2015).Wetheninterviewedunitcoordinators(n=71)toverifythisinformation,andmapWILactivitiesagainstthelearningobjectivesidentifiedbyEdwardsetal.(2015).Specifically,wefocusedon:
1. whetherWILactivitieswerepresentintheunitandifsowhattype(basedonthetypologyofWILactivitiesinEdwardsetal.,2015)
2. whetherthereisevidenceofscaffoldingandlinkingoftheactivityinthecurriculum3. adescriptionoftheactivityincludinglearningoutcomesandnamesofindustry/communitygroups
involved4. whetherWILwasclearlyarticulatedinthelearningoutcomesoftheunit.
Academicswerealsointerviewed(withHumanEthicsapproval)ontheirperceptionsofWILinthecontextofscience.
OurinitialfindingsindicatethatthereismorehiddenWILinearlierstagesofcoursescomparedwithlateryears.Thismaybeduetoacademicsidentifyingtheneedtodevelopskills,butnotcommunicatinghowactivitiesrelatebacktotheworkplace.WehavefoundvariablecoverageofWILlearningoutcomesandalmostnoscaffoldingofWILlearningoutcomesinthesciencedegrees.
Page29|WILinScience2015-2016
Toencouragestudentstobeproactiveinfindingplacementsduringtheirstudies,wedevelopedaunit(levelII)thatenablesstudentstogaincreditforsuchactivities.Thisunitalsoincludesactivitiestohelpstudentsidentifyandreflectonworkethic,workplaceskills,communication,teamwork,independentlearningandtemporalchangesinattitudesandexpectationsduringtheexperience.Inadditiontorecognizingandawardingcreditforthevaluableworkexperienceasignificantnumberofourstudentsalreadyengagein,thisunitalsoexpandstheuniversity’sengagementwithindustry.
AchievementsandimpactWenowhavethedatatovalidateourimpressionofWILinourcurrentcourses.Thishasprovidedthebasisforreconstructingsomeofourcourses.WehaveidentifiedbothhiddenandexplicitWIL,haveanunderstandingofthelevelofauthenticityoftheexperienceandwhetheritisscaffoldedandcoversthelearningoutcomesarticulatedinEdwardset.al.(2015).
Throughourdiscussionswithunitco-ordinators,wehavedispelledtheideasthatallWILinvolvesaplacementandthatembeddingWILalwaysrequiresradicalchangefromexistingpractice.Forinstance,justpresentingmaterialwithadifferentemphasiscanmakeWILmoreexplicitinunits.Theinterviewswiththeunitco-ordinators,whileextremelytime-consumingwereworthwhileasitalsogaveusachancetodiscusschangesinmodernpedagogy,learningoutcomesandtheengagementlevelsofthediversestudentcohortwhichwenowteach.Wearereinforcingtheterm‘ScienceProfessional’aswellas‘Scientist’asanoutcomeofourdegreesandencouragingprofessionalbehaviouralcharacteristicsfromfirstyear.
ThesediscussionsalsostimulatedcollaborationbetweentheHealthandSciencesidesoftheschool,resultinginthesharingofknowledgeandpracticalsupportwithplacementadministration.ThedevelopmentoftheWILunitinvolvedcollaborationwiththeCareersservice,resultinginastrongerrelationshipandbetterintegrationofcareersinscience.
WehaveembeddedWILinthemindsofacademicsacrossScience.AsstaffarebeingaskedtoconsiderWILinuniversitydocumentation,theyhaverespondedthattheynowfeeltheyareempoweredtoidentifyandembedWILinaconfidentmanner.TheprojectteamhavebeenaskedforinputintoWILactivitiesoutsideoftheprogramsinScienceandtoworkwithsomeprofessionalaccreditationbodiestoassessmeaningfulWIL.Theprofileoftheteam,withthesupportofexternalfundingandthepowerofgovernmentreportoutcomes,hasmeantthatnowWILhasaveryhighprofileinourschool.
ThroughtheroadshowsaroundtheLighthouseproject,severaluniversitieshavediscussedthemethodstheprojecthasbeenusingtoidentifyWILandtherubric.MosthavecommentedthatourmethodsareanachievablewaytostartinvokingchangeintheattitudeofstafftoWIL.
Asummaryofourrecommendationsfromthisprocessinclude:
• identificationofWILactivitiesmustincludetransferabilityofskillstonon-traditionalsciencecareers• listentostaffandcommunicate–useWILchampionstoshareknowledgeandsupport,andtobuild
profile• embeddingWILdoesnotalwaysrequireradicalchangefromexistingpractice–someWILissimply
‘hidden’,andonlyneedstobedescribedmoreexplicitly• reinforcetheconceptof‘ScienceProfessional’(tobothstaffandstudents)asanoutcomeofascience
degree
EmergingIssuesandnextstepsItisimperativethatstudentsgraduatenotonlywithcoredisciplineknowledge,butalsowithprofessionalskillsandcapabilities.WeareyettoevaluatehowthefirstgroupsofstudentsengageinthenewWILunit,andentryisrestricteduntiltheunithasbeentrialed.Implementationwithdetermine:demandfortheunit;developingappropriateandgenuineassessment,andplacementoftheunitasanalternatecoreunitintheB.Sc.(Advanced)andB.Med.Sc.(Advanced)competingwithtraditionallabbasedresearchprojects.Areasyettobeaddressedinclude:
• definingwhatistheminimumWILthatshouldbeprovidedviacoursesandwhichWILlearningoutcomescouldbedeliveredbyotherareasoftheuniversity(e.g.Careers)
• reviewingWSUdegreestructureswithWILprominentinthesediscussions• creatingWILas‘havingasenseofbelongingtotheprofession’whichencouragesacohortnetwork
amongststudentsandsupportstargetedactivitiesearlier.
RoleoftheWILinScienceprojectTheprojecthashadasignificantimpactonWILinScienceatWSU.Asoutlinedinthisreport,areviewofthe
Page30|WILinScience2015-2016
sciencecoursesisunderway,andwillconsiderWILalongsidedisciplinethresholdlearningoutcomesandgraduateattributes.Asadirectresultofparticipationinthisproject,theDeanandtheuniversityacknowledgetheprojectteamassectorleadersand‘champions’insharingknowledgeandapplicationofWILinscience.
Page31|WILinScience2015-2016
ExploringalternatemodelsforWILinScience:LinkingWorkwithLearningatthe
UniversityofQueenslandDecember2016
ProjectLeaders:Assoc.Prof.SusanRowlandandProfessorPeterAdams
Projectteam:DrDeanneGannaway,MsRobynEvans
Projectsummary
ThisprojectexploredanalternativemodelofWILinScience,linkingstudents’extantworktoexplicitlearningabouttheirskillsasscienceundergraduatesandtheiremployabilityinscienceandnon-science-focusedjobs.Weproposethatstudentsinanytypeofwork(scienceornon-science)aregainingvaluableskillsforemployment;whattheylackistheabilitytorecogniseandarticulatetheseskills.Weaimedtodevelopanacademicallyrigorouscurriculumthat(i)enabledstudentstoevidenceandarticulatetheirdevelopmentandunderstandingofmultipletransferableskillsthatarecommonlygainedduringworkand(ii)helpedstudentsexplicitlylinktheselearnedskillstotheirfuturecareersinscience.Ourpilotprojectusedasmallgroupofstudentvolunteersandanabbreviated“course”toexaminehowourproposedcurriculumwouldworkforSciencestudents.Context
ThisprojectwasconductedintheFacultyofScience(FoS)attheUniversityofQueensland(UQ).UQisalargepublicuniversity,andtheFoSisalargeFaculty,comprisedof7schools.FoScoursesserveover10,000enrolledstudentseachyear,andclassesinfirstandsecondyearScienceprogramsregularlyexceedenrolmentsof500.WILinFoSisdeliveredinafragmentedanduncoordinatedway,championedbyindividualacademics.ThereisnocentralWILofficeorstaffinggroup.Despitestaffkeentoseestudentsandindustryengage,theFoSstrugglestoofferindustryplacementstolargenumbersofstudents,particularlythosewhoarenot“elite”academicperformers.ThispaucityofWILopportunitiesisconsistentwitharecentAustralia-widestudythatshowedtheproportionofsciencestudentswhoengageinWILisverylow[1].Thisprojectaimedtoaddresstheissuesofscaleandvaryingstudentabilitiesandinterestsbyprovidingawayforstudentstogetcoursecreditforpaidworkorvolunteeringthattheyarealreadydoing.Theproportionofourstudentswhocanparticipateinthisprogramissubstantial.In2011,about50%ofAustralianstudentsaged15-24workedparttime,while42%ofstudentsagedover25workedfulltimeastheystudied[2].Studentsoninternationalvisascanworkupto40hoursperfortnightduringsemester[3].UQstudentshaveworkpatternsthatechothesestatistics.Formanystudents,paidworkisafinancialnecessity,whichmaylimittheircapacitytoengageinWILplacements.Formanyothers,itisahealthysocialoutletthatdevelopscorelifeandemploymentskills.Wearguethatanyformofworkislikelytodevelopnon-technical,generic,transferableemployabilityskillssuchasproblemsolving,interpersonalcommunication,professionalismandorganisationalskills.Clearlythisisofvalue–STEMemployersidentifycriticalthinkingandproblem-solvingcapabilityasthemostimportantgraduateattributesfornewhires[4].Cruciallyhowever,workexperiencedoesnotautomaticallyresultinstudentsbeingabletoexplicitlyarticulatetheirlearning[5].Thistypeofmetacognitionrequiresareflectiveprocessthatsupportsatransformationinunderstanding[6].Conversely,teachingemployabilityskillshaslittleeffectonemployabilityunlessastudentisalsoplacedinaworkplace[7].Approachtoimplementation
Inthisprojectwe(i)developedatransformationalcurriculummodel;and(ii)testedandevaluatedaprototypecurriculumpriortoimplementationasaformalcoursein2017.ThiscurriculumdiffersfromconventionalWILexperiencesinthatitrevolvesaroundworkthatastudentisalreadydoing(ormayhavedonerecently).UnlikeWILcurriculacommonlyusedtoraiseawarenessofgainsingenericemployabilityskills,thisprojectaimedtoraisestudents’metacognitiveskillsbyfacilitatingadeeperunderstandingoflearninggainsandexplicitlyforegroundingsciencelearningin
Page32|WILinScience2015-2016
workplacesettings.AsafoundationforthecurriculumtheprojectteamengagedinmuchfriendlyandphilosophicaldiscussiontobuildthefourLearningObjectivesshownbelow;wealsopresentedtheseObjectivestocolleaguesintheFoSforcommentanddiscussion.WenamedtheprogramSCIWILWORKasaplaceholder,untilapropercoursenamecanbedecided.LearningObjectivesforSCIWILWORK
Uponcompletionoftheproposedcourseastudentwillbeableto1. Criticallyreflectonexperiencesintheworkplaceandexplicitlylinkthoseexperiencestopotential
employmentopportunitiesasascience-basedprofessional.2. HaveawarenessofstrengthsandcapabilitiescultivatedinaBScandbeabletoarticulatehow
thoseattributescanbeappliedinaworkplace3. Criticallyreadtheliteraturerelatedtoscienceemployabilityandapplythisknowledgetoa
reflectiononcurrentworkexperience4. Presentalearningportfoliothatchartstheirdevelopmentthroughthecourse,reflectstheirskills
andinterests,andprovidesaplanfortheircareerdevelopmentTheprototypecurriculumtoaddresstheseLearningObjectiveswasbuiltonaseriesoffivefortnightlyeveningmeetings,eachtwohoursinlength.Werecruitedagroupofvolunteerstudentsasparticipantsandofferedcompensationof$100tostudentswhocompletedallaspectsoftheprogram.Studentsweregivenalightdinnerateachworkshopandstudentswhocompleteda“half-time”anda“post-pilot”interviewwiththeresearchteamweregivenanadditional$20foreachcompletedinterview.Ourinitialgroupofrecruitsconsistedof35students;therewassignificantattritionafterthefirstinformationsession(probablybecausestudentsrealisedthecommitmentrequiredtobepartofthepilot).Fifteenstudentsattendedthefirstprogramworkshop,and12studentsfinishedtheprogram.Duringtheworkshopsstudentsdrewontheirextantexperienceofworkanddiscussedsetreadingsofscholarlyliteratureaboutwork-relatedlearning,work-relatedbehaviour,andself-management.Studentsengagedinscaffoldedcriticalanalysesofthesepapers,reflectedonhowthefindingscontributedtotheirunderstandingoftheirworkplace,andconductedself-evaluations.InoneworkshopfiverecentBScgraduatescameandspokewiththestudentsfor90minutesabouttheirpathwaystowork.Academicstaffmembersfacilitatedtheworkshops,anddiscussionsintheclasseswerelively,insightful,andsometimessurprising.Outofsession,studentscompletedaseriesofactivitiesthatincludedpeermentoring,reflectiveexercises,interviewswithourresearchteam,andinterviewswithsciencegraduates.Attheendoftheprogramstudentssubmittedandpresenteda“Meinthree”talkinwhichtheyexplainedwhattheyhadlearnedfromtheproject.Evaluationdatawerecollectedfrommultiplesource,includingstudentandfacilitatorperceptionsofcurriculumeffectivenessandstudentlearninggainsviasurveys,interviews,andexaminationoflearningartefacts(writtenresponsesandtalksgivenbythestudents).Achievementsandimpact
Thisprojectprovidedaplatformfordiscussionanddiscovery,withouracademiccolleaguesexpressingmixedopinionsaboutwhetheritwasanappropriateofferingforSciencestudents.Somecolleagueswereverysupportiveoftheinitiative–theyexpressedtheirconcernaboutstudentsandindicatedthat,intheiropinion,ourdutyofcaretostudentsmeantweshoulddefinitelybeworkingtohelpstudentsbuildtheiremployability.Othercolleaguessawtheinitiativeas“soft”,lackinginrigour,andsuperfluoustoaSciencedegree–theyindicatedthatstudentsshouldnotdothisactivityinafor-creditcoursebecauseitinterferedwiththeirdeepcontentlearninganddisciplinarymastery.IndevelopingthecurriculumforSCIWILWORKwearewalkingthelinebetweenhelpingstudentsdeveloptransactionalemployabilityskillsandhelpingthemdevelopadeepasetoftransformationalunderstandingsaboutthemselvesandtheiridentitiesasscientists.Althoughwesensethatscienceacademicsatouruniversityarewillingtoallowthetransformationalcomponenttobepartofthefor-creditcurriculum,wesuggesttheyarelessenthusiasticaboutthetransactionallearning.Thereisafeelingamongstourcolleaguesthattransactionalskillsshouldbetaughtinco-curricularprograms(e.g.,bystudentservices).Whatwefound,however,isthatmanyoftheactivitiesintheprogramhelpeddevelopboththestudents’transactionalskillsandtheirunderstandingofthetransformationalvalueofascienceeducationandofwork.Additionally,althoughallthestudentshadaccesstoUQstudentservices,
Page33|WILinScience2015-2016
theyhadnotusedthemtoanygreatextent,suggestingthatco-curricularimplementationoftheSCIWILWORKactivitiesislikelytohaveminimaluptakeandimpact.ThisworkhelpedusunderstandthatourstudentsneedhelpunderstandingandarticulatingtheirvalueasSciencegraduatesandtheirplacesinthecontinuumofthesciencecommunity.Onestudentstated,“Scientistsarenotcreative”,whileothersquestionedthevalueofunderstandingthehistoryofone’sdiscipline.Whenaskedtowritedowntheirstrengths,onestudentwasunabletowriteanythingotherthan“knowsscience”,andmanyweresurprisedtofindthattheyhadmultipleskillsandattributestheyhadnotpreviouslyconsideredsaleable.Ourstudentsalsoneedhelpwiththebasicsoffindingwork.Forexample,noneofthestudentsunderstoodthat(i)jobadvertisementshaveexplicitlyarticulatedorimplicitselectioncriteria,and(ii)thesecriteriashouldbeaddressedinanapplication.Theyalsolackedbasicawarenessofhowtoarticulatetheirskillsetstoothersinaninterviewsituation.Clearlytheyneedinstructionandpracticeinthesebasicskills.Verypleasingly,noteverythingwelearnedfromthestudentswasacauseforconcern.Theclassroomdiscussionswerelivelyandfun.Studentswerekeentomeeteachotherandsupporteachotherastheylearnedandprogressed.Astheydescribedtheirweaknessestoeachothertheyofferedtohelpbyteachingskills,actingascriticalfriends,ortakingotherstudentsintosocialsituationsthattheyfoundchallenging.Thestudentswerealsoeloquentandarticulate,oncetheylearnedthattheywererequiredtoprepareforandspeakintheclassroom.Theyhadinterestingopinions,andtheydevelopedthecapacitytoarguewithoneanotherinapositiveandrespectfulway.Theyaskedthatoneoftherulesoftheclassroombe“inthebeginningofeachworkshopwetake5minutesatourtabletogettoknoweachother”.Theyalsoquietlycametoacademicsintheroom,presentedproblemsatwork,andaskedforhelpusingtheirnewlylearnedphrase:“Iwouldvalueyouradvice”.Thefeedbackduringthe“MeinThree”sessionswasextremelypositive.Quotesfromthreestudentsareshownbelow.Meinthreequotesfromthreestudentparticipants
IlearntthatIneedtomarketmyselfnotasastudentbutasafutureprofessional.EngagingwitheveryoneasapotentialpersonthatmayknowsomeonetoemploymehasmademeoptimisticabouthowIcangrowmynetwork.(Student1)
Throughtheprogram,andreallyidentifyingtheskillsIalreadyhadandtheskillsIwaslearninginmySciencedegree,Ihaveactuallyappliedandinterviewedforajob(afterreallyaddressingtheselectioncriteria!!).WithoutcompletingtheSCILWORKprogram,Iwouldnothaveevenconsideredapplyingforthisrole.So,allbeingwell,thisisthedirectionmycareerwilltakefromnow.(Student2–post-script:thestudentdidgetthisjob!)
Themostimpressivesessionformeismentorandmenteeactivity.Asamentor,Ineededtogetmyselfwell-preparedandtriedtolinkthemessagetothedailyactivitiesofthementee.Bydoingso,Icanengageandinteractmorewiththementee.Asamentee,itisagreatopportunityformetolearnfromothers.Duringtheprocess,Ipaidextraattentionandshowedgreatinterest.Ifoundthataskingquestionsisaneffectivewaytointeractwellwiththementor.(Student3)
Ourexperiencesuggeststhereisaneedforatailored,for-creditofferinglikeSCIWILWORKintheBScprogramatUQ.WebelievethatwhatwehavedoneisembeddedbeyondtheprojectandthatitwillcontinuetoevolveasaninitiativethatwillbeofferedtostudentsintheFoS.EmergingIssuesandnextsteps
Wewillcontinuetodevelopthisunitduring2017.ThecurriculumanditsevaluationwillbepresentedtoacademicstaffinFoSandotherengagedstakeholdersforconsultation.Afteranyrequiredamendments,thecurriculumwillbesubmittedin2017forestablishmentasanelectivecourseinFoSdegreeprograms.Ournextchallengeistoembedemployabilityandwork-readinesstrainingintotheBScatUQ.Thereareseveralwaysinwhichwecandothis.Oneoptionistoprovideafull2-creditcoursethatisdedicatedtodevelopingemployability–somethingverysimilartoSCIWILWORK,butinanextendedformwithafullsetofworkshopsandassessmentitems.Anotheroptionistodevelopasetofactivitiesthatcanbefittedintocoursesatvariouslevelsofthedegreetohelpstudentsdeveloptheiremployability.Bothapproaches
Page34|WILinScience2015-2016
havemerit,andbothwillbeexploredin2017throughaUQTeachingFellowshipawardedtoteammemberRowland.TheUQStudentStrategywillalsoprovidefundingforeachFacultytodevelopaWILprogram.OurteamwillworkcloselywiththeFoStohelpdefinehowbesttodevelopandsustainWILforourstudents.WewillbeginbymappingalloftheWILactivitiesthatarecurrentlyofferedintheBSc.References
1. Edwards,D.,K.Perkins,J.Pearce,J,Hong,WorkIntegratedLearninginSTEMinAustralianUniversities.2015,ACER:Melbourne.
2. AustralianBureauofStatistics,Hittingthebooks:Characteristicsofhighereducationstudents.2013,Availablefrom:abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/[email protected]/Lookup/4102.0Main+Features20July+2013
3. AustralianGovernment.Workconditionsforstudentvisaholders.2015.Availablefrom:https://http://www.border.gov.au/Trav/Stud/More/Work-conditions-for-Student-visa-holders.
4. DeloitteAccessEconomics,Australia’sSTEMworkforce:asurveyofemployers.2014,OfficeoftheChiefScientist:Canberra.
5. Knight,P.T.andM.Yorke,EmployabilityandGoodLearninginHigherEducation.TeachinginHigherEducation,2003.8(1):3-16.
6. Cooper,L.,J.Orrell,andM.Bowden,Workintegratedlearning:aguidetoeffectivepractice.Vol.1st.2010,NewYork:Routledge.
7. Mason,G.,G.Williams,andS.Cranmer,Employabilityskillsinitiativesinhighereducation:whateffectsdotheyhaveongraduatelabourmarketoutcomes?EducationEconomics,2009.17(1):1-30.
Page35|WILinScience2015-2016
Developmentofprofessionalskillsinsciencestudentsthroughaworkintegratedlearning
honoursstreamatMonashUniversityJanuary2017
ProjectLeader:DrRowanBrookes
Projectteam:DrChrisThompson,MsLisaHappell,DrTimConnalon
ObjectivesThisprojectaimedtosupporthonoursstudentsinlearninghowtoengageeffectivelywithindustrypartnerstocompleteanindustry-basedgroupproject.Thisinvolvedthedevelopmentofonlineresourcestargetingpriorityareasoflearninganddevelopmentforsciencegraduates,asidentifiedbyemployersandstudentsthemselves.
ContextAtMonashUniversity,WILactivitiesinscienceareprimarilyoperatedthroughtheFacultyofScienceofficeundertheleadershipoftheDean,althoughsomeWILactivitiestakeplacewithinspecificSchools(e.g.Chemistry).TheShortTermIndustryPlacementProgram,anextracurricularprograminwhichstudentsdo80-hourplacementsinindustry,hasbeenrunbytheFacultyforseveralyears.School-basedactivitiesincludeembeddedindustry-alignedpracticals.TosupportWIL,theFacultyalsohasanembeddedCareersConsultant.TheprovisionofWILactivities,includingplacements,projectsandinternships,issupportedbyMonashUniversity’sstrategicplan‘Focus2020’and‘TheMonashBetterTeachingBetterLearningAgenda’fromtheOfficeoftheVice-Provost(LearningandTeaching).
TheFacultyoffersthreeundergraduatesciencecourses–theBachelorofScience,andtwoadvancedBachelorsofScience(Honours)–aResearchprogramandaGlobalChallengesprogram.TheGlobalChallengesprogramwasintroducedin2014,andthehonoursyearofthisdegree,duetorunforthefirsttimein2017,isthefocusofthisLighthouseproject.Thedegreedevelopsskillsinleadership,entrepreneurshipandsciencediplomacyalongwithasciencemajorandhasastrongfocusonbuildingemployabilityskills.Studentsarerequiredtocompletetwointernships(includingatleastoneinternationalinternship),aswellastheWIL-focusedhonoursyear(theWILInnovationChallenge).ThedegreeisoverseenbyaCourseDirector,withinputfromanhonoursyearcoordinatorandadministrativesupporttoassistwithindustryengagement(e.g.contracts)providedbytheFaculty.
ImplementationFortheWILInnovationChallenge,wehavepartneredwithanumberofexternalorganisations,whowilleachprovideanauthenticworkplacechallengeforstudents.Thestudentswillthenworkincross-science-disciplinarygroupstodesigncreativeandfeasiblesolutionsfortheirparticularproblem.Theassessmentisfocusedonhowtheyareworkingtowardsdeliveringprojectoutcomes,withthetraditionalresearchcomponentofhonoursreducedto20percentoftheassessment.
Samplechallenge:Everwonderedwhattheairqualityislikeonyourstreet?Orhownoisythelocalroadis?Accesstolocalenvironmentalinformationiscriticalinhelpingpeopleconnectwiththeirlocalenvironmentandmakeinformedchoicesabouttheirhealthandwellbeing.JointheEnvironmentProtectionAuthorityVictoriatodesign,buildandtestthenextgenerationof‘smartsensors’andassessmenttechniquesformonitoringurbanmicro-environments.
Thestudentswillreceivesupportfromfacultystaff,aswellasinputandmentoringfromtheindustrypartners.Theywillbebasedoncampuswithsitevisitsandmeetingswithindustrypartners.Topreparestudentstoworkeffectivelywiththeirindustrypartner,wedevelopedaseriesofonlinemodules:
‘Gettingtoknowyourpartner’‘Yourskillsintheworkplace’‘Gettingstartedonyourproject’‘Professionaletiquette’
Toensuretheonlinemoduleswouldeffectivelypreparestudentsfortheirprojects,we:
Page36|WILinScience2015-2016
• heldfocussessionswithindustrypartnersandalumniabouttheirneedsrelatingtothestudentsprofessionalskillsandknowledge;
• obtainedfeedbackfromstudentsandtheprojectteamonproposedlearningoutcomes;• engagedwithalumnitofeatureinthevideocontentassubjectmatterexperts.
Themodulesandotherlearningmaterialsweredesignedanddevelopedbyaneducationaldeveloper,theFacultyMoodledesignerandacareersconsultant.Themodulesarehurdlerequirements–studentsarerequiredtocompletethem,buttheyarenotassessed.Weinterviewedtheindustrypartnerstalkingaboutthetypesofskillsandattributestheywantstudentstoexhibit,andhaveincludedpartsoftheseinterviewsasvideosthroughoutthemodules.Themodulesaredesignedtoencouragestudentstoreflectontheirskillsandcapabilities,whattheymightneedtoworkon,andhowtheycanapplytheirknowledgeandskillstotheirprojects.EmergingIssuesandnextstepsThechallengethatremainsfor2017istosuccessfullyimplementtheinauguralhonoursyear.
Someofthebigunknownsinclude:
• Whetherstudentsaresufficientlyequippedwithskillsandknowledgefromtheirdegreetoworkinthismanner.
• Whatapproachestheacademicsupervisors,industrypartnersandhonourscoordinatorsshouldusetoworktogethertosupportthestudents.
• Howthestudentsbestengageacrosstheuniversityandwithindustrypartnerstosupporttheirownlearning.
• Whetherthelearningmaterialsareappropriateforthisdegree.
PendingthesuccessfulimplementationoftheWILInnovationChallengewiththeGlobalChallengescohort,theFacultyaimstoextendthishonoursoptiontoBScstudentsin2018.In2017theFacultyofSciencewillextendtheirWILprogramwithanew‘for-credit’industryplacementunit.Inaddition,anewMastersprogramwithanindustryplacementunitwillalsobelaunched.
WILprogramsareenormouslyrewardingforallpartiesinvolved,butengagementwithindustryrequiressignificanttime,delicatenegotiationsandastrongunderstandingofindustryanduniversityneeds.Thistypeofrole,andtheworkloadassociated,requiresdedicatedandhighlycompetentstaff.AppropriateresourcingoftheseunitsisoneofthebiggestconsiderationsforthesustainabilityofWILintheFaculty.
Page37|WILinScience2015-2016
Scaling-upProfessionalExperiencePrograms:developingaframeworktosupportbroad-
basedWILattheUniversityofTechnology,SydneyJanuary2017
ProjectLeader:ProfessorPeterMeier,UniversityofTechnology,Sydney
Projectteam:DrBlairNield,ProfessorGrahamNicholson,DrDavidvanReyk,MsShimaBaradaranVahdat,MsVikkiBanks
Objectives
Thisprojectfocusedonscaling-upexistingWILactivitieswithintheFacultyofScienceattheUniversityofTechnology,Sydney(UTS)to:
• MakeastepchangeinthelevelofWILactivityandcomprehensivelyembedWILinthecurriculumacrossallSciencedisciplines;
• Createaneffectiveleadershipteamtoensureongoingengagementwithacademicandprofessionalstaff;and
• EnsureprojectsustainabilitythroughthecreationofframeworksandstructuresthatsupporttheongoingimplementationofWIL.
TheaimwastobuilduponexistingprogramsandexperienceswithintheFacultyandembedtheminamoresystematicandsustainableway.Attentionwasequallyfocusedonthedevelopmentofstudentskillsandprofessionalidentity,asitwasonindustry-basedplacementofstudents.Context
TheUniversity’sstrategicplanfocusesprominentlyonthedevelopmentofstudents’professionalidentityandaViceChancellor’sdirectivehasbeenfocusedonthedeliveryofaninternshiporinternship-likeexperienceforallstudents.Thisissupportedthroughcentrally-operatedunitssuchasStudentServicesandtheCareersService.Otherwise,Facultiesareexpectedtodeliveronprogramsdevelopedwithinthecontextoftheirspecificdisciplines.TheFacultyofScienceoffersapproximately40courses,includingsingleanddoubledegreeoptionsacross11sciencedisciplines.WILactivities,includingclinicalorresearchinternships,industryplacements,WIL-basedlearningactivitiesandassessmentsaresporadicallyevidentacrossdifferentprograms.OneoftheprimaryaimsoftheprojectwastosystematisetheseapproachesandensurethatWILwaseffectivelyembeddedandsustainableacrossallprograms.ConsequentlytheprojectwasledfromtheportfoliooftheAssociateDeanTeachingandLearningwiththesupportoftheAssociateDeanInternationalandExternalEngagement.PriortotheestablishmentoftheWILproject,theFacultywasengagedinseveralWIL-focusedactivities,including:
• Afor-creditelectivesubjectCareerManagementforScientists,runjointlybetweentheFacultyandcentralCareerServicesunit,whichfocusesonstudents’abilitytoresearchandunderstandtherequirementsofemployersofsciencegraduatesandtodevelopprofessionalskillsandbehaviours
• Assessmentactivitiesthatfocusonemployabilitye.g.writingjobapplicationsormockinterviews,embeddedwithinseveralsubjects(butnotcomprehensivelywithinthecurriculum)
• Acomprehensive,internshipplacementsprogramforChinesemedicalstudentsincludinginternationalplacements;internalplacements(organisedbyUTSstaff);andexternalplacements(foundandorganisedbythestudents)involvingtrainingandassessmentactivities
• TheProfessionalExperiencePrograminBiomedicalSciencewhichisaFacultysupportedprogramfortheplacementofstudentsintoindustry-basedinternshipsandincludesascreening,trainingandassessmentprogram
• Researchinternshipsubjectsofferedtostudentsonapplicationbutdependentonavailabilityofsuitablesupervisorsandprojects.Thesecanbetakeninternallyorexternally
Page38|WILinScience2015-2016
ThisprojectwasalignedwiththewiderinstitutionalgoalsandcloselyalignedtotheFacultystrategicplan.ProjectplansweresubsequentlyembeddedintoFacultyprocessesandoperationalactivitiesandseniormanagementwithintheFacultyleadtheprojecttoensurethatithadsufficientgravitas.Implementation
TheteamundertookanauditofcurrentWILactivitiesanddevelopedasetofstrategiesrelatingtocurriculumrenewal,scalinganddevelopmentofindividualplacementprograms,andthecreationofadministrativeprocessestostreamlineandsupportinternshipactivities.Whereverpossible,theseactivitieswereintegratedintoexistingFacultyorUniversityinitiatives.Forexample,theFacultyisimplementingtheLearning.Futuresinitiativeaspartofacurriculumrenewalprocesswherebystudent-centredblendedlearningactivitiesareencouraged.SmallprojectfundsweremadeavailabletostaffwhoproposedtodevelopandintegrateWIL-basedactivitiesintotheirsubjects.Inanotherexample,theUniversitymovedtoathree-session,balancedperiodteachingcalendarin2016.Aspartofthisinitiative,theFacultysoughttorestructureitsprogramstoensuretherewasasession(semester)freeblockinprogramstoallowforaminimum12weekinternshipplacement.Thisinitiativewasdrivenbyfeedbackfromhostorganisationsindicatingtheirpreferencetohavestudentsonsiteforablockperiodofuninterruptedtime,whichwouldnotnormallybepossibleifstudentshadtoattendstandardclasses.Thosestudentsnotpartakinginaninternshiporinternationalexchange,orundertakingaparttimeplacementcouldstillenrolinstandardsubjects.Theindividualcomponentsoftheprojectsuchascourserestructure,developmentoftrainingprograms,developmentofvirtualinternshipsetcwereassignedtoacademicchampions.Standardprojectmanagementprocesseswereappliedandwhereverpossible,newprojectswereintegratedwithexistingsystemsandprocesses.Asmallcentralisedadministrativeteamwasestablishedtosupportacademicsintheimplementationoftheprojectandtodealwithenquiriesfromhostorganisationsandstudents.Achievementsandimpact
Therewereseveralmajorimpactsfromthisproject.Foremost,theprojecthelpedtheFacultyfocusitsattentiononWILinastrategicway.ThisallowedtheFacultytoleverageresourcesandensurethatWILwaseffectivelyintegratedintoprograms,rathertreatedasabolt-onactivity.ThisindicatedthebeginningofaculturalshifttowardsunderstandingtheimportanceofWILintegrationinanexplicit,ratherthanimplicitway.Throughthecurriculumrenewalprocessanumberofachievementswererealised:
• AnumberofsubjectswereredesignedtohaveauthenticassessmentsbasedonWILexperienceswhichmovedtheemphasisawayfromcontentandfocusedontheprocessoflearning.Thelearningactivitiesweremappedagainstgraduateattributesandthresholdlearningoutcomesinacumulativewayacrossprograms.Theoutcomeofthemappingisyettobefinalised.ThisprocessclarifiedtheneedforthedevelopmentofagraduateattributethatexplicitlyarticulatesWILandthiswillbeachievedin2017
• Fiftypercentofourcourseswererestructuredtoensurethatfourelectivesubjectscouldbetakenasablockinonesession(semester)tofacilitateexternalplacements.Thishadanindirectbenefitofsupportinginternationalexchange.Theremainingcourseswillberestructuredin2017
• Asuiteofnewsubjectswith6,12,18and24creditpointstructureswerecreatedtoallowfortheflexibilityofstudentstotakepartialorfullsemesterinternshipseitherstandaloneorincombinationwithcoresubjects.ThesenewsubjectshavebeenstandardisedforbroadlearningoutcomesandassessmentandhavereplacedprevioussubjectswhichallowsforamorestreamlinedapproachtotheintegrationofWILactivitiesandlearningoutcomes.
Asignificantdegreeofworkwasundertakentorationaliseprocessesforexternalplacementsincludingissuesaroundinsurance,voluntaryvspaidplacements,academicassessmentbyhostorganisations,workhealthandsafetyrequirementsetc.Aspartofthis,averymodestadministrativesupportstructurewasimplemented.Effectiverelationshipswerealsobuiltwithcentralsupportunitstoensureeffectiveandstreamlinedcommunicationprotocolsforhostorganisationswereimplemented.Thisinvolvedpartnershipsinthedevelopmentofpre-internshippreparationworkshopsandapplicationprocessesforplacements.
Page39|WILinScience2015-2016
Thetablebelowindicatessomeofthesuccessachievedspecificallyinrelationtoprofessionalplacements.Ofparticularinterestisthatmorethan30%ofstudentsfinddirectemploymentsuccessthroughtheirinternshipprograms(excludingtheChinesemedicineprogramwherestudentsmoveintoprivatepracticeaftergraduation).
PlacementProgram–percentageofstudentswhofinddirect
employmentsuccessthroughtheirinternshipprograms
2015
(%)
AsofNov2016
(%)
ProfessionalExperienceforBiomedicalScience 26 52
ResearchInternshipSubjects 67 73
VoluntaryPlacements–notforcredit 51 46
ChineseMedicineClinicalPlacements 60 60
ScienceInternshipProject(new) NA 10
Other(egpaidinternships) NA 2
EmergingIssuesandnextsteps
OneoftheemergingissuesidentifiedwastheneedforcleardefinitionsonwhatconstitutesWILactivity,andwithinthecontextoftheUTSenvironment,adefinitionspecificallyinrelationtowhatconstitutesaninternshiporinternship-likeexperience.Adebateoverthedefinitionsledtoanauditofexplicit(directlylinkedandassessed)animplicit(indirectlylinkedandpossiblyassessed)WILwithintheFaculty.Theoutcomesofthisauditwillbeknownin2017andwillassisttheFacultyinfurtherclarifyingandembeddingWILwithinthecurriculum.TheoutcomesofthisprojectwillresultinthedevelopmentofstrategiesthatfocusonWILskillsdevelopmentandauthenticassessment.ToensuresustainabilityofWIL,theprojectwillbeintegratedfullywiththeFacultycurriculumreviewprocessandtheUniversity’sLearningFuturesinitiative.Amajorchallengeidentifiedthroughtheprojectwastheneedtoprovideinternshipsatscalewithinacompetitivemarket.Itisestimatedthatapproximately1000placementsperyearwouldberequired.ThishaspromptedtheFacultytoadoptnewapproachestointernships,includingrethinkingwhataninternshipmayconstituteandhowplacementsoutsideofthetraditionalscienceworkplacemaybeintegratedintoasciencecourseexperience.TheFacultyisalsofundingthedevelopmentofavirtualinternshipprogramforstudentsacrossFacultieswithintheUniversity.Fundamentaltothesuccessofanyoftheseprogramshoweveristheneedforthecreationofformalleadershipstructuresthatrecognisetheworkandvalueofstaffcontributions.Equally,whiletheFacultyhasinvestedinadministrativesupport,thedegreeofadministrativesupportremainsverysmallbycomparisonwithotherdisciplinessuchasEngineeringorBusiness.ItisclearthatifuniversitieswantWILtosucceedinScienceinasustainablemanner,furtherandongoingresourceswillhavetobefound.IthasalsobecomeclearthattherewillbeanemergingneedforanationalbenchmarkingsystemforWILwhichwouldinvolvethevoluntarysharingofdataandhostingofthesedataonaneutralsitesuchastheACDS.Potentialpointsforcomparisoncouldincludethingslikethenumberofstudentsonplacements,studentandhostorganisationsatisfaction,andemploymentsuccessamongothermetrics.
Page40|WILinScience2015-2016
LearningtoWork,WorkingtoLearn:CurriculumdesignandteachingpracticeforWILin
theNaturalandPhysicalSciencesatDeakinUniversityJanuary2017
ProjectLeader:ProfessorMalcolmCampbell,DeakinUniversityProjectteam:DrAdamCardilini,A/ProfJoColdwell-Neilson,DrSharonLaFontaine,A/ProfStuartPalmer,MsShannonRogers(Intern),MrMarkTolson,DrKarenYoungObjective
ThisLighthouseprojectsetouttobuildthecapacityandcapabilityofkeyfacultyacademicstodesignanddeliveracoordinatedapproachtograduateemployabilitythroughthedevelopmentofscaffoldedcurriculuminitiatives.EmploymentratesforgraduatesfromthedisciplineofNaturalandPhysicalSciencesispoorincomparisontodisciplinessuchasEngineering,InformationTechnology,ArchitectureandBuiltEnvironment,andtonon-STEMdisciplines.ThisisalsotruefortheNaturalandPhysicalSciencesatDeakin.Asaninstitution,Deakinisredevelopingitsgraduateemploymentfocusthroughnewpolicydevelopment,cross-facultystrategygroupsandengagementwithindustryandcorporateorganisations.Thisfocusiswelcomedbutrequiresstudentengagementtooccurthroughcourseanddisciplineinitiativeswithintheexistingcurriculum.TheFacultyofScience,EngineeringandBuiltEnvironment(SEBE)atDeakinhashadalongstandingcurriculuminitiativeforallundergraduatecoursestoprovidestudentswithaWILopportunity.Currently,thesestudentofferingsarenotcoordinated,scaffoldedororganisedtoanylargeextentinwaysthatallowstudentstoevidencegrowthintheirlearningaboutwork,skillsandemployment.Thecurriculuminitiativesareofferedasamixoffacultyanddisciplinebasedunitsandwhilethereiscooperationandsharingbetweenteachingstaff,differencesexistintheunderstandingofacademicsaroundWIL,itspurpose,itsdeliveryapproaches,butmoreimportantlyitsassessment.GiventherangeofcoursesonofferintheNaturalandPhysicalSciencesspace(includingenvironment),theprojectsoughttoprovideresources,exemplarsandworkshopsforcoursedirectorsinordertobuildacoordinatedandbroaderapproachtoemploymentopportunitiesforourstudents.Context
Atthebeginningofthisproject,Deakinwasintheearlystagesofdevelopinganinstitutionalapproachtograduateemployment.Twothemesweredeveloped.Thefirstinvolvedengagingfacultiesinimprovingstudentaccesstocareereducation,linkingstudentstoemployersthrougheventsandotheractivities,andbuildinganon-campus‘freelancing’hub.Thesecondrequiredfacultiestodevelopdiscipline-basedWILcurriculuminitiatives,howeverSEBEwasalreadywelldownthispath.OverthepastfouryearsSEBEhasbeendevelopingWILinitiativesacrossallundergraduatecourses.Throughasmallcohortofdedicatedacademics,arangeof‘professionalpractice’curriculuminitiativeshavebeenintroduced.Thefacultydevelopedthreeimplementationmodelswhichweredevelopedascoreunits:Azero-creditunitwhichintroducesstudentstoWIL;a80-120hrdiscipline-basedplacementunit;oraunitfocusedondevelopingprofessionalpractice(non-placementunit).Eachcoursewouldonlyuseoneoftheseoptions.InadditiontotheseWILopportunities,SEBEalsoofferedInternshipsandIndustry-BasedLearningopportunitiesaselectiveunits.IndevelopingitsWILStrategy,SEBEhasrecruitedanumberofspecialistacademicandprofessionalstafftosupporttheprogram.TwoWILacademicsprovidecurriculumleadershipandsupporttothediscipline-basedprograms.TheseacademicsalsodelivertheelectiveInternshipandIndustry-Basedlearningprogram.Oneprofessionalstaffmemberprovidestheadministrativesupportfortheprogramincludingstudentrecruitmentandthemanagementofindustryscholarships.AmorerecentprofessionalstaffappointmentwasanIndustryEngagementManagerwhodevelopstheindustryrelationshipstosupportourprograms.WithintheSciencedisciplineintheFacultywealsohavetwoacademicswhoteachintotheprofessionalpracticeprogram.Theseacademicshavetakenonthisroleinadditiontotheirdiscipline-basedteaching.Theirroleistooverseetheplacementsundertakenbystudentsandtoprovideassessmenttasksthatevidencestudentlearning.TheSchoolprovidesadministrativesupporttomanageplacementcontracts.
Page41|WILinScience2015-2016
ThisWILstrategyhasbeensuccessfulingettingstudentsintotheworkplacebutinreviewingourWILactivitiesandanecdotalemployerfeedback,anumberofissueswereidentified:
• theprogramsurvivesonstudent-initiatedplacements,butstudentsdonothaveagoodunderstandingoftherangeofpossibleindustriesandemployersthattheycanapproach,leadingtomanystudentswantingtoworkwithalimitedrangeofemployers
• studentswhogooutonplacementsarewellpreparedinsciencebutareoftennotwellpreparedfortheworkplace
• thedevelopmentofworkplaceskillsisnotscaffoldedverywellwithinthecurriculum• WILisnotwellunderstoodbystudentsandtheymisunderstandwhatisrequiredtodemonstrate
learning• WILisnotwellunderstoodbyacademicsandthereforedifferentexplanationsandexpectations
areprojectedtostudents.• therewerenotwellestablishedassessmentstandardsthatallowedacademicstohaveconsistent
approachestolearningandevidencinglearning.TheWILLighthouseProjectwasanexcellentopportunitytoallowtheFacultytoaddresssomeoftheseissuesanddevelopsolutionsthatwillallowtheprogramtodeepenandgrow.Implementation
Thegoalofthisprojectwastoworkwithcoursedirectorstoimprovetheirunderstandingandabilitytoimplementwithincurriculum,arangeofWILopportunitiesthatstudentsvalueandusetofindemployment,eitherwithintheirdisciplineoroutsidetheirchosendiscipline.Clearly,improvedemploymentoutcomesareakeyindicatorofsuccessbuttheseareneverimmediateandareoftenaffectedbyexternalfactors.OtheroutcomesindicatingsuccessincludethewaystudentsapplyknowledgeandskillsafterhavingWILexperiences,theprofessionalismtheydemonstratebeforeoraftergraduation,therangeofindustriesthatareplacingstudents,andthefeedbackthatemployersprovideaboutourstudents.However,akeycriterionforsuccesswillbeincreasingthenumberofacademicswhoareengagedindeliveringWILexperiencestostudents.Westartedwithcoursedirectorsbuttheywillneedtobecomethementorsfortheacademicswhoteachintotheircourses.Aspartofthisproject,theFacultycreatedtheWILSteeringGroup,comprisingtheprojectteamandtheacademicscurrentlyengagedindeliveringWILopportunitiestostudentsintheSciencediscipline.TheSteeringGrouphadtwomaintasks:todefineWILwithinourcontext;andtodevelopanunderstandingofhowwecouldconsistentlyassessstudents.IndeliveringthesetwooutcomesfortheFaculty,theprojectteamconductedthreeworkshopswiththecoursedirectorsofBachelordegreesinBiologicalScience,BiomedicalScience,EnvironmentalScience,ForensicScience,Science,andZoologyandAnimalScience.Allcoursedirectorsattendedatleastoneworkshop.Anumberofcoursedirectorsattendedallthree.TheworkshopsfocusedonidentifyingthecurrentunderstandingofhowcoursedirectorsperceiveWILandhowtheythinkWILshouldbelocatedwithinthecoursecurriculum.TheprojectteamtooktheoutcomesoftheworkshopstoidentifyhowWILshouldbedefined,whatcurriculumactivitiescanbeclassifiedasWILandwhatisnotWIL,andwhatwouldconstituteappropriatescaffoldingactivities.ThisthinkingwascontinuallyreferencedbacktotheCourseDirectorgroup.TheprojectintendedtocompleteaformalsurveyofexistingemployersengagedwithourWILprogram,howeverthiswasnotpossiblewithintheprojecttimeframe.Instead,aninformaldiscussionwithafewemployerswascompletedtocollecttheirperspectivesofWILandtheprogramsweoffer.Achievementsandimpact
TheprojecthasallowedtheFacultytoformallypresentacoherentviewofWILtostaffandstudents.WehavebeenabletodefinewhatWILiswithinourcontextandwhatitisnot.ThemostsignificantpartoftheprojectwasfinallydefiningwhatWILmeanstous:
WorkIntegratedLearning(WIL)describestheintentionallearningactivitiesthatexposestudentstoauthenticandproximalopportunitiestohelpdevelopthetransferableskillsforemployment,furthereducationandactiveparticipationintheircommunity.
Page42|WILinScience2015-2016
WILactivitiesshouldseektoprovidestudentswiththeopportunitytolearnhowtoapplyspecificdisciplineknowledge,skills&practiceintheworkplacesofthefuture.WehaveembeddedWILinthemindsofCourseDirectorsacrossthesciencediscipline.TheyhaverespondedthattheynowfeelempoweredtoidentifyandembedWILinaconfidentmannerandthatthisaspectoftheirworkisimportantinthedevelopmentoftheircourses.Thedevelopmentofacommunityofpracticehasbeenthemostsignificantaspectoftheproject.TheWILSteeringGroupestablishedaspartofthisprojecthasbeenretainedbytheFacultyandexpandedtoincludeeachofthedisciplineswithinSEBE.ThisisagreatachievementandwillleadtofurtherdevelopmentofWILwithinnewcontexts.TheSteeringGrouphasmemberswhoarealsopartoftheDeakin-wideWILinitiativesandsotheideasdevelopedthroughthisprojectwillbegintogainagreateraudienceaswecommunicateouroutcomesmoregenerally.ThecontinuationoftheWILSteeringGroupalsomeansthatwecancontinuetodrivesubtleandthenpivotalchangesthroughgoodpracticeandscholarship.Ithasalsoallowedindividualstoidentifythemselvesasleadersinthisdomainandfeelempoweredtobeinnovativeintheircontextualisedcurriculum,tocreatespaceforcreativityandtrythingsisneededtoallowcurriculumtobeenhanced.TheGrouphavealsodevelopedaFacultyWILFactSheetthatdescribesWILinourcontextandprovidesthelanguageandconceptsaroundwhichwebuildWIL.
MappingofWILinthecurriculumhasbeenafrustratingprocess,inthatitmapsintentionsandnotoutcomes.Regardlessofhowgoodthechosenlanguageandschematicoftheunitcurriculumdescription,oreventhedetailedunpackingofthemeaningsforeachcriterionthroughsystemssuchasrubrics,theinterpretationoftheanalysisofassessmentlevelsandtypestothemappingcriteriawillalwaysinvolveanelementofsubjectivity.OnlywhenwearebetteratevidencingtheoutcomesoflearningwillwebeabletomapWILinthecurriculum.However,wehavecontinuedwiththecurrentprocessofmapping,notbecauseitprovidessomethingusefulinitsownright,butbecauseitisausefulplacetobegintheconversationwithcoursedirectorsaboutwhatinnovationsarepossible.Theoutcomesfromthisprojectshowthatbyincreasingthelevelofauthenticity(howcloselythelearningactivityalignstotaskswithintheworkplace)orproximity(theclosenessofstudentstoexistingpractitioners)ofassessmentitemsallowstudentstohaveanindustry-orientedandrelevantcoursethatwillimprovetheiropportunitiesforemployment,wherevertheychoosetolandupongraduation,andbeyond.Thedifficultyistosituateauthenticandproximalopportunitiesinascaffoldedwaywithinthecurriculum.OneideathattheSteeringGroupwillcontinuetofollowistofocusonauthenticitythatisenhancedthroughproximityratherthanstrivingforboth.Thiswillallowourprogramstobemoresustainableandscalableovertime.TheprojectteamidentifiedanumberofWILopportunitiesthatarenotplacementbased.ThechallengeistoshiftthinkingthatWILisreallyaboutplacementsandplacementsarereallyjustworkexperience.WILisaboutlearningoutcomesandso,afocusonnon-placementWILwillbeapriorityinthefuture.Wehavemadeanumberofobservationsinworkingwithemployers.EmployersliketoengageinplacementWILforanumberofreasons.Thesearewelldocumentedintheliteratureandcentreonaccessingatalentpoolofpotentialemployeeswhobringnewideasintotheworkplaceculture.However,wefoundthatemployersstrugglewithlowreturnoninvestments,particularlywithshort-termplacements,lowtake-upbysomestudentcohorts,cumbersomepaperworkandlongleadtimes.Theseissuesneedtobeaddressedifwearetoimproveplacement-WIL.EmergingIssuesandnextsteps
Wecontinuetostrugglewiththeterm‘WIL’or‘WorkIntegratedLearning’.Itisnotawidespreadtermthatiswellunderstoodbyindustry,studentsoracademics.TheprojectteamthinksthatamoreengaginganduniversallyacceptedtermwouldmaketheconceptofWILmoreattractive.Ourdilemmawasthatwecouldnotfindabetterterm.WeneedtoimprovethecultureofnewstudentstoengagemorefullyinWILandtopreparebetter.Wealsoneedtoimprovethecultureofworkplacestobemoreamenabletotakingonstudentsinplacements.Whilestudentscompletetheseactivitiesforcredit,tofullyengagestudentsneedtobepaidfortheworkthattheydo.Manystudentsneedtoforgotheirpart-timepaidworktotakeupshort
Page43|WILinScience2015-2016
periodsoffull-timeunpaidwork,albeitwithintheirdiscipline.ThisneedstochangeifplacementWIListobemoresuccessful.TheprojectteambelievesthatwehavedevelopedaworkableWILstrategy;workstillneedstobedonewiththemiddleyearsofacourse.WeprovidecareerdevelopmentandWILintroductionsforbeginningstudentsandplacementsoftenoccurwithinthefinalyearofthecourse.Theprojecthasallowedustorecognisethatweneedtofocusmoreonnon-placementWILopportunitiesinthemiddleyear(s).Thiswillallowstudentstoobtainamorevaluableexperiencewhentheydocompleteanextendedplacement.
Page44|WILinScience2015-2016
Appendix5|SummativeevaluationofLighthouseprojectsThepurposeofthisevaluationwastounderstandtheeffectsoftheWILinscience:LeadershipforWILprojectledbytheAustralianCouncilofDeansofScience(ACDS).TheevaluationprocessbeganwiththecommencementoftheWILinScienceprojectandconcludedwiththecompletionofthelighthouseprojects.
EvaluationapproachProjectleadersofthesixWILinScienceLighthouseProjectswereinterviewedtoexploreprojectfocusandimplementation,andprojectapproaches,benefits,challengesandoutcomes.Specificially,interviewssoughttodeterminehowparticipationintheWILinScienceLighthouseProjectshelpedto:
• establishvisibleWILorganisationandleadershipintheinterviewee’sSciencefaculty;• raiseawarenessoftheplaceandimportanceofWILinSciencerelateddisciplines;• influencethedevelopmentandembeddingofWILintocoursedelivery;• influencepersonaloutcomesandoutcomesfortheorganisationasaresultofparticipationin
lighthouseprojects;and• havebroaderimpact/influencebeyondtheorganisation.
Formativeevaluationthroughouttheprojectwasconductedthroughsurveyofnetworkmembers,commentaryfromtheexpertadvisorygroup,andsurveyofworkshopparticipantstoestablishvisibleorganisationandsupportforleadershipinwork-integratedlearning.Theresultsoftheformativeandsummativeevaluationweretriangulatedtocheckforconsistencyofoutcomesreported,andtodevelopanunderstandingoftheimpactoftheWILinScience:LeadershipforWILproject.Notesandobservationspresentedinthisreportarebasedoninterviewsconductedwithprojectleadersoftheselighthouseprojects.Thesediscussionsalsotouchedonmanybroaderaspectsoftheirworkinteachingandlearning.Conversationsduringtheinterviewwerepleasantandfriendlyandtheprojectleaderswereenthusiasticaboutsharingtheoutcomesoftheirteam’swork.Itisimportanttonotethattheprojectleaderswererecognisedchampionsofteachingandlearningintheirhomeinstitution.Theiroverwhelmingenthusiasm,andreportofprojectoutcomesthemselvesareevidenceofsignificanteffectsoftheWILinScience:LeadershipforWILproject.ThereportalsocapturesfurtherareasforworkandopportunitiesidentifiedbytheprojectleadersforimprovingWILinsciencerelateddisciplines.
InterviewthemesCommonthemesemergedfrominterviewees.
1. Focus:interviewsrevealedthatsciencefacultiesattheparticipantuniversitiesinthelighthouseprojectswereatdifferentstagesofconception,developmentandimplementationofwork-integratedlearning.
2. Benefits:averypositivepictureemergedfromprojectleadersabouttheimmediatebenefitsoftheirinvolvementinthelighthouseproject.Benefitsattributedinclude:horizonscanning&collaboration,strengtheningunderstandingofWIL,refiningworkdonesofar,meetingandinfluencinguniversitystrategicprioritiesforWIL,recognition,rewardandopportunityforcareerprogression.
3. Challenges:interviewparticipantsacknowledgedanumberofchallengeswhilenotingtheopportunitiesandtimethatthisprojectprovidedtoreflectonthechallenges.Commonchallengesincluded:
• staffengagement,resourceavailability,competingprioritiesandlackoftime;• culturalchallengessuchaschangingperceptionsofemployersandacademics,andchangesto
academicwork• curriculumchallengestoincludeintentionalindustry-engagedlearning,authenticassessment
andemployabilityskilloutcomes;• identifyingappropriateindustryplacements;
Page45|WILinScience2015-2016
• absenceofleadershipandassociatedlackofsupportandadvocacy• scalingupparticularinitiatives• makingWILasystemicapproach4. WILimplementation:intervieweessuggestedthatthechallengesforWILarethesameacross
disciplinesandsuggestedthekeytosuccessfulWILimplementationistohavecleargoalsandvision,understandtheimpetusforWIL,andstartwithsomethingthatyoucansucceed.
5. ImprovingWILinScience:Althoughnotovertlyexpressed,duringdiscussionitwasclearthatthebiggestchallengethattheprojectleadersfacedwaschangingtheperceptionsofstakeholders.
FindingsDiscussionsrevealedthattheWILinScienceLighthouseProjectswerequitedifferent,yettimelyandprovidedtheopportunityforreviewandreflectiononcurrentpractice.Thecharacteristicdifferencesintheprojectfocus,andthewaytheyweredevelopedandimplementedindicatedvariedlevelsofwork-integratedlearningandapproachestowork-integratedlearninginthehostfacultiesandinstitutions.Theprojectleadersreportedharnessingreneweddiscussionsaroundwhatwork-integratedlearningis,andhowwork-integratedlearningcouldbeimplementedinparticipantinstitutions.Theobviousfocuswasonstudentsandwhatemployabilityskillswereimportantforthemtoachievebeforegraduation.Interviewparticipantsreportedthebenefitsandadvantagesofhavingtheopportunitytopromotetheirwork,talktocolleaguesaboutinitiativesinotherinstitutionsandsharingpracticeandstrategies.Insomecases,theyreportedtherealbenefitwasinchallengingtheirpracticetoevaluateifcurrentstrategiesareeffectiveinachievingthevisionforWIL.SomeparticipantsarereportedpersonalbenefitsasaresultoftheirengagementintheWILinSciencelighthouseprojects.Itappearedthatrecognitionandrewardboostedthemoraleofparticipantsandmotivatedthemtodobetter.Butthemostvaluablebenefitswerenotablefromtheinfluencetheseindividualshavehadwithintheirfacultyandinstitution.However,themostimportantoutcomethatsurfacedfromdiscussionintheinterviewswastheshiftinthinkingorrethinkingthatthelighthouseprojectspromotedwithinparticipantinstitutionsamongvariousstakeholders,includingstudents.Withoutdoubt,theWILinScienceprojecthascontributedtothedevelopmentofleadershipandmentoringactivitiesininstitutions.Statementsofimpactfromtheprojectteams,theircommitmenttowardsWILoutcomesforstudentsandtheirworkinthelighthouseprojectprovideampleconsiderationsforongoingwork.Despitecontextualchallengesfacedbytheprojectteams,participantspointedouttheopportunitiesthesechallengesprovidedandthelearningtheyhaveachievedforthefuture.ProjectleadersalsohadacommonviewintermsofthechallengesinimplementingWIL.TheysuggestedthatthechallengesforWILarethesameacrossdisciplines.ThekeytosuccessfulWILimplementationistohavecleargoalsandvision,understandtheimpetusforWIL,andstartwithsomethingthatyoucansucceed.
ConclusionToconclude,theprojectactivitiesseemveryappropriateandtimelytobuildgraduateemployabilityoutcomeswithinSciencerelateddisciplinesforthereasonstheprojectteamidentify.Thelighthouseprojectsinparticularhaveprovidedtheimpetusforbuildingcapacity,todesignanddeliverWILprogramsthroughcollaborativediscussionsandsharingofstrategiesandpracticethroughthenationalnetworkofScienceWILleadersandpeer-to-peermentoringactivities.TheprojectleadersacknowledgedtheirinstitutionsaswellasthankedtheAustralianCouncilofDeansofScienceforthesupporttheyreceivedtoundertakeactivitiesintheirWILinScienceLighthouseProject.TheynotedthatACDSprovidedanimportantnationalforum,andprovidednationalrecognitionfortheirworkthroughthesupportfortheirprojects,whichinturnledtorecognitionintheirowninstitutions.
Page46|WILinScience2015-2016
Discussionsduringtheinterviewsandtriangulationoftheinterviewdatawiththeprojectaimsandintentions,anddatafromparticipantsurveysconfirmedtheformulationofarenewedcommunityofpracticetoraiseawarenessoftheplaceandimportanceofWILinSciencerelateddisciplines.Theprojectteamscertainlyhavethepotentialandleadershiptoinfluencechange,todevelopandembedWILincorecurriculum,toinfluencework-relatedoutcomesforstudentsandoutcomesfortheorganisation,andhavemuchbroadereffecttomentoringactivitieswithintheirorganisation.ThenextstepsidentifiedbyeachoftheWILprojectteamsarequiterightlythemostimportantnextstepsinmovingWILforwardinScience.Ofcourse,theseinitiativesneedfundingsupportandasetofcommittedleaders.TheWILinScience:LeadershipforWILprojecthasestablishedjustthat.IthankProfessorLizJohnsonforallowingmetheopportunitytoevaluatethisproject.Theopportunityhasbeenaverysatisfyinglearningexperience.ManythanksgotoJenAughtersonforschedulingandorganisinginterviewsandinterviewtranscripts.Ialsothanktheinterviewparticipantsfortheirtime,wordsofwisdomandenthusiasmthattheyshowedthroughouttheinterviewprocess.Dr.SivaKrishnanSeniorLecturer,CourseEnhancementLearningSupportTeam,FacultyofScience,EngineeringandBuiltEnvironmentPODDeakinLearningFutures
Page47|WILinScience2015-2016
References
Bowman,K.(2010).BackgroundpaperfortheAQFCouncilongenericskills.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.aqf.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/Generic-skills-background-paper-FINAL.pdf Bridgstock,R.(2009)."Thegraduateattributeswe’veoverlooked:Enhancinggraduateemployabilitythroughcareermanagementskills."HigherEducationResearch&Development28(1):31-44. Chubb,I.(2014).Science,Technology,EngineeringandMathematics:Australia'sFuture.OfficeoftheChiefScientist.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.chiefscientist.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/STEM_AustraliasFuture_Sept2014_Web.pdf UniversitiesAustralia;AustralianChamberofCommerceandIndustry(ACCI);AustralianIndustryGroup;BusinessCouncilofAustralia(BCA);AustralianCollaborativeEducationNetwork(ACEN)."Nationalstrategyonworkintegratedlearninginuniversityeducation.(2015)."Nationalstrategyonworkintegratedlearninginuniversityeducation."AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://cdn1.acen.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/National-WIL-Strategy-in-university-education-032015.pdf Edwards,D.,etal.(2015)."WorkIntegratedLearninginSTEMinAustralianUniversities."Canberra:OfficeofChiefScientist&AustralianCouncilforEducationalResearch.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.chiefscientist.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/ACER_WIL-in-STEM-in-Australian-Universities_June-2015.pdf Hernández-March,J.,etal.(2009)."Graduates’skillsandhighereducation:Theemployers’perspective."TertiaryEducationandManagement15(1):1-16. Jackson,D.(2010)."Aninternationalprofileofindustry-relevantcompetenciesandskillgapsinmoderngraduates."InternationalJournalofManagementEducation8(3):29-58. Jackson,D.(2015)."Employabilityskilldevelopmentinwork-integratedlearning:Barriersandbestpractice."StudiesinHigherEducation40(2):350-367. Johnson,E.D.,etal.(2012)."Championsorhelpers:leadershipincurriculumreforminscience."JournalofUniversityTeaching&LearningPractice9(3):7. Jones,S.,etal.(2011).Learningandteachingacademicstandardsproject:Sciencelearningandteachingacademicstandardsstatement.Sydney,OfficeforLearningandTeaching,AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.acds-tlcc.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/sites/14/2015/02/altc_standards_SCIENCE_240811_v3_final.pdf Kinash,S.,etal.(2015).Supportinggraduateemployabilityfromgeneralistdisciplinesthroughemployerandprivateinstitutioncollaboration,finalreportpreparedfortheAustralianGovernment,OfficeforLearningandTeaching.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.olt.gov.au/project-supporting-graduate-employability-generalist-disciplines-through-employer-and-private-instit
Matthews,K.E.,etal.(2015)."Socialnetworkperspectivesrevealstrengthofacademicdevelopersasweakties."InternationalJournalforAcademicDevelopment20(3):238-251. Norton,A.(2013)."Abubbleabouttoburst:whywedon’tneedmoremathsandsciencegraduates."TheConversation.fromhttps://theconversation.com/a-bubble-about-to-burst-why-we-dont-need-more-maths-and-science-graduates-15007. Oliver,B.(2015).Assuringgraduatecapabilities.Evidencinglevelsofachievementforgraduateemployability,AustralianLearningandTeachingCouncil.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.olt.gov.au/resource-assuring-graduate-capabilities-evidencing-levels-achievement-graduate-employability-2015
Page48|WILinScience2015-2016
Oliver,B.(2015)."Redefininggraduateemployabilityandwork-integratedlearning:Proposalsforeffectivehighereducationindisruptedeconomies."JournalofTeachingandLearningforGraduateEmployability6(1):56-65. Orrell,J.(2011).Goodpracticereport:Work-integratedlearning.Sydney,Australia,AustralianLearningandTeachingCouncil.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.olt.gov.au/resource-work-integrated-learning-2011 Patrick,C.,etal.(2009).TheWILreport:Anationalscopingstudy.FinalReporttotheAustralianCouncilforTeachingandLearning,ACEN.Sydney,Australia,AustralianCouncilforTeachingandLearning.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.olt.gov.au/resource-wil-work-integrated-learning-griffith-2009 Patrick,C.-j.,etal.(2014)."LeadingWIL:Adistributedleadershipapproachtoenhanceworkintegratedlearning:finalreport2014."OfficeforLearningandTeaching.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.olt.gov.au/resource-leading-wil-distributed-leadership-approach-enhance-work-integrated-learning-2014 Prinsley,R.andK.Baranyai(2015).STEMtrainedandjob-ready,OfficeoftheChiefScientist.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.chiefscientist.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/OPS12-WIL_web.pdf PWC(2015).ASmartMove:Future-proofingAustralia’sworkforcebygrowingskillsinscience,technology,engineeringandmaths(STEM),PriceWaterhouseCoopers.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.pwc.com.au/pdf/a-smart-move-pwc-stem-report-april-2015.pdf Scott,G.,etal.(2008).Learningleadersintimesofchange:AcademicleadershipcapabilitiesforAustralianhighereducation.AustralianCouncilforTeachingandLearning.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.olt.gov.au/resource-academic-leadership-capacities-uws-2008 Sharma,M.,etal.(2014).FosteringInstitutionalandCulturalChangeThroughtheAustralianNetworkofUniversityScienceEducators:‘SaMnet’.OfficeforLearningandTeaching.AccessedJan27,2017fromhttp://www.olt.gov.au/project-fostering-institutional-and-cultural-change-through-australian-network-university-science-ed Smith,M.K.,etal.(2014)."Acampus-widestudyofSTEMcourses:newperspectivesonteachingpracticesandperceptions."CBE-LifeSciencesEducation13(4):624-635. Velasco,M.S.(2012)."Morethanjustgoodgrades:candidates’perceptionsabouttheskillsandattributesemployersseekinnewgraduates."JournalofBusinessEconomicsandManagement13(3):499-517. Yorke,M.(2006)."Employabilityinhighereducation:whatitis–whatitisnot."LearningandEmployabilitySeries1.HigherEducationAcademy,York,viewed27Jan2017,https://www.heacademy.ac.uk/sites/default/files/id116_employability_in_higher_education_336.pdf. Yorke,M.andP.Knight(2006)."Embeddingemployabilityintothecurriculum."HigherEducationAcademy,York.viewed27Jan2017,http://www.heacademy.ac.uk/assets/documents/employability/id460_embedding_employability_into_the_curriculum_338.pdf.