Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Finn Arup Nielsen
Lundbeck Foundation Center for Integrated Molecular Brain Imaging
at
Informatics and Mathematical Modelling
Technical University of Denmark
and
Neurobiology Research Unit
Copenhagen University Hospital Rigshospitalet
December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Wikipedia
Finn Arup Nielsen 1 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
One can read Wikipedia . . .
Finn Arup Nielsen 2 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Randall Munroe, “The Problem with Wikipedia”, XKCD. (cc by-nc/2.5/).
Finn Arup Nielsen 3 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
One can write Wikipedia . . .
Finn Arup Nielsen 4 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
A cartoon by Danish cartoonist couple “Wulffmorgenthaler”
wrongfully claims that the Wikipedia is written by an extremely
dedicated squirrel. This is not the case, and the cartoon is not
reproduced here due to the faulty content.
Wulffmorgenthaler, November 2007.
Finn Arup Nielsen 5 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
One can support statements with references to trusted material . . .
Finn Arup Nielsen 6 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Randall Munroe, “Wikipedia Protester”, XKCD. (cc by-nc/2.5/).
Finn Arup Nielsen 7 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Citations as structured content
The Internet-based collaborative “database”/encyclopedia Wikipedia may
contain structured information, e.g., scientific citations:
{{cite journal|author=Filipek PA, Accardo PJ, Baranek GT ’’et al.’’|title=The screening and diagnosis of autistic spectrum disorders|journal=J Autism Dev Disord |date=1999 |volume=29 |issue=6|pages=439--84|doi=10.1023/A:1021943802493|pmid=10638459}}
Or Proteins:
{{protein|Name=5-hydroxytryptamine (serotonin) receptor 2A|caption= |image= |width= |HGNCid=5293 |Symbol=HTR2A|AltSymbols=HTR2 |EntrezGene=3356 |OMIM=182135 |RefSeq=NM_000621|UniProt=P28223 |PDB= |ECnumber= |Chromosome=13 |Arm=q |Band=14|LocusSupplementaryData=-q21}}
Finn Arup Nielsen 8 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Year of publication of cited journal article
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 20100
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
Year
Num
ber
of c
itatio
ns
Wikipedia output journal citations
Finn Arup Nielsen 9 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Analysis of scientific citations
102
103
104
105
106
107
102
103
Nature
Science
NEJM AstrophysJ
PNAS
Lancet
JAMA
BMJ
JBioChem
A&AIcarus
Cell AmJHumGenet
PhysRevLett AnnInternMed Tissue Antigens
AJ JAmChemSoc Neurology
Blood Pediatrics Australian Systematic Botany
NatGenet MedJAustral JInfectDis Circulation
AmJGastroenterol Contraception Gastroenterology JNutr
ArchInternMed
MNRAS HumImmunol PHOR JNeurosci Gut JAVMA NatMed AnnNeurol NAR AmJMed
JClinMicrobio JMedGenet JCI AmJBot AAC
AnnRevBiochem GRL JCO
JVirol CommACM AFP EHP
JAmAcadDerm BBRC AngewChemIntEd
AustJBot Chest JExpMed
Epilepsia AJTMH FEBSL Chemical Reviews
ArchNeurol Plant Physiology JCellBio
Classical and Quantum Gravity DigDisSci
JCR total citations x impact factor
Wik
iped
ia c
itatio
ns
Scientific citations from Wikipedia
to journals
Comparison against Journal Cita-
tion Reports from Thomson Scien-
tific
The Nature and Science journals are
the most cited from Wikipedia.
The product between total citations
and impact factor showed good cor-
relation with the Wikipedia citation
count (Nielsen, 2007).
Finn Arup Nielsen 10 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
105
106
107
101
102
103
Science Nature
PNAS
Neurology
JNeurosci AnnNeurol NatMed
Biological Psychiatry
Neuroscience Neuroscience Letters
European Journal of Neuroscience Archives of General Psychiatry NeuroImage NeuroReport
JCR total citations x impact factor
Wik
iped
ia c
itatio
ns
Finn Arup Nielsen 11 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
Growth in citations from Wikipedia . . .
2007 20080
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
80000
Year
Out
boun
d ci
tatio
ns fr
om W
ikip
edia
Finn Arup Nielsen 12 December 7, 2007
Scientific citations in Wikipedia
. . . So Wikipedia may not only be source for “human reading”
information but also a source for data that may be subjected to
computer-based analysis . . .
Finn Arup Nielsen 13 December 7, 2007
References
References
Nielsen, F. A. (2007). Scientific citations in wikipedia. First Monday, 12(8).http://www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue12 8/nielsen/.
Finn Arup Nielsen 14 December 7, 2007