22
Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a little transparent patch of cellophane. Of course we would be able to roll the paper in the same way into a little triangle and then unfold. What difference does the hole make? 1

Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a little transparent patch of cellophane. Of course we would be able to roll the paper in the same way into a little triangle and then unfold. What difference does the hole make?

1

Page 2: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

2

P = r0(P)

(rt , ρt)

rt(P) r1(P)

w1 = f(T)

(f0r1-t , ρ1-t)

f(P) = S

T

wt(f, λ )

Images by MIT OpenCourseWare.

Page 3: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Have there been any investigations into linkages that allow for points that can “slide” along edges?

3

Page 4: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

I made a linkage from paper strips to demonstrate how a parallelogram can flip into a contraparallelogram. But, I didn’t understand why this flippage breaks the gadgets.

4

Page 5: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

5

A B

C

D Ex

α

αy

A B

C

D

E

(B)

(A)

A B

C

D

E

(C)

Images by MIT OpenCourseWare.

Page 6: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

This image is in the public domain, and is available through Oxford Journals.

Source: Kempe, A. B. On a General Method of describing Plane Curves of the

nth Degree by Linkwork, 1876.

Created from Cinderella applet by Erik Demaine:

http://courses.csail.mit.edu/6.849/fall10/lectures/

L08_applets/L08_Contraparallelogram.html.

6

Page 7: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Could you go over the fix for the contraparallelogram gadget again?

7

Page 8: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

8

d c

a x b

y (A) (B)

a b

a+b

(C)

a b

ca2+c2 b2+c2

a

(A)

a

ssp

p

d db

(B)

b

r r

q

q

c

c

x

x

Images by MIT OpenCourseWare.

Page 9: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Image of "Cindy" by Jim Loy removed due to copyright restrictions.

9

Page 10: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

“Faster” Arthur Ganson

Courtesy of Arthur Ganson. Used with permission.To view video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJvK47ncVjU. 10

Page 11: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

In the case where 𝒅 = 𝟑 and the output follows a surface …, do we have two degrees of freedom in the linkage (to account for the two-dimensional surface)?

11

Page 12: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Has anyone looked at a Kempe construction for curves not represented by polynomials? In particular, for piecewise-defined curves … say … cubic splines?

The intersection gadget is clear, but what’s the union gadget?

12

Page 13: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

I would definitely be interested in learning more about these axioms. It seems so mind-boggling (at least, from someone used to compass-and-straightedge constructions) that one axiom […] would make the difference between solving fourth-degree and any-degree polynomials.

13

Page 14: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Photographs of drafting compass, straight-edge, and construction demos removed due to copyright restrictions.

14

Page 15: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

HUZITA AXIOMS

HATORI AXIOM

(1) (2) (3)

(4) (5) (6)

15

Image by MIT OpenCourseWare.

Page 16: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

[Abe 1970s]

[Messer 1985]

16

θ θθ/3

a

a/b = 3 2

b

Images by MIT OpenCourseWare.

Page 17: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Courtesy of Robert J. Lang. Used with permission. 17

Page 18: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

Courtesy of Robert J. Lang. Used with permission.18

Page 19: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

[Demaine & Demaine

2000] 19

n

n

(A)

(B)

(C)

(D)Image by MIT OpenCourseWare.

Page 20: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

[Demaine, Demaine, Lubiw 1999]

𝑘-gon 𝑘-hat

20

Page 21: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Truncatedtetrahedron.gif by Cyp

Screencap of animation of rotating truncated tetrahedron removed due to copyright restrictions.

21

Page 22: Why does having a hole in your 2D sheet of a paper pose a ... · 2D sheet of a paper pose a problem to your rolling method? I can imagine a piece of paper having not a hole, but a

MIT OpenCourseWarehttp://ocw.mit.edu

6.849 Geometric Folding Algorithms: Linkages, Origami, PolyhedraFall 2012

For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use, visit: http://ocw.mit.edu/terms.