Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
T I T L E
T Y P E
FIESTA DISTRICT
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS
NOVEMBER 2018
■ Connect Mesa’s Riverview and Fiesta Districts to the existing light rail systemConecta a los Distritos Riverview y Fiesta de Mesa con el sistema existente del tren ligero
■ Connect major activity centers in and around the study areaConecta a los principales centros de actividades dentro y alrededor del área de estudio
■ Support local planning priorities for transportation, land use and economic developmentApoya las prioridades locales de planificación para el transporte, el uso de terrenos y el desarrollo económico
■ Serve educational, employment and public facilities in the Fiesta DistrictServir a las instalaciones educativas, laborales, y públicas en el Distrito Fiesta
■ Provide a high-capacity transportation option for transit-dependent populationsProveer una opción de transporte de alta capacidad a las poblaciones que dependen del transporte público
■ Accommodate projected travel demand within the study areaDar cabida a la demanda proyectada de viajes dentro del área de estudio
PURPOSEPURPOSE
NEEDNECESIDAD
■ A study to evaluate the type of transit and route to meet transportation needsEs un estudio para evaluar el tipo de transporte y las rutas que se requieren para satisfacer las necesidades de transporte
WHAT IS AN ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS STUDY?¿QUÉ ES UN ESTUDIO DE ANÁLISIS DE ALTERNATIVAS?
T I T L E
T Y P E
FIESTA DISTRICT
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS
NOVEMBER 2018
Light RailTranvía Ligero
Bus Rapid Transit
Transporte Rapido de Autobus
StreetcarTranvía Moderno
SpeedVelocidad
HigherMayor
Higher to ModerateMayor a Moderada
ModerateModerada
Traffic LanesCarriles de tránsito
DedicatedExclusivas
Dedicated or shared
Exclusivas o compartidas
Dedicated or shared
Exclusivas o compartidas
Cost to BuildCosto para construirlo
$$$ $ $$
CapacityCapacidad
200 per car200 por unidad
90 per bus90 por autobús
160 per car160 por unidad
Average Cost to Operate*Costo Promedio para operar*
$ $$ $$$
TRANSIT TYPESTIPOS DE TRANSPORTE
Source: Valley Metro; 2018*Average operating cost per rider
Fuente: Valley Metro; 2018 *Costo promedio de operación por pasajero
T I T L E
T Y P E
FIESTA DISTRICT
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS
NOVEMBER 2018
RECOMMENDED TO ADVANCESE RECOMIENDA QUE SE AVANCE
Alternative 2b: Dobson-Extension/Baseline
Alternative 3b: Dobson-Country Club/Baseline*
Alternative 3a: Dobson-Country Club
Alternative 4: Riverview-Downtown**
■ Higher ridership potentialPotencial de alto número de pasajeros
■ Higher number of connections to existing transit routes Número más alto de conexiones con las rutas existentes de transporte masivo
■ More high-density housing and developmentMás vivienda y desarrollo de alta densidad
■ *Connects to the West Mesa Park-and-Ride*Se conecta con el sitio de estacionamiento West Mesa Park-and-Ride
■ **Connects downtown Mesa and Mesa Riverview to the Fiesta District**Conecta al centro de la ciudad de Mesa y a Mesa Riverview con el Distrito Fiesta
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
1 Mile1/2 Mile
LEGEND
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 3aAlternative 3bPotential Station Areas
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
LEGEND
1 Mile1/2 Mile
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 2aAlternative 2bPotential Station Areas
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
1 Mile1/2 Mile
LEGEND
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 3aAlternative 3bPotential Station Areas
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
T I T L E
T Y P E
FIESTA DISTRICT
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS
NOVEMBER 2018
RECOMMENDED TO ELIMINATESE RECOMIENDA QUE SE ELIMINE
Alternative 5: Downtown-Center
■ Does not serve Mesa Riverview and the Dobson CorridorNo provee servicio a Mesa Riverview y al Corredor Dobson
■ Potential right-of-way issues Potencial de problemas con el derecho de paso
Alternative 7: Riverview-Fiesta
■ Lower ridership potentialPotencial de bajo número de pasajeros
■ Does not serve the Dobson CorridorNo provee servicio al Corredor Dobson
■ Inconsistent with the adopted Mesa Transit Plan 2040Inconsistente con el Plan de Transporte de Mesa 2040 que ha sido adoptado
Alternative 6: Downtown-Mesa Dr.
■ Lower ridership potentialPotencial de bajo número de pasajeros
■ Does not serve Mesa Riverview and the Dobson CorridorNo provee servicio a Mesa Riverview y al Corredor Dobson
■ Inconsistent with the adopted Mesa Transit Plan 2040Inconsistente con el Plan de Transporte de Mesa 2040 que ha sido adoptado
Alternatives 8a & 8b: Canal-Country Club/Southern
■ Lower ridership potentialPotencial de bajo número de pasajeros
■ Inconsistent with the adopted Mesa Transit Plan 2040Inconsistente con el Plan de Transporte de Mesa 2040 que ha sido adoptado
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
LEGEND
1 Mile1/2 Mile
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 2aAlternative 2bPotential Station Areas
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
1 Mile1/2 Mile
LEGEND
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 6Potential Station Areas
LEGEND
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 1Potential Station Areas
1 Mile1/2 Mile
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
1 Mile1/2 Mile
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 5Potential Station Areas
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
1 Mile1/2 Mile
LEGEND
Valley Metro Rail/StationGilbert Road ExtensionFDAA Study AreaUPRRCity BoundaryAlternative 7Potential Station Areas
101
60
202
Downtown Mesa
Riverview Park Mesa
Riverview
Sloan Park
Fiesta District
Banner Desert
Medical Center
MesaCommunity
College
Former Fiesta
Mall
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache Blvd Main St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a Sc
hool
Rd
Exte
nsio
n Rd
Ariz
ona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter S
t
Mes
a D
r
Hor
ne
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
Alternative 1: Dobson-Alma School
■ Lower ridership potentialPotencial de bajo número de pasajeros
■ Lower number of connections to existing transit routesBajo número de conexiones con las rutas existentes de transporte masivo
■ Less land area compatible for redevelopmentMenos superficie de terrenos compatible para la reurbanización
Alternative 2a: Dobson-Extension
■ Moderate ridership potentialPotencial de un número moderado de pasajeros
■ Lower number of connections to existing transit routesBajo número de conexiones con las rutas existentes de transporte masivo
■ Less land area compatible for redevelopmentMenos superficie de terrenos compatible para la reurbanización
T I T L E
T Y P E
FIESTA DISTRICT
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS
NOVEMBER 2018
RECOMMENDED ALTERNATIVESALTERNATIVAS RECOMENDADAS
DOWNTOWNMESA
DOBSONBUSINESS
CORRIDOR
FIESTADISTRICT
EVERGREENHISTORICDISTRICT
ROBSONHISTORIC DISTRICT
WEST 2ND ST.HISTORIC DISTRICT
CLARKADDITION
GLENWOOD WILBUR HISTORIC DISTRICT
Hayden Canal
Consolidated Canal
Sloan ParkRiverview Park
Arizona Museumof Natural History
Nile Theater
i. d. e. a.Museum
Mesa Amphitheater
MesaConvention
Center
Phoenix Marriott Mesa
AZ InternationalMarketplace
Banner DesertMedical Center
FormerFiesta Mall
Mesa Riverview
GolflandSunsplash
MesaCity Hall
& CouncilChambers
WhittierElementary
School
EmersonElementary
School
Carson JuniorHigh School
WestwoodHigh School
SequoiaCharterSchool
MesaCommunity
College
RhodesJunior High
School
AdamsElementary
School
Apollo CollegeMesa
RedbirdElementary
School
PowellJunior High
School
DobsonMontessori School
MesaArts Academy
LincolnElementary
School
Crossroads
BurkeBasic
School
Pedro GuerreroElementary
WebsterElementary
School
TAPP
East ValleyInstitute ofTechnology
Mesa Community CollegeDowntown Center
EisenhowerElementary
School
ConcordiaCharter School
EarlyEducation
Center Mesa CenterFor HigherEducation
Queen ofPeaceSchool
Mesa CommunityCollege DowntownCenter /Centenn
Intelli-School Mesa
Career SuccessHigh School - Mesa
HeritageAcademy
BenedictineUniversity
DobsonMontessori School
Calvary Academy
RooseveltElementary School
Tempe Montessori School
The Aces SchoolEast Campus
MesaArts
Center
MesaPublicLibrary
MekongPlaza
MesaArizonaTemple
WashingtonElementary
School
Tempe Cross Cut Canal
Potential Commuter Rail Station
Tempe Canal
CrismonElementary
School
MESA
TEMPE
GILBERT
Mesa Country Club
Fiesta Lakes GC
Kokopelli GC
Kokopelli GC
Fitch Park
EscobedoParkEvergreen Park Washington
Park
Gateway Park
PioneerPark
Kleinman Park
GuerreroRotary Park
DaumierPark
Ehrhardt ParkHeritage Park
WoodglenPark
RanchoDel Mar Park
RIVERVIEWDISTRICT
Rio Salado Pkwy
University Dr
Apache BlvdMain St
Broadway Rd
Southern Ave
Baseline Rd
Guadalupe Rd
Dob
son
Rd
Alm
a S
choo
l Rd
Ext
ensi
on R
d
Ari
zona
Ave
McQ
ueen
Rd
Cou
ntry
Clu
b D
r
Cen
ter
St
Mes
a D
r
1 Mile1/2 Mile
LEGEND/LEYENDA
Valley Metro Rail/StationTren de Valley Metro/Estación
Gilbert Road ExtensionExtensión a Gilbert Road
FDAA Study AreaÁrea de estudio
City BoundaryLímite de la ciudad
RailroadFerrocarril
CanalsCanales
Activity CentersCentros de actividad
EducationalEducativo
Parks & Golf CoursesParques y campos de golf
Historic DistrictsDistritos historicos
New DevelopmentsNuevos desarrollos
Areas of InterestÁreas de interés
Alternative 2bAlternativa 2b
Alternative 3aAlternativa 3a
Alternative 3bAlternativa 3b
Alternative 4Alternativa 4
T I T L E
T Y P E
FIESTA DISTRICT
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS
NOVEMBER 2018
■ Conduct public outreach throughout the processRealizar esfuerzos de participación del público a través del proceso
■ Define a locally preferred alternative (LPA)Definir una alternativa preferida localmente (LPA por sus siglas en inglés)
● RouteRuta
● Transit typeTipo de transporte
● Station locationsUbicación de las estaciones
● Street configurationConfiguración de las calles
■ Conclude with local and regional approvalsConcluir con las aprobaciones locales y regionales
LOCALLY PREFERRED
ALTERNATIVE ADOPTION PROCESSPROCESO DE ADOPCIÓN DE LA ALTERNATIVA PREFERIDA
LOCALMENTE
EVALUATE ALTERNATIVES
EVALUAR LAS ALTERNATIVAS
DEFINE PREFERRED ALTERNATIVE
DEFINIR LA ALTERNATIVA
PREFERIDA
IDENTIFY ALTERNATIVESIDENTIFICAR LAS
ALTERNATIVAS
DEFINE PURPOSE AND NEEDDEFINIR EL PROPÓSITO
Y LA NECESIDAD
SCHEDULEITINERARIO
NEXT STEPSSIGUIENTES PASOS
20192017
WE ARE HEREESTAMOS AQUÍ
T I T L E
T Y P E
FIESTA DISTRICT
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS
NOVEMBER 2018
EVALUATION CRITERIAEVALUATION CRITERIA
■ Ridership PotentialPotencial de Pasajeros
Jobs, population, activity centers and transit connectionsEmpleos, población, centros de actividades y conexiones de transporte masivo
■ Economic Development PotentialPotencial de Desarrollo Económico
Future plans and land usePlanes futuros y uso de terrenos
■ Physical and Engineering ConstraintsRestricciones Físicas y de Ingeniería
Bridge crossings and lack of available right-of-wayCruces de puentes y falta de derecho de paso disponible
■ Transportation NetworkRed de Transporte
Current and future road conditionsCondiciones actuales y futuras de los caminos
■ Potential CostsCostos Potenciales
High-level construction and operation cost comparisonsComparaciones de los costos de construcción y operación de alto nivel
Eleven routes were considered using the following criteria in the preliminary evaluation.Se consideraron once rutas usando los siguientes criterios en la evaluación preliminar.
