What do we need ?

  • Published on
    25-Feb-2016

  • View
    17

  • Download
    5

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

What do we need ?. What do we need. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript

  • What do we need ?

    Sub-Component

    Status

    Can we build it?

    Risk

    Save money?

    Make it easier?

    Cost driver

    (investment )

    Responsible person for the chapter in the report

    Proton Driver

    ok

    yes

    moderate

    yes

    less intensity

    longer bunches

    yes

    Weirren Chou

    Target

    not ok

    no

    high

    power on target

    moderate

    outside expertise

    -SNS ? Tony Gabriel

    S.Childress

    Decay channel + ( rot

    not ok

    may be

    high

    no back off in present design

    yes

    Neuffer

    mini cooling

    (factor of 3)

    (3 m LH2)

    ok

    yes

    low

    no for this design

    less intensity

    no

    Kaplan

    LeBrun

    2nd (-rotation

    (induct) linac

    not ok

    may be

    very high

    only in exchange with low frequ. RF

    moderate

    Holtkamp

    LBNL

    LLNL

    capture

    not ok

    mainly rf problem

    high

    no (a little)

    lower Frequ. rf

    yes

    Neuffer

    cooling

    (factor of 50)

    not ok

    mainly rf problem

    high

    no (a little)

    lower Frequ. rf

    yes

    Kaplan,

    Lebrun,

    1st stage linac

    together with next row (RLAS)

    ok

    yes

    moderate

    no

    moderate

    CEBAF/ Cornell

    Court Bohn

    RLAs

    ok

    yes

    moderate

    no

    yes

    CEBAF

    Cornell

    Court Bohn

    Storage Ring

    ok

    yes

    moderate

    no

    compromise flux

    yes

    Finley,

    Diagnostic

    not ok

    moderate

    no

    no

    ?

    Summary of the people

    comment

    editor

    High power RF systems

    Holtkamp

    Moretti

    Reid

    Wildman

    Champion

    + rf suport

    70 %

    50 %

    50 %

    200 %

    Target

    only with Oak Ridge on board

    Childress

    S. Childress

    + target support

    50 %

    100 %

    Safety

    Finley

    Andrews M.

    Coulson

    10 %

    25 %

    FESS

    CIVIL Eng.

    Finley

    Sims

    Laughton

    + drawing support

    30 %

    30 %

    100 %

    Magnets storage ring & RLA arcs

    Technical Div.

    + ??

    100 %

    Power supplies

    Wolff

    EE/Wolff

    + support

    60 %

    50 %

    Power/cooling

    General Facilities

    Ersatz fuer Czarapata ?

    Czarapata

    +support

    35 %

    50 %

    Cryogenics

    Theilacker

    Theilacker

    + ???

    80 %

    Solenoids

    Alvin ?

    IHEP Protvino

    ??

    Accelerating Cavities

    H. Edwards

    25 %

    Beam Physics

    -polarization

    -Acceleration

    -magnets

    -targetry

    -beamlines

    if we have it

    Syphers

    Bohn

    Ostiguy

    Mokhov +

    Drohzdin

    Johnstone, J.

    10 %

    50 %

    35 %

    35 %

    25 %

    50 %

    Diagnostics

    Popovic

    Nezrick

  • What do we need

    Summary of the people

    comment

    editor

    High power RF systems

    ????

    Reid

    Wildman

    + rf suport

    Target

    only with Oak Ridge on board

    Childress

    S. Childress

    + target support

    Safety

    Finley

    Coulson

    FESS

    CIVIL Eng.

    Finley

    Sims

    Laughton

    + drawing support

    Magnets storage ring & RLA arcs

    induction linacs

    ????

    ???

    Holtkamp

    Technical Div.

    + ??

    Power supplies

    Wolff

    EE/Wolff

    + support

    Power/cooling

    General Facilities

    Plant

    support

    Duane Plant

    Cryogenics

    Theilacker

    Theilacker

    + ???

    Solenoids

    Tollestrup

    IHEP Protvino Tech Division

    Accelerating Cavities

    H. Edwards

    25 %

    Beam Physics

    -polarization

    -Acceleration

    -magnets

    -targetry

    -beamlines

    if we have it

    Syphers

    Bohn

    Ostiguy

    Mokhov +

    Drohzdin

    Johnstone, J.

    10 %

    50 %

    35 %

    35 %

    25 %

    50 %

    Diagnostics

    Popovic

    Nezrick