WEKIT Mid-term review mee1ng WEKIT WP1 WEKIT …dspace.ou.nl/bitstream/1820/8833/1/WEKIT_WP1_1st_re… · · 2017-12-13T1.1 Training Industry Assessment [OUNL] T1.2 Technology Industry

WEKITMid-termreviewmee1ng

Luxemburg|July4-5,2017

WEKITWP1WEKITFrameworkandIndustrialLearningMethodology RolandKlemke,BibegLimbuOpenUniversityoftheNetherlands(OUNL)

04/07/2017 WEARABLEEXPERIENCEFORKNOWLEDGE-INTENSIVETRAINING 1

Contentofpresenta1on GeneralInforma1on

 Objec1veofWP1

 Statusoftasks WEKITSurveys

 WEKITFrameworkandTrainingMethodology

 WEKITUseCases

 Conclusion

 Futuresteps


6M 12M 15M 3M

now

M7:!D1.1/1.2 needs D1.3 framework v1 D1.4 requirements v1

M20:!D1.5 framework v2

WP1 DURATION 1 36

M36:"D1.8 requirements final

M21:"D1.6 requirements v2

✓ ✓

PLANNED RESOURCES =42 PM

GENERAL INFO (WP1)

✓

✓ M35:!D1.7 framework final

T1.1 / T1.2 end


Objec1vesofWP1Todevelopaframeworkforwearableexperience.TospecifyacorrespondingmethodologyforKnowledge-Intensive/Voca=onalTraining.Tocreateexampleusecasesandscenarios.ToderiverequirementsforthetechnologicalplaAorm


T1.1TrainingIndustryAssessment[OUNL]T1.2TechnologyIndustryAssessment[VTT](TechnologicalGrounding)Taskobjec=ves:surveyingARindustry&trainingprac1ce;ResultsreportedinjointdelivarableD1.1&D1.2.

Progresstowardsobjec=ves:Tasksfulfilledtheirobjec1ves.SurveypartsofT1.1&T1.2combined.

Results:highinterest,highexpecta1ons,highlevelofacceptanceinaugmentedreality(AR)andwearabletechnologies(WT)foreduca1onalpurposesconfirmed.ExperiencewithAR&WTiss1llsparse.Challenge:provideaddedvalueAR/WTsolu1ons.

Devia=ons,correc=veac=ons:-

Nextsteps:Tasks1.1&1.2arenotac1veanymore.


T1.3Research&DevelopingWEKITFrameworkandTrainingMethodology[OUNL]Taskobjec=ves:frameworkforwearableexperience;methodologyforKnowledge-Intensive/Voca1onalTraining.

Progresstowardsobjec=ves:firstitera1oncompletedaccordingtoobjec1ves;resultsreportedinD1.3.

Results:literaturestudyinexper1sedevelopment;frameworkspecifyingtasktypesandtransfermechanismsspecified.

Methodologyspecifyingacributesoftasks,domains,anddimensions,accordingtowhichtheframeworksextensibilityisdesigned.


Nextsteps:Theframeworkandmethodologywillbeupdatedbasedonfeedbackfromfirstroundofpilotevalua1ons(WP6)


T1.4RequirementsforScenariosandTechnologicalplaAorm[RWTH]Taskobjec=ves:setupanagilemethodologyforrequirementscollec1onandrefinementusingtheRequirementsBazaar,anin-housedevelopedWeb-basedcon1nuousinnova1onplagorm.

Progresstowardsobjec=ves:RequirementsBazaarpreparedandintegratedintoWEKITcommunitywebsite.ImprovedRequirementsBazaar(dashboard;usability).

Results:StakeholdersinvolvedthroughtheWEKITcommunity;10categoriesfilledwith83requirements,42commentsand96votes.WithinRequirementsBazaar,theWEKIT.ONEprojectranksinthetoptenofover100availableprojects.


Nextsteps:WeaimtoembedRequirementsBazaarintheprac1ceofourstakeholders,tomakeiteasytosubmitanddiscussrequirements.


WEKITSurveysTRAINING/TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRY ASSESSMENT

804/07/2017 WEARABLEEXPERIENCEFORKNOWLEDGE-INTENSIVETRAINING

IndustryAssessmentMethods(T1.1/T1.2)Surveys• Firstsurveyforexpertsinthefield• Secondques1onnaire(re-designedakerinternalitemevalua1on)distributedpubliclytogatherinputfromaddi1onalpar1cipants

Interviews• Personal/companyinforma1on• CurrentuseofAR• Educa1onalneeds• ARtechnologyreadiness• Technologyacceptance–performanceexpectancy• Usecase


Insightsgained:IndustryNeedsInsightI1:AR/WTexpectedtoshortenprocessesandtofacilitateac/vi/es

InsightI2:AR/WTexpectedtofacilitatefastertaskcomple1on,reduc1onoferrors,increaseofprecisionanddecisionmaking

InsightI3:Appropriatetechnologyismoreimportantthanprice


Insightsgained:UserNeedsInsightU1:Increasingmarketpoten1al,butpioneersneedtobeconvincedwithstrongbusinesscase.

InsightU2:Marketpush:TogetAR/WTsolu1onsintoproduc1veuse,mo1vatebenefitandaddedvalue,strengthenacceptanceandaddressbarriers

InsightU3:WeraisedinterestfortheWEKITcommunityandcouldshow,thatWEKITisaddressingrelevanttopics.

InsightU4:Thewholeprocessofguidingandinstruc1ngthelearnershouldberethought

InsightU5:TheARsystemcouldbemorecomplexandlessmaturefromuserexperienceviewpointwhencapturingtheexpert’sperformance

InsightU6:Applica1ondesigninthegrass-rootlevelisimportant:thesystemmustbedesirablefromtheviewpointoftherealend-user

InsightU7:star1ngpoint:ARsystemgivesmoregeneralframeworkandguidelinesfortaskperformance


Insightsgained:TechnologyNeedsInsightT1:showandvisualizethingsthatcannotbeshowninnormaltrainingsitua1on

InsightT2:displayandvisualiza1onoflearningcontentshouldadaptto:levelofexper1seandpersonality.

InsightT3:Theuserinterfaceshouldbeadaptable

InsightT4:emerginginteroperabilitystandardsforAR/WTsuchasARLEMwillbeofincreasingimportance

àVendorsofAR/WTsolu1onsneedtoagreeoninteroperabilitystandardsandcontentexchangestandards

InsightT5:wearabledevicesbecomecheaperandcurrenttechnologicalconstraintsarebecominglessofabarrier

àAR/WTsolu1onsneedtosupportvariousplagormsinordertobesuccessful(smartphones,tablets,andsmartglasses)


WEKITFrameworkBACKGROUND


Background:Exper1seExper1seandExpertperformance• SuperiorMentalKnowledge• Highperceptualabili=es• Extensiveanaly=calskills• Elaboratedecision-takingstrategies

• Balancedcogni=veeffort

Shortcomingsofexperts• Domainlimited• Failuretorecallsurfacefeatures

• Inaccuratepredic=on,judgement,andadvice

• Inflexibilityandbias


Background:LearningTheory4C/ID(fourcomponentsinstruc1onaldesign)modelsupportsexper1sedevelopmentbyrepresen1ngcomplexlearningwithfourcomponents(Neelen&Kirschner,2016;VanMerriënboer&Kester,2014)


WEKITFrameworkINDUSTRY-FOCUSED LEARNING METHODOLOGY


WEKITIndustrialLearningMethodologyThreemajorphasesbasedonasytema1capproach:• Phase1:capturingexpertexperience

• Phase2:wearingexpertexperiencebytrainees

• Phase3:analysisandreflec1on

Asinglecapturedexpertexperiencecanbere-purposedformul1pletrainingandevalua1onsessions

 Systema=capproach:• overalltaskandobjec1vebrokendownintosubgoals

• subgoalisanisolated(modular)taskwithskillsandprerequisiteknowledge

• designofthelearningtasks• Challenge:breakingdownexper1seinacomplextaskdomainisnotsimple,exper1semaybeonlyrelevantatcertaincomplexitylevel

04/07/2017 17WEARABLEEXPERIENCEFORKNOWLEDGE-INTENSIVETRAINING

WEKITFrameworkTasksDescrip=on

Condi=onsofMastery

LearningDifficul=es

TeachingMethodologies

Suppor=ngAR&WTTransferMechanism

Example:High-precisiontask:allowsonlylimiteddevia1on

Condi=onsofMastery:staybelowdevia1ontolerance

LearningDifficul=es:precisionop1callyhardtotrace.

TeachingMethodologies:explana1on,simplifica1on,instruc1on,reflec1on

Suppor=ngAR&WTTransferMechanism:zoom,objectenrichment,thinkaloud


WEKITFrameworkTransferMechanismsDescrip=on

Requirementsforrecording

Requirementsforreplayorenactment

Example:Thinkaloudprotocol.Sensorrecordingofexpertac1onscombinedwithaudiocomment

Requirementsforrecording:Expertstartstheac1on;requiresmo1onsensorsandmicrophone;synchronisessensorsandaudio

Requirementsforreplayorenactment:Shouldbeenabledintherightsitua1on;requiresaudiooutputandvisualdisplayofsensordata;learnermayinterruptthereplay


WEKITFrameworkTaskxTransferMechanisms

20

ReferencesTask

TransferMechanisms Perceptualability

HighMemory

Collabora1veability

Decissionmaking

Highspeed Motorperformance

Highprecision

Interac1vevirtualobjects

Seichter,H.,(2004)

Nilssonetal(2011)

LahanasVet.al.(2014)

Quarleset.al.(2008)a

Rhienmoraetal.(2010)

Evansetal.(2014)

Hap1cfeedback Rozenblitetal.(2014)

LahanasVet.al.(2014)

Matassa&Morreale(2016)

Khademietal.(2012)

HighlightobjectofInterest

Roadset.al(2016)

Hahnetal.(2015)

Kotranzaetal.(2009)

DirectedFocusJarodzkaetal.(2013)Henderson&Fernier(2011)

Bioccaetal.(2006)

WEARABLEEXPERIENCEFORKNOWLEDGE-INTENSIVETRAINING04/07/2017

21WEARABLEEXPERIENCEFORKNOWLEDGE-INTENSIVETRAINING04/07/2017

WEKITUsecases


Method


DerivedUseCases(Selec1on)1.  Wetrehearsal

2.  Assessment

3.  ExperienceRecording

4.  HealthLearning

5.  IndoorNaviga/on

6.  Maintenance

7.  QualityInspec/on

8.  RemoteTutoring

9.  ResumeService

10. RetailTraining

11.  SafetyandWellbeing

12.  SmartLigh/ng

13.  Spa/alCoordina/on

14.  TangibleLearningObjects15. WorkShadowing


RequirementsBazaarhcps://requirements-bazaar.org


WEKITCommunityhcps://wekit-community.org/ideas


RequirementsBazaarRequirementsBazaarisasocialcon=nuousinnova=onplaAorm.

Itallowscommuni1estoexpress,discussandpriori1zetheirrequirementsandtracetheirrealiza1on.

OriginallydevelopedwithintheEUFP7ROLEproject,itisnowwidelyusedbyseveralEuropeanresearchprojectsandbeyond.

Ongoingwork• Embracingdesigners• Gamifica1on• EmbeddingintoARprac1ces

27

Conclusions


ConclusionsFirstversionofFramework,RequirementsandScenariosrealizedSpecifica1onsandimplementa1onforWEKIT.ONEprototype(hardware,recorderandplayer)basedonFrameworkFirstroundofimplementa1onsofFramework&ScenariosinWP2-WP5doneFeedbackduringfirstpilottestsindicaterelevanceofframeworkapproachandmethodologyImprovementsdueinsecondphaseoftheproject(details,moretransfermechanisms)


Futureplan Task1.3.-Theframeworkandmethodologywillbeupdatedbasedonfeedbackfromfirstroundofpilotevalua1ons(WP6)

  Feedbackfromtrials(usability,func1onality,expecta1ons)

  Levelofdetail&furthertransfermechanisms

  Reviewoftaskmodel

 Task1.4.-embedRequirementsBazaarintheprac1ceofstakeholders,simplifysubmissionanddiscussionofrequirementsè1ghterintegra1onofcommunityportal(inputofideas),requirementsbazaar(discussion&ra1ng),anddevelopmentprocess(issuetracker)(seealsoWP7)


D i s c l a i m e r T h i s p r o j e c t h a s r e c e i v e d f u n d i n g f r o m t h e E u r o p e a n U n i o n ’s H o r i z o n 2 0 2 0 r e s e a r c h a n d i n n o v a t i o n p r o g r a m m e u n d e r g r a n t a g r e e m e n t N o 6 8 7 6 6 9 . h t t p : / / w e k i t . e u /

WEKITMid-termreviewmee1ng

Luxemburg|July4-5,2017

Q&AProf.Dr.RolandKlemkeResearcher Technology-Enhanced Learning Innova7ons (TELI) Welten Ins7tute, Open University of the Netherlands [email protected]


Documents

WEKIT Mid-term review mee1ng WEKIT WP1 WEKIT …dspace.ou.nl/bitstream/1820/8833/1/WEKIT_WP1_1st_re… · · 2017-12-13T1.1 Training Industry Assessment [OUNL] T1.2 Technology Industry