Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
BSc Hons Information Technology and
Business Information SystemsBIS3324
Strategic Management and Information Systems Group Project
Private and Confidential
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
2 of 41
Information System in
Traditional Chinese Herbal Tea Industry
Private and Confidential
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Team No. 2
Student Name Student No.
Leader Name: Raymond M00501669
Team Member’s Name: Alan M00501672
Jemy M00501665
Samuel M00501664
3 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Table of Contents
1. Project Objectives...................................................................6
2. Company background...........................................................7
3. Methodology.............................................................................9
4. Analysis the Strategic Environment................................10
5. Newly Implemented I.T. Systems......................................18
6. Description of strategic IT system(s) to be used.........20Instant Order@E-coupon..............................................................................................20Smart E-order............................................................................................................... 21
Strategic Management View on New I.T.Systems.............21
Implementation of I.T. System (Physical View)..................22
Implementation of I.T. System (Logical View)....................22
7. Information Requirement....................................................23
8. Cost and Benefit Analysis..................................................25
9. Management Inspirations of Information Management........................................................................................................26
Business Case Studies...................................................................................................26i) Restaurant Industry................................................................................................26ii) YAMATOYA Chef Restaurant............................................................................27
10. Conclusion............................................................................28
11. Self-Evaluation / Reflection..............................................29
12. Reference..............................................................................30Major Milestones..........................................................................................................31Interview Letter for Hung Fook Tung Executive Director............................................32Interview Dialog...........................................................................................................33Consumer Survey Result Summary Report...................................................................37Study Plan.....................................................................................................................38Minutes.........................................................................................................................39
4 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
1. Project Objectives
Nowadays, business decision makers should adopt progressive way to overcome the
business competition, understanding customer favors and keep customers’ loyalty is the
important mission. Meanwhile, reducing the business cost is another significant key to
make the business win and success. Therefore, business operation models have to
integrate with appropriate Information System (I.S.) in competitive business environment
so that the company will be able to increase market share.
Strategy Information System (I.S.) is defined as crucial system that helps company
or organization improves their business model strategy and organizational operations. It is
used to stimulate the reaction time to company environmental changes such as CRM,
POS, ERP system …etc. They help in production low cost quality products. Information
systems have traditionally been considered primarily in terms of their effects on
individual organizations. (Blake and Gerard THE INFORMATION SYSTEM AS A
COMPETITIVE WEAPON, page 1)
The objective of our investigation will focus on local traditional herbal tea company
“Hung Fook Tong Holding Ltd”. Based on our observations and interviews to the
company, our project team had explored significant findings from this company. These
findings included the company’s strategic approaches; this led the understanding
outcomes from the information in the strategic environment that was believed to be
significant to strategic manager.
5 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
2. Company background
Hung Fook Tong Holding Ltd.’ (refer to ‘Hung Fook Tong’ thereafter) is a famous
local Chinese Herbal Tea manufacturer. With its biggest selling network covered with
multiples store areas, the company dominant Hong Kong retails market in selling
traditional herbal tea. Hung Fook Tong is the biggest herbal tea group in Hong Kong and
their Holdings started in 1980s. They have more than 700 staff members, 70 herbal tea
houses and self-invested factories in Hong Kong, a sales network with extensive coverage
in Hong Kong and overseas. The main products of Hung Fook Tong are Bottled Herbal
Beverage Series, Home-made Herbal Jelly Series and Home-made Soup Series. The
Group has become one of the largest herbal tea enterprises in Hong Kong with over 80
retail points, a central kitchen for producing freshly-made health products, a factory for
bottled herbal tea drinks. Hung Fook Tong also operates the first herbal chain store
"Health Express" in MTR stations. In 2007, it launched a new concept store "Herbal Tea
& Soup Square" to provide herbal tea drink and soup, and also set up its first herbal tea
outlet in Shenzhen. In 2008, Hung Fook Tong has further enhanced its "feel-like-home"
concept by the grand opening of "HFT Mall Square" in Paradise Mall. It is a 1,000 square
feet concept store conveying leisure, culture, arts, healthy diet and life style which brings
people a comfortable and healthy home.
In 2002, Hung Fook Tong was awarded "Hong Kong Top Brand" and "Superbrands".
According to Nielsen, Hung Fook Tong was ranked the first in terms of sales volume and
sales value in the wellness drink market for six consecutive years from 2003 to 2008. And
it has been certified by the "Hong Kong Q-Mark Service Scheme" and "Quality Tourism
Services Scheme" since 2004 and 2005 respectively. Besides, Hung Fook Tong has been
awarded "Caring Company" for 3 consecutive years since 2006. In 2007, it became the
6 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
first herbal tea brand in the region of Hong Kong and Macau to receive the honour of
"National Intangible Cultural Heritage" certification by the State Council of China. In
2008, Hung Fook Tong was awarded "2008 The Best Brand Enterprise Award (Greater
China)".
Based on the business annual return, it indicated that the current market status is
growing upwards. And, this company understands their selling networks are the biggest
and robust within the same industry in nowadays market. However, ‘Hung Fook Tong’ is
market sensitive so that the company invited our project team to conduct market strategy
review.
With rapid growth of market competitions in the industry, the research studies in this
project is to analyzes the possible ways to integrate new system to ‘Hung Fook Tong’ to
enhance its existing I.T. systems. Hence, the new installable system will be delivered to
strengthen its customer relationship management in order to secure the future market
shares.
Business Model – Hung Fook Tong
7 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
3. Methodology
In order to overcome the business competition, the company understood the
customer favors and let them appreciate the products. Another significant key was to
reduce the business cost for maximization of business’s market share. In order to
accomplish our object, we take an advantage to interview with company staff and street
customer survey to obtain useful results. With the references of I.T. Department’s
interview, customers’ survey, collections of company’s information; these are the
methodologies used to find out how the strategic manager could utilize for ongoing
market strategy. In addition, the results of findings could indicate whether information
system is a crucial adaptive approach to enhance the business strategy.
The methodologies listed below were being processed:
i) Interview with I.T. Department;
ii) Consumer Survey
Consumer Survey for Hong Fook Tong membership members
Street Level Survey
Interview with I . T . Department
Regarding the information gathering purposes, we request 4 days on-site workshop
with company’s Information Technology department to understand their company’s
operation.
Consumer Survey
This survey was designed by the google surveys web tools in generating the actual
questionnaires and distribute the consumer survey to all Hung Fook Tong members’
8 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
contact email. Meanwhile the survey will also publish on some Hong Kong popular
Internet discuss forum for any visitors fill up and return the feedback. On the other hand,
some survey forms will distribute on the streets in Hong Kong that obtains the useful
results.
4. Analysis the Strategic Environment
This project is to explore the business model adopted by a Chinese Traditional
Herbal Tea Manufacturer ‘Hung Fook Tong Holding Ltd’ in Hong Kong. ‘Porter Five
Force’ is the analytical tool to be used in analysis of current business environment with
this company. As such, crucial information revealed from the results of findings could
bring out the situation signals to this company. The analytical results also reflect the
company status in current business environment.
Porter Five Force
We are using the analysis tools “Porter Five Force” to analysis this industry’s
current situation in market status, analysis the company’s products in market share, the
company competitors and the degree of customers’ loyalty. By adopting ‘Porter Five
Forces’ analytical methods, the company’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and
threats can be revealed from its results of findings, for more detailed analytical results will
be described in next session.
Interview with Executive Director
In order to effectively recognize the role of strategic manager, we invited the
company strategic manager Dr Ricky Szeto (also known as Executive Director of Hung
Fook Tong Holdings Limited since 1999) to attend an interview session. Through the
interview with the company’s Executive Director “Mr Ricky Szeto” who is willing to
9 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
provide useful and important information, we would discuss the company’s business
strategy plan and cost benefit for coming five years.
Within the 20 minutes, he shared some information about the company vision and
their business strategy from Ricky Szeto. Moreover, he also introduced two innovative
projects which involved IT technology namely, “Instant Order@ e-coupon” and “Smart e-
order”.
Questions were prepared for this interview and mainly focused on the company
vision and currently used business strategy. More important, we tried to find out what
newly implemented projects involved with I.T. technology that can helps to achieve their
business goal and mission.
According the conversation from Ricky, he was very confident on business forecast
in terms of business benefit and he is looking forward to implementing similar project to
enhance the market share in the nearest future. After the interview session, we have
gathered and have consolidated all information to generate comprehensive analytical
results from two IT systems and such concrete results will show in the coming
paragraphs.
** Interview letter and dialog are enclosed on “Appendix III”
Recognition on Consumer Needs
We distributed the survey start from March 2014 in two weeks. A total 808 returned
survey were collected from Hung Fook Tong members, via google consumer survey and
on street collection points.
The questionnaire was designed by the project team and the aims was tried to
understand the customers’ choices in relation to traditional herbal tea product. The results
10 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
of findings aim at understanding the effective rates on using e-coupon promotion linking
to traditional herbal tea products. Thus, five survey questions were developed for this
purpose, all questions except question 3 the respondents just select their own answer by 1
to 5 stars (on a 5-point scale):
i) 1 is strongly disagree;
ii) 2 = disagree;
iii) 3 = no sure;
iv) 4=agree;
v) 5 = strongly agree
In question 3, the respondents require to show the number from their last
experience. After collecting all survey data, we divided into four ranges’ group based on
the survey results. The group sets are: (group 1 = [0], group 2 = [1 to 5]; group 3 = [6 to
9], group 4 = [over 10])). The respondent took only average 5 minutes to complete and
they also needed to fill up their age group before survey is being started.
The questionnaires set of 5 designed to this Consumer Survey are as follows:
Q1 Do you always online shopping by using smart phone or other mobile devices?Q2 When you consider buying a product, is the shopping coupon can help for making the
decision?Q3 How many times to use the e-coupon for shopping in last 12 months?Q4 When you choose a traditional Chinese habit tea, Hung Fook Tong will be your first choose?Q5 Do you feel satisfy on Hung Fook Tong herbal tea drink products?
According to the results of questionnaires, only 48 (6%) people in this sample have
accessed to online shopping through their smart phone or handheld computer. The results
of findings also revealed that over 61% agree the shopping coupon can affect them to
make the decision. And, we know 544 (67%) people in sample group have already gained
experience in using e-coupon for shopping in past 12 months and 264 (33%) have never
been using the e-coupon for shopping yet.
11 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
The results of findings also reflected more then 78% in sample group will buy the
traditional Chinese herbal tea with choices of Hung Fook Tong brand. And, 70% people
agreed they are feeling comfortable with satisfaction in selecting Hung Fook Tong
products. (BioMedCentral 2007)
Nowadays, using smart phones and mobile devices to searching information is very
common in Hong Kong. Especially, in young-age-group, mobile phones become
significant social communication tools and information source. Through the results of this
survey, it showed more then half people in sample already knew using the e-coupon in
shopping, thus it will becomes a trend for sale promotion and selling the product. Because
of this, Hung Fook Tong has driven the business in right way to developed the e-coupon
system to increase their profit and market share. Summary of survey results are as
follows:
Table 1 Answers Result
1(disagree) 2 3 4 5(Agree)
Q1 120 65 335 240 48
Q2 56 86 168 301 197
Q4 4 9 164 264 367
Q5 4 32 204 228 340
0 1 ~5 6 ~ 10 Over 10
Q3 264 375 157 12
Table 2. Pie chart
12 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Recognition on Consumer Needs
With the references revealed from the results of customer survey, we are able to
understand on what the products a they appreciate and suit for daily consumptions and in
what ways they used to purchase the products. Hence, we also develop a diagram below
for easy reference.
13 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Diagram – Recognition on Consumer Needs
Summary of Findings
With the newly implemented I.T. system, it will increase extra budget to “Hung Fook
Tong”. However, the new system brings the advantage to cover the new market trend (i.e.
social network of Internet’s population). This led a successful understanding in certain
extend; we are able to collection crucial information regarding role and value in the
strategic environment.
Furthermore, survey results also point out the differential elements in terms of
information requirements to different levels and functions of management. These are the
project objectives which provided analytical skills to understand whether ‘Information
System’ could make significant improvement on its market share.
After we used the porter five force method to analyze traditional Chinese herbal tea
market (Hung Fook Tong), we found that three area forces includes “Rivalry among
competing firms in industry”, “Threat of new entrants” and “Bargaining power of supply”
are less and low pressure. The forces of “Threat of substitute products” were found by
middle pressure caused by other competitors are not too difficult to produce similar kinds
14 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
of habit drink products. At last, the force of “Bargaining power of buyers” we found that
is belong to high pressure level, because nowadays consumer quality requirement is
become more high and higher, plus the consumer favors change very fast, they expected
more and more different new products launch in market, therefore the habit drink
producer need to keep understand their customer and produces more favor choice for
them, meanwhile they must keep their product quality in good level all the time.
Analytical Results of Porter Five Force
Rivalry Among Competing Firms in Industry
Pressure Rate: Low
1. Hung Fook Tong Holdings Company was established since 1986, they have 28
Years’ experience on developed their products line and also have a large number of percentage market share.
2. Hung Fook Tong have strong product sale distribute network, such as MTR, KCR,
Supermarket, and its department store, therefore competitors not easy to replace it.
3. In past 10 years, Hung Fook Tong were investing large money on TV advertising and various promotional activities, thus consumer already have deep impression on
Hung Fook Tong and their products.
Threat of New Entrants
Pressure Rate: Low
1. New entrant still needs to spend a lot of time and investment on develop
their distribution network and customer base, they can’t replace current competitors (Hung Fook Tong) quickly.
2. Hong Fook Tong have well developed business model and strategy, they
can take faster responses on market competitor actions, new entrant will not easy to affect their market share.
15 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Threat of Substitute Products
Pressure Rate: Middle
1. Making Chinese herbal drink does not need any secret formula, the
martial of herbal drink is not too hard to find it in the market, and therefore substitute product is not hard to reproduce for another competitor.
2. One of the most important business strategies of Hung Fook Tong is
recognition on consumer needs. Hung Fook Tong care about customer need and always extend their product category to fulfill different time customer expectation;
this is the strength point of HFT to against the threat of substitute products.
3. Nowadays, people likes emphasize to have healthful food and drink, therefore Traditional Chinese herbal drink is become more and more popular and
because one significant drink category which cannot be replaced.
Bargaining Power of Suppliers
Pressure Rate: Low
1. Hung Fook Tong is making and selling large number of products each
month, they need huge number of material resource for produce goods, and therefore they will have better bargaining power with suppliers.
2. This is the stronger requirement of manufacturing needs of Traditional
Chinese herbal drink. Always, the suppliers will keep pace with good deal to the giant buyers like ‘Hung Fook Tong’.
Bargaining Power of Buyers
Pressure Rate: High
1. Today, consumer favorite is always charging, it’s not easy to make consumer stick in same product with very long time. Consumer favorite changing
will base on different time and market trend, therefore company always needs to
16 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
know the customer thinking and expectation.
2. Currently it has few Chinese traditional Herbal drink brands products
selling in the Hong Kong market, therefore consumer can have some choose to make.
3. Consumer is very concern the product quality, if the product quality not
consistency and stable, consumer may change to select another competitors’ product.
4. Hung Fook Tong have a good distribute network in Hong Kong, specially some rental shop location can have exclusive selling the herbal drink; For
example inside MTR & KCR station, people not too much choose to buy a drink, sometime HFT is only choose they can have.
5. New ly Implemented I.T. System s
Executive Director Ricky Szeto have used his strong sense to analysis the current
market situation. Therefore, he can adopt progressive market strategy to absorb customers
from the local consumers. Starting from 2010, the company offered discount coupons to
various online ‘Groupon’ websites. This market strategy led its market share increased to
16% average from year 2011 to 2013. For the offering of online discount, they had used
the below format set paper coupons offered from the ‘Groupon’ partners’ websites:
In mid October 2013, with the successful reference from the applicable sale
method, the company under his supervision implemented two innovative I.T. systems in
17 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
parallel operating with ‘Groupon’ sales network. Sale automation system (SAS) has been
integrated into various I.T. systems and has gained wide range of reputations in I.T.
system development industry. With the technological advancement, new enhancement on
I.T. system has been created success opportunities and provides I.T. system solution to
business retails environment. Especially, the products’ strength is to integrated solutions in
connection with customer relationship management (CRM).
The innovation designs and deliverable solutions benefits to its business partners
with highest usability and scalability. The newly implemented I.T. system included:
i. Stock balance management;
ii. Selling patterns console (analytical software);
iii. Implement a new system to facilitate the sells orders from ‘Instant Order@E-
coupon’;
18 of 41
Whenever you spend HK$100 or retrieve the promotion E-coupons from mobile apps
You may use the downloaded e-coupons to redeem another set of discount coupon in shops
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
iv. Enhancement on ‘CRM System’; and
v. New ‘Smart E-order’ will be integrated in existing ‘CRM System’.
(sales managers can select the ‘best buy’ products and focus on the market trends on
specific items)
6. Description of strategic IT system(s) to be used
The new methods will be enabled by the new proposed I.T. system in i) Instant
Order@ E-coupon, ii) Smart E-order.
Instant Order@E-coupon
Instant E-coupon is a strategy planning to absorb the potential market from social
media networks. Social media networks have become a dominant force of almost
every aspect of a person’s communication strategy. Businesses are remaining
competitive by reaching their customers through social media networking. With
effective management practices and low cost social media marketing, businesses have
been able to use inexpensive ways to increase their visibility online. The extreme
growth of social media has also assisted businesses in tapping into previously
19 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
unknown markets.
QR code facilitation in cellar phone
Smart E-order
Smart E-order is one another strategy planning in ‘CRM system’ to increase
interactive relationship between customers and the company. CRM systems give
businesses the ability to personalize and customize relationships with their customers
regardless of which employee deals directly with them at any given time.
Touch pad device interactive with customers
Strategic Management View on New I.T.Systems
Before making decision on these newly planned I.T. systems, we have to
understand the existing infrastructure of I.T. System in Hung Fook Tong
CRM System
Customer relationship management (CRM) system allow the company to identify
its target customer, it is a complicate system and cost of implementation is very
expensive. In our case, “Hung Fuk Tong” get the following benefit from the CRM system.
CRM can decrease cost of customer gain, CRM report can correct the company to identify their target client and to focus of the marketing efforts;
CRM can increase the sales amount, analyzes the customer service behaviors and can be used to point out the shortcomings and areas that need to improvement. Good customer service will affect the results in a higher sales amount.
20 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
The management can align the sales marketing and customer service team to work
together to execute the business strategy according to analytics report.
POS System
The Point of Sale system is for managing the business operations including stock
control, consumer and supplier management. Monitoring all shops and stocks status, now
is become more easer for the management. The management can know retails turnover
and overhead from the Point of Sale System.
Implementation of I.T. System (Physical View)
The newly installed systems could have sufficient interaction with on existing CRM
and POS systems. The system diagram is illustrated as follows:
Physical View on Newly Implemented I.T. Systems
Implementation of I.T. System (Logical View)
The new systems integrated with the company’s systems (i.e. existing I.T. systems)
21 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
to provide more useful information to the company. These information will enhance the
data sets retrieved for business strategy, daily operational strategy, administrative
aspects, warehouse management, and extend to supply chain involved in Hung Fook
Tong.
Logical View on Newly Implemented I.T. Systems
7. Information Requirement
The success of business organizations depends on the strategic decision to made
progressive align with the business organizations, and especially that part of chain affects
the actual production. Information is one of the important element use in strategy decision
making. Decision maker use different information modes to learn about the environment
which separate Strategy level, Tactical level and Operational level. In such view, “Hung
Fook Tong” strategic management to make a decision to deploy new IS in the company
which is accepting the purpose from CEO “Mr Ricky Szeto”.
Strategy information
22 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Strategic management provides overall direction to the enterprise. As executive
director, Ricky Szeto needs to make sure organization alignment, that capacity needs are
addressed and available to make things happen. How does he obtain the strategy
information to make decision? He gather the strategy information from various parties
such as marketing report from marketing research company which to assess the marketing
environment and competitiveness, customer report from CRM system which to help a
business gain a better understanding of who their customers are, what they are buying and
also see how loyal the customer really is. Financial information collected from account
department which to help Ricky Szeto to spot opportunities, and know how to read
markets and match products and services with customer needs.
Tactical information
Tactical need to involve the actual steps needed to achieve that vision, Tactical
management need to aligning the resource and monitoring schedule to the project to
achieve company goals. IT manger need to execute the IT project which according to the
project plan provided from project manager and Sales management need to meeting with
strategy management to obtain the direction of company.
Operational information
Operational control serves to regulate the day-to-day output relative to schedules,
specifications, and costs. The operation Sales staff is to optimize the organization return
on human resource cost. They need to meeting with sales manager to obtain the sales
policy of the company.
The below table is showing the information needs of the company:
23 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Role Description Source
CEO CEO makes sure organization
alignment and that capacity needs are
addressed and available to make things
happen.
Marketing report from Marketing Research Company.
Customer report from CRM system
Financial information from Account department
IT/Sales
manager
Aligning the resource and monitoring
schedule to the project to achieve
company goals.
Project plan from project manger
Company Strategy meeting with CEO
Operation
Sales staff
To optimize the organization return on
human resource cost.
Meeting with Sales manager
8. Cost and Benefit Analysis
After the budget planning, the total cost of these new systems will be expected to
simulate the rise of market share to 10 – 15 % as a whole. In calculation of profit margin,
10% increase is equivalent to HK$ 1 million dollars. And, the expenditure on this project
will be broken even in beginning of year 2015 after 1½ years of system implementation.
24 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
9. Management Inspirations of Information ManagementBusiness Case Studies
i) Restaurant Industry
A leading nation restaurant chain wanted to increase their customer base and try a
25 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
different ways to make the advertising instead of traditional media methods. They
used an existing appetizer promotion to created campaign that the customer can
download the e-coupon via official company’s Facebook web site. When a customer
show up their e-coupon from smart phone or print out cope, they will have a free
appetizer. The result shows in the first 14 days, the company have more than
200,000 coupons were distributed and generated 426,949 new Facebook fans and
also found it have 15% business profit increase on at end of first month. (AccuData
2010)
ii) YAMATOYA Chef Restaurant
The Japanese chef restaurant YAMATOYA is one of the favorite traditional Japanese
cuisines in Japan. In September 2012, the restaurant owners agreed to have a pilot
test on using eMenu (company’s iPad eMenu) for six months. The purpose of this
test was to test whether this new technology and model can help for increases the
customer per order, when used on an eMenu.
Ultimately, after two months experiment, the result was that the table used the iPad
eMenu which was higher at 6% average spent per customer than which using the
traditional orders method. The restaurant owners were very satisfied on this result,
not only increases the average check per customer, they also can easily to achieve
the information of customer favorites and practices. (MiHormiga 2011)
10. Conclusion To cope with the competition of the market, Hung Fook Tong had taken progressive
26 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
steps to review its business environment from time to time. They recognized that it does
not only reduce the retail price of products to attract customer but also need to enhance its
existing I.T. systems. Based on our observations and findings of Hung Fook Tong, our
project team had explored significant findings from Hung Fook Tong. During the survey,
by using qualitative research approach in evaluating consumers' feedbacks on new
products, it provides the company with realistic, accurate and immediate check on
innovative product ideas. These findings included the company’s strategic approaches;
this leads the understanding outcomes from the information in the strategic environment
that was believed to be significant to strategic manager.
The new proposed I.T. system in Instant Order@ E-coupon and Smart E-order are
able to use inexpensive ways to increase their visibility online. The extreme growth of
social network also assists businesses in tapping into previously unreachable market share
and provides the business in capable of personalizing and customizing relationships with
their customers regardless of which employee deals directly with them at any given time.
The new system will increase extra budget to “Hung Fook Tong” and cost of
implementation planned have been estimated in the cost and benefit. For the new system,
product details including descriptions of products, quantities, and individual unit price
will be quoted before the implementation stage. In view of the system stability, the
ongoing maintenance cost and staff training fund have also been estimated as well.
However, after the company had adopted new Information System with creative
methodology to overcome the market competition, it is noticed that after the budget
planning, the total cost of these new systems will be expected to simulate the rise of
market share to 10 – 15 % as a whole and the expenditure on this project will be broken
even after 1½ years of system implementation.
27 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
11. Self-Evaluation / Reflection
At the beginning of this report, we mentioned “Hung Fook Tong” faced with the
rapid competitive of market share, and the business become more challenging and
strategy since the competitiveness of the company is complicated. This report let us
understand the company’s strategic approaches, the outcomes from the information in the
strategic environment that was believed to be significant to strategic management.
Although this report may not totally reflect overall business issues in “Hung Fook Tong”,
but we believe this report can help the company to analyze the current market
environment to improve their IT system to reach the new market strategy. Nowadays,
people connected to Internet purchasing platform becomes more popular, the company
should take a chance to build up a 7 x 24 online shop system to increase the marketing
share, which benefit can save the cost of rental and staff expenditures. And, the purpose is
to find out the new potential customer and better chance to increase the company sales
revenue. Value of the business strategic can be reflected in the system how to bring the
benefit or profit to the company.
28 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
12. Reference
AccuData (2010) ‘Industry Solutions Restaurant’ http://www.accudata.com/casestudy/restaurant-case-study-casual-dining-3[Available on 8 March, 2014]Blake and Gerard (1984 ) ‘THE INFORMATION SYSTEM AS A COMPETITIVE WEAPON’, page 1Benchmark analysis project in Hung Fook Tong: http://www.benchmark.org.hk/eng/3.2_hungfooktong.htm[Available on 5 March, 2014]Hong Kong Institute of Marketing(HKIM) field visits essay, page23: http://www.hkim.org.hk/image/data/7_Press%20Room_Publications/Members_Communicati
on_ME/ME-AUTUMN-2012-FINAL.pdf
[Available on 5 March, 2014]
Federation of HK industries interview with Executive Director of Hung Fook Tong: https://www.industryhk.org/english/fp/fp_hki/files/HKI1209_HFT_e.pdf[Available on 12 March, 2014]Hong Kong Institute of Marketing(HKIM) field visits essay, page23: http://www.hkim.org.hk/image/data/7_Press%20Room_Publications/Members_Communication_ME/ME-AUTUMN-2012-FINAL.pdf[Available on 5 March, 2014]MiHormiga (2011) ‘Yamatoya Chef restaurant’http://www.mihormiga.com/wp-content/uploads/Informe-ventas-emenu-ipad-mi-
hormiga-ingles.pdf[Available on 8 March, 2014]The Chinese General Chamber of Commerce bulletin: http://www.cgcc.org.hk/b5/chamber/bulletin/files/Bulletin_1281344424.87828_26-
33.pdf[Available on 5 March, 2014]
29 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Appendix I
Major Milestones
Milestones Planned Schedule
Completion Date
Start the “Porter Five Forces” analytical methods and define the
strengths and weakness.
20 Feb 2014 –
26 Feb 2014
Review and analyze the different aspect of the background of
“Hung Fook Tong”. Define which I.T application or system is
adopted by “Hung Fook Tong” currently.
27 Feb 2014 –
05 Mar 2014
Adopt “Porter Five Forces” to analyze “Hung Fook Tong” 06 Mar 2014 –
12 Mar 2014
Design and distribute consumer survey 06 Mar 2014 –
19 Mar 2014
Interview with Hung Fook Tong and on-site visit for their I.T.
department.
13 Mar 2014 –
19 Mar 2014
Sort out all of the information and interim review the whole
project.
19 Mar 2014
Analyze the risk and advantages of Implementation of new I.T.
system and the related technical feasibility
27 Mar 2014 –
02 Apr 2014
Final discuss and review of all the information. (e.g. interview,
on-site visit, research)
03 Apr 2014 –
09 Apr 2014
Check of all content, reference and finalize the project for
presentation and report submission
10 Apr 2014 –
16 Apr 2014
Appendix II
30 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Interview Letter for Hung Fook Tung Executive Director
28th February, 2014
Mr. Szeto12/F., ADP Pentagon Centre, 98 Texaco Road, Tsuen Wan, N.T., HK
Request for an Interview with getting the use of IS with business strategy
Dear Mr. Szeto,
We are student (Group 2 members) at Middlesex University of BIS, since we are studying the subject BIS3342 -Strategic Management and Information Systems, we need to submit a group project assignment about the use of IS with business strategy . Your company has an outstanding reputation in that field of practice. We would appreciate the opportunity to meet with you briefly and discuss the topic. Any further insights you have would be greatly appreciated. I will contact your office the week of March 2 to set up a mutually convenient time for this informational interview.
Yours Sincerely,XXXStudent MDX UniversityPhone: Email:
Appendix III
31 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Interview Dialog
Interview
Date: March 5 2014 2:40pm – 3:00pm (20 Minutes)
Location: Hung Fook Tong office Guest Room
Interview Person: Mr Ricky Szeto Executive Director of Hung Fook Tong Holdings Ltd
Visitor: Raymond, Alan
Us: Good afternoon, Mr Ricky Szeto. IT’s pleasure to have chance to meet you today.
May I say you some questions about Hung Fook Tong business strategy in
Information technology?
Ricky: Yes, of course.
Us: What is the vision of Hung Fook Tong Holdings Ltd?
Ricky: We would like to popularize our traditional Chinese habit drink culture to global
by every means.
Us: What is your business strategy to achieve your company’s vision?
Ricky: Starting from long time ago, we had tried various methods to introduce our
products to the customers in different countries such as TV media, advertising and
charity…..etc.
Us: Among your strategy and future planning, is there any project involve new
information technology?
Ricky: Yes, we do. In the past year, we started two IT projects. One of them is called
“Instant Order@ E-coupon”. Another on is “Smart E-order”. We have established
“Instant Order @ E-coupon” mobile application to deliver e-coupon through the
most popular internet social media network. The main purpose of this software is
to increase the market share and selling value.
32 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Regarding “Smart E-order”, it is very convenient for the customers to place their
orders through iPad inside our retail stores. All the data collected by the system
which will be analyzed by CRM system. This will help our top management to
understand more the trend and the needs of our existing customer.
Us: Do you satisfy with the result of those 2 project development?
Ricky: So far, both of projects are very successful. According to our last sales report, we
have 20% more in sales. And based on “Smart E-order” result, we will soon
launch 2 new products in the markets and we estimate there will be positive
feedback from the market.
Us: Thank you for your valuable time and your information.
33 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Appendix IV
1. Do you always online shopping by using smart phone or other mobile devices?
Rating out of 5 stars
2. When You consider buying a product , is the shopping coupon can help you to make the decision?
Rating out of 5 stars
3. How many times to use the e-coupon for shopping in last 12 months?
Open-ended text
34 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
4. What do you think on Hung Fook Tong herbal tea drink?
Rating out of 5 stars
Finish Thanks for your opinion and time.
Appendix V
35 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Consumer Survey Result Summary Report
Appendix VI
36 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Date Study and Presentation Schedule
Jan-22 (Week
1)Studying Strategic Management
Feb-05 (Week
2)Reading Course Materials and prepare for project proposal
Feb-12 (Week
3)review the draft copy of project proposal
Feb-19 (Week
4)submit project proposal
Feb-26 (Week
5)Reading Course Materials
Mar-05 (Week
6)Reading Course Materials
Mar-12 No Class (self-preparation for project work )
Mar-19 (Week
8)Group Project - Interim Presentation
Mar-26 No Class (self-preparation for project work )
Apr-02 (Week
10)Reading Course Materials and prepare project report
Apr-09 (Week
11)Reading Course Materials and prepare project report
Apr-16 (Week
12)
Group Project - Final presentation and report submissionParis Project - Submit Project Proposal (Final)
Study Plan
Appendix VII
37 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Minutes
1st Project Group meetingBIS3324 2.23.2014 3:25pm – 3:35pm Location: G/F. HKMA Li Kwok Po Meeting Project Group MeetingType of FacilitatorNote taker JemyTimekeeperAttendees Jemy, Samuel, Alan, RaymondProject Proposal and Presentation[Time [Presenter]
Agenda1. Finalized the structures of project proposal - what are the structures finalized2. Preparation Works of project - how to start the preparation works3. Presentation of project proposal - when will the project present4. Allocations of tasks - members involved in individual tasks5. Consolidation of project works - when and what the individual works are
Conclusions
Action Items Person Responsible Deadline1. Introduction Completed2. Objective Completed3. Research Methodology of Study Raymond4. Data Gathering Samuel5. Strategic Model and Analysis Jemy6. Summary of Analysis Jemy7. Information Requirements Alan8. Project Implementation Strategy Samuel9. Global Successful Stories Raymond10. Conclusion Alan11. Appendixes
38 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
12. References
2nd Project Group Meeting
BIS3324 3.6.2014 9:40pm – 10:00pm Location: Venue (FC)Meeting Type of Assignment 1. Project MeetingFacilitatorNote taker RaymondTimekeeperAttendees Jemy, Samuel, Alan, RaymondProject Proposal and Presentation[Time [Presenter]Discussion What’s remaining works on group project at this stage?
6. We have to summarize the project proposal and the proposal should NOT over 7. Prepare a project PowerPoint for next class group presentation8. Complete the “Information Requirements” session 9. Build up to report format
Conclusions
Action Items Person Responsible DeadlineProject Objective (Academic) & Introduction Jemy & RaymondResearch Methodology & Porters’ Five Forces Samuel & AlanStrategic IT Systems and Conclusion Jemy & RaymondInterview Questions All Group MembersInformation Requirements All Group MembersPorters’ Five Forces first draft Raymond
3nd Project Group Meeting
BIS3324
4.2.2014 9:40pm – 10:00pm Location: Venue (FC)
Meeting called by
Type of meeting Group Project Meeting – Final FacilitatorNote taker RaymondTimekeeperAttendees Jemy, Samuel, Alan, Raymond
Project Proposal and Presentation
[Time allotted] [Presenter]Discussion Continues the final project report
39 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
1. Final project report task allocation
2. Decided using 4 different color (red, orange, yellow, green) to represent each
team members works.3.
Action Items Person Responsible Deadline
Project Objectives and Company AlanProposed New I.T. System JemyMethodology RaymondAnalysis of strategic environment RaymondInformation Requirement SamuelDescription of strategic IT system(s) to
be usedAlan
Cost and Benefit Analysis Jemy
Management inspirations of
information managementRaymond
Global Successful Stories Raymond
Conclusion Alan
Reference Raymond
Major Milestones Alan
4th Project Group Meeting
BIS3324 9.4.2014 9:20pm – 09:45pm Location: Venue (FC)Meeting Type of Group Project Meeting – Final Report processFacilitatorNote AlanTimekeepAttendees Jemy, Alan, RaymondProject Proposal and Presentation[Time [Presenter]Discussio Continues the final project report
1. Final project report powerpoint slide task allocation
Action Items Person DeadlineProject background – objective, methodology, company introduction (2
Alan, Raymond 13 April 2014Summary of strategic issues of the
company (1~2 slides) Raymond
40 of 41
CMT3324 - Group Project(Group 2)
Values of strategic IT system (~ 6 slides)
(1) Description of the IT system (what is it ? What are functions provided)
(2) System /solution diagram
Jemy (1-4)
Samuel (5)
(3) Information requirement of strategic/tactical/operational manager or users
(4) Summary of Cost & benefits (tangible/intangible benefits)
(5) Other strategic issues considered in this project
Appendix (Optional)- Project plan and task allocation- SWOT/Porter/Questionnaire/Interview
Alan (milestone), Raymond
~ End ~
41 of 41