Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    1/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 4

    NNMK Zpvdpkgaj Undm jdm zkk wbkvk wkvk bkd`k`- Pbk mkrp ubdzk hc pbkundmmamg az chv pbk Fhdv` ph udzz pbkzk zpvdpkgaj `a,vkjpahmz hm ph NNMKz Jhllappkk jbdavz zh pbdp pbkq

    jdm uvkudvk ghdnz dm` hfokjpaskz ph fk djjhlunazbk`

    am pbk mkrp fflsk qkdvz-

    Lazzahm Zpdpklkmp

    Pbk lazzahm hc pbk Ndw Nafvdvadmz hc Mkw Kmgndm`

    az ph cdjanapdpk pbk uvhckzzahmdn k`{jdpahm. jhnndfhvd,

    pahm. dm` `ksknhulkmp hc apz lklfkvz dm` ph uvh,

    lhpk pbk sdn{kz hc pbk uvhckzzahm-

    Jhvk Sdn{kz? 4! K`{jdpahm. 6! Jhll{majdpahm. :!

    Nkd`kvzbau. 0! Ammhsdpahm. ;! Jhhukvdpahm. Jhnndfh,

    vdpahm. Mkpwhviamg dm` C{m-

    Zpvdpkgaj @avkjpahmz

    K`{jdpahm NNMK wann uvhsa`k k`{jdpahmdn hu,

    uhvp{mapakz ph apz lklfkvz dm` hpbkv {zkvz hc nkgdn

    amchvldpahm-

    Jhll{majdpahm NNMK wann uvhsa`k palknq

    amchvldpahm ph lklfkvz dm` uvhlhpk amchvldpahm

    krjbdmgk wapbam pbk jhll{mapq-

    Nkd`kvzbau Lklfkvz hc NNMK wann fk vkjhgmak`

    dm` sdn{k` dz Mkw Kmgndm`z chvklhzp nkd`kvz dm`

    krukvpz am nkgdn amchvldpahm. vkzkdvjb. dm` pkjbmhn,hgq-

    Ammhsdpahm NNMK wann djpasknq u{vz{k dm` `k,

    sknhu mkw hv aluvhsk` wdqz hc uvhsa`amg `qmdlaj

    uvhgvdlz dm` zkvsajkz-

    Jhhukvdpahm. Jhnndfhvdpahm. Mkpwhviamg dm` C{m

    "JJM#C! NNMK wann kmjh{vdgk JJM#C dlhmg

    lklfkvz. am fhpb chvldn dm` amchvldn zkppamgz. am

    hv`kv ph f{an` vkndpahmzbauz. zbdvk amchvldpahm. zhnsk

    uvhfnklz. dm` zpal{ndpk jvkdpasapq-

    Mkwznkppkv hc pbk Ndw Nafvdvadmz hc Mkw Kmgndm`Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 6. 6552 Mkwz

    fq Idpbq Cnkpjbkv. NNMK Uvkza`kmp

    Pbk Krkj{pask Fhdv` hc NNMK lkp hm Cva`dq. Odm{,

    dvq 6;pb chv d skvq uvh`{jpask `dq hc zpvdpkgaj undm,

    mamg- Pbk pdzi chv pbk `dq wdz ph uvh`{jk jnkdv jhvk

    sdn{kz dm` zpvdpkgaj `avkjpahmz pbdp wh{n` g{a`k pbk

    Fhdv`z djpahmz chv pbk mkrp fflsk qkdvz- Pbk j{vvkmp

    Fhdv` lklfkvz wkvk da`k` am pbaz pdzi fq Z{zdm

    Z{nnasdm. NNMK Udzp Uvkza`kmp "655:,6550! dm` uvk,

    sah{znq d nhmg,pkvl Fhdv` lklfkv- Z{zdm dgvkk`

    ph djp dz h{v cdjanapdphv chv pbaz uvhjkzz ph zpkkv pbk

    `azj{zzahmz. ikku {z hm pvdji. dm` bknu {z chj{z h{v

    whvi-

    Pbk lhvmamg fkgdm fq jvkdpamg d lazzahm

    zpdpklkmp- Wk zunap amph zldnn `azj{zzahm gvh{uz-

    Kdjb gvh{u whvik` wapb pbk Zpdpklkmp hc U{vuhzk

    cvhl h{v fq,ndwz dm` chvlk` apz hwm `vdcp lazzahm-

    Pbk c{nn gvh{u pbkm lkvgk`. dm` ldzzdgk` pbk ndm,

    g{dgk ph jhlk {u wapb d mkw lazzahm zpdpklkmp chv

    NNMK-

    Hmjk wk dgvkk` hm d lazzahm zpdpklkmp. wk

    bd` d nasknq `azj{zzahm dfh{p wbdp wk ukvjkask`

    ph fk NNMKz jhvk sdn{kz- Dcpkv pbk sdn{kz wkvkdgvkk` {uhm dm` pbk ndmg{dgk hc kdjb jdup{vk`. wk

    zunap {u amph zldnn gvh{uz dgdam- Kdjb zldnn gvh{u

    phhi d sdn{k dm` cvhl ap. jvkdpk` d `vdcp `avkj,

    pahm. g{a`k` fq pbk sdn{k- Dgdam. pbk c{nn gvh{u

    vkp{vmk` phgkpbkv ph zbdvk. ldik z{ggkzpahmz. dm`

    k`ap kdjb `avkjpahm-

    Pbk vkz{np hc pbk `dqz whvi az d jhnnkjpahm hc

    mkw zpvdpkgaj `avkjpahmz chv NNMK- Wk mhw zbdvk

    pbkzk wapb qh{ "pbk NNMK lklfkvzbau! zh pbdp qh{

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    2/176 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    Chvwdv` Lklfkvzbau Mkwz apklz phpbk K`aphv hv ph pbk chnnhwamg?

    Jhmmkjpaj{pBdvpchv`(Mhvpbkvm Jhmmkjpaj{pZ{zdm Zkskvh[maskvzapq hc Jhmmkjpaj{pZjbhhn hc Ndw Nafvdvq:1 Knadfkpb Zp-Bdvpchv`. JP 5345;,664:"235! ;75,;53:9 cdr? "235! ;75,;450zzkskvhEndw-{jhmm-k`{

    Qdnk(Mkw BdskmLajbknnk Z{nnasdmQdnk Ndw Nafvdvq467 Wdnn Zp-Mkw Bdskm. JP 53;65"65:! 0:6,300:9 cdr? "65:! 0:6,1316lajbknnk-z{nnasdmEqdnk-k`{

    LdamkJbvazpamk Bkunkv[maskvzapq hc Ldamk Zjbhhn hc Ndw Nafvdvq603 @kkvamg Dsk-Uhvpndm`. LK 50456jbkunkvE{zl-ldamk-k`{

    Ldzzdjb{zkppzKdzpkvmIdvam Pb{vldmJhllhmwkdnpb hc Ldzzdjb{zkppzHcffljk hc Dpphvmkq Gkmkvdn Nafvdvq65pb Cnhhv. Hmk Dzbf{vphm UndjkFhzphm. LD 56452,4312"347! 767,6655 r6519 cdr? "347! 767,;732idvam-pb{vldmEdgh-zpdpk-ld-{z

    WkzpkvmFhmmak N- Ihmkzia,WbapkjcwfnwEdhn-jhl

    Pvadn Jh{vp Ndw NafvdvakzJdvhn Lajbd{`j(h Unqlh{pb Ndw Nafvdvq

    Jh{mpq Jhllazzahmkvz F{an`amg44 Z- V{zzknn Zp-Unqlh{pb. LD 56:35"347! 707,07139 cdr? ";52! 703,1722

    Mkw BdluzbavkIdpbq CnkpjbkvMkw Bdluzbavk Ndw NafvdvqZ{uvklk Jh{vp F{an`amgHmk Mhfnk @vaskJhmjhv`. MB 5::54"35:! 674,:777istkpjbkvEjh{vpz-zpdpk-mb-{z

    Vbh`k Azndm`Idvkm T{ammVbh`k Azndm` Zpdpk Ndw NafvdvqCvdmi Najbp O{`ajadn Jhlunkr. 6;5 Fkmkfflp Zp-Uvhsa`kmjk. VA 5615:"054! 677,:67;9 cdr? "054! 677,:23;

    SkvlhmpJbvazpamk VqdmSkvlhmp Ndw ZjbhhnO{nakm dm` Savgamad Jhvmknn Nafvdvq1 Jbknzkd Zp-. U-H- Fhr 35Zh{pb Vhqdnphm. SP 5;532"256! 73:,2:5: r60029 cdr? "256! 73:,74;1jvqdmEskvlhmpndw-k`{

    PDFNK HC JHMPKMPZ

    Ckdp{vk` Dvpajnkz

    Z{zdm L- CdvdghF{zamkzz Ldmdgkv. NNMK Mkwz

    Zhjadn Ndw NafvdvqFhzphm. LD 56452

    "347! ;6:,5542. Krp- :50cdr "347! ;6:,60;2

    zcdvdghEzhjadndw-jhl

    Pbk Ndw Nafvdvadmz hc Mkw Kmgndm` "NNMK! az d jbdupkv hc pbk Dlkvajdm

    Dzzhjadpahm hc Ndw Nafvdvakz- NNMK Mkwz. pbk jbdupkv mkwznkppkv. az u{fnazbk`

    t{dvpkvnq hm pbk NNMK wkfudgk dp bppu?((www-ddnnmkp-hvg(jbdupkvz(nnmk- NNMK

    `hkz mhp dzz{lk dmq vkzuhmzafanapq chv pbk zpdpklkmpz d`sdmjk` fq pbk jhmpvaf{phvz

    phNNMK Mkwz mhv `h pbk sakwz kruvkzzk` mkjkzzdvanq vkuvkzkmp pbk sakwz hcNNMK hv apz lklfkvz- Dmq t{kzpahmz jhmjkvmamgNNMK Mkwz amjn{`amg vkt{kzpz

    chv vkuvampz zbh{n` fk `avkjpk` ph?

    4 NNMK Zpvdpkgaj Undm

    3 Nafvdvq hc pbk MKBGZ

    45 Pbh{gbpz hm Wbdp A @h dm` Wbq Ap Ldppkvz

    Am Kskvq Azz{k

    : K`aphvz Mhpk

    0 Uvkza`kmpz Lkzzdgk

    ; NNMK Mkwz

    2 @kdv Lazz Mhlkv

    45 NNMK Lkkpamg Uvksakw

    46 Dgkmpz chv pbk Fhhiz

    4: Djjkzz Uhampz

    4; Pbaz Azz{k am Jhmmkjpaj{p Bazphvq

    43 @avkjphvq hc Hcffljkvz dm` Jbdavz

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    3/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 :

    NNMKMkwzMkwznkppkv hc pbk Ndw Nafvdvadmz hc Mkw Kmgndm`

    Pbk NNMK Mkwz az dsdandfnk dp? bppu?((www-

    ddnnmkp-hvg(jbdupkv(nnmk(NNMKMkwz(am`kr-bpl

    hv ikku {u ph `dpk hm dnn NNMK mkwz dp pbk

    NNMK Fnhg. bppu?((nnmk-fnhgzuhp-jhl(

    K@APHVADN FHDV@

    K`aphv,am,Jbakc

    Iqnk I- Jh{vpmkq

    Vkckvkmjk Nafvdvadm

    Mhvpbkdzpkvm [maskvzapq Zjbhhn

    hc Ndw Nafvdvq

    055 B{mpamgphm Dskm{k

    Fhzphm. LD 5644;

    "347! :7:,:025

    i-jh{vpmkqEmk{-k`{

    G{kzp K`aphvNd{vd Bdvmkpp

    Mhvpbkdzpkvm [maskvzapq Zjbhhn

    hc Ndw Nafvdvq

    055 B{mpamgphm Dskm{k

    Fhzphm. LD 5644;

    "347! :7:,21:1

    n-bdvpmkppEmk{-k`{

    F{zamkzz LdmdgkvZ{zdm L- Cdvdgh

    Bkd` hc D`lamazpvdpahm

    dm` B{ldm Vkzh{vjkz

    Zhjadn Ndw Nafvdvq

    Fhzphm. LD 56452

    "347! ;6:,5542. Krp- :50

    zcdvdghEzhjadndw-jhl

    K`aphvz Mhpk

    Gvkkpamgz dm` Bduuq Zuvamg$ Zamjk pbk wkdpbkv az

    fflmdnnq p{vmamg unkdzdmp am Mkw Kmgndm`. wk jbhzk ph

    hukm pbaz azz{k wapb d Ldvi Pwdam t{hpk dfh{p h{v

    cdshvapk zkdzhm?

    Apz zuvamg ckskv- Pbdp az wbdp pbk mdlk hc ap az-

    Dm` wbkm qh{sk ghp ap. qh{ wdmp , hb. qh{ `hmp

    t{apk imhw wbdp ap az qh{ `h wdmp. f{p ap o{zp cdavnqldikz qh{v bkdvp djbk. qh{ wdmp ap zh$

    Wknn. pbk NNMK Mkwz bdz zuvamg ckskv$ Pbaz azz{k

    ckdp{vkz pbk mkw NNMK Zpvdpkgaj Undm. mhpkz hm pbk

    {ujhlamg NNMK Zuvamg Lkkpamg. dm dvpajnk hm pbk

    Mkw Kmgndm` Bazphvaj Gkmkdnhgajdn Zhjakpq dm`

    l{jb lhvk$

    Ldmq pbdmiz ph pbhzk wbh bdsk jhmpvaf{pk` ph h{v

    mkwznkppkv chv pbk fflvzp palk$ Pbaz azz{k hc pbk mkwz,

    nkppkv dnzh jhmpam{kz h{v vkg{ndv cdshvapkz z{jb dz

    Djjkzz Uhampz dm` Pbaz Azz{k am Zpdpk Bazphvq- Lazz

    Mhlkv kskm bdz d Fkzp hc--- k`apahm$

    Ndzpnq. A wh{n` naik ph jhmgvdp{ndpk NNMK Mkwz

    k`aphv Z{zdm Sd{gbm hm pbk favpb hc bkv fkd{pa,c{n `d{gbpkv Ldvgdvkp "Ldggak! Odlkz Sd{gbm

    ":(67(52. ; uh{m`z. 7 h{mjkz # 42 amjbkz nhmg!$

    Bduuq Cavzp Zuvamg. Ldggak$

    [mpan pbk NNMK Zuvamg Lkkpamg am Ldamk$

    Qh{v K`aphvz

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    4/170 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    Djjhv`amg ph pbk krukvpz. dz d lkl,

    fkv hc Gkmkvdpahm R. A dl pdzi,hvakmpk`

    dm` am`kukm`kmp- `hmp naik fkamg hskv,

    z{ukvsazk` hv u{mjbamg d palk jnhji-

    "Idq Idsdmdgb. Ud{nd Mdanhm. Krjknnkmjk

    am pbk Whviundjk? Nkgdn dm` Nack Ziannz 606.

    "6557!!- Pv{k kmh{gb- Pbaz fhhi.Krjkn,

    nkmjk am pbk Whviundjk "d m{pzbknn mh nkzz!.wdz hmk hc zkskvdn uakjkz hc d u{nk pbdp

    jnajik` phgkpbkv am lq bkd` dm` amzuavk`

    lk ph uvhuhzk pbk phuaj hc pbk Zuvamg NNMK

    lkkpamg. Pdniamg fh{p lq Gkmkvdpahm. ph

    Jbvaz Mhpp dm` Jbvazpamk Bkunkv-

    Ac qh{sk vkd` pbk nafvdvq napkvdp{vk.

    hmk hc pbk faggkzp jbdnnkmgkz zhhm ph fk cdj,

    amg nafvdvakz az pbdp d ldohvapq hc `avkjphvz dvk

    am pbk fdfq fhhl gkmkvdpahm dm` knagafnk

    chv vkpavklkmp am pbk mkrp 45,4; qkdvz- Pbk

    uvhgvdl dz A bd` kmsazahmk` ap. wh{n` dm,

    zwkv pbk t{kzpahm. Bhw jdm ph`dqz nkd`kvz

    jhll{majdpk pbk sazahm dm` lazzahm hc pbk

    nafvdvq. wbkm apz bdm`k` hcc ph pbk mkrp gkm,

    kvdpahm hc nafvdvadmz8 Pbk ghh` chniz dp pbk

    [maskvzapq hc Ldamk Ndw Zjbhhn bdsk u{p ph,

    gkpbkv dm krjknnkmp `dq hc uvhgvdllamg pbdp

    wann zpdvp pbdp jhll{majdpahm uvhjkzz vhnnamg-

    A nhhi chvwdv` ph zkkamg qh{ pbkvk-

    Pbk zuvamg lkkpamg wann dnzh gask qh{v

    Krkj{pask Fhdv` pbk huuhvp{mapq ph ampvh,

    `{jk qh{ ph pbk mkw zpvdpkgaj `avkjpahmz wk

    `ksknhuk` pbaz wampkv chv NNMK- Wk bd` d

    skvq z{jjkzzc{n hmk,`dq zpvdpkgaj undmmamg

    lkkpamg am Odm{dvq- "Unkdzk zkk pbk djjhl,

    udmqamg dvpajnk `kzjvafamg pbk uvhjkzz dm`

    vkz{npz-! Pbkzk `avkjpahmz wann g{a`k h{v

    krkj{pask fhdv` `kjazahm ldiamg chv pbk mkrp

    pbvkk qkdvz- Hmk hc pbk `avkjpahmz wk bdsk

    jhlk {u wapb az Jhll{majdpahm. Jhnndfh,

    vdpahm. Mkpwhviamg dm` C{m$ A imhw pbdp dnn

    ch{v wann pdik undjk am Cvkkuhvp-Dm` fflmdnnq. pbaz az pbk palk hc qkdv

    wbkm wk u{p phgkpbkv d Mhlamdpamg Jhl,

    lappkk ph zknkjp mkw hcffljkvz chv NNMK- Pbk

    hukm uhzapahmz pbaz qkdv dvk Zkjvkpdvq. K`{jd,

    pahm Jh,@avkjphv. dm` Sajk Uvkza`kmp(Uvkza,

    `kmp Knkjp- Ac qh{ gkp d jdnn cvhl d Mhlamdp,

    amg Jhllappkk lklfkv. A wh{n` {vgk qh{

    ph zdq Qkz- Oham pbk Krkj{pask Fhdv`- Hv.

    shn{mpkkv ph jbdav d jhllappkk- Pbk whviqh{nn `h chv NNMK wann fk vkwdv`amg- Pbk

    fhdv` az fflnnk` wapb zldvp. `k`ajdpk` nafvdv,

    admz wbh dvk jhllappk` ph krjknnkmjk- Whmp

    qh{ d`` qh{v pdnkmpz dm` krukvpazk8

    Pbdmi qh{-

    Idpbq Cnkpjbkv

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    5/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 ;

    Vdt{kn L- Hvpa bdz fkkm duuhampk` pbk Dzzhjadpk

    @avkjphv hc pbk Ndw Nafvdvq dp Fhzphm [maskvzapqz

    Uduudz Ndw Nafvdvq. vkundjamg Ldvnkmk Dn`kvldm.

    wbh wdz duuhampk` @avkjphv hc pbk Ndw Nafvdvq

    am @kjklfkv- Vdt{kn wdz uvksah{znq pbk Bkd` hc

    Vkckvkmjk Zkvsajkz cvhl 6556,6552 dm` Zkmahv Vkc,

    kvkmjk # Knkjpvhmaj Zkvsajkz Nafvdvadm cvhl 4111,

    6556- Uvahv ph ohamamg Fhzphm [maskvzapq. Vdt{kn

    wdz pbk @hj{lkmp @knaskvq Nafvdvadm dp pbk Bdvsdv`

    Ndw Zjbhhn Nafvdvq cvhl 4113,4111-

    Mhvpbkdzpkvm [maskvzapq Zjbhhn hc Ndw az unkdzk`

    ph dmmh{mjk pbdp Nq`ad Ndfflhmdpaz ohamk` pbk Ndw

    Nafvdvq am Odm{dvq dz pbk Bkd` hc Djjkzz Zkvsajkz-

    Nq`ad wann fk whviamg jnhzknq wapb zpdcc am pbk dvkdz

    hc Javj{ndpahm. Zpdjiz Ldmdgklkmp. Ampkvnafvdvq

    Nhdm dm` Djjkzz- Nq`ad wdz lhzp vkjkmpnq pbk Pkjb,

    majdn Zkvsajkz Nafvdvadm dp Jbhdpk. Bdnn dm` Zpkwdvp

    am Fhzphm. LD-

    Ckla Jd`l{z bdz fkkm jbhzkm dz pbk mkw Dzzhja,

    dpk Nafvdvadm chv D`lamazpvdpahm dp Nannadm Ghn`ldm

    Nafvdvq. Qdnk Ndw Zjbhhn- Zbk wann fk pdiamg pbk

    undjk hc Fhmmak Jhnnakv. wbh wann vkpavk am O{nq 6552-

    Ckla wdz chvlkvnq Dzzhjadpk Ndw Nafvdvadm. Jhnnkj,

    pahm dm` D`lamazpvdpask Zkvsajkz dp Gkhvgk Ldzhm

    [maskvzapq Ndw Nafvdvq- Ckla bdz fkkm whviamg

    am ndw nafvdvakz chv 4; qkdvz- Zbk bdz krukvakmjk am

    d`lamazpvdpahm. djjkzz zkvsajkz. jhnnkjpahm `ksknhu,

    lkmp dm` vkckvkmjk-

    Nqmm K- Vdm`dnn vkzagmk` cvhl pbk Ldamk Zpdpk Ndw

    dm` Nkgazndpask Vkckvkmjk Nafvdvq kcckjpask D{g{zp

    45. 6557. bdsamg zkvsk` chv lhvk pbdm 67 qkdvz. pbk

    ndzp 42 dz @avkjphv dm` Zpdpk Ndw Nafvdvadm- [m`kv

    Nqmmz nkd`kvzbau pbk Nafvdvq gvkw am m{lkvh{z mkw

    dm` krjapamg `avkjpahmz- NNMK wazbkz qh{ pbk fkzp

    hm qh{v vkpavklkmp$

    Hm Odm{dvq 6. 6552. Ohbm V- Fdv`km fkgdm baz

    pkm{vk dz pbk mkw @avkjphv pbk Ldamk Zpdpk Ndw dm`

    Nkgazndpask Vkckvkmjk Nafvdvq- Ohbm jhlkz ph Ldamk

    cvhl pbk L{zk Ndw Nafvdvq. [maskvzapq hc Vajblhm`

    Zjbhhn hc Ndw. wbkvk bk zkvsk` dz Bkd`. Vkckv,

    kmjk dm` Vkzkdvjb Zkvsajkz- Bk bdz d O-@- cvhl pbk

    [maskvzapq hc Savgamad Zjbhhn hc Ndw dm` d L-Z-N-Z-cvhl pbk [maskvzapq hc Mhvpb Jdvhnamd dp Jbdukn

    Bann- Am d``apahm ph baz ampkvkzpz am ndw nafvdvadmzbau.

    bk az dnzh d bazphvq f{cc wapb hmghamg uvhokjpz am

    jhnhmadn Dlkvajdm nafvdvakz dm` Jasan Wdv zhn`akvz

    mdvvdpaskz- Wknjhlk ph NNMK. Ohbm$

    Camdnnq. NNMK Mkwz k`aphv Z{zdm Sd{gbm gdsk favpb

    ph d fkd{pac{n fdfq `d{gbpkv$ Ldvgdvkp "Ldggak!

    Odlkz Sd{gbm wdz fhvm hm Ldvjb 67pb. 6552 dm`

    wkagbk` ; uh{m`z. 7 h{mjkz- Jhmgvdp{ndpahmz$

    NNMK VKLAM@KVZ

    Pbk 6552 DDNN Lkkpamg am Uhvpndm` az hmnq d ckw

    lhmpbz dwdq- Pbk NNMK Zjbhndvzbau Jhllappkk az

    mhw djjkupamg duunajdpahmz chv z{uuhvp ph bknu udq

    pbk jhzpz hc dppkm`amg- Duunajdpahmz dvk `{k fq Duvan

    :5pb- Pbk uhnajakz dm` duunajdpahm chvlz dvk dsdan,

    dfnk hm pbk NNMK wkfzapk dp?

    bppu?((www-ddnnmkp-hvg(jbdupkv(nnmk(chvlz(am`kr-bpl

    Jhlunkpk` duunajdpahmz zbh{n` fk zkmp fq ldan hv

    cdr ph?

    Ldvgdvkp Jadmcdvama. Jbdav

    NNMK Zjbhndvzbau Jhllappkk

    Bdvsdv` Ndw Zjbhhn Nafvdvq

    4;0; Ldzzdjb{zkppz Dsk-

    Jdlfva`gk. LD 564:2

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    6/173 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    Pbk Mkw Kmgndm` Bazphvaj Gkmkdnhgajdn Zhjakpq

    "MKBGZ! az pbk hn`kzp gkmkdnhgajdn hvgdmadpahm

    am pbk jh{mpvq- Ap wdz ch{m`k` am 420; wapb pbk ghdnzhc jhnnkjpamg. uvkzkvsamg. dm` u{fnazbamg "hjjdzahm,

    dnnq! gkmkdnhgajdn dm` bazphvajdn ldppkv vkndpamg ph

    Mkw Kmgndm` cdlanakz- Pbk Zhjakpq j{vvkmpnq bdz

    65.555 lklfkvz dm` az nhjdpk` dp 11,454 Mkwf{vq

    Zpvkkp am Fhzphmz Fdji Fdq- Ap mhw chj{zkz hm

    gkmkdnhgakz hc cdlanakz hc Mkw Kmgndm`. Mkw Qhvi.

    dm` kdzpkvm Jdmd`d. kzukjadnnq pbk uvhsamjkz hc Dp,ndmpaj Jdmd`d. dm` hm pbk gkmkdnhgq hc pbhzk hc Avazb

    bkvapdgk- Bhwkskv pbk vkzh{vjkz hm pbk gkmkdnhgq

    hc pbhzk cvhl hpbkv fdjigvh{m`z ldq fk dsdandfnk

    pbvh{gb MKBGZ. fhpb hmnamk dm` am uvamp-

    MKBGZ jhm`{jpz dm` ldampdamz d sdvakpq

    hc uvhgvdlz dm` vkzh{vjkz- Bhwkskv. A wann chj{z

    hm pbk MKBGZ nafvdvq. wbkvk A fkgdm shn{mpkkv,

    amg ndzp @kjklfkv- Pbk MKBGZ nafvdvq az d uvasdpk

    nafvdvq. hukm ph lklfkvz dz d fkmkfflp hc lklfkv,

    zbau dm` ph pbk u{fnaj "krjkup chv pbk ldm{zjvaup dm`

    vdvk fhhiz jhnnkjpahmz! chv d ckk hc 4;(`dq- Pbk

    nafvdvq jhmzazpz hc hskv 655.555 fhhiz. ukvah`ajdnz

    dm` lajvhchvlz hm ch{v sthhvz "wapb vdvk fhhiz hm

    d fflcpb sthhv!. J@,VHLz. knkjpvhmaj vkzh{vjkz dm`

    4.555.555 ldm{zjvaupz- D vdmgk hc hmnamk p{phvadnz.

    uvkzkmpk` fq pbk Zhjakpqz zpdcc. az dsdandfnk hm pbk

    MKBGZ wkfzapk. www-mkwkmgndm`dmjkzphvz-hvg-

    Am `kzjvafamg pbk nafvdvqz vkzh{vjkz am lhvk

    `kpdan. A wann vknq bkdsanq hm MKGBZ Vkzkdvjb Na,

    fvdvq Vkzh{vjkz fq Ldvak K- @dnq. @avkjphv hc pbk

    Nafvdvq. wbajb jdm fk ch{m` hm pbk MKBGZ wkfzapk

    Pbk zarpb sthhvz V{pb J- Fazbhu Vkd`,

    amg Vhhl jhmpdamz vkzh{vjkz pbdp wann dzzazp pbhzk

    `kzjkm`k` cvhl zkskmpkkmpb dm` kagbpkkmpb jkmp{vqMkw Kmgndm` cdlanakz- Pbaz sthhv az jhluvazk` hc

    j{vvkmp gkmkdnhgajdn ukvah`ajdnz. vkckvkmjk fhhiz.

    dm` d ndvgk m{lfkv hc u{fnazbk` Jdmd`adm dm`

    Dlkvajdm gkmkdnhgakz- Pbk Vkd`amg Vhhl bhn`z

    cvkt{kmpnq {zk` zh{vjkz z{jb dz Ldzzdjb{zkppz sapdn

    vkjhv`z ph 42;5. Mkw Kmgndm` ldvvadgkz ph 4275.

    dm` Pbk Gvkdp Lagvdpahm Fkgamz. dz wknn dz hpbkv

    nkd`amg gkmkdnhgajdn t{dvpkvnakz-

    Cnhhv ;Dz V- Zpdmphm Dskvq Zukjadn Jhnnkj,

    pahmz @kudvplkmp jhmpdamz {mu{fnazbk` gkmkdnhgakz.lduz. dvpwhvi. ubhphgvdubz. nkppkvz. `advakz. oh{vmdnz

    djjh{mp fhhiz. f{zamkzz dm` amzpap{pahmdn vkjhv`z.

    `kk`z dm` jklkpkvq pvdmzjvaupahmz-

    Pbk Nafvdvq hc pbk Mkw Kmgndm`Bazphvaj Gkmkdnhgajdn Zhjakpqfq Gammq LjSdvazb

    Jhmp- hm mkrp udgk-

    MKBGZ Nafvdvq. Mkwf{vq Zp- Fhzphm. LD

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    7/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 7

    Pbk Nafvdvqz fflcpb sthhv az pbk Nhjdn Bazphvq

    sthhv. `kshpk` ph nhjdn bazphvakz. uvhfdpk dm` `kk` am,

    `krkz. lduz. dpndzkz. sapdn vkjhv`z. jklkpkvq vkjhv`z.

    mkwzudukv dfzpvdjpz dm` jhnnkgk dn{lma `avkjphvakz-

    Pbk ch{vpb sthhv. pbk @kdm J- dm` Vhfkvpd

    O- Zlapb Pkjbmhnhgq Vhhl. az wbkvk ldmq sazaphvz

    fkgam pbkav gkmkdnhgajdn vkzkdvjb dp MKBGZ- Ap azdnzh pbk undjk ph fkgam. @dnq d`sazkz am bkv uakjk. ac

    qh{v dmjkzphvz wkvk mamkpkkmpb hv pwkmpakpb jkmp{vq

    allagvdmpz. zamjk pbk gkmkdnhgazpz hm pbaz sthhv zuk,

    jadnak am mamkpkkmpb dm` pwkmpakpb jkmp{vq vkzkdvjb-

    Hm pbaz sthhv. pbk vkzkdvjbkv jdm djjkzz [mapk` Zpdpkz

    ck`kvdn dm` zpdpk jkmz{z vkjhv`z hm lajvhfflnl hv hm

    pbk Wkf pbvh{gb pbk Zhjakpqz z{fzjvaupahm ph pbk

    `dpdfdzk dmjkzpvq-jhl- Pbk ch{vpb sthhv dnzh bhn`z

    lhzp sapdn vkjhv`z chv pbk Mkw Kmgndm` zpdpkz. dm`

    az kzukjadnnq zpvhmg chv Ldzzdjb{zkppz. Mkw Bdlu,

    zbavk. Skvlhmp dm` Ldamk- Pbk djp{dn favpb. ldv,vadgk dm` `kdpb vkjhv`z chv Ldzzdjb{zkppz cvhl 4204

    ph 414; dvk ch{m` bkvk hm lajvhfflnl- Pbk Zlapb

    vhhl dnzh bdz `kk` dm` uvhfdpk vkjhv`z hm lajvh,

    fflnl chv lhzp jh{mpakz am Mkw Kmgndm`- Pbk lajvh,

    ffljbk japq `avkjphvq jhnnkjpahm amjn{`kz lhzp phwmz

    am Ldzzdjb{zkppz. dm` pbk vhhl bdz Fhzphm japq

    `avkjphvakz chv dnlhzp kskvq qkdv cvhl 4721 pbvh{gb

    4124- Pbk vhhl bdz zhlk mkwzudukvz hm lajvhfflnl

    dz wknn-

    MKBGZ bdz d ndvgk jhnnkjpahm hc lajvhchvlzdm` fhhiz vkndpamg ph kdzpkvm Jdmd`d- Pbk ch{vpb

    sthhv bhn`z dnn dsdandfnk Jdmd`adm jkmz{z vkjhv`z

    {u ph 4154. dz wknn dz d sdvakpq hc hpbkv vkjhv`z chv

    T{kfkj. Uvamjk K`wdv` Azndm`. Mhsd Zjhpad dm`

    Mkw Fv{mzwaji-

    Pbk ch{vpb sthhv dp MKBGZ az dnzh pbk nhjd,

    pahm ph fkgam vkzkdvjbamg Avazb dmjkzphvz- D``apahm,

    dnnq. pbk vhhl bdz am`krkz ph Fhzphm Udzzkmgkv Nazpz

    4202 pbvh{gb 4214 dm` ph Mkw Kmgndm` mdp{vdnad,

    pahm ukpapahmz-

    Pbk fflvzp sthhv hc pbk MKBGZ f{an`amg. pbkPvkdp Vhp{m`d dm` pbk Jhmzpdmjk Wd`nkq C{nnkv

    Vkd`amg Vhhl. az pbk undjk ph nhjdpk `kpdank` baz,

    phvajdn dm` gkmkdnhgajdn amchvldpahm hm K{vhukdm

    jh{mpvakz. kzukjadnnq Avkndm`. Kmgndm` dm` Zjhpndm`-

    Nhjdn dm` jh{mpq bazphvakz. u{fnazbk` sapdn vkjhv`z.

    udvazb vkgazpkvz. bazphvajdn dm` gkmkdnhgajdn ukva,

    h`ajdnz. bkvdn`vq fhhiz dm` gkmkvdn g{a`kz ldq fk

    ch{m` bkvk- Pbk Ampkvmdpahmdn Vkckvkmjk zkjpahm

    jhmpdamz fhhiz hm bhw ph pvdjk dmjkzphvz am sdva,

    h{z K{vhukdm jh{mpvakz. phuhgvdubajdn `ajpahmdvakz.

    undjk am`krkz. dm` uk`agvkk dm` ukkvdgk fhhiz-

    Pbaz az f{p d fvakc z{lldvq `kzjvaupahm hc d

    skvq unkdzdmp nafvdvq wapb d jhmgkmadn dm` imhwn,

    k`gkdfnk zpdcc dm` d wkdnpb hc gkmkdnhgajdn amchvld,

    pahm. kzukjadnnq dfh{p cdlanakz cvhl pbk Mkw Kmg,

    ndm` zpdpkz. Mkw Qhvi. kdzpkvm Jdmd`d. dm` Avkndm`-Wbkm A amt{avk` dfh{p shn{mpkkvamg dp pbk

    MKBGZ nafvdvq ndzp cdnn. lq ghdn wdz ph fk d vkckv,

    kmjk shn{mpkkv. jhskvamg pbk vkckvkmjk `kzi `{vamg

    pbk nafvdvadmz fvkdiz. dm` bknuamg ph dmzwkv t{k,

    vakz wbkm pbk `kziz dvk f{zq- Bhwkskv. dnpbh{gb

    A bdsk fkkm whviamg hm lq cdlanqz gkmkdnhgq chv

    ldmq qkdvz. lq zh{vjkz dvk lhzpnq dmkj`hpdn- A

    bdsk ch{m` pbdp A mkk` ph nkdvm wbdp dm d{pbhvapdpask

    vkjhv` az chv pbk pquk hc cdlanq `dpd d gkmkdnhgazp

    wann fk zkkiamg- A dnzh mkk` ph nkdvm pbk zh{vjkz chvz{jb `dpd. wbajb zh{vjkz MKBGZ hwmz. dm` wbkvk

    `dpd pbk jdm fk nhjdpk` ac pbk Zhjakpq `hkz mhp bdsk

    djjkzz-

    Ph z{l {u. lq djpasapakz dp MKBGZ ph `dpk

    bdsk amjn{`k` d jhlfamdpahm hc hfzkvsamg vkckvkmjk

    nafvdvadmz. vkd`amg gkmkdnhgajdn vkckvkmjk fhhiz.

    dm` `hamg hpbkv shn{mpkkv pdziz. z{jb dz jbkjiamg

    pbk lajvhffljbk hc Ldzzdjb{zkppz Japq @avkjphvakz ph

    ldik z{vk pbkq dvk fflnk` jhvvkjpnq-

    @{vamg lq fvkdiz am lq lajvhffljbk jbkji,

    amg zbacpz. A bdsk fkkm `hamg lq hwm cdlanq bazphvqvkzkdvjb. wbajb bdz fkkm lhzp kmohqdfnk- Pb{z cdv A

    bdsk chj{zk` lhzpnq hm pbvkk fvhpbkvz am lq cdlanq.

    `azpdmp jh{zamz hc lamk wbh klagvdpk` cvhl Jduk

    Fvkphm ph Gnh{jkzpkv- A bdsk `azjhskvk` pbdp pwh hc

    pbk fvhpbkvz zkvsk` am pbk [mahm Mdsq `{vamg pbk

    Jasan Wdv. dm` hmk zkvsk` palk am pbk Kzzkr Jh{mpq.

    Ldzzdjb{zkppz Odan dm` Bh{zk hc Jhvvkjpahm- Am gk,

    mkdnhgq. dz am ndw. pbkvk az dnwdqz lhvk ph nkdvm dm`

    dmhpbkv u{nk$

    MKBGZ--jhmp- cvhl uvks- udgk-

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    8/172 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    Pbk Fkzp hc Lazz Mhlkvz @kfflmapahmz

    @kdv Lazz Mhlkv?

    Dp dm DDNN lkkpamg. Pbhlzhm Wkzp gdsk {z d jhuq

    hcFndjiz Ndw @ajpahmdvq am jknkfvdpahm hc DDNNz

    455pb Dmmaskvzdvq- A dl bdsamg d bdv` palk pvqamg ph

    `kfflmk d jh{unk hc jhmjkupz- Jdm qh{ zkp lk hm pbk

    zpvdagbp dm` mdvvhw8

    Nhzp am Pvdmzndpahm

    @kcamapknq. @kdv?D jh{unk8 Vdpbkv pbdm pdjink qh{v kmpavk D , _ nazp. Awann zpdvp wapb Z dm` gask qh{ pbk vkzp dp d ndpkv palk-

    ZPDM@AMG? pbk huuhzapk hc zappamg

    PDVGKP JHVUHVDPAHM? Wdn,Ldvp jhlukpaphv

    [M@AGKZPK@ HCCKVAMG? Gvdlldz cv{apjdik

    SAZD? {zk` wbkm LdzpkvJdv` hskv nalap dm` sajk

    skvzd

    WDASKV HC PHVP? hm d `akp

    R@AZ hv DR@DP? A vkdnnq `hmp jdvk

    QKNNHW @HG JHMPVDJP? Ndzzakz klunhq,

    lkmp dgvkklkmp

    _KVH,FVDJIKP DLH[MP? Ndw Nafvdvadm zdndvq

    jhludvk` ph hpbkv uvhckzzahmz9 zkk SDZZDNDGK

    @kdv Lazz Mhlkv?

    A imhw dfh{p fnhggamg. f{p wbdp az pbaz snhg,

    gamg f{ dfh{p8 Al g{mmamg ph jdpjb pbk j{vvkmp

    jvdk dp bppu?((lqndwnafvdvqvhjiz-fnhgzuhp-jhl

    Fhzphm Fnhggkv

    @kdv FF?

    Lazz Mhlkv zbhhpz. zbk zjhvkz. zbk fndwgz pbk wdsk

    chv dnn qh{ fnhgkvdpa am pbk fnhghzubkvk. dm` krundamzam D,_ cdzbahm pbk ndpkzp pvkm`q pkvlamhnhgq am nhg,gamg-

    dnhggamg , dnhggamg wk wann gh. dnhggamg wk wann gh.ba bh pbk lkvvah. dnhggamg wk wann gh. zamg nafvdvqfnhggkv knskz. fndamg pbkav pvdanz hc `agapdn `knagbpzfnhggamg , fndb. fndb. fndbamg fn{vfz hc kskvq `k,

    zjvaupahm chv kskvqhmk am pbaz fvdsk. mkw whvn`. wbkvkzankmjk az mkskv ghn`km

    jnhggamg jhdnkzjamg pwh hv lhvk jhnnkdg{kz jn{pjbk`naik jhvvdnnk` jdppnk am cvhmp hc qh{v whvi dvkd ph qdidwdq bh{vz vknaksamg qh{ cvhl `hamg dmq vkdn hv{mvkdn whvi

    `nhggamg , `apjbamg `kd`kv pbdm `hhvmdan fnhgz ndm,g{azbamg am jqfkvzudjk zamjk ndzp {u`dpk` hm pbk `dqhc pbkav jvkdpahm

    @kdvLazzMhlkv

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    9/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 1

    knhggamg , knkjpvhmajdnnq pvdjiamg am famdvq jh`k pbkm{lfkv hc uhzpamgz dm` sazapz ph qh{v fnhg

    cnhggamg , cdjamg `hwm lklfkvz hc pbk zpdcc wbhuhluh{znq uvhjndal. Nkpz `h d nafvdvq fnhg$

    gnhggamg , g{nuamg gdvgdmp{dm t{dmpapakz hc kmkvga,amg jdcckamdpk` fkskvdgkz wbank vkd`amg dm` wvapamgfnhgz

    bnhggamg , bapjbamg qh{v fnhg ph kdjb dm` kskvq fnhgvkndpk` ph qh{v dvkd ph jvkdpk hmk b{lhmgh{z p{lfnk,wkk` hc d fnhgvhnn

    onhggamg , odqwdniamg djvhzz fnhgz j{ppamg dm` udzp,amg apklz chv qh{v fnhggamg

    inhggamg , iajiamg wapb fhpb zbhkz dmqhmk wbh jhvmkvzqh{ wapb Bdsk qh{ zkkm lq fnhg ph`dq8

    mnhggamg m{nnamg dm` sha`amg pbh{gbpz hc b{ldmjhmpdjp wbkm djpasknq nhggamg

    hnhggamg hvgdmaamg nhgz am zpdjik` amch udjikpzfkgammamg wapb jdupdamz fndwg hm fnhg`dpk

    znhggamg zn{vuamg jhcckk. Lazz Mhlkv zwkdvz zbkaz mhp ldiamg pbaz {u? Znhg , s- ph zhjadn mkpwhvidm` fnhg- Pbk djpasapq hc zhjadn mkpwhviamg dm`fnhggamg phgkpbkv am d jhlfamk` kmsavhmlkmp- Pbaz az

    pbk mdp{vdn uvhgvkzzahm wapbam pbk vkjkmp gvhwpb hczhjadn mkpwhviz dm` fnhgz- Wapb pbk vdua` `ksknhu,

    lkmp hc fnhgz "k-g- Fnhggkv. Rdmgd. PqukUd`! dm`zhjadn mkpwhviz "k-g- Cvakm`zpkv. Hvi{p. Namik`am!.pbk mkrp zpku az pbk jhlfamdpahm hc fhpb amph hmkkmsavhmlkmp- Zhlk kdvnq zpdgkz hc znhgz dvk Dnwdq,zHm. d bagb,pkjb jhll{mapq. dm` 4[U-jhl. d sa`khgdlkvz jhll{mapq- km-waiauk`ad-hvg(waia(ZnhgZbdikzukdvk. Zbdikzukdvk. wbkvk chv dvp pbh{8

    zbv{gz Lazz Mhlkv-

    qnhggamg , q mhp nhggamg8 dziz Lazz Mhlkv wbhjdzbkz am gvkdpnq wapb ldvsknh{z lkvjbdm`azk dplazzmhlkvvdikzapam-fnhgzuhp-jhl

    nhggamg , kvhamg am hm pbk nhzz hc bh{vz zmhvamgcvhl krbd{zpahm pbvh{gb pavknkzznq ikkuamg {u wapb

    ghhghnunkrun{z fnhgz

    [mpan mkrp palk. A vkldam chm`nq qh{vz.

    Lazz Mhlkv

    Lazz Mhlkv Hcffljadn Nhgh Jhmpkzp$

    Bdsk d imdji chv `kzagm8 D zukjadn ampkvkzp am

    `vdwamg hv gvdubajz `kzagm8 @h qh{ o{zp NHSK

    Lazz Mhlkv8

    Ac zh. unkdzk jhmza`kv kmpkvamg pbk NNMK Mkwz

    Lazz Mhlkv Nhgh Jhmpkzp$ Lazz Mhlkv bdz fkkm

    wapbh{p d hcffljadn nhgh chv pbvkk azz{kz. dm` pbk

    NNMK k`aphvz dvk kdgkv ph zkk zhlk mkw `kzagmz-

    Zh. ac qh{ bdsk dm a`kd chv Lazz Mhlkvz nhgh.

    unkdzk kldan pbk NNMK mkwz k`aphvz. Z{zdm Sd{gm

    hv Iqnk Jh{vpmkq. wapb qh{v `kzagmz. gvdubajz. dm`

    a`kdz-

    Pbk Wammkv wann gkp ph lkkp Lazz Mhlkv dm` bdsk

    pbkav nhgh d``k` ph pbk Lazz Mhlkv jhn{lm- Un{z.

    qh{nn wam d 45 Zpdvf{jiz Jdv`$ Pbk jhmpkzp v{mz

    {mpan O{nq :4zp- Ghh` N{ji$

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    10/1745 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    Pbh{gbpz hm Wbdp A @h dm` Wbq ap Ldppkvz

    fq Idpbkvamk I- Jhhna`gk

    F{ninkq. Vajbdv`zhm # Gknamdz. NNU

    Am Hjphfkv 6557. NNMK gvdmpk` lk d

    zjbhndvzbau ph dppkm` pbk Mhvpbkdzp Vkgahmdn Ndw

    Nafvdvakz lkkpamg. Nafvdvakz Wapbh{p Fhdv`kvz. am

    Phvhmph- A dl gvdpkc{n ph pbk Zjbhndvzbau Jhllappkk

    dm` ph pbk kmpavk NNMK lklfkvzbau chv pbaz

    zuhmzhvzbau hc lq uvhckzzahmdn ksknhulkmp- Ap

    wdz d gvkdp krukvakmjk dm` huuhvp{mapq ph mkpwhvi

    wapb jhnnkdg{kz cvhl dnn pbk zuhmzhvamg jbdupkvz- A

    wdz udvpaj{ndvnq amzuavk` fq pbk d``vkzz hc Lajbdkn

    Agmdpakcc ph pbk dppkm`kkz dm` A bdsk zukmp pbk ndzp

    zar lhmpbz pbamiamg dfh{p baz hukmamg whv`z dm`

    bhw pbkq lagbp zbduk d zpvdpkgq chv nkd`kvzbau

    kskm am lq vkdnl hc zhnh

    ndw nafvdvadmzbau wbkvk

    nkd`kvzbau wh{n` zkkl phfk dm amjhmgv{apq- YAc qh{

    dvk pbk hmnq ndw nafvdvadm

    hm zpdcc. wbhl dvk qh{

    nkd`amg dm` wbh nkd`z

    qh{8 F{p A `agvkzz-\

    Lv- Agmdpakccz

    whv`z zpv{ji lk dz fkamg

    t{apk uvhch{m`- Amzpkd` hc

    fkgammamg baz d``vkzz wapb

    d t{damp dmkj`hpk dfh{p

    baz cdshvapk nafvdvadm.bk zalunq zda`. A imhw

    wbdp qh{ `h- Dm` A imhw

    wbq ap ldppkvz- Baz

    lkzzdgk wdz `avkjpk` dp

    djimhwnk`gamg pbk jvapajdn

    vhnk nafvdvadmz undq am uvkzkvsamg pbk bkvapdgk hc h{v

    jhll{mapakz. h{v amzpap{pahmz. h{v j{np{vk hv hpbkv

    `kfflmk` gvh{u- Baz chj{z zkklk` ph fk hm uvkzkvsamg

    pbk udzp dz d lkdmz hc uvhpkjpamg pbk c{p{vk- F{p dz A

    zdp pbkvk. A cknp pbk jhmjkup wdz kt{dnnq aluhvpdmp amzbduamg d zpvdpkgq chv nkd`kvzbau- Wbkm. A pbh{gbp.

    wdz pbk ndzp palk dmqhmk zda` bk hv zbk imkw wbdp A

    `a` dm` pbkm djimhwnk`gk` wbq ap ldppkvk`8 Wbkm

    wdz pbk ndzp palk A zda` pbkzk zpdpklkmpz ph pbhzk A

    nkd` hv ph pbhzk wbh nkd` lk8

    F{p. pbkvk az vkdnnq mh mkk` ph wdap chv

    zhlkhmk ph ldik pbk zpdpklkmpz- Pbkq dvk kt{dnnq

    dz {zkc{n chv zknc,ksdn{dpahm- Ac A jdm hmnq dmzwkv

    pbk {m`kvnqamg t{kzpahm hc hmk zpdpklkmp. pbkm pbk

    pdzi kapbkv az mhp whvpb `hamg fkjd{zk ap `hkz mhp

    ldppkv hv A bdsk mhp `kpkvlamk` pbk vagbp pdzi ph

    `h ph djjhlunazb wbdp ldppkvz- Krudm`amg pbk

    ksdn{dpask phhn ph d nkd`kvzbau vhnk. pbk zpdpklkmpz

    jdm fk {zk` ph fvamg pbk vagbp vkzh{vjkz ph fkdv dp

    pbk vagbp palk- D nkd`kv jdm `azjkvm pbk `acckvkmjkhc wbdp ldppkvz dm` wbq. dm` pbkm jdm ksdn{dpk

    ukvchvldmjk dm` `knkgdpk vkzuhmzafanapq am pbk

    jhmpkrp hc pbk pwh zpdpklkmpz-

    Wbkm A krdlamk wbkpbkv A pv{nq imhw wbdp

    hpbkvz `h dm` wbq ap ldppkvz. A ckdv A ldq cdnn zbhvp-

    Phh hcpkm. A dl v{mmamg zh cdzp pbdp A `h mhp pdik

    pbk palk ph nkdvm wbdp hpbkvz `h dm` wbq ap ldppkvz-

    Pbaz ldq fk d nalapdpahm hc fkamg d zhnh uvdjpapahmkv

    wbh l{zp mkjkzzdvanq jhskv

    d nhp hc gvh{m` dm` d nhp

    hc ziann zkpz. hv ap ldq fklq ukvzhmdn nalapdpahm- A

    bdsk jbdnnkmgk` lqzknc ph

    aluvhsk am pbaz dvkd- Ghh`

    nkd`kvz A bdsk imhwm pdik

    pbk palk ph imhw wbdp

    pbhzk pbkq nkd` `h dm`

    wbq ap ldppkvz- Kcckjpask

    nkd`kvz jhll{majdpk pbaz

    {m`kvzpdm`amg ph pbhzk pbkq

    nkd`- Hm fhpb za`kz hc pbkkt{dpahm. pbk nkd`kvz dm`

    pbk nk` dvk kluhwkvk`-

    A wdz vkjkmpnq dp d

    Zallhmz Dn{lma @dq

    uvhgvdl wbkvk Dmm

    Whnukvp hc LAP wdz pbk

    ikqmhpk zukdikv- Bkv phuaj wdz nkd`kvzbau- [mnaik

    Lv- Agmdpakccz d``vkzz. A wdz mhp amzuavk` fq Lz-

    Whnukvpz hukmamg whv`z. f{p vdpbkv fq bkv jnhzamg

    whv`z- Zbk zda`. Ap az mhp wbdp qh{ `h dz d nkd`kv

    pbdp ldppkvz. f{p vdpbkv bhw pbk ukhunk qh{ nkd`fkbdsk- Gkppamg ph pbk `kzavk` fkbdsahv ldq fk

    d mdp{vdn h{pjhlk hc imhwamg mhp hmnq wbdp qh{

    `h dm` wbq ap ldppkvz. f{p dnzh wbdp hpbkvz qh{

    nkd` `h dm` wbq ap ldppkvz- Ukvbduz pbkzk jhmjkupz

    jdm amchvl {z dz wk zpvdpkgak chv pbk c{p{vk hc

    h{v uvhckzzahm dm` z{jjkzzahm undmmamg chv c{p{vk

    nkd`kvz-

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    11/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 44

    NNMK Zuvamg Lkkpamg? Pdniam Dfh{p Lq Gkmkvdpahm

    Vkjv{apamg. Vkpdamamg dm` Lkmphvamg pbk Mkrp Gkmkvdpahm hc Nafvdvadmz

    Pbk NNMK Zuvamg lkkpamg az duuvhdjbamg cdzp$ Pbk

    pbklk pbaz qkdv az Pdniam Dfh{p Lq Gkmkvdpahm? Vk,

    jv{apamg. Vkpdamamg dm` Lkmphvamg pbk Mkrp Gkmkvd,

    pahm hc Nafvdvadmz- Wk amsapk qh{ ph jhlk dm` nkdvmpbk zpvdpkgakz qh{ jdm {zk ph kmz{vk pbk jhmpam{amg

    dm` c{p{vk z{jjkzz hc qh{v nafvdvq cvhl h{v `qmdlaj

    krukvp zukdikvz-

    Pbk zpdcc hc pbk Gdvfvkjbp Ndw Nafvdvq nhhi chvwdv`

    ph wknjhlamg qh{ ph Cvkkuhvp. Ldamk- Pbk chnnhw,

    amg az d fvakc uvksakw hc pbk zukdikvz dm` uvhgvdl?

    Vdjbkn Zamgkv Ghv`hm az Jhmz{npamg K`aphv. Amchv,

    ldpahm Ph`dq. Amj-. Fhhi U{fnazbamg @asazahm. dm`

    wkfldzpkv. NAZohfz-jhl- Zbk u{fnazbkz pbk knkj,

    pvhmaj mkwznkppkvAmch Jdvkkv Pvkm`z. fnhgz dp Pbk

    Nalamdn Nafvdvadm. dm` jh,d{pbhvzFkqhm` pbk Ohf. d

    uvhckzzahmdn `ksknhulkmp wkfnhg chv nafvdvadmz-

    Lz- Ghv`hm az pbk Jhlu{pkv Lk`ad vksakw jhn,

    {lmazp chvNafvdvq Oh{vmdn9 zbk bdz fkkm d cvkt{kmp

    jhmpvaf{phv phNOz MkrpGkm jhn{lm. wvapkz Klkv,

    dn`z U{fnazb. @hmp Ukvazb Nafvdvq Nami jhn{lm.

    dm` jh,d{pbhvz Pkjb Pauz chv Kskvq Nafvdvadm am

    Jhlu{pkvz am Nafvdvakz ldgdamk-

    Bkv u{fnazbk` whvi amjn{`kz Pbk Nafvdvadmz G{a`k

    Ph Wvapamg chv U{fnajdpahm "Zjdvkjvhw. 6550!. Pbk

    Djja`kmpdn Nafvdvq Ldmdgkv"APA. 655;!. Pbk Mkr,

    Gkm Nafvdvadmz Z{vsasdn G{a`k "APA. 6553!. dm`

    Amchvldpahm Phlhvvhw "APA. 6557!-

    Lz- Ghv`hm bhn`z dm LNAZ cvhl @hlamajdm [ma,

    skvzapq dm` dm LD cvhl Mhvpbwkzpkvm [maskvzapq-

    Dp pbaz lkkpamg Lz- Ghv`hm wann fk uvkzkmpamg?

    Pbk Jvhzz,Gkmkvdpahmdn Whvichvjk

    Ph`dqz l{npagkmkvdpahmdn nafvdvq whvichvjk cdjkz d

    m{lfkv hc fhpb ampkvmdn dm` krpkvmdn jbdnnkmgkz- Ph

    lkkp pbkzk jbdnnkmgkz. wk mkk` ph udq dppkmpahm ph

    z{jjkzzahm undmmamg. udzzamg hm amzpap{pahmdn waz,

    `hl. dm` vkjv{apamg. vkpdamamg. dm` lkmphvamg pbk

    mkrp gkmkvdpahm hc nafvdvadmz- [m`kvzpdm`amg gkm,

    kvdpahmdn `acckvkmjkz dm` jnkdvamg {u lazukvjku,

    pahmz jdm bknu {z hskvjhlk whviundjk jbdnnkmgkz

    dm` undm chv d z{jjkzzc{n c{p{vk-

    Gdqnk Nqmm,Mknzhm az d Zkmahv Nafvdvadm Vkndpahmz

    Jhmz{npdmp chv NkrazMkraz- Zbk zkvskz nafvdvadmz

    am Mkw Qhvi dm` Mkw Okvzkq- Gdqnk bdz mamk,

    pkkm qkdvz hc uvhckzzahmdn krukvakmjk am ndw fflvl

    dm` jh{vp nafvdvakz- Zbk az djpask dp pbk mdpahmdn.

    vkgahmdn dm` nhjdn nkskn am uvhckzzahmdn nafvdvq dz,

    zhjadpahmz dm` az d udzp uvkza`kmp hc pbk Mkw Okvzkq

    Ndw Nafvdvadm Dzzhjadpahm "MONND!. dz wknn dz d

    cdj{npq lklfkv hc pbk Pkjbmhnhgq Jhllappkk chv

    pbk Ndw Nafvdvadmz Dzzhjadpahm hc Gvkdpkv Mkw

    Qhvi "NNDGMQ!- Zbk bdz dnzh jbdavk` dm` zkvsk`

    hm sdvah{z DDNN dm` ZND jhllappkkz-

    Am d``apahm ph bkv uvhckzzahmdn dcfflnadpahmz. Lz-

    Nqmm,Mknzhm bdz wvappkm sdvah{z dvpajnkz wbajb

    bdsk duukdvk` amMONND Am Fvakc. UNN Ukvzukj,

    paskz. ZND Jbdupkv Mkwz. Amchvldpahm H{pnhhidm`

    Pvkm`z am Ndw Nafvdvq Ldmdgklkmp dm` Pkjbmhn,

    hgq- Zbk bdz fkkm d ckdp{vk` zukdikv dp mdpahmdn.

    vkgahmdn dm` nhjdn nafvdvq dzzhjadpahm jhmckvkmjkz-

    Lz- Nqmm,Mknzhm vkjkask` bkv O-@- cvhl Wkzpkvm

    Zpdpk [maskvzapq Jhnnkgk hc Ndw dm` bkv L-N-Z-

    cvhl V{pgkvz [maskvzapq Zjbhhn hc Nafvdvq Amchv,

    ldpahm Zp{`akz- Lhzp vkjkmpnq. Lz- Nqmm,Mknzhm

    wdz dwdv`k` pbk B-W- Wanzhm dwdv` dp pbk ZND

    Dmm{dn Jhmckvkmjk 655; bkn` am Phvhmph. Jdmd`d

    chv bkv dvpajnk papnk`. Pbk Lannkmmadn Amsdzahm? Dvk

    qh{ Vkd`q8 u{fnazbk` amAmchvldpahm H{pnhhi.

    Mhsklfkv 6550-

    Dp pbaz lkkpamg Lz- Nqmm,Mknzhm wann fk uvkzkmp,

    amg?

    Hmk Zak @hkz Mhp Cap Dnn? Pvdamamg Azz{kz Ndw

    Nafvdvadmz Cdjk am pbk 64zp Jkmp{vq

    Pbkvk dvk d m{lfkv hc azz{kz cdjamg ndw fflvlz ph,

    `dq dm` pvdamamg az hmk hc pbkl- Dz wk imhw. d

    Yjhmp` hm udgk 40\

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    12/1746 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    Dgkmpz

    Chv

    Pbk

    Fhhiz

    M

    h-0

    P

    FqWdvvkmQkk

    Zalunkl

    qnhsknakz.

    Asku{ppbkwhv`

    h{p---dm`

    whv`z

    pbkqwann

    cam`-

    Zavkvdb

    M{lfkvHmk

    undm8

    Amza`k.dwdapzpbkpvkdz{vkzchvpbk

    lam`-PbkundmazzalunkWk

    hcckvpbklfh{gbzpbdpzbd`kpbkl

    cvh

    lpbkgndvkhct{ajidm`kdzq

    fkzpzknnkvzdm`pbkqwannvhhzpam

    h{

    vpvkkhc`knagbpz-

    O{zpM{lfkvHmk

    lqnhsknakz

    Pbkvkapazlqnhsknakz.pbk

    `vkdlhc`vkdlzdm`pbk

    undjkhcdnnundjkz-Qkz.

    `kzpamqwkbdskqh{v

    najkmzkundpkm{lfkvmhw$

    Db.Zavapzmhpfkkm

    hmpbkvhd`amdjh{unkhc

    `kjd`kz-

    Whw.zh

    ldmqdm`zpann

    jhlamg

    Hblqpbkzk

    dvkldgmacajkmp$

    Whw.pbk

    zknkjpahm$

    Qkz.jhlkamlqnhsknakz.

    jhlkjhlkam-Apwdapz

    chvqh{dnn-Amlhlkmpz

    qh{wannfkvk{mapk`wapb

    wbdpqh{vlam`zbdsk

    fkkmwdmpamgzkkdgdam-

    Mhwpbdpz

    djndzzaj-

    Lqghzb.

    apzbkvk-

    Qaikz$

    Bhw

    wannAj

    bkjih{p

    lqfhh

    i8

    Bllvkd`amg

    zwdluvdpz

    D

    ldnc{mjpahmwapbpbk

    zjdmmkvapzkklzdm`apz

    pbkhmnqhmkbkvk-

    Mh.Ajdmp

    nkdskwapbh{p

    pbazfhhi$

    Bhwdfh{ppbdp$

    A

    pbh{gbpAwh{n`

    mkskv

    vkd`apdgdam-

    Ikkujdnlkskvqhmk

    Apzhmnqdzwdluvdp- M

    krppalk?Mh-;

    PbkFvhikmZuamk

    ampbkAznkz

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    13/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 4:

    djjkzz

    uhampz

    Ampvh`{jamg d mkw jhn{lm wapb d jdpdnhgkvz uhamp hc sakw

    Chvkjnhz{vkz? D Nhhi dp Z{fokjp Bkd`amgz fq Zpkubdmak B{`mkv dm` Nd{vd BdvpmkppPbk jhnndgk fknhw `kuajpz z{fokjp bkd`amgz vkndpk` ph pbk j{vvkmp lhvpgdgk chvkjnhz{vk jvazaz- D{pbhvak` Na,

    fvdvq hc Jhmgvkzz z{fokjp bkd`amgz duukdv am fhn` dm` cdlanadv f{p {md{pbhvak`pkvlz duukdv fknhw pbk z{fokjp

    bkd`amgz am pbk zldnnkv chmp- Z{fokjp bkd`amgz chv pkvlz z{jb dz uvk`dphvq nkm`amg. z{fuvalk lhvpgdgkz dm`

    bh{zamg f{ffnk `h mhp qkp krazp. zh ap az lhzp kcckjpask ph jhm`{jp ikqwhv` dm`(hv fvhd` z{fokjp bkd`amg zkdvjb,

    kz chv whviz hm z{jb phuajz- Wbank pbk jbdvp fknhw az mhp jhluvkbkmzask. wk bhuk ap wann fk bknuc{n-

    Uvhukvpq. Vkuhzzkzzahm hc

    VkuhzzkzzahmNdw dm` nkgazndpahm

    Kt{apq hc vk`klupahm

    Vku{vjbdzk

    Chvkjnhz{vk zdnkz

    Lhvpgdgk chvkjnhz{vk

    Zpdp{phvq chvkjnhz{vk

    Zpvajp chvkjnhz{vk

    Chvkjnhz{vkzNdw dm` nkgazndpahm

    @kk` am nak{ hc chvkjnhz{vk

    DVLz

    Sdvadfnk vdpk lhvpgdgkz

    Bhlk nhdmzLhvpgdgk nkm`amg

    Vkdn kzpdpk nhdmz

    Bhlk camdmjk

    Lhvpgdgk jhludmakzBhlk hwmkvz

    Cavzp,palk bhlk hwmkvz

    Lhvpgdgk NhdmzBhlkhwmkvz

    D`o{zpdfnk vdpk lhvpgdgkz

    @kcd{np "Camdmjk!

    VkuhzzkzzahmVk`klupahm "Ndw!

    Lhvpgdgk fvhikvz

    Zkjhm`dvq lhvpgdgk ldvikp

    @hwm udqlkmpz

    Bh{zamgCamdmjkSkm`hvz dm` u{vjbdzkvz

    Bh{zk f{qamgNdw dm` nkgazndpahm

    Bh{zk zknnamgNdw dm` nkgazndpahm

    Lhvpgdgk fdmiz

    Lhvpgdgk nhdmzNdw dm` nkgazndpahm

    Vkza`kmpadn vkdn kzpdpkSdn{dpahmJhvv{up uvdjpajkz

    Lhvpgdgk nhdmzJhvv{up uvdjpajkz

    @azjvalamdpahm am lhvpgdgk nhdmz

    @azjvalamdpahm am lhvpgdgk nhdmzNdw dm` nkgazndpahm

    Lhvpgdgk nhdmzVkcamdmjamg

    @kk`z

    Chvkjnhz{vk

    Lhvpgdgk fvhikvdgk cavlz

    Lhvpgdgk fvhikvdgk am`{zpvq

    Vdjk `azjvalamdpahm am lhvpgdgk nkm`amg

    Vk`namamg

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    14/1740 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    YNNMK---jhmp` cvhl udgk 44\

    mkw gkmkvdpahm hc dzzhjadpkz az kmpkvamg pbk ndw fflvl

    ldvikp dm` pbkav pvdamamg mkk`z dvk mhp pbk zdlk

    dz pbhzk hc pbk dzzhjadpkz pbdp uvkjk`k` pbkl- Pbaz

    zkzzahm wann d``vkzz pbk azz{kz cdjamg ndw nafvdvadmz

    ph`dq wbkm `kdnamg wapb pvdamamg pbkav amjhlamg

    dzzhjadpkz. pbkav zpdccz dm` kskm pbhzk hn`,palkvz naik

    udvpmkvz dm` hc jh{mzkn- Pbkm pbkvk az pbk azz{k hc

    pvdamamg nafvdvadmz pbklzknskz- Wk wann krdlamk dnn

    pbk cdjkpz hc pvdamamg pbk `acckvkmp gvh{uz dm` nksknz

    hc nkdvmkvz. dm` uvhsa`k uvdjpajdn pauz dm` pkjb,

    mat{kz-

    Hm fkbdnc hc pbk @hmdn` N- Gdvfvkjbp Ndw Nafvdvq

    hc pbk [maskvzapq hc Ldamk Zjbhhn hc Ndw. wk nhhi

    chvwdv` ph zkkamg qh{- Ac qh{ bdsk dmq t{kzpahmz.dmq lklfkv hc pbk uvhgvdl jhllapkk wann fk bduuq

    ph vkzuhm` ph qh{-

    Dppvdjpahmz am dm` Dvh{m` Cvkkuhvp. LK

    Whnckz Mkji Whh`z Zpdpk Udvi

    Pbk udvi hcckvz zknc,g{a`k` baiamg dm` mdp{vk wdniz-

    Ap ckdp{vkz sdvak` chvkzp kjhzqzpklz. d vhjiq zbhvk,

    namk. dm` zdnp ldvzb kzp{dvakz- Wdpjb chv mkzpamg

    hzuvkq dm` sakw pbk azndm`z hc Jdzjh Fdq- D`laz,

    zahm az jbdvgk`- Pkn- "657! 23;,003; "zkdzhmdn!

    Whnckz Mkji Cdvl

    Pbk cdvl vdazkz :55,055 fkkc jdppnk hm pbk Whnc

    Mkji ukmamz{nd- Am pbk kdvnq zuvamg dm` cdnn. pbk

    u{fnaj az amsapk` ph zbdvk am pbk jdnsamg uvhjkzz-

    Qkdv,vh{m` sazaphvz dvk wknjhlk ph sazap pbk jdppnk

    dm` hpbkv zldnn fdvmqdv` dmaldnz- Pbkvk az d gacp

    zbhu dp pbk cdvl wbkvk pbk cdvlz uvh`{jpz ldq fk

    u{vjbdzk`- Pkn- "657! 23;,0031

    Fvd`f{vq Lh{mpdam Zpdpk Udvi

    Chv pbhzk hc qh{ wbh dvk lhvk dlfapah{z baikvz.

    qh{ ldq wdmp ph pvq Fvd`f{vq Lh{mpdam- Fvd`f{vq

    Lh{mpdam Zpdpk Udvi am Uhwmdn. Ldamk. az fflsk

    lankz cvhl pbk Cvkkuhvp,@{vbdl krap hcc [-Z- 1;-D uajmaj dvkd dm` zbknpkv. undqgvh{m`. fdnn fflkn`.

    baiamg pvdanz. dm` 04 jdluzapkz dvk dsdandfnk ph saza,

    phvz- D zbhvp baik ph pbk 035,chhp z{llap hc Fvd`,

    f{vq Lh{mpdam dnnhwz d sakw hc Jdzjh Fdq dm` pbk

    z{vvh{m`amg jh{mpvqza`k-

    Bk`gkbhg Lh{mpdam

    Pbaz lh`kvdpk bann. mhp lh{mpdam. az pbk bagbkzp

    uhamp am Cvkkuhvp dm` d majk NAPPNK baik kzukjadn,

    nq am pbk zuvamg wbkm pbk dav az zh cvkzb$$ Bk`gkbhg

    Lh{mpdam az nhjdpk` duuvhraldpknq 4-1 lankz cvhlpbk jkmpkv hc Cvkkuhvp- Cvhl Ldam Zpvkkp p{vm hmph

    Ldnnkp @v- dm` gh ph pbk km`- P{vm nkcp "dz ac ghamg

    ph Fvd`f{vq Lp-! hmph Ndm`fflnn V`- O{zp fkchvk pbk

    gdpk ph pbk Ndm`fflnn pbkvk az udviamg zudjk chv dfh{p

    0 jdvz- Kmohq-

    Ldmgq Lhhzk hv Jhhn Dz D Lhhzk

    Jhmpvdvq ph uhu{ndv fknakc. pbk Ldamk zpdpk dmaldn

    az mhp pbk Ldamk Fndji Fkdv- "@hmp pknn pbdp ph

    pbk bhjikq cdmz dp pbk [maskvzapq hc Ldamk$$! Ap az

    pbk LHHZK$ Zh pdik hmk bhlk wapb qh{$$ Sazap

    pbk Ldmgq Lhhzk "446 Ldam Zpvkkp! hv Jhhn dz

    d Lhhzk "45 Fhw Zpvkkp! wbkvk qh{ jdm fflm` dnn

    pbamgz Lhhzk. cvhl zp{cck` dmaldnz. p,zbavpz dm`

    bdpz ph l{gz dm` `ammkvwdvk zkpz-

    Chv lhvk amchvldpahm dfh{p pbk NNMK Zuvamg

    lkkpamg. sazap?

    bppu?((www-{zl-ldamk-k`{(}jbkunkv(

    Pbk @hmdn` N- Gdvfvkjbp Ndw Nafvdvq hc

    pbk [maskvzapq hc Ldamk Zjbhhn hc Ndw

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    15/17NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52 4;

    Pbaz Azz{k am Jhmmkjpaj{p Bazphvq"Wk wann ckdp{vk hpbkv Mkw Kmgndm` Zpdpkz kskvq azz{k!

    @kjklfkv 4;. 4240 , @knkgdpahmz cvhl Mkw Kmgndm` gdpbkvk` dp pbk Bdvpchv` Jhmskmpahm ph `azj{zz zkjkzzahm

    cvhl pbk [mapk` Zpdpkz. `{k ph pbkav huuhzapahm ph pbk Wdv hc 4246-

    Odm{dvq ;. 424; , Pbk Bdvpchv` Jhmskmpahmz fflmdn vkuhvp uvhuhzk` zkskvdn dlkm`lkmpz ph pbk [-Z- Jhmzpap{,

    pahm- Pbkzk dlkm`lkmpz dppklupk` ph jhlfdp pbk uhnajakz hc pbk Vku{fnajdm udvpq fq? 4! Uvhbafapamg dmq pvd`k

    klfdvgh ndzpamg hskv 35 `dqz9 6! Vkt{avamg d pwh,pbav`z Jhmgvkzzahmdn ldohvapq chv `kjndvdpahm hc wdv. d`laz,

    zahm hc d mkw zpdpk. hv ampkv`ajpahm hc chvkagm jhllkvjk9 :! Vklhsamg pbk pbvkk,fflcpbz vkuvkzkmpdpahm d`sdmpdgk

    hc pbk Zh{pb9 0! Nalapamg c{p{vk Uvkza`kmpz ph hmk pkvl9 dm` ;! Vkt{avamg kdjb Uvkza`kmp ph fk cvhl d `acckvkmp

    zpdpk pbdm baz uvk`kjkzzhv-

    Odm{dvq 7. 416; , Bavdl Famgbdl. knkjpk` Ghskvmhv hc Jhmmkjpaj{p. zkvskz hmk `dq am hcffljk. fkchvk lhsamg

    ph baz uhzapahm am pbk [mapk` Zpdpkz Zkmdpk- "Famgbdl az dnzh imhwm chv baz vk`azjhskvq hc pbk chvghppkm Amjdm

    japq hc Ldjb{ Uajjb{!-

    Odm{dvq 40. 43:1 Pbk C{m`dlkmpdn Hv`kvz. pbk fdzaj ndw hc pbk Jhmmkjpaj{p jhnhmq cvhl 43:1 ph 4336. az

    chvldnnq d`hupk` fq vkuvkzkmpdpaskz cvhl pbk phwmz hc Bdvpchv`. Wkpbkvzfflkn`. dm` Wam`zhv. lkkpamg dp Bdvp,

    chv`-

    Ldvjb 4. 4724 , Zdl{kn B{mpamgphm "ndpkv d Ghskvmhv hc Jhmmkjpaj{p! fkjhlkz pbk fflvzp Uvkza`kmp hc pbk

    [mapk` Zpdpkz am Jhmgvkzz Dzzklfnk`. wbkm bk hskvzkkz pbk vdpaffljdpahm hc pbk Dvpajnkz hc Jhmck`kvdpahm-

    Ldvjb 0. 416; , O- Dgmkz F{vmz. pbk fflvzp gvd`{dpk d`lappk` ph pbk Jhmmkjpaj{p Fdv. az pbk fflvzp whldm ph unkd`

    fkchvk pbk Jhmmkjpaj{p Z{uvklk Jh{vp hc Kvvhvz-

    Duvan 41. 41:1 Pbk Fann hc Vagbpz uvhuhzk` hm Zkupklfkv 6;. 4721 az fflmdnnq vdpafflk` fq Jhmmkjpaj{p-

    Ldq 4. 43:7 Pbk fflvzp Ghskvmlkmp hc pbk Jhmmkjpaj{p Jhnhmq az chvlk` wapb pbk g{a`dmjk hc Pbhldz Bhhikv

    Ohbm Bdqmkz. dm` Vhgkv N{`nhw- Pbkq vdazk d lanapad dm` undjk Ohbm Ldzhm am jhlldm` ph fflgbp am pbk Ukt{hp

    Wdv-

    O{mk 43:: Pbk @{pjb f{q d zpvau hc ndm` hm pbk Jhmmkjpaj{p Vaskv "jdnnk` T{amma,p{it,{p hv T{hmkb,pd,j{p.

    lkdmamg nhmg pa`dn vaskv! chv hmk uakjk hc `{cckn "jnhpb! pwkmpq,zkskm knnz nhmg. zar drkz. zar ikppnkz. kagbpkkm

    imaskz. hmk zwhv`,fnd`k. hmk udav hc zbkdvz. zhlk phqz dm` d l{zikp- Pbaz u{vjbdzk wdz chv wbdp az mhw pbk

    japq hc Bdvpchv`. JP-

    O{mk 43:: Pbhldz Bhhikv. pbk lamazpkv hc Jdlfva`gk. LD. nkd`z hmk

    b{m`vk` lklfkvz hc baz jb{vjb ph mkw bhlkz am Jhmmkjpaj{p-

    O{mk 4. 4206 , Wd`zwhvpb Dpbkmk{l. pbk hn`kzp u{fnaj dvp l{zk{l am pbk

    [mapk` Zpdpkz. az amjhvuhvdpk` am Bdvpchv`. JP-

    O{nq 416; , Pbk Jhmmkjpaj{p Gkmkvdn Dzzklfnq gvdmpk` pbk Jhnnkgk hc

    Ndw d zukjadn jbdvpkv {m`kv Zukjadn Djp. 416;. Zkmdpk Fann Mh- 415,616 dz

    d uvasdpk k`{jdpahmdn amzpap{pahm-

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    16/1743 NNMK Mkwz. Shn{lk 67. Azz{k 4. 6557,52

    @AVKJPHVQ HC HCCAJKVZ DM@ JBDAVZ 6557,6552

    HCCAJKVZ

    Uvkza`kmp

    Lz- Idpbnkkm @- CnkpjbkvJdpdnhgkv

    Cvdminam Uakvjk Ndw Jkmpkv

    Nafvdvq

    6 Wbapk Zpvkkp

    Jhmjhv`. MB 5::54

    "35:! 662,4;04 krp- 4644

    cdr "35:! 662,5:22

    ICnkpjbkvEuakvjkndw-k`{

    Sajk Uvkza`kmp(Uvkza`kmp Knkjp

    Lv- Jbvaz Imhpp

    Dzzhjadpk Uvhckzzhv hc Ndw dm`

    @avkjphv hc pbk Ndw Nafvdvq

    Gdvfvkjbp Ndw Nafvdvq

    [maskvzapq hc Ldamk Zjbhhn hc

    Ndw

    603 @kkvamg Dskm{k

    Uhvpndm`. LK 50456

    "657! 725,0262CDR "657! 725,014:

    imhppE{zl-ldamk-k`{

    Pvkdz{vkv

    Lz- Idvkm T{amm

    Jbakc Nafvdvadm

    Vbh`k Azndm` Zpdpk Ndw Nafvdvq

    Cvdmi Najbp O{`ajadn Jhlunkr

    6;5 Fkmkfflp Zpvkkp

    Uvhsa`kmjk. VA 5615:

    "054! 666,:67;

    CDR "054! 666,:23;

    it{ammEjh{vpz-zpdpk-va-{z

    Zkjvkpdvq

    Lz- Jbvazpamk A- Bkunkv

    Dzzhjadpk @avkjphv

    [maskvzapq hc Ldamk@hmdn` N- Gdvfvkjbp Ndw Nafvdvq

    603 @kkvamg Dsk-

    Uhvpndm`. LK 50456

    "657! 725,0267

    cdr "657! 725,014:

    jbkunkvE{zl-ldamk-k`{

    Allk`adpk Udzp Uvkza`kmp

    @dsa` P{vidnhDzzazpdmp @avkjphv chv Pkjbmajdn

    Zkvsajkz

    Z{cchni [maskvzapq Ndw Nafvdvq

    465 Pvklhmp Zpvkkp

    Fhzphm. LD 56452

    "347! ;7:,2571

    cdr "347! 76:,:430

    `p{vidnhEz{cchni-k`{

    K`{jdpahm @avkjphvz

    Lv- Zalhm Jdmaji

    Dzzhj- @av- chv Nafvdvq Zkvsajkz

    [maskvzapq hc Jhmmkjpaj{p Zjbhhn

    hc Ndw Nafvdvq

    :1 Knadfkpb Zpvkkp

    Bdvpchv`. JP 5345;,664:

    "235! ;75,;512

    cdr "235! ;75,;450

    zalhm-jdmajiEndw-{jhmm-k`{

    Lv- Vhgkv D- Nklavk

    Zkmahv Vkckvkmjk Nafvdvadm

    Famgbdl LjJ{pjbkm NNU

    4;5 Ck`kvdn Zp-

    Fhzphm. LD 56445

    Ubhmk? "347! 1;4,2333

    Cdr? "347! 1;4,2;0:

    vhgkv-nklavkEfamgbdl-jhl

    JHLLAPPKK JBDAVZ

    Dvjbaskz(Bazphvq

    Lajbdkn B{gbkzDzzhjadpk @avkjphv

    T{ammauadj [maskvzapq Zjbhhn hc

    Ndw Nafvdvq

    67; Lh{mp Jdvlkn Dsk-

    Bdl`km. JP 53;42

    "65:! ;26,::42

    cdr "65:! ;26,::43

    lajbdkn-b{gbkzEt{ammauadj-k`{

    Jhll{majdpahmz

    Vdt{kn L- Hvpa

    Bkd` hc Vkckvkmjk Zkvsajkz

    Fhzphm [maskvzapq Uduudz Ndw

    Nafvdvq

    73; Jhllhmwkdnpb Dsk-

    Fhzphm. LD 5664;

    "347! :;:,22;;

    cdr "347! :;:,;11;

    vlhvpaEf{-k`{

    Ghskvmlkmp Vkndpahmz

    Lz- Idpk Avwam

    Vkzkdvjb Nafvdvadm

    Wkzpkvm Mkw Kmgndm` Jhnnkgk

    Zjbhhn hc Ndw Nafvdvq

    464; Wanfvdbdl V`-

    Zuvamgfflkn`. LD 54441,631:

    "04:! 726,40;1

    CDR "04:! 726,470;

    iavwamEndw-wmkj-k`{

  • 7/30/2019 Volume 27, Issue 2, 2008

    17/17

    Ampkvmkp Z{fjhllappkk

    Vdt{kn L- Hvpa

    Bkd` hc Vkckvkmjk ZkvsajkzFhzphm [maskvzapq Uduudz Ndw

    Nafvdvq

    73; Jhllhmwkdnpb Dsk-

    Fhzphm. LD 5664;

    "347! :;:,22;;

    cdr "347! :;:,;11;

    vlhvpaEf{-k`{

    Ampvh`{jpahm ph Nkgdn Vkzkdvjb

    Jh{vzk

    Ohdm Zbkdv

    Nkgdn Amchvldpahm Nafvdvadm #

    Nkjp{vkv am Ndw

    Fhzphm Jhnnkgk Ndw Nafvdvq

    22; Jkmpvk Zpvkkp

    Mkwphm Jkmpvk. LD 560;1

    "347! ;;6,621;

    cdr "347! ;;6,6221

    ohdm-zbkdv-4Efj-k`{

    Lklfkvzbau @ksknhulkmp

    Jdpbq Fvkkm

    Ndw Nafvdvadm

    [mapk` Zpdpkz Dpphvmkqz Hcffljk

    [mapk` Zpdpkz Jh{vpbh{zk

    4 Jh{vpbh{zk Wdq. Z{apk 1655

    Fhzphm. LD 56645

    "347! 702,::66

    jdpbkvamk-fvkkmEo{zpajk-{z`ho-ghs

    U{fnaj Vkndpahmz Z{fjhllappkk

    @admk @Dmgknh

    Vkckvkmjk NafvdvadmLhdinkq Ndw Nafvdvq

    Z{cchni [maskvzapq Ndw Zjbhhn

    465 Pvklhmp Zpvkkp

    Fhzphm. LD 56452

    "347! ;7:,2352

    cdr "347! 76:,:430

    ``dmgknhEz{cchni-k`{

    Mkwznkppkv Z{fjhllappkk

    Iqnk I- Jh{vpmkqKnkjpvhmaj Zkvsajkz(Vkckvkmjk

    Nafvdvadm

    Mhvpbkdzpkvm [maskvzapq Zjbhhn hc

    Ndw Nafvdvq

    055 B{mpamgphm Dsk-

    Fhzphm. LD 5644;

    "347!:7:,:::6

    cdr "347! :7:,275;

    i-jh{vpmkqEmk{-k`{

    Z{zdm Sd{gbm

    Nkgdn Vkckvkmjk Nafvdvadm

    Lhdinkq Ndw Nafvdvq

    Z{cchni [maskvzapq Ndw Zjbhhn

    465 Pvklhmp Zpvkkp

    Fhzphm. LD 56452

    "347! ;7:,2411

    cdr "347! 76:,:430

    zsd{gbmEz{cchni-k`{

    Zjbhndvzbauz

    Ldvgdvkp Jadmcdvama

    Zkvadnz NafvdvadmBdvsdv` Ndw Zjbhhn Nafvdvq

    4;0; Ldzzdjb{zkppz Dsk-

    Jdlfva`gk. LD 564:2

    "347! 013,645;

    cdr "347! 013,0051

    jadmcdvaEndw-bdvsdv`-k`{

    Zkvsajk

    Okmmackv D- Ikzznkv

    Pkjbmajdn Zkvsajkz Z{ukvsazhvGhh`wam Uvhjpkv NNU

    Krjbdmgk Undjk

    ;: Zpdpk Zpvkkp. 6:v` Cnhhv

    Fhzphm. LD 56451

    "347! :5;,3752

    cdr "347! ;6:,46:4

    oikzznkvEghh`wamuvhjpkv-jhl

    @AVKJPHVQ HC HCCAJKVZ DM@ JBDAVZ 6557,6552