8

Click here to load reader

Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Videophone Delivered Voice Therapy: A Comparative Analysis of Outcomes to Traditional Delivery for Adults with Parkinson's Disease. KMEA Group TV500SP Videophone.

Citation preview

Page 1: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

Mzo!S/!Ujoebmm-!Qi/E/-2!Svui!B/!Ivfcofs-!Qi/E/-3!Kptfqi!D/!Tufnqmf-!Qi/E/-4!boe!Ibspme!M/!Lmfjofsu-!Fe/E/5

2!Efqbsunfou!pg!Wfufsbot!Bggbjst!Nfejdbm!Dfoufs-!Mfyjohupo-!Lfouvdlz/!

3!Efqbsunfou!pg!Pddvqbujpobm!Uifsbqz-!Fbtufso!Lfouvdlz!Vojwfstjuz-!Gsbolgpsu-!Lfouvdlz/

4!Ejwjtjpo!pg!Dpnnvojdbujpo!Ejtpsefst-!5Ivnbo!Efwfmpqnfou!Jotujuvuf-!Vojwfstjuz!pg!Lfouvdlz-!Mfyjohupo-!Lfouvdlz/

Bctusbdu!Joejwjevbmt!xjui!jejpqbuijd!Qbsljotpo� t!ejtfbtf!)JQE*!vtvbmmz!efwfmpq!

b!tqffdi!ejtpsefs!dibsbdufsj{fe!cz!sfevdfe!mpveoftt-!ipbstf!boe!

csfbuiz!wpjdf-!npopupoz!pg!qjudi-!tipsu!svtift!pg!tqffdi-!boe!jnqsf.

djtf!dpotpobout/!Uif!jobcjmjuz!up!fggfdujwfmz!dpnnvojdbuf!jnqbjst!

uifjs!bcjmjuz!up!gvodujpo!jo!tpdjfuz!boe!rvbmjuz!pg!mjgf/!B!tvddfttgvm!

qsphsbn!efwfmpqfe!up!jnqspwf!tqffdi!jo!uiftf!joejwjevbmt!jt!uif!Mff!

Tjmwfsnbo!Wpjdf!Usfbunfou!)MTWU*®/!B!dsjujdbm!dpnqpofou!pg!uijt!

usfbunfou!jt!joufotf!ebjmz!uifsbqz!gps!5!xfflt-!b!sfhjnfo!uibu! jt!

ejggjdvmu!gps!nboz!fmefsmz!qbujfout!up!dpnqmfuf/!Usfbunfou!efmjwfsfe!

uispvhi!wjefpqipoft!qmbdfe!jo!uif!ipnft!pg!joejwjevbmt!xjui!JQE!

pggfst!bo!bmufsobujwf!boe!dpvme!jnqspwf!bddfttjcjmjuz!pg!usfbunfou!

jg!uif!sftvmut!xfsf!uif!tbnf/!Uijt!tuvez!dpnqbsfe!uif!pvudpnft!pg!

MTWU®!efmjwfsfe!wjb!wjefpqipoft!up!uif!pvudpnft!pg!usbejujpobm!usfbu.

nfou!efmjwfsfe!gbdf.up.gbdf/!

Lfz!xpset;! ufmfifbmui-!wjefpqipof-!wpjdf! uifsbqz-!Qbsljotpo� t!

ejtfbtf

Jouspevdujpouw|u. � w� v.o.rw�opzw|u.q}|rw� w}|.�wu|wtwqo|� z� . zw{w� �.o|.

w|rw� wr� oz� �.oq� w� w� ws�.}t.rowz� . zw� w|u.o|r.�� ozw� � .}t.zwts<?.

Oz� v}� uv.{� z� w~zs.sttsq� w� s. � � so� {s|� �.o� s.o� owzopzs. � }.

� sr� qs. � vs.sttsq� �.}t.qv� }|wq.rw�so�s�:.{o|� .w|rw� wr� oz�.

s� ~s� ws|qs.po� � ws� �:.�� qv.o�.{}pwzw� � .rstwqw� �.o|r.� � o|�~}� � o� w}|.rwt;

twq� z� ws�:.w|.oqqs��w|u. � vs�s. � � so� {s|� �<.bszsvsoz� v.{o� .ps.o.{s� v}r.

}t.�s� � wqs.rszw� s� � .� vo� .q}� zr.~}� s|� wozz� .szw{w|o� s.po� � ws� �.� }.oqqs��;

w|u.vsoz� vqo� s<.

W|� s�� wuo� w}|�.}t. � szsvsoz� v. � sqv|}z}u� . � }.rszw� s� .�~ssqv.o|r.

zo|u� ous.�s� � wqs�.vo� s.vw�� }� wqozz� .t}q� �sr.}|.o��s��{s|� <.a� � rws�.

vo� s.q}{~o� sr. � vs.oqq� � oq� .}t.rwou|}�w�.}t.zo|u� ous.rw�}� rs� �.

o{}|u.�� � }ys.~o� ws|� �.r� � w|u.toqs;� };toqs.o|r. � s{}� s.s� oz� o;

� w}|�. � �w|u. � v� ss.q}|rw� w}|�I.qz}�sr;qw� q� w� . � szs� w�w}|:.zo�s� .rw�q.

� sqv|}z}u� :.o|r.toqs;� };toqs.s� oz� o� w}|�<.\}.�wu|wtwqo|� .rwtts� ;

s|qs�.w|.rwou|}�s�. � s� s.t}� |r.o{}|u. � vs�s.o��s��{s|� .{}rozw;

� ws�<@:A.Z}� ;po|r� wr� v:.W|� s� |s� ;po�sr.� wrs}q}|ts� s|qw|u.vo�.pss|.

� �sr. � }.~� }� wrs. � svopwzw� o� w}|.q}|�� z� o� w}|�.t}� .swuv� .q}{{� |w� � .

v}�~w� oz�. � w� v.|}.�wu|wtwqo|� .rwtts� s|qs�. w|.qzws|� . �o� w�toq� w}|<.

\w|s� � .~s� qs|� .}t.~o� � wqw~o|� �.tsz� .o�.q}{t}� � opzs. � w� v. � szsq}|;

�� z� o� w}|.o�.� vs� .rwr.� w� v.q}|� s|� w}|oz.}|�w� s.q}|�� z� o� w}|�<B.bvs.

~s� t}� {o|qs.}t.or� z� �. � w� v.oq�� w� sr.p� ow|.w|x� � � .}|.�~ssqv.o|r.

zo|u� ous.o��s��{s|� .q}|r� q� sr.sw� vs� .o�.toqs;� };toqs.}� .o�.� wrs};

q}|ts� s|qs;po�sr.� szs� svopwzw� o� w}|.�s� � w|u�.vo�.oz�}.pss|.w|� s�� w;

uo� sr<C.`s�� z� �.rs{}|�� � o� sr. � vo� .~o� � wqw~o|� �. � w� v.vsor.w|x� � ws�.

~s� t}� {sr.�w{wzo� z� . w|.toqs;� };toqs.o|r. � szsvsoz� v.�s� � w|u�<.bv� �:.

� s�so� qvs� �.q}|�w�� s|� z� . t}� |r. � vo� . � szsvsoz� v;rszw� s� sr.o��s��;

{s|� �.� s� s.q}{~o� opzs.� }.toqs;� };toqs.s� oz� o� w}|�.}t.or� z� �.� w� v.

q}{{� |wqo� w}|.rw�}� rs� �<.

54;4$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$HIGIQFIV$644<$ HSM> $ 54254<=3 xqn2644<24484

PS JH JOBM ! SFTFBSDI

dwrs}~v}|s;Rszw� s� sr.d}wqs.bvs� o~� H.O.Q}{~o� o� w� s.O|oz� �w�.}t.]� � q}{s�.� }.b� orw� w}|oz.Rszw� s� � .t}� .Or� z� �.� w� v.^o� yw|�}|� �.Rw�so�s

Page 2: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

¬$QEV]$ERR$PMIFIVX0 $ MRG2$$ � $$ZSP2$58$$RS2$54$$ � $$HIGIQFIV$644<$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$54;5

ZMHISTLSRI1HIPMZIVIH$ZSMGI$XLIVET]

`s�� z� �.}t.�� � rws�. � vo� .w|� s�� wuo� sr. � � so� {s|� .}� � q}{s�.rs{}|;

�� � o� sr. � vo� . � szsvsoz� v.w�.o|.sttsq� w� s.{s� v}r.}t.rszw� s� � .}t.�~ssqv.

� vs� o~� .�s� � wqs�.t}� .o|.w|rw� wr� oz.� w� v.o.tz� s|q� .rw�}� rs� :.szs{s|� o� � .

�� � rs|� �. � w� v.o� � wq� zo� w}|.rw�}� rs� �:.o|r.w|rw� wr� oz�. � w� v.r� �o� � v� wo.

o|r.� }wqs.rw�}� rs� �<D£?>.O�.� s~}� � sr.w|.� vs�s.�� � rws�:.qzws|� �.o|r.qzw|w;

qwo|�. � s� s.vwuvz� .�o� w�twsr. � w� v. � szsvsoz� v.rszw� s� � .}t.�s� � wqs�:.o|r.

}� � q}{s.{so�� � s�. � szo� sr. � }.w{~� }� s{s|� �.w|.�~ssqv. � s� s.~}�w� w� s<.

a~ssqv.~o� v}z}u� .�s� � wqs�.o~~so� �. � }.ps. � szz;�� w� sr.t}� . � szsvsoz� v.

� sqv|}z}u� .rszw� s� � .o�.qzws|� �.qo|.�ss.o|r.vso� .o.qzw|wqwo|.uw� s.

w|�� � � q� w}|�.o|r. � sqw~� }qozz� . � vs.qzw|wqwo|.qo|.�ss.o|r.vso� . � vs.qzw;

s|� �� .� s�~}|�s�:.�w{wzo� .� }.� vs.toqs;� };toqs.qzw|wqoz.�s� � w|u<.

bvs.~� � ~}�s.}t. � vw�.�� � r� . � o�. � }.q}{~o� s.}� � q}{s�.}t.�~ssqv.

� vs� o~� .rszw� s� sr.� wo.� wrs}~v}|s�.� }.� � orw� w}|oz.toqs;� };toqs.rszw� s� � .

}t.�~ssqv. � vs� o~� <.dwrs}~v}|s�:. � �w|u.~zow|.}zr. � szs~v}|s.�s� � wqs.

6^]ba7:.� s� s.�szsq� sr.o�.� vs.� szsvsoz� v.� sqv|}z}u� .� }.s� o{w|s.� s{}� s.

rszw� s� � .}t.�~ssqv.�s� � wqs�<.bvs.Zss.awz� s� {o|.d}wqs.b� so� {s|� .

6Zadb»7??.� o�.qv}�s|.� }.� s�� .� vs.sttsq� w� s|s��.}t.� wrs}~v}|s�.psqo� �s.

w� . w�.o.�� � � q� � � sr. � vs� o~� . � w� v.o.qzso� z� .rstw|sr.~� }� }q}z.o|r.}� � ;

q}{s�.t}� .w|rw� wr� oz�.� w� v.wrw}~o� vwq.^o� yw|�}|� �.rw�so�s.6W^R7<??£?B

^s� qs~� � oz.�~ssqv.qvo� oq� s� w�� wq�.{}�� .t� s�� s|� z� .o��}qwo� sr. � w� v.

W^R.o� s. � sr� qsr.z}� r|s��:. � sr� qsr.~w� qv. � o� wopwzw� � :.v}o� �s|s��:.

w{~� sqw�s.o� � wq� zo� w}|:.o|r. � o� s.rw�� � � po|qs�. � vo� .q}|� � wp� � s. � }.o|.

}� s� ozz.~s� qs~� w}|.}t.rsq� so�sr.w|� szzwuwpwzw� � .}t.�~ssqv.w|.� vs�s.w|rw;

� wr� oz�<?C:?D.^s� qs~� w}|.}t.zs��.w|� szzwuwpzs.�~ssqv.p� .�~soys� �. � w� v.

r� �o� � v� wo.o��}qwo� sr.� w� v.W^R.qo|.ps.o� � � wp� � sr.� }.� vs.r� �t� |q� w}|.}t.

�s� s� oz.�� �� s{�<.O|.w{~ow� sr.� s�~w� o� }� � .�� �� s{.w�.rw� sq� z� .� szo� sr.� }.

rsq� so�sr.� }qoz.w|� s|�w� � :.p� � .{o� .w|rw� sq� z� .w|tz� s|qs.� sr� qsr.~w� qv:.

v}o� �s|s��:.w{~� sqw�s.o� � wq� zo� w}|:.o|r.w{~ow� sr.�~soyw|u.� o� s<.

Zadb». � o�.rs� sz}~sr.p� .`o{wu.s� .oz<??. � }.orr� s��.r� �o� � v� wo.

o��}qwo� sr. � w� v. W^R<. W� . w�.o|. w|� s|�s. � � so� {s|� . � vo� . t}q� �s�.}|.

w|q� so�w|u.� }qoz.z}� r|s��.p� .w|q� so�w|u.� vs.qo~oqw� � .t}� .� }qoz.stt}� � <.

Or{w|w�� � o� w}|.}t.Zadb». � s�� w� s�. � vs� o~� .t}� � . � w{s�.~s� . � ssy.t}� .

B. � ssy�I.�� qv.q}|qs|� � o� sr.~� oq� wqs.w�.q}|�w�� s|� . � w� v.~� w|qw~zs�.}t.

{}� }� .zso� |w|u:.�ywzz.oq�� w�w� w}|:.o|r.{� �qzs.� � ow|w|u<?C.\}|s� vszs��:.

� vs.vwuv.w|� s|�w� � . � vo� .{oys�.� vw�.~� }u� o{.�� qqs��t� z.w�.oz�}.o��}qw;

o� sr.� w� v.o.� s|rs|q� .� }.rsqzw|s.w|w� wo� w|u.� vs� o~� .}� .� }.{w��.� vs� o~� .

o~~}w|� {s|� �<.

bvw�.~� s�s|� . �� � r� .q}{~o� sr. � s�� z� �.}t. � wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr.

Zadb».� }. � vs.�� � r� .q}{~zs� sr.p� .`o{wu.o|r.q}zzsou� s�?B. � vo� .q}{;

~o� sr.� vs.sttsq� w� s|s��.}t.Zadb».}|.� }qoz.w|� s|�w� � .t}� .� v� ss.u� }� ~�H.

~o� � wqw~o|� �.6o.K.?B7.� w� v.W^R.� v}.� sqsw� sr.� � so� {s|� .6^R;b7:.~o� � wqw;

~o|� �.� w� v.W^R.� w� v.|}.� � so� {s|� .6^R;\b7:.o|r.~o� � wqw~o|� �.� v}.� s� s.

|s� � }z}uwqozz� .|}� {oz.6\\7<.Ozz.u� }� ~�.w|. � vs.`o{wu.s� .oz<?B.�� � r� .

� sqsw� sr.~� s� � so� {s|� .o��s��{s|� .o|r.o.~}�� � � so� {s|� .o��s��{s|� .

ot� s� . � vs.^R;b.u� }� ~.vor.q}{~zs� sr.Zadb».o|r.ouow|.o� .o.D;{}|� v.

t}zz}� ;� ~.s� oz� o� w}|<.[so�� � s�.}t. � }qoz.z}� r|s��.� s� s.q}zzsq� sr.t}� .

o|oz� �w�.}|.o.�� �� ow|sr. � }� sz:. � sorw|u.~o��ous:.{}|}z}u� s:.o|r.

~wq� � � s.rs�q� w~� w}|<.bvs.^R;b.u� }� ~.�v}� sr.�wu|wtwqo|� .w|q� so�s�.w|.

�}� |r.~� s��� � s.zs� sz.6a^Z7.t� }{.~� s;. � }.~}�� ;Zadb».o|r.t� }{.po�s;

zw|s. � }.D;{}|� v.t}zz}� ;� ~<.bvs.w|� s�� wuo� }� �.q}|qz� rsr. � vo� .Zadb».

� o�.o|.sttsq� w� s. � � so� {s|� .t}� .rsq� so�sr. � }qoz.w|� s|�w� � .o��}qwo� sr.

� w� v.W^R<.]� � q}{s�.t� }{.� vs.^R;b.u� }� ~.w|.� vs.�� � r� .p� .`o{wu.o|r.

q}zzsou� s�.rszw� s� sr.w|. � vs.toqs;� };toqs.q}|rw� w}|. � s� s. � �sr.o�. � vs.

q}{~o� w�}|.u� }� ~.t}� .� vs.~� s�s|� .�� � r� <.

bvw�.�� � r� . � s~zwqo� sr.� vs.`o{wu.s� .oz<.�� � r� .o�.qz}�sz� .o�.~}��wpzs.

o|r.� �sr.� vs.�o{s.{so�� � s�.}t. � }qoz.w|� s|�w� � .{so�� � sr.w|.rsqwpsz�.

6rP7<.P}� v. � vs.~� s�s|� .�� � r� .o|r. � vs.`o{wu.s� .oz<.�� � r� .q}zzsq� sr.

{so�� � s�.}t. � }qoz.w|� s|�w� � .}|.o.�� �� ow|sr. � }� sz:. � sorw|u.~o��ous:.

{}|}z}u� s:.o|r.~wq� � � s.rs�q� w~� w}|<.T}� . � vs.~� s�s|� .�� � r� :. � vs.|� zz.

v� ~}� vs�w�.� o�.� vo� .� vs� s.� }� zr.ps.�wu|wtwqo|� .rwtts� s|qs�.w|.� vs.}� � ;

q}{s.{so�� � s�.}t.Zadb».rszw� s� sr.� wo.� wrs}~v}|s�.q}{~o� sr.� }.� vs.

^R;b.u� }� ~.rs�q� wpsr.p� .`o{wu.s� .oz<?B.bvo� .w�:.wt.� wrs}~v}|s.rszw� s� � .

� o�.o�.sttsq� w� s.o�.toqs;� };toqs.rszw� s� � .}t.Zadb»:.� vs|.� vs.� s�� z� �.}t.

p}� v.� � so� {s|� �.� }� zr.ps.�w{wzo� <.

W|.orrw� w}|:.po�sr.}|. � vs. � sq}{{s|ro� w}|�.}t.Po�v�v� � :. � vo� .

~� }u� o{.s� oz� o� w}|.}t. � szsvsoz� v.w|qz� rs.o.q}�� ;ps|stw� .o|oz� �w�.t}� .

~� }� wrs� �:.qzws|� �:.~o� s� �:.o|r.�}qws� � :?E.� vw�.�� � r� .� o�.zw{w� sr.� }.q}�� ;

ps|stw� .t}� .qzws|� �.}|z� <.Q}�� ;ps|stw� �. � s� s.qozq� zo� sr.p� .q}{~o� w|u.

� vs. � w{s.o|r.{}|s� .�o� sr. � �w|u. � wrs}~v}|s. � vs� o~� . � }. � vs.oq� � oz.

q}�� .}t. � � orw� w}|oz. � � so� {s|� <.O|.orrw� w}|oz.{so�� � s.o��s��sr.qzws|� .

�o� w�toq� w}|.� w� v.� wrs}~v}|s.rszw� s� � .}t.�~ssqv.� vs� o~� <

Nbufsjbmt!boe!Nfuipetc~}|.o~~� }� oz.t� }{.}� � .c|w� s� �w� � . W|�� w� � � w}|oz.`s� ws� .P}o� r:.

@B.w|rw� wr� oz�.6@@.{ozs�:[email protected]{ozs�7. � s� s. � sq� � w� sr.t}� . � vw�.�� � r� <.

^o� � wqw~o|� �. � s� s.rwou|}�sr. � w� v.W^R.p� .o.|s� � }z}uw�� .o|r. � w� v.

v� ~}yw|s� wq.r� �o� � v� wo.p� .o.�~ssqv£zo|u� ous.~o� v}z}uw�� <.`}� � w|s.

zo� � |usoz.o��s��{s|� �.� s� s.q}{~zs� sr.}|.ozz.~o� � wqw~o|� �.p� .� vs.tw� �� .

o� � v}� .o|r.� s� ws� sr.p� .o.p}o� r;qs� � wtwsr.}� }zo� � |u}z}uw�� .w|.}� rs� .� }.

� � zs.}� � . � }qoz.t}zr.~o� v}z}u� . � vo� .{wuv� .q}|� � ow|rwqo� s.Zadb»<.bvs.

rs{}u� o~vwq.w|t}� {o� w}|.}t.~o� � wqw~o|� �.� v}.q}{~zs� sr.� vw�.�� � r� .w�.

�� {{o� w� sr.w|.Ubcmf!2<

bvs.~� s� s�� .o|r.~}�� � s�� .o��s��{s|� �.o|r.~� }qsr� � s�. � �sr.p� .

`o{wu.s� .oz<?B. � s� s. � s~zwqo� sr<.`sq}� rw|u�.}t. � }qoz. w|� s|�w� � .}t.o.

�� �� ow|sr.� }� sz:.� sorw|u.~o��ous:.{}|}z}u� s:.o|r.~wq� � � s.rs�q� w~� w}|.

� s� s.}p� ow|sr.w|.o.�}� |r;� � so� sr.� }}{<.R� � w|u.soqv.~� }ps.� o�y:. � vs.

tw� �� .o� � v}� .� sq}� rsr.�}� |r.~� s��� � s.zs� sz.6a^Z7.t� }{.� vs.rwuw� oz.vo|r;

vszr.�}� |r.zs� sz.{s� s� <.O|.w|� su� o� sr.o� s� ous.6a^Z7. � o�.qozq� zo� sr.

t}� .� vs�s.� o�y�.� �w|u.rwuw� oz.}� � ~� � .}t.� vs.�}� |r.zs� sz.{s� s� .~zoqsr.A>.

q{.t� }{.~o� � wqw~o|� �� .{}� � v�<.bvs.rwuw� oz.�}� |r.zs� sz.{s� s� . � o�.�s� .

Page 3: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

54;6$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$HIGIQFIV$644<

XMRHEPP$IX$EP2

XS!FZJVFLJ!XMJ!XSXFP!IYVFXNSR!SK!XMJ!WTJJHM!WNLRFP'!?SYRI!PJZJP!QJXJVW!

YWJI!NR!XMNW!WXYI]%!TYVHMFWJI!KVSQ!>FINS!?MFHO%![JVJ!:SIJP!++&*(--!

4NLNXFP&4NWTPF]!?SYRI!PJZJP!QJXJVW!XMFX!VJFI!-(!XS!)*.I2!?<9!#>FINS!

?MFHO!3SVTSVFXNSR%!6SVX!CSVXM%!@D$'!

<VJ&!FRI!TSWXQJFWYVJW!SK!NRXJRWNX]!SK!ZS[JP!TVSPSRLFXNSR%!VJFINRL!

TFWWFLJ%!QSRSPSLYJ%!FRI!TNHXYVJ!IJWHVNTXNSR![JVJ!VJHSVIJI!KFHJ!XS!

KFHJ!NR!XMJ!HPNRNH!KNZJ!XNQJW0!XMVJJ!XNQJW!FKXJV!XMJ!NRNXNFP!JZFPYFXNSR!

[NXMNR!*![JJOW!GJKSVJ!XMJ!WXFVX!SK!XVJFXQJRX%!FRI!X[NHJ!YTSR!HSQTPJ&

XNSR!SK!XVJFXQJRX'!@MJ!XMVJJ!NRNXNFP!GFWJPNRJ!TVSGJW![JVJ!HSQTPJXJI!SR!

*!WJTFVFXJ!IF]W'!<SWXXVJFXQJRX!TVSGJW![JVJ!HSPPJHXJI![NXMNR!)![JJO!

FKXJV!XMJ!PFWX!XVJFXQJRX!WJWWNSR!FRI![JVJ!HSQTPJXJI!NR!)!IF]'!@MJ!

IFXF![NXMNR!JFHM!JZJRX![JVJ!FZJVFLJI!KSV!JFHM!TFVXNHNTFRX!FRI!YWJI!

KSV!WXFXNWXNHFP!FRFP]WNW'!1LFNR%!XMJWJ!TVSHJIYVJW![JVJ!HSRWNWXJRX![NXM!

XMSWJ!NR!XMJ!>FQNL!JX!FP'!WXYI]'),

ARPNOJ!XMJ!>FQNL!JX!FP'!WXYI]%!FX!XMJ!HSRHPYWNSR!SK!XMJVFT]%!TFVXNHN&

TFRXW![JVJ!FWOJI!XS!HSQTFVJ!HSWXW!SK!F!ZNIJSTMSRJ!WTJJHM!XMJVFT]!

WJWWNSR!XS!F!KFHJ&XS&KFHJ!HPNRNH!WTJJHM!XMJVFT]!WJWWNSR'!3SWXW!NRHPYIJI!

XNQJ!FRI!QSRJ]!J\TJRIJI!KSV!WJWWNSRW!YRIJV!JFHM!HSRINXNSR'!;XMJV!

QSRJXFV]!HSWXW!NRHPYIJI!WYHM!NXJQW!FW!TYVHMFWNRL!F!QJFP!SV!WRFHO%!

TF]NRL!F!IVNZJV%!SV!TF]NRL!F!GFG]WNXXJV'!1IINXNSRFPP]%!XMJ!@JPJQJINHNRJ!

?FXNWKFHXNSR!=YJWXNSRRFNVJ!#@?=$)/![FW!FIQNRNWXJVJI!FX!XMJ!HSRHPYWNSR!

SK!XVJFXQJRX'

4YVNRL!XMJ!XVJFXQJRX!TMFWJ%!TFVXNHNTFRXW!YWJI!XMJ!@JPJZ]SY!@B!

-((?<e!#8:51%!?FR!4NJLS%!31$!NRWXFPPJI!NR!XMJNV!MSQJW!XS!VJHJNZJ!

XMJVFT]'!@MJ!@B!-((?<e!NW!IJWNLRJI!XS!FZSNI!HSQTPNHFXJI!NRWXFPPFXNSR!

TVSHJIYVJW'!2]!HSRRJHXNRL!XMNW!TVSIYHX!XS!F!TS[JV!SYXPJX!WSYVHJ!FRI!

WXFRIFVI!XJPJTMSRJ!PNRJ%!F!HSPSV!ZNIJSTMSRJ!HFPP!HSYPI!GJ!QFIJ'!@MJ!

ZNIJSTMSRJ!YWJW!FRFPSLYJ!QSIJQ!XJHMRSPSL]!XMFX!HSRRJHXW!XS!TPFNR!

SPI!XJPJTMSRJ!WJVZNHJ!#<;@?$'!@MJ!YWJ!FRI!HSRRJHXNSR!ZNF!QSIJQ!

FVJ!WNQNPFV!XS!QJXMSIW!YWJI!KSV!KF\!QFHMNRJ!XVFRWQNWWNSR'!@MJ!@B!

-((?<e!YWJW!7'+*,!WXFRIFVI!XJHMRSPSL]!KSV!STJVFXNSRFP!TVSXSHSP'!

@VFRWQNXXNRL!ZSNHJ!FRI!ZNIJS!SZJV!<;@?!PNRJW!NW!ORS[R!FW!PS[!GNX&

VFXJ!XJPJHSQQYRNHFXNSRW'!@MJ!TVSIYHX!NW!IJWNLRJI!XS!HFTXYVJ!HSPSV!

ZNIJS!FRI!ZSNHJ!G]!HSQTVJWWNRL!XMJ!WNLRFPW!XS!FPPS[!XVFRWQNWWNSR!

SZJV!WXFRIFVI!XJPJTMSRJ!PNRJW'!@MJ!ZNIJSTMSRJcW!RFXNZJ!WNLRFPW!FVJ!

XSS!PFVLJ!XS!KNX!NRXS!XMJ!<;@?!TMSRJ!PNRJ!FRI!FVJ!RSX!STXNQN^JI!KSV!

FHHJTXFGPJ!HFPP!UYFPNX]'!@MJ!ZNIJSTMSRJ!YWJW!WTJHNFPN^JI!QJXMSIW!

FRI!IJZNHJW!HFPPJI!3;453W!XS!HSQTVJWW!FRI!STXNQN^J!XMJ!WNLRFPW!

KSV!XVFRWQNWWNSR!SZJV!<;@?!TMSRJ!PNRJW!XS!F!VJHJNZNRL!ZNIJSTMSRJ'!

@MJ!VJHJNZNRL!ZNIJSTMSRJ!FHHJTXW!XMJ!HSQTVJWWJI!WNLRFPW!FRI!XMJR!

IJHSQTVJWWJW!XMJ!WFQJ!WNLRFP!KSV!STXNQFP!TJVKSVQFRHJ!SR!XMJ!VJHJNZ&

NRL!ZNIJSTMSRJ'!?JJ!#&%('$!"!KSV!F!VJTVJWJRXFXNSR!SK!XMJ!@B-((?<e!

ZNIJSTMSRJ'

1X!XMJ!GJLNRRNRL!SK!JFHM!XVJFXQJRX!WJWWNSR%!TFVXNHNTFRXW![JVJ!

HFPPJI!YWNRL!XMJ!@JPJZ]SY!-((?<e!ZNIJSTMSRJ'!1KXJV!F!ZNIJS!HSR&

RJHXNSR![FW!JWXFGPNWMJI%!TFVXNHNTFRXW!TSWNXNSRJI!F!WSYRI!PJZJP!QJXJV!

WS!NX!HSYPI!GJ!VJFI!G]!XMJ!NRZJWXNLFXSV!SZJV!XMJ!ZNIJSTMSRJ'!1KXJV!

JWXFGPNWMNRL!XMJ!HSRRJHXNSR%!FPP!XVJFXQJRX!KSPPS[NRL!XMJ!WXFRIFVIW!

KSV!9?B@e!FRI![FW!IJPNZJVJI!G]!HJVXNKNJI!HPNRNHNFRW'!@VJFXQJRX!GJLFR!

[NXM!XMJ!KNVWX!XFWO%!QF\NQYQ!IYVFXNSR!SK!F!WYWXFNRJI!ZS[JP'!6SV!XMNW!

XFWO%!TFVXNHNTFRXW![JVJ!NRWXVYHXJI!XS!`XFOJ!F!IJJT!GVJFXM!FRI!WF]!bFMc!

KSV!FW!PSRL!FRI!PSYI!FW!]SY!HFR'a!

@MNW!XFWO![FW!TJVKSVQJI!)-!XNQJW!IYVNRL!JFHM!XVJFXQJRX!WJWWNSR'!

6SV!XMJ!RJ\X!XFWO%!QF\NQYQ!KYRIFQJRXFP!KVJUYJRH]%!TFVXNHNTFRXW!

TVSIYHJI!`FMa!FX!XMJNV!MNLMJWX!FRI!PS[JWX!TNXHMJW!)-!XNQJW!JFHM'!@MJ!

134<7!$"!'7=?9A3@:;5!*>8?A=3C;?>!8?A!.3AC;5;@3>CB!*>5<D676!;>!C:7!0CD6E

.%/1*&*.%,1! )(,'(/ %)( 2(%/0!.#- &*' ++0(

& 5 ++ ' .) '-

' 5 ,' ' &%% ',

( 5 ,& ( .. (%

) 5 +, ' &%% (%

* 5 ,* ( &%% (%

+ 3 *. * &%% '*

, 5 ,, * &%% (%

- 5 +) & &%% (%

. 5 ,' * .( '+

&% 5 ,* ( &%% '.

&& 5 ,* ) .( '-

&' 5 +) ) &%% '.

&( 5 ,& ( .. (%

&) 5 +( ( ., '-

&* 5 ,+ ( &%% '.

&+ 5 ,( + &%% '.

&, 5 ,+ ( &%% '.

&- 5 -) ( ., (%

&. 5 -& & &%% (%

'% 5 ,, + .' (%

'& 5 *' & &%% (%

'' 5 -) & .. '*

'( 3 +* * &%% ',

') 5 *( ( .. '+

7$6"!CBEFBAE;F/!041"!0;AFD9?!4AEF>FGF;!<BD!F=;!1;9<!E;AF;A:;E'&/!5582"!5>A>!5;AF9?!

8F9F;!2H9@>A9F>BA#''

KMEA, Gilmanton, NH

Page 4: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

¬$QEV]$ERR$ PMIFIVX0$ MRG2$$ � $$ZSP2$58$$RS2$54$$ � $$HIGIQFIV$ 644<$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$54;7

ZMHISTLSRI1HIPMZIVIH$ZSMGI$XLIVET]

uijse!ubtl-!qsbdujdf!pg!gvodujpobm!tqffdi!mpveoftt!esjmmt-!xbt!bddpn.

qmjtife!cz!ibwjoh!qbsujdjqbout!qspevdf!21!gvodujpobm!qisbtft0tfo.

ufodft!evsjoh!fbdi!tfttjpo/!Uiftf!qisbtft!boe!tfoufodft!xfsf!dpn.

qptfe!cz!fbdi!qbsujdjqbou!qsjps!up!uifsbqz!gps!vtf!jo!uifjs!joejwjevbm!

ebjmz!dpowfstbujpo/!Uifz!sfbe!fbdi!qisbtf0tfoufodf!6!ujnft!fbdi/!Jo!

beejujpo!up!21!gvodujpobm!qisbtft-!uif!qspupdpm!gps!MTWU®!jotusvdut!

dmjojdjbot!up!qspwjef!beejujpobm!xpset!uif!gjstu!xffl-!tfoufodft!uif!

tfdpoe!xffl-!qbsbhsbqi!sfbejoh!uif!uijse!xffl-!boe!dpowfstbujpo!

uif!gpvsui!xffl!jo!b!ubtl!uibu!fodpvsbhft!mpve!tqffdi!xifo!qspevd.

joh!uiftf!tujnvmvt!jufnt/!Qbsujdjqbout!xfsf!fodpvsbhfe!up!dpnqmfuf!

ipnfxpsl!bttjhonfout!fbdi!ebz!evsjoh!uif!dpvstf!pg!usfbunfou/!

Bgufs!27!pof.ipvs!tqffdi!uifsbqz!usfbunfout!xfsf!dpnqmfufe!pwfs!b!

5.xffl!ujnf!gsbnf-!qbsujdjqbout!sfuvsofe!up!uif!tqffdi!dmjojd!xjuijo!

2!xffl!up!voefshp!uxp!qptuusfbunfou!ebub!dpmmfdujpot!bt!qsfwjpvtmz!

eftdsjcfe/!

SftvmutPof!qvsqptf!pg!uif!qsftfou!tuvez!xbt!up!dpnqbsf!pvudpnft!pg!

uijt!tuvez!up!qvcmjtife!ebub!pg!uif!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!tuvez/25!Qsjps!up!

bobmztjt-! uif!frvjwbmfodf!pg! uif!hspvq!gspn!uijt!tuvez!boe!uif!

QE.U!hspvq!jo!uif!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!tuvez!po!bhf-!ujnf!gspn!potfu!pg!

JQE!ejbhoptjt-!boe!qsfusfbunfou!nfbot!pg!wpdbm!ubtlt!xfsf!dpn.

qbsfe/!B!pof.tbnqmf!u!uftu!vtfe!uif!bhhsfhbuf!ebub!sfqpsufe!cz!

Sbnjh!fu!bm/25!gps!dpnqbsjtpo!up!uif!ebub!dpmmfdufe!jo!uijt!tuvez/!

Uxfouz.gpvs! joejwjevbmt!jo!uijt!tuvez! )33!nbmft-!3!gfnbmft*!ibe!

b!nfbo!bhf!pg!81/6!±!9/6/!Jo!dpnqbsjtpo-!uif!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!tuvez!

jodmvefe!gpvsuffo!qbsujdjqbout! )8!nbmft-!8!gfnbmft*!xjui!b!nfbo!

bhf!pg!78/:!±!:/1/!

Cfdbvtf!uif!fggfdu!pg!hfoefs!po!wpdbm!ubtlt!xbt!gpvoe!up!cf!jotjh.

ojgjdbou!cz!Sbnjh!fu!bm/-!ebub!jo!uif!qsftfou!tuvez!xfsf!qppmfe!xjui.

pvu!sfhbse!up!hfoefs-!bt!xbt!epof!cz!qsfwjpvt!sftfbsdifst/!Uif!pof.

tbnqmf!u!uftu!gbjmfe!up!jefoujgz!boz!tjhojgjdbou!ejggfsfodft!cfuxffo!

uif!nfbo!bhf!pg!qbsujdjqbout!jo!uijt!tuvez!boe!uif!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!tuvez!

)u)47*!>!1/98-!q!=!1/49*/!Uifsf!xfsf-!ipxfwfs-!tjhojgjdbou!ejggfsfodft!

)u)47*!>!5/13-!q!?!1/12*!jo!uif!nfbo!ujnf!qptupotfu!pg!JQE!ejbhoptjt!

gps!qbsujdjqbout!jo!uijt!tuvez!)4/3!±!2/6!zfbst*!dpnqbsfe!up!uif!Sbnjh!

fu!bm/!tuvez!)9/7!±!7/4!zfbst*/!Uijt!ejggfsfodf!dbo!cf!fyqmbjofe!cz!gpvs!

pvumjfst!jo!uif!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!tuvez!uibu!xfsf!npsf!uibo!26!zfbst!qbtu!

JQE!ejbhoptjt/

Qsfusfbunfou!dpnqbsjtpot!pg!uif!sftvmut!sfqpsufe!cz!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!

up!uif!qsftfou!tuvez!xfsf!dpnqmfufe!vtjoh!b!pof.tbnqmf!u!uftu!up!

fybnjof!nfbot!pg!wpdbm!ubtlt!cfuxffo!uif!uxp!hspvqt/!Uiftf!qsf.

usfbunfou!dpnqbsjtpot!bsf!qsftfoufe!jo!Ubcmf!3/!Bt!joejdbufe!jo!Ubcmf!

3-!uifsf!xfsf!op!tjhojgjdbou!ejggfsfodft!cfuxffo!uif!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!ebub!

boe!ebub!gspn!uijt!tuvez!po!b!qspmpohfe!wpxfm-!sfbejoh!qbttbhf-!

npopmphvf-!boe!qjduvsf!eftdsjqujpo/!

Up!fybnjof!qsfuftu!up!qptuuftu!dibohft!jo!uif!nfbtvsft!pg!eC!gps!

wpxfm!qspmpohbujpo-!sfbejoh!qbttbhf-!qjduvsf!eftdsjqujpo-!boe!npop.

mphvf-!b!qbjsfe!tbnqmft!u!uftu!xbt!jnqmfnfoufe!vtjoh!uif!nfbot!up!

jowftujhbuf!xifuifs!uifsf!xfsf!tubujtujdbmmz!tjhojgjdbou!jnqspwfnfout!

jo!wpdbm!mpveoftt!bttpdjbufe!xjui!wjefpqipof.efmjwfsfe!MTWU®/!B!

Cpogfsspoj!dpssfdujpo!xbt!bqqmjfe!up!uif!bmqib!mfwfmt!up!dpouspm!gps!

uif!qpttjcjmjuz!pg!b!uzqf!J!fssps!cz!ejwjejoh!uif!gbnjmz.xjtf!fssps!sbuf!

pg!1/16!cz!uif!ovncfs!pg!uftut!qfsgpsnfe-!jo!uijt!dbtf!5/!Uivt-!uif!

bekvtufe!"!mfwfm!xbt!1/1236!gps!uif!bobmztjt/!Sftvmut!pg!uijt!bobmztjt-!

Ubcmf!3/!Qsfusfbunfou!Nfbot!pg!Wpdbm!Joufotjuz!)eC*!pg!Sbnjh!fu!bm/25!Tbnqmf!jo!Bhhsfhbuf!Gpsn!Dpnqbsfe!up!Qsfusfbunfou!Nfbot!pg!uif!Qsftfou!Tuvez

UBTLSBNJH!FU!BM/

QSFTFOU!TUVEZ EJGG !WBMVF !WBMVF

0b0 7:/2!)6/2* 81/8!)5/5* � 2/7 !2/8: =!1/1:

Sfbe 82/4!)4/3* 7:/7!)4/4* !2/8 � 3/47 =!1/14

Npop 7:/1!)5/7* 78/9!)5/2* !2/3 � 2/44 =!1/31

Qjy 79/:!)5/7* 78/3!)5/:* !2/8 � 2/71 =!1/23

Sfbe-!sfbejoh!qbttbhf<!npop-!npopmphvf<!qjy-!qjduvsf!eftdsjqujpo/!

Opuft;!Gps!bmm!u!uftut!sfqpsufe!bcpwf!xjui!uif!pcubjofe!q!wbmvft!fwbmvbufe!bhbjotu!uif!bekvtufe!"!mfwfm!pg!1/1236!jo!psefs!up!cf!dpotjefsfe!tubujtujdbmmz!tjhojgjdbou/

Gjh/!2/!Ufmfwzpv!UW!611TQ®!)LNFB-!Tbo!Ejfhp-!DB*!vtfe!jo!uijt!tuvez/(KMEA, Gilmanton, NH)

Page 5: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

54;8$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$HIGIQFIV$644<

XMRHEPP$IX$EP2

~� s�s|� sr.w|.Ubcmf!4:. � s� sozsr.�� o� w�� wqozz� .�wu|wtwqo|� .w|q� so�s�.t}� .

~� s� � so� {s|� .o|r.~}�� � � so� {s|� .{so|�.}t.~� }z}|usr. � }� [email protected].

?B<G:.q.J.><>?7:. � sorw|[email protected]<B:!q.J.><>?7:.{}|}z}u� [email protected].

D<>:.q.J.><>?7:.o|r.~wq� � � s.rs�q� w~� w}|.� o�y�[email protected]<@:.q.J.><>?7.t}� .

� vs.~� s�s|� .�� � r� <.

b}.� s� wt� . � vs.�� o� w�� wqoz.~}� s� .}t. � vs.~� s� s�� .o|r.~}�� � s�� .qvo|us�.

o|r.� }.� �s.� vs.{}�� .� wu}� }� �.� s�� .}t.o.~� s� s�� .o|r.~}�� � s�� .rs�wu|:.o|.

o|oz� �w�.}t.q}� o� wo|qs.6O\Q]dO7.� o�.q}|r� q� sr<.bvs.~� s� s�� .{so|�.

� s� s.s|� s� sr.o�. � vs.q}� o� wo� s.o|r. � vs.~}�� � s�� .{so|�.o�. � vs.rs~s|;

rs|� . � o� wopzs<.bvw�.�� o� w�� wqoz.~� }qsr� � s.szw{w|o� s�. � vs. � o� wo|qs.r� s.

� }.� s~so� sr.� s�� w|u.o|r.o|� .}� s� zo~.}t.� vs.{so�� � s�.t� }{.� vs.o|oz� �w�.

o|r.� vs|.qozq� zo� s�.o.� s�� .}t.rwtts� s|qs�<?G.ew� v.O\Q]dO:.a^aa.vo�.

o.tso� � � s.t}� .qozq� zo� w|u.�� o� w�� wqoz.~}� s� .� vo� .� o�.� �sr.� }.qzo� wt� .� vs.

}� s� ozz.~}� s� .}t.� vs.�� � r� .� }.rs� sq� .rwtts� s|qs�<.

c�w|u.O\Q]dO:.� vs.sttsq� .}t.rP.qvo|us.}t.~� }z}|usr. � }� sz. � o�.

t}� |r.� }.ps.�wu|wtwqo|� .6G i?:@@k.K.?G<D?:.q.J.><>?:.~o� � woz.#@.K.><BE7<.

[so|.qvo|us.w|.rP.}t.� sorw|u.~o��ous.� o�.oz�}.t}� |r.� }.ps.�wu|wtw;

qo|� .6Gi?:@@k.K.?A<AC:.q.J.><>?:.~o� � woz.#@.K.><AF7<.T}� .{}|}z}u� s:.

{so|.qvo|us.w|.rP.~}�� � � so� {s|� . � o�.�wu|wtwqo|� .o�. � szz.6Gi?:@@k.K.

@F<@@:.q.J.><>?:.~o� � woz.#@.K.><CD7<.bvs.{so|.qvo|us.w|.rP.}t.~wq� � � s.

rs�q� w~� w}|.� o�.oz�}.�wu|wtwqo|� .6Gi?:@@k.K.C<@?:.q.J.><>A:.~o� � woz.#@.K.

><?G7<.Ubcmf!5.rw�~zo� �.� vs�s.� s�� z� �<

bvs.}p� ow|sr.ro� o.t� }{. � wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr.Zadb». � s� s.q}{;

~o� sr. � w� v. � vs.~� pzw�vsr.{so|�.}t. � vs.`o{wu.s� .oz<?B.�� � r� . � �w|u.

}|s;�o{~zs.u.� s�� �.� }.s� oz� o� s.� s�� z� �.}p� ow|sr.� |rs� .� vs.� � }.rszw� s� � .

q}|rw� w}|�<.bvs.qvo|us.�q}� s�.t� }{.~� s� s�� .� }.~}�� � s�� .w|.rP.}t.� }� sz.

~� }z}|uo� w}|:. � sorw|u.~o��ous:.{}|}z}u� s:.o|r.~wq� � � s.rs�q� w~� w}|.

� s� s.q}{~o� sr. � }. � vs.{so|.qvo|us.�q}� s�. � s~}� � sr.p� .`o{wu.s� .

oz<?B.bvs.}|s;�o{~zs.u. � s�� . w�.o. � s�� .}t.o.v� ~}� vs�w�.op}� � .o.�w|uzs.

~}~� zo� w}|.{so|.� vs|.� vs.~}~� zo� w}|.� o� wo|qs.w�.� |y|}� |:.p� � . � vs.

{so|.�q}� s. w�.y|}� |<@>.T}� .soqv.o|oz� �w�. � vs|:. � vs.{so|.qvo|us.

�q}� s. � s~}� � sr.p� .`o{wu.s� .oz<. � o�.s|� s� sr.o�. � vs. � s�� .�q}� s¡.o|r.

� vs.qvo|us.�q}� s.w|.� vs.� wrs}~v}|s.q}|rw� w}|.� o�.s|� s� sr.o�.� vs.� s�� .

� o� wopzs<.bvs�s.o|oz� �s�. � s�� sr. � vs.v� ~}� vs�s�. � vo� . � vs. � wrs}~v}|s.

q}|rw� w}|.� }� zr.~� }r� qs.�w{wzo� .w{~� }� s{s|� �.w|.� }qoz.qo~oqw� � .o�.

� s~}� � sr.w|.� vs.toqs;� };toqs.� � so� {s|� .q}|rw� w}|<

`s�� z� �.}t. � vs.q}{~o� w�}|.o� s.~� s�s|� sr.w|.Ubcmf!6:. w|rwqo� w|u.

� vo� .qvo|us.w|.rP.zs� sz�.}|.~� }z}|usr.� }� [email protected].><>F:.q.J.><GA7:.

� sorw|u.~o��[email protected].#?<?A:.q.J.><@E7:.o|r.~wq� � � s.rs�q� w~� w}|.

[email protected].><CC:.q.J.><CG7. � s� s.|}� .�� o� w�� wqozz� .rwtts� s|� <.bvs� s. � o�.o.

�wu|wtwqo|� .rwtts� s|qs.w|. � vs.{so|.qvo|us.}|. � vs.{}|}z}u� s. � o�y.

ps� � ss|.� vs.`o{wu.s� .oz<.�� � r� .o|r.� vs.~� s�s|� .�� � r� [email protected].#A<?@:.q.

J.><>?7<.bvs�s.� s�� z� �.ozz}� .� �.� }.� sxsq� .� vs.|� zz.v� ~}� vs�w�.t}� .� }� sz.

~� }z}|uo� w}|:.� sorw|u.~o��ous:.o|r.~wq� � � s.rs�q� w~� w}|.o|r.� vs� st}� s.

Ubcmf!4/!Nfbo!boe!Tuboebse!Efwjbujpo!)jo!qbsfouiftft*!pg!eC!TQM!pg!Qsf.!boe!Qptuusfbunfou!pg!uif!Qsftfou!Tuvez!Ebub!Evsjoh!Tvtubjofe!Qipobujpo!0b0!

UBTLQSF!EC!)TE*

QPTU!EC!)TE*

NFBO!EJGG!)TE* EG !WBMVF !WBMVF

0b0 81/8!)5/5* 95/1!)7/1* 24/4!)5/49* 34 25/: =!/12b

Sfbe 7:/7!)4/4* 86/6!)5/2* 6/9!)4/4* 34 !!9/5 =!/12b

Npop 78/9!)5/2* 82/6!)5/2* 4/7!)3/:* 34 !!7/1 =!/12b

Qjy 78/3!)5/:* 84/:!)4/3* 6/:!)5/7* 34 !!7/3 =!/12b

b!Tubujtujdbmmz!tjhojgjdbou!bt!uif!pcubjofe!q!wbmvf!jt!mftt!uibo!uif!bekvtufe!"!mfwfm!

pg!1/1236/Sfbe-!sbjocpx!qbttbhf<!npop-!npopmphvf<!qjy-!qjduvsf!eftdsjqujpo<!TE-!tuboebse!efwjbujpo/

Ubcmf!5/!BODPWB!pg!Nfbo!Dibohf!jo!eC!gspn!Qsfuftu!up!Qptuuftu

TPVSDF !WBMVF !WBMVFQBSUJBM!$!TRVBSFE

PCTFSWFE!QPXFS

Qsf!0b0 2 2:/73 1/12 1/58 1/:9

Qsf!sfbe 2 24/46 1/12 1/49 1/:5

Qsf!npop 2 39/33 1/12 1/67 2/11

Qsf!qjy 2 6/31 1/14 1/2: 1/69

Gps!bmm!u!uftut!sfqpsufe!bcpwf!xjui!uif!pcubjofe!q!wbmvft!fwbmvbufe!bhbjotu!uif!bekvtufe!"!mfwfm!pg!1/1236!jo!psefs!up!cf!dpotjefsfe!tubujtujdbmmz!tjhojgjdbou/

BODPWB-!bobmztjt!pg!dpwbsjbodf<!Qsf!0b0-!qspmpohfe!wpxfm<!Qsf!sfbe-!sfbejoh!qbttbhf<!Qsf!npop-!npopmphvf<!Qsf!qjy-!qjduvsf!eftdsjqujpo/

Ubcmf!6/!Pof.Tbnqmf! !Uftu!pg!Qptuusfbunfou!Dibohf!jo!eC!Mfwfmt!pg!Sbnjh!fu!bm/!boe!uif!Qsftfou!Tuvez!gps!0b0-!Sfbejoh!Qbttbhf-!Npopmphvf-!boe!Qjduvsf!Eftdsjqujpo

UBTLSBNJH!FU!BM/

QSFTFOU!TUVEZ !WBMVF !WBMVF

0b0 24/4!)7/53* 24/5!)5/49* 34 1/19 1/:4

Sfbe 7/7!)6/3* 6/9!)4/4* 34 � 2/24 1/38

Npop 6/6!)6/49* 4/7!)3/:* 34 � 4/23 1/12b

Qjy 6/5!)7/3:* 6/:!)5/7* 34 1/66 1/6:

b!Tubujtujdbmmz!tjhojgjdbou!bt!uif!pcubjofe!q!wbmvf!jt!mftt!uibo!uif!bekvtufe!"!mfwfm!pg!1/1236/

Gps!bmm!u!uftut!sfqpsufe!bcpwf!xjui!uif!pcubjofe!q!wbmvft!fwbmvbufe!bhbjotu!uif!bekvtufe!"!mfwfm!pg!1/1236!jo!psefs!up!cf!dpotjefsfe!tubujtujdbmmz!tjhojgjdbou/Sfbe-!sfbejoh!qbttbhf<!npop-!npopmphvf<!qjy-!qjduvsf!eftdsjqujpo/

Page 6: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

¬$QEV]$ERR$ PMIFIVX0$ MRG2$$ � $$ZSP2$58$$RS2$54$$ � $$HIGIQFIV$ 644<$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$54;9

ZMHISTLSRI1HIPMZIVIH$ZSMGI$XLIVET]

q}|qz� rs. � vo� . � wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr. � }wqs. � vs� o~� .w�.o�.sttsq� w� s.o�.

toqs;� };toqs. � � so� {s|� .}|. � vs�s. � o�y�<.V}� s� s� :. � vs.|� zz.v� ~}� vs�w�.

� o�.� s� ow|sr.t}� .{}|}z}u� s.w|.� vo� .� vs.̀ o{wu.s� .oz<.�� � r� .rwr.~� }r� qs.

u� so� s� .w{~� }� s{s|� �.t}� .� vw�.� s� poz.� o�y<

O.q}�� .o|oz� �w�. � o�.q}{~� � sr.p� .q}{~o� w|u.qzws|� ;� s~}� � sr.q}�� �.

w|.� w{s.o|r.{}|s� .}t.o.� � orw� w}|oz.�~ssqv.� vs� o~� .� w�w� .t}� .soqv.~o� ;

� wqw~o|� .� }.o.� wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr.� w�w� <.bvs.{so|.� w{s.w|� }z� sr.w|.o.

� wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr.�~ssqv.� vs� o~� .�s��w}|.� o�.?.v}� � .q}{~o� sr.� }.

o.{so|.}t.A<@.v}� � �.t}� .o.toqs;� };toqs.� w�w� <.[wzsous.t}� .o.� wrs}~v}|s.

� w�w� .� o�.� s� }.q}{~o� sr.� }.� vs.{so|.{wzsous.t}� .}|s.� � orw� w}|oz.� w�w� .

}t.?@B<?.{wzs�. � w� v.o. � s~}� � sr. � o|us.}t.><C. � }.A>>.{wzs�<.c�w|u. � vs.

W|� s� |oz.`s� s|� s.as� � wqs.6W`a7.qozq� zo� }� .t}� .{wzsous.}t.2><BF.~s� .

{wzs:. � vs.{so|.q}�� .}t.r� w� w|u.o. � svwqzs. � }� |r. � � w~. � }. � vs.qzw|wq.t}� .

}|s. � w�w� . � o�.2CG<CE. � w� v.o. � o|us.}t.2><@B. � }.2?BB<>><.]� vs� .q}�� �:.

�� qv.o�.{soz�:.� s� s.� s~}� � sr.� }.ps.� s� }.t}� .� vs.� wrs}~v}|s.� w�w� .o|r.

o|.o� s� ous.}t.2?D<F>.� w� v.o.� o|us.}t.2D<>>.� }.2AC<>>.t}� .o.� � orw� w}|oz.

� w�w� <.bv� �:.� vs.� }� oz.{so|.� w{s.o|r.{}|s� .o��}qwo� sr.� w� v.?D.� wrs};

~v}|s.� w�w� �.� o�.?D.v}� � �:.|}.{wzsous:.o|r.|}.}� vs� .q}�� �.q}{~o� sr.

� }. � � orw� w}|oz.rszw� s� � .}t.?D. � w�w� �.o� .C?.v}� � �.6w|qz� rw|u. � � o� sz.o|r.

� vs� o~� 7:.2GCA<>>.t}� .{wzsous:.o|r.2@DG<>>.t}� .}� vs� .q}�� �<.

^o� ws|� .�o� w�toq� w}|. � stzsq� �. � oz� s�.o|r.s� ~sq� o� w}|�. � suo� rw|u.

o�~sq� �.}t.vsoz� vqo� s<.bvs� st}� s:.o.{o� qv.ps� � ss|.qo� s.s� ~sq� sr.o|r.

qo� s.� sqsw� sr.� s�� z� �.w|.� �s� .�o� w�toq� w}|<?F.W|.� s�~}|�s.� }.� vs.|ssr.t}� .

� s�so� qv.w|. � vs.o� so.}t. � �s� .�o� w�toq� w}|:.gw~.o|r.q}zzsou� s�.rs� sz;

}~sr.o|r. � ozwro� sr.o. � �s� .�o� w�toq� w}|.w|�� � � {s|� :. � vs.bszs{srwqw|s.

ao� w�toq� w}|._� s�� w}||ow� s.6ba_7<.Ot� s� .rs� sz}~{s|� .}t. � vs.ba_:.gw~.

o|r.q}zzsou� s�?F. � �sr. � vw�.w|�� � � {s|� . � }.{so�� � s. � �s� .�o� w�toq� w}|.

� w� v.o.rwops� s�.sr� qo� w}|.~� }u� o{.or{w|w�� s� sr.� wo.� wrs}q}|ts� s|q;

w|u.s�� w~{s|� <.`s�� z� �.w|rwqo� sr.o.~}�w� w� s.q}� � szo� w}|.ps� � ss|.ba_.

o|r.�szt;� s~}� � sr.orvs� s|qs<.bvs. � s�so� qvs� �.q}|qz� rsr. � vo� . � szs;

{srwqw|s.s|q}� � ousr.{}� s.w|� s� oq� w}|.ps� � ss|.qzws|� �.o|r.vsoz� vqo� s.

~� }� wrs� �:.� v� �.~� }{}� w|u.q}{~zwo|qs<.

bvs.ba_.� o�.o~~zwsr.w|.� vw�.�� � r� <.bvw�.?B;w� s{.�� � � s� . � o�.q}{;

~zs� sr.p� .@A.}t.� vs.@B.~o� � wqw~o|� �.o� .� vs.q}{~zs� w}|.}t.� vs� o~� <.bvs.

ba_.w�.�q}� sr.}|.o.tw� s;~}w|� .�qozs. � vo� .o��s��s�.�o� w�toq� w}|.o|r.

� wzzw|u|s��. � }. � �s. � szsvsoz� v. � sqv|}z}u� .w|. � vs.t� � � � s<.`s�� z� �.}t.

� vw�.�� � � s� :.~� s�s|� sr.w|.Ubcmf!7:.w|rwqo� sr. � vo� .~o� � wqw~o|� �.w|. � vw�.

�� � r� . � s� s.vwuvz� .�o� w�twsr. � w� v. � wrs}~v}|s�.o�.o.{so|�.}t. � sqsw� ;

w|u.vsoz� vqo� s.�s� � wqs�. � w� v. � vs.vwuvs�� .�o� w�toq� w}|. � w� v. � vs.�o� w|u.

w|.� � o� sz.� w{s<.

Ejtdvttjpo^}�� � � so� {s|� . w{~� }� s{s|� �. � s� s.oqvws� sr.w|. � }qoz. w|� s|�w� � :.

rs{}|�� � o� sr.p� .�� o� w�� wqozz� .�wu|wtwqo|� . w|q� so�s�.w|.rP.zs� sz�.}t.

Ubcmf!7/!Nfbot!boe!Sbohft!pg!Fbdi!Jufn!po!uif!UTR29

JUFN NFBO

!!2/!!J!dbo!fbtjmz!ubml!up!nz!ifbmuidbsf!qspwjefs/ 34 5/76

!!3/!!J!dbo!ifbs!nz!ifbmuidbsf!qspwjefs!dmfbsmz/ 34 5/58

!!4/!!Nz!ifbmuidbsf!qspwjefs!jt!bcmf!up!voefstuboe!nz!ifbmuidbsf!dpoejujpo/ 34 5/68

!!5/!!J!dbo!tff!nz!ifbmuidbsf!qspwjefs!bt!jg!xf!nfu!jo!qfstpo/ 34 5/63

!!6/!!J!ep!opu!offe!bttjtubodf!xijmf!vtjoh!uif!tztufn/ 34 5/4:

!!7/!!J!gffm!dpngpsubcmf!dpnnvojdbujoh!xjui!nz!ifbmuidbsf!qspwjefs/ 34 5/89

!!8/!!J!uijol!uif!ifbmuidbsf!qspwjefe!wjb!ufmfnfejdjof!jt!dpotjtufou/ 34 5/72

!!9/!!J!pcubjo!cfuufs!bddftt!up!ifbmuidbsf!tfswjdft!cz!vtf!pg!ufmfnfejdjof/ 34 5/41

!!:/!!Ufmfnfejdjof!tbwft!nf!ujnf!usbwfmjoh!up!b!iptqjubm!ps!tqfdjbmjtu!dmjojd/ 34 5/94

21/!!J!ep!opu!sfdfjwf!befrvbuf!buufoujpo/ 34 2/68

22/!!Ufmfnfejdjof!qspwjeft!gps!nz!ifbmuidbsf!offe/ 34 5/37

23/!!J!gjoe!ufmfnfejdjof!bo!bddfqubcmf!xbz!up!sfdfjwf!ifbmuidbsf!tfswjdft/ 34 5/76

24/!!J!xjmm!vtf!ufmfnfejdjof!tfswjdft!bhbjo/ 34 5/81

25/!!Pwfsbmm-!J!bn!tbujtgjfe!xjui!uif!rvbmjuz!pg!tfswjdf!cfjoh!qspwjefe!wjb!ufmfnfejdjof/ 34 5/81

B!6.qpjou!tdbmf!xbt!vtfe!xjui!uif!gpmmpxjoh!wbmvft;!2!>!Tuspohmz!ejtbhsff-!3!>!Tpnfxibu!ejtbhsff-!4!>!Voefdjefe-!5!>!Tpnfxibu!bhsff-!6!>!Tuspohmz!bhsff/

Page 7: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

54;:$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$HIGIQFIV$644<

XMRHEPP$IX$EP2

~o� � wqw~o|� �.t}zz}� w|u. � wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr.Zadb»<.bvs.opwzw� � . � }.

sttsq� .�wu|wtwqo|� .qvo|us.t}� .w|rw� wr� oz�. � w� v.o. � }wqs.rw�}� rs� .o|r.

szw{w|o� s.� vs.|ssr.� }.� � o� sz.� }.o.v}�~w� oz.}� .qzw|wq.� v� }� uv.� szsvsoz� v.

� sqv|}z}u� .w�.o. � s� � .s|q}� � ouw|u.tw|rw|u.}t. � vw�.�� � r� <.W� .�� uus�� �.

� vo� .� szsvsoz� v.� sqv|}z}u� .{o� .s|opzs.w|rw� wr� oz�.� }.� sqsw� s.�s� � wqs�.

� v}.{wuv� .}� vs� � w�s.u}.� |� � so� sr<.

Q}{~o� sr. � }.`o{wu.s� .oz<:?B. � vs.{ou|w� � rs.}t.� vs.� � so� {s|� .sttsq� �.

t� }{.� vs.~� s�s|� .�� � r� .� s� s.�w{wzo� .s� qs~� .t}� .�wu|wtwqo|� z� .�{ozzs� .~}�� ;

� s�� .qvo|us.w|.w|� s|�w� � .r� � w|u.� vs.{}|}z}u� s<.[}|}z}u� s.�q}� s�.o� s.

rs�wu|sr.� }.ps.o.{so�� � s.}t.� }qoz.opwzw� ws�.o��}qwo� sr.� w� v.q}|� s� �o� w}|;

oz.�~ssqv<.Q}|� s� �o� w}|.� o�.� vs.{}�� .rwttwq� z� .o�~sq� .}t.� � so� {s|� .� �w|u.

� wrs}~v}|s�.r� s.� }.o.rszo� .}t. � vs.� w�� oz.�wu|oz.o|r.o� rw� }� � .tssrpoqy.

}|. � vs.� wrs}~v}|s.t}� .�}{s.~o� � wqw~o|� �<.Oz� v}� uv.{}�� .~o� � wqw~o|� �.

orx� �� sr.o|r.� s� s.opzs.� }.~o� � wqw~o� s.w|.q}|� s� �o� w}|:. � vw�. � ||o� � � oz¡.

q}|� s� �o� w}|oz.s� qvo|us.{o� .vo� s.rw{w|w�vsr.� vsw� .opwzw� � .� }.us|s� ozw� s.

t� }{.� vsw� .z}� rs� .� }wqs.� }.� �w|u.� vo� .z}� rs� .� }wqs.w|.q}|� s� �o� w}|<

[o|� .w|rw� wr� oz�.w|q� � .orrsr.q}�� �.� }.� sqsw� w|u.vsoz� vqo� s.o��}qw;

o� sr.� w� v.� � o|�~}� � o� w}|.� }.� sqsw� s.�s� � wqs�<.T}� .� v}�s.~s� �}|�.zw� w|u.

w|.� s{}� s.o|r.� |rs� �s� � sr.o� so�:. � vs.orrw� w}|oz.q}�� �.}t. � � o|�~}� � o;

� w}|.{o� .~� sqz� rs. � vs{.t� }{. � sqsw� w|u.|ssrsr.�s� � wqs�:.}� . � sr� qs.

oqqs��. � }.qo� s<.O�.rs{}|�� � o� sr.p� . � vw�.�� � r� :.~o� � wqw~o|� �. � }� zr.

vo� s.vor. � }.vo� s.r� w� s|.o�.{� qv.o�.A>>.{wzs�. � }� |r. � � w~.t}� .}|s.

�~ssqv. � vs� o~� . � w�w� <.bvs.q}�� .}t.uo�.{wzsous.o|r.~� � qvo�s.}t.{soz.

q}� zr.vo� s.q}�� .o�.{� qv.o�.2?EG<>><.evs|.{� z� w~zwsr.p� .?D:. � vs.

|� {ps� .}t.�~ssqv.� vs� o~� .� w�w� �.w|.Zadb»:.� vs.o� s� ous.q}�� .}t.� }� |r.

� � w~.{wzsous.t}� .� � orw� w}|oz.�~ssqv.� vs� o~� .� o�.qozq� zo� sr.o� .2GCA<>>.

o|r. � vs. � }� oz.|� {ps� .}t.v}� � �.qozq� zo� sr.o� .C?<><.bvs. � }� oz.q}�� .

�o� w|u�.w|. � w{s. � o�.AC.v}� � �.o|r.w|.{}|s� . � o�.2?:@@>:.q}�� �. � vo� .

o� s.|}� .� sw{p� � �opzs<.bvs�s.� }� oz�.� s~� s�s|� .}� � ;}t;~}qys� :.|}|� sw{;

p� � �opzs.s� ~s|�s�.t}� .w|rw� wr� oz�. � sqsw� w|u.�~ssqv. � vs� o~� <.T� � � � s.

� s�so� qv.{wuv� .oz�}.w|qz� rs.o|.o|oz� �w�.}t.q}�� ;ps|stw� . � }.~� }� wrs� �:.

t}� .s� o{~zs.w|.� sr� qw|u.� vs.|� {ps� .}t.�s��w}|. |}.�v}� �¡.}t.to{wzws�.

w|.� sr� qw|u.qo� suw� s� .p� � rs|.o�.� sq}{{s|rsr.p� .Po�v�v� � <?E

ao� w�toq� w}|.w�.o|.oqqs~� sr.w|rwqo� }� .}t.vsoz� vqo� s.�s� � wqs�<?F.evs|.

� vs� s.w�.o.{o� qv.ps� � ss|.qo� s.s� ~sq� sr.o|r.qo� s. � sqsw� sr:.~o� ws|� �.

vo� s.o.vwuv.zs� sz.}t.�o� w�toq� w}|<.Oz� v}� uv.�� o|ro� r.}� � q}{s.{so�� � s�.

o� s.q� w� wqoz. � }.uo� us. � vs.sttsq� .}t.o|.w|� s� � s|� w}|:.wt. � vs.w|� s� � s|� w}|.

w�. � |oqqs~� opzs.� }. � v}�s.� �w|u.� vs.�s� � wqs�:.� vs|.� vs.~� }u� o{.vo�.zs��.

� oz� s<.W|. � vw�.�� � r� :.~o� � wqw~o|� �:.}|.o� s� ous:. � s~}� � sr.{}rs� o� s. � }.

� s� � .�� � }|u.ou� ss{s|� .� w� v.ozz.w� s{�.{so�� � w|u.�o� w�toq� w}|<.bvs.rs{;

}|�� � o� sr.ps|stw� �.}t. � wrs}~v}|s�.q}� ~zsr.� w� v.vwuv. � �s� .�o� w�toq� w}|.

t� � � vs� .�� ~~}� � �.� vs.�� qqs��.}t.� szsvsoz� v.� sqv|}z}u� .�s� � wqs.rszw� s� � <.

O.� wrs}~v}|s.w|.� vs.v}{s.}t.o|.w|rw� wr� oz.� w� v.o.qv� }|wq.rw�so�s.

�� qv.o�.W^R.{o� .�s� � s.�s� s� oz.orrw� w}|oz.t� |q� w}|�.�� qv.o�.{}|w� }� ;

w|u.t}� .qvo|us�.w|.{srwqoz.�� o� � �<.dw�� oz.w|�~sq� w}|.}t. � vs.~� }u� s�;

�w}|.}t.� vw�.{}� s{s|� .rw�}� rs� .t� }{.v}{s.{o� .szw{w|o� s.s{s� us|q� .

� }}{.� w�w� �.}� :.oz� s� |o� w� sz� :.ozs� � .o.vsoz� vqo� s.~� }� wrs� . � vo� .o.toqs;

� };toqs.s|q}� |� s� .w�.|sqs��o� � <.

bvs� s.w�.o.|ssr. � }. � s~zwqo� s. � vs�s.tw|rw|u�. � w� v.}� vs� .u� }� ~�.}t.

w|rw� wr� oz�. � w� v.W^R.o|r. � }.rs� s� {w|s.wt. � vs.~}�w� w� s. � s�� z� �.}t. � vw�.

�� � r� .qo|.ps.s� � s|rsr.� }.}� vs� .�~ssqv.o|r.zo|u� ous.w{~ow� {s|� �:.o�.

� szz.o�.}� vs� . � sqv|}z}u� <.Stt}� � �.o� s.}|u}w|u. � }.rs� sz}~. � sqv|}z};

uws�. � vo� . � wzz.~� }� wrs.oqqs��. � }.vsoz� vqo� s.�s� � wqs�<.Q}{~� � s� ;po�sr.

~� }u� o{�. � �w|u. � vs.W|� s� |s� :.~s� �}|oz.rwuw� oz.o��w�� o|� �.6^RO7:.o|r.

q}{~� � s� w� sr. � � so� {s|� .~� }u� o{�.o� s.s� o{~zs�.}t. � szsvsoz� v. � sqv;

|}z}uws�. � vo� .{o� .ps. � �st� z.w|.w|q� so�w|u.oqqs��wpwzw� � .}t. � � so� {s|� .

� }.o.u� so� s� .|� {ps� .}t.w|rw� wr� oz�<.`wu}� }� �.w|� s�� wuo� w}|�.}t. � vs�s.

� sqv|}z}uws�.� }.~� }� wrs.}� .s|vo|qs.� � so� {s|� .o� s.|sqs��o� � .w|.}� rs� .

� }.s� o{w|s.� vsw� .sttwqoq� .o�.o.� }}z.� }.rszw� s� .vsoz� vqo� s<

bvs.� s�� z� �.}t.� vs.~� s�s|� .�� � r� .w|rwqo� sr.� vo� .� wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr.

�~ssqv. � vs� o~� .v}zr�. � vs.~� }{w�s.}t.s� ~o|rw|u.}~� w}|�.}t.rszw� s� � .

}t.�~ssqv.~o� v}z}u� .�s� � wqs�<.bvs.�wu|wtwqo|� .qvo|us.w|.~� s� � so� {s|� .

� }.~}�� � � so� {s|� .{so�� � s�.}t. � }qoz.z}� r|s��:.to� }� opzs.q}{~o� w�}|.

� }.~� pzw�vsr.}� � q}{s�.o|r.qzws|� .�o� w�toq� w}|. � w� v. � vs. � sqv|}z}u� .

q}{pw|s. � }.{oys. � wrs}~v}|s;rszw� s� sr. � vs� o~� .o|.sttsq� w� s.oz� s� ;

|o� w� s.{s� v}r.}t.�s� � wqs.rszw� s� � <.a~ssqv.~o� v}z}u� .�s� � wqs�.{o� .

ps. � szz;�� w� sr.t}� . � szsvsoz� v. � sqv|}z}u� I.vs|qs:.�~ssqv;zo|u� ous.

~o� v}z}uw�� �.z}}yw|u.t}� .oz� s� |o� w� s. � o� �. � }.~� }� wrs.sttsq� w� s:.zs��.

s� ~s|�w� s.qo� s.�v}� zr.q}|�wrs� .s� o{w|w|u. � szsvsoz� v. � sqv|}z}u� .o�.

o|.}~� w}|.t}� .w|rw� wr� oz�.� v}.� }� zr.}� vs� � w�s.� sqsw� s.zw{w� sr.}� .|}.

�~ssqv.� vs� o~� .�s� � wqs�<.

Bdlopxmfehnfoutes.o� s.� s� � .u� o� st� z.� }.R� <.X}v|.b<.azs� w|:.R� <.Vso� vs� .V<.e� wuv� :.

o|r.R� <.X}rszzs.T<.Rss{.t}� .� vsw� .vsz~.� w� v.|� {s� }� �.o�~sq� �.}t.� vw�.

�� � r� <.es.oz�}.� o|� .� }.� sq}u|w� s.� vs.� sqv|wqoz.o��w�� o|qs.~� }� wrsr.p� .

[wys.P� � |s�.t� }{.Y[SO<.a~sqwoz.u� o� w� � rs.w�.s� � s|rsr.� }.� vs.~o� � wqw;

~o|� �.o|r.� vsw� .to{wz� .{s{ps� �.� v}.~o� � wqw~o� sr.w|.� vw�.�� � r� <.

Ejtdmptvsf!Tubufnfou\}.q}{~s� w|u.tw|o|qwoz. w|� s� s�� .s� w�� �. t}� .o|� .o� � v}� .}t. � vw�.

{o|� �q� w~� <

SFGFSFODFT

2/! Lpcc!S-!Ipggnbo!O-!Mpehf!S-!Lmjof!T/!Foibodjoh!fmefs!dispojd!dbsf!uispvhi!ufdiopmphz!boe!dbsf!dppsejobujpo;!Sfqpsu!gspn!b!qjmpu/!Ufmfnfe!K!F!Ifbmui!2:91<:;29:� 2:6/

3/! Xfsu{!SU-!Espolfst!OG-!Cfsotufjo.Fmmjt!F-!Tivcjupxtlj!Z-!Fmnbo!S-!Tifobvu!H-!Lojhiu!SU/!Bqqsbjtbm!boe!ejbhoptjt!pg!ofvsphfojd!dpnnvojdbujpo!ejtpsefst!jo!sfnpuf!tfuujoht/!Dmjo!Bqibtjpm!2:98<28;228� 243/

Page 8: Videophone-Delivered Voice Therapy: a comparative analysis of outcomes to traditional delivery for adults with Parkinsons Disease - Tindall et al TMJ 2008

¬$QEV]$ERR$ PMIFIVX0$ MRG2$$ � $$ZSP2$58$$RS2$54$$ � $$HIGIQFIV$ 644<$$XIPIQIHMGMRI$erh$i1LIEPXL$$54;;

ZMHISTLSRI1HIPMZIVIH$ZSMGI$XLIVET]

4/! Xfsu{!SU-!Espolfst!OG-!Cfsotfjo.Fmmjt!F-!Tufsmjoh!M-!Tivcjupxtlj!Z-!Fmnbo!S-!Tifobvu!HL-!Lojhiu!SU-!Efbm!KM/!Qpufoujbm!pg!ufmfqipojd!boe!ufmfwjtjpo!ufdiopm.phz!gps!bqqsbjtjoh!boe!ejbhoptjoh!ofvsphfojd!dpnnvojdbujpo!ejtpsefst!jo!sfnpuf!tfuujoht/!Bqibtjpmphz!2::3<7;2:6� 313/

5/! Mfnbjsf!F-!Cpvesjbt!Z-!Hsffof!H/!Mpx.cboexjeui-!Joufsofu.cbtfe!wjefpdpogfsfod.joh!gps!qiztjdbm!sfibcjmjubujpo!dpotvmubujpot/!K!Ufmfnfe!Ufmfdbsf!3112<8;93� 9:/

6/! Hfpshfbejt!B-!Csfoobo!E-!Cbslfs!M-!Cbspo!D/!Ufmfsfibcjmjubujpo!boe!jut!fggfdu!po!tupsz!sfufmmjoh!cz!bevmut!xjui!ofvsphfojd!dpnnvojdbujpo!ejtpsefst/!Bqibtjpmphz!3115<29;74:� 763/

7/! Lvmmz!E/!Ufmfifbmui!jo!tqffdi!qbuipmhpz;!Bqqmjdbujpot!up!uif!usfbunfou!pg!tuvu.ufsjoh/!K!Ufmfnfe!Ufmfdbsf!3111<7)Tvqqm!3*;4:� 52/

8/! Nbtijnb!QB-!Cjslnjsf.Qfufst!EQ-!Tznt!NK-!Ipmufm!NS-!Cvshftt!MQ-!Qfufst!MK/!Ufmfifbmui;!Wpjdf!uifsbqz!vtjoh!ufmfdpnnvojdbujpot!ufdiopmphz/!Bn!K!Tqffdi!Mboh!Qbuipm!3114<23;543� 54:/

9/! Tdifjefnbo.Njmmfs!D-!Dmbsl!Q-!Tnfmu{fs!T-!Dmpve!B-!Dbsqfoufs!K-!Ipehf!C-!Qspvuz!E/!Uxp!zfbs!sftvmut!pg!b!qjmpu!tuvez!efmjwfsjoh!tqffdi!uifsbqz!up!tuvefout!jo!b!svsbm!Plmbipnb!tdippm!wjb!ufmfnfejdjof/!Jo!Qspdffejoht!pg!uif!46ui!Ibxbjj!Joufsobujpobm!Dpogfsfodf!po!Tztufn!Tdjfodft-!3113/

:/! Tjdpuuf!D-!Mfipvy!Q-!Gpsujfs.Cmbod!K-!Mfcmbod!Z/!Gfbtjcjmjuz!boe!pvudpnf!fwbmv.bujpo!pg!b!ufmfnfejdjof!bqqmjdbujpo!jo!tqffdi.mbohvbhf!qbuipmphz/!K!Ufmfnfe!Ufmfdbsf!3114<:;364� 369/

21/!Uifpepspt!EH-!Dpotuboujoftdv!H-!Svttfmm!U-!Xbse!FD-!Xjmtpo!TK-!Xppuupo!S/!Usfbujoh!uif!tqffdi!ejtpsefs!jo!Qbsljotpo� t!ejtfbtf!pomjof/!K!Ufmfnfe!Ufmfdbsf!3117<23)Tvqqm!4*;99� :2/

22/!Sbnjh!MP-!Cpojubuj!D-!Mfnlf!K-!Ipsjj!Z/!Wpjdf!usfbunfou!gps!qbujfout!xjui!Qbsljotpo!ejtfbtf;!Efwfmpqnfou!pg!bo!bqqspbdi!boe!qsfmjnjobsz!fggjdbdz!ebub/!K!Nfe!Tqffdi!Mboh!Qbuipm!2::5<3;2:2� 31:/

23/!Sbnjh!MP-!Dpvousznbo!T-!Uipnqtpo!MM-!Ipsjj!Z/!Dpnqbsjtpo!pg!uxp!gpsnt!pg!joufotjwf!tqffdi!usfbunfou!gps!Qbsljotpo!ejtfbtf/!K!Tqffdi!Ifbs!Sft!2::6<49;2343� 2362/

24/!Sbnjh!MP-!Espnfz!D/!Bfspezobnjd!nfdibojtnt!voefsmzjoh!usfbunfou!sfmbufe!dibohft!jo!TQM!jo!qbujfout!xjui!Qbsljotpo!ejtfbtf/!K!Tqffdi!Ifbs!Sft!2::7<4:;8:9� 918/

25/!Sbnjh!MP-!Tbqjs!T-!Gpy!D-!Dpvousznbo!T/!Dibohft!jo!wpdbm!mpveoftt!gpmmpxjoh!joufotjwf!wpjdf!usfbunfou!)MTWU®*!jo!joejwjevbmt!xjui!Qbsljotpo� t!ejtfbtf;!B!dpnqbsjtpo!xjui!vousfbufe!qbujfout!boe!opsnbm!bhf.nbudife!dpouspmt/!Npwf!Ejtpse!3112<27*;8:� 94/

26/!Dsjudimfz!F/!Tqffdi!ejtpsefst!pg!Qbsljotpojtn;!B!sfwjfx/!K!Ofvspm!Ofvsptvsh!Qtzdijbusz!2:92<55;862� 869/

27/!Bspotpo!BF/!Dmjojdbm!wpjdf!ejtpsefst/!Ofx!Zpsl;!Uijfnf.Tusbuupo-!2::1/

28/!Cbtitivs!SM/!Ufmfnfejdjof!fggfdut;!Dptu-!rvbmjuz-!boe!bddftt/!K!Nfe!Tztu!2::6<3;92� :2/

29/!Zjq!N-!Diboh!B-!Dibo!K-!Nbdlfo{jf-!B/!Efwfmpqnfou!pg!uif!ufmfnfejdjof!tbu.jtgbdujpo!rvftujpoobjsf!up!fwbmvbuf!qbujfou!tbujtgbdujpo!xjui!ufmfnfejdjof;!B!qsfmjnjobsz!tuvez/!K!Ufmfnfe!Ufmfdbsf!3114<:;57� 61/

2:/!Ubcbdiojdl!C-!Gjefmm!M/!Nvmujwbsjbuf!tubujtujdt/!Cptupo;!Ibqfs!Dpmmjot-!2::7/

31/!Uppuiblfs!MF-!Njmmfs!M/!Jouspevdupsz!tubujtujdt!gps!uif!cfibwjpsbm!tdjfodft-!3oe!fe/!Qbdjgjd!Hspwf-!DB;!Cspplt.Dpmf!Qvcmjtijoh!Dp/-!2::7;519� 51:/

32/!Ebwjt!I-!Tjmwfsnjo!T/!Ifbsjoh!boe!efbgoftt/!Ofx!Zpsl;!Ipmu-!Sjofibsu-!boe!Xjotupo-!2:81/

33/!Gpmtufjo!N-!Gpmtufjo!T-!NdIvhi!Q/!Njoj.nfoubm!tubuf;!B!qsbdujdbm!nfuipe!gps!hsbejoh!uif!dphojujwf!tubuf!pg!qbujfout!gps!uif!dmjojdjbo/!K!Qtzdijbus!Sft!2:86<23;29:� 2:9/

Orr� s��.� s~� w|� .� s�� s�� �.� }H.

Mzo!S/!Ujoebmm-!Qi/E/

Efqbsunfou!pg!Wfufsbot!Bggbjst!Nfejdbm!Dfoufs

2212!Wfufsbot!Esjwf-!237.DEE

Mfyjohupo-!LZ!51613

F.nbjm;.Z� |<bw|rozzN� o<u}�

Sfdfjwfe;.[o� qv.@F:.@>>F

Bddfqufe;.[o� .@E:.@>>F