Valenzuela-Alvarado, José-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Jurisdiction v. Abstention, Who Prevails?"

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    1/20

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    2/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q. @L[TINTMON MNZYI\TO \MKO2 SFO Z\IQ@MG[?

    Bo{ In|mko Q`ginryig`%@gq`|`do"

    XUM `demt' fosiqi|' tf`t tfiKon{tmtytmon oycft to li tfi {t`nd`|d oakon{t|yktmon ao| tfi g`s{' `nd tf`t sfi|iqi|tfi|i m{ `n iqmdint ozzo{mtmon' tfi g`s{ oycft tocmqi zg`ki to tfi Kon{tmtytmon. Lyt tfm{ dokt|mnim{ not didykmlgi a|oe `n} km|kye{t`nkizikygm`| to tfi zg`n oa tfi konqintmon' lyt a|oetfi cini|`g tfio|} oa ` gmemtid Kon{tmtytmon8`nd `{ a`| `{ mt m{ t|yi' m{ ipy`gg} `zzgmk`lgi toeo{t' ma not to `gg tfi [t`ti coqi|neint{. Tfi|ik`n li no olbiktmon' tfi|iao|i' on tfm{ `kkoynt'to tfi aidi|`g bydmk`ty|i sfmkf smgg not gmi`c`mn{t tfi gok`g bydmk`ty|i{ mn cini|`g' `ndsfmkf smgg not {i|qi to kondien iqi|}kon{tmtytmon tf`t `ttiezt{ to {it loynd{ togicm{g`tmqi dm{k|itmon.0

    M. Mnt|odyktmon

    Si k`n `gg `c|ii tf`t aidi|`g by|m{dmktmon f`{ ivz`ndid dy|mnc tfig`{t tin }i`|{ `t {oei dic|ii tf`t kmtmrin{ `nd g`s}i|{ f`qi tfi zi|kiztmontf`t {t`ti {oqi|imcnt} m{ eo|i `n mggy{mon tf`n tfi onki aidi|`gm{t konkiztmon.@giv`ndi| F`emgton' tfi @ytfo| oa Tfi Aidi|`gm{t No. 60' onki {`md2

    XMU t m{ mnfi|int mn tfi n`ty|i oa {oqi|imcnt} not to li`ein`lgi to tfi {ymt oa `n mndmqmdy`g smtfoyt mt{ kon{int. Tfm{m{ tfi cini|`g {in{i `nd tfi cini|`g z|`ktmki oa e`nhmnd8 `nd

    "@{{m{t`nt [ogmkmto| Cini|`g' Oaamki oa tfi [ogmkmto| Cini|`g oa tfi Koeeonsi`gtf oa Zyi|to\mko &

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    3/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    4/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    5/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    6/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    7/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    8/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    9/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    10/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    11/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    12/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    13/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    14/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    15/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    16/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    17/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    18/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    19/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2

  • 7/31/2019 Valenzuela-Alvarado, Jos-Enrico, XLIII Rev. Jur. Inter-American University Law 279, No. 2 (Spring, 2009) "Federal Ju

    20/20

    AIDI\@G BY\M[DMKTMON Q.@L[TINTMON MN ZYI\TO \MKO

    \IQM[T@ BY\DMK@ Y.M.Z.\. XQOG.VGMMM2