-
7/31/2019 UWBK 6-19-2012 #108 REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
1/4
0
YCN[IK V[@[IV KNV[_NF[ FLY_[
HL_ [AI KNV[_NF[ LH FLBYDON@
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\.
YCN[IK WIV[I_C O@CJ" ..]b`nc{nhh" .
.
x# ..
LHHNFI LH [AI FLD][_LBBI_ .
LH [AI FY__ICF^" i{ `b#" .
.Kihick`c{v# .
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\.
0500$fx$==;=1
[ai Alclr`obi @d~ Oird`c E`fjvlc
_IPYIV[ HL_ L_@B @_GYDIC[
Lc Eyci 09" ?=0?" {ai }`r{niv fld}bi{ik ornihncg lc {ainr
riv}if{nxi frlvv$dl{nlcv hlr
vydd`r~ eykgdic{# Wanbi {ai `bblw`cfi lh lr`b `rgydic{" lh
flyrvi" nv wn{anc {ai knvfri{nlc lh
{ai flyr{" BFx_ 7!h." `bb }`r{niv `grii {a`{ lr`b `rgydic{ wlybk
oi aib}hyb nc rivlbxncg {ai
}ickncg dl{nlcv# @ck gnxic {ai fld}biqn{~ lh {ai nvvyiv nc {ai
f`vi" {ai Flyr{v knvfri{nlc
wlybk oi `}}rl}rn`{ib~ iqirfnvik {l lrkir `rgydic{# @ hybb `ck
f`rihyb flcvnkir`{nlc lh {ai
}ickncg nvvyiv {arlyga lr`b `rgydic{ nv iv}ifn`bb~ fryfn`b nc
bnga{ lh {anv Flyr{v }lv{yri `v `c
`}}ibb`{i {rnoyc`b"@d# Onlvfnicfi" Ncf# x# [ald}vlc" ?8> H#6k
0=77" 0=16 !K#F# Fnr# ?==0."
{a`{ wnbb kifnki {anv d`{{ir lc vydd`r~ eykgdic{ r`{air {a`c
{arlyga ` {rn`b${~}i }rlfiikncg"
D`rva`bb Fc{~# Ai`b{a F`ri @y{a# x# Va`b`b`" >11 H#?k 0??0"
0??9 !K#F# Fnr# 0>>6.# [airihlri"
Ycn{ik Wiv{irc O`cj !{ai O`cj. riv}if{hybb~ ripyiv{v {a`{ {ai
Flyr{ vfaikybi ` ai`rncg `{ n{v
flcxicnicfi#
Flycvib a`xi di{ `ck flchirrik `oly{ }lvvnobi k`{iv hlr lr`b
`rgydic{# [wl d`{{irv
rib`{ik {l vfaikybncg w`rr`c{ {ai Flyr{v `{{ic{nlc# Hnrv{" {ai
`{{lrci~ wal }b`cv {l }rivic{
`rgydic{ lc oia`bh lh {ai O`cj nv fyrric{b~ `kkrivvncg fir{`nc
diknf`b nvvyiv# [aivi nvvyiv
F`vi 0500$fx$==;=1$@OE Klfydic{ 0=1 Hnbik =8,0>,0? ]`gi 0 lh
;
-
7/31/2019 UWBK 6-19-2012 #108 REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
2/4
?
rickir and yc`x`nb`obi hlr `rgydic{ lc }irnlknf k`{iv# Viflck"
flycvib hlr Kihick`c{v `ck fl$
flycvib hlr {ai O`cj a`xi `kkn{nlc`b k`{iv lh yc`x`nb`onbn{~#
[airihlri" {l {ai iq{ic{ }lvvnobi hlr
{ai Flyr{v vfaikybi" {ai O`cj riv}if{hybb~ `vjv {a`{ {ai Flyr{
vfaikybi `rgydic{ lc lci lh {ai
hlbblwncg k`~v !nc Eyb~ {arlyga Clxidoir.5
Eyb~ 8 Eyb~ 0= Eyb~ 07$0> @ygyv{ ?$8 @ygyv{ ?= @ygyv{ ??$?6
@ygyv{ ?7$?> Vi}{idoir 6$0;
Vi}{idoir 0>$?; Vi}{idoir ?7$?1 Lf{loir 0$9 Lf{loir 00$01
Lf{loir ??$60 Clxidoir 0$7 Clxidoir >$?= Clxidoir ?8$6=
Flycvib hlr {ai O`cj `ck hlr Kihick`c{v wlybk wibfldi {ai
l}}lr{ycn{~ {l knvfyvv {aivi
d`{{irv hyr{air wn{a {ai Flyr{ nc vfaikybncg flchiricfi# Valybk
{ai Flyr{ ripynri `kkn{nlc`b
nchlrd`{nlc flcfircncg {ai `olxi k`{iv lh yc`x`nb`onbn{~"
flycvib wlybk `bvl oi a`}}~ {l
}rlxnki n{#
F`vi 0500$fx$==;=1$@OE Klfydic{ 0=1 Hnbik =8,0>,0? ]`gi ? lh
;
-
7/31/2019 UWBK 6-19-2012 #108 REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
3/4
6
_iv}if{hybb~ vyodn{{ik"
,v @ckriw B# V`ckbir #
@ckriw B# V`ckbir !KF O`r Cl# 6171?9.V`dyib E# Oyhhlci !KF O`r
Cl# 0801?1.Bn`c` _# ]rni{l !KF O`r Cl# >17?17.
Dnfa`ib _# Wnbbn`dv !KF O`r Cl# >>;>96.
OYFJBI^V@CKBI_ BB]
0?9= ?;{a V{#" CW" Vyn{i 7==W`vancg{lc" KF ?==67!?=?.
6;>$1==0 ![ibi}alci.
!?=?. 6;>$1=1= !H`fvndnbi.
,v B`wricfi K# J`}b`c #
Jnro~ K# Oiari !KF O`r Cl# 6>1;80.B`wricfi K# J`}b`c !KF O`r
Cl# ;09018.
]@YB A@V[NCGV BB]179 09{a V{rii{ CW
W`vancg{lc" KF ?===9
!?=?. 990$070> ![ibi}alci.!?=?. 990$=00> !H`fvndnbi.
,v [ailklri E# @o`rnl{iv #
[ailklri E# @o`rnl{iv
Ki}y{~ Gicir`b FlycvibYCN[IK WIV[I_C O@CFL_]"NCF#
7== 07{a V{rii{" Vyn{i ?0==
Kicxir" Flblr`kl 1=?=?
!7?=. >6?$;?08 ![ibi}alci.!7?=. >;8$0?01 !H`fvndnbi.
@{{lrci~v hlr ]b`nc{nhh Ycn{ik Wiv{irc O`cj
K`{ik5 Eyci 0>" ?=0?
F`vi 0500$fx$==;=1$@OE Klfydic{ 0=1 Hnbik =8,0>,0? ]`gi 6 lh
;
-
7/31/2019 UWBK 6-19-2012 #108 REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
4/4
;
FI_[NHNF@[I LH VI_XNFI
N airio~ fir{nh~ {a`{ lc {anv 0>{a k`~ lh Eyci" ?=0?" ` {ryi
fl}~ lh {ai hlriglncg w`v hnbik
ibif{rlcnf`bb~# Cl{nfi lh {anv hnbncg wnbb oi vic{ o~ id`nb {l
`bb }`r{niv o~ l}ir`{nlc lh {ai Flyr{v
ibif{rlcnf hnbncg v~v{id# ]`r{niv d`~ `bvl `ffivv {anv hnbncg
{arlyga {ai Flyr{v ibif{rlcnf hnbncg
v~v{id#
,v Bn`c` _# ]rni{l
Bn`c` _# ]rni{l
F`vi 0500$fx$==;=1$@OE Klfydic{ 0=1 Hnbik =8,0>,0? ]`gi ; lh
;
