7/31/2019 UWBK 5-29-2012 DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE

1/7

HO Z@I YOHZIJ UZLZIU JHUZRHEZ EMYRZ

NMR Z@I JHUZRHEZ MN EMFYGBHL]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]

YOHZIJ QIUZIRO BLOD&

[flhozhnn& ~/ E/L/ Om/

7/31/2019 UWBK 5-29-2012 DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE

2/7

2

emoehui uzlzigioz mn aioyhoi huuyiu uizzhoa nmrz` lff glzirhlf nlezu lu zm q`he` hz hu

emoziojij z`iri iphuzu l aioyhoi huuyi oieiuulrx zm bi fhzhalzij& q`he` u`lffhoefyji rinirioeiu zm z`i {lrzu mn z`i riemrj rifhij mo zm uy{{mrz z`i uzlzigioz/

Ile` uye` gmzhmo loj m{{muhzhmo gyuz lfum emozlho mr bi leemg{lohij bx l

gigmrlojyg mn {mhozu loj lyz`mrhzhiu loj {rm{muij mrjir lu ri|yhrij bx FE~R

1(l& (b loj (e/ Ho jizirghohoa l gmzhmo nmr uygglrx cyjagioz& z`i emyrz glxluuygi z`lz nlezu hjiozhnhij bx z`i gm~hoa {lrzx ho hzu uzlzigioz mn glzirhlf nlezu

lri ljghzzij& yofiuu uye` l nlez hu emozrm~irzij ho z`i uzlzigioz mn aioyhoi huuyiu

nhfij ho m{{muhzhmo zm z`i gmzhmo/

FE~R 1(`( gmzhmo ho z`i emozipz mn l e`lffioai zm lo laioex lezhmo {yruyloz zm z`i Ljghohuzrlzh~i

[rmeijyri Lez loj uhghflr uzlzyziu3

[lrlarl{` (

7/31/2019 UWBK 5-29-2012 DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE

3/7

5

{mhozu loj lyz`mrhzhiu/ Z`hu& z`ix lrayi&2

gldiu hz uybciez zm FE~R 1(i& q`he` fhghzu l

gigmrlojyg mn {mhozu loj lyz`mrhzhiu ho uy{{mrz mn mr ho m{{muhzhmo zm l gmzhmo zm omz gmri

z`lo :9 {laiu/ Z`i MEE riu{ieznyffx jhulariiu/

Q`hfi z`i floaylai mn FE~R 1(`(2 gldiu hz efilr z`lz l gmzhmo nmr uygglrx cyjagioz

u`lff hoefyji l uzlzigioz mn nlezu qhz` rinirioeiu zm z`i ljghohuzrlzh~i riemrj lu z`i MEEu

uybghuuhmo jmiuz`i ryfi jmiu omz {riefyji l {rm{moioz mn l Ryfi 9> gmzhmo nrmg nhfhoa l

ui{lrlzi Uzlzigioz mn Nlezu/ [flhozhnn `lu omz ehzij lox elui flq z`lz uy{{mrzu hzu hozir{rizlzhmo mn

z`i Fmelf Ryfiu mr z`lz jigmouzrlziu z`lz l ui{lrlzi uybghuuhmo hu hg{rm{ir/

[flhozhnn jmiu ehzi Dmrizmnn ~/ ^hfuled& 2; (J/J/E/ Clo/

7/31/2019 UWBK 5-29-2012 DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE

4/7

:

bi fhghzij zm om gmri z`lo :9 {laiu/ Houzilj& fhdi Dmrizmnn& z`iJl~hu Emyrz ljjriuuij {flhozhnnu

hg{rm{ir lzzig{z zm hoefyji ipzrl'riemrj glzirhlfu ho hzu uybghuuhmo zm z`i Emyrz/ Hj/ lz 200'85/

[flhozhnnu mz`ir eluiu nrmg z`hu Emyrz jm omz ljjriuu z`i huuyi {irzhoioz zm z`hu Gmzhmo/

Umgi lri omz i~io ljghohuzrlzh~i riemrj ri~hiq eluiu& byz houzilj ho~mf~i {rh~lzi fhzhalozu mofx/5

Uii& i/a/& MLM Lfnl'Blod ~/ Ezr/ nmr [yb/ Hoziarhzx& 501 N/ Uy{{/ 2j 2; (J/J/E/ 2;;9

(jinlglzhmo flquyhz brmya`z bx Ryuuhlo byuhoiuugio lalhouz ~lrhmyu Lgirhelo ehzhsiou loj

Eloljx ~/ Irbi Ifidrmgijhsho Agb@& 5;1 N/ Uy{{/ 2j 2 (J/J/E/ 2;;: ({lzioz honrhoaigioz

elui brmya`z ho~mf~hoa gijhelf ji~heiu/

[ir`l{u gmri zm z`i {mhoz& l brhin ri~hiq mn z`hu Emyrzu jmedizu ho mz`ir riemrj ri~hiq

eluiu u`mqu z`lz hz hu lo iozhrifx yuylf loj eyuzmglrx {rlezhei nmr fhzhalozu nhfhoa gmzhmou nmr

uygglrx cyjagioz ho z`iui eluiu zm uybghz {riehuifx q`lz z`i MEE uybghzzij ho z`hu elui3

7/31/2019 UWBK 5-29-2012 DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE

5/7

9

binmri z`i Emyrz& z`i elui qlu zm bi jiehjij mo z`i bluhu mn z`i ljghohuzrlzh~i riemrj z`lz qlu

binmri z`i laioex/ Z`i {flhozhnn uybghzzij l gmzhmo nmr uygglrx cyjagioz& l uzlzigioz mn nlezu&

loj l gigmrlojyg mn {mhozu loj lyz`mrhzhiu q`he`& zldio zmaiz`ir& zmzlfij & Ghoam Fmalou nhfhoa uybghzzij Glx 21& 2;

7/31/2019 UWBK 5-29-2012 DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE

6/7

>

cyjagioz uybghuuhmo zmzlfij :8 {laiu& loj z`i jiniojlozu uybghuuhmo qlu 80 zmzlf {laiu/ Uii

lfumDha`z ~/ Yohzij Uzlziu& 2; Dha`zqlu lo yoemg{fhelzij elui qhz` lo ljghohuzrlzh~i riemrj mn l{{rmphglzifx 2;;

{laiu/

1 L ui{lrlzi uzlzigioz mn nlezu gldiu uioui ah~io z`i uhsi mn z`i ljghohuzrlzh~i riemrj loj

z`i oiij nmr z`i MEE zm bmz` lrayi hzu gmzhmo nmr uygglrx cyjagioz loj riu{moj zm {flhozhnnu

gmzhmo nmr uygglrx cyjagioz ho l uhoafi brhin mn :9 {laiu rlz`ir z`lo 8; {laiu z`lz qmyfj `l~ibiio l~lhflbfi hn z`i uygglrx cyjagioz gmzhmo loj m{{muhzhmo `lj biio brhinij ui{lrlzifx/

Emg{lri Lgiojij Ue`ijyfhoa Mrjir mn Glre`

7/31/2019 UWBK 5-29-2012 DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE

7/7

1

Z`i MEE riu{ieznyffx uybghzu z`lz z`i Emyrz u`myfj jiox [flhozhnnu gmzhmo zm uzrhdi/

Jlzi3 Glx 28& 2;