|JCTAR I MtsN I OF THE NAVYCOM','ANOER

MVAL SURFACE FORCE ATLAN'I'IC14l}0 MITSCHER AVENUE

NORFOT-K URGTN!{ 23651 -2.{91

5800Ser N02L/

From:Tor

$uDl: TNVESTIGATION I}.TTO SUSPECTED FRATERNIZATTON BETWESITI{E COMMAND MASTER C{IEF AND O}T BOARD USSNEW YORK (LPD 21)

Ref : (a) R.c.M.303, McM (2ooB ed.)(b) Mir- R- Evid. 305, MCM (2008 ed.)

1. this let'ter appoints you, per reference (a), t'o i4vestigat.ethe factE arrd eircumgtaltces Burrounding the diacovery of textmedEage€ and phone calls beLween the Cornmand Mastser Chief arldthe . on board USS IIEW YORK (LPD 21-) during a-'---- Limited Tf,aining Team inspection.

2. Review reference (b) prior eo interviewing any witnesgeg.

3. Report your findings in letter form by 03 Septse$lcer 2010,unlege an extension of tine i6 granted. You are to include withyouf, report all vrilllesE seaternenC€ and other doeumented evldencegathered.

4 - You may Eeek legal advice fromJAGC, UsN, duridg t'tre eourse of your inveatigation,

1 be reached aC ?57- or by e-maiL ats

By direction

^lnmander, Naval Surface Force Atlantic

DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVYmi,$ANDER

MVAL SURFACE FORCE ATLANTIC1430 MITSCHER AVENUE

NORFOLK VIRG|N|A 23551 -2494 1621Ser N02t/t l214 SEP 2010

-

FIRST ENDORSEMEM on __,-. .Cr of 03 Sep 10

From: Conmander, Naval Surface Force AtlanticTo: cornrnander. Ary)hibious Squadron EighL.

StTbJ: TNVESTIGATTON TNTO SUSPECTED PRATERNIZATIoN BETWEEN THECOMMAND MASTER CIIIEF AND ON BOARD USS NEWyoRK (LPD 21)

1. Forwarded as a natter under your cognizance. PleaEe reportback eo thie command any adrniniEt.rat.ive or digqiplinary actionstaken in connection with 1]hi6 matter. ,/

03 Septeirber 2010

To: Comnander, Naval Surface Force AtlanticS\rbj: INIESTIG.ATION INTO SUSPECTED FRATERIiTIZATION BET!{EEN TEE COMI,IAND MASTER

CHIEF AND ON BOARD USS NEW YORK {IIFD 21)

Encl: (1) Cetl- phone bi1t6 from october 2OO9 lhrough Au$rst 2010(2) Coftrnand Climate Survey hand-writted conunents regarding suspected

lraternization(3)

(4)

Personaf stalement fromboard USS rilEw YoRK (lPD 21)Personal slatement from CMDCM

Master chief on board Uss NEw

1. Findinge of fact.

a. Enclosure (1) is Eelephone records of governmene owned ce1l phoneBbelongiBg to uss IiIEw YoRK (LPD 21). Telephone number tshephone ' - .-o rhi{;:

---,-_ _ =._J( relephonenumber le phore ieEued to the Collsn&d Master chief (CMc),(:l!tDc'l.'t {sw) Robelt Stsocklin. A revie1,' of the phone recorde from December 2oO9to May 2010 shovd tha! the ClvC and - bawe been iD contact almost daily,

IISN .

(sw) Robert stocklin, usN, comnandYORK (',PD 21)

and sometlmeE inultsiple bimes a day. Phone calf8 lrere nade during the weeh,ower weetendE and holidays, and ats a1l tsimes of, lhe day tso irclude lateeventng hourE from 2000 Eo 0100. The phone cal1s lasted. on average, 15minuhes \rich a number of rhem lastsing over 25 minutes and a max of 64

b. Upon reporting to USS NEw YORK (!PD 21) on 30 August 2010 to conalucEtbe i--.eatidat nn r raceived verbal authorizaclon from the

to diEable tbe unclassi"fied accourlts of the cMc ard. r scanned che cddtente of ehe e-mail accounts and Otrtlook daca files

looking for personal e-Ilailg betvreen lhe CMC and No incriminating e-mails were found. I also confiscated the command celL phones fron the CMC

aad Ther.e were no tex! meseages or recent calls beeween the tltonumbers onl -phone. CMC,S phone showed lhat he had received a textmessage frolfr:'--'*-* )n sunday, 29 Au$rsts 2o1o at 3:3x PM that read "Busy?"CMC'g response to ats 3:32PM read '\No, still at ." fllele were noother text mesaageG or recents calIs between the two numbers on cMC's phorle,

c. I reviewed the conmand ctimate survey hhat was conductsed on 13 April2010. Two of over 100 hand-wrltsten commelltE specificalLy addreEsed command-wide runor8 of an inappropriate relationBhip betsween lhe CMC and a' one conirnent stated that tshese runors led Eo a severe degradationor euvd order and discipline. The€e comments have been incfuded as enclosure(2). e

d. I intserviewed lhe outgoingwho has been onboard for approximateLyobserved, on a few occasioDs, CMC and

two years and {orks fordeparcing Lhe ship within minutes

of each other at the end of the day. CMC andoffice, or cMc,s office, having coffee and chariing; on ewery occasion rhedoor has been open and the two have been scparated by space and/or a desk.He never observed any touching or. holding hands bet\,,een the two. Ee has no!observed lhe two in anyhhing oLher than a professionat Eetting or groupsoclal setting with a nunber of orher officers anal chief6.

e. I ihLerviewed thenoted that clrc and spend aalEo i,rhile they wexe in Avondalenas on rvatch at the quarterdeck,

lot of time logether \rhile on the ship andat the PCU. Ile nored tiro occasions when heand observed lhe two arriviDg at lhe brow

noted unduly faniliari behawioi between Ehenearly simultaneously.two during a barbecue insilting togethe! on rhecMC' s pockets, apparenrlythe level of confort anil

Avondale. The two deparred the group and wereEailgate of a pickup truck. reached into t} ereaching for keys, an act lhar he betiewes exceedsfandfiaxity expecred bebween an officer and a chief

was approached by some juniorf. I inlervieved rhe

pef,ception of frat:ef,nizaLion betweenThe perceived !elacionship berweenconmand and the command ctinare because

in lhe department and subsequenrly Epoke roand l:he CltC in the Spring of 2o1o

and CUC denigrated the chain ofersomel f e1t uabl e t6

approach the CMC about an issue since it was tikelv rharEpoken to him. rlso noEed that appeared to bave wery ferconnectionE with the officers in rhe waratroom, and tenaled ro spend a tot oftime with the CpOs whiLe in Avondate, r.A.

q. I interyie\,red the, lrho is CMC'S roonmatse on USS NE{ YORK-

noticed that the cMC spent more tsime wirh than any other officer;if lhe CMC was not in his own office. he could usually

office. In November 2009be found around the

was approached bysoEreone in the crew (he coufd nor recall whom) abouh Ehe amounr of lime cMcand spenE togethex. appxoached CljC abour tshe concerns anddiscussed the need fox boundaries between rhe officers and cbiefs ro ensuie

approached by , comnand Managemenr Equal opporruniry(CMEO) advocate, noting lhaL junior personnel reportsed having seen CMC and

in toun togeLher at a restsaurants in Earle, N,f . retayed that.he had nots heard abouh lhar jnstance, buts had atready spoken to CMC and ifanything else was brought up, he would bring the issue Lo lhe Conllllandi]lgOfficer,s attsention. Nothing else of note had been brought roatt.ention. so he never spoke ro the CO abouL lhe issue.

theie is no perceprion of improprietsy. A few days larer

h. I intervi ewed /opportsudity (CMEO) advocaLe.

., Ehe Command Managelent Equal. f,irsL became aware of a percepLion

of an unduly familiar relationship between CMC and in May 2009. Arthat !ime, it was noreal by severat junior person]]et rhar rbe rwo lrereconstanlIy logether, both on rhe ship and around rhe buitding where rhe

rnajorily of ofticers and chiefs resided while in Avondale, LA. .- aLsoreceived a numbex of reporls from junior officers. Over the past 1.5 monthetshe reports have lul1ed and 6urged, with reports being made as frequently agevery week. Reporta range from a peiception of preferenlial tsreatmenc !obeing seen i.n a car wltsh an arrn arornd the other,s shoulder or beiBg Been outsin Lovn logether at a bar or restauran!. One even! that produced a numbet ofrepo!t.6 vras tshat CMC and wele at a bar togelher in New York CiCyfollowing c:na 5 of tl _- .l.l Series in Noveniber 2009. After a runiber ofrePorls, *,__ . oenforcing boundaries to CMC.----- :- rhe nFL

-d tsh{- ,--,es, in February 2010. lt?-e later, -hab rhe situation had been dealt with and thah cMc and

been counseled- uss NEw v^n" conducied a Connanil Climate Survey thatcompleled i! April 2oLo. _ provided the prelininary lesufls of theEo the co and xo in early May 2010, which revealed chat- lhere was sone

between cMc and a rs one of those icens.

vho relayed his previous convereation ofAf*-- the 2OO9 holidays, !he*. -.-r iForhet

- i approached the fornertsold by

had

the close retatlonship between lhe cMc and sheprovided a Plan of Actior ard !4itescones {POA&M) tr Ehe Co to addresE anumber of isEues,/concerns broughE co light in r:he surwey. There r,rere a felttshings thae were excluded fron Ehe POA5.r'I because the Co said he would handletho6e igsueE personalfv - the concems about an inappropriate relaEionship

sinee Ausust 2oo' rs the combat sysLems off,icer (cso). In early 2010, \tbileeerving a€ cso, --- heard runors of a relalionshitri betweer CMC and

i.. I interl.i.ewed thebeen tbe actirlg --- iirrce 02 August 2010.

cMc spent more Eine with than lritsh other ofticers, but

. l,ho hashas been on Che ship

b\rE did not observe anyhhing firsEhand and did noe think the iEsue wascredibte enough go bring !o the attention of the Xo or CO. lle noticed that

stsruggling as a \{eaker - iand souqht out qui"--ce that CMC lvae

*irring to provide . ouriirs his tnirrov- tver wich ;he f o'm:r

rras briefed on tshe lesults ot lhe Command Climate Survey to i-nclude lheconcerns abou! a relatsionBhip between tshe CMC and a i however, heassr.med that ii: had alleady been addressed and taken care of by the forner

j . r interviewed : *

livision chief. she haal hear.d norumors of an inappropriate refat ionship'between the cMc and oor hadshe obsert/ed anything unloward. The tsimes cMC andtogetsher on tshe ship lhey vrere discussing lrork-related isEues, specificallyper.soDnel issues and depar.tmental l-eadership challenges. lssue6 in i ,Sdepartment over the pasts 15 moni:hs incL\rde a severe vehicle wreck in' -

Avonda]e, LA; deparlmentsal growih and keeping families tsogether while inAvondale, IJA; personnel showing up late for nork due to insufficienttsransporlatlon; sailors being sent on Indlvidual Augmen! (tAi assignnen!,over-stsressed j'mior Sailors, a Eevere car \,rreck involving the death of a

sailor in Nover,-oer 2009; and the ,)eing diagno6ed itilhcance!. -,-- did not notice any adwerse effects of CMC anddiscuEsion€ on tshe Chief's Mess, lepartmenh, or che overall command-

k. I intervietred , division chief, who had hearitrumors of an improper relationship bet.ween CMC and He had nofirsthand knowlerlge of anything untoward. noted that CMC and

spend a IoL of tsime batking and that t:here l! d perception that CMC

will tel] everything and vice versa. For instance, there have beentshings said in a Chief,s meeling that wexe immediately knolvn to andthere have been lbings said during a epartment leaderghlp meetingthat were immediately known to CMC. This has caused eo watch rhat hesays around ) and C!lC. Over the past few monehs hhe rumors ot aninappropriate relationship have decreased.

1. I int.erviewed the ' ,-,--, who firstbecane aware of a polenLial issue fr:om the CMEo in February 2010. The CMEO

relayed that she had received reporcs rhar the cMC andtoo nuch tine tsogether lvhi]e on the ship, and a few rumoxs Ehat they lrereseen together in New York City. There was norhing specific lhat caused

to lend credence co a fraternization allegatioo; he viewed the issue asa misgujded perception of male-female relalionships. Folfowing thediEcussion with cl.{Eo/ counseled abouts lhe perception offraEej.nization a$d reinforced professional relationEhips among the officers

conducted shortly after che and cMC had been counseled, the CO believedthat the coll!:nents were just held over flon a previous perception.received no other indicacion that thele was sci1l an issue. lle fett that hehad taken appropriate acEion by counseling the individuals and tha! the iesuewas resotwed. characterizee lhe relationshiD between CUC and

also diiected the . to counsel CMC onr watched more closely forthe lssue. Following the counseliog,

anytbing lhat may be perceived as fraternization between cMC anddld not obse!'ve anything inproper. A couple nontbs taler the Connand ClimaheSurvey lras conducted and the results were briefed to the Co and xo and by tsheCMEo in May 2010. Two of the hand written comments addressed the perceivedfraternization between the cMc and a . Since the survey was

as a mentor-mentored relationsbip; is one of Ehe weaker t

' whose Personal(3). adnii:ted that her relationshipa professional relalionship between an

who is below averase a!' leadership and interpersonal relationshipssince she is oftsen unable to relate to her peers and subordinatseE. The

depar.tnrent chiefs are also not the strongest leaders. so it oas viewedas a win-\rin to have CMC nore lnvolved in since he lvas abletso mentor the chiefs in the departsments and provide valuable leadership

m- I i ntervi e0ed ]:h.a

stsatsemenh ie included as enclosurewilh CMC oversbepped Lhe bounds ofofficer and a chief.

n. I interviewed the Command Masler Chief, CMDCM(SW) Roberl Stockfin,whose personal statement is included as encLosure (4) . cMC admilted thats hisrelationship witsh overscepped the bounds of a professional relationshipbetween a chief and ar offider

CMC and , as a result of spending an inordinate amounh of lime together,2. Surnnary of events. Runor6 of an inappropriate relationship betneen the

began to circulale in vSS NEW YORK (LPD 21) \,,hi]e the ship was in the yardBin Avondale, LA from May ho October 2009. Before the cren moved aboard theship, lhe chiefs and officers largely resided in t'he same building and heLdi{eekly barbecues. a'rd cMc were reqular altendees at these barbecues,buts were always acconpanied by other chiefe artd officers and [ever isofatedtshem6el.ves frorn the group. In Novenber 2009, whiLe lhe ship wae ir1 New YorkCity !or: comnissj.oning, members of the cre\r, to include CMC andatcended Game 5 of Lhe WorLd serles. Following the gaine, Ctr4C andouts to a baii $here other SailorE were also congregating and it lvas nobed ihatthey were hanging-out together. More rumors of an inappropriate relationBhipbetween the CMC and qader circulating after Lhe commisEioning. rhe

discussed the issue oitb cMC. There vras a lu1l in the rumorg over tshe

holiday periodr however, wben the crew reburned in January 2010, lunorsconbinued to circulate and were brought to Ehe attention of the CMEO onceagain. After the CMEo 'F.cived a nwJcer of complaints and concerns, sheapproaehed !h€ .-th the information in February 2010. Ttre andco looked into the issue and found no hard evidence of fraternization andcounseled cltc and on the peiception of fraternizacion in February orMarch 2010. Thele iE no recoid of the counEeling. There was a command

Cllnate Survey conducted 13 April 2OXO and there were lwo conments thatspecificaffy addreEsed an inappropriace relationship between the CMC and a

.. When the reeulls of the survey wete briefed to Lhe \e feltaE Ehough these cormentE sere just hetd over from previouE rumorE so nofurther counseling sas conducted. Allhough CMC and i,tere rnore ana:re ofthe tsime Ehey epenE together on Ehe Ehtp, they continued lo call and texteach oEher daily- rhe lumorE have abated over. tshe paEt fer,t months, and dooEher concerns have been brought up Eo Ehe

opinion6

a. An unduly familiar relationship prejudictal to good order anddiscipline exi6Es between CMDqM (sl'l) Robert stocklin andThe reLationship began on profes6ional terins; however, over Eine, Lhe lwogrew tso be friends aod confidant€, over6tepping the boundB of a profeseionaLrelarionship between an officer and a chief. The fr.equency of dailycommunicahion behween CMC andcloser personal. relationship.

via catls and gext neEsageB infers a much

., verbal reports indicate tshats thequestion. Tbe Commanding Officer should have conducted acounseling, in GiEing, tso document the siEuation.

b. The Comnanding officer thoughL tsha! he deafe witsh lhe sitsuacionappropxiacely through counseLing; however, despire the counsetilrg, tshe cMC

cootinued their inappropliate relationship. Although tshe Coftnandclimatse survey only identsifies lhe CMc as havirg a close relarionship wihh a

inmore formal

c. The close personal relationship between CUC and degj:aded tsheeftectiveness of communication and leadership in 1t. Theeffects of thie refationshipl,rere also obEerved on a comnand-iride tevel, but.!o a lesser deglee,

LCDR USN

uss NEW YoRK(LPD 21)FPO IE 01t5r917

ATTI,II

'la'

/o- o24

Fund cod.,(Clrcl. On.)r

PURCHASE NBR

Er{Rt, @

Vsrdor tniormatlon R€qudrt lnfoNama Dato 2n5no10

oty AT KY ZP POC

lt

5.01

I$

SCREENED TA 9A'ORY SOURCES (l.lSN,uNrco& MBr lsB. woDl

HIZMAT ACREENED AY COORD.

ADP IIA1EBIAL SCREEI,IEO

HU COqRO. tNtT:

co:

ADP REP INIT;

385.0'l

385-Ol

BILL 'IAS

BEEN VERIFIED FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

OEPAATMENI HEAD:

APPROVIIJ9 gFFlClALt

APC/SUPPLY OFTICER:

cO (lt ruqulr.d):

)UR SPRINT INVOICEuss NEw YORK (LPD 21)

12/O1/0+12/3t/o, !u, ic llE,/tr.t r-r- I

}UBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

ar.":JlllLsggl:F.hJ N.6l Drd c.tu.. gil-d.......,ausss - "#;ii i"**

I

Lar! 016€ wnib B.arhs

> SUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

,. c.llul* s.rtl6 C.ll O.tdl

.u_!l!,!r*.fhr,i !.!4,en !b,qr,..... _.. --Butic. E sdL rdd$ FC

Airlime lrlage D€r6II

€-.c.4 !!.9! q!r!ql4s !lil'4'. I r2lor 07:03P nofrfoLr(,va

a 12/oi o7roeF [!nFoL(,vA3r2102 07:3?P tEpHIS,Ixr r2lo3 03:5?P IIOFFOLj(,VA6 12103 0{r.t0P ll03f0u('v6 r?ld or:EiP lnc{inc712l03 o3i56P $t f,LorcvlttaB12/0. oo:02€ ronF!{l(,vI12los oo;i 1P afutrLoTsvL,va

ro 12104 o4:$P rdfor-K,v1112/0a 03j00F l.drrst2 i2lor 06r21P TORFOLX,v

r3 r2loa 06:23P tr06F0L(,Vl,l t2l05 05:414 Inoqllg1512/05 0rr14P lndin!!€12106 04:49P hdhc17 r2106 o€tlop iloaTmaooK, IL1312/05 0?i5?P hc{in!1e t2l05 oE r25P Incoiro!o 1?/05 09r22P lic iho2il2l050dt26pltdEo22 12l05 or:30P BAYSTLoUII,132312ld 03r'Fr( Ircdins2.12/06 11r,1,1 hcdint2512/C,€ 0r;57P hcding2612/07 o5: t4r Indim2712107 05r65P lnco.hs2s 12tdl o7t22P

'N8i!02e t2lo7 o7:3.P ilonmtx,varo l2l07 07r50P tloSFoLl(,v3i i2l0a 1o:s31rcnFoL&v

Bu.rn{r €x. l.r Add-n

rohl lidln U!{. chr!- 13.?6

'Re Mh:s- iE!&Antilhohhuie',Mdtonrl (Bonus)nind, l,lobll.roMobll.hlin t,any oblt.Antii,ih@[l.hl.ro Hom min6, .nd llLbL ro O{h. mhqh..F4tfiEb prd,6! phs hG u.d 2.o [Lbl. ro Mob/o nhur.r ooso Arr M6i. tu]tru 00 m Modolo tlom. mrtuI I Fno Mchir. F ofib. mLnurs

> SUBSCRIBEF ACTIVITY SUMMARY

Monthly R6currlng Acc6t charg€s

Buslness Esssnnab Add'on MRC for 12?01 ' 12131

ng ht 12n1 - 12131

C.Iulu S.rvlc.o ChlrgcC€ ular $arcd Us€s€ AdlAddtonal Anylim€ Mlnut€s

Tolal C€llular Sdvlc€s charg€s

Sprlnl Surch.rg..r Fsd€€l.Unlv Serv Ass6Es Non"LO

'spnirsudr.E- h.ff s.n@r b 6!d |!h yoJ h h.b d.ft.y 6rr irlq.d46. Su,6.ro, hdb..rn.ffi F D '!!h.d

e odbd arn Fu 6ry lD $@h.as tur incd.: F.d,.j cF, qlll.e.il.l ..dnlnbd6 !,'ro,, 9@ @irb.4a,r6. .rd orlF .h{!6 lrdrd ro Ee. d. &rodd.d {h\;m,nh.nratp!am.TlialM6.{d rh.dltiffi d.db..ldh sr.tdr. .M!, G drbid to de!!.

15,0010.00

u--ar., o^4'.'lhn a@sc chars€s

UBSCRIBER

C.llul€r gorvlco! C

e!l!- It!! _!).lTor2l0s 05:1sP hcqin!r2l0s 06:32P cSrfLoTSr2l00 06:33P POFTSIOU

. rzloe 06:4tP cllrnlols

'12llo 06:3aP rlsFolK,

$lr c.llul.r s*vlc.. cdt D.rdt

!t!!

odrr Chldi

No 06r. Tlh. C.X To Nu3a r2l19 r0.oir PORrsro{rHrvAm r2l19 10r3lA POqtsl(l)tH,VA3012/10 10r55A poRtS{OlJrH. VA3712l19 10:57 lncding3S J211€ 11r21A FqTmUI{IVAss l?/19 12:rP XoRFOLKiVA,0 r2ll' r2:sP rncdinrs1l2l1d 0r: r,rF *|pHrg,r92 i2l1S 01ta1P ilE pHrS,s3 i2l10 0s.r3! fof,FoLx,vat4r2ts 03:36P rnodit06 12l19 0tr1rP riconinq0612/il 03:21P Inc lng0712/is i0:6lP li@rngsg 12l19 10r50F POnrc{OUTll, VAs0 t2l20 05137 ilonrcu(,vA

r0012/20 02t44P hofling101 l2l20 02:lgF vIROIltIS0l{,vai0212120 03:rop rcFoLI,V10312/20 06:3iP h*nrntro,{ l2l20 06:42r hdii!ro5 r2120 07:3rP ihdrn!ro. 12120 o7r52P rnd4in!107 i2l21 12r65P tioFFOLK,VAr0012/21 0r:27P lndt sro0 l2l2r 01 :33P xsFolr(,vlilo 12l2i 01 :46P Vrio!ir30H,vAril l2l21 0lr46P Itu ingfi2 r2l2r o2:r5P rErFHrS, n1r3 12121 05rssP Iicoornt1i412/22 r0:,€A dnnloTsvL,va :

116 12/2? 01r00P rn.o.hqi16 i2123 10r59A ofiEAT s00.VA .11712121O2ralP ln ingils 1214 03156P hodinq111 12l24 01ro6P licodinst^ 12121 0f :23 t^dinj121 l2l27 07.$r iof,FoLK,V122 i 2 | 27 ot t2BP thcdr\ora t?/2t 01:a1P NonFou(,vi24 12/27 0la5P KFFOLK,Vi25l?/27 0?:o* rMr.ns12612t21 OZt11P ter,je127 t2127 02:2dP [GFot(VA123 12l2s 0!r16A ltuohriq120 i2l20 01:34 rSrHrS,Tl{130 l2l20 01:adP rsFoLx,v131 12l23 001?1P NoFFoLX,vA152 1212s 0At2n ltudjit13312/20 05:r6 lrOfiFor-X, Vri3,l 12/2t 06:20 lrcolligr3s r2l2e 06:.3P r.din!r33 r2l2e 03:57P PEc 60r.ru,Ms13712l30 05:21P rcBmL(,vAr3rr2/30 r r:27P o nrcrsvl,v13S 12l3r 02:4iP ilCfiFou(,VA140 l2l01 ozrll:lp llofiFol(VA

7r2lr1 0e:20p PoRrgFuT312/r1 0s:40P PoRist olT012/lr os:{sP hcqins0 i?/1r io:2ap roRFoLI.vr r2l12 r1:11A hoonrnc,212112 rr.63A tnc{tngB r2l12 o7:,tsP hcmin!i412l12 11.24P hooningi5 12/13 03:51^ POFTS&UTj6 r2lrs 1o:ila rncortn!j7 12l13 02:40P ttofiFoLl(v;3 r2113 03:26P ilOhFOLXiti0 12/13 03:2BP Oima,(,Vi0 12li3 o,ti00P ricoring:i 1?/13 0a:23P rncorrnsj2 r2lr3 07ri1P rnoo.l.g6312/14 05: 1oA I10RF0LK,!64 r2l r4 05:26A rnc'in!c5 i 2/i4 10:15P rncdino66 12l15 03:03P N0RF0LK,\6712l15 06:07P lncdln!6312/15 05.22P lncqin!59 12l15 06:,(1P JACK3o{V[70 r2l16 05:otA roBFoLlq r7r r2l15 05:07 rncuiig7212l16 03 r25P N0iF0LKrV7312116 06r27P Inc ins7,1 1?/16 07ra3F PofiTEl]Ul7512/17 05 r07A tnc ino76 r2lr3 04:$F rncdin!7712lr3 os:42P xE PHrs.l73 t2l1S 07:199 NoFFoLK,V79 r2lr0 02:03 [oaFoLx,v30 12l19 02:45a lnco.in!sj l2l1s 07:35a oFFoLKiV

s312/r9 09 ra6A PonT$t)Ut

tE (1)

)UR SPRINT INVOICE

iUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

Ccllular Sqvi... Cdt Betsil

F@rd€ .Long od / Td.trrspq 2) Mins- u!{. o)g chaJF

t:00 0,00

o,26

:00 na.50 40.00lOsrsncaodw6tunitnclcd-ayLG,!**_-,,,.doddaddale

Addirionsl Iil6{9ing D.r.flNcn*.r.1

USS NEW YOFK {LPO 2J ),noJ,*,no- NEA.! Et- |

hdlid Fs& Tobt 'pLhouboins oftP.r<

l2lst 06:04P ilOATltle@q r!l2l31 06:32P Pr€Cr6O{rLl,XS12/31 0€:s,1P t€DrcArcErr Tx

:flTI" ?1. !g if/T qrr.. Addny€r '%nud

hie. vobi. b vdl..Fne.al' Md,h/.,"ru nhur.6 Mohr.

Fd ii:h{Fbd,hlptehs6.a |,130 Mohi.b dL nitu, m:ooar, !k5lt./Anrdm., oo{o tt St bHd.ft h,.d 6!0 ltdL ! ofio. mh6.

ond IXiICI Conn€cl on Spilnt SummaryTdal Phn

Mh:56

I Addr0ond n-..gtne chlrgrDal,. Sflio- U.ag. D€ldt

iUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

I6t.llld.rDhcconndd$i.ro{a- aostkt :Thb

'.i.d l?ddB hh6jsn&q'.d 6 yd m.j€ Odcdnd od Srrl phoe, Olw Connd.n sain( !hor,

T.$DC, {d OciJn T{hOc caih dkhc G. bifino D.ilqd

:-::,-.j> SUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

L.m (Br LcOh' grhbr!Ewibln Fls KE€hnt KEiEtrt' r€,EFr.

lJ*;;

rorMs Epo6 e Qmplbd a a 6uey b h.F }!U 4.lyz. r.a. rbid6 ad tui.g. Fur.dr6ds* -liilty,

$*.?qp.alelltln!tc'."e... . . ...... ...9I$.rr{.!..r$r*.

llonthly n dring Acct . ch.rg6Budn.$ E$ontals Add-on MRc icr 12101 - 1z3rUnllmlled 2"Way Text lt{essaqinq lor 1201 .12ls1

llr15.0010.009r.q9r4.n14,o,'l_sA!(..........,..............-f?qsL9y!i.cx!!-.er-:9R1n

,e944 gg-tsi*r!:Totel Monhly Fedlnlng Acc.r. ChaA.6c€llulr sdvl... Ch.rg-c€!'iar sh.r€d Usas. AqAddionsl Anylim€ Mlnut€b

,.

\

$25. OO

-8.508,50

Toral c.llular sdvi€s chaEes

Sp.inl Surchlrg€3

' ffirsJ .Unfu S6rv Asse.s tlon-L-D 3.430*

$0,00

0.36rqr oih- llhiL R.4h! $o.3eTohl Spdni SuEndgG

}R SPRINT IN'

NSTEFT

BSCRIBER ACTII

ffE€. tuF ed re vi.t sdini.lldar S€rvic€. Cdt D6r.

uss NEw YoRK ([m 211

12/01r

C.llul- Iwic- cdl D.tril

E4!e

/0J 04:51P ltmrcr(,va

,04 04:s8a onFoLK,va

Y04 05:59P trOFFoLl(,vA,04 061ooP OSFoLK,VA,05 05;11A XoAFOLk,VAr/05 06:24 Nof,FOLK,vAvos 09r2aP l{ofifoL.t(, va,0€ 03:€^ lofiFotl(rvr/06 01:55F N*FoLK,VAr/@ oi:57P ilo€rcu(var/07 os:1{A tocFoll(iv

r/0I 0?:22P NORFoU(,V

2/09 05:00P lloRFotKjvAr/o€ o5:,t3P rceFotKrv?/r2 r1:,ra lonFoL(,v2/l? l1 :53A il4FOL(,VA,/r? o7:19F r{onroLK,vaz/r 2 r 1:24P rlofiFOLK,V2/13,q2ilsP fioRForKrv^211'3|02i2rP NoFFoLK,VA2/13 02:35P TIoFFOLK.VA

?/19 04:00P NoRFOLX,VA2/13 04i23P NonFOLK,VA2/13 07:ilP aloSFOLKiVA

2/14 05:264 XOfiFoLK,VA2/ra 07r 19P I{ORFOT(,VA2/14 r0:4rP NORFOLX,VA2/r. 10:45P ofiFOLK.VA2/r5 06:o7P NOFFOLK,VA2/rs 06:22P rcnmlK,V2/16 05:074 IO€FOL(,VA2/r6 06.21r ilOnfoL(,V2/16 o0:27P ilOnF€Lr(,V2/r7 05:074 OnFOLI(,VA2/13 0,t:56P onfcll(,Y2/19 02:16 XSfOTX,V2/re 02:.6 rroRFor&v^2^9 03:35p qFOtl<,Vr211s 03:3sP llolmu,v

r2l20 02:1-{P ][O0FOlx,Vr2l20 03:s6P OAFOLK,V

l!o. o.b rm c.t ro51 12120 05:3rP ilonFoLx,v^62 i2l20 06r,tzP XSFOLI(,VA63 12l20 0Br52P iloRFoLl(,VA61 i?/?r 02:27P ffiFoLXiVA55 12/21 0Z:3rP tiofi FoLX,va53 12121 02r33P rrofi FoLKTVA57 12l2r 02:33P iloFFOLKIVAse 12/21 02r33P rncmlit59 12l2i 02r,(6P IIoRFOU(,VA30 12/2i 02:47p trORFO|.X,VA3l 12l?2 02rOoP rrlRFOLK,VA3212/23 03:4lP lhfiFoLK,V63 12123 04:s3P flogFoL(,VA61 12/29 05r06P IiOSFoL&VA9512/21 10r 23p {ofiro1(,va6d i2l27 o9r23A IoRForX,yA0712/27 o3[9r rrco.l.q6a 1rl2? or :2@ Nor.oLx,vao i2127 0i:r1P Incdins7o12l2? or:r+ rcfiF'(,v7l 1212? 02:O3f rffFltx,V72 r2l27 o2:o3P ilOnfoajqv?s r2l27 02:05F rofrFo{lqv7. r2l27 o2:l.P rofrForr,vt512l2f o2r21P lndins73 trl23 05:r&r Knfouqv7' 1?/r3 01 :3?P rcFos(v73 l2l23 or:!3P rcr..!{&vD12123 01:,loP Indinsto 12/24 06:27p XOamU(,v0112/2S 05r164 lrc{iiq32 12/29 05:204 nofr F!tr(,vA33 l2l31 0.1139P rlof,Folx'vA

l' tl c.l&le silc- ft:m.'Lom Oll|io.Orhr @lutr iNlud6 diy Lds 0l

I Addltlonal lfetgins D€l.ll

Ior.I lddllLnd l-{fu qu!-

O Ddrg€flic.. urg. D.!il

Ch!!d

qlsaslg

--9r9S

rofr

OUR SPRINT INVOICE

21) cont.

SUBSCRIBER INFORi'ATIONAL REPORTS

utur b h.! yq...lrb a.c.nun Dd trlq. Fu' !'neb.. sny

USS NEW YOBK (LPD 21)'""fk--* NEfiE- l'

J/^

frb:-t( 4^ hn /ea,4,"d +nd( u',. ^? ' A

Spdnr Dd. sdi6.,. . .. .,|i*n $:.19*&r . . . .. .

C.lodrlArilcr. Fouins hdud.dCrlld lO

Odreio LO Fd. toOolec M

Anydm MiruL3Lq Dictu Whlh Rar'9rftbiLtor obll.MleErhadd vdl6ir.i

!!'!4 rtar! q !!!'d !{!'a,r' 9e!9F_ut9!9.,...,_.-.-...

dimo Ulag€ Det8il

n ardlh u.{. ch.'!

Tod oih.r Bll$b TdlMinrse MhSa Mh:s& Mins* ch.ts'r

u Mn:s- tElud. AhniF ha@, Addriond (8dE) dr6. lldL b M.bb rh6, a^v M.br.ani ni6,xob"loh6 mhuB. .nd Moblb b Ofiic. mi.eu'ririil,i,,l'i**r'-** ro€?no ohi.b!tdr.mhd,o0!oAnvMobN'Ainrm' oofl Mobir'bHomo

c, and 6(l$ ra.6L b Olla. mhc

uss NEW YORKILPD

,R SPRIN1

,USSN

BER A(

lJss NEw YoFK (LPo 21) #;i::"' lk"** rvecre- l'O Dd! Swlc.a U$gc D.h

Lal(B/ L*s Odr.r siLhl.EEbinF,ln t@EMb KB/Ekrr. KB/Eek

olluld S€wic6 Cdt t

!e-,@-- 94ro _

/?1 06:27P Poiftt(ruTll,v

'2402|10rPoRTS,I.|JIH'vA

?4 02:05P mq sno(l4q tL

2S 07i13P PoqTSmJfl,V

nc./ortrs 6r!dn ldud- dy L1

lilion€l MGtaglng D.l,Nun$...1M.e:on

Chrl!.r

Ltd Dd. S.!t{ Ch.t!-

> SUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

9:lis!fl_i!'.{................_...._........ ....,ts1-Fl,y._d-br,!4E.9s!En_ql,sFilr.-.....,....,......_..,.. _.r!eer_P!!g-c.c!r?g.:.sP,'tI.

.?|fel Ps: &ql!e

t n9 Dh@ WhiL Bodh!

Ed!!!!4 Vg!el!t4

!trie!r'..fjtrtt_!.!!(r8.llt.g?n-. .. _.B6id E!:rih addd mc

ftriln tb.9 D.tall'Pl

dp.6k Mhls& MdS- Mhrs& Mhs+ ch.@

Y"t tr/nimiE dt !!--'pi.n liris- aE!d. tntdr mhcb, A<ldldond (SnF) tril6 $obb to dr' m'uL Anv [{dl',^'ni@ miiM' iLblob Hom minur., !d MotiL io ollL. mhd*

;d;;,;;;;; rs,imu--.M.b!..h* m ooAn' r,tdr'&'nru' d @ rldr'b q'h'iilc, .nd 0oo rloti. b ofilo. nhd*

_- ao.oo

NEWYORRGFEEJ

IUR SPRINT INVOICE

UBSCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

Datarnu Ttrta prrryGOatq u6aq€

rotat OaU ana nru earty SerVoasSpilnt Surchlrga.' Federal .lJniv S€ t€.€ss Non-LDTotal Sprlnt Surcherye; $0.96

"*j!::::hl!:_T t,1*.:.!*. b cor4 16r }bu6h.hd.n y 6i. rnp...d oi 6 sucrqe& Nidbrddortr.*...Fqrrtd b c.rd nn 1* ryr"*. sd"r'a-,a,.1,a" i*l.r risl"t',*r-fi; -*-

e_mh6de cn!rt., s@ 6c.d5.e!-, ft od; d.I!* ti:{,!d bM q.;,id; d,-!ffiffidp,qnm rbl,ruiEi.nd f66nlFdwb @ ioc*!b;3udE9. .twd,G,4d bdqE _

UBSCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

Collql€l S.rvlc- Cdt D.tait

Dd. Tim. C.t To

0r/02 03r00A rcnFoLKrva

01/02 0a:26P rcAFOL(,Vlor/02 06:dP PoalsurrH, vA

or/a o6:5€P rc{Fotx,v^

01 /04 01r31P r{Of, FoLK.V01/ 04 L 12P I1ORFoIK,VA01/06 10 t,17A oBFOLKTVA

0l/06 12r32F rcqFoLK,V

01/07 09:a3r rcnFoLK,vol/07 1lr33r No{FoL(,vl

USg NEW YORK {LPO 21)

.EL I"

Cdful* Sfii{ro C

lkl Dd Iifu c.l 19

21 0r/o7 0s:qP h{iist0 0t /07 0a:21P chRLOTg3r 01/0? Ds:2r qunLoTE32 01/07 o7:SSP reqtn!!3 01/0s 01:1&l rndin!nr 0r /03 0

'22a rndin{

3,5 or /os o2:06P Po€rsrcu.saol/o911r12r rnMins3701/o.12r€3p ri41n033Ol109 12i51P [0RF0r(,!s9 01 /or o3:5aP roconlnda0 01/00 10:51P tncohrno410i/10 01.1sP lnc thg42 01/10.02 r43P rrcdiis13 01/10 06r13F lndino4,t 01/10 07r5?P hdinq16 0l /10 0s:3@ lmqinqla01/11 05.16r{tlcdingr? 0r/11 07:r!rp iqFou(vr130ta12 05:lt^ mfou(vra00r/r2 05:r? rndir'g5.0i/r2 0?r..r rndrno5l 0l/12 o?:rap roeFou!v,52 0l/12 07:50P hqinq5n 0l/ls 06:o{P ronForxrv,5,1 01 /13 06:05P NonFo$,Vl16ot/rs os:a6P Imdins5601/1105r17A hdrns5701/14 03:o2p rncdiis5301/1,1 0Br10P Incolig00 0j/15 0rr2rP oqFol(,v60 01/10 0sr21A lnooiihg61 01/16 111504 PoqrsnurH,a201/t6 l2r30P XOflFot(,VA33 01/1€ i2:5SP Ponrspufl,34 0t/15 olra POnnircurH,d5 0l /17 01 r3€P hdjns.sorlr7 02r01P rlrcdr.o670t/1? o7r.lP rndinq6ror/r7 08:o6c rdrrs31 0in3 02:35P hdlgto 0!/ia 06:15 xcRRxjcv7r ol/la o5:r2P hdlns?20t/ta 0s:50f hdincrs 0!^e 6:@ ildf!{.rqv7a 01/rc 06r57P Pofrr€su'fi,t76 01/1r 07:02P lIdlng70 0l/J€ ot:o6P l@inq770rlr9 07:o7p &\YsTLdr6,r7301/19 07r10P Incorhgn 0l/10 07r39F rncdiig30 or/1S 0or57P PO6Tsr0UT1l,t

0i 01/19 11rs8F TolI F..e C.

82 /20 06r l?l lio{Folr,va33 0r /20 03:3?t Poflrs! ,vs401120 01;3sP Inodins3501/2! 0{:5{P Insdug

0.99

$0,99

0.36

, Ohd CJd!.r

0,00

OUR SPRINT INVOICEuss NEw YoFK (t"PD 21) *i.$ry^'kT:-** NHrH- [F&rusy 04,2010

USS NEW YORK (LPD 2l) conr.

SUBSCRIBER INFOFMA'IIONAL REPORTS

[dime U!8ge D€tdlslrhl.

Mhs* MhsG ch.@

,t.tAlt1l".u.r.ch.r!- a!.o1{ Mlis* hclud. Antrim mhul€i, Addtitnrl {Bru) r!tuL., M.6L It Mobt hhh.AnvlrobL.A.Ydsrid-'tL6l.tLru hid, -n M.bL b ol&. nhqlx.

q lrh b{ Bba. d* phm h.. u..d 127es lLbL b rL6{. mlrh. @no tuv lAL&t{h. c.io rloh&b rb'tnl.16, {d ssoMobr.b Oitu hli!t-,

uss NEw yaRK-iIEiZij

/R SPRINT INVOICEUSS NEW YORK (LPD 2]) ffii,_ffi::""'"'J*"",* nro<ru- l"

e' s;i;-i:';, i:;: ;&;; " "'.' .e!*{ 9iri.(!Ay!! > SUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

Ld! Olrrs Wtur. Fddl!

!,.!ais,.9......,_...,._ .......... ... gfqtMtiir!€

sE lrcl..anrrm nhtu,rdclld (8 .6) di6, M6lk b r.!aa tu, Anr **r.tu M6, Mora.nn@, .nd u.ht b oifr nhtull pdied, rhl phm hG 6€d 12so rrobrh ro Mobi. miih, oono anr Mob{.Anlm, oono M.,bb b r@ nitub,

]SCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

)nlhly R.cuning Acc€.. Chtg..:ir€s6 Ess€ntals 4000 MRC for 01lo1 -Otl31 112.49

10.00

IBSCRIBER INFOHMAIIONAL REPORTS r F€deral -Unlv S6v As€€ss fbn-t_O

.$dd sudr!- d dd s.r@.6 rcId {En Fq b h+ o.rny @rb,ra, edl@ m, hud.: Fdj usF, Bnbo t[B

lleqrdlre-.0'I F+bdnEq.ndd: cwa iE,!dbMce .@;$i1i,-tuE u'.d b .&c s@r!. .l]nr!, o ejd m .heq..

S, C!{trl!I Sorvl@6 c€ll O.tail

;d@

1 01/01 10,1A Nof,F"rrtl,2 ol/ol 03:o8P ilonFolx,v,3ovo2 o7:r2a xonFouqvr4 01/02 03.oo rn*ino5 0r/02 0l:osP 03F0lk,yr6 01/or 02:roP lrciFoLr,vr7 0r /02 0,r:26P rrcdings 01/0s 10:51A iloqFolrqvtI 01/03 0€jt9P [!FFoLX,VA

10 01 /0s 05:.BP lrofilotx,v^11 0l/0n o3:56F hdinq12 0l/03 0g:2gP rcnfol&V^13 0l/03 00r30P rcRFoLX,V1,r0t/0,{ rx:2?P xonFotx,v15or/0a 0r:3rp lftding1301i06 r0:4? hdrnqt7 01/05 10:,r8a NoFFotx,va19 01 /05, 0r. r2P riofiFor-rq vAIror/05 05r31P llontoL{,v^20 0l /o5 fi i26p ranFoLx,v21 0l /06 1 I ..16P lloBFoLK,vA22 01103 1?rs2P lnodinC25 01/07 0.ra2 tocFo(x,v2r d/07 0rt52r tcForl(,v?5 01/07 oe:43 rncoriis26 0l /07 03:s4P lmfiFolK,V27 01/07 07:39P rOFlOLt,vA2S 01/ol 01:16 lohFouc,v29 ot/03 01r22A CqFoL&VA30 0i /0s 1l12a 1to8F!LK.Vsl 01 ros tars3P iloarcLKv12 0i /00 6:5tP tioiFoL](v^3g 01/09 oe,olP lcFoLr(rv3,( 0l /00 l0r61F ltOFFoLx,v35 ol tlo 01:1$ mFFotr,va36 01 /10 02:,€r lfrfol-l(,v3701/r0 o5r,(3P rqmu(,v93 01/10 07,52P iIoRFoLK,VA

'1,.€ Od / Tdrlurya-,-9U!r -_9!!re!

ial Monlhly F€drrlns Acc$5 Charq€s

USS NEWYORK(LPO 21)

8llll!AD.d*-

--0ll.r

,TINT INVOICE

ISCRIBER ACTIVITY SUiIMARY

lC.llullr aorvlo.. C.ll D.t

Ch{!.t

0, o0

lul€r S6rvh€ CharA-luhl Sharcd U6a€e Adllltonal Anydh€ Mlnut€s

rl Cellulsr S€rutces Charg6s

n Spdnt Sunhglg€s

r@ The .munb, .id f€ qpd{6 ui.d b dt !L;s{ch.r!. dd,i3, e !d.c b ch.,ro..

SCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

ihl Surchsged€ral -Unlv S6w Assess Non-LD

23 02/0S 0€r52P ionFq_Krv^2e o2l0s 06r5?P rtottllx,v3002/10 05rlar $FoL&VA31 0210 0.r13P KnFoL(,vA3204/10 03116P rcnFlL(.VA3ao2/tO o6:2€P Ircdiis3402/10 0o:3rf lhdlnl3502/10 07:66P rhoonlno9302/fi 05j 13A XOSFoLjqVA97m/1l o5r66t rrcrinq3302/11 !3:1lP Inoortnq .s302^2 05:12 reF6L&Vao02l12 05:22 rturrlsal02/12 03r07P Inc{tisa202l110€:1aF rEdrrqat02/12 sr13t ftnFou(,vr1402/1311:314Ino iig.502/13 02.1+ rndlrs :16o?/1( o3rla hD rns170211,1 0,{:2€P Inoortnsr302/11 09:0{9 rtu ir{4e 02/r. 00:15P roFFou(v5002/la 09r15p lloRFou(,va5l o2l14 oer16? ltudirll5202/15 0S:1r hodrns6302/16 10:i{0 honing5il02115 02r96P Irc{in!4502/15 06:1rP rMoninq5302/15 10:$r hcdlno6702/16 05: rir riosfolK,vr!sm/10 05:22 rcnFo$rv3e 02^6 0€:20P XORFoLX,VA

60o2/1. N:':rP Indlno3t 02/13 o6r3aP NOnFolqVA52 o2l17 osil,r NoxFoll<,v$ 0et17 05125 tndln!6402/17 o7r26P ric lno35 o2l10 05r12 tiOiFo{X,VA6.!2t1S 612ol rnqhq3702/19 oBr19P Inooniir03 02/t0 osioln c$Fotrqv3.02/ll0a:09F ltu !n!7002^9 06:35P l@nln!fl ozlre 0€:0oP Imdlng7202120 12:5CA hcdliqt3 02/20 io:06A Ino{iic7402/20 t0:07 lloRFol-x,v75 02/20 10:!a XCmU(V700?/20 11r23 hoonlns77oelft 01:laP ltu{tng7S 02/21 o3:3$ Inc{tn!79o2l21 orr!0 NofiFolllvA

3! 02/21 lorl9 Ino$inq i32 02/21 12:921 ltuolnoa3 o2l21 12:S5P qITALOT8IL,VA ,

3101/21 01rJ6P ho lnt

-7,67.6

$0.o

0.36

$0,36utse rdbdLcrqn)qb,ta. surch.4a;4,i r|/. F;d UsF, ,.rut&r;.,F,1'f,16 cM!6, sE EdrFr dElo dd dtlrdrioc r rcdb.@

rEd. her ehd rtu vidt SprhlEd

d€( g..dc.! Cdl t).bil

rho cdTo,_ -

0,00

UR SPRINT INVOICEuss NEw YoFK (LPD 21)

['ifll'#]""' liff;:-"** ttE<TEt IMarch04,2010

USS NEW YORK (LPD 2t) cofi,

UBSCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

Cellulat S€rvico3 Coll Dstr

02/?1 01:13P Inconlhqd2l21 01r23P llORFOT-K,VA

,02/?1 0t:36P NEI{PT E{]E,VA

02/22 05: 10A lloFFoLK,VA

-!-&4!!

,0rlr3 05r r0A NaRFoLK,va3 02/23 06r30P hoodinq4 02l23 07;01P rloflFolK,VA6 02l?4 06:11A r\rRFoLr(, VA

602/24 05t23P !nc0[1n0r702l?4 03:41P NoRF0LK,V)a02/24 00141P NonFoL!VA:0 d2l?5 06:1lA lloFF0L(,var0 o?/2s o5;3oA Inco lngn o2l25 o5:23P NofiFOLK,VA02 02l25 06r43P Incomin00302/26 05r 11A NOfiFoLK,VA04 02/27 01r41P CnF0LK,VAos02r27 02rosP POSTSUoUTH, VA

03 02l27 02r10P PoF ls1,IouTrl,vA,07 02l2? OS1o3P *AnLoTS{t, VA

r03 02/27 06rr1P rncomlns1o€02/27 07:50P [nlPHIS,TNr1o 02/27 00:s3P NoAFoLK,VA111 02l27 09r4?P toRFOL(,VA112 02/27 09r65P In.ohn011302/23 03r31A hc rnqll4 02124 1o:s4A Incotrlno115 02/?3 10:14A In.drns1r6 02/23 12r43P lncohinqr17 o2l23 olr15P hc ino

] 02/2s 01r49P lic.nln!

Lcaq Odd@ Whlb F.amns

r"".6i run' s""r"o c't'oso'Lons Did cdothq dluM indlud* dY L(

E Addllional lil.$aging Dora

> SUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

-od

ddhu d!.s. chr{6 Mdo Antu€ nrcb! rloor.:Pd r,tn se id"o. Air' m iys ^ddi d'B'dG)rhrm Mo

l:n";m,*x;:n r-g":ii:L ".- - "*' -'-'- * -

mhqk, dmooMobibborlE'rr F

addlrloial M-..slng chd!..

"d{T llt{

, NEW

)RIBER ACTI

Bllllng Period

Ffu-* NE$EL l"ussNEwYoakGm2t MsDho4.zO1O

C.lluld 3d

No D.L In! C.

r S..vic€o Cdt tLts

io cal l0 q'!@

lot.l c.llhr s.dte- ch.('Loll q.b$.orhs 6&6 I

I Addiliond il€.€.

sMs L[ ll$s!.!Iou rddmond |l{gh4 c

(D D.bs.rvlcr. tl

> SIJBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

M6{d Ch]06

ripdlt o 6dbd d 46u'!.yio

gFsqqlrs9r*!T...... ......................tjgqi'.*!gggl"!9 9!rbao us. $rh 6rs.ti-r

)UR SPRINT INVOICEUSS NEW YORK (LPD 21)

i{r,Llf:l-"";3;:*.* uncrrt I

iUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS k// -M lz!" /t'u14!d far0 u,u ArJ't

-[*-

Lonq oi'l!.€Whllo Romh!

Ehh'r"d vohl-"ltr. -. . . -

dGs ErdialB a0co MFC

i ime bags D.lallodiq SllbbL Tolrl

Mhisx Mh:6& cfi!'ld

1d []in S* nolud€ l$]dru Flnd6, Addilonal GonG) mlnub MdHr. ro Mohib mhub', Anvtloblr'.Anrrino mhe' irobb

r rlom€ hind'e. .nd Mob0c to ollh. mhdldi,iii" rliiiiE,*'rii ii;i; ;;

'i.i,ro v*i.

" v"ti. ".'* oo00anvvoo'JaAnFft oomMdt.bHo-'

indss. rd 0o!0 Mchll€ lo O1lic6 minurG

or.l Akllft u&q. ch!r!@

,ussNEwEmFEi?ij

R SPRINT INVOICE

ISCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

uss NEw YOFK (!PD 21)

BlllndPdod p!s.

ffi$f '"^' itk-** t-toctu- [flo. p.! rlr c.tto

3{ 05/25 0t:15P PORrsl3503/25 00: tAP PoRrSl,s603/25 09;tA? N0FF0!s703/25 09r1SP NoRFOL3t 03/25 09la1P hqt3S 03/26 05rotP tC&I,40 rN"23 05rO2P InnFoLa1a3/23 c6r1oP !rc t.12 03/26 0Sr47P lio l,ls 03/23 darl€P licdj.4 03/2711rroA tno ia6 03/27 12rt7F toRFota€ 03/2t r2:3,tP lndl17OSl2? 06r!5p ||mFol

t0 03/27 03! t7t NoRFol60 03/27 odj8rp ri48Fol5j 0sl?3 o3 r24P rndqr52 09121 05r 16{ ilaRtut63 0gl2c 06r10P tnqr5r 06/F 06r$F rnc :55 0S/30 06113 iloBFot

To c.nrlj.a.rvld ct.llrL.rE Olbnc./oIh.r 6lum iL

I Addldond anVr.C€ Nunbrd EllbL lia.i hlil Addbrf,l Addli'n l

sirt64p. liPln M*€e rl€{- Fd. M-@ Rdr M@ cha!6sMs TdiLn€.. 30 0s so

lc XB/ Lco$s BlLbhEFnt ln PLn KmEft K8€wnn KA€ds

rinl Sutcharg€s

3SCRIBEF AC,TU!rY DETAIL

rllular S.rvic€s Ci

o Tih6 csl To

s/25 05r2tP a{oeFotx,

otrq ch46

Totilldddrn.l .{h!chrrlr

O od. S..vlo.e U!.9. D.t ll

Tor.l DlIl s.dl{. chlg{

> SUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

YOUR SPRINT INVUICE

--r Ew YORK (LPD 2t) cont.

USS NEW YOBK (LPD 2'

> SUBSCRIBER '

-l

olhlrcha!.i

> SUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS{ catutr scrvi"r cr

No. D& Trn. car To

!t!d-9e!'pg.g!-si!--....-. - -.--.,..--.---.---tq$l-pi!g-crft!!9:-sF!!-

103/0i 05:0r rnqlng2 osror o.:55P NRmLx,v3 o3l0r 06r0?F ilona4x,\

6 03/01 05r059 BAYSTLC!)

6 03/01 06r!AP rceFOLK,\703102 05: 16,r rn.dlhc0 0r/02 04r22P lonfoLx,ls 03/02 01150P ilo8FOLK,r

1003/02 07r20P NoaFoLl(!r1i 0s/i1 03rabF no9Folx,r12 03/12 00:2Sp rogFotlqrl3l)3/13 1I r,l{A rlo0Flxl(,1lad/ 0s:5rP r.€flFoLK,'1503/1,r ol rl iP rncodtnc1603/23 05r1lA rncdtnd

rror/23 06:53P ilCAR Lrqieos/$ 0a:soP xdFolx,20 03/23 06:6SP roflFOLX!

2303/?a C5r0e h.dlnq21 os/25 0E:074 rhcotlis25 d3/25 06rl3a hcorlnr23 03/25 05:57P [onFOLl(,2rm/25 07:36p XOf,FOLl(.

?6 OS/2s 0tr13P oRFOtlq

2l oS/26 09r,llP NORF0LK'

t0 03/26 01:s2P NoRFoLXT

3i $rfi 05:02P I.cdrir32 03125 06r top ileFoLx,3103/t ll:404 KaFot(3,t 0s/27 1g:27P rncdln5603/27 12rS,(P o€FoLK

3a 6/27 06r$P r$6F0LX37 !3/27 06:35P rhcdrn

3o 03/23 03 :07P NlnFOLl(

10 os/ae 06116A h.oih11 03/20 05:10P I{oRFOLX

.2cr2r o3:a3P rsiFotl<4 6/ao 06:19r rmdln

Torrl c.llulll ldb. qtrry.

'LolE Dinin .Dlhdelum ld

Loic Dhlrd Whl/. Boshc

l{ttqtsd-1ld,nq_}.rt4-l,ll'.lf,'.i_....._.....,,,..._...9{.u!*..\h-u!!...._..SuliiG' E3-di.]! Add{n MRc Monlhlr Pl* chrs€

> SUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

- ta."o -- .o.oo

f, l Llonlhly Roclnlng Acc... ctlrg-Bu6ln€s6 Ess€ndals 4ooo MRC ior 03/01 - 03,€1

unllmltsd 2-way Text M€cr€glng bt osiol -03/91

Total Monhly tu(,lnins Acc.65 Che€66

sprlnl Su(chtrg-" Fedoral -Untv S€rv A.s.6€ N,on-LD

'spMr sud,ld o eus.rw. b or.d rln 'ou

b h@ d.v d.-,ry9:::1:..:1j*1?I * * "#jiX ;:;i G-JU-I v",cth, s"Lh'a-tuYi"&d''F didusF trlu'bryddod#ililL-."#::iliiJi iiii iii"iiiJiil"''o"'n''*.:YE11to**""il;:;. il;;:;;a;6;;.d roo.rq,h; sudl"'!'d"' 9"S*9:

112.45i0.00

\

YOUR SPR.INT INVOIUbUSSNEWYORK(LPD 21)

rtE lt Et- |,aa"rm > SUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL> SUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

$, Collular S6rvic€6 Catt tleiail

.fe*.! pq.flqq!9.t

Monthly Rsc{rrrlng Acc€.. Chargo€Busin€ss Ess€nuals 4ooo [4 RC fo. og/01 - 03,€ 1

.03/0r 05r03P ln.oh!no

:9:191 T'!9! glY!ruoule'* PP/Prr60s/01 06rsgp oRrcu,va , pp/riir/pu sl:do ;,fi ;.;;703/02 05:15A rnm.lhs , op/w/pu lsroo o,oo o.o;s03/02 04:2?P {onFoL(vA PP/PI]e0s/02 01r50p NcfFoLtt,va , pp/flr/pu 2sro0 0,00 ;.;o1003/02 o7r2!P NoqFoLK,VA pp/|]M/pu loro0ri 03/lt osrs5p .sFoL(,va Fp/titiltpu l:oo ;,;;

1203/12 o3r29p IioAFOLK,VA ppllu/pu io:oo o,o01303/13 llrlta |oBFoLK,yA op/Nt/pu t:oo o,o1103/11o3r61F NonFoLK,VA op/r /pu siooi5o3/14 o,rir1P rncodhs oflr,m/Fu sroo1303/23 06 r1A licdins op/tw/pu lsroo1703/23 06;30A NCfFoLK,vA op/wlpu 3:oo1303/23 06rs3P |IRFoLk,VA pplr{l/plr tioors03/29 o6:59P oFFou,vA ppls/pu t:oo2003/23 06150P rioiFOLX,VA pp/fi/pu i:oo21 03/2r o6:60P NoRFoLt(,VA220Sl23 07:2sP rioRFoLX,VA pp/u /pu 4:oo23 0s/24 05:094 hcooiiO opllrr/pu l5:oo24 03/25 0s:07A rncomlns op/l{i/pu toroo25 03/2s 06:1€1 rncohlng op/w/pu 7:oo2603/25 06:67P oRFOLI,VA pp/ rl/pu 2:oo27o3l2s 07j3Sp NoRFOLk,VA PP/PU2S03/25 09:r6P NoFFOLK,VA op/w/pu 1:002903/25 oSrllP NOFFOLK,VA opllit/pu 7r0o3003/26 0{:52P No8FoLK,VA pp/urvpu t;oo3103/26 0s:02P hconing pp/r*/Fu sroo3203/?6 0sr10F NoRmLKiVA Pp/l,r/pu 1Sr0o3309/271l:4oANonFoLK,VA op/$r/Pu 6100

o'/rd[rft r: oo3603/?7 i2r31P NofrFola,vA @twtpu 2ttoo

@,w/PL 1.00o.oq

03@/27 o6:15P rncdins @/lAllPu i:oo9903/23 o3:07P NoFFoLK,VA oF/PU4003/2s 05116A Incodtng 0P/, r/PU 2Sj00,fi 03/29 06:,r0P NoRFOLK,VA pF/r*/pu 3r ioo.42o3l2s 06:13P lloFFoLK,VA PPlfi/PU 13:0013 03/30 0s:r9A Incmthq ,v. oP/rd/PU 22:00

Lois DbbE. Whlls Fohtn!

> SUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

Ti

dP

\

112.49Unlimit€d 2-Way T6xt l\,rl€ssasins tor os/crlTotal Monlhly Rodrning Acc€ss ChaE€sSpdnlSuroharg..' Fed€lal-Univ S€lV Ass€.s Non-LD 3.750t

$122.49

3.50Total Sprint Surcharges $3.50'spftt suro\6rs* e ds F cl@.o b 6tLd t6m tq b h€h d.iray odds itrF@od oi u,. s!rchlrs* ar d bx6 qroud- @ a€ GqLi,.d b cdl*r l! .. Fadrsj usF, €!u ao, r duryi,sonhi*dlv. ch6a6 glc @$. o .wr 6* 6@:tud d s@hr.nrdprce.m3 nE sdd, lid fi. enlpq.dr G.n b c!,cute suda!€ moutr, d aHdlo.h.n!..

Iohr c.rkllr s.fl* ch*!s'Ltrd DLdarcdorh.r oluhn lidudG aiy LmE Dkrffi., Dirdory AsdtuG {11l), ed our o, A@.h4d

R SPRINT INVOICE

ISCRIBER ACTIVITY SIJMMARY

r&ral -llntu S€w t€6€s3 N,on-LD

al Sprint Surchsigesfitsslnal* e te rc oh$s b c.ld lbh !e!ro hlb d.tnycod |fiF{d s ui slrEn r!* e rcrl.For,d # e E+l.d b cdrd lM )b! br ts. suldl:'!6 F.y tndud. F.d*d JsF, ElL6rydrrc4,,r ddt !tus. 9b 'qhb o\.id, xd od.' d'.rFr tnorEd brld' 6a ddid.d *h sd.mmad9M3. Th. mocns, .nn $. ehFdr$b us.d ro ..l!tb 3ft1u!. l@n!, e tubl.d ro choca

USS NE\'{ YORK (LPD 21) ffi'""'ffi[-"-* ruaan- [C.llulat S.rvio!€ C€ll o.trtl

Es Ra' r,dr.bvd qxii-,ltul.r S6rvlc.. Cdl o.tdl

No 0e nm c.r ro Nun$3 fu:?r !4!!e______qr!___9!!_ !\a*3rN/2s oo:isp ponlsrdrrx,va toPDr/PU 1,00 0.003t o!/25 0r:r6F R8rElr'orlr,va oP/r/Ptr 2:oo36 03/25 d0r3P toBtuL&V op/P!3703/25 09r9P ITORFoLX,VA d/rr/?U 1:o0s303/26 osr,tlP rtldr@ #/ll/ru ?:o03e 0rrr23 06rolP lofiltl.l(rva40 0llt23 05r02t &nFor(v^ pPllllPu r:oo1103/26 06:10F Indiig PP/f,UPU rs:oo.t2 0s/23 05:17P rnodtm PP/r /Plr r7,oo,tsos/2s o€r1sp Incd n! PP/ttl/PU 1o:oo 0 00

1r o3/2711r.0A Ieding oP/qr/PU 5:oo1503/2712:27P llOf,FO!&VA oFAo/PU i:00 o.o040c,3/27 l2:3aP In@lm oellll/pL ?r:00 0.00 0 00

oP/u/cu 3:o0.Bos/27 o6r15P xanFot(va oP/r.t/N 1:00

rsogirz oa:rn rcfi.os,vr oP/oL6003127 o0:s2P NOfiFOLI(.VA o,/lrl/pL 6:00ii mi* oe,zp rc-'m ap/ur/'u r:ooiraries os,ru neeorx vr oP/s/ro 23:mnnirc urop t***i tPlr/PU 3r:oogoizo oa,rgp n"*-" ptnalPu €:@iioin mi'sr !"nFoLX,v,. ,o or/g/Fu 2:oo

roi.l c.lllLr s..rl{ cl$!-.!droa..../onF.!tlumh.lllk $v!d!otj.d Dildrylr*.!l€{41o.rdoddAudor'

El Addlton l tle.llsins oltlll

s.7504 0.39

$0.s9

]SCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

Focnd. 't'! t)dj Tdd

i01 06:osa rcnFo(,v^101 05:17F tjtOFFOLK, VA

r02 05|15 t{oFFOLt(r VA

/11 03:SSP NORFoLK!VA/11 03:35P ltof,FoL(,V

/r1 0a:36P OnFOLK.VA/r1 03r!7P ftAnLoTaVL, VA/11 09:53P PASCA(pUI ,rc112 06.o.P {o{FoLK,v

/r. 0r:304 JAcKwLEcd I FL

./14 0r:r1F rcnFOU(!Vr/23 05r 11A NOFF0LX,VA

r/23 06:s7P NORFOLK,VA

)/23 0ar53P IoFFOLK,VAl/23 06rsgF 0iF0!K,VA

t23 0z: i7P E PHrstrN

9/2S 07:26P EttP8I3, TIc/24 05io€A NoeFoLK.V3/25 05ro7A NOAFOLK,V3/25 05:13r rceFoLK,v3/25 05izrP ICfFOLXTV

Nhb'rol[l.qs Numbe ol EllthL

ln Plo Mdro. M!{loc

O 0d. S.rvlc$ u3!go oadl

Fd. M6s Fd. Md@. chrclitul lniid Addlrbnd Adddond

> SUBSCBIBER IT'IFORi'ANONAL REPORTS

r6d ll.b srtls clr.or

_,( sPRtN]

---

,usst

SUBSCRIBER T

--r

v,.w coy6ra9. maF€ {d db vi

L cellular sorut.c€ cat

U6S NEW YORK (LPO 21)

lro odr lim. cd Io

ffi ""'" iiT'J:",.-. NnaEt l"C.lluhr Slrvid c6ll lter;

qEL c ta*I Od€ Im. Car ro105/05 osirlp rncqho2 o5/o5 06 r,13P tncoiris305/05 03:i7P PORTsn.05/05 0a:27P oMnLOTSV5o5/o5 o3:s6P rnc inq6 05/06 12:514 cH nlorwr7 05/06 02r22P II'BFOLK,Vr305/06 03:rsp rn6rn€I 0s/o6 03:53P NOAFOLK,V/

10 05/06 03r3sP IoRFOLK,VT11 06/03 o3rssP rhoohino12 05/06 03:s7p rnooringi3 05/16 05:34p osFoL(,v/r{ 0s/J5 06r12P r{0€FOLK,V/r5 05/1S 12:srP NoFFOL(,Vl16 05/17 1i io3A rnconinsl705/17 o?:03p rncdin!3 05/r 7 03r45P fiOnFoLX,V/

re0s/1s o0:51A oBFOLX,V/r0 05/13 02i60P hcorihs!1 0s/r0 03:04P o{FoL{,v/12 05/13 05: r 0P Incorins3 C6/1A 06r35P tncohino4 05/23 03:3c{ lnoo.ino5 05/23 0,r:12P PonTSUOUn0 06/23 0?:1s PORTs&Utl705/24 05r00a NoFFoLK,vir0 05/21 09:25P tncdings 06/24 09 r2€P rcAFoLK,Vro05/2r o€:46P rncdine

05/25 04:1tP rlOBFOtX,Vr05/25 os:o?a oRFOL&V/06/26 03r29P NOSFoLK!V'

610s/30 li 1l1a hconings2 05/s0 0r:rzp c8 f,LoT€[rL,v^53 06/30 o2r40P VTRCT AEcA,VA5. 05/30 or)r00P Fl[10^r,Hr55 05/90 04r13F fiof,TH8RooK, t L566/30 06ra4P il6THEA00K! rL57 05/30 03r{0P rncoino53 os/30 o0r33F floRFOTX,VA50 05/s1 03:174 ttu*in!3005/31 r2:5rP rnco ng3r c6/3t oi:srF rn.{ins62 05/31 06:07P lof, FoLJqV^63 06/31 0S:SlP EFHTS,Tt

Tot l c.l&hr s.rvrd cft.{-'Lois O*sc.ra1hq 6lum hdd6 !El Addilional M.o.aglns D

t0'oordr Aldrilo!.r tlrt!'l clrll-

O D.tr s.rvlo.. U.as. O

e.*r ir""'*arc,S.Do ofi P.rk Edb U"d Ev.i6h Plm KBEMT5 KB€vnB K€iE€ib

;ll;* r?5.00_

> SUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

5 05/26 06r26P IIO€FOLK,V'7 05/27 os:o7a NoRFoLX,v.r 05/27 03r67P lnc6in!r 05/27 03:a?P lnodtnor05/23 o3:43A rncodhc1 05/23 11:07A rncorins?06/23 03:52P theo.in!) 05/23 0sr07P hc@!n!r05/?r o0:11a lncotringr 05/23 00.16A NoCFOL(,VAi05/2e 03i12p Vlnctnftcfl,05/2S 03: j3P 0€F0Ll(,Vr 06/2s 03: 15P PASCACOILAr05/2s 03:16P Inco n€

UR SPRINT INVOICEUSS NEW YORK (LPD 21)

L

i*'ii#'*"' if,J-** ruoae- l-

JBSCRIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

}lluhr A€rui6. C.tt I

rwl-9hl9s!r+: Cr !!

4/05 03:59P floRFOLK,VA4/05 0,r:01 P loRForx,vA4/05 04r01P ilonFoL( va4/06 04: t2p oRFoLK,VA4/os 04:56P ORFoLX.VA4/05 04:57P tOffFOLl(,V1/06 0.:s8p toFFoLl(,vA4/03 03:32A NEtPl fl€iS,VA,1/06 03 r13A VTFOINT€CH,V4/06 09 | 1?A NoAFoLK,VA4/06 01 r56P VISCIMSCU,VAr/06 03:23P Ion'OLX,VA.i/06 0s :36P xqtFol(,va,{/r 7 0gr,roa *aqFoLKlvA4/13 03:r3A IoFFOLK.VA4/13 09:2oA r{oRF0LK,VA4/r a r1:33 NORF0LKTVI4/13 0S r42P XqFOLK,VA1/1S r0:,{?A XOftuL(,Vra/1s o?: r8P TFFOLK,Vr4/1S 05 r34P NORFoLK,VA

)d{c.r'Olh.. cdqm ln lcd6ayLAddl0onal M6reglns lt€t

'Lo@ obr./q qlrq Ch.@

Lq o{dm vvhib R4dins

E!F$+.Y..dYg

Airlim6 U!.9. D.tdl

Bdnsftf,'dn &o0 MFC Mdlty PLr char9.

lrdd Po/d Tdd 'Fl$oubolig oltP.ak Mh.S.c Mlis*

'Plan MnS- hold. Antltu mh@ ,Jdiridll (8on6) niie, ]\r.bl. b Modl. hlih. Anr Mo6r' Anrim6 m nukt lJobih

b tlrn. mhd, .nd M.bL io Olllc. nhur.€Fqhbbl Fi dlb ph-, ha u..d 351sr otil b rlrbr. mhe mfl Ant lrobbAinjtu o0 0o [&bLb ]rdn'dil6, {d 0o!0 riobl.b olli- 6k6

* _='.-

rifld Andhon.r addiion.

ddl onll ll.qglno cnrE{Dqia SorYicar U!!ge Doteil

F€*/ {!tr$.rdt€,r L6!€/ LdO$s Stlrbk F&t€r€!6 KE€Fd Ks/Et* ch.€e

JBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

onro @d3 e @dLd s 3 @6r ro h.lp you unt . u..0. bidr .tu ltoo pu r!e@r svry

OUR SPRINT INVOICEussNEwYoRK(!PD 2l)

05/01/10-05/gt /1b ilff"** NEXIE- |. uss NEw]ERKllFdZij

ur Eata Hans

SUBSCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

Loic DILE W*b ash

tlln€ Uug. Dotril

$. O.ltul.r s*Ylc.. C€l

n Mii Se hcld. Anl,lh. dhui.r, rddiriqd (E n!3) hind€, Mo6{6 b Mdr. mhd, a.r [6l..Anytim nid, lld{.tu min@, :nd M.bI. b 016r. frhG.hk bl I Fqlod, rhb ph@ hd G.d 660rco Mob{. ro M.bl€ mh@, m:6 Any o6|.Annlm, c0@ liLlrbb rhm'lG,

&d 00fi Mo*'L 16 ofi.. mrnd-

oih{ chat

Addd.ial Tddlrd.gi F.r. M.q4! .=-,, _ _

l6dh/ P.dd lodOdsoino OiPo* Mh:S*

'Pld on{ Btlbk ToulMiirs- l,lh:S- Midse ch!r!6 I 05/02 o:r:r(P hcdi(,

2 06/0,1 oil:20P rloRFoL(,v3 06/0,1_ 0. r.F rrr rfi€ot4 05106 11r16A toRFOLK,\50s/05 11:16 srFfoi-(,\I o5/05 11 :134 IOnFOLK,\

306/0s 12r2AP r.odlioI05/05 0a:35t rcnFou('r

10 05/06 01r35P tilllolrsHl11 05/06 o8rltP tnc illl1206/06 0rrj44P ilolFoLl(,lt3 051d3 rxr:,a5P lloRFoLl('1406/0€ 03r63P riodrngr506/12 04:t3P rrc{lngt6 06/25 o2r1oP inco ingi7 05/?€ oe:s,o vnoluBl3 06/26 0r:35A NEiPT E

Tohl c.lklc a.de- ch.lltrL@ Dr-.!.€ih*61utu lndi

El Addlllonal lil6.tagliUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

Monlhly R.currlng Acc... Chrg!.Bu6ln€ss Ess€nllals Add.n MRC for 05m1 .05/31

Unlimlted 2-Way Text M€ssqging tor q5O1 -{5/3115.0010.00

Tolal Mon$t Fe.uning Accass Ctwg€s

c€[ul6r Sdvicoa Charg6c€llular She/€d Usass Adj :

$25.00

- 10.50

* C.lhd.f 9€.vtc6 Chlrg6

l*tt{.sd{?d .1. 19- ! c!d! b.dtd rcn Fu b h.F d.rEy d i:pdd m E. surch.s- e d s6 orqqrlq & 6 qlrtd b cdtd i!rn.l.! by i.r su;hlcd;n.y h;ud.: r*id usr, q"a*y,i.oo.,.d"iqdrdqi.. se.dhb.;.d..* * a;r- ri ri*;;:;;;'r;;;-,",prolmt. ir .ffi, &d ln. camdd u..d b crLlln; suid.l!. tu.b, @.ubhd ro ohar..

Tor.l Addlrbn.l c{.4lit chrqo

.."/R SPRll,lT lNl,OtCE

--.Cffi{reo-?|-> SUASCFIEERINFOruATIONATNEPORIII

> SUASCfiBCN ACIMTY S|IITINY

ffiffi r&r rd L.lrtr b e.srdkrtE-5-r;-;6-----

rE-[

/dNT INVOICE

- ---, -iS NEW YOFK (LPD 21) cont.

ISCFIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

,ition6l tl€4eaging D€lail

Mq.a6 Nutr$do{ Btlt'h hl:lrn Pun M*.!- [r*:a- F&

lnti.l Addido.r Ad&onaltuh M€.g

uss NEW YORK (LPD 2r )

i

SilllnO P.dod03/01/10.03/31/10 !1:.".*. ruoaa I'

I

.Pbn Mh:s- tndd. airnh. miid*, Addilon l (Bdu) ilnb, lLhl. b M.bh minG, A.y MobI. Anyrino minul6, Mobll.lo lbF filidr*, id llldl€ b of - mhlbeF; fih brt 9.bd dE pl'* h- uq .09 m Mo6b

'o Mo{. mild, ooso Anv v.br.AnFn..0o.oo Mo6lt b For.

dnnul.q rnd 00 00 r/o8Lio Olllc. mllc.

aservic$ t rag. O.tall'o'm'

L6 ohd Bihbl€ Td.lKBEvrnb l(s/Ewb kg€q& ch{rd

P.*/ NurSf,.lKB/ L6lG/OlP..k EMbU..a EEtuli Pl{

Lr_l j^ lpt+ r/cr,Aq{ h*f "uu_ u,\ 0.

SCRIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

,.pdl*@Rt .",rutb- t{ !.Frt". EqF t-nd,.nd mrna. t!'r lltcdor - 'rv

!e - . S{.&,!!4h .-.-..-.-........rlnsFh! . -... _ _. .....f,"tq:19*3 99,t!!9_: +]q

P.*d oe KlqbYtqq

EiLn-d vob{l.i

Lon! dr1ad lvhllo Rffns

UR SPRINT INVOICEUSS NEWYORK(LPD 21)

Yollr A{. Pb..

Blfln'lifioooo,,. ilff"""*", NEffEL

l",, USS NEW YORK (LPD 21) conl,

C.lluhr S..vic€r Cdl Drlrll

JBSCRIBER ACTIV

!d! &b6 W L H.dh!

cl!@

)rdd../o*|..6rlm rndud. {y Ld

\ddluond l!l...aslnr DclllNhbrotMdrli . - .,..-_ ,--@nd Addlhn.l Toul

Trr. _l" Pl- 1.-@- M*.oc tul.

.Plo Mi S- h.!d. Anfm. nlnLt . Addilsil (Boi6l mric, Mobt. b M.6t. hhtu, tuy Mo6ll.,Ailrkn. nhe,! Mohiblo Htu mlnub.,.nd Mob{. lo qb. mhut...F( thh btl p<lod, fi]e phom i@ c!.d s51o0 MoblL r. Mohl. mlnus, m 00 Aiy MobtnAinh., m oo MoSt. to Hoh.mhllr, dd lblo MdbL ro Of,ih. 6lnd...

i_, *.> SUBSCRIBER ACTIVITY SUMMARY

,(/05 0,r:orP inSFotK,va4/05 0r:02P onFoLX,v

Budn.E Errlb&d{n Wic

Alrum. Ur.go [r.&il

Mont{y Plsn Ch.{r.

h;h/ Pd/./ Tot lOrtsolns ofi Psk MlnS*

olhd Slthbt&ii:Se MhS& Ch:@

tohl ArlD Lr.!. ch.@

ddldon l L-{ln{ ch.ri.).t S..vic.a t .agc D.bl

Ls lG/ L6O c BlhU. Bd@*k*d

IBSCRIBER INFORMAI'IONAL REPORTS :l l Monthly R.drnlng Acc... Ch{g..15.O010.00*'l l+d! e @Fo.d o: 6tfur b t b F! &drb a.o. td .&d tuEo.ydn$n db.. diiiy.

Rlto Pllns

yi,,-d[c... _...,,.. _.,,....... _,.. -.. _.. _...q4.h'r!d,],.:o.rt1!9.6,,! 9d,lt..,..,......... _ -... _ -._ -....,lh$Lqbg &r!'!!q:$rir!

Tobl Monhly R€drrlng A.oals Charlss

* c.[uli s.rvlc.o ch.ry-C€llul Sharod Usage AdAddtonal Anytmg Mh'186

$?5. OO

-9.509,50

$0.00Tobl C€llular Ssrvi@s ChaEes

SPRINT INVOICE

)RIBER ACTIVITY DETAIL

's(vic6! call Deb[

N"@00o

a70r00 ao.oo io.oo 10,00rh' 6lud indud6 sy L{€ o-(,/E, otdory a.jrlE (al 0, lld od.l Ae d$s.nal M€saging D€dail

lvt.-.F Nunih- otin PGn NlGq- M.€a!e

Aeanl Num!.r

uss NEw YoBK (LPo 20

Auimc t .€9. D.lril

'l:fu--* NDffEL Ilidiv P..U Tdd .?ltnodooiM o{P..t MlnS@ Mh€*

t d llnld Ut{. ch.tll.F1tn M.:S* hctuh A.iiErltld, Addbml (Bflul iii(b, Mob{. b Mc6ib 6h!1d, Aiy Mdilo aiyiln. nnh, Mebi.ro Htudhdd, and[ldl.tooJlb. mi k,

xvic.c Usagc Detlita0'm

KEEH! xs/Ew chq-

)RIBER INFORMATIONAL REPORTS

€&{ohpibdDrd!tuyrotEtsyo!u.ly..6.!.frndrmdr .!.y!u:!bdb..dttr.

LoE &m6 Whib F*nits

Ed'lrEed ve!qt!!!

?lease provide any wrinen commcDts itr the spact below. Use additional paper ifneeded'.}

. /EI,T .OT.,N'MMS WILL BE PROVIDED TO YOIJR COMMAND EXACTLY AS TI{EY ARE WR]TTE}.

(o Lzsntth4/ M *cflic+D lu-ryh.arcmh gledids.ftut*ck */ ahh*6'{a-s a utuu) + e"&a frhv1ui& a*d &^"*nt

a! a ca,rrrnad d&drz I rutjW.tla{;ei s*/*"Snuc^w-fi,* shna d*r4 ot^- W"e*rf izts ltzj lo

^,n -+bz Vtto4 adLL dW disct/iu dnbaRd , ,2,

- (omwanl @id/ rAh4qs'l&a+ a and IALCn< *rz ,tkt,+pdfttec^.*tko -hd 4u4 rzfia + .srtp fq&aiz\+,l,l"anl1z; l

rPro,l T e rfu 2 l*7, et"x-' fi e*/s Aipeq{,kRed<fD.^4ed dt 4+* {tt {Ca.

- Cfo nas* { ttir'rd7ve,1,,\ bX* }"* inla^o( c&<k<-

*Ad p"da4v'4 y'nfto *.1;t^ . sawL Fkah? 4e.Pnuwn 4a W {o"+ pta,al "(iiliw &* ho".: 6,"-gt4 , t;11 hzlp aneletL Pz?+aa o^7 We&eu gr'iS,

you for your responses. Please

ou may send comments rogarding this survey dir€ctly to:

ofRosearchEqual opportunity Managemetrt Institute

6 Tuskegee Airman Drive Building 352atrick Air Force Base, Florida 32925-3399

your auswer sheet and

f?C4*{n*on"ru^f af&a*s

leqreJ**o

tA

^na

ee

)i

- fuor 1a"*,*1 ,X, * M hptd lePt,+tc"ds "lo a fw,Sland*€d o*P,+,s Jtat tat;<.*d t^*u, thd vp *rra,t4s+ ryj,*f. y|jr.#rl:* ^ytrW.t tttadi "rc a7,A+t" +*, tr, e n-x,.'-fW!s a

^P3!'4, !& ;

il: suppod.@deocs.net

SUSPECT'S RIGHTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT/STATEMENT EE JAGMAN 01FTJLL NAME (ACCUSEDiSUSPECT}

Ug^r4

USS Js" Yo.r-

COr,r,r.J+tlg.)e fr ,tJrI-OCATION OF INT!R\,'IEW

t6t'A1,lp.17-

\, sri(

3tA4r-t

RIGHTSI certify ald acknowledge by my signaturc ard initials set forth beiow that, before ihe interviewerrequested a statement ftom me, he wamed me that:

(1) I am suspecred of having conmitred nte followins offense(s)l

vls LJ€."J Yr.,

(2) I have ihe righr ro rcnaiD siletrt; - - - , - - - , - - -

(3) AJIy slatement I do make may be used as evidence against me in rial by coun-martiat, , - -

(4) I have L\e right to consult wilh la$f€r counset prior to any questiorirg. This tawyercounsel may be a civilian la$yer retained by me ai my own expense, a mitilary tawyerappointed to act as my counsel wilhour cost to me, or borh: and -, - - - - - - -

(5) I have fte dght to have such Ierained civilian lawyer and/or appointed milirary lawyerpresent duiing this interview. - - - - - -, - - - - - -,

WAWER OF RIGIITS

I further ceflify and acknowledge tbat I have read the above srarement of my rights and fullyunderstand them, and rhar,.. --- --.

(l) I expressly desire to waive my righr ro remain silenr; - - - - - - -, - - - - - -

(2) I expressly desire ro make a stalement:, -,, - -

(3) I expressly do nordesire to consult with eifier a civilian lawyer rctaireil byme or amilitarylawyerappointedasmycounselwilhoutcosttomepriortoanyquesrioning;_____-_---

(4) I expressly do nor desire to have such lawyerpresent wilh medu ng $is inteNiewi and , _ --

t tt ut I

lf,lease provide any writtel1 comments in the space below. Use additional paper ifneeded..l} -,ALL COI,{'ASI\TS WILL BE PROVIDED TO YOI]R COMMAND EXACTLY AS TIIBY ARE WR]TTEN-

c l"1sht e' '!#

"' 'o " " , \. r6i *!1, cr^,r h,ir1r.* ,$ : rr,tduat i.''' *

mei$ u-r,i i'r t.!.t 1 ['&" . , ^ ,r\ ,!s.r,r.r:rr 4br l{rt 's

lu,,|u***

o'0,

"r::,o ' ,:

u: , "*:'" "' ]' '

o^r .Ltt'rttt'y | 6't'<!u t ta

-rhe l!4. i Stl9xr" 15 Clzr'/t\ &btr* -'istr

I {:+ptr:a" rl ' fne.""i

;l- ;', :,i15 f&.rs#trr € d -: 9* rl'c i[dJ ]rr i'i '1di:r16 nr{

dtfS rr, rt"l i & 1t* lu'w n'o"d }*i'nJt -

'ht ' * ttb &'t'a* h*PN

,you for your responses. Please provide yow unr1""" tli""t -d this iruvey to your suwey

ou may send comments regarding this survey directly to:

otorate ofResearch)etbnse Equal Oppoftunity Management Institute66 Tuskegee Air.man Drive Building 352

ick Air Folce Base, Flotjda 32925-3399: support@deocs.net

(&"{ r,nu,,rt $t Jel , € e ,

44 .lht -lalafr $a,taa' 4{"t a 6}-

S,t 1,'. rl Fur., Ii t1l ynuLltv

flxl 'g-tr"-';'&" :: lo r ,ii1,1.

$ or do *c;

lAbrq* ufr* rlo htlt' ws'nJ

wert /at'Jk) Y 4r */ ** "t'

, ti5u eci.'J'

V *14" I6,'r't Suz.tt u p 4t V* 11aa-4' !at'l<r

ti

qrt rAj\,tErr.- cE66,-Y-,

UsS J6^l Y"?+-

SUSPECT'S RIGIITS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT/STATEMENT JAGMAN 01

tlSll

I6MAK lqlzds^(

3

Cor,Ly'x.lsua-6r.*,-br

I-OCATION OFIMIERVIEW

\J SS lJe!, Yod-k-

RIGHTSI cefiify and acknowledge by my sigaturc and initials set follh below that, before the interviewer /rcquested a statement from me, he wamed ine thal:

(1) I am suspected of having conrmitted the foliowing offense(s):

(2) I havethe nghlto renain silenr - - - - - - - -.

{3 ) Any stalemenl I do make may be used a5 evid€nce against me in trial by "our,.*"*n.

- - - - .

(4) I have the right to consult with lawyer counsel pdor to any questionjng. This lawyercounsel may be a civilian lawyer retain€d by me at my own expense, a miliiary la*yerappoinaed to act as my counsel without cost to me, or bo6; ald - - - - - - - - - -

(5) I have the rigbt to have such retained civiljan lawyer and/or appointed military lawyerprese dunng fiis interview. - - -- - - - - - - - - - - -

-----r:l

WAII'ER OF RIGHTS

I flrther certiti and acknowledge that I have read the above statemeDt of my righls and fullyundel.srand lhem, and fiar, - - - - -. - - - --- - - - - -

(1) I expressly desire to waive my right to remain srlent; -- ----------

f2) T exFessl) desiie Lo make a sLrtementl - - -.

(3) I expressly do no! desire to consDlt$rirh eirha acivilian lawyer tetained by me ot amiItary lawyer appoiored a5 my coun sel w, thour cosr to meplior ro any questioning: - - - - -- - .

(4) I expressly do not desile to have such lawyerpresent with lne during this intelview; and - - -

(5) Tbis ackrowledgment and waiver of rights is made fteely and voluntnily by, and withou.any promises ol threats having been made to me or ptessrrle or' €oercion of any kind having been

used againsl me.- -- - - - -

314uGtt)

bt A'C tJ

3( t+4< tc)

The statement which appeds on dris page (and the fotlowtg & page(s), all of which are signed by me), is madefrcely and volunarily by me, and without any promises or thrcals having be€n made to me or pressue or coercion ofany kind having been used against me.

'a /tSIGNAIUF.E (ACCUSED/SUSPECT)

SIGNAIUFEII}UERVGWER)-'_.+_'€.':B

g.- a.dlL

(5) This acknowledgment and waiver ofrights is made fteely and voluntarily by, ard eithourany promises or lheats having been made to me or pressurc or coercion of any kind having beenused againstme.,,-- - - -

sroNATtrRE (ACCUSED/SUSPECT! DATB

&AttGt,2

DAlB

3 oAuJ4 I

The statemenr which appears on rhis page (and the following <2 page(s), a[ of which are signed by me), rs maatefteely and voluntarily by me, and without any promises or threats having been made to me or pressue or coercion ofany kind having been used against me.

SICNATi]'RE (ACCUSED/SUS?ECD

lnterview of the ' rs advised of her ri8hts pertaining

to being suspected of fratern izatio n with ClvlDCM {5W)Robert Stocklin. She characterized her

relationship with the CMC as a professional relationship in which she looked to him for senior enlisted

Suidance and mentorship, especially while the a _ .Juas aealing with being diagnosed

:r in April 2009 and going to a number of associated appointments throughout the year

leadership in th( )epartment. She acknowledged that the relationship developed beyond purely

professional and became a close friendship, but denied any sexual contact. The two often discussed

work-related issues over coffee onthe ship either in the!|=F. _.-_rortheCMC'soffjce. During

these discussions the door was always open and they were separated by physical space and/or a desk.

There have been a number of issues in . .__ ._,:.!....Jlhat caused ' :o seek advice from CMC

- serious car wreck invofving {:__ -_

,-- -r in laie l\i;e mber 2009 wlth a death of another NEW

YORK service member. Also, as stated previouslyll . ,,.-- indattending appoints from April 2009 to the present, and the continuous struggle with not having a

consisteht LCPO presence causing r requesting advise and assistance d!ring this. lt was

determinedbytheChainofCommandthatthet--_-,-..LCPOunderwent )r

her .- - - ttus the ship was presently in.

Although there is an email string that details the planninB of a trip together to Kings Dominion, ' , .

said that shewasjokingend did notgo to Kings Dominion with CMC;she stated thatshe has neverevenbeentoKingsDominion.Anumberofotheremallswerereviewedand-,,.---:knowledgedthattheywere undulyfamiliar, but noted that therewas nothing behind them, merelyfriends bantering.

lJpon reviewin8 phone records ofthe command issled government cell phones,' ,statedthatthevast majorityofthe convercations were professional, however some discussions o€curred regarding' , strained relationship at home.

While the USS NEW YORK (LPD 21) was being built and the crew was living in Avondale, LA, ' and

CMC often socialized with other officers and chiefs at weekly barbecues behind the buitdings where theywere living. While USS NEW YORK was in New York City for commissioning in November 2009, the twoattendedgame6oftheWorldSeries,accompaniedbyapproximately30othercrewmembers.

Following the game, CMC and' ) went outfora beer at a nearby bar where other Sailors were aiso

celebrating. went to CMCS residence in Suffolk, Virginia in April 2010 when invited to a

barbecue; when she arrived, there were only a few other members of the Chlefs mess, so she stayed fora couple drinks and then departed. ' also had coffee with CMC at the Starbucks at the NEX in

Norfolk on two occasions in lanuary 2010. All other contact off the ship was at command events orSports and always with other members ofthe Wardroom, Mess, and/or crew.

wascounseledbytheCommandingOfficer,._ .--.---,,,-,inearly2010regardinBallegationsand the perception ofan inappropriate relationship between her and the CNy'C. Thetoneofthecounseling was that the perception of frate rn i2ation exists and that needs to cease. No record ofthe

was more aware ofthe time spent

at Portsmouth Naval Medical Center, Norfolk and in New Orleans, LA in late Summer and associated

follow-up appointments that continue to date at Portsmouth Naval Medical Center that impacted the

counseling was provided to I Following the counselinB,

-//n ? 1) (--

-t

'odf l laq jo atuasqe 0] anp p?nutluol saSesselLr

lxal pue suollesla^uol auoqd /ra^aMoq lsuorlesla^uol qlnslo uolldaslad aql pue f|/\ll o] Surllel

SUSPECT'S RIGHTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT/STATEMENT EE JAGMAN O17O

FUIL NAME (ACCUSED/SUSPECI)'t--+ru "-ASITWTruNIT

tjss r'.!a., \b*u

SoLeL *fI-OCATION OF INIERVIIW

uss da, %'"p

RIGITTSI certiry and achrowledge by my signature altd iniiials set forth below that, before the inten'iewerrequested a stalement from me, he wamed me ttrat:

(l) I am suspected ofhaviDs coErritted fie followins offense(s):

12) I have the righr lo remain silenr. - - ------

(3) Any statement I do make may be used as evidence against Ele in tdat by cowt-mafiial, - - _ -

(4) I have the right to consulx with lawyer counsel pdor to any questioning. This lawyercounsel may be a civilia! lawyer retained by me at my own expense, a military lawyerappointed to act as my colnsel without cost to me, or bothi and -

(5) I have the dght to have such retained civilian lawyer a#/or appointed military lawyerpresent during lhis interview. - - - - - - -- ---- --

WAIVER OF RIGHTS

I ftrther certify and acknowledge that I have read the above stalement of my rights arrd fullyunderstand tfiem, and thal - - - - - - - - - - -

(l) I expressly desie to waive my righ! io remain silent;' - - '' - - - - - - - - -

f2) I expressly desle to lnale a qlatemenl -

(3) I expressly do not desire to coDsult with either a civilian la[yer rctained by me or amilitarylawyerappointedasmycounselwithoutcosttomepriortoanyquesdoning;----------

(4) I expressly do Dot desire !o have such lawyet present wirh me during this iDterview; and - , --

_t

,2

----4-

/2

SUSPECT'S RJGHTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT/STATEMENT EC JAGMAN 01

L\SJ

Oorl-r.J *v s,,raFupcxlfI.OCAI]ON OFINTERVITA/

r.)ss ,,,lar Yo.c--t

RIGHTSI c€rtify and acklowledge by my signafi[e and iDitials set forth below that, before the interviewerrequested a statement from mq he wamed me that:

(l) I an suspected of haviDg corunitled the follo$/ing offerse(s):

(2) I ha\e $e flght ro 'emain silenr: - .

(3) Any staternenr I do make may be used as evidence against me in trial by court-maitial, - - - - -

(4) I have &e right to consult with lawyer cows€l prior to any questioning. This lawrercounsel may be a civilian lawyer retained by me at my own expense, a rnililary lawyerappoinied to act as my counsel without cost to me, or bothi and - -

(5) I have lhe right to have such retained civilian lawyer andor appointed military lawyerpresenrduring rhis jnre iew.- - -------

WAIVER OF RIGHTS

I firrther cerli& and acknowledge that I have rcad the above statement of my rights and fullyDndeNtand them, and that, - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - -

(1) I exprcssiy desire to waive my right to rcmain silent; - - - - - -,, -

(2) I expressly desire ro mate a stakment: - - - - - -

(3) I expressly do notdesire to consult with either a civilian la$yer rerained by me or amilitarylawyerappointedasmycounselwithou!costtomepriortoanyquestioning;---------,

(4) I expressly do not desire to have such lawyer present with me du ng tbis i erview; and - - .-

I

(5) This acknowledgmenr and waiver ofdght! is rDade fteely and volunlarily by, and withoutany Fomises or threals having been made to me or Fessue or coercion of any kind having beellIsed ag"incrme---. .. --. -.

,6

The srarement w-ttrfiEFears otr thrs page (ard the folowing _ page(s), all of which are signed by me), is madefre€ly and voluntarily by me, aod without any promisss or rhrcars having been made !o me or pressure ot coercion ofany kind having been used against me.

------------:---SIGNATIJRE (ACCUSED/SUSPECIT--\

Interview of Conmand Master Chiel cMDCM (sW) Robert stocklin: CMDCM {SW) Stocklin was advised

of his rights pertaining to being suspected offraternization with ' 'le characterized his

relationship with . . , asserving as a soundinB board for r during the sianding up ofthe crew.

They were both part ofthe nucleus crew that stood up the ship ahd the XO at the time was perceived as

a bit hard to relate to. As such, the sought advice and mentorship from CMC. Over time the

relationship developed into a friendsh'p that overstepped the hnllnds nf professionalism between a

and command master chief, but there was no phvsical aspect to the relationship,

Whilethe UsS NEWYoRK (LPD 21)was being builtand the crew was living in Avondale, LA, and

cMCoften socialized with other officers and chiefs at weekly barbecues behind the buildings where they

were living, While USS NEW YORK was in New York City for commissioning in November 2009, the two

attended game 7 ofthe World Series, accompanied by approximately 30 other crewmembers.

Followint the game, CMC ahd J went out for a beer at a nearby barwhere other saildrs were also

celebraling. cMc drove , to her house following an underway period after most other folks had

left the ship and there was no one else available to get' . . to her car. AII other contact offthe ship

was at or after events or sports with other members of the Wardroom, Mess, and/or crew.

CMC was counseled bythe forme .!. tr, February(?) 2010 l_e*l:[l-gallegations and the perception of an inappropriate relationship between him and the ' gThe tone ofthe counseling was thatthe perception of frate rnization exists and that it needs to cease.

No record of the counseling was provided to CMC. FollowlnB the counseling, CMC was morq aware ofthe time spent talking to ._ / while on board USS NEW YORK a nd the perception of such

conversations; however, phone conversations and text messages continued. CMC rationalized that

misperception could not be attached to phone calls.

There is a picture of a person asleep on a couch set as the contact icon for , on CMC'S command

issued cellphone. The picture isnotof' ,,butCMCthoughtitwasironictosetitastheiconsincehe could not ima8ine ' ,.inthatstate.sincesheisalwaysonthego..,....,,,.,.J.,.........--....,.-..,, -,

At no time did CMC have any indication that his relationship with ' was adversely affecting the

Mess, theWardroom, orthe ship.

CMC is concerned about sullyinB the reputation ofthe ship. He has a great pride in the Navy and ln the

USS NEW YORK and does not want any bad light cast on either as a result of his misjudgement.

This statement was prepared b! ---.,conversations.

edited by me, and is an accurate reflectlon of our

cMDCM{SW), USN

(5) This achowledgment aIId waiver of righls is made freely and voluntarily by, and wiaholtany Fomises or tlueats having been made to me or pressrue or coercion of any kind haviog beenused agaiDst me.- - - - -- - - - -

, --)

3fta6-rosIGNAruRr2'frxE :

3/ frl,(C(O

The slatement which appears on this page (and the fouowing _ page(s), all of which are signed by me), is madefteely and voluntarily by me, and withour any promiscs or rhreats having been made ro me or pressue or coercion ofany kind havirg been used against me.