Update: BPA Emerging Technologies Presented to: Regional Technical Forum May 2010 Presented by: Jack Callahan, P.E., CEM, CMVP Emerging Technology Program

Update: BPA Emerging TechnologiesPresented to:

Regional Technical ForumMay 2010

Presented by:Jack Callahan, P.E., CEM, CMVP

Emerging Technology Program ManagerBPA Energy Efficiency

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

EE Emerging Technology (E3T) Synopsis

Focus is on emerging technologies

Utilize BPA strengths– Regional scale and coordination– Utility relationships– Technical expertise and objectivity

• Measurement & Verification (M&V)• Technology Management

Vision:

A trusted source for emerging energy efficiency A trusted source for emerging energy efficiency technologies and solutions, providing a steady technologies and solutions, providing a steady

stream of valued innovations to BPA, utilities, and stream of valued innovations to BPA, utilities, and end-users.end-users.

2


3

BPA 2010 Emerging Technology Team

Mira VowlesProject Managermkvowles@bpa,gov

Jack [email protected]

Jonathan [email protected]

Jack CallahanProgram [email protected]

Ryan FedieEngineering [email protected]

Rob Penny [email protected]

Kacie BedneyProject [email protected]


In 2005, Bonneville re-started its R&D program. Bonneville created a series of “technology roadmaps” The group has developed a Portfolio Philosophy, as well as a Portfolio

Decision Framework.

4

The FY’09 portfolio includes 57 projects funded at about $7.5 million.

Takeaways Technology Roadmaps Portfolio Philosophy Learn quickly & cheaply Stage Gates


5

NORTHWEST ENERGY EFFICIENCYTECHNOLOGY ROADMAP

MARCH 2010BPA Technology Innovation


Prioritization: EE Technology Roadmap 2010 - Top 15 R&D

6

Rank Product & Service Priority (Max=1001 Residential Heat Pumps 1002 Heat Recovery 983 Retro & NC Air Sealing 974 Manufactured Homes 975 Deep Retrofits -Residential & Commercial 956 Retro & NC Air Sealing 957 Improve Task/Ambient Application 958 Net Zero Energy Home 929 Retro and NC Windows 91

10 Day Lighting Walls 9111 Commercial HVAC 9012 Easy/simple user interface controls 8913 Net Zero Energy Home 8814 Retrofit Insulation 8715 Retro and NC Windows 84


Prioritization: EE Tech Roadmap 2010 - Top 15 Market/Programs

7

Rank Product & Service Priority

1 Data centers 1002 Virtualization and consolidation of small system 963 Solid state lights 954 Heat pump water heaters with exhaust vent 905 Mini split with space and water heat 876 HVAC 857 Commercial variable refrigeration flow 838 Minisplit - Residential space and water heat 789 Efficient home electronics 76

10 Environmental interlocks – hotel key locks 7511 Integrated building design 7512 DCV for commercial kitchen hoods 7413 Wireless homes 7414 Power conversion 7315 Smart plug strips 72


BPA E3T – Energy Efficiency Emerging Technology Program

8

Part 1 E3T -Technology Identification and Selection

Technology MWh MW PerformanceYears to Market

Ductless HVAC xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx

LED yyyyy yyyyy yyyyy yyyyy

HAN zzzzz zzzzz zzzzz zzzzz

PlugLoad wwww wwww wwww wwww

E3T Intake List

Energy Smart Innovation

Center

Technical Advisory GroupsEnergy Smart

Innovation Center

Technical Advisory GroupsTechnical Advisory GroupsBPA Technology Innovation and Confirmation






E3T Priority List






E3T Priority List






E3T Priority List

Stage Gate 2-4

Stage Gate 1

Stage Gate 5Scan Screen Assess New Offer

Stage Gate 6-7

Stage Gate 2-4

Stage Gate 1


Stage Gate 6-7

Stage Gate 2-4

Stage Gate 1


Stage Gate 6-7

Measure Identification



Measure Benefits & Potential ScorecardsMeasure Benefits & Potential Scorecards

E3T Project List

4

9

6

2

7

0

2

4

6

8

10

0 2 4 6 8 10

Tech

nica

l Pro

mise

Time to Market

Size of Market Potential

Funding Proposal Scorecard

E3T Project List

4

9

6

2

7

0

2

4

6

8

10

0 2 4 6 8 10

Tech

nica

l Pro

mise

Time to Market


E3T Project List

4

9

6

2

7

0

2

4

6

8

10

0 2 4 6 8 10

Tech

nica

l Pro

mise

Time to Market




New Offer Documentation







E3T Qualified Measure List













Selection Process Web Site

HVAC

Technical Advisory Groups

Lighting

Energy Management

Collaboration

Lighting TAG Ashland, NWPCC, E Source, Lighting Design Lab, LEI, Lighting Research Center, WSU Energy Program, e2co

HVAC TAG EWEB, NEEA, NYSERDA, SMUD, Davis Energy Group, NBI, MacDonald Miller, PSE, PAE, LBNL, SCE, Arip, SCL, AHRI, BC Hydro, PG&E

Energy Management: New members needed for 2010.


Emerging Technology Scope for BPA Consideration

9

Emerging Not yet assessed for nor included in BPAprograms or measures

Small Market Share Commercially available (or nearly so) with only a small market share in the Northwest Region.

Energy Efficiency Significant potential to provide quantifiable, reliable, and cost effective electric energy savings for end-use consumers in the Northwest region.

Technically Sound Reasonable certainty that it will perform as intended.

Relevant Performance-related features readily identifiable and related to BPA identified program or R&D gaps.


E3T Technology Identification and Selection Process






E3T Intake List

BPA Technology Innovation and Confirmation






E3T Priority List

New Offer

Assess

Stage Gate 2-4

Stage Gate

1ScreenScan

Stage Gate

5

Stage Gate 6-7

TechnologySummary

Benefits & PotentialScorecard

Project Portfolio

4

9

6

2

7

0

2

4

6

8

10

0 2 4 6 8 10

Tech

nica

l Pro

mis

e

Time to Market


Funding ProposalScorecard







EE Qualified Measure List

TechnologyPotential

Project Proposal

Identification Scorecard

10


2009 Lighting Technical Advisory Members

11

Larry Giardina City of Ashland Ashland, OR

Charlie Grist Northwest Power and Conservation Council Portland, OR

Michael Lane Lighting Design Lab Seattle, WA

Jonathan Livingston Livingston Energy Innovations San Francisco

Doug Oppedal Energy Trust of Oregon Portland, OR

Mark Rea Lighting Research Center Troy, NY

Peter Morante Lighting Research Center Troy, NY

Luís Fernandes California Lighting Technology Center Davis, CA

Joe Vaccher Eugene Water & Electric Board Eugene, OR

Jack Zeiger Washington State University Energy Program Olympia, WA

Rob Penney WSU Energy Program Olympia, WA

Ira Krepchin E Source Boulder, CO

Craig Ciranny BPA Energy Efficiency Portland, OR


2009 HVAC Technical Advisory Members

12

Name Organization Location

Bob Carver NYSERDA Troy, NY

Charlie Grist Northwest Power & Conservation Council Portland

Dave Bisbee Sacramento Municipal Utility District Sacramento, CA

David Springer Davis Energy Group Davis, CA

Howard Reichmuth New Buildings Institute White Salmon, WA

Jack Callahan Bonneville Power Administration Portland

Jared Sheeks MacDonald Miller Engineers Seattle

Joel Jackman Puget Sound Energy Bellevue, WA

Keith Elder Coffman Engineers, Inc. Seattle

Marcia Karr WSU Energy Program Olympia

Mark Firestone PAE Consulting Engineers Portland

Mary Ann Piette Lawrence Berkeley National Lab Berkeley, CA

Mike Lubliner WSU Energy Program Olympia

Paul Delaney Southern California Edison Irwindale, CA

Edwin Hornquist Southern California Edison Irwindale, CA

Peter Alspach Arup Seattle

Phoebe Warren Seattle City Light Seattle

Xudong Wang Air-Conditioning, Heating & Refrigeration Inst. Arlington, VA

Tom Yin BC Hydro Burnaby, BC

KC Spivey PG&E San Francisco, CA


Prioritization: Technologies Reviewed by 2009Technical Advisory Groups

13

Technology Title Priority

Bi-level stairwell lighting with occupancy sensors H

Bi-level parking lot and garage lighting with occupancy sensors H

Integrated Classroom Lighting System H

Bi-level office lighting with occupancy sensors H

Wireless lighting controls L

Simplified daylight controls Pending

LED's for Commercial Signs & Linear/Channel SSL Signage Pending

Mesopic Lighting for low light visibility Pending


Prioritization: Technologies Reviewed by 2009Technical Advisory Groups

14

Technology Title Priority

Variable refrigerant flow (VRF) heat pumps -- "Multi-split" H

Demand-Controlled Ventilation H

Demand Controlled Ventilation for Commercial Kitchens H

Indirect-Direct Evap Cooler L


Technology Identification and Selection - Web Site

15


BPA E3T – Energy Efficiency Emerging Technology Program

Part 2 Portfolio of Assessment Projects

Ductless Heat Pump

Heat Pump Water Heater

16

Smart Plug Strips

LED Demo

Web-Enabled T-stats

VRF Systems

Demand Controlled Ventilation

PTHP withOccupancy Control


Current BPA Technology Assessment ProjectsTechnology Team Activity Status

Ductless Heat Pumps NEEA, Fluid, Ecotope

Manufactured Homes Field Test

In Progress

Mnfc Homes, Forced Air, Small Commercial, Cold Climate

TBD Application Expansion

Scoping

Multi-Family Reverse-Cycle Chiller Demo

SCL, Ecotope Feasibility Study Demonstration M&V

Demonstration in 2010 - 2011

Heat Pump Water Heater

Ecotope Lab Test Testing to begin in Spring 2010

EPRI, Snohomish, Others TB

Field Test Begin Spring 2010

17


Current BPA Technology Assessment Projects

Technology Team Activity Status

Smart Plug Strips

TBD Field Tests RTF Provisionally Deemed

PTHP with Occupancy Control

Inland Power, Flathead Electric, EMP2

Field Test In Progress

Demand Controlled Ventilation

City of Eugene, EWEB, SUB, PECI

Multiple Field Tests

In Progress

18


Current BPA Technology Assessment Projects

Technology Team Activity Status

Variable Refrigerant Flow System

EPRI, Clark PUD , EWEB

Field Test Scoping

Web Enabled Thermostat

SCL, Clark PUD, Cadmus, MacDonald Miller

Demonstration and Field Test

Active

Monitoring Based Cx and Dashboard

Example

City of Ashland, SOU

Development and Demonstration

Scoping

Advanced Lighting

WSU Energy Program, Lighting Design Lab, PNNL

Demonstration Active

19


HPWH Lab TestingHPWH Lab Testing

Synopsis

Lab Testing of three new integrated units from major US manufacturers.

Team: Ecotope, National Renewal Energy Lab (NREL), NEEA

Spring 2010: Begin Lab testing

20


HPWH Field TestHPWH Field TestSynopsis EPRI nationwide testing of 200+ residential HPWHs

BPA will install 30 Treatment Sites

Snohomish will install 10 Treatment Sites

10 Control Sites in our region

Monitor for: efficiency, performance, reliability, electric demand, application issues and customer behavior

Complimentary to HPWH Lab Testing

Schedule March 2010 - Request for Utility Participants Spring 2010 – Start Installations

21


Smart Strip Assessment Project

Synopsis Staff research, Collaboration with ETO 2010 BPA program offering

Accomplishments Compilation of research Results for ETO/Ecos field test RTF Provisionally Deemed

Expected Benefits ~100 kWh/yr Energy Savings

Tech Transfer/Application to BPA Commercial Smart Plug Strips added to

Implementation Manual April 2010

Project Direction/Next Steps 1-year pilot Post/Post/post Evaluation

PlugLoad

Residential Load Growth

22


Synopsis Hotel/Motel PTHP/Occupancy Controls Field Test and energy savings

determination. This project is a combined effort between Inland Power & Light Company, Best

Western Peppertree, BPA and EMP2 to investigate the energy Phase I installation complete. Collecting data & preliminary analysis Final Report to be issued by end of April 2010.

Expected Benefits (annual) PTHP Retrofit = 800~900kWh/room PTAC/PTHP Occupancy = 400~500kWh/room

Next Steps Additional sites M&V Development of Savings Calculator

PTHP w/ Occupancy Control Field TestPTHP w/ Occupancy Control Field Test

23


Premium Ventilation Assessment - Phase 1SynopsisSynopsis

Proof of Concept Field Test Collaboration– Bonneville Power Administration

– Eugene Water & Electric Board

– Energy Trust of Oregon

– NPCC Regional Technical Forum RTUG

AccomplishmentsAccomplishments Field test of 4 units Complete– The field test included development of measure specification,

costs, and– preliminary savings projections Identified New Project Direction

Premium Ventilation Package1.Optimum start2.Resistance heat lockout3.Ventilation lockout4.Economizer control with integration5.Demand controlled ventilation (DCV)6.Variable speed drive (VSD) fan control

24


Premium Ventilation Assessment

ProjectProject Direction/NextDirection/Next StepsSteps

Phase 1Phase 1 Wrap up premium ventilation long term report

• Complete heating savings analysis Field proof of concept testing of DCV-IFC

• Upgrade to Digital Controls• Two flavors of premium ventilation

– Variable speed drive during idle– DCV based fan cycling

Phase 2: Expected Value Savings Development• Simulation• Limited field testing• Lab testing

Phase 3: Program Pilots with Evaluation – Next Summer

25


Emerging Technology Lighting Demonstration ProjectsEmerging Technology Lighting Demonstration ProjectsSynopsis LED down-light Demo: BPA will provide up to ten, LED down-

lights to up to twenty utilities

Emerging Technology Lighting Demonstration: Lighting Design Lab to facilitate demos, working with serving utilities

Outcomes

Confirm product performance and installation barriers.

Demonstrate and promote LED down lights to customers.

Transfer of information through case studies.

Develop incentive specifications and application guidelines.

26


What’s Next: Lighting

27

Integrated Classroom Lighting System •User-friendly controls•High quality indirect lighting•30% to 50% savings•Dimming for audiovisual presentations•Efficient fluorescent light fixtures Bi-Level/Occupancy Control

•40% to 60% savings•Stairwells, Parking Garages, •Parking Lots, Offices•Combine with Fluorescent, LED

On the Horizon• Mesopic Lighting

• Wireless Controls

• Plasma Lighting

• Electron Stimulated Luminescence

• OLED

Solid State Lighting


How to Participate - TAGs

28

E3T Technical Advisory Groups Purpose: Regional and national experts submit, evaluate and prioritize emerging technologies and make recommendations to BPA through an in-depth guided process.

Participation: New members for Energy Management are needed for 2010.

Contact: Jack Callahan, BPA Energy Efficiency, [email protected]

Jack Zeiger, WSU Energy Program, [email protected]

Learn More: Visit the BPA Web site: www.bpa.gov/energy/n/emerging_technology/index.cfm


How to Participate - Demonstrations

29

E3T Demonstration Projects

BPA-EPRI Heat Pump Water Heater (HPWH) field test.

Contact: Kacie Bedney, BPA, [email protected]

BPA-EPRI Variable Refrigerant Flow (VRF) system field test.

Contact: Mira Vowles, BPA, [email protected]

BPA Emerging Lighting Technology Demonstrations.

Contacts: Mira Vowles, BPA, [email protected]

Jack Zeiger, WSU Energy Program, [email protected]


Overview of Achievements and Next Steps

30

Year Achievement Focus Development Focus

FY 2009

Established Lighting and HVAC Groups Publish E3T Framework and User Guide

o Process Flow Charto Report and Scoring Templateso TAG Process Guidebook

Initiated 10 “Quick Start” TI 140 Projects

Design Process and Systems Develop and Test Processes Identify Needed Resources

FY 2010

Version 1.0 E3T Web Site on-line Lighting & HVAC TAG Recommendations BPA EE New Measure Process w/E3T Regional/BPA EE Roadmap□ Version 2.0 E3T Website□ Completed Projects

Add needed staffing □ Collaboration (TAGs, NEEA, RETAC,

ETO, DOE, Utilities)□ Outreach (Utility Forum, Webcasts,

Utility Visits)□ Integration with EE Programs□ Project Management


31

BPA 2010 Emerging Technology Team

Mira VowlesProject Managermkvowles@bpa,gov

Jack [email protected]

Jonathan [email protected]

Jack CallahanProgram [email protected]

Ryan FedieEngineering [email protected]

Rob Penny [email protected]

Kacie BedneyProject [email protected]

Documents

Update: BPA Emerging Technologies Presented to: Regional Technical Forum May 2010 Presented by: Jack Callahan, P.E., CEM, CMVP Emerging Technology Program