20
UNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015 Region: Global Office: New York headquarters Evaluation year: 2016 Evaluation report sequence number: 2016/010 Person in charge for follow-up to management response: Mr. Omar Abdi, Deputy Executive Director, Programmes Overall response to the evaluation: The Ebola epidemic in West Africa was a grim reminder of the stark threat posed to humanity by communicable diseases. In the aftermath of the outbreak, there is widespread agreement that such threats will continue to arise and concerns that they may become more complex (because of drug resistance, population growth and other factors). Drawing on the key findings from this evaluation, the recommendations presented in this report have been key to ensuring that UNICEF can be better prepared and capacitated to deal with future health emergencies. Planned use of evaluation: UNICEF is already responding to the recommendations of this evaluation report; most actions outlined below are under way. The findings are being used to strengthen key management functions to better prepare for and respond to health emergencies, including through global coordination, strategy development, planning and monitoring. Strategies and results related to public health emergencies are being integrated into the UNICEF Strategic Plan, 20182021. Actions are also under way to strengthen capacities for rapid, large-scale deployment of financial, human and material resources in all emergencies. Building on lessons learned from the response to Ebola, UNICEF is focusing on strengthening capacities and systems for health and child protection at the community level in countries at highest risk of a future health emergency. UNICEF will also strengthen the capacity of staff at headquarters, regional and country levels as well as government partners on community engagement and social mobilization to better prepare for and respond to health emergencies in high-risk countries.

UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

UNICEF Evaluation Management Response

Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

Region: Global

Office: New York headquarters

Evaluation year: 2016

Evaluation report sequence number: 2016/010

Person in charge for follow-up to management response: Mr. Omar Abdi, Deputy Executive Director, Programmes

Overall response to the evaluation: The Ebola epidemic in West Africa was a grim reminder of the stark threat posed to humanity by

communicable diseases. In the aftermath of the outbreak, there is widespread agreement that such threats will continue to arise and

concerns that they may become more complex (because of drug resistance, population growth and other factors). Drawing on the key

findings from this evaluation, the recommendations presented in this report have been key to ensuring that UNICEF can be better

prepared and capacitated to deal with future health emergencies.

Planned use of evaluation: UNICEF is already responding to the recommendations of this evaluation report; most actions outlined

below are under way. The findings are being used to strengthen key management functions to better prepare for and respond to health

emergencies, including through global coordination, strategy development, planning and monitoring. Strategies and results related to

public health emergencies are being integrated into the UNICEF Strategic Plan, 2018–2021. Actions are also under way to strengthen

capacities for rapid, large-scale deployment of financial, human and material resources in all emergencies. Building on lessons learned

from the response to Ebola, UNICEF is focusing on strengthening capacities and systems for health and child protection at the

community level in countries at highest risk of a future health emergency. UNICEF will also strengthen the capacity of staff at

headquarters, regional and country levels as well as government partners on community engagement and social mobilization to better

prepare for and respond to health emergencies in high-risk countries.

Page 2: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

2/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

Evaluation recommendation 1: The UNICEF West and Central Africa Regional Office (WCARO), Country Offices (COs) and partners in the three most-

affected countries (Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone) should ensure at minimum that: (a) health systems retain a rapid response capacity to prevent Ebola

outbreaks and develop International Health Regulations (IHR) core capacities; (b) community health systems are reinforced in the most-affected communities;

and (c) children most affected by Ebola receive adequate protection.

Management response: Agree.

However, community health systems should be strengthened in all communities in these three countries, as future health emergencies may affect populations

beyond those most affected by Ebola. In addition, actions to retain rapid response capacity and strengthen IHR capacities are predicated upon partner

commitments, and the role of UNICEF is determined within the context of national plans and strategies.

1.1 Retain rapid response

capacity to respond to

epidemic/infectious disease

outbreaks. This includes

establishing/maintaining

response coordination

structures at national and

decentralized levels;

strengthening human resource

capacity at all levels, including

training community health

workers; providing the

necessary infrastructure and

equipment for rapid response,

including the maintenance of

epidemic/infectious disease

care and treatment centres,

improving water, sanitation

and hygiene (WASH)

Health, WASH,

Supply, Social

policy,

Communication for

development

(C4D)

Deputy

Representative and

Chief of Emergency

Child Survival and

Development

(CSD/)/Chief of

Health

Throughout

2017 (and

ongoing)

Under way All three COs have

retained and

continue to fine-tune

the rapid response

mechanism at

country level, in

coordination with

Governments and

key stakeholders

and in line with the

components outlined

in action 1.1.

Country office

reports,

publications and

situation reports1

National plans for

post-Ebola

recovery, and

national health

policies and plans

1 See: www.scoop.it/t/ebola-by-ebola-news-and-views

Page 3: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

3/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

infrastructure in health

facilities and disease

surveillance and early warning

detection systems; and pre-

positioning of supplies,

including Rapid Isolation and

Treatment of Ebola kits.

1.2 Reinforce community

health systems in all three

countries, including in the

most-affected communities.

This includes supporting

development and

implementation of the

necessary health policy

frameworks and health

emergency strategies; building

human resource capacity,

including training community

health workers, and

strengthening capacity to

monitor epidemics for early

warning at community level.

COs/Deputy

Representatives/

CSD/Health

Section, C4D

Deputy

Representatives and

Chief of CSD/Health

Section

December

2017

Under way As part of their

support to

implementation of

national post-Ebola

recovery plans, all

three UNICEF COs

are strengthening

community health

systems in the most-

affected

communities.

Actions have

included

development and

improvement of

national community

health policies,

community health

strategic plans, and

community

contingency plans,

providing technical

Country office

reports,

publications and

situation reports2

National post-

Ebola recovery

plans and national

health policies and

plans

2 See: www.scoop.it/t/ebola-by-ebola-news-and-views

Page 4: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

4/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

and financial

support to

community health

programmes with

paid community

workers, and

training community

health workers.

UNICEF is also

modelling

innovative

approaches for early

warning and

monitoring of

epidemics at the

community level

using RapidPro.

1.3. Document good

practices, including

Community Care Centre

models in the three countries

(Guinea, Liberia and Sierra

Leone), and share these with

all countries in the West and

Central Africa region

(WCAR) and with partner

organizations.

Regional office

(RO)

Chief of CSD/Health

Section, in

coordination with

Chief of Planning,

Monitoring and

Evaluation, and Chief

of Communication in

consultation with the

Office of Emergency

Programmes

(EMOPS),

Programme Division

(PD), WASH

December

2017

Not started

Page 5: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

5/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

1.4. Develop a roster of

experts for health

emergencies, for rapid

deployment to countries

when requested.

RO Chief of Health

Section, in

coordination with the

Emergency Section,

PD, EMOPS, WASH,

C4D, Supply Division

December

2017

Not started

1.5. Develop strategies to

support the Governments of

Guinea, Liberia and Sierra

Leone in designing and

implementing enabling

policies, strengthening

human resource capacity,

and identifying innovative

financing for community

health systems. These

strategies will be based on

rebuilding trust in health

systems, community-based

disease surveillance and

strengthened community

capacity to maintain basic

social services in outbreaks

and broader humanitarian

situations.

RO CSD (Health, WASH,

Nutrition, C4D, Child

Protection) in

coordination with PD

and EMOPS

December

2017

Not started

1.6. Continue case

management so that child

survivors of and children

affected by Ebola benefit

COs Chiefs of Child

Protection

December

2017

Under way All three countries

are:

(a) following up on

Ebola-affected

Reports generated

from the child

Page 6: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

6/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

from family visits and home-

based psychosocial support.

children through

case management;

(b) mapping child

survivors or children

affected by Ebola

who did not receive

at least two post-

reunification family

visits; and (c)

conducting follow-

up visits during

post-reunification.

All three UNICEF

COs are also

providing a

minimum package

of child protection

services to children

who lost one or both

parents or

caregivers.3 In

Guinea and Liberia,

respectively, 6,220

and 5,401 children

affected by Ebola

received protection

services,. In Sierra

protection

databases

Child Protection

Information

Management

System (Sierra

Leone)

CO situation

reports

3 This package includes (a) psychosocial support provided through community-based child protection network members; (b) referral of children to other basic social services as

required (e.g., health, education, justice, etc.); (c) distribution of basic supplies, including hygiene kits; (d) family tracing and reunification for children who lost both parents; (e)

placement in alternative family care for orphans whose extended families have not been found; and (f) family visits to ensure effective and sustainable reunification.

Page 7: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

7/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

Leone, out of 12,012

children provided

with child protection

services, 5,236 are

orphaned by the

Ebola virus disease.

The case

management has

been successful

partly because of the

establishment of the

Child Protection

Information

Management

System, a database

run by both the

Ministry of Social

Welfare and non-

governmental

organizations

(NGOs).

1.7. Strengthen community-

based child protection

systems (CBCPS) so they can

identify cases early on and

provide necessary support.

COs Chiefs of Child

Protection

December

2017

Under way All three countries

have mapped the

existing CBCPS

that were

established during

the Ebola crisis, and

have activated early

warning systems.

Reports generated

from the child

protection

databases

Child Protection

Information

Management

Page 8: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

8/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

System (Sierra

Leone)

Country office

situation reports

1.8. Advocate and provide

technical support for

including child survivors or

children affected by Ebola in

government social protection

schemes.

COs Chiefs of Child

Protection and Chiefs

of Social Policy

December

2017

Under way All three COs are

documenting and

monitoring children

in need of

government social-

protection schemes,

providing technical

support so that

national social-

protection

programmes include

these children in the

existing schemes,

and will conduct

family visits to

verify if all referred

children benefit

from the schemes.

CO monitoring

reports

1.9. Support fundraising to

strengthen child protection

systems at decentralized

level, particularly for

prevention services, early

warning, case management

and referral of children to

RO, COs Chiefs of Child

Protection, Regional

Child Protection

Advisers and Child

Protection Specialists

December

2017

Not started

Page 9: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

9/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

other basic social services.

This includes identifying

potential donors and joint

proposal development by the

RO and COs.

1.10. Improve the existing

Child Protection in

Emergencies (CPiE) regional

human resources roster and

train staff and partners on

CPiE, including through the

certification programme on

CPiE developed with the

Bioforce Institute.4

RO, COs UNICEF CO

Representative,

Regional Child

Protection Adviser,

Regional CPiE

Specialist, and

Division of Human

Resources (DHR)

December

2017

Under way The RO is pre-

screening CPiE

profiles for

inclusion in the

CPiE regional

roster. As of

February 2017, the

roster contained 270

profiles.

UNICEF staff

members and staff

in partner

organizations are

being identified for

CPiE training,

which includes a

module on case

management.

CO CPiE

preparedness plans

Existing updated

CPiE regional

roster

Bioforce Institute

curricula for CPiE

Project

Management

Certificate

Training reports

4 In 2016, UNICEF worked with the Bioforce Institute (www.institutbioforce.fr/en), a French organization that provides training, support and accredited certification for humanitarian

professionals, to develop a CPiE Project Management Certificate programme. UNICEF headquarters and WCARO, the Child Protection Area of Responsibility and the Child

Protection Global Alliance have supported implementation of this programme for UNICEF national staff and local NGO partners.

Page 10: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

10/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

In addition, the RO

is identifying Child

Protection staff who

will participate in

the more intensive

three-month

Bioforce

certification

program on CPiE.

As a complement to

the RO roster, the

RO is making sure

that country- level

CPiE- preparedness

plans are completed.

Evaluation recommendation 2: The UNICEF Global Management Team (GMT) should develop a policy and accountability framework for responding to

public health emergencies that includes: (a) specific goals; (b) programme guidance; (c) global partnership objectives; and (d) assessment of broader

humanitarian risks. Whether produced as an addendum to the Core Commitments for Children (CCCs) in Humanitarian Action or a separate policy, it should

complement and build on rather than duplicate existing UNICEF emergency response policies and processes.

Management response: Partially agree.

The UNICEF accountability framework does not recognize the GMT as the body for policy or procedure authorization, but rather it is an advisory body, and

delegates this to the ‘business owner as appropriate (defined in the responsible section/s column)’. The CCCs provide the overall framework for action in

humanitarian contexts. We agree that UNICEF should develop the necessary procedures and guidance for responding to public health emergencies as a

complement to the existing CCCs and Simplified Standard Operating Procedures (SSOPs), as outlined in this recommendation.

2.1. Identify key areas of

work that need to be

strengthened to improve

PD/EMOPS/

Supply Division

(SD) and DHR

Health Emergencies

Preparedness

Initiative (HEPI)

March 2017 Under way Under HEPI,

UNICEF has

defined principles

Core Commitments

for Children in

Page 11: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

11/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

preparedness, response and

recovery for health

emergencies based on the

existing organizational

accountability framework.

Coordinator/

Principal Adviser on

Health Emergencies

and areas of work5

for preparedness and

response to health

emergencies.

Humanitarian

Action6

UNICEF Approach

to Health System

Strengthening7

UNICEF Health

Emergencies

Preparedness

Initiative (internal)

2.2. Integrate strategies and

indicators aligned to public

health emergencies into the

UNICEF Strategic Plan.

PD/Division of

Data, Research and

Policy

(DRP/)/EMOPS

Directors/Chiefs

PD/DRP

September

2017

Under way Health emergencies

included in the

UNICEF Strategic

Plan, 2018–2021

UNICEF Strategic

Plan, 2018–2021

2.3. Develop sectoral and

intersectoral programme

guidance on preparing and

responding to health

emergencies and recovery.

PD/EMOPS/SD Principal Adviser on

Health Emergencies

in collaboration with

the Directors of PD,

EMOPS and SD

September

2017

Under way As part of HEPI,

first drafts of

‘packages of

support’ for

Category 1 diseases

have been

developed.8

Guidelines and

standards for

Draft packages of

support for

Category 1 diseases

5 Areas of work identified include (a) internal organization and prioritization, (b) disease-specific preparation, (c) institutional strengthening, and (d) cooperation with partners. 6 See: www.unicef.org/publications/files/CCC_042010.pdf 7 See: www.unicef.org/health/files/UNICEF_HSS_Approach_-_5Jun16.pdf 8 Category 1 diseases are Yellow Fever, Dengue, Zika, Chikungunya, Avian Flu, Pandemic flu, Ebola, Marburg, Cholera, Malaria, Measles, Meningococcal disease and Polio. The ‘packages

of support’ for each Category 1 disease include disease-specific quick notes, programme sector guide, supply requirements, repository of guidance, tools, training materials and C4D guidance

and tools.

Page 12: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

12/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

UNICEF

community-based

risk assessments still

need to be

developed.

PD/Child

Protection Section

PD Director December

2017

Under way Addendum to the

inter-agency

Minimum Standards

for Child Protection

in Humanitarian

Action, featuring

recommendations

for child protection

preparedness and

response in

epidemics, is being

developed.

Minimum

Standards for Child

Protection in

Humanitarian

Action, Child

Protection Working

Group9

Terms of reference

for developing an

addendum to the

Minimum

Standards for Child

Protection in

Humanitarian

Action

PD/WASH Section PD Director May 2017 Under way Development of a

module on Health

Emergencies in the

UNICEF WASH in

Emergencies

training, which will

be provided to all

Draft training

module

9 See: www.unicef.org/iran/Minimum_standards_for_child_protection_in_humanitarian_action.pdf

Page 13: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

13/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

UNICEF WASH

staff.

Evaluation recommendation 3: The UNICEF GMT should recognize areas for improvement and strengthen coordination, strategy and information capacities

for public health emergencies. Drawing on lessons learned from the Ebola response, UNICEF should develop tools, guidance and mechanisms and strengthen

capacities for: (a) global emergency coordination; (b) planning, programme support and performance monitoring; and (c) information and knowledge

management functions.

Management response: Partially agree. The GMT is an advisory body and is not accountable for action on the recommendations.

As noted in response to recommendation 2, tools and guidance are the accountability of the relevant business owner as defined in the responsible person/s and

responsible section/s columns. We agree with the need to strengthen capacities on global emergency coordination; planning, programme support and

performance monitoring; and the information and knowledge-management functions. This will be done in line with the Inter-Agency Standing Committee

(IASC) guidance on L3 activation for disease events.10

3.1. Define leadership and

coordination structure

within UNICEF to prepare

and respond to health

emergencies and identify

and address capacity gaps.

EMOPS/PD/SD Directors of EMOPS,

PD and SD, under the

guidance of the

relevant Deputy

Executive Directors

September

2017

Under way Proposal to

strengthen

leadership and

coordination

structure for health

emergences in

UNICEF was

submitted to the

Office of the

Executive Director

and was agreed to.

Recruitment of

Principal Adviser

for Public Health

Proposal to

strengthen

leadership and

coordination

structure for health

emergencies

(internal)

Terms of reference

for Principal

Adviser for Health

Emergencies

(D-1)

Draft addendum to

L2 and L3 SSOPs

10 The IASC guidance on L3 activation for disease events (December 2016) outlines procedures for the assessment of infectious disease events, the consultation and decision-making processes

on L3 activation for such events, the activation and deactivation criteria and procedures, and the implications for IASC members and other collaborating organizations.

Page 14: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

14/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

Emergencies (D-1)

is under way.

Addendum to L2

and L3 SSOPs on

Core Commitments

for Health

Emergencies has

been drafted.

for Core

Commitments for

Health

Emergencies

3.2. Increase physical stocks

in UNICEF of supplies

identified as critical for

priority diseases.

SD SD Director First quarter

(Q1) 2017

Under way SD is finalizing

remaining long-

term agreements

(LTAs) with

suppliers for

supplies identified

in Category 1

disease-supply lists

and has put in place

physical stock at the

SD warehouse or

suppliers’ premises

for these items. All

LTAs will be in

place for Category 1

supplies by the end

of Q1 2017.

LTAs with

suppliers

3.3. Integrate outbreak risks

in the Emergency

Preparedness Platform

EMOPS/PD/ ROs EMOPS Director,

with inputs from PD

Director

Q1 2018 Under way UNICEF Procedure

on Preparedness for

Emergency

Response was

UNICEF Procedure

on Preparedness for

Emergency

Response

Page 15: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

15/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

(EPP),11 and monitor

preparedness actions at

headquarters, RO and CO

levels.

Regional Directors

(responsible for

monitoring

preparedness actions

at RO and CO levels)

issued in December

2016.

Roll-out started in

Feb 2017.

Development of

EPP software is

under way.

EPP specification

document

3.4. Review all country

programme strategy notes

for inclusion of anticipation,

planning and response to

health emergencies.

Field Results

Group (FRG) in

collaboration with

ROs, PD and

EMOPS

Directors of FRG, PD

and EMOPS

Ongoing as

COs develop

strategy notes

Under way All strategy notes

produced in 2016

were reviewed for

inclusion of

anticipation,

planning and

response to health

emergencies.

Country

programme

strategy notes

(internal)

3.5. Include reporting on

humanitarian indicators as

part of the annual corporate

reporting.

FRG, in

collaboration with

PD and EMOPS

Directors of FRG, PD

and EMOPS

December

2018

Under way All humanitarian

performance-

monitoring

indicators have been

included in the

Results Assessment

Module (RAM) as

standard indicators.

List of standard

indicators in RAM

11 EPP is a tool (under development) to implement the UNICEF Procedure on Preparedness for Emergency Response, which COs, ROs and HQ will use to plan effective short-

term preparedness activities and to monitor their preparedness levels.

Page 16: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

16/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

3.6. Jointly identify and

address key coordination

and research gaps for

cholera control (and other

outbreaks) with the United

States Centers for Disease

Control and Prevention

(CDC), World Health

Organization (WHO) and

other stakeholders.

PD/WASH

Section/Health and

Immunization

PD Director Ongoing Under way UNICEF is leading

the Global WASH

Technical Working

Group of the Global

Cholera Task Force.

Coordination and

research gaps are

currently being

identified, and a

plan will be

developed to jointly

address these with

CDC, WHO and

other stakeholders.

In addition,

UNICEF is

participating in

regional platforms

on cholera in the

Eastern and

Southern Africa

region (ESAR) and

WCAR to

strengthen

coordination and

research with CDC,

WHO and other

stakeholders.

Terms of reference

and workplan for

WASH Technical

Working Group of

the Global Cholera

Task Force

Page 17: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

17/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

3.7. Consolidate and

distribute:

(a) lessons learned from

UNICEF and partners’

response to outbreaks;

(b) data on morbidity and

mortality from

epidemic/pandemic-prone

diseases with a focus on

children;

(c) outbreak risk

assessments; and

(d) research articles,

guidelines, tools and training

material.

PD/EMOPS/SD Principal Adviser on

Health Emergencies,

in collaboration with

the Directors of PD,

EMOPS and SD

Ongoing Under way Updates on

morbidity and

mortality related to

Zika and other

priority epidemic

diseases have been

consolidated and

disseminated to

UNICEF

headquarters, ROs

and COs.

UNICEF Sharepoint

site on public health

emergencies, which

contains key

updates, guidance

and tools, has been

established.

Zika updates

(internal)

UNICEF

Sharepoint site on

public health

emergencies

(internal)

Evaluation recommendation 4: The UNICEF GMT should continue to strengthen capacities for rapid, large-scale deployment of financial, human and

material resources in emergencies by: (a) applying lessons and protocols from the Ebola response on duty of care; (b) significantly increasing emergency

human-resource capacities and emergency competencies in country offices; and (c) involving operational and administrative staff in strategy and programme

management.

Management response: Partially Agree.

As noted in response to recommendations 2 and 3, the GMT is an advisory body and is not responsible for such actions. EMOPS will support the designated

coordinator for health emergencies to coordinate components 1 and 2 of the recommendation. Component 3 – involving operational and administrative staff in

strategy and programme management – will be addressed through guidance under the Health Emergencies Preparedness Initiative.

Page 18: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

18/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

4.1. Clarify duty of care

measures and procedures for

personnel operating in

health emergencies.

DHR, with

EMOPS

DHR Director December

2018

Under way UNICEF

participates in the

Global Working

Group on

reconciling “duty of

care” for United

Nations personnel

while operating in

high-risk

environments,

which is under the

United Nations

High-level

Committee on

Management.

A UNICEF template

and procedure has

been developed to

review the duty of

care upon

declaration of a

public health

emergency.

UNICEF template

and procedure to

review the duty of

care upon

declaration of a

public health

emergency

4.2. Map existing expertise

and develop multisectoral

surge roster at global level

for outbreaks and health

emergencies response.

DHR, with support

from EMOPS, PD

and SD

Directors of DHR and

EMOPS, PD and SD

December

2017

Under way SD roster with

supply logistics and

Emergency

Response Team

staff has been

expanded to include

staff with a

SD roster

Page 19: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

19/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

background in

health emergencies.

Evaluation recommendation 5: UNICEF EMOPS and the UNICEF Programme Division should further develop the community-based approach as an

implementation modality inclusive of strong AAP [Accountability to Affected Populations] and community engagement components. Recognizing the central

role of communities in stopping Ebola, UNICEF should focus on strengthening local capacities and systems for health and social protection at the community

level. This effort should include means of increasing capacity within UNICEF for community engagement and social mobilization and improving programme

integration at the community level.

Management response: Agree.

5.1. Establish community

engagement coordination

platforms in key countries

(in line with cluster

arrangements). This is an

initiative co-led by UNICEF,

the United Nations Office for

the Coordination of

Humanitarian Affairs,

International Federation of

Red Cross and Red Crescent

Societies, and the

Communicating with

Disaster-Affected

Communities Network.

EMOPS/cluster

leads and

Humanitarian

Policy Section

(HPS), PD/C4D

EMOPS/cluster leads

and HPS, PD/C4D

Ongoing

through 2018–

2019

Under way The global inter-

agency

Communication and

Community

Engagement

Initiative for

emergency response

was established in

Q4 2016.

Inter-agency C4D

guidance for health

emergencies (Zika)

(internal)

Inter-agency C4D

guidance for health

emergencies

(Yellow Fever)

(internal)

Draft concept

note/workplan for

Communication

and Community

Engagement

Initiative

5.2. Strengthen UNICEF

C4D capacities at CO and

RO levels to address health

emergencies. This includes (a)

PD/Health Section,

in collaboration

with all sectors and

the C4D Section

PD Director Ongoing Under way New York

University Outbreak

Communication

course: A total of 50

Curriculum of the

Outbreak

Communication

Page 20: UNICEF Evaluation Management Response · PDF fileUNICEF Evaluation Management Response Evaluation title: Evaluation of UNICEF’s Response to the Ebola Outbreak in West Africa, 2014–2015

20/20

Action Responsible

section/s Responsible person/s

Expected

completion

date

Implementati

on stage:

Not started

Under way

Completed

Cancelled

Action taken Supporting

documents

training UNICEF staff and

technical personnel on

outbreak communication; and

(b) training relevant

government institutions

involved in preparedness and

response to health

emergencies on C4D and

community engagement in the

context of outbreaks.

UNICEF CO and

RO staff (C4D and

monitoring and

evaluation) have

been trained and are

now deployable in

emergencies.

Training will be

expanded in 2017.

Staff from

Ministries of Health

in 16 countries in

ESAR were trained

on C4D and

community

engagement in the

context of outbreaks

by C4D/Polio teams

in June 2016.

Training will be

expanded to WCAR

in 2017.

course and list of

trained personnel

Reports from

training sessions

________________