Upload
augustine-gordon
View
213
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Two-Step Authentication Patents December 2013
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK - PRODUCT
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 1
Discussion Topics
About Russ August & Kabat
Analysis Of The ‘360 Patent Family
Licensing Strategy
Discussion
Russ August & Kabat Is A Fit For You
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 2
About Russ August & Kabat
Rapid Growth And A Deep Bench Of Experience
Attorneys From Top Firms And Law Schools Including Harvard, Columbia, Michigan And UCLA
Founded In 1990
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 3
4
The Patent Team
Recruited From Top Law Firms –Irell & Manella (11 Attorneys), Munger Tolles, Winston & Strawn
More Than 20 Patent Trial Lawyers
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED
The Patent Team
Patent Group Chair
Lead Trial Counsel In CWC v. Hyundai Lead Trial Counsel
In Clear With Computers
Nearly 20 Years Of Patent Litigation
Experience
Worked For 5 Years At Microsoft
Clerked For Federal Judge Lawrence
McKenna (Southern District Of New
York)
Litigate Cases Against Google,
Amazon, Cisco, Dell, IBM, LinkedIn
DropBox, Facebook
Broad Experience Negotiating
Licensing Agreements
Litigated Cases In California, Texas, Delaware, New
York, Etc.
Extensive Experience
Representing Patent Holders
5
Exemplar Litigation – CWC
Clear With Computers Litigation
Hyundai's Attorneys Were The 900-attorney International Law Firm Winston & Strawn
Hyundai Spent Over $1.35 Million Just On Expert Witnesses Trying To Defeat The CWC Patent
RAK Obtained An $11.5 Million Judgment, Affirmed By The Federal Circuit
V.
6
Exemplar Litigation - TQP
TQP Litigation
Successfully licensed the technology to 139 companies (over $45 million in licensing revenue)
At trial in November 2013, RAK obtained a $2.3 million judgment
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 7
Discussion Topics
About Russ August & Kabat
Analysis Of The ‘360 Patent Family
Licensing Strategy
Discussion
Russ August & Kabat Is A Fit For You
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 8
Russ August And Your Patent
RAK Focuses On Patent Holders
Plaintiff Side Focus Avoids Conflicts Of Interest
Deep Experience Litigating In Key Jurisdictions
Successful Licensing Campaigns In This Field
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 9
Russ August And Your Patent
Represent Patent Monetization Entities
IP Navigation Group
Empire IP
Capital Legal Group
Tessera Technologies
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 10
Understanding Patent Owner Concerns
Venue And
Joinder
Standing Issues
Patent Damages
Changes In The Law
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 11
Efficient Licensing Campaigns
RAK Focuses On Multi-Defendant Cases
TQP v. Merrill Lynch, EDTX, encryption
Clouding IP v. Google, D. Del., cloud computing
Minerva v. Motora, EDTX, smart phones
Linksmart v. T-Mobile, EDTX, dynamic redirection
DataTern v. Oracle, EDTX, rel. db/GUI mapping
PACid v. Cisco, EDTX, encryption
API v. Facebook, EDTX, network distributed media
Data Tech v. Speed, D. Del., memory management
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 12
Discussion Topics
About Russ August & Kabat
Analysis Of The ‘360 Patent Family
Licensing Strategy
Discussion
Russ August & Kabat Is A Fit For You
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 13
The ‘360 Patent
Recent And Widespread Adoption Of Two-Step Authentication Using Two Communication Forms
Hardware Makers Financial Services Companies
Website Operators Software Companies
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 14
Background On The ‘360 Patent
Prosecution History
Prior Licensing Of The Patent
Your Development Of The Invention
Current Monetization Efforts
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 15
U.S. Patent No. 8,589,271
The ‘360 Patent
The ‘360 Patent Family Requires Experienced Plaintiff Patent Counsel
Changes In Patent Law Present Particular Challenges
Avoiding Transfer To Forums Skeptical Of Patents
Section 101 Challenges To Patentability For Authentication Patents
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 16
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED
17
Discussion Topics
About Russ August & Kabat
Analysis Of The ‘360 Patent
Licensing Strategy
Discussion
Russ August & Kabat Is A Fit For You
Licensing Strategy
‘360 Patent Family Target Analysis
Websites And ApplicationsGoogle, Facebook, Salesforce, Paypal, Dropbox, Twitter, LinkedIn, Duo Security, MicroStrategy, SecurEnvoy, Swift Identity, Secure, Vasco, Dynapass, Encap, Authy, Microsoft, Evernote
Financial ServicesBank of America, Citibank, JPMorgan, Chase, PNC, Fidelity, Visa, Amex, Mastercard
Hardware & Backoffice IBM, Cisco, RSA, SafeNetSwivel, Palo Alto Networks
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 18
Licensing Strategy
Jurisdiction Analysis
Where Non-Practicing Entity Cases Were Filed In 2012
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 19
Licensing Strategy
Jurisdiction Analysis
District Court Declaratory Judgments Filed In 2012
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 20
Licensing Strategy
Jurisdiction Analysis Of Potential TargetsDefendant State of Inc. Principal Place of Business
Google Inc. (Gmail; Google Authenticator)
DE Mountain View, CA
Facebook Inc. DE Menlo Park, CASalesforce.com, Inc. DE San Francisco, CAPayPal, Inc. DE San Jose, CADropbox, Inc. DE San Francisco, CATwitter, Inc. DE San Francisco, CALinkedIn Corporation DE Mountain View, CADuo Security, Inc. DE Ann Arbor, MIMicroStrategy Inc. DE Tysons Corner, VAIBM Corporation NY Armonk, NYSwift Identity N.A. Global HQ: Montreal,
CanadaSwivel Secure, Inc. DE Global/UK HQ: Wetherby, West
Yorkshire; US HQ: Seattle, WAVasco Data Security, Inc.(Digipass)
DE Oakbrook Terrace, IL
Dynapass Inc. DE Costa Mesa, CAEncap Security Inc. DE Palo Alto, CAAuthy Inc. DE San Francisco, CAMicrosoft Corporation (Windows Azure)
WA Redmond, WA
Evernote Corporation DE Redwood City, CACloudFlare, Inc. DE San Francisco, CA
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 21
Licensing Strategy
Multiple Wave Litigation
Single Wave Litigation
Target Modest Initial Settlements With Objective Of Longer Litigation Against Key Targets
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 22
Deal Structure
Overview Of Deal Structure
Your Obligations
Ensuring Beneficial Tax Structure
Russ August Attorneys Have Experience Structuring Flexible, Tax-Efficient Structure
Various Options For Minimizing Tax Liability
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 23
Deal Structure
Benefits Of Our Structure Over Patent Monetization Firm
Focus On The ‘360 Patent
Family
Ensures Top Plaintiff Firm
Representation
Minimizing Risk Of Invalidation
Of The ‘360 Patent Family
Experience In Licensing
Authentication & Encryption
Patents
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 24
Timing Concerns
Pending Legislation Could Negatively Impact The ‘360 Patent Family
Supreme Court Decision In Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank Could Have A Large Impact On The ‘360 Patent Family
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 25
Discussion Topics
About Russ August & Kabat
Analysis Of The ‘360 Patent Family
Licensing Strategy
Discussion
Russ August & Kabat Is A Fit For You
CONFIDENTIAL - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT - PRIVILEGED 26