Upload
marshall-bravestar
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
1/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARKRECREATION SITE CONCEPT PLAN
MAY 2009
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANYUrban Design & Planning
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
2/50
Report Prepared For:
County of San Diego
Department of Parks and Recreation9150 Chesapeake Drive, Suite 200San Diego, California 92123Consultants:
Rick Engineering - Urban Design & Planning
5620 Friars RoadSan Diego, CA 92110www.rickengineering.com
Beals Alliance
3400 Bradshaw Road, Suite BSacramento, CA 95827www.bealsalliance.com
May 5th, 2009
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK RECREATION SITE CONCEPT PLAN
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
3/50
I INTRODUCTION 5
1. Purpose 52. Concept Plan Process 73. Long Term Development of the Site 94. Zoning 95. Coastal Zone 96. MSCP/MHPA 9
II OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS 11
1. Utilities 112. Topography 153. Geology & Soils 174. Circulation 19
5. Hydrology & Water Quality 236. Land Use & Planning 297. Context 328. Community Plans 359. Visual Resources 4510. Agriculture 4711. Biological Resources 49
III NEEDS ASSESSMENT ANALYSIS 51
1. Inventory of Regional Facilities 532. Public Input Survey 573. Facilities Options 634. Case Studies 655. Site Allocations 69
6. Five Concepts 70
APPENDICES 78
Appendix 1. Zoning & Regulatory Context 78 Coastal Zone 79 MSCP 93 MHPA 95
Appendix 2. CEQA 97Appendix 3. Environmental Impact Reports 99
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
4/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT4
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 1
REGIONAL LOCATION
_______________________________
PROJECT S I TE
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
5/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
6/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT6
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 2
SUBREGIONAL LOCATION
_______________________________
exicoMexico
Pacific Ocean
NationalityCity
Tijuana River ValleyTijuana River ValleyRegional arkRegional ParkUnitedStatesUnitedStates
PROJECT SITE
hulaChulaistaVistaPROJECT S I TE
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
7/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
8/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT8
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 3
SITE CHARACTERISTICS
_________________________Note that the high point of the site
is in the southeast corner, with thelow point being in just west of thenorthwest corner.
PROJECT SITE
(Low Point)
Legend
Flood Protection Rip Rap
Soil Berms
Topography
Vegetation
Fencing
Photo Locations
Water Source
High Low
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
9/50
9
3.LONG TERM DEVELOPMENT
OF THE SITE
The County has secured funding for the
conceptual design process. Once a conceptdesign is completed, the County will follow along range plan for the development of theproject site which includes:
Seek Funding for DevelopmentDevelop Construction DocumentsEnvironmental & PermittingRequirements
Phased ConstructionPartnership for Operation & Maintenance
4. ZONING
The project site, and the properties adjacentto the west, east and south are zoned OF-
1-1 (Open Space Floodplain) under Chapter13 of the City of San Diego Municipal Code.
Although within the City of San Diego, theproposed Project Site is on land owned byand under the jurisdiction of the County ofSan Diego. As such, the Project would beundertaken by the County of San DiegoDepartment of Parks and Recreation (See
appendix for more information).
5. COASTAL ZONE
The entire project site is within the CoastalZone. An overlay zone of additional
restrictions is placed upon the existing zoningcategories. The State of California GovernorsOffice of Planning and Research has postedan explanation of the consequences for localgovernments in general. This has beenincluded in the Appendix.
6. MULTIPLE SPECIES
CONSERVATION PROGRAM
The project site is within the Multiple SpeciesConservation Program (MSCP) but out of theMultiple Habitat Planning Area (MHPA ). TheMSCP exists within the vicinity of the projectsite and impacts nearby development and
could be restrictive on expansion beyondthe project boundaries. Therefore it bearsexamination. An overview of the MSCP/MHPA is included in the Appendix.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
10/50
10
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INT
ERNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO L
LIS
TE
R
STR
EE
T
HOLLISTER
STR
EET
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT10
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
S
TREET
INTERNATIONALROAD
Legend
PROJECT SITE
8 Water Line
8 Sewer Line
10 Sludge LineForce Main
30 WastewaterForce Main
EXHIBIT 4
UTILITIESDesign Considerations
_________________________DIAGRAMATIC LOCATIONS
INTERNATIONALROAD
HOLLISTER
S
TREET
SUNSET AVENUE
NOTES:
The sewer lines along SunsetAvenue must be taken into accountin any future planning with respect tohonoring the utility easements
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
11/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
12/50
12
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INT
ERNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO L
LIS
TE
R
STR
EE
T
HOLLISTER
STR
EET
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT12
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
S
TREET
INTERNATIONALROAD
EXHIBIT 5
RENEWABLE ENERGYDesign Considerations
_________________________
Legend
PROJECT SITE
Potential Opportunity
Potential Constraint
Potential EnergyReceptor Location
HOLLISTER
STREET
INTERNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
NOTES:
Abundance of sunlight could reduceAbundance of sunlight could reduceelectric energy costs and allow for theelectric energy costs and allow for thelocation of solar-powered lighting inlocation of solar-powered lighting inlocations remote from power lines.locations remote from power lines. Peak hour heat from sunlight, though a
potential power source, is also a factorthat needs to be mitigated with trees,and shade structures.
Sea breezes produce a sustained 10knot wind from the west/southwest.
Fall and Winter Santa Ana winds fromthe Mojave Desert are a sustained 18-24 knots from the east.
SUNLIGHT
SEABREEZE
S
SANTA
ANAWIND
S
HEAT
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
13/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
14/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT14
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 6
SLOPE ANALYSIS
_________________________
SUNSET VESUNSET AVE
PROJECT SITE
NOTES:
The slope characteristics of thesite, and the surrounding areas,reveals a largely level sub-regionwith deviations caused by naturalstream beds and berms anddepressions associated with thehighway network.
The level nature of the site reducesthe amount of grading necessary, butcomplicates the drainage challengeduring the design phase because watercould tend to pond.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
15/50
15
2. TOPOGRAPHY
The 64-acre project site is relatively level.The project site slopes from the southeastcorner to the northwest corner at less than2%.
OPPORTUNITIES:
The project site is well suited for largeland demand active recreation playfields (e.g. soccer, football, baseball).This is a rare and precious commodity in
a regional context since most level landwithin the region has been built upon oris remote from population centers andpotential sports participants.Open vistas to distant mountain ranges.These views are notable and present adistinct opportunity. Facilities designedfor repose, rest and gathering shouldbe located near the eastern side of theproperty and should be designed toprotect, frame and celebrate the views.Provides unique topographic relief fromadjacent hillsides and valleys.
CONSTRAINTS:Drainage could be more difficult toachieve. Preliminary analysis indicatesthat the natural drainage tends tomigrate to the northwest.
ADDITIONAL STUDY:
The relatively level site will present
drainage challenges. Plans should
account for the possibility of requiring
the installation of a water quality and
storm water retention facility withinthe project site.
The subject site exhibits a very gentle slope of less than 2%. (View east from Hollister Street)
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
16/50
16
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INTERNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO L
LIS
TE
R
STR
EE
T
HOLLISTER
STREET
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT16
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
STREET
INTERNA
TIONALROAD
EXHIBIT 12
GEOLOGY & SOILSDesign Considerations
_________________________
EXHIBIT 7
SOILS & SURFACEATTRIBUTESDesign Considerations
_________________________
INTERNAT
IONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
Legend
PROJECT SITE
Potential Opportunity
Potential Constraint
Berms
Levee
NOTES:
TheLargely treeless site requiresLargely treeless site requiresshade for usersshade for users.Unused underground tanksUnused underground tanksrequire further hazardous materialrequire further hazardous materialinvestigation.investigation.
The large stand of EucalyptusThe large stand of Eucalyptuspresents potential shaded retreat. Butpresents potential shaded retreat. ButEucalyptus is not a desired long-termEucalyptus is not a desired long-termplant therefore underplanting mightplant, therefore underplanting mighthave to be done to establish a long-have to be done to establish a long-term tree shade canopy.term tree shade canopy.
HOLLISTER
STREET
TANKS
EUCA
LYPTUS
SHADE
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
17/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
18/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT18
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 8
ACCESS/ CIRCULATION
_______________________________
Primary access to the projectsite occurs via Hollister Street,from Tocayo Avenue, MonumentRoad or Coronado Avenue.
Legend
Tijuana River ValleyRegional Park Boundary
Primary Access Route
Freeway Interchange
MEXICO
HollisterSt.
SaturnBlvd.
Monum
entRd. DairyM
artR
d.
Monument Rd.
Oro
Vista
Rd.
Bey
erB
lvd.
Palm Ave.
Coronado Ave.
TocayoAve.Wardlow St.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
19/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
20/50
20
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INTE
RNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO
LLIS
TE
R
STR
EE
T
HOLLISTER
STRE
ET
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT20
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
ST
REET
INTERNA
TIONALROAD
EXHIBIT 9
CIRCULATIONDesign Considerations
Legend
Equestrian. Pedestrian &Multi-Use Trail
Existing Trail Connection
Primary Road
Secondary Road
Confluence of MajorCirculation Types
NeighborhoodVehicular Connection
Existing NeighborhoodPedestrian Connection
Potential Road Extension
HOLLISTER
STREET
INTERNATI
ONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
NOTES:
The International Road access pointdoes not accommodate handicapaccess and cycling.
POTENTIAL ADDITIONAL PARKING
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
21/50
21
Additional traffic analysis will be importantdetermine long-term circulation needs.
ADDITIONAL STUDY:
A traffic study should be conducted to
determine precise current traffic on
Hollister and Sunset.
Once a Concept Plan for the project
site is designed, a traffic study will be
conducted as part of an Environmental
Review Process. This traffic analysis
should account for periodicflooding, and
its impact on emergency evacuation.
Any long-term traffic study should
account for the long-term land uses ofprivate property within the vicinity ofthe project site, including any potential
expansion of the Regional Park.Concept Designs should consider usingSunset and International for angledparking to relieve pressure to useprecious recreational lands for vehicle
parking, storage and circulation.Additional directional signs should beconsidered to and from the site along themajor access points of Hollister Road,
I-5 and Dairy Mart Road for regional
access.
Potential vehicle/pedestrian conflicts at
Hollister and Sunset should be addressed
in any long-term plan.
Sight-distance at existing Sunset on to
Hollister should be examined to determine
if reduced speed limits on Hollister are in
order to maintain safety once the project
site is developed.
Any parking study should examine if
parking spaces for equestrian users, of
sufficient length for horse trailers and
their tow trucks, should be built into the
project area.
Extensions of the existing trails system
should be examined, including the
installation of bike lockers within the
project site near parking areas and trailheads.
The public face of the project site is
very poor. The project should include
aesthetic improvements wherever
the project exhibits an adjacency a
public right-of-way. Streetscape and
gateway improvements can help build
a constituency in the neighborhood forthe long-term recreational use of the site
by providing good will and giving back
to the neighborhood.
5. HYDROLOGY & WATER
The current access point at the stub of International
Road is not ADA accessible, is unsightly, and isuninviting. Properly designed, it could become an
attractive gateway.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
22/50
22
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INTE
RNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO
LLIS
TE
R
STR
EE
T
HOLLISTER
STRE
ET
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT22
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
ST
REET
INTERNA
TIONALROAD
EXHIBIT 10
HYDROLOGY & WATER
_________________________
Legend
PROJECT SITE
Flood Control Levee
Non-Flood Control Berm
Flood Zone X
Flood Zone AE
Streams &Drainage Ditches
ORO AD
DLOWA
OAOA
HOLLISTER
ST
REET
NTERNA
TIONALROAD
FLOOD ZONE X
HOLLISTER
ST
REET
INTERNA
TIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
FLOOD ZONE X - .Areas protectedfrom the 1% chance offlooding bylevees.
FLOOD ZONE AE - Areas with a 1%chance offlooding annually
Levees that performflood control mustremain.
Berms that do not control floodingmight be reduced or eliminated.
FLOOD ZONE AE
NOTES:
The project site is located in aregulatory floodway. This hasa regulatory impact on futuredevelopment and the ultimateplan.
LEVEE
BERM
BER
M
AE Floodplain
AE Floodway
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
23/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
24/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
25/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
26/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT26
Diagram 1Floodplain Schematic
City of San Diego Council Policy 600-14
Because of the flood characteristics ofthe project site, it is subject to City of SanDiego Council Policy 600-14 regarding
development.
DEVIATION CRITERIA:Where a deviation from the EnvironmentallySensitive Lands Regulations of the LandDevelopment Code (Sections 143.0145and 143.0146) is requested, the decisionmaker shall consider all relevant factors,all technical evaluations, and all standardsprovided by the City Engineer in addition tothe following conditions:
A deviation shall not be approved within anydesignated floodway if any increase infloodlevels during the base flood discharge
would result. (See Diagram 1, FloodplainSchematic in Appendix A of Council Policy600-14).
A deviation may be approved only upon:1. a showing of good and sufficient cause;
2. a determination that the proposed
deviation is the minimumnecessary to afford relieffrom special circumstancesor condition of land, not ofthe applicants making;
3. a determination that failureto grant the deviation wouldresult in exceptional hardshipto the applicant; and
4. a determination that thegranting of a deviation willnot result in increased floodheights, additional threats topublic safety, extraordinarypublic expense, createnuisances, cause fraud onor victimization of the public,or conflict with existing local
laws or ordinances.
b. A deviation may be issued for newconstruction and substantial improvementsand for other development necessary forthe conduct of a functionally dependentuse provided that the structure or other
development is protected by methods thatminimize flood damages during the baseflood and create no additional threats topublic safety.
c. Any applicant to whom a deviation is
EXHIBIT 11SOURCE: City of San Diego Council Policy 600-14
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
27/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
28/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT28
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 12
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEYREGIONAL PARKLand Utilization
_________________________
Legend
Fallow
Grazing Land
Farmland
Urban & Residential
Ballfield Complex
Natural - Open
Natural - Vegetated
Tijuana River Valley
Regional Park BoundaryNOTES:
The project site is fallow - itwas once farmed but is nowuncultivated.
Farmland is south of the projectsite and to the west.
An established subdivisions isdirectly north of the project site.Less structured residences withequestrian facilities are to thesouth and northwest.
PROJECTSITE
SOURCE: EIR , Dept. of Agriculture, modified by RICK Engineering Co.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
29/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
30/50
30
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INTER
NATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO L
LIS
TE
R
STR
EE
T
HOLLISTER
STREET
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT30
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
STREET
INTERNATIONALROAD
TijuanaRiver ValleyRegionalParkBoundary
HOLLISTER
STREET
NOT A PART OF THETIJUANARIVER VALLEY
REGIONAL PARK
NOT A PART OF THETIJUANARIVER VALLEY
REGIONAL PARK
NOT A PART OF THETIJUANARIVER VALLEY
REGIONAL PARK
EXHIBIT 13
LOCAL LAND USE MAP
_________________________
Legend
PROJECT SITE
Fallow
Open Space
Habitat
Field Crops
Single Family Residential
Equestrian
TJ River Park Boundary
HOLLISTER
STREET
INTERNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
ORO AD
DLOWA
OAOAVE
UE
Tijuana iver ValleyRegionalParkBoundary
NTERNATIONALROAD
UNSET AVENUESUNSET AVENUE
INTERNATIONALROAD
PRIVATEEQUESTRIAN
SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCES
COMMUNITY
GARDENS
BALLFIELD COMPLEX
HABITAT
FALLOW
NOTES:
The project site is fallow - itwas once farmed but is nowuncultivated.
Equestrian uses are prevalent tothe south and west.
There is potential habitat to theeast and southeast.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
31/50
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INTER
NATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO
LL
IST
ER
ST
RE
ET
HOLLISTER
STREET
31
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
STREET
INTERNATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
EXHIBIT 14
LAND USEDESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
_________________________
HOLLISTER
STREET
SUNSET AVENUE
Legend
PROJECT SITE
INTERNATIONALROAD
NOTES:
Picnic, rest, and gathering facilitiesshould take advantage of thepanoramic views to the east.the east.
There is ample space for several landintensive large play fields.
Efficiency could be achieved bysiting additional ball fields next to theexisting ball fields.
The habitat lands east of the projectsite are a biological treasury but alsorestrict eastward expansion.
Equestrian uses in the area promptconsideration of equine facilities onthe southwest.
EXISTINGEXISTINGB LLFIELDBALLFIELDCOMPLEXCOMPLEX
POTENTIAL
HABITATEXPERIENCE
POTENTIALB LLFIELDBALLFIELDCOMPLEXCOMPLEX
POTENTI LPOTENTIALB LLFIELDBALLFIELDCOMPLEXCOMPLEX
POTENTIL
RODEXTE
NSION
POTEN
TIALROAD
EXTEN
SION
POTENTI LPOTENTIALEQUESTRI NEQUESTRIANF CILITYFACILITY
POTENTI L L RGE PL Y FIELDSPOTENTIAL LARGE PLAY FIELDSBRR
IERTOEXP
NSION
BARRIER
TOEXPAN
SION
NE RBY NEIGHBORHOODNEARBY NEIGHBORHOOD
Notable Views
Potential Opportunity
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
32/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
33/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
34/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT34
Neighborhood inputhas revealed a con-sistent concern regarding the need foradditional parking during programmedevents at the adjacent sports fields.Project design should consider locatingadditional parking facilities in this area.
ADDITIONAL STUDY:Study the areas closest to HollisterStreet and International Road, wherethe neighborhood access pointsexist, could be developed with localpark uses, such as picnic grovesand playgrounds. Such facilities
should incorporate natural and/orartificial shade. It will be essentialthat the uses chosen be compatiblewith the adjacent residential uses.Final design should consider thelocation of the existing little leagueballfield complex use and plansimilar or complimentary uses in the
general area.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
35/50
35
FIGURE 2. CIRCULATION
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
36/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT36
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 15
COMMUNITY PLANNINGAREAS
_________________________The project site is in the northernpart of the Tijuana River Valley
Community Plan area .
- 18 -
FIGURE 2. CIRCULATION
OTAY NESTOR
SAN YSIDRO
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY
PROJECT S I TE
UNITEDSTATE
SOFAMERICA
REPUBLICOF
MEXICO
Legend
Community Plan Boundary
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
37/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
38/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT38
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 16
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEYCOMMUNITY PLANLAND USE MAP
______________________
PROJECTSITE
- 6 -
FIGURE 1. LOCATION MAPPROJECT S I TE
Legend
Community Plan Boundary
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
39/50
39
Legend
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERINGCOMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 17
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEYCOMMUNITY PLANCIRCULATION MAP
____________________
- 18 -
FIGURE 2. CIRCULATION
2-Lane Collector
Community Plan Boundary
Legend
PROJECT S I TE
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
40/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
41/50
41
Legend
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERINGCOMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 18
OTAY MESA-NESTORCOMMUNITY PLANPARK MAP
_________________________The project site is immediately
south of the Otay Mesa-NestorCommunity Plan area .
PROJECT S I TE
Legend
Community Plan
Boundary
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
42/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT42
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
EXHIBIT 19
SAN YSIDROCOMMUNITY PLANPARK MAP
_______________________
Tijuana River Valley
Regional Park
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY
REGIONAL PARK
Legend
PROJECT S I TE
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
43/50
43
Legend
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERINGCOMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEYTIJUANA RIVER VALLEY
OTAY MESA-NESTOROTAY MESA-NESTOR
MONUMENTRD
SUNSET AV
HOLL
ISTERS
T
WSAN
YSIDROBL
15TH
(SB
)S
T
S A T
U R N
B L
BIOLA
AV
BRANDODR
TOCAYO
AV
PIKAKE ST
ARBODAR
RD
DORAN ST
DALISAY ST
WARDLOW
RODEAR
RD
CHAVEZ
QUADRAAV
VIAC
V A L A N C E
S T
LAW
NDALES
T
INTERNATIONAL
RD
REVENAST LEATHERWOODST
PLANICIE WY
WINTERSWEET
STD
EEPHAVE
NLN
B A N D O L
I E R
L N
GALVEZ
CT
TOCAYO
AV
MPERIAL BEACHPERIAL BEACH
CV-1-1
OF-1-1
AR-1-1
RS-1-7
AR-1-1
AR-1-1
AR-1-1
AR-1-1
RM-1-1 RM-2-5- -
AR-1-1
RM-1-1
TIJUANA
RIVER
AR-1-1
APN 637-010-67
APN637-010
-11
APN637-010
-10
APN637-010
-09
OF-1-1
EXHIBIT 20
ZONING
NORTH
PROJECT SITE ZONING
Legend
City of San Diego Boundary
Community Plan Areas
Parcels
Zoning
ZONE_NAME
PROJECT SITE
Holliste
rStreet
Sunset Avenue
InternationalRoad
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
44/50
44
OROVISTAROAD
WARDLOWAVENUE
TOCAYO
AVEN
UE
INTERN
ATIONALROAD
SUNSET AVENUE
HO L
LIS
TE
R
STR
EE
T
HOLLISTER
STREET
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT44
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
HOLLISTER
STR
EET
INTERNATIONALROAD
Legend
Notable Views
EXHIBIT 21
VISUAL RESOURCESDesign Considerations
HOLLISTER
STREET
SUNSET AVENUE
NOTES:
Structure height, orientation, bulk,mass, color, function and lighting mustaccount for the potential views to visualresources from adjacent residents.. Axial views for southbound trafcAxial views for southbound trafficand pedestrains from the adjaceand pedestrains from the adjacentnt
subdivision into the project site andsubdivision into the project site andbeyond are signicant and should bebeyond are significant and should beframes and enhanced by improvementsframes and enhanced by improvementsto within the adjacent streets rights-of-to within the adjacent streets rights-of-way.way. Project fencing and landscapingshould minimize blocking these views.
Though the project site is relatively
level, it serves as a stage for viewto the west and southwest that areworthy of protection, enhancement andcelebration. The development programfor the site should examine sitinggathering places, such as picnic grovesand shelters, in areas where the viewscan be enjoyed.
NOT BLE VIEWSNOTABLE VIEWS
INTERNATIONALR
OAD
XI L VIEWS FROM DJ CENT STREETSAXIAL VIEWS FROM ADJACENT STREETS
ENHANCE
DNEIG
HBOR
HOOD
STREETSC
APE
ENHANCE
DNEIG
HBOR
HOOD
STREETS
CAPE
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
45/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
46/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT46
EXHIBIT 22
PROJECT SITE / NEIGHBORHOOD INTERFACE
Future project site development could be an opportunity to upgrade the project site/neighborhood interface .
These are views of the boundary between the project site and the neighborhood today.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
47/50
47
10. AGRICULTURE
The use of the project site for recreationalpurposes would preclude most, or all, of theuse of the land for agricultural purposes.
Under CEQA the diminution of use of the landfor agricultural purposes would have to beassessed to determine if such a consequencewould result in a significant impact.
Factors that could help determine thesignificance of the impact would include:
Loss of Revenue: The reduction orelimination of revenue the County isreceiving by those who lease the landfor farming.
Loss of Agricultural Lands: The lossof the use of the land for productivefarming.
Recent Fallow Status: The fact thatthe land has not been farmed in recentyears.
Original Intent: When the County acquiredthe property, long-term agricultural usewas not anticipated; instead, the long-
term plan was to use the property forrecreational purposes. Agricultural usewas an interim use only.
ADDITIONAL STUDY:Determine the significance, if any, of
the use of the property for recreationalpurposes, as opposed to agriculture.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
48/50
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL PARK - RECREATION SITE - CONCEPT PLAN OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS REPORT48
NORTH
R I C KENGINEERING COMPANY
Urban Design & Planning
SUNSET VESUNSET AVE
PROJECT SITE
EXHIBIT 23
BIOLOGICAL RESOURCESVegetation Communities
_________________________The project site has a largelymonochromatic vegetation palette
due to decades of agricultural use.
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
49/50
8/14/2019 Trvrp Oc Part i and II (1)
50/50