13
t9/09/79 BEFORE THE MAHA RASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI 1) Aooe al No. AT0o6000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti & Anr. v/s. M/s. Ruchi Priya Developers Pvt. Ltd. 2) Apoeal No. AT006000000000171 Mr. Izharulhaq Siddiki v/s. M/s. K.D. Builders 3) Appeal No. ATOO5OOO000000O97 Mr. Mahendra Dayaram Bhanushali v/s. M/s. Link Promoters & Poker Enterprises 4) Aooeal No. ATOO 6000000000262 Mustafa Firoz Tinwala v/s. M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS s) Aooeal No. ATOO 60000000002s4 Mustafa Firoz Tinwala v/s. M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS 5) Aooeal N o. ATOO5OOOOOO010387 M/s. APZ Realty v/s. Kiran Prasad 7) Appeal No. AT0O5OOOOOOO1O382 1 Pinnacle Vastunirman v/s. Sunil S. Dharmadhikari

TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

t9/09/79

BEFORE THE MAHA RASHTRA REAL ESTATE

APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI

1) Aooeal No. AT0o6000000000149

Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti & Anr.v/s.

M/s. Ruchi Priya Developers Pvt. Ltd.

2) Apoeal No. AT006000000000171

Mr. Izharulhaq Siddikiv/s.

M/s. K.D. Builders

3) Appeal No. ATOO5OOO000000O97

Mr. Mahendra Dayaram Bhanushaliv/s.

M/s. Link Promoters & Poker Enterprises

4) Aooeal No. ATOO 6000000000262

Mustafa Firoz Tinwalav/s.

M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS

s) Aooeal No. ATOO60000000002s4

Mustafa Firoz Tinwalav/s.

M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS

5) Aooeal No. ATOO5OOOOOO010387M/s. APZ Realty

v/s.Kiran Prasad

7) Appeal No. AT0O5OOOOOOO1O382

1

Pinnacle Vastunirmanv/s.

Sunil S. Dharmadhikari

Page 2: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

\9/09/19

Atif Gesawatv/s.

Mass Enclave

9) Aopeal No. AT0O5O0OOO001O498YughalChelani

v/s.K.D. Lite DeveloPers

10) Aooe I No. ATOO60000000 os30Sony Nijesh

v/s.Mrs. Pradnya Nikhil Sable

11) Apoeal No. ATOO60O0O0O01O546Mr. Hemendra MaPara

v/s.Kutubuddin H. Lokhandwala

AD I No. ATOOsoooooo0 o591M/s. Maruel Realtors & Developers Ltd.

v/s.Mr. Wffhal M. Jadhav & Anr.

13) Ao I No. ATOO60000000 0585M/s. Akshar SPace Art.Ltd.

v/s.Mr. Shrikant Muthineni

r4) Aooea! No. AT0O60OOOOO01O613Bhavan Valji Baruadia

v/s.M/s. Rohan DeveloPers A/t.Ltd.

rs) Aooea! No. ATOO5OOOOOO01O747Mr. Sagar Pravinbhai Patel

v/s.M/s. Twin Star Infrastructure

Aopea I No. AT006000000010 83sM/s. Renaissance Indus Infra Pvt.Ltd.

v/s.Mr. Parth Bharat Suchak

2

16)

s) Appeal No. AT006000000010463

12)

Page 3: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

19109119

17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869Mr. Hemendra Mapara

v/s.Mr. Kochikar Pai

18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956M/s. Spire Associates

v/s.Mr. Ghevarchand Ganeshmal Dhumavat

19) Aopeal No. AT0O5OOOOOOO1O98OMr. Mukesh Kailash Singh

v/s.M/s. Lodha Developers

20) Appeal No. ATOO5OO0O0OO1O804Mr. Kailas Patil

v/s.Mr. Raju Bana

Aooeal No. AT00600ooooo10809Mr. Kailas Patil

v/s.Mr. Hemant Varade

22) Aopeal No. ATO06OO0O0OO1O811Mr. Kailas Patil

v/s.Madhavi Naik

23) Aopeal No. ATOO6OO0OOOO1O31OMr Kailas Patil

v/s.Mr. Rahul P. Kadam

24) Aooeal No. AT006000000010875Mr. Vinit Methi

v/s.Indiabulls Park 4

Apoeal No. AT006000000011106Mrs. KnjalKaria

v/s.Mr. Jayant Mehta

2s)

3

2t)

Page 4: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

t9lo9h9

26) Aopeal No. ATO 000000021146M/s. VidhiRealtors

v/s.Asad Anwar Khatau

27) Appeal No. ATOO6OOOOOOO21152M/s. VidhiRealtors

v/s.Sainath Rakumar Sarode & Ors.

28) Appeal No. AT006000000021174M/s. Raui Developments

v/s.Mr. Arun P. Veer

29) Aopeal No. AT006000000021178S. Karthikeyan & Anr.

v/s.M/s. Whispering Towers

30) Appeal No. ATOO 6000000011027Mr. Yogesh Shivalkar

v/s.M/s. Housing Development & Infrastrudure Ltd.

Appeal No. ATOO 6000000021203M/s. Monarch & Qureshi Builders

v/s.Mr. Arif Lussanwala

32) Appeal No. AT0O50OOOOO021222Mr. Wvekanand K. Gaonkar

v/s.M/s. Neptune Ventures & Developers A/t Ltd.

33) Appeal No. ATOO6000000021223M/s. AnmolAlliance

v/s.Prabha Kannan

34) Aopeal No. ATOO6O00000O212O5M/s. Monarch & Qureshi Builders

v/s.Shikha Sharma

4

31)

Page 5: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

79/09119

Mr. Yogesh ladhavv/s.

Mr. Sanjay Chintala

36) Aooeal No. AT006000000021242Mr. Yogesh ladhav

v/s.Mr. Wrendra Pandare

37) Aooeal No. ATOO6ooooooo21245M/s. Shantee Housing & Anr.

v/s.Mr. Naeem Abdul SattarShaikh

38) AppealNo . AT00s000000021268M/s. MaruelSigma Homes A/t.Ltd.

v/s.Mrs. Kamakshi L. Matai

39) Appeal No. AT006000000021198Mr. Ashish lain

v/s.M,/s. Lucina Land Development Ltd.

40) Apoeal No. AT006000000021367Mr. Sunil Daga & Anr.

v/s.Larsen and Turbo

4t) Appeal No. AT0O6000000021249Mr. Thomas Verghese

v/s.Mr. Ravi Developments

42) Appeal No. ATO06O00OOOO21416Mr. Madhusudanan Menon

v/s.M/s. Ravi Developments

Apoeal No . AT006000000021448M/s. Build Tech Group

v/s.Mr. Anjum Abdul Deraiya

43)

5

3s) Appeal No. AT006000000021241

Page 6: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

\9l0elrs

44) Aopeal No. AT006000000021468M/s. M.K. Shelters

v/s.Mrs. Aisha Abdul Deraiya & Anr.

4s) Appea I No. AT0060000 021486M/s. Dhan International

v/s.Kishore Thakural

46) Aooeal No. ATO05O0OOOO021496Mr. Himanshu B. Rajure

v/s.M/s. Wshwakarma Developers

47) Aooeat No. AT005O0OO0 2L403M/s. Om Developers-Projed Green

v/s.Mr. Abhay Shrirangwar

Mr. Mahesh Nalawadev/s.

Mr. Vaibhav V. Balwantkar

49) Aooeal No. ATO 000000031512Mr. Kailash Patil

v/s.Mr. Naresh Patil & Ors.

Mr. Jeetendra Pathakv/s.

M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

s1) Aooeal No. ATOO50OOOO 31518Mr. SuneelR. Hoshing

v/s.M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

Mr. Manik S. Hoshingv/s.

M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

6

48) Apoeal No. AT00500O000031505

50) Aopeal No. AT0050OOOOO031515

52) Appeal No. ATOO50OOOOOO31519

Page 7: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

19109179

s3) Appeal No. ATO05 00000003 1520

Mr. Shreyas G. Prabhudesaiv/s.

M/s. D. S. Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

54) Apoea! No. ATOO5O00OO0021455

Mr. Ameya Nawathev/s.

M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

5s) Aopeal No. ATOO50OOOO0031522

Mr. Mayur Vasant Somwanshv/s.

M/s. D.S. Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

CORAM INDIRA JAIN J.,CHAIRP ERSONS.S. SANDHU, MEMBER (A)

19TH SEPTE BER, 2019.

Called.

Perused office submissions dated 19.8.2019 and mail

dated 17th July, 2019 forwarded to the respective parties in

the above appeals. From the date of filing online appeal

as shown in the chart below, it is apparent that appellants

have failed to submit hard copies since long despite

individual mail notices and notice on website.

Hence all the 55 (fifty five) online appeals stand dismissed

for failure to submlt hard coPies.

7

*.

(None for the parties)

DATE :

Page 8: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

L9lO9lLs

CHART

Sr. No. Appeal No. AppellanUsV/s.

Respondent

Date of filingOnlineAppeal

1 Ar09F0p0000900'!4eMahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800006008

Mr. Sharnala SureshBaheti & Anr.V/s.M/s. Ituchi PriyaDevelopers Pvt Ltd.

22.03,2018

2. AT0060 00000171MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800008606

Mr. Izharulhaq SiddikiV/s.M/s. K D Builders 05.04.2018

3. AT0060090000q0097MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800005290

Mr. Mahendra DayaranrRhanushaliV/s.M/s. Link Promoters &Poker Enterprises

04.0s,2018

4. AT0q6000000000262MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 90001 0592

Mustafzr F iroz'l'inwalaV/s.M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS

05.05.2018

5. AT0060000000002p4MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 90001 0592

Mustala Iriroz TirrwalaV/s.M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS 22.05.2018

b. AT005q0000001 0387MahaRERA Reg No.

P52'100000942

M/s. APZ Realt-v

V/s.Kiran Prasad 06.06.2018

7, AT00500000001 0382MahaRERA Reg No.

P52100A04125

Pinnacle VastunimranV/s.Sunil S. Dharmaclhikari 08.06.2018

8. AT00500000001 0463MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 80001 0794

Atif GesawatV/s.Mass Ilnclave 09.07.2018

9. AT00600000001 0498MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800004525

Yughal ChelaniV/s.M/s. K D LiteDevelopers

24.07.2018

10. ATooq0o000ool 0530MahaRERA Reg No.

P51700012252

Sony NileshV/s.Mrs. Pradnya NikhilSable

09.08.2018

8

Page 9: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

19/09l19

11. AT00600000001 0546MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800005482

Mr. I Ietnendra MaparaV/s.Kutubudciin H.Lokhandrn'ala

25,08.2018

12. AT00500000001 0591

MahaRERA Reg No.

P52100001627

M/s. Marvel Rcaltors &Developers Ltd.V/s.Mr. Vitthal M Jadhav &Anr.

03,09.2018

13. AT006000000010s85MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700003889

M/s. Akshar Space Pvt.Ltd.V/s.Mr. Shrikant Muthineni

04.09.2018

14. AT00600000001 061 3

MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 900001 899

Bhavan Valji BarvadiaV/s.M/s. Rohan DevelopersPvt Ltd

14.09.2018

15. 10747

MahaRERA Reg No.

P521 00009509

Mr. Sagar PravinbhaiPatelV/s.Ms. Twin Starlnfi'astructure

20.10.2018

16. AT006000000010835MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 70001 3956

M/s. Renaissance Indus

Inl'ra Pvt LtdV/s.Mr. Parth BharatSuchak

11.11.2018

17 AT00600000001 0869MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800005482

Mr. Hemendra MaparaV/s.Mr. Kochikar Pai 24.11.2018

18. AT00500000001 0966MahaRERA Reg No.P52100011908

M/s. Spire AssociatesV/s.Mr. GhevarchandGaneshmal Dhumavat

04,01.2019

19. AT00500000001 0980MahaRERA Reg No.P521 000001 74

Mr. Mr"rkesh KailashSinghVis.M/s. Lodha l)eveloper

15.01.2019

20. AT006000000010804MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Mr. Raju Bana 27.01.2019

21 AT00600000001 0809MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Mr. Hemant Varacle 28.01.2019

9

.Y

Page 10: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

19/091L9

22. AT00600000001081 1

MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Madhavi Naik 28.01.2019

23. AT00600000001 081 0

MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Mr. Rahul P. Kadam 28.01.2019

24. AT00600000010875MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 900000467

M/r. Vinit MethiV/s.Indiabulls Park 4 01.02.2019

25. AT00600000001 1 1 06MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 80001 0479

Mrs. Kinial KariaV/s.Mr. .Iayant Mehta 13.02.2019

26. AT006000000021 146MahaRERA Reg No.

P5'1800007949

M/s. Vidhi RealtorsV/s.Asacl Anwar Khatau 27.02.2019

27 AT006000000021 152MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800007949

M/s. Vidhi realtorsV/s.Sainath RajkurnarSarode & Ors.

27.02.2019

28. AT006000000021 174MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 80001 1407

M/s. I{aviDevelopmentsV/s.Mr. Arun P. Veer

27.02.2019

29. AT006000000021 178MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800007809

S Karthikeyan & Anr.V/s.M/s. WhisperingTowers

28.02.2019

30. AT00600000001 1 027MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800007809

Mr. Yogesh Shivalkar'V/s.M/s. HousingDevelopment &Inl'rastructure Ltd.

28.02.2019

31 AT006000000021 203MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 80001 0967

M/s. Monarch &Qureshi BuildersV/s.Mr. Arif Lussanrvala

09.03,2019

32. AT006000000021 222MahaRERA Reg No.

P990000001 09

Mr. Vivekanand K.GaonkarV/s.M/s. Neptune Ventures& f)evelopers Pvt Ltdv

10

12.03.2019

Page 11: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

t9/09179

33. AT006000000021 223MahaRERA Reg No.P51 800004209

M/s. Anmol AllianceV/s.Prabha Kannan 13.03.2019

34. AT006000000021 206MahaRERA Reg No.P51 80001 0967

M/s. Monarch &Qureshi BuildersV/s.Shikha Sharna

1s.03.2019

35. AT006000000021 241

MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800008680

Mr. Yogesh.ladhavV/s.Mr. Saniay Chintala 18.03.2019

36. AT0060 oo021242MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800008680

Mr. Yogesh.IadhavV/s.Mr. Virendra Pandare 18.03.2019

37 AT006000000021 246MahaRERA Reg No.P99000001 441

M/s. Shantee Hor-rsing

& Anr.V/s.Mr. Naeem AbdulSattar Shaikh

19.03.2019

38. AT005000000021 268MahaRERA Reg No.P52100041711

M/s. Marvel SigmaHornes Pvt LtdV/s.Mrs. Kamakshi L. Matai

26.03.2019

39 AT006000000021 1 98MahaRERA Reg No.P52000002658

Mr. Ashish JainV/s.M/s. Lucina LandDevelopment Ltd

27.03.2019

40. AT006000000021 367MahaRERA Reg No.P51 800003307

Mr. Sunil l)aga & Anr:.V/s.Larsen and Turbo 05.04.2019

41 AT006000000021 249MahaRERA Reg No.P51700A07276

Mr. 'fhomas VergheseV/s.M/s. RaviDevelopments

12.04.2019

42. AT006000000021 41 6

MahaRERA Reg No.

P51700407276

Madhusudanan MenonV/s.M/s. Ravif)evelopnrents

13.04.2019

43. AT006000000021448MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800009965

M/s. Build T'ech GroupV/s.Mr. Anium AbdulDcraiya

25.04.2019

1.1.

Page 12: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

t9l09lt9

44. AT006000000021468MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800009965

M/s. MK SheltersV/s.Mrs. Aisha AbdulDeraiya & Anr.

10.05.2019

45. AT006000000021486MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800001 637

M/s. Dhan lntemationalPvt LtdV/s.Kishore 'l'hakural

20.0s.2019

46. 4T005000000021496MahaRERA Reg No.P52700003997

Mr. Himanshu B.ItajureV/s.M/s. VishwakarmaDevelopers

27.05.2019

47 AT005000000021403MahaRERA Reg No.

P521 00005869

M/s.0M Developers-Project GreenV/s.Mr. Abhay Shrirangwar

28.0s.2019

48. AT005000000031 505MahaRERA Reg No.P521 00002331

Mr. Mahesl, NalawadeV/s.Mr. Vaibhav V.Balwantkar

30.05.2019

49, AT006000000031 51 2MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailash PatilV/s.Mr. Naresh Patil & Ors 31.05.2019

50. AT005000000031 515MahaRERA Reg No.P52 1 000051 58

Mr. Jeetcndra PathakV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

02.06.2019

51 AT005000000031 51 8MahaRERA Reg No.P52 1 00005't 58

Mr. Suneel R. HoshingV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

03.06.2019

52. AT005000000031 51 9

MahaRERA Reg No.P52100005'158

Mr. Manik S. HoshingV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

03.06.2019

Y

12

Page 13: TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI - MahaOnline · 19109119 17) Aopeal No. AT006O0OOOOO1O869 Mr. Hemendra Mapara v/s. Mr. Kochikar Pai 18) Appeal No. AT005000000010956 M/s. Spire Associates v/s. Mr

Leloeh9

53, AT005000000031 520MahaRERA Reg No.P521 000051 58

Mr. Shreyas G.PrabhudesaiV/s.M/s. D S KulkamiDevelopers Ltd.

03.06.2019

54, AT005000000021455MahaRERA Reg No.Ps21 000051 58

Mr. Arneya NawatheVis.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

03.06,2019

55. AT005000000031 522MahaRERA Reg No.

P52100005158

Mr. Mayur VasantSomwanshV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

04.06.2019

trnor#6nrN r)

ed(1-6,8-26,28-57-Online appeals dismi$ed for non submission of hard copi6).

13