Tribological Design Guide Part 5 Wear

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Tribology Design

Citation preview

  • 1

  • 2

  • 3

  • 4

    .

    V2

    V

    V1

    V

  • 5

    Wear

    situation

    Motion/With

    or Without Slip

    Lubed or

    Unlubed

    With or

    Without

    Particles

    Typical Mechanisms1

    Adhesive Single-Cycle

    Deformation

    Repeated -

    Cycle

    Deformation

    Chemical Thermal

    Sliding2 Unidirection Lubed Without

    Unlubed Without 5 6

    Lubed With

    Unlubed With 5 6

    Reciprocating

    (large

    amplitude)

    Lubed Without

    Unlubed Without 5 6

    Lubed With

    Unlubed With 5 6

    Reciprocating

    (small

    amplitude)

    Lubed Without

    Unlubed Without 5

    Lubed With

    Unlubed With 5

    Rolling3 With slip Lubed Without

    Unlubed Without

    Lubed With

    Unlubed With

    Without slip Lubed Without

    Unlubed Without

    Lubed With

    Unlubed With

    Impact4 With slip Lubed Without

    Unlubed Without

    Lubed With

    Unlubed With

    Without slip

    (compound

    impact)

    Lubed Without

    Unlubed Without

    Lubed With

    Unlubed With

    1 Except in hostile environments, where thermal and chemical wear mechanisms can be

    significant and dominate the wear behaviour. 2 Repeated-cycle deformation mechanisms tend to be dominant, but chemical mechanisms

    can be significant; with particles, abrasive wear can be dominant; mild to severe wear

    transitions with load and speed common in unlubricated situations; lubrication generally

    required for metal and metal-ceramic pairs; galling and fretting are forms of sliding wear. 3 Mildest wear situation; repeated-cycle deformation mechanisms tend to be dominant;

    wear increases with slip and particles; with particles and slip abrasive wear can be

    dominant; smooth surface particles preferred. 4 Repeated-cycle deformation mechanisms tend to be dominant; gross plastic deformation

    generally unacceptable, unless in short life applications; stresses should be in the elastic

    range for lives greater than 106 impacts; wear increases with slip. 5 With metals. 6 With polymers.

  • 6

    Asperity Contact Mutual aperity deformationand formation opf adhesive bond

    Brittle fracture

    Ductile fracture

  • 7

    Two-Body Abrasive Wear

    Two-Body Abrasive Wear, with Embedded Particles

    Three-Body Abrasive Wear

  • 8

    High impact velocity; soft

    material

    High impact velocity; very brittle

    material

    Slow crack growth in deformed

    layers

    Impact wear as a form of oxidative

    wear

    High Impact Energy

    Ductile Extrusion from Contact

    High Impact Energy

    Cracks

    BrittleFracture

    PlasticallyDeformedLayers Oxygen

    Removal ofOxide LayersAfter Impact

    Metal

  • 9

    Oxide

    1 2 3

    Regrowth

    (a) (b)

  • 10

  • 11

    "Running-in"

    Wear

    Volu

    me

    Time or Sliding Distance

  • 12

    h

    KPS V

  • 13

    Unlubed

    GoodLube

    GoodLube

    GoodLube

    GoodLube

    PoorLube

    PoorLube

    PoorLube

    PoorLube

    Unlubed

    Unlubed

    Unlubed

    Unlubed

    Unlubed Lubed

    Lubed

    2 -Body

    Rampant Benign - EP Action

    High Abr.Concentr.

    3 - Body Low Abr.Concentr.

    ADHESIVEWEAR

    ABRASIVEWEAR

    CORROSIVEWEAR

    FRETTING

    IdenticalMetals

    CompatibleMetals

    Partly CompatibleMetals

    Incompatible Metals

    Non-metal on Metal or Non-Metal

    Excellent Lube

    Excellent Lube

    ExcellentLube

    WEAR COEFFICIENT

    10-1 10-2 10-3 10-4 10-5 10-6

  • 14

    Wear Mechanism Model Parameters

    h

    KPS V

    n KNvV

    9

    '

    01

    2000

    m

    y

    r N

    '

    r

    h

    PSk V

    tan2

  • 15

    nA

    VQ ~

    AH

    FF N~

    0

    0~

    a

    vrv

    where:

    V = Wear volume

    An = Apparent contact area

    FN = Normal load

    H = Hardness of the softer material

    v = Sliding velocity

    r0 = Radius of the pin

    a0 = Thermal diffusivity of the material

  • 16

    0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.00

    500

    1000

    1500

    2000

    2500

    UIC60 900A vs R7 Wear Map

    Severe

    Mild

    Severe -

    Catastrophic

    Transition

    Catastrophic

    Rail Head/Wheel TreadRail Gauge/Wheel Flange

    Conta

    ct P

    ressure

    (M

    Pa)

    Sliding Velocity (m/s)

  • 17

  • 18

    INC

    REA

    SIN

    G C

    OM

    PLE

    XIT

    Y

  • 19

  • 20

    Unidirectional sliding

    Unidirectional or

    oscillatory sliding

    Unidirectional sliding

    Unidirectional sliding

    Unidirectional sliding

    Unidirectional sliding or

    unidirectional sliding plus

    oscillatory motion

    Unidirectional sliding

    Normal impact and

    normal impact plus

    sliding

    Reciprocating sliding

    Unidirectional sliding

    Oscillatory sliding

    Small amplitude

    oscillatory sliding

    (fretting motion)

    Small amplitude

    oscillatory sliding

    (fretting motion)

    Pure rolling and rolling

    plus sliding

    Unidirectional sliding

  • 21

    Operational

    Parameters

    Structure of Test

    Configuration

    Tribometric

    Characteristics

    Type of motion

    Contact geometry

    Load

    Velocity

    Temperature

    Duration

    Friction force

    Friction coefficient

    Noise, vibrations

    Temperature

    Wear

    Contact conditions

    Surface characteristics

    Surface topography

    Surface composition

    (4)

    (3)

    (1)

    (2)

    (1) Triboelement(2) Triboelement(3) Lubricant(4) Atmosphere

  • 22

  • 23

  • 24