35
Treatment of Offenders Treatment of Offenders

Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

Treatment of Offenders

Treatment of O

ffenders

Page 2: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

1

Contents

Page

KeyPoints 3

1 Purpose 5

1.1 Overview 5

1.2 Structureofreport 5

2 Communitybasedtreatment 7

2.1 Overview 7

2.2 Keyfeaturesofsuccessfulcommunityprogrammes/interventions 7

2.3 Keyphaseofcommunityprogrammes 8

2.3.1 Arrestandtheperiodfollowingarrest 8

2.3.2 Courtappearance 9

2.3.3 Communitysentence 9

3 Prisonbasedsubstancemisuseprogrammes 11

3.1 Featuresofsuccessfulsubstancemisusesprogrammesinprisons: 11

3.2 Assessment 11

3.3 Careplanning 13

3.4 Interventions-psychosocial 13

3.5 Interventions-pharmacological 14

3.5.1 Appropriateprescribing 14

3.5.2 Opioids 15

3.5.3 Alcohol 16

3.5.4 Benzodiazepines 17

3.5.5 Stimulants 17

3.5.6 Supervisedconsumption 18

3.5.7 Preparingforrelease 18

3.6 Preventingsubstance-releaseddeaths 19

3.6.1 Overdose/toxicity 19

3.6.2 Naloxone 19

3.6.3 Blood-borneviruses 19

3.7 Co-occuringsubstancemisuseandmentalhealthproblems 20

3.8 Tobacco 20

3.9 Offenderswithalearningdisability 21

3.10 Naloxone 21

4 Releaseandresettlementprogrammes 23

4.1 Goodpracticeinrelease/resettlementprogrammes 23

TREATMENTOFOFFENDERS

Page 3: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

2

Appendix1 25

Appendix2 28

Bibliography 31

Glossary 34

Page 4: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

3

KeyPoints

Aimedatadultoffenders(aged18andabove)Communitytreatmentsarelikelytobemoreeffectiveformostproblem•substancemisusingoffenders.Imprisonmentcanhaveunintendednegativeconsequencesforproblemsubstancemisusingoffenders,andtherearemanypracticalissuesthatfrustratethedeliveryofsuccessfuldrugtreatmentprogrammesinprisons,particularlyforshorttermprisoners.

Successfulcommunityprogrammesarebaseduponhavingawiderange•ofservicestomeetthedifferingneedsofindividualdrugusingoffenderse.g.servicesthatpromotereintegration(suchashousing,educationandemployment)inordertoimprovelong-termoutcomes.

AneffectiveArrestReferralservice,managedwithintheCriminalJustice•IntegratedTeams(CJIT)iscentraltothemanagementofoffenderswithsubstancemisuseproblemsinCriminalJusticesettings.

TheDrugInterventionsProgramme(DIP)providesapackageofsupport•fordrugmisusingoffendersreachingtheendofaprisonbasedtreatmentprogramme,completingacommunitysentenceorleavingtreatment.

Goodpracticeinprisonsbasedprogrammesfortreatingsubstancemisuse•arebaseduponhavingarangeoftreatmentoptionsandaccesssimilartothoseinthecommunity,includingmaintenanceandsubstitutionoptions.Highqualityharmpreventionprogrammes,toreducedrug-relateddeathsbothfromoverdose/toxicityandblood-bornevirusesneedtobeincluded.

Acomprehensiveassessmentoftheoffender’sneedsandlevelofrisk•shouldbeginassoonaspossibleafterenteringprisonsothatappropriatecareandsupportcanbeprovided.

Effectivelinksbetweenprisonandcommunityservicesarevitalandthe•useofacommonclientrecord,careplanandcollaborativecareplanningwillfacilitatethis.

Protocolsshouldbedevelopedbetweenprisonsandaftercareservices•todealwithearly,unanticipated,andFridayreleases.

Drug-relatedmortalityamongstnewlyreleasedmaleandspecifically•femaleprisonersissignificantlyhigherthantherateamongsttheirpeersinthecommunityandshouldbeamajorconsiderationindischargeplanning.

Aftercareindividualsappearmorewillingtoengagewithserviceswhen•apersistentandnonjudgementalapproachisadopted.Regularcontactwithpotentialclientsininstitutionsislikelytoresultinhigherlevelsofengagement.

Page 5: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

4

Page 6: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

5

1 Purpose

1.1 OverviewThisdocumentprovidesasummaryfromtheevidenceandprofessionalopiniononwhatisbestpracticeinrelationtothetreatmentofoffenderswithsubstancemisuseproblems.

Itistargetedatplanners,commissionersandprovidersofsubstancemisusetreatmentservicesinboththecommunityandprisons.Itisintendedtoassistthemintheplanninganddeliveryofappropriateservicesanddevelopmentofstandardsfortheprovisionoftheseservices.

IthastobesetinthecontextofthenewWelshAssemblyGovernmentsubstancemisusestrategyforWales“Workingtogethertoreduceharm”.

ThedocumentalsohastobereadinconjunctionwithpreviousevidencebasedgoodpracticeguidanceforWelshAssemblyGovernmentparticularlythosefor:

CommunityPrescribing•

Psychosocialinterventions•

CoexistingSubstanceMisuse/MentalHealthProblems•

AlcoholMisuseinWales.•

Themodulealsohastobereadinconjunctionwiththepublications-Drugmisuseanddependence:UKguidelinesonclinicalmanagement(2007),andtheWelshAssemblyGovernmentPrisonMentalHealthPathway(2006).

Thedocumentdoesnotaddresstheparticularproblemsofyoungoffenderswhichwillbethesubjectofseparateguidance.

WhilstitisacceptedthattheprisonestatewithinWalesdoesnotaccommodatewomenprisoners,theguidancecontainedwithinthisdocumentbydefinitionapplies.OperationalprotocolsareinplacewithlinkedcustodialestablishmentsthroughouttheUK,designedtoensurethatanywomenbeingdischargedintoWalesaredealtwithinaccordancewithpresentingneed.

ThemoduleisbasedupontechnicalreportsprovidedbytheNationalPublicHealthServiceforWales(NPHS)VulnerableGroupsTeamwhichareaccessibleontheNPHSwebsite.AsummaryoftheevidenceforcommunitybaseddrugprovisionisincludedinAppendix1thisdocument.

1.2StructureofreportThereportisessentiallyinthreepartssectionanddetailsgoodpracticein:

CommunitySettings(includingearlyinterventions) Prisons Resettlement

Page 7: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

6

Page 8: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

7

2 Communitybasedtreatment

2.1 OverviewCommunitytreatmentsarelikelytobemoreeffectivethanimprisonment•formostproblemsubstancemisusingoffenders.

Imprisonmentcanhaveunintendednegativeconsequencesforproblem•substancemisusingoffenders,andtherearemanypracticalissuesthatfrustratethedeliveryofsuccessfuldrugtreatmentprogrammesinprisons,particularlyforshorttermprisoners.

Maximisingtheuseandeffectivenessofcommunitysentencesislikely•tobemorebeneficialthanimprisonmentofproblemsubstancemisusingoffendersforcomparativelylessseriousacquisitivecrimesanddrugpossessionoffences.

Communitysentenceshavethepotentialtoofferbettervalueformoney•anddeliversimilarreductionsinoffending.

Awideandcomplexrangeofsubstancemisuseinterventionprovision•existsinWales.Theseincludeprocessestoidentifysubstancemisusers,interventionstopromoteengagementwithtreatment;andotherservicesandinterventionsthataddresssubstanceuseand/oroffending.(ThisprovisionissummarisedinAppendix2).

ManyoftheseinterventionsaredeliveredwithintheDrugInterventions•Programme(DIP).TheDIPpurposeisto‘breakthecycle’ofdrugrelatedoffendingandprisonbyencouragingoffenderstoengageandremainengagedwithtreatmentservices. (Figure 3 illustrates how the Programme intervenes in the cycle to move offenders out of crime and into treatment.)

TheDIPwillalsoprovideapackageofsupportfordrugmisusingoffenders•reachingtheendofaprisonbasedtreatmentprogramme,completingacommunitysentenceorleavingtreatment.

2.2 Goodpracticeforcommunityprogrammes/interventionsSuccessfulcommunityprogrammesarebasedupon:

Havingawiderrangeofservicestomeetthedifferingneedsofindividual•drugusingoffenders,forexampleservicesthataddressthespecificneedsofstimulantusers.

Effectiveassessmentofproblemdrug-usingoffenders,inordertomatch•themtoappropriateinterventions,withregularreviewsandreassessment.

Havingservicesthatpromotereintegration(suchashousing,educationand•employment)inordertoimprovelong-termoutcomes.

Afocusontheimpactonoutcomesofdeliveryissues,suchasstaff•skillsandpersonaldevelopment,moraleandmanagement,thatimproveconsistencyofservicequality.

Page 9: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

8

Adequateattentiontosupervisionandmonitoringofpractice,including,•consideringthepotentialforgreateruseofpositiveincentivebasedstrategiestoensurecompliance(contingencymanagement)ratherthanthecurrentpunishmentorientatedfocus.

Interventionsthatadoptholistic,problemsolvingapproachestoaddressing•druguse.

ExtendingtheuseofdrugtestingonArrestinspecificpolicecustody•suites,byexpandingtherangeoftriggeroffencesortestingforawiderrangeofdrugs,isaHomeOfficeinitiative,tobeimplementedasfromthe1April2009.Testingonarrestratherthattestingonchargehasbeenshowntobeeffectiveinincreasingthenumbersengagingintreatment.

Usingschemes,(e.g.DrugInterventionProgramme(DIP)Conditional•Cautioning),thatdivertdrugusingoffendersintheearlystagesoftheiroffendingandproblemdrugusingcareersfromprosecution,onconditionthattheyaddresstheirsubstanceuseandotherproblemsmayhavemerit.

2.3 Keyphasesofcommunityprogrammes2.3.1 Arrestandtheperiodfollowingarrest

AneffectiveArrestReferral(CriminalJusticeInterventionsTeam-(CJIT))Serviceiscentraltothemanagementofoffenderswithsubstancemisuseproblems.ThisservicecanbeprovidedbyArrestReferralWorkers,custodysuitenurses,forensicmedicalexaminersorcustodysuitestaff,applyingtheirspecialistskills.GoodpracticeguidelinesfortheclinicalmanagementofsubstancemisusedetaineesinpolicecustodyhavebeenpublishedbytheFacultyofForensicandLegalMedicineRoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists(2007).TheRoyalPharmaceuticalSocietyofGreatBritainhaspublishedguidanceonthepharmaceuticalcareofdetaineesinpolicecustody(2007).

CJITteamsworkinginthecustodysuitesshould:

Identifythosewithsubstancemisuseproblems.•

Undertakedrugtestingonarrest.•

Assess,advice,supportandprovideinformation.•

Referfortreatment.•

Identifyhazardous,harmfulanddependentdrinkers.•

Provideascreeningassessment.•

Giveadviceonalcoholanditsimpactandproviderelevantinformation.•

Providesimplebriefinterventionsforhazardousandharmfuldrinkers•whichcouldbedeliveredbyarangeofappropriatelytrainednon-specialistpractitioners.

Refermoderatetoheavydrinkersincludingthosewithdependenceformore•intensiveinterventions.

Beawareofthekeyissueofsafetyforoffendersatalltimes.•

Page 10: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

9

Incommunity settingstheprovisionofspecificprogrammesbyCriminalJusticeInterventionTeams(CJIT)caseworkersshouldprovide:

Furtherassessment,careplanningandcasemanagement,foraminimum•periodof13weeks.

Counselling,(whichinsomecircumstancescanincludealcoholmisuse)•groupwork,education,diversionaryactivities,psychosocialinterventions.

Familysupport,includinghousing,financialmanagement,supportwith•familyrelationships.

Prescribing/rapidprescribingservices.•

Asingleassessment/clientrecord.•

AnassurancethatwhereBailrestrictionsareimposed,theyareadhered•toinamannerconsistentwithclearoperationalguidelines.

2.3.2 Courtappearance

ThekeyworkersatthecourtphaseareCJITworkers,providingthe‘ArrestReferral’service.Theirmajorresponsibilitiesaretoprovide:

Assessment,advice,supportandinformation(drugsandalcohol).•

Referralfortreatmenttodrugandalcoholserviceproviders.•

EffectiveLiaisonwithCounsellingAssessmentReferralAdviceand•Throughcare(CARAT)servicesandforthosegivencustodialsentencesviajointCARAT/CJITprotocols.

2.3.3 Communitysentence

WithregardstothecommunitysentencestagetheserviceismanagedbytheProbationservice/NationalOffendersManagementService(NOMS).

TheirmajorresponsibilityisthedeliveryofDrugRehabilitationRequirementsandthecommunitymanagementofPersistentandProlificOffenders(PPO’s).NOMShasclearresponsibilitiesinmanagingthetransitionbetweenCustody,DIPandTier3services.Inthisareaofworkitisimportanttoemphasisethatabstinencebasedapproachestotreatmentmayhavelimitedsuccess,ifthereisanexpectationthatoffenderswillbecompletelydrugfreewithinweeks.TheProbationServicealsooffersalcoholtreatmentprogrammesdeliveredinacommunitysetting.

Page 11: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

10

Page 12: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

11

3 Prisonbasedsubstancemisuseprogrammes

3.1 GoodpracticeforsubstancemisuseprogrammesinprisonsGoodpracticeinprisonsbasedprogrammesfortreatingsubstancemisusearebasedupon:

Highqualitysystemsofclinicalgovernance.•

Assessmentofneedsacrossthefourdomainsofdrugandalcoholmisuse;•health;socialfunctioning;andcriminalinvolvement.

Arangeoftreatmentoptionssimilartothoseinthecommunity,including•maintenanceandsubstitutionoptions,withthesamelevelofaccessasinthecommunity.

Arangeofinterventionsforsubstancemisusetreatment,including•psychosocialandpharmacologicalinterventionsasappropriate.

Highqualitypreventionprogrammestoreducedrug-relateddeathsboth•fromoverdose/toxicityandblood-borneviruses.

Acareortreatmentplanbasedontheneedsoftheindividual,•whichisregularlyreviewed.

Managementofthecareortreatmentplanbyanamedindividual.•

Supporttomaximisecontinuityofcare,especiallyonrelease.•

Assessmentofriskstodependantchildrenforallsubstancemisusingparents•inrelationtohomevisitsandrelease.

3.2 AssessmentTheassessmentprocessbeginsatreceptionintoprisoncustody,withreceptionscreeningforsubstancemisuse,thepurposeofwhichisto:

Enquireaboutdrugandalcoholmisuse,andtoscreenforevidence•ofdependenceinthosewhoreportcurrentorrecentuse.

Determineimmediatehealthcareneeds,includingwithdrawal,•forwhichthereshouldbeaccesstoadequateandeffectiveprescribingformanagementuponreceptionintolocalprisoncustody.

Afteraninitialassessmentincludingariskassessment,cliniciansshoulddevelopplansofcarewithoffenderstoaddressimmediateconcerns.

Assessingriskisanintegralelementinscreening,triageassessmentandcomprehensiveassessment.Itprovidesinformationthatwillinformthecareplanningprocess.Riskassessmentsshouldinclude:

risksassociatedwithsubstancemisuse(suchasphysical/mentalhealth•damage,acutetoxicity/overdose);

riskofself-harmorsuicide;•

riskofharmtoothers(includingchildprotectionandotherdomestic•violence,abusiveand/orexploitativerelationships,andharmtotreatmentstaff);

Page 13: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

12

riskofharmfromothers(includingdomesticabuse);and•

riskofself-neglect.•

Whenrisksareidentified,managementplanswillneedtobedevelopedandimplementedtohelpmitigateimmediateconcerns.

Ifclinicianshaveconcernsabouttheneedsandsafetyofchildrenofsubstancemisusersorofvulnerableadults,localprotocolsmustbefollowed.

Acomprehensiveassessmentoftheoffender’sneedsandlevelofriskshouldbeginduringthefirstnightandinductionperiodsothatappropriatecareandsupportcanbeprovided.

Rapidwithdrawalfromdrugscanupsetanindividual’smentalequilibrium,heighteningtheirriskofimpulsiveself-destructivebehaviour.Anoffendercomingintocustodywithcomplexneedsshould,therefore,beprovidedwithclinicaltreatmenttostabilisetheirwithdrawalfromopioidorbenzodiazepinedependence.Considerationshouldbegivenatthisearlystagetotheindicationformaintenanceopioidsubstitutiontreatment.

Acomprehensiveassessmentshouldincludethefollowing:

treatinganyemergencyoracuteproblem;•

confirmingthattheoffenderismisusingsubstances(history,examination•anddrugtesting);

assessingdegreeofdependence;•

identifyingphysicalandmentalhealthproblems;•

identifyingsocialproblems,includinghousing,employmentand•domesticviolence;

assessingriskbehaviour;•

determiningtheoffender’sexpectationsoftreatmentanddesire•tochange;and

determiningtheneedforsubstitutemedication.•

Theassessmentprocessalsoprovidesanexcellentopportunityforclinicianstoprovidebriefinterventionstoreduceimmediateharmfromsubstancemisuse.Itisalsoimportanttoassessthemostappropriatelevelofexpertiserequiredtomanagetheindividual’streatment(thismayalterovertime),andreferorliaiseappropriately.

Theassessmentprocessshouldresultinawrittendocumentthatcanbereferredtoandusedasabasisfordiscussingcareplanning,goalsandobjectiveswiththeoffender.

Agreementoncommon‘standards’ofscreening,assessmentandrecording,isimportantindevelopinganintegratedsystemofcareintheprisonsetting.

Basicawarenesstrainingofassessmentstocustodialsuitestaffandescortstaffcanonlyaddvaluetothecareandattentionofprisoners.

Page 14: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

13

3.3 CareplanningAssessmentprovidesinformationthatwillcontributetothedevelopmentofacareplan,whichmeetsagreedstandardsandshouldbeagreedwiththeoffender.Itshouldnormallycovertheirneeds(andhowthesewillbemet)inoneormoreofthefollowingdomains;substancemisuse,physicalandpsychologicalhealth,andoffending.IdeallythecareplanshouldbeintegratedwiththeCareProgrammeApproach(CPA),theDrugInterventionRecord(DIR),andTheWalesIn-DepthIntegratedSubstanceMisuseAssessmentToolkit(WIISMAT)specialistsubstancemisuseassessmentprocessforpeopleusingspecialist,substancemisusetreatmentservices.

Thecareplanshouldincludethefollowing:

Settingthegoalsfortreatmentandmilestonesforachievement.•

Indicatinginterventionsplannedandbywhom.•

Makingexplicitreferencetoriskmanagement.•

Identifyinginformationgiventootherprofessionals/agencies.•

Indicatingthenameofthekeyworker.•

Identifyareviewdate.•

Aswithsubstancemisusemanagementinothersettings,thereisaneedtointegrateprescribingpracticewithpsychological,medicalandsocialinterventions.Thiswillrequireclinicianstohaveinputfrom,orfacilitatereferralto,arangeofotherprofessionals.Integrationwithmentalhealthandprimaryhealthcareservicesisalsoveryimportanttoaddressthehighlevelsofcomplexneedswithintheprisonpopulation.

3.4 Interventions-psychosocialTreatmentforsubstancemisuseneedstoincludeapsychologicalcomponent.Psychosocialinterventionsarethemainstayoftreatmentforthemisuseofcocaineandotherstimulants,andforcannabisandhallucinogens.

Psychosocialinterventionscanbedeliveredalongsidepharmacologicalinterventionsoralone,dependingonassessedneedandthegoalsoftreatment.Discreteformalpsychosocialinterventionsmaybeprovidedeitherforsubstancemisuseproblems,suchascocainemisuse,ortoaddresscommon,associatedorco-occurringmentalhealthdisorderssuchasdepressionoranxiety.

Keyworkingisabasicdeliverymechanismforarangeofkeycomponents,includingthereviewofcareortreatmentplansandgoals,provisionofdrug-relatedadviceandinformation,harmreductioninterventions,andinterventionstoincreasemotivationandpreventrelapse.Helptoaddresssocialproblems,suchashousingandemployment,isalsoimportantaspartofthroughcareandaftercare.Discreteformalpsychosocialinterventionsmaybeprovidedinadditiontokeyworking.Theseshouldbetargetedtoaddressingneed.

Page 15: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

14

StandardsforpsychologicalinterventionsforsubstancemisusehavebeenissuedbytheWelshAssemblyGovernment.Astructuredcarepackageofpsychosocialsupportshouldbeprovidedforoffenderswithsubstancemisuseproblemsinorderto:

complementclinicalinterventions;•

takeintoaccountprevioustreatmentinthecommunityorcustody;and•

provideaplatformforlonger-termsubstancemisusetreatmentinprison•andonrelease.

Interventionsthatneedtobeavailableinthecontextofsubstancemisuseincludebriefmotivationalinterventionsandmutualaid(self-help)approaches.Arangeofmoreintensive,structuredpsychosocialinterventionsmayberequiredforoffenderswithhighlevelsofdependenceonsubstance(s),forthosewithrecurrentproblems,forthosewithcomplexneedsandforthosewhomaybemorevulnerable.Psychologicalinterventionsshouldalwaysbeconsideredforoffenderswhoaredependentonbenzodiazepine.Evaluationoftheapproach,togetherwiththetrainingandsupportneededtosupportit,willbeneededbeforeitcanbeimplemented

Offenderswithsignificantdrugmisuseproblemsmaybeconsideredforatherapeuticcommunitydevelopedforthespecificpurposeoftreatingdrugmisusewithintheprisonenvironment.Forthosewhohavemadeaninformeddecisiontoremainabstinentafterreleasefromprison,residentialtreatmentshouldbeconsideredaspartofanoverallcareplan.

ItisworthdenotingthatoffenderswithanIQlessthan80cannotbeconsideredforaCBTprogrammeandsupportservicesneedtobecognisantoftheneedforCBTorotherpsychosocialinterventions.Thisplacesademandoncommissionerstoensurethesearecateredfor.

3.5 Interventions-pharmacological3.5.1 Appropriateprescribing

Inviewofthepotentiallyrapidonsetofwithdrawaleffectsinprisonandaheightenedriskofself-harmandsuicideamongsubstancemisusersduringtheearlydaysofcustody,aclinicalresponsetophysicaldependenceisessential.Prescribingprotocolsmayprovideasolutiontotheclinicalchallengespresentedbytheprisonenvironment.

Aswithpracticeincommunityservices,non-medicalprescribingshouldbeencouragedanddeveloped.

Adecisiontoprescribe,whatandhowmuchtoprescribewilldependon:

theoveralltreatmentplanfortheindividual;•

clinicalguidelines;•

theclinician’sexperienceandcompetencies;•

discussionwithothermembersofamultidisciplinaryteam;and•

advice,wherenecessary,fromaspecialistinsubstancemisuse.•

Page 16: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

15

Inthecontextofprescribing,theBritish National Formulary(BNF),whichisupdatedtwiceayear,isakeyreference.ThedosagesstatedintheDrugMisuseandDependence:UKGuidelinesonClinicalManagementandintheBNFareintendedforgeneralguidanceandrepresent,unlessotherwisestated,therangeofdosesthataregenerallyregardedasbeingsuitableforprescribing,inthecontextoftreatingadultswhohavebecomedependant.

Offendersmustbemadefullyawareoftherisksoftheirmedication.Prescribingarrangementsshouldalsoaimtoreducerisks,includingaccidentalingestion,tochildrenandothersinthecontextofhomevisitsorrelease.

Cliniciansshouldaimtooptimisetreatmentinterventionsforoffenderswhoarenotbenefitingfromtreatment,usuallybyprovidingadditionalandmoreintensiveinterventions(pharmacologicalandpsychosocial)thatmayincreaseretentionandimproveoutcomes.Treatmentexitsshouldbenegotiableandrevisited.Intheeventofrelapseinprison,theclinicianshouldexplorethereasonsforthiswiththeserviceuser,anddiscusstreatmentoptions.

3.5.2 Opioids

Opioid substitution treatment

Whereopioidmisusersarereceivedintoprisonhavinghadtheircommunitydosecontinuedinpolicecustody,thistreatmentshouldbecontinuedinprison,subjecttoregularreview.Timespentinpoliceandcourtcustodyoftenresultsinabreakinoffendersreceivingsubstitutemedicationbetweenthedayoftheirarrestandtheirsubsequentreceptionintoprison.

Cliniciansshouldseektoverifyprescriptionsandconsumptionwithcommunityservices,thepoliceorboth,anduseappropriatedrugteststoverifythepresenceofopioidsinthebody.Asoffendersfrequentlyarriveinprisonintheevening,itmaynotbepossibletosecurethisinformationduringaninitialassessment.Prescribingwillthereforeneedtobecircumspectenoughtoaddresstherisksrelatedtothisabsenceofinformation.

Methadoneorbuprenorphine,usedattheoptimaldoserange,areeffectivemedicinesformaintenancetreatment.Buprenorphineandnaloxonecombination(Suboxone®)hasbeenapprovedforrestrictedusewithinNHSWalesforthetreatmentforopioiddependence,interimtoguidancefromtheNationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence(NICE)shoulditsubsequentlybepublished.

Inthecontextoflowavailabilityofillicitdrugs,offendersmaystabiliseonlowerdosesofopioidsubstitutiontreatmentsinprison,thantheywouldinthecommunity.However,cliniciansshouldbepreparedtouseequivalentdosestothoseusedinthecommunitywhereneeded,toalevelthatachievesappropriateclinicalstability.

Priortorelease,considerationshouldbegiventoreviewingthecurrentdoseofopioidsubstitutewiththeserviceuser,tooptimisetheirlikelyretentionintreatmentonreturntothecommunity.Thismayentailincreasingthedosepriortorelease,inconsultationwiththecommunityprescriber,andexplainingtotheserviceuserwhythisisappropriate.

Page 17: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

16

Wheredoseinductionisclinicallyappropriate,theindividualshouldbestartedonasuitabledoseofopioidsubstituteandthedoseoptimisedthroughtitration.Thisshouldaimtoachieveaneffectivedosewhilealsoexercisingcautionabouttheinherentrisksoftoorapidanincrease.

Detoxification from opioids

Peopleinprisonshouldhavethesametreatmentoptionsforopioiddetoxificationaspeopleinthecommunity.Cliniciansshouldtakeintoaccountadditionalconsiderationsspecifictotheprisonsetting,including:

practicaldifficultiesinassessingdependenceandtheassociatedrisk•ofopioidtoxicityearlyintreatment;

lengthofsentenceorremandperiod,andthepossibilityofunplanned•release;and

risksofself-harm,deathorpost-releaseoverdose/toxicity.•

Polydruguseiscommonamongoffendersenteringcustody.Incasesofco-dependencyonanycombinationofalcohol,opioidsandbenzodiazepines,morethanonereductionregimenmayberequired,withadditionalcautionnecessaryduetotheinteractionofthesesubstances.Detoxificationfrommorethanonesubstanceshouldnottakeplaceconcurrently.Whenthisisrequired,alcoholdetoxificationshouldusuallybetheinitialpriority.

Methadone,buprenorphineandlofexidinearealleffectiveindetoxificationregimens.Opioiddetoxification,usingthemedicationtheindividualhasbeenmaintainedon,shouldbeofferedinanappropriatesettingtothosereadyforandcommittedtoabstinence.

Whenanopioidsubstituteisprescribed,aperiodofstabilisationoverthefirstfivedaysisadvisableratherthananimmediatereductionofthedose,becauseoftheriskofself-harmandsuicideinthisperiod.Theremayalsobeanincreasedriskofsuicideclosetotheendof,orjustfollowing,completionofadetoxificationregimen.

Detoxificationshouldbeprovidedinassociationwithpsychosocialsupport,aspartofapackagewhichincludespreparationandpost-detoxificationsupporttopreventrelapse.

3.5.3 Alcohol

Offenderswithanalcoholproblemwillneedsupportparticularlywhentheriskofwithdrawalsymptomsishigh.Pharmacologicalinterventionsaremosteffectivewhenusedasenhancementstopsychosocialtherapiesaspartofanintegratedprogrammeofcare.Thisusuallyinvolvesdetoxificationfollowedbyarangeofpsychosocialandpharmacologicalinterventionsasappropriatetopreventrelapse.Thestandardtreatmentsforalcoholdependenceandmisuseapplytothosewhoalsomisuseotherdrugs.

Page 18: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

17

Threeclassesofpharmacologicaltreatmentshavebeenidentifiedthatareeffectiveinthetreatmentofalcoholmisusers:

medicinesfortreatingwithdrawalsymptomsduringassistedalcohol•withdrawal,

medicinestopromoteabstinenceorpreventrelapse,includinganti-craving•agentsandsensitisingagents,and

nutritionalsupplements,includingvitaminsupplements,asaharmreduction•measureforheavydrinkersandhighdoseparenteralthiamineforthepreventionandtreatmentofindividualswithWernicke’sencephalopathy.

3.5.4 Benzodiazepines

Suddencessationinbenzodiazepineuseinthosewhoaredependentcanleadtoarecognisedwithdrawalstate.However,thereislittleevidencetosuggestthatlong-termsubstituteprescribingofbenzodiazepinesreducestheharmassociatedwithbenzodiazepinemisuse.

Prescribingtoassistwithdrawalshouldonlybeinitiatedwherethereisclearevidenceofbenzodiazepinedependencyfromtheserviceuser’shistory,observedsymptomsanddrugtesting.

Iftheserviceuserisalsoreceivingalong-termprescriptionofmethadoneforconcomitantopioiddependency,themethadonedoseshouldbekeptstablethroughoutthebenzodiazepinereductionperiod.Concurrentdetoxificationfrombothmedicinesisnotrecommendedincommunitysettings.

3.5.5 Stimulants

Clinicianswillseestimulantuserswithawiderangeofseverityofproblems.Themainstayoftreatmentispsychosocialandnon-pharmacological.Therearenoeffectivepharmacologicaltreatmentstoalleviatetheeffectsofwithdrawalfromstimulantsatpresent,includingcocaine.Likewise,nonehaveconvincinglybeendemonstratedtobeusefulinpromotingabstinence.Stimulantwithdrawalshouldbetreatedaccordingtoclinicalindications.

Emergingsymptoms,suchasdepressedmoodandinsomnia,arelikelytobeshort-livedandanyprescribingforthisshouldgenerallybeshort-termandreviewedbeforerenewal.Offendersarrivinginprisonwitharecenthistoryofstimulantuseshouldbeobservedduringthefirstthreedaysofcustodyforanysignofemergingacutephysicalorpsychologicalproblems.Offendersdemonstratingsymptomsofpsychologicaldistressshouldcontinuetobemonitoredandreferredformentalhealthassessmentiftheyareshowingsignsofpsychosisorotherseriousmentalhealthproblems.

Page 19: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

18

3.5.6 Supervisedconsumption

Supervisedconsumptionshouldbeavailableforalloffendersforalengthoftimeappropriatetotheirneedsandrisks.Thisisusuallycontinuedthroughouttheperiodofremandorprisonsentenceforopioidsubstitutiontreatment.

Additionally,benzodiazepinesmaybeprescribedforsupervisedconsumptiontoenhancecontrolofdiversion.

3.5.7 Preparingforrelease

Researchondrug-relatedmortalityamongstnewlyreleasedmaleandfemaleprisonershighlightsthattheyare29and69timesmorelikely,respectively,todieduringthefirstweekofreleasefromprison,comparedtomalesandfemalesinthegeneralpopulation.Around90%ofthesedeathsweredrug-relatedwithopioidsinvolvedinalmost97%ofthem.

Theprincipalobjectiveinpreparingasubstance-misusingoffenderforreleaseshouldbetopreventoverdose/toxicity.Preventingrelapseandfacilitatingcontinuationintreatment(ifneeded)oraccesstosuitableaftercareprovisionorsupportareimportantinthemselvesandasameansofpreventingoverdose/toxicity.Thefollowinginterventionscanallhelpachievetheseobjectives.

Detoxified,formerlyopioid-dependantindividualswhoaremotivatedtoremaininasupportivecareabstinenceprogrammemaystarttreatmentwithnaltrexonepriortoreleasefromprison.However,naltrexoneshouldbeadministeredundersupervisionanditseffectivenessinpreventingopioidmisusereviewedregularly.

Priortoreleasesomeoffendersrequestre-inductionontoopioidsubstitutiontreatment.Re-inductionshouldbeconsideredforoffenderswhoareabouttoleaveprisonandforwhomthereisaclearlyidentifiableriskofoverdose/toxicity.Thosewiththemostsignificantriskofdeathhaveahistoryofinjectingopioidmisuseimmediatelypriortocustody,longstandingopioiddependenceandpolydrugdependence.Theymayalsohaveahistoryofnon-fataloverdose/toxicity.Re-inductionmaybeofferedaftertheindividualhasbeenofferedanddeclinedrelapsepreventioninterventions,andoncetheimplicationsofrestartingopioidmisusehavebeenexplained.

Prescribingtopromoteabstinenceorpreventrelapseinalcoholdependence,includinganti-cravingagentsandsensitisingagents,maybestartedpriortoreleasewhereappropriate.

Preparationsforsubstancemisusetreatmentpost-release,ifrequired,shouldbeplannedwhereverpossible.Wherereleaseisunanticipated(whenanoffenderisreleasedfollowinganorderfromthecourt,forinstance,orwhereanindividualleavesprisonoutsideofstandardworkinghours),cliniciansshouldoperateacontingencyarrangement,whichmayinvolvemakingadirectreferraltoacommunity-basedsubstancemisusetreatmentservice.

Inadditiontoasubstancemisusetreatmentservicereferral,cliniciansshouldattempttosecureGPsforoffendersbeforetheyleaveprison,adviseboththesubstancemisusetreatmentproviderandGPofdischargemedicinesand,ifappropriate,theneedtoquicklytakeoverprescribing.

Page 20: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

19

3.6 Preventingsubstance-relateddeaths3.6.1 Overdose/toxicityprevention

Allprisonsshouldhaveanemergencyprotocolinplacethatcoversthemanagementofsubstance-relatedoverdose/toxicity.

Substance-relateddeathsarehighinthefirstweeksfollowingreleasefromprison.Reduced/lossoftoleranceisconsideredtobeasignificantriskfactor.

Fataloverdose/toxicityofteninvolvestheuseofopioidsaloneorincombinationwithotherrespiratorydepressantssuchasalcoholand/orbenzodiazepines.Likewise,alcoholaloneorincombinationalsohasasignificantroleinsubstance-relatedoverdose/toxicity.

Retainingserviceusersinhighqualitytreatmentprotectsagainstoverdose/toxicity.Thisprotectionmaybeenhancedbyotherinterventionsincludingtrainingsubstancemisusersintherisksofoverdose/toxicity,itspreventionandhowtorespondinanemergency.

3.6.2 Naloxone

Naloxoneisanopioidantagonistwhichtemporarilyreversestheeffectsofopioidssuchasheroinandmethadone.Itsuseaspartofapackageofoverdose/toxicitypreventionmeasuresisestablishedpracticeinsomepartsoftheUK.AnumberofdemonstrationsitesarebeingestablishedincommunityandprisonsettingsinWalestoprovidetrainingonoverdose/toxicitymanagementandnaloxoneprovisiontoopioidusersandtheirfamily/carersifappropriate.

Theprisonsiteswillissuenaloxonetooffenderswhoareassessedasbeingatriskofoverdoseonreleasefromprison.Whereoffendersarereleasedfromprisonwithoutanassessmentoriftheyneedtohavetheirinitialsupplyreplaced,theycanvisitademonstrationsiteinthecommunity.Wewilllearnthelessonsfromthedemonstrationsitesandconsiderationwillbegiventorollingouttheprovisionasappropriate.

3.6.3 Blood-borneviruses

Thegeneralprinciplesinrelationtoblood-bornevirusesandotherinfectionsapplyequallytoprisons.Manyoffendersinprisonareatparticularriskofblood-borneviralinfectionsnotonlyduetoinjectingdrugusepriortoprison,butalsoduetotherisksofongoingtransmissionwhilstinprison,suchassharinginjectingequipmentandparaphernalia,unprotectedsexandtattooing.

Prisonsneedtohavehighqualityprogrammesofharmreductionpreventioninterventionsinplace.Reducingpotentialharmduetooverdose,blood-bornevirusesandotherinfectionsshouldbeapartofcareforalloffendersinprison.

Atpresent,policyforprisonsinEnglandandWalesisnottointroduceneedleexchangewheresecurityremainsofparamountimportance.Althoughprovisionofdisinfectanttabletshasbeenintroduced,thereissomeconditionalinternationalevidencetosuggestthatitmaynotbeparticularlyeffective.Thereisgoodinternationalevidencethatisitpossibletoprovidearangeofharmreductionmeasures,includingneedleexchange,withinacustodialsetting.Theemergingevidencebaseneedstobetakenintoaccountindeterminingbestpractice.

Page 21: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

20

Prisonpresentsanopportunityandachallengetoaddressawiderangeofclinicalneedsofsubstancemisusers,especiallyharmreductioninterventionssuchashepatitisBvaccinationandhepatitisCtreatment.

AsstatedintheImmunisationagainstInfectiousDiseaseguidelinesTheGreenBook,allhighriskdrugmisusersshouldbeofferedvaccinationagainsthepatitisB,andagainsthepatitisA,whereindicated.HepatitisBvaccinationsshouldbecompleted(onasuper-acceleratedschedule).Thisshouldincludeinformationonhowindividualscancompletevaccinationandreceiveaboosterinthecommunity,ifreleasedbeforecompletion.

Alldrugmisusersshouldbeofferedtesting,andifrequired,treatmentforhepatitisC,andhumanimmunodeficiencyvirusinfections.

3.7 Co-occurringsubstancemisuseandmentalhealthproblemsItiscommonforthosewithsubstancemisuseproblemstoalsohaveothermentalhealthdifficulties.Interventionsforthementalhealthproblemsmayalsoneedtobeprovidedintheprisonsetting.Anintegratedapproachisrecognisedasbeingthebestwayofmanagingpeoplewithcomplexneeds.ThisinvolvesconsultationbetweentheCARAT,clinicalsubstancemisuse,primaryhealthcareandmentalhealthteams.

Thosewithseverementalhealthproblemsshouldhavehighqualitycareintegratedwithmentalhealthservices.Detailsofanyplannedcareprovidedbythepatient’scommunitymentalhealthteamandsubstancemisuseservicespriortocustodyshouldbeestablished.Theoffender’sinformedwishesandtheadviceofcommunityprovidersshouldbetakenintoaccountwhenclinicalsubstancemisusecareisplannedintheprisonsetting.Ifdetoxificationisthepreferredaction,thenagradualreductionprogrammeshouldbeprovided.

Whilstinprison,wherethereislessreadyaccesstoillicitdrugs,anoffender’smentalstatemayappeartoberelativelystable.Thereleasecareplanneedstotakeintoaccounttheprevioushistoryofsubstancemisuse,astheoffendermayreturntosubstancemisuseuponrelease.Similarly,aprevioushistoryofsubstancemisusemustalsobeconsideredwhenanoffenderistransferredtoanotherprison.

3.8 TobaccoSmoking-relateddiseasesarehighlyprevalentinsubstancemisusers.Dependenttobaccosmokersarelikelytogainsignificanthealthbenefitsfromquitting.Evidencesuggeststhathelpwithsmokingcessationmaybeassociatedwithimproveddrugtreatmentoutcomes.ChangesinsocietalattitudesandthesmokingbanthatwasintroducedinWalesinApril2007mayincreasethedemandfortreatmentfortobaccodependencegenerally.Offenderswithsubstancemisuseproblemswhosmoketobaccoshouldbeofferedsmokingcessationinterventions.

Page 22: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

21

3.9 OffenderswithalearningdisabilityOffenderswithbothalearningdisabilityandasubstancemisuseproblemhaveparticularrequirements.Theseareessentiallyaroundissuesassociatedwithcommunication.Itisimportantthatprisonstaffareawareoftheirparticularneedsandthatprogrammesandinterventionsaredeliveredaroundacceptedgoodpractice.Contactwithspecialistlearningdisabilityservicesandprofessionalsareanimportantpartofthisapproach.

Page 23: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

22

Page 24: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

23

4. Releaseandresettlementprogrammes4.1 Goodpracticeinrelease/resettlementprogrammes

Withregardstogoodpracticeinsubstancemisusetreatmentfollowingrelease,evidenceindicatesthat:

Onentryintocustodyorrehabilitationcentreanindividualshouldbe•assessedassoonaspossibleforthroughcareandaftercareneeds,althoughthesemaychangeastheprisoner/residentprogressesthroughtreatment.

Inprison,priorityforassessmentsshouldbegiventoremandandshort-•sentenceprisoners.

Effectivelinksbetweenprisonandcommunityservicesarevitalandthe•useofacommonclientrecord,careplanandcollaborativecareplanningwillfacilitatethis.

Protocolsshouldbedevelopedbetweenprisonsandaftercareservices•todealwithearly,unanticipated,andFridayreleases.

Aftercareclientsappearmorewillingtoengagewithserviceswhen•apersistentandnonjudgementalapproachisadoptedbystaff.Regularcontactwithpotentialclientsininstitutionsislikelytoresultinhigherlevelsofengagement.

Routinemeetingofclientsattheprisongatewillhelpensurethattheyare,•andremain,incontactwithservices.

Agenciesshouldbeflexible,bothintermsoftheirconditionsforaccepting•clients,andtheamountoftimeforwhichsupportisoffered

Whereverpossible,communitybasedtreatmentservicesshouldcarryout•apostreleasecareplanforthoseheldincustody,ideallypriortorelease.Thisprocessshouldincludethesecuringofcontinuedprescribingatanappropriateclinicallevel.

WorkingrelationshipsbetweenTransitionalSupportServices(TSS)•andprisonstaffneedtobegoodtofacilitatereferrals.

Peermentorsanda24-hourpointofcontactarehighlyvaluedbyclients,•evenifthelatterisrarelyused.

Aftercarestaffrequireclearguidance/trainingregardingthesignsorfeatures•ofhigh-risksituationsandcharacteristicsthatpredisposetheirclientstorelapse,tooverdose(deliberatelyorsemi-deliberately),andtoreturntocrime.

ItisworthacknowledgingthattheProbationServicealsooffersalcohol•treatmentprogrammesdeliveredinacommunitysetting.

Page 25: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

24

Page 26: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

25

Appendix1

Maintypesofcommunity-baseddrugprovisioninEnglandandWales

TypeofProvision Evidence/Evaluation

Testingonarresttoidentifyheroin,crackandcocaineusersfollowingarrestforacquisitivecrimes.

Thereisnoevidenceontheeffectivenessoftestingeitherasastandaloneformofroutinemonitoringorinprovidedaddedvaluewhenusedincombinationwithtreatmentinterventions.

‘ToughChoices’whichintroducedtestingonarrestandmandatoryassessmenthasincreasedthenumbersbeingtestedandengagingintreatment(TypeIVevidence).

Thereissomeevidencethatsuggeststheeffectivenessofdrugtestingonarrestforidentifyingproblemdrugusingoffendersnotincontactwithservicesmaybeerodedovertime.(TypeVevidence).

Mandatoryassessmentsfollowingapositivetestwhichmayleadtoareferraltodrugtreatmentservices.Itisanoffencetorefusetheassessmentbutnotthetreatment.

Introductionofmandatoryassessmentsfollowingapositivedrugtestonarresthasimprovedtheratesofparticipationinassessment.(TypeIVevidence).

Arrestreferralinvolvesspecialistworkersseeingdetaineesinpolicecustodysuites,andincreasinglyincourttoprovideinformationand,whereappropriate,referraltotreatmentorothermeansofassistance.

Arrestreferral(inareaswherethereisnotesting)hasbeenshowedtobesuccessfulinidentifyingandengagingdrugusersintreatment.(TypeIVevidence)Currentlytherearenopublishedevaluationsthatcomparetheeffectivenessandvalueformoneyofapproachesforidentifyingproblemdrugusingoffendersincustodysuites.

CriminalJusticeIntegratedTeams(CJITs)arethecoreoftheDIP.Theycasemanageoffendersover18andcoordinateservicesandagencies.

Anationalevaluation(undertakenbeforetheintroductionofmandatorydrugtesting)reportedsignificantreductionsindruguseandoffendingamongstthosetakenontoCJITcaseloads(TypeIVevidence).

RestrictionsonBail(RoB)followingapositivetestallowsfordrugtreatmenttobeaconditionofcourtbail.

EvaluationofpilotsinthreeEnglishsitesconcludedthattheimpactonillicitdruguseandoffendingwasunclearbutthereweresomepositivefindingsintermsofcomplianceandtreatmentengagement(TypeIVevidence).

Page 27: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

26

TypeofProvision Evidence/Evaluation

Prolificandotherpriorityoffenderprogrammeaimstotargetresourcesatoffendersinthecommunitywithsixormoreconvictionsintheprevious12months.

Evaluationoftheschemeshoweda43%reductioninoffendingcomparingthetotalnumberofconvictionsinthe17monthsbeforeandthe17monthsaftertheprogrammeimplementation(TypeIVevidence).

Conditionalcautioningallowsforaconditionconducivetorehabilitation,whichcanincludedrugtreatment,tobeaconditionofapolicecaution,withprosecutionfortheoriginaloffencepossibleiftheoffenderdoesnotcomply.

Anassessmentoftheearlystagesofimplementationshowedthattheuseofconditionalcautionsvariedwidelybetweenareas.Ofthosegivenaconditionalcautionaboutafifthhadsomesortofdrugreferralcondition.Aboutaquarterofthosegivenaconditionalcautionsfailedtocomplywithsomeaspectsofthisandwereprosecuted.

DrugTreatmentandTestingOrders(DTTOs)andnowDrugRehabilitationRequirements(DRRs)arecommunitysentenceswhichresultinsanctionsiftherequirementsarenotmet.

TodatenoevaluationofDRRhasbeenpublishedbutareportontheimpactofDTTOsonoffendingwaspublishedbytheHomeOfficein2003.Thisreportwasbasedon210offendersfollowedupfor2yearsafterthestartoftheorder.

• Datawereonlyavailableon174offenders,ofthese80%hadbeenreconvictedwithin2years.

• CompletionratesforDTTOswerelow.Outcomeinformationwasavailablefor161offenders,30%finishedtheirorderssuccessfully,67%hadtheirordersrevoked.

• Therewasastatisticallysignificantdifferenceinoffendingbetweenthosewhocompletedtheirorders(53%)andthosewhoseorderswererevoked(91%).

• 44%ofoffendersinEnglandandWaleswhostartedDRR/DTTOin2006/2007completedcomparedwith28%ofthosewhostartedin2003(TypeIVevidence).

TheOffenderSubstanceAbuseProgramme(OASP)andAddressingSubstanceRelatedOffending(ASRO)areaccreditedbehaviour-changeprogrammes,sometimesattachedtocommunityorders.P-ASROisaprisonbasedversionofASRO.

ThereisnopublishedevidenceassessingOASP,ASROandP-ASRO,howevertheseprogrammesareaccreditedTheJointPrisonProbationAccreditationPanel.

Page 28: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

27

TypeofProvision Evidence/Evaluation

Drugcourtsandsimilarcommunityjusticecourtshavebeenpiloted.TheybuildonDTTOsandDRRsbyprovidingcontinuityofsentenceforthereviewprocessanduseaproblem-solvingandinter-agencyapproachtohelpaddressthecausesofoffending.

Goodinternationalevidencebase.EvaluationofthedrugcourtpilotsinScotlandfoundthatasizableproportionofclientsmadesubjecttoDrugCourtOrderswereabletoachieveandsustainreductionsindruguseandassociatedoffendingbehaviour.(TypeIVevidence)

Type1evidence(strongestevidence):atleastonegoodsystematicreview(includingatleastonerandomisedcontrolledtrial).

TypeIIevidence:atleastonegoodrandomisedcontrolledtrial.

TypeIIIevidence:welldesignedinterventionalstudieswithoutrandomisation.

TypeIVevidence:welldesignedobservationalstudies.

TypeVevidence(weakestevidence):expertopinion;influentialreportsandstudies.

Source:BarkerJ,WeightmanAL,LancasterJ.ProjectfortheenhancementoftheWelshProtocolsforHealthGain:projectmethodology2.Cardiff:DuthieLibrary;1997.

Page 29: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

28

Appendix2

Figure1:Interventionsforproblemdrug-usingoffenderswithinthecriminaljusticesystem-community-basedprovision

Processestoidentify

drugusersforinterventions

Interventionstopromoteengagementwithtreatment

andotherservices(ormaintaindrug-freestatus)

Interventionsaddressing

substanceuseand/oroffending

Drugtestingandmandatoryassessment

ArrestReferral

Court-basedassessments

Criminaljusticeinterventionsteam(CJIT)case-management

Prolificandotherpriorityoffender(PPO)programme

RestrictionsonBail(RoB)

Conditionalcautioning

Diversionfromprosecution

Probationorderswithdrugtreatmentconditions

DrugRehabilitationRequirements(DRRs)

DrugCourtsandCommunityJusticeCourts

InterventionOrders

Drugtestingandotherdrug-relatedconditionsonreleaseonlicence

AddressingSubstanceRelatedOffending(ASRO)

OffenderSubstanceAbuseProgramme(OASP)

Page 30: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

29

Figure3:HowtheDIPprogrammeworksatallstagesoftheCJS

Case management by CJIT

Case managem

ent by CJIT (by CJIT or NO

M)

Case

man

agem

ent

by C

JIT

Case management (by CARATs in prison or NOMS in community)

Adultdrug-misusing

offender

Access to theProgramme via CJIT

worker in police custody(Required Assessment

or voluntaryassessment)

Restrictionon Bail drives

access totreatment

Access totreatmenton remand

Community sentence

Access to treatment via

Drug RehabilitationRequirement

Access to treatmentand release planning

in custody

Access to aftercaresupport (housing,

training etc) in appropriate cases

Access totreatment

via conditionalcautioning

Access to theProgramme via CJIT worker

in police custody (Required Assessment

or voluntaryassessment)

Custodialsentence

No (or reduced)drug misuse

and offending No (or reduced)drug misuse

and offending

Courtprocess

Release andresettlement

Trigger offence,arrest, drug

testing (Class A)

Charge where applicable,drug testing (Class A)

if not carried out earlier

Page 31: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

30

Page 32: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

31

BibliographyAssociationofForensicPhysicians,RoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists.SubstanceMisuseDetaineesinPoliceCustody:GuidelinesforClinicalManagement.London,RoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists.2006

AllWalesMedicinesStrategyGroup.FinalAppraisalReport:Buprenorphine/naloxone(Suboxone®).Cardiff.WelshAssemblyGovernment.2008

BellinE,WessonJ,TomasinoV,NolanJ,GlickAJ.Highdosemethadonereducescriminalrecidivisminopiateaddicts.AddictionResearch1999;7(1):19-29

BennettTDrugsandCrime;TheresultsoftheseconddevelopmentalstageoftheNEW-ADAMprogramme.HomeOfficeResearchStudy204.London:HomeOfficeResearchandStatisticsDirectorate(2000)

BorehamR,CronbergA,DollinLandPudneySTheArresteeSurvey2003-2006.HomeOfficeStatisticalBulletin12/07.London:HomeOffice(2007)

CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.HIVTransmissionAmongMaleInmatesinaStatePrisonSystem-Georgia,1992-2005.MMWRWeekly,421-426.

DawsonP,CuppleditchL.AnimpactassessmentoftheProlificandotherPriorityOffenderprogramme.HomeOfficeOnlineReport08/07

DepartmentofHealth(England)andthedevolvedadministrations.DrugMisuseandDependence:UKGuidelinesonClinicalManagement.London,DepartmentfHealth(England),theScottishGovernment,WelshAssemblyGovernmentandNorthernIrelandExecutive.2007

DepartmentofHealth.Afirstclassservice:QualityinthenewNHS.1-7-1998.London,DepartmentofHealth.12-3-2008.RefType:Report

DepartmentofHealth.ClinicalManagementofDrugDependenceintheAdultPrisonSetting:IncludingPsychosocialTreatmentasaCorePart.London,DepartmentofHealth.2006

DepartmentofHealth.PsychiatricmorbidityamongprisonersinEnglandandWales.London,TheStationeryOffice.1998

DolanK,HallW,WodakA.Methadonemaintenancereducesinjectinginprison.BMJ1996;312(7039):1162

DolanKA,ShearerJ,MacDonaldM,MattickRP,HallW,WodakAD.ArandomisedcontrolledtrialofmethadonemaintenancetreatmentversuswaitlistcontrolinanAustralianprisonsystem.Drug&AlcoholDependence2003;72(1):59-65

FarrellM,MarsdenJ.Drug-relatedmortalityamongnewlyreleasedoffenders1998to2000.HomeOfficeOnlineReport40/05.2005

FoxA,KhanL,BriggsD,Rees-JonesN,ThompsonZ,OwensJ.Throughcareandaftercare:approachesandpromisingpracticeinservicedeliveryforclientsreleasedfromprisonorleavingresidentialrehabilitation.HomeOfficeOnlineReport01/05

GossopM,BrowneN,StewartD,MarsdenJ.Alcoholuseoutcomesandheavydrinkingat4-5yearsamongatreatmentsampleofdrugmisusers.JournalofSubstanceAbuseTreatment25;135-143(2003)

HarmanK,PaylorI.AnevaluationoftheCARATinitiative.TheHowardJournal44(4);357-373(2005)

Page 33: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

32

HealthProtectionAgency,SCIEH,NationalPublicHealthServiceforWales,CDSCNorthernIreland,CRDHB,UASSG.ShootingUp;InfectionsamonginjectingdrugusersintheUnitedKingdom2002.London,HealthProtectionAgency.2003

HollowayK,BennettT&FarringtonD.Theeffectivenessofcriminaljusticeandtreatmentprogrammesinreducingdrugrelatedcrime:asystematicreview,HomeOfficeOnlinereport26/05London:HomeOffice(2005)

HomeOfficeAnintroductiontothedruginterventionsprogrammeprisonsandprobationservices.London:HomeOffice2007

HomeOffice.Drug-relatedmortalityamongnewly-releasedoffenders.HomeOffice,2003

HoughM,ClancyA,McSweenyTim,TurnbullPJ.TheimpactofDrugTreatmentandTestingOrdersonoffending:twoyearreconvictionresults.Findings184,London:HomeOffice,2003

HucklesbyA,EastwoodC,SeddonT,SpriggsATheEvaluationoftheRestrictiononBailPilotFinalReport.HomeOfficeOnlineReport06/07.London:HomeOffice(2007)

JointFormularyCommittee.BritishNationalFormulary.Number57.2009.London,BritishMedicalAssociationandRoyalPharmaceuticalSocietyofGreatBritain2009

JürgensR.InterventionstoaddressHIVinprisons:needleandsyringeprogrammesanddecontaminationstrategies.GenevaWorldHealthOrganisation,2007

King’sCollege,London;UniversityofBristol;ImperialCollege,London;andtheLondonSchoolofEconomicsandPoliticalScienceNationalEvaluationofCriminalJusticeIntegratedTeams:Summary.London:TheInstituteforCriminalPolicyResearchSchoolofLaw,King’sCollege,London(2007)

McIvorG,BarnsdaleL,EleyS,MallochM,YatesR,BrownA.TheOperationandEffectivenessoftheScottishDrugCourtPilots.ResearchFindingsNo81/2006.EdinburghScottishExecutive.SocialResearch,CrimeandCriminalJustice

McSweeneyT,StevensA.HuntN,TurnbullPJ.Twistingarmsorhelpinghand?Assessingtheimpactof‘coerced’andcomparable‘voluntary’drugtreatmentoptions.BritishJournalofCriminology47,470-490(2007)

MinozziS,AmatoL,VecchiS,DavoliM,KirchmayerU,VersterA.Oralnaltrexonemaintenancetreatmentforopioiddependence.CochraneDatabaseofSystematicReviews2006onlinereview

NationalOffenderManagementService.IntegratedDrugTreatmentSystem:TheFirst28Days:PsychosocialSupport.London,MinistryofJustice,2006

NationalTreatmentAgencyforSubstanceMisuse.ClinicalGovernanceinDrugTreatment:Adraftgoodpracticeguideforprovidersandcommissioners.OnlinereportNationalTreatmentAgency.2008

NICE.Drugmisuse:opioiddetoxification.NICEclinicalguideline52.London,NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence,2007

NICE.Drugmisuse:psychosocialinterventions.NICEclinicalguideline51.London,NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence,2007

NICE.Methadoneandbuprenorphineforthemanagementofopioiddependence.NICEtechnologyappraisalguidance114.2007.London,NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence

Page 34: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

33

NICE.Naltrexoneforthemanagementofopioiddependence.NICEtechnologyappraisalguidance115.2007.London,NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence

RichterKP,ArnstenJH.Arationaleandmodelforaddressingtobaccodependenceinsubstanceabusetreatment.SubstanceAbuseTreatment,Prevention,andPolicy2006;1(23)

RoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists.Co-existingproblemsofmentaldisorderandsubstancemisuse(dualdiagnosis):Aninformationmanual.BanerjeeS,ClancyC,CromeI,editors.2001.London,RoyalCollegeofPsychiatristsResearchUnit.18-10-2007.RefType:Report

RoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists.Prisonpsychiatry:adultprisonsinEnglandandWales.2007.London,RoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists.11-12-2007.RefType:Report

ShawJ,ApplebyL,BakerD.Saferprisons:Anationalstudyofprisonsuicides1999-2000bytheNationalConfidentialInquiryintoSuicidesandHomicidesbyPeoplewithMentalIllness.2003.London,DepartmentofHealth.14-11-2007.RefType:Report

SkodboS,BrownG,DeaconS,CooperA,HallA,MillarT,SmithJ&WhithamK(2007).TheDrugInterventionsProgramme(DIP):addressingdruguseandoffendingthrough‘ToughChoices’.HomeOfficeResearchReport2.London:HomeOffice

StrangJ,HeustonJ,WhiteleyC,BacchusL,MadenT,GossopMetal.IsprisontattooingariskbehaviourforHIVandotherviruses?ResultsfromanationalsurveyofprisonersinEnglandandWales.CriminalBehaviourandMentalHealth2000;10:60-66

WelshAssemblyGovernment.AlcoholMisuseinWales.Cardiff:WelshAssemblyGovernment,2008

WelshAssemblyGovernment,HMPrisonServiceCardiffPrisonMentalHealthPathway(2006)

WelshAssemblyGovernment.PsychologicalTherapyandPsychosocialinterventionsintheTreatmentofSubstanceMisuse.Cardiff,WelshAssemblyGovernment,2006

WorkingTogethertoReduceHarm.TheSubstanceMisuseStrategyforWales2008-2018.WelshAssemblyGovernment,2008

RoyalPharmaceuticalSocietyofGreatBritain.Pharmaceuticalcareofdetaineesinpolicecustody.Onlinereport:RoyalPharmaceuticalSocietyofGreatBritain:2007

SondhiA,O’SheaJandWilliamsT.Arrestreferral:Emergingfindingsfromthenationalmonitoringandevaluationprogramme.DPASpaper18.London:HomeOffice;2002

BirchA,DobbieF,ChalmersT,BarnsdaleL,McIvorGandYatesR.Evaluationofthearrestreferralpilotschemes.CrimeandCriminalJusticeResearchProgrammeResearchFindingsNo.87/2006.Edinburgh:ScottishExecutive;2006

StrangJ,HeustonJ,GossopM,GreenJ,MadenT.ResearchFindingsNo.82:HIV/AIDSRiskBehaviourAmongAdultMalePrisoners.London:HomeOffice;1998

Page 35: Treatment of Offenders - gov.wales · e.g. services that promote reintegration (such as housing, education and employment) in order to improve long-term outcomes. • An effective

34

GlossaryArrestreferralservice Arrestreferralworkersoperateinpolicestationsand

interviewarresteestoidentifythosewithadrugproblemforonwardreferraltootheragencies.

CARAT Counselling,Assessment,Referral,AdviceandThroughcareteamsoperatewithinprisons.Theyundertakeassessmentsoftheneedfordrugservicesandprovideone-to-onemotivationalsupportandgroupworkforproblemdrugusers.Theyalsoprovidecasemanagementfacilitatingaccesstoawiderrangeofservicesbothincustodyandoninitialrelease.

CJIT CriminalJusticeIntegratedTeamsarecommunitybasedandassessoffenderswhotestpositive.Theyprovidecasemanagement,referringoffenderstotreatmentandorganisingtheprovisionofothersupportsuchashousingandemploymentservices.

DIPDrugInterventions Programmeprovidesarangeofinterventionsaimedatgettingproblemdrug-usingoffendersintotreatmentandothersupport.

TSS TheTransitionalSupportServiceaimstoprovide‘throughthegate’mentoringandsupportforshortsentenceprisoners(usuallylessthan12monthssentence)forupto12weeksfollowingtheirrelease.Theserviceisdesignedtoaddressthepracticalresettlementneedsofthosewithon-goingsubstancemisuseproblems.Theprimaryfocusisonincreasingaccesstodrugtreatmentbuttheschemealsoaddressesproblemsthatmayleadtore-offending,suchashomelessness,relationshipdifficulties,finance,loweducationalattainmentandunemployment.

NOMS TheNationalOffenderManagementServiceisresponsibleforoverseeingthemanagementofoffendersinprisonandinthecommunity.NOMSusestheconceptofthe‘end-to-endmanagement’ofoffenders.AsingleoffendermanagerwillsuperviseeachoffenderthroughouttheircontactwiththeCriminalJusticeSystem(CJS),anddrawonanappropriaterangeofservicesprovidedbyagenciesfromallsectors.