Upload
truongkien
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Initiatives to profit from the Fourth Railway Package
Munich, April 2017
Winning from liberalization
Transportation
2
EU-wide railway market liberalization is in its final stages – Existing players need actionable plans on how to benefit from this scenario
1st council directive
2001 2004 2016 2012 1991 2007
1st railway package
2nd railway package
3rd railway package
Recast directive
4th railway package
Context market liberalization
> Enable connected rail traffic across Europe
> Liberalize rail traffic and open it up to further operators
> Increase efficiency of the railway system
> Establish open access principles for international rail freight and cross-border passenger service
EU regulation efforts have pushed market incumbents to improve operations efficiency and quality of service
Past – Cope with increased impact of regulations and initial opening of markets
> Understand the current market environment and respective impacts from most recent railway package
> Identify key levers for successfully navigating through the on-going push for liberalization
> Re-shape organizational set-up to allow for a more powerful, flexible and lean decision-making process
> Benefit from measures to improve operations efficiency and profitability
Market incumbents will have to lay out a strategic concept on how to benefit from regional openings
> Define a common approach towards rail safety regulation
> Create prerequisites for interoperability
> Separate infrastructure mana-gers and transport operators
> Found common representation of interests, i.e. the European Union Agency for Railways (ERA)
The European Union (EU) to… The market incumbents to…
Now – Win from full liberalization of domestic and regional passenger transport
2019
Full liberalization target – On-going PSCs/PSOs not affected until max. 2034
3
As of today, the degree of rail market liberalization within the EU is still quite diverse – UK and Sweden with full liberalization
Degree of market liberalization
Full
Large
Partial
Quasi
None
Competitors (non-incumbent)
Fully liberalized markets
> All pkm are in open access or all Public Service Contracts (PSCs) are competitively tendered, e.g. Sweden and UK
Largely liberalized markets
> More than 33% of pkm are in open access or correspond to competitively tendered PSCs, e.g. Austria, Germany and Italy
Partially liberalized markets
> Less than 33% of pkm are in open access or correspond to competitively tendered PSCs, yet new entrants have taken up a significant share of the liberalized market, e.g. the Netherlands, Czech Republic and Portugal
Quasi-liberalized markets
> The whole market is open for access, but there is no effective competition in the market
> New entrants operate directly awarded PSCs, e.g. Denmark and Poland
Non-liberalized markets
> Incumbent operates all commercial services and Public Service Obligations (PSOs), e.g. France, Spain, Belgium and Finland
Source: European Parliamentary Research Service, IRG Rail
Note: Analysis based on overall share of total pkm; respective focus on regional or inter-city transport with potential to slightly distort the picture; Czech Republic considered increasing its share of tendering for PSCs; Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Slovakia all PSCs should henceforth be de jure competitively tendered; in reality, only the incumbents participated in the tenders; Germany, the amount of train-kilometers of PSOs competitively tendered has progressed to 51%; Switzerland and Norway both with a share of 18%
25 13
10
135
42
19
8
3
13
2
4
12
1
# 17
4
Now, the Fourth Railway Package targets a fully open domestic and regional passenger transport market as of 2019
Content of the Fourth Railway Package
Expansion of ERA's powers
> European Union Agency for Railways as One-stop-shop for rail suppliers and operators
> Wide-spread implementation of harmonized signaling system
> EU-wide vehicle authorizations and single safety certificates
Enhancement of rail governance structure
> Immediate access to the passenger markets in the EU by 2019 for suitable rail operators
> Reinforcement of infrastructure managers
Introduction of risk control measures
> Implemented by all rail contractors, infra-structure managers and entities in charge of maintenance
> Reinforced powers over national authorities allowing ERA to carry out audits and inspections
Liberalization of passenger transport
> Mandatory public tendering and non-discriminatory access to rolling stock
> Voluntary introduction of integrated ticketing and information exchange schemes
Maintenance of a skilled railway workforce
> Mandatory take over of workforce of public services
Improvements to ERA governance
> Establishment of an Executive Board and independent board(s) of appeal
> New sources of funding
The Fourth Railway Package
Governance and market pillar Technical pillar
Source: UNIFE World Rail Market Study 2016, European Parliamentary Research Service
5
Opening domestic passenger markets is thought to increase com-petition, resulting in better prices and higher customer satisfaction
Elements of liberalization
1
3 2
New entrants
Operational amendments
Mandatory tendering
Liberalization of domestic passenger transport
1 New Entrants
> Allow companies to either offer competition in the market, meaning they can provide competing commercial services, or to give them the chance to compete for the market, meaning they can bid for public service rail contracts
2 Mandatory tendering
> Authorities will be mandated to publicly tender public service rail contracts, a significant change from the current situation with many contracts being awarded directly, which only in some exceptional situations will be allowed in the future
3 Operational amendments
> Encourage authorities and railway operators to set up integrated ticketing schemes on national levels
> Requirement for authorities to take over the financial risk of the rolling stock's residual value and thus ensure non-discriminatory access to suitable rolling stock
More attractive prices
Increased customer satisfaction
Source: UNIFE World Rail Market Study 2016
6
Decreasing subsidy needs will further support the regulatory push for liberalization in the regional rail transport sector
Competitors Deutsche Bahn
Operating performance in RRTS1)
[in million train km] Subsidies in RRTS1)
[in EUR cent per pkm]
1995 1997 2015
13.8 13.6
2009 2011 2013 2005 2007
17.0
14.3
1999 2001 2003
14.9 15.8
14.1
-22%
16.6 16.6 17.1 17.3
Source: Deutsche Bahn AG
Effects of liberalization – Example Germany
2007 2011
633 643 644 629
2009 2013
654
2015
500
2005
633
2003
619
2001
599
1999
555
1997
526
1995
+8%
Competitors' market share
3% 6% 10% 24% 29%
1) Regional rail transport sector
7
Regional rail transport incumbents will need to apply five key levers to benefit from liberalization
1 2 3 4 5
Key levers for rail incumbents
Marketing and Lobbying
Competence centers
Transformation
Personnel
Maintenance
> Following key account management principles, marketing and lobbying is to be intensified with key regional authorities and clients
> Functional descriptions of services are set up to define the desired target state, yet leave room for entrepreneurial decision making
> Cross-regional task forces are to be implemented to increase hit rate on any tender-related topics
> Transfer of cross-regional competence principle also onto other topics such as efficiency assessment of regional infrastructure and assets
> Business restructuring on target costing basis to ensure lean organiza-tional structures and hierarchies, allowing for an improved responsive-ness and decision-making towards tender-related topics as well as adaptation of operation networks, following a change in competition
> Increased competitiveness of personnel tariffs despite anticipated resistance from employee/union representatives
> Focus on work-force flexibility as well as reliability and conditions of service
> Competitive target costing principle to be applied also for maintenance
> Innovative concepts such as preventive maintenance, mobile mainte-nance teams, etc. must be introduced to reduce maintenance costs and increase vehicle availability
Implement future
oriented target operating
model
Develop powerful,
flexible and lean tender-
response setup
8
A stringent setup ensures pro-active account management and proposal delivery as well as effective aftersales activities
Tender-response setup
Market potential evaluation
> Tenders and schedules overview
> Network/route profitability analysis
> Competitive landscape screening
> Strategic roadmap and "battlefield" setting
Organizational design
> Cross-regional synergy assessment
> Governance structure review/re-design
Operational adjustments
> Outcome-related down- or up-sizing
> New operations setup definition
> Process blue book update
Professional tender management
> Focus on market-oriented tender planning, bidding and winning
> Strategic marketing unit to spearhead future tender management efforts
> Business unit restructuring to bundle core competencies for increased impact and success rate
> Dedicated cross-regional key account management for large-sized "VIP" customers
> Tender task force set-up
Concept focus on
> Excellence
> Efficiency
> Profitability
> Impact
> Responsiveness
> Flexibility Aftercare solutions
> Proposal refinement (if needed)
> Communication of outcomes and learnings
Governance excellence
Feedback
Operations leadership
9
Future oriented target operating model
Learning from new competitors…
…to ensure sustainable competitiveness in liberalized markets
A B Operations leadership
Governance excellence
> Performance bench-marking and continuous process improvement measures
> Organizational restruc-turing to ensure lean/flat hierarchies and less bureaucracy
> Target costing-based process restructuring for front- and back-end units/services
> Impactful transfer of decision-making powers and capabilities, e.g. as part of task-force setting
> New business model generation and adjacent, added-value service offerings
> New partnership models setup, JV opportunities screening and innovation focus
Exemplary advantages of new railway players entering the market:
> Flat hierarchies and more flexible decision-making structures
> Lean and agile operational processes approach, based on e.g. greenfield set-up opportunities
> Focus on profitable core business with established network of partner-ships for supporting services, e.g. maintenance and handling
> Possibility of Day-1 outsourcing, automation and digitization of e.g. non-core business items
> Lower-to-no legacy costs
In addition incumbents will have to aim for operations leadership and governance excellence to ensure sustainable competitiveness
10
Your contacts at Roland Berger
+33 (1) 53670-926 [email protected]
Didier Bréchemier Partner, Paris
+55 (11) 97203-7337 [email protected]
Gustavo Lopes Partner, Sao Paulo
Th
e au
tho
rs
Yo
ur
glo
bal
co
nta
cts
+86 (21) 5298 6677-871 [email protected]
Sarna Yeung Partner, Shanghai
+31 (20) 7960-620 [email protected]
Rene Seyger Partner, Amsterdam
+49 (30) 39927-3316 [email protected]
Tobias Schönberg Partner, Berlin
+1 (514) 875-2000-213 [email protected]
Alexis Gardy Partner, Montréal
+49 (89) 9230-8364 [email protected]
Andreas Schwilling Partner, Munich
+49 (211) 4389-2193 [email protected]
Dr. Martin Streichfuss Head of Transportation, Düsseldorf
12
In particular within the European RRTS, various RB projects have already tackled the inevitable impact of market liberalization
Selected Roland Berger project portfolio
Market studies > Creation of a strategic overview on European regional public transport
> Identification of current and future market size and volumes
> Development of relevant market entry strategies and prerequisites
Strategy development
> Assessment of future business model relevance and partnership opportunities
> Evaluation of Joint Venture candidates for more profitable market coverage
> Organizational and operational design of joint fit-for future business setup
Value chain optimization
> Benchmarking of key financial and performance indicators to identify value drivers and threads
> Business model re-design, incl. pricing, for services and production units within the value chain
> Development of measures and tools to ensure successful steering and monitoring
Improvement potential identification
> Analysis of loss-making operations following a series of new operating license acquisitions
> Conception of a restructuring framework to improve profitability levels
> Organizational and operational re-design to monetize on newly found volume increase
Commercial re-franchising
> Assessment of commercial opportunities and risks of a franchise model restructuring
> Financial impact calculation including probability assumptions on e.g. payment default
> Identification and recommendation of potential opportunities for diversification of operations