Upload
intervarsity-press-samples
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 1/41
T r a n s f o r m a t i v e
E n c o u n t e r s
The Intervention of God in Christian
Counseling and Pastoral Care
E d i t e d b y
D a v i d W. A p p l e b y a n d
G e o r g e O h l s c h l a g e r
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 2/41
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 3/41
T r a n s f o r m a T i v e
e n c o u n T e r s
The Intervention of God in ChristianCounseling and Pastoral Care
edtd by
Dd w. applby d
g ohlhl
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 4/41
IV P
P.O. Bx 1400, Dw Gv, IL 60515-1426
W W Wb: www.v.m
©2013 b Dv W. Ab G O
A v. N bk m b m w w m m
IV P.
IV P® bk-b v IV C Fw/USA® , mvm
v m v, U S
Am, mmb mvm I Fw Ev S. F m b
v, w Pb R D., IV C Fw/USA, 6400 S
R., P.O. Bx 7895, M, WI 53707-7895, v IVCF wb www.v..
A S q, w , k m HE HOLY BIBLE, NEW INERNAIONAL
VERSION®, NIV® C © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 b Bb, I.™U b m. A v
ww.
W bk , m m m bk v b
v v vv.
Cv : C K
I : B Hb
Im: w: G Fz/G Im
w: © xk/Sk
ISBN 978-0-8308-2822-7
D ISBN 978-0-8308-9550-2
P U S Am ∞
IV P mm vm b . A mmb G P Iv w wv b.
m b G P Iv, v www.v..L C C--P D
A lg d h bk lbl h Lby Cg.
P 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Y 31 30 29 28 27 26 25 24 23 22 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 5/41
Contents
P 11
Akm 15
F 17
Counseling and Psychotherapy on a New Foundation
E L. J
1 I 29
The Call to Transformational Living
Dv W. Ab & G O
Part One
Transormative Encounters Done in Church
2 T Ej H M I H 49
Mk S
3 T Py My 63
E Sm
4 D P T P 77
Dv W. Ab
5 Tm I B C 94
Ew . W
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 6/41
Part Two
Transormative Paradigms or Church or Clinic
6 Sy O C
B Ty 111
A Christian Approach to Transforming People by the Way of Christ
S-Y
7 C Hm 126
Offering the Holy Spirit the Tools of Our Trade
C L. Z, D S, Hm R,Rb C & J W
8 Cm F Py
C C 140
J. Mk S
9 G I P 155
The Concept of Christian Counseling at IGNIS,the German Association for Christian Psychology
W M
10 Tm T C
Em-F Ty 168
L C. W. Km-v D & E L. J
11 F B O G E
Fm C 183
W
12 T H Cy 198
A Transformational Model for Group Work
J P Hk & J N. Hk
13 H G Cm N Tm U
T F 211
Ev L. W J., Ab L. G, Dv J. J II,
C L. G & Y L
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 7/41
14 Py S W
C/B/Sym Ty 227
G O
Part Three
Transormative Interventions or Clinical Practice
15 C-C Vz
EMDR H Tm 245
A N MD & P J
16 T TRUTH P 260
Christian Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for
Depression and Anxiety
L Vk
17 G’ I Sx A 276
Mk R. L
18 Hm N C A Ry
W G Ty 288
Mk Wm D
19 T P C Tm U
Hmx B A 302
J H Hm & P J. H
20 F L C 323
Integrating Faith and the Science of Human Flourishing
C H Wb
Part Four
Toward Universal Transormational Practice
21 Tm E 337When God Steps In
Dv W. Ab
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 8/41
22 T U Ex H M 349
G O
Ax 365
Keeping Christ in Christian Counseling:
Recent and Developing Threats Eroding Precious Rights to Religious
Freedom and Client Self-Determination
G O
C 382
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 9/41
Preface
A Lesson in the School of the Holy SpiritM h g lg pl wk b w h
g d bk ppl d. J’ “l ,” h
h g h, d Lk 4:8-9, whh y:
T Sp h Ld ,
b h h d
pl gd w h p.
H h pl d h pd y gh h bld,
h ppd ,
pl h y h Ld’ .
Shg wh wh w d h . T Gk wd
h “ppd” m, wh wd llly
bk p d gly b bk bh h d bdy. J
dld h h w d bk h lk p bk
hw, g h d kg h whl. W d l
yg, “Ld, I w d h .” W w ll d hw ppl h
Gd’ ly p h d hlp h d h h .
Tgh h hly jy J dd xly h h hld h k,
d d d h dd.
Mll Ug, h 95 l, Bb Dm, y h h
h Sp h ph dg h
y dg bh bdy d d, whh l d (Ug, 95). Whl w h y xpl
J hlg bd d g d, w h h
h w l y wh J hd h l d wd
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 10/41
ransormative Encounters
wh h wh w lly dgd wll.
Wh w y wlk J’ p hlg , p-
lly w p h pl, y y h hlg wh h O wh g . W h py,
h g, h gd p, h hl d l
hg h gh h by whh hlg ppd .
W lk hd d wld lk pkg h p , bx.
G h y wy h hlg h hd -
ld h bk, h d ld ly h wll-g b
ll bl h h hlg h k hlg pbl,
h k ll h d.
P Bll Jh Bhl Chh Rddg, Cl, wh h
ll p h l f b d hl d ll-
d gd gy, ll h y h wll wh fg p:
Lg h Gd’ d llw H ld jyl d xg, y I
d l kp dg. I w G C, g hh
d Nhll, ., wh w py. Sh w -
fd wh hd h hd . A I d py h, I l hk y h h I w py. I h , hg w d-
. I ld ll J w gg hl h, y l I wld
wh h wk Gd I pyd ld hd h. I w’ llwd
k d hlg h p h wll, J dd wh,
“G y wy; h d h g y dgh” (Mk 7:9).
T w’ hlg w b hl h Sp . I kd h
l h y h h y gg d h wld’
d h. Sh dd I qd. T I d h h bk y k, b b bl. I l lk h l lwly fwg dwwd, I
ld h h g w fwg dw h k. Sh d h l . Wh
hd h b, I ld h h k hld b hld by w. Sh d
b wy h wld h d p b, ly d h w,
, hld.
I h I lzd wh Gd w dg. I w ply-by-ply -
, lk pg . I w y plg db wh Gd
w dg h H hwd y w bdy. H wd hl hwh fwg hgh , whh hgh py, d h lyg
hd. I p dd h lwy Gd wh
hl. (Jh, 0)
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 11/41
P
N w l J dd Sp w d xly h
wy. W ’ hlp b wd dy g lkd p-
d ppl, hgh hy h l, gh wk g d y d wh h Fh dg. I’ lg q
whh Gd’ wll hl. Nw ’ ly q hw. Dlpg
h b h h h . Wh w kw
kp wh w d kw w d’ y hldlk p-
ph l d y.
I pbbly h l b gzg d h ld
g h l wkbl p d ppl
dg y. T h l h w hp y wll k dg
d wg h bk. W yg, d’ d h wll d
y d y l. W h y wll d h g d g-
zg h lly y d pl
p wh hp d dg d.
M h h, w yg, d’ p y lg y h
gzd h l lglly. T l d g lg y
wll d h y y d. D k h x p,hw, ggd by Jh h wd: p d yld yl
Gd wh h py bg h dp d bg lk
ll hld d lg l wh y “ ” h whp
Gd, wh y d’ y h kgd Gd kg hp gh
y.
Rb h g l h h: h h ly l y
h, h y wll y k y jb lk lk l. D’ ply l
hd hlg py d h h p wll
pply qlly wll y l ph. I y h d Gd’
hk y p, d h bkd dg hg h d
plly lgl d l, h y kw hw p l
l Gd d b fxbl, kwg h h b d-
wy g h jb d pply. W j h b w
hw Gd w d .
I p w wll h hllg y h pl wh Gd d l bh h l d l ld
Ch lg d hlp h hg gdly d-
. J b, wh y h ld yhg y
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 12/41
4 ransormative Encounters
h h, hzl pl, h y bg h l d
h hl h Sp. T y l b ll, l h
h d ll d d h h ll ll Gd whp whh wy g. W d d h l d
h l.
References and Recommended Resources
Jh, B. (0, Mh). Y’ g h pw. Cm. Rd <hp://
www.hg./-h/496--gz-l//49
-y-g-h-pw>.
Ug, M. (95). Bb m . Wh, IL: V Kp P.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 13/41
Foreword
Counseling and Psychotherapy
on a New Foundation
Eric L Johnson
T f Ag h Ch hh h W h b
. O h g wk—T C G (958)—w -p ll h y W lz p h dg
h h pp h Bbl. Ag gd h h
dlly ly w h wld: h wh bl
J Ch (h Cy Gd) d h wh d (h Cy Hy).
T , Ag w, l Gd d dp l, d h l l l
d dp Gd. Ag, , dd h Ch hld
h hl. T wh l d wh bd, Gd
h l. H bld h w l dlly
h w , hy x y l hgh h
h hy, d hd wd h pl lz h g .
Ag’ w-y dl hy pd l p
wk pphg ’ l d h Ch’ pl ,
plly wh dg hw pph d pyhlgy.
Wg d h h d pyhlgy w bg dd,
Abh Kyp (898)—Dh hlg, hh d p - (904–908)—k Ag’ wk p h d gd
h h g h Hly Sp dd by h Ch ld
h dlp w h h , dghd
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 14/41
8 ransormative Encounters
dlly by h p wldw. Kyp gzd
h h wll b bd g bw h wh g
bg b p h p— xpl, bb, d lgl ly. “Wh h b d wll
by , d b d g by y” (p. 59). Nhl, h g-
ld h p “ pp d, b
hy h d g-p” d “w hg d wy”
(p. 55), bly bg b bl d. F x-
pl, Ch h h wll b dghd by
h l Sp. Cqly, Ch h h
wll p h ly bm —ll d hg
dpd Gd’ dg pl—d ly pbl ly fhg
wh Ch; wh -Ch wll p h
ly m d pbl fhg by h w pw.
Kyp wld lkly h ppd h bk y hld y hd,
l wy plly Ch dl lg.
S h lly lld h kd pj C (E,
989; Jh, 007; Rb & W, 00) m - (C & Hll, 00). I gl h dlp h ph-
d d ph pyhlgy pbl (ldg
hy, h d p) bd Ch wldw. A Kyp
gzd, h pj wll l d llb wh h -
’ pyhlgy, b wll b dghd h
wh d h x h Ch p k d-
pyhlgl hy, h p.
I wh w-/w- pph, y Ch
pyhlgy h pd h d dl d by d-
(h gg wldw h Cy Hy h W) d
h l d dd by d pyhlgy (.g., h
phb g xpl ppl Gd Sp). A l, h
Ch h dd d pyhlgy h
hl d hp d h dd
h lg b h lbl Chy.Md pyhlgy h pld kbl py-
hlgl kwldg h p hdd y, d Ch
pyhlgy l hl h kwldg. Fllwg Ag
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 15/41
Fw 9
d Kyp, h q , Wh l d hld b g
p? I dq Ch bg wh d pyhlgy d
b wll-dd kwldg d p, d ly dwh Chy h y b pl pyhlgl p? O wld
b b Ch hl h l h-
l d hp Chy, d ly h l
d pyhlgy, h b ghly pd h lgh
Ch wldw p?
T pbl Ch dy h w lll y
gp. I d g g d p plly,
Ch dd d lzd wh dlly l
wldw y. A l, hy xpd d p
p h h “l,” l pph h ly lg wy
hk b d hpy, d p lg d pyh-
hpy l, wh wkg wh Ch. (Fll dl:
I d y PhD dl pyhlgy Mhg S Uy,
I h b h f yl.)
O h wl h h d wh lg d pyhhpy h p wy y
Ch dp h b h kbl pg p h d-
pl lg d ply. P h p h ld
g h bg pblhd “lg-d” p-
ph lg d pyhhpy, wh l, plly
dd dl dpd lg , ldg
“Ch-d” pph, whh dp h p-
lly Ch wh wkg wh Ch (
Whg, Jh, Hk & A, p).
Ch-d dl hpy ly h b
dd Ch dl hpy h. T p
h wk , b p Ch d
p wdly pd dl h h ldy b plly
ldd d d h h kd Ch hpy l
l hpy, hby lgg Ch hpy,bdly dd, h y , lg bd d
p. T bk ld xll xpl
Ch-d hpy.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 16/41
0 ransormative Encounters
Hw, llwg Ag-Kyp h h -
, w gh l xp h lg d pyhhpy h Cy
Gd wld lk blly d h h Cy Hy.A l, l dbl dlp dl lg d pyh-
hpy wkg wh Ch h wh w gh ll “Ch-
dd”—h , dl h g d bd xply
Ch p, bl d p ( Jh, Whg,
A & Hk, p). Sh dl y b h kwldg d
lg gh d pyhlgy, b Chy, h h
d, pd h g p. Sh gd lkly
ld dl h plly d qly f Ch d-
d h h lkly plly p
Ch d l lkly b dld by h l p
d dl hpy. Wh gh hz Ch-dd
dl lg d pyhhpy?
The Rebuilding of Counseling and Psychotherapy
Gy Cll w h Ch l p h d, h l x T Rb P (977). Tgh h d h
lbl h pph, h gd pyhlgy bl
Ch d h h h d pyhlgy. I h llwg
, h l Ch d wll b lghly pdd, g-
zd d lbd, plly wh gd lg d pyhhpy.
I h wldw l h h dd d
pyhlgy, Cll wd bld pyhlgy h wldw
p (h Gd x d h ll h) d lly (h
h kw h, ly ld wy) ( hp. 8
Cll, 977). Fllwg C d Hll (00), w gh dd h kwg
h Ch l xpg, lg d bg d by
. Blw d h wkg p Cll’
ppd “pyhlgy w d.”
Exp p. T p bd by d py-
1It made sense or Collins (1977) to include “modied reductionism” as one o the six working
assumptions o the new oundation or psychology, given the remaining infuence o atomism
and behaviorism when he wrote. However, there is much greater appreciation or the contextual
nature o both human lie and knowledge, so it seems to me less unnecessary to include it today.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 17/41
Fw
hlgy h l 800 b lgly d by
pyhlg h p, p j by py ph-
lph (Spp, 977). A l, d pyhlg(d y Ch d by h) d h, hy-
bldg d ll wk pl g h ly lg
(p) kwldg. (Tklly, h pl h
p pyhlgy, whh h lzd phlphl d lg
kwldg l lly, dg h dl
p .)
T h phlphl, hlgl, pl d pl
h Ch d g h bg d hw h
ll q h xlly pl d py-
hlgy. Al, bg d p Gd k Ch l lkly b-
lz d g. A l, Sp d l -
f —h bbll d d hlgy— b dd
lg pyhlgl kwldg Ch (php
bdpl, lg d ly), wll
h dy h hy Ch l- p. M, phl-phl ly pd pl ly d lgl h h
gly d pyhlgl hy, h d ll p. Tgh
y d pyhlg gh j h xpdd p, h
hld p Ch hldg .
Bb b. Gg p h, Cll (977) d
h h Bbl hd py ll h kwldg. Cl
(559/960) lld h Bbl h Ch’ “pl,” blg h
b d p ly (Gd, h , h d l).
F h Bbl l b hl d pl bl d -
( “Bbll hplgy” blw) h gd h
bl, l d l, h bbll l pd h “ ppl”
Ch pyhlgy. T gg h h Ch-dd
lg d pyhhpy wll glly lz Sp dg d
dg hp g.
C p. G’ . Expdg Cll’j p, Ch-dd lg d pyhhpy
h h b pply dd p Gd d h h
l h dy d pyhlgl . T w .
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 18/41
ransormative Encounters
F, bg d h g Gd h x lly
l h; d, Gd b h bg d ld h-
y p ; d hd, h w d by Gd l h gly ( C 0:) d d h g hpp lg, byg
d whpg h. T d dlly dgh Ch
pyhlgy d d p d .
G’ . Chy d h lg by bl
h Gd : bg h p—Fh, S d Hly Sp
(M 8:9). S, Ch-dd lg d pyhhpy wll
p h xp Gd Fh; wk wh h pdd
by h bl’ wh Ch h l, dh d ; d
ly xplly h pw h dwllg Sp bg b h-
p hg hgh h bl’ h. T ll h
Gd l h gd h ll h bg. I-
ddl h pl g wh g d d
by h l wh h h.
Bb py. “Pyhlgy hld p dl d-
d h Bbl” (Cll, 977, p. 5). T Bbl’ p- d wy gz h dl. A y’ h
l y wh whh hy dd hl d h pl
h . Md pyhlgy’ l l.
Chy’ b zd d b ld
pp h bg.
C. Tgh Ch hk dp w Gd dd , hy bl
h d hy gd (G :). T phyl d pyhlgl ,
p d kll h bg h dlly gd. C-
qly, Ch-dd lg d pyhhpy wll gly wk
wh ppl’ d , lg wh h Ch’ dp.
I l pyhlgy, hw, wll d dpd
Gd. I dd, Ch-dd lg d pyhhpy wll
h l dl bdd, , pbl g, wh
dd x by blgl f d lz.
. Cll Chy l h h w
2Collins (1977) made “determinism and ree will” and “biblical anthropology” distinct working
assumptions. Here the ormer will be subsumed under the latter.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 19/41
Fw
ll—h , ld h C d d h d
S, hg pd d , bl p h ll
gd d lh dg Gd’ gl dg (R :0-),d hdg wd d d. S l pyh-
phlgl d h ’ bdy, h d gl,
dp pl , d h h l
l h h xp, h lgh ld h p kd
pyhphlgy gzd by wldw , lk
dp d hzph. hgh Ch bl b ll
d g d , hy g bl k
pbly h hl d ld py d
hly lbl hpy, d h h bg dg h
b (W l., 007).
H ll l pd wk pg h
g d wk. H ddbly y d h, d
d hpy ghly k ll h. Ch-dd -
lg d pyhhpy, hw, l d h p
g lgh Gd’ lg, pp pd d h dh d Ch, whh b bl bl d
wh p g d h whh dbl h p.
Rm. Chy l w J Ch Gd’ py -
hlg h l. Tgh Ch’ l, dh d ,
bl ld Gd d bg w l h w (
C 5:7), whh bg lzd w by h Hly Sp by h
bl’ “wd dpg” (Kkgd, 990, p. 4).
T dp hp gdlly d h
bl wy hl d Ch, wh wh
hy wh Gd (Cl :0), g ( J :9),
dp Gd’ ly (Gl 4:5-6), h dwllg d pwg
h Hly Sp (R 8:9), d w l (Cl :9-0). Sh b
d whh l xpl d dy h l dy-
wh h d gl d h h d d.
Ch lg d pyhhpy dghd d p by l Ch d h Hly Sp.
Gd h l d h hh b h l l wh h
hg plly lzd l, pbldg lhp wh
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 20/41
4 ransormative Encounters
h (Eph 4:-6). A l h ll hh dly -
dd b hp, d p gd lg h hg
hlp h hh lll h llg (.g., klld Ch , -l, pyhhp).
T Ch pl dpl bl bl l hl
h hp Chy. Ag h l h
pp py, Bbl dy, Bbl d, whp, l -
h d h, ll whh b h hlg h b/l
wh h hlp h Sp.
Sl lg d pyhhpy wk lly wh l-hlg
p d wh h ll (.g., hp ll, -
phy), whh hlg wld d h mm
—h , g lbl ll h, l, gdl h
pl lhp wh Gd. Ch-dd lg d pyh-
hpy l k h l hp p, b wh
wkg wh Ch, l l wk wh h dp -
h wh Ch.
T mm. Ch l bl h bl gh b -d, b “Gd g bgh d lg h
wh h l h” (Cll, 977, p. 5). Fg
lg bld g bl hpp d hp dy d hlp
h p wh p d p g, wh h dg
lg bd l lly g d gl.
Sy. T gg ly y h hp
lbl Ch lg pyhhpy, whh -
dd dd, bl “ w d.” (F lb,
Jh, 007, p; C & Hll, 00). E hgh w h h Bbl,
ly Gd kw lly wh Ch-dd lg pyhhpy
lk lk, h db ll h dl wll y d-
bly d ly ll h Gd’ ddg. Sh wll
b h bk. Nhl, bg gh h
ph dl Ch-d d Ch-
dd hpy . Eh hp qly Ch pph lg wh Ch, d h lz Sp, Gd’
p d l h q hp h fw
Ch d wh h.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 21/41
Fw 5
Lay and Pastoral Models of People-Helping
O p d . O h bk’ bl -
h l hdl wh dy ld b lld Chly pl dl ppl-hlpg ( p )—h , dl
dlpd by Ch ly ppl d -
py pyhlgl hy, h hd d ll p. A
l, h d h d b h
dl, ldg l d xggd l, p hlgy d
g, d h pbl h d by d xpd
ly ppl wkg pbl byd h p.
h llg d d g. A h
, h l b p d h h
kd dl.
1. T h hy h h hh, d b Ch-
d Hly Sp–dpd bh, d ly Sp
h py pyhlgy, k lkly h hy ly
Ch-dd d f dly Ch hd l
hlg. T l hld w h yph Ch-
h ld. Idd, y b h h Ch-dd
dl b dlpd by h wh w d d -
lzd by py l pyhlgy.
2. S h dl h b pd lly ( l -
dlly) h Ch y dd— xpl,
hlg py (Sd, 947) d bbll lg (Ad, 970).
F h , p h dl h b pd - h.
3. T ly g h dl hl, d bw
h d h dl ld by Ch d -
py pyhlgy, d h ly x d
d ll kd hh. Php h , d-
lyg Ch hp ppl wk h.
. T b ly lg wll dd. T hld ld
l hyph gdg Ch ly pl dl
ppl-hlpg, whh h gh b d.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 22/41
6 ransormative Encounters
. yl (985) h gd h pyhlgy h b bd
ld h xp (ly pyhlgy) b ld. Ohw,
h pyhlgy k ly dg h l ( hp-pd h hydy bh). T lg ppl -
dl ppl-hlpg d hld h g
h ly d pl dl.
I lgh h d, Ch d py py-
hlgy hld glly d h lly l-dlpd Ch
ppl-hlpg dl h h gd h g h hh
bj why g. A hy bjd pl ,h pbl wll b dd d ld, bd dl wll b -
jd, d gly phd d , dly Ch
hq d dl lg d pyhhpy wll b dlpd.
Investigating Christian-accommodated and
Christian-derived Counseling and Psychotherapy
T ld php h pg d Ch lg d
pyhhpy h dy. pph G. K. Ch, Ch-
dd lg d pyhhpy h b gd d d
wg; h b gd. I dd, h dd
Ch-d lg d pyhhphy ( Whg,
Jh, Hk & A, p). Nw h d h l
wh h hgh pl dd d hw hy p l
dl. Fh dw h d, wll b y whh dl wk
b wh whh kd ppl (dl hp) d whh kd dd (p hp). I wld b wdl q h
bk p h g h d
y ll h dl d wh h pg.
References and Recommended Resources
Ad, J. (970). Cm . Gd Rpd: Zd.
Ag. (958). C G (G. G. Wlh, S. J., D. B. Z, S. J., G. Mh,
O. S. U., & D. J. H, .). Nw Yk: Ig.Cl, J. (960). I C (F. L. Bl, .). Phl-
dlph: W. (Ogl wk pblhd 559.)
C, J. H., & Hll, . W. (00). P S: C m-
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 23/41
Fw 7
. Dw G, IL: IVy P.
Cll, G. R. (977). T b : A
C . Wh, IL: ydl.E, C. S. (989). Wm m : A C
. Gd Rpd: Bk.
Jh, E. L. (007). F : A C .
Dw G, IL: IVy P.
Jh, E. L. ( p). R : T
C . Dw G, IL: IVy P.
Kkgd, S. (990). F -xm. J v! (H. V. Hg &
E. H. Hg, .). P, NJ: P Uy P.Kyp, A. (898). E : I . Nw Yk: Chl
Sb’ S.
Rb, R. C., & W, P. J. (00). A Ch pyhlgy w. I E. L. Jh
(Ed.), P C: Fv vw (pp. 49-78). Dw G, IL:
IVy P.
Sd, A. (947). T . S. Pl, MN: Ml Pk.
Spp, F. (Ed.). (977). T . Ub, IL: Uy
Ill P.yl, C. (985). Hm : P 1. Nw Yk:
Cbdg Uy P.
W, P. J., M, R. J., Ly, ., Hk, M. B., & Gzzl, S. (007). Bl
b : Adp pl lhp wh lg , l-
, d h , dpd d x l. E:
J S C P, 1(), 57-65.
Whg, E. L., J., Jh, E. L., Hk, J. N., & A, J. D. (Ed.). ( p).
Ev-b C . DwG, IL: IVy P.
Whg, E. L., J., Jh, E. L., Hk, J. N., & A, J. D. (hg).
Ed-bd p lgh h Ch d(): Rf d
d. I E. L. Whg, E. L. Jh, J. N. Hk & J. D. A
(Ed.). Ev-b C .
Dw G, IL: IVy P.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 24/41
1
Introduction
The Call to Transformational Living
David W Appleb & George Ohlschlager
G m w H m w H v.
A w H v C m, .
Hv C m w —
v m q.
Joni Eareckson Tada, he Popular Encyclopediao Christian Counseling
Bg (0) ll h y h A p wh kd
A Eppl p dg glbl y , “Why d y ppl h dd y hh?” A h phl
d fbbgd p h A l, h A p
d b , “J dd. T pl dd. W d. Why d’ y?
D’ y bl l? T why w dg y A-
A h dy— bl y lg
pl Gd.”
Tgh h h wd bg d h dd,
w bh kw ppl wh h wd h l. Nw,
y y, hy ll h wh w d wd. W bh bl
h l-wkg Gd, bl h dh wh pl wd h
w l pl—bl, , yhg hg.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 25/41
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 26/41
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 27/41
ransormative Encounters
Gd . Y wll g h h h Gd d
h Gd h, , d p wy h h w’ l h
. F h g .
Toward Spiritual Transformation
mv E db ph g -
l pl d h h b hw k
d h l Ch bl. T bk h d d-
dly Ch pph h dlpg h p-
ly d lg h h w g lg d pyh-
hpy. T hl fg l hlh
Pyhdy, Bh, H, Mlll, d Rlg
Fh d Sply. W wll x pl d -
h, hgh h pl wk Gd J Ch, h p-
dd hg.
T bk ll d pl p d ll h -
d h wy h Gd l by h y dl Ch
lg, d pl ld h bk. I hw hw Gd d hl, d, d d p hl h l
h wh ly k h. I h, w wll l hw Gd hw p d
p h l kg bl lg d pl ,
wll hg, dplg d l .
I h bk w d h h d bl’ pl l—
d dg l-hgg Ch lg, pl d
pl — h p Ch, wh d by h Fh d
d l h d d by h Hly Sp. M, w h
h l bbll p , h ll, dp d gl-
h h h ly l d pyhlgy (w
h E Jh, h wd h bk, gl
“”). S h, wh w d wk
d d h l bg b lg hg, Gd
dwll d . H bld bg b l, pyh-
pl hg h h y p l. T hg l Gd-pd gly, b xpd ly h h
d w d l g ll pl y, ll
hlg d y.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 28/41
I
W h d h y b ll p, pl
l, h, h d l xp Ch
lg, pl d d pl y h wh hg, bl y Ch hy p . W d b-
l x pl/ll d pl/ly dl hg d
gwh—wy dg Ch lg dl by h wh
dg hgh-p d Sp-pd wk wh h d.
W h ddd h wy-w hp : ()
py, hlg d pw d ply h hh; ()
hlpg pdg p h hh l; () h b p-
pld dl pl-ll Ch lg
pl; d (4) h dlp plly-d, gh-
bd dl (pg p h y dl)
wy--y Ch gg. Flly, h ppdx pp
h d d gwg h Ch y p d
wh w d dd d p gh lg d
d l l-d.
Against the Flow
W gz h h bk h h d d -
lzg d A l dy. W ly
wg p g -qkg fw d d
pd wld h p wh q ly -
l h d h ly Gd d d y -
d pl . Lk llg Ch
lg d y, w l d wk h dl bdy h
bh h hd (whl jg d p-
) d h Gd wh bk h l wld, ly zg
h wld d h lw by whh p pl hg
by l .
T gg, l/pl lhp, d h bb d fw
h l, l p ky g pp h bk. W
bl h Ch lg hld b bh d p-l , pg h b dg h ll
d bg wllg b ll l pl g. Y w l
hld h ld h b Gd h Bbl. W w h
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 29/41
4 ransormative Encounters
h bg wh dg p, whh
h ly h hg h b plly p ly x. W j
h ppp h h l wld ll h h , d h Gd h l h hld h d h
(Cl & Ohlhlg, 00).
W h l b hghly ld by Gy Cll’ l
x Rb P (977). Cllg bbll d h-
wldw whby “Gd x d h ll h,”
Cll g “ w d” p whh bld Ch
lg d pyhlgy. Cll l pp h h Bbl b h
b ll dl d wldw dlp, hg h h
l ld wld p b whh hld b h
p y Ch pg ly Gd-d
dl lg pl —plly h dg
“Ch-dd” lg (Jh, Whg, Hk & A,
p; l wd).
Al p bldg “ld lhp” wh h Gd ll -
h ddg gll by l wk dRb Hdg (004) hllgg h l hlh y -
p lg dy dp ll h lly pd by
h p. T ddg hld b bl b h-
zg, b d h xpl bw Gd d bl.
H ll p “ wldw h llw xpl
ddg h d” (p. 5), gzg h gll Ch-
w h wld hllly, g h pl d h l
wld bg w d h . D y h w dy
ph h bdy h? W .
Y y h ldy ldd h w l h bl h
A p pg y h h A l. Idd, w
d ly wh h b l, w w pp h—
Gd lg h wy. W w kw h Gd xp-
lly h h pdlly hd by wh
d g. W w h h bkg d g ld d x h h d w. A J gh h Ld’
Py, w w h kgd d h wll b d h
h (M 6:0).
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 30/41
I 5
M h wld h h “p,” lk S Cl
d h E By, wll d w g d g dd. Wll, h w
wll gd d y wll dd. Nhl, w ll bl h Gd l, Gd wh ly p lhp—
p--p y w wh h O wh l
byd wd.
W g wh DM ( d Bh, 007), wh y h h
p bw bbll hgh d ll h -
bl, wh w y d hw w kw d wh w kw. T
bl p . Bbll hgh h hg
d wh l pd hgh. Whl w g y
hg b gl l d dy (
g), wh pl l Ch, bl d
bl g h h h
whh ld.
Apg Gd’ g h d d g g h
h lwy b h gl wkg wh bd d hpl l
(bh Ch d bl) wh gd dw by dd, by lg z, by hg g, by lh d ddg p,
by zy-kg, wk lg wh pbl dd. I -
l w h pw hg h l d d -
l phl, h h h p. Gd l bl
plh h hg, d h hl d h hw
p d b h pl l. W hpl h h
dl d l wll y hlpg h hpl d xhd
d bld wl h Fh’ lg .
M . O w d ly l hh
g bd w w h hldy l Vg: “My y h
g wh J Ch h Nw Y.” W wld
j d xd h hp bl d bl lk, h
ly d h l-hgg w h h p
Gd. E wh h lg Gd, plly hy q
d xpd, ll xpdly w l, y yg gwh d y hy
Gd’ kgd.
Nhl, h bk w d h l pp gg -
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 31/41
6 ransormative Encounters
l, p, hh , ll p, d d d-
-g h b wk h wh dg h kd Ch-
d y—g Gd p h hlpg y d wy h wk l hg. W d p-
wh hlly xp Gd hw p h d h -
lg pl , hlp wh ly Gd h l
h l, gdl bh h ll hy hlpg dl, d
whh Gd ld xplly plly. T h hllg
ll bl h Gd wll hl d h
hld wh h d hl d wll yhg d h.
M h b h bk y wll kw, ldg
h b ld wy--y y h hh
d p h ll . Oh dg hl d
h wk y h . S hp y hd-,
whl h hl, hlgl h d. F-
h, h ld h pl d h dl,
h hllg g d d h ldg h, d ll h
p h wll-d d b-d dl ll d p-l p. All b hllg p, dlp d
h h by yg, “Wh w p h d Gd h Fh,
Ch d h Hly Sp h , wh h kd l,
g h kd pbl h dlpl g, h zg
hg hpp.”
Ey b w hllgd ld d
wh Gd w d hw p d bg hg. W
d hg Gd-fd hg bl, bh
h d l gg k whlg
dl h dld g g y h pd —
h w . T hg h l, hg
h wld h k y h y ld h b
gd ll, b w plhd wh Gd’ hlp h h
. Ey b l wh hpp wh Gd d
bk l wld d bg hly l d whppd d wy ppl. W hp h y y wll d yl, d
xp yl, wh ld h, d wll dp h
hp y w l wk.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 32/41
I 7
F b. A w bg wk hgh h
dl h pd h bk, h h h -
p b. Kwg d pg h -f hw lly h dl y b d.
Y v G m kw m. Chg
whp hdlg h h Gd wld b w . S
y Ch w bl d gg d d
Gd, y dlz hdlg h h
pbly. R, “” hlgy, py d lg wk
l h w p lg Gd. T hg
dk d h w pl Gd h h wll lwy
l d d wh w w h d. S l b dbly l:
Rdg h p l h w hp wll lwy pd
dd p w’ wk d h whl p h bk. A
Ch w d p l h jp b
ly d hllgd. A g h h dl h
wh Gd hgh ply pg pd l.
T dl h w b Gd d wk-d lgh h hgh k bg bd by kg Ch b h
d bw lg d h dly ly
d. T pl d h, h, Gd p d w l
p b gh by h. Tlg Mhl H (0),
l C , p h Gd k h
d dw . W d g p h. “O h dl -
, bdg d p. W lk gd w g h
h h Gd wh lly h” (p. 6).
G b m . I d h
ll h w l w l d h l h, w
k gd w l d g. Wh gd w d, h
Gd h Bbl. Wh Gd hw p p g l, w
y d Gd w h g bg dy h ky, dlg
pl d bk d ll 4/7 b. S
g h w bl h h p h l hdwk d py, h w hw d h p. W,
wh h d’ hl w d, w bl h—-
g h bg g d lg.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 33/41
8 ransormative Encounters
Sm v w G. N d h
h l d h hllg. T wh h
ld b bly l-l, wh dply d -h yl, h ld h g h ld ly p d
w. g Gd k j b h bj h
h hgd (lhgh h hg d gh d dy). I
Gd hl wh d wh h g p g p h
h l h. Ig h lg Gd d hw hl d h
lg ld k h l-hgg k. Wh dlgh
wk wh wh yld d pd d pld wh h
l d jy h Gd bg.
G’ m mk . O h -
blg h h wy Ch h y g—hw g
pd h y kw Gd dply pbl.
Sd gly, h xp g p l k
Gd dply h yhg l. Wh hg gg wll, w y
hk h, b w lx d d k Gd yhg
dply h h. Y wh hg gg wll—plly whl k—w h k Gd p l h
whh h . T py Pl 5 p:
Yl , d h y ,
F I dl d d.
T bl y h h lgd;
Bg y d!
Lk y d y p,
Ad g ll y .
Cd y , hy y;
Ad hy h wh l hd.
Kp y l, d dl ;
L b hd, I p y Y.
L gy d pgh p ,
F I w Y. (P 5:6- nv)
Smm G k w b b . Yldg Gd y dg h g d d “p h
p” w lh p. Ad wh w h x-
hd d py, w l h Gd hl bl l h
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 34/41
I 9
wh ll h, d, l d gh; d l h w
l l (M :7-40). Rgdg h hg p
gwh, Jh h Bp xld wh dbl - g: “H [J] , b I d” (J :0 nv).
P l h h y P 5:5-7: “All y, lh yl wh
hly wd h, b, ‘Gd pp h pd b
hw h hbl.’ Hbl yl, h, d Gd’
ghy hd, h h y l y p d . C ll y xy
h b h y.”
Maturing Spiritually in the Five Domains of Living
T py d by whh w l d dd h
dlp. T ld dy, g, , lhp d b-
h d. Ah, h wy g db w I m,
w I k, w I , w I v d w I . Hw w w h d-
fd by lhp wh Gd; whh w h
ly whh w . O gl ll wlk kgd l, l
h ld h y gdly . T l ld by “pg h ld ” wh dd d h, d “pg h
w ” Ch ( Cl :9-0). T h bd l h Gd
p ll wh k.
Iy. Chgd dy fw h hgd whp.
T Ch lg h h w; h wh h yldd h ll
w blg Gd. “D y kw h y bd pl h
Hly Sp, wh y, wh y h d Gd? Y
y w; y w bgh p. T h Gd wh y bd”
( C 6:9-0). W lld l h “w ” “w w” wh
dd by, d Ch, d phd wh h hly bld.
O w dy Ch l f w zhp. “O -
zhp h. Ad w gly w S h, h Ld
J Ch, wh, by h pw h bl h bg yhg d
h l, wll lwly bd h hy wll b lk h
gl bdy” (Phl :0-). T hly zhp wh llw bldly h h g (Hb 4:6) p Kg h
hly yhg— h whh pbl
d w.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 35/41
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 36/41
I 4
A l, Gd p yhg—h lgh p dply
h dk—d w g w y by whh d k
w l h Sp. Af. T w hd h wh l
h lll, g hg. I l l. Ezkl 6:6-7
y “I wll g y w h d p w p y; I wll
y y h d g y h fh. Ad I wll p y
Sp y d y llw y d d b l kp y
lw.” Wh h w w bl l h hg h Gd l.
S d wll d.
Hw, hg h hgd lly w l. T whh
bk h h w bk . T hg h h j l
ll wh jg. T hg h h p l -
f p p . O wll l p wh h
b h pl h pl llw h b lgd wh
Gd’ h. Ad h w bl phz dply wh h
h bh d h wld .
Cy lgdg d h hh g , wg l l pdbl d llbl, w gly
h l. I , w bl h h p
bk hh hy w Jh Edwd’ l C
R Af (746). H bld h dp lhp wh h
lg Gd hd b d lg p by ’ l l—p
g l bd, h Gd w lgh wk.
Wh g l h, Gd ly
bk wh d p d ly pld by h dl h dw
d lly l l.
Rp. W hdwd lhp, d ll w , d d
b bddd lhp. Gd , -
lg h h l lhp wh hl Fh, S d
Sp. T, by dg , Gd h l d lly
wh hl, d wh h ppl wh p h glbl/l ly.
Rl :7 y, “Wh h , l h h wh h Sp y h hh. h wh , I wll g h hdd
. I wll l g h p wh wh w w
, kw ly h wh .”
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 37/41
4 ransormative Encounters
N h Sp ly pk dy, b l pk
ly lhp, h dl ll ll gp lhp,
d dp y bw h d h d. I l ly g hd w ly h glbl p. I
Mhw :46-50 dd h
Whl J w ll lkg h wd, h h d bh d
d, wg pk h. S ld h, “Y h d
bh dg d, wg pk y.” H pld h,
“Wh y h, d wh y bh?” Pg h dpl, h
d, “H y h d y bh. F wh d h wll y
Fh h y bh d d h.”
Hbw : gg h hg. “Bh h wh k ppl
hly d h wh d hly h ly. S J
hd ll h bh d .” Ey h
pl wh Gd’ l gd h lg ly
Eh—Gd’ kgd ly, glbl pl y h ld by
h S, J Ch. Ad h Ch ppg h ppl
h — g wddg d h h h pl
Jl. h —h dy h pl—
g yy. Nhl, h Sp l p
h l lhp bw Ch d h bd, h
wldwd hh.
I jg Gd’ ly by h, w bg d lly h
dl wy. O py lhp bg hd
h dd p fh d bld, l d, h dd p h f h Hly Sp. T
hg ply h d h h pl b -
d, bh h xp l d y gdly h
. I “w l,” w g
w dy, w bg “ Ch” d w ly whh l h
wd l.
B. I bh, ldg hw w d hpy y,
l d? Y h y d wd, y h pld
d y ly g hgd wh ly hgg hw y
bh. W bly f h pbl h w (Mk 4:-4),
h w y d (d l) g h
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 38/41
I 4
wh w pld wh h d Gd. W bly kwldg,
plly h “l dy,” h y “d” Ch h wld
wll h h yg dy h Gd wld ll h hy hd byd d pd h ll.
Y hgd h hld l f hgd bh; h gwg
Ch lk d lk Ch hl. W llw
Gd lwy kg gg, lh p
hd. F h wh b l d dlgh Gd, h
pl h p hg hw w
l l, ply d ply, h
hh, d h . S d gwh
y d hg wh w d d y, w d “p ”
w Ch. M, h pp d, l
f hw w l d h ppl h Gd bg
hlg d gwh.
Where Is Christian Counseling Going?
W kw h h Hly Sp p g Ch -lg. H p—ywh, ll h , hl h -
d O. H l h d h ll g—h -
O—wkg d hgh bh h hp d h l.
Wh d, h hd b h y lwy wkg ghly
h hlpg lhp. H d b h l p h wk
h hp h/h p bg hlg d d h
l. H h y h l b h l h l
d d h h l b wh h h h
bdg (Zd, 004).
C L p . A Ch hp (
ppd l l, d Ch wh d hpy
wh Gd) w k bg h whl hp p
d h Ldhp J Ch (Jh, 997). T, w bl,
l dlpg d wkg g l py-
hlgy. w j q llw h dd wldw.F, w dlg pph Gd d dy h Sp
bh h d p Gd’ hlg dg. A l
ppp ppl, l d d h Sp d
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 39/41
44 ransormative Encounters
h hgh Gd dply, kg h l h pl wy h
q p h h h hlp. Sd, h l h
w d wh “plg pyhlgl h d h dpl h Hly Sp” (Zd, 004, p. 5). Zd g
b h l q:
Rh h k, “Hw d I lllly g y g pyhlgy
d l wh Ch d” h p Ch
Hl k, “Hw d h Hly Sp w y g hlp h
l wh h h l?” I Ch Hl, plg
l h dpl h lg Gd h p h
p pbl hl g. (p. 5)
Oy L p . I Ch lg, w
kg Gd h “p,” h bh Gd h h b
bhd , b bhd g—d g d g.
W gw plly w, dldg l d pg
l p wh w y. Slly, w b whl d
wh Gd’ g ; d w q, ydy
. W l ly k Gd p h h
zg wk h Hly Sp, fw ll g d
h l h wh h hlp. I h hppg w
l, h hpp h l l d ph.
Id, y , p Gd g d wk
lk ly dl h y l hp, p p-
y py h bgg d . y
h ld ply g “bbll wldw” d h k p h g h Hly Sp. I’ b w d’ w h
h h; b w d g p
l Gd d k d ly h Hly Sp. (Ag d
y, llbl!) M, y h
b d by y ly lg d dg h -
wk, w h h by d w h lg.
B y y . W d y h
d h dbl wd d y w’ b. O
h p wd g d d p d pph
lg. All , hw, h Gd wh h d
h, bbll Chy. W h b
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 40/41
I 45
y gll, hdx bl, h h hh
d h Agl-Chl; ll h hw p h bj d
h gly bd h bk.O hp h Ch hp, p, d d h
ll p, h wh g xp d h j bgg h -
, wll h h ppy d b h dply l
h d hdlg b d p h fw h
h Gd d h p ll h h h lly d. W
hp h y wll Gd g l h pg, h h ll ll
pkg wd hg y h d b d whp h
O wh bl l wh dh hw g. Ad w hp
h y wll b ld d d dp l w wy,
y wy, Gd w h hllg bgg h p
l h y .
References and Recommended Resources
Bg, P. (0, Jy ). Cg Ch . T Am I:
R O C. Rd <hp://blg.h--./bg/0/0//g-h-/>.
Cl, ., & Ohlhlg, G. (00). Cm C : F
m . Cld Spg: WBk.
Cll, G. R. (977). T b : A
C. Wh, IL: ydl.
DM, G. (Ed.). (007). P : T m G
L. B. Pwd Spg, GA: A V.
Edwd, J. (746). A f. B: S. Kldd . G.
Hdg, D. R. (004). Sply d ppl wh l ll: Dlpg p-
l py d . Fm S, 85, 6-44.
H, M. (0, Db). T gd Gd wh dw: T Gd ld
Ch d wh d ly d. C , 55(),
4-9.
Jh, E. (997). Ch: T Ld pyhlgy. J P T-
, 25(), -7.Jh, E. (Ed.). (00). P C: Fv vw. Dw G,
IL: IVy P.
7/28/2019 Transformative Encounters edited by David W. Appleby and George Ohlschlager
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/transformative-encounters-edited-by-david-w-appleby-and-george-ohlschlager 41/41
46 ransormative Encounters
Jh, E. L., Whg, E. L., J., Hk, J. N., & A, J. D. (hg).
Ed-bd p lgh h Ch d: Rf d
d. I E. L. Whg, E. L. Jh, J. N. Hk & J. D. A(Ed.). Ev-b C .
Dw G, IL: IVy P.
Sd, . (0, Spb). A w g l. C , 56 (8), 48-5.
d, J. E. (0). Fh. I T C (pp. 5-
54). Eg, OR: H H.
Zd, C. (004). T C: -
mv C m. Bdb, PA: Jl’ H.