Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Appendix 10 Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
A10-1
Appendix 10
Traffic Impact
Assessment
(Total No. of pages including blank pages = 46)
* A colour version of this Appendix is available on the digital version of this document
PINE HILL UNIT TRUST ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Appendix 10
Report No. 941/01
A10-2
This page has intentionally been left blank
Pine Hill Unit Trust ABN: 539 499 667 62
Pine Hill Quarry
Traffic Impact Assessment
Prepared by
Constructive Solutions Pty Ltd
September 2016
This page has intentionally been left blank
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
Traffic Impact
Assessment
Prepared for: R.W. Corkery & Co. Pty Limited 62 Hill Street ORANGE NSW 2800
Tel: (02) 6362 5411 Fax: (02) 6361 3622 Email: [email protected]
On behalf of: Pine Hill Unit Trust ABN: 53 949 966 762 48-54 Gilholmes Rd OBERON NSW 2787
Tel: (02) 6335 6273 Fax: (02) 6361 4232 Email: [email protected]
Prepared by: Constructive Solutions Pty Ltd PO Box 1498
TAMWORTH NSW 2340
Tel: (02) 6762 1969 Fax: (02) 6762 1969 Email: [email protected]
September 2016
PINE HILL UNIT TRUST ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
2
This Copyright is included for the protection of this document
COPYRIGHT
© Constructive Solutions Pty Ltd, 2016 and
© Pine Hill Unit Trust, 2016
All intellectual property and copyright reserved.
Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study, research, criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright Act, 1968, no part of this report may be reproduced, transmitted, stored in a retrieval system or adapted in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, plate copying, recording or otherwise) without written permission. Enquiries should be addressed to Constructive Solutions Pty Ltd.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
CONTENTS Page
3
COMMONLY USED ACRONYMS ............................................................................................................. 5
1. INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................. 9
1.1 BACKGROUND ..................................................................................................................... 9
1.2 SCOPE OF REPORT .......................................................................................................... 12
1.3 CONSULTATION ................................................................................................................. 12
2. THE SURROUNDING ROAD NETWORK .................................................................................... 13
2.1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................. 13
2.2 ROADS ................................................................................................................................ 13
2.2.1 Blenheim State Forest Roads ................................................................................. 13
2.2.2 Lowes Mount Road ................................................................................................. 15
2.3 INTERSECTIONS ................................................................................................................ 16
2.3.1 Project Site / Quarry Access Road ......................................................................... 16
2.3.2 Black Bullock Track / Lowes Mount Road Intersection ........................................... 17
2.4 TRAFFIC VOLUMES ........................................................................................................... 20
2.4.1 Current and Forecast Traffic Volumes .................................................................... 21
2.4.2 Quarry Operational Traffic....................................................................................... 21
2.5 ACCIDENT (CRASH) DATA & QUARRY INCIDENT RECORDS ....................................... 22
2.6 SIDRA INTERSECTION ANALYSIS ................................................................................... 22
3. ASSESSMENT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................................... 24
3.1 ROADS ................................................................................................................................ 24
3.1.1 Blenheim State Forest Roads ................................................................................. 24
3.1.2 Lowes Mount Road ................................................................................................. 26
3.2 INTERSECTIONS ................................................................................................................ 27
3.2.1 Project Site / Quarry Access Road ......................................................................... 27
3.2.2 Black Bullock Track / Lowes Mount Road Intersection ........................................... 27
3.3 DRIVERS AND HEAVY VEHICLES .................................................................................... 28
3.4 SCHOOL BUS SERVICES .................................................................................................. 28
3.5 PEDESTRIAN AND CYCLIST ACTIVITY ............................................................................ 28
3.6 CUMULATIVE TRAFFIC IMPACTS..................................................................................... 28
3.7 MITIGATION SUMMARY ..................................................................................................... 29
4. REFERENCES ............................................................................................................................... 30
............................................................................................................................................ 31
ANNEXURE A LOWES MOUNT ROAD – TRAFFIC COUNTS .................................................... 33
ANNEXURE B EXTRACT FROM THE QUEENSLAND FORESTRY ROADING MANUAL (2014) ................................................................................................................................ 37
PINE HILL UNIT TRUST ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
4
TABLES
Table 1 Turn Treatment Lengths .............................................................................................................. 18
Table 2 Estimated Sight Distances for Turn Manoeuvres ........................................................................ 20
Table 3 Existing and Forecast (Year 10) Traffic Volumes ........................................................................ 21
Table 4 Forecast Maximum Quarry-Related Daily Traffic Movements .................................................... 22
Table 5 Quarry Operation (Maximum), Current Traffic and Combined Traffic Volumes .......................... 22
Table 6 Quarry Operation(maximum), Forecast Traffic (Year 2026) and Combined Traffic Volumes ............................................................................................................................. 22
Table 7 Summary of Mitigation Measures ................................................................................................ 29 FIGURES
Figure 1 - Locality Plan ............................................................................................................................. 10
Figure 2 – Proposed Layout and Access ................................................................................................. 11
Figure 3 – BAL Intersection Treatment .................................................................................................... 19
Figure 4 – Crash Data .............................................................................................................................. 23
Figure 5 – Proposed Quarry Access Road Formation ............................................................................. 25
Figure 6 - Truck Warning Sign ................................................................................................................. 26
Figure 7 – T Intersection Warning Sign .................................................................................................... 26 PLATES
Plate 1 – Black Bullock Track ................................................................................................................... 13
Plate 2 - Glenmore Road .......................................................................................................................... 14
Plate 3 – Former Fire Trail ....................................................................................................................... 15
Plate 4 – Lowes Mount Road ................................................................................................................... 16
Plate 5 – Proposed Quarry Access to the Quarry Access Road .............................................................. 17
Plate 6 – Lowes Mount Road/Black Bullock Track Intersection ............................................................... 18
Plate 7 - Property Access on Lowes Mount Road south of the Intersection ............................................ 18
Plate 8 - Sight distance to the north along Lowes Mount Road ............................................................... 20
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
5
COMMONLY USED ACRONYMS
AADT Average Annual Daily Traffic
AUL
BAL
BAR
BB
CHL
Auxiliary left turn lane
Basic left turn lane
Basic right turn lane
Double unbroken lines
Channelised left turn lane
CHR Channelised right turn lane
DoS
LoS
MR
RMS
SIDRA
TMP
Degree of Saturation
Level of Service
Main Road
Roads and Maritime Services
Signalised and un-signalised Intersection Design and Research Aid
Traffic Management Plan
PINE HILL UNIT TRUST ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
6
This page has intentionally been left blank
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
7
Executive Summary This Traffic Impact Assessment (TIA) has been prepared for R.W. Corkery & Co. Pty Limited
on behalf of The Pine Hill Unit Trust to assess traffic-related impacts of the proposed Pine Hill
Quarry (the Proposal). The report has been prepared to support an Environmental Impact
Statement (EIS) for the Proposal.
The Pine Hill Unit Trust (the Applicant) propose to develop a quarry on Lot 267 DP 757068 of
the “Pine Hill” property (“the property”) to supply gravel materials for road sheeting, road base
and other construction projects in the local area. The property is located in between two
sections of Blenheim State Forest (SF), approximately 5.5km north of Oberon, via Lowes
Mount Road and Gilholmes Road. The Applicant proposes to haul quarry products between
the Quarry and Lowes Mount Road using roads within the Blenheim SF.
The TIA has been prepared in accordance with the NSW Roads and Traffic Authority’s (RTA)
(2002) Guide to Traffic Generating Developments (now Roads and Maritime Services), the
Austroads Road Design Guide, and addresses relevant matters raised by the RMS and the
Oberon Council in their contribution to the Secretary’s Environmental Assessment
Requirements (SEARs) for the Proposal.
The scope of the TIA is to address traffic-related impacts on the existing access road within the
Blenheim SF and the intersection with Lowes Mount Road, in accordance with the RTA’s
Guide to Traffic Generating Developments, and the specific matters nominated by the Oberon
Council.
An appreciation of the existing traffic situation on local roads to be accessed by the proposed
development was gained by examining the existing road network, reviewing recent traffic
volumes on the existing road network and liaising with relevant stakeholders. These aspects
are discussed in this TIA.
A range of mitigation measures have been identified to accommodate the traffic generated by
the Proposal. If the mitigation measures proposed are successfully implemented, it is
anticipated that the impacts to traffic and other road users would be successfully mitigated.
PINE HILL UNIT TRUST ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
8
This page has intentionally been left blank
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
9
1. I N T RO D U C TI ON
1.1 BACKGROUND
The Pine Hill Unit Trust (the Applicant) propose to develop a quarry on Lot 267 DP 757068 of the “Pine Hill” property (“the property”) to supply gravel materials for road sheeting, road base and other construction projects in the local area. The property is located in between two sections of Blenheim State Forest (SF), approximately 5.5km north of Oberon, via Lowes Mount Road and Gilholmes Road (refer Figure 1).
The location of the proposed Pine Hill Quarry (“the Quarry”), which would encompass a final area of approximately 4.5ha, occurs at the southern boundary of “Pine Hill” property on Lot 267 DP 757068 with Blenheim SF (referred to as the Project Site, see Figure 2).
The Applicant proposes to haul quarry products between the Project Site and Lowes Mount Road using roads within the Blenheim SF. The alignment of the preferred route of the “Quarry Access Road” through Blenheim SF is identified in Figure 2.
This Traffic Impact Assessment (TIA) has been prepared in accordance with the NSW Roads
and Traffic Authority’s (RTA) (2002) Guide to Traffic Generating Developments (now Roads
and Maritime Services), the Austroads Road Design Guide, and addresses relevant matters
raised by the RMS and the Oberon Council in their contribution to the Secretary’s
Environmental Assessment Requirements (SEARs) for the Proposal.
The scope of the TIA is to address traffic-related impacts on the existing access road in the
Blenheim SF and the intersection with Lowes Mount Road, in accordance with the RTA’s
Guide to Traffic Generating Developments, and the specific matters nominated by the Oberon
Council.
An appreciation of the existing traffic situation around the Project Site was gained by
examining the existing road network, reviewing recent traffic volumes on the existing road
network and liaising with relevant stakeholders. These aspects are discussed in this TIA.
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
10
Figure 1 - Locality Plan
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
11
Figure 2 – Proposed Layout and Access
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
12
1.2 SCOPE OF REPORT
This TIA has been prepared to support an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the
Proposal for the Pine Hill Quarry, prepared by R.W. Corkery & Co. Pty Limited, in accordance
with Part 4 of the Environmental Planning & Assessment Act 1979 (EP&A Act). The TIA
assesses the traffic-related impacts of the Proposal on the surrounding road network that
would be affected over the life of the Proposal. This report assesses traffic-related impacts in
accordance with the RTA’s Guide to Traffic Generating Developments, and the specific
matters nominated by the RMS and the Oberon Council.
1.3 CONSULTATION
Consultation with the Oberon Council, has been undertaken and is detailed below.
The Works and Engineering Director, Mr Chris Schumacher, was consulted during a site
meeting at Lowes Mount Road on 26 April 2016, and subsequently in June 2016. A summary
of Council’s concerns that should be addressed in the traffic assessment are provided below.
That the proposed access does not impact on the safety of road users on Lowes
Mount Road, including the school bus.
That there is sufficient sight distance from the proposed access along Lowes
Mount.
The standard of the intersection of the existing access road in the Blenheim SF
and Lowes Mount Road.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
13
2. T H E S U R RO UN D I NG R O AD N E T W OR K
2.1 INTRODUCTION
The Applicant proposes to haul quarry products between the Project Site and Lowes Mount
Road via a Quarry Access Road which utilises roads within the Blenheim SF. The alignment of
the preferred route through Blenheim SF is identified in Figure 2.
2.2 ROADS
2.2.1 Blenheim State Forest Roads
The roads of Blenheim SF to be incorporated into the Quarry Access Road include Black
Bullock Track, Glenmore Road and a section of former fire trail from Glenmore Road to the
northern boundary of Blenheim SF / Project Site access point (see Figure 2).
Black Bullock Track and Glenmore Road are formed access tracks that are used for forestry
operations including planting, weed spraying and logging, as well as occasional public access
for recreational purposes. These tracks are typically approximately 6.0m wide or greater
between side drains, where they exist (see Plates 1 and 2).
Plate 1 – Black Bullock Track
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
14
Plate 2 - Glenmore Road
The existing forest roads are a low speed environment (60km/h or less).
The final 100m section of the Quarry Access Road, between Glenmore Road and the Project
Site, follows a former fire trail separating plantation pine (west) from a patch of remnant native
forest (east) (see Plate 3). There is currently no road formation with construction required to
allow access between Glenmore Road and the Project Site.
The topography falls to the west, however as the alignment of this section of road occurs along
the top of a natural ridge line, there is only limited natural drainage to the west.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
15
Plate 3 – Former Fire Trail
2.2.2 Lowes Mount Road
Lowes Mount Road is a local road that provides a north-south road link between Oberon to the
south and Tarana (via Mutton Falls Road) to the north. Lowes Mount Road, adjacent to the
intersection with the Black Bullock Track, consists of a sealed surface that varies from 6.6m
wide to the north of the intersection, to 6.8m wide to the south of the intersection, with no line-
marking and unsealed shoulders each approximately 0.5m wide (see Plate 4). The regulatory
speed limit is 100km/h.
Generally, the pavement is in good condition. No evidence of pavement failure or deterioration
was observed on the road within 200m in each direction of the intersection with the Black
Bullock track. However, there is some evidence on the road surface of potholes that have
previously been repaired. In the vicinity of the Black Bullock Track intersection, delineation on
Lowes Mount Road is provided by guide posts only.
There are two existing property accesses on Lowes Mount Road in the vicinity of the Black
Bullock Track intersection, approximately 23m to the north and south of the intersection.
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
16
Plate 4 – Lowes Mount Road
2.3 INTERSECTIONS
2.3.1 Project Site / Quarry Access Road
The proposed access to the Project Site will form a T intersection with the fire trail section of
the Quarry Access Road (refer Figure 2). This access point (see Plate 5) does not currently
exist and will require design and construction.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
17
Plate 5 – Proposed Quarry Access to the Quarry Access Road
2.3.2 Black Bullock Track / Lowes Mount Road Intersection
This intersection has a T-intersection configuration, with Lowes Mount Road as the priority
road. There are currently no advanced warning signs for the intersection on Lowes Mount
Road. Two property accesses are located approximately 23 metres north and south of the
intersection on the western side of Lowes Mount Road (refer Plate 6 and Plate 7).
The posted speed limit for Lowes Mount Road is 100km/h. The Black Bullock Track is a low
speed environment forest access road (60km/h or less).
The configuration of the intersection is a simple T intersection with no treatments provided for
left or right turn movements in either direction.
It is arguable whether an intersection treatment is currently warranted as the intersecting road
(Black Bullock Track) may be considered to be equivalent to a property access. However, if
the assumption is made that it is a public road, the required configuration of the intersection for
current traffic volumes is Basic Right Turn Treatment (BAR)/Basic Left Turn Treatment (BAL)1.
The associated lengths of the turn treatments and requirements in accordance with Austroads
(2010)1 are shown in Table 1.
1 Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 4A, Figure 4.9.
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
18
Plate 6 – Lowes Mount Road/Black Bullock Track Intersection
Plate 7 - Property Access on Lowes Mount Road south of the Intersection
Table 1 Turn Treatment Lengths
Turn Treatment Lane Actual Length Required
Basic Left Turn Treatment (BAL) 0m 53.0m
Basic Right Turn Treatment (BAR) 0m 117.5m
The layouts of the required BAL and BAR treatments are illustrated in Error! Reference source not found..
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
19
Figure 3 – BAL Intersection Treatment
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
20
The Safe Intersection Sight Distances (SISD) for the intersection in accordance with Austroads (2010) are shown in Table 2. As the required SISD for the existing intersection is not achieved to the north (see Plate 8), the Extended Design Domain (EDD) SISD2 for the intersection is also considered and provided.
Table 2 Estimated Sight Distances for Turn Manoeuvres
Turn Manoeuvre
Estimated Sight Distance Speed Limit (km/h) SISD
SISD (EDD) North South
Left or Right from Black Bullock Track on to Lowes Mount Road
205m 250m 100 234m 208m
Plate 8 - Sight distance to the north along Lowes Mount Road
The following information is provided for the assessment of the EDD SISD in Table 23.
An Observation Time (OT) of 1.5s is appropriate as Lowes Mount Road carries
less than 1 000 vehicles per day (Table A8, p. 178).
There are two sets of EDD SISD calculations provided, one for ‘norm’ base case
and one set for ‘truck’ base case (see p. 179). The ‘truck’ base case is most
appropriate.
Minimum EDD SISD for 100km/hr speed zone is 219m (Table A12, p. 183).
This reduces to 208m on application of a reduction of 11m based on a 4%
gradient on approach (refer Table 3.3, p.22).
2 Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 4A, Table A9.
3 Referenced Tables and page numbers are for the Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 4A.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
21
2.4 TRAFFIC VOLUMES
2.4.1 Current and Forecast Traffic Volumes
Traffic volume data for Lowes Mount Road was obtained from counts undertaken by the
Oberon Council. The count was undertaken in August 2016 utilising a tube counter. No traffic
volume data is available for the Black Bullock Track. The count for Lowes Mount Road is
shown in Table 3. The traffic count data is presented in Annexure A.
Table 3
Existing and Forecast (Year 10) Traffic Volumes
Existing Traffic (2015) Forecast Traffic (2026)
Road Site
Light Vehicle
(LV)
Heavy Vehicle
(HV) Total
Light Vehicle
(LV)
Heavy Vehicle
(HV) Total
Lowes Mount Black Bullock Track Intersection
279 49 328 340 60 400
Black Bullock Track Assumed data 10 2 12 12 3 15
Table 3 summarises the current and estimated forecast traffic levels for Lowes Mount Road.
Forecast growth was extrapolated to 2026, in accordance with RMS requirements to provide
10 year traffic growth projections. An average annual growth estimate of 2% per annum has
been assumed.
2.4.2 Quarry Operational Traffic
Forecast traffic volumes have been calculated for Lowes Mount Road and estimated for the
Black Bullock Track (see Table 3). The following information is provided in relation to vehicle
movements associated with operations of the proposed quarry.
Products would be transported from the Quarry by road registered trucks, with the predominant arrangement being 30t Truck and Dog. Smaller capacity rigid trucks would also be used for some haulage.
Hourly, daily and weekly truck movements would vary, however, the following represents the maximum rates.
8 movements (4 truckloads) per hour.
60 movements (30 truckloads) per day.
300 movements (150 truckloads) per week.
Traffic volumes will generally be less than this, with many weeks where there are no truck
movements.
Expected maximum light and heavy vehicle daily traffic volumes are listed in Table 4 based on
the assumptions outlined above. Note that this is a maximum quarry traffic scenario and not
the average expected daily traffic.
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
22
Table 4
Forecast Maximum Quarry-Related Daily Traffic Movements
LV HV Total
Lowes Mount Road and Black Bullock Track 8 60 68
Current and forecast combined traffic volumes are shown in Table 5 and Table 6 respectively.
Table 5
Quarry Operation (Maximum), Current Traffic and Combined Traffic Volumes
Current Traffic Additional
Quarry Traffic Combined Traffic Combined
Total
Road LV HV LV HV LV HV (LV & HV)
Lowes Mount Road 279 49 8 60 287 109 396
Black Bullock Track 10 2 8 60 18 62 80
Table 6
Quarry Operation(maximum), Forecast Traffic (Year 2026) and Combined Traffic Volumes
Forecast Traffic Additional
Quarry Traffic Combined Traffic Combined
Total
Road LV HV LV HV LV HV (LV & HV)
Lowes Mount Road 340 60 8 60 348 120 468
Black Bullock Track 12 3 8 60 20 63 83
2.5 ACCIDENT (CRASH) DATA & QUARRY INCIDENT RECORDS
Crash data was obtained from the NSW government Centre for Road Safety website. The data
obtained plotted crashes on Lowes Mount Road between 2011 and 2015. The crash data is
provided in Figure 4. The crash data shows that there have been no reported crashes on
Lowes Mount Road, in the vicinity of the proposed access to the quarry at the Black Bullock
Track intersection.
2.6 SIDRA INTERSECTION ANALYSIS
Due to the low existing and forecast traffic volumes on Lowes Mount Road and the Black
Bullock Track, a SIDRA intersection analysis is not required.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
23
Figure 4 – Crash Data
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
24
3. AS S E S SM E N T AN D R E C OM M E N D AT I O NS
The following subsections review the impacts resulting from the anticipated forecast traffic on
the roads of Blenheim SF and associated intersection with Lowes Mount Road. Discussions
relevant to the recommendations for impact mitigation or other controls are also included,
where appropriate.
3.1 ROADS
3.1.1 Blenheim State Forest Roads
The general alignment of the Black Bullock Track and Glenmore Road is considered suitable
for the additional traffic from the proposed Quarry. However the width and pavement of the
roads should be upgraded for the proposed quarry traffic. Forestry Corporation (NSW) has
advised that published standards for forestry roads are not available, and that standards for
road upgrades are considered on a case by case basis. In lieu of a Forestry Corporation
standard, the Queensland Forestry Roading Manual (2014) has been used to determine an
appropriate road standard. An extract from the manual is provided in Annexure B. It is
recommended that the road through the forest is upgraded and maintained in accordance with
Road Standard B of the Queensland Forestry Roading Manual (2014), i.e. a 5.5m wide gravel
pavement over an extended road formation.
It is understood the Applicant is negotiating a commercial agreement with NSW Forestry
Corporation for the use of Blenheim SF roads. This agreement is to include construction,
upgrades and maintenance of the roads to be incorporated into the Quarry Access Road
based on Road Standard B of the Queensland Forestry Roading Manual (2014). Figure 5
presents the indicative cross-sections for the three sections of road which form part of the
Quarry Access Road, namely:
Section 1: Black Bullock Track.
Section 2: Glenmore Rod.
Section 3: Fire Trail.
Further description of the proposed design and maintenance of these sections of the Quarry
Access Road is provided in the EIS for the Proposal (RWC, 2016).
Maintenance including regular watering and grading would be required during haulage.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
25
Figure 5 – Proposed Quarry Access Road Formation
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
26
3.1.2 Lowes Mount Road
The general alignment and typical section of Lowes Mount Road are considered suitable for
the additional traffic of the Proposal.
The approaches along Lowes Mount Road from the north and south toward the Black Bullock
Track intersection require additional warning signs to slow approaching traffic. It is
recommended that truck entering signs (refer Figure 6) and T intersection warning signs
(Refer Figure 7) be erected on Lowes Mount Road on both approaches to the Black Bullock
Track intersection.
Figure 6 - Truck Warning Sign
Figure 7 – T Intersection Warning Sign
Guideposts should be maintained as a priority to ensure there is adequate delineation.
Maintenance of vegetation approaching the intersection will be required to ensure adequate
sight distance is maintained.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
27
3.2 INTERSECTIONS
3.2.1 Project Site / Quarry Access Road
The proposed quarry access will form a T intersection with the constructed section of the
Quarry Access Road (over the former fire trail) (see Figure 2). Access to the Project Site does
not currently exist and requires design and construction. It is understood this will be negotiated
between the Applicant and Forestry Corporation and the proposed design and maintenance of
this section of road is presented in the EIS (RWC, 2016). This includes:
clearance of regrowth pine and other vegetation.
a 6m to 7m formation with 200mm of compacted gravel base.
a 1V:4H fill batter stabilised with grass or equivalent artificial stabilizer.
resheeting and compaction completed of the gravel formation as required (prior
to, during and following each production campaign) (see also Figure 5).
The existing forest road is a low speed environment (60km/h or less). It is recommended that
an unsealed gravel intersection is designed and constructed with geometry suitable for the
turning paths required for the largest heavy vehicle that is expected to access the quarry, and
that safe intersection sight distance of 123m is achieved by clearing of vegetation where
required.
3.2.2 Black Bullock Track / Lowes Mount Road Intersection
The existing intersection is described in section 2.3.2. The required configuration of the
intersection for the estimated future and Quarry traffic volumes is for a BAR/BAL treatment.
(Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 4A, Figure 4.9) The current configuration has no turning
treatments provided and will require upgrading. It is recommended that bitumen sealed
BAR/BAL intersection treatments are designed and constructed to the dimensions provided in
Table 1. It is also recommended that a stop sign be installed on the Black Bullock Track leg of
the intersection.
For the turn manoeuvres utilised by haulage vehicles associated with the proposed Quarry, the
available sight distance of 205m to the north for vehicles turning from the Black Bullock Track
on to Lowes Mount Road is less than the SISD required by Austroads. However, the available
sight distance is within 3 metres of the required SISD when the Austroads provisions for
approach gradient and Extended Design Domain are applied. The sight distance is considered
to be acceptable when considering the following factors.
Intersection and truck turning signs have been recommended on Lowes Mount
Road.
Haulage from the Quarry will be on a campaign basis, meaning that no additional
traffic will be using the road for extended periods of time. Additional temporary
signs, similar to those used during forestry haulage operations, are
recommended for use during haulage.
A driver’s Code of Conduct is recommended that clearly outlines the expectations
of the truck drivers, their responsibility whilst operating the trucks, and the safe
use of the Lowes Mount Road intersection.
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
28
It is also recommended that the location of trees within the road reserve are considered in the
design of the upgraded intersection and any trees that may obstruct sight distance be removed
during construction.
3.3 DRIVERS AND HEAVY VEHICLES
The drivers of heavy vehicles need to be suitably qualified and experienced. Records
pertaining to these requirements need to be kept. In addition, it is recommended that a driver’s
Code of Conduct be developed. The code of conduct will clearly outline the expectations of the
truck drivers, their responsibility whilst operating the trucks and the consequences of not
adhering to a suitable code of conduct.
A suitable system for identifying the weight of loads and the associated Gross Combined Mass
(GCM), Gross Vehicle Mass (GVM) and axle combination limits should also be implemented to
ensure the trucks are not overloaded, which could consequently impact on the associated road
pavements and braking distances. All laden trucks entering or leaving the Quarry need to be
covered to prevent loose materials falling from the truck body.
The above measures should be incorporated into a system of auditable procedures,
inspections and records which can be used to validate compliance with the driver’s Code of
Conduct and inspection regimes.
3.4 SCHOOL BUS SERVICES
There is currently a school bus service along Lowes Mount Road. Currently pick-up and drop-
off occurs at approximately 8:00am and 3:30pm.
It is recommended that liaison with the school bus operator occurs prior to construction and
operations of the proposed Quarry and that any agreed mitigation measures are included in
the driver’s Code of Conduct.
3.5 PEDESTRIAN AND CYCLIST ACTIVITY
There was no pedestrian or cyclist activity witnessed during the site inspection. Given the rural
location and narrow shoulder width the road is generally considered to be unsuitable for
pedestrians and cyclist activity.
If at any time during the life of the Quarry pedestrian and cyclist activity increases,
consideration will need to be given to the available shoulder width, speed limit and potential
other related pedestrian facilities.
3.6 CUMULATIVE TRAFFIC IMPACTS
There are no known cumulative traffic impacts that are likely to affect Lowes Mount Road.
Based on the RMS guidelines, background traffic growth of 2% has been taken into
consideration and Lowes Mount Road is considered to be able to accommodate the estimated
cumulative traffic for the 10 year period considered.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
29
3.7 MITIGATION SUMMARY
A summary of proposed mitigation measures is provided in Table 7 for the Quarry Access
Road and the Lowes Mount Road intersection.
Table 7 Summary of Mitigation Measures
Location Recommendations Responsibility
General A suitable Code of Conduct should be developed for drivers of heavy vehicles including subcontractors where applicable.
The Applicant
All truck loads should be covered to prevent loose materials falling onto the roadway or the creation of excessive dust.
The Applicant
A system for identifying the weights of loads and the associated GCM, GVM and axle combination limits should be implemented to ensure mass limits are not exceeded
The Applicant
Monitor whether any pedestrian and cyclist activity occurs and ensure the requirements in the Code of Conduct are reinforced.
The Applicant / Oberon Council
Lowes Mount Road
Install truck entering signs on Lowes Mount Road on both approaches to the Black Bullock Track intersection.
The Applicant / Oberon Council
Install intersection warning signs on Lowes Mount Road on both approaches to the Black Bullock Track intersection.
The Applicant / Oberon Council
Ensure delineation is maintained along Lowes Mount Road in liaison with GTCC.
The Applicant / Oberon Council
Quarry Access Road
Upgrade the existing forest access roads in accordance with the standards described in section 3.1.1 of this report.
The Applicant
Regular watering and grading of the road during haulage. The Applicant
Design and construct a suitable access from the proposed quarry to the upgraded forest access road.
The Applicant
Quarry Access Road / Lowes Mount Road Intersection
Upgrade the existing T intersection to provide bitumen sealed BAR/BAL turning treatments in accordance with Austroads 2010
The Applicant / Oberon Council
The location of trees within the road reserve are considered in the design of the upgraded intersection and any trees that may obstruct sight distance removed during construction.
The Applicant / Oberon Council
Install a stop sign at the Black Bullock Road leg of the upgraded intersection.
The Applicant / Oberon Council
Include the requirement for all truck drivers to stop at the stop sign on the Quarry Access Road before entering Lowes Mount Road within the driver’s Code of Conduct and visually monitor driver behaviour and encourage compliance with the intersection controls.
The Applicant
Liaise regularly with the school bus operator to ensure any issues are included and addressed in the driver’s Code of Conduct.
The Applicant
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
30
4. R E F E RE N C ES
Austroads (2010) Guide to Road Design – Part 4A: Un-signalised and Signalised
Intersections.
Roads and Traffic Authority (RTA) (2002). Guide to Traffic Generating Developments.
RW Corkery & Co. Pty Limited (2016). Environmental Impact Statement for the
Proposed Pine Hill Quarry. Prepared on behalf of Pine Hill Unit Trust.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
31
Annexure A Lowes Mount Road – Traffic Counts
Annexure B Extract from the Queensland Forestry Roading Manual (2014)
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
32
This page has intentionally been left blank
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
33
Annexure A
Lowes Mount Road – Traffic Counts
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
34
This page has intentionally been left blank
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
35
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
36
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
37
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
38
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
37
Annexure B
Extract from the Queensland Forestry
Roading Manual (2014)
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
38
This page has intentionally been left blank
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT PINE HILL UNIT TRUST
Traffic Impact Assessment Pine Hill Quarry
Report No. 941/01
39
Pine Hill Quarry ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
Pine Hill Quarry Traffic Impact Assessment
Report No. 941/01
40