1 of 66

Town of Southampton: Town-owned Historic Cemeteries [revised]

EAST QUOGUE CEMETERY (METHODIST CHURCH) 584 Montauk Highway East Quogue, NY 11942 TM #340-1-52.1 Historic Cemetery Inventory #EQ2 HUBBARD CEMETERY Hubbard Park [Suffolk County] Rte. 24/Red Creek Road Flanders, NY TM #150-1-22 Historic Cemetery Inventory #FL3 SQUIRES [FOURNIER] CEMETERY 142 Red Creek Road Hampton Bays, NY 11946 TM #473689-152-1-9 Historic Cemetery Inventory #HB1 “INDIAN PREACHER”/REV. PAUL CUFFEE GRAVESITE 199 East Montauk Highway Hampton Bays, NY 11946 TM #227-1-11 Historic Cemetery Inventory #HB3 NORTH END BURIAL GROUND 165 Main Street Southampton, NY 11968 TM #904-006-2-1 Historic Cemetery Inventory #SO1

2 of 66

[Town of Southampton: Historic Cemeteries/Town-owned/2] NORTH SEA BURIAL GROUND 16 Millstone Brook Road North Sea (Southampton), NY 11968 TM #473689-077-1-24.1 Historic Cemetery Inventory #NS1 OLD NOYAC BURIAL GROUND 4340 Noyac Road Sag Harbor, NY 11968 TM #473689-019-2-2 Historic Cemetery Inventory #NO2 OLD SOUTHAMPTON BURYING GROUND 205 Little Plains Road Southampton, NY 11968 TM #473605-19-3-32 Historic Cemetery Inventory #SO2 PLEASURE WOODS CEMETERY Golden Leaf Trail Flanders, NY 11901 TM [between] #900-145-5-17.1/19.1 Historic Cemetery Inventory #FL1 WESTHAMPTON CEMETERY (PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH) 90 Meeting House Road Westhampton, NY 11977 TM #370-3-20.1 Historic Cemetery Inventory #QU1

3 of 66

Town of Southampton Historic Cemetery List (As of 8/2004)

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List BRIDGEHAMPTON [3] [3] [4] [1] BR1 Edgewood Cemetery #19742 [+] #86 Edgewood Ave [900-071-2-23] Photos #Edgewood 001-006 BR2 Hayground Cemetery #21339 WA-48[**] [+] #100 Windmill Lane [900-084-1-3.1] Photos #Hayground 001-012 BR3 Bridgehampton BR-19 [+] [+] Cemetery Montauk Hwy/Hull Lane [900-086-2-27.1] Photos #Bridgehampton 001-014 BR4 Mecox Burying Ground #27081 BR-78 [+] #90 Jobs Lane [900-134-1-54] Photos #Mecox 001-005 EAST QUOGUE [2] [1] [3] [1] EQ1 Oakwood Cemetery #41169 [+] #100 Spinney Rd. #41264 [+] [900-288-1-62.1 & 900-288-1-155] Photos #SpinneyRd 001-005

4 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List EQ2 E. Quogue Methodist [T] Cemetery EQ-25 [+] [+] #584 Montauk Hwy [900-340-1-52.1] Photos #EQuogue 001-009 EASTPORT [2] [1] [2] EA1 Tuttle Graveyard #46737 [+] #4 Tuttle Ave. [900-349-2-15.2] Photos #Tuttle 001- 006 EA2 Eastport Cemetery #46741 EA-6 #22 Tuttle Ave [900-349-2-18] Photos #Eastport 001- 013 EA3 Eastport Gospel Church Cemetery #386 Montauk Highway [900-349-2-17] Photos #EastportGospel 001-010 EA4 Hawkins Gravesite [+] #4 South Bay Ave. [900-352-1-2] EA5 Tuttle Gravesite North Bay Ave. [t/b/d] Photos #Tuttle/2 001- 003

5 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List FLANDERS [1] [2] [3] FL1 Pleasure WoodsCemetery [+] [+] [T] #15 & #19 Golden Leaf Trail [900-145-5-17.1 & 900-145-5-19.1] Photos #PleasureWoods 001-005 FL2 Flanders Cemetery #30694 [+] [+] #1377 Flanders Rd. [900-170-1-12] Photos #Flanders 001-013 FL3 Hubbard Cemetery [+] [T] Flanders [County] Park, Rte 24/Red Creek Rd. [900-150-1-22] Photos #Hubbard 001-005 HAMPTON BAYS [5] [1] [3] [2] HB1 Squires/Fournier Burying #29403 [+] [+] [T] Ground #142 Red Creek Rd. [900-152-1-9] Photos #Squires 001-008 HB2 Good Ground Cemetery #69127 HA-3 [+] #13 Cemetery Road & #33237 #99 Riverhead Road [900-223-1-8.3 & 900-205-3-14] Photos #GoodGround 001-008

6 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List HB3 Rev. Paul Cuffee #35655 [+***] [T] Gravesite #199 E. Montauk Hwy. [900-227-1-11] Photos #Cuffee 001- 003 HB4 Cuffee Burial Ground [a/k/a Canoe Place Burial Ground] #35797 [HA-21****] [adj.] #178 Wakeman Rd. [900-229-1-30.1] Photos #CanoePlace 001- 003 [X] “Old Dane’s” Cemetery [+] NORTH HAVEN [1] [*] [5] [1] NH1 Ferry Road Cemetery #1854 [+] [+] #243 Ferry Rd./Rte 114 [901-004-2-82] Photos #NorthHaven 001-012 NH2 Martha Havens Gravesite [+] Ferry Road/Rte 114 [901-005-1-50.6] Photos #Havens 001-003 NH3 Payne Avenue Cemetery [+] off Payne Ave./Fair Oaks Ln. [901-005-1-3] Photos #Payne 001-004

7 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List NH4 Stock Farm Cemetery [+] off Ezekills Hollow Rd. [901-002-3-1.3] Photos #StockFarm 001-003 NH5 William Davall Gravesite off Payne Ave./Fresh Pond Rd. [901-005-1-10.2] Photos #Davall 001-004 NH6 Maycroft Burial Site Ferry Road/Rte 114 [901-006-4-1] Photos #Maycroft 001-003 [X] Indian burial mound/ [+] Rte. 114 NORTH SEA [1] [1] [1] [1] NS1 North Sea Burial #20369 NO-11 [+] [T] Ground #16 Millstone Brook Rd. [900-077-1-24.1] Photos #NorthSea 001- 012 [X] McKeown’s Farm [+] Cemetery adj. Old Rose House NOYAC [3] [2] [2] NO1 Rogers Graveyard #13093 [+] Burkeshire Dr./Rogers Ct. [900-014-1-66.22] Photos #Rogers 001-007

8 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List NO2 Noyac [Edwards] Cem. #13782 [+] [+] [T] #4340 Noyac Rd. [900-019-2-2] Photos #Edwards 001-009 NO3 St. Andrews Cemetery #14389 [+] #1175 Brick Kiln Rd. [900-024-3-58.1] Photos #StAndrews 001-005 NO4 Jessup Burial Ground Morton National Wildlife Refuge Noyac Road [900-002 & 900-003-2-1] Photos #Jessup 001-006] QUIOGUE [1] [1] QU1 Westhampton Presbyterian #50051 [+] [T] Church Cemetery #90 Meeting House Rd. [900-370-3-20.1] Photos #Quiogue 001-008 QUOGUE [1] [*] QU2 Quogue Cemetery #3442 #58 Lamb Ave. [902-008-1-20] Photos #Quogue 001-012 QU3 Davies Gravesite Church of the Atonement #17 Quogue Street [t/b/d] Photos #Davies 001-004

9 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List REMSENBURG/SPEONK [1] [3] [1] RS1 Tuttle Burial Ground #50726 [+] [+] Remsen Lane [900-380-1-95] Photos #Tuttle/3 001- 005 RS2 Remsenburg Cemetery #167 South Country Road [+] [corner/Basket Neck Ln.] [900-375-2-72] Photos #Remsenburg 001-010 RS3 Tuthill Burial Ground [+] #11 Club Lane [900-380-2-46.1] SAG HARBOR [2] [*] [2] [1] SH1 Old Burying Ground #10777 [+] [+] Madison/Church St. [903-003-4-27] Photos #SagHarbor 001-014 SH2 Oakland Cemetery #11067 [+] #90 Jermain Ave. [903-006-2-13.1] Photos #Oakland 001- 015

10 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List SAGAPONACK [2] [2] [2] SA1 Poxabogue Cemetery #20033 [+] [+] #11 Sagaponack Main St. [900-074-1-1] Photos #Poxabogue 001-006 SA2 Sagg Cemetery #24167 [+] [+] #807 Sagaponack Main St. [900-107-1-4] Photos #Sagg 001-009 SHINNECOCK HILLS [1] [1] [SK1] Shinnecock Reservation [+] [+] Cemetery Shinnecock Reservation Montauk Highway/Rte. 27A [900-273-1-2] [X] Hills Station Road SOUTHAMPTON [2] [*] [2] [2] SO1 North End Burial Ground #5246 [+] [+] [T] #165 Main St. [904-006-2-1] Photos #Southampton North 001-011

11 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List SO2 Old Southampton Burial #6970 [+] [+] [T] Ground #205 Little Plains Rd. [904-019-3-32] Photos #SouthamptonOld 001-037 TUCKAHOE [3] [2] TU1 Southampton Cemetery #26598 [+] #441 & #545 North Sea #30004 Road [900-131-2-11 & 900-159-1-18] Photos #Southampton 001-011 TU2 Sacred Hearts of Jesus #26599 [+] and Mary Cemetery #231 County Rd. 39 [900-131-2-12] Photos #SacredHeart 001-005 WATER MILL [2] [2**] [2] [2] WM1 Water Mill Cemetery #25176 WA-7 [+***] [+] #731 Montauk Hwy. [900-114-3-2] Photos #WaterMill 001-008 WM2 Flying Point Cemetery #30086 WA-1 [+] [+] Wickapogue Rd./Flying Point Road [900-160-1-21] Photos #Wickapogue 001-007

12 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List WESTHAMPTON/ WESTHAMPTON BEACH [2] [*] [2] [1] WE1 Westhampton Cemetery #68729 [+] #28 Montauk Hwy. [900-355-2-4.1] Photos #Westhampton 001-021 WE2 Jagger Family Burial #49792 [+] [+] Ground #141 Montauk Highway [900-369-3-4] Photos #Jagger 001- 007 ___________________ _______ ______ _______ _____ TOTALS 48 34 9 38 22 KEY: [1] Number of cemeteries identified in prior surveys [see below] [T] Owned by Town of Southampton and maintained by Town Parks & Recreation Dept. [+] Identified on prior survey [X] Identified on prior survey but no longer survives [?] Identified on prior survey but current location or existence unverified

13 of 66

HAMLETS/Parks & Rec. Town List TOS NYS Cem DAR Districts [CAC] Class “695” Survey[*] Inventory List FOOTNOTES: [*] TOS Survey did not include the five Incorporated Villages [North Haven, Quogue, Sag Harbor, Southampton and Westhampton Beach] [**] TOS Survey identified “WA-48” as located in Water Mill [BR2/ Bridgehampton] [***] Double entries in NYS Inventory [HB3/Hampton Bays] [****] TOS Survey reference to Canoe Place Chapel cemetery is included in “HA-21” [HB4/Hampton Bays] SURVEYS/LISTS: Town List Class “695” “Tax Classification List” is maintained by Southampton Town Assessors Office. TOS Survey “Southampton Cultural Resources Survey.” GAI Consultants, Inc. Monroeville, PA. June-September 1999. NYS Cem “New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997.” Compiled by The Association of Municipal Historians of New York State. Part III. Pp. 861-865. DAR List Compiled by the Southampton Colony Chapter, DAR. c. 1920-30s. Original records at Southampton Historical Museum; copies filed at DAR Headquarters, Washington, DC. [revised 8/10/04]

14 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemBR1________ Photo # ______Edgewood 001-006________ Hamlet __Bridgehampton___Town List No. ______#19742_____Acres ___11.2 ____ Street Address ___#86 Edgewood Ave___________Section/Block/Lot/_900-71-2-23___ Common Name____Edgewood Cemetery_________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____Edgewood Cemetery____________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___Paul Brennen, Sect., Edgewood Cemetery Association__ Phone # ___ (631) 537-5900 [x103]__[work]_________ E-mail ___________ Address __P. O. Box 1158, Bridgehampton, NY__________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___________________________________________ # Headstones [approx] _500+___ DAR # ___n/a_____ Date Range __20th c.___ Stone Types ___marble, granite_____________________________________ Condition _____generally very good; active cemetery is well maintained____ Miscellaneous Features ____________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? _____no________ Other? _Edgewood Cemetery Association_ Date Recorded ___March 2004_______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth___________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources __New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 861]________________________________________________

15 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemBR2________ Photo # ____Hayground 001-012________ Hamlet __Bridgehampton___Town List No. _____#21339___Acres ____1.3 _______ Street Address __100 Windmill Lane__Section/Block/Lot/_900-84-1-3.1_ Acres _1.9A Common Name____Hayground Cemetery__________________ Status? __active___ Historic Name _____Hay Ground Graveyard__________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Paul Rogers/Hayground Cemetery Assoc. [information only] Phone # ____726-4477_______ E-mail _____________________________ Address ___1514 Montauk Highway, Water Mill, NY__________________ Description: Prominent Features _polygonal lot surrounded with picket fence [1985] supported on granite piers [historic], with significant early grave markers___ # Headstones [approx] __350___ DAR # __________ Date Range _1725-20th c_ Stone Types __marble, sandstone, slate, granite & zinc [one]_______________ Condition _generally good, with normal tilting, breakage & surface growth_ Miscellaneous Features __rough-cut granite piers serve as fence posts___ Maintained by: Town? ___no__________ Other? _Hayground Cemetery Assoc.____ Date Recorded ____February 2004____ Recorded By _________Z. Studenroth_____ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __Armbruster [Vol. 5/#650 (Feb/1924); Vol. 11/#1406 (Nov/1923) & #1407 (Feb/1924)] Published Sources _Southampton Town Map Records. Book 1 [p. 22]; Halsey, Sketches, [pp 52-53]; Southampton Cultural Resources, File No. WA-48____

16 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemBR3________ Photo # ___Bridgehampton 001-014___ Hamlet __Bridgehampton_____Town List No. ______n/a____ Acres __2____ Street Address ____Montauk Hwy./Hull Lane___Section/Block/Lot/__900-86-2-27.1_ Common Name____Bridgehampton Cemetery_____________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name _____Bridgehampton Old Burial Ground______________________ Owner/Contact Person: _____Marjorie Van Cott_[information only] ___________ Phone # _______________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address _____P O Box 942, Bridgehampton, NY 11932___________________ Description: Prominent Features __2-acre site, enclosed with wooden picket fence__ # Headstones [approx] _200+_ DAR # _________ Date Range __1782-1920s___ Stone Types _______marble, sandstone, slate & granite__________________ Condition ____relatively good; site well maintained_________________ Miscellaneous Features _____________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? ______no__________ Other? ____________________ Date Recorded _____February 2004_________ Recorded By _____Z. Studenroth___ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources __Halsey, Sketches [pp. 53-59]; Munsell, History of Suffolk County, “Town of Southampton“ [p. 31]; Southampton Cultural Resources Survey, File No. BR-19______________________________________________

17 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemBR4________ Photo # ________Mecox 001-005_______ Hamlet __Bridgehampton___________Town List No. _______ #27081____________ Street Address ___Jobs Lane____Section/Block/Lot/___900-134-1-54___Acres __1.7__ Common Name____Jobs Lane Cemetery_________________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name ________Mecox Burying Ground______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ______John Halsey___[information only] ___________ Phone # ____537-0175__________ E-mail _____________________________ Address ____#795 Mecox Road, Water Mill 11976___________________ Description: Prominent Features _1-acre site, flat & surrounded by open farmland_ # Headstones [approx] _100_ DAR # __________ Date Range __1717-1925__ Stone Types _______marble, sandstone, slate & granite________ Condition ____relatively good; site free of large trees and well maintained _ Miscellaneous Features ______________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? ________________ Other? _____________________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth______ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __________________________________________________________ Published Sources __Munsell, History of Suffolk County, New York [1882], “Town of Southampton,” [p. 31]; Halsey, Sketches [p. 51]; Southampton Cultural Resources Survey, BR-78_________________________________

18 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # __HistCemEA1__________ Photo # _______Tuttle 001-006_______ Hamlet ___Eastport_____ Town List No.___ #46737__ Acres __ [less than 1 acre] _ Street Address _____#4 Tuttle Ave.___________Section/Block/Lot/_900-349-2-15.2___ Common Name____Tuttle Family Graveyard_____________Status? ___inactive__ Historic Name ___________________________________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Betty Matson/Eastport Cemetery Assoc._[contact: information only] _____________________________________________ Phone # _______________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address __P. O. Box 74, Eastport, NY 11941___________________________ Description: Prominent Features __small, rectangular burial plot surrounded with board fence, adjacent Eastport Gospel Church Cemetery [HistCemEA5] ___ # Headstones [approx] __15___ DAR # __n/a____ Date Range _1815-1967___ Stone Types __marble [11], granite [4] & 7 footstones__________________ Condition _generally good, one stone tilted, one broken [lying on the ground] Miscellaneous Features __central obelisk inscribed “TUTTLE” [D. Wesley Tuttle d. 1892, M. Caroline Tuttle d. 1892, and “infant daughter” d.1856]___ Maintained by: Town? ______no____ Other? __Eastport Cemetery Association____ Date Recorded ___February 2004_______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth_________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________

19 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemEA2________ Photo # ______Eastport 001-013_______ Hamlet ________Eastport______Town List No. ___ #46741_____ Acres ___4.5_____ Street Address ___#22 Tuttle Ave.__________Section/Block/Lot/_____900-349-2-18_ Common Name____________Eastport Cemetery___________ Status? ____active___ Historic Name ____________Eastport Cemetery______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Betty Matson/Eastport Cemetery Assoc._[information only] Phone # _______________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address ____P O Box 74, Eastport, NY 11941__________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___earliest gravestones located in south section___ # Headstones [approx] __700___ DAR # ______ Date Range ___1851-present_ Stone Types _____marble, granite, zinc [one]______________________ Condition __generally very good: some leaning, some surface lichens; marble tablets set in ground are deteriorating__________________________ Miscellaneous Features _____________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? _____no______ Other? _Eastport Cemetery Association___ Date Recorded _______February 2004___ Recorded By __Z. Studenroth___________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __________________________________________________________ Published Sources __Southampton Cultural Resources Survey File No. EA-6_

20 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemEA3________ Photo # ______EastportBible 001-010___ Hamlet ________Eastport______Town List No. ___n/a_____ Acres __1.1___ Street Address ___#386 Montauk Highway___Section/Block/Lot/__900-349-2-17_ Common Name__Eastport Gospel Church Cemetery_______ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name _____Eastport Methodist Church Cemetery_____________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Betty Matson/Eastport Cemetery Assoc._[information only] Phone # _______________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address ____P O Box 74, Eastport, NY 11941__________________________ Description: Prominent Features _marble obelisk [Lydia Ann DeFord d. 1882] ___ # Headstones [approx] __20___ DAR # ______ Date Range ___1850-1880s_ Stone Types _____marble____________________________________________ Condition __generally poor; several stones dislodged from the ground and leaning on fence; obelisk-type stone has broken top__________________ Miscellaneous Features _____________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? ____no_______ Other? _______Eastport Gospel Church___ Date Recorded _______February 2004___ Recorded By __Z. Studenroth___________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __________________________________________________________ Published Sources __New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory, 1995-1997 [p. 861]; Southampton Cultural Resources Survey, File No. EA-6_

21 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemEA4________ Photo # ______[none available] __________ Hamlet ____Eastport__________Town List No. ________ Acres __________________ Street Address _____4 South Bay Ave.______Section/Block/Lot/___900-352-1-2____ Common Name__Hawkins Family Burial Plot_______ Status? ____inactive______ Historic Name _____Hawkins Gravesite____________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___Ronald Michne, Jr. [information only] _____________ Phone # ___631-288-4909_____ E-mail _____________________________ Address _c/o Village Graphics, 20 Mitchell Rd., Westhampton Beach, NY__ Description: Prominent Features __gravesites hidden beneath heavy vegetation; interments believed to include Zachariah Hawkins [1788-1853], Mehitable Tuttle Hawkins [1793-1864] and their grandson Henry Hawkins [1855-1857] # Headstones [approx] ___2/3___ DAR # __n/a____ Date Range __19th c___ Stone Types _______unknown_______________________________________ Condition _________________________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features ______no markers remain visible_______________ Maintained by: Town? __no___ Other? _ property maintained by private owner____ Date Recorded ______________________ Recorded By _________________________ References: Maps/Views _______________________________________________ Published Sources ___NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 865]; Michne & Michne, “Historical Profiles of Eastport, Speonk/Remsenberg, Westhampton January, 2004__________________

22 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemEA5________ Photo # _____Tuttle/2 001-003___________ Hamlet _____Eastport______Town List No._________Acres_____________________ Street Address _____North Bay Ave.________Section/Block/Lot/__900-352-1-2___ Common Name____Tuttle Gravesite______________ Status? _____inactive_____ Historic Name ___________________________________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___Ronald Michne, Jr. [information only] _____________ Phone # ___631-288-4909_____ E-mail _____________________________ Address _c/o Village Graphics, 20 Mitchell Rd., Westhampton Beach, NY__ Description: Prominent Features ___small, private family burial site once belonging to main house facing Montauk Highway______________________________ # Headstones [approx] __3__ DAR # __n/a____ Date Range __mid-19th c.____ Stone Types _____marble_____________________________________ Condition _____broken fragments, several lying on the ground___________ Miscellaneous Features __only one grave marker survives intact [on ground]; one footstone appears to be undisturbed_______________________________ Maintained by: Town? _____no____ Other? _____privately maintained by owner___ Date Recorded ____June 2004_________ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________

23 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemEQ1________ Photo # ___SpinneyRoad 001-005_________ Hamlet __East Quogue__Town List No. ___ #41169 & #41264___ Acres__20.4__ Street Address _100 Spinney Road_ Section/Block/Lot/_900-288-1-62.1 & 288-1-155_ Common Name____Oakwood Cemetery___________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____Oakwood Cemetery_______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Oakwood Cemetery Association; Allyn Jackson [contact] __ Phone # _____(631) 653-6571____________ E-mail ____________________ Address ____West Side Ave., E. Quogue, NY 11942_____________________ Description: Prominent Features ___cobble piers mark entrance on Lewis Road____ # Headstones [approx] ___300+___ DAR # __n/a__ Date Range _20th c.___ Stone Types ____granite, marble___________________________________ Condition ___generally very good overall in well maintained active cemetery_ Miscellaneous Features ___two contiguous parcels: primary parcel [cemetery] is lot 288-1-62.1 fronting Spinney Road; secondary parcel is lot 288-1-155 [Cemetery Road] which gives access to cemetery from Lewis Road________ Maintained by: Town? _____no______ Other? _Oakwood Cemetery Association___ Date Recorded ___February 2004__ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth_____________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources ___New York State Cemeteries Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 863] _______________________________________

24 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemEQ2________ Photo # _____EQuogue 001-009__________ Hamlet _____East Quogue_____Town List No. ___ n/a______ Acres ___2.1_____ Street Address ___584 Montauk Hwy.__________Section/Block/Lot/_900-340-1-52.1_ Common Name____East Quogue Methodist Church Cemetery__Status? _inactive___ Historic Name ______East Quogue Cemetery____________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features __large, prominent angel monument___________ # Headstones [approx] __125___ DAR # __n/a___ Date Range _1850s-20th c__ Stone Types _________marble, sandstone, slate & granite_____________ Condition ___generally good; several stones broken, eroded & leaning______ Miscellaneous Features ____several obelisk-type monument, one crypt_______ Maintained by: Town? ___yes______ Other? __________________________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Published Sources __New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 861]; Southampton Cultural Resources Survey 1999 File. No. EQ-25____________________________________________________________

25 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemFL1________ Photo # ________PleasureWoods 001-005___ Hamlet ______Flanders______Town List No. __n/a___ Acres _[less than 1 acre]____ Street Address _[between] #15 & #19 Golden Leaf Trail__Section/Block/Lot/__900- 145-5-17.1 & 900-145-5-19.1__________________________________________ Common Name____Pleasure Woods Cemetery______________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name _____Pleasure Woods Cemetery_____________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features _small, rectangular fenced plot in wooded setting _ # Headstones [approx] __8___ DAR # __________ Date Range __1822-1840 __ Stone Types __marble _______________________________________________ Condition _neglected, extensive damage & breakage w/ evidence of vandalism Miscellaneous Features _ large central obelisk [Havens] is badly damaged ___ Maintained by: Town? _____yes___________ Other? _________________________ Date Recorded ___February 2004____ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth__ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Published Sources ___New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [pp. 863-864] ______________________________________

26 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemFL2________ Photo # __________Flanders 001-013___ Hamlet _____Flanders_______Town List No. ___ #30694____ Acres ____1.2_______ Street Address ___1377 Flanders Road___________Section/Block/Lot/_900-170-1-12_ Common Name____Flanders Cemetery__________________ Status?___active___ Historic Name _______Flanders Cemetery_______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ____Charles Penney, contact_[information only] ___________ Phone # ___727-8143 ____________________ E-mail __________________ Address ____Bay Avenue, Flanders, NY _______________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___all stones face west; earliest are located in northeast corner________________________________________________ # Headstones [approx] __310___ DAR # ___n/a__ Date Range _1770s-present _ Stone Types __marble, brownstone & granite _________________________ Condition __generally good, several broken or leaning, some dislodged _____ Miscellaneous Features __family plots set in raised granite curbing _______ Maintained by: Town? ____no________ Other? __Flanders Cemetery Association__ Date Recorded ____February 2004_____ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth__________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __________________________________________________________ Published Sources __New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 861] ________________________________________________

27 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemFL3________ Photo # ________Hubbard 001-005_____ Hamlet _____Flanders________Town List No. ____n/a___ Acres ___317.7______ Street Address ___Rte. 24/Red Creek Road__Section/Block/Lot/__900-150-1-22___ Common Name____Hubbard Cemetery___________________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name ___________________________________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205] and Richard Martin, Director, Suffolk CountyParks,_Dept./Historic_Services_(631) 854-0987____ Phone # ___ (631) 728-8585__________ E-mail __________________ Address ___6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY________________________ Description: Prominent Features _small, fenced graveyard; gravestones vandalized_ # Headstones [approx] __8__ DAR # ___n/a___ Date Range __19th c.______ Stone Types ___marble & granite________________________________ Condition ___historic stones broken, dislocated_________________________ Miscellaneous Features ___replacement memorial tablet intact__________ Maintained by: Town? _____yes_________ Other? _________________________ Date Recorded ___February 2004______ Recorded By _________Z. Studenroth___ References: Maps/Views _______________________________________________ Published Sources __New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 862] ________________________________________________

28 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemHB1________ Photo # _________Squires 001-018_______ Hamlet __Hampton Bays____Town List No. __ #29403____ Acres ________________ Street Address ___142 Red Creek Road__________Section/Block/Lot/_900-152-1-9__ Common Name_Squires [a/k/a Fournier] Burying Ground____ Status? _inactive__ Historic Name _____Squires Cemetery_____________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features _______rectangular, fenced graveyard_____ # Headstones [approx] __45___ DAR # __________ Date Range _1802-1901_ Stone Types __marble_____________________________________________ Condition _generally good, several broken & leaning; 2 on the ground____ Miscellaneous Features ____new [plastic] fence and decorative iron gate; trees threaten integrity of stones_[NB: erroneously listed as “Hubbard Cemetery” by Southampton Town Parks Department : see FL3]____________________ Maintained by: Town? _____yes_________ Other? _____________________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004____ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth__ References: Maps/Views ______________________________________________ Published Sources __Meigs, Suffolk County Cemeteries, Vol. 1, pp 162-163;__

29 of 66

New York State Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 862]; Southampton Town Map Records, Book 6 [p. 20] _______________________

30 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemHB2________ Photo # ______GoodGround 001-008____ Hamlet __Hampton Bays_Town List No. _#69127 & #33237___ Acres __18.3____ Street Address _#13 Cemetery Road & #99 Riverhead Road__Section/Block/Lot/___ 900-223-1-8.3 & 900-205-3-14___________________________________ Common Name____Good Ground Cemetery__________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____Good Ground Cemetery_________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___Good Ground Cemetery Association/Mrs. Winifred J. C. Penny, Secretary___________________________________________________ Phone # _(631)-728-2677_____ E-mail _____________________________ Address ___52 Donellan Road W., Hampton Bays, NY 11946___________ Description: Prominent Features __large rectangular cemetery with village setting_ # Headstones [approx] _______ DAR # ________ Date Range _1835-present_ Stone Types _predominantly marble [“old” section], granite [“new” section]_ Condition __generally very good, some leaning, very little breakage________ Miscellaneous Features sign reads “Founded 1882” [post-dates earliest stones] cemetery stretches to the north across Sunrise Highway SR 27 [205-3-14] ___ Maintained by: Town? __no___ Other? __Good Ground Cemetery Association_____ Date Recorded ___February 2004______ Recorded By __Z. Studenroth____________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Published Sources __NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 861]; Southampton Cultural Resources Survey 1999, File No. HA-3____

31 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemHB3________ Photo # __________Cuffee 001-003____ Hamlet __Hampton Bays____Town List No. __ #35655_____ Acres ____1.1 acres___ Street Address ___199 East Montauk Hwy._______Section/Block/Lot/_900-227-1-11_ Common Name____Rev. Paul Cuffee Gravesite_________ Status?____ inactive_ Historic Name _____Indian [Preacher] Grave/Indian burying ground_____ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features ____inscription [see continuation sheet] ________ # Headstones [approx] __1___ DAR # __________ Date Range ___1812___ Stone Types __marble cenotaph________________________________ Condition __marker is in “fair” condition, site is neglected______________ Miscellaneous Features __cast concrete & pressure-treated post & rail fence__ Maintained by: Town? ____yes____________ Other? ___________________ Date Recorded ___February 2004___ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth_________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __Armbruster [Vol. 1/#31 (Nov/1922); Vol. 5/#667 (July/1922); Vol. 12/ #1988-#1989, #1991-#1992 (1922); Vol. 12/#1990 (April/1927)]_____________ Published Sources ___Munsell [1882], “Town of Southampton“ [p. 30]; NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [pp. 862 & 864] _________

32 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemHB4________ Photo # ______CanoePlace 001-003__ Hamlet ___Hampton Bays___ Town List No. __ #35797__Acres __[less than 1 acre]_ Street Address _ [adj.] #178 Wakeman Road____Section/Block/Lot/_900-229-1-30.1_ Common Name_____Cuffee Burial Ground_______________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name ____Canoe Place Burial Ground___________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Douglas King, owner; Emily Oster, Town Historian__ [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # _____________________________ E-mail ______________________ Address _________________________________________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___land-locked site, accessible over private land___ # Headstones [approx] ___2____ DAR # ___n/a____ Date Range _mid-1800s__ Stone Types ____marble, granite [replacement stone] _________________ Condition __historic stones are severely damaged and in fragments___ Miscellaneous Features ___replacement marker records birth/death dates of three Cuffee family members ________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? _____no_________ Other? _____________________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004__ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth__________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________

33 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNH1________ Photo # ______NorthHaven 001-012_____ Hamlet __North Haven___Town List No. ___#1854___ Acres __ [less than .2 acres] __ Street Address ____#243 Ferry Rd./Rte. 114______Section/Block/Lot/__901-4-2-82_ Common Name____Ferry Road Cemetery________________ Status? ____inactive___ Historic Name _____North Haven Cemetery________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Incorporated Village of North Haven; Joseph Zaykowski, North Haven Village Historian_[contact/information only] _____________ Phone # ___725-2651_______________ E-mail ___________________ Address ___P. O. Box 643, Sag Harbor, NY_________________________ Description: Prominent Features __small, polygonal-shaped cemetery w/concrete post & rail fence; 1797 Betsy Byram headstone [mother/Ephraim Byram]__ # Headstones [approx] __14_____ DAR # _____ Date Range _1792-1856____ Stone Types ____marble, sandstone___________________________________ Condition ___relatively good, several stones tilting_____________________ Miscellaneous Features __iron fence, concrete posts donated by Mrs. Joseph Fahys in 1916; maintenance resumed by North Haven Village Improvement Society in 1983____________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? _no__ Other?_North Haven Historical Cemetery Assoc., Inc._ Date Recorded _____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps/Views ___Zaykowski photos___________________________

34 of 66

Published Sources __Vail, “Tomb Stone Inscriptions from the Cemeteries In and Near Sag Harbor, L.I.” [1950]; NYS Cemeteries Name/Location___ Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 861]; Welch, Richard F., Momenti Mori: the Gravestones of Early Long Island 1680-1810; “A Historic Cemetery Fights to Stay Alive,” New York Times, November 27, 1994 _______________________

35 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNH2________ Photo # ______Havens [001-003]________ Hamlet __North Haven___Town List No. _______ Acres ___3.7_______________ Street Address __ #216 Ferry Rd./Rte. 114___Section/Block/Lot/__901-005-1-50.6_ Common Name____Havens Gravesite_____________________ Status? __inactive___ Historic Name _____Martha Havens Gravesite______________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Joseph Zaykowski, North Haven Village Historian_ [information only] ________________________________________ Phone # ___725-2651_______________ E-mail ___________________ Address ___P. O. Box 643, Sag Harbor, NY_________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___isolated family burial plot in wooded setting__ # Headstones [approx] __1__ DAR # ___n/a____ Date Range __early 19th c__ Stone Types ____slate_______________________________________ Condition ____deteriorated & broken_______________________________ Miscellaneous Features ____endangered by future development___________ Maintained by: Town? ____no_____ Other?______private property owner________ Date Recorded _____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps/Views _________________________________________________ Published Sources ___NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 862] __________________________________________________________

36 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNH3________ Photo # ______Payne 001-004________ Hamlet __North Haven______Town List No. __________ Acres ____2.3___________ Street Address __Payne Avenue/Fair Oaks Lane__Section/Block/Lot/_901-005-1-3.3__ Common Name____Payne Avenue Cemetery_____________ Status? ____inactive___ Historic Name _____Payne Family Burial Plot_________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Joseph Zaykowski, North Haven Village Historian_ [information only] ________________________________________________ Phone # ___725-2651_______________ E-mail ___________________ Address ___P. O. Box 643, Sag Harbor, NY_________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___isolated, private family burial plot contains Abigail Hamilton [1799] and Sally Loper gravestones_______________ # Headstones [approx] ___2___ DAR # ___n/a__ Date Range ___late 18th c. _ Stone Types _____slate, brownstone_________________________________ Condition ____fair to poor_________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features ___endangered by private development_________ Maintained by: Town? ____no_____ Other?______private property owner.________ Date Recorded _____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps/Views _________________________________________________ Published Sources ___NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 863] __________________________________________________________

37 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNH4________ Photo # ______StockFarm 001-003______ Hamlet _North Haven_Town List No. _____ Acres __36.9 [cemetery plot 25’ by 50’]_ Street Address __[off] Ezekills Hollow Road __Section/Block/Lot/__901-002-3-1.3___ Common Name____Stock Farm Cemetery_________________ Status? __inactive___ Historic Name _____Havens Family Burial Plot_____________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Incorporated Village of North Haven; Joseph Zaykowski, North Haven Village Historian_[information only] ____________________ Phone # ___725-2651_______________ E-mail ___________________ Address ___P. O. Box 643, Sag Harbor, NY_________________________ Description: Prominent Features __Havens family burial plot overlooks Genet Creek in extensive Village-owned waterfront open space______________ # Headstones [approx] __20___ DAR # __n/a__ Date Range ____1751-1852__ Stone Types ___slate, marble_____________________________________ Condition _____fair to poor____________________________________ Miscellaneous Features __small rise of land is typical of siting for family burial plot____________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? _no_ Other?__North Haven Historical Cemetery Assoc., Inc._ Date Recorded _____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps/Views ___Zaykowski photos________________________________ Published Sources ___NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 864]; Historic Landmark Application Form, Village of North Haven____

38 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNH5________ Photo # ______Davall 001-004________ Hamlet __North Haven______Town List No. __________ Acres ____3_____________ Street Address _Payne Avenue/Fresh Pond Rd. _Section/Block/Lot/__901-006-3-50___ Common Name____William Davall Gravesite_____________ Status? ____inactive___ Historic Name _____William Davall Gravesite_______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Joseph Zaykowski, North Haven Village Historian_ [information only] _______________________________________________ Phone # ___725-2651_______________ E-mail ___________________ Address ___P. O. Box 643, Sag Harbor, NY_________________________ Description: Prominent Features __isolated burial plot_________________________ # Headstones [approx] ___1__ DAR # __n/a_____ Date Range __1797_______ Stone Types ___slate________________________________________ Condition ______poor________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features __endangered by land development__________ Maintained by: Town? ____no____ Other?__private property owner_______________ Date Recorded _____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps/Views _________________________________________________ Published Sources _________________________________________________

39 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNH6________ Photo # ______Maycroft 001-004________ Hamlet __North Haven______Town List No. __________ Acres ____43.5_________ Street Address ____Ferry Road/Rte. 114 ____ Section/Block/Lot/_____901-006-4-1___ Common Name____Maycroft Burial Site_________________ Status? ____inactive___ Historic Name _____Maycroft Burial Site_______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Joseph Zaykowski, North Haven Historian_[information only] __________________________________________________________ Phone # ___725-2651_______________ E-mail ___________________ Address ___P. O. Box 643, Sag Harbor, NY_________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___central marker flanked by rows of simple wooden markers________________________________ # Headstones [approx] __7_____ DAR # ___n/a__ Date Range __20th c.___ Stone Types ___marble, wood__________________________________ Condition ____several are intact, others deteriorated__________________ Miscellaneous Features __burial plot for Order of the Teachers of the Children of God; endangered by land development______________________ Maintained by: Town? ____no____ Other?________private property owner _ Date Recorded _____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps/Views _________________________________________________ Published Sources _________________________________________________

40 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNS1________ Photo # ______NorthSea 001-039_______ Hamlet __North Sea_______Town List No. _____ #20369__ Acres ___.58 Acres_____ Street Address ___16 Millstone Brook Road______Section/Block/Lot/_900-77-1-24.1_ Common Name____North Sea Cemetery________________ Status? ____inactive___ Historic Name _____North Sea Burial Ground_______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features _Victorian iron fencing around several family plots # Headstones [approx] __125____ DAR # ______ Date Range _1782-20th c.____ Stone Types ____sandstone, marble and granite________________________ Condition _generally poor, many stones broken, dislodged or leaning; cast iron and pipe fencing surrounding family burial plots is damaged________ Miscellaneous Features ___Rose family tablet markers___________________ Maintained by: Town? ____yes____________ Other? __________________________ Date Recorded ___February 2004_________ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth_____ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __Armbruster [Vol. 5/#624 (Oct/1924); Vol. 12/#1919 (Oct/1924)] ___ Published Sources __Meigs, “Suffolk County Cemeteries,” Vol. 1 [pp. 211- 220]; NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 862]______

41 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNO1________ Photo # _______Rogers 001-007________ Hamlet ______Noyac_________Town List No. __ #13093___ Acres ___1,655 sq. ft.__ Street Address _Burkeshire Drive/Rogers Court__Section/Block/Lot/_900-14-1-66.22_ Common Name______Rogers Burial Ground______________ Status? ____inactive__ Historic Name ___________________________________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: __Carol & Edward D. Burke, owners; Emily Oster, Town Historian [information only: #653-5205] ___________________________ Phone # ___ (631) 725-7457_____________ E-mail ______________________ Address ____15 Berkshire Dr., Sag Harbor, NY, 11963__________________ Description: Prominent Features __small, square fenced burial plot_________ # Headstones [approx] ___2_______ DAR # __n/a____ Date Range __1840s___ Stone Types ____marble________________________________________ Condition ___one stone remains standing [broken at top], the other and misc. fragments of at least one other gravestone lie on the ground________ Miscellaneous Features _____________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? ____no_________ Other? ____privately maintained_______ Date Recorded ___February 2004_______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________

42 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNO2________ Photo # ______Edwards 001-014_______ Hamlet ____Noyac________Town List No. ___ #13782___ Acres ___1.13_________ Street Address ___4340 Noyac Road____________Section/Block/Lot/___900-019-2-2_ Common Name____Old Noyac Cemetery________________ Status? ___inactive___ Historic Name _____Edwards Cemetery/Noyac Burying Ground_______________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features _fronted by hedge along Noyac Road; open grassy site; stones face west; Edwards family predominate _________________ # Headstones [approx] ___52______ DAR # ______ Date Range _1768-1868___ Stone Types ___sandstone, marble & slate_[marble predominates] _________ Condition _large cedar trees overshadow markers; several leaning, broken_ Miscellaneous Features _notable early slate and brownstone gravestones __ Maintained by: Town? ____yes____________ Other? _________________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004_________ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth____ References: Maps/Views _________________________________________________ Published Sources __Vail, Louis T., Comp. “Tomb stone inscriptions from the cemeteries in and near Sag Harbor, L.I.” White Plains [1950] pp. 1-3; NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 863]___________

43 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNO3________ Photo # ______StAndrews 001-005_____ Hamlet ____Noyac___________Town List No. __ #14389__ Acres ___12.7_______ Street Address ___1175 Brick Kiln Road_________Section/Block/Lot/_900-24-3-58.1_ Common Name____St. Andrews Cemetery___________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____St. Andrews R.C. Cemetery___________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___St. Andrews Roman Catholic Church______________ Phone # _______________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address __________________________________________________________ Description: Prominent Features __________________________________________ # Headstones [approx] ________ DAR # ___n/a__ Date Range ___20th c._____ Stone Types ____marble, granite____________________________________ Condition _________________________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features ______________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? __no____ Other? ___St. Andrews Roman Catholic Church__ Date Recorded ___February 2004_______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ___________________________________________________________ Published Sources __NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 864] ________________________________________________________

44 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemNO4________ Photo # ______Jessup 001-006________ Hamlet ____Noyac___________Town List No____n/a__________ Acres _143.2____ Street Address ___Noyac Road___ Section/Block/Lot __900-002 & 900-003-2-1____ Common Name____Jessup Burial Ground__________________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name _____Jessup Burial Ground________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service; Bill Stewart, c/o Morton National Wildlife Refuge [#725-2270]__________________________________ Phone # ___ (631) 286-0485__________ E-mail __________________________ Address ____U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service______________________ Description: Prominent Features ___Abigail Jessup gravestone [1724]________ # Headstones [approx] ___1_____ DAR # ___n/a_____ Date Range __1724___ Stone Types ____slate [headstone & footstone_____________________ Condition ______very good with little weathering to face of stone________ Miscellaneous Features ___hidden from public view off wildlife trail; 2nd brownstone headstone removed from original location and stored in utility shed [c.1800]_______________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? __no____ Other __ Morton National Wildlife Refuge ______ Date Recorded ___March 2004_______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Published Sources ___Welch [1983], p. 24; “Southampton Long Island 1640/1965 325th Anniversary.” Southampton Town, 1965. ______________

45 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemQU1________ Photo # _________Quiogue 001-008______ Hamlet __Quiogue____Town List No. ___ #50051_______Acres____4.5________ Street Address _#90 Meeting House Road______Section/Block/Lot/_900-370-3-20.1_ Common Name_Westhampton Presbyterian Church Cemetery_ Status? _inactive_ Historic Name ______Westhampton Churchyard______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Supt., Southampton Parks & Recreation Dept.; Ronald Michne, Jr.[information only: #288-4909] Phone # ___(631)-728-8585___________ E-mail _________________________ Address _____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY__________________ Description: Prominent Features __small, rectangular graveyard located behind Westhampton Presbyterian Church, 2-board fence; ____________________ # Headstones [approx] __38___ DAR # ___n/a_____ Date Range _1850s-1906_ Stone Types __marble, granite_______________________________________ Condition _relatively good condition overall; large evergreen threatens site_ Miscellaneous Features _impressive marble obelisk marker [approx. 12’ high] located near center [John Henry Jessup, Civil War vet d. 12/7/1864]________ Maintained by: Town? ____yes______ Other? _________________________________ Date Recorded ___February 2004___________ Recorded By _____Z. Studenroth___ References: Maps/Views __________________________________________________ Published Sources __LI Traveler, April 16, 1907; NYS Cemeteries Name/ Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 865]________________________________

46 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemQU2________ Photo # ___Quogue 001-012_________ Hamlet __Quogue______Town List No. ______ #3442____Acres ___ 4.1_______ Street Address ___58 Lamb Avenue____________Section/Block/Lot/___902-8-1-20_ Common Name____Quogue Cemetery______________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____Quogue Burial Ground_________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ____Ms. Cindy Brandt/Robcyn Associates________________ Phone # __631-288-0388_______ E-mail _____________________________ Address ______43 Main Street, Westhampton Beach, NY ______________ Description: Prominent Features __large, active cemetery w/ 2-board fence______ # Headstones [approx] ____ DAR # ________ Date Range __1750s-present_ Stone Types __slate, marble, sandstone, granite_______________________ Condition _____relatively good overall; early brownstone markers in poor condition______________________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features ___earliest stones at north end; all face west________ Maintained by: Town? ______no________ Other? ___Robcyn Associates______ Date Recorded ___February 2004__________ Recorded By _____Z. Studenroth____ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources ___Munsell, “Town of Southampton,” p. 28 [1882]; Welsh, Gravestones of Early Long Island [pp. 52, 56, 61 & 82] ________________

47 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemQU3________ Photo # _____Craig 001-004____________ Hamlet __Quogue___________Town List No. ___n/a_______ Acres ____.9 acres_____ Street Address ___17 Main [Quogue] Street____Section/Block/Lot/___900-7-1-25__ Common Name____Craig Gravesite______________________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name _____Craig Gravesite___________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: __Church of the Atonement [Episcopal], c/o Mrs. Finnegan; Ronald Michne, Jr. [information only: 631-288-4909 c/o Village Graphics, 10 Mitchell Rd., Westhampton Beach, NY]_______________________________ Phone # ____________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address __36 Cathedral Ave., Garden City, NY, 11530__________________ Description: Prominent Features __small, fenced gravesite behind Church of the Atonement [1884]; two matching gravestones are tablet-type, granite __ # Headstones [approx] _2___ DAR # __n/a____ Date Range __1904-1916_ Stone Types __granite_____________________________________________ Condition ___excellent, some surface vegetation present_________________ Miscellaneous Features _________iron fence surrounds gravesite________ Maintained by: Town? __no___ Other? __Church of the Atonement [Episcopal]____ Date Recorded ___February 2004__________ Recorded By _____Z. Studenroth____ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________

48 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemRS1________ Photo # ______Tuttle/3 001-005_______ Hamlet __Remsenburg/Speonk___________Town List No. ____ #50726__________ Street Address ___Remsen Lane____________Section/Block/Lot/___900-380-1-95___ Common Name_____Historic Remsenburg Cemetery________ Status? __inactive__ Historic Name _______Tuttle Burial Ground____________________________ Owner/Contact Person: __Remsenburg Association;___Ronald Michne, Jr.__ [information only] ________________________________________________ Phone # ____631-288-4909_____ E-mail _____________________________ Address _c/o Village Graphics, 10 Mitchell Rd., Westhampton Beach, NY___ Description: Prominent Features __small, rectangular plot w/ 2-board fence [new]; all stones face west; sign reads “Remsenburg Cemetery c. 1826” # Headstones [approx] __16___ DAR # ___16___ Date Range _1791-1914_ Stone Types _______________marble______________________________ Condition __relatively good overall; two broken and repaired_______ Miscellaneous Features _large trees growing in plot, lower limbs pose threat__ Maintained by: Town? ____no____________ Other? __Remsenburg Association_ Date Recorded _____February 2004____ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ___________________________________________________________ Published Sources ___NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 865] __________________________________________________________

49 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemRS2________ Photo # ______Remsenburg 001-010_______ Hamlet _______Remsenburg____Town List No. ____ n/a_____Acres ___1.2_____ Street Address ___#167 South Country Rd.___Section/Block/Lot/_900-375-2-72___ Common Name_____Remsenburg Cemetery________ Status? ________active__ Historic Name ______Remsenburg Cemetery_____________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _____Remsenburg Community Church __________________ Phone # _____631-325-1016__________ E-mail ____________________ Address _____Main Road, Remsenburg, NY ______________________ Description: Prominent Features __rectangular church yard extends behind [west] of Remsenburg Community (Presbyterian) Church [1853]; P. G. Wodehouse gravesite [d. 1975] located in the rear section___________________________ # Headstones [approx] _330_ DAR # __n/a____ Date Range __1850s-present__ Stone Types ___marble, sandstone & granite__________________________ Condition __good overall; several older stones tilting__________________ Miscellaneous Features _large trees & shrubs growing throughout cemetery pose potential threat to earlier marble stones; otherwise well-maintained___ Maintained by: Town? ____no_____ Other? __Remsenburg Community Church_ Date Recorded _____February 2004____ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps/Views __________________________________________________ Published Sources __NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 864] _________________________________________________________

50 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemRS3________ Photo # ______not available______________ Hamlet _______Remsenburg___Town List No. ____ n/a_____Acres ___1.46___ Street Address ___#11 Club Lane_________Section/Block/Lot/___900-380-2-46.1__ Common Name_____Tuthill-Phillips Gravesite________ Status? ____inactive______ Historic Name ________________________________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___Vito W. & Rose Fazio_____________________________ Phone # ___325-8440___________ E-mail _____________________________ Address ______P O Box 202, Remsenburg, NY 11960_________________ Description: Prominent Features ___________________________________________ # Headstones [approx] __30___ DAR # ______ Date Range __1790s-1890s__ Stone Types ___marble_________________________________________ Condition _____________________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features __________________________________________ Maintained by: Town? ____no_____ Other? _______Vito & Rose Fazio ________ Date Recorded _____March 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ___________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________

51 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemSH1________ Photo # ____SagHarbor 001-014______ Hamlet __Sag Harbor____Town List No. ___ #10777________Acres ___1.1____ Street Address _[corner] Madison/Church Streets__Section/Block/Lot/_903-003-4-27_ Common Name____Old Burying Ground________________ Status? ___inactive___ Historic Name _________same_________________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Mayor, Village of Sag Harbor; Dorothy I. Zaykowski & members of The Committee for the Old Burying Ground [information only]_____________________________________________________________ Phone # ___ (631)725-0222_____________ E-mail _______________________ Address _____Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY __________________________ Description: Prominent Features __village setting adjacent landmark church___ # Headstones [approx] _333__ DAR # _____ Date Range __1767-1870___ Stone Types ______________marble, sandstone & slate______________ Condition ___generally poor, extensive breakage, advanced weathering & tilting; many stones now resting on the ground__________ Miscellaneous Features ___examples preserved of stone carver Ithuel Hill __ Maintained by: Town? ____no _________ Other? ___Village of Sag Harbor ______ Date Recorded ___February 2004______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps/Views _Armbruster [Vol. 13/#2141 (Aug/1924) & #2144 (1922)] Published Sources _Vail, Louis T., Comp. “Tomb stone inscriptions from the cemeteries in an near Sag Harbor, L.I.” [White Plains, 1950] pp. 1-23;_____

52 of 66

Zaykowsky, comp., The Old Burying Ground at Sag Harbor, LI, NY [2003]; NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 863] ___________

53 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemSH2________ Photo # _______Oakland 001-015_______ Hamlet __Sag Harbor_____Town List No. ____ #11067_______Acres____28.4____ Street Address ___90 Jermain Avenue______Section/Block/Lot/___903-006-2-13.1_ Common Name____Oakland Cemetery______________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name ______Oakland Cemetery____________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _____Oakland Cemetery Association____________________ Phone # _______________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address ____P. O. Box 359, Sag Harbor, NY________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___obelisks, crypts & decorative fencing______ # Headstones [approx] _3,700_ DAR # _____ Date Range __1840-present__ Stone Types __marble, sandstone & granite__________________________ Condition __good overall; many monuments requiring cleaning & minor repair; overgrown plantings are a potential threat___ Miscellaneous Features ____ “Broken Mast Monument” ______________ Maintained by: Town? ___no______ Other? ____Oakland Cemetery Association____ Date Recorded ___February 2004_______ Recorded By __Z. Studenroth__________ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views __________________________________________________________ Published Sources ___NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 863];_Zaykowski, comp. Index [March 1983]_____________________

54 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemSA1________ Photo # ___Poxabogue 001-006________ Hamlet __Sagaponack_______Town List No. ___ #20033______Acres ___1.2_____ Street Address ___11 Sagaponack Main Street_____Section/Block/Lot/_900-074-1-1_ Common Name____Poxabogue/Evergreen Cemetery__________ Status? _inactive_ Historic Name _________Poxabogue Graveyard_______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: __Evergreen Trustees; Don Sachar/Sagaponack Association [contact/information only]________________________________________ Phone # _____537-1354____________ E-mail _______________________ Address ___P. O. Box 414, Sagaponack, NY____________________________ Description: Prominent Features __picket fence [new] encloses two sides; granite fence posts survive along east & south property lines_________ # Headstones [approx] _______ DAR # __________ Date Range__1773-__ Stone Types ___marble, sandstone & slate___________________________ Condition _very good overall, some early stones leaning & minor_breakage__ Miscellaneous Features ___cemetery association founded 1898 by Mrs. Russell Sage to recognize family ancestors [Piersons] __________________________ Maintained by: Town? __no ___ Other? ___Evergreen Trustees__________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004______ Recorded By _______Z. Studenroth_____ References: Maps/Views___________________________________________________ Published Sources __NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 864]; Suffolk Life, May 28, 2003___________________________________

55 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemSA2________ Photo # ___________Sagg 001-009_______ Hamlet __Sagaponack______Town List No. ____ #24167______Acres ___1.1____ Street Address ___807 Sagaponack Main Street____Section/Block/Lot/_900-107-1-4_ Common Name____Sagg Cemetery______________________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name ________Sagaponack Burying Ground________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ____Merrall T. Hildreth__[information only] ____________ Phone # ____537-0715_______________ E-mail ________________________ Address ____P. O. Box 375, Sagaponack, NY____________________________ Description: Prominent Features __cemetery occupies village green setting surrounded on both sides [east & west] by Sagaponack Main Street__ # Headstones [approx] _________ DAR # __________ Date Range _1686-_ Stone Types ___sandstone, slate & marble___________________________ Condition ___effects of weathering, breakage and tilting observed throughout the site; vegetation is a minimal threat______________________ Miscellaneous Features ___post-and-rail fence encloses the cemetery___ Maintained by: Town? ______no________ Other? _____________________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps/Views __________________________________________________ Published Sources ___Munsell, History of Suffolk County, “Town of Southampton,” 1882 [p. 33]; NYS Cemetery Name/Location Inventory 1995- 1997 [p. 864]; Town Trustees Records, Part I 1741-1826, Book 1 [p. 134]___

56 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemSO1________ Photo # ___SouthamptonNorth 001-011____ Hamlet __Southampton______Town List No. ___ #5246_______Acres ___1.8____ Street Address ___#165 Main Street____________Section/Block/Lot/__904-006-2-1_ Common Name____North End Burial Ground______________ Status? _inactive___ Historic Name _______North End Graveyard_________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features __large, rectangular burial ground stretches between two village streets in downtown urban setting ______________ # Headstones [approx] __670___ DAR # __________ Date Range _1712-1940__ Stone Types ___marble, sandstone & slate________________________ Condition _____generally “poor“; extensive erosion of stone surfaces due to weathering, with pervasive breakage and loss of stone fabric___________ Miscellaneous Features ___extensive survival and integrity of early stones; footstones repositioned against headstones to facilitate maintenance____ Maintained by: Town? _____yes_______ Other? _____________________________ Date Recorded __February 2004_________ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps ________________________________________________________

57 of 66

Views _Armbruster [Vol. 5/#625 (July/1923); Vol. 12/#1749-51 (July/1923)]_ Published Sources _NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 862]; Southampton Town Map Records, Book 4 [pp. 56 & 60]; Town Trustees Records, Part I, 1741-1826 Book V [pp 170, 173 & 185]; Welch, Gravestones of Early Long Island [p. 82] ________________________

58 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # _HistCemSO2_________ Photo # __SouthamptonOld 001-037_____ Hamlet __Village of Southampton__Town List No._____#6970 ___Acres __2.1___ Street Address __#205 Little Plains Road______Section/Block/Lot/_904-019-3-32_ Common Name __Old Southampton Burial Ground___________Status? _inactive___ Historic Name ____South End Burying Ground_______________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Town of Southampton/Allyn F. Jackson, Superintendent, Southampton Parks & Recreation Department ; Emily Oster, Town ______ Historian [contact/information only: #631-653-5205]__________________ Phone # ____(631)-728-8585___________________ E-mail _______________ Address ____#6 Newtown Lane, Hampton Bays, NY 11946_______________ Description: Prominent Features _grassy, L-shaped site surrounded by high hedges # Headstones [approx] ___47_____ DAR # __________ Date Range_1682-1897_ Stone Types ___brownstone, marble, slate & granite [replacement stones] ___ Condition _some 17th/18th c. brownstone markers are severely deteriorated,_ others display breakage [some repairs], tilting and surface vegetation _____ Miscellaneous Features __early burial ground surviving in village setting___ Maintained by: Town? ___Southampton Town/ Dept. of Parks and Recreation _____ Date Recorded ____10/3/03___________ Recorded By _Z. Studenroth_____________ References: Maps/Views Armbruster [Vol. 2/#114-116 (Sept/1924); Vol. 4/#509- 511(Sept/1924); Vol. 12/#1903-1915 (Sept/1924)] _______________________ Published Sources NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-97 [p.863]; _ Vail (1950) [pp. 1-23]; Welch, Gravestones of Early Long Island [p. 82]

59 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemTU1________ Photo # ____Southampton 001-011_____ Hamlet __Tuckahoe_____Town List No. ____ #26598_& #30004__Acres __36.4___ Street Address __ #441 & 545 North Sea Road ___Section/Block/Lot/__900-159-1-18 & 900-131-2-11____________________________________________________ Common Name____Southampton Cemetery__________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____Southampton Cemetery_________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ____Southampton Cemetery Association/Robert Bennett, Superintendent___________________________________________________ Phone # _____631-283-3212_______ E-mail _____________________________ Address ____P. O. Box 1081, Southampton, NY 11969___________________ Description: Prominent Features __numerous crypts, hedged lanes & plots; brick entrance wall & piers dedicated in 1913 [“In Memoriam/ William Curtis Gulliver 1847-1909 and Curtis Gulliver 1881-1892]; located on Co.Rd. 39__ # Headstones [approx] __12,000+_ DAR # _n/a_ Date Range __1885-present__ Stone Types ___granite, marble_________________________________ Condition ____excellent___________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features ___two contiguous parcels; founded 1885__________ Maintained by: Town? _____no_________ Other? __Southampton Cemetery Assoc._ Date Recorded _____February 2004______ Recorded By __Z. Studenroth____ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________

60 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemTU2________ Photo # ___SacredHeart 001-005_______ Hamlet __Tuckahoe_____Town List No. ____ #26599_______Acres ___13.1 _____ Street Address ___231 County Road 39__________Section/Block/Lot/_900-131-2-12_ Common Name_______Sacred Heart Cemetery_____________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary Cemetery____________ Owner/Contact Person: ___Catholic Cemetery Association/Suzanne Marchisella__ Phone # _631-283-0097____________ E-mail ________________________ Address ___168 Hill Street, Southampton, NY___________________________ Description: Prominent Features __bordered by hedge along County Road 39_____ # Headstones [approx] _____ DAR # __________ Date Range _____________ Stone Types ______________________________________________________ Condition ______________________________________________________ Miscellaneous Features _borders Southampton Cemetery [TU1] east/north_ Maintained by: Town? ____no___ Other? ___Catholic Cemetery Association_____ Date Recorded ___February 2004______ Recorded By _____Z. Studenroth_____ References: Maps ________________________________________________________ Views ____________________________________________________________ Published Sources __________________________________________________

61 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemWM1________ Photo # ______WaterMill 001-008_______ Hamlet __Water Mill_____Town List No. _____#25176______Acres ___1.9_____ Street Address ___731 Montauk Highway_________Section/Block/Lot/_900-114-3-2_ Common Name____Water Mill Cemetery_________________ Status? _active___ Historic Name _____Water Mill Cemetery__________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: __Bill Corwith [contact/information only]________________ Phone # ____ (631)726-4896_______________ E-mail ___________________ Address ___Head of Pond Road, Water Mill, NY 11976 ________________ Description: Prominent Features __1-acre village setting adjacent green______ # Headstones [approx] __200_ DAR # __________ Date Range _1731-present_ Stone Types ___sandstone, marble, slate & granite____________________ Condition __relatively good; some breakage, weathering of early stones__ Miscellaneous Features __angel, weeping willow & death‘s head motifs___ Maintained by: Town? ____no_________ Other? _____________________________ Date Recorded ____February 2004______ Recorded By ____Z. Studenroth________ References: Maps/Views ________________________________________________ Published Sources __Munsell, History of Suffolk County, “Town of Southampton”, 1882 [p. 30]; NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 865]; Southampton Cultural Resources Survey 1999, File No. WA-7; Water Mill Celebrating Community, Water Mill Museum, 1996____

62 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ____HistCemWM2______ Photo # _____Wickapogue 001-007_____ Hamlet ___Water Mill___Town List No._______ #30086 _____Acres _____1_____ Street Address _Wickapogue Rd/Flying Point Rd _Section/Block/Lot _900-160-1-21 _ Common Name__Flying Point Cemetery___________________ Status? __active___ Historic Name ___Flying Point Cemetery_________________________________ Owner/Contact Person: _Flying Point Cemetery Association; Jeffrey Jones, President Phone # ___726-1945 _____________ E-mail __________________________ Address ____P. O. Box 665, Water Mill, NY 11976_______________ Description: Prominent Features ___well-kept, open, grassy burial ground retaining several early slate and brownstone markers_________________________ # Headstones [approx] __241____ DAR # __________ Date Range _1732-20th c Stone Types ___slate, marble, granite, brownstone___________________ Condition generally good, several tipping, some breakage, NB: Halsey marker Miscellaneous Features _large Burnett family obelisk in SW corner, evergreen hedge on north/east sides, 2-board [plastic] fence along south/west sides __ Maintained by: Town? ____no____ Other? ____Flying Point Cemetery Association__ Date Recorded _____June 2004_____ Recorded By _____Z. Studenroth_________ References: Maps/Views ____________________________________________ Published Sources _NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 861]; Southampton Cultural Resources Survey 1999, File No. WA-1; Welch, Gravestones of Early Long Island [p. 82] ______________________________

63 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemWE1________ Photo # ______Westhampton 001-021___ Hamlet __Westhampton____Town List No. _____ #68729______Acres _____11____ Street Address _#28 Montauk Hwy. [at Station Rd.]_Section/Block/Lot/_900-355-2-4.1 Common Name_____Westhampton Cemetery___________ Status? ____active___ Historic Name ______Westhampton Cemetery____________________________ Owner/Contact Person: ____Westhampton Cemetery Association/Thomas Betjemann, President_________________________________________________________ Phone # __(631)-288-1532______ E-mail _____________________________ Address ___P. O. Box 304, Westhampton, NY 11977 [home: P. O. Box 307, Westhampton, NY 11977]________________________________________________ Description: Prominent Features ___Civil War monument dedicated Aug. 1, 1866__ # Headstones [approx] _1,000+_ DAR # __n/a__ Date Range _1754-present__ Stone Types __marble, sandstone, slate & granite [predominate]__________ Condition __relatively good overall, earliest stones [southwest section] evidence considerable loss and surface deterioration __________________ Miscellaneous Features __earliest gravestones survive from original Presbyterian church [built 1742 at adjoining Beaver Dam],_associated with first Westhampton settlement____________________________________ Maintained by: Town? __no ___ Other? __Westhampton Cemetery Association___ Date Recorded ___February 2004______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth_______ References: Maps/Views _____________________________________________

64 of 66

Published Sources _NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 865]; Southampton Town Map Records, Book V [p. 14]; Welch, Gravestones of Early Long Island [p. 82]; Michne & Michne, “Historical Profiles of Eastport, Speonk/Remsenberg, Westhampton January, 2004_________________________________________________________

65 of 66

TOWN OF SOUTHAMPTON: HISTORIC CEMETERY INVENTORY SHEET Survey File # ___HistCemWE2________ Photo # ________Jagger 001-007_______ Hamlet __Westhampton_____Town List No. ____ #49792_____Acres ________ Street Address ___141 Montauk Highway__________Section/Block/Lot/_900-369-3-4_ Common Name____Jagger-Wells Cemetery______________ Status? _active_______ Historic Name _____Jagger Family Burial Ground_____________________ Owner/Contact Person: ___Helen Batcheller [information only: #27 Jagger Lane, Westhampton, NY 631-288-1996]_Linda_Schwartz, Vice President; Trust and Financial Services Group, SuffolkCounty National Bank___________ Phone # _______________________ E-mail _____________________________ Address __SuffolkCounty National Bank, 3880 Veterans Memorial Highway, Bohemia, NY _11716_____________________________________________ Description: Prominent Features __deep, L-shaped [“flag lot”] burial ground is fenced and enjoys a secluded setting off Montauk highway and Jagger Lane_ # Headstones [approx] __40___ DAR # __n/a___ Date Range _1830s-present_ Stone Types _______marble [16] & granite [24]_________________________ Condition ______________very good overall___________________________ Miscellaneous Features __granite replacement markers used to document names and dates of marble stones that have become difficult to read due to surface weathering; vegetation poses potential threat ________________ Maintained by: Town? ___no ____ Other? ___Suffolk County National Bank___ Date Recorded __June 2004_______ Recorded By ___Z. Studenroth________

66 of 66

References: Maps/Views _____________________________________________ Published Sources __NYS Cemeteries Name/Location Inventory 1995-1997 [p. 862]; Michne & Michne, “Historical Profiles of Eastport, Speonk/ Remsenberg, Westhampton January, 2004__________________