View
294
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
TOURISM POLICY PROFILES
Problems, designs and actors
1. Tourism policy A basic model Key dimensions
2. Organising tourism policy3. Analysing policy discourse
The case of Denmark The case of Siberia?
[email protected] http://www2.ihis.aau.dk/~halkier/
TOURISM POLICYA basic model
Source: Inspired by inter alia Ham & Hill, Jenkins, Sabatier, Parsons, Winter – Elaborated on the basis of Henrik Halkier: Institutions, Discourse and Regional Development, Brussels: PIE Peter Lang, 2006, chapter 3.
Political environment
Public actors
Private actors
Discursive terrain
Implementing organisation
Political sponsor
Organisation
Policy design
Economic & socio-cultural environment
Public actors
Private actors
Cultural patterns
Discursive terrain
Policy target
Firms
Organisations
Public authorities
Tourists
PROBLEM DEFINITION
POLICY OUTCOME
Analysing public policy in practice
KEY DIMENSIONS
Topographical inside/outside up/down
Temporal past/future cause/consequence
Strategic subject/object assistant/opponent
Sour
ce:
Insp
ired
by
inte
r al
ia K
osel
leck
and
Å
kers
trøm
And
erse
n –
Ela
bora
ted
on th
e ba
sis
of
Hen
rik
Hal
kier
: Ins
titu
tion
s, D
isco
urse
and
Reg
iona
l D
evel
opm
ent,
Bru
ssel
s: P
IE P
eter
Lan
g, 2
006,
cha
pter
3.
Topographical inside/outside up/down
Temporal past/future cause/consequence
Strategic subject/object assistant/opponent
Sour
ce:
Insp
ired
by
inte
r al
ia K
osel
leck
and
Å
kers
trøm
And
erse
n –
Ela
bora
ted
on th
e ba
sis
of
Hen
rik
Hal
kier
: Ins
titu
tion
s, D
isco
urse
and
Reg
iona
l D
evel
opm
ent,
Bru
ssel
s: P
IE P
eter
Lan
g, 2
006,
cha
pter
3.
Social geography a problem where? a problem for whom?
Policy design in what sense a problem? ways of addressing problem?
Policy process who is active/passive? who helps/gets in the way?
Analysing public policy in practice
KEY DIMENSIONS
National tourism policy as
POLICY DOMAIN
Private firms
Tourists
Sub-nationalorganisations
Nationalorganisations
National tourism policy as
POLICY DOMAIN
Private firms
Tourists
Sub-nationalorganisations
Nationalorganisations
PromotionStandardsResearchSafety
National tourism policy as
POLICY DOMAIN
Private firms
Tourists
Sub-nationalorganisations
Nationalorganisations
PromotionStandardsResearchSafety
Product developmentExpansionSpatial planningFair playPartnership
National tourism policy as
POLICY DOMAIN
Private firms
Tourists
Sub-nationalorganisations
Nationalorganisations
PromotionStandardsResearchSafety
Product developmentExpansionSpatial planningFair playPartnership
EncouragementSponsorshipRegulationCoordinationPartnership
National tourism policy as
POLICY DOMAIN
Private firms
Tourists
Sub-nationalorganisations
Nationalorganisations
PromotionStandardsResearchSafety
Product developmentExpansionSpatial planningFair playPartnership
EncouragementSponsorshipRegulationCoordinationPartnership
Three underlying assumptions:• market positioning• public-private relations• territorial relations
International tourism policies
THE ULTIMATE TOP-DOWN?
Private firms
Tourists
Nationalorganisations
Internationalorganisations
ResearchSafety
Fair playSafety
Regulation?Coordination
85
95
07
02
Danish Tourist Board
Local associations
DANISH TOURISM POLICYActors and policies in transition
85
95
07
02
Danish Tourist Board
Local associations
Destination partnerships
Tourism export groups
Regional Tourism Boards
DANISH TOURISM POLICYActors and policies in transition
85
95
07
02
Danish Tourist Board
Local associations
Destination partnerships
Tourism export groups
Regional Tourism Boards
Product partnerships
Regional partnerships
DANISH TOURISM POLICYActors and policies in transition
85
95
07
02
Danish Tourist Board
Local associations
Destination partnerships
Tourism export groups
Regional Tourism Boards
Product partnerships
Regional partnerships
Social geography national/local problem, then also regional private firms, public promoters?
Policy design too few tourist, then also inadequate product promotion, firm-level projects and networks
Policy process central/local levels inform,
regional/partnerships develop? competitors, risk-averse firms, internal
competition?
DANISH TOURISM POLICYActors and policy discourse in transition
Social geography a problem where? a problem for whom?
Policy design in what sense a problem? ways of addressing problem?
Policy process who is active/passive? who helps/gets in the way?
SIBERIAN TOURISM POLICYActors and policies in transition