49
TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

TOUCHPOINT AUDIT:

IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

Page 2: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

INTRODUCTION

Page 3: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

WHY WE CAME Current level of member satisfaction and the member experience need to be analyzed so that both can be improved

To understand who can and should champion Regence’s customer experience

Page 4: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

WHAT THIS WILL MEAN TO YOU

Regence’s implementation of our recommendations will help your management teams make better consumer centric decisions

Regence will be more in touch with the consumer and have a better pulse on the marketplace

Page 5: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

OUR TEAM OBJECTIVES Design a methodology and framework that analyzes the customer experience through touchpoints on how customers are served

As part of the framework, create ScoreCards to measure touchpoint effectiveness and drive out costs

Provide Regence with recommendations, tools and spreadsheets to improve touchpoints, ultimately optimizing customer experience

Page 6: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

BRINGING REGENCE SUCCESS

Increased customer

satisfaction

Improved customer

loyalty

Higher revenue/ margins

Our Framework will lead to…

Page 7: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

OUR METHODOLOGY

Page 8: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

WHAT WE DID AT REGENCE… Conducted over 60 employee interviews

Analyzed focus group findings, survey data, marketing/sales collateral

Listened to customer service member calls

Healthcare  Services  

Innovation  

Healthcare  Informatics  

RITS  

Executives  

StratComm  

Product        

eBusiness  

Sales  

 Customer  Service  

 

Marketing  

Page 9: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

…AND OFFSITE Conducted interviews with members and brokers

Researched generational trends and customer experience strategy utilizing Mintel and Forrester

Analyzed the competition and other Blues Plans via Hoovers, press releases and news databases

Page 10: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

PLEASE READ THESE INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE OPERATING

5CS FRAMEWORK: INSTRUCTIONS INSIDE

Page 11: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1.  Determine who will execute the framework

2.  Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3.  Choose a stage in the customer’s journey

4.  Pick your touchpoint

5.  Run through framework

Decision Time!

Page 12: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

STEP 1: DETERMINE WHO WILL EXECUTE THE FRAMEWORK

Form or hire an inter-departmental team that would gather customer insights and data

The team would build bridges between departments and open new lines of communication

Page 13: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

STEP 2: CHOOSE YOUR AUDIENCE

Page 14: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

STEP 3: CHOOSE A STAGE IN THE CUSTOMER JOURNEY Our interviews, research, data analysis, and internal insights provided insights into constructing the journey that Regence’s members take:

Awareness Evaluate Sales & Enrollment Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal

Page 15: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

STEP 4: PICK YOUR TOUCHPOINT Awareness Evaluate Sales/

Enrollment Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal

• WOM • Events/

Sponsorships • Ads • Public Inform. • Brokers/

Agents • Direct Mail • Regence

Reps

• Regence Reps

• Collateral • HR/Decision

maker • Brokers/

Agents •  Inquiry • Sales Team • Regence.com

• HR/Decision maker

• Sales Team • Account

Executive • Premium Bill • Forms

• myRegence • Member Card • Welcome

packet • Provider List • Customer

service

• Medical Visit • Pharmacy • Regence

Advantages • myRegence • EOB • Evangelist

Demos • Claims • Customer

Service • Nurse hotline/

CareEnhance • Claims

disputes • Case

Managers • Special

Beginnings

• Sponsored Events

• Evangelist Demos

• Newsletter • Social Media • myRegence

engagement messages

• Notice of Termination

• myRegence • Brokers/

Agents

Page 16: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

STEP 5: 5CS FRAMEWORK " Customer satisfaction requirements/Operational metrics

" Competitive insights

" Channel analysis by touchpoint

" Cost analysis

" Card •  The ScoreCard analyzes new opportunities uncovered from the

above criteria

Page 17: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

STEP 5 (CONT.): 5CS FRAMEWORK

Touchpoint Opportunities

•  Satisfy customer? •  New Service

Channel/ Service migration?

•  Lower costs? •  More competitive?

ScoreCard •  (See next slide)

GAP

ANALYZE

Existing Touchpoint Analysis Customer satisfaction criteria

☐ Pain points ☐ Relevance ☐ Access ☐ Timely ☐ Ease ☐ Low cost

☐ Understandable ☐ Responsive ☐ Helpful ☐ Positive ☐ Need

Operational metrics

•  Web metrics •  Membership

changes

•  Customer Service correspondence

•  Surveys Competitive Insight*

•  Products •  Programs

•  Long/short term goals •  Revenue

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone

Radio/TV

Regence ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion*

______ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ______ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ______ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Unit Cost Regence Cost $

_ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ *Competition includes other Blues plans & general health insurance landscape.

Page 18: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Step 2: Internal Considerations

Points

Person who can champion the touchpoint (+4)

____ No additional line of communication/collaboration (+3) ____ Capabilities/resources available to maintain it (+2)

____ Works well with other touchpoints (+1)

____ Total /10

Step 1: Cost Considerations

Points

Potential for revenue (+4)

____ Affordability of touchpoint/unit cost (+3) ____ Technology/production cost (+2)

____ No additional cost to other touchpoints (+1)

____ Total /10

STEP 5 (CONT.): SCORECARD LAYOUT

Step 3: Customer Quality Criteria

Points

Potential to improve customer satisfaction overall (+4)

____ Fulfills the customer need (+3)

____ Ability to obtain measurable customer data (+2)

____ Increases access to the customer (+1)

____ Total /10

Step 5: Strategic Concerns

Points

Mission statement relevance (+4)

____ Brand promise fulfillment (+3)

____ Core strategy fit (+2)

____ Alignment with future goals (+1)

____ Total /10

Step 4: External Considerations

Points

Competitive opportunity (+4)

____ Outside parties involved (take a point off for each involved party) (+3) ____ Level of market demand (+2)

____ Not impacted by regulation (+1)

____ Total /10

Final Touchpoint Score

Points

Cost Considerations Score x3 /30

Internal Considerations Score x1 /10

Customer Quality Criteria Score x3 /30

External Considerations Score x2 /20

Strategic Concerns Score x1 /10 Total /100

Page 19: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

THE 5CS AT WORK

EXAMPLE:

MEDICARE

Page 20: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

UNDERSTANDING MEDICARE Importance of Segment:

•  Rapidly growing segment: Almost 10,000 Baby Boomers turn 65 every day (AARP)

•  Regence services 3 of top 10 metro areas for highest “pre-senior” (age 55-64) growth - (Boise ID, Provo UT, Portland OR) (Brookings Institution)

•  Approximately 10.8% of Regence’s membership base •  Traditionally little turnover

Segment is becoming much more tech savvy: 37% of the entire population online is made up of Baby Boomers (Forrester)

•  We interviewed Medicare

members and brokers to get a consumer-centric perspective

•  Adding Medicare members has the potential to increase revenue

Chart supplied by Regence

Page 21: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

MEDICARE TOUCHPOINTS

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal

• Events/ Sponsorships

• Collateral • Premium Bill • Welcome Packet

• myRegence • Engagement Messaging

•  The following touchpoints are important to Medicare and will be taken through the 5Cs Framework:

Page 22: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

•  Events timed throughout the year

•  Online event or Webinar

EVENTS/SPONSORSHIPS Customer satisfaction criteria

þInformative event þRelevance þPresentation

☐ Timing þ Professionalism þ Accessible  loca+ons  

Operational metrics

• Size of Event • Customer satisfaction

survey

• __% Increase in Web traffic/web metrics

Competitive Insights

• UnitedHealth holds Medicare Events at senior centers and homes to educate consumers.

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion UnitedHealth þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

____________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

____________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want þ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard (See ScoreCard slide)

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗

Page 23: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Step 1: Cost Considerations

Points

Potential for revenue (+4) 3

Affordability of touchpoint/unit cost (+3) 3

Technology/production cost (+2) 2

No additional cost to other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 9/10

Step 2: Internal Considerations

Points

Person who can champion the touchpoint (+4) 3

No additional line of communication/collaboration (+3) 3

Capabilities/resources available to maintain it (+2) 2

Works well with other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 9/10

SCORECARD FOR WEBINAR

Step 3: Customer Quality Criteria

Points

Potential to improve customer satisfaction overall (+4) 2

Fulfills the customer need (+3) 2

Ability to obtain measurable customer data (+2) 2

Increases access to the customer (+1) 1

Total 7/10

Step 4: External Considerations

Points

Competitive opportunity (+4) 2

Outside parties involved (take a point off for each involved party) (+3)

3

Level of market demand (+2) 1

Not impacted by regulation (+1) 0

Total 6/10

Final Touchpoint Score

Points

Cost Considerations Score x3 27/30

Internal Considerations Score x1 9/10

Customer Quality Criteria Score x3 21/30

External Considerations Score x2 12/20

Strategic Concerns Score x1 10/10 Total 79/100

Step 5: Strategic Concerns

Points

Mission statement relevance (+4) 4

Brand promise fulfillment (+3) 3

Core strategy fit (+2) 2

Alignment with future goals (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Page 24: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Jargon-free materials • Develop DVD that

clearly explains Medicare

• Summary sheet that lists the most common out-of-pocket expenses

COLLATERAL Customer satisfaction criteria

☐ Understandable þContains needed info þ Questions answered

þ Well organized ☐ Simple language summary sheet þ Big print

Operational metrics

• ___% inquiries about collateral messages & the types of questions asked.

Competitive Insights

• UnitedHealth has won awards for its clear language about Medicare and the videos it developed.

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion

UnitedHealth ☐ þ ☐ L ☐ ☐

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard (See ScoreCard slide)

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗

Page 25: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Step 2: Internal Considerations

Points

Person who can champion the touchpoint (+4) 4

No additional line of communication/collaboration (+3) 3

Capabilities/resources available to maintain it (+2) 1

Works well with other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 9/10

Step 1: Cost Considerations

Points

Potential for revenue (+4) 3

Affordability of touchpoint/unit cost (+3) 3

Technology/production cost (+2) 1

No additional cost to other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 8/10

SCORECARD FOR MEDICARE DVD

Step 3: Customer Quality Criteria

Points

Potential to improve customer satisfaction overall (+4) 4

Fulfills the customer need (+3) 3

Ability to obtain measurable customer data (+2) 2

Increases access to the customer (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Step 5: Strategic Concerns

Points

Mission statement relevance (+4) 4

Brand promise fulfillment (+3) 3

Core strategy fit (+2) 2

Alignment with future goals (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Step 4: External Considerations

Points

Competitive opportunity (+4) 4

Outside parties involved (take a point off for each involved party) (+3)

3

Level of market demand (+2) 2

Not impacted by regulation (+1) 0

Total 9/10

Final Touchpoint Score

Points

Cost Considerations Score x3 24/30

Internal Considerations Score x1 9/10

Customer Quality Criteria Score x3 30/30

External Considerations Score x2 18/20

Strategic Concerns Score x1 10/10 Total 91/100

Page 26: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Add online, credit card, & automatic bill payment options

• Reminder of benefits on bill

PREMIUM BILL Customer satisfaction criteria

☐Service summary ☐Bill shows value

þ Clarity of bill ☐Various payment options (credit card, online)

Operational metrics

• __% of inquiries regarding forms and monthly premiums

• Survey Satisfaction • Focus groups

Competitive Insights

• Humana does a monthly SmartSummary statement that gives health care spending & offers tips on saving money

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence þ þ ☐ þ þ ☐

Com

petit

ion

UnitedHealth þ ☐ ☐ þ þ ☐ Humana þ ☐ ☐ L þ ☐

Customers Want þ þ ☐ þ þ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard (See ScoreCard slide)

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal

✗ ✗

Page 27: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Step 1: Cost Considerations

Points

Potential for revenue (+4) 2

Affordability of touchpoint/unit cost (+3) 3

Technology/production cost (+2) 2

No additional cost to other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 8/10

Step 3: Customer Quality Criteria

Points

Potential to improve customer satisfaction overall (+4) 4

Fulfills the customer need (+3) 3

Ability to obtain measurable customer data (+2) 1

Increases access to the customer (+1) 0

Total 8/10

Step 2: Internal Considerations

Points

Person who can champion the touchpoint (+4) 4

No additional line of communication/collaboration (+3) 1

Capabilities/resources available to maintain it (+2) 2

Works well with other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 8/10

SCORECARD FOR REMINDER OF BENEFITS ON BILL

Step 4: External Considerations

Points

Competitive opportunity (+4) 4

Outside parties involved (take a point off for each involved party) (+3)

3

Level of market demand (+2) 2

Not impacted by regulation (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Step 5: Strategic Concerns

Points

Mission statement relevance (+4) 4

Brand promise fulfillment (+3) 3

Core strategy fit (+2) 2

Alignment with future goals (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Final Touchpoint Score

Points

Cost Considerations Score x3 24/30

Internal Considerations Score x1 8/10

Customer Quality Criteria Score x3 21/30

External Considerations Score x2 20/20

Strategic Concerns Score x1 10/10 Total 84/100

Page 28: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Send welcome email offering an online version if desired

• Link to video tutorial in electronic welcome packet

WELCOME PACKET Customer satisfaction criteria

þComes quickly ☐Easy to understand

☐Delivery choice ☐Step by step/hand-holding

Operational metrics

• _____inquiries to customer service • Customer surveys

Competitive Insights

• Cigna has won awards for its easy to read materials-it’s jargon free.

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion Cigna ☐ þ ☐ L ☐ ☐

__________ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ __________ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ __________ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want

☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐

Unit Cost Regence Cost $

_ _ _ _ _ _

Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard (See ScoreCard slide)

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗

Page 29: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Step 1: Cost Considerations

Points

Potential for revenue (+4) 2

Affordability of touchpoint/unit cost (+3) 3

Technology/production cost (+2) 2

No additional cost to other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 8/10

SCORECARD FOR ONBOARDING VIDEO TUTORIAL

Step 2: Internal Considerations

Points

Person who can champion the touchpoint (+4) 4

No additional line of communication/collaboration (+3) 3

Capabilities/resources available to maintain it (+2) 2

Works well with other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Step 3: Customer Quality Criteria

Points

Potential to improve customer satisfaction overall (+4) 4

Fulfills the customer need (+3) 3

Ability to obtain measurable customer data (+2) 2

Increases access to the customer (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Step 5: Strategic Concerns

Points

Mission statement relevance (+4) 4

Brand promise fulfillment (+3) 3

Core strategy fit (+2) 2

Alignment with future goals (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Step 4: External Considerations

Points

Competitive opportunity (+4) 4

Outside parties involved (take a point off for each involved party) (+3)

3

Level of market demand (+2) 2

Not impacted by regulation (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Final Touchpoint Score

Points

Cost Considerations Score x3 24/30

Internal Considerations Score x1 10/10

Customer Quality Criteria Score x3 30/30

External Considerations Score x2 20/20

Strategic Concerns Score x1 10/10 Total 94/100

Page 30: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

•  More customized information

•  Evangelist demonstrations at community centers

•  Mobile version of website

MYREGENCE.COM Customer satisfaction criteria

☐Easy to navigate þ Relevance þ Useful information

☐ Customized ☐ Evangelist demonstrations

Operational metrics

• _____inquiries into customer service • _____web metrics/traffic • 12% of Medicare members have accessed

myRegence • Only 53% rate myRegence as good or excellent

Competitive Insights

• Aetna invested heavily in its website.

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion Aetna ☐ L þ ☐ ☐ ☐

UnitedHealth ☐ þ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ Cigna ☐ þ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ Humana ☐ þ þ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want ☐ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard (See ScoreCard slide)

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗

Page 31: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Step 1: Cost Considerations

Points

Potential for revenue (+4) 2

Affordability of touchpoint/unit cost (+3) 2

Technology/production cost (+2) 1

No additional cost to other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 6/10

Step 2: Internal Considerations

Points

Person who can champion the touchpoint (+4) 4

No additional line of communication/collaboration (+3) 3

Capabilities/resources available to maintain it (+2) 2

Works well with other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 10/10

SCORECARD FOR CUSTOMIZED PROFILE ON MYREGENCE.COM

Step 4: External Considerations

Points

Competitive opportunity (+4) 3

Outside parties involved (take a point off for each involved party) (+3)

3

Level of market demand (+2) 2

Not impacted by regulation (+1) 1

Total 9/10

Step 3: Customer Quality Criteria

Points

Potential to improve customer satisfaction overall (+4) 4

Fulfills the customer need (+3) 3

Ability to obtain measurable customer data (+2) 2

Increases access to the customer (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Step 5: Strategic Concerns

Points

Mission statement relevance (+4) 4

Brand promise fulfillment (+3) 3

Core strategy fit (+2) 2

Alignment with future goals (+1) 1

Total 10/10

Final Touchpoint Score

Points

Cost Considerations Score x3 18/30

Internal Considerations Score x1 10/10

Customer Quality Criteria Score x3 30/30

External Considerations Score x2 18/20

Strategic Concerns Score x1 10/10 Total 86/100

Page 32: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Telephone reminders about screenings

• Printed materials • Text reminders for

those with chronic illnesses

ENGAGEMENT MESSAGING Customer satisfaction criteria

þ Interesting þ Informative ☐ Relevance ☐ Choice of format

þ Other languages ☐ Helpful Reminders þ Timely þ Email

Operational metrics

• Surveys • Web metrics

• Feedback

Competitive Insights

• UnitedHealth makes reminder calls about screenings; found a 56% increase in the number of people who received the screening

• Aetna launched a text-messaging program for members with diabetes

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion Aetna ☐ þ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ UnitedHealth ☐ þ ☐ ☐ þ ☐

Customers Want ☐ þ ☐ þ þ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard (See ScoreCard slide)

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗ ✗

Page 33: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

SCORECARD FOR TEXT REMINDERS Step 1: Cost Considerations

Points

Potential for revenue (+4) 2

Affordability of touchpoint/unit cost (+3) 3

Technology/production cost (+2) 2

No additional cost to other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 8/10

Step 2: Internal Considerations

Points

Person who can champion the touchpoint (+4) 2

No additional line of communication/collaboration (+3) 3

Capabilities/resources available to maintain it (+2) 1

Works well with other touchpoints (+1) 1

Total 7/10

Step 3: Customer Quality Criteria

Points

Potential to improve customer satisfaction overall (+4) 2

Fulfills the customer need (+3) 2

Ability to obtain measurable customer data (+2) 0

Increases access to the customer (+1) 1

Total 5/10

Step 5: Strategic Concerns

Points

Mission statement relevance (+4) 3

Brand promise fulfillment (+3) 2

Core strategy fit (+2) 1

Alignment with future goals (+1) 1

Total 7/10

Step 4: External Considerations

Points

Competitive opportunity (+4) 3

Outside parties involved (take a point off for each involved party) (+3)

2

Level of market demand (+2) 1

Not impacted by regulation (+1) 1

Total 7/10

Final Touchpoint Score

Points

Cost Considerations Score x3 24/30

Internal Considerations Score x1 7/10

Customer Quality Criteria Score x3 15/30

External Considerations Score x2 14/20

Strategic Concerns Score x1 6/10 Total 67/100

Page 34: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

5CS FRAMEWORK RESULTS: MEDICARE

Summary Considerations

Selected Opportunities Cost Internal

Customer Quality

External

Brand Total

Onboarding Video Tutorial 24 10 30 20 10 94 Medicare DVD 24 9 30 18 10 91 Customized Profile on MyRegence

18 10 30 18 10 86

Reminder of Benefits on Bill 24 8 21 20 10 84 Webinar 27 9 21 12 10 79 Text Reminders 24 7 15 14 7 67 •  The 5Cs Framework, does not just uncover potential

gaps, but also prioritizes quality touchpoint opportunities within each step of the journey map

•  Each stage of the 5Cs ensures effective touchpoints; however, the text reminders scored low. The gap was based only on the competition

Page 35: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

INTERPRETING THESE SCORES These scores show two different results

•  Where the touchpoint is strong/weak •  How the touchpoint fits comparatively overall within each step

of the journey map

By comparing scores managers can prioritize their efforts to ensure higher customer satisfaction

Touchpoints will need to be continually rescored as the environment changes

Page 36: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

SUMMARY

Page 37: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

HOW TO IMPLEMENT In order for the 5Cs Framework to be effective, it will require continual examination and will need to be applied across the company An inter-departmental team should be established to utilize the 5Cs Framework regularly to produce results

•  It will be this team’s responsibility to confer with every department about customer criteria, metrics, competitive insights, etc., which will lead to better communication across the organization

Page 38: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

SUCCESS WITH THE 5CS Uncovers the diamond in the rough:

•  A clear method to analyze current and future touchpoints

•  Finds gaps in the way that Regence touches members throughout their journey

•  Provides a customer-centric focus while benchmarking the competition and analyzing cost

Page 39: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

5CS FRAMEWORK

Touchpoint Opportunities

•  Satisfy customer? •  New Service

Channel/ Service migration?

•  Lower costs? •  More competitive?

ScoreCard 100

GAP

ANALYZE

Existing Touchpoint Analysis Customer satisfaction criteria

☐ Pain points ☐ Relevance ☐ Access ☐ Timely ☐ Ease ☐ Low cost

☐ Understandable ☐ Responsive ☐ Helpful ☐ Positive ☐ Need

Operational metrics

•  Web metrics •  Membership

changes

•  Customer Service correspondence

•  Surveys Competitive Insight*

•  Products •  Programs

•  Long/short term goals •  Revenue

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone

Radio/TV

Regence ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion*

______ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ______ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ______ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Unit Cost Regence Cost $

_ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ *Competition includes other Blues plans & general health insurance landscape.

Page 40: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

APPENDIX

Page 41: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

THE 5CS AT WORK ADDITIONAL EXAMPLE:

NEW MEMBER, LARGE EMPLOYER GROUP

Page 42: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

TESTING THE 5CS FRAMEWORK We will test touchpoints for new members from a large employer group (100+) at each stage of the customer journey

Awareness Evaluate Sales/

Enrollment* Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal

• Regence Reps

• Collateral *Employer only • Member Card • EOB/Claims • Newsletter

Page 43: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Event that welcomes family members

• Online event

REGENCE REPRESENTATIVE COMPANY VISITS

Customer satisfaction criteria

þKnowledgeable þQuestions answered þPresentation

☐ Visit Timing þProfessionalism ☐ Have spouse present

Operational metrics

• __ % Attended • Visit Satisfaction

Survey

• __% Increase in Web traffic/web metrics

Competitive Insights

• Unknown

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone

Radio/TV

Regence þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion

____________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

____________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

____________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

____________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want þ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard Analyze Opportunities

GAP

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗

ANALYZE

Page 44: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Jargon-free materials • Summary sheet that

lists common out-of-pocket expenses

• Make online collateral mobile/tablet

COLLATERAL MATERIALS Customer satisfaction criteria

☐ Understandable þContains needed info. ☐ Questions answered

þ Well organized ☐ Helpful Summary sheet ☐ Viewable on all devices

Operational metrics

• ___% calls about collateral & types of questions asked

• ___% wanting to go “green”/paperless Competitive Insights

• Cigna won awards for its jargon free collateral; reducing customer service calls.

• UnitedHealth, Aetna & Cigna launched materials to demonstrate an improved customer experience.

• Aetna invested heavily in its website. Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone

Radio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion Cigna ☐ þ ☐ L ☐ ☐

UnitedHealth ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐ Aetna ☐ L ☐ þ ☐ ☐

Customers Want ☐ þ þ þ ☐ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard Analyze Opportunities

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗ ✗

Page 45: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal

This interaction takes place between the employer and the sales team

At the member level, the member deals with his/her company’s human resources department and not directly with Regence

Page 46: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Mobile Member Card • Activate card by

phone

MEMBER CARD Customer satisfaction criteria

þArrives quickly þInformation is correct þIncludes needed information

☐ Always convenient ☐ Fits with busy lifestyle

Operational metrics

• _____member card complaints • _____% of cards resent

Competitive Insights

• Aetna has a strong mobile program, including a mobile card.

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion Aetna ☐ þ L þ ☐ ☐

UnitedHealth ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐ Cigna ☐ þ ☐ þ ☐ ☐ Humana ☐ þ þ þ ☐ ☐

Customers Want þ þ þ þ ☐ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard Analyze Opportunities

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗

Page 47: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

•  Mobile EOB •  Create clearer to

read EOB

EOB/CLAIMS Customer satisfaction criteria

☐ Understandable þ Correct/Accurate þ Contains needed info.

☐ Electronic version (all forms)

Operational metrics

• _____# of customer complaints • _____# of Inquiries to customer service • ___% wanting to go “green”/paperless

Competitive Insights

• Cigna has won awards for its easy to read EOB-it’s jargon free.

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ þ þ ☐

Com

petit

ion Aetna ☐ þ þ þ þ ☐

UnitedHealth ☐ þ þ þ þ ☐ Cigna ☐ þ þ L þ ☐ Humana ☐ þ þ þ þ ☐

Customers Want þ þ þ þ þ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard Analyze Opportunities

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use &

Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗

Page 48: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

Touchpoint Opportunities

• Customize based on readers’ interests, needs, demographics

•  In Spanish & Russian • Ability to share easily

on social media • Create a newsletter

mobile app

NEWSLETTERS Customer satisfaction criteria

þ Interesting þ Informative ☐ Relevance

☐ Other languages þ Easy link to myRegence ☐ Sharing w/o limits ( Twitter)

Operational metrics

• Surveys • Web metrics

• Feedback

Competitive Insights

• Unknown

Service Channel (L=Market leader in touchpoint if applicable)

Face to Face

Online

Mobile

Print

Telephone R

adio/TV

Regence ☐ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Com

petit

ion

________________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ________________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ________________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ________________

☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

Customers Want ☐ þ þ ☐ ☐ ☐ Unit Cost Regence Cost $ _ _ _ _ _ _ Potential Gaps ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐

ScoreCard Analyze Opportunities

GAP

ANALYZE

Awareness Evaluate Sales/ Enrollment Access Use & Support Re-Engage/

Renewal ✗ ✗

Page 49: TOUCHPOINT AUDIT: IMPROVING THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE · 5 STEPS TO THE 5CS FRAMEWORK 1. Determine who will execute the framework 2. Select your audience (i.e. LOB) 3. Choose a stage

ADDITIONAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR MEDICARE Support

•  Promote services like case managers to Medicare as 64% of Baby Boomers have a chronic illness

•  95% of Medicare members rate the Nurse Hotline as important, there is an opportunity to expand this service to live chat as Baby Boomers age into the population

Online

•  Seniors use social media sites like MyWay Village; Regence may want to partner with similar sites

•  Baby Boomers are high users of email, consider using this vehicle Mobile

•  Jitterbug has marketed cell phones and mobile applications that give medical advice to seniors. This could be an opportunity for Regence to partner with a similar company.

Clinics

•  Humana operates urgent-care clinics which makes for a better member experience with reduced wait times, lower costs, longer hours, and no appointments needed