17
To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J. Walch General Counsel Southern Nevada Water Authority

To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

To Kill a Shortage:Targeting

Augmentation and Conservation

2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual ConferenceDecember 11, 2014

1

Gregory J. WalchGeneral Counsel

Southern Nevada Water Authority

Page 2: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

Southern Nevada relies on Colorado River resources to meet 90 percent of its water demands.

Page 3: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

January 2000 Elevation: 1,214 ft. July 2010 Elevation: 1,087 ft.

The drought has had devastating impacts on Lake Mead’s water elevations.

Page 4: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

2000Hoover Dam, Lake Mead

Hoover Dam, 2000Hoover Dam, 2014

The drought has had devastating impacts on Lake Mead’s water elevations.

Page 5: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

Projected Dec.31, 2014

17% of capacity

1,220 ft.

1,087 ft.

1,000 ft.

Hoover Dam

40% of capacity

Lake Mead Capacity – Projected (Dec. 31, 2014)

5

Drought Update

100% of capacity

Intakes 2 & 3

Page 6: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

• Limited access to water supplies

• Compromised water quality

• Additional treatment and power costs

• New facility or facility upgrade costs

• Supplemental resource costs

Note: Analysis done using Historical Hydrology only

How do low Lake Mead elevations impact Southern Nevada?

Page 7: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

Our Response? CONSERVE

Development codesLandscape rebatesWatering restrictionsFixture retrofit kitsWater auditsCar wash couponsEfficient irrigation programsWater Efficient TechnologiesPool cover rebatesWater Smart Contractor programWater Smart Home programWater Upon Request programWater Conservation CoalitionWater Smart Innovations ConferenceConservation HelplineDemonstration GardensH2O UniversityWater waste investigations

Page 8: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

Since Water Smart Landscapes Program inception:

• $205 million invested to date

• 78 billion gallons saved

• 170 million square feet of turf converted*

*Southern Nevada has removed enough grass for a roll of sod to extend 86 percent of earth’s circumference. (Approximately 25,000 miles)

Page 9: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 20130

50,000

100,000

150,000

200,000

250,000

300,000

350,000

1.5 mil

1.6 mil

1.7 mil

1.8 mil

1.9 mil

2 milPopulation

9

Southern Nevada consumptively used about 32 billion gallons less water in 2013

than in 2002, despite annual population increases and millions of annual visitors.

Water Use (Acre-feet)

Page 10: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

In Good Company…• Phoenix reduced use by 35% since 1980

• All of Scottsdale’s reclaimed water is reused for turf irrigation or recharge

• Ag and urban conservation efforts by water agencies in MWD’s service territory have reduced CO River water use by 20% since 2002

• Southern California imports less water today than it did 20 years ago despite significant increases in population

• Denver Water has reduced overall use by 20 percent and saved more than 1 million acre-feet of water since 2002, while serving an ever-increasing population

Page 11: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020950

1000

1050

1100

1150

1200

2001:Interim Surplus Guidelines

AZ Water Banking Agreement

2007:Interim Guidelines

2012:Minute 319

2003:QuantificationSettlement Agreement

1999:Interstate BankingRegulations

2017:First Shortage Declaration

The Response – Adding Tools to the Toolbox

Page 12: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

July 2014 Pilot System Conservation Agreement

• Two year pilot funded by BOR, Denver, MWD, CAP, and SNWA

• $11 million ($2.75 million in Upper Basin) – real money, but baby steps

• Evaluate feasibility of mitigating drought impacts through compensated voluntary reductions in use or loss

• Protection of critical elevations in both Powell and Mead

• Benefits of reductions inure to system as a whole and NOT to any one entitlement holder

Page 13: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

• Sector diversity• Geographic diversity• Cost/acre-foot of conserved water• Relative size of project• Comparative ease of administering

contract with user and confirming reduction in use

• Project timing• Required compliance• Third party impacts• Downstream “juniors” or need for

forbearance• Relative measurability of benefits to

system• Ability to leverage other money• WaterSMART program evaluation criteria

Selection Criteria – Program Goals

Page 14: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

System Conservation Status: Upper Basin• Concerns/Outreach– Movement of water into Powell, below upper basin

agriculture– Sheparding water to Powell– (mis)perception that lower basin interests are buying up

water in the upper basin to fix long term supply/demand imbalance

• Yesterday, Upper Colorado River Commission passed resolution to “Support pilot programs such as those contemplated under the July 30, 2014 System Conservation Agreement”– Can cast SCA as evaluation of demand management in UB– Ideally suited to do outreach relating to benefits of maintaining Powell

elevations

Page 15: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

System Conservation Status: Lower Basin• BOR is administering the program in

the lower basin• Sent pre-proposal solicitation

October 5• Received 14 pre-proposals• Geographically diverse• Sector diverse – tribes,

municipalities, irrigation districts• Include efficiency, conveyance loss

reduction, fallowing, reuse, and landscape conversions

• Price diverse ($100 - $1000/af)• Don’t have sufficient funds for all

Page 16: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J

• Complete review of pre-proposals

• Goal to contact all applicants prior to February 1, 2015

• Implementation in 2015

Lower Basin Next Steps

Page 17: To Kill a Shortage: Targeting Augmentation and Conservation 2014 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference December 11, 2014 1 Gregory J