Upload
reinmund-weyker
View
114
Download
9
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
To Feel To Feel (in) (in) the the DaggerDagger
The concept of Fuhlen The concept of Fuhlen without contact of blades without contact of blades
(presentation of a (presentation of a hypothesis)hypothesis)
Karel Černín, RevertarKarel Černín, Revertar
Sources for techniques Sources for techniques usedused Danzig (1452, Cod.44.A.8Danzig (1452, Cod.44.A.8 ))
Talhoffer (1443, MS Chart.A.558; 1450, MS Talhoffer (1443, MS Chart.A.558; 1450, MS 78.A.15; 1459, MS Thott.290.2º; 1467, 78.A.15; 1459, MS Thott.290.2º; 1467, Codex Icon 394a)Codex Icon 394a)
Kal (cca 1470, CGM 1507)Kal (cca 1470, CGM 1507) Wallerstein (cca 1470, Cod. I.6.4°.2)Wallerstein (cca 1470, Cod. I.6.4°.2) Falkner (1495, MS KK5012)Falkner (1495, MS KK5012) Goliath (cca 1510, MS German Quarto 2020)Goliath (cca 1510, MS German Quarto 2020) Dürer (1512, MS 26-232)Dürer (1512, MS 26-232) Berlin (1512, Libr.Pict.A.83)Berlin (1512, Libr.Pict.A.83) Glasgow (1508, MS E.1939.65.341)Glasgow (1508, MS E.1939.65.341)
partly: Liberi (cca 1410, Pisani-Dossi partly: Liberi (cca 1410, Pisani-Dossi Edition)Edition)
Marozzo (1536, Opera Nova)Marozzo (1536, Opera Nova)
InspirationInspiration
Eli SteenputEli Steenput: oponents reaction to : oponents reaction to one technique can create opening one technique can create opening and opportunity for anotherand opportunity for another
Colin RichardsColin Richards: Fuhlen can be : Fuhlen can be used to choose between different used to choose between different techniquestechniques
Anton KohutovičAnton Kohutovič: to apply Fuhlen : to apply Fuhlen you need to put oponent under you need to put oponent under pressurepressure
Executive summaryExecutive summary PRIMARY COUNTER (plan A)PRIMARY COUNTER (plan A):: Catch attacker´s armed hand, push it Catch attacker´s armed hand, push it
out of the wayout of the way,, keep contact and keep contact and control.control.
If you have a dagger, stab. / If not, hit If you have a dagger, stab. / If not, hit him in the face and throw him.him in the face and throw him.
FUHLEN:FUHLEN: If you fail (he counters), feel the If you fail (he counters), feel the
pressure of his armed hand.pressure of his armed hand.
SECONDARY COUNTER (plan B)SECONDARY COUNTER (plan B):: According to WEICH or HERT apply According to WEICH or HERT apply
locks, breaks, disarms and throws.locks, breaks, disarms and throws.
High stab – Upper High stab – Upper shieldshield
Talhoffer 1459 64vTalhoffer 1459 64v
Primary counter = Primary counter = stabstab
Liberi (Pisani-Dossi) 10vLiberi (Pisani-Dossi) 10v
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary counterscounters
Talhoffer 1467 t. 182, Goliath t. 11Talhoffer 1467 t. 182, Goliath t. 11
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary counterscounters
Wallerstein 25r, Talhoffer 1450Wallerstein 25r, Talhoffer 1450
System in the System in the dagger fighting: dagger fighting:
A hidden truth or a A hidden truth or a sophisticated lie?sophisticated lie?
Reasons FOR the Reasons FOR the systemsystem Complex locks and disarms donComplex locks and disarms don
´t work as primary techniques ´t work as primary techniques beacuse:beacuse:
a)a) attacker escapesattacker escapesb)b) attacker countersattacker counters
Quick primary counter forces Quick primary counter forces attacker to react and opens attacker to react and opens opportunity for applying more opportunity for applying more complex techniquescomplex techniques
Reasons AGAINST the Reasons AGAINST the systemsystem Not supported by manuscripts – all Not supported by manuscripts – all
techniques appear to be „primary“.techniques appear to be „primary“.
Different possible explanations for Different possible explanations for broad portfolio of techniques - broad portfolio of techniques - choice might be based on: choice might be based on:
a)a) defender´s preferences or intentdefender´s preferences or intentb)b) attacker´s characteristics attacker´s characteristics
(taller/smaller, stronger/weaker…)(taller/smaller, stronger/weaker…)c)c) attack (angle, positions of feet…)attack (angle, positions of feet…)
Chaotic situation after primary Chaotic situation after primary counter – „what if“ syndromcounter – „what if“ syndrom
Still want to hear more of our Still want to hear more of our „sophisticated lies“?„sophisticated lies“?
Here we go! Here we go!
A.A.UnarmedUnarmed
High stab – left hand High stab – left hand blockblock
Talhoffer 1450Talhoffer 1450
Primary counter = neck Primary counter = neck throwthrow
Talhoffer 1450Talhoffer 1450
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary counterscounters
Talhoffer 1459 61v, Durer t.48, Berlin 52v (Danzig 86r)Talhoffer 1459 61v, Durer t.48, Berlin 52v (Danzig 86r)
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary counterscounters
Talhoffer 1443 t. 121Talhoffer 1443 t. 121
B.B.ArmedArmed
High stab – left hand High stab – left hand blockblock
Falkner 46vFalkner 46v
Primary counter = Primary counter = stabstab
Talhoffer 1467 t.190Talhoffer 1467 t.190
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary counterscounters
Talhoffer 1467 t.178, Talhoffer 1459 Talhoffer 1467 t.178, Talhoffer 1459 70v,70v, Talhoffer 1467 t.188Talhoffer 1467 t.188
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary counterscounters „„| Merck | hat er den | Merck | hat er den
degen gefast | das degen gefast | das die scheib an seine~ die scheib an seine~ klaine finger stet | klaine finger stet | vnd sticht dir oben vnd sticht dir oben zu° so ver ker dein zu° so ver ker dein lincke hant | vnd var lincke hant | vnd var von vnden auf | vnd von vnden auf | vnd begreif ÿm den begreif ÿm den arm~ vorñ peÿ der arm~ vorñ peÿ der hannt vnder seine~ hannt vnder seine~ degen | vnd würg degen | vnd würg ÿm den degen mit ÿm den degen mit deine~ lincken arm~ deine~ lincken arm~ vbersich auf “vbersich auf “
Danzig 94v-95rDanzig 94v-95r Falkner 48vFalkner 48v
A.A.UnarmedUnarmed
High stab – right hand High stab – right hand blockblock
Talhoffer 1450Talhoffer 1450
Primary counter = Primary counter = throwthrow
Marozzo t.61Marozzo t.61
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary counterscounters
Talhoffer 1443 t.118Talhoffer 1443 t.118
„„Sticht Er aber den Sticht Er aber den oberñ stich zu dir / nach oberñ stich zu dir / nach deine~ haubt / oder zu deine~ haubt / oder zu der prust / so far von der prust / so far von vndtñ auff mit der vndtñ auff mit der rechtñ ewichen hant / rechtñ ewichen hant / vndter sein rechte vndter sein rechte hant / vnd begreyff in hant / vnd begreyff in den arm~ / vnd mit der den arm~ / vnd mit der linckn hant vber sein linckn hant vber sein rechtñ arm~ / thue den rechtñ arm~ / thue den tegen võ dir / so nymbst tegen võ dir / so nymbst du im den tegeñ / oder du im den tegeñ / oder wurfst in vber ein pain / wurfst in vber ein pain / als oben gemalt stet / als oben gemalt stet / „„
Glasgow 98rGlasgow 98r
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary counterscounters
Talhoffer 1450Talhoffer 1450
B.B.ArmedArmed
High stab – right hand High stab – right hand blockblock
Berlin 61vBerlin 61v
Primary counter = Primary counter = stabstab „„| Merck sticht er von oben nyder | vnd | Merck sticht er von oben nyder | vnd
hat den degen gefast das die scheib hat den degen gefast das die scheib hinden an der hant stet | So fass dein hinden an der hant stet | So fass dein degen auch also | vnd stich von vnden degen auch also | vnd stich von vnden auf mit verkartem degen gegen seinen auf mit verkartem degen gegen seinen stich | vnd lass dir die hant nicht stich | vnd lass dir die hant nicht begreiffen | vnd stich in das gesicht ~begreiffen | vnd stich in das gesicht ~““
Danzig 95rDanzig 95r
Berlin 65vBerlin 65v
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary counterscounters
Talhoffer 1443 92r, Kal 77v Talhoffer 1443 92r, Kal 77v
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary counterscounters
Berlin 55r, Talhoffer 1459 65v Berlin 55r, Talhoffer 1459 65v
A.A.UnarmedUnarmed
Low stab – both hands Low stab – both hands blockblock
Talhoffer 1450Talhoffer 1450
Primary counter = Primary counter = throwthrow
„„Var mit deiner lincken hant Var mit deiner lincken hant vorñ für sein hals | vnd schreit vorñ für sein hals | vnd schreit mit deinem lincken fues hinder mit deinem lincken fues hinder seinen rechten | vnd würf ÿn seinen rechten | vnd würf ÿn vber dein lincks knÿe aus dem vber dein lincks knÿe aus dem fuess ~“fuess ~“
Danzig 96rDanzig 96r
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary countercounter
Falkner 52rFalkner 52r
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary countercounter „„| Wenn dir einer mit dem degen vnden | Wenn dir einer mit dem degen vnden
zu° sticht so begreif ÿm den arm~ zu° sticht so begreif ÿm den arm~ arm~ mit paiden henden | vnd lauf ÿm arm~ mit paiden henden | vnd lauf ÿm durch den arm~ | vnd halt fest | So durch den arm~ | vnd halt fest | So prichstu Im den arm~ auch nÿmpstu Im prichstu Im den arm~ auch nÿmpstu Im den degen | ob dw wild ~den degen | ob dw wild ~““
Danzig 96rDanzig 96r
Berlin 53r Berlin 53r
B.B.ArmedArmed
Low stab – left hand Low stab – left hand blockblock
Kal 76v (catching the hand - Danzig 94v)Kal 76v (catching the hand - Danzig 94v)
Primary counter = Primary counter = stabstab
Berlin 38rBerlin 38r
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary countercounter
Talhoffer 1467 t.182 Talhoffer 1467 t.182
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary countercounter
Kal 77rKal 77r
bonus:bonus:ArmedArmed
High stab – dagger High stab – dagger blockblock
Talhoffer 1443 88vTalhoffer 1443 88v
Primary counter = arm Primary counter = arm breakbreak
Wallerstein 22vWallerstein 22v
HERT: Secondary HERT: Secondary countercounter
Talhoffer 1459 64rTalhoffer 1459 64r
WEICH: Secondary WEICH: Secondary countercounter
Wallerstein 25vWallerstein 25v