Upload
muhammad-ilham-a-m
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Contoh kegiatan Lomba debatdebate english
Citation preview
Technical MeetingNSDC Kota Yk 2014
Technicalities
Adapted World Schools Format3 on 3Casebuilding : 30 mins
NO : gadget, internet, 4th party
YES : printed materials, dictionary
Substantive speech : 7.20Reply speech : 4.20
Technicalities
POIs are allowed during Substantive Speeches
POI time is 15 secsTeams are obliged to offer and
accept min 1 POI
Overview
Day 1 (Sept 28)3 Preliminary
RoundsQuarter Final
Round
Day 2 (Sept 29)Semi Final
RoundGrand Final
Round
Awards
1st – 3rd WinnerTop 3 best speakers
Winning A Debate
Matter – Manner – MethodDeveloping “your case”
Problem identification Solutions/Goals Supporting arguments
Emphasis on Philosophical Ground, avoid Feasibility, Effectivity and other Practicalities
Adjudicators are blank papers
Ranking & Match Up
Ranking
1. Victory Point
2. Judge Point
3. Team Score
Break and Slide (Prelim)
Power Match (Elim)
Individual Scoring
60 – 80(average 70)
Matter - Manner - Method
Prepared Motions
THBT experimental drugs should be made available for Ebola patients
THW stop gentrification in rural areas
TH, as the Nigerian government, would pay ransom to Boko Haram in exchange for releasing hostages
1st Speaker
( + )BackgroundTeam SplitArgument
AssertionReasoningEvidenceLink back
( - )• Responses/
negation• Team split• Argument– Assertion– Reasoning– Evidence– Link back
2nd Speaker
( + )• Clarification• Response/negation• Argument– Assertion– Reasoning– Evidence– Link back
( - )• Clarification• Response/negation• Argument– Assertion– Reasoning– Evidence– Link back
3rd Speaker
( + )• Clarification• Response/
negation• Conclusion
( - )• Clarification• Response/
negation• Conclusion
Reply Speech
“biased overview of the debate” Clashes in the debate Opponent’s weakness Team’s strength
“Why YOU should WIN”
Thank you